Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Texas Killing Fields | The Women Who Vanished Along I-45
Transcript
- Nicholle: Welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicole, mom. It's 1984, Leek City, Texas. A woman named Heati Fye is working as a bartender. She's 23 years old. She's got a life, people who care about her, a future she's building. And one night she uses the public pay phone and she vanishes. Just gone. A few months later, a dog out in the field, about 25 acres of scrubland near Calder Road finds something, a skull. Thank Zalle: and I'm Zayley. Nicholle: Today we're starting something big, something that can't be covered in just one episode. We're doing a three part series on the Texas killing fields. Zalle: And honestly, I'm super glad that you're taking the lead on this one, mom, because this case is a lot. And it's crazy because I've grown up and like basically was raised out in like the Houston ish area my whole life. And a couple of times throughout my life, I've lived literally like within an hour of where all of this was happening. And I had no idea that this was going on. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yep. Zalle: That's how this starts. Not with the detective, not with the tip line, with the dog. A field and a skull. And that field, it doesn't stop giving up its bed. Over the next seven years, it's a Hold on, ma. You need to turn your volume all the way off, because that's going to pick up and that's going to echo. Nicholle: That's how this starts, not with the detective, not with the tip line, with the dog, a field and a skull. And that field, it doesn't stop giving up its dead. Over the next seven years, three more. Right, So it is a lot. It's multiple killers across multiple decades. It's law enforcement failures that are still being studied. It's families who waited decades for answers and some who are still waiting. And it's a case that is literally still unfolding as we speak. Zalle: Say it again, You didn't unmute yourself. Yeah, you mute it every time we record audio. The Netflix series was a way of young college students to get into the state of became part of the college. The way young college students learned about the American technology of 1980s became part Nicholle: Have you started now? Zalle: I didn't hear it till just then. Nicholle: I didn't hear it. The Netflix series highlights this pattern, the way public pay phones, which should have been safe, became hunting grounds. The way young women using the most ordinary technology of the 1980s became targets. I heard it, but for some reason I didn't. Thank you. I like your video. Zalle: Literally as in like arrests were just made a couple weeks ago Nicholle: Yes, so we're going to take this in three parts. Episode one today is the setup, the geography, the victims, the mystery of that field and the pay phones that connected them. Episode two, we'll get into the suspects, the theories, the forensic breakthroughs. And then in episode three, we'll talk about what went wrong with the investigation, what changed and where things stand right now. It's 1984, Lake City, Texas. A woman named Hedie Pye is working as a bartender. She's 23 years old. She's got a life, people who care about her, future she's building. One night she uses the pay phone and she vanishes, just gone. A few months later, a dog out in a field about 25 acres of scrubland near Calder Road finds something, a skull. Zalle: 1984, Lake City, Texas. A woman named P-5 is working as a bartender. She's 23 years old. She's got a life. People who care about her, future she's building. Nicholle: but the Calderode IV, Heady, Laura, Audrey, and Donna are just the center of a much larger pattern. Along the I-45 corridor from the early 1970s through the 1990s and even into the 2000s, bodies kept appearing. Zalle: I am excited for this one, so I'm ready. Let's get into it. How many total bodies like appear during the time? Nicholle: Let's do it. Okay, so before we dive all the way in, what are we drinking today? Because I feel like I need to know you're prepared. So the most common number that's cited is 34. But that depends on how you define the corridor, in which cases you include. Some of the cases are solved, some have suspects, and some are still completely cold. So let me give you a sense of the timeline. We have 1971 to 1972, where a cluster of teenage girls That's how this starts, not with the detective, not with the tip line, with the dog, a field and a skull. In that field, it doesn't stop giving up its dead. Over the next seven years, three more women would be found in that same patch of ground. And here's what haunts me. Two of them disappeared after using pay phones, pay phones just miles apart, pay phones that should have been safe. And over the next four decades, Zalle: So today I'm trying this new like mocha or chocolate coffee that you gave me and like with the little coffee, not coffee, chocolate thingies. Thank you, thank you. I don't know why I was struggling with that. Yes, yes, just some creamer in it. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. the little melting chocolate at the bottom. It's okay. Okay, all right. Well, I have basically the same thing. I just took the little melting chocolates and put them at the bottom with some strong strong coffee and a little creamer and I have my little my little cute cup that my white lady gave me. I'm sorry, my mom. Yes, is Ailey's poo and my white lady. So that's a little fancy cup. disappears from the Galveston area. That was Sharon Shaw, Rhonda Johnson, Collette Wilson, Gloria Gonzalez, Debbie Ackerman, and Maria Johnson. Most of those were found dead. Most remain unsolved. In 1979, Susan Bowers, who was 12 years old, disappears. In 1983 to 1986, that was the Calderode Cluster. Heady, Laura, Audrey, plus The number of bodies found along I-45 corridor between Houston and Galveston would climb to 34. Some identified, some still nameless, some with suspects, some with nothing but questions. This is the Texas killing fields. And this is one of the most complicated, heartbreaking, and most infuriating cases in American criminal history. Zalle: The white lady is her mom, yes, yes. Yes, that's my pooh. Nicholle: Because we got to be fancy sometimes, especially with all this going on. We got to do what we can to keep our spirits up. Welcome back to Coffee and Crime. Zalle: Yeah, for sure. Nicholle: Sandra Ramber, who disappeared in 1983 and was never found in the field. And then 1986 is Shelly Sykes. She was 19 and that's when she was last seen. And then 1988, Susan Renee Richardson, she disappeared in 1991. Donna Prudhomme was found in that field. 1996, Crystal Jean Baker, who was 13. All right, so I want to take a quick minute to clarify our schedule for this series because we're doing something a little a little different. Zalle: Right, so this ended up turning into a three-parter, which is not what we were expecting when we originally said we're going to be doing the Texas Killing Fields next. Nicholle: No. Right. So yeah, it's a three parter because it's so much information. Like I was saying, so just for episode one, we'll be doing that today and we'll just kind of be covering, giving you an idea, setting up the scene. And then episode two will be next Monday and three drops the Monday after that. So over the next three weeks, every Monday, you'll get a new installment of our Texas Killing Fields series. was raped and strangled. Her case was solved in 2012 and Kevin Edison Smith was convicted. And then in 1997 is the William Reese murders, Laura Smither, Kelly Cox and Jessica Kane. And they are separated from the Calder Road cluster but along the same corridor. And then 2001 to 2006, there are more disappearances, Tat Tran Harriman, Zalle: That makes my whole chest hurt like ⁓ Yes, and then on Fridays we are still doing Nicholle: Now the four women found in that field, they are the anchor of this case. Everything else spirals out from them. Yes. So on Fridays, we're doing many episodes, little quick hits, case updates, behind the scenes, maybe some listener questions. If you send them in, those ⁓ will be shorter, punchier, and they'll go up on our socials as teasers throughout the week. And those are going to be more of the cases that they'll still usually have some true crime because we'll be updating other things or covering cases that haven't. Sarah Trusty and Teresa Venegas. Zalle: There are so many names in the timeline. And that is some of them because some of them women, there were more women found that were unidentified or women not found, probably still in the fields and stuff that we don't know about. Decades and dozens of women and a lot of them, like I said, are still unsolved. That is... Nicholle: Let's say their names. Let's say their names and let's talk about the pay phones because the pay phones matter. you want to do I don't know what part that is. okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Zalle: Let's their names. Do you wanna do the, I'm sorry. Do you wanna do this part? Nicholle: completed yet that are kind big at the moment that we're interested in and then maybe just some other topics that we find interesting that we want to share with you. That'll be our mini episodes. Zalle: ⁓ okay, look, we'll just read it. It's no need to do the clip, because it tells you what it says. Go ahead. I'm sorry. I'm gonna up. Right, right. And so like we'll do after we finish the Texas Killing Fields, we'll start back with probably giving teasers for our Monday episodes in our coffee moments for you guys. So that way you can keep up with that schedule. And then we will give the teasers for what our Friday episodes will be through social media. They'll be posted like where all of our podcasts are posted, but the teasers for those won't be given in our actual episodes. They'll be given. Nicholle: It's just sad and heart breaking. Zalle: So many women whose lives, who just nobody knows, you know? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Heady was 23 years old. She worked as a bartender in Lake City, according to Texas Monthly and the Netflix docu-series crime scene, the Netflix crime scene, the Texas killing fields. Heady was last seen using a public pay phone. Then she disappeared. And on April 4th, 1984, a dog roaming that field near Calder Road came back with the human skull. It was Heady. Yeah. Yeah. And here's what makes it complicated. This wasn't one killer with one pattern. The evidence points to multiple offenders using the same region over time. Some cases are connected. Mm-hmm. Right. Right. you Zalle: on our social media. if you don't follow us, go and follow us on all of the socials, the Instagrams, the Facebook. I don't think we have Facebook. I don't think we have Twitter. have, we have, okay, mom on the Twitter and I didn't know about it. We got TikTok. We got all this stuff. And of course our emails are. Nicholle: I'll look at that. Twitter, have Twitter, have Instagram, Twitter and Facebook. I'm doing, you know. Zalle: That is so crazy that it was a dog that just randomly found her and just to touch on it her name is Heidi but her family did refer to her as hee-dee so that is what we're gonna call her as hee-dee because that's how they addressed her in the documentary. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. So maybe we don't have Twitter. Maybe I had an old moment. It's TikTok we have, not Twitter. It's TikTok. It was a T. We may have a Twitter. I set up something and forgot about it. So it could be Twitter, but it's so many me doing so much of the socials. Yeah. Keeping up with the three that would plus YouTube and putting the shorts and stuff on there. So we're kind of everywhere. If you look for Coffee and Crime with Mom, you should see our pretty faces. Yes, and the dog found her and that detail has always stuck with me because it tells you something about how exposed these remains were. This wasn't a carefully hidden grave. This was a field that was in some ways being used. Heady had been shot in the head and her discovery is what put that field on the map. Zalle: Right. Yeah. Nicholle: I'll be careful. Zalle: Yes, and we said all of that to give clarification about the Guampane Ramsey case, because I said that was going to come next on our, one of our episodes. So yeah. Right, and to think that it could have easily been those people's kids instead of that dog that found that body. It's terrifying. And she was just the first one. She was not the last one found in the area. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. That's terrifying. Yeah. And we know people that's a big case and everybody gets excited when they hear it. So we'll definitely cover it at some point. It's on the list, but after this big case and then probably next we'll be doing Gilgo Beach. So those are kind of really heavy big cases, even though Gilgo Beach shouldn't be three parts. But, ⁓ but I mean, we don't know, we're not done with it, but I'm hoping that maybe we can keep, maybe the two. You can go on. Come on. Come on. not by a long shot. Then we have Laura. ⁓ Zalle: Do you want to hear the heady one and then see if you want to put it in there? you okay with just that? ⁓ Nicholle: Come on. Zalle: We won! Nicholle: No, because then that's gonna be them telling the whole story. The ones that are kind of like clips about information like the crime scene, different details, like the people talking, but not just necessarily repeating what we're saying. Ready? All right, Laura Miller found February 2nd, 1986. She was 16 years old, a sophomore at Clear Creek High School. Zalle: Got you. Nicholle: But we'll see. However long it needs to be to get the information that we need to get out, that's how long it'll be. These just seem heavier to me. It's like you got to really sit in it for... ⁓ Right. ⁓ Zalle: different. Okay. Nicholle: I heard him howling. Why? ⁓ Zalle: Net. Let off. Right, but don't worry, that's coming. Yeah. I think it just seems that way because it's so much. But we are going to do John Benet-Ramsey. It's coming, just not today. Nicholle: Okay. ⁓ yeah. Some cases like this. Yeah. We have to keep that for children. It's not my favorite. Zalle: yet some cases are connected okay Nicholle: Musically gifted, she had recently moved to League City and was struggling socially due to debilitating seizures that had forced her to leave school, I'm sorry, to leave the school choir. On September 10th, 1984, Laura asked her mother to drive her to a payphone at a convenience store on the corner of West Main and Hobbs in League City. So I guess we can. Zalle: You can do the start with the geography of the graveyard. Nicholle: you Yeah, so let's start with the place because the place matters. The Texas Killing Fields refers to approximately 25 acres stretch of rural land near Calder Road and Urban Street in Lake City, Texas. So it's about halfway between Houston and Galveston, right along the Interstate 45. I make sure food season is fixed. See the chocolate still about enough. And I started yours. I thought I did. Zalle: Yeah, I saw when I took a squiggle I said, ooh, there you go, Chunk. ⁓ Nicholle: The family's home phone hadn't been connected yet. She needed and she wanted to call her boyfriend. Her mother dropped her off. Laura planned to walk the half mile home afterward and she never made it. Can you just imagine being her mom? Zalle: Right, and I have driven that stretch of I-45 several times. It's really unremarkable. It's just a highway and marshland and oil fields and really the kind of place that you wouldn't look twice at. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Absolutely not. I cannot imagine my kid not coming home. Nicholle: And really the fact that they're doing the point-sale. Right, exactly. And that's the point. The terrain is wild marsh, abandoned oil fields, vast beaches, land that makes concealment easy and discovery hard. Since the early 1970s, roughly 30 to 35 bodies have been found along the I-45 corridor. I'm sorry, I-45 coastal corridor. So in the same area, the same kind of location, a public payphone where a young woman could be seen, could be watched, and could be targeted. Her parents reported her missing, but law enforcement dismissed her as a runaway, told them she'd call home, but she never did. Her father, Tim Miller, would spend the rest of his life fighting for answers. Zalle: We're almost done. So we just gotta finish this before the joints get here. Nicholle: Yes, we need to put in some time for you to be able to edit it. you can edit it and I can go get the boy we can get this one replaced take the other one down and we'll go on to the other two we got to get at least these two done today we need to do the short one too He founded Texas EquiSearch, a search and recovery organization that has helped find hundreds of missing people because of lore. And here's the detail that still haunts him. Hold on, let's jump too far. But the heart of it, the part that gets the most attention is that 25 acre patch where four women were found between 1983 and 1991. Zalle: I mean that's crazy, four women in one field in less than a decade. Nicholle: That's tomorrow, but I haven't even done anything on that one. Them phones dead. ⁓ Right. Yes, four women. And here's what makes it so complicated. Those four may not all have been the work of one person. In fact, the evidence suggests that probably it isn't. But before we get into that, let's talk about the corridor itself. I-45 runs from Dallas all the way down to Galveston and along that stretch, particularly the Houston to Galveston portion, there have been clusters of disappearances and bodies And here's the detail that still haunts him. Laura's body was found on February 2nd, 1986, just 60 feet, 18 meters from where Hedie Fie had been found two years earlier. Zalle: And here's what I don't know if you still have. Right, 60 feet. Like that's not random. they kept... So in the documentary when they were talking to Tim, he was saying that while she was missing, he saw... Nicholle: you can play with your baby for a bit after you home after you edit this, then we'll jump back in. And when is y'all's legs getting turned back on? Hopefully they'll. embodied discoveries for over 50 years. Some researchers call it the highway of tears situation, similar to what you see in Canada. Zalle: the information about Heidi and how her body had been found. he went to the police and he's like, this could possibly be connected. So like, y'all should search the area. And he told him, these are completely ⁓ isolated incidents. And he told them, and then he told Heidi's people specifically, don't contact each other. They're dealing with the loss of their kid. Y'all shouldn't be in contact. That's why I asked for $50. We got all, we got $50 short. Yeah, I thought we could work, we thought we were gonna make it till Friday. We like, we can make it. They just, they just a little packed. They was like, not playing truth. Give me my money. My money today. Okay. a where the geography itself becomes a tool for predators. Like, it literally is nothing out there. Nicholle: Right. Right. ⁓ Oh, well if you actually need $50 to pay for your life. Mm-hmm. Exactly. It's easy access. It's a remote dumping site, transient populations because there's not really any businesses or homes right there off of 45. And so for decades law enforcement treated each case as isolated and that caused them to miss the patterns that were right in front of them. Zalle: And he brushed him off every time he was like, y'all should search this area. And he said, when they did it, literally when they found his body, it was just a couple feet from where he was telling them that he thought that they should look for her because of the story he heard. So then he had to live with that because he's like, I just listened to what the police said. And it was just right there. And they could have found her all these years ago because she was there the whole time. Nicholle: and aggression of the attacks and the officers just carried them in. Zalle: No, it's just oil filled and stuff. Nicholle: Well, you can ask that, telling you just if you especially if you're paying back tomorrow. That way at least because the department not going to turn it right back on. They're going to say they got to come out. They didn't have to come out to turn their shit off. But they like to tell you they got to come back out to turn it back on. So if you can get it today that way by tomorrow, it'll be back on. You're not sitting up there all weekend without no lights. That's just crazy. ⁓ Right, and it was just 60 feet. Right. And as Tim Miller said, no grass has ever grown in that spot. No grass has ever grown where Laura's body was found. And here's what makes it even more disturbing. While searching for Laura, they found someone else. Zalle: Well, I'm Nicholle: I'm gonna lie from this end like a ghost. I mean, I am, I got a little foot here. I am compared for recording today. I say we just gonna get comfortable. We now gonna try to rush this shit because then we both get frustrated and shit don't get done. And then we'd be up at three o'clock in the morning looking like meth addicts. I know I did. I look like a damn meth addict on that recording. Okay. Some cases are connected. Some aren't. Some might be connected and we just don't know yet. Zalle: Someone else. my, and they're so close. They're so close. Nicholle: right? That it just makes you, I don't know, like what, how were you looking? What was that search like? I don't understand. Zalle: Then we'd be frustrated. Yeah. I know, we're good. And how do you feel like they're not connected? Like they're dropped right within and then their bodies were all laid out in the same position. Everybody was found on their back in a certain position almost like it was somebody trying to make their like what they called it their personal graveyard. Nicholle: Right now just in the same field but next to each other just about. And for decades, law enforcement treated each of them as isolated incidents. That's what shut it all down. Right. And so then we have Audrey Lee Cook also found February 2nd, 1986. And she was found, as we said, the same day as Laura Miller during the same search. She was 30 years old. She was a mechanic from Memphis, Tennessee, but she was living in the Houston area and she had been seen in December, 1985. Zalle: That is exactly what the problem is because even if they are not connected if you look at them You can see where the other ones are connected some of them. It is no way in the hell no way inhale All those bodies are found All of those bodies are found in the same spot some of them a lot of them same age range and she was found seated in the basement during the second and third. She was 30 years old. Nicholle: You look at everything. Yeah, you look at everything. No, not especially when you're talking over 50 years of this. I mean, I love Texas, but this don't. Audrey was lying near a tree in a supine position, not buried, but hidden from view. She had a small caliber gunshot wound to the back that severed her spine. injuries were several, I'm sorry, additional injuries to several ribs. But Audrey was a Jane Doe. No one knew who she was. She would remain unidentified for 33 years. Zalle: Same similar type background couple then found in the same area like taking our last scene in the same areas like come on Nicholle: same soup. I mean, once you find four bodies, let's just check the rest of this patch of land. Overreact, overdo it. If you overdo it and it's nothing, well, we did our job and we know that there's nobody else out there. Zalle: 33 years as a Jane Doe and all because when they did go to do the identifying like how they figured out who these people were they used the dental records and they just didn't have her dental records or she didn't pop up any like Let's just go on scan outward. We're going to start right where we found this one and everybody go out in a circle formation so everything get covered. And we will aim nothing else out of that. But ain't no reason we had to go back years between, because it was two years between five and six. Nicholle: And whoever this guy was, if it was the same guy for those four, he just that if they would have, well, I guess because they were finding the people, they found them all. if it's just like somebody, something could have been stopped and people's families could have known what was going on. So they aren't wondering and worrying about them. Even the people who didn't know. Zalle: Missing persons system it nothing matched like her description once they did what they could to try to bring like her her back to create that So 33 years as a Jane Doe, that's a lot Nicholle: is important. Zalle: they found them all. It's just like somebody could have been stopped. Nicholle: . Right. Right. And her family didn't know where she was. They didn't know what happened to her. They didn't even know she was dead. She was finally identified in 2019 through DNA analysis and genetic genealogy, the same technology that's been breaking open cold cases all over the country. Zalle: Wondering, worrying about the Right, that's what the dad was saying. Yeah, even people didn't know what their future was. Even if they knew, like one lady, even their parents didn't know. They just discovered their parents. And so, 30 years ago, the adults didn't know what their future Nothing, I know nothing. They just never knew. And adults didn't know their story to be told. Yeah. Nicholle: Yeah, even the people who didn't know where their children were, even, you know, like the one lady in their parents didn't know, their family just didn't know where they were. And even those people, so for 30 years, they don't know where their person is. Whatever those circumstances were, they deserve to know. And that person deserved their story to be told and their killer to be found. Zalle: Yes, my goodness. I would mourn for her and her family for that. ⁓ Nicholle: Audrey Lee Cook, that was her name, and she deserved to have it spoken out loud for 33 years. And then I can't imagine waiting 33 years to know what happened to your person. I do not understand. And then we have Donna Gunsulun Prudhon. She was found September 8th, 1991. Zalle: And I don't think that it should matter what your background is. Like, oh, you're a prostitute or you're homeless or whatever the case is, you're colored or whatever. It should be a search or you come from a poor background. It should be a search for everybody. Everybody should think about it as if this was my mom or this was my sister or my whoever. I would want people to help me look for them. Nicholle: Right. It doesn't matter. It's a person. It's somebody's family. Zalle: No. ⁓ Nicholle: Right. She was the fourth body found in that field. She was 34 years old and a young mother who had reportedly left an abusive husband. Like Audrey, she was a Jane Doe when she was found and investigators called her Janet Doe. And like Audrey, she would remain unidentified for decades until 2019 when DNA and genetic genealogy finally gave her back her name. And just to think that she Zalle: She was the fourth mother of a man the field. She was 34 years old and had done medical care before she left in Houston, Like Audrey, she was a Jane Bell, she was a staff member and was a senior doctor at the time. And like Audrey, Nicholle: And everybody should be mad about it, whether you have money or you don't, because the thought you should just consider, they wouldn't care if you didn't have money. Like they still wouldn't care about your person. They're not doing this because they care so much about whoever your child is. They're doing it because you have the money to make it. Now as a parent, I wouldn't care. But after the situation, would, and I see that happening to other people to infuriate me. Zalle: Right. Yeah, completely. Nicholle: So we've touched on the investigative failures in previous episodes. ⁓ So we've touched on the investigative failures in previous episodes, but now I want to go through them in detail because understanding how this went wrong is the only way to prevent it from happening again. was reportedly leaving an abusive husband, getting out of that situation, and then she ends up dead in this field and nobody knows where she is or who she is for 33 years. Zalle: Know that it was so like so heartbreaking and I just want to point out a couple patterns that I have seen because this Helps you guys understand where my head is ⁓ as far as like the theories and stuff behind what's happening so far out of the four women right we have Laura we have Audrey we have Heidi ⁓ Yeah, we're going to go through the failures for this one because I mean all of the all cases have failures. Otherwise, there wouldn't be unsolved cases. Right. Where people, you know, false imprisonment or any of that. is everything has its failure. All of it. That's just part of life. You just live in life. You got failures. But I don't even know where to start with this one because I feel like Nicholle: that. Right. They wouldn't have no, there wouldn't be true crime podcast, unsolved mysteries. Yeah. Yeah, Laura, Audrey. Yeah. Zalle: Laura, do we we do we talked about Laura right? Laura, Audrey, yeah Laura, Audrey, Donna, okay so there that's more let me see sorry give me a second let me get my math together that's one Heidi, two Laura, three Audrey, and four Donna. So four so far. Nicholle: So many of the women who disappeared along the I-45 corridor were labeled runaways or troubled teens. Zalle: that we've already named a couple. Nicholle: down there. Some were sex workers, some came from low income or unstable backgrounds. And because of those labels, investigations were delayed. Missing person reports weren't filed immediately, searches weren't launched, media coverage was minimal at best. Right ⁓ Zalle: Two are Jane Doe's for over 30 years. Two of them are 30 years old and are supposed to be, are suspected to be in their 30s. And they're all four found within just a couple yards of each other in the exact same spot. And you are trying to tell me that there's no connection to that. Yeah, so that's what we were saying the vulnerability bias it should none of that should matter None of that should have anything to do with the runaways trouble team. First of all, how would you know about that? Just because somebody goes missing. Why would you automatically assume? there runaway are there a trouble team? Nicholle: Right, right, right. And it's not unique to this case though. It's a systematic issue, which is what we were saying. We're not pointing out any detectives or anything. This is an issue of how the system works. And it affects missing persons investigations across the country. When a victim is perceived as troubled or at risk, Zalle: to the age being, the age range of being the same, the location being the same, how their bodies were found being the same. It's a lot of same to not be a connection. Mmm. Yeah. Nicholle: And that they were found not only in the same field, but so close together. All of those things together. there's an unconscious assumption that they chose to disappear, that they'll come back, that the situation isn't urgent. But that assumption costs lives because the first hours and days after a disappearance are critical for evidence collection. For witnesses interviews, for tracking movements and delays cost evidence. And then lost evidence means cold trails. Zalle: Right. Nicholle: I mean, I realize we're looking back on it and they say, you know, hindsight is 20-20, but we're also not detectives. And I would just feel like even in 1980, whatever, you would still be able to reason these things out. After I find the fourth body in the same field, that is at least going to be a lane that I go down to try to see if there's something there. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Everybody knows that. You would still be able to repeat these things out after I've done the body and the body feels. That is a big lane that children have to try to take their time. I almost feel like because like watching the documentary there was, I cannot remember her name, but there was a woman who was speaking throughout the documentary. She's one of the main people speaking and she was saying about how Which sucks horribly. Why waste any time? That should automatically be, let's go, let's go, let's go. Let's look for the evidence. That's what we need to be doing. Let's figure it out. And if they had listened to like for Laura's situation, they had listened to the dad, then it would have been evidence in her. Her cause of death wouldn't have gone in as unknown, like because the animals and stuff had got to her and stuff. She had been out there so long. So I mean, Nicholle: Right. Yeah, exactly. ⁓ Zalle: like during the time when the fourth body was found, did DNA was around. They had the option to do DNA. But for some of the cases, for some of the discoveries, they could not because League City was doing such a bad job with their evidence that the evidence was destroyed. There was no DNA to test. They couldn't even go back and test it because they weren't doing a good job. So I feel like that is partially them trying to cover up. So in this case, what do you think maybe should have happened? Nicholle: Well, for me, it's clear that the immediate class of a classification as endangered missing persons is important. An immediate amber alerts are equivalent notifications and immediate search efforts because every disappearance should be treated as potentially life threatening until proven otherwise. Period. So what happened? That just makes it worse. Right. And I was going to say to clarify like we did on the first. Zalle: Like the shitty job that was being done. Not by everybody, but by those that were messing up. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: time that we did this episode. We're not necessarily speaking about individual investigators or police officers. This is more of a systematic failure for these people because they were vulnerable people. And as easy, as simple as this seems to put together, for me, it seems like it didn't matter. The effort just wasn't put there because these people were less dead than, you know, some Zalle: I agree. Nicholle: different departments handled different cases. Houston Police, Galveston County Sheriff's, Leek City Police, and each had their own files, their own systems, and their own priorities. There was no shared database, no way to cross reference disappearances across jurisdictions, and no way to see patterns that were staring them in the face. And I would just like to point out here that when we're talking about Houston Police and Galveston County Sheriff and Leek City Police, Zalle: Yeah. And as easy as see what things to put together. For me, it's like it didn't matter. The effort was worth it. There was this need for people who were the last hit. You know, some person wasn't homeless or on drugs or in a particular situation. Nobody really cared. And some people just wanted to know what had happened there. Nicholle: person that wasn't homeless or on drugs or in transition or whatever the situation, nobody was really caring because some of these people's families didn't even know what had happened to them. These are especially, we'll make it relational to Texas. These are close cities. know, it could take you an hour and a half, two hours, sometimes three hours to drive across Houston, depending on traffic and time of day and exactly where you're coming from and where you're going. But we're talking about right next to each other, these cities were. So it wouldn't be difficult. And ⁓ I'm assuming that the way, especially in small towns, people talk. Zalle: I mean, and it doesn't even matter the background information between all of it. It's how many murders or how many disappearances our bodies found and there's nothing. And this is just the beginning. These are just the four that brought the attention to it. It's not that there was nothing else happening. So that's the tip of the iceberg as they would say. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: right next to the city. Nicholle: Bye. Right. And so. ⁓ that the police had to hear at least the gossip, which should have triggered something. Zalle: I completely agree and if I'm remembering correctly in the documentary it was saying over the whole like the stretch of where all this is happening off of I-45 it was 11 jurisdictions involved in this so I mean that itself is insane that is a large amount of jurisdiction but to know that none of them are talking like Nicholle: These were women who, for one reason or another, weren't immediately missed in a way that triggered massive searches, women whose disappearances didn't make front page news, and women who, because of their circumstances, as I was saying, their backgrounds, their lifestyles, slipped through the cracks of a system that was supposed to protect them. And that is one of the most infuriating parts of this entire case. Zalle: It was devastating to hear Tim Miller say on the documentary that he felt like the police did everything in their job. Nicholle: Yeah. Right. Zalle: Nobody so a girl disappears in Galveston and then another in Leek City and then another in Houston and nobody connects them because nobody's talking so Nicholle: gallons big. ⁓ Right. Nobody's information. Nobody's... It doesn't to me, I don't know this for a fact, but it does not to me seem that these officers, that these departments were doing what they were supposed to do just in general. Because if you hear... I mean, I know small towns because I've lived in a few. People talk. Zalle: like in their will and in their power to make it feel like he was losing his mind and going crazy when he was trying to get them to go do these searches or like, hey, maybe these are these connections or whatever the case is. And that's horrible. And for it to just be like, go home, she'll call you. Like, and it seemed like so many of these women for the family who were there trying to make the effort to figure out what was going on, they just kept dismissing them. But that is what Headey's parents said. That's what Tay Miller was saying. Nicholle: Bye. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: Right. Exactly. ⁓ Zalle: Everything. Nicholle: People talk, even in schools, when you guys were in school in small, you know everything that's going on, whether it's the true story or not. So the police had to be hearing this and it's, I don't understand because each department is looking at their own case in isolation. They're not seeing the geographic cluttering. They're not seeing similar victim profiles. They're not seeing the pattern of serial offender operating along a highway corridor. Mm-hmm. Yeah. ⁓ So that makes it seems even more like a cover up because we don't want y'all to talk to each other. Either it is a cover up or this is massive ineptitude and laziness. It's one or the other. Zalle: the that it was like, yeah, we couldn't be in contact. Why would you, why would that be a thing to say? Right. Yeah. Which is crazy because I'm not a police officer and I picked up on all of that just watching the documentary or like even doing the research and looking into the different things. There are so many similarities and there are cases in like instances along the different situations where clearly it's not the same person. You know, they are not all connected. That is true. But there are strong connections between certain ones that were just Because I don't understand even if it's like, they're dealing with the loss. Wouldn't it be more beneficial for us to be in contact because we are going through the same thing? Like I lost a daughter the same way. Nicholle: Right. Where Right. And when did the cops ever said that? When did police officers start being therapists for victims' families? That's not what they do. So that's not why they were doing that in my mind. This is my opinion. But that's not why they were doing that. That wasn't their concern because they weren't concerned about these women. So they damn sure weren't concerned about their families. Zalle: That's not your job description. Yeah, that's I agree. Yeah. And to just disregard and push a dad like, yeah, whatever, we're not going to do that. That case has nothing to do with this. And like, you should just let me do my job. But like, if you were doing your job, I wouldn't have to do it. I wouldn't be here. Right, right. Yeah, so that's. Nicholle: Right. Right. Zalle: overlooked and I don't think that that should have happened. Nicholle: There's no, there's no reason it should have happened. What should have happened, which I think we've moved more into is a centralized tracking system. So our modern systems like NamUs, the national missing in unidentified person system exists now because of cases like this. But in the 1970s and 80s and even the 90s that court. Zalle: Mm-mm. Nicholle: Great. But you would be coming to me with these things. I wouldn't have to come to you. This is what we're doing now to find your daughter. This is what we're working on now. You will be coming to me with this information. I wouldn't be coming to you giving you ideas of what to do because that is literally your job. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. That is more than just your job. Correct. And that was just... Nicholle: Excuse me, I can't talk. That coordination didn't exist. Today, when a body is found or a person goes missing, it can be entered into NamUs and in cross-reference nationally. That technology could have changed everything in the Killing Fields case. Zalle: Yeah. complete disrespect and uncalled for from the officer who said it whoever it was that was handling Mr. Tam Miller. Uncalled for. Nicholle: Right. And to think about how helpless and frustrated you had to feel to the point where I no longer want, I don't want anyone else to feel how I feel in this situation and how the families that are going through this with me are feeling. So I'm going to do what I can and to help just strangers in this situation. I mean, it says a lot about him. Zalle: No, definitely, most definitely, especially if the officers were putting it to use. Nicholle: Right. if things like that definitely make it easier now. And even now we see that serial killer cases in particular are very hard to connect because the ⁓ killer doesn't often know the victims and the victims don't know each other. So it's hard to connect those things until you see the pattern. But I mean, we're talking four bodies in a small area of people, even if we just talk about the Caldera four. Zalle: Yeah. I mean for somebody who's like has personal experience with like missing persons because I had a close friend of mine go missing my freshman year in college over ⁓ Christmas break she just she never came back we we didn't hear from her we got fake text messages from the person she was supposed to be with it was like a whole thing so All right. Right, and then like I mentioned earlier, clearly was like crime scene mismanagement happening somewhere around here because I mean, no evidence, no DNA being able to be tested. Nicholle: So, I think I'm Zalle: I can understand the emotion he had originally, to be able to turn all of that. And then I definitely feel like what he was getting, the kickback he was getting from the police that definitely fueled that pain. It helped turn that into like, yeah, it helped turn that into I'm not going to let anybody else feel this way, regardless to what the police are or are not willing to do. I'm going to make sure that you know somebody out there. Yeah, that's amazing. That's amazing. Hats off to Tim Miller. Nicholle: Clearly. Yes. Right. Right. So what happened? The dump sites, particularly the Calder Roadfield, were not properly secured. Bodies were left exposed to the weather and environmental contamination, and evidence was lost to rain, to animals, to time. I guess we've got more to do. Yeah, and then determination. anybody else. There will be somebody to help. Yeah, there will be somebody to help. Zalle: How could you not protect the scenes like that that's literally what you need to solve these cases Nicholle: Yes, yes. So let's really talk about the distances because in this case geography is evidence and sometimes the only evidence we have. When I was first hearing that, like, are they referring to how the bodies were out in the field? Like they were just exposed to the elements. And so that was the breakdown. But no, I mean, of course that was a part of it, but we're talking about within the investigation, they didn't protect the scenes. And in some cases, the scenes weren't even recognized as crime scenes immediately. When Hedy Pye's skull was found by a dog, it took time to establish the full scope of what was in the field. Zalle: Yeah, sometimes. for this situation, like we keep saying that they were close. So we're going to tell you how close they were. Yeah, once they were discovered. Nicholle: exactly how close. So, Hedy Fye, again, found April 4th, 1984. She was the first body found. And then we have Laura Miller, who was found February 2nd, 1986. And she was 60 feet, or 18 meters, from Hedy Fye. By the time systematic searches were conducted, evidence had degraded. DNA had broken down. Vibors had washed away and trace evidence was gone. Zalle: 60 feet. Nicholle: Audrey Cook, same name, same search area near a tree. So within whatever this small search area was, because it had to be small because they didn't find Laura when they found Heidi. Well, no, it was a small search area because they were finding these people piecemeal. Not every, you know, these two were together and then later on they find somebody else, but these two are like just feet. Zalle: And so like not all of that is on the police. You know what I'm saying? Like them not being able to find Heidi's body or Hedy's body and right when they found the skull they had to go search for that. That's nothing that they could have done about that but that did affect the evidence that was out there not due to anything that the police or investigators had part of. Nicholle: Right. Right, right, absolutely. It is. Right. So what should happen in these types of cases, I would think, is you immediately control your perimeter. You know, you preserve the forensic evidence from the moment of the remains are discovered. Grid searches and evident collection protocols need to be followed. Zalle: Yeah, they were just feet from each other. They all were, and them. So it's crazy that they didn't find Laura and Audrey when they were searching, when they found Heidi because they were so close. If you watch the documentary on Netflix, they show you the like map with the pinpoints and how close they is literally like right there. Nicholle: Yeah. Modern forensic archaeology and anthropology techniques can recover evidence from even degraded scenes, but only if the scene is protected from further contamination. Right. ⁓ They're right there, right there. And then Donna Pru home, that was September 8th, 1991 in the same field. And she was discovered by horseback riders near Stardust Trail Rides. Zalle: And that makes me wonder if like when they were doing these searches, since they weren't finding these other women, like I feel like they should have, if they were doing the grid searches, like they should have, because I feel like you would have found them. They were so close to each other. ⁓ and then also all of the confessions throughout the investigation with all of these things happened. Like we said, this is years. Nicholle: Right, they would have found it. Right, right. So... ⁓ Zalle: which is in the same field and that is ⁓ the only business that was out there in this area off of Calderot. And like, so a very concentrated area. It's very close. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That's a trail ride. Mm-hmm. Yes. Extremely concentrated. All four bodies were found in the 3,000 block of Calder Road in the same abandoned field within a space you could walk across in minutes. And here's what the Netflix docu-series, Crime Scene, The Texas Killing Fields, emphasizes. This wasn't a random scattering. It's just crazy. Yeah. Yeah. And it's so many. It's just crazy. So Michael Lloyd self confessed to some of the early 1970s murders and law enforcement relied heavily on that confession. They built cases around it, but the confession was likely coerced. The details were inconsistent with physical evidence and so may have been innocent. So Zalle: Yes. And then the pay phones connect them to at least two of them. So they closed cases based on bad confessions, which is not unheard of. People have definitely done this for different reasons. Nicholle: This was a dumping ground. Someone or multiple someones knew this field, knew it was remote, knew it was accessible from I-45 and knew they could leave bodies there and they wouldn't be found immediately. Right, Heidi Fye and Lastine at a payphone and Laura Miller, Lastine at a payphone, both in Leek City, both visible and clearly both vulnerable. And I hope, right, right. And so, yes, there were cases that were closed based on a bad confession. And, you know, I think over the years, our law enforcement has realized that it's part of their job to see when someone is just confessing, you know, like these people who just go to these cases that aren't solved and just for some reason that I don't understand start confessing. Now, hopefully, you know, I think they have Yeah. Zalle: payphone. Nicholle: things in place where they can kind of suss that out. Like leaving information out of the news and things like that. Zalle: gotta find it Yeah, which I think is awesome tactic. Missing... Nicholle: Right, but in this case, them closing these cases based on that confession, they may have stopped looking for the real offender. They may have created a false sense of security in the we got the guy while the actual killer continued to operate. Zalle: Bye. Nicholle: Okay, thanks, I guess we'll just explain. Zalle: think so. which obviously in somewhere in some aspect that is what happened because there's no way this went on for as long as it did and you had who you needed to have. Nicholle: Right, clearly. So evidence first investigations are important. Confession should be corroborated with physical evidence, timeline analysis and witness statements. If the confession doesn't match the evidence, you don't build the case around the confession. You question the confession. And cases were treated as isolated incidents. So the serial pattern wasn't recognized for years, possibly decades. Zalle: Even with the four bodies all in the same field, that's the part. Because how is that pattern not recognized? None of that. Nicholle: You know, the fourth one, I don't know if you mean the same thing. That's the part. Right, because the field was a search systematically after Heady was, Heady 5 was found. Laura Miller wasn't found until a dedicated search was conducted two years later. Audrey Cook was found during that same search and she was a Jane Doe. So there was no missing persons report to connect to her. Donna Perth home wasn't found until 1991, five years after Lauren Audrey. I don't know if that makes sense. The pattern was there, but nobody saw it until it was too late. Zalle: Which is insane. And I feel like when they say there's no missing persons report, I believe that it's in what they had, like the system or database they had. I don't think that's everywhere. I don't think they had the like connected, like the database to connect everywhere or check like NAS and yeah. I think it was just what they had in League City or wherever she was found. that way that's what they mean when it says no person, missing persons report. Nicholle: and other jurisdictions if somebody is missing in their area. That's what they knew. It's not a person. And like the, was it Laura who had just moved to League City? They had just moved there. Right, so she was new in that area. So behavior and geographic profiling is necessary when multiple bodies are found in the same location. Zalle: had just moved there from Dickinson. Yeah. Nicholle: That should trigger immediate serial offender protocols. FBI involvement, BICAP, the Violent Criminal Apprehension Program should have been engaged. Those tools existed. They just weren't used. Why would you not? That just builds on the fact that there was either corruption or just inept police work. It was something. This goes even further than just a general breakdown because they had tools at Zalle: feel like I played that clip a little too long. I forgot to go to the clip on the computer. didn't go to the show. Let me... I'm gonna have go in there and take that out. should have been. Nicholle: I'm going go in there and take that out. Zalle: Which is crazy because I don't understand how it didn't trigger Nicholle: You want to edit that part so you know where it's at and it doesn't take forever to edit. Zalle: Right. I can stop and then I'll notice Nicholle: But the systems put the tools in place for them to use, but they weren't using it. Zalle: Yeah, yeah, and I think a lot of that was just because of what we were talking about already, the vulnerability bias and them not wanting to put those tools towards it. Nicholle: Thank you. They're feeling like they'll come back or these people disappear all the time. It's not worth our effort. Yeah. So expect, especially victims from low income backgrounds in unstable homes or marginalized communities, they receive less media coverage and less urgent law enforcement responses. That is not. Zalle: Yeah. For whatever ridiculous reasons. And that is not just these cases that we're talking about that happen so frequently and it is horrible. It's almost disgusting that that happens so frequently because. How you less dead? Yeah. Nicholle: And that we have a name for it, that people are less dead because that's how it's treated. That's horrible. That's horrible. So it's a major systematic issue that persists today. The missing white woman syndrome is a documented phenomenon. Certain victims receive disproportionate media attention while others are ignored. But the Texas Killing Fields case shows the deadly consequences of that bias. When victims aren't seen as worth searching for, killers operate with impunity. Zalle: Yeah, because who's pushing back when I know that you're not? Look, I got away with it this time. I got away with it the second time. And then I see these people getting away with, you know, attacking these people. Why wouldn't I get away with that? Nicholle: Hey! I found the perfect victim. Right. And for some serial killers, that's why they choose the people they choose, because it's easier because people aren't going to look for them. And even if their family says, hey, they're missing, the police don't respond. And it's important that we have equal response for every missing person, regardless of background, circumstances, or their perceived risk factors. Every disappearance is a potential homicide until proven otherwise. So that's where we are at the end of episode one. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Right. Yes, yes. Nicholle: We have a field, four women found there, two identified immediately, two Jane Doe's for over three decades, a corridor with 30 plus bodies over 50 years, a system that failed to see the patterns, failed to protect the vulnerable and failed to bring answers to families who deserved them. And we have pay phones, ordinary technology that became hunting grounds, 60 feet between two victims, a pattern hidden in plain sight. Zalle: breaking. Yeah, we have one, payphone. One payphone for two women and even that. No connection. Crazy. Next week, I'm going to be taking the lead and we're going to talk about the suspects because it's kind of juicy. Like that's where it's like, Nicholle: Right. And even though no connection. I hope we can really dig into some of the psychology of the type of people who do this. Zalle: Yeah, and the theories and like, okay, so do we agree or do we not agree? Nicholle: So. Right, right. So we'll be talking about Clyde Hedrick, James Elmore Jr. and Reese, I'm sorry, William Reese and Edward Harrell Bell. I cannot talk. And the theories about who did what, when and to whom. We're also going to talk about the forensic breakthroughs, the DNA, the genetic genealogy that finally started giving names back to the nameless. And we're going to talk about a father who refused to let his daughter's case go cold and how his refusal may have just cracked this thing wide open. Zalle: Yes, we're going to talk about Tim Miller, my favorite dad, dad of the galaxy. Nicholle: Right? That of the galaxy. So again guys, we'll see you next Monday for part two. ⁓ Follow us on all the socials. Follow, share, like, follow, review. Do all of the things. you see us somewhere, just hit all the buttons. Hit all of them. Zalle: share, like, comment. all of the buttons available except for the block. Nicholle: No, don't do the block, just the buttons. Don't hit the little three lines to go find things. So you're focusing on the wrong things, just the things right there in your face. Zalle: Right, right, right. And I'm super excited for next week because I like the genetic genealogy and the way they'll be able to do all of that with the DNA science is extremely, when they use it like that, it's extremely fascinating for me. So we'll see you guys next Monday and take care of yourselves. Nicholle: It's a great day and a lot of stuff. Bye guys! ⁓