Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / When Police Records Disappear
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: All right.
- 0:00Adam Stirling: I thought I'm kind of time for a regular regular segment joined as always by Barister and sister with Mulligan Defense Lord legally speaking on Facts and Michael Mulligan.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Michael, afternoon.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: I'm doing great.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: What's on our agenda for today?
- 0:17Michael Mulligan: Well, the first case on the agenda today is a case that just recently came out from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: And it's a case dealing with a criminal charge that originally came out of Alberta.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: And there are a few interesting things about it.
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: First of all, it's a case that deals with the issue of disclosure about police misconduct and disciplinary filings, uh findings.
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: And the background to that is this.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: A long time ago, prior to the charter, uh the crown might choose to tell defense about what evidence they had that might show the accused person did or didn't commit the offense, but only as sort of a professional courtesy.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: Uh and whether that occurred and in what way that occurred and when it occurred would be wildly variable depending on who was prosecuting the case and how they wanted to uh to do that.
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: Back in 1991, the Supreme Court of Canada in a case called Stinchcomb made it clear that that's a constitutional obligation, right?
- 1:19Michael Mulligan: If you want to have somebody have a fair trial, one of the obligations there is that the crown turnover evidence the police have collected that show that the person is likely guilty or likely not guilty of the offense.
- 1:30Michael Mulligan: Sort of makes sense.
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: Um and so things went, but pretty quickly one of the issues that developed was well, what about evidence that is not things that the police collected in that particular investigation?
- 1:43Michael Mulligan: Like what about um, I don't know, records about the mental health of the uh complainant, for example, right?
- 1:50Michael Mulligan: Police may not even have that.
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and in a case that came a few years later called O'Connor, the Supreme Court of Canada set out a different regime dealing with what are referred to as third-party records, like uh evidence that's not in possession of the police or crown, but somebody else, right?
- 2:07Michael Mulligan: And when the defense wants to get those things, they would have to show that uh the material is likely relevant.
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: And then if a judge agrees, the judge would be able to review the material and determine whether it should be provided to the defense or not.
- 2:21Michael Mulligan: So those are the two broad categories of disclosure.
- 2:24Michael Mulligan: What's called first party disclosure, like the actual evidence the police gathered, and third party, like the uh medical records or things of that sort that uh would be held by somebody else, right?
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: Or what else might they be?
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: Let's say a video recording of what happened, but it's held by the store or something, not the police.
- 2:41Michael Mulligan: The police didn't get it for some reason.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: And then a final issue uh got crystallized back in 2009 when the Supreme Court of Canada dealt with the issue of what about disciplinary records for police that were involved in the investigation?
- 2:57Michael Mulligan: What if the main investigator had been disciplined for dishonesty or something, right?
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: What is that?
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: Is that a first party record?
- 3:06Michael Mulligan: Is that like in from that stinchcomb case?
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: Is that like the fingerprints the police collected at the bank?
- 3:12Michael Mulligan: Or is that more like, you know, oh, some evidence collected in some other case or like something that uh some other party might have?
- 3:20Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada in that case, McNeil, found that broadly speaking, that sort of material, like records the police have about officers that were disciplined who were, you know, integral to the case, witnesses, um, that that material is dealt with in a way closer to the first party records, like the evidence collected in the uh the actual investigation.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: And so Crown then would have an obligation, uh, the Supreme Court of Canada made clear to disclose um information about uh police disciplinary records that could have relevance to you know the reliability or trustworthiness of a police officer, for example.
- 4:00Michael Mulligan: Um well, what's happened since then is some jurisdictions, including in this case Alberta, uh passed provincial legislation and regulations that provided that after a period of time, even if a police officer had been disciplined, for example, for something relating to dishonesty, that those records would be sealed and destroyed, and the officer could not be asked about them uh after a certain time period.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: And so in this particular case, um the police sent to Crown with their report a note saying, Oh, none of these officers have any disciplinary records.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: Um, and the defense counsel on the case kind of heard by the by, hey, that officer in your case may have a serious disciplinary record.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the lawyer wrote to Crown and said, Hey, what about this?
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: And Crown went and um ferreted that out of some older file before like that they had received before the uh disciplinary records had been destroyed by the police pursuant to that provincial legislation.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: And so the issue became, well, what Trumps what's the rule here, right?
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: You've got that McNeil case from the Supreme Court of Canada saying relevant disciplinary records that might go to, you know, the credibility, for example, of a police officer, that should be provided.
- 5:18Michael Mulligan: Whereas you had this provincial legislation that said, no, after some number of years it's destroyed, and the officer can't be asked about it.
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: And the judge, the original judge at the trial, found that no, the the province might have some authority over how disciplinary records could be used in the course of like, let's say, for employment purposes or promotional purposes in the police department, but they can't pass a rule that sort of trumps the criminal obligation to uh provide the accused person with information about that might suggest, for example, the key police witness was dishonest in some uh previous uh police dealing, uh, and so ordered it uh to be disclosed.
- 6:00Michael Mulligan: Now, the first interesting uh just procedural tidbit here is that there was that trial decision um in Alberta that yes, that should be disclosed, but and the crown was happy to do that, they weren't opposed to it.
- 6:14Michael Mulligan: Who was opposed to it were the police organizations.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: They wanted this uh seizing, this um destruction of records to prevail.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: But neither the crown nor the accused person appealed that decision to the court of appeal.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: And the first interesting procedural thing is that there is a there is some provision in the legislation that deals with the Supreme Court of Canada that can permit, in narrow cases like that, an application to be to appeal a trial decision straight to the Supreme Court of Canada, never having gone through the Court of Appeal.
- 6:48Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada on that basis granted leave to appeal the decision that you know the provincial legislation saying the disciplinary records are to be destroyed could be reviewed right by the Supreme Court of Canada, pursuant to the request from the police organizations without first making its way through the uh Alberta Court of Appeal.
- 7:07Michael Mulligan: And so that's how the case wound up there.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: Um ultimately, the Supreme Court of Canada agreed with the trial judge and found that the uh provincial legislation just cannot prevail.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: Uh, it cannot be that um, given that, for example, that right to disclosure of information about you know a serious disciplinary matter that might go to the honesty or reliability of the police officer, that obligation can't just be circumvented uh by the province passing legislation saying that disciplinary records shall be destroyed after some number of years, and nobody may ask the police officer about what they did before.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the that's the final outcome, and the Supreme Court of Canada has confirmed that no matter what the province does, uh they can't uh have a process in place that foils the obligation to uh tell the uh accused about uh uh the police officer's disciplinary history.
- 8:03Michael Mulligan: And they've also affirmed that the decision about whether those things, like that's kind of a record, is significant and should be provided, is relevant, is a decision that crown counsel needs to make, could be reviewed by a judge, but a decision for crown and not the police themselves.
- 8:21Michael Mulligan: Uh otherwise the police could just say, well, we don't think any of this is relevant.
- 8:24Michael Mulligan: We're just gonna say no.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada has made clear now that the police are obliged to tell Crown Counsel about uh those kind of disciplinary records so that Crown can then make an assessment about whether this is some uh potentially relevant thing, like the dishonesty by the lead investigator, or maybe it's something that is uh dated and irrelevant, like, you know, the officer was uh disciplined for being late for their shift five times, you know, ten years ago.
- 8:53Michael Mulligan: You know, but that has nothing to do with anything.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: And so the uh crown will be responsible for doing that vetting, not the police.
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: And so it's now clear that the province can't trump the constitutional rights.
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: And it's also clear that the decision about disclosing that kind of information, whether it's relevant or not, will be a decision for crown rather than the police themselves.
- 9:13Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada on uh disclosure of information about police misconduct in criminal cases.
- 9:21Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers legally speaking will continue right after this.
- 9:25Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers, continuing on C FACT 107.
- 9:30Adam Stirling: Michael, what's next on our agenda today?
- 9:33Michael Mulligan: Uh next on the agenda is a bankruptcy uh case uh which deals with uh the uh aftermath of a Ponzi scheme and what happens in terms of what the court referred to as the net winners and the net losers in that entire operation.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: Um and the background of it, there's a fellow named Quigley who is a per person behind this scheme.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: Um, and like most Ponzi schemes, maybe all of them, the basic theory of it is that the person operating it with it, operating it, will take in money purportedly to be used as an investment and will then uh pay out early quote investors with uh the additional money taken in by more and more people investing money, if that makes any sense, right?
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: Um and so they he this fellow was promising people like 18% interest um if you'd uh loan money for these purported um investment opportunities.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: And it went on for years.
- 10:33Michael Mulligan: Uh it went on from November of 2008 until August of 2020.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: And uh this fellow quickly had uh issued some 2,508, quote, promissory notes uh to all these people offering these uh returns of money.
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: There was no investment, of course.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: It was just the later investors' money being used to pay out the 18% interest or whatever he was offering to earlier investors to keep the whole thing going.
- 10:59Michael Mulligan: But naturally, of course, you eventually run out of people that are uh trying to get in on this uh and the whole thing collapses.
- 11:06Michael Mulligan: Uh and when it all collapsed, it it became clear that there were no investments at all being made.
- 11:12Michael Mulligan: Uh, and this fellow was just using, it looks like some$8.3 million of the$174 million he had taken in and paid out in this way just to fund a lifestyle.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: Um he was just spending it.
- 11:24Michael Mulligan: Uh then he was declared bankrupt and he was charged criminally, uh, and maybe a little bit of karma came about him because uh before his criminal trial in 2025 could occur uh in June of 2024, he drowned in the Okanagan River and so he died.
- 11:42Michael Mulligan: But what this Ness left behind was this uh bankruptcy trustee who was faced with all of these people who had invested, like, you know, their life savings and retirement savings and whatnot, trying to recover something uh of the money that they had invested with him.
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: Uh and that there there were claims totaling some$26 million from all these people who had paid this fraud artist money uh in the hopes of these higher returns.
- 12:08Michael Mulligan: And the uh initially the trustee was only able to collect uh modest things to sell, like there's a boat and a motorcycle and a half interest and a house, and originally the trustee was only able to collect some$528,000 from get getting those things collected up and selling them.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: But what the trustee then focused on was trying to collect money from what were described as the net winners in this entire scheme.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: And so this is really important to know about if you're ever facing something and you're wondering, you know, is this investment opportunity good too good to be true?
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: And if you're somebody who might think, oh, maybe I get in early on this uh, you know, pyramid of Ponzi or whatever it might be.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: But what the um trustee set out to do is say, look, the money that the quote investors who were the net winners, like people who were in early enough before this scheme came tumbling down, weren't really getting investment proceeds.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: They were just getting money from other victims.
- 13:06Michael Mulligan: And so the trustee set about uh trying to collect back the money from people who got more out of this scheme than they put into it.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: Because of course there are some people where that happens.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: The scheme went on for 12 years, right?
- 13:21Michael Mulligan: And so some of the early people that got in on that may well have and did, in fact, get paid back more money than they put into it.
- 13:29Michael Mulligan: And that's part of what feeds these schemes, of course, right?
- 13:32Michael Mulligan: Because you could have somebody coming to you saying, you know, hey, this was great.
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: I gave this guy$100,000, and he gave me back two months later$118,000.
- 13:41Michael Mulligan: It's fantastic.
- 13:42Michael Mulligan: You know, what are you doing?
- 13:43Michael Mulligan: Get in on it.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the uh trustee, first of all, uh filed civil claims against all the people described as the net winners, the people that got more out uh than they put in, uh, but then also made application in the course of the bankruptcy proceedings uh to ask the judge uh that there be some order that that money be returned.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: And there's a basis for all of that, and some of it comes from a principle that people may be familiar with, which is referred to as a fraudulent conveyance or a fraudulent preference.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: And the idea there is that if you have somebody who knows, like, hey, I'm gonna go and go down the tubes here, it looks like my Ponzi scheme might unravel.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: And so what I'm going to do is, for example, pay out all my friends, uh, and then the other people will just be out of luck because all the money will be gone.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: Those kinds of transactions could be referred to as a fraudulent preference and can be set aside and reversed so that a debtor uh can't just say, I'm gonna pay out my friends and family, and then too bad for everyone else uh involved.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: What can happen there is the other people that wound up losing out, the net losers in the scheme, uh, can uh apply to a court to set aside those transactions and have the money taken back from the friends and family and someone who may have been paid out first, lest people think, well, I can just avoid all these problems by paying out the people I care about.
- 15:10Michael Mulligan: And so the judge dealing with the bankruptcy found that that was a completely appropriate thing to do, and that that could be accomplished either by way of suing each of those people on the basis that, hey, these were you know, you unjust enrichment or fraudulent preference or fraudulent conveyance, right?
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: That money you got as the uh from the scheme wasn't really an investment proceed, it was just money from somebody else uh that this fellow didn't spend on motorcycles or boats.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: Um, and so that's what's happened here.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: The uh uh bankruptcy judge has uh ordered effectively that.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and so there will now be a process whereby uh the uh trustee and ultimately the uh judge dealing with the bankruptcy will be able to look at the records to determine who got paid out more than they put in from other people's uh money, uh, and those things may all be reversed uh to try to even it out.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: Money is going to be lost, there's no way to get back the money the fellow spent on boats and motorcycles and a high flute and lifestyle before he drowned in the river, but the the money that was just passed along to other people earlier in the Ponzi scheme process um can be unwound.
- 16:20Michael Mulligan: And so that's exactly what's going to go on here.
- 16:22Michael Mulligan: And so I thought it was worth knowing about both in terms of some of those principles like fraudulent preference and fraudulent conveyance, how the bankruptcy process can work, uh lest uh, and perhaps to encourage people, if you have some reason to think, hey, I've been offering something that seems much better than any uh financial institution might offer, it seems too good to be true, even if you are some early person in the scam and and happen to get paid out, um, you may find that all of that money is just clawed back from you because you've just managed to get money from other people who were victims in the scheme.
- 16:56Michael Mulligan: And there's no suggestion necessarily that the people who got paid out uh the net winners, they may have not been complicit in that at all.
- 17:04Michael Mulligan: Uh they may have just thought, hey, this seems like a great deal, and in fact it worked out for them, and they got paid out money perhaps years ago, uh, and uh they may find that uh that's now getting clawed back and redistributed in an even way so that everyone's gonna wind up with uh a haircut rather than some people making a bunch of money and some people winding up with a big loss.
- 17:25Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's the latest sort of the BC Supreme Court in terms of how bankruptcy uh can be used to deal with the uh circumstance of the uh net winners and losers in a Ponzi scheme when it inevitably unravels.
- 17:37Adam Stirling: All right.
- 17:38Adam Stirling: And we've got three and a half minutes left.
- 17:40Adam Stirling: Up next, it says an allegation, a breaching, a conditional sentence order.
- 17:44Adam Stirling: What needs to be proven for something like that?
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: So, first of all, a conditional sentence order is sometimes referred to as house arrest, right?
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: If somebody who's been convicted of a criminal offense, but a court determines that they wouldn't be uh an undue risk to serve their condition, for example, on exactly that, house arrest, right?
- 18:01Michael Mulligan: Or some other very strict conditions.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Uh one of the conditions that's common uh is a condition that amounts to like a curfew.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: If you're not permitted, not required to be in perhaps all hours, maybe somebody's allowed to go out for work, there will often at least be a curfew imposed.
- 18:16Michael Mulligan: Um, and the curfew conditions will often also include conditions like answer the door or something to make sure that you're home, otherwise pretty hard to enforce.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: The legal issue in this case uh involved what is the mental require like what's the uh mental requirement to be guilty of breaching your conditional sentence order?
- 18:35Michael Mulligan: And the fact pattern here was the fella was on a um one of these orders and he was ordered to be at home between certain hours.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: The police came by as they do uh to check to make sure the person was there, and at 3 50 in the morning, uh police officer, she her evidence was that she knocked on the door uh three times with her middle knuckle, and she said she knocked on the screen door uh and there was no response to the knock on the screen door um at 3.50 in the morning.
- 19:02Michael Mulligan: Uh it was a mobile home, so it wasn't a big residence, but nonetheless it was knocking the middle knuckle on the screen door.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: Then the officer said she made a phone call and got no answer.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that was the basis upon which the man was charged.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: Um at the hearing into that alleged breach, he testified, sorry, I just slept through it.
- 19:20Michael Mulligan: And his girlfriend testified too, said yes, I was there, I wasn't woken up either by this rapping on the door.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: The crown nonetheless argued that in a conditional sentence breach, unlike in a criminal charge, all they need to do is prove on a balance of probabilities that the person didn't comply, in this case by answering the door, and unless the person had a quote reasonable excuse, which is some of the language found in the section, the person could be found in breach of their conditional sentence order.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: The reason that matters is that the starting point, if you breach your order when you're on house arrest, can be you just go straight to jail and serve the whole rest of your sentence in prison.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: And so the judge had to wrestle with, well, what is the requirement here?
- 20:00Michael Mulligan: Is this like a criminal case?
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: What is the what's required?
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: And ultimately, looking at all the law and including a previous breach of conditional sentence case uh that uh involved a person who uh had to report to a supervisor and called the wrong number and left a phone number at the Crown Council's office rather than the conditional sentence supervisor's office, the judge ultimately concluded that uh no, like with other criminal charges, it's necessary to prove uh a mens rea, like an intention to do something wrong, not just you didn't hear the knock on the door.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that yes, even though this is not a criminal charge on its own, it's a breach hearing about somebody who's already been sentenced, uh, that nonetheless it was necessary for the crown to prove subjectively that the person uh failed to do what was required.
- 20:50Michael Mulligan: And so the the upshot is the fellow that slept through the wrapping with the middle knuckle on the screen door, has not been sent to jail to serve the rest of his sentence there.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: Uh, and is now made clear that the crown does have to prove the person did it intentionally, not just didn't hear the knock of the door.
- 21:06Michael Mulligan: So that's latest on breach of conditional sentences from the BC provincial court.
- 21:10Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:15Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:16Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:17Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:18Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: All right.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: Quick break.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: News is next.