Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Donald X. Vaccarino
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamer's Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamer's guild. Find out more at grand gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. But which will they choose? My
- 1:00guest this week is a legend in the modern gaming world. The programmer with
- 1:03a love for magic the gathering. He invented one of the most used mechanisms
- 1:07in modern gaming. In his Spielder's jaris winning game Dominion, a game that
- 1:12is as popular now as it's ever been. He went on to win his
- 1:15second Builders Jarus with Kingdom Builder, and He's also designed to nefarious and greed,
- 1:21amongst many others. My guest this week is Donald X Vaccarino. Donald's
- 1:25Welcome to the Cabin. Hello, So we sort of went back and forth
- 1:32when we were arranging this sort of about the concept of the of the podcast.
- 1:37And believe me, the premise is as thin as it's possible to be.
- 1:41But how difficult was it for you to pick five games to take to
- 1:42the cabin? Yeah, I'm just I'm just hopelessly accurate sometimes. And it
- 1:52just seemed like it was clear you didn't really mean the premise the way you
- 1:56said it, And I was stuck assing that I bring the game with the
- 2:05cookies in it so I can eat the cookies in the cabin. See how
- 2:10difficult was it picking these games? Four of them? Three or four of
- 2:17them? Okay, what did I pick? He said? I mean,
- 2:21I had some questions about what would be acceptable to you. I ended up
- 2:24a video game, in an unpublished game because they seemed to fit into this
- 2:32interview of talking about my life as a board game designer, what I had
- 2:38to say about games and rather than like what would I want to play a
- 2:45lot in a cabin? Yeah, that was it. I just had to
- 2:51just had to wrestle with my own doubts about what would be acceptable to you,
- 2:53and in the end I went for it, and anything is acceptable to
- 2:58me, believe me. So so what kind of game are you? Because
- 3:04I wrote a first draft of notes asking you about the states of the modern
- 3:07industry, and you wrote back saying I really don't keep abreast of those sorts
- 3:10of things. I mean, are you a regular gamer? Are you someone
- 3:14who plays just to design? Or what kind of gamer are you? There's
- 3:20this. I've done a bunch of interviews and in the early days I would
- 3:24give the wrong answers to a few questions, and there would be people like
- 3:29in the comments saying, oh, he's the worst person ever, and pragularly
- 3:31refine these to try to be to give the same answer in a clearer way.
- 3:38And so people would say, you know, so do you play other
- 3:42people's games much? And initially I would say no, and you know,
- 3:46he's the worst person ever, And I refined that to the people that I
- 3:53played games with, the friends who want to play games only have so much
- 3:59time to play games, and so I need to mostly spend that time play
- 4:05testing in order to get enough play testing done. And so there are periods
- 4:12where I play a bunch of games that aren't mine because things are slow in
- 4:16the area of what I'm getting play tested. And there are always times when
- 4:24it comes up, for whatever reason, that I play some other game.
- 4:29There's a board game cafe that I sometimes go to and play play games that
- 4:35But but yeah, I mean, I spend a lot of time playing my
- 4:38own games because because the people I play games with only have so much time.
- 4:44So I remember there's there's a British band called Swede, and I remember
- 4:47reading an article with the lead singer in the nineties and he said, I
- 4:50don't listen to other people's music because it interfere or I don't read books either
- 4:56because it interferes with the own purity of my own creation. And I've spoken
- 5:00to Rana Knitzi and he says he really doesn't play other people's games. And
- 5:04both of you are right, and both of you are quite original. Is
- 5:12there this notion that you know if you if you play too many other people's
- 5:16games, it'll interfere with your own creative process. I'm zero worried about that.
- 5:23I guess that's not quite true. I mostly avoid looking at other people's
- 5:30dominion derivative games, both because it won't be much fun and I don't want
- 5:41people accusing me of copying that. Whenever I finally make dominion derivative games myself,
- 5:47and there's not much to worry about there because people just aren't doing the
- 5:55ideas that look good to me to do, so when I get there,
- 6:00it will all be fine. Uh. But yeah, I'm not worried that
- 6:05I'll play some game, and you know, if I play some game and
- 6:10it has some idea that I had in the file, like oh I was
- 6:13going to make that game, then you know that will save me the trouble.
- 6:16I can make some other game. It's fine. Uh, this has
- 6:19totally happened, you know I had. I mean, I know it's happened.
- 6:26Happens to everybody, right, I know. I know. At one
- 6:28point, Ryan Knitzia found out that he designed Quirkle independently. You know,
- 6:33someone told him this is Quirkle. Sorry, brain, brain will catch up
- 6:40not distracted by this quirkle story. Yeah, you know, like I had
- 6:45a big list of of ways to have people make simultaneous decisions and do stuff
- 6:50based on that. And one of the things was that you would pick an
- 6:55action and everybody would do it. And then that was what Puerto Rico did
- 7:00it. And that was fine, right. I didn't think I both didn't
- 7:02think, oh that that premise is just dead now, and you know,
- 7:08I didn't feel like, uh, like it mattered at all. It was
- 7:13fine someone else did it. I talked with Andreas Sayfarth about it briefly and
- 7:17he was like, dude, go for it. But I never did,
- 7:23except one day I made my own version of San Juan, just as a
- 7:26fun little project. So on the subject of dominion, like games, is
- 7:31there is there any sort of small part of you that makes you grind your
- 7:34teeth when you when you when you you see you know, the latest deck
- 7:40builder come out, and it's you know, for all intents and purposes,
- 7:43dominion. I mean, you know, it's great that people got to make
- 7:48games inspired by Demian and sad what they chose to do with this privilege.
- 7:54Uh, there are at this point in the early days there were all these
- 7:58games that were so derivative, and the big less derivative game that was so
- 8:03derivative was Ascension. And I just described Ascension in the initial interview about Dominion.
- 8:11You know, it was a game I chose not to make, and
- 8:18so I wasn't so impressed, though it was like, obviously I should have
- 8:20also made that one, because there are certainly people who prefer it that way.
- 8:26But you know, there are all these games that were just horrible demanders
- 8:28that I don't even want to name. I don't want to give them any
- 8:31airtime. And finally, some people made games that were inspired by Demian,
- 8:37but we're actual new games. I always cite this is years ago, though
- 8:43I always cite a few acres of snow. I was going to say that
- 8:46I think that's the first kind of integrated bold play and tech building. Right
- 8:52Eminent Domain was the other early one, and where it's like it's more derivative
- 8:58of Puerto Rico than Dominion. Really, I mean it is, it is,
- 9:01it is inspired by Dominion, but you know it's its own thing,
- 9:05and that you know, there could have been endless pray to those and that
- 9:07wouldn't have bothered me at all. And you know, it did suck that
- 9:11some people thought they could just make dominion as if, as if all the
- 9:13decisions that I'd made getting to that point, we're just built into the premise
- 9:18of you build a deck, which they so were not, and and call
- 9:26it a new game. And that's just the way it goes. And you
- 9:28know, one thing you can say is supposing somebody makes Cat Dominion and it's
- 9:33just a dominion rip off, but it's cat theme, and there'll be people
- 9:35out there who are like, oh boy, cat Dominion, and you know,
- 9:39there's more of them than there are of me. Ultimately it's good,
- 9:43you know, ultimately help me. Copyright is bad for humanity except to degree
- 9:48that it gets people to publish, and it doesn't need to be anywhere near
- 9:52so generous to get people to publish. So yeah, I don't sleep over
- 9:56that. You know, I don't respect those people making those games, but
- 10:07I'm not going to show you. I'm going to show you my deck building.
- 10:09And so let's let's go back to the beginning. Let's go back to
- 10:13the beginning. Then, So, so where did you grow up and what
- 10:15effect do you think that had on the person you are now? Huh?
- 10:18I grew up in a mixture of Ohio and Oregon with divorced parents. I'm
- 10:26again, I'm hopelessly being accurate. Like what effect did that have? Well,
- 10:31I don't know what effect that had, but I know a couple of
- 10:35things about how how you grow up affects you. And the first is that
- 10:41there's all these ways that it doesn't that you have these personality tests ocean ocean,
- 10:48I think it's called I forget. It's an acronym, and uh,
- 10:52you look at it's all these questions that are trying to define your personality,
- 10:58and you give the tell all these people, and you compare results for siblings
- 11:03and identical twins, and siblings growing up in the same house, and identical
- 11:07twins growing in the same house and growing up in separate houses, and random
- 11:11strangers growing up in the same house due to adoption or growing up in different
- 11:13houses, and the end result is that your personality is about fifty percent genetic
- 11:20and the other fifty percent is unknown. It's not it's it's not. The
- 11:24shared environment growing up in the same house didn't do anything. And obviously this
- 11:28isn't including people who had really extreme bad childhood. It's just you know,
- 11:37ordinary people. And then you can say, well, does this test really
- 11:41evaluate personality? But that's just moot. Like the test is tons of questions
- 11:45that are trying to be about your personality, and your answers to these questions
- 11:48correlate fifty percent with genetics and zero percent with where you grew up. But
- 11:54obviously, so that's part of it, right, All these things about who
- 11:56you are just don't don't care about where you grew up, what country you
- 12:01know, what economics, styles, etcetera, etcetera. But obviously all sorts
- 12:07of things do matter. Both, like we can say, you know,
- 12:11you grow up speaking French and you know that's different, or you you've got
- 12:16piano lessons that you know the piano and you know that's all. What opportunities
- 12:20did you have? But also some of our basic programming is tied to that.
- 12:26And the example I like is that if you show kids around the world
- 12:30pictures of different terrains. There's two terrains everyone especially likes, and the first
- 12:35is Savannah's because we're Savannah monkeys, and the second is wherever they grew up,
- 12:41because if your parents could survive there, probably you can too. And
- 12:46so you know where you grew up determines what kind of terrains you find pretty
- 12:50for example, that is part of who you are. So my long you
- 12:56know, instructive example, and to this is that because that, yeah,
- 13:01I have no idea, and obviously lots of things were unaffected and other things
- 13:05work. So you also a programmer and many game designs I've many game designers
- 13:13I've met have dabbled in this area. Or is this something about the mind
- 13:18of a programmer that leads you to game design. I think there's a lot
- 13:22of math people in game design in particular, not necessarily programming. And I
- 13:31don't know, it depends on your approach, but you know, at a
- 13:35certain point, you know, you you had these questions about the industry and
- 13:41mostly I just don't know. But but I can't say. There's something I
- 13:46was paying attention to, which was games got a lot better in the nineties,
- 13:50and a big thing I think was people trying to figure out how to
- 13:54make games that worked rather than just like simulating something, hoping and all these
- 14:01old games. It's like, well, you simulate something, and then you
- 14:03see, did that turn out to be a game? Did it turn out
- 14:07to be fun? And and eventually people started to work out. Well,
- 14:15Like, if we eliminate a player, what do they do if you had
- 14:18a friend come over to play? Do they go home? It's getting kind
- 14:22of late. They don't want to sit around watching, right, and so
- 14:26all these these things. That's a really good core example, right that you
- 14:30don't really want to eliminate players unless unless the game has a few minutes left
- 14:33and there'll be a movie. They'll be super fun to watch. But you
- 14:39know, people figured this stuff out in the nineties nine. Need to remember
- 14:41what your question was. So some of that is, you know, math
- 14:46and programmer related, right, It's it's definitely good to try to figure out
- 14:54how to make good games, to have this more abstract to approach this uh,
- 15:01this design approach, that's that's uh yeah, it's not really programming exactly,
- 15:11it's design. But you want to be a design person. How helpful
- 15:16is that? And a lot of them are math people. Uh but yeah,
- 15:26I haven't done any studies on this. I'm again I'm a gatting stuck
- 15:28being accurate for you. I don't know, but you're right, there are
- 15:33some there are some math people, some programmers in game design, right,
- 15:37I know Richard Garfield and Ryer Knetia. They're math people. Uh. And
- 15:43so you talk about you talk about the the nineties when games started to get
- 15:50good. What what were the some of those sort of foundational games that really
- 15:54inspired you. Oh, it's not so much like that. Well it is
- 16:00kind of. I mean, so I'm just gonna erase your question and please
- 16:08do so. Uh. You know, I played you know, bad games
- 16:15as a kid, like anybody, you know, whatever was around right.
- 16:18Uh, these you know, monopolies and so forth, and these these old
- 16:23games like chess, which you know, I can go on at length about
- 16:27all the problems with chess. Uh. You know, it compares favorably to
- 16:30Monopoly. Oh you know Monopoly. How's it's it's positives that people miss when
- 16:36they're pointing out how bad it is. But I played these games, and
- 16:41then I got into D and D and I played lots of D and D
- 16:42and and for a bit I considered, you know, what I needed to
- 16:47do for a career was make D and D products. And you know,
- 16:52I made my homemade stuff. No one actually played DND by the rules because
- 16:56they were bad. Uh. But so you know I had them, you
- 17:03know, the rules the way I would have them. But you know,
- 17:06everyone did that as far as far as far as I could see. And
- 17:11and I don't think this really has much to do with my game design career
- 17:17other than that I still like D and D flavored things where it's like a
- 17:25dungeon and you fight monsters and you know, build up your fantasy hero.
- 17:32I'm still into those things. But in terms of game design, it wasn't
- 17:36much of an influence. So I didn't pick it as one of my five
- 17:38games. Like it was a huge game in my life for several years,
- 17:41you know, for when I was a teenager and didn't make the five was
- 17:48it was a cool idea in its day. And uh, you know,
- 17:52I made a few games in my youth that tended to be based on existing
- 18:00games, like here's what I would do with that, Here's here's what I
- 18:03would do with risk. And I had friends who were really into trivia games.
- 18:08So I made a trivia game using existing trivia questions, but changing the
- 18:14framework to be something cooler. And uh, and what really changed things was
- 18:19Magic. I started playing Magic, and it didn't just introduce me to Magic,
- 18:26it introduced me to you know, a community of gamers who were getting
- 18:30the German games that had the rules translated and printed out on a sheet of
- 18:36paper, you know, because the game hadn't been published in English, and
- 18:41so I got to I got to play those games due to magic. And
- 18:48you know, the person I was initially really impressed with was was Ryer Kenisia.
- 18:52And I mean he'd done a zillion games, and we have much different
- 18:56game design philosophies. I would guess, Uh, I am so hardcore into
- 19:03variety and he is not, Like he has made so many games that will
- 19:10play the same every time, where the variety you get is like the variety
- 19:15of a of a normal deck of playing cards, where it's not that there's
- 19:19no variety, it's not that there's no new experience. But you know,
- 19:23I'm just ramping that up in my game, giving you as much new experience
- 19:27as I can. And he's like, you know, honing it down,
- 19:33narrowing it down to the one experience that was especially good. He said,
- 19:37So anyway, yes, to try to answer your question, those were some
- 19:41of the games the ones and I made. I made a homemade expansion for
- 19:48Medici that you know, Donald X is it. I always think someday I'll
- 19:53just make that game. But you know, a bidding game that it's just
- 19:59it's just Medici with the deck of twist cards like a new Phraous. So
- 20:02you turn over two cards at the start of the game, and they just
- 20:04change the rules somehow. So it's like this game. Every week you remove
- 20:10your token. Every day. Every day you remove your token from the grain
- 20:14pyramid, and the boats hold an extra card or whatever. It'll be two
- 20:21rules, and then you try to evaluate or how does that change things?
- 20:25Right? How what is grain worth now that you don't get to preserve your
- 20:27progress? It's still worth something and that's it. And you know, a
- 20:36few times I've thought, I need to find out who publishes Medici and see
- 20:40if they want this Medici expansion. But you know, probably no one is
- 20:44really buying Medici this many years later, with so many zillions of games,
- 20:51and I could just make my own bidding game. And it's just never it's
- 20:56never been near the top of the list of projects to do. But anyway,
- 21:02that was me just randomly naming Medici as an example. But yeah,
- 21:07especially liked Clash of Gladiators. I don't know what year that is. It's
- 21:11it may not even be nineties, it is. I know, it's like
- 21:14long out of print at this point. It's a you draft teams of gladiators
- 21:21and they affect and then you roll dice, and the gladiers affect how your
- 21:25dice workd Uh. It's you know, it's a pretty cool game that,
- 21:30as far as I know, is utterly obscure by Kenia. And of course
- 21:36I played all these Richard Garfield games, you know, for for a bit
- 21:40he was putting out new trading card games, and then he got some other
- 21:44published, filthy rich and Roborelli. Ah. But I mean I played a
- 21:51lot of stuff. I mean I played a lot of bad stuff too.
- 21:53I played, you know, whatever showed up, whatever people brought. I
- 21:59don't know. I don't know that I have the most thorough knowledge of what
- 22:03games there are, but I have some knowledge. I don't know why I
- 22:10had to say that. Where are we? You say something? I will?
- 22:14So your first game, then is you've already mentioned it. That's magic,
- 22:17the gathering. So magic seems as healthy as health, you go.
- 22:25I started playing Magic in nineteen eighty four. I found out about it from
- 22:30Games magazine, and uh, you know, the big thing it had was
- 22:38interacting rules on cards. I mean, the fact that you you you got
- 22:44to customize your experience. Was very cool. But of course you know you
- 22:51do that in D and D also and the you know, it's not that
- 23:00it was the first game with interacting rules on cards. You know, I
- 23:03know Richard Garfield's SIT's Cosmic Encounter and its War as inspirational games. Ah,
- 23:12and I hadn't even I hadn't even needed to see it to have the cosmic
- 23:18power idea. I know we always call these cosmic powers now because of cosmic
- 23:22gutter. But you know, I'd made a game where you had cosmic powers.
- 23:26Uh, you know, you had rules that applied just to you from
- 23:33you know, years earlier. But I hadn't hit that point. And I'd
- 23:37made cards that had rules on them and they could potentially interact, but I
- 23:41hadn't hit that point of seeing, oh they could really interact, like that
- 23:45could be The whole idea is that you were going to have cards that interacted
- 23:48in all these ways, and uh, you know, go nuts getting getting
- 23:56your variety of experiences from that. And and also it's like, well,
- 24:04I don't know how much I want to credit that to magic, but certainly
- 24:07part of it this idea of games where the rules wouldn't always be the same.
- 24:14And this was a thing I really focused on early in in my game
- 24:18designer days. Then in the mid nineties, I was trying to figure out
- 24:22all these ways that that a game could have the rules vary, and it
- 24:27turned out like you couldn't make the players come up with them, like some
- 24:32players would just be really bad at that, and and generating them out of
- 24:37components, like you combine two halves of a role really mystified lots of people.
- 24:42It was just over the top complex. You really just want a card
- 24:45with a rule on it, which was fine because I get to make those
- 24:48cards. And then there's like how often do you change the rules? And
- 24:53I had games where the rules changed every turn? Right, Like there was
- 24:59one game, the Rules Dude's Game, which had two checkerboards and one board
- 25:07had pawns that were and every square was a rule, and the other board
- 25:14was just a checkerboard with some pieces, and the where the pawns were on
- 25:18the one board determined what the rules were on the other board. And this
- 25:23is like, you know, a ludicrous game, Like it may sound cool,
- 25:29but you do not want to struggle through playing this. And this was
- 25:33the thing that that when you're when your rules changed constantly, you're just playing
- 25:37the game of how the rules change, and you're not actually playing the game
- 25:42that the rules generated. You know, that game, it's just nothing,
- 25:47you know, for for competing here on the game of changing the rules.
- 25:52And so you really don't want the rules to change that drastically that often you
- 25:57don't need them to just you know, A A good way to go is
- 26:00to just have the rules change once at the very start, which I do
- 26:04for for things like nefarious and well yeah and dominion right and dominion. You
- 26:14have the set of rules at the start on all the cards, and that's
- 26:17it. That's this game. Uh. And you can you can change the
- 26:21rules during the game if you only do it a little, which is different
- 26:25from just like we play a card that gives us an ability, but you
- 26:27know, more drastically changing how everything works for everybody. Anyway, a little
- 26:32speech on that so magic, it was it was key for forgetting me to
- 26:38think, you know, and it was fun. It was like, uh,
- 26:42you know, I could be I could be making these games with interacting
- 26:45rules on cards and this could be amazing, and I get really into this
- 26:48hole. Yeah, how do I how do I best make games that will
- 26:52you know, where the rules will wildly change and and at the same time,
- 26:57you know, I met all these people due to going to cafes to
- 27:00play Magic and they had the German board games. Ah. And you know,
- 27:08other than that, I think Magic hasn't It hasn't loomed over my game
- 27:15design like Magic has. It has huge flaws and it has Magic has so
- 27:22many interacting rules on cards that it makes you really sit down and try to
- 27:26figure out how do we possibly make a game cope with this? And I
- 27:33put a lot of work into that for my own games, and it's all
- 27:36applicable to Magic, but it's just the general problem. It's like the computer
- 27:40the computer programming problem of rules text, where yeah, how how do you
- 27:47phrase things that people will understand it? And how do you deal with with
- 27:52conflicting rules and how do you make that clear? And there's a lot of
- 27:56work you can put into that. And No, Magic wasn't hugely inspirational in
- 28:00terms of then it was hugely inspirational to me, you know, pursuing game
- 28:04design as a career, like I'm going to be a game designer. Uh,
- 28:10you know, before that, I had thought I wanted to make video
- 28:11games. I mean I did, I mean I wanted to make video games,
- 28:15but uh, board games are there. I'm stumbling over how I could
- 28:30say this. I'm happy to be confined to board games. There are some
- 28:37things that you can't do so easily or can't do it all. But the
- 28:41video games are mired down in gigantic costs and giant teams of people, and
- 28:47maybe your project never happened. As I know, Richard Garfield learned the hard
- 28:52way, and the board game you can, you know, in the case
- 29:00of Dominion, you know, you can type up some cards on Saturday and
- 29:04be cutting and sleeving them Sunday and try the game out on Monday. Ah.
- 29:11It's really a nice level. But anyway, you know, I yeah,
- 29:15I thought I would make video games, but I was a computer programmer,
- 29:18not making video games. And then with Magic, I thought, okay,
- 29:22I want to do this. I want to I want to make board
- 29:25games and card games with rules on them. And at the same time I
- 29:32encountered, well, I want I want to say one more thing about about
- 29:34Magic, which was that there's like a card frame, and in the card
- 29:41frame it says like this card is a creature dash Goblin and that was also
- 29:48influential on the paid A Milligue games that have this here these card types on
- 29:56the card somewhere that sometimes so that you can refer to those types for different
- 30:02classes of abilities. Sometimes it's simpler, right, like in some games,
- 30:07you know, every card in this deck is a building, and we just
- 30:08it's just the building deck and you don't need to put the word building on
- 30:11it. But where was that going from? This magic? So so at
- 30:18the same time that I discovered magic, I also read a book on game
- 30:25theory. It was Prisoners Dilemma by Will Impound Them and it's about half biography
- 30:33of von Neumann and others and half about game theory. And game theory was
- 30:41not something that really involved it was really involved with board games. You know,
- 30:48the classic game three thing is like the prisoners dilemma, and there's all
- 30:51these similar dilemmas like chicken, and they're not about you know, the board
- 30:56games weren't weren't that right? And von Neuman, you know, was like,
- 31:03Chess isn't a game, it's a form of computation. And uh,
- 31:07but so I thought, here's the thing I could do. I'll make board
- 31:11games that have game theory and one of my earliest games at this point not
- 31:17you know, so post magic, you know, the guy pursuing game design
- 31:22for a career though though it still wouldn't happen for another decade or so.
- 31:30One of my first games was was was a whole game of dilemmas where you
- 31:34built a payout grid of eight cards. It was Pirates Dilemma. You had
- 31:40eight cards in a grid and in every you know, four grid spots.
- 31:42In every spot there's a card for you and a card for your opponent,
- 31:45and one of you picks the row and one of you picks the column,
- 31:48and then those two cards are what happens to you. And that premise,
- 31:52you know, still sounds cool. It just has the problem of every turn
- 31:56redate cards and explain ending these payoff grids to people is not grade either.
- 32:02But this was an early an early inspiration too then was you know, here's
- 32:08the direction I can go to make some cool new games. And that is
- 32:12my story as of nineteen ninety four. I want to talk now about your
- 32:16design. So you spoke about designing games and not really having a career as
- 32:23a designer for ten years. What were you doing in those ten years?
- 32:30That enabled you to become a professional. So yeah, I mean I designed
- 32:34a few games in my youth, which is to say, prior to nineteen
- 32:37ninety four, and then in the and then of course I showed Dominion to
- 32:45Rio Grande in two thousand and six, and I was published in two thousand
- 32:47and eight. And in the late nineties I just cranked out games. I
- 32:57made dozens of games, and you know, gradually figured out how how to
- 33:07do them, how to make the games the way I liked them. And
- 33:10then I also had some trips up to Wizards of the Coasts and got to
- 33:16play my games with Richard Garfield and the other current magic people. And eventually
- 33:25in the early aughts there was a period where I didn't design so many games,
- 33:30and I wrote some screenplays, and then then I got back into it
- 33:40in two thousand and three and made it, you know, made several games,
- 33:45not at the pace that I had in the nineties, but eventually making
- 33:50Dominion in two thousand and six, and then thinking well, if any of
- 33:52these can get published, this one can, and so so I never really
- 33:57tried to get games published, except that I showed games to Wizards the Coast
- 34:02and they were interested in Monster Factory and then that died somehow, And so
- 34:12you know, you were designing these games, you were showing them towards to
- 34:15the coast, and you know, I write and I act and I'm I'm
- 34:21riddled on a daily basis with the feeling that I'm that I'm awful, and
- 34:25it might just be that I'm awful. But I mean, during that during
- 34:30that time, did you have any moments of existential dreads regarding your design?
- 34:35Yeah? I mean you you have this question here in this outline, when
- 34:37did you realize you had a talent for design? And you know my first
- 34:42thought as well. You know, I was reading this outline for an interview
- 34:45I was going to do where it said when did you realize you had a
- 34:47talent for design? And I thought, oh my, I think I might
- 34:55the For me, the biggest hurdle for any game is for it to get
- 35:01to the point where I have enough faith in the idea to actually make the
- 35:06prototype and test it. And I've gotten I've gotten really good at half assing
- 35:09things, at making the minimal prototype that will tell me anything to try to
- 35:19get me to do the rest of the work so that we can really be
- 35:22playing the game. But but yeah, you know, the idea will sit
- 35:27in the file. The idea for for dominion sat in the file. Uh
- 35:32it was, It was at least a year old. I could look it
- 35:35up. But you know it's sat in the file. This sounds good and
- 35:40you know, waiting for me to talk myself into it. Yeah, it's
- 35:51there's also like you, I mean, when you play the game with your
- 35:55friends, you'll immediately have any idea if if they like it, even if
- 36:00they're tight lipped about it. And you know, there's I've managed to accumulate
- 36:05some people who will be outspoken and how much they didn't like it. But
- 36:09there are also people who who are just too nice and will never tell you,
- 36:13but you'll you'll get an idea at least at some point that they would
- 36:17rather play something else. But when you are played just in the game,
- 36:23of course, it's always in the company of people who have the maximum amount
- 36:30of experience with the game, and you know everyone is trying it and really
- 36:35giving it a chance, and then we know something about it. And there's
- 36:38always the people who have played the game the most right there at the table,
- 36:44and so you can really fail to account for how will this gameplay then
- 36:50when no one has played it before, in the final game, you know,
- 36:55the game comes out and you're not sitting at the table, and there's
- 37:00these things where it'll be like, you know, it was really important to
- 37:05be pursuing strategy, to actually be caring about the future, but maybe nobody
- 37:08at the table did that, and then everyone thought that was stupid. There
- 37:14was no strategy to it. And so sometimes you need to really push that
- 37:17stuff in people's faces, you know, really make it clear. And I've
- 37:22made this mistake, one of these one of a few mistakes that I've tried
- 37:28to learn from of making things too subtle. And in fact, both Dominion
- 37:31and king the Builder have an element of subtlety to them that makes them worse
- 37:37for some people that they're not playing with an expert. And you can have
- 37:43a table of people playing Dominion for the first time, and maybe they played
- 37:47the first game and they buy random cards and they have fun. In the
- 37:50second game, someone just buys money and wins, and they're like, oh,
- 37:52this game is stupid. You just buy money, and there isn't a
- 37:54good player at the table to show them no. That just loses. And
- 38:00there's a similar thing with Kingdom Builder. Where like people can blow it really
- 38:06badly on their first turns, not care at all about what terrains are adjacent
- 38:10to, and just be stuck right, not be able to jump to other
- 38:14areas of the board due to the specific rules for kingom Builder, which are
- 38:17admitted from this conversation. And then they'll think, oh, that was stupid.
- 38:22I just you know, I turned over a card and it said for
- 38:25us, and I put three pieces on for us, and there was really
- 38:28no choice. And of course if you had a good player then you would
- 38:31find out that there was more to it. But you know, it's just
- 38:35a little too subtle, and those it didn't sink those games. But it's
- 38:39a it's a it was a it was a bad thing for Temporum that people
- 38:44didn't didn't quite see to the point that they would if if they were playing
- 38:50with somebody who knew the game. And yes, and this was all aproposa
- 38:55what it was sells doubt, self doubt, yes, so yeah, you
- 39:04can also you know, blow it and not realize you should be doubting yourself
- 39:08enough too. But but yeah, I'm constantly worried that I think the idea
- 39:16won't be good enough. And there's no point trying it, and it sits
- 39:21in the file and every every at any given point, there's all the ideas
- 39:25that may be amazing games that are struggling to convince me that they're good enough
- 39:30to actually try. And if you ever feel like that, you need to
- 39:32immediately get it, get it done, get the prototype made before you change
- 39:37your mind to decide no, because if you actually play the prototype, you
- 39:39learn so much more than just staring at the idea. It's so helpful,
- 39:45and it's still it's still can be very hard to get to that stage.
- 39:49And once the game is working, like I make a prototype and we played
- 39:52and oh that was fun, then it's no trouble at all. Then it's
- 39:57a breeze working on the game and it's just this card was overpowered and maybe
- 40:01we could fix this tracking somehow, and uh, you know, you you
- 40:07accumulate things that make the game better. And the next struggle really is getting
- 40:14people to stop playing and move on to the next game, right, because
- 40:17this game is working, we all like it, and the next game will
- 40:23not. You know, it may it may utterly fail, or it will
- 40:27not be refined. But yeah, you know, at the very beginning is
- 40:32is very difficult. And that was the thing that I had in the nineties
- 40:37that I was much better at just saying here's a thing, let's try this,
- 40:42and not worrying about you know, how much it would probably stuck and
- 40:46and and does success improve self doubt? Or is there a pressure? You
- 40:51know, you design dominion, it's a it's a it's it's it's game to
- 40:55nine. Success just isn't like that. It's uh. You know, I
- 41:00tell people I'm a board game designer and I write as a hobby, but
- 41:04really I'm a board game designers designers a hobby too, and I collect world
- 41:07He's on demean as a job. You know, most games sell no copies.
- 41:14That you don't make enough money to pay for going to a convention to
- 41:16promote the game, is the way I like to put it. But it's
- 41:22also true. And you know, I only have the one successful game.
- 41:30Kingdom Builder, made some money when it came out. It won this Field
- 41:34is yards and that sells you a pile of games in Germany that Christmas.
- 41:39But it doesn't it doesn't make anywhere near enough money to live on. It's
- 41:46you know, it's very minor at this point, and all the other games
- 41:51are behind that, right, I think nefarious is third. And you know,
- 41:55it did nice business for a random board game, because mostly they don't
- 42:00all at all. So you know, it's like, yeah, you know,
- 42:02you count yourself as a success if you sold ten thousand copies and if
- 42:07you got a dollar per copy, that's ten thousand dollars. And I don't
- 42:10know where you live, but it's not enough. And you know, and
- 42:16a lot of work went into that, right, months the month of work
- 42:20went into that game. Ah, so yeah, you know, so it's
- 42:24not like uh yeah, and the publishers, the publishers see this too.
- 42:30And a key thing to learn at some point was that the publishers all got
- 42:35into it because they like games. They're you know, they could be pursuing
- 42:39some better investment, and the games are low risk, they're cheap, but
- 42:47they're also you know, unlikely to succeed, and so, uh, you
- 42:54know, the publishers. When Dominion came out, publishers weren't just like,
- 42:58oh, we need to publish it, do all the game. Maybe that
- 43:00game will also be a hit. They you know, couldn't be bothered to
- 43:05even look at them. And it took winning this Field of Ars twice for
- 43:07people to say, Okay, we can try our game. Maybe we also
- 43:13want to publish something that someone might buy in addition to you know whatever,
- 43:16they really want to publish what they got into the business for. Ah.
- 43:23So yeah, and so you were asking about being successful versus versus as opposed
- 43:30to how the BLI you're asking about being successful and how that relates to self
- 43:38doubt. And I guess the thing is, at this point, I'm pretty
- 43:43confident in demeaning expansions. Doing it was successful enough, and I've gotten good
- 43:49at making the expansions. When I make a new demeaning expansion, you know,
- 43:52I don't know if it will be like the best received one or what,
- 43:55but I think there will be a lot of people who like this.
- 44:00And for anything else that's like, you know, well, you know we
- 44:02liked it, but that doesn't that doesn't tell you anything really, Right,
- 44:07We had a blast plate to Think tim Form and it didn't sell. And
- 44:09you know, Gallet of Fools is out of print, and I played to
- 44:12at that with the with the publisher, right, he was right there having
- 44:16input into the game the whole time, and we had a lot of fun
- 44:21played to Think Gallet of Fools and it fell victim to a different pitfall,
- 44:25which is like people would play Galet of Fools as a bidding game where you
- 44:31you there are a set of hero weapon pairs and you bid by putting boasts
- 44:37on them, like you know, one arm tied behind my back or without
- 44:40breakfast, and uh, you know, if you want it, you can
- 44:46take a hero from somebody else by putting an additional boast on it, and
- 44:52eventually someone will take the worst hero with no boasts and uh, and then
- 44:55we fight through a dungeon and see who survives the longest. And people played
- 45:01this game and didn't do the boasting, they didn't do the bidding. They
- 45:05were just like, well, let's just see how it goes, right,
- 45:07we don't know what things are worth. We'll just see. And that's like
- 45:09playing Medici and not bidding. Just take stuff on our boats and then see
- 45:15see how this goes. And no one would ever think of doing that,
- 45:17Like, clearly you're not playing the game if you don't bid in Medici.
- 45:21But people actually did that in gall out of Holes. They just didn't bid,
- 45:23and then was like there was no game there because we didn't play it,
- 45:28and it was a lesson in how well and how you have to meet
- 45:32expectations somewhat in that. There were people who like bidding games and there's people
- 45:37who like dungeon crawls, and probably I shouldn't have combined those things, you
- 45:40know, rolling lots of dice and you know, the I could have used
- 45:45the premise to make a bidding game that was focused on the kinds of things
- 45:49people do in bidding games, that was you know, an economic game.
- 45:52So that so it was clear, you know, obviously we're supposed to do
- 45:57this bidding not you know, you could think, oh, we'll just see
- 46:00how the Dundeon crawl goes. But but you know, I had this good
- 46:06flavor, you know, I'll beat you with one art track by my back
- 46:10and ran with it. And now you have it callt of wool. Now
- 46:15I've talked about that though. This was all self doubt, So yeah,
- 46:22I don't Yeah, I still have plenty of self doubt. I have,
- 46:27you know, all the ideas that don't seem good enough to and you know
- 46:30the ones that are at the top of the list that are hoping I do
- 46:32them. So your next game, then is the one you're known for,
- 46:37and that's dominion. So you know, you talked to my processing games and
- 46:44enjoying them. Was there any point when you were doing Dominion that you thought,
- 46:47A, this is totally original and B this is gonna be successful.
- 46:55Well, at the very beginning, I certainly thought it was original. I
- 47:00certainly thought there was nothing like that. But that was something that I heavily
- 47:04pursued for years that I still pursue right that it. You know, there
- 47:09were all the games that I played and I was trying to make games that
- 47:13didn't exist that and I made a few games that just so didn't exist.
- 47:17You know. One of one of the games that one of the real standouts
- 47:22for me was a game called Pirates Quandry, which is unpublished, and I
- 47:25showed it to several publishers who liked it that didn't want to publish it,
- 47:29and they were totally right, like, no one would buy this game.
- 47:32It could have come out long enough ago that it meant something, but you
- 47:37know, like it was a drafting game wherever it turn you drafted a card,
- 47:40and that was from nineteen ninety eight, so that was not a thing.
- 47:45And it was the style of draft was a cake draft where you split
- 47:50stuff into two piles and there was nothing like that, and it two people
- 47:55won the game. You know, it was a competitive game that you play
- 48:00with three or more players and two people win, and that certainly seemed novel.
- 48:05And it was just this big pile of like, there's nothing like this.
- 48:08And of course, you know you can only maximize one variable. This
- 48:12is a big, a big life lesson from Donald X. You know,
- 48:15it's the which, you know, which is taller, the tallest mountain or
- 48:19the mountain with the longest name. It could be a tie, otherwise the
- 48:22tallest mountain is taller, and that's just seems trivial. But this comes up
- 48:27endlessly in ways that are more subtle, and it comes up endlessly in game
- 48:31design, where it's like, you know, someone is someone is right as
- 48:36we speak doing the layout for a game that will probably come out next year,
- 48:39and you know, the which will look prettiest, the prettiest thing,
- 48:46or the most functional thing, and which will be more functional the most functional
- 48:51thing that the prettiest thing. You know, they're they're just opposed, right,
- 48:54the getting the best functionality out of the cards will be different for making
- 49:00them look as good as they can look. And you have to decide one
- 49:02way or the other, and of course I lean heavily towards having them be
- 49:06better functionally. Yeah. So, so originality doesn't doesn't just mean you know,
- 49:12anyone likes your game or that's successful or anything. Right, It's it's
- 49:15it's not really your goal. Your goal is to have fun games or successful
- 49:22games, which is different of course, but uh so pursuing originality it you
- 49:28know, I'm not sure it even correlates, but it is fun. I
- 49:32do like it. I like to pursue originality. And so so I've made,
- 49:37you know, a typical game of mine. It's certainly trying to carve
- 49:39out its niche. That's, you know, explore its new territory and not
- 49:44just be something that you could play already. But but I don't. I
- 49:50don't confuse that with like a recipe for success. Uh, It's just something
- 49:54I like to do. So I thought, I thought, for sure Deminian
- 50:00with plenty original h and you know after you know, when when we initially
- 50:07played it, uh, you know, I had a Magic night and a
- 50:12Dominion and a game night, and they both turned into demean Night. And
- 50:17then we got an extra nights of just playing Dominion, and I made a
- 50:22couple of new games and no one would play them. And it was clear,
- 50:24you know, this was a good game and that and that. You
- 50:29know, I wasn't convinced I could even get it published, but that if
- 50:31somebody published it, I was confident there would be a shelf of Dominion products
- 50:37at the board game stores. Now I didn't anticipate that there would be another
- 50:42shelf of Dominion revative products, but yeah, I mean yeah, I wasn't
- 50:49convinced I could even get it published, but I certainly thought it would be
- 50:51successful. But I also thought Monster of actually would be successful. And it
- 50:53just died. I mean it, you know, it sells a trickle of
- 50:58copies. It's another another classic of the modern hobby. Came out the year
- 51:04the Dominion didn't that was Pandemic And speaking to matt Leecockey told me that it
- 51:07was a slow burn. It didn't happen straight away. How was it with
- 51:12Dominion did it? Did it charge out of the gates? You know?
- 51:15Pandemic? Pandemic lost every award to demean possibly possibly Pandemic one Game of the
- 51:22Year in Austria, because I know that Mean didn't win that one. But
- 51:27this is the thing I always say, it's you know, uh, somebody
- 51:30will feel the need to tell me. You know, I don't like Dominion
- 51:34and so that's okay, it's not for everyone here. Didn't win Game of
- 51:36the Year in Austria. Uh it's uh so so pandemic. You know,
- 51:42Pandemic must have been sad, you know, award after award did and in
- 51:50these days, pandemic sells better. You know, you go on you go
- 51:52on Amazon. I don't I don't have actual numbers, but you go on
- 51:55Amazon, you'll hit Paneic before you hit Dominion. Uh. I haven't been
- 52:00recently, but you know anytime I've checked, and Dominion of course, since
- 52:07it won the spield as yours, that sells you this heap of copies that
- 52:12Christmas in Germany. That is the thing. That's that's what's special about this
- 52:16award. It's like there's all these awards you can you can you can win
- 52:22that don't really mean anything. Like you know, the publishers do not associate
- 52:29these these awards with selling more copies. Like sure, it's nice to win
- 52:32the award, who knows, you know, maybe it will sell more copies,
- 52:37but it won't sell more copies to a degree that matters. That at
- 52:42least, Like, I don't know how true that is today, and I
- 52:44don't know, I don't know if there's some other award that matters now.
- 52:47But the perception at the time was that the only award that mattered was the
- 52:51spield to Yars, and that award would sell you two or three hundred thousand
- 52:53copies immediately just that Christmas in Germany. And so Dominian did that and Kimbuilder
- 53:01did it. Uh. And but like I'm trying to evaluate this, like
- 53:09what was this curve of success for Dominion? Like from my perspective, it's
- 53:16the number, the amount of money that came in from Dominan. It's just
- 53:21a number and a computer somewhere. Like the effect on my life from that
- 53:25point onward didn't very Like I get to be this guy who you know,
- 53:34as I say, there's no clock in my bedroom. H here I am,
- 53:38It's Thursday and one pm. Do this interview. Uh, it's a
- 53:45it's a it's an easy life and a dream job, you know, making
- 53:49board games that for the most part won't sell and that will be okay because
- 53:53I've got Domion. But so like, in terms of yeah, how that
- 53:59number of very like I don't even remember so much. It went up for
- 54:02a while, and then it went down, and then the pandemic hit and
- 54:07it went back up. The pandemic was very good for business, especially online,
- 54:14which had made no money prior to that, and it's going back down
- 54:20again. That's the secret course of things for Dominion. But like, there
- 54:29were a bunch of there are a bunch of interviews right away, and those
- 54:32trickled out. It wasn't like people, I mean, yeah, people like
- 54:38you showing up to interview me are rare at this point. H yeah,
- 54:43I don't know. But but dominion wasn't Dominion wasn't a piric victory though it
- 54:47was. It was a genuine victory in your eyes. You know, I
- 54:52should have showed games to people earlier. You know, my big board gaming
- 54:57regret is that, you know, my my first game of Every Turn You
- 55:01Draft a Card was from nineteen ninety eight, and when Seven Wonders was announced,
- 55:08I had a drafting game at one publisher not being played that I switched
- 55:12to another publisher who didn't play it. And by the time Greed was published,
- 55:16there had already been a wave of Seven Wonders relative games, and it
- 55:20was just some other drafting game, And I feel like I could have been
- 55:22the drafting guy too, Like I could have had two things. Wow,
- 55:25he's the deck of one guy. I am the drafting guy. But my
- 55:28games just didn't come out. And part of that was that I didn't show
- 55:31games to publishers until until not just Dominion, until Dominion, right, Deminian
- 55:38was aside from this Wizards of the Coast, who which wasn't going anywhere the
- 55:45the I showed games to Rio Grande and and one other publisher at that same
- 55:52convention because they were there, but they didn't so much take me seriously.
- 55:57And I showed ten games Rio Grande and he took two of them. And
- 56:04then I thought, I'll wait until Dominions out so that I'm somebody to start
- 56:09showing these games off the publishers. And I did, and I got some
- 56:13games published. But I could have been trying to get games published at a
- 56:16variety of publishers in the nineties. And some of the games that did get
- 56:21published were from the nineties. You know, pen at Parata is from like
- 56:28ninety five or so, and so is Monster Factory, and Nefarius is ninety
- 56:35eight ninety nine and something something something, So yeah, it was a huge
- 56:42mistake to not try to get games published earlier. I don't know what path
- 56:45that leads me on. You know, I want the path to include making
- 56:47dominion at some point. But so so I want to move on now briefly
- 56:53to talk about your spielder, Jenres. I was just at the award ceremony
- 56:58speaking to the people who won, and they were they were German speaking designers,
- 57:02and their reaction was was disbelief and incredible joy. I mean, how
- 57:07does it feel for you to win it? Was it an impact on you
- 57:14or was it simply the you know this is going to be Yeah, I
- 57:19mean it was good. I like, witty a word, this is the
- 57:24important one. So it was especially nice to win that one. Like I
- 57:29said, you know, the instant respect in the industry kind of waited for
- 57:37King the Builder then I was somebody and I don't know why that is,
- 57:44you know, I have my theory that it's it's the publishers, you know,
- 57:47got into game publishing because they liked games, and so they didn't just
- 57:52want a game because some particular guy made it. H but you know,
- 57:59the being able to collect royalties from witting for a living was fantastic and the
- 58:07spield dis yar certainly factors in, like I don't know the path, like
- 58:10if dominion has its slow burned or what, I don't know how it goes
- 58:14right it It had immediately a lot of success, which you know, included
- 58:19that I feel like I had something else to say about this, you know,
- 58:27the spield dis yars changed as a result of dominion. I think they've
- 58:30said this flat out right. This isn't speculation. That they decided that dominion
- 58:36was heavier than they wanted and so they created the new award, the Kennish
- 58:40field. Is that the one yea in order to in order to you know,
- 58:49award a game like to Meinian, but not have it to be that
- 58:52all the families had it. And I mean, I'm you know, I'm
- 58:58glad they hadn't made the change yet because you still want to win the actual
- 59:01s fields of yards. So I got lucky there being being the cause of
- 59:09the change instead of after it. Oh no, you know there's a lot
- 59:15of when you when you do creative stuff for a living, and I guess
- 59:20you do also, so it will be sympathetic. There's all this gate keeping
- 59:25U and it's a bummer when you're the creative guy. It feels like,
- 59:32you know, can't this just go out and see if people like it?
- 59:36I know Frank Zappa had some speech about this where at some point in the
- 59:40industry he felt like they were just putting out records to see, you know,
- 59:45well, let's try to see if someone buys this. And at some
- 59:47point they closed that down and they were like, no, no, you
- 59:52know, this isn't what the kids will like. We need to we need
- 59:54to rain that all in h and so, yeah, it is a it
- 1:00:00is a bummer when you know I have games, you know, my my
- 1:00:04most popular unpublished game for years, you know, got rejected by a pile
- 1:00:08of publishers, and at some point it stopped feeling like I need to keep
- 1:00:13sending it to them. And you know, maybe they were right and no
- 1:00:16one would have bought it, but everyone has always a maze when they play
- 1:00:22it, and it is a you know, it's never made me feel like
- 1:00:29I want to get into self publishing. That just sounds awful, Like I
- 1:00:34don't want that to be a job, right, I want my job to
- 1:00:37just be the fun part, please, And it's not so bad in the
- 1:00:40end. If they don't publish the cool game. I can play it with
- 1:00:45my friends, and you know, it's true, it probably would have died
- 1:00:49anyway, because they mostly do. But there is there is a feeling in
- 1:00:53Germany. I live in Berlin and I play with German gamers. There is
- 1:00:58a feeling that once you win the Spield Jrs you're part of the German canon.
- 1:01:04Do you sense that or was that a completely alien concept? Like I
- 1:01:10am zero famous. And the anecdote that really illustrates this is I've been in
- 1:01:16a game store where people were showing up to playboard game and had somebody holding
- 1:01:23a copy of Dominion be introduced to me. I'm Donald X and then say,
- 1:01:30so we were going to go play Dominion. If you played, would
- 1:01:32you like to join us? That's how famous I am. But Germans well,
- 1:01:43no, oh, Donald X. You know, for when there's a
- 1:01:46random German person at the game store, they're you know, they're they're you
- 1:01:51know, their eyebrows raised like I know who that guy is. So yeah,
- 1:01:54I'm a very minor celebrity in Germany. You know tested this. I
- 1:02:00haven't gone to a restaurant in Germany and said I've done all that I can
- 1:02:05guarantee you'll get a free meal in any restaurant you go to. In this
- 1:02:07kind, it's years later too, so at that point they've got to have
- 1:02:13forgotten. It's like, oh, like you know, at the fields of
- 1:02:16yards as fields of yards at Essen. At Essen. I went to Essen
- 1:02:22one year and they the Altenburger, the the current German publisher of Dominion.
- 1:02:34It was Allenburger though at the time. At the time they were the printer,
- 1:02:37and they wanted me to do a some answer some questions from fans.
- 1:02:45And it was a tricky thing because they figured the fans wouldn't speak English and
- 1:02:49I only spoke English, and so they had like my face and then somebody
- 1:02:54did the translations and oh, this wasn't this wasn't the year I went to
- 1:03:00right, this was some other year they wanted to do this, and so
- 1:03:02I was phoned in. But anyway, so the people ask questions of the
- 1:03:09Dominion guy, and the most common question was like, did I have other
- 1:03:15games? And I had already won a build as yours or Kingdom other So
- 1:03:22I'm very happy to have Grand Games Guild come on to five g f D
- 1:03:25as a new sponsor. Now Mark is a super nice guy, but that's
- 1:03:30not important to you people listening to this, whether he's nice or not.
- 1:03:34What you need to know is that Grand Games Guild make absolutely fabulous games.
- 1:03:38The Artemis Project is a great euro But the game I really want to talk
- 1:03:43about this episode is Endangered. Endangered is one of those new raft of games
- 1:03:51coming out that is dealing with the main crisis facing humanity at the moment,
- 1:03:58which is environmental desires. And your role in Endangered is to try and save
- 1:04:03endangered animals. And I'm not so fascinating about this game is it's mostly a
- 1:04:10game of lobbying, political lobbying, trying to convince governments around the world to
- 1:04:15agree to your plan so you can save the tigers or the otters or the
- 1:04:19pounders. And it's a really nice, tight, simple and deep co op
- 1:04:27game. I've played this one a lot. I have it on my shelf.
- 1:04:30It's not going anywhere. And the great thing about Grand Gamers Guild is
- 1:04:34they always have really good production and you've got screen printed me pals and all
- 1:04:39of that sort of stuff, but it's not over the top. I mean,
- 1:04:42it would be ironic for an environmentally themed game to be filled with all
- 1:04:45the kinds of dildos and do dads that you get in these outrageous productions.
- 1:04:51It's not a game that's hugely expensive, and it's really interesting and it asks
- 1:04:58questions about very fascinating contemporary issues. So thank you to Grand game As Guild
- 1:05:03for sponsoring this episode of five g Ford And if you're interested and endangered or
- 1:05:09any other of their games, you can get a Grand game As guild dot
- 1:05:13com. Thank you for putting up with this five minutes of sponsor blurb your
- 1:05:17next game. Then these Heroes of Mice and Magic two? Why are you
- 1:05:20taking this one to the cabin? So this this was it was a it's
- 1:05:27not there's one very significant form of influence from heroes, but heroes. It
- 1:05:32just looms so large in my life. I've played this game a ton.
- 1:05:36Here's my Magic two and then here's my Magic three, which was very similar.
- 1:05:41Uh in the nineties, you know, while I was being a you
- 1:05:44know, forming game designer, I also also played heroes a lot, and
- 1:05:53I eventually worked on a mod for heroes that may still exist out there on
- 1:06:00the internet where I did my classic like push variety stuff to it, and
- 1:06:06eventually I made my own heroes Dudes of stuff and things computer game that I
- 1:06:13think my computer even won't play it anymore, but you know, a doss
- 1:06:16game that did all the stuff I wanted to see in any Heroes type game.
- 1:06:24And Heroes is a it's a turn based strategy game where you you fight
- 1:06:28monsters and build up castles and heroes on a map and try to gain control
- 1:06:31of it. And the big lesson of Heroes the thing that aside from like,
- 1:06:36well it is a game that loomed larger in my life, but Heroes
- 1:06:40made the list in D and D didn't. And the big thing was the
- 1:06:43big lesson from Heroes was the power of little rewards. And so it's that
- 1:06:48like there are some monsters and they're guarding a treasure, and you fight the
- 1:06:56monsters and have your little battle and you beat them and you get some experience,
- 1:07:00and the experience made you go up a level, and you pick what
- 1:07:03skill do you get for going up a level, and then you claim the
- 1:07:05treasure and it turns out to be whatever it is, and you're you're getting
- 1:07:12this incredible influx of rewards off you get a thing, you get a thing,
- 1:07:16you got a thing. That's very delightful. I think that's really the
- 1:07:20key to why like me and some friends who played tons of Heroes, you
- 1:07:25know why why we played so much of this game. You know, the
- 1:07:29combat is this hex grid based thing. That's fine. You know that they
- 1:07:33they had a reasonable take on the series. Then you know died utterly after
- 1:07:40Heroes three. But you know these other elements, like you could really fix
- 1:07:45up there the way you build up the heroes, You can make that a
- 1:07:47lot better. But but the basic game experience is just is just so joyful,
- 1:07:57and it was a lesson, like like one example is in board games
- 1:08:04is that so there's dice and there's cards, and by convention, dice are
- 1:08:11often used to be this different kind of randomness from cards, where with the
- 1:08:16dice you you get something or you don't, which we'll call lottery ticket randomness,
- 1:08:23and with the cards you get something and it's just a question what did
- 1:08:26you get, which we'll call birthday present randomness, And the birthday presents are
- 1:08:30way more fun than the lottery tickets. It's fun to you know, what
- 1:08:33did I get? And did I get something not nearly as good? And
- 1:08:38this is just a convention, like you can use dice to give you birthday
- 1:08:41presents and you can use cards to be a lottery tickets. But but this
- 1:08:46is how things have played out, and it's uh, you know, it's
- 1:08:49so much better to get the birthday presents. And somehow I've tied this in
- 1:08:55with Heroes, with its with its endless little rewards. Uh yeah, Heroes.
- 1:09:02Heroes made the list because because it was a it was a game that
- 1:09:05loomed in my life for how much I played it and and you know,
- 1:09:08even making my own version of it, and then uh, you know,
- 1:09:13it did have an interesting game design lesson you know that's applicable to board games.
- 1:09:18This this thing where you know it, I mean D and D has
- 1:09:25the whole like, I mean, it has all of this right, like
- 1:09:29you do something in a room. There's lots of little rewards in D and
- 1:09:31D two. I just really associate it with Heroes and I really like to
- 1:09:38do this in games, to have it be that like, oh, you're
- 1:09:41building up and you keep getting stuff. Uh. I've got all these games
- 1:09:45that are they are very heavy on toys, which is a jargon term for
- 1:09:51you know, your own personal little abilities that aren't that aren't just start of
- 1:09:55game, like a cosmic power and anyway that's what I say. And so
- 1:10:02you you mentioned earlier that you you initially wanted to get into video games.
- 1:10:08Why didn't that happen? You know, gatekeeping I mean, or you know,
- 1:10:15lack of effort on my part. I mean I started to make a
- 1:10:18game with a friend and then he lost interest and that was a lesson and
- 1:10:24how that can go. And I wasn't you know, it was it was
- 1:10:27too much work to just do it on my own. And I made a
- 1:10:32few video games at home and I applied I applied it Lucasfilm Games. They
- 1:10:40had an opening and they seemed interested in me, and then they said,
- 1:10:45well, you know, this job disappeared, and then they had a new
- 1:10:47job that was not nearly so exciting, but they brought me an interview for
- 1:10:54that one, and that didn't go so well. And you know, that
- 1:10:58was my brush with you know, could I possibly work on video games?
- 1:11:01And yeah, you know, I had a job, and it's no fun
- 1:11:05looking for a job, but maybe there are opportunities and I didn't manage to
- 1:11:12get in on them. But you know, it wasn't something you could just
- 1:11:17do alone. And that was huge, right. That was the thing that
- 1:11:20when I got into board games, Well, I could just make them.
- 1:11:24I mean I made video games on my own, you know, with crude
- 1:11:26graphics and uh crew date ways from Sunday. But but you know, still
- 1:11:32potentially fun. But with board games, you know you could you could just
- 1:11:36really I mean many of my board games, the prototype plays better than the
- 1:11:41published version because in the published version they cared more about visuals than about uh,
- 1:11:48functionality. They cared more about how pretty it was that how functional it
- 1:11:51was. You can see this for example, it ranges right in the case
- 1:11:56of like Pinia Parata, the public version is way less playable than the prototype
- 1:12:02just due to the art, just because the pretty art on the published version
- 1:12:06is much harder to recognize which thing is which, especially upside down, and
- 1:12:12on the pro type it was trivial or like in Kingdom Builder, they put
- 1:12:16in little bridges and things to make the map look nicer, and it just
- 1:12:19creates a rules question for everybody. Everyone who plays the game says, does
- 1:12:24this mean anything? This bridge? No is? And uh, but you
- 1:12:31know you can. You can whip out the game and play it. You
- 1:12:36know, you can make them so much faster than video games. But also,
- 1:12:40like a real published video game has you know, the giant team of
- 1:12:43people and dies and so anyway, yeah, like why didn't I end up
- 1:12:46in video games? It's like, uh, you know, lack of ability
- 1:12:49to pursue opportunities, this is probably the big reason. But I certainly had
- 1:12:55the talent. I mean I was there, Like like Ultimate Underworld came out
- 1:13:00and it had a three D engine and this was novel. It was so
- 1:13:03novel that they struggled to get it across in the ads like what it really
- 1:13:09meant? Right, Like there were these pictures of an aunt at slightly different
- 1:13:13angles, and it's like, what is this showing us? And they were
- 1:13:15trying to show you that you could just like tilt your head a little and
- 1:13:18get a slightly different angle, that it was really a three D game,
- 1:13:23And uh, you know I immediately made a three D engine so that,
- 1:13:29you know, for the joy of it, like you know, this sounds
- 1:13:30like a fun project. Let's see what I can do. And I worked
- 1:13:32it out, and you know, I felt like I was there. I
- 1:13:39was I was there with the cutting edge board game or video game technology.
- 1:13:45It weigh in the past, right, I have nothing to do with it
- 1:13:48now, But but yeah, I don't didn't actually pursue opportunities. I mean
- 1:13:55I didn't. I didn't get any opportunities, but I didn't I didn't struggle
- 1:13:58to find them. I didn't go to convention and harass video game publishers or
- 1:14:01anything. And the one time I interviewed at a place, they didn't hire
- 1:14:06me. So I want to talk now about what effect do you think you've
- 1:14:13had on the industry. I mean, it's clear when you see, as
- 1:14:15you said earlier, a shelf of dominion like games. To what extent do
- 1:14:20you think you've been an inspiration to other designers? I mean it's I think
- 1:14:26it's it's it's extremely hard to have any clue as to what that answer is.
- 1:14:30And people are way too generous to themselves. Like two guys thought of
- 1:14:34calculus, and Newton always thought leading. It must have stolen it from him
- 1:14:41somehow, but it seems clear that they independently came up with this, and
- 1:14:46that's calculus, you know. And so when you have an idea for like,
- 1:14:51okay, I could make a game where we all make we all you
- 1:14:58know, you pick an action and everybody as it, or it's going to
- 1:15:02be like scrabble, but with these symbols where it's you know the corkle thing
- 1:15:09right where it's uh they matched the color or the shape. I had another
- 1:15:14I had a game that had the the the steed of Corkle in it that
- 1:15:20I never recognized, like, oh, I could just make that as a
- 1:15:23game also, Right, So we know at least three people who thought of
- 1:15:27this, and so yeah, what you see is just like what gets published.
- 1:15:32Like maybe there are other people who thought of, oh, you can
- 1:15:34make a whole game of building a deck, but they didn't put in the
- 1:15:36hours, which is certainly a big part of it. Right now, now
- 1:15:40actually do it. Uh, it's uh so it's very it's very easy to
- 1:15:46you know, pat yourself on the back or I must have had this effect
- 1:15:50when you have no idea, right, people people will say, oh,
- 1:15:55this, this must be copying this trend in gaming when you made it ten
- 1:16:00years ago or whatever. Right, Like greed Greed looks like it comes from
- 1:16:03Seven Wonders and it was from two thousand and three. I don't know if
- 1:16:08Seven Wonders existed in two thousand and three. Is a prototype, but you
- 1:16:11know it was nothing to do with me, and it wasn't my first drafting
- 1:16:15game that was in nineteen ninety eight, but you know it looks derivative,
- 1:16:19so who knows, right. I would like to think that you know that
- 1:16:27that my games and especially Demean have inspired people in particular directions that they've that
- 1:16:31they've seen, like certain things that I like in games that maybe have gone
- 1:16:38on to some degree. But but it's really hard to know. You know,
- 1:16:42there's another game that has, like the Gallet of Fools premise, it's
- 1:16:45uh, white as Dungeon. It tells it entered the dungeon or I don't
- 1:16:51remember the name of this game, but you you either add you either take
- 1:16:58cards off of the hero or add cards to the dungeon until everyone has passed
- 1:17:04and somebody has to do the dungeon with that hero. And it's like,
- 1:17:08was that inspired by Golleta Pools? And you know, it may not be
- 1:17:11the tiniest bit. For all I know, maybe maybe there's an article by
- 1:17:15them and they say, oh, you know, this is they're taking Goleta
- 1:17:17pool I don't know, but it's it's very easy to to overrate yourself there,
- 1:17:25so so I'm hesitant to try to attribute much to me. Obviously,
- 1:17:30they are the games that just copy everything about doming and I'm pretty sure they
- 1:17:32got that from Dominion, but and people sometimes site it so okay, But
- 1:17:42but yeah, i'd like to you know, you see these you see more
- 1:17:45games that have more variety now, and I'd like to think I was part
- 1:17:49of that. Uh, I don't know. There's there's games that are,
- 1:17:56you know, my kind of game, and I always hope you know that
- 1:18:00they're from Dominion fans. But but you know, like there was a there
- 1:18:04was an instore, an instore event for a Domeini expansion that that the woman
- 1:18:14who made Quirkle showed up at and it turned out she was a Dominion fan,
- 1:18:17and you know, Quirkle Domelion, they're nothing alike. It's a I
- 1:18:29don't know if she went on to make a game that as I need to
- 1:18:30do with the mean but but yeah, so yes, Ultimately my answer to
- 1:18:36the question is I'd like to think that I had some positive effect, but
- 1:18:43you know, I have no idea. I mean, I think it started
- 1:18:46with, as you said, a few acres of snow. But now deck
- 1:18:50building as a component part of a of a greater game design is a common
- 1:18:59thing. I mean, are you surprised in the way that the mechanism has
- 1:19:04gone or is that advancement very plausible for you? Now? I mean the
- 1:19:11key thing, I will tell you the secret to deck building. The key
- 1:19:15thing, the key thing it brings to the table because you could just have
- 1:19:19a tableau, right, Why why I build a deck and not just have
- 1:19:24a tableau. And the key thing is that it hides information and so makes
- 1:19:30your game simpler. Right, So like like lab in Dominion, Laboratory,
- 1:19:36you know, when you draw it, you can play it and draw two
- 1:19:39cards, and we can we can conceive of this as a card that just
- 1:19:42sits on the table and in fact, mean, how's that card which is
- 1:19:45Hireling, which it sits on the table and gives you an extra card of
- 1:19:47return and you could do formulas based on it. So it wasn't quite as
- 1:19:51generous, right because how good is lab It varies based on how big your
- 1:19:55deck is and how many labs are in it. And at some p point
- 1:20:00you know early in the game, you know, laboratories you're not playing at
- 1:20:02every turn. It's not like an extra card every turn, and eventually you
- 1:20:05are and uh so, uh so the key thing I'm stumbling again, the
- 1:20:14key thing to this, uh to the deck building is that it hit all
- 1:20:18this information, so you don't have a table covered inabilities. And when you
- 1:20:21have that table, and this is something I've put so much time into and
- 1:20:27talk about it for multiple games, you know, when you have that table
- 1:20:30covered with cards, it's extremely easy to miss that things are going are supposed
- 1:20:33to happen, right, and it's thought, oh wait, this card was
- 1:20:36going to give me an extra dollar. When this happened, It's so easy
- 1:20:41to miss, and it's a big problem that you want to address for all
- 1:20:44these these cool game premises where you have where you gain abilities during the game
- 1:20:49and you spread them out. They have to be somewhere, and so you
- 1:20:53spread them out on the table and you need to catch them all and in
- 1:20:57de meaning you know, it's all in your hand, it's all in your
- 1:21:00deck. And so you you draw a card. Now you can use it
- 1:21:03and it really lowers the complexity, which lets you raise it, which is
- 1:21:09the whole thing. Like the complexity does not actually go down, it's just
- 1:21:12that you get to we get to give you a much more complicated position,
- 1:21:18you know, a more complicated game state because we were hiding everything in this
- 1:21:25depth. And you know, the deck it's not that's not the entirety of
- 1:21:29what deckling gives you an and deckling isn't the entirety, but the mean you
- 1:21:31get you deck building. Also, you know there's stuff involved with Okay,
- 1:21:35so what does it mean to have a deck? Is a data structure in
- 1:21:39a game, and you can do some stuff with that that that's novel because
- 1:21:43you haven't done it previously, and even like Magic hadn't really done it because
- 1:21:48you just draw one card to turn. So it just it's just drastically different.
- 1:21:54And uh, and then there's the other stuff to me and has has
- 1:21:57like it has this the set of cards on the table that vary every game,
- 1:22:02so that that's giving us variety, and that where you can just we
- 1:22:04can all build up from the same from the same cards. We can all
- 1:22:09decide we're gonna, you know, we want to pursue this strategy involving these
- 1:22:13particular cards on the table. It's not like what you drew and so you
- 1:22:16pursued that strategy and I drew different cards and had to pursue that strategy.
- 1:22:20Right, we all get to we all get to work from the same thing.
- 1:22:23So Demian Demi and had more than deck building, or you know,
- 1:22:27if you pair those two things together, well you know, they're really two
- 1:22:30separate ideas. And obviously you can have deck building where you don't have the
- 1:22:36cards all laid out on the table, and people have done that right where
- 1:22:41they have like a you know, you buy a card and it gets replaced
- 1:22:44by a new one. So now you know, we both have different opportunities.
- 1:22:46So your next game then, is an unpublished one of yours, and
- 1:22:50that's Evolution. Can you can you tell us about this one and why you
- 1:22:55wanted it is one of your five games? Yeah, I'm gonna So there's
- 1:22:59a bunch of things that I like in board games that you know that I
- 1:23:02do endlessly in my own games because I like them, and a lot of
- 1:23:06it crystallized in Evolution. So I can tell you about all these things with
- 1:23:12this same game. And it was a very important game for me in the
- 1:23:16late nineties. I think I made it in nineteen ninety seven and I was
- 1:23:21trying to figure out all these things about how games worked, and it all
- 1:23:27it all comes together in Evolution. So the way the game, the actual
- 1:23:32game, initially it was you had cards that were body parts and you start
- 1:23:40out as a lizard, because you have to be something. And every turn
- 1:23:43you would play an action card, and you would play a body part,
- 1:23:46and we all played simultaneously. We would put these things on the table and
- 1:23:49reveal them, and you could attack and build both attacked to the other players
- 1:23:55and multiply gain you lizards and defend, defended you against attacking, and explore,
- 1:24:00got you more cards. Sort are five actions, and do you play
- 1:24:04an action, you do a card, and later versions of Evolution folded those
- 1:24:08together, so you just played a card, and what card you played also
- 1:24:11determined what action you would do. And so there's all these all these things
- 1:24:16about what I like in games and about solutions I have to these issues that
- 1:24:20come up in those games that all come together in Evolution. So first of
- 1:24:24all, it's got this. Oh and I didn't quite explain all the roles,
- 1:24:28but I mean that's most of it. You know, it takes eight
- 1:24:32You play for eight turns and that's it, and most lizards wins, and
- 1:24:36so you'll gradually put together You're you're tricky, you your monster, whatever it
- 1:24:42is. Right, you played scales and then an extra head and then fire
- 1:24:45breathing, and everyone else has done their own thing. Right. So the
- 1:24:49first thing is variety, where you have a lot of different experiences based on
- 1:24:55which set of cards came up for you. You know, which ones you
- 1:24:59decide to play, you all these different creatures. The second thing is simultaneous
- 1:25:03play. So this is so huge for my games. And yet Dominion and
- 1:25:09kingdomle are both just have conventional take turns. But if you were going to
- 1:25:14describe my games prior to Dominion coming out, you're gonna say, oh,
- 1:25:16what's the Donald X game? Like this is one of the things that you
- 1:25:19would you would lead with, is like, well, we all we all
- 1:25:24go at the same time. And this kind it goes back in part to
- 1:25:29a friend I have named Bruce, who would get board playing a game and
- 1:25:35reach over to the bookshelf casually and take a book and start flipping through it.
- 1:25:41And when it's your game being played, this is just heartbreaking and you
- 1:25:45about to fix this. And and at the same time, I you know,
- 1:25:51as I said, there was there was both magic and there was this
- 1:25:56book on game theory and game game theory. It's all simultaneous, right,
- 1:26:00we both make this at the same times, and then that determines the thing
- 1:26:01that happens and so initially I was pursuing these game theory based games where we
- 1:26:06would make simultaneous decisions and you would care what the other person was going to
- 1:26:11pick. And I still really love this mechanism that, you know, the
- 1:26:14trying to anticipate what the other players going to do as we as we simultaneously
- 1:26:17pick things, although most of my simultaneous play games don't really have that element,
- 1:26:23like simultans, play by itself doesn't give you dilemmas or you know,
- 1:26:28maybe give you a tiny number of them if you haven't pushed dilemmas too.
- 1:26:31I do have at least one published dilemma game, although they kind of removed
- 1:26:36the dilemma from it, which was Infiltration. It was drastically changed for publication.
- 1:26:43But initially, you know, we all we all pick what to do
- 1:26:45every turn as we as we're thugs looting a bubble gum factory, and you
- 1:26:53care a lot about what other people have picked the same turn if you're near
- 1:26:57them on the board. But anyway, so so simultaneous play this this was
- 1:27:02a big thing. We're all gonna we're all gonna make decisions at the same
- 1:27:05time, and not only does it give us the possibility of dilemmas and everything
- 1:27:09that's cool about them, the psychology of what you know, trying to outguess
- 1:27:13the other person. But also it means we're really involved in the play.
- 1:27:16Like you can also see this as an extension of the of the philosophy which
- 1:27:21caught on in the nineties of like maybe we shouldn't actually be eliminating players because
- 1:27:28how much fun is that? And it's a key design philosophy overall, Like
- 1:27:33the number one design philosophy is that it has to be fun to lose,
- 1:27:36because most people lose most games. You know, if you play a four
- 1:27:41player game and one person wins and three people lose, and so there's a
- 1:27:44lot of this losing experience. It really needs to be good. And if
- 1:27:47it's fun to lose, nothing else, nothing else matters, Right, You're
- 1:27:50set as long as you've made it fun to lose. So anyway, so
- 1:27:56so so it's good to not eliminate players. Well, you know, it's
- 1:27:58even better than not elimiting them is letting them constantly play, not not having
- 1:28:01to sit there waiting for your turn, Like in dominion you can have somebody
- 1:28:05has a really long turn and and it is you know, trying carefully to
- 1:28:12make decisions while laying out card after card, And it's really great if instead,
- 1:28:17you know, we all we all make decisions. You're waiting for the
- 1:28:19slowest to decide person, but that's drastically faster than waiting for turn after turn
- 1:28:25to happen. And we're we're all constantly involved. We do our things and
- 1:28:29we get ready to do the next thing. And this became such a huge
- 1:28:31thing in my games that I've made so many games with simultaneous play, and
- 1:28:36an evolution was a key one. It wasn't even the first one, because
- 1:28:40Pirates Dilemma was, but it was it was key was right there, like,
- 1:28:43Okay, we're all gonna make decisions simultaneously because this is what you should
- 1:28:45do. And so the next thing is politics. So politics is a it's
- 1:28:51a gamer's jargon. I don't know how much this has caught on or if
- 1:28:55I just copied from Richard Garfield and then you know we're the two people who
- 1:28:58say this. But politics, it's basically it's situations in a game. We're
- 1:29:02trying to convince somebody else to do something is the most valuable thing. It's
- 1:29:08it's situations where where you know someone can do something that's helpful both to them
- 1:29:14and to somebody else, and you have a chance to try to argue them
- 1:29:17into doing it, and uh, in you know, the a classic way
- 1:29:26that politics shows up in games is just any like pick who to hose,
- 1:29:29like pick who to attack, which is so common in so many games.
- 1:29:32Right, there are games that are all about it, like risk, where
- 1:29:34all you're doing is, you know, I pick who to attack and so
- 1:29:38so the game doesn't come down to like how well you can do whatever thing
- 1:29:44like it's it's scrabble and how well can you anagram? The game comes down
- 1:29:47to just this one thing, which is negotiating over who should be allowed to
- 1:29:51win. And uh, I don't really enjoy that experience. I know there
- 1:29:57are people who do, but I don't. And it's especially that if you're
- 1:30:00the game designer, right, like, well he must know what he's doing,
- 1:30:03let's attack him. But you know I've I've put in my hours playing
- 1:30:10like Settlers and saying no, you know, don't put the robber there,
- 1:30:15put it on Tom's bricks. Tom's about to win. Look, he's just
- 1:30:16about to get the longest road, And uh, you know that's just not
- 1:30:21how I want to spend the evening, so so you have to come up
- 1:30:26with So then what do you do to minimize politics? And in a game
- 1:30:30that's really interactive and you know, has more than two players, with two
- 1:30:34players, of course you just have no politics. And if your game doesn't
- 1:30:38have interaction, it doesn't have politics, like in some way, like in
- 1:30:41Trivial Pursuit. You know, they read the question to you and that's it,
- 1:30:45right, that's the interaction. But but when you have interaction, you
- 1:30:50almost certainly are going to have some politics. And all you can do is
- 1:30:53try to make it as small as as you can. And so all my
- 1:30:57games try to really reduce the politics, to eliminate it as much as possible.
- 1:31:01And for me, this started back then with Evolution, where you attacked
- 1:31:05the other players, but you always attacked everybody. You didn't get to pick
- 1:31:10who to attack at all, and when you defended, you defended against everybody,
- 1:31:14and that was that. And this has, you know, gone on
- 1:31:16to be a thing I always do. And so like in Dominion, you
- 1:31:18know, you play which and everyone else gets a curse, and we can
- 1:31:21arrange for a political moment in Dominion, and you know, you can have
- 1:31:28a kingmaking experience and everything, but it is very reduced, it's very minor
- 1:31:34compared to you know, actual political games. And in Kingdom Builder, the
- 1:31:40premise of the game came from, how do I have a game where we
- 1:31:45put pieces on a board and you can block somebody else and yet not have
- 1:31:48it be too political. And that led directly to this thing where well,
- 1:31:54if they've blocked you off, you get to go anywhere, so they'll only
- 1:31:58want to you know, they'll want to block you off from high scoring spots
- 1:32:01sometimes, but but it just it just drastically reduces how much the game is
- 1:32:08about trying to decide who's winning, so I can screw them over. And
- 1:32:13people will have this experience playing my games, or they did in the Murky
- 1:32:17Paste, where you know, they would get to a point where they were
- 1:32:20like, oh, it looks like Donald X is going to win, and
- 1:32:23it's like, wait a minute, there's nothing we can do about it,
- 1:32:25Like what happened. They were used to games where it would just be like,
- 1:32:29well, now we all attack him anyway, So low politics that was
- 1:32:34the next thing. And of course there's the interacting roles on cards, which
- 1:32:41evolution was just you know, a solid example of and then there's a simplicity.
- 1:32:46And I always think of nefarious for this, but it applies the evolution
- 1:32:49too. There was a period where I I realized that I made some some
- 1:32:57very complex games, and I end that it was possible to simplify them and
- 1:33:00still have all the good cards. And complexity is really a panacea in board
- 1:33:05games. It's, uh, whatever problem you've got, you can solve it
- 1:33:11with complexity, except for the problem of too much complexity. And it'll be
- 1:33:16like, this card isn't enough fun and so I add a line of text
- 1:33:19that makes it more fun, or this card is too powerful and too weak,
- 1:33:24and and those things aren't always you know the numbers that you have maybe
- 1:33:28two course, so that you know if you if you raise it from four
- 1:33:30to five, now it's awful, but it or it was crazy. But
- 1:33:34you can add text to try to address this problem. Let's let's give it
- 1:33:39a little booster or a little penalty on the other side, and your game
- 1:33:44will, you know, just just inexorably proceed towards being unplayable. And so
- 1:33:50you have to somehow rein this in and I've I've really taken this approach over
- 1:33:55my career of trying to make games ludicrously simple if possible. You know,
- 1:34:01often like when I teach people of dominion, I teach it to him three
- 1:34:05times. You know, some new new to dominion person sits down at the
- 1:34:10table and it's like, you know, yeah, I can just teach you,
- 1:34:12and I explain the rules, and then I explained the rules again,
- 1:34:14and I explained the rules again, because it just takes no time, right,
- 1:34:18It's I you know, I explained the simple version of rules, and
- 1:34:23I go into detail and that you know, I give it to them.
- 1:34:25I give it to him a third time. I've now said that to you
- 1:34:27three times. And that's that's you know how fast it goes h And you
- 1:34:31know, so many of my games, the rules, the rules for the
- 1:34:36prototype are you know, they've been on a page and this is it.
- 1:34:40This is all there is to say. Uh. And that may be you
- 1:34:44know, with like some corner cases considered. And so this this really hit
- 1:34:49again. The example I think of it is nefarious because with nefarious and we
- 1:34:54haven't gotten infarious yet, but with nefarious, I had a more complex version.
- 1:34:58And then i'm it was called mad scientists, and then I made Mad
- 1:35:01Scientists Light, which just pared it down into the core part that I thought
- 1:35:09was the best and simplified as much as possible. In the case of Evolution,
- 1:35:14I had Evolution, and then I'm ae Evolution Light, but I aside,
- 1:35:16I've gone too far, and then I'm made Evolution. Homestyle was in
- 1:35:19between, and so I think these I think these are the things I can
- 1:35:29say about Evolution. So in the nineties, in the nineties, I was
- 1:35:32trying to figure this stuff out, like what makes for a good game,
- 1:35:34and you know, how do you make a game where the rules are different
- 1:35:38every time and yet people can cope with it? And what's the way that
- 1:35:42will work the best? And all these other things came up, like,
- 1:35:45oh, it's sure sucks to eliminate players, and wait a minute, it
- 1:35:47even sucks if you're not if you're sitting there waiting, and yeah, picking
- 1:35:53who who wins, voting on who wins sure sucks. And I worked out
- 1:35:57all these things and they all crystallized for me, Evolution in particular, and
- 1:36:01it's not even a game I'm trying to get published now, Like I like
- 1:36:03Evolution, it's kind of it would have been totally sweet when I made it,
- 1:36:11or you know, when i'd fix it up some right. If it
- 1:36:13had come out in say, nineteen ninety nine, it would have been good.
- 1:36:17At this point, me other people have made so many evolution games,
- 1:36:23and you know, it doesn't It doesn't have an idea anymore. Its idea
- 1:36:30is just the basic Donaldics game with no twist, right. We just have
- 1:36:33cards and we play them and it takes eight turns and somebody wins, and
- 1:36:39it's simultaneous, and there's low politics and these things. But I always do
- 1:36:43those things, and so it doesn't stand out in any way at this point.
- 1:36:46It's just some game. It's you know, it's the vanilla game,
- 1:36:51but it was, it was key in its day. And there you have
- 1:36:56an evolution. So I want to talk now about the future. Well do
- 1:37:00you have coming out in the future. I don't know. I don't know
- 1:37:03how much I can talk about that. I guess that's not true. I
- 1:37:10am confident that I can tell you as much as I want to and that
- 1:37:14publisher will not care. But at the same time, I feel like it's
- 1:37:19friendlier to the publisher to not blab about these things. I can say I
- 1:37:29have three projects that probably all come out next year, and one of them
- 1:37:35is a demeaning expansion, and that shouldn't be like that's unannounced, that should
- 1:37:41not be a surprise. And I'm trying to slow down the rate of the
- 1:37:45demeaning expansions and get other games made. And I feel like I've even successfully
- 1:37:48done that because I've gotten some other games made. But there is still one
- 1:37:56coming and I haven't even told Jay about it. But you know, it
- 1:38:00will happen, I'm sure, and just at the point at which I decide
- 1:38:08it's good enough to you know, it's it's done enough to start getting art
- 1:38:12and yeah, I will, we'll probably, Yeah, I imagine that I
- 1:38:15will contis year and it will certainly be done. Uh. And I have
- 1:38:20two other games that Rio Grande is publishing that I expect will come out next
- 1:38:25year. They're in the process of having art made and they're both being done
- 1:38:29by one artist, which means they take a while, and so I don't
- 1:38:34know when exactly they'll get finished, how this will go, but they're being
- 1:38:42worked on, you know, progress is being made, and they're both you
- 1:38:45know, they're both games I'm pretty excited to have come out that you know,
- 1:38:50that we had a lot of fun playing and that they both have their
- 1:38:54unique ideas that I don't think exist, and they're they're both classic and on
- 1:38:59all the games in in a bunch of respects. I mean, they have
- 1:39:03cards with rules texts on them that interact and simultaneous play. That is my
- 1:39:11future beyond that, you know, I have, I have the big list
- 1:39:14of projects. You know, there's there's always there's there's more games to work
- 1:39:18on than I will ever get to, and they're always the ones that are
- 1:39:23near the top. And there's one that real ground I also wanted to publish,
- 1:39:27but I decided I wasn't ready yet that I need to finish and you
- 1:39:33know, I've changed it drastically, and I need to get enough playtesting done
- 1:39:36on it, which is which is taking time. And uh, and then
- 1:39:41there are these other projects that you know that seem real exciting to me currently
- 1:39:45that there's a couple things that go back to the pandemic where I had,
- 1:39:54you know, several games in motion that all stopped at the same time because
- 1:39:57I had no more game night, and that I'm finally getting back to,
- 1:40:00like I didn't immediately get back to them once I could play games in person
- 1:40:04again. And yeah, I mean, my my plan is certainly to keep
- 1:40:14making board games. Uh, you know, I don't know if there will
- 1:40:18be a point in my life where I decide that i'd either that that I'm
- 1:40:28not into doing it anymore, or that I can just make them and not
- 1:40:31try to get them published. But for the moment, you know, I'm
- 1:40:35into making them and getting them published, and it's a it's a fun life,
- 1:40:42and I have no plans to give it up. So your last game
- 1:40:46then, is another one of yours, and it's nefarious. Can you tell
- 1:40:51us something about this game, especially how it sort of taps in to wal
- 1:40:58He's a donald nex gay. I mean, Nefarius is a it's a it's
- 1:41:04a quintessential Donald's game. It's it's it's uh, you know, Nefarius and
- 1:41:10Greed or both, they're both very much the kind of thing like you played
- 1:41:14a bunch of unpublished prototypes. They're very much my kind of thing. I
- 1:41:17mean, Greed at this point is Greed is like a showcase for Drafting that
- 1:41:24doesn't need to exist because Drafting came out without it. So Nefarius was the
- 1:41:31Mad Scientist game. It's uh, mad scient is trying to threaten the world
- 1:41:36into submission wholesome entertainment for the whole family and you. The original game,
- 1:41:45the premise was that there would be there would be a game of investing in
- 1:41:50what you thought people would do. So there was a line of cards that
- 1:41:54were these investments and they would vary over the course of the game. And
- 1:42:00then I made Mad Scientists Light, which is the actual published game to Curious,
- 1:42:02where I stripped it down. I had texts on the cards initially,
- 1:42:05and I got rid of that and just had icons. And I felt like
- 1:42:11there was enough stuff to do with just the icons here that I didn't need
- 1:42:15the text, and the text was I'm going to add a lot, and
- 1:42:17the the investments I boiled down to just caring which action people had picked.
- 1:42:27And I eventually did other investments in the expansion. But but this was another,
- 1:42:31you know, significant simplification. So this was a game that really it
- 1:42:35really stands out for for this U you know, ruthless, ruthless paring down
- 1:42:43of what the of the rules of the game and the complexity of the game
- 1:42:48to get the game experience in the in the simplest possible form. And and
- 1:42:56it I'm sure I had more say about it. Yeah, and Nefarious has
- 1:43:03all these elements that are so so Donald EXE where where we all you know,
- 1:43:10in terms of my unpublished games, where we all make decisions at the
- 1:43:13same time. The game is very fast paced. New players will be astonished
- 1:43:17after the first turn when we're all waiting on them, but the second turn,
- 1:43:23like really, you know already they had to make another decision. But
- 1:43:28it's very fast paced, and you know, experienced players complains fifteen minutes and
- 1:43:30it's different every time, which is you know, one of my top things.
- 1:43:35This this huge amount of variety due to the twist and the twists.
- 1:43:39You know, the cards in your hand don't give you as much variety,
- 1:43:43but the twists give you a little puzzle to solve each game, right,
- 1:43:46like this anticipates dominion where you know so so in Nefarious, there's the two
- 1:43:50twists, and there are two rules that change how this game works, and
- 1:43:55you try to decide based on those twists, which cards have gotten more power
- 1:44:00powerful and less powerful, and which investments are now better or worse. And
- 1:44:03you play that out very quickly and see how how well you guessed, and
- 1:44:10and then you have a new experience. Then we deal out two new twists
- 1:44:13and it's different and just in Dominion, you know, we deal out the
- 1:44:15ten cards and you decide, Okay, what's the strategy for this. It's
- 1:44:18a much more complex version of that, but Nefarius still stands out for me.
- 1:44:25Is one of my favorite of my own games that that I've played it
- 1:44:29a lot and it's still fun. Uh yeah, I don't know. I
- 1:44:34mean I must have said more, but you know, it made the list
- 1:44:40for the you know, not just because it's it's one of my favorite games,
- 1:44:43but also and and it's and it's very it's just so very much what
- 1:44:46my games are about, even though it doesn't have text on the cards,
- 1:44:51but also because it was it was really the poster child for simplicity where I
- 1:44:58had a more complex game and was able to just prune it down and be
- 1:45:03happy with that. And yeah, so you're heading out down the road heading
- 1:45:11to the cabinet, and you go around a corner in the back door,
- 1:45:14the car flies open. Four of the games fly down a ravine into a
- 1:45:17river and swept away. Which one do you hope is sitting on the back
- 1:45:21seats of the car. Well, I mean, sadly, it will just
- 1:45:26be Dominion. I've I've had to play, had to play. Let's put
- 1:45:30it. I've been forced to play so much to me in my life,
- 1:45:34right it. I made it in two thousand and six in October, and
- 1:45:40we played it and played it and played it, and there have been fifteen
- 1:45:45expansions. And I've put in so many hours playing Dominion. And you know,
- 1:45:50there's a there's an online version. There are two online versions, but
- 1:45:56there's a newer one that only has an early acts release. That's an app.
- 1:46:02And you know, I play it for fun a few times a day,
- 1:46:10like I totally do not need to, So Damian Israeli held on for
- 1:46:17me, and I mean, it's just this, it's the you know,
- 1:46:21every game gives you this puzzle of what are you going to do to to
- 1:46:28do the best here? And you get to see new things, you know,
- 1:46:30in part because there are fifteen expansions, but but you know, you
- 1:46:35continually see things you never saw before that and that's exciting. That's that's a
- 1:46:43big thing I look for. And of course it has all these other elements
- 1:46:45I like, except for the except for the samlthoneus play excellent. Well,
- 1:46:50Donald X Vaccarina, thank you very much. Anytime, I don't mind you
- 1:46:57can support the show in many ways. You can tell your friend so you
- 1:47:00can talk about it on social media. You can talk about it in your
- 1:47:01own blog, podcast, or video. You can support it directly by going
- 1:47:04to Patreon dot com, forward slash five g ford for a rolling donation,
- 1:47:09or for a one off donation hitting the PayPal link at the bottom of the
- 1:47:11website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's these donations that keep the show
- 1:47:15going. Also, if you want to say something nice about the show,
- 1:47:17if you want to say something horrible about the show, can contact me on
- 1:47:19Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send me an email at five Games for
- 1:47:24Doomsday at gmail dot com. And if I managed to leg it to avoid
- 1:47:28the fang dripping bloods and the British national anthem, I'll see you in two
- 1:47:32weeks for another five Games for Doomsday