Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Time Insider Sales After Lockup
Transcript
- Lucas: So look, if you've ever watched a post ipo stock chart, you've probably seen that dip right around the lockup expiry. The assumption is that insiders are just waiting for the moment their shares unlock to dump them. But here's the thing — that's rarely how it actually plays out. Luna: Right, because they'd tank their own stock. So what do they actually do? I mean, they still want to sell eventually, don't they? Lucas: They do, but the smart ones plan it months in advance. They set up what's called a 10b5-1 plan. That's a pre-arranged trading plan where insiders commit to selling a fixed number of shares at a preset price or date, often over a long period. It's like setting up automatic payments for your mortgage, but instead, you're dribbling out your equity. Luna: So you're telling me the CFO isn't waking up on lockup expiry day and saying, 'Oh, today's the day, let's sell a million bucks'? Lucas: Exactly. That would be a nightmare for optics and probably for the stock too. The point of the 10b5-1 plan is that it's set up when they don't have material inside information. That's the legal cover. Then the trades execute automatically regardless of what's happening with the stock price. Luna: Got it. And I remember the SEC updated those rules a few years back, right? There was a cooling-off period added? Lucas: Yes, that was in late 2022, and the rules went into effect in early 2023. Now there's a cooling-off period — for directors and officers, I think it's 90 days after they adopt or modify a plan. That means you can't just set up a plan on Monday and start selling on Tuesday. The idea is to make sure the plan isn't being used to time the market based on inside info. Luna: So that's a big shift from the old days. I bet in the dot-com era, insiders were just selling whenever they felt like it. Lucas: Oh, absolutely. There were some legendary examples of founders selling right before the bubble burst, and they got away with it. The rules are much tighter now. But even with the cooling-off, there's still a lot of nuance in how these plans are structured. Luna: Like what? Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Okay, take a company that goes public and the lockup is 180 days. The founder might wait until day 170 to adopt a 10b5-1 plan. Then the cooling-off period is 90 days, so the first sale happens around day 260. That's still early, but it's not an immediate dump. And then they might sell quarterly, say 10,000 shares each time, over two years. Luna: That's the disciplined approach. But I've also seen founders sell a token amount early — like a tiny slice — just to show they're not locked up forever. Is that a signal? Lucas: It can be. A small sale often reads as 'I need some liquidity, but I'm not worried about the stock.' Whereas a huge sale right after lockup — even with a plan — can spook investors. That's why a lot of companies encourage their insiders to use these plans and to keep the selling gradual. Luna: And what about the actual lockup expiry day itself? Does the stock always drop? Lucas: Not necessarily. A lot of the selling is already priced in by the market. And often, the float available is much smaller than people think, because many insiders don't sell immediately. They hold for years. The real pressure can come months later, when a big early investor like a venture fund decides to rebalance and sells a large block. Luna: So the narrative that 'lockup expiry equals doom' is oversimplified. Lucas: Yeah, it's one of those things that sounds scary but isn't always the cliff everyone expects. Look at the market this week — you've got a mix of moves. Palantir is down a bit, Airbnb is flat, Shopify's off slightly. But none of those are necessarily lockup-related. The broader tech selloff is more about macro worries — the ten-year Treasury yield has been creeping up all month. Luna: Right, and that hits growth stocks harder than anything. But back to insider selling — are there any companies that have handled this really well recently? Lucas: I think the ones that communicate early and clearly do best. They announce that insiders have adopted 10b5-1 plans, they disclose the terms, and they explain that it's part of normal financial planning. That takes the mystery out of it. The worst thing you can do is have a founder sell a huge chunk and not say anything until the 13D filing comes out. Luna: So it's really about managing the narrative as much as the actual selling. Lucas: Exactly. And the SEC filings are the raw material. When an insider files a Form 4, it's public within two days. So the market sees every sale. That's why the plan matters — it shows the sale was premeditated, not a reaction to news. Luna: And what about the timing of these plans? Is there a sweet spot? Like, should they start selling before or after an earnings release? Lucas: The 10b5-1 plan is designed to get around the blackout windows. As long as the plan is set up during an open window, trades can execute even during a blackout. But the plan can't be adopted when they have inside information. So the sweet spot is right after earnings, when the information is out and the window is open. Luna: That makes sense. And they can't modify the plan too easily either, right? I think the SEC has restrictions. Lucas: Right, each modification resets the cooling-off period for that plan. So you can't just tweak it every time the stock moves. That's the tradeoff — you give up flexibility for legal protection. Luna: So what's the takeaway for investors? If we see a big insider sell-off, should we panic? Lucas: Not necessarily. Look at the context. Is it a founder who's never sold before? Is it a planned sale that was disclosed months ago? Or is it a venture firm that's been holding for eight years and is finally taking some chips off the table? The latter is pretty normal. Luna: And I guess the real red flag is when insiders are selling into weakness — like when the stock is already down and they're dumping shares. That's a bad sign. Lucas: Yeah, that's when the market really punishes you. But with a 10b5-1 plan, you don't have that discretion. The trades are on autopilot. So even if the stock drops, the selling continues, which can look bad. But it's often just the plan executing. Luna: Interesting. So it's a tradeoff between legal safety and market perception. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why post ipo companies spend so much time thinking about this. It's not just about selling — it's about how it looks when you do. Luna: You know, this whole conversation reminds me of the show itself. We're in the business of breaking down these complex topics, and it only works because our listeners care about the details. If you're one of those listeners who finds these conversations useful, there's a simple way to keep them coming: buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest thing, but it helps us keep the podcast ad-free and focused on what matters. Lucas: Yeah, it's a nice way to say thanks if you got something out of today's episode. No pressure, ever. But we appreciate every coffee. Luna: So back to insider selling — one thing I want to ask: with the IPO market picking up this summer, are we seeing any new trends in how companies handle lockups? Lucas: A few things. Some companies are experimenting with shorter lockups — 90 days instead of 180 — to signal confidence. Others are staggering the lockup expiry, so a portion unlocks at 90 days, another at 180, another at 270. That smooths out the selling pressure. Luna: Staggered lockups seem smart. It's like a controlled release. Lucas: And it gives the market time to absorb the selling. But it also means the 'lockup cliff' is less dramatic, which might be a good thing. Investors don't have to brace for a single day of potential volatility. Luna: So if I'm a retail investor, should I be looking at the lockup calendar before buying a recent IPO? Lucas: Definitely. The lockup expiry is a known event, so it's often priced in. But if you see a big block of shares unlocking that's not covered by a 10b5-1 plan, that's a signal to dig deeper. Sometimes you'll see a company announce a secondary offering right after lockup, which can be a way to get ahead of insider sales. Luna: Ah, so the company itself might facilitate the selling. That's a different angle. Lucas: Exactly. If the company does a secondary, the shares are sold by existing holders, but the company controls the timing and the messaging. It's a cleaner way to bring in new investors without the overhang of insider sales hanging over the stock. Luna: So what's the bottom line for our listeners? Lucas: The bottom line is: don't just see a Form 4 and panic. Look at the plan, look at the history, look at the company's communication. Insider selling is a normal part of the post ipo lifecycle. What matters is whether it's planned, transparent, and gradual — or reactive, opaque, and sudden. Luna: That's a great way to put it. And I think that's a wrap for today. Lucas: Yeah, we've covered a lot. If you're thinking about the next IPO pipeline for the fall, keep an eye on those lockup calendars. It's a detail that can make a difference.