Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Virginia Roberts 2nd Amended Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's 1st Discovery Request (Part 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're going to start taking a look
- 0:06at Virginia Roberts. Second Amended Supplemental Response and Objections to
- 0:11Defendants First Set of Discovery Requests to Plaintiff Case number
- 0:16fifteen DASH CV DASH zero seven four three three dash
- 0:21RWs Virginia Roberts, Plaintiff first Glane Maxwell, the defendant plaintiffs.
- 0:27Second Amended Supplemental Response and Objections to defendants first set
- 0:31of Discovery requests to plaintiff. Plaintiff hereby serves her second
- 0:36Amended Supplemental Response and Objections to defendants First set of
- 0:40Discovery requests General objections. Defendant's first set of discovery requests
- 0:46violates Local Civil Rule thirty three dot three. Defendant has
- 0:49served interrogatories that are in direct violation of that rule
- 0:53because the interrogatories are not restricted to those seeking names
- 0:57of witnesses with knowledge of information relevant to the subject
- 1:01matter of the action, the computation of each category of
- 1:04damage alleged, and the existence, custodian location and general description
- 1:09of relevant documents, including pertinent insurance agreements and other physical
- 1:14evidence or information of a similar nature. Local Civil Rule
- 1:18thirty three dot three. A. Instead, they seek information under
- 1:23subsections B and C of Local Civil Rule thirty three
- 1:27dot three, and therefore they should not be served because
- 1:30they are not a more practical method of obtaining the
- 1:33information sought than a request for production or a deposition,
- 1:38and because they were served in advance of the period
- 1:41thirty days prior to the discovery cutoff date Local Civil
- 1:46Rule thirty three dot B and C. The interrogatories you
- 1:50serve to violate local Rule thirty three dot three, and
- 1:53we ask that you immediately withdraw those interrogatories. See Rule
- 1:57thirty three dot three. Local rules for the other District
- 2:00of New York. Also C. Shannon versus New York City
- 2:04Transit Authority number zero zero SIEVE five zero seven nine
- 2:09sweet J two thousand and one, WL two eight six
- 2:13seven two seven AT three SDN Y, March twenty second,
- 2:16two thousand and one. According to Gary Friedrich Enterprises, LLC
- 2:21versus Marvel Enterprises Incorporated Number zero eight SIV one five
- 2:26three three PSJ JCF twenty eleven, WL one sixty four
- 2:32two three eight one AT four SDN Y, April twenty six,
- 2:36twenty eleven. A unless otherwise ordered by the court at
- 2:40the commencement of discovery. Interrogatories will be restricted to those
- 2:44seeking names of witnesses with knowledge of information relevant to
- 2:48the subject matter of the action, the computation of each
- 2:52category of damage alleged, and the existence custodian location and
- 2:57general description of relevant documents, including pertinent insurance agreements and
- 3:02other physical evidence or information of a similar nature. B
- 3:07During discovery, interrogatories other than those seeking information described and
- 3:11paragraph A above may only be served one if they
- 3:14are more practical method of obtaining the information sought than
- 3:18a request for production or a deposition, or two if
- 3:22ordered by the court and see at the conclusion of
- 3:25other discovery and at least thirty days prior to the
- 3:28discovery cut off date. Interrogatories seeking the claims and contentions
- 3:33of the opposing party may be served unless the court
- 3:36has ordered otherwise. Similarly, requests for production numbers one, two, four, six, I, nine, twelve, thirty,
- 3:45thirty five, and thirty seven also violate Local Rule thirty
- 3:49three dot three in that they rely on the offending
- 3:52interrogatory requests. The rule provides that a party must first
- 3:57try to obtain discovery through document production and NI testimony.
- 4:01Discovery does not close in this case until July one,
- 4:04twenty sixteen, and the defendant has not yet noticed a deposition.
- 4:08As such, the interrogatories violate local Rule thirty three dot
- 4:12three and are premature. Defendant's first set of discovery requests
- 4:16also violates Rule thirty three fed OURSIVP, which provides a
- 4:20party may serve on any other party no more than
- 4:24twenty five interrogatories, including discrete subparts, and that the defendant
- 4:28has served a total of fifty nine interrogatories including subparts,
- 4:33in violation of rule thirty three. We ask that you
- 4:36immediately withdraw those interrogatories that exceed the twenty five interrogatory
- 4:41limit set by rule thirty three. Miss Roberts subjects to
- 4:44Defendant's first set of discovery requests to the extent that
- 4:48they seek information that is protected by any applicable privilege,
- 4:52including but not limited to, attorney client privilege, work product privilege,
- 4:56joint defense, common interest privilege, public interest privilege, and any
- 5:00other applicable privilege. Miss Roberts objects to the request to
- 5:04the extent Defendant's first set of discovery requests call for
- 5:07the production of documents or information that is already in
- 5:12the possession, custody, or control of the defendant. Miss Roberts
- 5:16further objects to the requests to the extent that defendant's
- 5:19first set of discovery requests is duplicative of documents and
- 5:23information that can equally or more readily be obtained by
- 5:27the defendant. Miss Roberts objects to the requests to the
- 5:31extent that they seek documents that are not relevant, material,
- 5:35or necessary to this action, and thus are not reasonably
- 5:38calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Many
- 5:42of the requests in the defendant's first set of discovery
- 5:45seek documents that are in no way limited to their
- 5:48relation to this case. Indeed, they seek documents that are
- 5:52not important to resolving the issues, documents that are not
- 5:55relevant to any party's claim or defense, and documents that
- 5:59are not propared portional to the needs of the case.
- 6:02Such requests create a heavy burden on Miss Roberts that
- 6:05outweighs any benefit. Such discovery is prohibited by the Federal
- 6:09Rules of Civil Procedure, particularly under the twenty fifteen amendments
- 6:14to Rule twenty six B one FED are sivep and
- 6:18is wholly inappropriate. Miss Roberts objects to the request to
- 6:21the extent that they are overly broad and unduly burdensome,
- 6:25as individually logging all privileged responsive documents would be overly burdensome.
- 6:31Plaintiff contends that requests targeting such privileged information are overly
- 6:36broad Rules twenty six B one fed our sivep. Specifically,
- 6:40Miss Roberts objects to the requests as overly burdensome to
- 6:44the extent that they would require logging large and ever
- 6:47increasing privileged communications between Miss Roberts and OER Council after
- 6:51the date litigation commenced on September twenty first, twenty fifteen.
- 6:56Miss Roberts objects to the requests as overly burdensome to
- 7:00the extent that they would require logging volumes of privileged
- 7:03documents between Miss Roberts and her council related to Jane
- 7:07Doe number one and Jane Doe number two. United States
- 7:10Case number zero eight eight zero seven three six Dash
- 7:14Sieve dash Mara, pending in the Southern District of Florida.
- 7:18Bradley Edwards and Paul Kassel versus Alan Dershowitz Case number
- 7:22ca CE fifteen DASH zero zero zero zero seventy two,
- 7:28pending in the seventeenth Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Florida and
- 7:32Jane Doe number one oh two Verst Jeffrey Epstein case
- 7:36number zero nine eight zero six five six dash Sieve
- 7:40Dashmara Johnson, Southern District of Florida. Accordingly, due to the
- 7:44undue burden of individually logging responsive privileged documents related to
- 7:49defendants overly broad requests, Plaintiff has employed categorical logging of
- 7:54such privileged responsive documents pursuant to Local Rule twenty six
- 7:58dot two c. Miss Roberts objects to the requests in
- 8:02that they seek to invade her privacy for the sole
- 8:04purpose of harassing and intimidating Miss Roberts, who is a
- 8:08victim of sexual trafficking. Miss Roberts objects to the request
- 8:12to the extent that they are overly broad and unduly burdensome.
- 8:16Miss Roberts objects to Defendant's definition of your attorneys because
- 8:20it includes names of attorneys that do not represent her,
- 8:23including Spencer Covin and Jack Scarola. Miss Roberts' responses to
- 8:28Defendant's first set of discovery requests are being made after
- 8:32a reasonable inquiry into the relevant facts and are based
- 8:36only upon the information and documentation that is presently known
- 8:40to her. Miss Roberts reserves the right to modify and
- 8:44or supplement her responses. Miss Roberts is producing documents and
- 8:48information herewith and will continue to review and produce relevant
- 8:52documents until completion. Miss Roberts incorporates her above listed general
- 8:58objections in the rest response is Herein Interrogatories one, state
- 9:04A your present residential address. B each residential address you
- 9:08have had since nineteen ninety eight, including any residential treatment facilities.
- 9:14See the dates you lived at each address. D the
- 9:18other persons who live with you at each address, and
- 9:21for what period of time they lived at such address.
- 9:26Response to Interrogatory one, Miss Roberts objects to this interrogatory
- 9:31in part because it violates Rule thirty three dot three.
- 9:34Miss Roberts objects to this interrogatory in that it seeks
- 9:37information that is sought by defendant only to harass and
- 9:41intimidate Miss Roberts, who is a victim of sexual trafficking.
- 9:44Per the Plaintiff's first response and objections and per our
- 9:48representations during the March twenty first, twenty sixteen meet and
- 9:52confer phone call, we are working diligently to find information
- 9:57to supplement the blow information with regard to a end dates,
- 10:01and once that information is obtained, plaintiff will serve supplemental responses. Additionally,
- 10:07for the March twenty first, twenty sixteen, meet and confer
- 10:10a phone call. We are addressing with a plaintiff whether
- 10:13she will reveal her address to defendant's counsel confidentially and
- 10:18we will update you with her response. A. Due to
- 10:21safety concerns with respect to Miss Roberts and her minor children,
- 10:25she is not at liberty to reveal her present residential location.
- 10:29To ensure that the defendant is not prejudiced by the
- 10:31failure to provide information about Miss roberts specific residential location,
- 10:36Miss Roberts agrees to have her attorneys accept service on
- 10:40her behalf of any necessary communications or filings in this matter. B.
- 10:45Miss Roberts can recall living at the following addresses during
- 10:49the period of nineteen ninety eight to the present. Miss
- 10:51Roberts may have lived at other locations for which she
- 10:55does not presently have the address. Miss Roberts is providing
- 10:58the information she has presently to the best of her
- 11:01recollection and review of documents, and will supplement to the
- 11:05extent she obtains additional information responsive to this interrogatory, Miss
- 11:11Roberts believes she has lived at the following residences. In
- 11:15January nineteen ninety eight, Miss Roberts was fourteen years old.
- 11:18Miss Roberts recalls one facility named Growing Together that was
- 11:23located in or around Palm Beach, but she does not
- 11:26recall the dates that she resided at that facility. From
- 11:30two thousand to two thousand and two, Miss Roberts lived
- 11:33and traveled with Jeffrey Epstein and stayed at his various
- 11:37mansions in New York, Palm Beach, New Mexico, the USVII,
- 11:42Saint Thomas, Virgin Islands, and Paris. Jeffrey Epstein also rented
- 11:46a residence for Miss Roberts in Royal Palm Beach. The
- 11:49exact address and dates of the rental are in the
- 11:52possession custody in control of Jeffrey Epstein, Tony Figueroa, James
- 11:56Michael Ostrich, and a few other individuals for whom Miss
- 12:00Roberts cannot recall the names of stayed with her from
- 12:03time to time at the residences that Jeffrey Epstein rented.
- 12:07Miss roberts parents' address was one two nine five nine
- 12:11Rackley Road, locks A Hatchie, Florida thirty three four seventy
- 12:15and she lived there from time to time with her mother,
- 12:17her father, and her brothers to c. Quentin, Saint Base
- 12:21Hill and SW in approximately two thousand and three, but
- 12:25she is not certain of that date. At this location,
- 12:27Miss Roberts lived with her husband, Robert N. Paramentata, NSW
- 12:33from approximately two thousand and three to two thousand and five,
- 12:37but she is not certain of those dates. At this location,
- 12:40she lived with her husband Blue Bay, n SW from
- 12:43approximately two thousand and five to two thousand and eight.
- 12:46At this location, Miss Roberts lived with her husband three
- 12:50Elk Street, n SW from approximately two thousand and eight
- 12:53to two thousand and nine, but not certain of those dates.
- 12:57At this location, Miss Roberts lived with her husband fifty
- 13:01robertson Road, Bass Hill and SW from two thousand and
- 13:05nine through January twenty ten. At this location, Miss Roberts
- 13:09lived with her husband fifty Bundina Road, Glenning Valley and
- 13:14SW from approximately January of twenty ten through October thirteenth,
- 13:19twenty thirteen. At this location, Miss Roberts lived with her
- 13:23husband five zero three five Winchester Drive, Titusville, Florida, from
- 13:28approximately November sixth, twenty thirteen to October twenty fourteen. At
- 13:33this location, Miss Roberts lived with her husband. Twelve seventy j. Street, Penrose, Colorado,
- 13:39eight one two four zero from approximately October of twenty
- 13:43fourteen through October of twenty fifteen. At this location, Miss
- 13:48Roberts lived with her husband. All right, folks, we're going
- 13:51to wrap up Part one right here and in the
- 13:53next episode talking about the topic, we'll pick up with
- 13:56part two. All of the information that goes with this
- 13:59episode can be found in the description box.