Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Bitcoin, AI, and the Credit Air Pocket with Michael Tanguma
Transcript
- 0:00Bitcoin 17 years 10 years is a $2 trillion asset and I could
- 0:05kill less with Bitcoin Trace for.
- 0:07It's just a matter of the money. The money.
- 0:11The money is bottom strength. In my view, because his entire
- 0:16mindset based on. Here's a different way to see
- 0:18the world will be owned. All of the good money in the
- 0:22world and you offer it to me for $25.
- 0:26I wouldn't take it because what would I do?
- 0:28Welcome back to Over the Horizon, a Bitcoin podcast.
- 0:30Today I'm joined by Michael Tanguma, founder and CEO at On
- 0:33Ramp. Michael, thank you so much for
- 0:34joining me then. Yeah, thanks for having me.
- 0:36It's late in the afternoon on Friday, so I'm sure we're both
- 0:38excited for the weekend. And so it's a good end of the
- 0:41day. I think Bitcoin hit 78 today at
- 0:43some point, now sitting around 77,000.
- 0:45That's right. Hopefully by the time we upload
- 0:47this on Tuesday, the price is relatively similar.
- 0:49But right now behind me it is 77,006.
- 0:52The S&P 500 just closed brand new all time high.
- 0:56I guess we could we could sort of start there and then we could
- 0:58dive into some of the stuff that we had prepared previously.
- 1:00Like what on earth do you think is behind this rally in in
- 1:03Bitcoin, obviously in the broader market isn't entirely
- 1:06related to the war. Is it something else?
- 1:08Like how do you view what's happening right now?
- 1:10It's a good question. I, I was texting some of the
- 1:12guys early like last week and I had this tweet that was meant to
- 1:15be tongue in cheek around bitlock boom and what was going
- 1:18on and the Spidey senses were tingling and it was relating it
- 1:21to, to Gary Leland having that. And the reason why was because
- 1:26part of that tweet was looking back at 2020 and it was really
- 1:29August that that conference went down.
- 1:30And then everything in 2020, if you think about Q3 and Q4, there
- 1:34were sailors stepping in publicly, there was Ross
- 1:36Stevens, there was NYDIG. And you just saw this left
- 1:39because we had been in this band below 10K, maybe teetered above
- 1:42it, but for years, since 17. And then the price took off and
- 1:45it did its thing and it feels very similar, similar kind of
- 1:49like I don't call it geopolitical conflict, but but
- 1:52the conflict and potential inflation and all the things
- 1:56associated what's happening in Iran.
- 1:58But I personally think what's where the Spidey senses were
- 2:02tingling on like we're ready to kind of like start to move up
- 2:05again was I felt that the price action has been an organic.
- 2:08I don't think it gets talked about enough that the bull run
- 2:11wasn't a proper bull run in all metrics from adoption to when
- 2:16you look at the heuristics. If you talk to anybody else
- 2:18selling hardware devices like usually get these uptrends and
- 2:21it's been down and to the right since 21 or 22, the blow off top
- 2:26that we had there. Another great example is like
- 2:28how many Bitcoin companies are have been like spawned off or
- 2:31new entrepreneurs? Like that's generally A
- 2:33catalyst. You have net new entrance, you
- 2:34have more adoption, you have more interesting products to
- 2:36come about. South point B is we never got
- 2:38the proper bull run. We never got the proper
- 2:40reflexivity for the market to do its thing.
- 2:42So we're not going to proper bear market either.
- 2:44What we're going to get is I think it's not popular to say
- 2:47because it sounds like coke, but ultimately in the same way gold
- 2:50has its version of manipulation. There is a version of pegging
- 2:55that price for a certain point because there's a lot of things
- 2:59that needed to get in place and what are those things?
- 3:01Morgan Stanley launching ETF is one of them.
- 3:03Charles Schwab launching Trading Clarity Act getting in place for
- 3:08a lot of institutions. There's no shortage of stuff
- 3:10with NASDAQ and securitizing tokenized assets every region
- 3:14across the world. Pakistan just came on.
- 3:16You got Hong Kong working on stable coin stuff.
- 3:18You got Switzerland working on stable coins, you have all this
- 3:21market structure in place and then Hyper Liquid is doing its
- 3:23thing and you know, defy or like outside the system, which is
- 3:27fascinating in itself because obviously don't hold any of this
- 3:30stuff. But I do think it's interesting
- 3:32how they're projecting. And I haven't read that colossal
- 3:35piece, Colossus piece on the founder of Hyper Liquid.
- 3:38But it's this idea that Tranfi really is like enamoured by it
- 3:42because of the 24/7 market. So you have all of these markets
- 3:46like commodities and potentially like secondary markets for like
- 3:50SpaceX and others trading on this thing that nobody you know
- 3:52manages. And it gives them insights into
- 3:55markets that are historically 9 to 5 S.
- 3:57Point being is you have all these things coming into place
- 4:00and I think once they were in those pipes were ready to go.
- 4:05Now you start to have to see the inflows and and I think it's
- 4:08going to coincide more than likely with a lot of you know,
- 4:11printing of money and then also interest rates having to lower
- 4:15at the same time. It definitely feels that way,
- 4:18like the institutional groundwork that's being laid.
- 4:21And on my main YouTube channel, I made several videos about this
- 4:24and they did really well. It was, you know, the first it
- 4:26was Morgan Stanley, right, $9 trillion in total global client
- 4:29assets launched their own Bitcoin ETF, clearly trying to
- 4:32start a fee war, 14 basis points undercutting the incumbent with
- 4:35I bet clearly they want to get in on this.
- 4:38Clearly it's for a reason to debt.
- 4:40And then you have, you know, on top of that Charles Schwab
- 4:42launching their crypto trading today crypto we we care about
- 4:46Bitcoin only. And then you've got Morgan
- 4:48Stanley also sort of dipping their toe in, though you're not
- 4:50Morgan Stanley rather, but Goldman Sachs sort of dipping
- 4:52their toe in the water with this premium income ETF.
- 4:55I'm of the belief that this is sort of like a trial balloon, if
- 4:57you will, a travel balloon isn't the right word, but testing the
- 5:00water to see if there's appetite for an eventual spot Bitcoin ETF
- 5:02of their own. So really it seems like the
- 5:04institutions are flooding in. You couple that with probably a
- 5:07little bit of insider trading or you know, Washington DC type
- 5:10trading. Sherry Biggs, representative
- 5:12from South Carolina, I believe today about 200th of Bitcoin or
- 5:15she disclosed a purchase of $250,000 worth of Bitcoin.
- 5:18So in my mind, chances are that tells me that this institute or
- 5:21this clarity out of Washington that we've been looking for as
- 5:24far as regulatory clarity is, is on the horizon here.
- 5:29So to me, it does feel like a pretty big move is coming up.
- 5:34You pair that with the Iran war. I was just talking to Lawrence
- 5:36Lombardi yesterday and we uploaded that show this morning.
- 5:39And he tends to think that what's happening right now with
- 5:42Iran is deliberate in an attempt to erode the value of the
- 5:47dollar, which to me 5050 not exactly sure, but in his mind,
- 5:52what he knows And, and you know, I'm, I'm sort of the same belief
- 5:55here that Trump and his base, he sort of, you know, by going to
- 5:59war with Iran, he, he went against the best wishes of his
- 6:02base. And now really all he has left
- 6:05heading into the midterms is markets.
- 6:07And so he's going to try to juice markets to the best of his
- 6:09ability. You also had Hank Paulson come
- 6:12out say that the Fed needs to have a backup plan in the event
- 6:16that demand for U.S. Treasuries dries up.
- 6:17I'm not sure if you've seen that clip, but that's pretty insane.
- 6:19He went on Bloomberg Wall Street week and, and talked about that.
- 6:22He was the guy engineer the response to the great financial
- 6:25crisis. So it seems like everything's
- 6:27really coming to a head now. I guess the one question for me,
- 6:30and I guess I'll pose it to you too, do you think that between
- 6:32now and when we see new Bitcoin all time highs, there will be
- 6:35sort of a zero to one event where we do see some sort of
- 6:38massive crash, a big print as it were?
- 6:40Or do you think that like a melt up rally now that the Iran war
- 6:43seems to be coming to an end as the path to least resistance?
- 6:46It's a great question because I think this maybe ties into the
- 6:49first part about without going into the geopolitical,
- 6:53geopolitical situation in politics, there is a real
- 6:56reality of what Larry's saying who's a good friend of we get
- 6:59trapped. And I think it's the same thing
- 7:01with the sailors and Shrek. Stuff we'll talk about later is
- 7:04there's 1D solution, there's 2D solutions or 2D takes, and
- 7:09there's three-dimensional. And generally the real world
- 7:11operates in the third dimension. But most people that we talked
- 7:14to that listener on Twitter or the second dimension, it's just
- 7:17enough to think you're clever, but not enough to actually know
- 7:19what's going on. And then the Dunning.
- 7:20Kruger. I guess I don't necessarily know
- 7:23what that is, but the first dimension is like CNN, right?
- 7:26And the second dimension is you go on Twitter and then the third
- 7:28dimension is like the actual truth.
- 7:30And so the angle there is like Elon Musk never understanding
- 7:34Bitcoin. It's like, so the guy that is
- 7:35the smartest, wealthiest person never understood proof of work
- 7:38and all that's like that. I don't believe it in the same
- 7:39way that so Trump doing what he did wasn't going to stop start
- 7:43this whole situation on round movement of commodities like oil
- 7:47and what that would have been from the lubrication of the
- 7:49whole global financial system. It's like doesn't make any
- 7:52sense. So I do think that there's a
- 7:54process in play there. Now the 2D3D layer on, do we get
- 7:59a crash before the run up? We saw that in 2020.
- 8:01So that was kind of the day's case a couple weeks ago where
- 8:04everything starts to seize up and you're like, this feels like
- 8:07it's going to hit a tipping point and we're going to get
- 8:09that real like March 2020 and a deleveraging moment before
- 8:13things really rally. I feel like that might be the 2D
- 8:16and I was in that camp. That might be the 2D logic
- 8:18versus the three-dimensional is like everyone's waiting for
- 8:20that. We don't see it.
- 8:21I don't, I truthfully don't know.
- 8:24What I do know is that if you look at the silent hand, the
- 8:30machine right is the commercial way.
- 8:31There is things that guide the global.
- 8:33You see ETFs launch and then everyone across the world starts
- 8:36to adopt digital assets and frameworks and and green light
- 8:39it in the same way that I've always felt with a high degree
- 8:42of certainty where I make a bet that clarity was going to get
- 8:44passed ultimately because everything you describe that the
- 8:47machine, it needs proliferation of dollars.
- 8:50They need demand for treasuries from a socio economic
- 8:54perspective in the US. They need an asset or assets
- 8:58that behave like sponges for liquidity that don't have the
- 9:02reflexivity of real estate inequities IE gold and BTC.
- 9:06Hence, ETFs getting launched because if you go back to the
- 9:10history of ETFs, there was back because I don't know how much
- 9:15you know about my history, but I've been in the space building
- 9:17since 2019-2020. And so you get very close to
- 9:21private clients that work at large institutions, large
- 9:23institutions. And people really forget from
- 9:262020 to 2022 when FTX, Celsius and all those firms fell apart.
- 9:30When you talk to people at Citadel, BlackRock and Coin and
- 9:34Fidelity and all these firms, they looked at Coinbase like a
- 9:37web three company. That's the way that they would
- 9:39discuss it. They would never trust them.
- 9:41This is pre Coinbase IPO and pre ETF and this is part of why EDX
- 9:46markets was stood up. It was a consortium between
- 9:48between Charles Schwab, Fidelity and Citadel.
- 9:52And that was the narrative and the atmosphere.
- 9:57And then 23, it all flipped and a lot of people likened it to or
- 10:01they referenced the GBTC and what was going on in the legal
- 10:06aspect, but it never fully sat right.
- 10:08Because when that flip the ETS for green light and Coinbase was
- 10:12the base for all of effectively all of them.
- 10:15The the two that aren't using them, I don't think they have
- 10:17any flows. But the point being is that
- 10:19there was a lot more embedded in my view with the ETS being
- 10:22launched, which was the understanding of a lot of the
- 10:24things that are going to play out.
- 10:25And you can even marry this back to, there was all these offshore
- 10:28derivatives exchanges that were really demonized.
- 10:32And then once we had this new administration and the new
- 10:35framework, everyone came into the fold, right?
- 10:37You look at Darabit was acquired, you look at like a lot
- 10:40of the market structure, everyone's cool with the way
- 10:42things are because the apparatus can wrap their arms around it
- 10:44from a legal, from a tax perspective.
- 10:46So what I'm sharing with you is you look at just all that
- 10:49pattern recognition and framework and you can see how
- 10:51this is a tactical strategic lever for the financial system.
- 10:57Still a small asset class compared to everything else.
- 11:00Like Bitcoin, 1.7 trillion, gold sits at 34 trillion.
- 11:04And there's a bunch of other things happening in the
- 11:06administration and very smart people's minds that need to be
- 11:08in place. So it's similar when Trump got
- 11:11into office, like we wanted all these things, but the reality
- 11:13was that there was an order of operations.
- 11:15And so I think that's what's just been playing out and that's
- 11:17why we didn't get the exciting 25 that we all wanted.
- 11:20But I do think nobody knows timing, but I think within the
- 11:23next 12 to 24 months we do get that kind of real exciting kind
- 11:27of like reflexive loop where you get the the real bull run.
- 11:31Yeah, it's certainly wager. You know, if I if I were a
- 11:33betting man, I'd say that that was the case because it just
- 11:36seems that all this groundwork is being laid.
- 11:39It has to have been laid for a reason.
- 11:40One of the things I want to ask you about, particularly about
- 11:43obviously, you know, you, you run on ramp and so self custody
- 11:46is a major, major aspect of of your day-to-day and what you're
- 11:49thinking about. How do you, how do you think
- 11:51about these new ETF launches? Right?
- 11:53Morgan Stanley coming into the fold, launch their own ETF.
- 11:57What do you think the role is that Bitcoin ETF play?
- 12:00I have long said for a couple of years now and now we're sort of
- 12:04starting to see it because Charles Schwab just launched
- 12:06spot Bitcoin trading at the ETFs are sort of the inroad for large
- 12:10pools of institutional capital, but also people who who just are
- 12:13just normal retail investors to get into Bitcoin.
- 12:16But over time, there's going to be a demand from those same
- 12:18people for spot Bitcoin exposure.
- 12:20Once they learn what the asset is, I've said that they'll come
- 12:23for the number, go up, they'll stay for the self sovereignty.
- 12:26Is that how you view ETFs or do you view them a little bit more
- 12:28adversarially? No, I think it's a really smart
- 12:31take. I think we're going to enjoy
- 12:32this combo because we haven't really discussed, I don't know
- 12:34how much you've heard, but we're I think aligned in and I'll give
- 12:37you, I'll add some more ammo or more wood behind that arrow in
- 12:40the sense of it's less on the sovereignty.
- 12:43It's ultimately the economic practicality of why you don't
- 12:46want to pull vehicle on a single party exchange.
- 12:49So if you, if you humor, humor me for a second, I'll give you
- 12:53some context into how and why we do what we do.
- 12:55So my background, I was actually maybe where some of these takes
- 12:58are interesting or different is I had a background in
- 13:00traditional tech. So I was like at like big
- 13:02companies like Google, YC back companies.
- 13:04I was with Adam Newman at Wework lighting money on fire in New
- 13:08York City while I was learning about money.
- 13:10That's kind of the joke is in 17 I was finding out about Bitcoin.
- 13:13I was reading the standard nights and weekends while I was
- 13:15just working in 18 hour days with Adam Newman.
- 13:18So I was learning about money while I was lighting on fire.
- 13:21And the point being is I adopted a material position meaning like
- 13:25majority of my wealth. And I had to realize or come to
- 13:30the conclusion, well, if I do this and I did this, I couldn't
- 13:33leave it on the third party exchange.
- 13:34At the time I was using Gemini, I was in New York.
- 13:37And you come to that conclusion because it's it's rational that
- 13:40you can't get knocked out of the game because you wake up the
- 13:42next day and it's gone and it can be gone because they don't
- 13:45like you. It can be gone because your
- 13:46phone was intercepted. It can be gone because they lost
- 13:48it. All right, so that led me down
- 13:50the journey of custody. I ended up becoming good friends
- 13:53with Parker Lewis joined Unchained and I built basically
- 13:55multi state collaborative custody for a few years.
- 13:58And there was a lot of learnings there.
- 14:00The main one was when FTX Celsius block file collapsed.
- 14:04It was this real like visceral moment of, oh God, not only did
- 14:08I see the like ceiling of self custody where people, I think
- 14:13that it's obviously what makes the system work, but I think
- 14:17that at the meta level, custody is a reason why people think
- 14:21Bitcoin is speculative at best and a Ponzi at worst.
- 14:24And what that means is because if you tell anybody about it
- 14:28that isn't, that just thinks you're crazy, it's because
- 14:32they're subconsciously understanding you're giving them
- 14:34a problem, not a solution, because you're first telling
- 14:37them there's a new form of money and a new thing to, to protect
- 14:39you. And now you're putting the
- 14:41agency on them to go figure it out and then manage it.
- 14:45When all they've ever heard is it ends up in landfills and ends
- 14:47up in North Korean wallets. It ends up re hypothecated FTX,
- 14:50like all these things. My grandma, God bless her soul,
- 14:53she texted me after knows very little what I do, but she texted
- 14:56me after FTX like, are you OK? It's like, I'm perfectly fine,
- 14:59but nobody understands that, right?
- 15:02So the core ideas, this is where the custody layer is the main
- 15:04focus. Because if you can figure that
- 15:06out and you can figure it out at scale, you have generational
- 15:10business to be built, but you also can really help people
- 15:13because the way I look at it is like Bitcoin is the best savings
- 15:15technology and then honor and provides the best savings
- 15:18account because you have to harness that technology.
- 15:20It's almost like nuclear. And if you just like get it and
- 15:22you don't know what to do with it, you can really blow yourself
- 15:24up. So where this ties into what you
- 15:26asked was built on chain 22, the market collapses and I started
- 15:31to look at the market structure and the market structures
- 15:34effectively the thing that's existed for thousands of years,
- 15:37you either have a third party custodian that holds the asset,
- 15:40which is existed for thousands of years.
- 15:42Somebody holds the horse and you got to go give him the gold if
- 15:44you want the horse. And that's similar if he's
- 15:46Coinbase holds the, you know, BTC metaphor gold, you got to
- 15:50send them the money. So there's nothing different
- 15:52there. It's just digital and then
- 15:54Bitcoin is a bearer instrument and we've had bearer instruments
- 15:57forever, but nobody tells anybody to take all of their
- 16:00gold or their dollars home. Yes, you can hold more of it in
- 16:02your hands, but you still end up with the same problems and why
- 16:05you needed a bank. Whether it's because you get
- 16:07cancer and pass away, whether it's inheritance, planning,
- 16:10dynasty, trust, E access to financial services.
- 16:12You don't want to get your family killed because somebody
- 16:14learns about your Bitcoin. All the things that are going to
- 16:16happen as the price runs to hundreds of thousands of
- 16:18dollars. This is what leads people to
- 16:20ETFs or other products that are easier.
- 16:23The point being is that if you look at that trajectory, you
- 16:27start to be concerned about an existential crisis for Bitcoin
- 16:29because worded gold failed. Anybody that really has a
- 16:32material allocation of Bitcoin, I would imagine had to
- 16:34underwrite gold and where gold sat on a global scale and how it
- 16:38underpinned money. And so you start to learn well
- 16:41it centralized and that was ultimately the problem.
- 16:44So you look at the trajectory, the trillions of dollars that
- 16:46we're going to come in our business was founded in 22 pre
- 16:50ETFs. So but it wasn't possible to
- 16:51forecast. You already saw what Grayscale
- 16:52had done in their trust pre ETFs that what happened in what or
- 16:57what was going to happen happened in that you're going to
- 16:59have trillions. I think the number in the past
- 17:0124 months, we went from 2% to 12% of all that coin is now held
- 17:05by Dats or ETFs and it was going to continue to happen because
- 17:09there's no other solution because those institutions
- 17:11aren't going into coal card ledgers and trezors.
- 17:14So that's how we thought about, that's how we funded.
- 17:16That's why we created on right now to your point, the most
- 17:20bullish thing for anybody that wants to build and what what I
- 17:23think we're building is Arthur Hayes was on a recent podcast.
- 17:27He's a little bit of a, you know, kind of out there, but he
- 17:29has some really good takes. He's been around for a long
- 17:31time. Is he referenced how he doesn't
- 17:33care about clarity or genius or all this crap.
- 17:36And he basically said because we don't need them.
- 17:39And he's saying that this is a retail driven phenomenon.
- 17:41It's been a retail driven phenomenon.
- 17:43And if you think about it, this is the part that gets missed by
- 17:45Triad Phi is because individuals are consensus of one.
- 17:49They don't need a board to figure out how to buy that coin
- 17:51and get into it. Retail holds the empirically the
- 17:55vast majority of Bitcoin in self custody.
- 17:57They're the most sophisticated because they knew they couldn't
- 17:59trust a third party custodian, but that was over time,
- 18:02education. And if they did trust a third
- 18:04party, more often than not, they lost all their Bitcoin block by
- 18:06Celsius, FTX, Genesis. You know, you can go down to the
- 18:09Mount Gox, Quadriga or you can go forever.
- 18:12So you see where I'm going with this, that like the entry point
- 18:15for retail, whether it's Strike Cash App or if the reason these
- 18:20institutions like Morgan Stanley and Fidelity and Goldman Sachs
- 18:23is because there's demand at the retail level.
- 18:25Now, retail is different for everything.
- 18:27It's not like crypto retail. This is like family offices and
- 18:29high net worth individuals that sold businesses.
- 18:31But the point being is retail drives this market.
- 18:34Institutions are building products for other institutions
- 18:36which are omnibus pooled wallets, No assurances, no
- 18:39insurance that covers it, all these things.
- 18:41But they're buying small slivers in the same way somebody buys a
- 18:45small sliver on cash App or strike right off the bat.
- 18:47When somebody gets serious about Bitcoin, they have to do what I
- 18:50talked about in 2018 that I did. I had to figure out the custody
- 18:53aspect because it's rational. If you're going to buy large
- 18:56amounts of Bitcoin, you got to understand how those keys are
- 18:59protected and you have to make sure you don't get knocked out
- 19:01of the game. You can't have a single point of
- 19:03failure. So all that's to say a long way
- 19:05is the ETFs are very bullish. It's they get people in.
- 19:09But the economically rational thing is the ETFs will leverage
- 19:12something like multi institution custody.
- 19:14The individuals will move over those assets, whether it's in
- 19:17kind, which will be allowed, or they'll just sell their shares,
- 19:19have to take the tax head, and then they will go into something
- 19:22that provides better assurances. I've no question that's the
- 19:25trajectory of the industry, because once your economic value
- 19:28is tied to that, the rational thing to do is to participate in
- 19:31something that you can't get knocked out of the game the next
- 19:33day because somebody effed it up.
- 19:36Fantastic. I think that's a really, really
- 19:37good pitch for multi institution custody just for those who are
- 19:40hearing about that term for the first time.
- 19:43I, I highly doubt people listening to a Bitcoin podcast
- 19:45haven't heard of you guys or multi institutional custody.
- 19:48But what, how does your setup differ from traditional
- 19:50collaborative custody setups that people may be more familiar
- 19:53with? And then, you know, what do you
- 19:56think is going to drive wealthy clients based on the
- 19:59conversations that you've had with them?
- 20:01What is the dominant reason that they're choosing you guys over
- 20:03allocating their capital to an ETF?
- 20:06Yeah. So most individuals are not at
- 20:09this stage if like we work with ultra sophisticated individuals,
- 20:14meaning and these are people that work at like the largest
- 20:17stratified firms that lead their research teams to people that
- 20:21hold thousands of Bitcoin. And so when I consider
- 20:23somebody's ultra sophisticated is the person that basically
- 20:26played hot potato, because I don't think there's anybody
- 20:28that's been in Bitcoin this long that still holds the underline
- 20:31in some form of custody that hasn't had to move it around
- 20:35because everything's failed them.
- 20:36Whether it's a third party, whether it's a data leak,
- 20:38whether it's a the Bitcoin price rose or their family grew and
- 20:42they can't get knocked out of the game for their wife has to
- 20:44be able to find it if they get hit by a bus and everything
- 20:46under the sun dynasty, trust, all of that.
- 20:48So the point being is we're like that end state.
- 20:51And it kind of makes sense because I was there, I had to
- 20:53live through it. I use this because I need my
- 20:55wife to be able to manage it. And so the notion of multi
- 20:58institution is really straightforward.
- 21:00It's multi sig, which is interoperable.
- 21:03It's whatever it's, it's the hardened infrastructure that
- 21:06almost powers almost every large custodial exchange.
- 21:09Think about Fidelity, Coinbase, Bitco and it's the same
- 21:12technology that collaborative custody providers would do like
- 21:15a Casa or Unchained, right? It's the only asset that has it
- 21:19built into the protocol. So it's not a smart contract.
- 21:21There's nothing that's proprietary about it.
- 21:24And that's very important because for anybody that does
- 21:26anything in Bitcoin, when you move over to a custodian, you
- 21:29ultimately want to know not only the reputation of them, but you
- 21:32want to know the architecture and you don't want to be
- 21:34proprietary. And if it's new, you need years
- 21:37of like battle testing and hardness before you go and adopt
- 21:40it because you don't necessarily know if there's anything wrong
- 21:42with that. So all we did with the
- 21:45difference between collaborative custody, the easiest way I
- 21:47describe it, and where we're at in bitcoins phase.
- 21:50And this is probably not popular, but I think we're like
- 21:52in a very much hobbyist phase right now.
- 21:53We're 17 years into this big thing.
- 21:56And what I like in the meetups, which have been a big part of a
- 22:00Parker and Austin and all things, I love all the bit
- 22:02corners. But I think of the meetups very
- 22:04similar to a parallel in 1970s and late 70s where you had a
- 22:08bunch of quasi nerds and they were all get together and they
- 22:10would fight over what does a hard drive look like and what
- 22:12does a motherboard look like and what does a RAM look like.
- 22:15And they were developing APC and we still have that.
- 22:17And that's more power to anybody.
- 22:19But the reality is to cross the chasm, something happened where
- 22:23you had commercial individuals and the easy people and there's
- 22:26compact and others, but the fun ones are like Gates and jobs.
- 22:28They said, well, what if we just ship the computer to the
- 22:30individual? Because there's an infinite
- 22:32amount of value that they get, They open it up, they do their
- 22:35thing, they close it and go back.
- 22:37And so that's what I think about on ramp and multi institution
- 22:39custody is it gives you like 10 to 100 acts, the security and
- 22:43assurances without any of the complexity.
- 22:45And we just ship Mac books. They just work.
- 22:47There's no viruses and the core idea is that those keys are held
- 22:51by multiple institutions that cannot unilaterally ever move
- 22:54the assets. And then you have the lead.
- 22:56So you have a technical construct, which means that no
- 22:59institution can move or lose. But then you have a legal
- 23:01construct, which means that the title of the bitcoins always
- 23:04yours. And then you have a legal
- 23:05relationship with each of the custodians.
- 23:07So we have this nice unified experience.
- 23:09It takes a couple minutes to onboard.
- 23:11Used to take Me 2 to 8 weeks to onboard.
- 23:12People, everyone listening here knows you got your seeds, you
- 23:15got your hardware device, and you got your wallet config
- 23:16files. You got to separate them all.
- 23:18You end up with a problem them because if you put them all in
- 23:20different places now, who has access to them?
- 23:22What if you travel, there's an attack service and you put them
- 23:24all in your room, You have that. I'm not saying it's not for
- 23:27everyone or there's not a nice barbell approach.
- 23:29It's just our approach has been that for a vast majority of
- 23:33people, as the price rises, they're going to run into the
- 23:36fact that inheritance, dynasty, trust, lending against it,
- 23:39access to financial services. And then also there's a real
- 23:43market structure problem that everyone doesn't like to talk
- 23:45about, which is nobody kidnaps Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg for
- 23:49their equity portfolio. But everyone knows you can go
- 23:52after crypto or Bitcoin holders because they're very close to
- 23:54the asset, whether they have it in multi Sega, they have it on
- 23:56Coinbase and multi institution doesn't solve that right off the
- 23:59bat because you can put time locks on a 7 day or 365.
- 24:03It's more of a legal time lock. There's nothing like technical.
- 24:05It's just you're saying that some of our clients say I don't
- 24:07want to move this for 365 a year and then I have to go meet you
- 24:12if I want to move it before then.
- 24:14But the point being is that you can.
- 24:17It's not until the market has this as a standardization layer,
- 24:21which I believe this is how the market will kind of standardize.
- 24:23And then you this is how you cross the chasm because then you
- 24:26never have the question of what if it's lost because I got hit
- 24:30by a bus or the custodian went down.
- 24:32The analogy like to positives or the example like to show is
- 24:36Bitcoin has such great product market fit from storing value
- 24:40that I got to $2 trillion without anybody credibly knowing
- 24:44tomorrow if it'll be there with 100% certainty.
- 24:47Phenomenal. I really, really like that
- 24:49analogy because ultimately those are the things that that really
- 24:53changed the world, right? Personal computing didn't take
- 24:55off because we were able to develop a hard drive that could
- 24:58do its job 100 times better. We we put it into a package that
- 25:02was end user ready and we shipped it.
- 25:04And ultimately that's sort of what you guys are doing.
- 25:06I really like that analogy. Speaking of which, what you guys
- 25:08are doing in on ramp, You guys have a major announcement today.
- 25:11Well, actually, you know, I'm, I'm learning about this in
- 25:13advance. I'm a lucky guy, but when people
- 25:15are hearing about this, the announcement will be live on
- 25:18ramp finance. So you're announcing that for
- 25:19the first time here. I'll go ahead and share my
- 25:21screen as well. I've got something to that you
- 25:23sent over, but for the viewers at home, what is it?
- 25:27I I pass the mic off to you. Yeah, I appreciate you sharing
- 25:30that in the sentiment around the crossing the chasm, because I
- 25:33truly am like the ideological crazy, you know, Bitcoiner in
- 25:37the sense of if you look behind me, I'm sitting on this
- 25:39property, you know, worried about all the things everyone's
- 25:41worried about. But the thing I kept running
- 25:43into is 99.9% of the world isn't there and they think we're all
- 25:47crazy and so we can wait for the market to come to us.
- 25:51And I believe as the market, you know, price appreciates and good
- 25:54things and bad things happen, it will come.
- 25:58A great example is in 22, I think we were sharing before we
- 26:01started recording or maybe it was the previous call.
- 26:02I've had a lot today. But it's this notion of out of
- 26:04all the AUM, the billions of dollars we brought into
- 26:07unchanged walls, 75% of it happened when FTX, Celsius and
- 26:10Block Fi. So it's the thing that people
- 26:13miss is liquidity is such a great thing in the sense of
- 26:15Bitcoins price, but all this risk gets inserted whether it's
- 26:19rehypothecation, physical attacks, digital attacks,
- 26:22insolvencies, all of that. And so we could wait for that to
- 26:26happen and then the market to understand it or we can go play
- 26:29offense and help to bring people into the fold into our platform.
- 26:33So the launch of Andre Fame and it is really to bring and bridge
- 26:36the gap to the rest of the world.
- 26:37It's bringing in dollar accounts earning up to 5%, earning cards
- 26:42where you can earn up to 1 1/2% to spend lowest cost Bitcoin
- 26:45brokerage, Iras lending basically a unified financial
- 26:49platform for existing clients. Anybody that's been thinking
- 26:52about multi institution, but then for everyone else that's
- 26:55not ready for multi institution, they can still get access to all
- 26:58this at no cost. And so we're incredibly excited
- 27:01about it because I think that all the platforms in Bitcoin do
- 27:04something really well, but it hasn't really been tied in and
- 27:07unified together. But the real kicker where our
- 27:10real ambitions are is how do we cross the chasm for the other
- 27:1299% that aren't even in Bitcoin that need access to dollars
- 27:16Bitcoin. And then we're also inserting
- 27:18Argo apartment bars or Spock family firm to get Spot gold
- 27:22exposure where you can take delivery if you want serial
- 27:24numbers. Because I think this is the big
- 27:26part that we miss on the Bitcoin side is as gold or liquidity
- 27:31comes in and inflation, the equence price does its thing,
- 27:34but gold is moving and it's going to continue to move.
- 27:37And everyone has their own risk profile and trajectory.
- 27:40This is the narrative of Stretch and MSTR and all the things that
- 27:44they can't handle the volatility.
- 27:46The way I see the future working, and this is the stuff
- 27:47we talked about with banks and I think our platform works, is you
- 27:50have your dollars, you get your interest on it, you get your
- 27:53rewards, you have low yield savings, which is your gold, you
- 27:56have it secured. And in this instance it's Royal
- 27:59Canadian. It will have other events and
- 28:01that's your low yield for people that are old that the guys love
- 28:04to talk about, people that are 80 years old.
- 28:06Well, I think gold's a lot better than holding, but we'll
- 28:08talk about the unsecured claims later.
- 28:10And then you have your high yield, which is your Bitcoin,
- 28:13and you go through that. And I think truly when this
- 28:17asset in this narrative understands of savings versus
- 28:20investing, this will just be in the background like that
- 28:23MacBook. It'll just be behind the scenes.
- 28:25You'll know it'll work because 3 is better than one, IE multi
- 28:28institution versus single custodian.
- 28:30And this is how you can just kind of help people preserve
- 28:32their wealth because I think that's the thing that gets lost
- 28:35in all of this is there's a fundamental difference between
- 28:38savings and investing. And that's the big lie and the
- 28:41big like dark matter that lives here.
- 28:42Everyone needs to go out and then they believe they have to
- 28:44invest. But you've already gone out and
- 28:46invested in risk your capital, meaning your personal time to
- 28:49make the money. It was just supposed to compound
- 28:51for you and in preserve your wealth.
- 28:54And so that's what really what we think of as the money
- 28:56platform of the future is how do we unify all that, the three
- 28:58forms of money, dollars, gold and Bitcoin.
- 29:01Dollars golden Bitcoin, I like you and you know, ultimately I
- 29:04really like that you guys integrated gold in there because
- 29:07a lot of older folks or even just general sound money
- 29:09advocates who may be younger on the Bitcoin side.
- 29:14One thing that I've found we were a lot better at than the
- 29:16gold bugs is the gold bugs love to integrate the bitcoiners
- 29:20about a lot of Bitcoiners. You included Larry Leopard
- 29:22myself as well. Like it's very clear if you're
- 29:25just an honest clear at a person that gold performs a very
- 29:28similar monetary function to Bitcoin when global liquidity
- 29:31expands, gold is a tremendous absorbent of that.
- 29:34Bitcoin just says that better. So the fact that you guys put
- 29:37that onto the platform really is a testament that what you guys
- 29:40are doing is trying to integrate sound money directly into
- 29:43people's day-to-day experience without excluding gold.
- 29:47What means you want to pursue this?
- 29:49What made what made this the next step for you guys instead
- 29:52of just going deeper into Bitcoin custody?
- 29:55It's a great question. One thing on this platform and
- 29:58on the website, shout out to your buddy Matt Ball.
- 30:01He joined on the design side. He worked incredibly hard on
- 30:04this, I call him Matty ball game because sometimes you start off,
- 30:07he starts off a little slow, but he always shows up at the end
- 30:10and he he crushed it on his design.
- 30:12So appreciate all the work he did on the the going in this
- 30:20direction. So this will be a nice trip down
- 30:23memory lane. I've wanted to do this for like
- 30:255 years. And the reality is one part, and
- 30:29I think this ties back to just being in traditional tech and
- 30:31like really seeing growth and scale is that it made rational
- 30:36sense for an individual and also just market adoption that you
- 30:39need to put dollars in a world where we have dollar denominated
- 30:42liabilities next to Bitcoin. Like that's amazing.
- 30:45And the reality though, was the administration in a lot of the,
- 30:50you know, like stigma around digital assets, specifically
- 30:53Bitcoin banks weren't willing to touch this.
- 30:55So I had this really interesting experience where because there's
- 30:59stuff we can go into if you want, we're like you can build a
- 31:01lot of products within a multi institution vault around
- 31:04lending. The product that I had this idea
- 31:06for was you can effectively have in multi institution like a
- 31:09loan, but you have a card issued against it.
- 31:11So we got accepted because I was connected with Kai Sheffield who
- 31:14leads Visas team and we are going to build that product
- 31:16where you can have Bitcoin in a multi institution vault.
- 31:19You can have a card and then so you have that collateral sitting
- 31:22there. You can run up that balance and
- 31:24then you can either pay it at the end of the month or roll the
- 31:27juice over, because it's kind of plain that our, well,
- 31:29inflation's running here. The interest is here.
- 31:31Maybe I don't spend my dollar to sack more Bitcoin, collateralize
- 31:33it. The point in sharing that is
- 31:35that took years, millions of dollars in compliance, all this
- 31:38stuff. And it all blew up because FTX
- 31:40blew up. And then all the banks got
- 31:42scared and all the banks that were willing to do this because
- 31:44there's a whole slew of issues about primary issuers and the
- 31:46bank merchant service and how you develop the car.
- 31:50So I had been thinking about that for a long time.
- 31:52Well, with the new administration, specifically
- 31:54with the Genius Act, knowing that the there's a green light
- 31:58around stable coins, new financial settlement,
- 32:00infrastructure strike. Getting into this, we developed
- 32:03a partnership with Stripe to basically power all of this
- 32:07infrastructure with clicks of APIs.
- 32:09And I mean, it's obviously a little more complex, but it was
- 32:11something that we could put together in months time that
- 32:14would have historically taken years and millions of dollars
- 32:17into. Once I found out we could do, it
- 32:20was like, Oh my God, we have to because we are already planning
- 32:22to launch trading in the accumulation because a lot of
- 32:25Bitcoin holders want to start just on accumulation before they
- 32:27get ready for multi institution. Felt like we got to pause this
- 32:30because the reality is we can embed so much more value for
- 32:33somebody when they can get dollars next to their trading
- 32:35and IRA and multi institution blending against it and then
- 32:37also being able to spend. And so it's just a rational
- 32:40thought. The only thing I'll share, and
- 32:42this is kudos to River because River just announced something
- 32:46on being able to offer cash yield or earn.
- 32:49And then also I think they'll pay is that I have no doubt that
- 32:53the companies of the future, there's a convergence that's
- 32:55going to happen with Travi naturally adopting these
- 32:58services because they want to retain client deposits and
- 33:01revenue. And then on the other side of
- 33:03it, if you're native to the space, you're going to have to
- 33:05meet them with similar products and build bit better and
- 33:08natively. Because the rational thing for
- 33:10those other 99% of people is if you have a mortgage and you have
- 33:13all these other things with the bank and they offer Bitcoin,
- 33:16even if it's marginally better or less better, it's not as good
- 33:19as a river. The rational thing for most
- 33:22people is to stay with that firm.
- 33:23So you really have to increase the experience, whether it's
- 33:26money movement or something like multi institution.
- 33:29And so we're coming in at both angles.
- 33:30What's funny now is not all the large institutions we talk with
- 33:33because when you're just a Bitcoin custody provider, they
- 33:35look at you a little funny like, oh, that's niche and cute.
- 33:38The second you bring in dollar deposits, there are ears perk up
- 33:41because that's what they're all trying to retain the client
- 33:42relationship in those dollar deposits.
- 33:45Fantastic, I love it. What?
- 33:46What? Why do you think that so many
- 33:49players are converging on this right now?
- 33:52Tether launched something very similar river in the app.
- 33:56Now I, I haven't done the bill pay thing yet.
- 33:59I don't think my wife would let me because she doesn't want us
- 34:02to, to sell any of our Bitcoin. But all of all of the major
- 34:06players in the space, all the smart people are suddenly
- 34:08converging on this architecture where you've got dollars, you've
- 34:11got gold, you've got Bitcoin. At the very least, you're,
- 34:13you're integrating traditional banking functions into your
- 34:17Bitcoin experience. Why do you think that's
- 34:19happening? What do you think it says about
- 34:21the future of finance? And also, I guess in the flip
- 34:22side too, I just, it just made me think of this at the same
- 34:25time that you guys are sort of becoming an everything app,
- 34:29Coinbase is also becoming everything app and a couple of
- 34:32other shops have done it, but in a different way.
- 34:34You guys are becoming more of an everything app for sound money
- 34:38and, you know, low time preference, whereas Coinbase is
- 34:41now added like prediction markets and sports betting.
- 34:43And same thing with Gemini. I get notifications because I
- 34:45have the Gemini credit card, which I might drop soon for this
- 34:49about like, you know, oh, the New York Knicks are up and I'm
- 34:52like, I don't care, right? This is an app that's supposed
- 34:54to be used for for investing in Bitcoin, But it's showing these
- 34:57things to me. I guess speak a little bit to
- 34:59the the the disparity there between like the direction that
- 35:02the Bitcoin and sound money firms are headed and then the
- 35:04direction that sort of these these crypto firms are headed.
- 35:07Yeah, I think this ties into like the notion of what's
- 35:09obvious is obviously wrong and also why there's very few like
- 35:13principles or Bitcoin only companies are companies with
- 35:16like Bitcoin centric financial services.
- 35:19It's because like there's been this real bar rail because we're
- 35:23so early to Bitcoin where you had the ideological principled
- 35:26individuals, but generally you had to have a couple screws
- 35:30loose to to get into Bitcoin that early.
- 35:32And so maybe those screws loose also probably didn't have you
- 35:35working at big companies and and thinking about
- 35:37commercialization. You're thinking about like got
- 35:39my citadel, my guns and I'm good to go.
- 35:40My cold car, I'm ready to rock'n'roll.
- 35:43And so you got the the story and even the book ends right.
- 35:46But it's like, how do I get from here to there and make money and
- 35:48meet the market? And then the other side, which
- 35:51you're referring to is like the Wall Street crypto Bros, the dab
- 35:54Bros, all the stuff on that side.
- 35:55It's like they read the Ford to the Bitcoin standard, but they
- 35:58never opened the book right and so or they never read gradually
- 36:02and suddenly there was like a tweet about the Bitcoin's the
- 36:04great de financialization. Everyone do real well in 2026.
- 36:08You go read partners graduate suddenly or just like that
- 36:10specific article, because when you break down from 1st
- 36:12principles, like if people just preserve their wealth, there's
- 36:15not a need to go speculate and that fundamentally is going to
- 36:17re architect a lot of how the system works.
- 36:19Not to say credit and financial services shouldn't exist.
- 36:22It's just the reality is going to look fundamentally different.
- 36:24And in that monetization phase, you don't want to get caught off
- 36:26sides, not holding the underlying.
- 36:28So that obvious is obviously wrong, leads to all this
- 36:31craziness because the only way to get funding, if you think
- 36:34about it, if you live in this world, that's incentivizing
- 36:36velocity of movement, diversification, private credit,
- 36:40and all the things associated with the SpaceX stuff in the
- 36:43secondaries and SP VS. That is all just a proxy for the
- 36:47amount of liquidity in the system that people have to go
- 36:49further and further out on the risk curve to justify the
- 36:51management fees or justify existing or justify how do I get
- 36:56a return above what inflation is because you're a sucker if you
- 36:58hold the money. And so that's what you have when
- 37:01you have Coinbase and you have Polymarket, you have all these
- 37:04things. They're being told that and they
- 37:05don't get funding, they don't get the traction, they don't get
- 37:07the narrative. So but the problem where they
- 37:10miss it, and this is really what I hold dearly, and a lot of this
- 37:13was learned from building before.
- 37:14This is financial services at the end of the day.
- 37:17And everything happening here is not technology based.
- 37:19It's not even necessarily money based.
- 37:21It's it's relationship based and if you don't have the
- 37:24relationships, you don't have brand, you don't have
- 37:26credibility. And This is why we're so adamant
- 37:28about the preservation and taking a conservative view to
- 37:31this because for 17 years, if you didn't, you lost all your
- 37:34Bitcoin. So we're willing to be wrong
- 37:36once in a while if that's the case.
- 37:37We probably don't think we are, but it's still OK because you're
- 37:39preserving the capital and Bitcoin's going to do its thing
- 37:42either way. And so really that's the view.
- 37:44And I think Leishman hold him in a high regard because he's
- 37:46always held that and he comes from that Silicon Valley
- 37:49background. So I think that's a testament to
- 37:50like what is embedded in a lot of what Rivers done.
- 37:54And then the only other thing is like tethered TBD on their
- 37:57intent long term. But from a sophistication level,
- 37:59they're easily one of the most sophisticated market
- 38:01participants. Like when you look at their
- 38:03balance sheet alone, being a head of the gold real estate,
- 38:06AI, compute and then BTC. And so it's rational that if
- 38:10they're that sophisticated, they developed this wallet you're
- 38:12referencing, it's a little bit different than what we're doing
- 38:15in the sense that this is more from emerging markets because
- 38:17it's the mobile phone itself, custody, it's tokenized gold,
- 38:20it's BTC in a hot wallet and then Tether.
- 38:23But it still serves an insane amount of value for a lot of
- 38:26people that don't have a banking relationship with ability.
- 38:29And where I think a lot of this goes and they know is that we
- 38:33end up going more to a free banking style world where the
- 38:36credibility of the institution underpins a lot of the
- 38:39relationship. But then also think about stable
- 38:42coins. If we end up in this world where
- 38:44stable coins are out there and there's going to be this
- 38:46credibility that's tied to them based on what's backing them and
- 38:50treasuries are backing them today.
- 38:52But if the dollar's cooked and treasuries are moving around and
- 38:54volatile, Tether understands you're going to have to back
- 38:58them with other sound assets. I the kicker goes all the way
- 39:01back full circle to how do you custody the BTC?
- 39:04Because if the credibility and the free floating of that stable
- 39:06coin is tied to the underlying bull.
- 39:08If it's lost now the credibility, this is the whole
- 39:11issue that goes, and maybe this is a good deal for your the DAT
- 39:14DAT area is like the very base layer of the DAT is like it all
- 39:19goes. It's all faulty because the
- 39:21custody is faulty. And so the second one DAT lost
- 39:24the custody, everything's because of the market.
- 39:26Retail market doesn't necessarily understand that the
- 39:28custody is a problem and it's been a problem for 17 years.
- 39:31I think there's a lot of people that weren't around in 22 or you
- 39:34just assume because we appeal to authority that like now Coinbase
- 39:37and Fidelity are and they just are infallible and you can't
- 39:39lose it. And it's just fundamentally like
- 39:40a false premise. And so anyway, that just, I
- 39:43think that's the angle around where the market goes.
- 39:47And then the beauty of what's obvious is obviously wrong, is
- 39:50that if you're right, it's the whole notion of, you know, hard
- 39:53choices, easy life, easy choices, hard life.
- 39:55If you take the harder path, on the other side of it is where
- 39:57the rewards are, because that credibility in the relationship
- 40:00is what drives the market to you if you've been doing things the
- 40:02right way the whole time. Beautiful.
- 40:05When you guys were developing this, my last question on this
- 40:08and then we'll we'll move into some of the other stuff we've
- 40:09got slated here. When someone hears like this is
- 40:14all in one platform. How do you how did you develop
- 40:17this in such a way where like you weren't adding a whole bunch
- 40:20of counterparty risk by integrating dollar deposits, by
- 40:22integrating your your multi institutional custody and the
- 40:25gold functionality as well. How did you sort of retain the
- 40:28no single point of failure ethos while you're developing this
- 40:31additional functionality for on ramp finance?
- 40:33It's a great question because it comes up a lot in like money
- 40:37movement. Naturally when you look at a lot
- 40:39of the proliferation of these new settlement layers for
- 40:42finance and dollars, you have this notion of money's going to
- 40:46start floating like I think all banks will have to offer similar
- 40:49what we're doing and passing back the interest and then
- 40:51better money movement. The example I use is like
- 40:53Mercury. Mercury is a multi billion
- 40:56dollar business. They didn't do anything
- 40:57different. They provided a better user
- 40:58experience for banking. So now you have these new rails
- 41:02that are just one to 1 backed. I would take the case that
- 41:05they're at least at par, if not more secure than a bank deposit,
- 41:08simply because a bank deposit, it's not yours, it's
- 41:10rehypothecated multiple times. These just sit in treasuries,
- 41:13right? So if we're ever going to offer
- 41:14dollars, we either had to become a bet, a bank or become a
- 41:17primary issuer like a circle to offer this.
- 41:20So we were always going to have a counterparty where we have to
- 41:23have the dollar Sitting in treasuries with the way we think
- 41:26about it is multi institution is the base level of cold storage
- 41:31for the money of the future. And so we started with the
- 41:35hardest part first, which is effectively how do I take those
- 41:38keys, segregate them with different institutions, take
- 41:40them offline. If anybody goes away, those
- 41:43assets are still secure. And then the idea is as capital
- 41:46comes into our system, it's to migrate it over from dollars to
- 41:50BTC or GLD. And the gold instance, the best
- 41:54you can get with gold is sovereign mitts.
- 41:57You can't multi say gold. A funny trail is this is the
- 42:00difference between Bitcoin and gold.
- 42:01It's not in my view, 2220 million 21.
- 42:05That's arbitrary. Fix supply.
- 42:06Not advocating for more inflation, but you can make the
- 42:09case you get inflation and still have a global reserve asset.
- 42:12The thing that will make Bitcoin successful is that you can
- 42:14insert governance at the asset layer.
- 42:16You can distribute those keys. And so gold can't do that.
- 42:20So the best we can do is have sovereign mints.
- 42:22I'm in the great state of Texas. We have our own bullying
- 42:24depository here. I would like over time to be
- 42:27able to park gold in the bullying depository there have
- 42:30cameras on isolated vehicles of that.
- 42:32So we can think through from a Bitcoin lens all of these
- 42:35properties. And I think that's what will
- 42:36make us different because everyone knows, like it's the
- 42:39same thing with AI where there's this dark forest component where
- 42:42there's all these bad actors online doing all these prompt
- 42:44injections and crazy things. Bitcoiners have had to be living
- 42:47in that world from an OPSEC perspective.
- 42:49So we take that Bitcoin centric view of security with the
- 42:52Bitcoin and then we layer it into any counterparty or
- 42:55anything else. We do I like it.
- 42:57I like that the ethos remains consistent throughout.
- 42:59I want I want to talk briefly about Oh yeah, go ahead, I.
- 43:02Just want to share one thing because this ties into you, you
- 43:04mentioned I think offline and then for anybody.
- 43:07So this is coming out right at the time.
- 43:10So there will be a slots available.
- 43:11I don't know if you saw this, but we have Genesis, which is
- 43:14the 210 first sign ups to get access to the highest reward
- 43:18tiers. But also anybody that's loves
- 43:20Parker Lewis, there's sign graduate and suddenly book a
- 43:23whole like swag packet, a bunch of other stuff that's on the
- 43:25landing page. I won't go through, but just
- 43:27something worth calling out because we wanted to make sure
- 43:30it's exciting for the market when we launch those.
- 43:33Perfect. Yeah.
- 43:33So the link to that will be in the description, Michael, if you
- 43:35just want to send me that after this, the link that will be in
- 43:37the description below. So be sure to sign up if this is
- 43:42if this is of interest to you. So you can get those exclusive
- 43:44parks and read more about that on the landing page there.
- 43:46I appreciate that, Michael. That's good, good marketing.
- 43:49So the one thing I, I, I do also want to touch on pivoting away
- 43:53from honor and finance is last week he got into a bit of a
- 43:55heated exchange with Matt Cole on X specifically talking about
- 44:00digital credit or what did what it's been dubbed right.
- 44:02It began last year with strategy.
- 44:05They have a huge balance sheet where the Bitcoin and began
- 44:07issuing preferred stocks and the 4th preferred stock that they'll
- 44:10end up issuing. Stretch has proven to be wildly
- 44:12successful. They've had several days last
- 44:15week where they were above a billion dollars in volume before
- 44:18the ex dividend date. Clearly it's proven to have a
- 44:20great deal of demand. You have a lot of folks who are
- 44:22doing the same thing. Strive has launched SATA here in
- 44:25the United States, paying I think 13% now at the time this
- 44:29recording. Metaplan is looking to do
- 44:30something similar. How do you view digital credit
- 44:34or just these preferred stocks generally in relation to
- 44:37Bitcoin? Are they a net positive for the
- 44:39space and that negative? Are people just misconstruing
- 44:42what they are? Sorry, I can't.
- 44:44I can't hear you. No just kidding.
- 44:46It remind me of I was talking about it yesterday wrong.
- 44:48Remember during the the COVID crisis where the guy was on that
- 44:52was. Hilarious.
- 44:53What does the company do? And he said I can't hear.
- 44:56You. Yeah, no, yeah.
- 44:58So maybe going back to how this started is there's two
- 45:01components to it. One of the main 1 is that
- 45:05because this is a retail driven phenomenon, like full stop, it's
- 45:08easy to get exposure. Individuals that a lot of the
- 45:13individuals that were influencers for these dads,
- 45:15they're all underwater. They targeted retail.
- 45:18No matter what they say from capital pulls, it's inconsistent
- 45:20because they'll reference volatility, but then their
- 45:23stocks are insanely volatile. And then you mentioned it
- 45:26before, I didn't know it was 82%.
- 45:28This the stretch is, is 82% driven by retail and retail if
- 45:33they're concerned about volatility, will there's other
- 45:35instruments that there's risk associated and I don't think
- 45:39you're getting compensated for the risk.
- 45:40That's the thing. I think it's fundamentally
- 45:41interesting. But where I take where I don't
- 45:45like the products and where I spoke out was ultimately wasn't
- 45:47even about any of the products. It was that I think that there's
- 45:49a better risk adjusted way, which is ultimately put out a
- 45:53tweet that you can park, you can pick your profile in whatever
- 45:56pool is volatile or concerning, and you can put that percentage
- 46:01in money market funds or now something like what we have here
- 46:04where you can earn up to 5% and then you can sweep the earn the
- 46:09rewards or you can take some of that percentage and put it in
- 46:12spot Bitcoin. And when you and we have a
- 46:14calculator now on the website, you can blend those rates and
- 46:17you end up with not only more USD or BTC because it's in cold
- 46:22storage. You don't have to use on rent
- 46:23for this. You can use anything you can go
- 46:24time for, you know, on your finance and take it into cold
- 46:27storage. But the point being is that you
- 46:29end up with a better risk adjusted return than putting it
- 46:34at risk in any of these theoretical products.
- 46:37And so when you mentioned digital credit, I think all of
- 46:39these things are theoretical at best.
- 46:40I think they're worse, but I won't, I won't say here.
- 46:42It's that in 17 years, you can effectively close your eyes and
- 46:47and put all the things you described and then all the
- 46:49things that have existed that Al for any kind of credit on top of
- 46:53Bitcoin and you could throw a dart and you would hit one that
- 46:56went belly up and everyone lost the money.
- 46:58So it's not to say that it will happen, but it's to say that
- 47:01it's not risk free and they're marketed at retail.
- 47:04And if you go back to the beginning of the pod, it's
- 47:06insanely hard for people to understand Bitcoin.
- 47:09It's really impossible. So when you take individuals
- 47:12that understand that that were thought to be influencers and
- 47:15then they they propagate and promote this thing.
- 47:18And The thing is that most people forget Bitcoin is this
- 47:22Platypus, this alien tech that doesn't fit within a 6040.
- 47:26It's not a it's not a bond, it's not an equity.
- 47:28So the market forces are always going to go in the favor of
- 47:31whatever the wrapper I can buy that looks more of what is like
- 47:35that. So you take this version of, oh,
- 47:37it's like Bitcoin, it's amplified Bitcoin.
- 47:38All these things are insane. They're not true.
- 47:40They're going to end up in a lot of misery.
- 47:42They're going to end up with a lot of people not holding any
- 47:44Bitcoin or less Bitcoin. And the beauty is if I'm wrong,
- 47:49adopt the thing and then Bitcoin was still going to do its thing.
- 47:51It's just like, do you want to be on that side?
- 47:53And specifically a capital at risk.
- 47:55So that's how the basic wing started was just effectively
- 47:57saying, look, you're not getting compensated for the risk.
- 47:59Take whatever you want. If you're concerned with
- 48:01volatility, park it in high yielding treasuries, take the
- 48:04rest in Bitcoin and cold stories.
- 48:05You reduce your counterparty risk.
- 48:06You still have a counterparty. It's the US government, but
- 48:08ideally they don't default and you just end up in a better
- 48:11position. And then that's effectively how
- 48:13it started. And we have a pretty
- 48:15sophisticated team. We have people we were on board
- 48:17of the first UK pensions. Glenn Cameron is a rock star.
- 48:19He sits in the United Kingdom. If anybody ever wants to like
- 48:23talk about it in like put together their thing and you can
- 48:26go on Twitter and see all this. It's pretty straightforward.
- 48:29And then he was going, I don't even understand it, but
- 48:31effectively last night explaining the arbitrage between
- 48:34the X division. And then when it goes up and
- 48:36like how it's not sustainable long term.
- 48:38I think we're going to put out a bunch of reports on this.
- 48:40It's just not propagated. And I guess the last thing is
- 48:43it's a retail driven thing. It's a inconsistent to say like
- 48:46the pools aren't there and then you go on Twitter and you have
- 48:51AI slop ads. That's a, you know, ad and it's
- 48:54like whatever sailors promoting or to whatever the next thing.
- 48:58That's why they spend all their time on Twitter.
- 49:00The funny part about that engagement is I don't really
- 49:01spend much time on Twitter. I was supposed to be on
- 49:04vacation, so I had my phone in front of me.
- 49:05So I was able to actually like be on be on Twitter and go back
- 49:09and forth. But it's just funny because I
- 49:10was like, I know Matt's all day long.
- 49:12That's what they do is they're out there like promoting the
- 49:14deal. And I was like, this is what
- 49:15they do all day. It's it's a sign when you had to
- 49:17get all the influencers to come promote your dad because it's a
- 49:21retail driven deal. If it was for an institutional
- 49:24market, you would go higher institutional people to sell the
- 49:27product. Gotcha, gotcha.
- 49:30You know, it's a it's a sensible take.
- 49:32I think it's balanced in my view.
- 49:33And curious to hear what what other folks think.
- 49:36And also if this gets clipped, because this podcast typically
- 49:38does get clipped. So if and when it does get
- 49:40clipped, we might get get reposted and have some people
- 49:43challenge you for a debate or something like that, which could
- 49:46be interesting. So, so to you, I mean looking at
- 49:49strategies website, one of the things that sticks out to me is
- 49:52that they have something like 42 years worth of dividend coverage
- 49:56across all of their preferreds with the current outstanding if
- 49:59Bitcoin did nothing to me, the premise of being able to package
- 50:04bitcoins typical CAGR, which over the last couple of years
- 50:07has been pretty disappointing, but it's pretty rational to say
- 50:112025% potentially over over a longer time frame into a fixed
- 50:15income product. To me that seems like a
- 50:19reasonable take. What you're saying is it's just
- 50:22a function of counterparty risk and not marketing this in good
- 50:27faith I suppose. Well, it's not even a good
- 50:29product when you think about like there's a lot of Fed speak,
- 50:33we talk where we have a lot of traffic guys, world class people
- 50:36from B&Y, Stifle, Brown brothers across the world, Goldman.
- 50:40And so we have a podcast and we talk about this stuff and I
- 50:42always have to like caveat or when we talk about two percent,
- 50:463% inflation, because everyone understands inflation is
- 50:48anywhere between 10 to 25% if not greater, specifically COVID,
- 50:51like post COVID event horizon from the amount of capital
- 50:54injected and everyone that knows anything understands it
- 50:57structurally, it has to increase and the velocity is only going
- 50:59up. So at best stretch or any of
- 51:03these products are keeping you right at par with inflation or
- 51:06maybe going backwards or maybe 1% above.
- 51:09So you're not getting compensated, you're staying
- 51:11static. So the notion is that a, you
- 51:15have, you're not keeping pace with where the market's going.
- 51:18When you look at everything layered into this, it goes to
- 51:22the same point of the ETFs where rationally, when you have real
- 51:25money, you don't park it into the system.
- 51:27It's contradictory move because you effectively take this asset
- 51:30that's in its monetization phase.
- 51:31You get all the aspects of private credit, gold and
- 51:34whatever, but you get the upside of all that.
- 51:36So the only thing to do is like make sure you preserve that
- 51:38capital at risk and you want the optionality.
- 51:41The Iran thing was one of the biggest movements because you
- 51:43look at the utilization of it to settle sovereign oil, which
- 51:46every sovereign needs. That's showing you that in the
- 51:49future you will need this, whether it's a gente, commerce
- 51:51or any other reason. So to give an offset, you can't
- 51:54eat your Strat, your Strat or whatever it's called, your
- 51:57stretch or your MSTR in this. But you can transact in dollars,
- 52:01you can transact in gold, you can transact in DTC if locally
- 52:05you need those units. So you're giving up the downside
- 52:08protection of any kind of air pockets in a system.
- 52:11Like a lot of the conversation last night was talking about
- 52:15global financial collapse or hyperinflation of the dollars.
- 52:17It's like, good luck with your dollar denominated liabilities
- 52:20in that ish in that situation. So you give all that away, you
- 52:23give away the ability to increase your purchasing power.
- 52:27Like Bitcoin already just moved up 10% in like 24 hours.
- 52:31So you give that upside, you're you're barely keeping pace and
- 52:34if inflation is going to continue to have to ramp, you're
- 52:37going to be working backwards on whatever percentage when you
- 52:40could have put your liquidity profile in treasuries, got some
- 52:43of those dollars and then you could have parked the rest in
- 52:45cold storage Bitcoin. And then if you're afraid of
- 52:49Bitcoin, well then that's a way you have to market and educate.
- 52:51But it's not to say like the market is going in this asset
- 52:54because they just look at people love Fiat.
- 52:58This is why the speculation works.
- 53:00And so if you tell somebody you get 11%, like I love it.
- 53:03And so that's like the the whole like I think trade off for the
- 53:06way it's not really articulated is there's just better products
- 53:09to effectively preserve your wealth.
- 53:13Got it. Thank you for giving your
- 53:14perspective. I really appreciate it.
- 53:16We, we have limited time here. We didn't even get a chance to
- 53:19touch on AI. But I suppose I'll ask you about
- 53:23about a couple of things before you have to go.
- 53:26Can I, can I share one more thing just on that?
- 53:27Is that the thing that's not, and this is honestly the, the
- 53:31biggest issue is you can make the case that MicroStrategy
- 53:38holding their assets at three different custodians is riskier
- 53:40than holding it at 1:00. Because the reality is that all
- 53:45of this becomes mute if any custodial situation happens.
- 53:48And this isn't crazy to say because for 17 years we took
- 53:51this whole podcast has been around custody and that the
- 53:53problem with it. So if you have 3 custodians now
- 53:56you have an attack surface 3 different ways it could go
- 53:58South. And if any of them are lost and
- 53:59any assets are lost, not only just confidence in the whole
- 54:01that whole system, any debt, but specifically that whole trade
- 54:05goes out. That's just the first level that
- 54:08never gets addressed and never gets talked about.
- 54:10If it was sound, all you would take is your 60 billion in your
- 54:13darling and you would park some capital in the same way they
- 54:15parked it for the stretch dividend and go develop a
- 54:18solution, put it on chain and verify it.
- 54:20That should be the red flag to start with everything because
- 54:23that false premise is built into it.
- 54:25Everyone else builds the dots and the narratives built on like
- 54:28what I effectively think of micro strategy is fundamentally
- 54:29different than everything else happened in that space.
- 54:31It's like the Immaculate Conception for Bitcoin.
- 54:33That's what MSTR is. And so you create a maze from
- 54:36bitcoins pristine thing and then Michael Saylor did this first
- 54:39thing and then everyone else is making that grift off the top
- 54:42and they make some money while everyone else is underwater.
- 54:45The problem is when you're underwater, it's like if you've
- 54:47ever played poker, when you get into a hand, there's at some
- 54:50cost balance. You keep throwing good money
- 54:51after bad, hoping that that amplified Bitcoin is not going
- 54:54to just keep amplifying to the downside.
- 54:57So the fact that custody doesn't get talked about tells you
- 55:00everything because if somebody would address it, build a better
- 55:02product, if they really believed in like what they were selling.
- 55:05Got it. Like so I want to ask you
- 55:07specifically about something that you mentioned you wanted to
- 55:09talk about this credit air pocket and you just mentioned it
- 55:12a moment ago and in your last, your last answer, AI is
- 55:15obviously extremely deflationary for the real economy.
- 55:19You know, you and I both know we live in this credit based
- 55:21monetary system where they need to continue extending credit in
- 55:24order for growth assumptions to hold true.
- 55:26Given that AI is deflationary for the real economy, what is
- 55:30the market missing? Right?
- 55:31It's kind of ironic that the market is, you know, celebrating
- 55:34a potential end of the war in Iran.
- 55:36It's at all time highs, but you have this force behind the
- 55:39scenes. Claude just launched a brand new
- 55:41product today. It seems like every single week
- 55:43it's launching a product that's destroying an entire sector of
- 55:46the US stock market. And it seems like nobody cares.
- 55:48On top of that, you have the credit component that that I'll
- 55:50let you speak to. But how are you thinking about
- 55:52AI as it as it plays in the US economic growth in the current
- 55:55credit based economy that that we reside in?
- 55:58Yeah, I think it happens to do with like the pattern
- 56:00recognition more of instincts and that if you've ever
- 56:04imagined, I know you have is like what would Bitcoin look
- 56:06like at $1,000,000 and like where are we at?
- 56:09And it's always felt instinctually right that the,
- 56:12the, the world be a little crazy, it'll be a little chaotic
- 56:14because just, regardless if it's 12 months or 12 years, that if
- 56:20that was happening, a lot of things are breaking or the
- 56:23market sentiment around this digital bare acid that came out
- 56:25of nowhere got to $1,000,000, that the, the zeitgeist in the
- 56:30atmosphere would be different. And so when I look at that or
- 56:33believe that and you see the acceleration of AI, it feels
- 56:36like that fills into its narrative of just the amount
- 56:40that you can do with less the ability where I think of like we
- 56:44talked about wanting to hold Bitcoin, I really think there's
- 56:47going to be a convergence of the store of value narrative and
- 56:49then the technology component and the store of value.
- 56:53The corollary or the tie into that is like settlement of
- 56:55sovereign commodities and oil and need for that.
- 56:58And then just bigger things, what regardless of what it is,
- 57:00you just need a mutual form of money that's, you know, easier
- 57:03to transport than gold. And then on the other side of
- 57:06it, I think in the next 12 to 24 months, it's going to accelerate
- 57:08where Bitcoin sits with these ingenetic layers because it's
- 57:11just better tooling and it's interoperable and it's not
- 57:13permission like a stablecoin is, even though I think stable coins
- 57:16will take the lead to start. And so you tie that into AII
- 57:21think it's just your point with Anthropic, the acceleration is
- 57:24just insane. I know you and most people
- 57:25listening, you're probably playing with it and we're all
- 57:27just barely like touching the surface.
- 57:29And so you tie that into what already was forecasted.
- 57:33When you hike up interest rates and you already have this over
- 57:35levered market that there's air pockets everywhere.
- 57:38You see the private credit seizing, you see what has
- 57:40happened to SVB like it's all over the world bail in's that
- 57:44we're not in a normal world where counterparty risk doesn't
- 57:47exist. And this is that whole notion
- 57:49around good. Speaking of which, I'll bring
- 57:51this quote up on screen. I'll actually share the screen,
- 57:54but it says, and this is from Apollo Global Management, chief
- 57:57economist. And he says that hedge funds now
- 57:59on roughly 8% of the entire 31 trillion U.S.
- 58:02Treasury market, up from 3% just five years ago.
- 58:06And it's been fueled by heavy borrowing with combined
- 58:09financing by repurchase agreements and prime brokerage
- 58:11is now exceeding $6 trillion. So this levered U.S.
- 58:14Treasury trade is another sort of pocket here where it's
- 58:17getting a little bit dicey. And you've also had, you also
- 58:19have Hank Paulson saying that the Fed needs to create a
- 58:22bailout plan for demand once it drives up in the US Treasury
- 58:25market. It seems like we're markets are
- 58:28sort of balancing on the head of a pin right now and they're more
- 58:30fragile than ever despite them being at all time highs.
- 58:33Yeah, it's exactly right. I mean, there's a little bit out
- 58:35of my domain and expertise, but if you go look at what's
- 58:37happening from a geopolitical perspective with oil, that if
- 58:41sovereigns need to find the capital for higher oil prices,
- 58:44they have they have to dump treasuries.
- 58:47That causes the Treasury yields to spike, which breaks
- 58:49everything. And I think the, again, going
- 58:52back to pattern recognition, you look at COVID because I think
- 58:54most people listening in the Western world, we said in the
- 58:57US, you could never have fathomed that they would lock
- 58:59everyone in a box and everything would just go completely
- 59:02haywire. Like everything is on the table.
- 59:04And so you have this world getting increasingly more
- 59:06chaotic and we just have lived in this random situation over
- 59:10the past X number of years where things have been stable, they've
- 59:13been relatively consistent. Larry Laporte's probably been
- 59:15the loudest cheerleader to where I think we love him begin.
- 59:17He loves us because sure, he talks about all the time, it's
- 59:20like he was fighting this fight all alone.
- 59:22And the gold bugs have one part, but they're almost like the the
- 59:25libertarian, like they love to lose where he wanted to win.
- 59:28And so that whole adage, he understands why gold is money.
- 59:34I had this article today. Gold and money and Bitcoin are
- 59:36money. Everything else is credit.
- 59:38That's been understood forever. But the reality is in this Fiat
- 59:40world, you layer in all these things and everyone miss prices.
- 59:43The counterparty risk. I've long held this, I've told
- 59:46me and Marty would go back and forth.
- 59:47It was around SVV specifically, but knowing what you know about
- 59:50everything in the financial system and the value of Bitcoin,
- 59:53what would be the number where you would take less Bitcoin in
- 59:56dollar terms, but Bitcoin versus a dollar sitting in a bank?
- 1:00:00Not to say and you have to sit there for 36 months or whatever
- 1:00:02it is. So like I like to just say, is
- 1:00:04it $1,000,000 in cash sitting at SVV or is it 500K in some
- 1:00:09outside way to hold your Bitcoin?
- 1:00:11Right, because that's the thing that gets mispriced.
- 1:00:13It's asymmetric in the truest sense that it's not only the
- 1:00:16upside you're getting, it's the downside you're protecting
- 1:00:18yourself against. And that's again, goes back to
- 1:00:21all the stuff we talked about before is it's just not
- 1:00:22rationally discussed that we live in this fragile time.
- 1:00:25And if you're going to take the inside money approach in a world
- 1:00:28where there's all these air pockets, it's the thing that
- 1:00:30makes your thesis right about inflation.
- 1:00:32Why Bitcoins valuable and where this digital credit narrative
- 1:00:36goes, It's the thing that also kills why you want the money in
- 1:00:39the system because all of that deleveraging, you don't want to
- 1:00:41be inside of that when it happens.
- 1:00:43Hence going back to bitcoins of great de financialization, we're
- 1:00:46going to get a lot worse and you're going to want to hold
- 1:00:48outside money before it gets better.
- 1:00:50And so I have no problem and idea that they'll be capital
- 1:00:53markets and credit that forms in Bitcoin.
- 1:00:55But do you want to be the first person doing that?
- 1:00:57Because you don't want to be the first person to block by
- 1:00:58Genesis, Celsius, FTX and whatever.
- 1:01:00Talk about AI. One thing that I've noticed is
- 1:01:04that it it genuinely, I wasn't really to Bitcoin for your
- 1:01:07reference, I came into Bitcoin I think 2021, so very, very late
- 1:01:10in the year. I had heard about it in 2020
- 1:01:12when we had cratered. My friend who now works at BTC
- 1:01:16Inc had told me all about this thing.
- 1:01:19I had ignored it. Price went from 3000 back up to
- 1:01:2210,000 after the crash. I, I had my eye on it and then
- 1:01:26it went from 10 to 60 made its first run at 60.
- 1:01:28And so that's why I came in. I came in quite late, but right
- 1:01:33now it feels almost like in AI. It feels very similar to what I
- 1:01:37imagined it felt being in Bitcoin in like 2011, 2012,
- 1:01:40where you have such a small portion of the population
- 1:01:44actually utilizing these tools effectively or even paying for
- 1:01:47these tools. Whereas it, it seems like .001%
- 1:01:52of the population is, you know, geeking out on the weekend,
- 1:01:56buying several instances of cloud credits throughout the day
- 1:01:58because they're running out. And at the same time, in tandem,
- 1:02:02you have Bitcoin adoption, right?
- 1:02:03So how do you square those two tracks happening at the exact
- 1:02:07same time? Where do you think we are as far
- 1:02:10as AI adoption is concerned and how do you think AI is going to
- 1:02:14inform the next wave of Bitcoin infrastructure over the next
- 1:02:185-10, twenty years? Yeah, there's a lot there.
- 1:02:21I think the one thing I'll share with you is you came at the
- 1:02:23perfect time. I truly believe the best time
- 1:02:25for somebody to get into the space and for the long term
- 1:02:28longevity of it is to go in on the upswing.
- 1:02:32Because when you're going in, as the price is running up,
- 1:02:35specifically closer to the top, if you write it on the way down
- 1:02:39and you're getting educated, you're prepared for everything
- 1:02:41else that comes out of it. It's generally where somebody
- 1:02:44buys at the top, they sell on the way down and then they're
- 1:02:47just, they're just burnt across the board.
- 1:02:50So, and I definitely don't think it's early.
- 1:02:52I know you hear the people say it, but it's, it's, we're still
- 1:02:54insanely early on the Bitcoin and AI front.
- 1:02:57You know, I've been doing this for a while and have a lot of
- 1:03:00thoughts and, and one of the articles I just need to start
- 1:03:02doing more like writing or, or talking and, or rating out with
- 1:03:05these tools is there's this notion of like Moore's law and
- 1:03:08Metcalf's law, where Metcalf's law is like X ^2 or whatever
- 1:03:12R-squared. And it's just the notion of like
- 1:03:14Ethernets and the amount of connectivity, the network.
- 1:03:17And Moore's law is like the inverse of that where you're
- 1:03:20like reducing semiconductor capacity and so reducing the
- 1:03:24cost. And that's really what caused
- 1:03:26the proliferation of what the society and technology we live
- 1:03:30in today, right? Because you connected people
- 1:03:31with computers and then you also added the ability for everyone
- 1:03:34to hold it. And now you can have an iPhone
- 1:03:36and, and all the stuff associated.
- 1:03:38So, but the kicker is that took like 30 to 40 years.
- 1:03:42We're living through that. Like whatever that law is
- 1:03:45squared with Bitcoin is the Metcalf's law in that world
- 1:03:50because the connectivity in the borderless perspective of like
- 1:03:53anybody can transact and move. And then that's Metcalf law.
- 1:03:57And then the Moore's law is the AI because you can do more with
- 1:03:59less. So you can bottle up more and
- 1:04:00more of that like nuclear energy of the intelligence.
- 1:04:04And so think about when you tie those two things on top of like
- 1:04:07technologies already existed and you could you let go together,
- 1:04:10This is what's going to cause it to move so much faster.
- 1:04:13And so I don't know if you know this, but we have a venture arm
- 1:04:15that's Bitcoin denominated. It was based on this whole
- 1:04:17premise. It's called early writers.
- 1:04:18It's the only Bitcoin denominated firm, but it was
- 1:04:21based on this premise because AI had saw liquidity in dollars
- 1:04:24just kill all businesses because you make you raise too much
- 1:04:27money and then it kills all the soundness and strategy in the
- 1:04:29business. So we built our business like
- 1:04:31bootstraps with my own balance sheet, my own Bitcoin.
- 1:04:33But we started this was right at the AI wave was starting to take
- 1:04:36off in 22. So we started to do a lot more
- 1:04:38with less leveraging all these tools because the whole game of
- 1:04:41this business has been to be a Bitcoin positive flow business
- 1:04:45to like print Bitcoin to build that scale.
- 1:04:47So we took the leanest approach and everything we did to the
- 1:04:49most like conservative and how we grew.
- 1:04:52And that gets you to the most like rational, inefficient way
- 1:04:56to build a business. And I think that this is really
- 1:04:59the biggest opportunity that exists, like on the planet earth
- 1:05:02is when the Bitcoin camp and the people that work at these firms
- 1:05:06with all the bureaucracy and all the fat that exists, when they
- 1:05:10lead those firms because they've been disenfranchised,
- 1:05:12marginalized, because that's what bureaucracy, everyone
- 1:05:14listening as I know this, I've hired the people I was that you
- 1:05:17know, where the world's going, you try to change it.
- 1:05:19I call it the carrot or stick. You first start with the carrot
- 1:05:22because you're trying to help the firm, try to get them to put
- 1:05:24their coin, the balance sheet, whatever it might be.
- 1:05:26And then the stick is OK, now I can RIP these shackles off,
- 1:05:30these golden handcuffs because I have a better form of money.
- 1:05:31I have a parachute to actually go and try something and you
- 1:05:35know where all of the dead bodies are buried so you can run
- 1:05:37back the playbook and you know the competition and you can
- 1:05:40build 10 to 100 X better and faster with 110th to one 100th
- 1:05:45of the cost. But the kicker is now you have a
- 1:05:47better store value on your balance sheet while everyone
- 1:05:50else is inflating away and they're having to increase their
- 1:05:52costs, reduce their margins. And you're playing with like the
- 1:05:55nuclear reactor of AI plus the nuclear reactor of money and
- 1:05:58Bitcoin. And that's the most interesting,
- 1:06:00like honestly, like business opportunity that exists because
- 1:06:03that's going to touch every industry across the world.
- 1:06:05And that's effectively like what we invested.
- 1:06:06I don't know. Did you know we did that or or
- 1:06:08no? No, Yeah, I know.
- 1:06:09Yeah, I'm aware. Of OK, well, I didn't know.
- 1:06:10I, I you set up the question really nicely, so I didn't know,
- 1:06:13but yeah. Oh, you're good, you're good.
- 1:06:15That's why that's it really is fascinating to see one of the
- 1:06:19one of the topics specifically regarding AI being a disruptive
- 1:06:22forces. All of the jobs that is going to
- 1:06:25destroy and all of the different companies is going to destroy
- 1:06:27being I suppose, like what is what?
- 1:06:29What sort of businesses or sectors in your mind are most at
- 1:06:32risk of being disrupted to the point of being completely?
- 1:06:39How do I phrase this correctly? I suppose you can think of it in
- 1:06:41one of two ways, right? One being like it's going to be
- 1:06:43this massive boom to productivity.
- 1:06:45It's going to invent entirely new sectors of the economy,
- 1:06:47which is true. But there's another school of
- 1:06:49thought that like in tandem with that, it's going to destroy
- 1:06:52areas of the economy, certain businesses, certain sectors in
- 1:06:56your mind, like how, how do you think about those two things?
- 1:06:59What sort of productivity gains is this going to bring about?
- 1:07:03And then also, if you've put any thought into it, what industries
- 1:07:07is this just just going to completely dematerialize and
- 1:07:09remove the need for entirely? Yeah, I don't, I maybe can get
- 1:07:14specific here. I think that the notion that I
- 1:07:16can add value or insights is like we I think believe in a
- 1:07:21maybe utopian version of there's some angle where everything's
- 1:07:25perfect for everyone, right? And I don't think we're in that.
- 1:07:28I think the way society evolves and technology evolves, it's
- 1:07:31like a fractal where it's centralized.
- 1:07:34You go back to wherever in the beginning and then it just
- 1:07:37naturally expands and expands and like the printing press is a
- 1:07:40good example and you open up the aperture for intelligence and
- 1:07:42education and that grows out and you get more and then you get
- 1:07:45like, you know, the Internet and you get money.
- 1:07:49And it's this notion of like, I think one of the parts is like,
- 1:07:52well, Bitcoin solves the this version of K shaped economy.
- 1:07:56Like it's a travesty, but it's also was always going to be a
- 1:07:58reality of that. There's people that have a lot
- 1:08:00of money. There's people that don't.
- 1:08:01I think that you get a democratization of the ability
- 1:08:04for more people get more like asymmetric power.
- 1:08:07The gun was a great example of it, encryptions another great
- 1:08:10example. So you're going to get, the
- 1:08:13point is like with AID material dematerializing jobs, you're
- 1:08:17going to get more people with agency, the ability to do more
- 1:08:20things. The problem is that I think it's
- 1:08:22Pareto distributed like all things in life, where you get
- 1:08:25more people that didn't have the opportunity, a chance to do
- 1:08:27something. But a lot of people are just not
- 1:08:28going to take it. I think it's a sad state of
- 1:08:30where you end up with Ubi and all this.
- 1:08:32And a great example that I like to think about that doesn't get
- 1:08:35talked about is the Western aspect of it, right?
- 1:08:37Because we've like offshored and sent out a lot of like key
- 1:08:42infrastructure and things to other countries.
- 1:08:46And then we had these jobs and we've had, you know, the product
- 1:08:49manager from COVID that, you know, was at the pool.
- 1:08:51Like that person's probably in a rough spot because she maybe
- 1:08:54didn't have the agency, didn't learn and have that grit.
- 1:08:57So we look at it from a Western lens, but think about it from
- 1:09:00the other side, where now those jobs are open to anybody.
- 1:09:04You add Starlink so you have an Internet connection.
- 1:09:07You had a global form of money that anybody can have.
- 1:09:09You have a form of intelligence that anybody can have that
- 1:09:11compute on their phone in the future.
- 1:09:14And what does that mean from a societal perspective?
- 1:09:16We're just going to like kind of change the shifting of power and
- 1:09:19who has that, And they'll be winners, they'll be losers.
- 1:09:21I think on the net, net, you end up with more winners.
- 1:09:24And that's just how society forms.
- 1:09:25But we don't end up in this world where everyone's like
- 1:09:28living with hot universal high income or whatever.
- 1:09:31Right. Yeah.
- 1:09:31It it's sort of you see this bifurcation accelerate where you
- 1:09:35have high agency, high IQ individuals, you know, building
- 1:09:38digital cathedrals as it were, and then low agency, low IQ
- 1:09:42individuals or just people who just, you know, don't have that
- 1:09:45get up and go per SE, who just don't use the tools in front of
- 1:09:48them. And then as a result, we have
- 1:09:49massive productivity gains over here.
- 1:09:51But then for some people, they're just as destitute as
- 1:09:54they are today. It's unfortunate, right?
- 1:09:56You can lead a horse to water, you can't make them drink.
- 1:09:58You can create literally the best product market fit tool of
- 1:10:02all time clawed, install it on somebody's machine.
- 1:10:05And if they don't have the willingness and desire to learn
- 1:10:07about it and learn how to improve their life, learn how to
- 1:10:09build a business, then nothing will come of it.
- 1:10:12I think that's exactly right. And I think that's like the sad
- 1:10:14part of stable coins and centralized issuance of things
- 1:10:18that it reminds me of like encryption in the Internet.
- 1:10:20It's like you have this technology that's super
- 1:10:22asymmetric, but a lot of people won't necessarily think about
- 1:10:24how many things we do and knowing the things we do that we
- 1:10:26shouldn't when it comes to Google and all that because it's
- 1:10:28convenient. And so it's similar going to be
- 1:10:31with the money. But on the net, net, it gives
- 1:10:33more power, but at the same time, it can be used as the
- 1:10:36thing against you. Just to give you an answer to
- 1:10:39your question, I think financial services is an easy angle to
- 1:10:42look at and how this gets disrupted because you have two,
- 1:10:46a confluence of things happening.
- 1:10:48One is you can do a bunch more with less.
- 1:10:50When you think about research, analysis, everything that goes
- 1:10:53into what is a traditional fight, compliance, regulatory,
- 1:10:56like there's a lot of things that you can automate and then
- 1:10:58have humans in the middle of the loop on.
- 1:11:01But then the other aspect, if there's a true essence of wool,
- 1:11:04it's all just math, right? Like you have these two fixed
- 1:11:06supplies where Bitcoin has its thing and then gold has its
- 1:11:10relative fixed supply. And so from a mathematical
- 1:11:13perspective, those things will outpace inflation because
- 1:11:16they're sponges for everything else in the universe, right?
- 1:11:19And so the point, and you can look at copper oil and maybe
- 1:11:22they do its thing, but you can't eat them, you can't transact
- 1:11:24them. It's Barber.
- 1:11:24So that's why you have any money instruments.
- 1:11:26So if that world goes there, that's the bet we're making.
- 1:11:29Well, then what's the need for a financial advisor taking 1% when
- 1:11:32they're underperforming those things?
- 1:11:34It's another idea that I'd love if he was listening to.
- 1:11:36It's like I want asset management firms.
- 1:11:38I want products that are gold and Bitcoin.
- 1:11:39Whether it's you hold gold Bitcoin, I make the case that
- 1:11:43gold BTC would outperform in whatever ratio you want,
- 1:11:4680202080 almost any active passive manager, any like fund
- 1:11:51because you're taking these two instruments that are on the
- 1:11:53right side of history around inflation.
- 1:11:55And so point being is when that transpires and that becomes
- 1:11:59understood in the zeitgeist, well, Travis kind of like cooked
- 1:12:02when you think about it and you're kind of seeing this
- 1:12:04around like how many bankers and people does JP Morgan have and
- 1:12:08is it, are they needed? So I think that's going to be an
- 1:12:10easy industry. And he's kind of seen this with
- 1:12:12a lot of the fintechs that are launching and offering kind of
- 1:12:15like better rails and better money movement with a fraction
- 1:12:17of the team. Michael, thank you so much for
- 1:12:20coming on. I I suppose as we wrap up here,
- 1:12:23any parting thoughts on anything we discuss, like anything that
- 1:12:25you hadn't spoken about that you want to leave viewers with as we
- 1:12:29go off into this week? No, you, I mean, this was, this
- 1:12:34was probably one of my favorite pods.
- 1:12:36You asked a lot of great questions.
- 1:12:38You can tell you well researched and yeah if anybody's interested
- 1:12:42reach out love to talk about any of the stuff we talked about we
- 1:12:45have a podcast book of consultation.
- 1:12:47You want to learn more. I think maybe the biggest thing
- 1:12:49is we truthfully just look at ourselves as the safe guardians
- 1:12:52of our clients capital. And so we look at it we take it
- 1:12:55upon ourselves to at least identify risk and then share
- 1:12:58them because historically for 17 years in Bitcoin, there's always
- 1:13:02something out there that it's the notion of a shout out to
- 1:13:05Michael Goldstein. Bitstein is everyone's a scammer
- 1:13:08and there's only 21 million of them.
- 1:13:09And so we just take a very ultra conservative approach because
- 1:13:13we've seen everyone blow up and we don't want to be on that
- 1:13:15side. And we're playing the long game.
- 1:13:17So hopefully you take that from this podcast and a little bit of
- 1:13:20commentary. That was fun.
- 1:13:21And we'll, we'll do some do some clicks on, you know, I'm sure
- 1:13:24Matt Cole will appreciate it. Most definitely.
- 1:13:26Michael Tanguma, thank you so much for coming on the show.
- 1:13:29Where can people find you if they want to find more of your
- 1:13:30work and check out on Rev Finance?
- 1:13:33Honor and or honor bitcoin.com and you'd probably buy that URL
- 1:13:36and then M take you on Twitter. Shoot me a note DM if you want
- 1:13:39to come check out what we're doing.
- 1:13:41Have ideas and then early writers.com.
- 1:13:43If you're looking for capital in your building in this space.
- 1:13:46We'd love to talk with you if any of this resonated because
- 1:13:48they're probably not going to resonate with a lot of people.
- 1:13:49But if it resonate with you, it's you're our kind of client.
- 1:13:52Fantastic, Michael. Thank you so much for coming out
- 1:13:54then. Yeah.
- 1:13:55Thanks, Joe. Which does not fit a Bitcoins
- 1:13:59should be like that. Bitcoin 17 here 15 years is a $2
- 1:14:04trillion asset and I could kill less with Bitcoin trace for it's
- 1:14:08just a matter of. The month.
- 1:14:10The month of the month.