Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 14 - AI agents hit checkout: ChatGPT shops for you, WTO tariff drama, and Amazon’s Big Spring push
Transcript
- 0:04[Max] Welcome to the Checkout Point,
- 0:06[Max] your quick dive into this week's e-commerce buzz with me,
- 0:09[Max] Alex,
- 0:10[Max] powered by Blikett.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends,
- 0:14[Max] news and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Hey everyone,
- 0:27[Rachel] welcome back to The Checkout Point.
- 0:29[Speaker 3] Yeah, yeah, good to be back.
- 0:31[Speaker 3] If you care about profit and not just vibes,
- 0:34[Speaker 3] you're in the right place.
- 0:35[Rachel] Vibes are off balance sheet anyway.
- 0:37[Rachel] Today,
- 0:38[Rachel] we've got a big one.
- 0:39[Speaker 3] Right. So first up,
- 0:41[Speaker 3] ChatGPT as a storefront.
- 0:43[Speaker 3] OpenAI flirted with one-click autonomous buying,
- 0:46[Speaker 3] then tapped the brakes.
- 0:47[Rachel] Yeah, and meanwhile Shopify,
- 0:48[Rachel] Walmart,
- 0:49[Rachel] Sephora,
- 0:50[Rachel] all piling into agentic commerce. We're talking like your olive oil reorders itself while you're cooking.
- 0:55[Speaker 3] Which you literally did.
- 0:57[Speaker 3] My question is, what do you even measure in that world?
- 1:00[Rachel] Exactly. Is it conversion,
- 1:02[Rachel] AOV,
- 1:02[Rachel] returns,
- 1:03[Rachel] margin risk,
- 1:04[Rachel] or who actually runs the store behind these agents?
- 1:07[Speaker 3] And who owns the mistake when the bot blows up your return rate?
- 1:11[Speaker 3] That's where I start watching KPIs like a hawk.
- 1:13[Rachel] Honestly,
- 1:14[Rachel] watching someone obsess over KPIs like a hawk, that's my comfort TV.
- 1:17[Rachel] I could do this all day.
- 1:18[Speaker 3] Laughing.
- 1:19[Speaker 3] Sad,
- 1:20[Speaker 3] but true.
- 1:20[Rachel] Then we're walking through a really practical framework.
- 1:23[Rachel] Go five rung AI ladder for merchants.
- 1:25[Rachel] Research,
- 1:26[Rachel] copy,
- 1:26[Rachel] creative,
- 1:27[Rachel] support,
- 1:27[Rachel] merchandising, and I get genuinely excited about frameworks like this, the kind that separate what should be automated from what actually needs a human calling the shots.
- 1:36[Speaker 3] We'll compare Shopify's Tinker toolkit with Genstores don't worry,
- 1:40[Speaker 3] we'll do it all pitch and draw a hard line,
- 1:43[Speaker 3] AI on low consequence stuff,
- 1:45[Speaker 3] humans on pricing and brand risk.
- 1:47[Rachel] If you've ever nerded out on CRO and unit economics like I have,
- 1:50[Rachel] I have this is the part where you're rewiring your playbook.
- 1:53[Speaker 3] And later,
- 1:54[Speaker 3] global fun.
- 1:55[Speaker 3] The WTO eCommerce moratorium might end,
- 1:58[Speaker 3] which basically means new digital tariffs trying to quietly eat your margins.
- 2:02[Rachel] We'll give you a three-step playbook to scenario plan,
- 2:05[Rachel] reprice, and actually talk to your customers without sparking a panic spiral email thread.
- 2:10[Speaker 3] Plus, quick hits on Amazon's Big Spring Sale,
- 2:13[Speaker 3] Reddit's new shopping tools,
- 2:14[Speaker 3] and how not to torture margin chasing short-
- 2:17[Speaker 3] Short-lived promo bumps.
- 2:18[Rachel] Alright, enough setup.
- 2:19[Rachel] Let's go.
- 2:20[Speaker 3] Wow.
- 2:21[Rachel] Let's get into Segment 1,
- 2:23[Rachel] agentic commerce and how ChatGPT just became your weird new store manager.
- 2:27[Speaker 3] Buckle up, here we go.
- 2:34[Rachel] Three easy ways to get your questions to us.
- 2:36[Rachel] Check the description for our web form,
- 2:38[Rachel] text us at 747-293-4612,
- 2:42[Rachel] or call the same number to leave a voice question.
- 2:45[Rachel] However you reach out, we can't wait to hear from you.
- 2:52[Rachel] Okay,
- 2:52[Rachel] so this is the moment where it stopped being theoretical for me.
- 2:56[Rachel] People are actually buying stuff inside ChatGPT now,
- 3:00[Rachel] not a demo,
- 3:00[Rachel] not a press release,
- 3:02[Rachel] real carts,
- 3:03[Rachel] real orders.
- 3:03[Speaker 3] Yeah,
- 3:04[Speaker 3] this jumped from cute AI toy to actual storefront fast,
- 3:08[Speaker 3] but I want to see the metrics before I believe it's real.
- 3:12[Rachel] Exactly.
- 3:12[Rachel] OpenAI basically backed off the pure one-click agent idea,
- 3:16[Rachel] that we'll just buy things for you in the background thing freaked people out.
- 3:20[Rachel] out loud.
- 3:20[Speaker 3] Right, because like nobody wants a mystery box charge on their card.
- 3:24[Speaker 3] What went wrong there in your mind?
- 3:26[Rachel] They skip the shopper brain.
- 3:28[Rachel] People want control.
- 3:29[Rachel] So now the flow is more guided.
- 3:31[Rachel] You say,
- 3:32[Rachel] I need running shoes,
- 3:33[Rachel] ChatGPT asks questions,
- 3:35[Rachel] shows options,
- 3:36[Rachel] you compare,
- 3:37[Rachel] then you choose.
- 3:38[Rachel] The agent helps,
- 3:39[Rachel] it doesn't secretly pull the trigger.
- 3:41[Speaker 3] So it's moved from rogue personal shopper to helpful store associate.
- 3:45[Speaker 3] See it in your phone.
- 3:46[Rachel] Yeah,
- 3:47[Rachel] and here's the wild part.
- 3:49[Rachel] Shopify stores plug right into that.
- 3:51[Rachel] The catalog,
- 3:52[Rachel] variants,
- 3:53[Rachel] inventory,
- 3:54[Rachel] all piped into ChatGPT as product options.
- 3:57[Speaker 3] So as a merchant,
- 3:58[Speaker 3] my PDP is basically getting rewritten as a conversation.
- 4:02[Rachel] Exactly.
- 4:03[Rachel] Instead of here's a grid of 48 products,
- 4:06[Rachel] the agent says,
- 4:07[Rachel] given what you told me,
- 4:09[Rachel] here are three that actually fit.
- 4:10[Speaker 3] Okay,
- 4:11[Speaker 3] tell the olive oil story because this is the moment that stopped.
- 4:14[Speaker 3] stopped feeling theoretical for you.
- 4:16[Rachel] Yeah,
- 4:17[Rachel] so I'm cooking,
- 4:18[Rachel] hands full of flour,
- 4:19[Rachel] realize I'm out of olive oil,
- 4:20[Rachel] I yell at my phone,
- 4:22[Rachel] order olive oil.
- 4:23[Rachel] The AI remembers my favorite brand,
- 4:25[Rachel] checks price across merchants,
- 4:26[Rachel] reads reviews,
- 4:27[Rachel] checks delivery time, and just buys it.
- 4:29[Rachel] Zero taps,
- 4:30[Rachel] zero apps.
- 4:31[Rachel] That's the moment I was like,
- 4:33[Rachel] okay,
- 4:33[Rachel] this is actually shipping.
- 4:35[Speaker 3] And now we're basically there,
- 4:37[Speaker 3] which means the operations behind it have to be
- 4:40[Speaker 3] be bulletproof.
- 4:40[Rachel] We're a half step away.
- 4:42[Rachel] Today,
- 4:43[Rachel] you'd say that to ChatGPT.
- 4:44[Rachel] It would surface a few options from Shopify merchants,
- 4:47[Rachel] maybe Walmart,
- 4:48[Rachel] maybe others.
- 4:49[Rachel] Ask this one and you say yes.
- 4:51[Rachel] That's the bridge between my messy kitchen and an actual merchant's checkout.
- 4:55[Speaker 3] Somewhere a DTC founder is screaming,
- 4:58[Speaker 3] but what about my carefully crafted homepage?
- 5:01[Rachel] Gone.
- 5:02[Rachel] The agent is the homepage,
- 5:03[Rachel] the PDP, the search bar.
- 5:05[Speaker 3] So as a merchant,
- 5:06[Speaker 3] my new job is feed the
- 5:08[Speaker 3] Feed that agent clean catalog data,
- 5:11[Speaker 3] great descriptions,
- 5:12[Speaker 3] real inventory and stop hoping.
- 5:14[Speaker 3] Garbage in,
- 5:15[Speaker 3] garbage out. I learned that the hard way.
- 5:17[Rachel] And structure the data.
- 5:19[Rachel] If your size chart is in some janky image or your materials are buried in a paragraph,
- 5:24[Rachel] the agent has nothing to work with.
- 5:26[Speaker 3] This is where your CRO brain kicks in.
- 5:28[Speaker 3] For years you were like,
- 5:30[Speaker 3] feed the algorithm your best stuff.
- 5:32[Rachel] Exactly. This is what I used to say in my CRO days:
- 5:35[Rachel] feed the algorithm your best stuff.
- 5:36[Rachel] Except now it's agents instead of Facebook.
- 5:39[Rachel] Messy data equals messy shelf placement.
- 5:42[Rachel] Period.
- 5:42[Speaker 3] OK,
- 5:43[Speaker 3] zoom out.
- 5:44[Speaker 3] It's not just OpenAI and Shopify.
- 5:46[Speaker 3] Walmart has Sparky. Sephora's playing with AI shopping,
- 5:49[Speaker 3] too.
- 5:50[Speaker 3] What are they trying to do here?
- 5:52[Rachel] They want the agent to carry the shopper from "I have a need"
- 5:55[Rachel] all the way to "cart is done," not just bolt a chatbot on the side.
- 5:59[Speaker 3] Yeah,
- 5:59[Speaker 3] so no more chat bubble in the corner that answers FAQs.
- 6:03[Speaker 3] We're talking full journey,
- 6:05[Speaker 3] search,
- 6:06[Speaker 3] compare,
- 6:06[Speaker 3] recommend,
- 6:07[Speaker 3] add to cart.
- 6:08[Rachel] Exactly.
- 6:09[Rachel] Walmart Sparky is like,
- 6:11[Rachel] I need snacks for a kid's birthday party.
- 6:13[Rachel] It builds a list,
- 6:14[Rachel] checks budget,
- 6:15[Rachel] swaps items.
- 6:16[Rachel] That is a cart building engine,
- 6:17[Rachel] not a support bot.
- 6:19[Speaker 3] And Sephora's version is,
- 6:21[Speaker 3] I have oily skin,
- 6:22[Speaker 3] I'm on camera a lot,
- 6:23[Speaker 3] I hate heavy foundation,
- 6:25[Speaker 3] and it builds a routine with shades,
- 6:27[Speaker 3] with add-ons.
- 6:28[Rachel] Yeah,
- 6:29[Rachel] merchants used to obsess over navigation.
- 6:31[Rachel] Is it in the header or the...
- 6:32[Rachel] After the sidebar,
- 6:33[Rachel] the agent says,
- 6:34[Rachel] "Forget the sitemap,
- 6:35[Rachel] just tell me your life and I'll figure out the basket.
- 6:38[Speaker 3] Okay; but I live in the P&L; what metrics should merchants actually track here?
- 6:43[Speaker 3] Because the AI seems cool does not pay the bills.
- 6:47[Speaker 3] I need conversion lift,
- 6:48[Speaker 3] AOV and net margin,
- 6:50[Speaker 3] period.
- 6:51[Rachel] Totally,
- 6:52[Rachel] and honestly the first metric I'd look at is conversion rate from agent conversation to cart completion.
- 6:58[Rachel] Does this flow close better than site traffic?
- 7:00[Max] because if it doesn't we're chasing novelty not business yeah
- 7:03[Rachel] And I'm immediately worried about attribution chaos.
- 7:06[Rachel] Who gets credit?
- 7:07[Rachel] The brand?
- 7:08[Rachel] Shopify?
- 7:09[Rachel] OpenAI?
- 7:10[Rachel] That matters when you're deciding where to spend money,
- 7:13[Rachel] and I've seen this movie at Walmart scale.
- 7:15[Max] attribution is going to be a mess you might see direct orders spike while your paid channels look worse even though the same people are just finishing in ChatGPT
- 7:24[Rachel] So I'd tell a merchant, treat this like a new performance channel.
- 7:28[Rachel] Track revenue and orders that originate from agent flows as their own line.
- 7:33[Rachel] Don't measure it,
- 7:34[Rachel] don't deploy it.
- 7:35[Max] Yep,
- 7:35[Max] and then compare AOV from agent driven carts versus your normal site traffic.
- 7:39[Max] I'm betting these skew higher because the agent naturally reads your full catalog and cross sells intelligently.
- 7:45[Rachel] I'm half with you:
- 7:46[Rachel] the agent is great at "Hey,
- 7:48[Rachel] you bought the serum—want the moisturizer too?" but it returns spike because the AI pushed the wrong shade or wrong size.
- 7:55[Rachel] that AOV bonus disappears.
- 7:57[Max] That's fair.
- 7:58[Max] So your metric set is conversion rate,
- 8:01[Max] AOV,
- 8:02[Max] attach rate of recommended items minus return rate on those recommendations.
- 8:06[Max] That's your measurement framework.
- 8:07[Rachel] Exactly.
- 8:08[Rachel] Don't just brag about AI-boosted AOV unless your net of refunds and customer support blowups.
- 8:15[Max] AI-sold five upsell sounds great until those five come back with angry emails and shot margins.
- 8:21[Rachel] Where I also worry is margin.
- 8:23[Rachel] If the agent always picks fastest shipping or most deluxe bundle,
- 8:28[Rachel] that might push customers into options that look great top line,
- 8:31[Rachel] but wreck contribution margin.
- 8:33[Max] So merchants need rules,
- 8:35[Max] like "Don't offer this bundle if discount plus shipping drops margin below x"
- 8:39[Max] or "Prefer products with high review counts,
- 8:42[Max] not just high price.
- 8:43[Rachel] Right.
- 8:43[Rachel] Think of it like merchandising guardrails for a super eager junior sales
- 8:47[Speaker 4] person.
- 8:47[Rachel] A salesperson who never sleeps.
- 8:49[Max] Love that.
- 8:50[Max] They're good at talking,
- 8:51[Max] you're good at setting boundaries.
- 8:53[Rachel] Okay,
- 8:53[Rachel] practical question:
- 8:54[Rachel] If I'm running a Shopify store right now,
- 8:57[Rachel] what's the first step to be ready for this ChatGPT storefront world?
- 9:01[Max] Step one,
- 9:02[Max] fix your product data.
- 9:03[Max] Titles,
- 9:03[Max] tags,
- 9:04[Max] materials,
- 9:04[Max] use cases,
- 9:05[Max] all clean.
- 9:07[Max] Step two,
- 9:07[Max] rewrite descriptions in plain language that actually answers what your customers want to know.
- 9:12[Max] Will this fit my carry on?
- 9:13[Max] Is this safe for sensitive skin?
- 9:14[Max] Again,
- 9:15[Max] get weird with specificity.
- 9:17[Rachel] And step three,
- 9:18[Rachel] from my side,
- 9:19[Rachel] define success-decide if this agent flow can drive x percent of revenue at y margin,
- 9:25[Rachel] I'll invest more in it.
- 9:26[Rachel] This isn't optional,
- 9:27[Rachel] it's how you avoid burning cash.
- 9:29[Max] And Honestly,
- 9:30[Max] test it like a shopper; go into ChatGPT,
- 9:33[Max] talk the way your customers talk and see if you show up.
- 9:36[Rachel] If you don't, that's your wakeup call-and it might be an expensive one.
- 9:40[Max] The thing that keeps hitting me is,
- 9:42[Max] we're all obsessing
- 9:43[Max] Passing over the agent talking to the customer; but behind that,
- 9:46[Max] someone still has to run inventory,
- 9:48[Max] pricing,
- 9:49[Max] support,
- 9:50[Max] campaigns.
- 9:51[Rachel] Yeah- if the front of the store is an AI,
- 9:54[Rachel] who's actually running the back of the store?
- 9:56[Max] And how much of that can be AI too,
- 9:58[Max] before you blow up margins or your brand?
- 10:00[Rachel] That's the question I want to dig into.
- 10:03[Rachel] AI owns the shopper conversation,
- 10:05[Rachel] but humans stay in the loop where the margin lives-that's the permission matrix.
- 10:09[Rachel] Thanks.
- 10:10[Speaker 3] He wandered down the street,
- 10:11[Speaker 3] the
- 10:11[Speaker 4] crowd of people growing thicker and thicker.
- 10:11[Speaker 3] He was in a strange city,
- 10:12[Speaker 3] and he was looking for a place to live.
- 10:14[Max] With that in mind, I want to flip to the inside of the store.
- 10:17[Rachel] Yeah,
- 10:18[Rachel] like who's actually running the back office when the bot just dropped an order on you?
- 10:22[Max] Exactly.
- 10:23[Max] So if you're listening and thinking,
- 10:24[Max] Cool,
- 10:25[Max] agents bring me customers,
- 10:26[Max] now what?
- 10:27[Max] There's a super practical AI ladder for merchants to climb.
- 10:30[Rachel] Okay,
- 10:31[Rachel] ladder sounds manageable.
- 10:32[Rachel] Walk me through it fast.
- 10:33[Max] Step one is research.
- 10:35[Max] Product ideas,
- 10:37[Max] keyword gaps,
- 10:37[Max] competitor angles.
- 10:39[Max] Have AI surface ten options on each,
- 10:41[Max] then you decide which.
- 10:42[Max] And which ones actually fit your brand and margins?
- 10:44[Rachel] So this is like the intern that never sleeps, just cranking raw material,
- 10:49[Rachel] but only if your product data is already garbage.
- 10:51[Rachel] Garbage in, garbage out.
- 10:53[Max] Yeah.
- 10:53[Max] Step two is copy. Product descriptions, emails,
- 10:57[Max] SMS,
- 10:58[Max] meta titles,
- 10:59[Max] the boring but profitable stuff.
- 11:00[Max] You still approve,
- 11:01[Max] you still tweak for brand.
- 11:03[Rachel] Step three, I'm guessing,
- 11:04[Rachel] is creative.
- 11:05[Max] Yep.
- 11:06[Max] Thumbnails, ad concepts,
- 11:08[Max] UGC script ideas.
- 11:09[Max] is even rough video storyboards.
- 11:11[Max] Not all of it ships,
- 11:13[Max] but it unblocks you.
- 11:14[Rachel] And then support.
- 11:16[Rachel] That's tier one automation,
- 11:17[Rachel] and I'm fine with it if the policies are locked down and escalation paths are clear.
- 11:22[Max] Right.
- 11:22[Max] Step four is support.
- 11:24[Max] Drafting responses,
- 11:26[Max] tagging intent,
- 11:27[Max] routing tickets.
- 11:28[Max] AI handles where is my order and how do I return with clear policies.
- 11:32[Rachel] What's the last rung?
- 11:33[Max] Basic merchandising.
- 11:35[Max] What should be homepage hero?
- 11:37[Max] What bundles actually move the needle?
- 11:38[Max] the needle.
- 11:39[Max] Stuff I spent years hunting for in Google Analytics back in my CRO days,
- 11:43[Max] except now AI does the grunt work.
- 11:45[Rachel] So for a small team, if they just climbed that ladder,
- 11:49[Rachel] they'd already feel like AI is running half their day.
- 11:52[Max] Exactly.
- 11:53[Max] You don't need a sci-fi warehouse of robots.
- 11:55[Max] You just need to stop writing every ticket reply from scratch at midnight.
- 11:59[Rachel] Okay,
- 11:59[Rachel] now tie that to actual tools,
- 12:01[Rachel] because right now everyone's inbox is like,
- 12:03[Rachel] try this AI thing.
- 12:04[Rachel] I think it'll change your life. And I'm like, show me the unit economics first.
- 12:09[Max] Yeah.
- 12:09[Max] So Shopify's new Tinker app is basically a big free starter box. It gives you access to a ton of mini tools and templates tied into your store.
- 12:18[Max] Product ideas,
- 12:19[Max] description generators,
- 12:21[Max] simple automations.
- 12:22[Rachel] So like, I want to test a new bundle and it helps you wire the basics without custom dev.
- 12:27[Max] Exactly.
- 12:28[Max] This is the feed the algorithm your best stuff philosophy.
- 12:31[Max] I've been preaching forever,
- 12:32[Max] except now it's agents instead of Facebook pixels.
- 12:35[Max] You draft ninety,
- 12:36[Max] approve the last ten percent,
- 12:38[Max] ship it.
- 12:38[Rachel] And you like it because it's inside Shopify,
- 12:41[Rachel] not fifteen random Chrome extensions.
- 12:44[Rachel] Consolidation beats fragmentation every time.
- 12:47[Rachel] Whoever controls the plumbing controls the margins.
- 12:49[Max] Yes,
- 12:50[Max] from a CRO brain,
- 12:51[Max] speed between idea and live test is everything.
- 12:55[Max] If Emergent can go from "That bundle might work"
- 12:58[Speaker 4] to
- 12:57[Max] To actual traffic in an hour that's the velocity advantage that moves real money.
- 13:03[Rachel] Okay,
- 13:03[Rachel] now contrast that with Genstore,
- 13:05[Rachel] because their pitch is basically,
- 13:07[Rachel] "Why climb a ladder when the elevator runs the entire building for you?" And I'm immediately suspicious of the word "entire.
- 13:15[Max] Yeah,
- 13:15[Max] their promise is wild:
- 13:17[Max] The idea is—you give the agent access to your catalog,
- 13:20[Max] ad accounts,
- 13:21[Max] email,
- 13:21[Max] support,
- 13:22[Max] even fulfillment rules.
- 13:23[Max] And it's supposed to optimize end to end.
- 13:26[Rachel] So not just write copy,
- 13:28[Rachel] but decide budget,
- 13:29[Rachel] launch campaign,
- 13:30[Rachel] adjust bids,
- 13:31[Rachel] change pricing?
- 13:32[Max] Exactly.
- 13:33[Max] In theory,
- 13:34[Max] it watches performance and acts like an operator,
- 13:37[Max] not a tool.
- 13:37[Rachel] Okay,
- 13:38[Rachel] so from your CRO days,
- 13:40[Rachel] where do you actually feel okay letting something like that drive?
- 13:43[Rachel] Because I need to know where the down side is contained.
- 13:46[Max] Ads is the easiest entry point—not brand strategy,
- 13:49[Max] just
- 13:50[Speaker 4] -
- 13:49[Max] Just create variations and daily budget tweaks inside hard constraints you set up front,
- 13:55[Max] like "don't bid above x," "hit this ROAS floor," "don't touch hero
- 14:00[Speaker 4] campaign," etc.
- 14:00[Max] Grow SKUs—Guardrails,
- 14:02[Max] not free rein!
- 14:03[Rachel] So you define constraints the agent plays inside the box.
- 14:07[Max] Yeah,
- 14:08[Max] same with product descriptions.
- 14:09[Max] Let AI draft ninety percent,
- 14:11[Max] you approve the last ten.
- 14:13[Max] That is low risk,
- 14:14[Max] high time savings.
- 14:15[Rachel] What about support?
- 14:17[Rachel] Where are the guardrails when the bot is deciding whether a customer actually qualifies for a refund or exception?
- 14:23[Max] I'm comfortable with AI running tier one support on clear,
- 14:26[Max] policy driven scenarios.
- 14:27[Max] Orders.
- 14:28[Max] Order status,
- 14:29[Max] basic how to,
- 14:30[Max] standard returns.
- 14:31[Max] You only jump in when it gets messy or the customer is upset.
- 14:35[Rachel] That lines up with what I've seen.
- 14:36[Rachel] You can automate a lot of where's my stuff without nuking your brand.
- 14:40[Max] Exactly.
- 14:41[Rachel] Now let me push.
- 14:42[Rachel] Where do you not want the robot touching the wheel?
- 14:45[Max] Pricing experiments with no human oversight,
- 14:48[Max] that actually scares me.
- 14:50[Max] Margin exposure,
- 14:51[Max] returns floods,
- 14:52[Max] fraud risk,
- 14:53[Max] and agent chasing conversion through aggressive discounts, you wake up.
- 14:56[Max] You wake up with a trashed warehouse and zero profit left to defend.
- 14:59[Rachel] Yeah,
- 15:00[Rachel] and it might juice short term numbers,
- 15:02[Rachel] then train customers to only buy at thirty percent off.
- 15:05[Rachel] We don't need AI making faster versions of expensive human mistakes.
- 15:09[Max] Totally.
- 15:10[Max] Same on merchandising big bets:
- 15:12[Max] swapping homepage hero products,
- 15:14[Max] changing shipping promises,
- 15:16[Max] turning on free returns everywhere.
- 15:18[Max] That stuff should be proposed by AI but approved by a human.
- 15:22[Rachel] I'd add approvals for anything that changes your risk profile.
- 15:24[Rachel] Well, return policies,
- 15:26[Rachel] fraud thresholds, even some post-purchase upsells. You might drive AOV and then quietly double your return rate.
- 15:34[Rachel] That's flying blind on actual margin.
- 15:36[Max] Yeah,
- 15:37[Max] you get this illusion of efficiency while your net margin falls off a cliff.
- 15:41[Rachel] So if I'm a merchant,
- 15:42[Rachel] my rule of thumb is AI can drive where the downside is time and mediocre copy.
- 15:48[Rachel] Humans stay in the loop where the downside is margin.
- 15:50[Rachel] An Inventory or Brand Trust
- 15:52[Max] That's the right filter.
- 15:54[Max] Ask yourself,
- 15:55[Max] if this goes sideways,
- 15:56[Max] do I lose hours of work or do I lose years of brand equity?
- 16:00[Max] Then set AI permissions based on that risk.
- 16:03[Rachel] And wherever you do let agents act,
- 16:05[Rachel] attach a simple KPI.
- 16:07[Rachel] This bot owns first response time and CSAT; this ad agent owns ROAS and new to file customers.
- 16:14[Rachel] No vague AI magic.
- 16:16[Rachel] Measure it or don't deploy it.
- 16:17[Max] Yeah,
- 16:18[Max] agents need a job description,
- 16:20[Max] not a vibe.
- 16:21[Rachel] Put that on a mug.
- 16:23[Max] With that in mind, there's another constraint nobody selling cross-border can ignore.
- 16:27[Rachel] You're talking about the WTO drama.
- 16:30[Max] Yeah,
- 16:30[Max] you can have the smartest agents and automations, but if digital tariffs change,
- 16:35[Max] the math on global orders shifts overnight.
- 16:37[Rachel] So next I want to dig into that eCommerce duties moratorium fight,
- 16:41[Rachel] because if that unravels, every pricing and margin model people just set with AI...
- 16:47[Rachel] has to be rerun.
- 16:48[Rachel] I've got battle scars from the old days of tariff surprises.
- 16:51[Max] Yeah,
- 16:52[Max] I spent years hunting landed costs across currencies,
- 16:55[Max] VAT rules,
- 16:57[Max] de minimis thresholds during international expansion.
- 17:00[Max] Every policy shift broke something.
- 17:02[Max] This WTO mess is exactly that chaos turned way back up.
- 17:06[Rachel] Stay with us,
- 17:07[Rachel] because this is the unsexy part that decides whether those shiny AI wins actually hit your bottom line.
- 17:13[Rachel] That's where I live.
- 17:20[Max] All right—flip that script; we've spent all this time talking about AI protecting your margins,
- 17:25[Max] now policy's about to attack them!
- 17:27[Rachel] Yeah,
- 17:28[Rachel] the boring sounding stuff that quietly nukes your P&L.
- 17:31[Rachel] Start with the WTO thing in plain English; no policy theater.
- 17:36[Max] All right, no law school needed.
- 17:38[Max] There's this WTO e-commerce moratorium,
- 17:41[Max] fancy term for countries agreed not to slap customs duties on digital products and online trade.
- 17:47[Rachel] So like downloads,
- 17:49[Rachel] SaaS,
- 17:50[Rachel] and cross-border digital services, right?
- 17:52[Max] Exactly.
- 17:53[Max] It set a norm that you don't tax every tiny cross-border digital sale like it's a physical import,
- 17:59[Max] kept a lot of stuff zero duty by default.
- 18:01[Max] Then the U.S. and India got stuck and the whole thing nearly fell apart.
- 18:05[Rachel] So what were they actually stuck on?
- 18:07[Rachel] Because that's where the real risk lives.
- 18:10[Max] India said,
- 18:11[Max] we're losing tariff revenue as stuff goes digital- we want options.
- 18:15[Max] The U.S. said, if you tax digital,
- 18:17[Max] you break global eCommerce.
- 18:18[Max] No compromise to the whole thing nearly expired.
- 18:22[Rachel] So,
- 18:22[Rachel] if it lapses, what changes for a merchant?
- 18:25[Max] Your cross border orders stop being clean and start looking like regular imports governments can tax.
- 18:31[Max] Countries could add new tariffs on digital products and some will extend that logic to physical eCommerce too.
- 18:37[Max] Net effect:
- 18:37[Max] higher landed cost,
- 18:39[Max] weirder rules,
- 18:40[Max] more paperwork.
- 18:41[Rachel] Uh,
- 18:42[Rachel] this is where my duties and taxes trauma from the Walmart days comes in.
- 18:45[Rachel] I spent years on this,
- 18:47[Rachel] mapped it,
- 18:48[Rachel] modeled it,
- 18:49[Rachel] thought we'd solved it,
- 18:50[Rachel] but policy never stops moving.
- 18:52[Max] Oh yeah,
- 18:53[Max] I spent years hunting landed costs across currencies,
- 18:56[Max] VAT thresholds, de minimis rules.
- 18:59[Max] Every time a country changed one thing,
- 19:01[Max] we'd break conversion funnels for a week.
- 19:03[Max] This WTO mess,
- 19:05[Max] it's like someone turned the entire chaos dial back.
- 19:07[Max] I'll back up.
- 19:08[Rachel] And the big risk is fragmentation.
- 19:10[Rachel] Each government tinkers with its own digital tariff rules.
- 19:14[Rachel] Your AI agent optimizes price all day,
- 19:16[Rachel] but if the policy moves overnight,
- 19:18[Rachel] you're flying blind on actual margin.
- 19:20[Max] Okay,
- 19:21[Max] so you're a bigger operator hearing this,
- 19:23[Max] you're not going to solve geopolitics. What do you actually do on Monday?
- 19:27[Rachel] On three moves:
- 19:29[Rachel] one,
- 19:29[Rachel] scenario planning,
- 19:31[Rachel] two,
- 19:31[Rachel] repricing rules,
- 19:32[Rachel] Three,
- 19:33[Rachel] transparent communication.
- 19:34[Rachel] That's the framework.
- 19:36[Max] Love it. Let me tease those out from Ops side.
- 19:39[Rachel] On scenario planning,
- 19:40[Rachel] you don't model every country—pick the top five by cross border volume and the ones where governments are loud about tariffs.
- 19:47[Rachel] Concentrate your math where it matters.
- 19:49[Max] Yeah; top five countries by cross border revenue.
- 19:52[Rachel] Mm-hmm.
- 19:52[Rachel] Within those,
- 19:53[Rachel] pick your high GMV SKUs and map it:
- 19:57[Rachel] Current Price,
- 19:58[Rachel] Landed Cost,
- 19:59[Rachel] Unit Margin.
- 20:00[Rachel] Add a column,
- 20:01[Rachel] What if another five to ten percent duty hits—that's your stress test bucket.
- 20:05[Max] And highlight anything where that extra duty kills more than a third of your margin—those are your stress test SKUs,
- 20:13[Max] the ones where policy can actually blow up your unit economics and your P&L.
- 20:17[Rachel] Exactly.
- 20:18[Rachel] Second lever is pricing rules:
- 20:20[Rachel] you don't want a human manually changing four hundred prices every time a policy guy sneezes.
- 20:26[Rachel] That's when you get garbage data and blind spend.
- 20:29[Max] No vague AI magic-set guardrails.
- 20:32[Max] So you set guardrails up front; if new duty in country acts is under three per cent,
- 20:37[Max] we absorb it; between three and seven,
- 20:39[Max] we split it; above seven we reprice and communicate; system executes,
- 20:44[Max] human sets the rules.
- 20:46[Rachel] And your system knows when to flip those switches.
- 20:48[Max] Right.
- 20:48[Rachel] Third is communication,
- 20:50[Rachel] where a lot of brands blow it.
- 20:52[Rachel] They hide costs and then wonder why repeat purchase rate tanks and brand trust craters.
- 20:57[Max] Yeah,
- 20:57[Max] they hide the cost,
- 20:59[Max] hope nobody notices.
- 21:00[Max] Then get absolutely roasted on Reddit when customs fees hit.
- 21:03[Max] Great way to kill repeat purchase rate and destroy brand trust.
- 21:07[Rachel] Firm—if your landed cost is going up,
- 21:10[Rachel] tell the customer at checkout.
- 21:12[Rachel] Better yet,
- 21:13[Rachel] test copy like "Includes new local import fee,
- 21:16[Rachel] no surprise bills at the door." Measure the conversion hit. It's usually smaller than you think.
- 21:21[Max] That line alone can move conversion because you're making a trade:
- 21:25[Max] slightly higher price,
- 21:26[Max] zero surprise anxiety.
- 21:28[Max] And honestly,
- 21:29[Max] that trade usually wins.
- 21:30[Rachel] One more for the large operator crowd:
- 21:33[Rachel] add up
- 21:33[Rachel] a policy risk column to your country's scorecard,
- 21:37[Rachel] not just CAC and AOV,
- 21:39[Rachel] but likelihood of new tariffs in the next year.
- 21:42[Rachel] That's how you actually score where to allocate inventory and logistics bets.
- 21:48[Max] And you weight that into decisions like where to open the next 3PL or localize a pull store instead of shipping cross border.
- 21:54[Rachel] Moving stock inside the country can be cheaper long-term than paying mystery duties forever.
- 21:59[Rachel] However,
- 21:59[Rachel] I modeled this at Walmart scale.
- 22:02[Rachel] If you're already near break-even,
- 22:04[Rachel] it works,
- 22:04[Rachel] but you need the volume.
- 22:06[Max] This is where the AI talk from earlier comes back – let AI crunch the scenarios all day long, that's what it's good for,
- 22:12[Max] but a human makes the call:
- 22:14[Max] two points of margin?
- 22:15[Max] We eat it.
- 22:16[Max] Ten points?
- 22:17[Max] Absolutely not.
- 22:18[Rachel] Right.
- 22:18[Rachel] Policy sets the playing field.
- 22:20[Rachel] Your job is deciding which games are still profitable.
- 22:24[Max] And speaking of games being played,
- 22:26[Max] there's a completely different way
- 22:27[Speaker 4] of doing business.
- 22:27[Max] different one happening right now.
- 22:29[Max] Amazon's running Big Spring,
- 22:31[Max] training shoppers to expect heavy discounts,
- 22:33[Max] and Reddit's quietly building high intent shopping channels inside niche communities.
- 22:38[Rachel] So next we should talk how to ride those waves for revenue without destroying the margins we just spent ten minutes protecting.
- 22:45[Rachel] That's the operator's real game.
- 22:47[Rachel] Short-term wins,
- 22:49[Rachel] long-term sanity.
- 22:50[Max] Short-term wins,
- 22:51[Max] long-term sanity.
- 22:52[Max] Let's get into the promos and performance next.
- 22:54[Max] NEXT.
- 22:59[Max] Shifting gears,
- 23:00[Max] I want to hit this Amazon Big Spring Sale thing head on.
- 23:04[Rachel] Yeah, go there,
- 23:05[Rachel] because my inbox is just like television screaming at me.
- 23:09[Rachel] Every discount is a margin question I need the math on. I can't operate in the dark.
- 23:13[Max] Exactly.
- 23:14[Max] The simple reality:
- 23:16[Max] Amazon is training shoppers to anchor on heavy discounts for big ticket electronics in March and April.
- 23:21[Max] Those reference prices are now burned into their brains.
- 23:24[Rachel] So if you sell TVs,
- 23:26[Rachel] headphones,
- 23:27[Rachel] laptops?
- 23:27[Rachel] You are now compared against Amazon's Spring Sale price,
- 23:31[Rachel] not your old list price.
- 23:33[Rachel] That's the new anchor—and it's brutal if you're not prepared.
- 23:36[Max] Right,
- 23:37[Max] and even if you're not on Amazon,
- 23:39[Max] people anchor on that discount.
- 23:40[Max] They Google your brand,
- 23:42[Max] see your price,
- 23:42[Max] and go,
- 23:43[Max] "Hmm,
- 23:43[Max] feels high.
- 23:44[Rachel] So what do you do if you cannot match those discounts without nuking margin?
- 23:49[Rachel] That's where most operators panic instead of think.
- 23:51[Max] Two moves.
- 23:52[Max] First,
- 23:53[Max] protect your hero SKUs. That's where your real margin lives.
- 23:56[Max] Lives—discount the accessories instead; full-ish margin on the laptop,
- 24:01[Max] sweeter deal on the case,
- 24:02[Max] dock,
- 24:03[Max] warranty.
- 24:04[Rachel] So basically shift the value story to the bundle,
- 24:07[Rachel] not the base item.
- 24:08[Rachel] Protect your hero margin,
- 24:09[Rachel] sweeten the accessories—that's real operating leverage.
- 24:12[Max] Exactly.
- 24:13[Max] Second move,
- 24:14[Max] non price perks.
- 24:16[Max] Faster shipping,
- 24:17[Max] extended returns,
- 24:18[Max] maybe set up support on electronics instead of torching another ten per cent off your margin.
- 24:23[Rachel] Yeah, service instead of straight margin burn,
- 24:26[Rachel] but measure the ROI on that service,
- 24:28[Rachel] don't just assume it sticks.
- 24:30[Max] And here's where I get nerdy: track attachment rate,
- 24:34[Max] blended margin per order,
- 24:35[Max] and crucially refund rate on those promo orders,
- 24:38[Max] because margin is just theory until returns eat it.
- 24:41[Rachel] Let me add one-liner contribution profit,
- 24:45[Rachel] not just ROAS.
- 24:46[Rachel] You might win the sale and lose on shipping or returns.
- 24:49[Rachel] That's money on fire,
- 24:51[Rachel] and you won't see it if you're staring at the wrong metric.
- 24:54[Max] Totally.
- 24:55[Max] OK,
- 24:55[Max] swing to Reddit because this is the opposite energy:
- 24:58[Max] tiny budgets,
- 24:59[Max] super high intent.
- 25:00[Rachel] Yeah!
- 25:01[Rachel] Reddit rolling out better eCommerce ad formats plus Shopify integration means you can actually target niche communities where people are already problem aware and ready to buy.
- 25:12[Rachel] High intent,
- 25:13[Rachel] low waste,
- 25:14[Rachel] that's the operator's dream.
- 25:16[Max] Like VR home theater crew shopping receivers or the r/skincare addiction debating sunscreens?
- 25:22[Rachel] Exactly—these people have ten tabs open before breakfast.
- 25:26[Max] So if I'm a brand,
- 25:27[Max] how do I test this without lighting money on fire?
- 25:30[Max] I need a clear KPI and hard budget caps,
- 25:32[Max] or it's just spend with hope.
- 25:34[Rachel] I'd start with one or two subreddits that literally describe your buyer profile.
- 25:38[Rachel] Run simple promoted posts.
- 25:39[Rachel] No fancy video production.
- 25:41[Rachel] Link to a tight landing page,
- 25:43[Rachel] not your home page.
- 25:44[Rachel] One variable at a time,
- 25:46[Rachel] always.
- 25:47[Max] And set a hard experiment box.
- 25:49[Max] Tiny daily budget,
- 25:50[Max] say a couple hundred total,
- 25:51[Max] one clear KPI like cost per add to cart,
- 25:54[Max] measure it or don't run it.
- 25:56[Rachel] Yes,
- 25:56[Rachel] and the creative has to sound like an authentic comment,
- 25:59[Rachel] not an ad.
- 26:00[Rachel] Tested three of these,
- 26:01[Rachel] this one actually solved my problem style.
- 26:04[Rachel] That's where the conversion happens.
- 26:05[Max] And please,
- 26:06[Max] for the love of ROAS,
- 26:07[Max] use UTM tags.
- 26:09[Max] You want to see,
- 26:10[Max] did Reddit traffic bounce?
- 26:11[Max] Did they add to cart?
- 26:12[Max] Did they actually buy?
- 26:13[Max] If you can't track it, you can't repeat it.
- 26:15[Rachel] Okay, so bring this home with a playbook.
- 26:17[Rachel] What are you testing this week if you run a store?
- 26:19[Rachel] And I mean real testing,
- 26:21[Rachel] not just spending.
- 26:22[Max] On Amazon or your own site,
- 26:24[Max] A-B test two offers.
- 26:25[Max] Version A,
- 26:26[Max] smaller discount plus free shipping.
- 26:29[Max] Version B,
- 26:29[Max] bigger discount but shipping costs money.
- 26:32[Max] Measure margin per order and conversion rate.
- 26:34[Rachel] Nice.
- 26:34[Rachel] That's real structured thinking.
- 26:36[Max] Second test,
- 26:37[Max] bundle versus solo.
- 26:39[Max] Run the hero product standalone,
- 26:40[Max] then as a bundle with accessories that f***.
- 26:42[Max] Is it feel like a deal; watch AOV and attachment,
- 26:45[Max] but also watch return rate on those bundles.
- 26:47[Rachel] OK,
- 26:48[Rachel] my side-on Reddit,
- 26:49[Rachel] one week probe,
- 26:50[Rachel] one subreddit,
- 26:51[Rachel] one message,
- 26:52[Rachel] one product.
- 26:53[Rachel] Cap spend,
- 26:54[Rachel] then judge it against your other prospecting channels on cost per Checkout initiated.
- 26:59[Rachel] Structured,
- 26:59[Rachel] measurable,
- 27:00[Rachel] done.
- 27:00[Max] And if it works,
- 27:02[Max] don't scale ten x overnight; add one more subreddit,
- 27:05[Max] test one new creative,
- 27:06[Max] and keep your eyes on contribution margin.
- 27:08[Max] margin.
- 27:08[Rachel] Exactly.
- 27:09[Rachel] Treat Amazon Sale as a pricing and offer lab.
- 27:12[Rachel] Treat Reddit as a targeting lab.
- 27:14[Rachel] Both need clear hypotheses and measurable wins,
- 27:17[Rachel] or you're just guessing.
- 27:18[Max] If you do that,
- 27:19[Max] you're not chasing sale noise,
- 27:20[Max] you're running actual experiments that make your P&L smarter next quarter.
- 27:24[Rachel] And that's how you survive promo season without your P&L getting torched.
- 27:28[Rachel] Structure beats hope.
- 27:29[Rachel] Measure it or don't run it.
- 27:36[Max] All right, I think that's a good place to stop before an AI agent actually ships someone another bottle of olive oil while they're literally listening to this.
- 27:44[Rachel] Please check your carts,
- 27:46[Rachel] people!
- 27:47[Rachel] But seriously,
- 27:48[Rachel] agentic commerce only works if shoppers still feel in control.
- 27:52[Rachel] That's the margin-safe version.
- 27:54[Max] Yeah.
- 27:54[Max] One-liner takeaway,
- 27:56[Max] treat AI agents like a new performance channel with rails,
- 27:59[Max] but keep your...
- 28:00[Max] humans owning the calls that actually move your margin.
- 28:03[Rachel] Exactly. If you remember anything,
- 28:05[Rachel] remember that.
- 28:06[Rachel] Start small on the AI ladder,
- 28:08[Rachel] measure revenue and margin from those flows separately (that's not optional), then level up.
- 28:14[Max] And seriously,
- 28:14[Max] if this helped you map out your own AI ladder or figure out your promo playbook,
- 28:19[Max] hit subscribe so you don't miss the next breakdown.
- 28:21[Rachel] Yeah,
- 28:21[Rachel] and share this with one operator friend wrestling with AI or margin pressure.
- 28:26[Rachel] We built this for people running the numbers at scale.
- 28:29[Max] Plus it tells every algorithm out there,
- 28:31[Max] human and machine,
- 28:32[Max] hey,
- 28:33[Max] this is the good nerdy eCommerce stuff we're here for.
- 28:35[Rachel] Thanks for hanging out with us during this weird in between phase where AI agents are almost running store operations.
- 28:42[Rachel] I've seen stranger things at scale,
- 28:44[Rachel] but not often.
- 28:45[Max] We'll be back next week with more experiments,
- 28:47[Max] more plays you can actually run,
- 28:49[Max] and I promise at least one fired up rant about value.
- 28:51[Max] What about budget waste or margin loss?
- 28:53[Rachel] Looking forward to it!
- 28:55[Rachel] Take care,
- 28:55[Rachel] and keep those margins healthy.
- 28:57[Rachel] It's the only math that really matters.
- 28:59[Max] See you at the next Checkout Point.