Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Middle Eastern conflict, windfall tax, and Wood
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. Conflict in the Middle East,
- 0:13Windfall tax remains, but maybe promises of it being removed,
- 0:17events in London and wood finally getting sold.
- 0:20Maybe let's put a question mark on that.
- 0:23That's an awful lot to be discussing if you're just me.
- 0:25Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, but thankfully, I'm joined
- 0:28by a crack team of experts This week.
- 0:31I've got renewables reporter Michael Baer.
- 0:33How are you doing today, Michael?
- 0:34I'm doing good. I mean, it's a weird week to say
- 0:37that anyone's doing good as I think we're all under bit of
- 0:40anxiety about the the future of the world, but I'm doing as well
- 0:44as can be hoped. Certainly.
- 0:46And Speaking of the situation in the Middle East, E Forward
- 0:49editor Ed Reed, you've been looking at that quite intensely
- 0:53this week. Has it put us a grey cloud over
- 0:56your week looking into what's happening there?
- 1:00Yes, I mean, I think that's the thing.
- 1:01I think, you know, certainly you can't help but, you know, sort
- 1:04of see these really dramatic images coming out of the Middle
- 1:07East and think, Crump, this is, you know, this is a really
- 1:09serious thing. So yeah, I mean, I feel like,
- 1:12you know, there there is that kind of, you know, there is
- 1:13obviously there's a sort of geopolitical impact, you know,
- 1:15and there's kind of like higher energy prices, but there's also
- 1:17like a really kind of a human impact that obviously, you know,
- 1:20sort of people, you know, literally dying in Iran and sort
- 1:23of around the region. I think you know, it's pause for
- 1:26thought for us all. Yeah, no, I was.
- 1:27I was listening to original 106, the the local radio station up
- 1:31here in Aberdeen, also owned by DC Thompson wrapping the brand.
- 1:36And yeah, they were they were reporting this morning that
- 1:39flights had arrived in Edinburgh just last night with folks from
- 1:43Dubai. Flights seem to be sort of
- 1:46returning. So it, yeah, that has been the,
- 1:50the major focus for myself, you know, looking at this,
- 1:53especially the sector that we, we operate and, and we report
- 1:57on, there's a, there's an awful lot of people from the UK that
- 2:02go out there for work, go out to, you know, especially the
- 2:05UEUAE. And it might, yes, it, it must,
- 2:09it must be a very scary time for those people and for their
- 2:12families. So I mean, yeah, let's let's get
- 2:14into to what's, I feel like I always start these segments by
- 2:18saying, Ed, Ed, what's happening.
- 2:19But I mean, frankly, I feel like everyone knows what's happening
- 2:22and at the surface level, you can't avoid it.
- 2:25So what's what's been your takeaways this week?
- 2:28I mean, I think that's the thing as you say, right?
- 2:29I feel like the, you know, this week everyone has been talking
- 2:32about, you know, sort of Hormuz and you know, sort of 20 million
- 2:35barrels per day of liquids that is essentially frozen, right?
- 2:37I feel like that is, it feels like the most commonly repeated
- 2:41energy fact for the, for, for the week, if not the month,
- 2:43right? So I feel like, you know that
- 2:45and that's, that's, that's a really important thing to think
- 2:47about. I think actually, you know, the
- 2:48kind of the downstream impact of that.
- 2:49What does, what does that mean? So I think there's a, there's a
- 2:52couple of things. I think you know, clearly in
- 2:54this sort of the local impact, there's a question around
- 2:56storage, right? And I think you know that you're
- 2:58looking at Iraq, looking at Saudi, really big producers, you
- 3:01know, sort of Iraq's what sort of three and a half, 4 million
- 3:05barrels per day. And a lot of that 2/3 of that
- 3:08comes out of Basra. So that's that's in the South
- 3:10and that's directly impacted. They can't move that oil out.
- 3:13And you know, the question is obviously when do, when does
- 3:16storage fill up, when, when do they have to sort of start
- 3:19starting fields? And we've already seen some
- 3:21impact, some, some discussion around ABP field that's
- 3:25apparently gone offline, but it feels like clearly more will
- 3:28have to follow given this, this sort of challenge.
- 3:32And then I suppose the sort of the, the broader question is
- 3:34around is around prices, right? Obviously, you know, here in the
- 3:38UK we've, we've just had Rachel Reeves spring statement with the
- 3:41OBR kind of coming out rather unfortunately saying like, oh,
- 3:45we're sort of seeing, you know, gas prices, you know, with
- 3:47they're forecasting gas prices to fall, which obviously the
- 3:49government really needs to, to, to be able to deliver on its
- 3:52industrial and economic plans. It was just very unfortunate
- 3:57that that, that publishing that report, which obviously takes us
- 3:59sort of a longer term view, kind of came out the same week that
- 4:02obviously you know, sort of Qatar has, has, has, has halted
- 4:06LNG production. And the sort of the knock on
- 4:08impact of, of that around the world is, is, is really
- 4:11remarkable. And I suppose this sort of the,
- 4:13the kind of the, the kind of the next step from that is around
- 4:16sort of hedging. So obviously we're seeing prices
- 4:19really going up, you know, and you know, so this for the, for
- 4:21the, for the next month, right? So, so oil companies are clearly
- 4:24looking at how to, you know, sort of, you know, hedge, hedge,
- 4:29hedge their exposure for the future, trying to lock in sort
- 4:31of higher prices. But at the moment it feels like
- 4:35the hedging is, you know, the, the sort of opportunities in the
- 4:38quite near term, but sort of further out it falls away.
- 4:41So I think there's a, there's a kind of a question around how
- 4:43long do people expect this conflict to last, which, you
- 4:46know, it's obviously the big question.
- 4:48Well, I mean, that's something that I feel like, you know, I
- 4:50don't think it's controversial to say that I don't think the,
- 4:53the orange man in the big White House knows, does he?
- 4:56I mean, Donald Trump seems to be quite flippant in his comments
- 5:00around, around the, the attacks that took place in Iran over the
- 5:06weekend and sort of the, the, the fallout of that.
- 5:10But I'd I'd like to cycle back to, to the UK because we are,
- 5:15you know, extensively AUK focused publication.
- 5:19You mentioned the, the windfall tax there.
- 5:21We obviously had the spring statement this week as well.
- 5:23And I was, you know, I was interested because obviously
- 5:26yesterday at the time of recording, so that's Wednesday.
- 5:30We had meetings between Rachel Reeves and, as she described it,
- 5:34North Sea leaders. We know that Neil McCulloch from
- 5:38Ajura was there. We know that BP were in the room
- 5:41Offshore Energies UK among others.
- 5:44And you know it, it seems that the take away from it is the
- 5:48esim is going to kick in. Now for those of you that don't
- 5:51know the esim is the energy security investment mechanism
- 5:55and they seem to be saying, Oh yeah, it's going to kick in.
- 5:58It's going to happen. We're forecasting the the six
- 6:01months of low oil and gas prices to allow the windfall tax to
- 6:05fall away to take place by September next year.
- 6:09Now this, this feels like you say, I mean, the OBR obviously
- 6:15had to do its homework well in advance of, you know, Saturday,
- 6:18right? So that's that.
- 6:22If I don't know, I, I, I'm struggling to square this circle
- 6:26a little bit. And Ed, maybe you'll be able to
- 6:28help me because from the meetings yesterday, it seems
- 6:31like, oh, yeah, the ESA, you know, Rachel Reeves is saying,
- 6:34oh, the ESAM's still going to kick in September.
- 6:37We can have a fall, you know, the windfall tax fall away three
- 6:39years earlier than we meant to. Then we set the, the date for
- 6:43everything's going to be magic. But we've got to remember why
- 6:46the windfall tax is here, which was a direct response to the,
- 6:51the war in Ukraine, which saw oil and gas prices rock it up.
- 6:55As you know, sanctions were put on Russia in that limited the
- 6:59world's hydrocarbon supply quite significantly.
- 7:02We've now got war in the Middle East.
- 7:03We're speaking about fields shutting down.
- 7:05It's obviously speaking about the Strait of Hormuz.
- 7:08There's an awful lot going on here that I'm.
- 7:10I'm struggling to see when I'm looking round, especially up
- 7:15here in Aberdeen, I'm sort of seeing sort of local
- 7:17commentators champion this and say, oh great, three years
- 7:21early, it's going to be a magic. But we saw all oil barrels,
- 7:25price of oil barrels hit over $80 this week.
- 7:30Is it likely that we're going to get six straight months of low
- 7:32prices? I mean, well, this is yeah.
- 7:34I mean, I think like it's a, it's a, it's a, it's like kind
- 7:36of the central question, isn't it, for the North Sea?
- 7:38I feel like, look, it, it, it clearly needs to happen for the
- 7:41for the producers in the North Sea.
- 7:43But, you know, looking at sort of current events, it's, it's
- 7:46hard. I mean, I, I feel like it's a
- 7:48question of like, how long does conflict last, right?
- 7:49And I feel like once that conflict ends, then obviously
- 7:55oil can start flowing again. There will be some damages to
- 7:58repair. But, you know, people can
- 7:59actually, you know, surprisingly resilient.
- 8:02I feel like if you look at like the attacks on Saudi Arabia and
- 8:05Abkaik a few years ago, the, the speed at which they were able to
- 8:08resume production was, was really startling.
- 8:10So I feel like, yes, the, the, it, it really just hinges on how
- 8:15long the conflict lasts. And, and that becomes a question
- 8:18of, you know, what are the US and Israeli aims?
- 8:21And also what is the, the amount of, of material that, that, that
- 8:25both sides can kind of bring to bear, right?
- 8:27I feel like how many, you know, Tomahawks is the US firing?
- 8:31How many, how many can it manufacture?
- 8:33What is the Iranian capacity? I've, I've heard some numbers
- 8:36suggesting that Iran has maybe one to three weeks of sort of
- 8:39missiles and then an unknown quantity of drones.
- 8:42And it feels like, you know, if Iran can keep that up, obviously
- 8:46as time goes on, pressure will mount on the US and Israel to,
- 8:50to, to bring things to an end. So look, the, the, the US and
- 8:53Israelis need a, a, a quick win. But as you know, but again, it's
- 8:56that question of like, what is a win, right?
- 8:58And it feels like at the moment, Iran is pretty defined.
- 9:02I mean, there's some discussions like, oh, you know, maybe there
- 9:04are, you know, sort of, you know, there have been some
- 9:05discussions. Maybe they were sort of reaching
- 9:07out in food sort of back channels, but that there has to
- 9:10be a sort of, you know, like a like a, a, a mutually agreeable
- 9:14kind of a way to resolve this problem.
- 9:16And at the moment it's hard to see how that happens.
- 9:18But these things will happen really fast, right?
- 9:20I feel like the war starts really quickly and it may end
- 9:24really quickly, but it's just hard to sort of pick a date.
- 9:26And as a result, I would hate to be in Rachel Reeves shoes trying
- 9:31to say, look, you know, yes, we're we're looking at high
- 9:35prices now, but then I'm expecting, you know, six months
- 9:38of low prices that will then allow us to to to move off the
- 9:42EPL and also, you know, provide that sort of industrial Philip
- 9:46the the clearly the UK needs. But it's, there are so many
- 9:49events happening in the world and I feel like Rachel Reeves's,
- 9:52you know, something of a of, of a victim to, to, to global
- 9:55shifts. Yeah.
- 9:56I mean, I, I do feel like the rumours we heard last week that
- 9:59All Reeves might scrap the windfall tax, it looks, you
- 10:02know, it looks likely that she's going to do it.
- 10:04In the spring statement, I was hearing folks sort of, you know,
- 10:08with slight insider knowledge saying maybe six, it was a 6040
- 10:11decision before the weekend. I feel like the weekend really
- 10:16shifted that in obviously in favour of not scrapping it or
- 10:19not bringing forward the end date anyway, that does it for
- 10:23this, but we are sticking around with Rachel Reeves and going
- 10:27down to London as editor Erika Askeland has been down in the
- 10:30big smoke. Hello, I'm Edreid, the editor of
- 10:33E Ford. E Ford is a membership community
- 10:36that brings together the entire UK energy supply chain, every
- 10:40hub, every sector, every stage. Our aim is to deliver growth to
- 10:44the energy sector, working with industry and policy makers to
- 10:47unlock the UK's opportunities and advantages.
- 10:51This is the movement to secure increased investment, improved
- 10:54policy making and better collaboration by providing our
- 10:57members with visibility, influence and access.
- 11:00Join me forward today. So as I said before the break,
- 11:05Erika Askeland, our news editor and fearless leader has been
- 11:09down in London at the Future of the North Sea event.
- 11:13And Speaking of that, that meeting that Rachel Reeves had
- 11:16with our North Sea industry leaders, she caught up with
- 11:20Offshore Energy's UK Chief Executive Dave Whitehouse to
- 11:23discuss the meeting. This was, this was just before
- 11:27Dave shot off to #11 So he's maybe a little bit candid about
- 11:31the outcomes. And then after that, she'll be
- 11:33speaking to Miles Allen, head of Atmospheric, Oceanic and
- 11:38Planetary Physics at the University of Oxford, discussing
- 11:43a simple solution to climate change that could rock the socks
- 11:47off ACORN. Dave Whitehouse, We're here in
- 11:50London and we're at a very interesting conference talking
- 11:55about some very interesting potential approaches for the
- 11:58North Sea. And then of course, yesterday we
- 12:01had a non decision yet. You're going to the Treasury
- 12:05later to talk potential decisions.
- 12:08So that's a lot to just kind of unpack.
- 12:10We've got only a few minutes, but I'm very nice to see you
- 12:13here. What are your thoughts?
- 12:16So I thought, so today's debate really was about the energy base
- 12:19in the UK and, and we've always advocated honestly, the UK
- 12:22should be proud of the resources of the people we have.
- 12:25If we get this right, by actually recognizing, building
- 12:28on our oil and gas skills and strengths, producing the oil and
- 12:31gas that we need as a country and using that as part of our
- 12:35build out of renewable energy and and supporting the build out
- 12:38of renewable energy. That path is the way for success
- 12:40for the UK where we create real economic growth, deliver joined
- 12:44up energy security and producing more of your own energy has
- 12:48never been more important. You had a very interesting
- 12:52discussion about, you know, why the North Sea matters to energy
- 12:58security. So is that message getting
- 13:02through? You know, I, I hope so.
- 13:04I think when you see, you know, unfortunate events in, in the
- 13:07Middle East, the UK becoming more reliant on the imports of,
- 13:10for example, liquefied national and natural gas from, from Qatar
- 13:14and other places, it is so important that we have our own
- 13:16domestic supply. So I, I think that that message
- 13:19does resonate, that does land with, I think with the, with the
- 13:22public. We must prioritise our own
- 13:24production, our own production of oil and gas, but also,
- 13:27alongside that, build out of renewable energy.
- 13:29Do you think before the spring statement, there was a lot of
- 13:33discussion with industry going on in Treasury?
- 13:36Do you think the war has changed things because oil prices are
- 13:40inevitable? Oil and gas prices are going up.
- 13:42They are going to have an impact on our costs.
- 13:45And do you think they're just swiveling about changing policy
- 13:48on the hoof? Are you worried about, you know,
- 13:51kind of this has ruined our chance to see the energy profits
- 13:54Levy scratch. Actually the, you know, we are
- 13:57always making the, we're always making the case actually to do
- 14:01the right thing, what we think is the right thing for the UK
- 14:04and for us. The energy profits levy is
- 14:06holding back the investment, investment in oil and gas that
- 14:08we need, supporting jobs that we need.
- 14:10And actually what the government brought forward last November
- 14:13was a new mechanism, this oil gas price mechanism, which
- 14:17actually is a mechanism that means when oil prices high, when
- 14:20gas prices high, we continue to pay high levels of tax.
- 14:23But we think it's fair and we think it would attract
- 14:25investment. We're going to continue to make
- 14:27the case. We want to see that implemented
- 14:29now. We implemented, now we see it
- 14:31unlocking significant investment supporting jobs up and down the
- 14:33country. And presumably, in the wake of
- 14:36war, it could probably be good news for the Treasury, too.
- 14:40You know, I think what what Events has has highlighted once
- 14:43again is the UK now is the time where we are prioritizing our
- 14:47own production, our own production of energy, our own
- 14:50production of oil and gas and renewable energy in a volatile
- 14:53world. That has to be the path of the
- 14:54world. Thank you so much, David.
- 14:56You're so patient with us. I always appreciate your insight
- 14:59into this. Thank you so much.
- 15:02We're here with Professor Miles Allen from the University of
- 15:05Oxford. And you're a specialist in
- 15:08atmospheric physics, is that correct?
- 15:10That's right, yes. Now you had some fascinating
- 15:15points raised about what the world can do about removing
- 15:21carbon through the energy system.
- 15:26Well, the main point people need to get their minds around is
- 15:29that ultimately the climate problem is not actually
- 15:33primarily an energy problem. It's a carbon management
- 15:36problem. Now, at the moment, you know,
- 15:40people need to accept that we are going to generate more
- 15:42carbon dioxide than we can afford to dump in the
- 15:44atmosphere. We may have done so already.
- 15:46I mean, so, so we're going to have to get rid of carbon
- 15:48dioxide permanently on a planetary scale.
- 15:52And it's a, it's a huge challenge that we're not really
- 15:55stepping up to at the moment. At the moment, we put back
- 15:58underground about .1% of the carbon atoms we extract out of
- 16:02the ground, OK, So, and most of that's for EOR.
- 16:06So that's going to go up to 100% if we're actually going to stop
- 16:10fossil fuels from causing global warming.
- 16:12Now, if we were to do that, that would probably make, that would
- 16:17certainly make producing fossil fuels more expensive.
- 16:21And so it would either make them more costly or less profitable
- 16:24or perhaps both. And so that's where the rest of
- 16:28the energy industry comes in, in helping facilitate the
- 16:32transition to a net 0 oil and gas industry.
- 16:35But at the end of the day, if we don't get to a net 0 oil and gas
- 16:39industry, and we also need the coal industry for the net to be
- 16:42net 0. But I, I do wonder whether the
- 16:46coal industry would still exist if it was required to be net
- 16:48zero. I think that that's probably not
- 16:50the main focus here. It's oil and gas that, that,
- 16:53that really matters. If the oil and gas industry
- 16:56doesn't itself become net zero, then to some extent it doesn't
- 17:00really matter what else we do because we'll still have a
- 17:03problem. So, so that's, that's the the
- 17:05way I like to reframe the issue and to really focus it on how do
- 17:10we fix this particular problem, this particular product that's
- 17:14causing these two particular products that are causing global
- 17:16warming. Yeah.
- 17:18How feasible or simple or difficult is it to make EU KS
- 17:24oil and gas industry net 0? Well, I was hearing from David
- 17:27Winehouse today that actually we're quite likely to be a net
- 17:30zero basin in the North Sea in the mid twenty 30s anyway if we
- 17:34just carry on the way we're going.
- 17:35But we're not making a fuss about that.
- 17:37We're not saying make sure the North sees a net zero basin as a
- 17:41condition for continuing to extract oil and gas.
- 17:44If we were to do that, we would massively simplify the public
- 17:47debate and draw a lot of the sting out of it because people
- 17:50would say, well, OK, is this field viable as a net 0 field or
- 17:55not economically? And if it is, then there's no
- 17:59reason not to license it and allow the production to go
- 18:01forward if it, you know, it becomes a commercial decision.
- 18:06It doesn't become a a sort of global environmental conscience
- 18:11decision. And, and, and that's where
- 18:14ultimately for the world, the oil and oil and gas industry
- 18:19needs to get to. And Britain could really show a
- 18:21way forward here. We could make a huge difference
- 18:24by simply showing what a net 0 oil and gas industry looks like.
- 18:27Yeah. But is that feasible?
- 18:31You know, it sounds like a very expensive problem, and we're
- 18:34already saying that. I know it's too expensive to
- 18:37exploit the North Sea. It's too expensive to, you know,
- 18:41for energy users. But you kind of suggested that
- 18:46maybe it wasn't as complicated as we thought.
- 18:49Well, if it was done by a requirement on the industry
- 18:52rather than a subsidy from government, I'm 100% confident
- 18:55the industry would find much cheaper ways of doing it than
- 18:58they are at the moment. I mean, the, at the moment, if,
- 19:00if something is done as a subsidy service, then it, it, it
- 19:03always ends up expensive. That's just the way things seem
- 19:06to work. So the, the, the, the, the, the,
- 19:11the one thing I, I would absolutely do is this, this
- 19:14requirement to get rid of CO2 would have to be applied to
- 19:17everybody, including importers. So you wouldn't just impose it
- 19:20on domestic producers. You'd require anybody bringing
- 19:22fossil carbon atoms into the UK to start to get rid of the CO2
- 19:26they generate. I emphasize start to because you
- 19:28wouldn't require 100% disposal overnight.
- 19:31Of course not. That would that would be in both
- 19:34impossible and ridiculously expensive.
- 19:36But we need to get to 100% disposal eventually, at some
- 19:39point in the second-half of this century.
- 19:40So over the next few decades we need to be progressively
- 19:43increasing the fraction of CO2 we dispose of.
- 19:47And we could do that and we can do that affordably. 10% capture
- 19:50would add an imperceptible amount to the cost of fossil
- 19:53fuels in the UK and it would create, at no cost to the
- 19:56taxpayer, a world leading carbon capture and storage industry.
- 20:01That sounds like a very good idea.
- 20:03And up in my neck of the woods in Peterhead, of course, we have
- 20:08a project called Acorn. It's kind of running aground.
- 20:11It feels and. And it shouldn't be.
- 20:13We, we need it, OK, But the point is when I fill my car with
- 20:17petrol and I do still fill my car with petrol, I should be
- 20:20contributing to Peterhead because I'm benefiting from
- 20:23continued use of fossil fuels. And yet the way we, the way we
- 20:29sort of incentivise carbon capture in the UK, it's only the
- 20:34plants that are particularly required by the ETS or whatever
- 20:38to capture their CO2 that would contribute to Peterhead that
- 20:41would end up paying for that project.
- 20:42And that's what's difficult. That's, that's those, those
- 20:45plants often have very low margins.
- 20:47And so on the additional cost, you know, it would add, you
- 20:50know, a 10% capture requirements applied across the board would
- 20:55add a, you know, a few pence to the cost of litre petrol.
- 20:57If people were really stressed about that, they could always
- 21:00bring down the taxes to compensate, You know, it,
- 21:03they're going to lose tax revenue anyway as we electrify.
- 21:06So the government's going to have to work out what to do
- 21:07about that. So I don't see why the the the
- 21:13vast majority of fossil fuel users who are not particularly
- 21:16sensitive to fossil fuel prices shouldn't pay for the
- 21:20development of carbon capture and storage.
- 21:22At the moment we impose the full cost of development of carbon
- 21:25capture and storage on a very small number of players, often
- 21:28who are working at really small type margins.
- 21:31And those are the players who say, well, you know, we just
- 21:33can't afford this technology, we're going to move somewhere
- 21:35else. Whereas if you had a blanket
- 21:37requirement on the entire economy to get rid of a
- 21:41progressively larger amount of the CO2 generated by the fossil
- 21:44fuels we use, then the cost would be spread across everybody
- 21:48and would be much more manageable.
- 21:49And crucially, those companies that are producing CO2, nice
- 21:53pure, clean CO2 that is cheap to inject, they would actually be
- 21:57able to sell it instead of being penalized for producing it.
- 22:00And that would be transformative.
- 22:01Perhaps you could even imagine a future where Britain would
- 22:04become a great place to locate a fertilizer plant because you
- 22:07could sell your CO2. Imagine that at the moment we're
- 22:11driving fertilizer plants away by charging them for their CO2.
- 22:15We could do the exactly the opposite and make CO2 into a
- 22:18valuable commodity. Well, I hope sometimes the
- 22:23government gives the impression that it doesn't listen very
- 22:26well. I hope they're listening to you.
- 22:27Thank you ever so much for sharing your thoughts.
- 22:30Thank you. Cheers.
- 22:32No, we're zigzagging up and down the country because just after
- 22:36this we're waiting fly all the way back up to Aberdeen to
- 22:39discuss Wood and its sales process.
- 22:44Be a part of the conversation shaping Scotland's investment
- 22:48future. The Scottish National Investment
- 22:51Bank Conference 2026, in association with Energy Boys and
- 22:55The Press and Journal, brings together investors, business
- 22:58leaders and policy makers. We're driving economics, social
- 23:03and environmental impact across Scotland.
- 23:06This is your opportunity to hear directly from those deploying
- 23:10mission LED capital. If you're serious about
- 23:13investing with purpose, whether you're raising capital,
- 23:16allocating it or shaping policy, this is the room you need to be
- 23:20in. Get your tickets online today.
- 23:26So the trials and tribulations of would have been well
- 23:29documented and anyone who's been a long term listener of energy
- 23:32Voice out loud will be all too familiar with what's happening
- 23:36with them this week. We got a couple of updates
- 23:39back-to-back actually that I feel like sort of give us some
- 23:43insight into the the process that's taking place.
- 23:47So the day that this, this podcast goes out, which is
- 23:51Friday the, the 6th of March 2026, would will be appearing at
- 23:56a court hearing to sort of sign off the, the the last of its
- 24:01tick box exercises before Sedara is able to, to complete its
- 24:06deal. However, the day after it
- 24:09announced this, the Financial Conduct Authority sort of piped
- 24:13up and concluded it's, it's review of, of the, the company.
- 24:19You may remember that they launched an investigation in
- 24:22July last year and it's resulted in a a near 13,000,000 LB slap
- 24:28on the wrist for the engineering firm.
- 24:31Now that has been dropped by about 30% because would have
- 24:36said fair cop Yep, you've got us.
- 24:38That's, that's understandable. I do kind of wish speeding
- 24:42tickets were like that, you know?
- 24:43Oh, yeah, fair enough, officer. I was, I was driving too fast.
- 24:47Now your fines 30% less. But that's not how things work.
- 24:51It does in the world of a big business, though.
- 24:53So essentially, wood has been sorry, hauled in front of the
- 24:59FCA for a quote, inaccurate financial reports.
- 25:04It said that it made accounting judgements that were
- 25:07inappropriately influenced by its desire to maintain
- 25:09previously stated financial results.
- 25:12Now this was in relation to its full year results, 2022 and 2023
- 25:18financial results, as well as its half year results in 24,
- 25:23which if you remember were delayed somewhat as the company
- 25:26was going through some financial turmoil.
- 25:29A lot going on there. Michael, you've, you've been
- 25:31following this sag. It's so much so that every time
- 25:34I write about Wood, I link back to that timeline that you've
- 25:37you've pulled together for us of everything that's happening with
- 25:40Sedara and Wood. Do do we think that the ends
- 25:43insight Ashley Kelty over at Panmure Liberum certainly does.
- 25:46Yeah, I think that we've spent the the whole process up until,
- 25:51and I'm going to say right until the very end, hedging our bets
- 25:54and being, look, it's not a done deal yet.
- 25:56As if there's going to be this sort of I object at the wedding
- 26:01moment, someone's going to come in to screaming, no, you can't
- 26:05always. Going to come back in and say no
- 26:06I want to pay for you. Exactly.
- 26:10You know, it does feel like things are on rails and we're
- 26:13moving towards an end. I don't know if this this is the
- 26:17sort of thing that feels like in an in, like you said, the, the
- 26:23world that doesn't belong to big business where we can't
- 26:25negotiate our our speeding tickets.
- 26:28The this might be the sort of thing the last bit to derail the
- 26:31deal for if I were buying a company and I found out that
- 26:35they are some of the, the finances on which you're basing
- 26:39the deal of being inaccurate. But there's the bit of me that
- 26:43sort of feels like, well, did they know ahead of time?
- 26:48This is pure speculation. Well, that's like, you know
- 26:50what? It was a speculation on the part
- 26:52of Ashley Kelty as well. I mean, maybe slightly, slightly
- 26:54more informed. They don't mean to take a jab at
- 26:56you, Michael, but more build up a friend of the program from
- 27:00time you're liver him as he was. Yeah.
- 27:02He was essentially saying the same thing.
- 27:04You know, Sadara will have been involved in these talks.
- 27:08This wouldn't have come as a surprise to it and you know, the
- 27:13the bank creditors, you know, that would are in debt to
- 27:18they'll know about this too. So it's a case of as as far as
- 27:22Kelty was a was concerned, the bank's not going to object to
- 27:26anything because they're saying, well, this is the best way that
- 27:28we're going to make our money back and for Sadara, well, they
- 27:32already knew. So maybe just a just an
- 27:35interesting situation for that slight stumbling block.
- 27:39I'm. Going to throw in a a suggestion
- 27:41that so Sedara is going to pay 35 PA share right?
- 27:48Just checking the price this morning.
- 27:52Wood is trading at about 2829 PA share.
- 27:56That suggests that there's still some uncertainty in the market
- 27:59about right. Because if, if, if everyone has
- 28:01agreed that it was a done deal, then obviously you would just
- 28:04buy wood now and like the price and then sell it when, when,
- 28:08when the Sadara deal completes, right?
- 28:09Then you just make an instant kind of a profit, right?
- 28:11Like it's a fairly straightforward thing.
- 28:13So I think there is still an uncertainty premium that is kind
- 28:16of baked into that share price. So I feel like, yes, it feels
- 28:19like, you know, we're clearly making progress, but until the
- 28:22deal's done, the deal's not done.
- 28:23Well, that's very true. I mean, I I am, I am waiting for
- 28:26a for Yeah, as as Michael described the sorry stop the
- 28:31wedding I object moment. But it it's it's it's such an
- 28:36interesting saga, isn't it? Because if you, if you thought
- 28:40about this a few years ago, you wouldn't have thought that Wood
- 28:43would have found themselves in this particular situation, maybe
- 28:46pre COVID pandemic and it's followed this sort of way of
- 28:50Petrofac and to a certain extent, obviously different
- 28:53situations with business dealings and so on and so forth.
- 28:57But two massive service firms kind of found themselves in
- 29:01financial doldrums. And yes, Sadara, Sadara's it, it
- 29:06seemed like they were getting a bargain and presume they still
- 29:09are. You know, they'll think they're
- 29:10getting a bargain. But as you say, the share, the
- 29:12shareholders maybe don't think so just yet.
- 29:14And it's, it's interesting because after they announced
- 29:18the, the court hearing would take place on Friday, and that
- 29:23was on, I believe Tuesday, they said that the share prices did
- 29:27tick up. If you if you go on the LSE, I'm
- 29:29sure you can see, see that funky wee graph that everyone loves
- 29:33looking at. So, you know, I think there it
- 29:36did sort of provide a little bit of surety to the market this is
- 29:39taking place. But it's, yeah, it does feel
- 29:43like nothing is set in stone with this deal, with this deal.
- 29:47But then we had we did have last year, the shareholder is voting
- 29:52quite decisively in in favour of this this takeover.
- 29:57So it feels like is the only person that could pull the plug
- 30:00now Sudara. And if so, can we see any reason
- 30:05why they I? Was wondering what are the the
- 30:07object like who's objecting who's coming into the wedding?
- 30:11Is it? I don't think of Paul's coming
- 30:14in It was a good joke. No, but I think it's no one's
- 30:17going to come in to object. It's theoretically I'd say it's
- 30:20all in wooden Sedara to to get. Cold feet.
- 30:23Well, that's and you know, they I'm glad you said cold feet
- 30:25actually, except reminds me of it again.
- 30:27I'm leaning very heavily on Ashley this week.
- 30:30But yeah, Kelty is said said the same thing, you know, but if if
- 30:35they were to get cold feet, it feels like they would have done
- 30:37it before now. There's a lot of due diligence
- 30:40obviously taking place already. It would be interesting to speak
- 30:44to Zadara though, because obviously when you when you're
- 30:48buying a company, you get your due diligence time, you get time
- 30:51to look at the books and you know, if if the books were
- 30:54inaccurate. Now that's quite interesting.
- 30:57But does this all relate back to this is going to get very
- 31:00speculative, but I think it's interesting to discuss.
- 31:03You'll remember that Ian Torrance, now CEO of the company
- 31:11was was brought in after some CV discrepancies with the the
- 31:17company's old CFO. And I think I described it at
- 31:21one point as ACV mishap. And that ended up, yeah, he
- 31:26ended up coming in as interim CFO and now he's kind of found
- 31:30his himself in the top job after Chemical Martins left.
- 31:33But these these reports kind of maybe excluding the the delayed
- 31:392024 results do kind of fall under the previous the previous
- 31:44CFO. Do do we think that maybe this
- 31:47is the the scapegoat? It's just that, well, we we
- 31:49dealt with that problem, it's gone I.
- 31:51Mean if you were looking for a scapegoat, you couldn't do do
- 31:54much worse or much better. But that so that's it.
- 31:59So I mean, the deal is the deal is set to come to come to an
- 32:02end. You know, we're, we're
- 32:03predicting in quote, the coming days that the deal will will
- 32:07conclude. I, you know, I was speaking to,
- 32:10to Wood this week and it seems like, you know, we'll get an
- 32:14announcement maybe next week about something, whether that is
- 32:17just the results of the court hearing that's taking place on
- 32:20the day this episode goes live or maybe something wider.
- 32:23Ed, you're looking like you. Might speak.
- 32:25Yeah. Sorry, I've got to come in an
- 32:27apology, right? I feel I've misled you.
- 32:29And of course our listeners. I said Cesar had offered 35 P
- 32:33That was the earlier offer. They cut it to 30P in sort of
- 32:37August, I think of last year. So I feel like just wanted to
- 32:40clear that up. So I feel like it's still,
- 32:43there's still area of uncertainty, but I feel like,
- 32:45you know, the, the market is getting closer to.
- 32:47Agree. 2 pence per share is a considerably less wider golf
- 32:52than 7 pence. Yeah, 100%.
- 32:55So maybe, yeah, it's an interesting time.
- 32:57I feel like maybe this time next week we can have an announcement
- 33:01of deal done. It feels like this sag is coming
- 33:06to an end and I'm going to be able to stop writing about it.
- 33:11That does it for this week, unless Mike wants to come in.
- 33:16I mean if I mean I suppose this is now the time for me to run
- 33:20off and buy 100 shares of wood at 29 P and then sell them for
- 33:2330P and make that pound. Profit.
- 33:25You know what I'd love to I'd love to encourage this Michael,
- 33:28but I do feel like it's probably irresponsible of us as business
- 33:32journalists reporting on wood to to buy shares and and the
- 33:36company but episode violations we're.
- 33:39Not, I mean, yeah, I believe the code of ethics says we're not
- 33:43allowed to, so you should have kept that under.
- 33:47Your house good. That is absolutely fine 'cause I
- 33:48have no idea how to actually go about buying shares.
- 33:53Fair enough. Well, do you know what, maybe it
- 33:55may be Michael's way to go watch The Wolf of Wall Street or
- 33:58something after this episode. But that does it for this this
- 34:01week. So thank you very much, Ed and
- 34:03Michael for joining me and thank you very much for listening.
- 34:07If you'd like to listen to us again, well, we'll be back at
- 34:09the same time, same place next week.