Latest / Seasons of Joy / Understanding The Four Tendencies
Transcript
- 0:00You know that moment when everything finally just clicks, when you realize that
- 0:04the problem that you've had with someone wasn't what you thought it was at all.
- 0:08Maybe it's a simple conversation with your spouse about a decision that the
- 0:12two of you are going to make, and then suddenly it turns into an argument.
- 0:16But you probably aren't fighting about the decision.
- 0:20You're fighting because you have two different people that believe the other
- 0:24person should just get it.
- 0:26Sometimes the answer to the struggle isn't about trying harder.
- 0:30It's understanding that we're all wired differently.
- 0:34I'm Jill Pack, and this is the Seasons of Joy podcast. And today,
- 0:38in episode 175, we're talking about Gretchen Rubin's four tendencies.
- 0:44Are you a woman of faith who is struggling to navigate your current season of life?
- 0:48Do you feel like life is just happening to you instead of for you?
- 0:52My name is Jill Pack, and I'm a certified faith-based life coach and a member
- 0:57of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- 1:00I want you to know that no matter your season or your circumstance,
- 1:05it is possible to create a more
- 1:07joyful life, and I would love to show you how. Are you ready? Let's go.
- 1:17Now, I've spent years helping people navigate life's challenges,
- 1:20but I have had to learn these lessons in my own life first.
- 1:25The tools that I teach here and to my clients are things I have spent a lot
- 1:28of time learning about and how to apply them to myself and to my life,
- 1:33and I'm continually working on them.
- 1:36So I am in this with you.
- 1:39I also believe that life is 50-50.
- 1:42Family life is beautifully hard. Career growth is challenging.
- 1:46And it's that contrast, that opposition, that friction that creates the growth
- 1:51that we're all searching for because we are wired to grow and to become.
- 1:55However, we're not meant to operate the same way. We can't expect the people
- 2:00we love to operate the exact same way that we do.
- 2:03So today we're going to explore why strategies that work for your spouse might
- 2:08not work for you, why your teenager or young adult isn't being difficult,
- 2:13they're just being themselves, and why understanding these differences might
- 2:17be what's missing in that stuck relationship.
- 2:20Now, as we go through this, I want to invite you to think about one relationship,
- 2:24whether it's family or work, that just feels stuck right now.
- 2:28Just focus on that one, and let's see what shifts for you as we begin to explore
- 2:33and understand the different wiring at play.
- 2:37Thank you for being here, and let's dive in. Let's talk about family life.
- 2:41Maybe you think your daughter is being stubborn when she questions every family
- 2:46rule, or your husband thinks you're being controlling when you want to create structure.
- 2:51It may feel like you're swimming upstream because you're fighting against your
- 2:55natural wiring instead of understanding it.
- 2:59Now, we all have two types of expectations pushing at us every single day.
- 3:04We have outer expectations. This is what other people need from us.
- 3:09Family responsibilities, work deadlines, social obligations.
- 3:12And we have inner expectations, those promises we make to ourselves,
- 3:16exercise goals, creative projects, personal growth.
- 3:20But what if people aren't actually trying to make life difficult for us?
- 3:24We just process these expectations differently.
- 3:28When we understand this, our relationships actually can improve.
- 3:33Think about New Year's resolutions. Do you naturally keep them?
- 3:36Do you research first? Do you need someone else that's counting on you,
- 3:41or do you want to do the opposite of what you should do?
- 3:44Your answer tells you how you're wired.
- 3:48There are four patterns, and they're what Gretchen Rubin calls the four tendencies.
- 3:52I'm going to explain each one briefly, and then we'll dive in a little deeper.
- 3:56First, we have upholders, and they say, I keep promises to others and myself.
- 4:01They're planners, they're rule followers, and they create systems, and they stick to them.
- 4:06We have questioners. They say, I'll do it if it makes sense to me.
- 4:11They're researchers who need to know the why behind everything.
- 4:15Then there are obligers that say, I'm reliable for others, but terrible for myself.
- 4:21They're people pleasers who struggle to take care of themselves.
- 4:25And finally, rebels. They say, don't tell me what to do, but I might choose to.
- 4:30They seek freedom and they resist all expectations, even ones for themselves.
- 4:36There's no perfect tendency, however, because each tendency has gifts and challenges.
- 4:42And so the goal isn't to fix anyone or change anyone, it's to understand the wiring that we all have.
- 4:50Now, upholders. In family life, upholders are the natural organizers.
- 4:55They remember everyone's schedules, they keep traditions alive,
- 4:58they follow through consistently, and they expect others to do the same.
- 5:03The struggle for upholders is that they become the family's default organizer.
- 5:08Everyone leans on them to remember the details, to keep things running,
- 5:12and then those same people feel smothered by all the systems and checklists. It can be lonely.
- 5:19You're doing what everyone else expects, and somehow you end up feeling like too much.
- 5:24An upholder parent might create a chore system with charts and rewards,
- 5:28and it works for one child, gets ignored by the other, and overwhelms the third entirely.
- 5:35Same system, three different responses. The upholder feels like a failure.
- 5:40At work, upholders excel in structured environments, but constant change throws
- 5:46them off. It can feel like they're being set up to fail.
- 5:49So if you're an upholder, I want you to pause and think about this for a minute.
- 5:53Are you managing your family or are you serving them?
- 5:56Are you advancing in your career or are you following someone else's plan?
- 6:01Now let's talk about questioners. In family life, questioners ask the questions
- 6:06everyone's thinking but not saying out loud. They make well-researched decisions,
- 6:11and they want to teach kids to think critically.
- 6:15Questioners don't mean to be difficult when they ask why for the 10th time.
- 6:19They genuinely need to understand the logic, the why.
- 6:23But to everyone else, it feels like they're never satisfied.
- 6:27Think about the questioner teenager or young adult who doesn't make their bed.
- 6:31They're probably thinking, no one even sees my room anyway.
- 6:34Yet, they're willing to do the dishes because they believe something like food safety matters.
- 6:40Their logic is consistent, it's just not what the parents expected.
- 6:44At work, questioners might get labeled not team players because they ask questions.
- 6:50They think they're helping, but leadership thinks they're being difficult.
- 6:54When questioners can find work that makes sense, they can actually become unstoppable.
- 7:00Yet when it feels arbitrary or random, it's hard for them to perform well.
- 7:04It can be easy for a questioner to feel like they're a bother.
- 7:08If you're a questioner, what if your questions are a gift? What if you can lead
- 7:12with curiosity instead of apologizing?
- 7:16Now let's look at obligers. In family life, obligers show up for everyone else, always.
- 7:22They're the glue. They sacrifice their own needs so naturally that everyone stops noticing.
- 7:27Obligers are strong until they're
- 7:30not. They handle everyone's needs beautifully, but their own goals?
- 7:34Exercise plans, creative projects, career dreams? They struggle without that
- 7:39external accountability.
- 7:41Sometimes they have obliger rebellion. This is when years of unexpressed needs
- 7:46explode in what looks like anger, but really is exhaustion.
- 7:51The family is shocked because the obliger never seemed to mind being busy.
- 7:56At work, obligers stay late. They take on extra projects. They make everyone's job easier.
- 8:01They're also the ones who train their replacements for promotions they might
- 8:05not ever ask for. They feel selfish advocating for themselves.
- 8:09So if you're an obliger, I want you to think about this.
- 8:13Taking care of yourself isn't selfish. it's sustainable.
- 8:17Your family and your workplace need you healthy and fulfilled,
- 8:21not martyred and resentful.
- 8:23And finally, rebels. In family life, rebels bring authenticity and independence.
- 8:29They adapt beautifully. They teach everyone the value of choice and personal agency.
- 8:34Rebels don't wake up thinking, how can I make everyone's day difficult?
- 8:39They wake up thinking, how can I be true to myself today?
- 8:42In a family that needs structure and predictability, this can feel overwhelming and even threatening.
- 8:49When families try to control rebels with consequences, it often backfires because
- 8:55the rebel will just calculate if the consequence is worth their autonomy.
- 9:00They're not being defiant. They're being logical within their own value system.
- 9:05At work, rebels see what everyone else misses. They question systems that aren't
- 9:10working. They bring fresh perspectives.
- 9:12But put a rebel in a micromanaged environment, they slowly die inside or they just give up.
- 9:19They need freedom to do their best work.
- 9:21Rebels can even rebel against their own goals if they start feeling like shoulds.
- 9:26They'll sabotage their own success to maintain their sense of choice.
- 9:30If you love a rebel in your family or at work, what if you gave them choice
- 9:35within structure instead of rules without flexibility?
- 9:40So what does it look like when everyone has different wiring?
- 9:43Let's look at some examples. First, here's a family life example.
- 9:47Upholder dad checking his watch, stressed about being late, question her daughter
- 9:52asking why we have to go to this gathering,
- 9:55obliger son agreeing to be ready but still in pajamas because he got distracted,
- 10:00rebel mom suddenly feels trapped by a commitment she made in a different mood.
- 10:05By 10 a.m., everyone's feeling frustrated. The upholder feels disrespected.
- 10:10The questioner feels dismissed.
- 10:12The obliger feels rushed. The rebel feels controlled. Same situation.
- 10:18Four different experiences. This pattern repeats in families everywhere.
- 10:24Upholder parent plus a rebel teenager or young adult is a classic rules versus freedom battle.
- 10:30The upholder creates structure for everyone's benefit, but the rebel experiences it as an imprisonment.
- 10:36Neither is wrong. They're just wired differently. A questioner spouse plus an obliger spouse.
- 10:43One needs to understand the why behind every decision.
- 10:46The other just wants to move forward. One feels rushed into bad choices.
- 10:51The other feels like their input doesn't even matter.
- 10:54It isn't about character flaws.
- 10:56It's different operating systems trying to run the same program.
- 11:01The old way was to parent how we want to be parented, or maybe the opposite of how we were parented.
- 11:08But what if we could just parent to how our child is wired?
- 11:12Upholder children need clear, consistent systems. Questioner children need logic behind the rules.
- 11:19Obliger children need external accountability for personal goals.
- 11:24Rebel children need choice and identity-based motivation.
- 11:27I want to invite you to pause here. Is there one family conflict that keeps repeating?
- 11:34And what if the solution, again, isn't about trying harder, What if it's about
- 11:39understanding the different wiring systems at play?
- 11:43Let's look at work life for a minute. You've probably heard the career advice, just network more.
- 11:49For obligers, this works. It's an external expectation from a career counselor or a boss.
- 11:55But for the questioners, it feels manipulative. For rebels, maybe fake.
- 12:00And upholders need to know exactly how to network with what goals following
- 12:05what system. Or how about follow your passion?
- 12:08Rebels light up at this because it's about identity. But questioners need way
- 12:13more information first.
- 12:15Obligers worry about letting people down. Upholders want to see the structured
- 12:19path before they make a move.
- 12:22The advice isn't wrong. It's just incomplete.
- 12:25We need career strategies that match how we're wired.
- 12:29Upholders do well with clear advancement paths. They struggle when priorities
- 12:34keep shifting or when no one's defined what success actually looks like.
- 12:39Questioners thrive when they understand the mission and they see how their work matters.
- 12:44They struggle with arbitrary rules or bosses who say, because I said so.
- 12:49Obligers succeed when they have external accountability through a mentor,
- 12:53a coach, a colleague who checks in on their career goals.
- 12:56They struggle with advocating for themselves. Rebels flourish with autonomy and variety.
- 13:03Even when they respect their manager, they struggle being micromanaged.
- 13:07So what if you stop trying to fit into someone else's career strategy?
- 13:11What if you built one that actually matches how you naturally work?
- 13:15Before we talk about how we make our different wiring work together,
- 13:19I want to invite you again to pause, take a breath, and think about that one
- 13:23relationship that feels stuck.
- 13:25What if the person isn't trying to be difficult? What if they're just wired differently?
- 13:32The goal is not to turn your rebel teenager or young adult into an upholder,
- 13:37or your questioner spouse into an obliger.
- 13:40The goal is to create space for everyone's wiring to contribute.
- 13:45As an obliger, I have to pay attention when I'm struggling with setting limits
- 13:50or telling people no, because I know that this is a sign that I might be sacrificing my own needs.
- 13:57I also know for myself that accountability is an important strategy for me when
- 14:02I want to create a new habit.
- 14:05Here are some helpful shifts that can help you as you interact with people that
- 14:09are wired differently than you.
- 14:11With upholders, appreciate their organization instead of calling them controlling.
- 14:16With questioners, give them the information they need instead of asking them to just trust.
- 14:22With obligers, create external accountability for their personal growth.
- 14:26And with rebels, offer choice within structure instead of rules without flexibility.
- 14:31In your family and work life, I encourage you to build on these four pillars. Self-awareness.
- 14:38Understand your tendency and how it affects your relationships and how you do at work.
- 14:45Self-acceptance. Stop fighting against your natural wiring. Learn more about it.
- 14:50Accept what it is and play to your strengths.
- 14:54Self-compassion. Be gentle. When your approach differs from others,
- 14:59it doesn't necessarily mean that you're wrong. It just means you do it differently.
- 15:03So be kind to yourself. Give yourself some grace and compassion.
- 15:06And finally, self-trust.
- 15:09Believe your way of working does have value.
- 15:12As Gretchen Rubin says, when we understand ourselves and how our tendency shapes
- 15:17our perspective on the world, we can adapt our circumstances to suit our own nature.
- 15:23And when we understand how other people's tendencies shape their perspectives,
- 15:28we can engage with them more effectively. The four tendencies explain why we act and why we don't act.
- 15:36So this week, try one thing differently. Remember, life is 50-50,
- 15:41beautifully hard, necessarily challenging.
- 15:44Family relationships will have friction.
- 15:47Career growth will feel difficult sometimes. But when we understand how we're
- 15:51all wired differently, we can work with that friction instead of against it.
- 15:57So your invitation, figure out what your tendency is.
- 16:00You can take Gretchen Rubin's free quiz at GretchenRubin.com.
- 16:05I'll put a link in the show notes, as well as a link to her book that talks
- 16:09about the four tendencies.
- 16:11And then what tendency is one important person in your life?
- 16:15How might understanding this shift that relationship?
- 16:19And what would happen if you stopped fighting against your wiring and you started working with it?
- 16:26I believe understanding leads to compassion for ourselves, for the people we love.
- 16:31When we stop trying to change each other and we start trying to understand each
- 16:35other, our relationships change.
- 16:37You don't have to have it all figured out. You just have to be willing to pause,
- 16:42ponder, and try something different.
- 16:44Thank you so much for being here, and I wish you a joyful week.
- 16:48Thank you for tuning in to the Seasons of Joy podcast. I hope you enjoyed today's
- 16:53episode, and if you like what you heard, don't forget to subscribe,
- 16:57leave a review, and share with your friends and family.
- 16:59If you want to learn more about me or how to work with me, just visit my website,
- 17:04www.seasons-coaching.com, and have a joyful weekend.