Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The 2025 LA Fires: Your Insurance and Legal Rights in the Aftermath, and What toto Expect in 2026
Transcript
- 0:01you Welcome to the 2025 LA Fires A Year in Review
- 0:06and What's Ahead in 2026. I'm Belinda McCauley,
- 0:10BHBA's Executive Director and CEO. Just over
- 0:12a year ago, right after the fires, our speakers
- 0:15today presented a public service webinar through
- 0:17BHBA about how to file homeowner insurance claims.
- 0:20More than 10 ,000 people watched that webinar,
- 0:22which was scheduled for an hour, but ended up
- 0:24going more than two and a half hours so that
- 0:26the attorneys could answer a huge volume of audience
- 0:28questions. We received extensive feedback about
- 0:30how helpful that program was, so we invited the
- 0:32speakers back a year later to share more of their
- 0:34time and expertise. So I'm honoured to be here
- 0:37today to introduce them. Digitality, and Riddle
- 0:43LLP, where she represents clients in complex
- 0:46litigation matters, including business employment
- 0:48and mass torts, while also serving as the firm's
- 0:50managing partner. A recognized leader in mass
- 0:53tort disaster litigation, she has held court
- 0:55-appointed leadership roles in major wildfire
- 0:58and explosion cases, helping secure a landmark
- 1:00$13 .5 billion settlement in the PG &E bankruptcy
- 1:04and more than $1 .5 billion in compensation for
- 1:07more than 6 ,000 victims. Ms. Riddle also leads
- 1:10the firm's employment law practice and is known
- 1:12for her commitment to public service, including
- 1:14co -founding the San Mateo County Bar Association
- 1:16Legal Clinic Committee to provide legal services
- 1:18to unhoused people. Stacey Monahan Tucker is
- 1:21the founder and principal of Monahan Tucker Law,
- 1:23where she leads the firm's insurance practice,
- 1:26which is focused on complex disability, life,
- 1:28and long -term care matters. After earning her
- 1:30law degree from the University of Chicago Law
- 1:33School, she spent the first decade of her career
- 1:35at Jones Day and Quinn Emmanuel in San Francisco,
- 1:38representing insurers in high -stakes litigation
- 1:40involving multi -million dollar claims. Her background
- 1:43as a management consultant to national insurers
- 1:45and elite insurance litigators provides her with
- 1:48deep insight into the most complex insurance
- 1:51disputes affecting executives, professionals,
- 1:53and business owners. Stacey also chairs the HBA's
- 1:56insurance law section. John Torbett is a trial
- 1:59lawyer at Kramer Law, whose practice focuses
- 2:02on complex business, real property, and insurance
- 2:04litigation, including bad faith, landlord -tenant,
- 2:08partnership and governance disputes, entertainment,
- 2:10and securities matters. An experienced trial
- 2:13advocate, he's tried multiple jury and bench
- 2:15trials and FINRA arbitrations, securing seven
- 2:17-figure judgments, numerous six -figure settlements,
- 2:20and a $5 .6 million inverse condemnation verdict
- 2:23against the city of LA. Mr. Torbett brings industry
- 2:26-specific insight from representing clients across
- 2:28film and television, real estate, finance, hospitality,
- 2:32and digital commerce, as well as from his early
- 2:34career work in the entertainment industry following
- 2:36his education at Vanderbilt University and SMU
- 2:39-Deadman School of Law. And now, let's get started.
- 2:42Hi. I was here a year ago talking with all of
- 2:47you about what your... options are in the face
- 2:51of a massive disaster like losing your home and
- 2:54a wildfire, especially when thousands upon thousands
- 2:57of other people are dealing with it as well.
- 3:01We delved last year into the weeds quite a bit
- 3:05on what the current state of the law and regulations
- 3:10were governing these issues. I'm going to do
- 3:13a quick review of those since I realize not all
- 3:17of you were with us a year ago and also are living
- 3:22our lives and not dealing with insurance regulations
- 3:25every day. So just to start with as a quick reminder,
- 3:30The California Department of Insurance has issued
- 3:33a variety of regulations that largely went into
- 3:37effect in 2024 and the beginning of 2025, just
- 3:41before the wildfires. One of the things we've
- 3:44seen is that insurance companies, partly because
- 3:47these are new and partly because insurance claims
- 3:51adjusters are all over the country. often abruptly
- 3:56assigned to these California wildfires, they
- 3:58don't necessarily have a background in knowing
- 4:01the law in California and the regulations they
- 4:03have to follow. as a reminder to you and you
- 4:07can remind your claims adjusters if these remain
- 4:10issues. Your insurer, if you lost your home,
- 4:14was required to advance four months of additional
- 4:17living expenses immediately upon the loss of
- 4:19your home. Hopefully that's a non -issue as this
- 4:22is well in the past, but be aware of that. If
- 4:25you are still struggling with living expenses
- 4:27and they did not do in advance, that is something
- 4:31you can push on. They had to offer an immediate
- 4:34payment of at least 30 % of the value of your
- 4:38coverage A, coverage A is their home replacement,
- 4:42up to $250 ,000 for your personal property, which
- 4:46is usually listed as coverage C. They don't have
- 4:50to exceed the value of your personal property,
- 4:53but they do have to go up to $250 ,000 if you
- 4:56have that much coverage. If you are making a
- 5:00claim, and you're fighting with the insurance
- 5:03company about how it's set up, you don't have
- 5:05to use their forms. You just have to provide
- 5:08them the information in any format that's easiest
- 5:10for you. You can bulk list items. You don't have
- 5:14to itemize everything. If your insurer is pushing
- 5:18back on this and causing a lot of delay and frustration,
- 5:22you can remind them of that. That is Insurance
- 5:25Code Section 206A23, if that's helpful. Even
- 5:32if your property was unharmed, your insurer was
- 5:35required to pay living expenses while you were
- 5:39restricted from accessing your property. As you
- 5:42know, many people were unable to access their
- 5:45homes even if they weren't destroyed in the wildfires
- 5:48because the entire neighborhood was closed off.
- 5:51If that remains an issue for you, you can continue
- 5:54to push back on that. Also, your insurer has
- 6:01to provide you a copy of the policy, the entire
- 6:05policy, not just the declarations page. They
- 6:08have to provide you all documents in your file
- 6:11upon request. They don't seem to know that most
- 6:16of the time. So if you want to know everything
- 6:18that's happening in your claim, you can demand
- 6:20a copy of all claims related documents under
- 6:24Insurance Code Section 2071 that can let you
- 6:28see the information they're working with and
- 6:30their internal notes about what's happening.
- 6:33They have to respond to questions, letters, calls
- 6:36and emails within 15 days of receiving them.
- 6:40They are supposed to accept or reject a claim
- 6:43in full within 40 days of receiving proof of
- 6:46the claim. This is something that's hard to tie
- 6:49insurance companies to because what constitutes
- 6:52receipt of proof of the claim when it's an ongoing
- 6:55claim and an ongoing rebuild process? In reality,
- 7:00nothing is going to be done within 40 days, as
- 7:02I'm sure all of you living through this are well
- 7:05aware. If your claim is denied for any reason,
- 7:09they have to put all the factual and legal bases
- 7:12in writing in the denial letter. And if they
- 7:14accept the claim, they have to pay all the undisputed
- 7:18portions within 30 days. As I noted, the regulations
- 7:23provide a pretty easy way around these timeframes,
- 7:25though, because they can ask for more time if
- 7:28they need to dig into something more. They just
- 7:31have to note that they're taking that extra time
- 7:34in writing. As you've seen, claims adjusters
- 7:38are overwhelmed during disasters. They have hundreds
- 7:41upon hundreds of files assigned to them. Everybody
- 7:44wants immediate assistance, which is understandable.
- 7:48Insurance, because of that, the insureds often
- 7:51didn't have a point of contact that they could
- 7:55rely on. And the California Department of Insurance
- 8:00requires somebody who's been assigned to three
- 8:04or more different claims adjusters in a six -month
- 8:07period, the insurance company now has to provide
- 8:10a written status report summarizing what's happening
- 8:13in the claim and provide one ongoing person to
- 8:17be a stable point of contact. If you've been
- 8:20dealing with that and your insurance company
- 8:21hasn't been following that, that is now required
- 8:25under Insurance Code Sections 2071 and 14 -0
- 8:30-47. So you can push back on your insurer if
- 8:33you have no idea what's happening and you're
- 8:36just getting bounced around and not getting any
- 8:37clear answers. Be aware. You can get up to 24
- 8:44months of additional living expenses automatically
- 8:46plus an additional 12 months. So a full 36 months
- 8:51if you're encountering delays in your rebuild.
- 8:56A lot of people have been asking me if that extension
- 9:01also applies to purchasing a new home. And no,
- 9:05it does not. This applies to rebuild because
- 9:09there can be so many difficulties in rebuilding.
- 9:12The same difficulties don't exist in identifying
- 9:15and purchasing a new home. You do not have up
- 9:19to three years to find a new home at your convenience
- 9:23while you are living on ALE. Be aware of that.
- 9:30That's been coming up a lot. Also, if you are
- 9:33having difficulty with your insurance company
- 9:36agreeing on what it's going to cost to rebuild,
- 9:39you should invoke the appraisal provision in
- 9:43your policy. Every insurance policy has one.
- 9:47You can demand appraisal. Both sides have to
- 9:51pay for their own appraiser and split the cost
- 9:54of a third neutral appraiser. All three of those
- 9:57appraisers look at what it should cost to rebuild
- 9:59your home and agree on an amount. And then the
- 10:04insurance company is tied to that amount. They
- 10:07have to pay it. This is by far the fastest and
- 10:12cleanest way to get the amount that it will cost
- 10:15to rebuild your home quickly and indisputably
- 10:21determined. I've had many of the calls I've received
- 10:25have been looking to hire an attorney to represent
- 10:28them in these negotiations and to be clear, you
- 10:31don't want an attorney to hire you to represent
- 10:35you on an ongoing basis with your insurance company.
- 10:38It does not speed it up. It simply costs you
- 10:41a lot of money. And on top of it, if you hire
- 10:45a lawyer during the negotiation process, that
- 10:49lawyer is quite possibly going to be barred from
- 10:54representing you in any litigation that might
- 10:57be required against the insurance company because
- 10:59they are a witness to everything that happened
- 11:01in the negotiations. I always recommend finding
- 11:06a reputable public adjuster to represent you
- 11:10in these negotiations if you strongly feel that
- 11:13you need representation. That is literally what
- 11:16they do. It is the reason for their existence.
- 11:20And if you want somebody to represent you, That's
- 11:24the road to go. A lawyer is going to cost a lot
- 11:28more. And in the long run, you anticipate that
- 11:31the lawyer that you hire will be able to help
- 11:33you in any litigation. But in fact, that's not
- 11:36how this works. Also, one more thing about appraisal.
- 11:43If the damage is due to a government declared
- 11:45disaster, the insurer cannot compel you to use
- 11:51appraisal. I believe you can still require it,
- 11:54however. And not every wild victim, as I mentioned,
- 11:58wants to rebuild. anything you want in terms
- 12:06of purchasing a new property and all of your
- 12:08coverages can be put towards that. That includes
- 12:10extended replacement coverage, separate structure
- 12:13coverage and building code upgrade coverage.
- 12:16All of it can get bundled in to the purchase
- 12:18of a new home. However, you're not going to be
- 12:22able to access those coverages until you show
- 12:24that you are under contract for a new home. So
- 12:27there's a certain amount of a chicken and egg
- 12:30issue that I've had insureds call me about. How
- 12:33do I purchase this if I don't have the funds
- 12:35until after I purchase? It's a good question.
- 12:38Usually you need to go into the mortgage yourself,
- 12:42get all of that set up, and then once you have
- 12:45a contract that you can show the insurance company,
- 12:47you're entitled to the funds. I understand that
- 12:50this is frustrating, but there's no way around
- 12:54it. And as previously noted, the... time extensions
- 12:58that apply for rebuilding when you run into delays
- 13:02do not necessarily apply to the purchase of a
- 13:05new home. So keep that in mind. Hopefully nobody
- 13:12has had their insurance cancelled because of
- 13:15the wildfires. The insurance companies are not
- 13:16allowed to do that. They have to offer to renew
- 13:19for at least 24 months after the fire. So you
- 13:23should have coverage at least you had it through
- 13:262025. Hopefully you should have it through 2026
- 13:28as well. After that, however, it is possible
- 13:32for them to decline to renew. So please be aware
- 13:38of all of that. And what we've been seeing in
- 13:432025 and into the beginning of 2026 are an enormous
- 13:47number of smoke and ash claims that people have
- 13:52been struggling with. obtaining coverage on,
- 13:56especially with the fare plan. Many people are
- 14:00covered by the fare plan, including in the Palisades
- 14:03and Eaton areas. And the fare plan has taken
- 14:07repeatedly a hard line against providing any
- 14:10sort of coverage for smoke and ash, insisting
- 14:14that it can be simply cleaned up. and there's
- 14:17no issues. There was a case that came out in
- 14:21February 2025. It's called, if I'm pronouncing
- 14:24this right, Garibian versus Wawanessa. And in
- 14:30that case, the insured sued their insurance company
- 14:34because they were not damaged at all in the fire,
- 14:38but they had fire debris throughout their property
- 14:41and wanted the insurance company to pay to clean
- 14:43that up. It went to the appellate court in California
- 14:49and the appellate court held that direct physical
- 14:52loss requires actual damage and needing to clean
- 14:57up debris does not constitute damage. And so
- 15:01the court found in favor of the insurance company
- 15:05on that. And the fair plan has been pushing on
- 15:08that, claiming that if it can be cleaned up,
- 15:11that they don't need to cover it. However, a
- 15:15number of sources have disagreed on that, including
- 15:19the California Department of Insurance, who is
- 15:22currently pursuing a fair plan directly about
- 15:25this refusal to pay for smoke and ash. Because,
- 15:30as those of you living with it know, smoke and
- 15:33ash isn't a simple matter of taking a washcloth
- 15:37and cleaning out your house. it completely can
- 15:41destroy the interior and livability of your home.
- 15:44And that is very different than having to pick
- 15:47up burnt branches in the back of your yard. And
- 15:51so the California Department of Insurance has
- 15:54been focusing on this. And there is also a plaintiff
- 15:58side law firm called Curly Shafer, who is bringing
- 16:03class actions against insurance against the fair
- 16:06plan for all of its various failures, which include
- 16:12the position they take on smoke and ash. My understanding,
- 16:17and I am not involved in this litigation in any
- 16:19way, but just to be clear, my understanding is
- 16:22they are looking at the fair plan's attempts
- 16:26to limit coverage, to fail to meet state requirements,
- 16:31and to refuse laboratory testing, and the typical
- 16:37approaches required in remediating smoke and
- 16:41ash damage. I don't know where that stands right
- 16:44now, but I do know that it's been filed and I
- 16:47would encourage somebody who is dealing with
- 16:50this themselves with Fair Plan to reach out to
- 16:53Curly Shafer and find out what they're doing
- 16:55and how you can be involved. I would also encourage
- 17:01anybody who is finding themselves repeatedly
- 17:08stonewalled by their insurance company to the
- 17:11point where their coverage is not being paid
- 17:14or they've received an actual denial, especially
- 17:17with an actual denial, to reach out to counsel
- 17:21and find out what your options are. This is not
- 17:24the same situation as asking someone to represent
- 17:26you in ongoing negotiations. Insurance companies
- 17:29delay. I would love to tell you that that in
- 17:33and of itself is a basis for litigation, but
- 17:35in most cases, it's not going to resolve it.
- 17:39It will take another two to five years for that
- 17:42lawsuit to get resolved. There may be faster
- 17:45ways for you to get past the amount of delay.
- 17:53Stacy, just while you're on those notes, we're
- 17:57getting a lot of questions in the Q &A about
- 18:02Loss of use coverage. So if the insurance companies
- 18:06are delaying in paying out, does that result
- 18:11in an extension of the loss of use? If a loss
- 18:14of use is either 24 months or 36 months or a
- 18:17lump sum and that lump sum has already been paid
- 18:20out or those 24, 36 months are exhausted before
- 18:25the rebuild was completed, will the insurance
- 18:30company extend that? ALE coverage? They do not
- 18:34have to. There are situations, depending on the
- 18:39language of your policy and the exact situation
- 18:42in which you're in, where the insurance company
- 18:45can choose to, but they are not required to extend
- 18:50beyond the 36 months. They are also not required
- 18:54to extend beyond the lump. Whatever amount is
- 18:57if there's a cap in the policy, which many policies
- 19:01have caps on the amount of loss of use that's
- 19:04going to be paid in total, they do not have to
- 19:07pay anything beyond that, even if it's taking
- 19:10a ridiculous amount of time for the rebuild.
- 19:13And even if those delays can be laid at the foot
- 19:17of the insurance company, that could potentially
- 19:20be the basis for a lawsuit. And that that basis
- 19:24could be a reason that the insurance company
- 19:26could choose to cover this rather than find themselves
- 19:30dealing with an entirely separate lawsuit on
- 19:34this issue. But there is nothing in the policy
- 19:37or in the insurance regulations that requires
- 19:40them to do it. And that is another issue that
- 19:43I hear a lot is we need more ALE. How can I maximize
- 19:48this ALE? It is limited to what is in the policy
- 19:51and the extension that the regulations provide.
- 19:54If you have a cap on it, That cap is a hard cap.
- 19:58They are not required to pay more, even if your
- 20:02house is nowhere close to being built at the
- 20:04time that you run out. I recognize that is not
- 20:08what people want to hear, but it is the law and
- 20:12it is very difficult to get around. So be aware
- 20:16of that. And John, you look like you might have
- 20:18had some experience on that front with your own
- 20:21clients. Well, we have, and to be honest, a lot
- 20:25of my experience is from the Woolsey fire. And
- 20:27obviously the time frame on getting these rebuilds
- 20:30done, especially now, given the volume of permits
- 20:36and everything else. I drove around the Palisades
- 20:39about six weeks ago. I saw, I counted, I saw
- 20:42nine houses being framed in the main park, kind
- 20:46of where the alphabet streets around the village,
- 20:49just in that area. and thousands of lots just
- 20:53sitting there fallow. But that's unfortunately
- 20:55going to be an issue. And if there's no third
- 20:57viable third party for litigation, typically
- 21:00that's what you do, is you sue the responsible
- 21:02party to try to make up the delta between your
- 21:04insurance coverage and what your actual losses
- 21:06are. And unfortunately, in the palisades, and
- 21:09I'll get to that when it's my turn, just the
- 21:11brief discussion of the litigation going on there.
- 21:15That there, whatever that'll be, we'll see how
- 21:18that's resolved fairly shortly. But unfortunately,
- 21:22the insurance, they're obligated to pay out what
- 21:24the contract amount is on the policy. And if
- 21:28you've got losses that exceed that, that's really
- 21:32brutal, but that's just the way it is if there's
- 21:34no viable third party for litigation. And I'm
- 21:38going to wrap this up because I realize we have
- 21:40a lot to cover. But one more, the other area
- 21:43that I've been receiving a lot of inquiries about
- 21:45is under insurance. Most people, now that they
- 21:49are dealing with this, realize that they are
- 21:51underinsured and they are very frustrated. They
- 21:54want to blame the insurance company for this,
- 21:56which I completely understand. The courts have
- 22:00been clear, there are very limited situations
- 22:03in which an insurance company can be held responsible
- 22:05for your underinsurance. Most insurance companies
- 22:09on an annual basis provide the summary of your
- 22:16coverage and their estimate of what it would
- 22:19cost to rebuild and say, if you have any questions,
- 22:23contact us. If you received those, if you received
- 22:27an estimate of what it would cost to rebuild
- 22:31your house broken down into various categories
- 22:34and you did not respond, even if you didn't notice
- 22:38it, if it was buried in a 40 -page dump of documents
- 22:42that they give you each year, unfortunately,
- 22:45the courts hold that sufficient. The situations
- 22:48in which you can push back on underinsurance
- 22:50are when you contacted and can demonstrate that
- 22:54you contacted your insurer and you asked, do
- 22:58I have enough insurance? I'm worried about this.
- 23:01And they come back to you and they say, yes,
- 23:05you have enough to rebuild. Don't worry about
- 23:08it. If your agent or the insurance company had
- 23:12that exchange with you. especially if it's in
- 23:15writing. That is a situation in which you could
- 23:19potentially have the basis to push back on your
- 23:23underinsurance. Short of that, it is extremely
- 23:27difficult to make the argument that you were
- 23:31underinsured and it is the fault of the insurance
- 23:34company. The law is clear that the insureds,
- 23:39we... choose our own insurance amount. And while
- 23:41we all know, in reality, it doesn't work that
- 23:43way, that they provide you a number and you accept
- 23:46it. And that's pretty much it. The law was put
- 23:50into place on this well a long time ago when
- 23:53you had the option of complete guaranteed coverage.
- 23:57And at that point, the court said, well, if you
- 23:59have the option of guaranteed coverage and you're
- 24:01choosing not to accept that, then you've chosen
- 24:04your coverage and that's on you. Since then,
- 24:07guaranteed coverage has disappeared. There's
- 24:08nothing we can do about that. Courts have decided
- 24:11to continue to rely on the argument that you
- 24:15choose your own coverage. If you contacted your
- 24:19insurer or your agent and asked for more coverage
- 24:22and you were denied, or you asked for more coverage
- 24:26and they told you you had enough, those are the
- 24:29situations in which you may have an argument.
- 24:31Short of that, I've received dozens of inquiries
- 24:36about this. Short of that, there's really not
- 24:38much you can do. And with that, I'm going to
- 24:41turn it over to the people who have been dealing
- 24:43with the third party lawsuits in this trying
- 24:47to find out who's responsible for the fires and
- 24:51what they can be expected to receive from them.
- 24:58Yeah, do you? Well, do you want to talk? Do you
- 25:01have any specific insurance bad faith issues
- 25:04you want to add to Stacy before we move on to
- 25:06third party liability? Because I know that's
- 25:08also your area. I think Stacy covered pretty
- 25:11much everything. If there are questions that
- 25:13people have, I am dealing with specific cases,
- 25:16which obviously may or may not have any application
- 25:19to anybody out there now. But obviously there
- 25:21are issues dealing with mortgage payments, and
- 25:24there's been a. Stay on whatever the term is
- 25:27that they they there's a tour tour and yeah on
- 25:31those payments which is about to end. But i've
- 25:33got a case where i had lender placed insurance
- 25:36on a mortgage on a on a mortgage and they claim
- 25:39that they cancel it right before the fire and
- 25:41we're in the process of dealing with that. You
- 25:45know that i had a guy call me who. Didn't understand
- 25:49that there was the need to get fair plan when
- 25:52he purchased us what was ultimately a supplemental
- 25:55policy. For home for fire insurance on his house
- 25:59but he had lost his previous policy a couple
- 26:03years ago and it wasn't clear he didn't understand
- 26:06at least that he was supposed to obtain the fair
- 26:08plan as the base insurance policy. and he had
- 26:13been then paying for a supplemental policy through
- 26:16his broker. That should never have been consummated,
- 26:21that transaction, without the base bear plan.
- 26:24He called up his insurance carrier and they said,
- 26:27you don't have coverage for his $5 million house.
- 26:30That's an issue with his broker and the communications
- 26:32there. So at any rate, and then the smoke and
- 26:36ash case is obviously that that's ridiculous.
- 26:39What Stacey said is true. And I know this from
- 26:41the from the the Woolsey fire as well. You know,
- 26:44you can have smoke damage to your house and you
- 26:47have to tear out the, you know, the wall board
- 26:50and clean everything out behind for the hygiene
- 26:54just to clean everything because there's toxic
- 26:56material in your house. And it's a very tough
- 26:58issue. taking cases in those cases as well. But
- 27:03the bottom line is that the coverage issues are
- 27:06not easy. Stacey's correct. They're hard fought
- 27:09by the insurance. This is a well documented area
- 27:12of the law. God knows the insurance companies
- 27:14have great lobbyists and statutory. protections
- 27:19in addition to a bunch of case law out there
- 27:21about these, you know, like the Caribbean case
- 27:23and others. So you do need to talk to a lawyer.
- 27:26And I agree with you. I think it's counterproductive
- 27:28to get a lawyer when you're still dealing with
- 27:31the with the with the, you know, with the claim,
- 27:35if it hasn't been finally denied or granted.
- 27:38because that can end up taking longer, having
- 27:41the lawyer be involved. You need to get the lawyer
- 27:44once there's been a final determination on your
- 27:46claim and then we can see if there's a basis
- 27:49for a lawsuit. Just one other thing too, the
- 27:54status of litigation in the Palisades Fire, people
- 27:58may have heard there was the indictment by the
- 28:00U .S. Attorney against the... uber driver who
- 28:05they said it was arson i don't know if his negligence
- 28:07or intentional but either way set off the fireworks
- 28:09apparently on uh on new year's eve and i have
- 28:13a uh another guy that wanted me to take a case
- 28:16he had pictures from palisades islands that he
- 28:19took on new year's eve where the you know the
- 28:21fire was and the smoke um and he literally stood
- 28:25in the exact same position on the morning of
- 28:27january 7th and you could see the smoke i mean
- 28:29the same palm frond and the And framed exactly
- 28:33the same. That's where it started. And that's
- 28:35the allegation that's in the indictment, which
- 28:37is clearly, obviously, this doesn't mean anything's
- 28:40been adjudicated. It's their allegations. But
- 28:43the allegations in the indictment, I think, do,
- 28:47as best I can tell, based on the evidence that's
- 28:50out in the public domain, they allege correctly
- 28:54what happened in Palisades, which is there was
- 28:56the fire on New Year's Eve. They came and put
- 28:59it out. I believe that was the L .A. City Fire
- 29:01Department, but it was still smoldering. And
- 29:03the hotspot theory is a real theory. I mean,
- 29:05they were talking about that a year ago, even
- 29:07in the press. And there's been video I've seen
- 29:11of the actual trailhead up at Skull Rock, just
- 29:16right by the Palisades Highlands. It was still
- 29:19pretty evidently smoldering in the days after,
- 29:22like you could see it, after the fire. And then
- 29:26the idea that the allegation is, is that the
- 29:30wind, the dry wind and the conditions were so
- 29:32bad on the seventh that it caused the fire to
- 29:35reignite in that same spot. And then that's ultimately
- 29:37what led to the January 7th Palisades fire. So
- 29:40the point is that that's probably a pretty good
- 29:43explanation of what happened. Obviously the Uber
- 29:48driver is not a viable third party for $25 billion
- 29:51of damage, whatever it may be. Right now, there
- 29:56were a bunch of lawsuits filed. I don't believe
- 29:59they've been consolidated yet, but there is a
- 30:02demurrer that was filed by the City of Los Angeles,
- 30:05and a demurrer is a challenge to the complaint.
- 30:08It says essentially it doesn't matter what the
- 30:09facts are, just legally there's no claim. So
- 30:12it's a challenge to the pleading itself for whatever
- 30:16to not get too. granular and the legal aspects
- 30:19of it. But the point is, that's scheduled for
- 30:22hearing on February 5th in L .A. County Superior
- 30:25Court in front of Judge Jessner. There were a
- 30:31bunch of arguments made in those complaints.
- 30:34They tried inverse with saying that there was
- 30:37no water in the reservoir, in the fighter hydrants.
- 30:41That's not necessarily an inverse claim, and
- 30:43that's one of the arguments made in the demurrer.
- 30:46The other problem is that there are some very
- 30:49extensive immunities provided to the city state
- 30:55and any kind of public entity under the government
- 30:58code. And there's really no duty even to fight
- 31:02a fire, to be honest. So the point is, and I
- 31:06did a lot of research earlier this year on that
- 31:08to see if there was going to be some basis for
- 31:10liability against the city. I'm certainly not
- 31:14the judge. I'm not going to tell you how the
- 31:15judge is going to rule, but I think that's an
- 31:18extraordinarily difficult uphill battle for these
- 31:20people to get around those immunities. And they're
- 31:24definitely with some creative pleading in by
- 31:27the plaintiffs. They said that there was an inverse
- 31:31or a taking based on the fact that there was
- 31:33no water and the water infrastructure. I don't
- 31:35know that we'll see if the judge buys that or
- 31:38not. And then there was another attempt, they
- 31:41found some video of some power lines that were
- 31:46operated by the Department of Water and Power
- 31:48that combusted. And I think that's correct, but
- 31:52the arguments made in the demur that they didn't
- 31:54allege properly, it still may be a question of
- 31:56fact for a jury, but the establishing causation
- 32:02that some power lines down at PCH. How did that
- 32:06cause houses up in Marquez to burn? That's going
- 32:09to be a tough, tough thing to prove. So the point
- 32:11is, that's an uphill battle, but that's going
- 32:14on. And then the first big event in the litigation
- 32:18for palisades is going to be on February 5th.
- 32:21And we'll see how Judge Jessner rules. And then
- 32:25there's maybe some other theories. One quick
- 32:27thing too, we're past the one -year deadline
- 32:30for the Government Claims Act for injury to real
- 32:35property. It's six months for other kinds of
- 32:36injuries. But people have until January 6th or
- 32:407th, depending on how, if you think the statute
- 32:42applies to the government claims, I think it
- 32:44does. We're past that deadline now. So if people
- 32:47did get a government claim form in against the
- 32:51state, I think there's maybe a theory that might
- 32:55be plausible on a dangerous condition, maintenance
- 32:59of the dangerous condition case, but even then
- 33:01you've got the government immunity. The point
- 33:03is that's an uphill battle in palisades. Amanda
- 33:07can talk about that's a whole nother kettle of
- 33:09fish. But it's certainly not over because it
- 33:13really hasn't even started in terms of the actual
- 33:15litigation. But we'll find out on February 5th
- 33:18how that's going to work. how that was the first
- 33:22step. And then with insurance, like I said, Stacey
- 33:26covered it all. But there are different wrinkles
- 33:29in so many different cases. You definitely still
- 33:32have time. And Stacey, correct me if I'm wrong,
- 33:35but the statute of limitations typically runs
- 33:38from the date of a final determination on your
- 33:41claim in terms of some bad faith. That is correct.
- 33:45For bad faith, you have two years from the final
- 33:48denial. And for contract, it's quite a bit longer,
- 33:53although there may be something in the policy
- 33:55that limits. Usually, there's a statutory limit.
- 33:57Usually, yeah. They set a statute limit. But
- 34:02then the prudential case says that they may or
- 34:04may not be. So the bottom line is, here's the
- 34:10best thing I can say. Times are the essence for
- 34:12anybody. You've got to just make sure, just consult
- 34:14with an attorney. Don't necessarily have them
- 34:16involved until the time is right in the process
- 34:19of your claim. But definitely, given that there
- 34:23may be something about the data loss in terms
- 34:25of that being the time that it sets off the,
- 34:28or whatever, that starts the clock ticking. You
- 34:32just need to talk to a lawyer as soon as you
- 34:34can. So you at least have an idea of where you
- 34:36stand in the claims process and when and if you're
- 34:39going to have to hire a lawyer to file a litigation
- 34:43after there's some adverse conclusion made by
- 34:47the insurance company. But anyway, that's pretty
- 34:49much what I have. Yeah, I think that the Palisades
- 34:56litigation is in an unfortunate place. Um, you
- 35:01know, when we, when we look at these fires, the
- 35:03first thing we look at is origin and cause who
- 35:06caused the fire, who could be held responsible
- 35:08for the fire. And as John said, in Palisades,
- 35:11unfortunately that's someone who's not going
- 35:14to be able to be, you know, sustaining $25 billion
- 35:17of damages and judgments. And then the other
- 35:21component of that case is the spread, the argument
- 35:24that because LA County, the fire department,
- 35:27the California state parks, um, uh, division,
- 35:31you know, didn't properly, uh, maintain water,
- 35:34maintain, um, the environment that there was
- 35:37a spread. But like John said, uh, the government
- 35:40has a lot of immunities in California. And so
- 35:44it's just unfortunately going to be a very, um,
- 35:47difficult battle to fight. Um, going to the Eat
- 35:50and Fire litigation, the Eat and Fire, of course,
- 35:52is the, the one that was in Altadena and Pasadena.
- 35:55Um, we have a much different situation. That
- 36:02case is just kind of logistically, that case
- 36:05is a mass tort. It is not a class action. So
- 36:09a mass tort is a case where you've got a whole
- 36:12bunch of individual cases and they're related
- 36:15together in front of the same judge. So all of
- 36:18the Eat and Fire cases, are in front of Judge
- 36:22Laura Siegel in LA downtown complex. When I say
- 36:27individual cases, we generally look at as a case,
- 36:30you know, by household because household members
- 36:33tend to have intertwined cases. So those cases
- 36:36are related together. They still remain individual,
- 36:39but they're related together so that all of the
- 36:41common issues can be addressed at once. The common
- 36:44issue generally being who caused who or what
- 36:48caused the fire and how do we hold that entity
- 36:51accountable? But the cases otherwise stay individual.
- 36:55so that they can resolve separately from each
- 36:59other. And this allows each family's unique story
- 37:02and unique damages to be addressed apart from
- 37:07each other, which a class action doesn't do that.
- 37:09So that's how the Eaton fire litigation is structured.
- 37:12So in Eaton... Who are we suing and why? The
- 37:16main defendants in the Eaton Fire case are Southern
- 37:20California Edison and its parent company Edison
- 37:22International. The origin of the Eaton Fire is
- 37:27Eaton Canyon. The evidence is pretty darn clear
- 37:32and for those of you who have seen this ARCO
- 37:35video, this famous ARCO gas station surveillance
- 37:37video floating around, what we know is that there
- 37:41was the origin of the the Eaton fire was tower
- 37:45208, which is a small SCE tower up in Eaton Canyon.
- 37:52What we understand happened is that there was
- 37:54a fault somewhere on their transmission system.
- 37:59That fault resulted in a surge of electricity
- 38:02through their transmission system over energizing
- 38:05their lines well beyond what they're normally
- 38:07energized at. And that tower 208 which had actually
- 38:12been de -energized since 1971, but sat in disrepair
- 38:17because Edison had not been maintaining it. It
- 38:21re -energized, absorbed some of that electricity
- 38:24because of the failure in the tower. It sparked
- 38:28and dropped sparks down to the heavily overgrown,
- 38:33mismanaged by Edison vegetation below. And that's
- 38:36what we know sparked the Eaton fire. So that
- 38:39is the main focus of the Eaton litigation. For
- 38:45in the last I think ten months now It's been
- 38:48a year, but the litigation probably kind of got
- 38:50going within a month two months after that We've
- 38:53done inspections of the equipment both in the
- 38:56canyon that tower has been removed It's been
- 38:59taken to pieces in labs all over the place. Some
- 39:02of it was flown to Kentucky for some special
- 39:06X -ray machine they had there So inspections
- 39:10of all the equipment have been done Information
- 39:14has been required Documents have been requested
- 39:16from Edison. We are in the middle of depositions
- 39:20talking about, you know, how do they do inspections?
- 39:23How do they do maintenance? How do they manage
- 39:26their transmission system and their towers? What's
- 39:29their wildfire and safety mitigation programs?
- 39:32All of these things lead to failures in their
- 39:35systems that result in these, you know, frankly,
- 39:38at this point, well -known potential events.
- 39:42We also, you know, as I said, well known. We've
- 39:45got this history with Edison in the last several
- 39:48years. They caused the 2017 Thomas fire, the
- 39:522018 Woolsey fire that John was heavily involved
- 39:55in, the 2020 Bobcat fire. So in addition to the
- 40:00specific cause here, we've got a history of this
- 40:04corporation placing profits over safety and failing
- 40:08to properly maintain their equipment, running
- 40:11their equipment to failure. and failing to properly
- 40:16fund wildfire and mitigation programs. That is
- 40:21the, you know, the focus. Edison has now countersued
- 40:26the county of LA, the LA Fire Department, the
- 40:29city of Pasadena, the city of Sierra Madre, a
- 40:33number of water districts and irrigation companies,
- 40:36as well as Southern California Gas, arguing that
- 40:39because of, for instance, LA County's failure
- 40:44to manage certain vegetation, or so CalGas's
- 40:47failure to turn off gas, in a certain time the
- 40:52LA. county fire department's failure to warm
- 40:55for evacuation, that the fire spread and was
- 40:59more destructive. SCE is probably going to run
- 41:03into a lot of the same immunities that John was
- 41:06talking about. LA County has immunities, the
- 41:08fire department has immunities, the cities will
- 41:11have immunities, and frankly it's, you know,
- 41:15from our perspective a delay tactic on the part
- 41:17of Edison to try and push, you know, liability
- 41:21or attention and responsibility onto another
- 41:24entity versus taking that accountability on themselves
- 41:27as they should. The first trial date in that
- 41:31case is January 25th, 2027. That's going to be
- 41:36what we call a bellwether trial, which is a trial
- 41:41where in Eaton there's going to be about 30 ,000
- 41:44plaintiffs. So obviously all 30 ,000 can't go
- 41:47to trial at the same time. So what we do in these
- 41:50mass tort cases is we select representative households,
- 41:55households who lost their home, households whose
- 41:57home were damaged, households who had a smoke
- 42:00and ash, you know, households maybe where there's
- 42:03a personal injury, someone was home, someone
- 42:05was not representative of the larger kind of
- 42:09docket. of cases, take those to trial, see what
- 42:12a jury would do, and work on, use that as a baseline
- 42:17and instruction on what other case values will
- 42:22be. So the first bellwether trial is January
- 42:2425th, 2027. So we are, that's only a year away,
- 42:29but in our world, a year is not very long when
- 42:32you've got so much work to do. Quickly on the,
- 42:39The Edison compensation program so that the evidence
- 42:42is so strong against Edison that they've launched
- 42:44their own compensation program. I don't have
- 42:48time to fully get into it today, but I will tell
- 42:51you that that program was drafted by Edison,
- 42:54you know, for the benefit of Edison without properly
- 42:58consulting anybody who represents the eaten fire
- 43:02survivors. It is a program they administer themselves
- 43:07so that people who burn down your house are deciding
- 43:09how much they should pay you. So, you know, look
- 43:12at it in that context. And they're making take
- 43:15it or leave it offers based on formulas. So,
- 43:18you know, in these cases, it's so important.
- 43:23And many of you know this, who are impacted directly
- 43:26by these fires. It's so important to have your
- 43:29voice heard and to have your family's story told
- 43:34and make sure that you're compensated, not just
- 43:36some lump sum money, you're compensated. And
- 43:39so the Edison program will not give you that.
- 43:43It may work for certain people who've got relatively
- 43:46simple cases, but for any kind of complex case
- 43:49that needs individualized analysis. this individualized
- 43:53attention, the Edison program's not gonna do
- 43:56that. In addition, the CEO of Edison, Pedro Pizarro
- 44:00has publicly said that the purpose of that program
- 44:04is to minimize the amount of money that Edison
- 44:08has to pay out in order to minimize the amount
- 44:10of money they have to take from the California
- 44:13Wildfire Fund. So he's publicly said, look, this
- 44:15is a discount settlement program. So take that
- 44:19for what you will. Deadlines to file on Eaton.
- 44:26So if you are suing Edison and Edison International,
- 44:30Southern California Edison, your deadline to
- 44:33file a case for personal injury, which includes
- 44:37bodily injury, emotional distress, is two years
- 44:41from the fire. So that will be January 7th. 2027.
- 44:46Your statute of limitations, your deadline to
- 44:49sue Edison and Edison International for property
- 44:52damage is three years from the fire, so that's
- 44:55January 27, 2028. I do not recommend you wait
- 45:00that long because the train is moving very quickly
- 45:02in that case, but you do have those time limits
- 45:06if you if you choose to take them. So that is
- 45:10that is all I have on Eaton. Let's talk about
- 45:16what's happening in 2026. So what's coming is
- 45:21it is a very busy year in wildfire related legislation.
- 45:26So we've got a number of bills that have been
- 45:29proposed. We've got a number of reports that
- 45:31are coming out from everyone I've talked to.
- 45:36The focus, this large focus is really on how
- 45:40do we get How do we mitigate fire? How do we
- 45:44prevent the risk of fire? Not only with regard
- 45:47to the utilities, but also with regard to our
- 45:51environment, with climate change, with the built
- 45:54environment, making sure that we're building
- 45:56in a way that minimizes fire risk. I will tell
- 46:00you, having worked on wildfire cases for over
- 46:04a decade, It's really hard to minimize fire risk
- 46:09once a wildfire starts going, but there are ways
- 46:11to do it. So there are a lot of discussions going
- 46:15on with the state, with experts on those kind
- 46:18of issues. And then, of course, you know, the
- 46:22main discussion is how do we make sure that people
- 46:25who are impacted by these wildfires get their
- 46:29insurance money sooner rather than later. So,
- 46:32John and Stacey, you want to take one of these?
- 46:34Because I'm about to start coughing. I need some
- 46:35water. Sorry. Honestly, I'm not that familiar
- 46:42with what's coming down in 2026. I do know that
- 46:45there have not been any major changes in the
- 46:49regulations in 2025. There were very few substantive
- 46:56changes. What I've been seeing is more a focus
- 46:59on the Department of Insurance looking to the
- 47:03insureds to better tighten up their fireproofing
- 47:07and offering often significant ways significant
- 47:12benefits to insureds if they are willing to do
- 47:16so. That seems to have been the focus of 2025.
- 47:20I would love to talk about 2026, but I actually
- 47:23don't know much about what's coming down the
- 47:25pike yet. So I would not be the right person
- 47:27to do that. So, so I can now that I'm no longer
- 47:30coughing, I can take it back. Um, so there's
- 47:33on that on that note, um, the insurance commissioner,
- 47:36along with, uh, the Senate Insurance Committee
- 47:39chair, who is Steve chairs, Steven Padilla, who's,
- 47:43um, out of San Diego have proposed a bill. It
- 47:47is SB. eight seven six and it's a fire and residential
- 47:52property insurance bill um it's billed as a comprehensive
- 47:57legislative reform to speed up disaster recovery
- 48:00for homeowners so it's going this proposed bill
- 48:04requires a discovery a disaster recovery plan
- 48:09from insurance companies handling claims, new
- 48:13timelines. In other words, how do you scale up
- 48:17quickly to manage these large disasters? They're
- 48:22not one -off insurance claims, so these insurance
- 48:24companies under this bill would have to have
- 48:27a disaster recovery plan. It would double penalties
- 48:32during a declared emergency for violations of
- 48:35insurance fair claims practices. It would require
- 48:38insurance companies to pay restitution directly
- 48:41to policyholders when they violate the law. It
- 48:44would address delays resulting from assigning,
- 48:47and this is a lot of what we've dealt with in
- 48:49the last year, this assignment of multiple claims
- 48:52reps. You're getting passed from one to another
- 48:54and that causes delay, it causes confusion. So
- 48:58this bill would address that. that. and require
- 49:02status reports to the policyholder within five
- 49:06days anytime a new adjuster is assigned. I think
- 49:09that would actually really be a great benefit
- 49:11because it's gonna require this new adjuster
- 49:13to get up to date on your case sooner rather
- 49:17than later. It improves recovery by expanding
- 49:21policy limits another 100 % if there's a declared
- 49:24disaster. And as Stacey mentioned, it has safer
- 49:28building, safer rebuilding requirements, mandatory
- 49:33building upgrades, coverage for the time of rebuild
- 49:37that are more focused on wildfire prevention.
- 49:42So that's SB 876. There's two more, SB 877. Amanda,
- 49:49real quick. Go ahead. The 100 % extension on
- 49:52coverage, that's for ALE, correct? Correct. not
- 49:56the total claim. It's just your alternative living
- 49:59expense when there's a declared emergency. They
- 50:02understand that it's going to take so long to
- 50:04get back. rebuilt etc so that's where the hundred
- 50:06percent extension would be specifically correct
- 50:08exactly specifically sorry if i didn't make that
- 50:11clear and i that really goes to a lot of the
- 50:13questions we had earlier about you know when
- 50:16there are these mass disasters as stacy and john
- 50:19were mentioning it takes longer to rebuild because
- 50:22there is a you know there's a strain on resources
- 50:25and so this bill would address that extension
- 50:28that a number of people asked about earlier SB
- 50:32877, introduced by Senator Sasha Perez. She represents
- 50:37Altadena Pasadena. And this also addresses insurance
- 50:43delays. It requires transparency and accountability
- 50:47in the loss estimate. Homeowners very often are
- 50:53just sent little bits of paper from their insurance
- 50:56companies, and it's really hard for them to piece
- 50:59together. This would increase the requirements
- 51:02on what kind of documentation would need to be
- 51:05maintained and provided to the insured. It would
- 51:15address their issues of altering, reducing, rewriting
- 51:19loss estimates so that it's very, very confusing.
- 51:23And so that bill will address those issues. And
- 51:28then a third one, SB 878, it's called the Insurance
- 51:34Payment Accountability Act, strengthens existing
- 51:38prompt pay insurance laws by imposing interest
- 51:42penalties. So if your insurance companies are
- 51:44just taking darn long to pay you then there's
- 51:48going to be penalties on basically interest.
- 51:53They're going to be charged interest. California's
- 51:56deadlines requiring insurers to respond to claims
- 51:59promptly and pay out all undisputed amounts within
- 52:0230 days are routinely evaded and so that's going
- 52:06to be addressed with this insurance issue. And
- 52:11it's it's gonna address this you know continuing
- 52:14problem of insurance companies which i think
- 52:18is exacerbated. most often by the switching in
- 52:22of these insurance claims reps, but it's going
- 52:25to address, you know, the constant delay on payments
- 52:29and the need for people to follow up. So those
- 52:31are three bills SB 876 -877 -878. Look into those.
- 52:38Definitely talk to your elected representatives
- 52:41if you want to make sure they support them and
- 52:44encourage them to vote in favor of those. So
- 52:50just another, we got five more minutes. We can
- 52:52take some questions after that, but just one
- 52:54more thing, the California Wildfire Fund. So
- 52:57a lot of you have heard about this. You probably
- 53:00weren't familiar with it before January 7th,
- 53:022025. And now it's like insurance, one of those
- 53:05things you're intimately aware of. So for those
- 53:09of you who aren't, when PG &E up North filed
- 53:13for bankruptcy in 2019, And all of our clients
- 53:18from the 2015, 2017, and 2018 fires caused by
- 53:23PG &E in Northern California got pulled into
- 53:25the bankruptcy court. One of the things we did
- 53:28was lobby the state for essentially a safety
- 53:31net for the investor owned utilities. We've got
- 53:34three of them in California, PG &E, SoCal Edison,
- 53:37and San Diego Gas and Electric. And the goal
- 53:41was to make sure that when they cause another
- 53:44one of these massive fires, there is an insurance
- 53:47safety net to make sure that they can compensate
- 53:50all the fire survivors and victims without having
- 53:53to go into bankruptcy and cause incredible delay
- 53:56in that compensation. So that original fund is
- 54:00AB 1054 -1054. That original fund is a fund of
- 54:07up to $21 billion. I think right now it's been
- 54:11funded to about It funds generally at about $1
- 54:15.6 billion a year. And so that original fund
- 54:20happened. That fund is what Southern California
- 54:24Edison is going to be tapping into to make sure
- 54:28that it can cover all of the damages that it's
- 54:31going to need to pay out to eat and fire survivors.
- 54:34We then at the end of last year, The governor
- 54:38essentially wanted more of a backstop, just in
- 54:41case. Unfortunately, because we do have an epidemic
- 54:44of utility caused wildfires in California. So
- 54:48SB 254 expanded and added created an additional
- 54:53fund of 18 billion dollars. That is only available
- 54:57for Victor ensure. Sorry, investor owned utilities
- 55:02who caused fires after that bill. is in place,
- 55:06so it's not going to help Eaton Fire survivors
- 55:10or Palisade Fire survivors, but it is. for future
- 55:15fires. And then we've got on the proposed legislation
- 55:21right now, AB 1554, so they're all ending in
- 55:2554, proposed legislation to implement more regulations
- 55:30to carry out wildfire mitigation and recovery.
- 55:33So under AB 1054, the investor -owned utilities
- 55:39have to create a wildfire safety plan. every
- 55:43three years, and the California Earthquake Authority,
- 55:48which is actually the government entity that
- 55:52manages the California Wildfire Fund, they have
- 55:57to put out a report. The report's coming out
- 56:00in April, 2026. It's gonna have, you know, a
- 56:04number of issues addressed essentially relating
- 56:07to a broader movement on control of the environment
- 56:10and landscape and utilities to mitigate wildfires.
- 56:15because, of course, we can mitigate the cause,
- 56:18but we also need to mitigate the destructiveness
- 56:21and the spread, and that's hugely going to be
- 56:25addressed by managing the environment, managing
- 56:27the built environment and the landscape and the
- 56:30wild lands. So that report's coming out in April
- 56:332026, and AB 1554 is a proposed legislation.
- 56:39It's pretty vague, and it basically says Whatever's
- 56:43in that report that we think looks like it's
- 56:46beneficial. It's going to work. We want to put
- 56:49out some legislation to require enforcement of
- 56:52those. proposals and those suggestions. So that's
- 56:57coming down too. So that's what's going on 2026.
- 57:03Like I said, there's really a large movement
- 57:06right now towards how do we mitigate the cause
- 57:11of fire and the spread of fire across the state.
- 57:14Our utilities, we do have an investor -owned
- 57:17utility problem in California, but they generally
- 57:20only cause about 10 % of wildfires. They're generally
- 57:28only responsible for about 10 % of the ignition
- 57:32of wildfires. Most wildfires are man -made. We
- 57:36did have a bunch of lightning strike wildfires,
- 57:38you know, in like 2020, 2021 up in Northern California,
- 57:41but generally they are, you know, human caused
- 57:45either by accidents or arson or by our investor
- 57:49owned utilities. But what makes them so destructive
- 57:52is unfortunately we've got huge amounts of overgrowth
- 57:58due to climate change. What happens in the winter
- 58:01is we have these excessive storms and they cause
- 58:04vegetation to grow very rapidly. And then we
- 58:07have spring comes and summer comes and everything
- 58:10dries out and we've got a lot of fuel. And obviously
- 58:14there's urban expansion into more rural areas.
- 58:19is a multifaceted issue. I definitely, my practice
- 58:24area is holding utilities accountable, but there
- 58:27is a huge movement to mitigate the spread of
- 58:31these fires in the first place. And that's obviously
- 58:34a very important thing for our representatives
- 58:37to support. So that's what's on the horizon.
- 58:43Do we have time, Belinda, for questions? We just
- 58:48hit 1101. Absolutely. Hey, Amanda, one question.
- 58:54Oh, sorry, John. Go ahead. I was going to say
- 58:57somebody was asking if any of those bills are
- 58:59going to be retroactive to apply to the Palisades
- 59:02fire. And I don't believe they are. I don't know.
- 59:05But I saw that question. I don't know. I doubt
- 59:08they are under the law. As John Stacey knows,
- 59:13yeah, under the law, it's very, very rare that
- 59:17new legislation is retroactive. And if to make
- 59:22a legislation retroactive, it has to specifically
- 59:25state that it is. And I didn't see that that
- 59:28proposal was in any of those bills. If you all
- 59:33have time to answer questions, we will stay on
- 59:36until your hard stops kick in. So. I have a very
- 59:41small amount of time. I accidentally left my
- 59:44calendar open after this and somebody booked
- 59:46an 11 a .m. call. I just told them I'm going
- 59:48to be a few minutes late. So if there are any
- 59:50questions I can specifically answer right now
- 59:54that I would be the best person to ask, please
- 59:58ask now and I will answer and then I've got to
- 1:00:01go in about five minutes. I've got to go in about
- 1:00:03five minutes as well. But yeah, Stacey, go ahead.
- 1:00:09Pull some questions for you here. This is a good.
- 1:00:11I mean, this is this is one of those kind of
- 1:00:13basic insurance questions that we answer in the
- 1:00:16beginning when the insurance company sends out
- 1:00:18correspondence after the house burns down. Where
- 1:00:21does that correspondence go? That is a really
- 1:00:24important tip, which is if your house does burn
- 1:00:28down, one of the first things that you should
- 1:00:31do is open up a PO box, because unfortunately,
- 1:00:36as a lot of people know, after these fires, you
- 1:00:40end up in a rental, but then you move again.
- 1:00:43We've got clients in Eaton who have moved 10
- 1:00:45times, 11 times for various reasons. So the best
- 1:00:49thing to do is open up a PO box so that you have
- 1:00:51a stable address and then call all of your credit
- 1:00:55card companies, your insurance company, all of
- 1:00:58those bills and change your address to that PO
- 1:01:02box so that at least you have a stable address
- 1:01:04even if you have to move around. I see some questions
- 1:01:09in here about the extension of ALE for a federally
- 1:01:12declared disaster. As you noted, the 2026 bill
- 1:01:16is not likely to be retroactive, but there is
- 1:01:20already extension of ALE for up to 36 months
- 1:01:24if the amount in your policy covers it. Be aware
- 1:01:29of that. That may not help you in your individual
- 1:01:33situation, depending on how much coverage you
- 1:01:35had in the first place, but just be aware that
- 1:01:37you can extend it for up to 36 months. I'm reading
- 1:01:47through the questions right now, so just making
- 1:01:48sure that I've answered anything that I personally
- 1:01:52know how to answer. What impact will gridlock
- 1:01:55on declarations of disaster at FEMA have on wildfire
- 1:01:58claims? um have on wildfire claims so that the
- 1:02:03problem that we had in Eaton and Palisades um
- 1:02:09due to a changing of the administration uh and
- 1:02:13a difference in policy i'll put it that way was
- 1:02:16that um so generally the way it works is the
- 1:02:20governor declares a state of emergency and then
- 1:02:23writes to the president and asks the president
- 1:02:25to declare to to dispatch FEMA That happened
- 1:02:29on January 7th when Joe Biden was still president.
- 1:02:33And then when Trump came into president on January
- 1:02:3920th, the FEMA funds were minimized. and of course
- 1:02:47there has been a movement to limit FEMA funds
- 1:02:51being dispatched so right now my understanding
- 1:02:55is FEMA still owes the state of California about
- 1:02:5840 billion dollars of money that the state of
- 1:03:01California had to put out fighting fires or sorry
- 1:03:03for for debris removal and recovery, which would
- 1:03:08have otherwise come from FEMA. So that is going
- 1:03:12to have a huge impact. The other thing that we
- 1:03:15had in Eaton, I'm not sure if it happened to
- 1:03:17Palisades too, but I would expect that it did,
- 1:03:20is generally when FEMA comes in, they bring the
- 1:03:23Army Corps of Engineers. And the Army Corps of
- 1:03:26Engineers has a three -phase cleanup. They first
- 1:03:29remove all hazardous materials so that residents
- 1:03:32can go back into their lot. and look for anything
- 1:03:36that they can recover. Then they scraped the
- 1:03:39lot. And then the third phase is that FEMA and
- 1:03:45the Army Corps of Engineers will do soil contamination
- 1:03:49testing. That third phase was not done. as a
- 1:03:53result or after the LA fires because FEMA did
- 1:03:57not allow the Army Corps of Engineers to pay
- 1:04:00for it. And as a result of that, as many people
- 1:04:02know, we've got a lot of independent soil contamination
- 1:04:06testing going on. So yeah, the politics is definitely
- 1:04:10going to impact that kind of issue. And I'm afraid
- 1:04:16I need to go. But thank you very much for having
- 1:04:21me here. And I'm also, if anybody wants to contact
- 1:04:25me directly, I'm always happy to answer questions.
- 1:04:27It doesn't mean I'll be able to resolve your
- 1:04:30issue, but I can certainly answer questions.
- 1:04:32I'm always happy to do that. Thank you so much
- 1:04:35for your time, Stacey. And I know John used Sadio
- 1:04:39to go. And I think, Amanda, we really appreciate
- 1:04:41it. The speaker's contact information is in your
- 1:04:44materials. And we have the questions. We have
- 1:04:48enough here, I think, for a whole other webinar.
- 1:04:51So if you registered for this and were able to
- 1:04:54do a follow -up, we'll reach back out to you
- 1:04:56via email. Thank you so much, everybody. All
- 1:04:58right. Thank you. Thank you.