Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🏠Case-Shiller vs FHFA: Which Index Should Home Buyers Trust in 2025? Should you buy the dip?
Transcript
- 0:00OK, here's a thought. What if the way we measure
- 0:02something as fundamental as home prices, what if it's actually
- 0:06missing like half the story? We hear about the housing market
- 0:09all the time, right? But what's truly going on
- 0:11beneath those headlines beyond just the the medium price tag?
- 0:15Today we're doing a deep dive into arguably the most famous
- 0:18name in U.S. housing data, the S&P CoreLogic Case Shiller Home
- 0:23Price Index. Yeah, And our mission for you
- 0:25today is pretty clear. We want to unpack what this
- 0:27index really measures. We'll get into it's well, it's
- 0:29fascinating history, explain exactly how it's put together
- 0:32and crucially, dissect what it's telling us right now.
- 0:34We'll also explore his blind spots because it definitely has
- 0:37them. And compared to other key
- 0:38indicators, the goal. So you can walk away with a
- 0:40really nuanced understanding of what those numbers mean for you.
- 0:44Absolutely. And we've pulled together a ton
- 0:45of sources for this, everything from academic papers, the
- 0:49original stuff, right through to the very latest market reports.
- 0:52OK, let's unpack this. Yeah, so let's start at the
- 0:54beginning. The Case Shiller index, it was
- 0:57designed to solve a pretty big problem with older housing
- 1:00metrics. Wasn't it that famous
- 1:02composition by? It exactly that's the key.
- 1:04You know, where maybe a bunch of expensive homes sell one month
- 1:07and suddenly the median price jumps makes it look like the
- 1:10whole market soaring, even if you know your house's value
- 1:12hasn't really changed? Right.
- 1:13It's like saying my average spending shot up because I
- 1:16bought a car, not because coffee got more expensive.
- 1:19Very misleading. Yeah.
- 1:20So that's why Economist Carl. Case, Robert and Alan Weiss
- 1:23created this index way back in the 1980's.
- 1:26The primary goal was building a constant quality index.
- 1:29Constant quality, meaning it measures the average change in
- 1:32market value, but only for existing single family homes
- 1:36within specific areas and then rolled up for the whole US.
- 1:40And it's really important to be clear what it doesn't measure.
- 1:43It's not tracking new construction costs or how much
- 1:46repairs add or, you know, values after a hurricane.
- 1:48Nope, purely existing housing stock.
- 1:51OK. So it's focused existing single
- 1:52family homes, but is it just one big national number we see or is
- 1:57it more granular than that? Oh, much more granular.
- 2:00That's a great question. It's not just one number.
- 2:02People often call it a family of indices.
- 2:04It's managed by S&P Dow Jones Indices using data from
- 2:07CoreLogic. OK.
- 2:08Yeah, so you've got the big one, the S&P Core logic, K Schiller
- 2:12U.S. National Home Price Index that
- 2:14pulls from 9 census divisions gives you the broadest view.
- 2:17Then you have the composites, the 10 city composite that's the
- 2:20oldest one includes places like Boston, Chicago and New York.
- 2:23And the 20 city composite that adds 10 more like Dallas,
- 2:26Seattle, Detroit. This is when you often hear
- 2:29quoted in the news and beyond those, they also publish
- 2:32individual metro area indices for each of those 20 cities,
- 2:36which is crucial, right? Because real estate is always
- 2:38local at the end of the. Day, right location, Location
- 2:40location. Exactly.
- 2:42And the significance of Case Shiller goes way beyond just
- 2:44being a number in a report. I mean, it's deeply embedded in
- 2:47the financial system. Well, primarily because it's
- 2:51used as the underlying pricing for real estate futures and
- 2:53options, the ones traded on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, the
- 2:56CME, that's a huge derivatives market.
- 2:59Wow. OK, so it's not just a statistic
- 3:01for economists then? People are actually trading
- 3:03based on this number that changes things.
- 3:05Big financial stakes involved. Precisely.
- 3:08It makes it a truly actionable, tradable instrument.
- 3:11The fact that the CME uses it well, that gives an enormous
- 3:14credibility with big institutional players.
- 3:17It creates this sort of feedback loop.
- 3:19The index's credibility supports the derivatives market, and that
- 3:22market in turn makes the index even more important.
- 3:25So that monthly release last Tuesday of the month, 9:00 AM
- 3:28Eastern, it's a really big deal. It directly influences trading
- 3:32investment strategies. And think about this.
- 3:34Any flaws, any biases in that index, they could lead to
- 3:38mispricing billions, billions in derivatives.
- 3:41That's why getting under the hood is so critical.
- 3:42OK. That definitely raises the
- 3:44strikes. So we know what it measures, why
- 3:45it matters financially. Let's get into the how the
- 3:48engine behind it, this repeat sales technique, this is where
- 3:50it gets really interesting, right?
- 3:51It really is. The core idea is actually pretty
- 3:53elegant, simple almost to measure just price change.
- 3:57You track the sale and then the later resale of the exact same.
- 4:01Yeah, exact same one, yeah. This approach wasn't totally
- 4:03new. Bailey, Muth and Norris talked
- 4:05about it back in 63, but Case and Shiller really refined it
- 4:09and made it work on a large scale in the 80s.
- 4:11And the beauty of it, it directly tackles that
- 4:14composition bias we started. With right because you're
- 4:16holding the house constant. Exactly.
- 4:18Size, quality, location all help constant.
- 4:20Theoretically, you create these sales pairs and the difference
- 4:23between them. That's your pure market
- 4:25appreciation or depreciation. It's a pretty clever.
- 4:29OK, the repeat sales idea sounds great in theory, but I mean,
- 4:32real estate data must be messy, right?
- 4:33Millions of transactions? How do they actually filter that
- 4:37down to get a clean sample? How do they avoid just measuring
- 4:40noise? You're absolutely right, it's a
- 4:41huge task. Core logic pulls in massive
- 4:43amounts of data from county records.
- 4:45But then there's this really rigorous filtering process.
- 4:49First property type. It's strictly single family
- 4:51detached homes. Only those.
- 4:53So no new builds, no condos. Correct.
- 4:55New constructions out. No prior sale, right?
- 4:58And condos co-ops, they're excluded too.
- 5:01Different price dynamics. Second, transaction type, only
- 5:04arm's length sales count. So sales do family members
- 5:08transfers like that, those get tossed out because they might
- 5:10not reflect true market value. Third, property integrity.
- 5:15They try to screen out properties where they've been
- 5:17huge physical changes between sales, like a massive addition
- 5:20or if the property type changed. And finally, high turnover.
- 5:24They exclude homes that sell more than once within six
- 5:27months. To filter out the quick flips.
- 5:29Speculation. Maybe fraud.
- 5:31Exactly. Filter out those speculative
- 5:33flips, redevelopments, potential fraud.
- 5:35But it's crucial. Remember, these are all
- 5:36deliberate trade-offs. They make the index
- 5:38statistically cleaner, maybe, but they also create blind
- 5:42spots. The index isn't just passively
- 5:44reflecting the market, it's an act of construction, arguably an
- 5:47opinionated 1. OK.
- 5:48So they filter heavily, but after they have this cleaner
- 5:50sample of repeat sales, it's not just a simple average of those
- 5:53price changes, is it? You mentioned this art of
- 5:56waiting. Right, waiting is key.
- 5:58There are several layers. First, and this is a big one,
- 6:01it's evaluating. Meaning.
- 6:03Meaning price changes for more expensive homes have a bigger
- 6:05impact on the index number. The weight is based on the price
- 6:08from the first sale in the pair. The rationale is that the index
- 6:11should reflect the change in the aggregate value of all housing
- 6:15stock, not just what's happening to the average priced home.
- 6:18OK, so shifts at the high end matter more.
- 6:19What else? Then there's quality control
- 6:21waiting. This basically down weight sales
- 6:24pairs that show really extreme price changes, like a massive
- 6:28jump might signal a big renovation they didn't catch.
- 6:30A huge drop might signal neglect.
- 6:33It tries to adjust for things other than pure market forces,
- 6:36and finally there's time interval waiting.
- 6:38This gives less weight to sales pairs where there's a really
- 6:40long time between the two sales. Less weight for longer gaps.
- 6:43Well, the statistical thinking is that over a longer period
- 6:46there's a higher chance of unobserved changes to the
- 6:48property or just more statistical noise, so they give
- 6:52it less influence. But as we'll get into this one's
- 6:54becoming pretty controversial now, especially with people
- 6:56staying in homes longer. Yeah, I can see how that might
- 6:59be an issue today. OK, so filtering, waiting, yeah.
- 7:03How does it all finally become the index number we see reported
- 7:06each month? So after all that, the weighted
- 7:09sales pairs are used to create the city level indices.
- 7:12Then those are aggregated up to the US National Index, again
- 7:15weighted by the total estimated value of the housing stock in
- 7:18each area. The final numbers you actually
- 7:20see published there are three months moving average, so the
- 7:23number from March actually uses data from January, February and
- 7:27March. To smooth things out and maybe
- 7:29account for reporting delays. That's exactly smooth volatility
- 7:32helps compensate for data lags. And for context, the indices are
- 7:35all normalized. They set the baseline value at
- 7:38100 back in January 2000. So if you see an index value of
- 7:41say 300 today, it means nominal home prices have basically
- 7:45tripled or gone up to 100% since it started 2000.
- 7:48Oh, and one last thing that a data gets revised.
- 7:50The numbers for the previous 24 months can actually change a bit
- 7:53as more complete data comes. In right, so it's not set in
- 7:55stone immediately. Correct.
- 7:57So what you end up with is this very specific, carefully
- 8:00curated, statistically weighted basket of homes.
- 8:03And if you don't understand what's in that basket and what's
- 8:06not, you can easily misinterpret the signals.
- 8:09Like Case Shiller might look stable, but maybe the condo
- 8:12market next door is going crazy. Yeah, you wouldn't see that
- 8:14because condos aren't in the basket.
- 8:16That makes sense. It's measuring a specific thing
- 8:18very carefully. OK, with that foundation, let's
- 8:20dig into the latest numbers. What's the index telling us
- 8:22right now? We've got data through April
- 8:242025. OK, so the latest headline
- 8:26figures for April 2025, the US National Index came in at
- 8:31327.90, which means nominally prices are about 228% higher
- 8:37than they were back in January 2000.
- 8:39But the key thing is the change. The year over year game was only
- 8:42plus 2.7%. That's actually the slowest
- 8:45annual rise we've seen since mid 2023, and it's the third month
- 8:49in a row that the annual gain is decelerated.
- 8:51It's cooling. OK, 2.7% nominal gain, still
- 8:54positive but slowing down. What about inflation?
- 8:57That's the kicker. When you adjust for inflation
- 8:59using the CPI component for owners equivalent rent, real
- 9:02home prices actually went down. Month over month they fell .8%
- 9:05and year over year real home prices were down 1.5%.
- 9:08Wow. So those nominal gains
- 9:10completely wiped out and then some by broader inflation.
- 9:12Homeowners lost real value over the year.
- 9:14That's the picture, yeah. The 10 city and 20 city
- 9:16composites also showing that cooling depreciation trend.
- 9:19And this regional picture, this is where the national average
- 9:21really starts to hide the interesting stuff, right?
- 9:22The divergent between different cities.
- 9:24Oh, absolutely. Yeah, it's not a uniform market
- 9:26at all. We're seeing this regional
- 9:28reshuffling. Some of the markets that
- 9:29absolutely boomed during the pandemic, they're lagging now.
- 9:32Look at Tanto Florida. It's a year over year decline of
- 9:342.2% A. Decline, OK.
- 9:36Meanwhile, some of the more, let's say historically stable
- 9:40markets are now leading the pack.
- 9:41New York City up almost 8% year over year, 7.95%.
- 9:45Chicago up over 6%. Detroit up 5.5%.
- 9:50It's really becoming a patchwork quilt.
- 9:52Not a single blanket covering the whole country.
- 9:54That's a huge difference between Tampa and New York.
- 9:56OK, what about seasonality? Spring is usually a busy time
- 9:59for housing. Does the data tell us anything
- 10:01there? You mentioned something
- 10:02interesting comparing adjusted versus unadjusted data.
- 10:05Yes, this is a really telling detail.
- 10:06So the raw, the non seasonally adjusted index, it did show a
- 10:10monthly gain from March to April, which you know you'd
- 10:12expect spring buying season and all that.
- 10:14However, the seasonally adjusted national index, the one that
- 10:17accounts for those typical spring bumps, it actually
- 10:20declined by .4% month over month declined.
- 10:22Even in Spring. What does that suggest?
- 10:24It suggests that the raw increase we saw was actually
- 10:26weaker than what you'd normally expect for April.
- 10:29The seasonal tailwinds were there, but they weren't as
- 10:30strong as usual. It applies to the underlying
- 10:32fundamental headwinds like affordability issues are
- 10:36starting to overpower the typical seasonal boost.
- 10:39You can almost see it as a a Canary in the coal mine, a quiet
- 10:42warning about potential weakness ahead, especially as we move
- 10:45past the peak season. A weaker than expected spring
- 10:48bounce. So connecting this back, what
- 10:52are the big macroeconomic forces driving these trends?
- 10:54Affordability has to be key. Huge.
- 10:57Absolutely huge. First, mortgage rate pressure
- 11:00rates were hovering in the mid 6% range during April.
- 11:02That pushes monthly payments way up in generational highs.
- 11:05For many. It severely cramps
- 11:06affordability. Just prices people out.
- 11:08Second, you get this golden handcuffs effect.
- 11:12So many homeowners locked in super low rates like below 4%
- 11:15during the pandemic. Right.
- 11:16Nobody wants to sell and give up that rate to buy something else
- 11:18at 6.5% or 7%. Exactly.
- 11:21It creates this powerful disincentive to move and that
- 11:24severely restricts the supply of existing homes hitting the
- 11:26market. So you end up with this really
- 11:29tense supply demand imbalance. Demand is dampened because rates
- 11:32are high, but supply is also constrained because of these
- 11:35golden handcuffs and that fragile balance.
- 11:37It's basically ended the era of just broad based rapid price
- 11:41jumps everywhere, the market shifting.
- 11:43It's becoming much more selective, fragmented.
- 11:46Local factors matter a lot more now.
- 11:48OK. So it's a powerful index,
- 11:50reflects these big trends, but it's not perfect.
- 11:53What are the big limitations, the blind spots we really need
- 11:55to keep in mind when we look at Case Shiller numbers?
- 11:57Well, the biggest one arguably is the timeliness gap.
- 12:00It's fundamentally a rear view mirror.
- 12:02How? Delayed are we talking?
- 12:03Well, there are a couple of layers.
- 12:04First, the reporting lag data for say March sales, it doesn't
- 12:09get released until the end of May.
- 12:11That's two months right there. Then remember that three month
- 12:14moving average calculation? That adds another layer of
- 12:17smoothing or lag, so combine those and the index you're
- 12:20looking at is effectively reflecting market conditions
- 12:23from three to four months ago 3. To four months, OK, so great for
- 12:26seeing confirmed long term trends, but definitely not good
- 12:29for catching sharp turns in the market in real time.
- 12:32Exactly. It's a lagging indicator.
- 12:33Excellent for historical context, poor for identifying
- 12:36inflection points as they happen.
- 12:38Then there are the gaps in coverage, what the index misses.
- 12:41Like the condos and new builds we talked about?
- 12:43Precisely excluding new construction, condos and co-ops
- 12:46is a major limitation. Think about densities in some
- 12:49urban cores. Those categories can represent
- 12:51upwards of 50% of all sales. 50% so the index could be missing
- 12:55half the action in some major cities.
- 12:57Easily. And as cities continue to
- 12:58densify, you have to wonder if the index becomes less and less
- 13:01representative of the total housing market there.
- 13:04And geographically too, the 20 city composite, it famously
- 13:08leaves out huge metro areas like Houston and Philadelphia.
- 13:12And the national index itself is incomplete.
- 13:14It can't get data from up to 13 states that have non disclosure
- 13:17laws where sales prices aren't public record.
- 13:19Wow, OK, lagging misses key property types, misses whole
- 13:23states. What about the methodology
- 13:25itself? Any critiques there?
- 13:27Potential biases. Oh yeah, there are definitely
- 13:29methodological debates. The repeat sales method itself
- 13:32while Cliver create sample selection bias.
- 13:35By definition, it only includes includes properties that have
- 13:37sold at least twice, so all new homes are immediately out.
- 13:39Everything built since 2000 that hasn't resold yet?
- 13:41Not captured. The index can also get skewed by
- 13:44what kind of properties happen to be selling repeatedly at any
- 13:46given time. Remember 2008?
- 13:48A disproportionate number of distressed sales were happening.
- 13:51Some argue that skewed the Case Shiller downwards, maybe
- 13:54exaggerating the price declines compared to the overall market.
- 13:56So the sample might not always represent the whole market.
- 13:59It might not. And some critics point out the
- 14:01actual sample size is pretty small.
- 14:03Each month, maybe less than half a percent of all homes are in
- 14:06these sales pairs. Can you really draw broad
- 14:08conclusions from that? It's debated.
- 14:10And the waiting schemes we talk about, they have critics too,
- 14:13that time interval waiting giving less weight to sales with
- 14:16long gaps. Yeah, the one you said it was
- 14:18controversial. Right, because now with these
- 14:20golden handcuffs, homeowner tenure is lengthening.
- 14:23People are staying put much longer.
- 14:26So if you're systematically down waiting those long hold sales
- 14:29pairs, could the index be misreading or understating price
- 14:32moves in markets with low turnover?
- 14:34Think San Francisco, LA, Boston. It's a real concern and
- 14:38evaluating making it more sensitive to the high end.
- 14:41Right hides what's happening for average folks.
- 14:43It could obscure important dynamics in the middle and lower
- 14:46price tiers, which arguably are more relevant if you're thinking
- 14:50about broad household affordability.
- 14:53There's even academic research suggesting the underlying
- 14:55statistical model for waiting might be miss specified,
- 15:00potentially leading to biased index values, especially,
- 15:03ironically, for the very metro areas whose indices are used for
- 15:07those CME financial derivatives. Misspecified.
- 15:10That sounds problematic if billions are being traded on it.
- 15:13OK, this definitely raises a big question then.
- 15:15Is the Case Shiller index maybe becoming a less reliable guide
- 15:18than it used? To be it's a really important
- 15:20question. Some people talk about
- 15:21methodological decay, the core assumptions that made the index
- 15:25so robust back in the 80s. Things like typical homeowner
- 15:27tenure, the sheer dominance of single family detached homes,
- 15:31those assumptions are being challenged by how the market
- 15:33works today. So yeah, there's this growing
- 15:35potential gap between what the index measures so carefully and
- 15:37the housing market that actually exists and transacts.
- 15:40Now. It's reflection might be getting
- 15:42a bit distorted over time. OK, so if Case Shiller has these
- 15:45issues, you can't look at it in a vacuum.
- 15:47How does it compare to the main alternative, the FHFA House
- 15:51Price Index? Federal Housing Finance Agency.
- 15:54Right, the FHFAHPI. It's crucial to compare them
- 15:57because they both use that repeat sales method, but they
- 15:59often tell slightly different stories, especially during
- 16:02volatile times. Remember, after 2008 Case
- 16:05Shiller showed much, much steeper price drops than the
- 16:08FHFA index did. Why the difference if they use
- 16:11the same basic method? It comes down to the details,
- 16:14the data source, the waiting. Let's do a quick head to head
- 16:17data source. Case Shiller uses public
- 16:19records. It captures all financing types,
- 16:21conventional loans, jumbo, subprime and back in the day
- 16:23FHAVA loans. It casts a wide net, the
- 16:26FHFAHPI. It only uses data from
- 16:29conforming conventional mortgages, the ones bought or
- 16:31backed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
- 16:33So it's a narrower data set. It automatically filters out the
- 16:36Super high-priced homes, jumbos and often the riskiest loan
- 16:39segments. OK.
- 16:40So FHFA is more prime conventional loans only.
- 16:42Pretty much included loans. Case Shiller includes all types.
- 16:46FHFA conforming only included transactions.
- 16:50Case Shiller is purchase only. FHFA includes both purchase
- 16:53transactions and appraisals done for refinancing.
- 16:56Refinance appraisals too. Does that make a?
- 16:58Difference, yeah. Refinance appraisals tend to be
- 17:00less volatile than purchase prices, especially during
- 17:03downturns. So that contributes to FHFA
- 17:05often looking smoother waiting. We talked about case sheller
- 17:09being evaluated. Expensive homes matter more.
- 17:11FHFA is equal weight within its sample.
- 17:13Every home field pair has basically the same influence.
- 17:16Equal weighted versus evaluated. Big difference.
- 17:18Huge geographic coverage. Case Shielder has those data
- 17:21gaps we mentioned. FHFA actually has comprehensive
- 17:23coverage for all 50 States and major metro areas.
- 17:26So summing it up, Case Shielder captures the broad market
- 17:29including the high end and non conforming loans, which can make
- 17:32it more volatile or potentially skewed by those fringes.
- 17:35FHFA measures the core conventional market with wider
- 17:37geographic coverage, but it misses what's happening in the
- 17:40jumbo space or with government backed loans.
- 17:43OK, so maybe an analogy helps here.
- 17:45Like Case Shiller is a really sensitive microphone picking up
- 17:48the whole orchestra, including the crashing cymbals and maybe
- 17:52some noise from the edges. Yeah.
- 17:53That's a good way to put it, capturing the full spectrum,
- 17:56including the volatile fringes. Whereas the FHFA HPI is more
- 18:00like a microphone focused just on the stable center of the
- 18:02orchestra, the main melody played by the conventional
- 18:05market. That's an excellent analogy.
- 18:06It captures the core conventional segment well.
- 18:09So does that mean Case Schiller being that sensitive mic might
- 18:12be too noisy sometimes, especially for just an average
- 18:15person trying to figure out their own situation?
- 18:17It definitely can be, and that's why understanding they measure
- 18:20different things is key. There was actually a landmark
- 18:23study back in 2008 by OAPO, which is the FHFA's predecessor
- 18:27agency. They dug into why the two
- 18:29indices diverged so much during the housing crisis.
- 18:32They pinpointed 3 main reasons. One, Case Schiller including all
- 18:36those non conforming loans, especially subprime, Two, FHFA
- 18:40including the less volatile refinance appraisals and three
- 18:44differences in how they handle that time interval waiting.
- 18:46So the big take away isn't about which index is right or wrong,
- 18:50it's that they measure distinct market segments.
- 18:52OK, so how should we use them together?
- 18:54An astute analyst looks at them in tandem.
- 18:56If you see a big divergent between Case Shiller and FHFA,
- 18:59that's a red flag. It suggests instability might be
- 19:02coming from the fringes of the market, maybe the high end,
- 19:04maybe riskier loan types. But if Case Shiller and FHFA are
- 19:08moving pretty much in lockstep, that's a stronger signal that
- 19:10the price movement is broad based, reflecting the core
- 19:13conventional market. You use the difference, or lack
- 19:16thereof, as another piece of information.
- 19:18Got it. Use them together to get a
- 19:19fuller picture. Exactly.
- 19:21So to kind of summarize the Case Shiller index itself, it really
- 19:24is a monumental achievement and economic measurement.
- 19:27Its core strength, that constant quality approach, is fantastic,
- 19:31but it's also inextricably linked to its flaws.
- 19:34The time lag, the coverage gaps, the potential waiting biases.
- 19:38It's amazing really how much statistical work goes into
- 19:40creating these numbers that we often just see as a single data
- 19:43point in a news headline. Yeah, you definitely don't think
- 19:46about all that filtering and waiting usually.
- 19:48OK. So bringing it all together,
- 19:50what are the best practices? How should people use this index
- 19:53wisely, especially now in this complex market?
- 19:56OK, Best practices first case Shiller is best suited for
- 19:59analyzing macro level long term trends, putting today's market
- 20:03into historical context. Next, seeing the big cycles.
- 20:06It is fundamentally inappropriate for micro level
- 20:08analysis. Don't use it to price your house
- 20:10or decide if your specific neighborhood is hot or cold.
- 20:13It's too broad, too lagged, and real estate is intensely local.
- 20:16Right. Don't use a national lagged
- 20:17index for a local immediate decision.
- 20:19Precisely. Intelligent use requires
- 20:22triangulation. You need to look at Case Shiller
- 20:24alongside other data. What are mortgage applications
- 20:27doing? What about pending home sales?
- 20:29Which are more timely? Inventory levels?
- 20:31New listings? And crucially, always, always
- 20:33cross reference it with the FHFA house price index asked are they
- 20:37telling the same story? If not, why not?
- 20:39Is the action in the core market or on the fringes?
- 20:41Triangulate look long term compared with FHFA.
- 20:44Good advice. And looking at the current
- 20:46signals from Case Shiller and other data, it really points to
- 20:49AUS housing market that's in a period of well, profound
- 20:53transition. That era of just easy, broad
- 20:56based rapid price gains everywhere that seems to be
- 20:59over. We're moving into a much more
- 21:00selective environment where local economic fundamentals, job
- 21:03growth, inventory levels didn't matter much more.
- 21:05The future path is really being forged in this tension between
- 21:08high mortgage rates keeping buyers out and stubbornly low
- 21:11inventory propping prices up somewhat.
- 21:13But right now, affordability constraints seem to be the
- 21:16dominant force leading to that cooling.
- 21:18We're seeing a. Profound transition driven by
- 21:21rates versus inventory. OK, we talked about that
- 21:24methodological decay, how the index's original assumptions are
- 21:28maybe less true today. That really leaves us with a
- 21:30critical thought, doesn't it? For everyone listening, the Case
- 21:32Shiller Index is undeniably a brilliant map.
- 21:35A brilliant map of the very specific territory, existing
- 21:38single family home sold at arm's length, not flipped too quickly,
- 21:40weighted by value. But as the housing market itself
- 21:43keeps changing, more condos, different financing, people
- 21:46staying put longer. Is that map brilliant as it is,
- 21:48still showing you the territory you really need to navigate?
- 21:51Or is the map itself slowly degrading, becoming less useful
- 21:54over time? Something to think about, What
- 21:56stands out to you? Just a quick reminder, all the
- 21:59analysis we discussed today is based on publicly available
- 22:01sources. And of course data can be
- 22:03revised and interpretations can differ.
- 22:05This content is for educational purposes only.
- 22:07It is definitely not investment advice.
- 22:09Always do your own research and due diligence before making any
- 22:12investment decisions. If you found this deep dive
- 22:14valuable, we'd really appreciate it if you'd like and subscribe
- 22:17to the deep dive on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or our
- 22:20YouTube channel. Hey, don't forget to check the
- 22:22episode description for our recommended book list on value
- 22:24investing. Also, if you'd like to support
- 22:27us in our project to bring a Buffett Indicator app to life,
- 22:29there's a GoFundMe link in the description for that too.
- 22:32Your support really helps us keep doing these deep dives.
- 22:35Thanks for listening.