Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Net Income vs. Owner's Earnings: Which one Buffett cares about more?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everyone, and welcome back to the Deep Dive.
- 0:02Today we're tackling something you see all the time.
- 0:04You know, a company post these huge net income numbers, big
- 0:07earnings announcements. Sounds fantastic, right?
- 0:09Pure profit. But here's the question we're
- 0:12digging into. Is that really the cash the
- 0:15business is generating, like the actual money an owner could
- 0:18pocket without messing things up?
- 0:20Or is there, well, something else going on under the hood?
- 0:23So our mission today is to really unpack that.
- 0:25We're exploring the crucial difference between net income
- 0:29and this other metric, owner's earnings.
- 0:31And we've done our homework, gone through some really
- 0:33insightful stuff, especially an article called Net Income Versus
- 0:36to help us figure this out. Exactly.
- 0:38And our goal is pretty clear. We want to show you why these
- 0:41two numbers, which seem like they should be similar, often
- 0:45tell very different stories. We'll breakdown what each one
- 0:48actually means and really why. Understanding this difference
- 0:51is, well, it's vital. Vital if you want to get a real
- 0:54sense of a company's health or if you're making decisions, or
- 0:56even if you just want to be a smarter observer of the business
- 0:59world. We think you'll find that
- 1:00looking past those headlines reveal something pretty
- 1:03fascinating about how businesses actually work.
- 1:06OK, let's dive in. Let's start with the one we all
- 1:08know. Net income.
- 1:10It's everywhere. What is it actually measuring?
- 1:13Why does it get so much attention?
- 1:14Right. So net income, people call it
- 1:16the bottom line or just earnings.
- 1:18It's fundamentally an accounting profit.
- 1:20It's calculated using GAP. That's generally accepted
- 1:24accounting principles. And the key thing is it's based
- 1:27on accrual accounting. What that means is revenues get
- 1:30counted when they're earned, expenses when they're incurred.
- 1:32It doesn't always matter when the cash actually, you know,
- 1:35changes hands. So it includes everything, cost
- 1:37of goods sold, SG and a interest, taxes, and importantly
- 1:42things like depreciation, which aren't cash expenses in the
- 1:45current period. It's the official number.
- 1:48OK, so the official score based on a set of accounting rules
- 1:51makes sense, but then what's this owner's earnings?
- 1:53The name itself sounds, I don't know more real more.
- 1:57Tangible. That's exactly the idea.
- 1:59Owner's earnings tries to measure something much closer
- 2:01to, well, the true cash that's available to the owners.
- 2:05That's after the business covers its everyday running costs and
- 2:08after it spends what it needs to just maintain itself to keep
- 2:11everything in good working order.
- 2:13Think of it like this, what's the maximum cash an owner could
- 2:17pull out this year without damaging the businesses ability
- 2:20to keep operating and competing? Warren Buffett actually
- 2:23popularized the term because he wanted to know, you know, what's
- 2:26the real take home pay from owning a piece of that business.
- 2:31OK. So how do you get from net
- 2:32income to this owner's earnings number?
- 2:35Is there a formula? Yeah, there's a standard way to
- 2:37think about it. You start with net income, then
- 2:39you add back non cash charges. Depreciation and amortization
- 2:43are the big ones. These reduce your net income.
- 2:45But no actual cash went out the door for them this period,
- 2:48right? The cash was spent earlier.
- 2:49Right for the factory or machines.
- 2:51Exactly. Then you adjust for changes in
- 2:54working capital, like if inventory piles up, that ties up
- 2:57cash. If customers pay faster, that
- 2:59frees up cash. So that plus or minus goes in.
- 3:02And then this is really crucial, you subtract maintenance capital
- 3:05expenditures. Maintenance cap X not just all
- 3:09capital spending. Precisely.
- 3:11Just the spending needed to keep the business humming along at
- 3:14its current level, replacing worn out equipment, Essential
- 3:16upkeep. Not the spending on, say,
- 3:19building a whole new factory to grow bigger.
- 3:21OK. I think I'm getting it.
- 3:22So net income is the accounting profit by the rulebook.
- 3:25Owners earnings is trying to figure out the real spendable
- 3:29cash leftover after keeping the lights on and machines running.
- 3:33It's like accounting theory versus cash reality.
- 3:35That's a great way to put it. One's a standardized report
- 3:37card. The other is about the actual
- 3:39economic fuel the business generates.
- 3:41All right, here's where it gets really interesting for me.
- 3:43Why? Why do these numbers often
- 3:47diverge so much? What creates that gap between
- 3:50the accounting profit and the owner's cash?
- 3:52Well, it really boils down to that accrual accounting we
- 3:55mentioned for net income. It's full of non cash items and
- 3:58estimates. Depreciation is a big one
- 4:01obviously, but think about stock based compensation too.
- 4:05That's a real expense. It hits net income, but it's not
- 4:09cash flowing out of the company's bank account, right?
- 4:11It's equity. Good point.
- 4:13Or asset impairments. If a company writes down the
- 4:16value of some asset, that crushes net income, but again,
- 4:19no cash is involved in that specific write down moment
- 4:22owner's earnings. Though it tries to strip out all
- 4:25that accrual noise, as some people call it, it focuses
- 4:29purely on the cash and critically, it only deducts the
- 4:32necessary capital spending, the maintenance part.
- 4:34That gives you a much clearer view of the cash you could
- 4:37actually deploy. So it's trying to clean up the
- 4:38picture, get rid of the accounting estimates and focus
- 4:41on cash in, cash out for essentials.
- 4:43Exactly. Now just a practical point here.
- 4:45In the real world, figuring out just maintenance CapEx is
- 4:48tricky. Companies don't usually report
- 4:50it separately. Oh, OK.
- 4:52So how do analysts deal with that?
- 4:54Well, they often use free cash flow FCF as a proxy.
- 4:57The common formula is cash from operations minus total capital
- 5:01expenditures. Now someone like Buffett would
- 5:03ideally swap total CapEx for just maintenance CapEx if he
- 5:07could get the data. But since we usually can't, FCF
- 5:10is the closest publicly available number we generally
- 5:13use to approximate owners earnings.
- 5:15It's not perfect because it includes gross spending too, but
- 5:18it's often the best we can do. Got you.
- 5:20So FCF is like owners earnings light, maybe a practical
- 5:23substitute but the goal is the same.
- 5:25Get past the accounting entries to see the real cash.
- 5:28Precisely. That's the cash for dividends,
- 5:30buybacks, paying down debt, actual reinvestment, the real
- 5:33economic engine. OK, this makes so much more
- 5:35sense now, but let's make it concrete.
- 5:37Can we look at some actual companies?
- 5:39Seeing the numbers should really drive this home.
- 5:41Absolutely. Let's look at the latest
- 5:43completed fiscal years for some big tech names.
- 5:45It's quite revealing. Let's start with Apple for their
- 5:48fiscal year 2024 for Apple reported a massive net income,
- 5:53$93.7 billion, huge number, wow. But their free cash flow, our
- 5:59stand in for owners earnings was even higher, $108.8 billion.
- 6:04Higher, so a positive gap. Yeah, a positive gap of $15.1
- 6:07billion. What's driving that?
- 6:09Mostly it's large depreciation charges hitting net income.
- 6:13Remember non cash on assets they already paid for plus their
- 6:16CapEx while significant is relatively modest compared to
- 6:19the their scale. So more cash is sticking around
- 6:22than the profit number suggests. Fascinating.
- 6:24More cash than profit? Yeah, that seems like a good
- 6:27problem to have as an owner. But not everyone's like Apple,
- 6:29right? Especially with all the AI
- 6:31spending lately. Exactly right.
- 6:32Let's flip to Microsoft fiscal year 2025.
- 6:35Their net income? A whopping 101.8 billion
- 6:39dollars. Even bigger than Apple's.
- 6:41Right. But their free cash flow only
- 6:43$71.6 billion well. That's way lower.
- 6:46A negative gap of $30.2 billion. Almost a mirror image of Apple
- 6:50situation. The key driver?
- 6:51Immense capital expenditures, building out cloud
- 6:54infrastructure, data Centers for AI.
- 6:55Plus they had a big swing and working capital, likely buying
- 6:58up hardware for AI. $30 billion less cash than profit.
- 7:01That's a stark difference. It shows how much they're
- 7:04reinvesting just to power that growth.
- 7:06And I bet we see this pattern elsewhere You.
- 7:08Bet Look at Alphabet, Google's parent.
- 7:11Fiscal 2024 Net income $100.1 billion Free cash flow $72.8
- 7:18billion. Another big negative gap, about
- 7:20$27 billion. $27.3 billion negative gap, yeah, again, AI
- 7:25driven data center CapEx is the big story.
- 7:27They do get some cash flow benefit from adding back stock
- 7:30based compensation, but the sheer scale of their investment
- 7:34spending overwhelms that. OK.
- 7:35And Amazon, they must be spending a ton too.
- 7:37Absolutely. Amazon fiscal 2024 net income
- 7:41$59.2 billion, free cash flow $38.2 billion, a negative gap of
- 7:46$21.0 billion. Enormous spending on fulfillment
- 7:49centers and AWS cloud infrastructure just drags that
- 7:52owner earnings number way down compared to the accounting
- 7:55profit. Makes sense.
- 7:55And one more NVIDIA. They're at the heart of the AI
- 7:57boom, right? NVIDIA fiscal 2025 huge net
- 8:00income $72.9 billion, but free cash flow was $60.9 billion, so
- 8:05a negative gap of 12 point $1,000,000.
- 8:07Still negative, but maybe less dramatic than Microsoft or
- 8:09Google. Less dramatic percentage wise
- 8:11maybe that's still significant for NVIDIA.
- 8:14It wasn't just Cap X for new fabs, but also a massive buildup
- 8:18in working capital, specifically inventory, getting ready for
- 8:21their new Blackwell GPUs that tied up a lot of cash even as
- 8:26their accounting profit exploded.
- 8:28These examples are powerful. It really shows the difference.
- 8:30It does. And the key thing isn't just the
- 8:32size of the gap, it's the direction.
- 8:35A positive gap. Like Apple's tells you, gap
- 8:37accounting might actually be understating the cash
- 8:40generation. It's conservative, good news for
- 8:42owners. But a negative gap like we saw
- 8:44with Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, NVIDIA, that's a warning
- 8:48sign. It suggests the reported
- 8:50earnings might be painting a rosier picture than the actual
- 8:53cash reality for shareholders right now.
- 8:55This isn't just academic. That negative gap shows how
- 8:57these tech giants, even ones that seemed asset light before,
- 9:01are now in this intense investment cycle, especially for
- 9:05AI. Their net income might be
- 9:07soaring, but a lot of that isn't translating into cash owners can
- 9:10actually access today. It forces you to think
- 9:12differently about their valuation.
- 9:13OK. So let's connect all these dots.
- 9:15What does this mean for you listening right now?
- 9:18Why should you really care about net income versus owners
- 9:21earnings? It sounds important, but how
- 9:23does it apply practically? It's hugely practical.
- 9:26First off, it highlights just how critical capital expenditure
- 9:29intensity is today. As we saw this AI race is
- 9:33forcing companies like Google and Amazon, companies we used to
- 9:36think of as software or platform businesses into becoming massive
- 9:40physical infrastructure builders, heavy CapEx and that
- 9:44directly shrinks their owners earnings compared to net income.
- 9:48So if you're looking at a company with exciting net income
- 9:50growth, you have to ask how much cash are they actually burning
- 9:53through just to achieve that growth?
- 9:55Are they a cash generator or a cash guzzler right now?
- 9:58That's a crucial question. High profit doesn't always mean
- 10:00high cash flow. Exactly.
- 10:02And 2nd, and this is maybe the most important point, owners
- 10:06earnings or FCF as its proxy is simply the better yardstick for
- 10:10valuation. If you're trying to figure out
- 10:13what a company is truly worth, maybe using a discounted cash
- 10:16flow model or just trying to gauge its ability to pay
- 10:19dividends or buy back stock, you need to look at the cash it
- 10:23actually generates for owners, not just the accounting profit.
- 10:27Especially for companies in these heavy investment phases,
- 10:30owners earnings gives you a much more accurate picture of the
- 10:33company's real economic profit, the wealth it's actually
- 10:36creating. I've seen investors get tripped
- 10:38up by this so many times, focusing only on soaring EPS
- 10:41while ignoring negative free cash flow.
- 10:43It really changes your perspective, doesn't it?
- 10:45It helps you avoid just taking the headline number at face
- 10:47value and gives you a deeper look at the company's real
- 10:50financial strength, like understanding the engines power,
- 10:53not just how fast this speedometer needle is climbing.
- 10:55That's a perfect analogy. So for people listening who want
- 10:58to start doing this themselves right away, is there a quick
- 11:01mental checklist if you pull up a company's financial report,
- 11:05like a 10K or 10Q, How do you estimate owner's earnings?
- 11:08Where do you look? Yeah, absolutely.
- 11:10It's pretty straightforward once you know where to look.
- 11:12First, go straight to the statement of cash flows, find
- 11:15the line item for cash from operations.
- 11:17That's your starting point, cash from the core business.
- 11:20Second, you need to subtract maintenance capital
- 11:22expenditures. Now remember the cash.
- 11:24Companies don't usually break it out separately.
- 11:26Right. So if you can't find specific
- 11:28maintenance cap X data, you use the reported total capital
- 11:32expenditures, often listed as purchases of property, plant and
- 11:36equipment, as a conservative substitute.
- 11:39Subtract that total cap X from cash from operations.
- 11:42What you're left with is free cash flow FCF and that's your
- 11:46best practical approximation for owners earnings.
- 11:49OK. Cash from OPS minus total cap X
- 11:52equals FCF which is our proxy. Simple enough.
- 11:55Pretty much. Then you can do a quick sanity
- 11:57check with a few adjustments if needed.
- 11:59Like if there was a genuinely huge one off restructuring
- 12:02charge that hit cash flow but won't happen again, maybe add
- 12:05that back mentally. Or if the company made a big
- 12:08acquisition paid for with cash, that cash outflow isn't really
- 12:11from running the existing business.
- 12:12So you might want to adjust for that to see the underlying
- 12:14operational cash and maybe try to mentally smooth out big
- 12:18seasonal swings in working capital, like a retailer
- 12:21stocking up for Christmas. Look at the trend over a full
- 12:23year perhaps. But honestly, just focusing on
- 12:26that cash from operations minus total cap X gets you most of the
- 12:29way there. It's this cash based view.
- 12:32Well, it explains why investors like Warren Buffett often glance
- 12:35at the headline EPS but then dive straight into the cash flow
- 12:38statement. That's where the real story
- 12:40unfolds. Fantastic.
- 12:41That's incredibly helpful. So the core insight here is
- 12:45crystal clear. Understanding the gap between
- 12:48net income and owners earnings and focusing on that real cash
- 12:51generation gives you a much sharper, more actionable view of
- 12:55a company's financial reality. It's about getting beyond the
- 12:58accounting roles to the economic substance, understanding the
- 13:02engine, not just the speedometer.
- 13:04Absolutely. And maybe a final thought for
- 13:06everyone listening to them all over.
- 13:08The next time you see a company's earnings report pop
- 13:10up, don't just look at the net income figure and stop there.
- 13:13Pause for a second. Imagine you actually own that
- 13:15whole business. Ask yourself, how much cash
- 13:18could I actually take out this quarter or this year?
- 13:20Go find that cash flow statement.
- 13:21Calculate the free cash flow. See how that number compares to
- 13:24the reported profit. Especially if it's a company
- 13:26that's growing fast or investing heavily, like in AI right now,
- 13:30You might be surprised by what you find.
- 13:32What new insights will you uncover?
- 13:34Great challenge and if you are interested in tracking market
- 13:37valuation metrics like the one named after Buffett or just
- 13:41keeping an eye on overall market temperature using data-driven
- 13:45approaches, you might want to check out the Buffett Indicator
- 13:48iOS app. It's available on the Apple App
- 13:50Store. Just search Buffett Indicator.
- 13:53And just our standard reminder, all the analysis we've discussed
- 13:56today is based on public information and our
- 13:59interpretation. Things can change and other
- 14:01interpretations exist. This is purely for educational
- 14:04purposes. It's definitely not investment
- 14:06advice. You absolutely need to do your
- 14:08own research and due diligence before making any investment
- 14:11decisions. Well said, and if you found this
- 14:14deep dive helpful, we'd really appreciate it if you'd like and
- 14:16subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or our YouTube channel,
- 14:20Deep Value Investing. And don't forget, there's a list
- 14:23of great value investing books in the episode description.
- 14:26Thanks for tuning in.