Latest / Keen On America / To Catch a Fascist: The Ethics of Unmasking the Radical Right
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, my name is Andrew Keen.
- 0:02Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Show about everything that matters with the
- 0:07world's leading commentators and thinkers.
- 0:30Hello everybody.
- 0:31It is Wednesday, the 4th of February 20, 26, few days ago, and an old friend of
- 0:37the show, John Roush, had an influential essay on the Atlantic in which he
- 0:42announced he used to be a fascism skeptic.
- 0:46And, uh, when it comes to the Trump regime, at least he believes
- 0:50that yes, it is indeed fascism.
- 0:53So, uh, uh, Donald Trump is indeed.
- 0:57August Company of Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini Elise, according to John.
- 1:04Uh, and I'm gonna try and get John back on the show actually to talk more about it.
- 1:08Uh, yesterday an interesting new book came out on the F word too.
- 1:12It's called to Catch a Fascist, uh, the Fight to Expose the radical right.
- 1:19It's by my guest today, Christopher Mathias uh, Chris, um, I'm
- 1:25assuming you're in the Roche camp, although I'm guessing also that
- 1:28you were never much of a skeptic.
- 1:29Did you always believe that Trump was a fascist?
- 1:33Yeah.
- 1:33You know, I think, um, I think he certainly had those
- 1:36characteristics from the jump.
- 1:38Um, I think as a journalist, I probably didn't use the term myself
- 1:42in a headline until 20, uh, 18, 20 19.
- 1:49Um, it was actually a very specific, uh, scenario.
- 1:52I covered a Trump rally in Greenville, North Carolina, where I saw.
- 1:57The president, uh, whip the crowd into a frenzy, uh, over Ilhan Omar, and, uh, get
- 2:05the entire crowd to chant, send her back.
- 2:07Um, and, uh, I, I ended up writing an article immediately afterwards called
- 2:13a Fascist Trump rally in Greenville.
- 2:16Uh, dur in which I, I kind of emailed a bunch of different scholars of
- 2:19fascism to ask for their take.
- 2:21Um, and yeah, so I guess I've been in the call using the f
- 2:25word camp for for a minute.
- 2:27So what, for you, I don't want to turn this into a, a
- 2:30scholastic discussion of fascism.
- 2:32Sure.
- 2:33Everyone has different definitions, but what for you distinguishes a fascist from.
- 2:40A conservative or just a reactionary?
- 2:44Yeah.
- 2:45You know, um.
- 2:47I guess it's, it's always a little tricky 'cause um, the, the way I kind
- 2:51of define fascism in the book, and it's kind of like my working definition
- 2:55obviously, um, but is kind of like a, a right wing politics of domination
- 3:02that sit situates a particular subgroup of people above a social hierarchy
- 3:07and then targets already marginalized groups for expulsion and, and death.
- 3:14Um, all in this effort to kind of, you know, quote, purify or cleanse a, a nation
- 3:19to restore it to some mythical, uh, past of cultural and, and ethnic homogeneity.
- 3:27Um, and I think, you know.
- 3:31You could all, I think throughout, uh, the history of conservatism in America,
- 3:36it's always, you know, danced around the edges of explicit, uh, fascism.
- 3:40And, and I think, you know, something I try to get at in the
- 3:43book is that, um, in a way, um.
- 3:46Fascism was in America before, you know, we called it fascism.
- 3:51Um, Langston Hughes, uh, speaking at this writer's conference in the 1930s famously
- 3:57said like, you don't need to tell, uh, the black man in America about fascism.
- 4:03We've, we, we are familiar with, uh, Nordic supremacy.
- 4:07Um, and its, and its, uh, trials.
- 4:10Um, so.
- 4:12I think when it comes to Trump and, and more recently using the F word, um, I
- 4:16think he basically took kind of a lot of maybe implicit or dog whistling,
- 4:24um, you know, racism, am bigotry and just made it that much more explicit.
- 4:29Um, and I think just exhibited, um, a lot of the characteristics that, um, I felt
- 4:36made him a fascist, and especially in the second administration and like your, uh.
- 4:41Friend, friend of the show wrote in the Atlantic.
- 4:44Um, I think the, the evidence is just everywhere.
- 4:46Now.
- 4:49The original fascist, of course, Mussolini made the term up fascism, uh, Hitler,
- 4:54they were at one point, at least in their political careers, extremely popular.
- 4:59Mm-hmm.
- 4:59Uh, Trump seems to have some degree of popularity.
- 5:02At least he won the last election.
- 5:04Uh, in your view, if you believe that Trump.
- 5:08And his inner circle of fascists, does that make people who voted for him or
- 5:14the majority of people who voted for him, does that make them fascists too?
- 5:19You know, that's a, that's an interesting question.
- 5:21I think, um, I would certainly characterize MAGA at this point
- 5:24as a, as a fascist movement.
- 5:27Um, and I think, um, it is something we should come to terms with.
- 5:33Um, you mean the like kind of explicit.
- 5:36Uh, racism not only in the last campaign, but uh, of this current administration
- 5:42is just so blatant and over the top.
- 5:45Um, I, um, I, you know, whether or not.
- 5:52It's interesting the way we use the word 'cause I don't think anyone in the
- 5:56Trump administration would necessarily self-identify as a fascist, even
- 5:59though there was that hilarious moment
- 6:01with, uh, Zohran Mamdani in, uh,
- 6:04the White House when Trump said, you know, call, call me a fascist.
- 6:07It's fine.
- 6:08Um, uh, but.
- 6:12You know, as for calling individual Trump supporters, fascists.
- 6:15So I, I don't know.
- 6:16I mean, I think they're, I think they're swept, they're mixed up
- 6:19in something fascist for sure.
- 6:21Um, you know, this is kind of a distinction I make in the book, right?
- 6:24'cause the book is about anti-fascist activists, um, who target, um.
- 6:30You know, what they see as fascist groups, um, for, you know, confrontation,
- 6:35for, uh, espionage, for research, for kind of unmasking members of,
- 6:40of fa of secretive fascist groups.
- 6:42Um, but you know, there.
- 6:45They're identifying these people, they're unmasking these people and calling them
- 6:48fascists, calling them Nazis, but they're not, you know, going to Trump rallies and
- 6:51I identifying Trump supporters as fascists or, you know, doxing them, exposing them.
- 6:57Um, you know, they're kind of targeting the worst of the worst.
- 7:00Um, so yeah, I don't know.
- 7:02I, I think it's an interest.
- 7:03Interesting question.
- 7:06I'm not sure if you given it, it's an interesting question.
- 7:09I'm not sure if you fully answered it.
- 7:11Um,
- 7:12okay.
- 7:12What, what, what, what would, what would be your, your take on that?
- 7:14Well, I mean, of the, I don't know, however many million, 70, I don't
- 7:19know, 70, 80 million, a hundred million peop Americans who voted for Trump.
- 7:24Mm-hmm.
- 7:24Of those who, who, I mean, what a number of approximately 20, 30, 50% are fascists.
- 7:31I mean, it's an important
- 7:34question for better or worse.
- 7:36I mean, I, I, I know it's a hard one to answer.
- 7:40Yeah.
- 7:40It's just, I, I mean, yeah, I don't know.
- 7:43It's, there's a lot to parse there, you know, I mean, like, uh, in, um, during
- 7:50the civil rights era, um, or I mean, if you go further back, I don't know, like
- 7:56during reconstruction in America, um.
- 8:00Like,
- 8:04could you arguably call?
- 8:07Um, I don't, I don't know what I'm getting at.
- 8:09I just, I just think it's, it's, it's a really hard thing to parse.
- 8:12Um, I think, uh, yes, I think they're part of a fascist movement.
- 8:15I don't know, um, if I would call them in particular.
- 8:19Each and every Trump supporter are fascist.
- 8:22I mean, the reason I ask Chris is because your book is about the
- 8:26fight to expose the radical, right?
- 8:28And in part, I guess it's a kind of an exercise in, in doxing, uh, yeah, fascism.
- 8:34I mean, if there are 40 or 50 or 70 or a hundred million in Americans who voted
- 8:39for Trump, should they all be exposed?
- 8:41Should there be some sort of, sort of the, like the Vietnam.
- 8:46Uh, in Washington DC should there be a big wall or should there
- 8:49eventually be a big wall somewhere where these people are identified
- 8:53in terms of their support for Trump?
- 8:55Is that what you are arguing?
- 8:57And to catch a fascist, who's to to determine who gets to
- 9:02be exposed and who doesn't?
- 9:04That's my question.
- 9:05Sure.
- 9:06Yeah.
- 9:06That's not what the book is arguing whatsoever.
- 9:08Um, that is, this is, have you read the book, Andrew?
- 9:13Yes.
- 9:14I've looked at it.
- 9:15You've looked at it.
- 9:15Sure.
- 9:16Okay.
- 9:16So the book is, um, you know.
- 9:20Basically about anti-fascist group, this kind of de antifa, you know, commonly
- 9:26the way we commonly call it, uh, the kind of this decentralized underground
- 9:30network of anarchists and, and socialists who, um, you know, don't trust.
- 9:36The state or law enforcement to combat, um, fascists in their communities.
- 9:42Um, so they do the work themselves and the large part of the work they're doing
- 9:48is exposing, you know, very explicit neo-Nazis and white supremacists.
- 9:53These are members of groups like Identity Europa and Patriot Front, and a lot of
- 9:58the Nazis that marched in Charlottesville.
- 10:01Um, and they are doing the work to uncover the identities of, of these people,
- 10:06um, and, you know, often revealing them to be, um, men in positions of power.
- 10:12Um, and the idea of that is to kind of hold these people accountable is to
- 10:16say if you, for example, are, you know, one of the stories, uh, is about a, uh,
- 10:23Nazi EMT who runs a, one of the most.
- 10:27Popular neo-Nazi podcast in the country called The Daily Showa, the Showa, of
- 10:31course, being a, a word for the Holocaust.
- 10:33Um, and he is working as a paramedic as an EMT in Virginia.
- 10:38Uh, on that podcast, he makes explicit references and stories to
- 10:43treating black patients differently.
- 10:45Anti-fascists expose this and becomes a, a story, and he.
- 10:48Gets fired.
- 10:49Um, there's another story, for example, of a neo-Nazi, a member of
- 10:54a group called Identity Aropa, which is very explicit about wanting to
- 10:57expel non-white people from America.
- 11:00Um, and.
- 11:02He, uh, is in Charlottesville.
- 11:05He's the security guard for Richard Spencer, who's kind of the, um,
- 11:09you know, poster boy of the, of the so-called alt-right in 2017.
- 11:13Um, and then he goes back to Massachusetts afterwards that, um, and he goes
- 11:18back to his job as a police officer, anti-fascist, figure out who he is.
- 11:23Uh, they publish a, a docs or a story if you, if you will.
- 11:26Um, and he, you know, basically resigns before he is fired.
- 11:32So.
- 11:33From this perspective, this type of anti-fascist work is a form of community
- 11:37self-defense and accountability.
- 11:39And it's a way of kind of creating a social cost for being, you
- 11:44know, part of a, a fascist group.
- 11:46It's, it's kind of a way of saying like, yeah, you can join those
- 11:49groups if you want to, but, um, you know, you don't get to wear a mask.
- 11:53We're gonna figure out who you are and, and hold you accountable for it.
- 11:57The book, um.
- 11:59As you say is sympathetic to that aspect of the, the Antifa movement.
- 12:05Um, and you, you know, in an interesting piece in the, in the nation that not,
- 12:09not all liberals are, are comfortable with that work of exposing people.
- 12:15What rights then do these individuals have when it comes to
- 12:19privacy, when should and shouldn't?
- 12:23Antifa have the right to expose these people.
- 12:26Uh, you talked about, we've done shows on Charlottesville.
- 12:29Should everyone who showed up for that rally in Charlottesville,
- 12:32should they be exposed?
- 12:34Should they lose their jobs?
- 12:35Should they be humiliated?
- 12:38Um, yeah, it's an interesting question.
- 12:39I think, um, you know, one of the.
- 12:41Groups I profile in the book, um, is is a group of anti-fascist
- 12:46researchers called Ignite The Right.
- 12:48Um, ignite the Right is dedicated to doing exactly what you just
- 12:53said is to identifying and exposing everyone that was in Charlottesville.
- 12:57Um, and you know, I was in Charlottesville.
- 12:59I covered it as a reporter.
- 13:01Um, and.
- 13:02You know, I do not see, um, a way in which you attended that rally without,
- 13:10um, or participated in that rally without being an explicit neo-Nazi.
- 13:15Um, it was one of the most horrible things I've ever witnessed or experienced.
- 13:19Um, you know, I interviewed people, uh, after the car attack.
- 13:23I witnessed the beating of Deandre Harris.
- 13:26Um, and yes, I think if you attended that as, um.
- 13:32A member of, like a participant in Unite the Right Rally.
- 13:34Yeah.
- 13:34You, you probably deserve some accountability.
- 13:37Does that mean that there isn't a, a like room or path for
- 13:42forgiveness or understanding?
- 13:43No, of course not.
- 13:44There, there's definitely an avenue for that.
- 13:46Um, I think one of the things I, you know, talk about in the book,
- 13:50um, is you know, this kind of, uh.
- 13:55Anti-fascists will often, you know, kind of do this thing called amnesty
- 13:59where, you know, they, if, if you're a Nazi and you're participating in
- 14:03something, but you've left the movement behind you, but you, you know, you might
- 14:06be exposed, you'll often go to these anti-fascists and be like, listen, I left
- 14:10these movement, this movement behind me.
- 14:12And, and anti-fascists will be like, okay, yeah, well we won't do anything.
- 14:15You know, like, you know, we, we'll be honest though.
- 14:18Like if we see you mixed up in this again, we might.
- 14:20You know, post something.
- 14:21Um, so it's, I think it's just a method of, of, um, accountability.
- 14:28What about the accountability though of, of Antifa?
- 14:31I mean, who, who is to determine who's on these boards and who is
- 14:34exposing who it sounds to me, or to some liberals at least, it might
- 14:38sound as if, as a degree of moral.
- 14:41Equivalency here of one group of radicals exposing another group for being evil.
- 14:46I, I'm guessing that right wing radicals would probably have panels or groups
- 14:53or committers doing the same thing.
- 14:56Yeah, no, totally.
- 14:57And, and um, you know, I think a lot of people will make that equivalency.
- 15:02Um, uh, you know.
- 15:06There is no board or leadership or headquarters for Antifa de
- 15:10despite what, um, the Trump administration, you know, might say.
- 15:14Um, it is typically, you know, decisions are arrived at locally and,
- 15:18and democratically and tediously.
- 15:21Um.
- 15:22And, you know, that's not to say they get it right every time.
- 15:26Um, uh, I do think that there is a big, I, you know, I, I will personally
- 15:34argue that there's not an equivalency between kind of right wing doxing and
- 15:38the, the doxing I describe in the book.
- 15:40Um, you know, I think, um, you know.
- 15:45I am in support of unmasking and identifying, uh, fascists in, in
- 15:50my community and, um, would rather it not go the other way around.
- 15:55You wrote an interesting piece, uh, last week in The Guardian about Antifa
- 16:01unmasking, uh, not just neo-Nazis, but now members of, uh, ice, uh,
- 16:08the group of course, who very much in the news, in involved in there.
- 16:14Uh, in their violence on the streets of Minneapolis.
- 16:18Um, sh lots of debate about whether or not ICE agents or people who are working for
- 16:25ICE should have the right to anonymity.
- 16:28What do you argue, uh, Chris in the book on catching a fascist
- 16:33in terms of ice in your view is everyone who works for ICE a fascist.
- 16:39You see, this is a, this is a kind of a, a distinction in terms that I
- 16:43think I don't, you know, get caught up in, like, I'm not identify, like I, I
- 16:48think it's worthy, uh, completely to identify the people in ICE right now.
- 16:53I think what ICE is doing right now is reprehensible, and I think
- 16:56it's, um, part of a. Pretty explicit project of ethnic cleansing.
- 17:01And I think it, you know, in, in my personal opinion, I think it meets every
- 17:05def definition of a fascist project.
- 17:08Um.
- 17:09Now does, um, each individual, am I, you know, does each ice
- 17:17agent, are they a fascist?
- 17:19Um, you know, I don't know that they think of it consciously in
- 17:22that way or self-identify that way, but what I would say is that they
- 17:26are involved in a fascist project.
- 17:28Um, and I also think that they are, you know, kind of publicly funded.
- 17:34Um.
- 17:36Uh, you know, employees of, of the state, they're like kind
- 17:40of public officials in a way.
- 17:42Um, and that typically, you know, police aren't masked and they
- 17:45have to identify themselves.
- 17:47Um, and so I think it's a very kind of scary escalation that the people
- 17:52doing this, um, are wearing masks.
- 17:55And I think, I think the reason, you know, uh, thank you for
- 17:57bringing up the Guardian article.
- 17:59You know, I think, um.
- 18:01Someone I interview in that says that the um reason.
- 18:06Um, that ice wear wears masks is 'cause they know what they're
- 18:11doing is, is unpopular or, you know, that it, um, might be wrong.
- 18:17Um, and I, and I think there's some, some truth to that.
- 18:20Um, and you know, I also just say I think it's really interesting, and
- 18:26this is something I try to, uh, bring up in the book, is that, you know,
- 18:29throughout the history of American.
- 18:33White supremacy, um, and specifically masked white supremacy.
- 18:38Um, you know, you wear a mask in hopes of creating a world in which
- 18:43you won't need a mask at all.
- 18:44Um, the, the first Klan wears a mask to kind of terrorize black people in the
- 18:49south and to overthrow reconstruction to destroy the gains that, uh, recently
- 18:54freed black people have, have gained.
- 18:57When, when reconstruction is abandoned, um, you know, the Klan is isn't really
- 19:02needed anymore and it kind of disbands.
- 19:04That's part of the reason it disbands.
- 19:06Um, they kind of, you know.
- 19:08Trade the anonymity of the hood for the anonymity of the lynch mob.
- 19:11Um, and I think it's, uh, important and to consider the world, a world in which ICE
- 19:19agents, um, are comfortable carrying out what they're doing, uh, without a mask.
- 19:27Um, and um, yeah, I think.
- 19:31That's the reason as the, um, the Guardian article you brought up, uh, you know,
- 19:37mentions is that anti-fascists have, uh, you know, kind of changed their
- 19:41targets and are identifying ice agents in Minneapolis and, and elsewhere.
- 19:47The article also, uh, quotes, uh, people who argue that you need to identify all.
- 19:55Ice and, and DHS officers, that's the homeland security, uh, department.
- 20:03Those are many thousands of people.
- 20:05Chris isn't, aren't there?
- 20:06I mean, how, how is, firstly, how's that gonna work?
- 20:09And secondly,
- 20:11it's, it's, it's, it's, it's targeting.
- 20:13I, I think.
- 20:15I think you might be misreading.
- 20:16I think it's targeting border patrol agents active in the missions in
- 20:19Minneapolis on the streets to kind of abduct people off the street.
- 20:23There are many thousands of those.
- 20:25Uh, I mean they're not just on the street, they're on the streets of Los Angeles.
- 20:28They're on the border, there are in Minneapolis.
- 20:30Who knows where else they are.
- 20:31There are,
- 20:32mm-hmm.
- 20:33Many thousands of these agents.
- 20:35Are you suggesting in the book that.
- 20:38Uh, leaving aside the F word that they should all be somehow exposed,
- 20:43that everyone should know what they're doing and shamed, essentially.
- 20:48Um, so the, the book was written before the current kind of escalation of, of ice.
- 20:54Um, so I don't make an argument about that,
- 20:55although I'm guessing that this doesn't necessarily surprise you what's
- 20:59happened on the streets of Minneapolis.
- 21:02No, not at all.
- 21:03I mean, I think it is, um, exactly what, um.
- 21:07MAGA and, and Trump have promised to do.
- 21:10I mean, if you're going to promise to Massport, uh, millions and
- 21:16millions and millions of people, of our neighbors and friends and and
- 21:19loved ones, it's gonna look like this and it's gonna be, um, a spectacle.
- 21:23Um, you know, I think, uh.
- 21:26Steven Miller, who I think a lot of reporting suggests this is kind
- 21:30of his brainchild and, and project.
- 21:32Mm-hmm.
- 21:32Um, you know, he is, um, steeped in, in a kind of explicit
- 21:38white supremacist literature.
- 21:41Um, and, you know, he was, his emails were leaked, um, to the Southern
- 21:46Property Law Center years back, and they showed him just kind of swimming
- 21:50in these, uh, you know, waters online of, um, you know, kind of.
- 21:55Explicit great replacement talk of, of the, the term Remi, which is really
- 22:00just a euphemism for ethnic cleansing.
- 22:02Um, and you know, of ado of, you know, kind of promoting books like
- 22:06Camp of Saints, which of course is like, you know, this really kind
- 22:10of racist, dystopian, uh, novel.
- 22:13Um, so.
- 22:15Um, no.
- 22:16I mean, sadly I think like there's, um,
- 22:19no, and I take your point on, on Miller.
- 22:21I mean, I wouldn't argue with you on Miller, although everybody knows
- 22:24who he is, he doesn't wear a mask.
- 22:27Right.
- 22:27My question was about the tens of thousands of, of ice agents who
- 22:31presumably, some of them at least, are looking for work and their.
- 22:35Doing that, they're working for the state in, in the way in which many
- 22:39Americans have done historically.
- 22:40Would you distinguish, I mean, is everyone who works for ice, should they all be
- 22:45exposed or is there only ice agents on the streets or those who are violent?
- 22:50How are we gonna know?
- 22:52Well, I mean, that's what, what's happening.
- 22:54The, the current kind of grassroots effort to identify ice, you know,
- 22:59they're not identifying like.
- 23:01Administrative people or, you know, I think there's actually, um, there's a site
- 23:06called isis, which isn't like an Antifa project per se, but they, they make this
- 23:10distinction, I think, and I think this is what you're getting at, which is that like
- 23:13they're not going to identify the people.
- 23:15Working the daycare at, you know, DHS, uh, taking care of government, employees,
- 23:20kids, um, like they're, and they're not gonna, you know, docs or unmask
- 23:24the everyday employees necessarily of DHSI think they are so far, at least
- 23:29what they've done and, and what I've detailed in the article is that they are.
- 23:33Identifying people that have taken place in, or taken part in a
- 23:38particularly bad or, or brutal bits of, uh, violence or kind of especially,
- 23:44um, egregious, uh, you know, um.
- 23:48Abductions or deportations, whatever, whatever you wanna call them.
- 23:50I think, you know, one of the officers that's identified in, in my article
- 23:55is someone who pepper sprayed a protestor at point blank range.
- 23:59Um, one of the, some of the other people that they've identified were the
- 24:04agents seen, uh, bringing an elderly man, uh, out of his house, shirtless
- 24:10and like zero degree temperature as his grandchild with out the window.
- 24:14Um, you know, I think they are.
- 24:16Targeting, uh, those people.
- 24:18Um, you know, I don't really see them nor, nor would they necessarily
- 24:24have the resources at this point to identify, you know, the
- 24:27thousands of employees of of DHS.
- 24:30I think they are creating accountability for, you know, the people committing
- 24:37kind of the most egregious acts.
- 24:40And, and how would you respond to, uh, an ice agent?
- 24:44I don't suppose one would appear on this show.
- 24:46Probably not show their face certainly, but mm-hmm.
- 24:49Who would simply say, well, we're just doing our job and we we're trying
- 24:54to, uh, uh, obey the rules of the state when it comes to immigration.
- 25:00Sure.
- 25:01Um.
- 25:03Yeah, I mean that it, it sounds almost trite to say, but you know,
- 25:06we're just doing our job sounds a lot like we're just following orders.
- 25:09Um, you know, which of course, um, you know, I think in moments like
- 25:15this, it's, it's important to say that, you know, there are some
- 25:19orders that shouldn't be followed.
- 25:21Um, and what is happening, you know, particular, particularly in Minneapolis,
- 25:27um, you know, from all accounts of, from the people living there is.
- 25:32A straight up occupation.
- 25:34Um, I think there's been reports, um, uh, I think maybe in EO or elsewhere, uh,
- 25:43kind of detailing, um, that morale is not necessarily high within ICE at the moment.
- 25:50Um, and I think they see that this huge community uprising in response, um.
- 25:56You know, they, they know how unpopular they are and that they might have to
- 26:01live with the shame of what they're a part of for a while, um, you know, we're,
- 26:04we're seeing the popularity of, of ice and this project of these deportations
- 26:12just kind of plummeted in the polls.
- 26:13And a, a phrase like abolish ice, which, you know, year, a few years ago, I
- 26:17think was, felt like pretty radical.
- 26:19Um, is reaching an all time record high, um, even 20% of Republicans support.
- 26:25Um, abolishing ICE at this point, or support that phrase, I believe.
- 26:30Um, so, um,
- 26:35yeah, I'm, I'm sorry.
- 26:36I, I, I forgot your initial question, but, um,
- 26:38no, I, I think you answered it.
- 26:40Um,
- 26:41yeah.
- 26:42So for you or perhaps for the anti Antifa group, and, and maybe this is,
- 26:48this is a compelling argument, shame is, is, is a powerful political tool.
- 26:53Yeah.
- 26:54Yeah.
- 26:55No, I, I think, I think that's really it.
- 26:56And, um, I'm, I'm glad you put it that way 'cause I've been thinking
- 27:00a lot about it this week because Tom Homan, of course, the, um,
- 27:04the, the head of ice at the moment.
- 27:05Yeah.
- 27:06Um, he, uh, recently came out with a statement where he, he tried
- 27:10to kind of flip my book on, its.
- 27:12Uh, on its side, right?
- 27:13He said like, you know, we are, we're filming the people that are standing
- 27:17up against ICE and we're gonna create a database and they're gonna be shamed
- 27:21and they're gonna lose their jobs.
- 27:23So like, there is like, you know, in a way, I think, and I'm so glad you
- 27:26phrased the question that way, Andrew.
- 27:28Um, there is like, kind of this battle over, um, shame and, and, and what
- 27:33we're supposed to be ashamed of.
- 27:35Um, and I think, um.
- 27:38It's just a, it's a push and, and, and a pull.
- 27:40It's a, it's a, it's a, it's a real fight.
- 27:44So what becomes, as I said, you've been quite critical, I think of conventional
- 27:48liberals when it comes to this stuff.
- 27:49What becomes of our right to privacy is that only people who
- 27:56are moderates who have a right to privacy or people on the left.
- 28:01You know, I think the, the argument for, um.
- 28:06Unmasking, kind of straight up.
- 28:09Fascist is just a form of community self-defense.
- 28:14It's to know that the people, there are people in your community
- 28:19that are explicitly calling for violence online, that are, that
- 28:23are liable, uh, to commit violence.
- 28:26Um, you know, one of the stories I tell in the book, um.
- 28:31And I will, you know, admit, like this is not like a, from the kind of
- 28:35militant, anti-fascist perspective, um, you know, they have a, uh, a
- 28:41different approach to concepts of, of freedom of speech than, than your
- 28:45kind of more moderate liberal, um.
- 28:48You know, one of the stories I tell in the book is that an anti-fascist
- 28:52spy goes into, um, the planning server for the Unite the Right Rally in
- 28:57Charlottesville, where all these Nazi groups are planning, um, the event and
- 29:03this spy collects reams of data, of memes and messages, just kind of evidence of
- 29:10these Nazis murderous intent for that day.
- 29:13Um.
- 29:14He gives them to local anti-fascists in Charlottesville, who then give
- 29:19them to the local city government, uh, pleading with, um, you know, the
- 29:24mayor, the, the council to revoke these Nazis permit, uh, for their rally.
- 29:30Um, you know, the officials decide not to do that.
- 29:32Um, uh, and of course, you know, what happens in Charlottesville happens,
- 29:38um, and I think from like the militant, anti-fascist perspective, like.
- 29:44You know, these fascists always pose an inherent threat when
- 29:49they're allowed to organize.
- 29:50Um, and, um, it's a fight to, um, you know, to stop their
- 29:58violence from happening.
- 29:59And, and part of that work is unmasking them and, uh, knowing who they are,
- 30:04um, you know, in the pre-internet era.
- 30:07This anti-fascist work in America in the eighties and nineties, often
- 30:11involved activists like digging through the dumpsters of like neo-Nazis houses
- 30:16and fi, and finding discarded mail and finding their real names and then
- 30:20posting, you know, meet your local Nazi posters on telephone poles.
- 30:24Um, so, but back to your original question, like who
- 30:29is deserving of privacy?
- 30:32Um, you know, I think we are.
- 30:36All deserving of privacy.
- 30:37But I think if you are actively, you know, agitating as part of a movement
- 30:45to expel a good portion of this country for not being white, um, then it's a
- 30:51matter of kind of actual community self defense to know who those people are.
- 30:58I love the title of the book.
- 31:00Um.
- 31:01Uh, yeah, it reminds me, of course, uh, your book is called, uh, to Catch
- 31:06a Fascist, uh, Hitchcock's 1952, uh, or 1955 movie to Catch a Thief
- 31:14with Carrie Grant and Grace Kelly.
- 31:15Very different,
- 31:16which, which I, which I still haven't watched.
- 31:18I I should
- 31:19Oh, you haven't watched it yet.
- 31:21It's, it's, it's very different.
- 31:23Are you?
- 31:24And it, and of course it's a fun movie and a romantic movie.
- 31:27Are you optimistic now given?
- 31:30What happened on the streets of Minneapolis?
- 31:32Do you feel that the worst is over, Chris?
- 31:36Yeah, you know, I, I really don't know.
- 31:38I think, um, we've had so many moments like this where, um, you know, 'cause
- 31:43we did in a sense see Trump like retreat a little bit in Minneapolis, right?
- 31:46Like he dispatched with Bovino, you know, kind of the guy in charge
- 31:51that who really dressed like a Nazi.
- 31:53Um, but, um.
- 31:57Uh, you know, we also know that abductions and these kind of deportations are
- 32:01taking place all over right now, still in places like Los Angeles and even
- 32:06in New York, um, where I am and, um.
- 32:12All I can say is that, um, what we saw in Minneapolis, I
- 32:16personally found very heartening.
- 32:18Um, it was like an organic grassroots response, uh, by the people there to say
- 32:24that, you know, this is not acceptable.
- 32:26Um, and it reminded me a lot of the kind of grassroots.
- 32:33Militant anti-fascist response to the wave of fascist groups and Nazi groups
- 32:37that marched on the streets of America in 2017 and 2018, where you are confronting
- 32:42these people in the streets, you're following them, you're monitoring them,
- 32:45you're identifying them, you're pressuring venues and hotels, not to host them.
- 32:51Um, you know, it's just creating a social cost.
- 32:53And we, we've seen that.
- 32:55All over Minneapolis.
- 32:57And I think it's working and I think it's providing a, a model of, uh,
- 33:03resistance, um, for across the country.
- 33:06So in, in that way, yes, I, um, feel optimistic.
- 33:10I think, you know, one of the, uh, mantras, uh, that.
- 33:15A couple mantras or axioms that you hear in anti-fascist circles
- 33:18are, uh, we protect, we protect us.
- 33:21Um, and I think Minneapolis showed that, you know, they weren't
- 33:25relying on the law enforcement.
- 33:26They weren't relying on the Democratic party or their local government to
- 33:30defend, uh, themselves against ice and defend their neighbors against ice.
- 33:34They, they realized that it was up to them to defend their, their neighbors.
- 33:38Um, you know, and then the other expression you hear a lot, um.
- 33:42Maybe, you know, I just have Woody Gut three on the Mind, but is, uh, you
- 33:45know, all you fascist bound to lose.
- 33:47Um, and I do think, um, you know, that fascism is ultimately
- 33:56a self-destructive ideology.
- 33:57'cause it constantly needs to manufacture new targets and new subgroups to,
- 34:02to scapegoat and, and eliminate.
- 34:04Um, and until eventually, you know, there's no one left, it's
- 34:07kind of like eating its own.
- 34:09I, I do this.
- 34:11Fascist moment that this fascist movement is bound to lose.
- 34:15It's just kind of what's important right now is to stop this movement from doing
- 34:19as much destruction as as possible.
- 34:23So you seem to be saying two things.
- 34:24On the one hand, it's gonna eat itself, so we could just leave it alone.
- 34:28On the other hand, you seem, and, and correct me if I'm wrong, to be suggesting
- 34:31that in, in some ways these people, or at least their views should be illegal.
- 34:36So
- 34:37I'm, I'm, I'm not saying they should be illegal.
- 34:39Um, I'm saying that there should be consequences.
- 34:41I think one of the analogies that I draw in the book is,
- 34:46um, let's say you're in a bar.
- 34:48And a, um, guy comes in and starts, uh, shouting racial slurs,
- 34:55maybe throws up a, a Nazi salute.
- 34:57Um, you, there's a recognition that that guy poses a threat, that
- 35:02he's liable to do something and you're gonna ask him to leave.
- 35:06Um, if he doesn't leave, uh, you might for, you might force him to leave.
- 35:10Um, I think.
- 35:13I, I, I, I feel like your question's kind of around freedom of speech.
- 35:16Am am I correct, Andrew or?
- 35:18Yes.
- 35:18Yes.
- 35:19Yeah, yeah.
- 35:19Okay.
- 35:19Yeah.
- 35:20So I think, um, there's the distinction I think maybe I'm trying to draw here
- 35:24is not like freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences.
- 35:29Um, you know, it like if you say racist shit in a bar, you're
- 35:34liable to get, get punched.
- 35:36Um, and you know, I.
- 35:40I don't know if that's a, a bad thing.
- 35:44Uh, tomorrow we've got, uh, lawyer, uh, Andrew Guthrie Ferguson.
- 35:49He has a new book out called Your Data Will Be Used Against You.
- 35:52Are you at all concerned, Chris, that, that the, the tactics that
- 35:57you are supporting in this new book to catch a fascist will be used by
- 36:01the right against guys like yourself or certainly members of Antifa?
- 36:08Uh, sure.
- 36:09Yeah.
- 36:09I mean the, um, it's, uh, I mean, it's, it is essentially, well, I think
- 36:14what you're touching on is that, and what I describe in my book is that it
- 36:17is essentially an underground war of intelligence and counterintelligence.
- 36:21It's kind of an informal, uh, uh, intelligence agencies that a
- 36:27war with each other, if you will.
- 36:28There, there, there definitely are far right efforts and right-wing efforts
- 36:31to identify anti-fascist activists.
- 36:34Um.
- 36:35And, you know, there are websites to that effect.
- 36:37Um, you know, we also saw during the, um, uh, uprisings and the protests
- 36:44against, uh, the genocide in Gaza, that there were websites like Canary Mission
- 36:48that were identifying, um, uh, you know, members of those demonstrations.
- 36:53Uh, there's a website called Antifa Watch, uh, which claims
- 36:56to identify members of Antifa.
- 36:59Um, I personally have been doxed, um, and, you know.
- 37:04By doxed, I mean, um, you know, when I, when I say dox in the
- 37:08anti-fascist sense, I mean the kind of the digital equivalent of ripping
- 37:11the white hood off of a Klansman.
- 37:13Um, when I say I personally was doxed, it means, you know, my, um, phone number
- 37:18and address and that of my families was posted online and we all received death
- 37:22threats and I had to file police reports.
- 37:24Um, so that is definitely already happening.
- 37:29Um.
- 37:30I will say that I think the left, um, is much better and much
- 37:35more careful at it as a project.
- 37:37Um, the right often mis identifies people all the time or is very
- 37:40sloppy, um, sloppy with it.
- 37:43Um, and you know, I think when the right does it, they often do
- 37:48it as a way of inviting, um, real harassment and, and violence.
- 37:53Um.
- 37:55Uh, whereas I think, you know, a lot of the anti-fascist docs as I described
- 37:58in my book, um, you know, sometimes they might post a Nazis address,
- 38:02but most of the time they're not.
- 38:04Um, so yeah.
- 38:06Um, it's, it's, it's definitely kind of already happening.
- 38:10It's, it's a bit of a battle.
- 38:12It certainly is a bit of a battle, uh, interesting conversation.
- 38:16The book is out.
- 38:17It was out yesterday to catch a fascist.
- 38:20The fight to expose the radical.
- 38:22Right.
- 38:23Very interesting.
- 38:24And I'm gonna bring the book up when I talk to, uh, Andrew Ferguson tomorrow.
- 38:27Congratulations, Chris on the new book and continue with your good work.
- 38:32Thank you so much.
- 38:33Thanks so much for having me, Andrew.
- 38:34This was a pleasure.