Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 99: Some thoughts on tip culture, in France & beyond
Transcript
- 0:08Do listen to the New Paris. I'm your host, Wendy trim, you
- 0:12do. There's no guests for today's
- 0:15episode. I know it's been a while since
- 0:17I've done one of these monologues but I wanted to talk
- 0:19about a topic I was recently asked to write about for Elle
- 0:23Magazine in France, and that's the subject of tipping and tip
- 0:27culture. Given that tourism across France
- 0:29is back in a big way and the French themselves are back to
- 0:32traveling beyond their borders. The question of if and how much
- 0:35to tip has resurfaced and because my story was in French,
- 0:39I had a few requests to discuss the theme in English.
- 0:42So here we go. Let me preface this by saying it
- 0:45was a particularly timely and fresh in mind subject of debate
- 0:49for me to write about because I was recently in the US I'm no
- 0:54stranger to American tip culture but it felt especially jarring
- 0:57on this last trip. Sure.
- 0:59Due to an ongoing supply chain issue and the Start of Greater
- 1:03inflation. At that time, I noticed that
- 1:05products and services simply cost more, but that doesn't
- 1:08fully explain why. I wager I Must Have Spent
- 1:11between 50 to 60 percent more on average for meals services and
- 1:16experiences than I ever do in France.
- 1:19For the record, I was in New York City and the Philadelphia
- 1:21suburbs. Overall, after living in France,
- 1:24for 16 years. The sticker shock at every turn
- 1:27was simply overwhelming. So at the end of each meal, the
- 1:32way things would go whenever I was eating outside of the home,
- 1:36my dining Companions and I would dig into our wallets fiddle with
- 1:40our smartphone calculators and then decide how much money to
- 1:43give our server or a bartender for a job.
- 1:46Well done. Now even before covid any less
- 1:49than 20% on the bill before tax in the US was considered.
- 1:53Insulting as a kid. I remember, it was much lower
- 1:56than that. But over time, this has climbed
- 1:59to 20% after a massive push to show solidarity for restaurant
- 2:03and service workers throughout covid.
- 2:05Some people even edged that up to 25 percent and according to
- 2:09who you ask that may One D, One Day become the new standard of
- 2:14course, by the end of my first week in the u.s.
- 2:16I was ready to forego dining out, entirely a separate topic.
- 2:20We can discuss at some point would be the value the quality.
- 2:23Of the food you're getting for the money spent but again I'll
- 2:27leave that for another day. So the question is, why does
- 2:30this system exist and how should you navigate the same issue of
- 2:33tipping in France? Well first, let's begin with one
- 2:36thing. It's easy to assume that tip
- 2:38culture was born in the US but in fact that's not entirely true
- 2:42historically. It's believed that wealthy
- 2:44Americans on a luxurious voyages to Europe in the Years leading
- 2:49up to the Civil War brought back the custom of tipping, it is
- 2:52thought to have Of originated actually in the 17th century.
- 2:55In England, in English taverns were customers would slip a
- 2:59little extra money to the waiter to insure prompt service in the
- 3:03late 1800s. Following the Civil War, there
- 3:06was a movement against tipping in the US as many Americans
- 3:09believe that tipping, when against the country's ideals and
- 3:12allowed a clear survival class, that would be financially
- 3:15dependent on a higher class. There were even failed attempts
- 3:19to pass anti tipping bills, that would have deemed the practice.
- 3:24Of course, we know how things shifted after that, and without
- 3:27a legal framework, tube, and gratuities employers hiring
- 3:30recently, emancipated slaves and also immigrants in Hospitality,
- 3:34or on the railroad took that to mean that they could pay them
- 3:37next to nothing, forcing them to rely on gratuities for the
- 3:41majority of their pay from there.
- 3:43The practice anchored in exploitation, proliferated.
- 3:48Even today, as some reports indicate tip, tipped workers of
- 3:52color, continue to suffer the consequences of this Legacy in
- 3:55the restaurant industry alone, over 27 percent of black
- 3:58workers. Live in poverty, about 37% of
- 4:02tipped workers are mothers and nearly half of these.
- 4:04Women are single mothers one last bit that's crucial to
- 4:08understand and which most foreigners don't realize.
- 4:10Is that in the u.s. there are minimum wages for hourly workers
- 4:14which could range from $7.25. Which is the federal minimum
- 4:19wage to $15 an hour in cities, like New York.
- 4:22But there are federal and state laws that allow employers to pay
- 4:25workers who receive tips far less than the minimum wage.
- 4:29That's called the federal sub-minimum tipped wage and it
- 4:32has been stuck at $2.13 per hour since 1991.
- 4:38So when you're dining out, you're essentially paying the
- 4:41salary that the employer should actually be paying the worker,
- 4:45some restaurant industry leaders like Danny Meyer's.
- 4:47Whose group is behind the Gramercy Tavern and the fast
- 4:50casual chain Shake Shack. Have tried to end tipping
- 4:53policies, Myers actually pioneered the idea in 2015, but
- 4:57reinstated them in the summer of 2020.
- 4:59Citing slashed revenues, from the pandemic.
- 5:02You can read more about that at the link I shared in the show
- 5:04notes of this episode. So the u.s. context is very
- 5:08particular in France, aside from the majority of delivery workers
- 5:12service workers earn a salary, it may be minimum wage, which is
- 5:16currently a The rate of 10 euros and 85 cents or more according
- 5:21to an establishments ability to offer higher wages.
- 5:24Some 20 to 30 years ago tipping was more common in France and
- 5:27represented a 13th or 14th month of earnings.
- 5:31But over time the mentality has shifted first, there's the
- 5:35belief that due to the Social and fiscal system in France,
- 5:37which also allows for certain level of labor protection.
- 5:40That Americans simply do not have tipping.
- 5:43Seems like an unnecessary bonus. Also French, people have grown
- 5:47accustomed to consuming more cheaply.
- 5:48If you look at the development of big-box supermarkets and fast
- 5:51food, chains that have dominated the French landscape for the,
- 5:54the last 20 to 30 years, they struggled to see the value in
- 5:58paying for service on top of the food or beverage itself.
- 6:03A more modern issue is also that the French pay more and more by
- 6:06card. One out of two transactions.
- 6:08In France has actually paid by credit card or debit card
- 6:11leading to empty change. Purses.
- 6:14If you pay by card, you may not have the same.
- 6:15In kind of spare change on you, that you used to when you were
- 6:18paying everything by cash, the US has mostly adjusted for this
- 6:21Reality by allowing customers to add tip on their credit card
- 6:25payment but that has yet to take off in France.
- 6:28So what's the suggestion? And what's the rule in France?
- 6:31Forces elsewhere in and around Europe?
- 6:34I hate to say it but there's really no absolute truth here.
- 6:37Leaving a little tip is still considered a bonus for great
- 6:40service in most European countries as opposed to an
- 6:43integral part of someone's livelihood.
- 6:45Tips are certainly widespread and widely appreciated
- 6:48particularly in Italy, Spain and Germany were they are more
- 6:51expected than even in Belgium or France.
- 6:54The exception is perhaps in Denmark.
- 6:55Norway Sweden, Finland and Iceland were service.
- 6:58Charges are built into prices and employee wages.
- 7:01What you can do if you'd like his round up to the nearest Euro
- 7:04when you pay for services. But beyond that, it isn't
- 7:06compulsory to add extra in restaurants or hotels.
- 7:10However, in Iceland no professions are tipped.
- 7:13As a matter, of course, So should you leave a little
- 7:16something in France? Yeah and maybe you want to leave
- 7:19a little more than the French who want to average hover at
- 7:21five percent tip making them the worst tippers in Europe here.
- 7:26If you're not sure how much to leave you can go with the 10%
- 7:28rule in most places that's considered fair and even
- 7:32generous and won't offend in taxis you can round up to the
- 7:35nearest Euro and you can offer a little something extra to your
- 7:38hairdresser here to with less purchasing power.
- 7:41Not everyone can give the tip they like.
- 7:44But if Can in restaurants, think of it this way, one or two
- 7:48Euros, extra in a cafe. If the service was Solid 5
- 7:52Euros, give or take if the service was exceptional.
- 7:55Resist the temptation to leave one cent pieces.
- 7:57If the service was awful. I know you think that might be
- 8:00sending a message but it's just better to leave nothing at all.
- 8:03And in fine, dining restaurants where you may already be
- 8:06emptying your wallet or your life savings.
- 8:08Five to ten percent is plenty generous.
- 8:11If of course you feel you want to leave something extra As is,
- 8:16as I said, there is no hard and fast rule.
- 8:18So, go with your instincts, I hope this helps as you're
- 8:21potentially traveling through, France and clarifies a bit of
- 8:24the complicated and problematic origins of tipping to begin
- 8:27with. If you're in, France, and read
- 8:29French, I'll also be in this week's issue of Elle talking
- 8:32about the problem of no-shows in restaurants, and how a group of
- 8:35around 100 chefs in Industry, workers are standing up to put a
- 8:38stop to bad behavior. I'll be back soon enough with
- 8:42new episodes until then you can find me online.
- 8:44Or if I'm doing this whole boundary setting thing properly,
- 8:47maybe you won't either way. Thanks as always for listening
- 8:51and I'll be up to laughs that's the show for today.
- 8:55As always, thank you for listening subscribing and
- 8:58sharing with Friends, you can find all previous episodes of
- 9:01the new Paris podcast wherever you stream your podcasts and on
- 9:04world radio Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 9:07conversations, please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 9:09Paris book or my recent release for new Precision from your
- 9:13local Bookseller. Hours, until next time, I'm in
- 9:16poop.