Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Intersection of Intellectual Property Law and Real Estate
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Howard Gould. I'm co -chair of the
- 0:06real estate section for the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:08Association. And want to thank you all for coming
- 0:13to our program. I'm taking just a minute to let
- 0:15all the people joining us populate into the webinar.
- 0:21And we'll get started very shortly because we
- 0:24do have a lot of material to cover today. You
- 0:29will find a link to the program materials in
- 0:32the chat. If you haven't seen those already,
- 0:35you can get the latest version of the program
- 0:38materials through the link that's in your chat.
- 0:46I wanted to let everybody know about some of
- 0:48our upcoming programs. We have a program on real
- 0:53property tax law that we're going to do probably
- 0:56in November. We're looking at a 1031 exchange
- 1:00program, which it looks like it's going to be
- 1:02in December. In January, we have a former president
- 1:06of the state bar who's going to talk on some
- 1:08ethics issues related to risk management for
- 1:11lawyers, a real important subject for everybody.
- 1:15In February and March, we generally do a program
- 1:20that reviews the new law and new cases from the
- 1:22prior year. And also I generally invite someone
- 1:27from the California Association of Realtors to
- 1:29come and talk about this year's changes in their
- 1:32forms or any new forms that they have and other
- 1:35issues that are. are sort of the hot issues for
- 1:39the California Association of Realtors on residential
- 1:42real estate. We also are planning a program next
- 1:45year on the changes that have taken place in
- 1:48foreclosure law. I want to remind everybody that
- 1:54you put your questions please in the question
- 1:57in the Q &A and we'll be monitoring those and
- 2:00try to respond to all of them at an appropriate
- 2:02time during the program. And finally your MCLE
- 2:06credit certificates will go out promptly after
- 2:10the program. The Beverly Hills Bar tends to be
- 2:12very good about getting those out quickly. So
- 2:17it's my pleasure to invite our speakers who are
- 2:21actually lawyers not in California. They're both
- 2:23with the Aaron Fox Schiff law firm. First, I'm
- 2:31going to introduce Lindsey Korotkin. Lindsey
- 2:33is a partner in the New York office of Aaron
- 2:35Fox Schiff, which is an Amla 100 US law firm
- 2:39with approximately 650 attorneys whose intellectual
- 2:43property group is highly ranked and recognized
- 2:45by chambers, the Legal 500, and the World Trademark
- 2:49Review. on brand protection and intellectual
- 2:54property counseling and litigation for clients
- 2:56ranging from Fortune 10 companies to individuals
- 3:00and family businesses across a wide array of
- 3:02industries, including architecture, interior
- 3:05design, and real estate. On the litigation side
- 3:08of her practice, Lindsay represents clients in
- 3:11connection with IP infringement, defamation,
- 3:14breach of contract, and other related claims
- 3:16in both federal and state courts. She also helps
- 3:19clients obtain trademark copy registrations around
- 3:22the world and negotiates contracts including
- 3:24the IP terms in complex real estate and design
- 3:27related agreements. Also with us is Sarah Alberstein
- 3:33from the DC office of Aaron Fox where she is
- 3:37an associate. Sarah advises fashion arts and
- 3:40entertainment tech and retail clients on global
- 3:44and domestic intellectual property prosecution
- 3:47enforcement. counseling, transactions, and litigation,
- 3:51and she also conducts due diligence for real
- 3:53estate and merger and acquisition transactions.
- 3:57So here we go with the intersection of intellectual
- 4:00property law and real estate. Thank you both
- 4:02for joining us. Thank you. Thanks, Howard. Thanks
- 4:06everyone for being here. We can go to the next
- 4:09slide. We are here today to talk about the intersection
- 4:13of IP and real estate. One of the things we're
- 4:16really going to focus on is the tension between
- 4:18the rights of IP owners and the rights of real
- 4:21property owners. As we'll see in the cases we
- 4:24discuss, sometimes the IP owners win, sometimes
- 4:27the real property owners win, and it's fascinating
- 4:30to see how and why that happens. in this CLE
- 4:35is to arm you guys as the listeners with the
- 4:38tools to identify where IP rights may exist in
- 4:41the world of real estate and architecture. We're
- 4:43going to go through cases, identify some of the
- 4:46hot button risks and issues in this space, and
- 4:49then do our best to give you the tools to try
- 4:51to attack those risks head on and mitigate them
- 4:54where possible, including as early as the contract
- 4:57negotiation stage. We'll start with the world
- 5:00of copyright. Then we'll talk about how trademark
- 5:03and trade dress rights come into play in the
- 5:05world of real estate. We'll then go into VARA
- 5:08and the issue of moral rights. And we'll wrap
- 5:10things up by talking about some unique cases
- 5:13of landlord liability for IP infringement of
- 5:16its tenants. And we'll end with some trends in
- 5:19listing photography litigation. We can go to
- 5:23the next slide, which will lead us to the world
- 5:26of copyright. And in this section, we'll be looking
- 5:30at how copyright can be used to protect buildings,
- 5:33designs, and plans. We can go to the next slide.
- 5:38So level setting. What is copyright? Copyright
- 5:41is a type of intangible property, IP right. It
- 5:45generally protects original works of authorship
- 5:48fixed in a tangible means of expression. Things
- 5:50that might come to mind are paintings and novels,
- 5:53but there are ways that copyright law can be
- 5:56used to protect assets within the world of real
- 5:59estate and architecture. First, we have the easy
- 6:03case. Architects, designers can protect plans,
- 6:07drawings, schematics as two -dimensional works.
- 6:10You can also protect models as sculptural works.
- 6:13If you own a copyright for any of these works,
- 6:16this gives the IP owner the exclusive right to
- 6:19make and distribute copies, to publicly display
- 6:21the work, and to make derivatives, which is really
- 6:24a fancy way for saying a version based off of
- 6:27the original version. The other thing that the
- 6:29copyright gives the owner the right to do is
- 6:31to sue for infringement. What is infringing is
- 6:34a complex question, but for our purposes, we
- 6:36can just say you can sue for infringement if
- 6:39someone uses the same work or something that's
- 6:43substantially similar to your work. Going to
- 6:45the next slide, the more complicated and more
- 6:49nuanced and narrower way that we can have copyright
- 6:52protection in the world of architecture. It's
- 6:55really new since 1990. The US Copyright Act was
- 6:58amended to provide some copyright protection
- 7:01for buildings themselves as architectural works
- 7:04in order to To meet this qualification, the building
- 7:08has to be habitable by a person intended to be
- 7:12permanent and stationary. What does that mean?
- 7:15It means bridges, dams, walkways, and RVs cannot
- 7:19get copyright protection as architectural works,
- 7:22but houses and skyscrapers potentially can. In
- 7:25order to meet this qualification, the work has
- 7:27to be original. And even if you get the rights,
- 7:30you can't use copyright in an architectural work
- 7:34to claim protection. over standard features like
- 7:37the fact that the building has a door or a window.
- 7:40Copyrights really trying to protect unique expression
- 7:42and not just ideas or general concepts. There
- 7:47are two important exceptions we'll see in the
- 7:49cases for architectural works. First, you can't
- 7:52use an architectural work copyright registration
- 7:55to per... protect, to prevent someone from an
- 7:59artistic reproduction of that architectural work
- 8:02if the building is invisible in a public place.
- 8:05The second caveat that comes into play more is
- 8:09that you cannot use an architectural work copyright
- 8:12registration to restrict a building owner from
- 8:15altering the building without consent. And we'll
- 8:18see how that comes up in the cases in a minute.
- 8:22But going to the next slide, before we get into
- 8:24those cases, we wanted to quickly give you guys
- 8:27a level setting landscape of what are the key
- 8:29questions that come up in a copyright infringement
- 8:32or litigation action. Number one, key question,
- 8:36is the asserted work original to warrant protection?
- 8:39Number two, was there actionable copying? Number
- 8:43three, this is the heart of these cases, is there
- 8:45substantial similarity between the protectable
- 8:48elements of the works? So we're not just looking
- 8:50at, do the works both have doors, but do they
- 8:53both have the same unique elements of the door
- 8:55that are protectable? Is there some sort of interesting
- 8:58engraving or something interesting about the
- 9:01ratio that would make that door protectable beyond
- 9:03the idea of a door? And then lastly, are there
- 9:06contractual provisions or defenses that come
- 9:09into play, which often tends to be the case?
- 9:12Going to the next slide, the first case that
- 9:15we're going to look at is the Freedom Tower case.
- 9:18This is a case that came up between a student
- 9:22who claimed that his model was infringed by an
- 9:27architect who worked with Skidmore and Owens,
- 9:30who was also a juror. for this student's design
- 9:33competition when they were at Yale University.
- 9:36The outcome of this case is that the student
- 9:38won in part. The court found that there were
- 9:41triable issues about whether or not there was
- 9:44substantial similarity, actionable similarity
- 9:48to support a copyright infringement claim between
- 9:50the student's model and the architect's design
- 9:54for the Freedom Tower. It was a long drawn out
- 9:57case. The case ended up settling before trial
- 10:00in 2006. We don't know the terms of the settlement,
- 10:05but we can assume that the student probably got
- 10:07something considering that the court found there
- 10:09was a reason to at least have a trial. Going
- 10:13to the next case. We have Cornice and Rose versus
- 10:17Four Keys. This is a pretty straightforward case
- 10:20that shows us the power of that Section 120 exception
- 10:24to architectural work protection we just talked
- 10:26about. In this case, a bank purchased an incomplete
- 10:29building through bankruptcy. They decide to complete
- 10:32the building without permission from the original
- 10:35architectural firm, and they also didn't involve
- 10:37that firm. We don't know the exact facts of what
- 10:40happened, but We do know that the architect still
- 10:43owned the copyright in the building as an architectural
- 10:47work. So the architect had some leverage, tried
- 10:50to sue for copyright infringement, and basically
- 10:52said, by you new owner completing the building
- 10:55without me and without my consent, you have violated
- 10:59my copyright and my architectural work. You've
- 11:01created a derivative. This is infringement. The
- 11:05court pretty swiftly dismissed that claim and
- 11:08said under Section 120, this claim can't survive.
- 11:13The building owner is allowed to alter the building
- 11:16even if the architectural work is protected and
- 11:18even if the building owner doesn't own that copyright.
- 11:22This decision was affirmed by the Eighth Circuit,
- 11:24although on procedural grounds that weren't related
- 11:27to that issue there. That takes us to contractual
- 11:31considerations, which is the next slide. So here,
- 11:37we just wanted to quickly sum up for you guys.
- 11:39If you're dealing with agreements involving IP
- 11:41creators and building owners, you want to keep
- 11:44a few things in mind. First, you want to make
- 11:47sure you confirm and specify ownership. That
- 11:49includes ownership of plans, models, buildings,
- 11:52and derivatives. Ownership is always the best.
- 11:55You're going to be in the strongest position
- 11:56if you own the rights. There can only be one
- 11:59owner. So if you're representing a client or
- 12:02your own interest and you can't have ownership
- 12:04over the IP, the next thing you want to be looking
- 12:07for is a robust licensing right. License is second
- 12:11best. Ownership is best. When you're in the world
- 12:14of a license, the broader, the better. And you
- 12:17want to make sure that the license is, if you
- 12:19want to have the rights to do new things, include
- 12:21the right to make derivative works, which has
- 12:24to be expressly called out. And with that, we're
- 12:27gonna move over to Sarah and talk a little bit
- 12:30about how trademark and trade dress comes into
- 12:32play for protecting buildings. Thanks, Lindsay.
- 12:36Yeah, as Lindsay just mentioned, we're gonna
- 12:38pivot over to trade dress. This is not mutually
- 12:40exclusive with copyrights and we often advise
- 12:43clients to consider protecting both their copyrights
- 12:46and their trade dress as a sort of more robust
- 12:49protection and enforcement strategy. Moving to
- 12:53the next slide. So what exactly is trade dress.
- 12:57It protects the overall look and feel of a product
- 13:01or its packaging. We often see this, here's some
- 13:04examples on the side, you know, with consumer
- 13:06products like so, you know, bottles of soda,
- 13:10shoes, things like that. In the real estate context,
- 13:14what we're talking about is the visual appearance
- 13:17of the buildings and structures, the interior
- 13:20store layouts, and the facades of the buildings.
- 13:23And as we'll get into later, we'll provide some
- 13:26examples of each of these. Importantly, to actually
- 13:29secure trade dress registration, The trade dress
- 13:32must be distinctive, either inherently or through
- 13:37secondary meaning or acquired distinctiveness,
- 13:40which we'll go through later on in the presentation.
- 13:43The trade dress must also be non -functional,
- 13:46which can sometimes be a tough barrier to clear
- 13:49in the world of architecture and real estate.
- 13:52But as we'll see later on, it is possible. And
- 13:55lastly, it must be source identifying. And what
- 13:58we mean by that is that a consumer encountering
- 14:01the trade dress in the world should be able to
- 14:03see it and know by looking at it who the source
- 14:06of the underlying goods and services actually
- 14:08is. Importantly, trade dress can be registered
- 14:13or unregistered. Unregistered trade dress rights
- 14:16are enforceable. However, we generally recommend
- 14:19to secure registrations wherever possible because
- 14:22they provide prima facie evidence that indeed
- 14:25this trade dress is distinctive, non -functional,
- 14:28and source identifying. That can be a really
- 14:30helpful tool when you're enforcing those rights
- 14:33out the gate. Where are you registering the trade
- 14:37dress? So you register the trade dress with the
- 14:40United States Patent and Trademark Office, and
- 14:43that secures you national trademark rights in
- 14:46that trade dress, such that you can enforce it
- 14:48in any number of states. So it's basically registered
- 14:52as a trademark? Yeah. Trade dress is basically
- 14:55subsumed within trademark law. The same acts
- 15:00apply to trade dress. They're just slightly different.
- 15:03rules and levers that you would use for trade
- 15:06dress versus a word mark, for example. Okay,
- 15:11so moving on to the next slide. Before we get
- 15:14into this case, I also just want to briefly touch
- 15:17on a little bit what distinctiveness means in
- 15:20the world of trademark. It's very complicated,
- 15:23so I'll try and keep it relatively high level.
- 15:26Distinctiveness is basically a spectrum of protectability
- 15:29for a mark or trade dress. Essentially, the more
- 15:33distinctive or unique trademark or trade dress
- 15:36is, the more likely to be protected. want is
- 15:41something to be on the upper end of distinctiveness
- 15:44and the more generic or basic something might
- 15:46be. the less likely it is to be eligible for
- 15:49protection in the first place. And even if it
- 15:53is eligible, the more barriers you'll have to
- 15:56registration or enforcement of those rights.
- 15:59So now digging into this case, two cases versus
- 16:02Taco Cabana. This is actually a seminal trade
- 16:05dress case in general. And for our purposes,
- 16:07we're lucky because it's also a real estate case.
- 16:11This is a Supreme Court case from 1992. dispute
- 16:16between two Mexican restaurants. They both featured
- 16:20very colorful palettes, a highly distinctive
- 16:25patio. The interior store layouts were the same.
- 16:31Basically, the senior restaurant sued the junior
- 16:35restaurant for infringement of their trade dress.
- 16:38And this case is so important because for the
- 16:41first time, the Supreme Court held that trade
- 16:43dress can be inherently distinctive. And in fact,
- 16:47you know, a restaurant physical building trade
- 16:50dress can be inherently distinctive. And so in
- 16:52this case, the Supreme Court ruled that there
- 16:56was, in fact, infringement of the trade dress
- 16:58without a showing of secondary meaning. So this
- 17:02has had significant ramifications in the trade
- 17:05dress world in general and is, like I said, a
- 17:09landmark ruling. How would you measure damages
- 17:12or would it simply be an injunctive case? So
- 17:16in trademark cases, you can pursue both injunctive
- 17:19relief and damages. There are statutory damages,
- 17:23and there are also actual damages available.
- 17:27A lot of times, the calculus is based on the
- 17:31sort of financial loss to the business based
- 17:36on the junior users. abuse of the goodwill in
- 17:40that mark. It can sometimes be really difficult
- 17:42to track down unlike in copyright law, for example,
- 17:45where there's a really clear statutory range.
- 17:48But in answer to your question, both injunctive
- 17:50relief and damages are available. Thank you.
- 17:55Pivoting to the next slide, we wanted to show
- 17:59you some examples of what it actually, you know,
- 18:03some actually federally registered trade dress.
- 18:06We're going to show you examples of trade dress
- 18:08in the buildings themselves, facades of buildings,
- 18:11and in interior store layouts. So here we have
- 18:14some two really good examples. We have the Perot
- 18:17Museum of Science in Dallas, Texas, and we have
- 18:19the Wynn Casino on the Vegas Strip. Both of these
- 18:23registrants were able to secure registration
- 18:25in their trade dress for the buildings. As you
- 18:28can see, these are both really unique building
- 18:30designs. That's kind of exactly what we're looking
- 18:33for with trade dress. Someone walking down the
- 18:35street sees this, and they know exactly who is
- 18:38behind these buildings. One thing to also note,
- 18:43so these illustrations on the top are what you
- 18:46would actually submit to the US Patent and Trademark
- 18:49Office to detail what your trade dress actually
- 18:54is versus, of course, we have the actual physical
- 18:58structures below. One thing also to note in the
- 19:02illustrations, the dashed lines are expressly
- 19:05excluded from the scope of protection for that
- 19:07trade dress. What you're looking at is the solid
- 19:11lines. That's what's being protected here. So
- 19:14moving on to the next slide. I always like to
- 19:18include the Infinity dealerships, because I think
- 19:23that this is a really excellent example of how
- 19:26trade dress can be used by businesses. So basically,
- 19:32if you go to any Infinity dealership across the
- 19:35country, you're going to see this facade. So
- 19:37not only are you sort of strengthening your IP
- 19:42here, you're anywhere you go, you're seeing the
- 19:45same thing. the more consumers kind of encounter
- 19:48this, the more source identifying and more sort
- 19:51of vigorous your protection is. This is exactly
- 19:54kind of what we're looking for. And I think it
- 19:57can be really useful, especially for businesses
- 19:59that use a franchise model. You want to be repeating
- 20:02the trade dress over and over again and creating
- 20:05this association in consumers' minds that this
- 20:08facade is our business. Every time you see this,
- 20:11it's us in infinity. I think you know I often
- 20:15think about like the Pizza Hut example where
- 20:17when you you go to any Pizza Hut for a while
- 20:19I don't think they're like this anymore now that
- 20:21they're more modernized but for a while you would
- 20:23see like this hut and you knew immediately that
- 20:26was Pizza Hut. Another example here is the Medina
- 20:29Country Club. Here they were able to secure trade
- 20:32dress registration for their distinctive design.
- 20:35That's just another example of a facade that
- 20:38was capable of trade dress registration. Going
- 20:41to the next slide, we'll actually see how you
- 20:44can secure registration not only for the exterior
- 20:46of your building, but also the interior store
- 20:49layout. I think the Apple Store example is a
- 20:52really good illustration of this. You can close
- 20:55your eyes and imagine the layout of an Apple
- 20:58Store. That's the source identifying function
- 21:01of trade dress, even without the name Apple on
- 21:05the facade here or on the... you know, on the
- 21:07walls of the store, we know that that's an Apple
- 21:10store. It's distinctive. It's unique. You're
- 21:14only going to see this in an Apple store. We
- 21:16know that you're going to be able to buy Apple
- 21:18products when you come across a store that looks
- 21:20like this. That's sort of the real function of
- 21:22trade dress and is why it's kind of an important
- 21:25complement to copyright. It kind of protects
- 21:27this source identifying feature of the store.
- 21:31The Gibson store is another good example of this
- 21:34and I think is a really good example of what
- 21:36you know these dashed lines ring really particular
- 21:39about what you're claiming and protect claiming
- 21:41protection in um here you know i'm sure that
- 21:44gibson owns wordmark registrations and their
- 21:47stylized gibson marks but they've excluded it
- 21:49here they're really focusing on the store layout
- 21:52as as what they're seeking protection in in this
- 21:54case So pivoting to the next slide to actually
- 21:57see some applications of these concepts, we have
- 22:00In re Palacio del Rio. This is a case where a
- 22:04party was not successful in securing trade dress
- 22:06registration. The examiner refused registration
- 22:10because they felt that this building, which is
- 22:14a wall of windows and pretty basic structures,
- 22:18was not sufficiently distinctive to warrant trade
- 22:20dress protection. The application argued that,
- 22:23well, to the extent that these individual features
- 22:25are not protectable, the amalgamation of them
- 22:28creates a distinctive trade dress, and we should
- 22:31be able to secure registration in it. The trademark
- 22:34trial on a billboard disagreed, and they in Ray
- 22:39Pasio was ultimately not able to secure the registration,
- 22:42the application went abandoned. If we go to the
- 22:45next slide, we can see a really strong sort of
- 22:47comparison, right? We have in Ray Seminole tribe
- 22:49of Florida. Here, the building is the shape of
- 22:52a guitar. That is just extremely unique, highly
- 22:56distinctive, exactly the kind of thing you would
- 22:59expect to be able to secure trade dress in, even
- 23:02though in this case, the examiner initially refused
- 23:06registration. The applicant appealed to the trademark
- 23:10trial and appeal board. The board agreed with
- 23:12the applicant and said, no, this is exactly what
- 23:14we're looking for. This is highly distinctive.
- 23:17In fact, there are no other buildings in the
- 23:19country that look like this. The applicant should
- 23:21be able to secure registration. And indeed, they
- 23:24did so. One thing I'll also note here is that
- 23:28in this case, the board cited to this prior holding
- 23:32an in -ray furniture mart holdings 1 LLC, which
- 23:35was a case that held that a building's facade
- 23:38can function as a trademark. So we have this
- 23:41kind of growing body of TTAB precedents that
- 23:45helps us secure trade dress protection for these
- 23:48very, very unique buildings. Pivoting to the
- 23:52last slide in this section, we have another application
- 23:56of trade dress with respect to the interior of
- 24:01stores. Here we have Best Sellers, which is a
- 24:05wine retailer that created this really unique
- 24:09layout. You can see a picture of it here. Grapefines,
- 24:13which had a wine store in Washington DC. Their
- 24:17principals actually visited the best seller stores,
- 24:20were very entranced by it, as I'm sure we all
- 24:22are looking at this image, and decided that they
- 24:25would go ahead and replicate it. That was not
- 24:28taken well by best sellers who sued for trade
- 24:31dress infringement and were successful in securing
- 24:34a preliminary injunction from the court who found
- 24:38that best sellers trade dress in their interior
- 24:40store layouts and design was inherently distinctive
- 24:43and non -functional. So they were successful
- 24:48in stopping grape vines from proceeding in this
- 24:50case. So that takes us to the next question.
- 24:55A couple quick questions, Sarah, about that.
- 24:58Sure. Do the interior designers, decorators,
- 25:02architects seek trademark protection, or is it
- 25:05usually the owner of the store? It's usually
- 25:09the owner of the store. Because again, what we're
- 25:11talking about with trade dress and trademark
- 25:13is the source of the underlying goods and services.
- 25:16So in this case, it's not the architect or the
- 25:19designer who created this that's offering this
- 25:23wine. It's the business bestsellers, Inc. Of
- 25:26course, you want to have really robust agreements
- 25:28in place with any third parties that you're involving
- 25:31in the design process to ensure that any rights
- 25:35they may. have or claim to have or are sort of
- 25:38very expressly assigned to. the business at the
- 25:42end of the day. But typically what we see is
- 25:44the businesses applying for registry. And I suppose
- 25:47like - Yeah. And Howard, I would just jump in.
- 25:50We do also represent a lot of interior designers
- 25:53who are expressly hired for the look and feel
- 25:56of their style. And negotiating those types of
- 25:59agreements can get more complicated because the
- 26:02store wants to own the rights to the look and
- 26:04feel of the store, but they also want the look
- 26:06and feel of the interior designer, which they
- 26:09need to protect in order to be hired. again,
- 26:11so it can get very tricky. Very interesting.
- 26:14I suppose, as in most trademark cases, if you
- 26:18have a registration, it's going to be much easier
- 26:20in the litigation than if it's an unregistered
- 26:24trade dress. Yes, that's absolutely the case.
- 26:31This takes us to the world of VARA, Visual Artist
- 26:35Rights Act. In the US, through the Copyright
- 26:37Act, we have some limited protection for artist
- 26:40rights, also sometimes referred to as moral rights.
- 26:43We can go to the next slide. This tends to be
- 26:46one of the... a great area of law for the artists,
- 26:49but can be very, very scary for building owners.
- 26:52A lot of them don't know about it, and they do
- 26:54need to know about it to avoid getting into trouble.
- 26:57So generally speaking, the Copyright Act provides
- 26:59some limited protection for these rights. What
- 27:02is protected? Paintings, drawings, sculptures,
- 27:05prints, certain types of photographs as well.
- 27:08It does not protect things like maps or technical
- 27:11drawings or works that are made for hire. A few
- 27:15different rights that are protected. The first
- 27:17right is pretty easy, the right of attribution.
- 27:19The author has the right to claim authorship
- 27:21and to prevent from false attribution. So if
- 27:24you have a cause sculpture in your lobby, you
- 27:26have to say cause made it. And if you have a
- 27:28knockoff, you can't say that cause made the knockoff
- 27:31or you could get into trouble. Where things get
- 27:34more interesting and a little more complicated
- 27:36involves the right of integrity. through U .S.
- 27:40law artists are given the right to object to
- 27:42the intentional distortion, mutilation, or modification
- 27:46of their work if it's prejudicial to their reputation.
- 27:50Very difficult to prove exactly what this is,
- 27:52involves a lot of litigation, but some easy examples.
- 27:55If you have a mural on the wall of your building
- 27:57and the paint chips, you can repair it faithfully
- 28:01to the color that was chipped off, probably without
- 28:05violating the right of integrity. But if you
- 28:07completely change the color, you could get into
- 28:10an issue where the artist claims that your modification
- 28:13of the work was prejudicial to their reputation.
- 28:16Within the universe of the right of integrity,
- 28:20there is also a limited right to prevent the
- 28:23destruction, the intentional or grossly negligent
- 28:25destruction of works protected under VARA. But
- 28:30this is a little more narrow and it's limited
- 28:32to works of recognized stature, which usually
- 28:35means the artist is famous or well -known or
- 28:37the community has some appreciation for the work.
- 28:42If a toddler, does a painting on a wall and the
- 28:44wall gets destroyed, it's probably not a Vara
- 28:46violation. But if a famous museum exhibiting
- 28:49artist has their mural destroyed, it probably
- 28:52is a violation of this provision under Vara.
- 28:55We can go to the next. Yes. What happens if you
- 28:58have a building beyond its useful life? For economic
- 29:03reasons, you need to touch that artwork and change
- 29:07the building. You may have an issue, and we'll
- 29:10go to the next slide and start to talk about
- 29:12some of the caveats. But you may have an issue,
- 29:15and there are times where moral rights will see
- 29:18Trump the rights of real estate property owners.
- 29:21So we have some caveats. There are legislative
- 29:24ones, as well as contractual. First, under US
- 29:28law, VARA doesn't apply to works that are installed
- 29:32in buildings on consent before the effective
- 29:34date in 1991. It also doesn't apply to work made
- 29:38for hire. So that's another safety valve. And
- 29:41then contractually, we'll get to it more on the
- 29:43next slide, but borough rights can be waived
- 29:46away in an agreement. Going to the next slide,
- 29:49which I think touches on some of what Howard
- 29:51was addressing, when it comes to the question
- 29:55of whether a work is destroyed or distorted,
- 29:58mutilated, or modified in some way, there are
- 30:01a few different safety valves that are in the
- 30:03statute. So first, if you're dealing with non
- 30:06-removable work, there is no valid liability
- 30:09if the work is destroyed, distorted, or mutilated
- 30:11if either the artist consented to the installation,
- 30:15and that all happened before 1991. So older works,
- 30:18before Vera, if you destroy the whole building
- 30:21and the sculpture gets destroyed, you're not
- 30:23going to have a claim on your hands because you
- 30:26had it installed before this law even existed.
- 30:30And then the second way you can be protected
- 30:33is if you have a waiver. So you're dealing with
- 30:35works installed after 1991, and the artist has
- 30:38to consent in a document that the removal of
- 30:41their work after installation could result in
- 30:43destruction, distortion, mutilation, or modification.
- 30:47It's where contracts come in and are so important.
- 30:49Artists, for various reasons, might not always
- 30:51agree to that term, which we'll talk about in
- 30:53a little bit, but waiver is the safest way to
- 30:56be protected as a building owner. The other caveat
- 31:00that's in the statute, if you're dealing with
- 31:02removable works, if the work can be removed without
- 31:06destroying, distorting, mutilating, or modifying,
- 31:08which tends to be the vast majority of these
- 31:11works. There will be no vera liability even if
- 31:14you destroy the work, assuming that you either
- 31:16make a diligent good faith attempt without success
- 31:19to notify the artist, the creator of your intended
- 31:22action, or you give them actual notice at 90
- 31:26days. And within those 90 days, the artist does
- 31:30not remove or pay for the removal of the work.
- 31:33Then you can go ahead and knock down the building
- 31:35without there being a vera violation. Where this
- 31:39leaves us, one of the biggest risks is you have
- 31:41a work that's installed after 1991. There's no
- 31:45contractual of our waiver, and the work cannot
- 31:48be removed without destroying it, distorting
- 31:51it, mutilating it, or modifying it. In this case,
- 31:53you're in a very difficult situation. What you
- 31:55need to do is call your lawyer. Do not bulldoze
- 31:58your way through it, no pun intended. It's a
- 32:00tricky situation. Usually, you know, with money
- 32:04or other terms you can negotiate your way out
- 32:06of this problem, but you have a problem on your
- 32:08hands and you should not just destroy the building.
- 32:11You should try to work this out a different way.
- 32:15There is some good news. We know that things
- 32:18like incidental damage due to exposure from the
- 32:20elements or the passage of time doesn't create
- 32:23their liability. That's a little bit of good
- 32:26news for property owners. We're going to get
- 32:29into some cases now, but the takeaway as we'll
- 32:32see is that sometimes the real property owner
- 32:35loses. And it can be a real shock because a lot
- 32:39of property owners don't. either they don't know
- 32:42about bar or they don't really understand the
- 32:44implications of what they're doing, or they may
- 32:47even forget that there's a site -specific artwork
- 32:50in the building in the first place when they
- 32:52decide to modify or tear down or destroy in some
- 32:55way. Going to the first case, this ends up being
- 32:58a good case for the property owner. Here on appeal,
- 33:04the work was determined to be a work made for
- 33:06hire. works made for hire are not protected under
- 33:09VARA, so the building owner won. This case was
- 33:13a little bit shocking though because Basically,
- 33:17there was a lower court decision, there was a
- 33:20TRO and a PI, and then a bench trial, all go
- 33:23in favor of the artist. The court ends up granting
- 33:25a permanent injunction, but no damages, but the
- 33:29court enjoined the building owner and said, you
- 33:31are prohibited from destroying, distorting, mutilating,
- 33:34or removing this artwork for the lifetime of
- 33:37the artists, right? Could be decades. You have
- 33:40this big installation. Some people may like it.
- 33:43The new building owner here didn't. The lower
- 33:45court said, sorry, you're stuck with it until
- 33:48these artists pass away. gets appealed to the
- 33:51Second Circuit. The Second Circuit digs into
- 33:53the factual record in a different way and reaches
- 33:56a different conclusion based on a finding that
- 33:58this artist had been working for the original
- 34:01building owner for like two years, working on
- 34:03all different things around the building. This
- 34:05wasn't just a one -off commission. The relationship
- 34:08was more akin to an employee employer, which
- 34:10made it a work made for hire. And so Vara did
- 34:13not apply. So here the building owner was able
- 34:17to escape liability. after a very scary situation
- 34:22before the lower court. That's not always the
- 34:24case, as we'll see in the next case. So the next
- 34:29slide shows Martin versus City of Indianapolis.
- 34:32Here we have an instance where a Vara violation
- 34:35was found. In this case, an artist had created
- 34:38a sculpture on land owned by the artist's employer,
- 34:41but the record showed that the work was all done
- 34:43outside the scope of his employment. Most of
- 34:46the work was done on the weekends and the holidays
- 34:48and really had nothing to do with the work he
- 34:50was doing for the employer. In the meantime,
- 34:54the city of Indianapolis acquires the land and
- 34:57wants to destroy, wants to sort of do a clean
- 34:59slate, including get rid of the sculpture, didn't
- 35:02give the artist the right or ability to remove
- 35:04the sculpture. The artist was obviously upset
- 35:07about this. The artist sues the court grants
- 35:10summary judgment in favor of the artist. including
- 35:13awarding statutory damages of $20 ,000. Here's
- 35:16the kicker. The court thought that the city was
- 35:20really operating in bad faith, and so they also
- 35:23awarded attorney's fees and that attorney's fee
- 35:26and damages award was affirmed on appeal. Obviously,
- 35:30this was a big embarrassment for the city. If
- 35:32they had gone to the artist first and given the
- 35:35artist the opportunity to maybe take the work
- 35:37off the property, negotiated some of those terms,
- 35:40they might not have had this kind of situation
- 35:42on their hands. But this is really worst case
- 35:45scenario for property owners. We're going to
- 35:47now quickly shift over to some more recent cases
- 35:51dealing with Barrett issues in the world of street
- 35:53art and murals. Two cases with very different
- 35:56outcomes and Sarah is going to cover those. Sure.
- 36:00So this first case we have is called the five
- 36:02points case, Cohen versus G and M Realty. In
- 36:07this case, we had a developer that owns this
- 36:10series of kind of interconnected warehouses.
- 36:13And he decided that he wanted to turn this into
- 36:16kind of an outdoor exhibition space for graffiti
- 36:19art. He, you know, got a bunch of different artists
- 36:22to come and spray paint and cover the building
- 36:24in their art. Ten years later, he changed his
- 36:28mind, which, you know, people often do, decided
- 36:31he wanted to remove all this graffiti art. He
- 36:33planned to whitewash it. The artist caught wind
- 36:36of this and asserted their rights under Vara.
- 36:40and they sued and were successful in getting
- 36:43a TRO against the developer to stop the removal
- 36:47of these works. The court ultimately was hesitant
- 36:51to convert that TRO into a PI, but did expressly
- 36:55warn the developers that if... The case is going
- 36:59to proceed if the artists are successful and
- 37:02you take action while the case is pending, you
- 37:05may be liable for significant damages and in
- 37:07fact, potentially liable for willfulness. The
- 37:13developer sort of ignored that warning from the
- 37:17court and decided nonetheless to go ahead and
- 37:20whitewash all of these pieces and that ended
- 37:25up being a pretty costly mistake for the business
- 37:27developer. the court awarded maximum damages
- 37:33against the developer, including for willfulness.
- 37:36That resulted in a $6 .75 million price tag that
- 37:41the developer had to pay. This is another case
- 37:45where business developer made a grave error and
- 37:49ended up being quite pricey. This is just an
- 37:54example of people change their mind, you want
- 37:56to make sure from the jump that you set yourself
- 37:59up so that you can change your mind 10 years
- 38:00later if you want to. Next. This sounds like
- 38:04a case where the owner either didn't get proper
- 38:08notice from his council about the statutory 90
- 38:11days to salvage the art or just chose to ignore
- 38:14it. Yeah, there's a lot in the record about him
- 38:18being very aggressive, and it's interesting because
- 38:21you would think that graffiti can't be removed
- 38:24from the wall of a building, but the artist had
- 38:27actually presented testimony in this case that
- 38:29they could have removed it if they were given
- 38:31the opportunity to. Great. So this next case,
- 38:38the Vermont Law School case, Kirsten versus Vermont
- 38:41Law School, is a Interesting counter example
- 38:44to the five points case here again we have a
- 38:47mural on the building the school had commissioned
- 38:50an artist to make this mural over time as sort
- 38:55of. society kind of evolved. Many people felt
- 38:58that this mural was actually quite offensive
- 39:00and the school started to receive a lot of complaints
- 39:03petitioning for the removal of this mural. The
- 39:07school was maybe a bit more aware of Vera than
- 39:11the developer in Five Points was cautious and
- 39:14rather than destroy or, you know, paint over
- 39:18or remove this mural, they instead decided to
- 39:21obstruct it from view behind some panels. The
- 39:25artist was still pretty upset that the mural
- 39:28was was removed from public view and sued under
- 39:31Vara. However, the court held that you know,
- 39:35the school did nothing wrong, they didn't destroy,
- 39:38mutilate, the mural was still there, it just
- 39:41was covered up, and that is not actionable under
- 39:43VARA. So this is an interesting counterpoint
- 39:46where, you know, there can be creative solutions
- 39:48under this act. So going to the next slide, we
- 39:54can take kind of all that we've learned from
- 39:57the, you know, wins and losses from the last
- 40:00cases and, you know, The main takeaway from all
- 40:03of this body of law is that you really want to
- 40:05set yourself up at the beginning, before any
- 40:08disputes arise, before emotions and tensions
- 40:11run high, and that can happen at the contractual
- 40:14level. You want to be thinking about VARA rights.
- 40:18We know that they can be waived. That's something
- 40:21to consider putting in a contract as a property
- 40:23owner. oftentimes with more sophisticated artists
- 40:27who are aware of their rights under VARA or who
- 40:30are bigger and have negotiated a lot of these
- 40:32contracts, they're not going to be willing to
- 40:34waive their rights under VARA. And so you want
- 40:36to be having that conversation at the beginning
- 40:37to think about what kinds of other safeguards
- 40:40you can put in place, knowing that they may not
- 40:44be willing to waive their rights outright. So
- 40:46that can include considering the terms for removal
- 40:50or destruction. What does that actually look
- 40:51like when that time comes? Being explicit about
- 40:54notice and who bears the cost for removal. You
- 40:58want to pre -negotiate any. permissible alterations
- 41:01and modifications. This includes any necessary
- 41:04repairs, relocation. And then finally, we see
- 41:08how big these cases can get, how complicated
- 41:11litigation can be. And so we really encourage
- 41:14considering dispute resolution or ADR in the
- 41:17contracts out the gate. And that can really help
- 41:21save a lot of time and money down the road. So
- 41:25pivoting to the next section of the presentation,
- 41:28we're going to talk about landlord liability
- 41:30for tenants' infringements. Well, maybe I'm not
- 41:34sure, but I would venture to guess that a lot
- 41:36of you probably did not even know this was possible,
- 41:39but it is. So going to the next slide, we're
- 41:43actually seeing an increasing trend of this kind
- 41:46of liability in the IP space, where landlords
- 41:49are being held liable for the infringements and
- 41:54counterfeiting efforts of their tenants. This
- 41:58arises when the landlord has actual knowledge,
- 42:02should have known or turns a blind eye to counterfeiting
- 42:06efforts that are happening within their buildings.
- 42:10The most important takeaway from these cases
- 42:13is that you really can't ignore it. You can't
- 42:15bury your head in the sand. Once you become aware
- 42:18that there's counterfeiting, there's trademark
- 42:20infringement happening on your premises, you
- 42:23need to start taking action and you need to start
- 42:25documenting that action. So going to the next
- 42:28slide, we have a recent example of this in the
- 42:32Luxottica group case. So here, there was a mall
- 42:36where retailers within that mall, tenants within
- 42:40that mall were selling. counterfeit sunglasses.
- 42:44The manufacturers of those sunglasses were, they
- 42:47were sending demand letters to the mall. They
- 42:49were putting them all on notice and the mall
- 42:51just kept ignoring it. Ultimately, there were
- 42:55multiple raids at the mall. The project manager
- 42:58at the mall was served warrants with lists of
- 43:02the brands and products that were being counterfeited
- 43:04at that mall. There were trailers in front of
- 43:07the mall where they were loading up all the seized
- 43:09goods. There just was no way, really, for the
- 43:14mall to say, we had no idea, maya culpa. And
- 43:18ultimately, the manufacturer sued the mall for
- 43:23the infringements of the mall's tenants. And
- 43:26they were successful. And they secured a $1 .9
- 43:29million damages award that was affirmed on appeal.
- 43:33In this case, the defendants certainly knew,
- 43:37or at least should have known. Like I said, we're
- 43:41seeing an increasing trend often in the counterfeiting
- 43:45space. It's just something to be aware of. Going
- 43:49to the next slide. Again, this is another space
- 43:52where we can preempt a lot of these really negative
- 43:54outcomes at the contract stage. Knowing that
- 43:58as a building owner, you can be held liable for
- 44:01the infringements of your tenants. You want to
- 44:02bake that into your contract. express provisions
- 44:06prohibiting that kind of activity, prohibiting
- 44:09IP infringement and counterfeiting. And you also
- 44:11want to be clear about that being a basis for
- 44:14termination. And you want that to be really expressed.
- 44:17You know, if we see this type of activity, that's
- 44:20grounds for termination. And then finally, as
- 44:24I mentioned before, if you're starting to notice
- 44:27this happening if you have if you're starting
- 44:30to feel suspicious or if you become actually
- 44:32aware you need to start taking action and you
- 44:33need to start documenting that that way if and
- 44:36when a case is levied you can say sure but i
- 44:40terminated the lease like i'm not held liable
- 44:42i took action as soon as i became aware of this
- 44:45um and then we'll end on um another sort of quick
- 44:51thing to One more point on that, Sarah. I suppose
- 44:54you also could think about an indemnity provision
- 44:57if the tenant has assets or something. Yeah.
- 45:01Yeah. Yeah, that's a good point. OK, so this
- 45:06is the last section, which is just a quick note
- 45:09about listing photography in real estate listings.
- 45:13Going to the next slide, this is another space
- 45:16where we're seeing an increasing number of cases
- 45:18being filed against places like Zillow or other
- 45:24kind of real estate listing networks. What's
- 45:29important to note here is that Photographs are
- 45:32subject to copyright protection and each individual
- 45:35photograph is is protectable as an independent
- 45:38work. So just because you're coming across a
- 45:41picture of a house online, you can't just copy,
- 45:45paste and upload that to your real estate listing.
- 45:47You need proper permission, a license, ownership,
- 45:52something like this. You can take your own pictures
- 45:54in -house, but you can't just copy and paste
- 45:57existing photographs and upload it. So we can
- 46:03go to the next slide and I'll circle back to
- 46:05AI at the end. This is an example of one of these
- 46:08cases here. Zillow had copied over 2000 photographs
- 46:13belonging to VHT and uploaded it to their sites.
- 46:18VHT sued. Zillow tried to argue that, well, we're
- 46:23cropping the photographs. We're changing things
- 46:25a little bit. Therefore, it's transformative
- 46:28use. It's defensible. It's fair use. The court
- 46:32did not agree with that. They said, no, this
- 46:35is not fair use. This is copyright infringement,
- 46:38and issued a $1 .9 million damages award for
- 46:43VHT. And part of the reason that that damages
- 46:47award is so high is because as I mentioned, each
- 46:50individual photograph is subject to damages.
- 46:53So for each one, you're looking at damages of
- 46:57between $750 to $30 ,000 per photograph. And
- 47:01then that can go up to $150 ,000 for willfulness.
- 47:06So, you know, with sites like this, it's so easy.
- 47:09I mean, they copied over $2 ,000, 2000 photographs
- 47:13just here. So each listing can have, you know,
- 47:1512 photographs, each one of those 12 photographs
- 47:18is subject to damages. So that's just something
- 47:20to keep in mind. How would the damages go up
- 47:24from the $750 ,000 to the maximum there? What
- 47:27do they look at? The range, the $750 ,000 to
- 47:31$30 ,000 ranges at the discretion of the court.
- 47:35There are different, there are different fact
- 47:38patterns that result in different damages within
- 47:41that range. We're talking about the amount that's
- 47:44been copied. We're talking about if there's any
- 47:50relationship between the parties, but ultimately,
- 47:52it's really at the discretion of the court. If
- 47:55you're the counsel there, what sort of factors
- 47:58are you going to argue to the court to get it
- 48:01from the lower range to the higher range? Yeah.
- 48:07Oh, sorry, Lindsay, go ahead. I was just going
- 48:09to say that One of the key things will also be
- 48:11the market value for the photograph at issue.
- 48:15So you'll often look at the licensing rates for
- 48:19that work or for similar works. But you can get
- 48:22multipliers if a party is found to have been
- 48:26copying or infringing willfully, which can include
- 48:29willful blindness. And so that's where you're
- 48:31starting to look at multipliers off of what a
- 48:34market rate is. Thank you. Well, that actually
- 48:41closes out our presentation. We, I think, have
- 48:45a few, maybe 10 minutes for questions. Is that
- 48:48right, Howard? Yeah, and we want to go ahead
- 48:51and use the full 10 minutes, but I don't have
- 48:53questions from the people in attendance, but
- 48:58I had a couple other things to ask you myself.
- 49:02One of the things that I... talk to people about
- 49:05I mentioned this program and things like this
- 49:07that people you see lawyers and other people
- 49:10do quite a lot is they'll take a picture of the
- 49:13office building they're in and put it on their
- 49:15website or their business cards or things like
- 49:17that. My understanding is that that is problematic
- 49:20for the person doing it. Yeah, it depends on
- 49:26what the building is, but the nice thing is when
- 49:30you're doing things for personal use, there's
- 49:32often fair use exceptions. So there are things
- 49:35that you could see on someone's individual card
- 49:39or even posts you see on social media that either
- 49:43someone would never get sued over or there might
- 49:46be a fair use defense where if Coca -Cola did
- 49:49the exact same thing, they'd be considered to
- 49:51be. doing it for a commercial purpose and they
- 49:56would probably be liable. In addition to that,
- 49:59it's also permissible to take your own photograph
- 50:03of a building that's publicly viewable from the
- 50:06sidewalk. There's a pretty robust body of law
- 50:10around that. That would suggest that I could
- 50:14put it on my website and it wouldn't be a problem.
- 50:18What if it's a registered design? Yeah, even
- 50:23then, I mean, we, you know, for example, we've
- 50:28had clients where, you know, they have, you know,
- 50:34did a fashion shoot in front of, you know, on
- 50:39the streets of New York, there are buildings
- 50:40in the background. There's no infringement of
- 50:44the copyright in the architectural work there.
- 50:47Yeah, but where things can get a little tricky,
- 50:50going back to the like the Varro cases is if
- 50:53that building has a graffiti on it, we've seen
- 50:55a lot of cases where the artists then sue. So
- 50:58even if the building owner can't sue because
- 51:01they have a copyright in the building as an architectural
- 51:03work, that same kind of exemption doesn't apply
- 51:07for. art that is on the building. So you have
- 51:11cases, and there have been a few notable examples
- 51:13recently where graffiti artists say, your commercial
- 51:17infringed my copyright and my graffiti. You didn't
- 51:20get my permission to include it. And so I can
- 51:24sue you for copyright infringement. So it's not
- 51:26just the building, but what's on the building
- 51:28where you can sometimes get into trouble. So
- 51:30does a building owner have a problem if somebody
- 51:32puts graffiti up and they don't take it down
- 51:36right away. I assume that they have a right immediately
- 51:38to take it down or do something else. But if
- 51:40they leave it up for a long time, are they then
- 51:42perhaps subjecting themselves to liability when
- 51:45they do remove it? It's tricky. And there are
- 51:47actually, there are like two VARA cases on this
- 51:50issue. And so, you know, they've acknowledged
- 51:52it's a gray area of law because the statute doesn't
- 51:56expressly say that VARA is limited to works that
- 51:59were applied somewhere with consent. But the
- 52:02two courts that have looked into this issue have
- 52:04basically read in that as a requirement that
- 52:08in order to have VARA protection, the work has
- 52:11to be put up legally. And in the case of Five
- 52:13Points, the works were put up legally and there
- 52:16was a curator involved. So even though it, you
- 52:19know, it looked like graffiti and a lot of the
- 52:21artists who did the work have works around the
- 52:24world that they didn't do legally. In that case,
- 52:26they were legally applied. But there have been
- 52:29two cases that looked at the issue and said,
- 52:31you know, it would just, it would be a perverse
- 52:33incentive if we were to permit this kind of protection
- 52:36for someone who doesn't have the legal right
- 52:39to put graffiti or, you know, art on a building
- 52:42because then the building owner just by cleaning
- 52:44up the mess would be subject to liability under
- 52:48the Copyright Act, and that just doesn't seem
- 52:49to be the purpose and intent of the statute.
- 52:52But it's a harder question. We do now have four
- 52:55questions that just came up. Someone had to know
- 52:57if there's VARA protection for artists like Banksy.
- 53:01Yeah. And somebody else asked, when does posting
- 53:06a photo of a building or mural in a social media
- 53:08post turn from fair use into infringement? Or
- 53:12does it? Yeah, I mean, it can. It's more likely
- 53:15going to be the case if it's done by a commercial
- 53:19player and they're doing it in a way, if it's
- 53:21trademarked that it's confusing us to source
- 53:23or it can come up in the copyright context, too.
- 53:30But it's an interesting point because from our
- 53:33perspective, the world of social media is still
- 53:36a little bit like the wild, wild west. from a
- 53:39lawyer's perspective and IP lawyer's perspective,
- 53:41there's really two social medias. There's things
- 53:44that people do and things that businesses do.
- 53:48Sometimes things that people do, like in the
- 53:50case of reposting paparazzi photographs, you
- 53:53can get into trouble. But for the most part,
- 53:56a lot of what people do flies under the surface
- 53:58or would be fair use. If it's done by a business,
- 54:01the same thing could be found infringing. What
- 54:05if an individual uses photos, You took for their
- 54:09professional websites or linkedin .com Sorry
- 54:14to clarify the question is is the question a
- 54:17third party took a photograph of you and you
- 54:20upload it to your Website or you took your own
- 54:23photo and you put it on LinkedIn I think somebody's
- 54:28asking what if what if the individual? Took some
- 54:32photos and then somebody used it for their professional
- 54:35website or linkedin .com or something like that.
- 54:40I mean, it's technically actionable, even if
- 54:42you're the subject of the photograph. If a photographer
- 54:45took a picture of you, they own the copyrights
- 54:48in that photo, absent an agreement or some other
- 54:52transfer of ownership, and then you upload that.
- 54:55It's technically actionable. Again, as Lindsay
- 54:58said, there's a question about whether the display
- 55:02is commercial or not, what exactly you're using
- 55:04it for that can come into play, but at a baseline.
- 55:09Yeah, that falls under copyright. So somebody
- 55:12just puts an interesting photo up in social media
- 55:15and somebody says, gee, I like it. And they take
- 55:17it and use it on their website or LinkedIn or
- 55:20something. They could have liability to that
- 55:22individual who put it out publicly in social
- 55:26media. Yeah. And that's why we see so many. I
- 55:29mean, there's a whole sort of industry of these
- 55:33third party kind of they're almost like troll
- 55:35adjacent copyright. monitoring services that
- 55:39just crawl the web for this exact type of copying
- 55:43that a lot of people just aren't thinking might
- 55:46subject them to liability. And as soon as they
- 55:48see one of their clients uploaded, one of their
- 55:51clients works uploaded to another website, you'll
- 55:53get a letter that says, pay me $30 ,000, whatever.
- 55:58Because it happens just like this, you come across
- 56:00something online, you copy it, you think it's
- 56:02innocent, and it's not always innocent. Yes,
- 56:06and we're even I've worked on a lot of these
- 56:07with Sarah we're seeing a lot of these even if
- 56:09there's a Creative Commons license involved because
- 56:12under the old versions of the Creative Commons
- 56:15license, if you like violated a small term like
- 56:18you didn't put in the right attribution the license
- 56:21would basically be ineffective. And so we would
- 56:24have, you know, we would get these kinds of letters,
- 56:26even though the the photograph was under Creative
- 56:29Commons license because it wasn't technically
- 56:31complied with. And there are these services that
- 56:34just scrape the internet looking for violations.
- 56:39Somebody else asked, I'm not sure if I get this
- 56:41completely, is there any successful case of fair
- 56:44use for the property market? I'm not sure exactly
- 56:50in what context that would come up. And their
- 56:55second question was, how is AI used so far in
- 56:58the property market? Oh yeah, that's a great
- 57:01reminder. I said that I would circle back to
- 57:03AI and didn't. I was going to mention in the
- 57:06listing photography section that we are seeing
- 57:09more, in general, we're seeing AI used more.
- 57:12We're also seeing it used to generate listing
- 57:16photographs. As of right now, it's an ever -changing
- 57:20area of law, but as of right now, there's no
- 57:23copyright protection for works generated by AI
- 57:27because it technically does not have human authorship.
- 57:31That may change, we don't know, but that's where
- 57:33it stands right now. I think there's a more complicated
- 57:36question when, for example, you take a photograph
- 57:39off the internet that someone has copyrights
- 57:42in and then you use AI to, let's say, put furniture.
- 57:45in the image. I think that becomes a much more
- 57:48complicated question. I think one side might
- 57:51say, well, I have rights in that work. You've
- 57:54created a derivative of it. You're infringing
- 57:57my rights, and I have a claim. I think the other
- 58:00side would say, well, AI is a Wild West. I'm
- 58:05not doing anything that I'm not supposed to.
- 58:07AI just did this. It wasn't me. So I think it's
- 58:11a complicated area of law. I personally think
- 58:13in general, just don't use anybody else's pictures,
- 58:16whether you're attaching AI to it or not. I think
- 58:19in that case, even if you're putting pictures
- 58:23of chairs in the room, they still have rights
- 58:25in that image and you're copying that image.
- 58:28So if you have a defense that something was created
- 58:31by AI, how do you go in and find out if that
- 58:34particular work or that photograph was created
- 58:37by AI or not? I mean, there are a lot of Oh,
- 58:42sorry. Go ahead, sorry. I was going to say, this
- 58:45is not necessarily a legal answer, but there
- 58:46are a lot of telltale signs of AI use. We see
- 58:50this sometimes in the copyright space where someone
- 58:56took a photograph of soccer players on the field
- 59:00and they have trademarks on their jerseys, and
- 59:03then you ask ChatGBT to create. uh an image of
- 59:07two people playing soccer and you get this image
- 59:09back that kind of looks like it but it's like
- 59:12everything's kind of distorted people have like
- 59:14four different you know people have eight fingers
- 59:17whatever they're these kind of telltale signs
- 59:19of ai use um so that's that's how i've seen it
- 59:25i don't know lindsay if you're aware of other
- 59:27Yeah, I mean, there are discovery devices you
- 59:30can use. First, you know, it's becoming kind
- 59:32of standard practice for companies that are using
- 59:35some AI in their creative process to have their
- 59:38designers or creators have creation logs where
- 59:41they're documenting Wendy. AI input was included
- 59:45because the way copyright law works right now,
- 59:48you're going to need to tell the Copyright Office
- 59:50or telecourt what parts of the creation was made
- 59:52by a human and what parts was made by AI. So
- 59:55there's probably discoverable documents out there
- 59:58to show what, you know, if you're dealing with
- 1:00:00a professional business to show what. where AI
- 1:00:03was used and where it wasn't. But there are also
- 1:00:07third party subpoenas that can go out to the
- 1:00:10different AI companies. And open AI, for example,
- 1:00:13right now, it's under a preservation order. So
- 1:00:18all inputs and all outputs by court order have
- 1:00:21to be preserved, even if you say delete, because
- 1:00:25they're being sued for copyright infringement
- 1:00:27as a whole. a smart litigant could spin an open
- 1:00:31AI and potentially get that kind of discovery
- 1:00:34or other companies like it. So we'll see what
- 1:00:37happens when those cases die down, then things
- 1:00:40may be back to standard preservation terms. But
- 1:00:42as of right now, everything you're feeding into
- 1:00:45an AI company that is under litigation, you should
- 1:00:48assume, is being preserved in some law firm's
- 1:00:52bucket somewhere. someone says for property owner
- 1:00:55liability for infringements occurring on their
- 1:00:58property by tenants. Are there are there actions
- 1:01:02the IP owner must take for there to be liability?
- 1:01:06In other words, giving notice or something like
- 1:01:08that? The question is there actions that the
- 1:01:13the owner of the IP should be taking the owner.
- 1:01:18They have to give notice to the landlord. if
- 1:01:22they think that some tenants violating their
- 1:01:24IP. Yeah, they don't have to, but it's a good
- 1:01:27idea, you know, or to CC them on the letter,
- 1:01:29things like that. In the case that Sarah talked
- 1:01:32about there was actual notice, but there is also
- 1:01:35constructive notice. And courts have said constructive
- 1:01:38notice can be enough, and you can't be willfully
- 1:01:41blind. So if you see suspicious activity, or
- 1:01:45in that Luxottica case, there were $200 sunglasses
- 1:01:49being sold as new for $10. That's pretty suspicious
- 1:01:53in and of itself. repeated this question to sort
- 1:02:01of clean it up a little bit. They say most cases
- 1:02:03result in saying the use of photos isn't transformative.
- 1:02:07Are there any cases supporting transformative
- 1:02:09use of photographs where apparently that was
- 1:02:12allowed? Yeah, I mean, I'm not aware of one where
- 1:02:17the photograph wasn't changed at all. And really
- 1:02:19for something to be transformative, there has
- 1:02:21to be, you have to have some sort of change and
- 1:02:24courts have said just. Just a change in the medium
- 1:02:27or just a change in the context isn't going to
- 1:02:30be enough. Well, this has been fascinating. Certainly
- 1:02:34some things that most of us probably weren't
- 1:02:36aware of and wouldn't necessarily have expected
- 1:02:39could be issues. A little scary about how things
- 1:02:44that you don't really expect can create liability,
- 1:02:48especially, for example, the owner's liability
- 1:02:50for the tenant's infringement and issues like
- 1:02:53that. And we want to thank you so much for joining
- 1:02:56us and putting together this very interesting
- 1:03:01program on intellectual property and real estate
- 1:03:03coming together. And, you know, our thanks for
- 1:03:08putting together the program for us. And thank
- 1:03:10you to everybody who's attended.