Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E019: The Institutional Allocator’s Journey to Bitcoin-only with Glenn Cameron
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972000? Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 0:27when we sell. And we're live gentlemen, very
- 0:34interesting day to be meeting here.
- 0:36I was just saying markets are going a bit haywire right now.
- 0:40Oils up, interest rates are up, markets, stock markets are
- 0:45relatively flat. Consumption numbers are coming
- 0:48in low here in the United States below expectations.
- 0:52But we're here yet again to talk about Bitcoin.
- 0:55It's going to be chaotic out there.
- 0:57We've got this. Very pure protocol in the
- 1:01Bitcoin network that we can anchor to, and more people need
- 1:04to learn about it. And that's why we brought in
- 1:06Glenn Cameron from Cartwright to discuss what he's doing in the
- 1:10United Kingdom, advising pensions, giving investment
- 1:15advice, particularly around Bitcoin and digital assets at
- 1:19Cartwright. So we're very thankful to have
- 1:21you this week. Glenn, welcome to the show.
- 1:25Thanks for having me. Yeah.
- 1:27I guess before we jump into the music conversation, let's talk a
- 1:30little bit about your personal journey.
- 1:32You seem very up to speed with what's going on in Bitcoin and
- 1:38educating your clients about the opportunity that lays before
- 1:41them. So what is your journey,
- 1:45particularly within Bitcoin? And then tell us a little bit
- 1:48about a little bit about Cartwright and what you're doing
- 1:51within Cartwright yourself. So yeah, So what happened was my
- 2:01previous role I was working as a portfolio manager managing multi
- 2:07asset class portfolios on a discretionary basis.
- 2:12So basically controlling exactly what happens in the portfolio.
- 2:18And within this larger company that I was working at, there was
- 2:25a private wealth division where they were managing the wealth of
- 2:29high need with individuals. And some of our competitors were
- 2:33starting to give their clients access to crypto in adverts and
- 2:39commerce. And there was like a chat group
- 2:42where we would talk about markets and what we were
- 2:45thinking and whatever. And the head of that private
- 2:49wealth division asked for a volunteer to look into crypto
- 2:54and how we get our clients access to it.
- 2:58And I'd kind of had an interest previously and so I put my hand
- 3:04up and said okay, I'll do that. And so we ended up doing a load
- 3:10of research and then looking at fund managers.
- 3:17You know that that we used to give access to our clients and
- 3:23then went through all the due diligence process and whatever
- 3:27and then got a particular fund manager on the buy list and then
- 3:34that fund manager came out to South Africa, which is where
- 3:39this job was. I was working Cape time and they
- 3:43sort of did road trip around the country with us talking to all
- 3:47our clients about what they do and the reason to make an
- 3:52allocation and whatever. And then, yeah, and then.
- 3:59And then I started to kind of dabble myself and started by I
- 4:06bought Bitcoin, but I also, you know, bought uni swap and polka
- 4:12dot and and then and then I kind of.
- 4:20And then I came across the Bitcoin standard and I read
- 4:24that. And then I started to look at
- 4:26some of the other cryptos more closely and I suddenly realized,
- 4:30OK, we're making a big mistake here.
- 4:34But then at about that time, I'd been offered a job at Cartwright
- 4:39before, but I had to go home for family reasons.
- 4:43So I didn't take the job at Cartwright.
- 4:46But I always kind of intended to come back to the UK.
- 4:49I've spent about 20 years of my life in the UK and that's kind
- 4:54of about slightly less than 2/3 of my career.
- 5:01And I always wanted to come back.
- 5:02So I called up Sam, who's the Director of Investment
- 5:06Consulting, and said, hey, is that job still available?
- 5:10And so we had like 2 interviews about two hours each.
- 5:17And near the end of the second interview, he said to me, okay,
- 5:21one last question, what do you think about crypto?
- 5:26Right? And by that time, I'd kind of
- 5:29worked out the difference between Bitcoin and crypto.
- 5:34So, you know, I kind of thought the question might be a trick
- 5:38question, like a filter, Like if you say you like crypto, then
- 5:42you're not going to get the job. So I told him what I thought.
- 5:46I thought, listen, I think Bitcoin's the only real thing
- 5:48here. These are the reasons why and
- 5:50whatever. And and after I'd finished, he
- 5:53said to me, well, that's exactly what he thinks.
- 5:56And I explained to him what I've been doing at my previous
- 5:59employer. And so he said, well, if he
- 6:04gives me the job, he wants me to lead IF it in this space.
- 6:08So it's kind of funny because my official title is head of
- 6:14digital assets. But Cartwright think the only
- 6:18digital asset worth anything is Bitcoin.
- 6:21So I'm actually the head of a digital asset, right?
- 6:26Yeah. And we're doing a number of
- 6:27things in the space. Yeah, I can tell you about about
- 6:33the various avenues we're going down with Bitcoin.
- 6:36You're the head of Bitcoin? Yeah, exactly.
- 6:43Yeah, it just sounds more fancy if you say head of Digital
- 6:46Assets, right? Yeah, of course.
- 6:49What was it? What was it like personally for
- 6:51you at the end of that? In that second interview with
- 6:54your boss now to get to that point where you realize we're on
- 7:00the same page, this is awesome because in the world of
- 7:04institutional finance, there's a lot of noise and a lot of people
- 7:08who are still at the beginning stages of their rabbit hole
- 7:12journey that are a bit agnostic and want to do research on all
- 7:16these different crypto projects. Yeah, it was awesome because so
- 7:21my previous employer, once I figured it all out, right?
- 7:25So we'd have these once here, we'd have these investment away
- 7:28days and all the portfolio managers and like the Chief
- 7:31Investment Officer and all of us would go off site for a couple
- 7:34of days and we'd always have things on the agenda, right?
- 7:39So I pushed to get Bitcoin on the agenda and then I had this
- 7:42whole presentation explaining what I had figured out and
- 7:45whatever. And out of like 30 people on the
- 7:50investment team, I think there was one guy who had my back,
- 7:56right? Everyone else was, you know,
- 7:58laughing at me and thought it was absolutely ridiculous and
- 8:02whatever. And you know, because it's a
- 8:06traditional mindset, right? And obviously, when you dealing
- 8:10with large amounts of money that doesn't belong to you people,
- 8:15they slow to change their minds about things.
- 8:18You know, I mean, it's always been the case that when the new
- 8:21asset class comes into play, when it comes to institutional
- 8:24investors, happen with high yield bonds, happen with private
- 8:28equity. You know, when you first start
- 8:30talking to people about it, they just kind of poo poo it and say,
- 8:34you know, this is ridiculous, we're not interested.
- 8:37It's too risky, it's this, it's that.
- 8:39And then the next thing it's mainstream, right.
- 8:43So, yeah. And Sam, so that's that's the
- 8:49director of investment consulting, his name Sam
- 8:51Roberts, he kind of what happened was so he he was
- 8:59working through 2008, so was I. But he kind of figured something
- 9:04doesn't add up here, right the way financial markets are
- 9:07working, what's going on, it doesn't make any sense to me
- 9:11anymore. And so he started reading a lot
- 9:16and kind of by chance came across Austrian economics,
- 9:21right? And then all of a sudden things
- 9:23started to make much more sense and you could make sense of what
- 9:27happened back in the financial crisis.
- 9:31And then he became a gold bag, right?
- 9:33And then came across Bitcoin as in about 2013.
- 9:39Started dabbling in a little bit, but I don't think I mean,
- 9:42he told me he didn't really realize the significance of it.
- 9:48And then went the same route that a lot of us have gone.
- 9:53Started buying NFTS and crypto and all of this kind of stuff,
- 9:58and then started looking into it more.
- 10:02Read the Bitcoin standard, right.
- 10:04That's definitely a rite of passage, I think for a lot of
- 10:08people that have kind of figured out, you know, the signal from
- 10:13the noise and and then and then the next thing was he hired me
- 10:20and we spent the whole of last year figuring out what we want
- 10:24to do, how we're going to educate our clients.
- 10:30Yeah. And so that's kind of where it
- 10:33all came from there. The story is so fascinating
- 10:36because of the threat of the Bitcoin standard and.
- 10:41I just got like a little nostalgic thinking about, you
- 10:43know, when I was reading that 2017 and all the stuff going on
- 10:47then. But the this angle of, you know,
- 10:51Austrian economics, which is effectively just, you know, two
- 10:55schools of thought. One is like first principles
- 10:57thinking and then the state not into not needing to be
- 11:01intervening or be in the middle of of coordinating economic
- 11:05activity. And those are very like simple
- 11:06concepts. But if somebody can pick up that
- 11:09book and get through it, it's almost like the litmus test to
- 11:12the 30 people you referenced. And one of them said, no, like
- 11:16there's something else happening here.
- 11:17The other 29 thought you were crazy.
- 11:19It's not that that book is such a a good kind of though you you
- 11:22said ride a passage but like almost like a filter because a
- 11:25lot of people. And I don't know if it still
- 11:26gets brought up, but I know Marty, you've been around and
- 11:29Jesse on Twitter, where like that book is so polarizing where
- 11:32somebody looks at it and they're like, how could how could this
- 11:34be? And they just like, throw it on
- 11:35the floor. There's.
- 11:36And then if you can read the whole thing and you come out the
- 11:38other side, you're like, well, of course this makes sense.
- 11:40This is like this is very obvious and not that
- 11:43complicated. There it is.
- 11:48Yeah, it's. A hard.
- 11:49Yeah, go ahead. Go ahead, go ahead.
- 11:51When we do education sessions with our clients, right, we
- 11:59always give them all a copy of the Bitcoin standard, right?
- 12:04So yeah, And and also in the company, anybody can buy
- 12:08Bitcoin. I mean, buy the Bitcoin standard
- 12:10and expense it, right. And the people who do read it
- 12:14end up coming to me and saying, okay, how about that?
- 12:17Buy this thing, you know, in fact, helping somebody earlier
- 12:21buy Bitcoin, move it on that garden trays or hardware
- 12:28wallets, help them put it on and whatever.
- 12:32So that that that book works a treat if somebody wants to read
- 12:38it, right? Yeah.
- 12:39It's a hard book to read though. Like I think most people coming
- 12:44from finance, in particular Glenn, are probably not ready to
- 12:47read that right out of the gate. Like because it it really
- 12:51punches you on the nose in terms of your worldview about like
- 12:56what brings assets value and like attacking Keynesian.
- 13:03Norms and so that. That all under the bus.
- 13:06It's it's a painful read. But if you can get through that
- 13:09if you can like check your ego at the door your your your sense
- 13:13of like comfort at the door, it it is.
- 13:18I've told safety and it's more valuable than my Stanford MB A.
- 13:22In fact, it's sort of replaced my Stanford MB A because it
- 13:26actually explains the world and the world of value and in a way
- 13:29that that nothing else had before.
- 13:32It's just hard to get through. It's hard to accept.
- 13:35It's so fascinating. This is what makes us pod, I
- 13:40think special in like our diverse opinions but also
- 13:45backgrounds, but also how we got to Bitcoin because Jesse just
- 13:48said it was like. The easiest read and I feel like
- 13:50Marley, Marty, we need to be on this side or the middle because
- 13:53it was as inherent knowing that the world is completely messed
- 13:55up and it never trusted anything.
- 13:56And you read it was like, oh, this just like made it all make
- 13:59sense. And I remember reading it while
- 14:01I was at Wework and we were just like burning money.
- 14:03And I was like, this isn't real. And then you're reading this
- 14:05book and you're like, this actually starts to make sense.
- 14:08So yeah, it's fascinating because I could see how both
- 14:10sides look at And the other ones like, this is insane.
- 14:13Like literally can't get past the first couple chapters
- 14:15because this is like, this is blasphemy.
- 14:16This is not what I know or been taught.
- 14:18Yeah. And I actually think we're
- 14:22finding out something very important here in the context of
- 14:25Cartwright, like for your company, for the investment
- 14:30consultants within Cartwright to go out and actually articulate
- 14:33Bitcoin to people, it's most important to arm them with the
- 14:37education and the knowledge beforehand.
- 14:39So when we a lot of the focus on this show has been all right,
- 14:43how do we educate? Institutional investors and get
- 14:48them to come around to the thesis of Bitcoin and why they
- 14:50should get some exposure. And it really starts internally
- 14:54at institutions like Cartwright. And you need to equip your
- 15:00employee base with the knowledge to then go out and articulate
- 15:03that to your clients. And there's a lot of operations
- 15:06to all this, and if you were just gonna send people out there
- 15:07blind, like, yeah, you should get a Bitcoin exposure.
- 15:10It's probably not going to be as successful as sending out an
- 15:14army of consultants who are actually equipped with the
- 15:17knowledge to articulate the idea and the investment thesis behind
- 15:21this appropriately. Yeah, I mean, so the way that's
- 15:28kind of evolved within the company.
- 15:30So there was Sam and I, who understood this thing and wanted
- 15:34to pursue it and saw why it made sense and whatever.
- 15:38But the other investment consultants didn't know anything
- 15:41about the Bitcoin except what they read in the mainstream
- 15:45press, right? So the way it kind of happened
- 15:49was, OK, we're going to, we need to educate our clients on this.
- 15:53So we put together, because there's a lot to explain when it
- 15:57comes to Bitcoin, right? And it's kind of where do you
- 16:00start? So we put together 5 educational
- 16:05sessions, each one's an hour. The presentations only take
- 16:09about half an hour and then we leave about half an hour for
- 16:12questions and discussion at at the end.
- 16:16And as I put them together, I present them to Sam and then you
- 16:22hear suggest changes and stuff like that and I make those.
- 16:26And then you say, right, the next step is present to the
- 16:29whole investment team, right? And, you know, so at the first
- 16:34session, you know, there are a lot of eyes rolling and a lot of
- 16:40skepticism and whatever. But over the months as I've
- 16:43developed those educational sessions and I've had to do them
- 16:47for the investment team, all of a sudden I've got people in the
- 16:52investment team calling me, asking me questions, sending me
- 16:56messages on teams. A few of them have read the
- 17:00Bitcoin standard now and now only let's say over the last
- 17:05couple of months people have been coming to me saying to me,
- 17:08right, I want some Bitcoin, show me how to do this and whatever.
- 17:13So it is a long journey. I mean that's 18 months and I've
- 17:19had a captive audience. So when you're dealing with, you
- 17:24know, other, you know, clients and stuff like that, you don't
- 17:30always have the time. You know, you can't kind of nail
- 17:33them down and whatever. So it's a long journey to
- 17:37getting people comfortable, you know, with why.
- 17:40What is this thing like? Why should I care?
- 17:44Isn't it a Ponzi scheme? Isn't it just a load of rubbish?
- 17:48You know, why are you talking to me about this thing?
- 17:50And a lot of the investment consultants are kind of worried
- 17:53about approaching their clients because they don't want to be
- 17:56the one who approaches their clients and says, hey, I think
- 17:59you should make an allocation to Bitcoin.
- 18:02And the, I think the sort of unreal fear is that the client's
- 18:07going to turn around and say, well, if you're into that stuff,
- 18:10then I don't want you to be my investment consultant anymore.
- 18:14But my experience, because I've done loads of these educational
- 18:19sessions now, is that when I'm doing it for trustees of these,
- 18:25you know, charities, funeral trusts, pension schemes or
- 18:28whatever, I'm always pleasantly surprised we're actually in the
- 18:32session because a lot of them are professional trustees.
- 18:35So they'll sit on like 10 or 15 different pension schemes, and
- 18:39they're kind of worried about the reputational risk.
- 18:42So during the session, they'll ask all these sort of skeptical
- 18:46kind of questions or whatever. And then after the session,
- 18:49they'll come to me and say, hey, hey, do you mind telling me
- 18:52where I can get some Bitcoin, You know?
- 18:56So it's kind of a bizarre situation, but we always knew it
- 19:00was going to be a long journey and we're just kind of getting
- 19:04ready because the investment consultants are now at a point
- 19:09where they're saying, okay, I'm willing to talk to my clients
- 19:13about this. Obviously Sam and I are ready.
- 19:17So we just wanna be prepared. Yeah, it's an awesome little
- 19:22anecdote, A vignette, A microcosm of how this plays out
- 19:26everywhere, right? Like you are patient zero.
- 19:29You've caught this orange bug. And you are.
- 19:33Slowly spreading this, this sickness, this disease that is
- 19:38Bitcoin belief just by exposing people to the value of it and
- 19:45talking to it. And you have a captive audience
- 19:47with your your, your colleagues and you're slowly moving the
- 19:50needle within your organization. And I think, and I think that's
- 19:53happening everywhere, that's happening throughout society, in
- 19:56families, but also in organizations like yours.
- 20:00And that's why we're like really excited to talk talk with you
- 20:02today because you are at the front lines of of moving the
- 20:06needle in the finance world about the perceptions towards
- 20:09Bitcoin. And by the way for people
- 20:11listening like if if Glen's story sounds a lot like yours,
- 20:14if you are the orange pill champion in your organization,
- 20:17we would love to hear from you because we're trying to connect
- 20:20with with people like this. And and I I think it something
- 20:26you said earlier was really interesting to me about about
- 20:29how in your world this isn't really that new of a concept of
- 20:36having to introduce a new investable asset to the menu.
- 20:43You talked about how private equity wasn't a thing and how
- 20:47high yield debt wasn't a thing and wasn't on the radar of of
- 20:52the investment consultants and and the pensions as an option to
- 20:56include in their portfolio. And that you know your industry
- 20:59has seen has gone through this, this adoption curve of these
- 21:03other investable assets. And that because of that sort of
- 21:07recent learned wisdom you and and your boss see Bitcoin as on
- 21:15that same journey as and. And I don't think that we often
- 21:19connect the dots there about how there are other assets that
- 21:23didn't exist, you know and and were thought of as crazy at
- 21:28first recently you know in the last few decades.
- 21:33And the Bitcoin is is walking that same journey and and can
- 21:37and will continue on the adoption curve to normalize in
- 21:42the same way that private equity did as an investable asset.
- 21:47Yeah, I mean, I think that, you know, like, to be honest, okay.
- 21:53So I've worked with. I've taken over pension schemes
- 21:57where they'll have, say, a private equity allocation and
- 22:01it'll be sort of deep in the J curve.
- 22:04So I mean for the audience, what that means is there's just money
- 22:09kind of being taken out of the pension scheme to meet capital
- 22:15calls from the general partner of the private equity fund.
- 22:19And because of the way the fund is valued, there'll just be this
- 22:23sort of negative or definitely underperforming listed equities
- 22:28can be for like 5-6, seven years.
- 22:31And I've had clients that have kind of looked at that and said
- 22:36let's get rid of this private equity.
- 22:37If I'm not understanding that, that's the way it works, right
- 22:41that. You know, you go through the
- 22:44sort of death of the Jacob and then you come out of the other
- 22:47side and you only see the returns from years 7 to 12.
- 22:51And the interesting part about that for me is that people were
- 22:56willing to make an allocation to private equity without even
- 23:00understanding what they were investing in, right.
- 23:03And I think what it is, is that it's kind of in the you know.
- 23:09The investment kind of community milieu or particularly on the
- 23:15client side where it's kind of now the accepted norm to have
- 23:20private equity and and as soon as there's no reputational risk
- 23:25or anything like that, then if somebody suggests them, hey, you
- 23:29should have a allocation to private equity, they'll kind of.
- 23:34Do that even not really understanding what they're doing
- 23:37or what it is or how it works or anything like that.
- 23:40Just because they advisor or, you know, the investment
- 23:44professional that they're working with says this is what
- 23:47we should do, and I don't think we're quite there yet.
- 23:51With Bitcoin, if you just go to somebody and say, hey, make an
- 23:54allocation to Bitcoin, they're going to, they're going to
- 23:57blink, they're going to say why? Well, why are you suggesting
- 24:01this, you know? But I think we're getting there.
- 24:07Yeah. That's a good example of how,
- 24:10like the J Curve aspect of private equity is.
- 24:15That's what makes it a different asset class, right?
- 24:17Like it has its own idiosyncrasies that you have to
- 24:20understand in order to dabble in that.
- 24:23And here Bitcoin is the same thing.
- 24:26It has its own idiosyncrasies that you have to learn about and
- 24:29grapple with and understand. Yes, it's volatile.
- 24:33It has this crazy increasing scarcity mechanic built into it
- 24:36every four years that programmatically will happen.
- 24:39And that's really the, the core of it that you need to wrap your
- 24:41head around finite supply and increasing scarcity in order to
- 24:46understand why this is a different asset that has value
- 24:50alongside private equity and everything else in your
- 24:53portfolio. But it.
- 24:55So you know, and of course we all know that we all feel how we
- 25:00are earlier in that educational process in terms of the
- 25:03mainstream accepting that there's any merit there because
- 25:07most people don't even know the Bitcoin has a 21 million hard
- 25:11cap, let alone that there is a having coming in six months.
- 25:15People just don't know. And that's why it's such a a
- 25:19phenomenally interesting time for for all of us on this call.
- 25:23Because you know, we know, we know something that the rest of
- 25:28the world doesn't seem to process and and it's it's pretty
- 25:34exciting because then it then it becomes like being an early
- 25:37adopter of private equity. It's like being Bain Capital in
- 25:40the early 90s and you've got you know that things are mispriced
- 25:46and there's a big opportunity because nobody else is doing it.
- 25:49And I think that's where we're at right now.
- 25:51Glenn something that Jesse something that Jesse just said
- 25:55that is fascinating is there's there's almost two parts this
- 25:59whole equation. And you reference all the
- 26:01idiosyncratic or the idiosyncratic nature of the
- 26:04asset from understanding the underlying fundamentals, but it
- 26:08almost feels like that's a component.
- 26:09But then also there's the chaser that you reference with the
- 26:12private equity that people kind of like are gonna.
- 26:16Pass FOMO in exposure. Well, no.
- 26:20Just say like they're not gonna FOMO in, but they're gonna
- 26:22follow the lead of the black rocks of the world and and other
- 26:25firms. But then there's a secondary
- 26:27part. That precludes people from
- 26:30coming in even before BlackRock or even if BlackRock, which is
- 26:32the whole aspect of like does this thing just evaporate
- 26:34overnight, right. Like there's this chicken or egg
- 26:37thing that's always just like stuck in my head is that
- 26:38somebody can maybe not even be able to go down to understand
- 26:41the nuances or the like. They see a number go up.
- 26:45But it's like, well, I can't even really understand this
- 26:46because even if I got it, I can't allocate material amount
- 26:49of wealth to it because there's not even guarantee that it's
- 26:52going to exist in a year or ten years because historically it
- 26:54hadn't existed for investors. So I don't know if there's like
- 26:58a question there, but that's just another component of this
- 27:01is like even if you've got the fundamentals, you're like still
- 27:03how do I hold this long term and not look like an idiot because
- 27:05it just disappeared. Well, I got a question.
- 27:08This is building on something Jesse and I were discussing
- 27:11before Michael and Glenn hopped on, which is a dinner that we
- 27:16had last week. Michael with an asset manager
- 27:20and he had that same question like why should I?
- 27:25Tell my clients that they should be allocating the Bitcoin if it
- 27:27can go to 0. If it goes to 0, then I look
- 27:30like a terrible portfolio manager and I just flipped the
- 27:34frame on them is like, I get that I understand that career
- 27:37risk, but you also have to think about the career risk on the
- 27:39other side. If it runs to 200 K2 5500 K, God
- 27:44forbid, and you're sitting on the sidelines, they're going to
- 27:47ask you why didn't you get in and so just trying to juggle.
- 27:53That career risk dilemma that a lot of managers see themselves
- 27:57in and articulate that and then sizing accordingly with that in
- 28:01mind and expressing the trade-offs appropriately to your
- 28:05to your clients. Yeah, I mean, so The thing is
- 28:10that like the difference between, say, something like
- 28:14private equity and Bitcoin, right, is if a pension scheme,
- 28:20if a board of trustees. In conjunction with whoever the
- 28:24advisors are, make an allocation to a private equity fund and the
- 28:29thing blows up and does really badly.
- 28:32I mean it's it's not great. It's not going to look good.
- 28:36But at the same time there's kind of a level of more
- 28:41acceptance of that kind of thing where they they would kind of go
- 28:45well. That's investments, you know,
- 28:47there's risk, right? But.
- 28:50I think in people's minds with Bitcoin, if they make an
- 28:54allocation to Bitcoin right, and it turned out to be an illusion
- 28:59and went to zero, I think people would be a lot more harsh with
- 29:05them. But I get your point Marty,
- 29:08which is, which is our point, right?
- 29:11Because in in Sam, in my head this thing is kind of
- 29:16inevitable. And so we're on that side of the
- 29:21equation because we've got a better understanding of it than
- 29:23the people we're talking to. And we're saying, you know, do
- 29:27you want to be making your first 2% allocation to Bitcoin when
- 29:34you know the the people who did that earlier, their performance
- 29:39is, you know, leaving you in the dust?
- 29:44You know, we did work with, I mean, this is the kind of thing
- 29:47that we showed clients just as one part of what we showed them,
- 29:52but we kind of say them, right. This is what your portfolio
- 29:55looked like over the last five years, right?
- 29:58Let's put the 2% allocation to Bitcoin into your portfolio.
- 30:04You know, historically what would have happened if we'd made
- 30:07that 2% allocation to Bitcoin and we'll take that from
- 30:11equities because that's the next sort of most volatile thing in
- 30:14your portfolio. And we show them that the
- 30:18maximum drawdowns in the portfolio are no bigger, the
- 30:22volatility is no bigger. And then it makes this massive
- 30:26bump to the portfolio's performance over the last five
- 30:29years, right. And we say.
- 30:31So now the reason why we want to talk to you about this is
- 30:34because what if this keeps happening, you know?
- 30:39And then we obviously have to explain to them why we think
- 30:41it's going to keep happening. But yeah, when when you frame it
- 30:45that way, I'm sure you get the response of of past performance
- 30:50is not indicative of future results.
- 30:52And and yet we know that the conditions looking forward are
- 30:56just as positive for for Bitcoin, in part because of the
- 31:01programmatic nature of increasing scarcity, but also
- 31:04because of the, you know, inflation, the mounting
- 31:08sovereign debt. So how do you answer that like
- 31:12inevitable objection that pops up from people about, well, it
- 31:16doesn't matter that Bitcoin was the best performing asset of the
- 31:19last decade. That doesn't mean anything going
- 31:21forward. So the way we deal with that is
- 31:24we we, we talk to them about monetary premiums.
- 31:28Right. So we use the example of like,
- 31:32so there's a type of Ferrari. I can't remember, it's a vintage
- 31:35Ferrari. I can't remember what the model
- 31:37is, but it's the most expensive vintage car in the world, right?
- 31:43And we say to them, if this car's value was just in its
- 31:47utility, you know, just getting from A to B, it wouldn't cost,
- 31:51you know, $30 million for the car.
- 31:55So there's certain assets that contain a monetary premium,
- 32:00right. And people kind of get that.
- 32:02And we say, you know, if you buy like a just a normal car, you
- 32:09know, whatever, make a Volkswagen or something like
- 32:13that, you nobody considers that an investment, right?
- 32:17They understand that it's a depreciating asset and its own
- 32:21only value is a means of transport.
- 32:24Right. But with a Ferrari like that
- 32:27one, the the person who's bought that Ferrari, they definitely
- 32:31think that it is an investment and a good place to store their
- 32:37wealth, right? And so then we explained to them
- 32:41that all financial assets have a partly A monetary premium,
- 32:47right, but the monetary premium embedded in different asset
- 32:51classes. Is dependent on the currency in
- 32:54which they denominated. So if the real value of the
- 32:59currency is falling, then people are going to be looking to put
- 33:03their money into assets to protect it from that
- 33:08depreciating value, right? Then we kind of show them the
- 33:12what's happened to the money supply both in the US and the
- 33:16UK, right in the in the US it's kind of tripled since 2008.
- 33:22In the UK it's doubled, right. And then we show them the
- 33:26implications of that, right. And and so we start with the,
- 33:30the Cape ratio, the Shiller Cape ratio and we show them you know
- 33:35what the valuations of equities are compared to you know the 100
- 33:39year averages. And then we also look at like
- 33:42property. So we look at value to income
- 33:47multiples in property, you know and they sort of.
- 33:52Three times higher. So the the residential property
- 33:57in the UK and the US then in the US it sells at about 9 times
- 34:04average earnings is the average house price and in the UKI think
- 34:08it's slightly higher and before 2008 you could buy a house for
- 34:13about four times annual earnings, right, So somewhere
- 34:17between 2:00 and three times. And so we said to them, these
- 34:23things are overvalued because people are not just buying them
- 34:26for the intrinsic value from the because of the income they can
- 34:30earn from the asset. They're using them as a place to
- 34:34store their wealth just like that Ferrari, right.
- 34:37And now you've got something right that you don't need to
- 34:42manage, maintain. That is strictly scarce, can be
- 34:49traded globally 24/7, 365. It's very liquid.
- 34:58And so the people who are buying those Ferraris are probably
- 35:02going to say, hey, this is a hell of a lot easier.
- 35:04You know, if I want to sell that Ferrari, I can't sell it in a
- 35:07week. I've got to put it on the
- 35:09Sotheby's auction. It's a whole and the high
- 35:13transaction costs and whatever and here's something that's very
- 35:17scarce, they can park their wealth and it save themselves
- 35:22from that debasement, you know. So that's kind of the way we we
- 35:30go about explaining that. It's a really fascinating way on
- 35:34the position and of going to the like most I haven't heard it in
- 35:37that way is like the most non fungible thing that you would
- 35:41give up to being very valuable. It's like a Ferrari.
- 35:43It's vintage of course. Like it's most people would say
- 35:45yeah I agree it's worth that I wouldn't pay it.
- 35:47But it it's worth that. And then somebody who's valuing
- 35:50it, working backwards to like the fungibility and you know
- 35:54what you reference all the things we know about bitcoins
- 35:55properties and like well then that would have some value if
- 35:57you can get all that monetary premium captured in something
- 36:00digital that can't be replicated.
- 36:03Yeah. And and going back to Marty's
- 36:04point, right, about being on, you know the the wrong side of
- 36:10the all of this is what we say to clients is.
- 36:13So if the thesis is correct, right, the capital that flows
- 36:19into Bitcoin has to come from somewhere, right?
- 36:23So it's going to be coming out of all those other assets.
- 36:26So probably when this thing starts to take off, it's going
- 36:31to be at the same time as the values being sucked out of all
- 36:34these other things. So it kind of acts like a bit of
- 36:37a black hole, right, Just kind of sucking value into it.
- 36:41So we're saying the risk is that you don't have an allocation,
- 36:45not that you do. Yeah.
- 36:47Yeah. Get that black hole insurance.
- 36:50Yeah, Yeah. Or you or you're hoping that
- 36:53overvalued equities in terms of PE ratios keep going up or or
- 36:57you're hoping that housing, if you're, if you're going to buy a
- 37:01rental unit, you know to store your value in the house.
- 37:05You're hoping that that housing becomes more unaffordable.
- 37:09And conversely the those premiums that have built up in
- 37:12those, those asset classes that have been become monetized
- 37:16because the money is going bad. We've monetized all these other
- 37:19assets as store value assets and they're all over inflated
- 37:26because of it. And you're right.
- 37:27Here comes this little black hole that is a more perfect
- 37:31store of value that has all of instead of that house.
- 37:34You can store your value perfectly through time without
- 37:38any, you know, loss, any evaporation along the way, no
- 37:45maintenance, you don't have to deal with tenants, You know, you
- 37:50don't have to pay property taxes.
- 37:53That's a much more attractive store value asset once people
- 37:58actually understand the option at hand.
- 38:02Yeah. And again going back to like
- 38:03framing, using that as an example, Jesse, it's like how
- 38:08long do you really think this can persist in these other asset
- 38:11classes cuz whether it's real estate?
- 38:14And the value of housing going up to a point where it's
- 38:17literally becoming unaffordable for the vast majority of, well,
- 38:23just citizens in the United States will focus on our real
- 38:25estate market or equities. When you look at PE ratios, like
- 38:29how high can they really go before it gets insane, we know,
- 38:33Kane said. Markets can remain illogical far
- 38:36longer than you can remain solvent, but at some point the
- 38:40end of that road does come and and.
- 38:44Things have to fall back to reality, yeah?
- 38:48Yeah. There's so much irrationality in
- 38:51markets, right? So we're trying to explain this
- 38:55to our clients because The thing is, okay in a world without
- 38:59Bitcoin, what do you do? You look at the thing that can
- 39:02give you a real return, right? But if you.
- 39:09You know, if you put all your money and things that can give
- 39:12you a real return, it's going to be very volatile.
- 39:14And so for our kinds like defined like mature, defined
- 39:18benefit pension schemes or charities that are actually
- 39:22relying on the income from their portfolios or female trust that
- 39:27are more mature where they're paying out for funerals all the
- 39:30time and stuff like that, they can't afford to have the
- 39:33volatility because. If you're drawing the income on
- 39:37a very volatile portfolio, you'll deplete the capital
- 39:40faster than you know, 2 portfolios with the same return,
- 39:46but one's more volatile than the other one.
- 39:48The volatile one will reduce the capital more quickly and so.
- 39:57You know, so, so The thing is you can only invest so much in
- 40:00the things that are going to give you a real return.
- 40:02Then you got to look for OK, what is going to dampen the
- 40:05volatility, what is not correlated here and whatever.
- 40:09And so they go and invest in, you know, bonds and whatever,
- 40:14and we've got to match the liabilities of the portfolio.
- 40:19You know, for the type of clients is, is and whatever.
- 40:22But the reality is a lot of the time they're not getting a real
- 40:26return on a huge chunk of the assets.
- 40:28And we're saying, look, just put 2% of this thing here and it'll
- 40:32compensate for that, right? It'll it'll kind of make up all
- 40:37of that negative real return on you that you're getting on a
- 40:41huge chunk of your portfolio. It sounds like a no brainer to
- 40:48me. I mean it's either that or you
- 40:49you're buying NVIDIA at 100 hundred times price earnings.
- 40:54245 the last time we checked. Yeah.
- 40:59Yeah, it's absolutely crazy. Yeah.
- 41:01It's like I, I, I send emails to the other investment like I sent
- 41:06one the other day right, with like the the yield, the dividend
- 41:13yield on the S&P 500. OK, including buybacks, right,
- 41:20versus and this was before the big rise in yields now right.
- 41:27And then that compared to the yields on say 10 year treasury,
- 41:35right. And then you do the same
- 41:37comparison now, right and equity should be way lower because you
- 41:44know you used to get about the same yield on both right now you
- 41:50get a much higher yield on treasuries, but the valuation of
- 41:55equities hasn't gone down. So there's like all these
- 41:58irrational things that they don't kind of add up.
- 42:06And I I think this is kind of what Sam kind of was thinking
- 42:09about back in 2008. It was like, hey, this, this
- 42:13game that I've been doing for such a long time doesn't make
- 42:16sense anymore, right. And then you get this thing that
- 42:19gives you a different leans on the world and you realize, oh,
- 42:22because what I said to the other investment consultants was we're
- 42:27dealing with, you know, 10s of millions, hundreds of 1,000,000,
- 42:31you know, in aggregate billions of pounds.
- 42:34But we never think about what is actually at the base of it, what
- 42:38is the money? You know, we, we're thinking
- 42:42about equities, bonds, property, private equity, all of these
- 42:47things. But they're all denominated in
- 42:49the sphere currency. So if that thing's losing value,
- 42:53it doesn't matter what all of these assets are doing, right.
- 42:58It's a kind of first principles kind of thing from the ground
- 43:02up. First, figure out what's going
- 43:04on with the thing that's at the at the Foundation.
- 43:09Yeah, That's why I think all the benchmarks are, are flawed
- 43:11because we talk about real returns, but what are real
- 43:14returns when like the CPI print is what, you know, historically
- 43:17was 2%, it was much higher and now we say it's 3% and it's
- 43:20probably 10%. You know, like these numbers
- 43:22have all been skewed. So looking at that tail end of
- 43:25your retirement, what actually can you buy?
- 43:27What can you do when the stake is, you know, $20 a pound or
- 43:30whatever it cost? Yeah, So what we did was, so at
- 43:35first I was trying to write articles about Bitcoin.
- 43:38We brought like a PR agency that gets them published in all the
- 43:42different publications that are relevant for our client base.
- 43:45And I was trying to write Bitcoin once, but whenever I
- 43:47wrote one, they were like, I don't think this is going to fly
- 43:52with our audience, you know, So we changed tack and we were
- 43:56like, let's just write about money.
- 43:58We won't mention Bitcoin, right? And so the first article was we
- 44:04used that old analogy of like, you know, like a fish doesn't
- 44:09know that it lives in water. It spends its whole life in
- 44:12water and doesn't even know it's in water.
- 44:14And that's what how we live with money, right?
- 44:17We kind of operate with this thing.
- 44:20But we never questioned like where does this thing come from?
- 44:22Like, I can't remember what documentary it was, but I I
- 44:26watched this documentary where they went around London and they
- 44:30they interviewed people and they said to them, where does the
- 44:32money come from? You know, and like most of the
- 44:36people were like, well, the Bank of England's got gold in its
- 44:41vaults and then they issue pounds or or other people who
- 44:46were saying no. What happens is we all put our
- 44:49money in the bank, right? And then when people need to
- 44:52borrow some of it, then the bank acts as an intermediary, you
- 44:56know, so like not one person actually knew what was going on,
- 45:02right? The reality of the situation.
- 45:05And it's the same with investment consultants, right,
- 45:09Like all of our competitors. So there's more than 10,
- 45:12definitely, maybe as high as 20, like large investment
- 45:16consultancies in the UK And if you look at their name with the
- 45:20word Bitcoin in it, they've all got reports writing Bitcoin off,
- 45:24right? And it's because they don't
- 45:26understand things from first principles.
- 45:30Now it reminds me, I think Peter Schiff was going around Occupy
- 45:33Wall Street asking the same question here in the United
- 45:35States and everybody was like, oh, it's all backed by gold.
- 45:38It's like, no, it's not not backed by anything but the faith
- 45:42of future production of our economy.
- 45:45And it is scare. It is on the scary thinking that
- 45:49the vast majority of the world are fish and water who don't
- 45:54have any connection to. What is arguably the most
- 45:57important tool they use on a daily basis?
- 45:59Money. Yeah, well, you know, it's like
- 46:03they say on the notes, backed by the full faith and credit of
- 46:11whatever central bank or whatever, right?
- 46:14So people are under the illusion for some reason.
- 46:18I wonder why they don't think that nobody ever does it right
- 46:21that I can take a £50 note to the Bank of England and they'll
- 46:24swap it for gold, right? And of course that's not going
- 46:28to happen. And so it's like, so then you
- 46:31point that out to them and then they go, yeah, but it's still
- 46:34backed by the government. So I go okay.
- 46:36Well, if you take that piece of paper and you give it to the
- 46:39central bank, what are they going to give you in return?
- 46:42Another 40 pound note, you know what I mean?
- 46:45So and that's such a mind Bender for people.
- 46:49It's almost like it's almost because it's so it's so what's
- 46:56the word I'm looking for? Like outrageous, right?
- 47:02That that when you tell them that they can't, they can't,
- 47:05they can't like, wrap their mind around it, right?
- 47:09Yeah. It's, it's there's that
- 47:11component and there's a component.
- 47:12We had it on one of the earlier shows.
- 47:14At the time they had the chart from like Financial Times in the
- 47:17UK, inflation was running 20% like groceries.
- 47:20And there's this aspect of like the mental model from an
- 47:23individual. It's like 1 unit of currency
- 47:26buys you more eggs every week and the other one buys you less.
- 47:29And for folks on this call, they've been like stacking like
- 47:31you materially see the life, your life materially change when
- 47:35not from like. Philosophical level, just of
- 47:38like the comfortability and optionality and all these
- 47:41things. And it's just like this thing
- 47:42that they've been living in and it's like there's something
- 47:44dragging you down and it's like, what is it?
- 47:45What is it you're looking at in? And it's almost like sometimes
- 47:48to know what it is, is scary in itself, right?
- 47:51So like, there is this problem that is out there.
- 47:53I thought this was just the way the world works.
- 47:55That's on a more micro level, but I think it's important
- 47:57because it's what we've been saying on this podcast.
- 47:59It's like individuals like yourself and Sam that recognize
- 48:03it. And then it was something that I
- 48:05thought of earlier. I'm curious like how much you
- 48:07think of it is like we know there's individuals in in firms
- 48:13that feel the same way that it resonate and listen to this.
- 48:16But it's something that I've always respected Marty for on on
- 48:19his other pods and just always being out there and not not
- 48:22afraid to speak up which is very important.
- 48:24We've seen that past couple years, a lot of things that
- 48:25don't make sense and it's very important to bring those things
- 48:28to light and have the conversation.
- 48:29And it made me think, like how much is Cartwright?
- 48:32Like leading the space because there's two people there that
- 48:35are working very closely aligned.
- 48:37So you have that air cover of like, I'm not just a crazy
- 48:39person, Sam's over here, you know, and Glen's over here
- 48:42versus people are alone on that island in firms.
- 48:44And so it's just like more of that.
- 48:45One, how much you think that's a component that you have like a
- 48:49partner in this? But then two, just from anybody
- 48:52listening out there, it's like it really is the time to speak
- 48:55up because it's so paramount from like your career that you
- 48:57know the business. And that we know we're right.
- 49:00We've done the work. And so now it's time to just be
- 49:02able to find those partners. And then most importantly, the
- 49:05pensioners at the end of the day, yeah.
- 49:09So it's kind of interesting, right?
- 49:12I mean, like, so first of all, to your point, Marty, with the
- 49:16defined benefit pension schemes, right?
- 49:19So the way it works is people work their whole life for a
- 49:23company and at the end there's a formula that works out that, OK,
- 49:30we'll give you 60% of your final salary for life as long as you
- 49:35live for, right? But in that formula, it kind of
- 49:39says we'll increase your pension by the rates of CPI or whatever,
- 49:45right? And the pension scheme itself is
- 49:49only on the hook for the rules of that pension scheme.
- 49:54So if real inflation is actually 10% higher, the pension scheme
- 50:00itself is not on the hope for that, right.
- 50:03So, So what ends up happening is when those people retire and
- 50:08their pension goes up by only a certain percentage every year,
- 50:14you know, the real purchasing power of their pension is
- 50:17actually declining. So 10 years after they've
- 50:20retired, you know, even though they've been getting those
- 50:23inflationary increases, which helps, you know, the they're
- 50:27still kind of, they've got less purchasing power on a monthly
- 50:32basis, right. Whereas with charities or with
- 50:36defined contribution pension schemes there, you know, the,
- 50:44the investment portfolio's performance determines what the
- 50:48beneficiaries of the assets actually get, right?
- 50:51And there's no kind of cap because there's no rules that
- 50:55say, hey, once we've gotten here, we don't need anymore,
- 50:58right? And then in terms of what you
- 51:02were saying, Michael, I mean, I think there'd be a lot of times
- 51:08because if you're just surrounded by people who are
- 51:11skeptical about this thing and think that it's all some kind of
- 51:15fugazi that I've kind of, you know, become delusional about or
- 51:22whatever, and you don't have anyone around you who can see
- 51:26what you see. I think I would have battled
- 51:32with that. And there even times there, even
- 51:36times where because I'm out there battling against the
- 51:40perception of Bitcoin, because wherever I go, there's just
- 51:43skepticism, right? And then I'll, I'll go and
- 51:47confide in town. I'll say, Jeeps, I need a break
- 51:50from Bitcoin, you know, and it's sort of that I need a break from
- 51:53Bitcoin. I need to be.
- 51:56I need a break from being that guy that has to answer
- 52:00everybody's questions and, you know, all the criticisms and the
- 52:04skepticism and all of that kind of stuff.
- 52:08But you know, Sam believes that in to a degree that gives me a
- 52:15lot of comfort Like he's told me before that he can see a world
- 52:19where in 10 years time, not just through the allocations through
- 52:25our clients, but also through other avenues that we're
- 52:29pursuing to do with Bitcoin in the company where he can see
- 52:34that this will be 30 to 40% of our whole business.
- 52:38You know, so when somebody that I respect that much says
- 52:43something like that, then I'm like then all of a sudden the
- 52:48the motivation and the belief kind of comes flooding back into
- 52:52it. So it's I think it's definitely
- 52:54important to have people because I think it's also important to
- 52:59hear those kinds of things from people that you respect very
- 53:02high. Because, I mean, you know, if if
- 53:04you're just hearing it from other, you know, you know,
- 53:08people that you don't know, whether they know what they're
- 53:12talking about, then it doesn't really help that much.
- 53:15Yeah, definitely sounds exhausting.
- 53:16It sounds like that guy that we're at Thanksgiving.
- 53:18But every day, yeah, you know, I was introduced like when I do
- 53:23the presentations for the other investment consultants, I always
- 53:27start the meetings by saying it's time for another episode of
- 53:33Crazy Bitcoin guys. It's awesome.
- 53:39Same on on that to the extent you can share, be curious.
- 53:44You know how you, so you're having this these discussions
- 53:46you're educating, but we talked about one side of the coin which
- 53:49is you know just the asset and why, why it should be a
- 53:53percentage of a portfolio. But then there's the other side
- 53:55of who your partners are, counterparties, how do you
- 53:58evaluate, how do you think about whether it's custody firms and
- 54:03and their brand, what other currencies they support, Just
- 54:06anything you can share about like first principles, thinking
- 54:09of how you guys are evaluating the space.
- 54:11Yeah. So there's kind of three or four
- 54:15areas that we're looking at Bitcoin for, right?
- 54:19First of all is Bitcoin playroll.
- 54:22So paying our own staff a little bit of Bitcoin every month and
- 54:28giving them the option of taking some of their salary in Bitcoin.
- 54:32The other thing is we're talking to companies about holding
- 54:38Bitcoin as part of the corporate treasury.
- 54:42And then obviously we've discussed a lot about
- 54:47institutions making an allocation to Bitcoin and then
- 54:52sort of more related to the Bitcoin corporate treasury.
- 54:57So in the financial space now like because of all the ESG
- 55:03stuff, right, clients want to know that you your your own
- 55:12company. So card right is net zero,
- 55:15right. So we're just doing our normal
- 55:18business and then we send all of our activities to a carbon
- 55:22ordered firm and they come back to us and say right, you're
- 55:25going to offset 30 tons worth of carbon and then we have to go
- 55:29and buy enough carbon credits, right.
- 55:34So we came up with this idea because we got contacted by a
- 55:40Bitcoin miner here in the UK where they're doing two things.
- 55:46They're looking at using generators powered by landfall
- 55:52gas. And also they, they're basically
- 55:59taking animal waste on these big livestock farms, putting them in
- 56:04anaerobic respirators, capturing methane, running Bitcoin miners.
- 56:09And they're kind of battling A, to get the financing to expand
- 56:15and B, to to get the carbon credit because you have to get
- 56:21verified, you know, by one of these verification bodies or
- 56:25whatever. So what's interesting for us
- 56:28about that is when we go spend a whole lot of money on carbon
- 56:31credits, it's, you know, some organization goes and plants a
- 56:36million trees or protects a piece of forest or whatever, and
- 56:39then we get carbon credits, right?
- 56:41But when we buy those carbon credits, we don't end up with
- 56:44anything. There's nothing on our balance
- 56:46sheets. It's just an expense.
- 56:47So we were like, hey, why don't we rather buy bid, right?
- 56:52And this miner said to us, they'll give us the carbon
- 56:55credits for free, right? So that way we end up getting
- 56:58the carbon credits and we get the Bitcoin on our balance
- 57:04sheet, right? And then we thought, hang on,
- 57:07why don't we offer this to our clients?
- 57:09They're all buying carbon credits too, right?
- 57:13And we could say the same thing to them.
- 57:15Hey, when you do this, it's just an expense.
- 57:17You don't end up with anything. Why don't you rather buy Bitcoin
- 57:21and get the carbon credits you need?
- 57:25But then the problem has become that we can't get the guy
- 57:28verified, right? So we are actually now
- 57:32speculatively looking at could we become a verification button.
- 57:36So that's specialized in Bitcoin mining operations where we kind
- 57:41of go and look at the operations and then kind of verify what
- 57:47they're doing so that they can get the carbon credits and then
- 57:50the rest of it plays out And then like in terms of the actual
- 57:57institutional staff. So what we found is so we've
- 58:03kind of looked at all the different options for because we
- 58:07want the Bitcoin to be in a fund.
- 58:09The reason why that's important is because we hold all of the
- 58:13clients assets on an institutional investment
- 58:16platform. So everything from you know
- 58:19multi asset credit, equities, property, everything is on the
- 58:23investment platform. And then when we need to
- 58:26rebalance a portfolio or move things around or whatever, all
- 58:30the assets are in one place. So the first thing was we need a
- 58:33Bitcoin fund that can go on the institutional investment
- 58:36platform. But then we were saying how do
- 58:39we make sure given the nature of the asset that the Bitcoin is
- 58:44actually there because we don't want to be holding paper
- 58:46Bitcoin, right. So we, I mean if you buy an
- 58:51equity fund, you don't expect to see, you know, have a look
- 58:56through to, I mean it's basically impossible because the
- 59:02the equities themselves are held by a custodian.
- 59:04Everybody just kind of knows that these entities are heavily
- 59:08regulated and whatever. And if they say they've got an
- 59:11allocation of X to this company, you know that together, right?
- 59:17But if you buy a Bitcoin fund and they say, yeah, we've got,
- 59:21you know, X amount of Bitcoin in the fund and your allocation's
- 59:25there or whatever, how do we know they're not lending it out
- 59:28or we're hypothecating it or whatever?
- 59:32So then we started talking to you, we first started reading
- 59:35fund prospectuses, right? And the litmus test for us was,
- 59:40can we take an in specie transfer?
- 59:43So can we say we want to disinvest but we don't want the
- 59:46pounds or the dollars, we want the Bitcoin.
- 59:50So when we withdraw, give us the Bitcoin, right.
- 59:53And in most instances that's not possible.
- 59:59But then the second thing was, hey.
- 1:00:03We want to be able to check that my Bitcoin for this client is in
- 1:00:08the fund at any time, right? And you know a lot of the funds
- 1:00:17that's also not possible, right? And then the third thing was
- 1:00:21they were like concerning like once you start reading the risk
- 1:00:24disclosures in the fund perspective systems, you start
- 1:00:31seeing things like if there's a hard fork, the manager has
- 1:00:35absolute discretion on which fork to follow, right?
- 1:00:39And then the gating provisions. So if the manager deems and they
- 1:00:43don't kind of specify the exact sort of things that would need
- 1:00:48to happen before they prevented investors from disinvesting,
- 1:00:55they don't spell that out. They just say, you know things
- 1:00:57can happen and if we decide that it's a good idea to gate the
- 1:01:02fund, we gate the fund, right. So then I'm like hang on, you
- 1:01:09know, we know that this thing is not popular with governments,
- 1:01:14central banks, anything like that.
- 1:01:17And then you've got a lot of big institutions who 12 months ago
- 1:01:23thought were telling us that this thing was rubbish and rat
- 1:01:28poison and all this kind of stuff.
- 1:01:30Now all of a sudden saying, hey, we want to open our funds.
- 1:01:34And now when I read all of the terms and conditions, they're
- 1:01:38telling me they can gate the fund, they can choose which fork
- 1:01:44to follow. I can't verify if the Bitcoin
- 1:01:48that I think I've invested in is actually there.
- 1:01:52And this is a different type of technology where all of these
- 1:01:55things should be possible and it's a global asset, so why
- 1:02:00can't I take it into PC transfer, right.
- 1:02:04So those are kind of the main issues we've been kind of
- 1:02:07wrestling with and that's why, you know looking at the Onram
- 1:02:12solution is very interesting. Yeah, I appreciate you walking
- 1:02:17through that. I think you know anchoring to.
- 1:02:21Independent of you know Cartwright or or on ramp, I
- 1:02:24think the the core theme there at least what I identify is
- 1:02:28you've you've looked at this asset very deeply, you've
- 1:02:31studied it, Sam is studied as well.
- 1:02:33You've come and started you. You came from a first principles
- 1:02:36perspective. How do you value it?
- 1:02:38And so you would do the same when it comes to how do you
- 1:02:41store it from a custody perspective, your
- 1:02:43counterparties, the delivery mechanism that you're
- 1:02:46recognizing that this is a different asset.
- 1:02:49And the the thesis is long term, that's where everybody goes.
- 1:02:53It's just an asymmetry, asymmetry in the education of it
- 1:02:58as a financial instrument, but also in how do you safeguard it.
- 1:03:02So the past 15 years, the things that have happened don't happen
- 1:03:05to you for in your counterparties.
- 1:03:07So it's just it's very reassuring and also you know
- 1:03:11it's great to hear as far as like you guys are at this
- 1:03:14forefront, but you're thinking about it from the full stack.
- 1:03:18And that's the thesis is that's how everybody will will think
- 1:03:20about it over time. We're still very early.
- 1:03:22So we know a lot of people go into the GBTC trade or the
- 1:03:25BlackRock trade. But as that education, you know,
- 1:03:28continues, as content like this comes out, it's just becomes
- 1:03:32known that you want those things because it doesn't map to the
- 1:03:35traditional world, the traditional finance world.
- 1:03:38And so hearing you guys and how you're thinking about it is just
- 1:03:41very positive. Yeah, like, I think what's a
- 1:03:44bigger risk then making an allocation to Bitcoin and going
- 1:03:48to 0, right? Is making an allocation to
- 1:03:52Bitcoin okay and it goes through the roof and you all of a sudden
- 1:03:58find out that the fund that you're invested in has a huge
- 1:04:03hole in its balance sheets. And guess what?
- 1:04:06Bad luck for you, you know. So, and you can imagine what
- 1:04:11would happen to the reputation of the new investment consulting
- 1:04:14firm who gets that wrong, right, Because our clients, if we come
- 1:04:18to them and we say to them, listen, this is a good
- 1:04:21allocation to make in your portfolio.
- 1:04:24And we've done all of the due diligence and this is the best
- 1:04:28way to gain access to this assets and then we get that
- 1:04:32wrong. That's gonna be a big problem
- 1:04:35that's gonna be on the front page of the Financial Times.
- 1:04:38It's such good framing because I know Marty's a big fan of the
- 1:04:41man and the coma analogy and the thought of if we forget FTX or
- 1:04:46we just we think about all the allocations that institutions
- 1:04:50had on FTX that are effectively 0 now and we just.
- 1:04:54You know, go to sleep and we wake up in 5 or 10 years and
- 1:04:57Bitcoin does what it does. They have no exposure and and
- 1:05:00they're gonna see what happened to it and then they're gonna
- 1:05:02realize that. And that's just not FTX, that's,
- 1:05:04you know, there's ten different scenarios where that happened
- 1:05:07that institutions were, they thought they're holding spot BTC
- 1:05:11and their counterparty, you know, effectively went to zero
- 1:05:14because of leverage. Yeah, or other things.
- 1:05:18Yeah. And they crypto fund managers
- 1:05:20here in the UK who, you know, who are holding their funds, you
- 1:05:25know, ten, 1112% exposure to crypto assets in hot wallets.
- 1:05:32Well, they're probably the assets weren't even there on
- 1:05:35FTX. But there were also pension
- 1:05:39schemes, particularly in Canada, who had allocations to FTX and
- 1:05:45other, you know, crypto assets and stuff.
- 1:05:52You know, there were big venture capital firms that had
- 1:05:58investments in these kind of stuff.
- 1:06:00And so that's definitely a reputational hit, you know
- 1:06:05because particularly with like venture cap firms and stuff like
- 1:06:09that, you expect them to kick the tires and kind of know
- 1:06:13exactly what they're investing in.
- 1:06:15And when they're investing in you know something that's just
- 1:06:19hot air and that kind of comes out right, then how can you
- 1:06:26trust them on anything else even in the traditional asset space,
- 1:06:30right. So you got to get this right and
- 1:06:32it's complicated. It's a long learning process,
- 1:06:36you know multi signature, multi party computation, all of these
- 1:06:42kinds of concepts, they don't exist anywhere else, right,
- 1:06:45except in the space And you know, so I mean our competitors
- 1:06:53if you said it in what's a multi signature Bitcoin wallet,
- 1:06:56they're not going to have a clue, right.
- 1:06:59So it's a big learning kind of journey we've had to go and.
- 1:07:05It's it's very telling that you know, it's clear from all the
- 1:07:11things you know about crypto and and Bitcoin and going far down
- 1:07:15the rabbit hole you have come out.
- 1:07:19Aware of, you know, some of these hallmarks of when a fund
- 1:07:23knows what they're dealing with like the ability to take in kind
- 1:07:26distributions, You know the fact that multi sig is a superior
- 1:07:31form of custody and people should be using it.
- 1:07:35These things, these things are things that you're aware of and
- 1:07:40yet most of the fund managers out there dealing in this don't
- 1:07:43use this stuff or aren't talking about it or.
- 1:07:46Are you know aren't actually as far down the rabbit hole as you
- 1:07:50are and it becomes very revealing right that you know
- 1:07:54this is this is how we got connected because you took
- 1:07:58interest in in how onramp is doing things differently with
- 1:08:01with specifically with regard to these topics because we
- 1:08:07understand Bitcoin pretty deeply and have set it up in in what we
- 1:08:11believe is a better way the right way for a fund or.
- 1:08:16Any sort of custody in our opinion.
- 1:08:20And you know, so Glenn, you're you're at this stage where you
- 1:08:25can see through the bullshit that a lot of people out there,
- 1:08:30a lot of fund managers, crypto fund managers, talk a big game
- 1:08:34but don't really understand the technicals, the, the deep.
- 1:08:40Considerations of how to deal with this asset in the right way
- 1:08:43and how to ensure the right kind of assurances for the end
- 1:08:49client. Because you can have separately
- 1:08:53managed accounts where the assets live on chain in the cold
- 1:08:56storage vault and you can prove that 24/7, 365, that's just so
- 1:09:02different from the traditional world.
- 1:09:03And and you can smell the BS when people don't know that.
- 1:09:08Yeah, well, I mean that I've, I've been, you know, I get like
- 1:09:13invited to these lunches or dinners with fund managers and
- 1:09:18whatever and like, so I'll be talking to them about it and
- 1:09:22I'll say, so who's the custodian, right.
- 1:09:25Then they'll tell me the name of the custodian and then I'll say,
- 1:09:29do you have any financial relationship with the custodian?
- 1:09:32And then that's, I mean besides the fees you pay them for
- 1:09:37customs but like ownership or anything like that.
- 1:09:40And I'll go, oh, yeah, there's subsidiary of ours, right.
- 1:09:44And then I'll say, OK, so is it like a multisig solution and
- 1:09:49they'll be like they'll go, yes. And then I'll go, is it
- 1:09:54multiparty computation or multi signature?
- 1:09:57No, no. It's multiparty computation.
- 1:10:00And then I'll say to them, OK, well, so who's holding the three
- 1:10:03keys? Oh, no, the custodian holds all
- 1:10:06three keys, right. I mean, I'll say them, but like,
- 1:10:14how do you know that they're not just, you know, like some
- 1:10:17employee and organization? It's not just going to take all
- 1:10:20three keys? Oh, no, they're all in different
- 1:10:24departments. Right.
- 1:10:27And I'm like, you know, like we're talking about large sums
- 1:10:31of money here. You know, like that's not
- 1:10:34ideally the way you want to do things, right?
- 1:10:37You want this thing to be rock solid.
- 1:10:39I don't want to be and Sam doesn't want to be.
- 1:10:42You know, you know, not being able to sleep at night,
- 1:10:47wondering if you know a few people in one organization are
- 1:10:51going to collude and end up with in the Bahamas with our bit.
- 1:10:56Yeah, I think, I think Jesse brought this up the other day.
- 1:10:59But we have a lot of exciting stuff coming and it's just like
- 1:11:01when you want to move the asset, it should be like moving
- 1:11:03glaciers, it should be a process it you should know that there's
- 1:11:06a lot of participants involved and a lot of processes involved
- 1:11:09when you're thinking about this kind of allocations.
- 1:11:11Like Marty mentioned, this is people's lives, their assets,
- 1:11:14the as a fiduciary. And it just hasn't been treated
- 1:11:18as such. And we've just seen these things
- 1:11:19just like, evaporate overnight. It's actually kind of like mind
- 1:11:23boggling when you really think about what happened last year in
- 1:11:262022, because it's just like $100 billion went up in, you
- 1:11:30know, smoke. And everyone's like, oh, I guess
- 1:11:31that was another cycle, just like it was another cycle.
- 1:11:35Like it's just really insane to think that money is so like just
- 1:11:39out there and, you know, being flowing through the system that
- 1:11:42people can just lose $100 billion.
- 1:11:44It's like, oh, it was. We just write it off.
- 1:11:46We didn't do the due diligence. We watched Sam play on his, you
- 1:11:49know, World of Warcraft. Then we thought it was amazing.
- 1:11:51We get wrote him $100 million check.
- 1:11:53It's just it's nuts. Well, it's nuts, but I think,
- 1:11:58Glenn, you and Cartwright, you and Sam particularly are great
- 1:12:01example of the mark. Mccartwright, not Sam Bankman,
- 1:12:04Freed, but. Yes, Sam Mccart.
- 1:12:07But like a great example, like the market learning in real time
- 1:12:10and creating better standards, I mean, that's one thing.
- 1:12:13That I've been saying over the last year particularly after the
- 1:12:15FTX blow up is the standard hopefully come next cycle will
- 1:12:20be multi party, multi jurisdiction, multi CIG for
- 1:12:25custody of these assets. Whether you're engaging with
- 1:12:30somebody like on ramp Unchained, whether you're holding Bitcoin
- 1:12:34for business or an institution like you just mentioned there is
- 1:12:38a proper way to do this. Everybody on this call knows
- 1:12:42this. And it's just getting that model
- 1:12:44out there and making it the standard.
- 1:12:46And I think the efforts that Cartwright is making in this
- 1:12:50direction could be used as a flagstick out there where people
- 1:12:54can point at and say, no, they're doing it the right way.
- 1:12:57If you're not doing it this way, we're not going to give you our
- 1:12:59money. And we just need more
- 1:13:01institutions like Cartwright, like on ramp.
- 1:13:06Getting out there and just getting the standard out there
- 1:13:09and then literally forcing the market to say this is the best
- 1:13:12way to do it. If you're not doing it this way,
- 1:13:14you're not getting our money. Yeah, I mean, it's crazy, right?
- 1:13:18Because also if you look at the regulatory space, right?
- 1:13:22So you got the EU, you got the UK, the US, and they're spending
- 1:13:28all this time and energy figuring how to regulate a whole
- 1:13:34lot of rubbish. You know, really it's like if if
- 1:13:40if they understood what we understood right, it would be
- 1:13:43way simpler, right. You got one thing here, right?
- 1:13:46Figure out how to do it for this one thing, properly make
- 1:13:51standards and regulations around that done right.
- 1:13:54But instead you're trying to do it for 10,000 different things,
- 1:13:59you know, 9999 of which are just, you know that that it's
- 1:14:06literally like people are investing in Pokémon cards.
- 1:14:10I mean that, you know, like I, I watched this video of in the US
- 1:14:16Senate where they were questioning Gary Gainesley,
- 1:14:23right. And they.
- 1:14:25So the one senator, or maybe he's a congressman or whatever
- 1:14:31says to him is, is it if if I buy a a Pokémon card, right.
- 1:14:38If I sell somebody a Pokémon card, is that a security?
- 1:14:44So Gary Genser goes, no, of course not.
- 1:14:48So he says, OK, what if I tokenize and make a digital
- 1:14:52asset out of that thing is Adena security?
- 1:14:59And then Gary Genser says, I would have to think about that,
- 1:15:04right. I'm just thinking what are you
- 1:15:07people doing, man? We're literally you're
- 1:15:13essentially that is what you're doing.
- 1:15:15You're investing in 10,000 things that are as good as
- 1:15:18Pokémon pots. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:15:21You're wasting so much time and effort, and that's another.
- 1:15:26I think important thing of this bear cycle is it's the
- 1:15:30demarcation between Bitcoin and crypto is becoming clearer and
- 1:15:33clearer. It's not as clear as we'd like
- 1:15:34it to be yet, but I do think there has been a lot of progress
- 1:15:39in the distinction between Bitcoin and crypto.
- 1:15:44Maybe it's not, Gary Gensler may have it to some degree too.
- 1:15:48And yes, you see and the problem we deal with here in the States
- 1:15:51and probably imagine in Europe and UK.
- 1:15:55As well is just trying to rid ourselves of the crypto grifters
- 1:15:59who are trying to suck all the energy.
- 1:16:00And that's when you talk about the regulatory environment.
- 1:16:03Here you have, like Brian Armstrong and Novogratz and Ryan
- 1:16:06Sulcus, like we need to Bitcoin and crypto need to fight
- 1:16:09together. And I'm just like, get the hell
- 1:16:11away from me and let us like, work on actual important things.
- 1:16:15Can Glenn, can you actually, can you speak to how important that
- 1:16:19is? I think that's a very important
- 1:16:21topic because to Marty's point, what we're starting to see is
- 1:16:25that when people are starting to look back at the asset, they're
- 1:16:28you know, doing the research and realizing Okay, there's a
- 1:16:30there's a big difference. But part of that, and I think
- 1:16:33we've talked a little about this Marty and Jesse separately, is
- 1:16:37it's a dirty little secret in the industry that you have a
- 1:16:40trillion dollar roughly market cap across crypto assets.
- 1:16:43But the majority when you like start to break down by firm 80
- 1:16:46to 90% of their assets like under custody or the any of the
- 1:16:50trading revenue is all directly tied to BTC.
- 1:16:53But then it brings up a little while are you supporting all
- 1:16:55these things if you have regulatory burden you know
- 1:16:58headache when it comes to just infrastructure, right.
- 1:17:00There's tech debt, there's all the things associated and this
- 1:17:02goes back to like kind of the the, the Fiat world of like how
- 1:17:05can you raise if you only have this one asset from all these
- 1:17:07people? Because there's that group of 30
- 1:17:09people. That you referenced Glenn, that
- 1:17:11are sitting at these investment firms and part of the things
- 1:17:13like, well that can't be it like just one like what's the total
- 1:17:16addressable markets like. Well, it happens to be
- 1:17:17everything but in their mind they're like in their mind
- 1:17:19they're like no, no, we gotta go figure it out until like that's
- 1:17:23what's happened. And so if you think about like
- 1:17:25this silver bullet and then we kind of like have known that
- 1:17:28this is the winner. It's like, well, you could take
- 1:17:29out so much of, like your headache of just.
- 1:17:33Being Bitcoin only, even if you don't even believe in it to be
- 1:17:35honest, like you can believe in that Bitcoin has a certain
- 1:17:37value. If you just focus on that, you
- 1:17:39can go so much deeper with clients and your company versus
- 1:17:43having to deal with all this crazy nonsense that every week
- 1:17:46and every month there's something else getting thrown at
- 1:17:47the wall of where does this getting designated?
- 1:17:50Who do you have to go to another country?
- 1:17:52So anyway just curious like how you guys are you know if that
- 1:17:55impacts how you think about counterparties or or your your
- 1:17:58partners. So I'll talk in my personal
- 1:18:02capacity. I can't really talk on car
- 1:18:05drives on behalf with about what I'm going to say.
- 1:18:08But so I I've got suspicions right, because if I look at the
- 1:18:15direction of travel for the regulations particularly in the
- 1:18:20UK but also in the EU is I think what they trying to do is make
- 1:18:27sure that the regulations that they write allow for the
- 1:18:32tokenization of other assets and for CBDC's right.
- 1:18:37It's kind of like, you know, like with trust where if you're
- 1:18:43wealthy enough and you can hire the right individuals, you can
- 1:18:46protect your assets from capital gains tax and all these kinds of
- 1:18:54things. And they can't just say, okay,
- 1:18:57we're just going to scrap trust because trusts have all of these
- 1:19:02kind of other purposes that are, you know, required.
- 1:19:07So, you know, they have to kind of if they're going to, if
- 1:19:11they're going to try and close a loophole in the regulations,
- 1:19:15whatever, they've got to be careful that they don't.
- 1:19:18That doesn't have unintended consequences.
- 1:19:21So I think that they're looking at the space, right and they're
- 1:19:25saying okay, how do we regulate this thing in such a way that
- 1:19:29our agenda, right, in terms of are we going to tokenize money
- 1:19:35market funds and bonds and equities and going to have these
- 1:19:38private blockchains owned by, you know, the big asset
- 1:19:43managers, investment banks and all that kind of stuff.
- 1:19:46I think they're doing it with one eye on that at the same time
- 1:19:51that they're trying to, you know, shut down all the rubbish
- 1:19:55over here and kind of throwing Bitcoin, you know, into that,
- 1:20:02you know, inadvertently maybe. And so and and and also the
- 1:20:13other thing that's, you know, kind of weird about this whole
- 1:20:17situation is, is that. The, it's like a moving target,
- 1:20:23right? So you look at like, what are
- 1:20:25the regulations right now in the UK, right?
- 1:20:29And they say there's going to be 5 further phases to the
- 1:20:34development of the regulation. They're only at phase one,
- 1:20:38right, which only really covers things like AMLKYC promotional
- 1:20:44materials. You've got to get registered as
- 1:20:49a digital asset service provider, various things, right?
- 1:20:55But then there's these four other phases.
- 1:20:57And when you look into what those four other phases are,
- 1:21:00it's just kind of headings on a blank page, right?
- 1:21:04So nobody really knows what's going to happen further down the
- 1:21:08line and whatever, right. So it's almost like you have to
- 1:21:11figure out what is the rock solid way that we can set things
- 1:21:16up so that pretty much no matter what they come up with, they
- 1:21:19can't find a problem with what we've done, right.
- 1:21:23Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:21:26Regulator's bad. It's all so tiresome.
- 1:21:32It's, I mean, look, I'm all for them, you know, because like we
- 1:21:38said, you know, the 99.99% of the stuff is rubbish, right?
- 1:21:43So like when I see them making things difficult for for that
- 1:21:49kind of stuff and protecting people from that kind of stuff,
- 1:21:52I'm all behind them. All I want them to figure out in
- 1:21:55their head is that there's a difference here, right?
- 1:21:58Yep, that's. Jesse and I had conversations
- 1:22:02last week. And this topic came up, you know
- 1:22:07high net worth individuals, CIO's and investment firms and
- 1:22:11and very interested but kind of came up with the regulation and
- 1:22:14you know the government and the thing that gives me personally
- 1:22:17peace and building a business around this is Bitcoin being
- 1:22:20deemed A commodity. It's the equivalent of gold.
- 1:22:22In my mind, if Bitcoin was to be banned to be the effect of
- 1:22:25similar to banning gold. And then anchoring back to being
- 1:22:29in Texas and the understanding of property rights, you know, we
- 1:22:33talked, we talked exactly about this, you know, the gold bullion
- 1:22:35depository, I don't know if you know, Glenn, there's a, there's
- 1:22:38actually no state bullion. There was the first state
- 1:22:41bullion depository for gold is here in Texas.
- 1:22:44Kyle Bass brought UTEMCO, which is now the largest pension or
- 1:22:48I'm sorry, endowment in the country between University of
- 1:22:51Texas and A and M. And their gold was in New York
- 1:22:54City. And in like 2014, there's a
- 1:22:55bunch of articles about this. He got in armored trucks and had
- 1:22:58it driven down to Texas and they established this.
- 1:23:00So the gold sits here like on Texas soil.
- 1:23:04So anyway, the long way of saying I think that to your
- 1:23:06point of having a singular asset, that feeling very
- 1:23:08confident, as confident as you can feel on your property
- 1:23:11rights, that is, is deemed by the state in that regard, give
- 1:23:15some peace. But you go into this other stuff
- 1:23:17and you're like, what am I holding in the next day?
- 1:23:18It could be literally, like, banned.
- 1:23:21Yeah and and going back to the the Pokémon cards thing like
- 1:23:25they're wasting so much energy trying to figure out like where
- 1:23:29do you draw the line on on things what's the security what
- 1:23:32not like how do we address the 30,000 crypto tokens that are
- 1:23:35out there and figure out a framework for assessing it.
- 1:23:40Does the how we test apply what's the security what's not
- 1:23:43And and I feel for Kerry Gunsler in that situation because he
- 1:23:45kind of got he fell into a gotcha where it's like obviously
- 1:23:48a Pokémon card is not a security.
- 1:23:51But then, if you're talking about tokenizing, it, isn't it
- 1:23:54obviously not a security in that situation.
- 1:23:57But the difference is that you would only tokenize this thing
- 1:24:01if you. You would probably tokenize this
- 1:24:04thing with some stipulations about, like, you know, retaining
- 1:24:07some slice of the of the supply for the people who are doing the
- 1:24:12legwork of tokenizing. And then now suddenly you're
- 1:24:14talking about like a you know, a premine.
- 1:24:18With an expectation of profit based on efforts put in And then
- 1:24:21now you're talking about a security because you've added
- 1:24:23these other these other elements this, this company model to what
- 1:24:30was a commodity trading card. And and the the net of it is
- 1:24:35they're they're going to waste so much time and frankly it sort
- 1:24:38of provides some air cover for Bitcoin to continue its adoption
- 1:24:41curve before regulators realize that that's the only.
- 1:24:45The only thing here that will have staying power and and and
- 1:24:48could actually be a threat to the traditional financial system
- 1:24:53in terms of in terms of what is the de facto money for for for
- 1:24:57people to use you know, nobody no no U.S. government employee
- 1:25:04can can in in their right mind. You know advocate for Bitcoin
- 1:25:13over the US dollar but so long as they are not viewing it in
- 1:25:18that lens that's sort of what's allowed because they're
- 1:25:21preoccupied by dealing with Pokémon cards and that's fine
- 1:25:24but it it's all such a waste of of of energy when at the end of
- 1:25:30the day the only thing that will have staying power here is the
- 1:25:33the one that is actually a commodity and and.
- 1:25:37The one that will continued on its course towards mainstream
- 1:25:40adoption because of its inherent properties.
- 1:25:43And, and I know we've touched on it and Jessie, you're focused on
- 1:25:47the regulatory side of things, but it really should be like we
- 1:25:53should beat the drum and beat it into people's heads like
- 1:25:56Bitcoin. Only from a practical
- 1:25:58standpoint, running a business is the most advantageous
- 1:26:02strategy that you can employ. Like regardless of the
- 1:26:06regulatory side of things like trying to figure out uni, swap,
- 1:26:10yield, farming, staking, all this DEFY crap, like it, you're
- 1:26:15just going to spread yourself so thin with so many man hours
- 1:26:18doing research on roads that lead to nowhere on bridges that
- 1:26:22lead to nowhere. While you could have been
- 1:26:25focusing on value added services built on top of the Bitcoin
- 1:26:28protocol whether it be payroll, multi sig.
- 1:26:32Custody lending products whatever it may be like the the
- 1:26:37companies that have the Bitcoin only focus This is why on Rams
- 1:26:41Bitcoin only it's why 1031 million this invest in Bitcoin
- 1:26:45only companies is when you have that focus and your ability you
- 1:26:48have the ability to go a mile deep into a into Bitcoin and
- 1:26:54actually provide services is going to massively benefit you
- 1:26:58in the future whereas. If you're an investment firm
- 1:27:01trying to figure out all the 10,000 different crypto
- 1:27:04currencies, do research on them and try to educate your clients
- 1:27:07and consult them on how they should get exposure to this
- 1:27:11diversified world of crypto currencies.
- 1:27:13You're going to spread yourself too thin.
- 1:27:14You're going to send your clients on bridges to nowhere,
- 1:27:17and all the while you're not going to be able to focus on
- 1:27:20adding the value added services on top of the most important
- 1:27:23asset here, which is Bitcoin. That just reminded me of
- 1:27:26anecdotally, we've been having a lot of discussions and I can't
- 1:27:28remember if it was with a a legal team or RIA last week that
- 1:27:31they said one of their clients had had a bunch of Bitcoin and
- 1:27:34other stuff and they were like curious and they were moving it
- 1:27:37around. And if you guys remember like
- 1:27:39Black Friday in the States with like poker where you got to a
- 1:27:42site and it was like the feds have like, seized this.
- 1:27:44They got to their token site at one point and they were like the
- 1:27:47the government has seized this and it's like just like drop the
- 1:27:49computer through it in the trash and we're like, I'm never going
- 1:27:51back to any of this like, crap. It's like you literally can wake
- 1:27:54up one day. And I think of, without naming
- 1:27:56names, a VC and the crypto space invested in some stable coin a
- 1:28:01couple weeks ago, whatever. And it's like, oh, not for us
- 1:28:03investors. You gotta go to Bermuda and they
- 1:28:04gotta hop over to this island to get exposure to this stable
- 1:28:06coin. It's like, what are we talking
- 1:28:08about here that how can that? That does not sound palatable or
- 1:28:11interesting to have to just go to sleep at night wondering
- 1:28:14what, like hurdles you need to get through today just to live
- 1:28:17to tomorrow. Yeah, well, like Sam and I got
- 1:28:21like on this line of thinking, right Sam and I got invited to
- 1:28:25this lunch by this crypto fund manager, he's got a backcoin
- 1:28:29fund, right. And so they the they have like
- 1:28:34the chief investment officer there of the of the crypto firm
- 1:28:39and whatever. And I said to Sam before I went,
- 1:28:42I said, I'm going to ask, like explain to me why you're not
- 1:28:49only focused on, back on why you focus on all these other things,
- 1:28:53like what value do they have? Like what are they doing in the
- 1:28:57real world? They've got all these fancy
- 1:28:59bells and whistles and they promise all these things or
- 1:29:01whatever, but what are they actually achieving, you know,
- 1:29:04except you're just kind of moving these digital things
- 1:29:09around in cyberspace. But you know, and he, he had the
- 1:29:14opportunity to give me, I said just give me one example.
- 1:29:18Nice. And the example he chose was
- 1:29:21file coin. OK and so and and The thing is,
- 1:29:30right. So anyway, I thought, OK, let me
- 1:29:33go and do a little bit of research on file coin after the
- 1:29:36sledge. Right.
- 1:29:38And it turns out that because of the economies of scale, it's way
- 1:29:43cheaper to do file storage. No, no, no, Not through
- 1:29:49Filecoin, right? Stabilized instead, yeah.
- 1:29:53So that's why the price is like, I think it's about 99% down from
- 1:29:59the price it was near the end of 2021.
- 1:30:03And it's just like what I said to Sam is that's the other thing
- 1:30:09is if we're going to go to a fund manager and say okay, we're
- 1:30:12choosing you as our Bitcoin fund manager.
- 1:30:17I want somebody that I really respect the way they think.
- 1:30:20And I, you know, I think they, they know more than me
- 1:30:24hopefully, right. But when they say things like
- 1:30:28that to me, then it becomes very hard for me to think that they
- 1:30:32know what they're talking about. Yeah.
- 1:30:34And they're ultimately of much going, you know what I mean?
- 1:30:39It's like, yeah, if you, if you don't understand what I if you
- 1:30:44don't understand more than me, then why am I paying you?
- 1:30:50Yeah. Such a simple, such a simple way
- 1:30:54to to get to the bottom of the bullshit.
- 1:30:57And you've got this, you've got this, this added knowledge that
- 1:31:04I, I don't know how many people in the world really know this
- 1:31:09stuff at this point it's it's probably 100,000.
- 1:31:13Maybe it's 10,000. It's very few and far between.
- 1:31:17Well, importantly though, that number is growing and Glen,
- 1:31:21you're proof putting of that like and that's what gives me
- 1:31:26incredible optimism. It makes me incredibly bullish.
- 1:31:28It's slowly but surely over time more and more people are
- 1:31:31beginning to realize this. There's better educational
- 1:31:35content and more of it than there ever has been at any given
- 1:31:38point in time. And the high watermark of
- 1:31:40Knowledge is just getting higher and higher and eventually.
- 1:31:44Over time it it'll get to a point where you have people that
- 1:31:49are hired specifically with your set of understanding and your
- 1:31:53knowledge base throughout institutions across the world
- 1:31:56where we finally get past all the BS.
- 1:31:59Of course there'll be more BS moving forward, but I'm I'm a
- 1:32:02strong believer in that it'll it'll get less pronounced
- 1:32:06throughout each cycle because the crypto industry has had 15
- 1:32:11years to prove. Use case outside of Bitcoin and
- 1:32:15they haven't really done so successfully.
- 1:32:17File coin. Funnily enough I think their
- 1:32:19offices are down or down the street from where I am right now
- 1:32:22and it is a completely idiotic idea.
- 1:32:27Like it's all like why do we need any of that stuff like
- 1:32:30distributed file? Like do people really have
- 1:32:34problems getting access to files?
- 1:32:37And it's a blockchain, a solution now like just self
- 1:32:40hosted on your own server like. Sorry, I just kept hearing
- 1:32:43follow coin. I had a I had a I had this
- 1:32:47mental shift and model shift last week of it's like what
- 1:32:52we're talking about right now, honestly is literally the least
- 1:32:54sexy thing. And it's it's like the custody
- 1:32:58like, we're so early. We haven't even figured out how
- 1:33:00to hold this thing where there's a consensus of like, this is the
- 1:33:02right way. And to the point I'm already
- 1:33:05saying it's like once we figure that out, like we can start.
- 1:33:07We're we're just getting this base and we still got to figure
- 1:33:09that out And then the capital won't see you know orders of
- 1:33:12magnitude and price appreciation and all these interesting things
- 1:33:14that will continue to grow. But we literally so early that
- 1:33:16we haven't figured out like oh you should store it this way
- 1:33:19that you can feel comfortable and the custody in general is
- 1:33:24what I'm referring to an MPC and like who should hold it and
- 1:33:26should have unilateral control and it maps to the old world.
- 1:33:29So just a fascinating time that we're this early and to Jesse's
- 1:33:33point, that. 100,000 or 10,000, it's still very asymmetric in
- 1:33:37the amount of people and the knowledge that's been held.
- 1:33:40Yeah, I mean, I wouldn't be surprised if it's actually a lot
- 1:33:43more people than that because like, I mean, Sam's kind of been
- 1:33:49around because I was in Cape Town for a few years, right.
- 1:33:53And so I kind of don't have the networks and us, but when we've
- 1:34:00been to like conferences, right? So there was this like digital
- 1:34:05assets conference for institutions in London, right.
- 1:34:10And it was literally like, you know, going into the Death Star
- 1:34:13or something like that, right. And so Sam said, hey, why don't
- 1:34:18you invite these couple of guys that are bitcoiners?
- 1:34:22And the one guy's like a really senior guy in an investment bank
- 1:34:26here. The other guy was he's like he
- 1:34:33works at a investment technology company where I get we where we
- 1:34:37get our all our investment software.
- 1:34:40So I think there's like probably one Bitcoin at least or maybe 2
- 1:34:45in every single organization, right.
- 1:34:47And so it's going to slowly kind of spread and metastatize from
- 1:34:53those individuals. You know, they're going to
- 1:34:55slowly kind of as I've done, you know, we we've created a few
- 1:35:00more bitcoiners and Cartwright and yeah, yeah.
- 1:35:05It is funny how the the best way to visualize and conceptualize
- 1:35:09what's happening here is through like disease propagation.
- 1:35:14Not disease, Slime mold. Let's go with slime mold just a
- 1:35:16little bit more. Yeah, whatever you want to call
- 1:35:19it, it's you know you can, you can see that you can see the the
- 1:35:24world of of. Gray people, and then little
- 1:35:29dots of orange suddenly spreading their orangeness
- 1:35:33across the Petri dish. And and that's how this goes.
- 1:35:37It's spreading in real time. Marty's a block clock right
- 1:35:40behind his hot sauces at a 2727 Thousand.
- 1:35:43Yeah, about 27. Again, no.
- 1:35:47And the other thing I mean, we talked about this with.
- 1:35:54With Chris from Fidelity. But that's the other thing too.
- 1:35:56I think Bitcoin in the thesis has a lot of tailwinds where
- 1:36:00like we mentioned the beginning of the show, markets are
- 1:36:02completely haywire right now. Like you have oil above 90, the
- 1:36:06stock markets flat, you have yields going crazy, the dollar
- 1:36:10strengthening like Glenn, like you mentioned, like nothing
- 1:36:13makes sense right now and people are being forced to ask these
- 1:36:16hard questions like why has everything gone so haywire?
- 1:36:22And again, talking about tailwinds, whether it be the
- 1:36:25having having individuals like yourself in institutions that
- 1:36:30have the ability to influence decisions of people with a lot
- 1:36:33of capital, we're simply just the incumbent financial system
- 1:36:37going completely haywire as the Fiat experiment sort of runs its
- 1:36:40course like this. Is all Bitcoin just going to be
- 1:36:44waiting here? And that's Bitcoin only.
- 1:36:46People have been screaming for the rooftops for years now.
- 1:36:49Like the crypto stuff is noise. It's really Bitcoin.
- 1:36:52We're here to educate, like when the time is right, like we're
- 1:36:55going to be here, we're going to help you get on the ships.
- 1:36:58But it is pretty insane to think about all the tailwinds they're
- 1:37:02lining up heading into next year.
- 1:37:04I I was talking to Sam earlier and I think one of the biggest
- 1:37:09ones is what happened in February 2022.
- 1:37:12We had Japan, the UK, European Union, US all confiscate
- 1:37:20Russia's assets, right? That's the big one, right?
- 1:37:24That's when Sam was saying to me, when he saw that he was
- 1:37:29like, Bitcoin is now an institutional asset class.
- 1:37:33Yeah, because. And I think that is like, I'll
- 1:37:39tell you a story without him mentioning any names, right.
- 1:37:42So I got, I got invited to this dinner, very fancy kind of Haas
- 1:37:52with like, I don't know, £100 million or whatever, one of the
- 1:37:56big fund managers. And they've got like somebody
- 1:38:02who was a very senior minister in the British government on the
- 1:38:07Advisory Board. And it was like, so we're all
- 1:38:12sitting around this fancy dining room table and he was sitting on
- 1:38:16the other side. And the idea was we don't
- 1:38:19discuss between ourselves. He's kind of the focal point and
- 1:38:23we all ask him questions. So somebody asks a question,
- 1:38:26then he answers, then somebody else gets a chance to answer a
- 1:38:28question, Right. So the first question was from
- 1:38:32the chief investment officer of this fund manager saying, what
- 1:38:37do you think's going to happen in the regulatory space in the
- 1:38:40crypto world? And he was like, look, you guys
- 1:38:43can go away and look at what's going on at crypto.
- 1:38:46You don't in regulation for crypto.
- 1:38:48You don't mean to tell me that. What's more interesting is if I
- 1:38:52tell you why the regulations come in, right.
- 1:38:56And he said that in discussions with, you know, like the most
- 1:39:01senior people in the British government and about their
- 1:39:07conversations with the US government, right, that the US
- 1:39:13have told these senior British officials that they see, he
- 1:39:20said, crypto as a national security threat.
- 1:39:24Right. But I kind of in my own head
- 1:39:28translates that do they see Bitcoin as a national security
- 1:39:33threat? And I think the reason why is
- 1:39:39because if people use this as a treasury reserve assets around
- 1:39:45the world, right, and they stop using U.S.
- 1:39:48Treasuries for that, that would have massive implications for
- 1:39:53the US, right? So I don't think he was saying
- 1:39:57that they think this is inevitable, that there's a big
- 1:40:00chance of this, but they see it as a risk, right?
- 1:40:04And so? Yeah, just something that frames
- 1:40:10my thinking because it's allied to their actions that they took
- 1:40:14in February 2022 because now sort of you know, the 80
- 1:40:18countries around the world to sitting thinking hang on a
- 1:40:21second, that same thing could happen to us, right, if we do
- 1:40:25something that they don't agree with or they could force us to
- 1:40:30do things or say we're going to take your assets or you know,
- 1:40:33and so, yeah, so I think that that's what's kind of opened the
- 1:40:39door to this, you know, becoming an institutional asset class,
- 1:40:45just think it's going to take a long time for people to realize
- 1:40:48it. And you just hit the nail on the
- 1:40:50head why it's so important for you guys on the being able to
- 1:40:53take delivery because that's the big concern is you walk into
- 1:40:57effectively a trap where you're ending up with tokenized Bitcoin
- 1:41:00and then you just, you turn it off whenever you want.
- 1:41:03Yeah, exactly. I I, I think, you know, like, so
- 1:41:07there are institutions that are basically in bed with the US
- 1:41:12government. I mean, they've gotten to the
- 1:41:14position where they have because they're kind of so close to the
- 1:41:19government, right. And now you're going to give
- 1:41:22this, give your money to these people, right, that are so close
- 1:41:28to a government that thinks Bitcoin's a national security
- 1:41:31threat? Doesn't sound like a good idea
- 1:41:33to me. Yeah, very interesting and.
- 1:41:38It's coming. Yeah, it's coming.
- 1:41:41Amped up by that one holding up this Bitcoin war bonds.
- 1:41:46We have to create the custody solutions that make this
- 1:41:50impossible. The Executive Order 69420
- 1:41:54Building on Executive Order 6102.
- 1:41:57You guys know the story that Safety kind of made famous about
- 1:42:02what the Bank of England did in the run up to the First World
- 1:42:07War. You know, that sounds.
- 1:42:12I'm forgetting it. So they're basically, so it
- 1:42:16doesn't sound like a lot these days, but back then it was, you
- 1:42:20know, the GDP of the UK, right? They needed to raise £370
- 1:42:25million. So they issued war bonds at a
- 1:42:28higher interest rate than the normal government bonds, right?
- 1:42:32And only 120 million got taken up, right.
- 1:42:37So there were 250 million short. And So what they did secretly,
- 1:42:43and this was uncovered because the Bank of England decided to
- 1:42:47do a history of the Bank of England.
- 1:42:49So they hired these professional researchers and archivers and
- 1:42:53gave them access to all of the information of that time held in
- 1:42:58these vaults down below the Bank of England, Right.
- 1:43:01And what got uncovered, probably inadvertently right, was what
- 1:43:06they did was they loaned the 250 million to 2 senior members of
- 1:43:12the Bank of England in their personal capacities.
- 1:43:14And these two individuals then use that money to buy up the
- 1:43:18remaining bonds. And then they said to the press,
- 1:43:22this is proof that the the countries behind our entry into
- 1:43:30the First World War because the war bond issuance was
- 1:43:34oversubscribed and when you say light in 2017, right and a.
- 1:43:41Good thing, good thing. Nothing like that happens
- 1:43:43anymore, Glenn. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 1:43:47But that. Was their version of the the
- 1:43:48trillion dollar coin or whatever?
- 1:43:51No, that was their version of weapons of mass destruction.
- 1:43:53It's like that. There's a lot of demand for this
- 1:43:54war bond. We're going to war and.
- 1:43:58And Glenn, I you know the the example of how?
- 1:44:04This isn't potentially national security threat.
- 1:44:07It's it's just so rich because it it it's chickens coming home
- 1:44:11to roost. I mean it it is really just that
- 1:44:14the US got so comfortable being in this position of exporting
- 1:44:19U.S. Treasury bonds, new debt
- 1:44:20issuance in order to sustain a quality of life for, you know,
- 1:44:26U.S. government budget. That was unsustainable.
- 1:44:30It was not rooted in balancing a budget.
- 1:44:32It was deficit spending. And we got so comfortable with
- 1:44:36that and normalize that and we haven't balanced the budget in
- 1:44:3822 years and how dare anybody say, you know what, I don't feel
- 1:44:44comfortable participating in that kind of system where
- 1:44:49inflation is, is an exported tax.
- 1:44:55You know, in exchange for the US military being world police, you
- 1:45:02know, and and how dare anybody say this is not a system I want
- 1:45:05to participate in. And in fact, I would like to
- 1:45:07hold money that is finite. It is.
- 1:45:11It's pretty rich that it's a national security threat because
- 1:45:15the national security that we're talking about here is the
- 1:45:19monopoly on inflation. Marty, Marty Jones hasn't come
- 1:45:26out in the show yet and we try to keep him in the cage for the
- 1:45:28last trade. But it is extremely frustrating
- 1:45:31because it's really bitcoins biggest threat to the national
- 1:45:35military industrial complex. And if the US government and
- 1:45:39those in power actually cared about the security of the
- 1:45:41individuals, they were thinking about the actual security of
- 1:45:44American citizens. They would recognize that the
- 1:45:48debt situation that they've created over the last. 100 plus
- 1:45:51years is the actual security threats and Bitcoin is a way to
- 1:45:56sort of release and lessen the pressure that your everyday
- 1:46:00American citizen is feeling and allows them to escape the
- 1:46:05security threat that the government has created with all
- 1:46:07this debt. And these people do not have
- 1:46:12your best interests at heart. That's I'll be Marty will say
- 1:46:15it, Marty Jones will say it lightly There.
- 1:46:19I was going to say, I'll tell you another irony, right.
- 1:46:23So that's because once we've explained our thesis about
- 1:46:27Bitcoin and how it fits into portfolio and what function it
- 1:46:30provides and whatever, then the usual questions come.
- 1:46:34But isn't it bad for the environment?
- 1:46:36Isn't it only used by criminals? You know, all of this kind of
- 1:46:40stuff, right? So we figured, okay, we've got
- 1:46:43to address all these things. And the ESG framework is what
- 1:46:48everyone believes in, right? Right here or wrong here.
- 1:46:51So let's use the ESG framework to evaluate Bitcoin, right?
- 1:46:56So in the energy part, talking about the military industrial
- 1:46:59complex and everything, I point out the fact that after the US
- 1:47:06went off the gold standard in 1971, they did that deal with
- 1:47:10the Saudis, which created the Petro dollar, right?
- 1:47:15So at the same time that you're criticizing this thing for being
- 1:47:21in bad for the environment, the global reserve currency is also
- 1:47:26known as the Petro dollar. That's a pretty ironic thing,
- 1:47:31yeah. You guys have had a lot of time
- 1:47:36to think about this. I like it.
- 1:47:37I hadn't heard a lot of these anecdotes, but they're really
- 1:47:40they're really good to. Be able the position yeah, we
- 1:47:44talk about what the deal was that essentially we'll sell you
- 1:47:49as many weapons as you want right.
- 1:47:52And then you're part of the deal is you price oil in dollars,
- 1:47:59right. And then the rest of OPEC did
- 1:48:01it. And race is ancient history, you
- 1:48:05know, So this thing is actually the solution to all that kind of
- 1:48:11stuff, right? And they're trying to.
- 1:48:15I don't know who, I don't know if it's misunderstanding, but it
- 1:48:18certainly feels like there's an agenda here, right?
- 1:48:21Which is your point at the solution.
- 1:48:24And it's like you project all the things that you're guilty of
- 1:48:29onto it. You know, it's a Ponzi scheme.
- 1:48:33It's bad for the environment. It's, you know, all of these
- 1:48:36things, right? Yeah.
- 1:48:39It facilitates money laundering. It's like me to say you guys,
- 1:48:44trillions of dollars, literally. That's funny.
- 1:48:47I never thought about that way that the energy exists, like the
- 1:48:50energy exists of the Ponzi and the money laundering.
- 1:48:52It's just being deflected to a different direction versus it's
- 1:48:55still like there. They just have to put position
- 1:48:57it in a different way. Yeah.
- 1:49:03Before Marty Jones gets too far out of the cage, I think we
- 1:49:06should wrap up here because I can.
- 1:49:10I'll I'll channel that energy for rabbit hole recap in a
- 1:49:12couple of hours. But Glenn, just before we wrap
- 1:49:17up, like any party notes to any of the individuals who may be in
- 1:49:22similar positions at different firms across the world, like,
- 1:49:26what would your advice to them be?
- 1:49:28Yeah. So number one is read the
- 1:49:32prospectus, right? Make sure that the vehicle that
- 1:49:38you invest in is bankruptcy remote, right.
- 1:49:43Because one of the things that we set our clients is this thing
- 1:49:46exists outside the financial system, right?
- 1:49:50So one Bitcoin is always going to equal 1 Bitcoin, and it
- 1:49:53doesn't matter what goes on elsewhere, you're gonna still
- 1:49:57have that thing, right? But in some of the risk
- 1:50:00disclosures of the fund prospectuses that I've read,
- 1:50:04it's specifically lists as one of the risks that if there's a
- 1:50:09bankruptcy event, the Bitcoin could get bailed into the
- 1:50:13bankruptcy, right? So then what's the point of
- 1:50:16Bitcoin, right? And the second thing is, if the
- 1:50:22fund manager, the litmus test for us is, can we take, can we
- 1:50:30take custody of the Bitcoin ourselves?
- 1:50:32So do you allow an NSPC transfer and then show us how your
- 1:50:41custodial solution convince us that you know there's absolutely
- 1:50:48no way that you can? Because when I read through the
- 1:50:53prospectuses, right, what I want to see is for them to
- 1:50:57specifically say rehypothecation is not allowed, right.
- 1:51:03But they don't say that. So it's kind of like if you
- 1:51:07don't state that in the rules of the fund, how do I know that
- 1:51:11you're not going to do that at some point.
- 1:51:13So make sure that the custody solution, because this is a
- 1:51:19unique asset where you can have three people, five people, as
- 1:51:24many people as you like making sure that that Bitcoin is there.
- 1:51:29So make sure you set up a a solution like that.
- 1:51:34And you know like that famous fidelity thing is get off 0
- 1:51:40right, the wrong allocation for Bitcoin, the only wrong
- 1:51:44allocation for Bitcoin is 0 right.
- 1:51:48And I would also say that institutional investors, you
- 1:51:53know, you don't have to go to your full allocation at once.
- 1:51:57In fact, the way we would suggest to our clients to
- 1:52:00allocate to Bitcoin is to, in our case, palm cost average or
- 1:52:05dollar cost average into the asset, right.
- 1:52:09And if you're worried about risk, make sure that you set it
- 1:52:12up in such a way that rebalancing is easy, so you can
- 1:52:15control the risk of the whole portfolio.
- 1:52:19Yeah, those are the last things I can bring up here.
- 1:52:24That's fantastic guidance. Yes, but I'm very happy that you
- 1:52:28exist as a person, that you're in the position.
- 1:52:34That he does exist. Awesome.
- 1:52:35Yeah. Glenn, I'm really thankful for
- 1:52:37you for being a leader and speaking up and sharing, because
- 1:52:40I think, you know, we all want to be unique.
- 1:52:42But I think a lot of the thoughts you have, a lot of
- 1:52:44people are thinking about and they just, you know, either
- 1:52:46don't feel comfortable and insane or or or just need
- 1:52:49somebody to help them kind of like frame that.
- 1:52:52That model of what they're looking for, So I really
- 1:52:54appreciate it. My pleasure.
- 1:52:56Yeah, keep crushing it. I think this episode's gonna be
- 1:53:00very well received. Good stuff, man.
- 1:53:04All right, that's all we got this week.
- 1:53:06We'll be back here on the last trade for another episode next
- 1:53:10week. See ya.