Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Forcing Positive Thinking On Clients and Other Bad Therapists
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails, what do you say? Yeah, anonymous annual patron,
- 0:03she says, I had my new favorite worst therapy session today. I've been
- 0:08shopping around for a while, so as a client, I think so I
- 0:13had my new favorite worst therapy session today. I disclosed my borderline diagnosis,
- 0:19and after asking a few diagnostic type questions from the therapist, she told me
- 0:24today was the day I was going to make a life change via positive thinking
- 0:30and to just push away the negativity. I told her I frequently feel suicidal
- 0:35and get depressed, and she reiterated that today was the day all of that
- 0:40was going to change through positive thinking. Apparently she's been a therapist for over
- 0:44twenty years, and for twenty years she's been about as therapeutic as a Reddit
- 0:49thread. Little does she know, I've been listening to psychology and saddle my
- 0:56entire adult life and I'm not settling for that shit. Laugh l lmao.
- 1:00Thanks for reading. Any thoughts on that, Bob. Yeah, I'm the
- 1:06power of positive thinking now, I'm not a fan. So yeah, just
- 1:11based on what's written here, I would not have continued with that therapist or
- 1:15do you think they were coming from? There's just the sentence today is the
- 1:19day where your changer. You know, that's just a little bit cult of
- 1:22personality, kind of forceful, sort of blown smoke, you know, like,
- 1:26nah, man that I don't I think of a little bit more humility
- 1:30is in order. Yeah. Yeah, I've met people and therapists included,
- 1:34who have this simplistic, dogmatic belief that thinking positive will solve everything. Can
- 1:44thinking positive help? Sure? Absolutely, data shows that I can attest to
- 1:48that. Yeah. And can you have a form of therapy that involves this?
- 1:52Yeah, there's versions of humanistic therapy. Positive psychology arguably is in this
- 1:57direction. But there's nothing good about any form of therapy, And no,
- 2:01no expert would recommend that you discount someone's experience, especially when they're pushing back
- 2:07a little bit, by just man handling the client and saying like, well,
- 2:12you just need to think positive, essentially blaming the client yea for their
- 2:16problems and simplifying their problems to a simple choice to quote unquote think positive.
- 2:23It is. It's so sweepingly dismissive. Yeah, I mean it's akin to
- 2:27someone's spouse dies and someone comes to therapy and you're like, you just have
- 2:30to think positive. I mean, that's literally what you're doing, especially as
- 2:34someone with borderline who has been through a lot of lacial trauma. So yeah,
- 2:38now, having said that, if the therapist had said, well,
- 2:42here's my thing, and I get that you're going through this, and I
- 2:46understand and I've been there for suffering as real, and here's what I've found
- 2:51to be helpful if you would like to do. You know, this is
- 2:53part of that working alliance about collaborating on goals, collaborating on tasks. It's
- 2:57very important is that for any client out there with your therapist, you should
- 3:02know, either in a concrete way or in a mutual understanding way of what
- 3:08you are doing in therapy to meet the goal. And you should also agree
- 3:14on the goal. And some people are like, well, I don't know.
- 3:16I feel like I'm a therapist that doesn't do goals or something like this,
- 3:21and I just think you're an idiot, like conceptualized what you believe.
- 3:25Yeah, you can have a very floppy goal of say, I'm here to
- 3:30help people grow. Okay, how do you know that you're helping someone grow?
- 3:36Right? I'm guessing you could literally just ask the client is this helping
- 3:38you grow? And the client would say, yeah, and that's that's a
- 3:42goal. Yeah, and then you have to have an agreement on the tasks
- 3:46to reach that goal. It could be anything that you collaborate on in therapy.
- 3:51You could draw art, you could talk about your childhood, you could
- 3:54talk positive, you could try to think pot but you have to have agreement.
- 3:59To just force a task on a client without the client understanding where you're
- 4:03coming from or literally wanting to do it to begin with is counter to the
- 4:08standard of practice. Yeah. But yeah, so you know, I'm glad
- 4:13that you, Anonymous Annuel Patron, were able to feel empowered enough to see
- 4:17through the bullshit. If I think what you're saying is giving your life experiences
- 4:21and listening to this podcast, you know you deserve better and you can tell
- 4:26when therapy is bad and when it's good. Right, Yeah, exactly,
- 4:30Yeah, because so many people out there, they're just like, well,
- 4:31I guess this is what you do now with this kind of task. Might
- 4:36one do this sometimes in terms of helping clients to think positive? Yeah.
- 4:43I think it's a humanistic orientation that this therapist is operating from, of being
- 4:47in the here and now, and it can be kind of powerful that you
- 4:51try at least for a time. It's kind of a mindfulness thing too,
- 4:55or what you focus on that. Okay, let's just take half an hour
- 5:00and as intrusive thoughts or thoughts enter the mind that have to do with shame
- 5:06or past experiences or memories that plague you notice them, don't fight them,
- 5:13but don't don't let them take hold, don't let them set up camp.
- 5:17Just allow them to wash past you, and then return to this other focus,
- 5:24whether it's breathing or nothing, or a mantra or thinking positive or being
- 5:30in the here and now? You know where am I? What am I
- 5:32doing? Am I sitting on a chair? The wind is blowing outside,
- 5:36it's sunny. There's a lot of power in that. And that's a very
- 5:43humanistic idea here and now and it can help, But you have to explain
- 5:48it to the client. The client has to want to do it, and
- 5:54you don't just forge ahead with that model. And also you don't discount someone's
- 6:00feelings along the way. I should hope not all right. Next email patron
- 6:05Jenny from Minnesota. She says, would you ever be willing to talk about
- 6:09ethical dilemmas that people knew to the field experience in early career years, specifically
- 6:15how to handle when you see superiors or colleagues doing things that seemed to be
- 6:19lacking ethical consideration. Bob, just chiming in here. What do you think
- 6:25about that? Oh? I remember being in a supervision of group super group
- 6:29consultation at the clinic I used to work at when I got out of graduate
- 6:32school, and one of the therapists was complaining about the client that they just
- 6:36started with who has borderline symptoms, and was describing the borderline symptoms like this
- 6:42person's a pain in the ass and you just hold your eyes. And I
- 6:47said to them, well, yeah, but isn't that why they're coming here?
- 6:53Oh you said it? Oh yeah, yeah, I said it kindly.
- 6:56I don't think it would have been useful or you know, it would
- 7:00not have been cool to attack, but to gently point it out. Yeah
- 7:03for sure. Yeah. Yeah, what did they do? They ignored me?
- 7:11Did anyone else acknowledge it? Wow? It was the vibe of the
- 7:15consulates. So this is how many therapists are in the room, and what
- 7:19was the vibe of the conversation. So you have these polar opposites. You
- 7:24have the person presenting that is being judgmental and not thinking there's nothing wrong with
- 7:30being a therapist and inventing for a bit, but you return to differentiation.
- 7:35You returned to the standard of practice. But I've been there. I rolled
- 7:40my eyes because I've been There's so many times I can think of five moments
- 7:45in my career of that was exactly like that. Where I'm in consultation with
- 7:49other clinicians and someone is presenting on someone with borderline, whether they labeled it
- 7:55borderline or not, or something of this ilk where it's clear from meat my
- 8:00perspective that what they're describing is the client has relational traumas is being triggered in
- 8:05various contexts, including therapy, including by the therapist, and the therapist doesn't
- 8:09see it and is either having counter transference or just out of ignorance. They
- 8:16react as if the client is not a client they you know, like a
- 8:22typical example that's kind of extreme that will be provided in academia would be you
- 8:28have a borderline client who threatens to sue you, for example. It doesn't
- 8:31happen very often, especially if you manage the relationship well. I mean,
- 8:35as someone that specializes in people with borderline, I can I don't know if
- 8:37anyone ever threatened to sue me, But you talk to the average clinician and
- 8:43they'll be like, oh, yeah, all borderline people will threatened to sue
- 8:46you. I've had borderline clients that were threatening to sue other people. So
- 8:52I'm you know, it's not like but if you manage their relationship well enough
- 8:56and you know what you're doing, then you're the true hearing that was involved
- 9:01didn't get to that level. Yeah, I guess anyway, someone will be
- 9:07talking about how well, maybe let's downgrade it. So you know, someone
- 9:09in consultation will say, yeah, I have this client who has some suicidal
- 9:15thoughts sometimes and she also will cut at times. She has a history of
- 9:20that, so you know, I'm starting to hear some signs and her relationships
- 9:24aren't going well, and so I was trying to help her and she just
- 9:28started She just folded her arms and said that she didn't want to talk to
- 9:31you me anymore. And I did my best to try to tell her like,
- 9:37look, I'm just trying to help you, and she just stormed out
- 9:39of my office. And so you know, this is bullshit, Like she's
- 9:43obviously not ready for therapy, and I don't know why she even came into
- 9:48this office. End of story. Yeah, And I'm thinking from my possession,
- 9:52I'm like, is it possible that the reason why she's in therapy was
- 9:58played out before you? Yeah? And all you had to do was show
- 10:03that you cared, you know, and that you're a safe person. Like,
- 10:07in spite of her being triggered me, did you not learn that fundamental
- 10:11of change? And it's more that than the opposite, right, I mean
- 10:18in your DBT group, but they would all understand obviously they understood borderline.
- 10:22But in a non specialized rabble of therapists, I would say it's ninety percent
- 10:30of time if someone presents on someone that has a personal disorder, it will
- 10:35go like that, right yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yuck.
- 10:39Yeah. So what patron Jenny is asking is how do you handle well,
- 10:43have you ever seen a superior or a colleague doing other unethical things that would
- 10:48pique your the possibility of reporting them or talking to them? No? No,
- 10:54I mean I might disagree with somebody and they might be judgmental. I
- 10:58don't think that rises to the level of reportability. It is definitely something to
- 11:03be addressed, Like, come on, that's we get a change. But
- 11:07you know, people like I couldn't be argued though that it is reportable or
- 11:11at least you know that. The way that we're taught is, and it
- 11:16says this explicitly in our codes, is that you go to the unless it's
- 11:20something really egregious, you go to the clinician first and give them an opportunity
- 11:26to change, and then if they don't, then you go to their superior
- 11:31or the state licensing board, depending on the situation, of course. But
- 11:35so I would say that what you did was trying to help that clinician in
- 11:41the moment. Yeah, I was surprised that you did that because I usually
- 11:46am too afraid to say anything. Oh yeah, because I don't trust the
- 11:50room like you could argue in that moment that you just harmed your relationships with
- 11:56at least that person and maybe other people by trying and it doesn't change anything,
- 12:01and it just hurts you, you know what I mean. So that's
- 12:05usually the call that I make. Is Like now, in today's mind,
- 12:11given my position, I probably would I would hope I would. You probably
- 12:16would, But in the past I would. I didn't have that power,
- 12:20I didn't have that political power. I didn't have that clout, and so
- 12:24I would just be gritting my teeth and digging my fingernails into my hand under
- 12:30the table. You know, you could argue it wasn't ethical violation or something
- 12:33unethical was happening when something yeah, it's not okay, yeah, because it
- 12:39is a primary principle within the ethical code to benefit the client and to be
- 12:45competent in your job, and that person was exhibiting neither of those, right,
- 12:52But have you seen anything else that you know, like where you're like,
- 12:54whoa, I need to report that person? Oh? Nothing, sex
- 12:58with a No. No, I've never seen that. Bad paperwork. No,
- 13:05well no, I've never seen that either confidentiality breaches. I've seen that.
- 13:13I've seen people do that. I have never seen that. No,
- 13:18I haven't. It's funny I haven't. But don't get me wrong. I
- 13:22wasn't. I wasn't happy with the degree of professionalism or competence among the therapists
- 13:30at large at that agency, Like I didn't think that. I have this
- 13:35perspective now that the general vibe of the place is overwhelming burnout and people were
- 13:43behaving in ways that are consistent with overwhelming burnout, which means that there are
- 13:48lapses in areas where there ought not to have been. There's a difference,
- 13:54though, because you and I can be overwhelmed and burnt out and vent and
- 14:00upset and lose empathy temporarily, or we know we're having a hard time accessing
- 14:09it, we still know that compassion is there, and we know in the
- 14:13moment, at least at times when we're having that burnout, that we're in
- 14:20a state of burnout. I think that culture permitted it, which is one
- 14:24of the reasons I'm very grateful that I left. What do you mean.
- 14:28I think that there was a certain level of entitlement to misery and to whatever,
- 14:35you know, whatever fucking consequences that is on the world around me,
- 14:39So be it, and I think I would I see this in good clinicians.
- 14:45They simply hold regard for their client as central period. Right. So
- 14:52yeah, venting, frustration, burnout, yeah, all part of the thing.
- 14:56But those just get talked about his problems to be solved, not as
- 15:00like, oh, yeah, you have a right to that and we'll just
- 15:03leave you there. Yeah, what do we blame for that? What's the
- 15:07cause of this? When I think about that place, I think it was
- 15:11run poorly by people who were interested more in their success than in the well
- 15:18being and welfare of the business. End of that got over emphasized, and
- 15:24so they would squeeze as much out of the therapist as they could. They
- 15:31were funded and the whole, the whole thing, I think was set up
- 15:35for that to be the case, and so a degree of misery and cynicism
- 15:41grew and pervaded. And I don't see that in other organizations, even ones
- 15:46that aren't so well funded, because there's a dedication to a mission. Well,
- 15:52yeah, I think so. You were in that scenario. You were
- 15:56being squeezed as a as a labor and you were overwhelmed and maybe burnt out
- 16:02of time. Sometime you still kept your eye on the ball. I made
- 16:06a deal with myself. I said, you are a volunteer. Here you
- 16:10get to this is what you get. You get a paycheck in exchange for
- 16:15clinical hours, supervision, move towards license, your goals, and an opportunity
- 16:22to work with people in a way that you want. That is a fair
- 16:26exchange. You don't have to like the paperwork, you don't have to like
- 16:29the paycheck, you don't have to like the bureaucracy. You don't have to
- 16:32like the attitude, but you are a volunteer. You are not a victim.
- 16:37And that was a really important shift for me. I think I adopted
- 16:38that about a year or two into working there, because I didn't want to
- 16:45fall into that nonsense. I'm trying to understand. Are you saying that the
- 16:49shift and perspective was that you said, Okay, look, I'm here to
- 16:53get paid to do a job, and I'll do that job, and I'm
- 17:00another thing, which I volunteer to actually help these people. Yeah that okay,
- 17:06I was a volunteer there. I was not. Nobody made me do
- 17:08that. You had to add this other inspiration or identity beyond what was being
- 17:17modeled to you and what was being emphasized maybe by the organization. Yeah,
- 17:21otherwise I would have crumbled. Right, So why did you do that and
- 17:25the others didn't? I don't know. I blame culture, mentorship and teachers
- 17:32and professors. So I have seen this where you will have a professor who
- 17:38has they come from. It's almost like there are different pedigrees or something,
- 17:45you know. I would see a professor as a colleague or even as a
- 17:52student, and they would be of that sort where they didn't have that passion,
- 18:00that deep dedication to humanity. It was a job, and the clients
- 18:07were, you know, at best treated as people that you cared for,
- 18:12sort of but average baseline, the clients were kind of an annoyance, you
- 18:19know, and the and and sometimes the clients were ridiculed, you know,
- 18:27maybe even globally you know, well, you know, clients sometimes they're always
- 18:32asking for more shit all the time. They're always calling me, you know,
- 18:36and when you have a professor like that, and the students are being
- 18:41mentored along those lines and not inspired because it's tempting, you know, it's
- 18:47stressful. Community mental health is very stressful, unfair to the therapists and the
- 18:52clients for that matter. And it's not the fault of the mental health agencies.
- 18:55It's the fault of the politicians and by extension, the voters for not
- 19:00voting for politicians or pressuring politicians to allocate funds or raise taxes to pay enough
- 19:07for these services such that the therapists can instead of seeing forty two clients a
- 19:15week, they maybe they only have to see thirty clients. Will still be
- 19:18hard, but it's a little bit more hannibal anyway. So you know,
- 19:22they're overworked, and I get that, but and you want to vent about
- 19:26it. But if you have no mentorship, so so you're getting that from
- 19:30your professor, and say, just by the luck of the draw, all
- 19:33your instructors are either like that or they don't exhibit what we're talking about.
- 19:38Then you go to your agency, and luck of the draw, most of
- 19:42if not all, of your supervisors and colleagues are also like that. So
- 19:48you don't know any better. You don't know, you don't you don't know
- 19:51any different. Yeah. I also think that some people get into the field
- 19:53for a very different reason than you and I got into it, you know,
- 19:57for the money, yeah maybe, or for the prestige really, or
- 20:03because they didn't know what else they wanted to do. Yeah, yeah,
- 20:07I've I've met some and that can be a good thing or a bad thing.
- 20:11It can be a bad thing in the way we're talking about. But
- 20:15I have someone that I know, a colleague, a psychologist who does CBT
- 20:21only and getting to know the way that he sees the world. He just
- 20:26he recognizes that they're a therapist like you and me, and he values that
- 20:29and he thinks it's great. But for him and He hopefully tells his clients
- 20:33this the Pinna therapy, that he is there to do a model of therapy
- 20:40and if the client doesn't want to do it, then they don't want to
- 20:42do it. And he doesn't want to learn anything new, and he doesn't
- 20:45want to get into complicated areas. He just wants to provide his worksheet based
- 20:52cognitive therapy and behavior therapy and finds that that's good enough for him. And
- 20:59then he goes home from work and he doesn't think about therapy ever. He
- 21:02just you know, does other things. And it's a job, you know,
- 21:03it's fine. It's it's like any other kind of thing that you do,
- 21:07Like maybe accountants are similar, you know, it's like, yeah,
- 21:10it's fine. I go to work and do my thing and I like it,
- 21:12and it's it's it's okay, and I go home. Right, So
- 21:17I think that there's those people. But anyway, so for you and I,
- 21:21we must have had and I know we did, people who mentored us
- 21:23and taught us and influenced us in the way that we are. And then
- 21:29you and I go on to influence other people because in my supervision groups and
- 21:34individual supervision and in my case consultation class. I was adamant about this understanding
- 21:42in the shift, you know, because of course the interns would come in
- 21:45and start complaining about their clients, which is fine inventing, but I would
- 21:48always really take the time to walk not only the individual intern and supervise you
- 21:53through, but also the group, you know, to have everyone go okay,
- 21:57you know, understand, and I might even be explicit at times in
- 22:02terms of what we're talking about. Now. There's nothing wrong with being burnt
- 22:04out, it's normal, nothing wrong with venting. But you became a therapist
- 22:07because you wanted to help people correct. Okay, Then you have to find
- 22:14a road to compassion. That was my big thing. It's like, find
- 22:17the road to compassion, and I see you. You have not found that
- 22:22road yet, So let's figure out that road. And that road typically resides
- 22:26in your heart and in your conceptualization. You have to have faith, you
- 22:32have to have love to give, you have to want to hand yourself over
- 22:36and be open as a therapist, and you have to be smart enough or
- 22:40consult enough so that you have a way of seeing what the client is doing.
- 22:44Because you know, it's easy to be compassionate for acute seven year old
- 22:48kid who likes to draw and laugh and play games like it's easy, right,
- 22:53It's hard to have compassion for someone with a personality order who's attacking you
- 22:59or attacking their members right in front of you. That's when it becomes challenge.
- 23:02But you have to find a road to compassion, and if you can
- 23:04conceptualize it, it doesn't excuse what the client has done, but it does
- 23:07provide a way of seeing that they're operating from a place of vulnerability and being
- 23:12triggered in relational trauma. And it also gives you a path to treatment.
- 23:17You know, at the same time of finding your road to a compassion,
- 23:19it gives you actually what you should be focusing on. It gives you a
- 23:23road to change. And that was a lot of work. You know.
- 23:26I would have supervisees that would push back. You know, there's some notable
- 23:30supervisees that I can remember over the years that would get upset at me because
- 23:34I was to them invalidating their feelings, you know, telling them that that
- 23:40they're wrong, so to speak. I wasn't saying that, but that they
- 23:44were wrong for being angry at their client and giving up on their client.
- 23:48You know that they felt like it was righteous for them to quote unquote draw
- 23:52boundary with quote unquote inappropriate client behavior. Wow. Yeah, And if they
- 23:59weren't with me, and they were in the case consultation class next door,
- 24:03they might have actually received none of what I'm saying and received encouragement to be
- 24:07doing what they're doing. Like, there's a whole So that pedigree of the
- 24:15lineage of your training and exposure, if you've if you never had someone that
- 24:21thinks, you know, we must have. We come from a pedigree that
- 24:25had enough of what we're talking about that inspired us and solidified us and dedicated
- 24:30us. And we see it, you know, we we we notice it
- 24:33when it's not happening. Other people come from a different pedigree. I had
- 24:37a teacher, you remember, Dan callaher No Oh, he was a teacher
- 24:41and I guess on my side of the program, and it took a class
- 24:45with him. He was a lovely guy. He's probably passed on now.
- 24:49He used to work at Western State Hospital with children, and they were using
- 24:56behavioral management for kids with autisms, and so that included corporal punishment, which
- 25:02was not supposed to hurt the kid, but was supposed to provide you know,
- 25:04a negative stimulus or whatever. I don't know however they call it.
- 25:07But he said one day he went to spank this child and the child gave
- 25:12him. It was as a clinician, he went to go spank the child.
- 25:15Yeah, that that was actually the behavioral program is that they would use
- 25:18spanking. So this was in the sixties. This was a or seventies,
- 25:23a long time ago. And this is the cool part of this story is
- 25:27the kid made a face. This is a kid who did not he was
- 25:33nonverbal, right, and Dan keller Watch saw the face and he gently turned
- 25:37the kid around and he took down his pants and he saw that he was
- 25:41injured. And he said, I turned the kid around again, and I
- 25:45could see a golden light coming from his heart and we stopped doing That makes
- 25:52you cry thinking about it. Yeah, you know, I don't come from
- 25:56compassion, and you're chose not to or had a hard time. She had
- 26:03a hard golden get golden heart within you. Yeah. Yeah, a good
- 26:07guy, but ill equipped to raise four children. And anyways, the whole
- 26:12thing. And when I think about what I could have been, when I
- 26:15think about what's in me, I am so blessed to have met a guy
- 26:21like Dan kellerher who somehow found it within himself to wake up or at least
- 26:25just see what's around him. And Marshall Linhan, hard as she was to
- 26:29work for, exuded that towards her clients, and you and my own supervisor,
- 26:36David Taylor and Lilian and all the people that taught me. I am
- 26:41in my own therapists who love me. I am so lucky because I have
- 26:47that in me. I could be like that, rigid and hardhearted and all
- 26:51that shit, and I fucking don't want to, but I could have,
- 26:56and I could have languished in a commune mail health clinic feeling jaded and righteously
- 27:00indignant about my own victimhood. And I don't know how it happened, but
- 27:06I remember the day I became a volunteer at that job, and for four
- 27:10years I continued to work there, and I just didn't give a shit about
- 27:14the paperwork in the bureaucracy, and it was still annoying, right, and
- 27:18still difficult clients. Do you have any colleague that was sharing your point of
- 27:22view or were you isolated and alone? No? No, No, there
- 27:26were several like Noel, my friend, Noel, my friend Molly. My
- 27:30friend David Kerzy, who was a psychiatrist on that team and just one of
- 27:34the loveliest humans I've ever met. Did you and I talk about this?
- 27:37I'm sure we did back in the day. Do you remember any conversation stop
- 27:41talking about it? I feel like I've always been this way, you have.
- 27:48There's evidence. I don't remember thinking this specifically, but the fact that
- 27:53early on in my career I was working with a fair amount of intensely borderline
- 27:57clients and working well with them must have meant that I didn't give into the
- 28:04temptation of giving up, right. Yeah, yeah, But I don't remember
- 28:11specifically talking about it. I do remember having some internal clashes and not saying
- 28:15anything in consultation back then. But yeah, that's beautiful day. Oh I
- 28:21remember that too. In fact, when I was in case consultation in graduate
- 28:25school with Pam who Pam Hayes just great, I watched people give angry,
- 28:32not angry, judgmental advice and oh, you remember this the book recommendations.
- 28:37Oh well, have you read this book? Well, you know, you
- 28:40tell this story about what happened with your client, and they're like, oh,
- 28:42well, here's this book. You want to read blah blah blah blah
- 28:45blah. It's like it's like, damn fucking New York Times book review some
- 28:48bullshit, right, which in books I'm never going to read, can't even
- 28:52remember the titles. Yeah, look, there's nothing wrong. Was saying,
- 28:55Hey, you know, I don't know if this is going to help you,
- 28:56but I read this book that kind of has to do with what you're
- 28:59talking about. And here's the name of the book. Obviously there are other
- 29:03books out there, and there are other roads to learning what to do,
- 29:07but I'm just going to throw it out there, you know, a tentative
- 29:08thing. But ninety nine percent of the time what they will do is they'll
- 29:11say, have you read this book book? And you will have never heard
- 29:17of it before, because why would you have? And then they'll say like,
- 29:19you've never heard of this book before? And then I'm like, um
- 29:25no, should I have? Especially early in my career, I'm like,
- 29:27am I some sort of idiot for not knowing this book? And it was
- 29:30never a big It was a big book to that individual, which is fucking
- 29:34fine, But you know, don't act like it's this gift from God that
- 29:38this random author wrote a helpful book. For you, you know, and
- 29:42then they'd be, oh, well, you really have to read this book.
- 29:45Oh okay, So my implication, I'm an idiot for not knowing this
- 29:51book exists. I'm an idiot for not having read it. All my problems
- 29:55can be solved by reading this book. And if I don't read this book,
- 29:57I'm irresponsible as a clinician. Thank you. Yeah, that's so helpful.
- 30:00Yeah exactly, And that's all I have to say. That's it like
- 30:03that, that's there. Nobody's piece of advice. Yeah, hey, good
- 30:07job on this or um, you know, let's be supportive of you on
- 30:10that. So I remember we would write papers in that class periodically, and
- 30:14I wrote to Pam. I'm like, I am not saying another word unless
- 30:18I have something positive to say. I'm not going to participate in Wait what
- 30:21why? What was why? I didn't I didn't want to be one of
- 30:25the sharks women in there biting at people because they hadn't read the book or
- 30:29whatever. I mean, you noticed that people were tearing each other. Yeah,
- 30:33right, And so I wrote to her and I'm like, I'm not
- 30:36saying another word unless I have something positive to say. That is it?
- 30:38What did Pam say thank you, thank you. She noticed the negativity.
- 30:45Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, Well going on with email, right on.
- 30:49I have had many experiences working in residential treatment facilities, both kids and
- 30:52adults, that seem to be very unethical, physically restraining kids without legitimate cause
- 31:00for intervention, paying a client for something they made, giving clients special treatment
- 31:04and privileges, going into clients rooms without consent or authorization from the mental health
- 31:10professional, and there were no safety concerns present that would warrant this, Making
- 31:15accusations without evidence and finding out that they were wrong, and not making any
- 31:19attempts to apologize or mend the relationship, and telling clients where the cameras and
- 31:26telling clients where the cameras can't see them who meaning that the clinician is talking
- 31:33to the client purposely where the clients can't see them, or telling them here's
- 31:37where the cameras aren't get away with ship. Oh okay. Every job I
- 31:42have had in the field, I have seeing people doing shitty things. I
- 31:47mean, just chamming in here. I don't have that much experience with impatient,
- 31:51but I will say that everything that we've said thus far is amplified by
- 31:56impatient because it is even it's ten times more stressful than what you and I
- 32:02are talking about. The burnout is ten times worse, the underfunding is ten
- 32:07times worse. The clients are extremely challenging and prevent and present behaviors not often,
- 32:15but can be violent and can be concerning. So it really amps up
- 32:22the issues. Right. It doesn't mean that people should be allowed to be
- 32:27an ethical matter. But you know there's another factor too that I don't know
- 32:30this obviously, but anecdotally and intuitively or it makes logical sense that of the
- 32:37people who enter the general mental health field. You know, there's a reason
- 32:40why you and I have have never worked at an impatient Oh I have?
- 32:45Oh you have right right before you were there? Oh yeah, yeah,
- 32:47long time right. Um, well, there's a reason why once you had
- 32:51the option not to you didn't work there is Yeah, Because, like I
- 32:55said, it's underfunded, it's it's stressful, it's hard, it could be
- 33:00demoralizing because a lot of times the clientele are such that they're not necessarily going
- 33:07to get better over time, and it's not very fulfilling, right, And
- 33:10it's depending right, And so the people that land in those jobs, there's
- 33:17a higher proportion of people that were already burnt out, or are working there
- 33:22out of necessity because they can't get a different job or something, or they're
- 33:25not qualified to work in other arenas. So you have the stress. You
- 33:31have a staff that, when they've felt the calling to enter mental health,
- 33:37this is not the sort of job that they thought they would end up at,
- 33:40right, And so it causes people to be stressed out, and people,
- 33:45when they're burnt out, will start cutting corners. And you know,
- 33:51ethics, ninety nine point nine nine nine percent of good ethical decisions are made
- 33:59when the initian knows there's no consequence to doing otherwise. You know, you
- 34:04and I. All of the decisions that we make in the client's interest are
- 34:09self generated, and no one on the outside is going to tell us.
- 34:14And if we didn't do those things, no one would tell on us.
- 34:17The client might not even know that we're doing something that's wrong. So we
- 34:23are self policing in a very real way. Our ethical codes are self policing.
- 34:30Yeah, there, it's not an outside agency. You know, when
- 34:32you come to a stoplight, you stop. You're not self policing. You
- 34:37have been told by an outside organization, the government and the police force,
- 34:40the law enforcement that you must do that and if you don't, then they
- 34:45might consequence you. For us, we do have a licensing board that can
- 34:50consequence us. But the vast majority of how we police ourselves is through self
- 34:55policing. Yeah, we police each other, and we invent our own rules,
- 35:00We invent our own standard or practice. We establish that and then we
- 35:05require ourselves, you know, to follow it. And so if you are
- 35:10in an organization where people aren't super dedicated to the field and don't have that
- 35:16internal germ of I am here for a higher purpose than just working here,
- 35:23you know, there's a there's a bigger reason, a spiritual reason if if
- 35:29you will, yeah, and that if that's not really present then and you
- 35:34could get away with these things, then why not, right Why why would
- 35:37you work harder than you have to? Right? So, I think that's
- 35:44one of the reasons. And I don't want to paint in patient as all
- 35:47one thing. There's a lot of different types and there's obviously a lot of
- 35:51different people that work in these places. I know someone that worked at Western
- 35:53State Hospital like the person that you do, but they work there their entire
- 35:59career years for you know, fifty years and very compassionate psychiatrist and a good
- 36:05guy. And I don't know his specific the specifics of us work, but
- 36:08um, you know he cared. Yeah, not in the way that you
- 36:13and I do, I don't think, but but a lot you know,
- 36:15like a grandfather, a father figure. So it's not like everyone is like
- 36:19that. Yeah. Also, there are a lot of people that enter in
- 36:22patient treatment that it is temporary. They had a temporary spike and suicidality,
- 36:27or they went off their bipolar meds and they just need to get put back
- 36:31on and then they're fine. So it's not like everyone that enters those places
- 36:34or you know, very rarely will they be violent. But the fact that
- 36:38it's a possibility at work is stressful, you know, and the staff are
- 36:46often undersupported, where you literally just have a tech guy and you're just like,
- 36:52well, you're the biggest tech you know, you're six foot two,
- 36:55two hundred fifty pounds, So when Joseph over there as an episode, it's
- 37:00your job to actually wrestle him to the ground like that's that's that's not a
- 37:06yeah, you know, so it's difficult anyway. Yeah, I mean I
- 37:10had a friend who was in that position as a tech, and he told
- 37:15me the story about how he got isolated in this room with a known patient
- 37:22who was known to try to kill people, and he somehow got tricked to
- 37:28being alone in a room with him, and the door was swinging shut and
- 37:32if it's shut, it was gonna lock, and he wasn't, so he
- 37:36he got you know, he tried to open the door and they ended up
- 37:38in a wrestling match, and he was desperately trying to keep the door open
- 37:43so that he wouldn't literally be killed by this guy, you know. And
- 37:45it's that kind of thing, that's right. Yeah, And he's being paid,
- 37:50like, you know, a little bit more than minimum wage at this
- 37:52point, right, you know. So anyway, um going on, I
- 37:57am starting to realize really how barren the land of good mental health workers is.
- 38:01I mean, just chamming in there. If you're basing Jenny from Minnesota,
- 38:07you're experience and impatient as a representation of the entire field of mental health.
- 38:12That's not wise to do, right, Maybe it is a wise thing
- 38:17to conclude regarding impatient on average, you know what I mean? Certainly,
- 38:22like I said, there's a bill curve, but I am currently only a
- 38:25bachelor's level individual, but will be going on to my master soon similar to
- 38:31what you did right on. It makes me really sad to think that we
- 38:36have so many good mental health professionals, but the people working the floor and
- 38:39spending the most time with clients on the unit are often wildly flawed. And
- 38:45what good mental health practice looks like? How do I handle it when I
- 38:47see superiors and colleagues doing things that seem to be lacking ethical consideration? Well,
- 38:53I mean, you're probably really limited in your degree of power and you
- 38:59have to survive. I've in a place that may not change much. So
- 39:04pick your battles and you might decide not to do anything to stop the stuff.
- 39:09You know. Maybe maybe you decide what's egregious to you. Okay,
- 39:12great, great, and what you're willing to risk your job for. Okay
- 39:15fine, But um, you can't swim up stream and make the river turn
- 39:22turn backwards. Yeah, the thing that popped into my head and maybe this
- 39:28is not possible. But to find a person with more power than you,
- 39:32Yeah, that's a great idea that you can explore this with. Yeah,
- 39:37that's a great idea. There's pool you can trust. Yeah, there's probably
- 39:42a clinician who's thinking similarly to you, or at least as open to it.
- 39:46And if you could bond with that person, and that person will be
- 39:52able to do something much and be able also to interpret the ethical codes better
- 39:58than you can, and so then you would just use them and say I
- 40:01saw this so and maybe they would work with you on how to report.
- 40:06But to just be flailing on your own as a bachelor's level person, it
- 40:09would be hard to get anything to change. Yeah, you know you would
- 40:14get and you could easily get yourself professionally or actually employment wise shunned. Yeah,
- 40:20yeah, and thought about I mean, well, they could fabricate things
- 40:23against you, and who knows. It's just it's kind of unknown as to
- 40:29how safe you are. Right, take a break, we get back.
- 40:31Let's try to kind of do speed round because I was hoping to do more
- 40:35emails. What are you saying? All right, we're back from the break,
- 40:42anonymous patrons, She says, what are your thoughts on impatient psychiatric facilities?
- 40:45I am a clinician and a pretty at a pretty small hospital. One
- 40:50of my units is an impatient psychiatry ward, and I find it to be
- 40:52such an uncomfortable place. I wonder how much or helping patients versus how damaging
- 40:58this environment can be for them. Curious about your thoughts on impatient psychiatric facilities,
- 41:02Well, we've already talked a bit about it, but anything more,
- 41:06I'd say you're gonna have to keep your sites proportional to the environment. Most
- 41:12people that are in an impatient psychic unit are there either because they've had a
- 41:15psychotic or a manic episode and they're a danger to themselves or others, or
- 41:20because they're having suicidal crisis. So the goal of these places isn't isn't to
- 41:27cure anybody's mental health. It's to stabilize so that they can leave and you
- 41:31know, live in a least what they call it the least restrictive alternative or
- 41:35something like that. And it's out there where the bigger changes that I think
- 41:40the person who wrote in is thinking of. It's out there where those will
- 41:44take place. So if it were me, it's love who's there while they're
- 41:50there? Yeah, And I imagine to be successful and to like this kind
- 41:57of venue to work, you have to be a nerd for that kind of
- 42:00clientele. Yea. You know, there's some people are they're a nerd for
- 42:02people with schizophrenia or bipolar or suicidality, and they really get a lot of
- 42:09satisfaction working with that population, and they have a lot of compassion for those
- 42:15people, and they're okay with the occasional client that has more severe behaviors.
- 42:21You know, they frame it in a way they welcome it. They're saying,
- 42:24I'm going into this knowing that this is a part of the job,
- 42:28and I'm okay with it. In the same way that for you and I,
- 42:30Bob, wouldn't we specialize in personality s orders and treat people with borderline
- 42:36we accept And this is part of my mentorship and supervision of novice clinicians,
- 42:43is that this decision has to be made. I'll walk through it with in
- 42:47my supervision stance or my supervision position, because it's easier for me to describe.
- 42:52So i'd have a supervise who would be describing a client, and I
- 42:58would wonder if we're dealing with some sort of cluster b whether it be narcissism,
- 43:02borderline, or histrionic. And I introduce the topic and say this,
- 43:08remember all that studying you did in previous class about psychopathology, or that very
- 43:14limited exposure to the section on personality sorts, Well, now is the time,
- 43:19so let's get into it, and let's do some assessment, and next
- 43:22time you meet with that person, I want you to ask these questions and
- 43:25to look for these kinds of things, and then over time we discover Yeah,
- 43:30the client maybe even I could just ask the supervise in that moment,
- 43:34do you see this? Do you see that? And then I would start
- 43:36see her again on a conceptualization of let's say histrionic or something, And then
- 43:40I will say to the clinician that because often what they're telling me in the
- 43:47supervision meeting is that the client is attacking them or something like this as being
- 43:52frustrating, very frustrating, very triggering to the therapist, and I say,
- 43:58that's normal. Go through the same thing. It's an indication of cluster B.
- 44:02When you have those feelings, it's par for the course. It's normal.
- 44:06You can't have someone with moderate to severe preconise order in this category that
- 44:10doesn't do that to you. And you are at why in the road.
- 44:16So you can either right now say you don't want to work with these folks,
- 44:21and we can go down a road of figuring out how you're going to
- 44:24screen these sort of clients out before you meet them, which will be hard
- 44:29and limiting. I'm going to tell you you can do it, and I'll
- 44:31support you on a hundred percent, but I'm gonna judge you a little bit
- 44:35for that because I value and have a value that a true therapist is someone
- 44:42that loves everyone and does the work to help those people who need the help
- 44:47most, which are these people. We did not enter this field just to
- 44:52work with the easiest clients. You know, if you're a cancer physician and
- 44:57everyone that has a more advanced and you give up on those people, what
- 45:01kind of cancer physician are you? Yeah? You know what I mean.
- 45:05So I'm not gonna lie, but I'll support you, and I'm not gonna
- 45:08downgrade you as a supervise. I'm not going to punish you, but internally,
- 45:15maybe a better way to put it is, I'll be sad for you
- 45:17and for your career and for clients if you make that choice. But it's
- 45:21your choice when you do that. Yeah. Sure. The other direction and
- 45:24the why is that you will go down a very difficult road that I have
- 45:29been going down my entire career and others as well. That involves wrestling with
- 45:35your counter transference, having a very robust conceptualization of clients, having a very
- 45:40robust self care system, and consultation to supervision. You will make mistakes because
- 45:45you will get triggered, they will push you. There are risks the client
- 45:50might sue you. You know that these things will happen. So it's hard,
- 45:53it's difficult, but the rewards are so great. The amount of benefit
- 45:59that you can give a client that needs so much help is so great.
- 46:02I mean, a little bit goes a long way with these folks. I
- 46:07mean, just giving them a tether to love and compassion and relationships and someone
- 46:12that's not exploiting them can ground them away in a way that they've never been
- 46:16grounded. You know. But it's not going to be easy. But I'm
- 46:20going to be with you, and you're gonna you're gonna come to me next
- 46:22week and you're going to say you're wrong, this client isn't ready for therapy.
- 46:25You're going to have and other people are going to tell you that you're
- 46:29going to consult about this client and other I'm just gonna tell you, idiots
- 46:31are going to tell you that this client isn't ready for therapy, and that
- 46:36you need to terminate with them, You need to draw boundaries, And certainly
- 46:38that's your choice, and I'll support you if that's your call. You know,
- 46:42we can figure out a way or they'll tell you to refer the client
- 46:45or something you know, and and I'm going to tell you that that is
- 46:49not the way. That is not the way to help this person. That's
- 46:52not the way to developing as a clinician. The lessons that you will learn
- 46:55with this client will be life all ring. Yeah, not only for your
- 47:00career, but for your life. The understanding, the wisdom, the love,
- 47:06the compassion, the meaning, the purpose that I have found through this
- 47:12crucible. I wouldn't give that up for the world. So which is it?
- 47:15Yeah? So you know that's a that's a hard thing to do.
- 47:22And so when you enter in patient treatment as a clinician, it's a it's
- 47:28a parallel. Why in the road do you accept that one out of one
- 47:32hundred patients here are going to lash out violently or are going to threaten that
- 47:37or something. Do you accept that your clients are going to come to you
- 47:42when they're at their worst and leave when you've helped them to get a little
- 47:46bit more stable and then other people will pick it up where you've left off.
- 47:50Do you accept that there's going to be a lot of stress and people
- 47:53aren't going to value what you do and some of your colleagues might have some
- 48:00ethical problems. Do you accept that? Do you do? You? You
- 48:04know, if you have a mentor that's really helping helping you to do that
- 48:07And if the answer is no, I don't want that, then yeah,
- 48:12you probably shouldn't be working in this field. But but the environment, Yeah,
- 48:16but for many people, the like the psychiatrist that I was referring to,
- 48:21he obviously said yes to that because he never complained about anything. I
- 48:25mean, he had a patient show up at his house that I think escaped
- 48:30from Washington from the hospital and and tracked him down and in the middle of
- 48:35the night, like three in the morning, was was binging on on the
- 48:37door. Actually, I'll just say it's it's Unbarredo's stepdad. Oh yeah,
- 48:43oh fantastic, And and Berto was there in the house. Wow when when
- 48:46this happened? Anyway, trippy, So let's stay a break and we get
- 48:50back more emails. Are you say, yeah, okay, we're back from
- 48:58the bank break atron Elena, she says, Hi, doctor Hannah, thanks
- 49:01for your insurance rant in the reaction to John Oliver. So, I made
- 49:07a series of episodes reacting to John Oliver's show where he talked about insurance and
- 49:13mental health, and I was agreeing with a lot of the things. I
- 49:15was expanding on what John Oliver was saying. Here's how insurance recently screwed me
- 49:21over. Blue Cross audited me. So, for those who don't know,
- 49:23Blue Cross as a is a health insurance firm in the United States and they
- 49:30provide health and mental health insurance. Blue Cross audited me, which I have
- 49:37no issue with, and deemed me for not recording stop and start times.
- 49:42So just jimmy in here. This is a clinician, Elena, who is
- 49:46maybe paneled or whatever, using this insurance with at least some of her clients,
- 49:51and that insurance company audited her practice. And she's saying, I have
- 49:55no issue with that, but they inged me for not recording start and stop
- 50:00times. So I mean, like the session started at one o'clock and ended
- 50:04at one three, right, Like there, you need to have an exact
- 50:08I've never seen that before. Everything that before you, yeah, I've never
- 50:10seen that. I listed procedure code with time spent with each client. Yeah,
- 50:17which is right there, stand procedure codes. Yeah, why would you
- 50:21need more detail than that? Their time, their time descriptive. Yeah,
- 50:25but they wanted start and stop times even though I received nothing indicating this was
- 50:30a requirement, and they revoked payment for all sessions in the audit totaling three
- 50:35thousand dollars. That's just a scam. Yeah. I appealed and spoke to
- 50:39my state Psychological Association and the American Psychological Association. They thought it was ridiculous,
- 50:45but wouldn't do anything. One lawyer even told me that, well,
- 50:50you know, they've had to pay out a lot more for mental health with
- 50:53increased demand and accessibility through telehealth during COVID. Oh so yeah, I'm guessing
- 51:00what the lawyer is saying is, look, the insurance companies are bleeding money
- 51:05right now. To them, they're bleeding money. Yeah, and I get
- 51:09that because when you have a capitalistic based health insurance, you have the need
- 51:17for profit, otherwise you will literally go out of business as a as a
- 51:21health It's like if the price if you're a restaurant and the price of bread
- 51:25goes up, you have to raise your prices, and so if suddenly everyone
- 51:30is now you utilizing a service that was not as utilized before, you are
- 51:37now bleeding money and you might go out of business. So you have to
- 51:39do something until you can start raising rates later on when people re enroll because
- 51:45you get locked in on a contract, you know what I mean. So
- 51:49I get that, but you shouldn't lie and do illegal things and screw over
- 51:55clinicians who are just trying to make a living, you know what I mean.
- 52:00Not even would happen if if they just said no, I'm not giving
- 52:02you any money back, spend money on lawyers to track that down. I
- 52:08mean insurance companies, if if you're in private practice and you're by yourself,
- 52:15I would not advise that someone go against what the entrance. There's such a
- 52:21behemoth thing, deep deep pockets. They can destroy you. Yeah, you
- 52:23know, unless you have a lawyer that you believe in that says that refusing
- 52:30to pay them back might be a good thing because then you can go to
- 52:35court and then we can win and put an end to this bullshit. Or
- 52:37I don't know. Also they'll make them pay for your legal fees, you
- 52:40know, whatever it is, right, that's a risk that probably for three
- 52:44grand I wouldn't take Yeah, right totally, And Alina says your assessment was
- 52:50so spot on in the reaction videos to John Oliver. In my state,
- 52:52we have very good mental health parity laws. Just chiming here, meaning that
- 52:58there were laws passed that you need to have parody between health and mental health.
- 53:02So in that the benefit you give the customers of your health insurance,
- 53:08say we pay for eighty percent of medical procedures, will you also have to
- 53:13pay for eighty percent of mental health procedures, which was not the case in
- 53:15the past. But if they aren't enforced these parody laws, then this is
- 53:22what happens. I know how several providers. I know several providers who now
- 53:28don't take insurance because the audits were so absurd, which of course is what
- 53:31the insurance companies want. Yeah, let's do bad. Yeah. Blue Cross
- 53:36in Washington is actually great. They don't do any of this shit. But
- 53:42I never heard of anybody getting audited. Yeah, but I could imagine some
- 53:49insurance companies in Washington doing that. I mean, that's another annoying things.
- 53:52Like every state has its own system of health insurance companies, Like every state
- 53:59has a like if I when I would call blue Cross, for example,
- 54:02I would have to find the specific Washington office for blue Cross. Anyway,
- 54:08So in Washington, the shady insurance companies are United massively shady there. They've
- 54:17they pulled out into first place years ago there, so the second place is
- 54:22pretty far from them. But other second place people are people like Signa or
- 54:27Etna. So yeah, that's that's pretty awful. Yeah, And this is
- 54:31why one, you either need laws and regulators. You know, it's great
- 54:37to have a law, but so you know, you can have laws saying
- 54:42don't run a red light, but if you don't have any police officers that
- 54:45are enforcing it randomly to keep people honest, then people are just going to
- 54:50run red lights. Right. You can pass a law that says corporations can't
- 54:52pollute the environment, okay, But unless you have a regulating body that actually
- 54:57monitors that and takes complaints and actually punished and has the legal power to punish
- 55:01these corporations, then it's just a fucking law. It doesn't mean anything.
- 55:05And the way that you have these regulating bodies with power is that it's through
- 55:12taxes. It's allocation of funds. And when you have Republicans that are dismantling
- 55:16everything because they have this ridiculous dogma that government doesn't do anything and government doesn't
- 55:21help and smaller government is better. This is what you fucking get, people,
- 55:24So knock it off, all right. Another email annual patron Crystal from
- 55:30Canada. She says, my name is Crystal and I'm a nurse from Canada.
- 55:34Right on this podcast is the only reason I am still here today.
- 55:38Oh, both you and Bob's therapeutic approach is flawless in my eyes, and
- 55:45I am so thankful for what you do. I acquired PTSD while working in
- 55:50a pediatric operating room. Woow. Yeah, yeah, this has resurfaced sexual
- 55:55physical, and emotional abuse I endured from early childhood into adulthood. I've been
- 56:00off work for a year and a half under care of my province's insurance program,
- 56:07which forces me to work with one of their selected psychologists to continue receiving
- 56:12financial support. So just tell me in here. Yeah, you know,
- 56:15it's it's interesting because as Americans, as I was kind of ranting earlier,
- 56:20we tend to think that our health system sucks and that Canada's is awesome.
- 56:24Right, And when I actually hear from Canadians. They will say, well,
- 56:30there are some things that are better, like we don't have to pay
- 56:32for a lot of things, but it's not perfect. You know, people
- 56:37in Europe will say the same thing. They'll get put on these long waiting
- 56:40lists going on here. A few months ago, I made huge progress with
- 56:45exposure disposure with therapy and guessing. My therapist was over zealous with progress and
- 56:52moved forward too quickly, exposing me to extremely triggering event. Okay, a
- 56:57few months ago, I made huge progress with exposure, so that sounded positive,
- 57:01But then it sounds like the therapist was not doing it correctly. While
- 57:06it was happening, he realized he messed up and completely shut down during the
- 57:09exposure and left me with little explanation or answers to what was going on in
- 57:15his head. He admitted he messed up a few weeks later, which is
- 57:17good, and didn't assess A few weeks later, I didn't assess my triggers
- 57:22properly. Since then, the relationship has been devastating to my mental health.
- 57:29When I heard Bob talk about his experience with attachment theory, I felt understood
- 57:32for the first time. When you discussed transference the relationship with my therapist made
- 57:38sense. I got the courage. So it sounds like Crystal might have had
- 57:43a similar experience of the disorganized attachment feeling of wanting desperately to be close and
- 57:52to have secure attachment, have attunement, and being really preoccupied with that at
- 57:57the same time as being terrified of being harmed by people that are close to
- 58:02you, and then to have the therapist actually harm her. Yeah, and
- 58:07so since then the relationship has been devastating to a mental So it sounds like
- 58:12maybe a lot of triggering out, a lot of preoccupation with what's going on
- 58:16between her and her therapist. I got the courage to bring up both my
- 58:21suspected transference with my therapist and how I felt insecure attachment was a roadblock for
- 58:27me and our therapetic relationship. He essentially gave me his definition. He essentially
- 58:31gave me his definition and acknowledge these things can happen, then moved on and
- 58:36didn't address it further. So what do you think about that I missed opportunity?
- 58:42I yeah, right, I think that acknowledging the thing is insufficient,
- 58:49and I'm kind of thinking, geez, what would it be like in the
- 58:52moment after that and we don't take it any further, how awful that would
- 58:55be, how abandoning that might feel just yuck, and how it might actually
- 59:05not be workable. I mean, if the guy made a mistake and can
- 59:08say made a mistake, great, that's good. If they can talk about
- 59:12transference and attachment whatever and acknowledge that, Okay, great, that's that's cool,
- 59:17But that's not sufficient. Now what then? Now? What is really
- 59:22where we're at at this point? And if just based on what we've heard
- 59:25so far, it sounds like the therapist is enough to doing much with the
- 59:29now what? Yeah? Fuck? I wonder given the trapped nature that Crystal
- 59:37is in because she has to work with one of their selected psychologists to continue
- 59:42receiving financial support. So I wonder if there's an avenue to getting this psychologist
- 59:49educated and Crystal, I don't know how you manage that, but the fact
- 59:53that he apologized gives me hope. And maybe he just hasn't had good mentorship
- 1:00:00or education or something. So maybe if you were to have him listen to
- 1:00:08the episode that you heard that, or you just kind of lay it out
- 1:00:13for him or something. I don't know, that's ridiculous that you have to
- 1:00:16help him with that. But you know there are other in terms of just
- 1:00:21how fundamental this should be in our field and every therapist should understand it.
- 1:00:27But there are other things like that. Someone, I'm trying to think of
- 1:00:30a can you think of a time when a client said, I think you
- 1:00:34need to learn about X. What was X? Add? Okay? Yeah,
- 1:00:39and what was that? Like? That was back when I worked at
- 1:00:42the clinic. They weren't wrong, and I also didn't have the bandwidth or
- 1:00:47the interest. You know, that was back when I got assigned cases not
- 1:00:52based on what was interesting to me or what I wanted to do, but
- 1:00:55because you know, I had a note so the client was coming or add
- 1:01:00treatment and they just gave the file to you and they suggested that I think
- 1:01:07that Daniel Aman book. Yeah, so yeah, yeah, my supervisor just
- 1:01:10gave me the file and said, this is your clients. So you've never
- 1:01:13had any education in ADHD, never supervision or experience, and no interest.
- 1:01:20Right, and you know, you work in a place like that, you
- 1:01:23probably have to learn as much as you can about a lot of different things,
- 1:01:27even if you're not interested. If you want to do a good enough
- 1:01:29job. She wanted me to read that book. I think I think I
- 1:01:32tried to read it or I started reading it then, or was it later,
- 1:01:37I don't know which. Well, I can't imagine one book really doing
- 1:01:42the job. Yeah, it's pretty complicated. Yeah, and anything else like
- 1:01:46um, because there are a number of things like if if someone were this
- 1:01:52would have happened early in my career, if I had a black client,
- 1:01:54for example, and they were talking about family and upbringing, they might suggest
- 1:02:00or I might know that I need to become more familiar with themes that are
- 1:02:07common for black families growing up in that area, for example, so that
- 1:02:14I can have some background in terms of what the context was or how to
- 1:02:17interpret certain stories that they tell me or something, and without that, I
- 1:02:23might So there might be something like that where a client comes to us and
- 1:02:29the client might even tell us like I want you to learn about X,
- 1:02:30Y and Z. There's nothing wrong with that, and you know, therapists
- 1:02:36should be open to that and humble about that, humble yeah. Yeah,
- 1:02:40you know, I'd be a dick about it as a client and say like,
- 1:02:43you're an idiot as a therapist, but you can just be like,
- 1:02:45hey, you know, so there's this kind of theory or this style of
- 1:02:49therapy that I have known about that this podcast talks about or whatever. And
- 1:02:55I don't know if this would be useful for me, but I wonder and
- 1:03:01if you were to know about it, then maybe we could talk about it,
- 1:03:06you know that kind of thing, right, So going on here,
- 1:03:10I believe he has driven largely by his ego, approaches everything with extreme logic
- 1:03:17and very little empathy, and stays within his box of CBT, with little
- 1:03:22desire or interest in expanding the alternative approaches. That bugs me because good CBT
- 1:03:29therapists do understand about alliance. They're not technicians that just you know, I
- 1:03:35will, I'll apply exposure therapy. They actually have to understand alliance well enough
- 1:03:39in order to Yeah, but you don't think that's true. No, it
- 1:03:44is true. But I use cognitive therapy all the time, I use behavioral
- 1:03:46theory. Exposure is behavioral therapy, it is Indeed, I also understand other
- 1:03:52aspects of humans, you know that cognitive therapy and behavioral therapy doesn't really explain,
- 1:04:00you know. So there's nothing wrong with cognitive behavioral therapy. There is
- 1:04:04something wrong with ignoring aspects of humanity exactly. Yeah, like a good medical
- 1:04:11doctor is. I think it's incumbent on a good medical doctor to have some
- 1:04:15good interpersonal skill. Yeah, because you're not just there to treat the sprain,
- 1:04:19ankle or you know. But it might be beyond that though it sounds
- 1:04:24that, but it might be beyond just bedside manner for this therapist because oh
- 1:04:29yeah, yeah, there are two. There are two areas that from the
- 1:04:31description sounds like this therapist is deficient. One is fully understanding the pacing of
- 1:04:36exposure therapy. And a lot of people I would venture to say, the
- 1:04:44majority of people that I've come across anecdotally who know enough about exposure therapy through
- 1:04:50trauma focus CBT or even CPT, even EMDR that the majority of people I
- 1:04:58come across anecdotally will not fully appreciate how you have to tailor it to the
- 1:05:03client and you have to be really careful, particularly with some clients who have
- 1:05:08been through a lot of trauma. But that's so fundamental to doing it properly
- 1:05:14so that it actually helps. But Trauma focused CBT is manualized for ten sessions
- 1:05:20for everyone. Yeah. I think Cognitive processing therapy CPT another manualized protocol is
- 1:05:30similar maybe fifteen. Yeah, that's fucking ridiculous. I've had clients where they
- 1:05:35need three years of therapy to even begin to think about exposing themselves. Yes,
- 1:05:42of course, the research though for those treatments are not on folks with
- 1:05:45this kind of complexity, right, They're on simple stuff. And it's fine
- 1:05:48because you know, but you only learn a little bit. I remember my
- 1:05:54friend Katie being in tears one consultation. She was a DBT person at the
- 1:05:58clinic over there at the up and she was in tears because the client had
- 1:06:02a huge complex history of trauma and the exposure therapy isn't set up for it.
- 1:06:10And I remember my friend Melanie saying to her, Yeah, we actually
- 1:06:15do not have treatment that's sufficient to the level of trauma that this client many
- 1:06:20many others are suffering. So let's just do what we can. And no
- 1:06:27doubt, knowing what I know about Katie, she would have paced it properly
- 1:06:30and also been very clear with the client up front. Here's so you're saying
- 1:06:35that she was being advised to give up. No, No, quite the
- 1:06:39opposite. She was being advised to hang in and recognize that as a profession
- 1:06:44we do not have. We do not have we don't have a therapy that's
- 1:06:49designed to help with complex PTSD, at least we don't have a CBT therapy
- 1:06:54that's designed to help with that. So I mean, I think it can
- 1:06:58be modified fairly easily. Yeah, don't just have to wait until you just
- 1:07:01have to stretch those ten sessions out over ten years. Right. Those clients
- 1:07:06were research subjects that they would get a year and then the year would be
- 1:07:11up, and so it's fine, it's research though. Yeah, So there's
- 1:07:14a there's a prone con to that, and the advice was to just do
- 1:07:17what you can. Yeah, I mean one of the things that I see
- 1:07:21is that, like you know, there's well meaning efforts to find evidence based
- 1:07:28treatments for a particular thing like PTSD, and they develop something like Trauma focused
- 1:07:33CBT, and they base it on sound science, and they develop a protocol,
- 1:07:41and in their effort to get funding and also to limit the amount of
- 1:07:45money they have to spend because they don't have the money to spend, they
- 1:07:47have to limit it to simple PTSD. And they also screen out people that
- 1:07:53have confounding or comorbid issues like suicidality or person ice order, which is bizarre
- 1:08:01because you know, it is find you know, like not every study can
- 1:08:08be that inclusive. And then they run the study, they find what they
- 1:08:14find, they report it honestly, but at some point beyond that, the
- 1:08:19researchers possibly as well in order to promote because if you are at the spearhead
- 1:08:28of that research, your entire career might be made by that research. You
- 1:08:34know, if you're a research professor at a major university and this is your
- 1:08:40thing, then literally all year long you are involved in several studies with a
- 1:08:45number of different colleagues and graduate students, and in order to retain your job,
- 1:08:50in order to get famous, in order to get more funding, you
- 1:08:56have to be chrismatic and you have to sell like a car salesman, yep.
- 1:09:00And so you go to the public. Maybe even when you when you're
- 1:09:04interviewed on CNN or something, it's like you're Elizabeth Holmes trying to sell Parnos.
- 1:09:11So it's not quite like that that well, it's in that direction fraudulence.
- 1:09:15She was just lying through it. That happens though, now I get
- 1:09:17it, I get it. But a good researcher, they have all those
- 1:09:20constraints that you're describing, but they also are doing ethical work. Yeah,
- 1:09:27well there are some that aren't. But there are some, of course.
- 1:09:30But a good researcher is still going to have those constraints, and they're motivated
- 1:09:33and pressured because they're not just free to research there. They need to come
- 1:09:40up with a stick that will get them the funding and the job. And
- 1:09:44there might be a lot of employees they have, actually, and so when
- 1:09:47they talk about it, they're incentivized to downplay that. There are a lot
- 1:09:54of clients that present with PTSD that this model will not work for or can't
- 1:09:58talk about that, or the findings of this study will not apply towards because
- 1:10:02because they limited the participants in such a restrictive way because they had to.
- 1:10:09And also when you involve other disorders, it muddies the water. And you
- 1:10:15know, it's like when you're trying to study the hardness of grant it.
- 1:10:20You don't want to have other rocks in there. You want only grant it
- 1:10:25in there, otherwise it's going to mess it up. So it's a similar
- 1:10:30principle. Research is just toe holds. Yeah, it's good, it's also
- 1:10:34not climbing the whole mountain, right, So then you have a bunch of
- 1:10:39people who believe the hype that tribal focus CBT is. And the other thing
- 1:10:45is, if you're trying to promote a book or it's your lecture series or
- 1:10:49your program at your university, then you also will downplay other models. You
- 1:10:56will promote yours. You might even find research that says the other models don't
- 1:11:00really work. And then if you don't know what you're doing, and you're
- 1:11:04a student or a clinician or a journalist, then you just believe it.
- 1:11:08I know somebody that did that, and I don't know how they sleep at
- 1:11:11night. I'm not going to name them. Oh it's gross, meaning they
- 1:11:15demeaned other models, they promoted their own, despite the fact that there isn't
- 1:11:19any evidence for it. I'm not talking about who not a DBT person for
- 1:11:25whatever it's worth. But yeah, two thousands of people internationally, yeah oh
- 1:11:30yeah, yeah, that happened. You know, there are a lot of
- 1:11:31Charlotteans that we could name. And I don't even know if they think they're
- 1:11:35lying. I think they think they're telling the truth. I think they're just
- 1:11:39lying in themselves because they're incentivized to subconsciously going denial. We understand this,
- 1:11:44right, when someone is drinking every day, there is an incentive to deny
- 1:11:47that you have a drinking problem. When you are trying to make a living
- 1:11:51and all you have to do is go into denial about something, then you're
- 1:11:57going to do it. So it's basically self serving, right, especially when
- 1:12:00you have a system that you know, funnels people into denial essentially, So
- 1:12:05then you have all these people that drink the kool aid and they believe it,
- 1:12:10and then you have all these clinicians that just forced this model on people
- 1:12:14without any kind of critical thinking. And there's not a lot of people out
- 1:12:17there, not a lot of programs or professors who can contextualize everything. You
- 1:12:23know. I had some professors, you know, I talked about Bill Hoisler
- 1:12:28in a previous episode, and he would do that. He could tell us
- 1:12:32about the research, and he was evidence based, but he would also zoom
- 1:12:36out occasionally say well, but you have to ask yourself what was the research
- 1:12:43privileging in the methodology and in the reporting? Good question, yeah, like
- 1:12:47what are they emphasizing and what are they leaving out? What are the constraints
- 1:12:51on the researchers that influence how they're saying this, you know what isn't being
- 1:12:59addressed? You know, what are the things being left out? Right?
- 1:13:01We don't know if that's a fruitful exploration, but you know, if it's
- 1:13:04worth exploring. If you don't at least read it critically link with that in
- 1:13:09mind, you're going to miss the boat, right. But yeah, So
- 1:13:12that's one thing is that you might be able to help your therapists extend their
- 1:13:17knowledge a little bit by understanding pacing. You know, like to be a
- 1:13:21good so this is why, so to be a good CBT therapist. It's
- 1:13:26not necessarily what we're seeing here the bedside manner issue. It could be that
- 1:13:30the person doesn't really understand the principles that TFCBT all the other ones are based
- 1:13:36on and isn't utilizing those those facts when tailoring the treatment to the client.
- 1:13:42So that's one thing which is very common. The second thing that the therapist
- 1:13:47doesn't seem to understand potentially and might be hostile towards, is the idea of
- 1:13:53attachment to begin with. Because if you're fully drinking the kool aid about CBT,
- 1:14:00you know, depending but you will hear adherence to CBT that will talk
- 1:14:04about talking about the past is a complete waste of time. You know,
- 1:14:09you'll hear CBT therapist that will say if you go to therapy and the therapist
- 1:14:15talks about attachment or childhood or whatever, they're a Freudian therapist who is scamming
- 1:14:19you for money because they know that if they keep you in therapy a long
- 1:14:24time just rambling about your childhood, it'll make you worse, or at least
- 1:14:29just keep you the same and guess what, they laugh all the way to
- 1:14:32the bank on that, or they're in denial of the reality of evidence based
- 1:14:36therapy. I mean, so we don't know, but given that you're trapped,
- 1:14:42Crystal, I might run it up the flagpole and say, like,
- 1:14:47actually, maybe just have him listen to this whole this whole segment, actually,
- 1:14:50Crystal By you know you can absolutely he doesn't have to. You could
- 1:14:55actually use your time in therapy and and just make him listen to this whole
- 1:15:00thing. And by the way, if you are listening, dear therapist,
- 1:15:04I'm making we're making a lot of assumptions. So you know, feel free
- 1:15:08to email in if you have a rebuttal or if you need help for that
- 1:15:12matter. But just reading the last bit here, I'm at a loss.
- 1:15:17Let's see. His response was that he was sorry he couldn't help more and
- 1:15:23speed things up, and asked if I would like to increase sessions a twice
- 1:15:27a week or decrease or decrease to once every two weeks. So, yeah,
- 1:15:30I could see the wisdom of doing either. If you can get him
- 1:15:33to do the right kind of therapy, then twice a week might be helpful
- 1:15:36in the nice of him to offer. Or if you're just like, well,
- 1:15:41I have to see him in order to get funds to survive, then
- 1:15:45reducing to once every two weeks or even lesser might just be what you do.
- 1:15:49I don't know going on. I'm at a loss of what I can
- 1:15:54do or where I can go from here. I feel he has given up
- 1:15:56on me or does not care. Is there anything I can due to try
- 1:16:00and steer this relationship and or treatment into direction where I can regain help.
- 1:16:04Well, I feel like we already addressed it. I wouldn't assume he doesn't
- 1:16:08care. He's a human being. So if he has a road, you
- 1:16:12know, if if I could just give him, if I could just download
- 1:16:15Bob and Me into his head and he would just have this this um like
- 1:16:21if I was used a visual metaphor, Like, you have a carpenter who
- 1:16:27is being tasked with fixing a chair, but he has no hammer. He
- 1:16:30only has a screwdriver and he doesn't know a hammer exists, and he's trying
- 1:16:36to fix the chair, and you're like, how come you can't fix the
- 1:16:41chair? And eventually, as a carpenter, you're just like, maybe it's
- 1:16:43unfixable. But you hand the carpenter a hammer and you show him how to
- 1:16:46use it, and he's like and then now he enjoys it. He's like,
- 1:16:51this is the answer to my life, Like, oh my god,
- 1:16:55this tool. I've always wanted to help in this way and now I can,
- 1:16:59right, So it's possible that that's the key. Yeah, Crystal,
- 1:17:02I think the only answer is to have him listened to this segment, because
- 1:17:06I can't imagine you, Crystal explaining this to him, do you know what
- 1:17:11I mean? He might not hear it. Yeah, Hey, hats off
- 1:17:14to Crystal for hanging in. Yeah, like, like really hanging in.
- 1:17:18There's a thread through the whole thing of like interest in the therapist. What
- 1:17:25was a It just sounds like Crystal has interest in the therapist. It's like,
- 1:17:30yeah, not just like I've got an extra grind there a big jerk
- 1:17:31face blah blah blah blah blah, but actually wants the thing to work.
- 1:17:35It's really cool. Yeah, there's an actually, there's an easier path along
- 1:17:41the lines of what Bob is highlighting, which is that you could just subtly
- 1:17:45engineer the conversation. You know, it sounds like exposure therapy might not be
- 1:17:50advisable until you get reassurance that he knows how to pace things and how to
- 1:17:55monitor things. You could also kind of force him because it's up to you
- 1:17:58whether or not to enter exposure. Yeah, and discratch that. So,
- 1:18:02so let's let's put exposure aside for a second and talk about your relational traumas
- 1:18:06that you're recovering from. There's a possibility that you could engineer. You go
- 1:18:12twice a week or once a week and just say and maybe he has a
- 1:18:15bit of time where he checks in on homework for cognitive behavioral purposes, and
- 1:18:19you do it. But then after that you just kind of ask him questions
- 1:18:26and develop a relationship, you know, maybe even literally just asking him like
- 1:18:30what do you think about me? Like you do you care? About me
- 1:18:33or what you know there, or just talk about your life, and if
- 1:18:38he's a good enough listener, like maybe it's good enough as a corrective experience
- 1:18:42or something, you know what I mean, that's possible. I did a
- 1:18:45similar thing like that with a supervisor once who was very CBT by the way,
- 1:18:48just I think coincidentally, who every time I presented a case to her,
- 1:18:55she would say, Okay, what kind of skill should we help the
- 1:18:58client with, like, no matter what the case was, and it was
- 1:19:02always skills, skills, skills, skills. And in the beginning I'm like,
- 1:19:08well, surely this isn't her reaction to everything, but after a while
- 1:19:13it was. And I was later, you know, into my career enough
- 1:19:17to know that this was bad supervision, right, and I would, but
- 1:19:24she had power over me, you know, like she could consequence me negatively
- 1:19:28if I don't play ball. So I didn't have any choice. You needed
- 1:19:30to work with her. Yeah, yeah, So I played ball for a
- 1:19:33bit, But then as soon as I could, I would transition to making
- 1:19:38it as useful as possible to me, which I think amounted to me talking
- 1:19:43about cases and then her mostly giving very fishy and very dubious advice or something.
- 1:19:53But it gave me a chance to contrast what I think might have been
- 1:19:57helpful based on what she was saying, you know what I mean, Like
- 1:20:00I was like, well, internally, I'd be like, well that's dumb,
- 1:20:02but that's an idea, but I'm not going to do that, you
- 1:20:05know, just sort of learning what not to do, yeah right, right
- 1:20:09right yeah, and also having a chance to kind of clarify for myself or
- 1:20:14something, you know what I mean. That reminds me that this poster used
- 1:20:16to be in this donut shop my dad and I would go to when he
- 1:20:19was taking me to work right after I got out of high school, and
- 1:20:23it said everybody that comes here makes us happy, some when they arrive and
- 1:20:27some when they leave. So what was I everybody that comes here makes us
- 1:20:30happy. Someone they arrive and some and they leave. Yeah that is that's
- 1:20:36that is That's exactly what I'm talking. Yeah right, yeah, yeah,
- 1:20:42how long Jeff to endure it? Uh? Maybe a year, it's a
- 1:20:46long time, yeah, weekly, yeah, maybe less. But it was
- 1:20:51a slog, you know, I mean, it's perfectly nice person and it
- 1:20:57was never harmful to me or anything, right, um, not helpful,
- 1:21:00but yeah, just a waste of time. It could have been harmful if
- 1:21:03you had, you know, hook line and sinker. Oh yeah, we'll
- 1:21:08get into the skills here. I'd like skills skills have It could have harmed
- 1:21:12me, right if I let her convince me that that was the only answer
- 1:21:15that a therapist should be asking. Yeah, so, Bob, good nuck,
- 1:21:19Crystal, Yeah, I have something to tell you. Oh what,
- 1:21:24Oh that's the last email? No way, yes, the last one.
- 1:21:29We don't have any No, well, Stacy probably hasn't populated the Google doc
- 1:21:35with recent emails. But that's the last email. Holy cow, it's never
- 1:21:41been the last one. No. I thought we would just be sailing and
- 1:21:45sailing and never seen land. Maybe, Bob, the podcast is over for
- 1:21:49good because there's no more questions. What are we gonna do on Mondays?
- 1:21:57We'll talk about skills and that doesn't for that episode of psychology in Seattle.
- 1:22:02Everyone out there, please take care of yourself, and if you want Bob
- 1:22:05and I to answer a question, say it upfront. Say this is a
- 1:22:10question for Kirk and Bob, because then Stacy knows explicitly to put it in
- 1:22:13this document. And take care of yourself because you deserve it,