Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Child Custody Monitors: The When, The Who, and The What with Michael Hanasab, Hon. Susan Lopez-Giss, Robin Sax
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, and welcome to Child Custody Monitors,
- 0:06The When, The Who, and The What. I'm April Zonis,
- 0:10co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:13Family Law Section, and I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:16today's speakers, Michael Hanasab, Robin Sachs,
- 0:20and the Honorable Susan Lopez Giss. We would
- 0:23like to thank our section sponsor, White, Zuckerman,
- 0:26Warsawski, Luna, and Hunt, for their continued
- 0:28support in helping us bring essential programming
- 0:31to our members. Michael Hanasab is a partner
- 0:35at Jamra, Jamra and Hanasab, where he focuses
- 0:38exclusively on family law matters, including
- 0:41high asset divorce, custody disputes and complex
- 0:44property division. In addition to his litigation
- 0:47practice, he is trained in collaborative law
- 0:50and serves as a family law neutral for the Los
- 0:53Angeles Superior Court's ADR program. Prior to
- 0:56his legal career, Michael worked in the entertainment
- 0:59industry, a background that informs his representation
- 1:02of high profile clients in Southern California.
- 1:06He is an active member of several bar associations
- 1:09and a regular contributor to the California Family
- 1:12Law Report. Robin Sachs is both an attorney and
- 1:16a clinical therapist, offering a truly one of
- 1:19a kind practice that seamlessly blends legal
- 1:22and therapeutic skills. While her legal practice
- 1:25primarily focuses on the criminal justice system,
- 1:29Dear Co -Parent is where Robin's distinctive
- 1:31approach shines. Through Dear Co -Parent, Robin
- 1:35serves as a co -parenting therapist, behind the
- 1:38scenes coach, mediator and parenting plan coordinator,
- 1:42and mediator helping families navigate divorce
- 1:44and high conflict situations with both legal
- 1:47precision and therapeutic insight. Many professionals
- 1:51transition from law to therapy or vice versa,
- 1:54but Robin uniquely integrates both disciplines
- 1:57at once, providing a holistic solution -oriented
- 2:00approach to co -parenting challenges. And the
- 2:03Honorable Susan Lopez Giss is a respected mediator
- 2:06with ADR Services, following a 15 -year tenure
- 2:10as a family law judge on the Los Angeles Superior
- 2:12Court. Prior to her judicial appointment, she
- 2:16spent 30 years with the Los Angeles City Attorney's
- 2:19Office, where she pioneered domestic violence
- 2:21prosecution programs that gained national recognition.
- 2:26She later served as Assistant General Counsel
- 2:28for LADWP, handling complex litigation, regulatory
- 2:33matters, and major financial transactions. Judge
- 2:36Lopez -Giz is widely respected for her practical
- 2:39legal insight, collaborative approach, and commitment
- 2:43to resolving even the most complex disputes,
- 2:46which I can personally attest to. And now let's
- 2:49get started with today's program. Thank you,
- 2:52April. And thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 2:56The title of this program, Child Custody Monitors,
- 3:00The When, The Who, and The What, kind of came
- 3:06out of a collaborative conversation between Michael
- 3:08and then you. days later with Robin. All of you
- 3:13who practice family law are aware of the times
- 3:17when you were just concerned, the parties are
- 3:19concerned, the court is concerned, DCFS may be
- 3:23concerned about the safety of the children, and
- 3:26it would just seemingly be simple. We have the
- 3:30children monitored, custody monitored, but it
- 3:33hasn't been simple. As a bench officer, when
- 3:37monitors are appointed, we get the common complaint,
- 3:41they're not doing their job. And when and how
- 3:46and what should the monitors be doing and when
- 3:51do you bring them in? A simple, simplistic question
- 3:57or issue has turned into a whole seminar because
- 4:01when you start dissecting these issues, you start
- 4:04realizing that early on if you make the issues
- 4:08clear and the orders clear, the later problems
- 4:13don't arrive. So that is why we have Michael
- 4:17with his practical experience and Robin with
- 4:20handling these types of cases, putting together
- 4:23a program that hopefully will help all of you.
- 4:27The primary purposes of the monitors are obviously
- 4:29to protect the children during the visits, to
- 4:32ensure that the orders of the court are honored,
- 4:36As I would tell litigants, it provides objective
- 4:39documentation to show that a parent is in fact
- 4:43a good parent, to assess the parenting dynamics,
- 4:47and then to prevent and mitigate false allegations.
- 4:50But there are other purposes that we will talk
- 4:52about. In preparing for this presentation, I
- 4:56did speak with Judge Kaufman, who is the presiding
- 4:59supervising judge of the Family Law Department.
- 5:03She referred me to the self -help court website
- 5:08and I urge all of you to acquaint yourself with
- 5:10that as well as some of the materials that we've
- 5:13provided that will give you some background assistance.
- 5:18Next slide please. So when do we use monitors?
- 5:22I mean I think that this has been an evolving
- 5:25area and anybody who's been in practice has seen
- 5:27that there's been kind of the traditional areas
- 5:29where you know Monitor is absolutely clearly
- 5:33necessary, but then there's been an evolution
- 5:35of monitors being used and things that are not
- 5:37necessarily what one would. think about at first
- 5:41blush. So the more obvious cases where monitors
- 5:45get to be used or often used are cases where
- 5:48there's domestic violence, where there's been
- 5:50allegations of abuse, including child abuse,
- 5:52sexual abuse, or substance abuse, where there's
- 5:55been either an investigation or an ongoing case
- 5:58or potential criminal background or current conduct
- 6:01or something under investigation. If there's
- 6:04been allegations of a parent not being fit or
- 6:07capable, bordering into neglect. Oftentimes,
- 6:12they get used in very high conflict situations
- 6:15where there's been kind of a mess out there.
- 6:18And so we find that we use these to really, frankly,
- 6:22get third party cooperation to figure out what's
- 6:25actually going on and getting a sense of things,
- 6:27but also to help with the neutral transfer of
- 6:30kids from parent to parent. And sometimes that
- 6:33happens to a monitor. Robin? Yes. Do you see
- 6:38and have you experienced that in cases that do
- 6:42not involve domestic violence, do not involve
- 6:45sexual abuse or criminal conduct of any time?
- 6:48the use of monitors where parents just cannot
- 6:52co -parent. And there is a dispute about how
- 6:55the children are being taken care of, including
- 6:58but not limited to nap times, whether or not
- 7:02gluten has been introduced as the potentials
- 7:05poisoner of the child, or just in the sense of
- 7:08bedtime and other types of. parenting issues
- 7:12that would not necessarily be legal issues, but
- 7:14lead to a breakdown of the parental relationship
- 7:17and therefore the well -being of the children.
- 7:22Absolutely. First of all, we have the traditional,
- 7:24as I was kind of saying, is that we have the
- 7:26traditional environments where one would expect.
- 7:29there to be monitors right where there are these
- 7:31types of allegations out there but in in times
- 7:34especially in the very early stages of divorce
- 7:37and or when there's been a domestic violence
- 7:39restraining orders that may be filed or even
- 7:41as a preemptive measure of let's just get things
- 7:45going and let me show you that my client is actually
- 7:47well behaved. Monitors are getting used more
- 7:50and more to help navigate and understand a parenting
- 7:54dynamic. Hey let's see if there really is some
- 7:58sort of inept behavior, inept parenting, lack
- 8:02of parenting acumen. And what we're seeing, and
- 8:05Michael will probably talk about this a little
- 8:06bit more, is, okay, why don't we just volunteer
- 8:10and just to have a monitor? Because it's gonna
- 8:13help your case to just show that you are a capable
- 8:16fine parent. So while it used to be something
- 8:19that I think that very often was used or requested
- 8:23by the by one party kind of to show and put a
- 8:29caretaker or monitor there to make sure everything's
- 8:31going okay. I think there's a new use for people
- 8:35to negate allegations that there are a problem
- 8:39and use taking a defensive, what may have been
- 8:42a defensive type of intervention into an offensive
- 8:46intervention. In addition, if there has been
- 8:50a difficulty in a parent -child dynamic, It is
- 8:54sometimes a monitor allows for us to remove the
- 8:58parent -parent contact or whatever the influence
- 9:00of the perceived in -parent may be and utilize
- 9:04monitors to assist in the reunification process
- 9:07so that we're taking the parent -parent contact
- 9:09out of the situation and allowing for there to
- 9:11be a neutral to allow the transfers to help then
- 9:15kind of do an exposure therapy if you will to
- 9:18practicing spending time with someone that a
- 9:20kid may be a parent that a kid may have a difficult
- 9:24or resisting relationship. relationship with.
- 9:28OK, next slide. You know, that raises the question
- 9:32of who should serve as the monitor. I'm going
- 9:35to address initially professional monitors. Now,
- 9:37when I first got on the bench and I was dealing
- 9:41with restraining orders and the concern of the
- 9:43safety of children in a domestic violence situation,
- 9:47I would often never be asked about whether or
- 9:50not there should be a professional monitor on
- 9:52the custody sheet. for the initial temporary
- 9:56order, I often would say, I want the alleged
- 10:01offending parent to see the child, but not without
- 10:05a monitor. And so there typically is a page on
- 10:09the temporary order that allows for a professional
- 10:14monitor and that box would be checked. Under
- 10:18the family code section 3200 .5C2E, that's listed
- 10:25in this PowerPoint that you all will get a copy
- 10:29of, and the rule of court 5 .20E, it defines
- 10:33professional monitors. Professional monitors
- 10:36are required to have training, 12 hours in the
- 10:40courtroom, three hours of training on screening
- 10:43and monitoring and terminating visitation. I'm
- 10:46going to interrupt you, Judge, not in the courtroom,
- 10:48in the classroom. Too bad I can't read. That's
- 10:52okay. I'm sorry, 12 hours in the classroom. Thank
- 10:56you for that correction. Screening, monitoring,
- 10:59and terminating visitation, and then three hours
- 11:01of the developmental needs of the children, three
- 11:04hours of substance and child and sexual abuse
- 11:07and domestic violence, and then one hour of basic
- 11:10knowledge of family law. One would think that
- 11:13that seems like a lot of training, but in truth
- 11:16and fact, you can have... classroom training,
- 11:19but then dealing with children and parents who
- 11:22do not get along. And the concern about the safety
- 11:26of the children is not taught necessarily in
- 11:30the classroom. And so oftentimes judges would
- 11:34utilize early when I was first doing it, retired
- 11:37police officers, retired social workers, retired
- 11:41persons who had experience. dealing with children,
- 11:46but also dealing with children in high conflict
- 11:48situations. And the reason why that becomes incredibly
- 11:53important in your selection. of a monitor. When
- 11:57you have a domestic violence situation, it seems
- 12:00obvious that you'd want a professional monitor.
- 12:03But if you have two high conflict parents where
- 12:06there really is no domestic violence, but that
- 12:08the parents just cannot agree on anything and
- 12:11the child is basically the rope in the tug of
- 12:14war, oftentimes a family member isn't sufficient
- 12:18to be able to establish calm. And that is really
- 12:22what we're talking about, putting someone in
- 12:25there that can kind of reset the shot clock and
- 12:29make an area of calm where visitation can proceed.
- 12:34And for those of you attorneys out there who
- 12:37think getting a monitor would put a taint on
- 12:40your client, I suggest the opposite. I think
- 12:43A professional monitor being utilized initially
- 12:47in a high conflict case will basically show that
- 12:50your client is safe. Maybe not the kind of parent
- 12:54that parent was during the course of the marriage
- 12:57or the breakup, but now in a level playing field
- 13:01where there's a basically neutral person watching
- 13:05that person, I have seen parent -child relationships
- 13:09thrive. But I want Michael to talk about the
- 13:14non -professional monitor and in that circumstance.
- 13:18Before Michael goes there, just for one comment,
- 13:20I think that there is an assumption out there
- 13:23that professional monitors somehow have an MSW
- 13:27or have an MFT and that have all of this early
- 13:31childhood knowledge and skills in terms of the
- 13:34developmental, educational, emotional, psychological
- 13:37needs of children. a professional monitor with
- 13:42relatively very little knowledge of children.
- 13:45And so that's something that should be pointed
- 13:47out. Now, it's great if there are the people
- 13:49that Judge Loeb has guessed talks about having
- 13:52retired law enforcement, retired social workers,
- 13:55et cetera. But the expectation that that's who
- 13:58you're getting should not be an assumption that
- 14:01attorneys or anybody else is making. And I want
- 14:04to just point out one other thing. Like I said,
- 14:06when I first began, which was now 18 years ago,
- 14:10there was a plethora of people who would serve
- 14:14as monitors with professional experience. I will
- 14:18say that towards the end of my tenure on the
- 14:20bench, that wasn't so much that we had gone through
- 14:23COVID and we had gone through other issues with
- 14:28the economy. And I will say that people who became
- 14:31professional monitors came from various walks
- 14:33of life. But the one thing that I saw that was
- 14:37probably the common denominator that made professional
- 14:41monitors serve as good professional monitors
- 14:45or better professional monitors was the innate
- 14:48ability to be a individual who could not attack
- 14:55the other parent. Basically could calm both parents
- 14:59down and establish a credibility early on with
- 15:03both parents so that you wouldn't get the complaints
- 15:06that I used to get in court. The monitor is siding
- 15:09with the other parent. The monitor has a favorite.
- 15:13The best monitors are people who can seemingly
- 15:17float above the fray. And as a judge, I only
- 15:23know this when the cases come back to me with
- 15:25a report. And before we move on, it's also important
- 15:30to note when we talk about this, think about
- 15:33it. 24 hours of training, that's all that's required
- 15:36to be a professional monitor. And of that, of
- 15:38the 24 hours, one hour is basic knowledge of
- 15:42family law. That's it. So I think it's very important
- 15:47to think when we look at professional monitors,
- 15:50who we select as a professional monitor. Because
- 15:52while there are There are, if you Google professional
- 15:56monitors, Los Angeles or professional monitors,
- 15:59California, there's a list of people that pop
- 16:02up as professional monitors that, you know, if
- 16:04you've practiced in LA County long enough, some
- 16:07of which you know, and you can trust. And there
- 16:09are definitely, there's a short list of those.
- 16:12But then there's also a list of people that you
- 16:14may not have ever heard of before that have completed
- 16:17the quote, 24 hours of training and only 12 hours
- 16:20in a classroom. that can now qualify as a professional
- 16:24monitor, that we're going to talk about this
- 16:27as we go on, that can really play a very essential
- 16:31role in your case because these professional
- 16:33monitors are going to be fact gatherers for the
- 16:36court and can be really good fact gatherers for
- 16:40the monitored parent or the parent seeking the
- 16:43monitor because a lot of times, as we were saying,
- 16:47the whole idea of Give it a chance if you're
- 16:51being asked to be monitored to prove that you
- 16:53are not this bad parent You are not the parent
- 16:55that needs to be monitored You're not the parent
- 16:57that is feeding the child gluten per se when
- 16:59you need what when you're not supposed to be
- 17:01or you're aware of the peanut peanut allergy
- 17:04or you know what to do with a Crying two -year
- 17:08-old or you know how to change a diaper that
- 17:10monitor can be a great person that present evidence
- 17:14of the court That's a third party But just think
- 17:16about when we select who? Just because they're
- 17:19labeled a professional monitor. The family code.
- 17:24And the rules of court, which are in your packet
- 17:26that was sent to you. Really have a very limited.
- 17:31It's 24 hours period and of those 24 hours, it's
- 17:34very limited on what it is and. In fact, as of
- 17:392021, I believe there was a. Extra hour that
- 17:43was added and they said wait, but that extra
- 17:45hour is included in the 24 hours. So again, it's
- 17:49a limited amount. So now we can move to non -professional.
- 17:53Well, wait a minute, Michael, before you do that,
- 17:56I'm being me again. Let's go back to the prior
- 17:58slide. It doesn't matter. It can be either slide.
- 18:00It's a good intro to your slide. And all of the
- 18:05people who are listening to this need to keep
- 18:07one thing in mind. A judge is not going to appoint
- 18:11a specific person as a professional monitor.
- 18:15That is not anything that we know or are going
- 18:18to opine on or make the selection. That is up
- 18:22to the attorneys, the parties involved. And so
- 18:26when people are picking monitors, I know that
- 18:29there are some favorites and I know that some
- 18:32of the favorite people are favors of one and
- 18:36not the other and then there's the report back
- 18:39to court and then there is the well you know
- 18:42your honor that this person supports dads or
- 18:46you know this person doesn't see this as a problem
- 18:49no we don't know that we don't know anything
- 18:51about that and i think that the vetting and the
- 18:58understanding of the needs of your particular
- 19:00client are really really paramount in the initial
- 19:05selection of this monitor because we're joking
- 19:08about gluten and let me just say this when I
- 19:11first got on the bench I was sitting in Pomona
- 19:14and many people who were in front of me in Pomona
- 19:19had were on probation or parole and they had
- 19:24children and they were seeing their children
- 19:29a week out of custody. And the issues that many
- 19:35of those people who are on probation or parole
- 19:38had with the other parent was not putting the
- 19:42child in a car seat, not making sure that the
- 19:45child wasn't at a meeting where there could be
- 19:48gang members. Fast forward a few years later
- 19:52to me going to the West Side where the big concern
- 19:56was gluten. was the fact as to whether or not
- 20:00somebody got their nap on time. And so you need
- 20:04to understand that based on the specific needs
- 20:07of your case, a professional monitor in one case
- 20:11may not even see the issues that you have in
- 20:15yours, which becomes real important in that initial
- 20:18selection. And Judge, just a question for you,
- 20:21because that brings up a good issue. There's
- 20:23a lot of times where one party has an idea of
- 20:27who should be the monitor, or one side has an
- 20:30idea, and the other side doesn't agree. I mean,
- 20:33to me, I always think it's a good idea to put
- 20:35it to the judge to say, we've met and conferred,
- 20:37we've tried to agree on who a monitor is, we
- 20:40can't agree. And I mean, to me, there's a couple
- 20:42different options, and I'd love to hear what
- 20:44you think. It's either submit, each side can
- 20:47submit two or three names with CVs or online
- 20:52printouts of who the monitor isn't the court
- 20:54decide or I mean I almost like the idea of let
- 20:58party A pick three names and party B gets to
- 21:02select one of the three as a professional monitor
- 21:04because a lot of times there won't be an agreement
- 21:07for exactly what you said. So let me address
- 21:11what I used to do. There's you know the concept
- 21:14of one party picking three names and the other
- 21:16one selecting. I've had the scenario where none
- 21:19of the three names were good. So what I would
- 21:22prefer is a list of three names and each party's
- 21:28concerns or issues with that specific monitor.
- 21:32And in most of those cases, even though that
- 21:35person might have a concern, I wouldn't have
- 21:38the concern. I might appoint the monitor where
- 21:42dad had a concern and then I would list in the
- 21:46order. This needs to be addressed that, you know,
- 21:49this is an issue that needs to be addressed or
- 21:52is a concern or an issue. If I don't think it's
- 21:56a concern, I'll rule then. But I need to have
- 21:58the issue framed so that I can look at it and
- 22:01not just the complaint. I don't like that person.
- 22:04I need to know what the issue specific because,
- 22:07as I said a minute ago, if monitors are not one
- 22:10size fits all. And I think, Robin, in your experience,
- 22:13you've even seen that. And actually what I was
- 22:17also going to say, sometimes the selection of
- 22:19who in a professional monitor goes to logistical
- 22:22reasons. Who has the time? Who is answering the
- 22:26phone? Who is able to provide, and depending
- 22:29on the cases, it's sometimes nice to have the.
- 22:32you know, sometimes there's these monitoring
- 22:33companies that will send various different monitors.
- 22:37And based on the age and needs of kids, we need
- 22:39to select someone where maybe there's going to
- 22:41be more consistency from time in and time out,
- 22:43especially if there's special needs or other
- 22:44things going on. So, you know, there's a whole
- 22:47host of kind of the non -tangibles that are realistic
- 22:51parts and pieces of the selection of who should
- 22:54serve. And before we move on, sorry to make you
- 22:58go back one more time, Katie. Before you move
- 23:00on, just... But we didn't include two. There
- 23:03is an FL -324 -P form, which I can count on one
- 23:09hand how many times I've actually seen them filed.
- 23:11But they're supposed to be filed each time a
- 23:15professional monitor submits a report to the
- 23:17court. That form actually outlines the requirements
- 23:21that are set forth in the family code and the
- 23:23rules of court. And there was a question of what
- 23:25the differences are. The family code and the
- 23:27rule of court that are referenced are pretty
- 23:29similar, there's very minimal differences and
- 23:31the FL form pretty much copies the requirements
- 23:35of the local rule of court and has the monitor
- 23:39check it off and sign to say that they complied
- 23:41with it. But you know, to your point, they're
- 23:44filed with the court, but I can tell you, as
- 23:47a bench officer, I never checked and I don't
- 23:51know how many people do check and I've never
- 23:55seen anyone complain. that the form wasn't filed.
- 24:00And the reason why we included this to all of
- 24:04the participants or people who are watching this
- 24:07is that if that form hasn't been filed and the
- 24:12court somehow hasn't addressed it, if it's not
- 24:16there, you need to raise it. Because as a professional
- 24:19monitor, they need to have completed this document.
- 24:23They need to be in compliance. If nobody objects,
- 24:27the court's not necessarily on its own going
- 24:30to even recognize that it isn't there. But now
- 24:35moving on to nonprofessional monitors, I think.
- 24:37So the same family code, same rule of court,
- 24:41different sections provide the outline of what
- 24:43a nonprofessional monitor is. And essentially,
- 24:47you have to be over 21 years old, no record of
- 24:51a DUI, not on parole for the last 10 years. only
- 24:56within the last five years. No criminal, civil,
- 25:01or juvenile restraining orders within the last
- 25:0310 years, not financially dependent on the person
- 25:06being supervised, no record of child molestation,
- 25:10child abuse, or other crimes against a person,
- 25:13proof of automobile insurance if you're transporting
- 25:15the child, and no current or past orders where
- 25:20the nonprofessional monitor was monitored him
- 25:23or herself. pretty light standards, typically,
- 25:30and oh, by the way, there is an FL form, the
- 25:32FL324NP for non -professional, which is also
- 25:35attached to your program material. Here's what's
- 25:39interesting. When you look at the FL324NP, it
- 25:43actually allows us, which was going to bleed
- 25:45into the next slide, but it allows us to kind
- 25:47of think outside the box. Because while the family
- 25:50code and the rule of court provides these requirements
- 25:53for non -professional monitors, It also, the
- 25:57judicial counsel form allows you to check off
- 26:00a box that says, well, there's alternate qualifications.
- 26:03And we've decided to vary from the qualifications
- 26:06of the family code of rule of court. And here's
- 26:09why. It's either we've agreed to it or the court's
- 26:11ordered it. So typically, in my opinion, nonprofessional
- 26:15monitors are typically coming into a place where
- 26:19one, parties can't afford professional monitoring.
- 26:21and a court is concerned or a party is concerned
- 26:24that the other parent needs to be monitored.
- 26:28We can't afford a professional monitor because
- 26:30some of them can be pricey, but we need protection
- 26:33in place. Or two, there might be times where
- 26:36a professional monitor just the worry and concern
- 26:40might not lead up to the need to have a professional
- 26:42monitor. It might be more child -friendly or
- 26:45child -focused to have a friend of the family,
- 26:49a relative. a third party that we all know act
- 26:54as a monitor. Now, you have to get that party
- 26:57to agree to it. You have to have the party agree
- 26:59to sign the FL -324 form, and you have to get
- 27:02that party to essentially agree that they are
- 27:06signing on to being a witness in this family
- 27:10law case, which as we all know, sometimes can
- 27:13be very hard to get a third party to even testify
- 27:16with a subpoena, nevertheless, agree to volunteer.
- 27:19to become this witness as a non -professional
- 27:22monitor? You know, in cases that are not highly
- 27:26litigious with probably most of the lawyers who
- 27:30are watching this, I have seen where the parties
- 27:34say, I don't care if grandma's the monitor. I
- 27:36don't care if the uncle's the monitor. I don't
- 27:38care. I don't care. It's okay. I trust that person.
- 27:42It's okay. And sometimes you What is the phrase?
- 27:47Keep it simple, stupid. Sometimes it's really
- 27:50not that complicated. Oftentimes in those cases,
- 27:55the monitor basically says everything is okay
- 27:58and the monitor goes away. I don't want anybody
- 28:02who's watching this program to think that every
- 28:05single time there is a monitor that there has
- 28:08to be a fight. There have been so many cases
- 28:11that I have presided over where they're either
- 28:17been self -represented or even with attorneys
- 28:19where they say, I don't care, it can be the neighbor.
- 28:22They are not really looking to complicate it
- 28:26other than that they feel for whatever reasons,
- 28:29there needs to be someone there. I don't know
- 28:33how you feel about that, Robin. I don't even
- 28:35know if we discussed this. I don't think we did
- 28:37in our preparation. But it doesn't always have
- 28:41to be complicated. A hundred percent. And actually
- 28:44I've had cases that are even very, very high
- 28:47conflict, difficult, challenging cases. And that,
- 28:50you know, once you start talking about the economics
- 28:53of how much monitors cost, particularly if monitors
- 28:55are going to have, you know, fees are being split
- 28:57and both parties are bearing the burden. And
- 29:00once the costs start to rack up, depending when
- 29:02you see how things play out, all of a sudden
- 29:04there may be a meeting at the mines that someone
- 29:07may be appropriate. And it kind of reminds me
- 29:09a little bit, I was at a speech where they were
- 29:13talking about middle school admissions and who
- 29:15you should have letters of recommendation from
- 29:17and the head of school said one of the most reliable.
- 29:20Letters of recommendation can come from grandparents
- 29:23because grandparents have a unique ability to
- 29:26be able to judge and see how their kids are doing
- 29:29and have an innate desire to protect them. It
- 29:31almost transfers to this a little bit. I know
- 29:33that sometimes grandparents can get in the way
- 29:35of things in terms of when there's a custody
- 29:37case going on, but a trusted grandparent can
- 29:40be an excellent monitor because they have the
- 29:43protective side. They've been a parent to one
- 29:47of those parents theoretically. say it like it
- 29:51is. So we should not discount the non -professional
- 29:54monitor out there, particularly if it's gonna
- 29:57be over a protracted period of time and with
- 30:01long hours in there. And as a cost savings analysis
- 30:05too, I mean, especially post COVID world, there's
- 30:08been a lot of times where virtual visitations
- 30:11have been ordered or weekly telephone calls for
- 30:14an hour or two. And there've been times where
- 30:16they've been ordered to be monitored. And to
- 30:19me, especially with a Zoom call that's going
- 30:21to be monitored, as a lawyer, I might be more
- 30:25inclined to think of a nonprofessional monitor
- 30:26on a Zoom call, especially if the party who is,
- 30:32especially if the Zoom call can be recorded.
- 30:34Because then you have the documentary evidence
- 30:36that you may need to say the monitored parent
- 30:39acted inappropriately, and you can bring in the
- 30:43recording of the Zoom call if necessary. And
- 30:45you don't really rely on the non -professional
- 30:48monitor to provide the evidence of that. And
- 30:51it also gives you evidence to see if the non
- 30:53-professional monitor is actually going to stop
- 30:55or redirect or terminate the call if the monitor
- 30:59parents aren't acting correctly. Is there a regulatory
- 31:03board, Robin, for the professional monitors?
- 31:08No, there is not. They're not part of the Board
- 31:11of Behavioral Sciences. There is no degree. There's
- 31:14no licensure. It is simply, you know, take the
- 31:18class and check off the class, almost like, you
- 31:21know, minors council, if you will. And kind of
- 31:23the problem, Judge, guess of why I said it, you're
- 31:26looking at a very minimal hours if you actually
- 31:30think about in the long and short of it. Yes,
- 31:32it is a lot of hours and initial work, but that's
- 31:35it. There's no continuing education requirement
- 31:38in the family code. and there's no one governing
- 31:41it. And like I said, if you Google professional
- 31:43monitors in LA County, there's a list and you
- 31:47know, practicing family law for a while. We know
- 31:50the ones that at least I believe are reputable,
- 31:53but there is a list of people that you've never
- 31:54heard of. And I mean, you have to be careful
- 31:58in who you select to be a professional monitor.
- 32:01It can get, it can definitely get scary on who
- 32:06can be out there. Well, and along those lines,
- 32:09actually, I mean, you know, first of all, there
- 32:11are, even though there may not be any regulatory
- 32:13requirements, there are many different internal
- 32:17requirements that these various companies may
- 32:19have, right? That they do require that their
- 32:21individual monitors take extra classes. They
- 32:24may not be formalized, but these are things,
- 32:26actually, when I am helping people try to think
- 32:29about selecting a monitor, thinking about some
- 32:31of these things. And to me, And I know this often
- 32:34happens. We're all busy. You family law lawyers
- 32:36out there are super, super busy, busier than
- 32:38ever. And the last thing you have time to do
- 32:40is really do things in advance. But if you're
- 32:43watching this right now, take the time to get
- 32:46to know monitors now. Take the time to get to
- 32:49know monitors and interview them before you have
- 32:52a case. So you can develop an independent objective
- 32:55view of them and see, okay, what is their experience
- 32:57in training? Who are the people that are responsive?
- 33:01How do they select people? How many monitors
- 33:03are on their staff? Do they provide monitors
- 33:07that have the ability to do 24 -hour sleepovers?
- 33:11How many of those people? Do they have any monitors
- 33:14that have MFTs or MSWs on their credentials?
- 33:18So one of the things if I'm talking from, you
- 33:21know, giving advice to lawyers is start trying
- 33:24to do the work, interviewing and verifying credentials
- 33:27before you even have a case coming up so you
- 33:29know who there is and you have the relationships
- 33:31done. And then looking at those things like experience
- 33:34and training. The other thing is, is that when
- 33:36you're selecting a monitor, you kind of have
- 33:38the objective view of what the skill level and
- 33:43whether or not they have, you know, what their
- 33:45ability is to write a report, to witness things,
- 33:48to be objective, all of those kind of, you know,
- 33:51hard skills. But let's also then look at the
- 33:54nuances that come with every case, right? We
- 33:56have to look at each case as And each kid based
- 34:01on their individual personalities, dispositions,
- 34:04will they connect? Are you gonna have like a,
- 34:08what are, how will a little tiny three -year
- 34:11-old feel with a six foot eight monitor, right?
- 34:13Is that gonna? feel comfortable for the child?
- 34:17Do we want to look at a male versus female? Some
- 34:20of these other types of things that may come
- 34:22on based on what the facts of the case are. So
- 34:25you want to kind of take a balanced view of looking
- 34:28at both the objective factors in terms of the
- 34:31skill set, but then also the soft subjective
- 34:34factors and thinking. you know, really about
- 34:36what is going on in the case, right? If we've
- 34:39got a really challenging resist -refuse case,
- 34:42is the monitor strong enough to be able to assist
- 34:44in getting a kid out of the car if this is a
- 34:48kid that is likely to, you know, double down
- 34:52and not want to get out of a car? Are they able
- 34:54to help manage difficult parents who may call
- 34:57all the time or may write nasty gram emails or
- 35:00do any of this stuff? Do they have kind of those
- 35:02other skills that are going to be able to be
- 35:05addressed? And that also may be, and this is
- 35:08something that in our preparation, we had a little
- 35:10bit of debate about about what and we'll talk
- 35:12about more in terms of the role of the monitor.
- 35:15You know, but there are, you know, there's some
- 35:17gray area where you're monitoring and watching,
- 35:20but there may be a need for a monitor to intervene.
- 35:24And what is that monitor's ability to intervene,
- 35:27to stop something that may be a dangerous situation,
- 35:30need to stop a visit or a redirection of something,
- 35:33a kid goes running or doing something. I mean,
- 35:35the monitor is just not monitoring, watching.
- 35:37They're there to monitor, to intervene if it's
- 35:40necessary. And this is something that is subject
- 35:44to a lot of debate and we'd be curious for your
- 35:47feedback if you want to write this into the chat
- 35:49or whatever. But there is, you know, a debate
- 35:52out here about, you know, can a monitor be used
- 35:57to model parenting skills or allow for some collaboration
- 36:01to help redirect and help parent, right? It's
- 36:03like, for example, if you see a parent struggling
- 36:08to connect with the child, is it appropriate
- 36:11for the monitor to say maybe you shouldn't be
- 36:14doing this activity? Maybe instead you should
- 36:16be sitting on the floor and playing some Legos
- 36:18because maybe you'll bond better. So Michael
- 36:21and I have had this conversation with Judge Lopez
- 36:24-Giss about whether or not that's appropriate.
- 36:25I personally think anything to support a family
- 36:28unit and help, like the goal is to make everyone
- 36:31better and make the experience good, a little
- 36:34bit of corrective stuff may make be useful, but
- 36:36I'm sure Michael will clap back at me here in
- 36:39just a moment. Before Michael claps back at you,
- 36:42I just want to do a preemptive strike. I have
- 36:47had cases where a monitor has suggested that
- 36:50one parent or the other might be more effective
- 36:54doing this rather than that and maybe in a tantrum
- 36:57situation or when when the child seemingly is
- 37:01bored or seemingly has issues and I've seen the
- 37:05other side angry that you know complaining in
- 37:09court that the monitor you know is helping quote
- 37:13-unquote helping the other parent And, you know,
- 37:16let's go back to the purpose of a monitor. The
- 37:19purpose of the monitor is to make sure that a
- 37:22child is safe. And so that being safe, meaning,
- 37:27you know, not running out on the street, being
- 37:29safe, not, you know, ingesting poisonous materials
- 37:32and safe, meaning that that that they are protected
- 37:37from danger. But what too often happens is that
- 37:43the the definition of danger starts bleeding
- 37:48into, I don't like the way that other parent,
- 37:51parents. That's not necessarily danger. I really
- 37:55don't think it is. I think people have different
- 37:57techniques in in raising their children that
- 38:00are not, as I often say, legal decisions, their
- 38:03parenting decisions. And so what is the difference
- 38:08of a next door neighbor saying, you know what?
- 38:11You know, Johnny's taking the hose and squirting
- 38:13all the cars. And here, Johnny, take the hose
- 38:16and let's go water flowers as some sort of helping
- 38:20that other parent. And I think the ball that
- 38:25we have to keep our eye on is the best interest
- 38:27of the child, not proving that the other parent
- 38:31doesn't parent the way you want that parent to
- 38:34parent. But then this goes back to the issues
- 38:37of choosing the monitors and Michael, I cut you
- 38:45off. So I want you to talk. Well, I mean, I'm
- 38:47going to I think we're going to get to that.
- 38:49My only concern is if a monitor is providing
- 38:54advice to the monitored parent. And I don't think
- 38:57the I would not go to court saying that monitors
- 38:59help in the parent. That's not what the monitor
- 39:02is supposed to do. But I would be concerned about
- 39:04a bias issue because if monitor is. so aligned
- 39:08with the monitored parent that raises a concern,
- 39:13at least optically, as to whether or not that
- 39:17monitor is a neutral third party that's monitoring
- 39:20the visits, which is how would you define a line?
- 39:23Well, and I'm going to clap back, Michael, because
- 39:25this is what we're talking about. And they may
- 39:27say, listen, this guy's a ding dong, does not
- 39:29know how to do anything with his kids. So therefore
- 39:31I redirect it. So maybe it's a bias the other
- 39:33way. But to me, I don't know if that's what in
- 39:37my interpretation, that's not what the monitor's
- 39:39job is. The monitor's job is to be there and
- 39:41monitor what the parent is doing and to report
- 39:43back to the court what the parent is doing. So
- 39:46let's assume the monitor sees that the child
- 39:49is just, you know, drawing all over the walls
- 39:53or whatever it is. But and some parents wouldn't
- 39:56even have a problem because they're expressing
- 39:58themselves. But the monitor doesn't say, you
- 40:01know, look, Mary is seemingly bored. Does that
- 40:06mean? that the monitor is supposed to write a
- 40:08report that the child drew on the walls. I just
- 40:12don't think that that makes a parent a bad parent
- 40:15because where do you draw the there's so many
- 40:17parents who are just so laid back and lays a
- 40:21fair that that doesn't mean the child's not safe.
- 40:24And so I want to know from from you for the benefit
- 40:29of the people who are listening what the Do you
- 40:33define as a lawyer that you would bring to a
- 40:35judge as aligned with one parent or the other?
- 40:39Well, so it really depends. So it's situational.
- 40:42And I'm going to the worst case scenario and
- 40:45because I'm hoping for the best, but planning
- 40:48for the worst. And Robin and I had this debate
- 40:51where Robin was, you know, she's hoping for the
- 40:53best. And that's what Robin does with the co
- 40:57-parent and therapy, with helping people. you
- 41:00know, in the therapeutic venue of what she does
- 41:02for a living. That's great. But if I have a monitor
- 41:07that does not put in a monitor report, children
- 41:10are writing on the wall. And I then had you tell
- 41:12dad, maybe we should switch activities, but rather
- 41:15tells dad and doesn't report it. I have a concern
- 41:19because then query is what else is being left
- 41:22out of the monitor report? Well, no one said
- 41:24not to put it in the report. Well, but okay,
- 41:27then play with this out with me for a little
- 41:29bit. There's one thing, redirect. Dad, mom, monitor
- 41:33parent, please don't talk about the case with
- 41:35the children. That's not appropriate. You put
- 41:37that in the report, great. Monitor parent, I
- 41:41think we should change activities because child
- 41:43is seemingly bored. Maybe we should go from the
- 41:49swings to let's grab the soccer ball. And that's
- 41:52in the report redirected. Dad didn't notice that
- 41:54child was bored. I did. I told parent to change
- 41:57activity. Fine. That's in the report. If then
- 42:03the monitor decides to call the modern parents
- 42:05lawyer, per se, to say your client really needs
- 42:08to do different activities or really needs to
- 42:11kind of do focus on this or should get a should
- 42:13get a parenting coach to help them. I'm a little
- 42:16concerned because then that's not monitor and
- 42:18then that's not really acting as a third party
- 42:22neutral, that's really given advice to the monitored
- 42:25parent. And there starts to be an alignment.
- 42:27And then if it continues, and I've seen it continue
- 42:31where then a monitor starts making negative reports
- 42:35about the non -monitored parent. So for instance,
- 42:38non -monitored parents bring in child to monitor
- 42:42visit in sweatshirt and it was 95 degrees. Well,
- 42:45okay, you're not monitoring the non -monitored
- 42:48parent. Why is that in there? And now you're
- 42:50also helping the monitored parent. You start
- 42:54to at least paint a picture of a bias, which
- 42:57to me, if I'm representing the monitored parent,
- 43:00that doesn't help me because I want the monitor
- 43:02to be an independent third -party neutral witness
- 43:05that's going to say that my parent is not putting
- 43:09the child in danger and that the monitor is no
- 43:11longer needed. But see, Michael, that's where
- 43:13I disagree. I think you it is being neutral to
- 43:17report just the facts, right? So if you're saying
- 43:20they may not be good facts for you, for example,
- 43:23my client, eyewitness, parent A had trouble selecting
- 43:32activities. I suggested that maybe this parent
- 43:35should get a parenting coach because it'll be
- 43:37helpful for them to be more attuned to their
- 43:39parent, to their child. That's just reality.
- 43:44This is what I thought and it can be used in
- 43:46whatever. This is what I thought because a monitor
- 43:48is not just supposed to be a video camera of
- 43:51watching what's going on. Their job is to intervene
- 43:54if it's seemingly necessary. I have to push back.
- 43:58on this whole discussion because the whole purpose
- 44:01for me of monitors is to protect the child's
- 44:05safety what we're having disagreement about is
- 44:09parenting decisions and whether the child shows
- 44:11up in a sweatshirt and that means that the other
- 44:15parent was somehow overheating the child is in
- 44:18my opinion nonsense and whether or not the child
- 44:23is bored I mean, okay, the child is bored. But
- 44:28what I'm really worried about is the child safe.
- 44:32And if that is why a monitor is being appointed,
- 44:38because the child might be bored with mom or
- 44:41might be bored with dad and isn't having an e
- 44:45-ticket visit each time. I suggest that we're
- 44:49really misusing the purpose of monitors from
- 44:51my perspective. I've seen too many lawyers get
- 44:56into how many angels can dance on the head of
- 44:59a pen argument with respect to their own biases
- 45:02as to what is considered parenting. If a monitor
- 45:06is redirecting and includes it or doesn't include
- 45:10it, To me, that monitor doesn't have much to
- 45:15watch. I mean, I've seen where parents have had
- 45:19substance abuse problems, and I'm nervous about
- 45:22whether that child is being exposed to a parent
- 45:25who's either drunk and or loaded during that
- 45:28visitation. That's why the monitor is there.
- 45:31The monitor... is not there to make sure that
- 45:34the child goes to sleep at one o 'clock in the
- 45:37afternoon. If the child does or doesn't and a
- 45:40parent is not abiding by those concerns, I think
- 45:43that this goes back to early on as to why you're
- 45:47having a monitor appointed. You took the words
- 45:49out of my mouth. You took the words exactly out
- 45:52of my mouth because that's exactly what I was
- 45:54going to say is it really depends on what the
- 45:56purpose is for the case and why we're having
- 45:59them there and what we're trying to solve. And
- 46:01if it is an issue of, okay, I'm just going to
- 46:04agree to negate some of the issues or some of
- 46:07the concerns or to corroborate some of the concerns
- 46:10that have been there and they have to deal more
- 46:12with these kind of parent -child contact issues,
- 46:15then some of this observation may be more relevant.
- 46:18And you also have the local rule, California
- 46:21rule of court 5 .20i, which deals with conflict
- 46:26of interest, which makes it clear that the monitors
- 46:29to maintain neutrality should refuse to discuss
- 46:34merits of the case or agree with or support one
- 46:37party over another. So that's kind of where my
- 46:40pushback is, is that you have a local rule that
- 46:43states that. So if the monitor is discussing
- 46:45or trying to support one party over the other,
- 46:49and I think it's a fine line, but that is where
- 46:53the bias and conflict of interest comes into
- 46:56effect. And I mean, the vocal rule does not go
- 47:00into correcting behavior as a conflict of interest,
- 47:03but it's an argument. I mean, it does go into
- 47:05not to be financially dependent, not to be an
- 47:08employee of either of the people, and not to
- 47:10be in an intimate relationship. I do think that
- 47:14it's clear that they're to maintain neutrality
- 47:17and not and should refuse to discuss merits of
- 47:19the case or agree with or support one party over
- 47:22another. So, you know, we're getting to this
- 47:26discussion, and I think it leads into crafting
- 47:29the court order as to my point earlier as to
- 47:32what actually is intended by the parties in getting
- 47:38a monitor. So I. This is something that Judge
- 47:42Kaufman and I discussed, and I just want to underscore
- 47:46bold and make clear that whatever your concern
- 47:52is needs to be put in this order. Judges are
- 47:56not going to guess for you. If you think that
- 47:59a monitor should not be helping the other parent,
- 48:03make the child not bored, then put it in the
- 48:05order and somebody can argue it and the judge
- 48:07can make the decision upfront if that's going
- 48:09to be determined to be a concern. But the easy
- 48:14things, who selects the monitor? And can the
- 48:18monitor be determinated and by who? Because I've
- 48:22seen orders that talk about the child being monitored
- 48:25by a professional monitor, but with no end date.
- 48:28And that buys a request for order for termination.
- 48:34So at least put it in there, or at least under
- 48:37what terms the termination would occur, so you're
- 48:40not just left with this order that basically
- 48:44violates the rule against perpetuities. And about
- 48:48reporting requirements, this is when you want
- 48:52to have specific issues reported and what are
- 48:57the concerns, list the concerns. And if the initial
- 48:59concern is sobriety or the initial concern is
- 49:04that the parent doesn't pay attention and falls
- 49:08asleep, write those issues down because that's
- 49:11what the monitor is going to basically need to
- 49:14know as well as the custody visitation. And if
- 49:18there is a child who doesn't want to get out
- 49:21of the car or doesn't want to go, what is the
- 49:26monitor expected to do? And I think that needs
- 49:29to be discussed because it's often raised in
- 49:32court. The child doesn't want to get out of the
- 49:34car. Are you expecting the monitor to physically
- 49:37take the child out of the car? If that is an
- 49:40issue, it needs to be addressed in the order
- 49:42under what concerns Does a child get forced out
- 49:46of the car? If the child is two, it's different
- 49:48than if the child is five or six. And what kind
- 49:52of emotional distress are you going to put the
- 49:54child in? And if the child doesn't want to go,
- 49:57it needs to be addressed in the order as to what
- 50:00expectation there is for the monitor. And also
- 50:04in cases of disputes, if The monitor is not the
- 50:08judge, is not the referee. This is, you know,
- 50:11not a WWW fight. So if in fact it is left to
- 50:16be a dispute, the monitor can just note it and
- 50:21leave it. And then I think that no monitor has
- 50:25to be present in prohibited behavior. If in fact
- 50:29there is drugs, the monitor can terminate the
- 50:33visitation. And that needs to be said because
- 50:37I don't think a monitor is required to sit with
- 50:41a parent that's inebriated or intoxicated or
- 50:44in any way impaired just to finish the time.
- 50:49It has to be specific. And again, avoid vague
- 50:54language. I really think that, you know, included
- 51:00but not limited to is a problem. If you've got
- 51:04some real concerns, list them. I'd like to hear
- 51:08Robin's point and then end on this slide with
- 51:12Michael, because you're the one, Michael, who
- 51:15has come into court many times saying the monitor
- 51:18has not been complicit with the order. Well,
- 51:23I think that, first of all, Just, you know, there's
- 51:25actually a rule kind of in the social worker
- 51:27therapy world that if there's an issue with the
- 51:29professional, the first thing to do is to address
- 51:31it with the professional. That's actually like
- 51:33a standard ethical requirement in the therapeutic
- 51:35world. And I think that that would be something
- 51:37that would be. You know, obviously you want to
- 51:40have the order as clear and concise as possible.
- 51:43But the reality, as we all know, life is life.
- 51:45You cannot possibly account for every single
- 51:48possible scenario that could happen in the real
- 51:51world in a court order. We can't do it in terms
- 51:53of when we do judgments. We can't think of it
- 51:56in stipulations necessarily. And it's certainly
- 51:58going to sometimes be a problem when we're crafting
- 52:00an order to the extent that we can define certain
- 52:04roles, I think, and get make sure that we define
- 52:07the authority and what the scope of kind of what
- 52:10the monitor is to do and not to do. Obviously,
- 52:12that's great. But then the question is, is that
- 52:15there's different kind of rules of thumb and
- 52:18kind of monitors have their own rules that sometimes
- 52:21don't even necessarily make its way into court
- 52:23orders. For example, there are a lot of monitoring.
- 52:26monitor agencies that have an internal rule that
- 52:29they will not allow gifts to be given between
- 52:34parents and child on a monitored visit or that
- 52:36they won't allow phone calls. Like if the child,
- 52:40if that's during the middle of the monitor visit,
- 52:41the parent could not call a grandparent or another
- 52:44person or whatever. So we have to really think
- 52:47about and have those conversations if any of
- 52:49these scenarios come up and have the conversation
- 52:52and talk to the monitoring agency kind of about
- 52:55what are your internal rules and should those
- 52:58be incorporated into the court order? And I'm
- 53:02going to work my way backwards on this slide
- 53:03for a second, where it says avoid vague language,
- 53:07detail is critical. A lot easier said than done,
- 53:11especially when you have a DV and you're going
- 53:13in for a temporary restraining order and you
- 53:16check that box that says monitored visits, because
- 53:19at least when you're filing the initial TRO request,
- 53:24you don't get to talk to the judge. It's very
- 53:27hard to attach attachments to those forms. And
- 53:31if you do, whether or not they're even going
- 53:32to be looked at at the initial granting phase.
- 53:35So to me, a lot of the detail and being detailed
- 53:38in the order comes at the first hearing on the
- 53:41TRO request. Because a lot of times, you submit
- 53:44the monitored visit, the judge checks some boxes,
- 53:47you might list a name for a professional monitor,
- 53:50the judge might leave it blank, the judge might
- 53:52check the box that says, one parent pays 100
- 53:55% of the fees, but that's it. There's no real
- 53:58change on the forms. But a lot of this comes
- 54:01in on round two when you're there on the first
- 54:03hearing that's set within 21 -ish days. you assume
- 54:08one party is going to be asking for a continuance.
- 54:11And you're going to say, and you either have
- 54:13a no custody order or monitored visit order,
- 54:16and you're going to ask for detail to the order.
- 54:19Because if you don't have the detail, you have
- 54:22issues arise. And the issues can arise, for instance,
- 54:25of what are the prohibited behaviors? Now, the
- 54:29monitor and the family code sets out that monitors
- 54:33can. If rules of the visits have been violated,
- 54:37the child becomes acutely distressed or the safety
- 54:40of the child or the provider is at risk, the
- 54:43visits can be interrupted, rescheduled or set
- 54:46for a later date or terminated. But that's a
- 54:49broad subject. Are there certain behaviors we
- 54:51don't want? And I mean, there are different rules
- 54:55for sexual abuse allegation cases versus DV cases
- 55:00versus I just want a child being monitored because
- 55:02I'm afraid dad's going to talk about a case.
- 55:04So, are we going to include in the monitor order?
- 55:08The monitor parent shall not talk about the case
- 55:09to the monitor child if you want. But that's
- 55:12a rule. So, I don't have any problem you putting
- 55:14that in. That should be in almost every custody
- 55:15order anyway because that is the law, even though
- 55:18I don't think anyone knows that or cares, but
- 55:21it is the law. Well, it is, but is it in the
- 55:24monitor order? It should be. So I mean, that's
- 55:28where the detail goes in. You are putting in
- 55:30your hand, because this order is what you give
- 55:32to the monitor. And this is the rule and the
- 55:35guideline that the monitor is going to follow
- 55:37for the monitored visitations for as long as
- 55:40it's in effect. So where are the monitor visits
- 55:44going to take place? Are we concerned that the
- 55:46monitored visits take place at the monitored
- 55:48parent's home? Do we want it in public? Typically,
- 55:53Michael, my experience on the bench is that those
- 55:57specific points are included in the order that
- 56:01I sign. Where, when, for how long, and who's
- 56:05going to do the transportation. Those seemingly
- 56:09are monitor orders one. I mean, they're elementary.
- 56:15I agree with you, but that's not on the DV form
- 56:18and you get a DV order without an attachment.
- 56:20You don't have that. That's why we're having
- 56:22this seminar now to tell people we need it. Right.
- 56:25So I think that's very important. I think it's
- 56:27also the more detail, the better. So for instance,
- 56:30are grandma and grandpa allowed to come with
- 56:32a monitored parent for a monitored visitation?
- 56:36If you don't want it, include that they're not
- 56:39allowed to be present because otherwise it's
- 56:42vague and then it becomes a dispute. And the
- 56:46same with reporting requirements. You have a
- 56:49monitor report. You now have your hearsay Sanchez
- 56:52issues. Now, a court can't order Sanchez and
- 56:56hearsay to be waived. The parties have to stipulate
- 56:59and agree to that. So are we going to agree to
- 57:01that, or are we not going to agree to that? All
- 57:04of that has to be thought about in the order.
- 57:06Now, some can be ordered, some can be agreed
- 57:08to. But all of that needs to be thought of when
- 57:10we're coming up with the order. And you also
- 57:13have to keep in mind with payment, A lot of times,
- 57:16Judge Giss and I were talking about this with
- 57:18Robin when we were preparing for this, and the
- 57:21bench may not be aware, a lot of these monitors
- 57:23have their own written agreements that the parties
- 57:27have to sign. And these written agreements include
- 57:30who pays for what for the monitor. So even though
- 57:34the court order says parent A pays 100 % of the
- 57:37cost, your client's now going out to sign an
- 57:40intake. agreement with a monitor that says they're
- 57:43going to pay 50 % of the cost of the intake.
- 57:45They're going to pay for fees and costs for the
- 57:48deposition if they subpoena the monitor. They're
- 57:51going to pay for the fees and costs for the monitor
- 57:52to appear at court if they subpoena them to appear
- 57:55at court. So if there is something that's thought
- 57:59differently, or we want to include that the order
- 58:01supersedes the monitor agreement on payment,
- 58:05or we need the monitor to change his or her agreement
- 58:07based upon the order, All that needs to be thought
- 58:10of in advance so that when you go into court,
- 58:12there's not a dispute versus, well, the order
- 58:15says that dad pays 100 % of the fees. I subpoenaed
- 58:18the monitor. The monitor didn't show up. Well,
- 58:21your client signed a contract with the monitor
- 58:23saying that if they subpoena them, they're going
- 58:25to pay for them. All of that needs to be considered
- 58:28and presented at least at the initial phase,
- 58:30if at all possible. Well, and that goes back
- 58:33to my point of get to know who your monitors
- 58:36are well in advance of crafting an order so that
- 58:39you know the nuances and the contracts and the
- 58:41procedures and the rules and the issues. And
- 58:44sometimes it's a very helpful way to get information
- 58:49of what goes into the order is to ask the monitor.
- 58:51What types of things would you like to see in
- 58:53the order? And a lot of them have suggestions
- 58:55for you. And I can tell you there are some that
- 58:58have been being monitored for a while that will
- 58:59give you a packet with what they propose of sample
- 59:02orders that are beyond helpful. And I hope the
- 59:07purpose of today's seminar is that the lawyers
- 59:11have the ability to streamline and make the court
- 59:14aware of the issues. We're not going to be aware
- 59:17of a conflict of interest. We're not going to
- 59:19be aware if people are not following the procedures
- 59:23unless somebody brings it to our attention. can
- 59:28be anything brought to our attention. It has
- 59:30to be clear in the order. And as Robin said,
- 59:32there's no way you're going to predict or figure
- 59:34out every which way it can go wrong. But at least
- 59:38at the beginning, if you understand the point
- 59:40of the monitor and what you specifically want
- 59:43that monitor to do and what you expect and who's
- 59:46going to pay for it, and even include that this
- 59:49order supersedes any requirement by the monitor,
- 59:55you're at least being made aware of potential
- 59:58problems in the future that don't have to exist.
- 1:00:02And it leads to the, and this also kind of to
- 1:00:04rewind back to that judicial council forms, the
- 1:00:07FL324 forms. If we focus on the monitors signing
- 1:00:12and submitting them, you're also getting them
- 1:00:15to agree that they're going to comply with all
- 1:00:18the requirements of the family code and the rule
- 1:00:21of court. So that if they violate it, They've
- 1:00:25now submitted a document saying that they will
- 1:00:27comply with it. They violate it. To me, I go
- 1:00:30to court to say, judge, we need to replace this
- 1:00:32monitor because this monitor is not complying
- 1:00:35with the rule of court or not complying with
- 1:00:37the family code, has a conflict of interest,
- 1:00:40has taken and whatnot. And they've agreed to
- 1:00:43comply with it. They're not complying it. There
- 1:00:45now needs to be a replacement. And just so the
- 1:00:48parties who are listening or counsel who are
- 1:00:50listening to this, I will tell you that on some
- 1:00:53rare occasions, it did not happen very much.
- 1:00:54People would bring issues about the monitor and
- 1:00:57their failure to comply or their issues of conflict
- 1:01:01of interest. And yes, there is a hearing because
- 1:01:04it's important, but I can think of specific cases
- 1:01:09where the monitor was replaced. It just wasn't
- 1:01:11a fit. But the judge isn't going to know if it's
- 1:01:16not in the order and if the parties don't tell
- 1:01:18us. So this is good to manage and monitor relationships,
- 1:01:23because I see that we're running out of time.
- 1:01:25And we've talked a lot about a lot of these things.
- 1:01:27And I think the main thing is to really, especially
- 1:01:32from the therapeutic point of view, is if you're
- 1:01:35a therapist and mental health provider providing
- 1:01:38co -parenting work or doing work with individual
- 1:01:41folks, in preparation is really helping to prepare
- 1:01:46for monitor visits and to stigmatize the monitoring
- 1:01:49process. Because sometimes this could be a really,
- 1:01:51really helpful process to help take out the steam
- 1:01:55of what would be otherwise a high conflict situation.
- 1:01:58In addition, I'm a big believer and think it's
- 1:02:02great when we can support collaboration. And
- 1:02:04that's been the best part about doing this speech
- 1:02:07with Judge Lopez -Giss and with Michael is that
- 1:02:10we can talk about and recognize, OK, I think
- 1:02:12this, you think this, let's figure this out.
- 1:02:14And we can model. for our clients, and we may
- 1:02:18not necessarily all share exactly the same opinions,
- 1:02:21but we can find a solution that's going to work
- 1:02:23for a case in a way that's workable. And I think
- 1:02:26the more that professionals can collaborate and
- 1:02:28talk about it and manage our clients' expectations,
- 1:02:31the better chance of success. And I want to say
- 1:02:34this, even though I'm not sitting on the bench
- 1:02:37again. pretty connected with many of the members
- 1:02:40of the bar. I can speak for myself and I believe
- 1:02:45a lot of my colleagues who are off the bench
- 1:02:47have no problem answering questions about this
- 1:02:50in the sense of give us a call as to how you
- 1:02:53think a problem with an order is. Because at
- 1:02:57the end of the day, if you bring a request for
- 1:03:00order to the court or you return back on a report
- 1:03:03from a monitor and there's been a lack of compliance
- 1:03:09or there's been a concern, we hope that this
- 1:03:13program at least lets you know how to frame that
- 1:03:16question or that issue to the court. We don't
- 1:03:19have all the answers, but I can tell you a clear,
- 1:03:21concise order from the beginning will certainly
- 1:03:24help get you through the door to get somebody
- 1:03:26who, if not the appropriate monitor in this case,
- 1:03:30a better monitor. Thank you. Thank you. And we
- 1:03:38are here as resources. Feel free to reach out
- 1:03:40to us through the Beverly Hills bar, or I think
- 1:03:43our contact information is somewhere on our materials.
- 1:03:48If not, you certainly know how to. And there
- 1:03:49were materials that were attached so that every
- 1:03:52every participant will get the materials. I'm
- 1:03:55just looking at the questions that came in. Let's
- 1:03:58see. I mean, I'm going to. put this to Robin
- 1:04:02and the judge, I mean, when or if it's appropriate.
- 1:04:05And I think we sort of answered this for a monitor
- 1:04:07to pull a resistant child from a car. I mean,
- 1:04:12from a therapeutic point side, Robin, I mean,
- 1:04:15to me, I'm gonna, I think it depends on what
- 1:04:18type of monitor it is, number one. So, I mean,
- 1:04:20I'm going to say that is generally, I mean, I
- 1:04:22think that monitors will be hard pressed to put
- 1:04:25hands on a child, and I would not recommend putting
- 1:04:28hands on a child. That's just not something that
- 1:04:31that's over overstepping unless there is some
- 1:04:34sort of very specific order and agreement in
- 1:04:36advance where you have a special need or it's
- 1:04:38okay, you know, maybe to unsnap a kid from and
- 1:04:41lift them out of a car seat. But a resistant
- 1:04:44child from a car, that is beyond the scope, I
- 1:04:48think, of a monitor's role. And I would not recommend
- 1:04:51any monitor do that without specific orders and
- 1:04:53direction. I agree. And I actually think of a
- 1:04:56child doesn't want to go as resistant. The monitor
- 1:04:59notes that. and it's reported back. And if appropriate,
- 1:05:04a court is addressed. It is addressed to the
- 1:05:06court. But I certainly am not in favor of anybody
- 1:05:10pulling a resistant child. I mean, like I said,
- 1:05:13a child's one and a half and crying. Yes, you
- 1:05:15can take a child out. But when a child is three
- 1:05:17or four and kicking and screaming, that is just
- 1:05:20not going to be helpful. And so that goes to
- 1:05:24skilled monitors. Frankly, a skilled monitor
- 1:05:26can use words. and help cajole maybe a resistant
- 1:05:31child out of a car with effective use of words
- 1:05:33and not physical contact. Right. And I mean,
- 1:05:36I even think a skilled monitor can probably come
- 1:05:38up with an alternate solution. So maybe it is,
- 1:05:42you know, mom, child's being resistant. Why don't
- 1:05:44we drop the child off here with me, hang out
- 1:05:46for a little bit, and then you leave and leave
- 1:05:50the child with me when dad comes to join me or
- 1:05:52come up with a different alternative. I don't
- 1:05:54think pulling a child out of a car is, you know,
- 1:05:57going to be a wise move for a monitor. Another
- 1:06:01question, I think we answered, but let's just,
- 1:06:03will a court consider removing a monitor over
- 1:06:06the objective of one parent for conduct that
- 1:06:09violates rule of court 5 .20? If it's brought
- 1:06:14to the court's attention and the court is able
- 1:06:17to inquire, which is what I would do, yes, if
- 1:06:20it's appropriate, no, if it's not. I mean, if
- 1:06:22the parent objects, which is common to the conduct
- 1:06:25of a monitor, I've held a short hearing and asked
- 1:06:30the questions, and sometimes the monitor is removed,
- 1:06:33and sometimes I don't think it's an issue. But
- 1:06:35I believe that courts want to know about it because
- 1:06:42they have to go forward for the protection and
- 1:06:44well -being of the child. Well, and I think it's
- 1:06:46important, again, it goes back to the, I guess
- 1:06:49it's a practice pointer, the detail and the order,
- 1:06:52because if you have an order, And let's say it's
- 1:06:54a monitored parent that's complaining about the
- 1:06:56conduct of the monitor. If you have an order
- 1:06:58that doesn't indicate who and how the monitor
- 1:07:01can be terminated, a monitored parent can terminate
- 1:07:04the monitor and decide to hire someone else if
- 1:07:07you don't have a monitor's name listed. And that
- 1:07:10could cause a lot of problems. So again, it all
- 1:07:12goes down to the more detail you put in these
- 1:07:15requests and the orders. And I mean, I think,
- 1:07:18Judge, if I handed you an attachment, whether
- 1:07:20it's for DVRO or request for monitors, has a
- 1:07:24list of requested orders. I mean, to me, I think
- 1:07:27I'm helping you. And I mean, I - You are. You
- 1:07:29are. And Judge Kaufman would say the same thing.
- 1:07:33Yes, help us. Don't make us guess. I mean, I
- 1:07:36recently heard a judge say, you know, your job
- 1:07:39is to help me - I was sitting in court and the
- 1:07:41judge was in the audience and the judge was like,
- 1:07:43counsel, your job is to help me. Help me help
- 1:07:45you make this easier. So to me, handing the court
- 1:07:48a list of proposed orders of what you want with
- 1:07:51the monitored visitation, that's really the best
- 1:07:56path forward. I don't know a colleague of any
- 1:08:01either on the bench or off the bench that I've
- 1:08:03ever served with who didn't appreciate a proposed
- 1:08:07order. Doesn't mean we might not edit it or mark
- 1:08:10it off or add something, but it really is helpful
- 1:08:13because you know what the issues are. You know
- 1:08:16what the concerns are. Yes, we're reading the
- 1:08:19paperwork, but we can't guess all of the issues
- 1:08:22that you know from your client. Well, I think
- 1:08:26we want to thank everyone for attending. I hope
- 1:08:29everyone found this useful and helpful. And as
- 1:08:31Robin said, if you have any questions, don't
- 1:08:33hesitate to reach out. And again, thank you to
- 1:08:36the Beverly Hills Bar for giving us this forum.
- 1:08:39Thank you. And thank you for Katie at ADR for
- 1:08:41helping us put together the wonderful slides
- 1:08:43that, trust me, Robin and Judge Gibson, I could
- 1:08:46not have done without her help. So we thank her
- 1:08:48as well. Thank you. Okay, bye -bye.