Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Hollywood Racism Yammerings
Transcript
- 0:00So BIRDO. As promised in the last episode, in this episode, we
- 0:04are going to review what chat GBT spat out when I asked chat gipt to
- 0:11give the top movies with Hispanic American characters, with Asian American characters, with
- 0:20women, and with white Americans. And we'll compare those lists to see how
- 0:27many of these movies we even recognize and how good the movies are and how
- 0:33like iconic they are. So what do you say? Let's do it.
- 0:37This is the psychology in SADA podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkhana.
- 0:40I'm a therapist under professor. My name is Umberto cas and I bake socks
- 0:44for goblins. So is it fair to say that not always, of course,
- 0:50but that generally speaking, what chat gibt is spitting out is an averaging
- 0:58of all all the talk and all of the lists and all of the the
- 1:03culture. If you will, you know, if it's if I ask jat
- 1:07GVT give me the top twenty movies with Hispanic Americans, it's not going through
- 1:12all the movies and trying to determine for itself. It's just looking for how
- 1:18many lists or how many times is this movie referred to as like an iconic
- 1:23Hispanic American movie, right, yes, in that at its base, yes,
- 1:30Well, first of all, the basic thing that we talked about before
- 1:34that these things can do is that it can predict which words go together,
- 1:38right, And it just happens to be that if if the first words are
- 1:42make a list of great movies about psychology, then the next words that might
- 1:48go well with that are, oh, well, there's this movie, and
- 1:51there is this movie, and there is this movie. And statistically that all
- 1:55is derived in two ways, one from like you're saying, copious actual life
- 2:00online and things like that. Also people writing about it, reviews, all
- 2:02these things, all all places where the words movie and psychology appear together with
- 2:10these other words kind of thing. But then these companies, specifically Open Aye,
- 2:15paid a lot of money to people to then add additional training to these
- 2:21models in different fields. Now. I don't know that they paid someone to
- 2:23specifically make them good movie list makers, you know, but you can see
- 2:28them maybe the field of Hispanic studies or something, or yeah, or just
- 2:34media in general or whatever. Yeah. Yeah, So okay, so there's
- 2:37some thumbs on some skills that might well thumbs as in like human raiders that
- 2:43help say Yeah, that makes sense. No, that doesn't make sense,
- 2:45but not so much of Like I don't think it would have been so much
- 2:49editorializing. They're not thumbing on skills, they're just like, for whatever whatever,
- 2:54it doesn't make sense for whatever reason, that answer is so nonsensical,
- 3:00Like imagine in the movie list that you did, or even this one.
- 3:02Let's say you want movies about Hispanics and it puts in some movies that aren't
- 3:07about Hispanics, then a human raider would say, this is not one of
- 3:09those. Well, or a more absurd thing is the answer literally doesn't have
- 3:15anything to do with movies, right, or it could invent the movie that
- 3:17doesn't exist, right. And these are all the kinds of things that a
- 3:21human raider might say, Well, let's look at it, Burrow so well,
- 3:25just to give you an idea of how this can do when you ask
- 3:30it, perhaps an easier question. I asked it to list the top twenty
- 3:35movies about white Americans, and I'm just going to read them all in succession,
- 3:40and you tell me if you recognize yeah and oy and or if these
- 3:46are iconic The Godfather never heard of it, Titanic, shash Ankordemption, the
- 3:52Dark Knight, Fight Club, Forrest Gump, Great Gatsby, Goodwill, Hunting,
- 3:57American Beauty That Departed, Social Network, pulp Fiction, Big Lebowski,
- 4:01Breakfast Club, Wolfel Wall Street, A Few Good Men, The Truman Show,
- 4:05There Will Be Blood, Silver Linings, Playbook, The Green Mile.
- 4:09So seem not my list, but tons of great movies in there, and
- 4:14all of them instantly recognized. Yeah, I've seen all of them. Some
- 4:17of them I've seen many, many times. And but you know, you
- 4:23and I are movie people. But I would imagine most people that at the
- 4:27very least everyone has heard of ninety percent of them and probably saw them and
- 4:33have seen them many times. So now, so that's twenty. So I
- 4:38just look at Hispanic Americans's compare the prompt, and if I asked chat gpt
- 4:43to give me a hundred more, we would probably recognize the next hundred and
- 4:46by then. What was your prompt for the Hispanic one? Please list the
- 4:48top twenty movies about Hispanic Americans. Okay, pretty simple, And I actually
- 4:56asked chat GPT, what definition of Hispanic American are you using? Because I
- 5:01wasn't sure if because because my definition is someone who lives in the United States,
- 5:10and is of the heritage of south of the border, you know,
- 5:15Mexico, Colombia, whatever. Now they might be first generation or tenth generation.
- 5:21So anyway, So what chet GPT says definition is the term Hispanic American
- 5:28typically refers to individuals in the United States who have cultural ties to Spanish speaking
- 5:32countries. So I guess it even includes Spain, which I think is technically
- 5:36true. Right, so just cultural ties, Okay, okay, all right,
- 5:44So number one movie is Selena from nineteen ninety seven. Sure, so
- 5:48this is the true story of Selena and okay, then she died. Yeah,
- 5:55I mean, would you say that's a sort of iconic. Well,
- 5:59one was a very amous iconic movie that I didn't see because I didn't really
- 6:01know who Selena was. Neither me. I haven't seen it, and I
- 6:04still don't know who Selena is. I'm not that of that age. But
- 6:10but okay, to a certain generation of people, probably you know a Touchstone
- 6:15LaBamba, yeah right, Richie Allen's Yeah, and that movie was huge in
- 6:20the eighties. Everyone I knew saw it and liked it. It was what's
- 6:25his name? Uh uh? Well, who isn't Hispanic? By the way,
- 6:30I don't think Yeah, what's his name anyway, that guy next movie
- 6:35Coco, Yeah, definitely, but it's not a Hispanic American. It's Mexican.
- 6:41Right, that's a good point. That's I see, I fell for
- 6:46it. That's true. It's a great movie. True. But again,
- 6:50going back to their definition, it's refers to individuals in the United States who
- 6:57have cultural type. It has nothing to do with the United States. It
- 7:01doesn't refer to the US. That's a good point. There's there's no character
- 7:06from the US. It's entirely a story in Mexico. I was like,
- 7:12yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, so that's movie number three on the
- 7:15list. Okay, when we were going through the white Americans, we didn't
- 7:18run into a like a Boys in the Hood or something, you know what
- 7:21I mean. Well, because what's interesting is the reason I when you said,
- 7:25I was like, it's fine. It's because in my head, I'm
- 7:27thinking movies with you know, representation, Latin representation. But that wasn't your
- 7:31question. That wasn't my question that I didn't say, give me movies with
- 7:34Hispanic people. So the next movie on the list, you too, Mama
- 7:40Tombien. Definitely not again, it's it takes place and it's not and the
- 7:47director and writer is not American. Right, It's in Spanish. It takes
- 7:51place in Mexico with Mexican, Mexican actors, Mexican, which is great.
- 7:59It's a great movie. It's great movie. It's a great Mexican movie.
- 8:03It's not Hispanic American. But yeah, I like that movie when it came
- 8:07out. Next movie, Stand and Deliver. Okay, I was gonna say
- 8:11they better have Standing Deliver. Okay, that's with James are Almost what's his
- 8:16name, Jones, James Almost from the Battlestar. Yeah, uh so,
- 8:24okay, Hispanic American. Next movie, Real Women Have Curves. I remember
- 8:28seeing this back in the day. I didn't know it is Spanish, it
- 8:31is Hispanic American. It's in Los Angeles. Next movie, Rudeo E.
- 8:39Cursey. Never heard of it, never heard looked it up. Mexican Mexican
- 8:43comedy. Ok So the first I don't know, seven ish movies about half
- 8:50aren't Hispanic American. When I asked chatby TV, so I'm it's not Chat
- 8:56Gibt's fault. It's our fucking culture. So not only do we not have
- 9:01many Hispanic American movies, even though something like fourteen percent of Americans are Hispanic
- 9:09American. So therefore fourteen fourteen percent of the biggest movies would be a Hispanic
- 9:15American, or you would have Hispanic American movies that weren't about being Hispanic American,
- 9:20you know what I mean, where these movies are a lot about being
- 9:22a Hispanic American, because it's not like every white movie is about being white,
- 9:26you know, it's just about whatever the story says. So not only
- 9:31do we not have those movies, but there aren't enough listicles or commentary about
- 9:37Hispanic American movies so that jet GBT can accurately even answer the question, right,
- 9:41do you know what I mean? Another movie, Maria Full of Grace.
- 9:46Oh my gosh, that's from Colombia. Yeah, that's a Colombian movie.
- 9:50But I looked up the plot and she is a mule. But she
- 9:56comes to the States, right, well, she just comes to the United
- 10:00States. She's from Columbia. She's not an American citizen, she is.
- 10:03It's a Colombian movie, Colombian actors, Colombian director about a Colombian trying to
- 10:09get drugs smuggled into this country. And Okay, so I didn't know I
- 10:13read the It's a great movie, it's touching, heartbreaking, but not Hispanic
- 10:18American. No, yeah, okay, it's Colombian Colombian. So because I
- 10:24read the description, I thought, well, maybe she spends most of her
- 10:26time in the United States, but apparently not. Okay. So another movie,
- 10:31El Norte It is nineteen eighty three. Two indigenous youths who flee Guatemala
- 10:39due to ethnic and political persecution of the Guatemalan Civil War make it to the
- 10:43US. Haven't seen it. We'll take their work to the US, so
- 10:48we'll take their word for it. Mi vi de loca. It's, you
- 10:52know, an American coming of age drama, gangs. I think it's in
- 10:56La so that counts. Yeah. Next movie, uh, the Mella Geral
- 11:03Beanfield War. Cut to the Chase, Mexican movie. I'm not Hispanic American.
- 11:09Like Water for Chocolate, same Mexican movie. And here's what's interesting,
- 11:15Selma Selma. It's about Martin Luther King. Oh that's Selma. So I
- 11:22was I like, I was watching who isn't Hispanic American? By the way,
- 11:28right she is? Right? I thought she was. I thought she's
- 11:31Egyptian? Is she? Well? She his Spanic she speaks Spanish, she
- 11:39she plays a lot of Oh no, she is Mexican American. Where did
- 11:46I get in my head that she was? She might be. I mean,
- 11:48just because you're a Mexican American doesn't mean you don't have roots that could
- 11:50be Egyptian. Yeah, I mean my last name does sound Egyptian. I'm
- 11:56just think, oh yeah, yeah, her her father is is Lebanese.
- 12:00Okay, not Egyptian, not Egyptian, but but okay, but you know,
- 12:07so she's Lebanese excent, all right, but this is Selma the Martin
- 12:11Luther King, right. So I tried to look up why chat GBT would
- 12:16identify it as a Hispanic American movie, and maybe there's an a span,
- 12:20but I don't remember any notable Hispanic American character or storyline. So I think
- 12:26this is just chat GBT going, well, it's not white. Well,
- 12:31it's like if they had included stand by Me instead of stand and Deliver.
- 12:35Yeah, Freda, Again, that's Spain or Mexican Mexican movie, not Hispanic
- 12:41American. And it's the artist right like the yeah pretty Colo Spanglish, which
- 12:46is you could argue Hispanic American rom com does that have I don't remember.
- 12:52I think it j Loo, Yeah, I think so. The thirty three,
- 13:00which is not Hispanic American. It's it takes place in Chile, based
- 13:05on the real life event in which these miners are Oh yes, yes,
- 13:11yes, this is definitely not close to America. True. Well, actually
- 13:16that's wrong. It is in America. It's just not close to the United
- 13:18States Hispanic American. And again, if that's why I was thinking, it's
- 13:22like, did it think the American Well, maybe it's being more okay,
- 13:26maybe, but I asked, and it said individuals in the United States and
- 13:31people from Chile don't call themselves Chilean Americans. No, they just call themselves
- 13:35Chilean. They might say, yeah, I guess generally speaking, we're Americans
- 13:39because we're from Machete. Danny Treyo, you know, it's Hispanic American,
- 13:46I guess. I mean, I don't know how many Hispanic American characters there
- 13:50are, but Danny trey hoo americs paros again. Yeah, how did I
- 13:58pronounce it as moiss No? No, no, it's amodis as it takes
- 14:07place in Mexico City. It's a Mexican movie. It's a great movie.
- 14:11Volver, which is a Spanish comedy that again not Hispanic American, and West
- 14:18Side Story, which West Side Story counts right because it's got ye and it's
- 14:22iconic. You know, there's everyone A lot of people have heard of it,
- 14:26so I think they're shooting at fifty percent. And the movies that are
- 14:31on there are you know, some of them. I would imagine very few
- 14:35people unless you're a Hispanic American have heard you know, Hispanic Americans have heard
- 14:41of pulp fiction and Forrest Gump and The Godfather, But how many white people
- 14:48have heard of El Norte and real women have curves and even machete. I
- 14:54mean that's kind of a I mean I know of that because that's sort of
- 14:58in our wheelhouse. But so not great, not a great reflection of our
- 15:05society, right, burto not great. So let's take a break, we
- 15:09get back, let's shame our culture even more. What do you say,
- 15:13Let's do it all right back from the break? So student opp burdo.
- 15:20Oh, these people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty one and
- 15:24have stayed patrons through thick and thin, giving us the ability to do this.
- 15:28These are all middle tier patrons. So these are like, you know,
- 15:33special patrons. We have Jessica from Halifax, Nova, Scotia. Oh,
- 15:41I believe Canada. Mike from Old Street, London. We have Zahira
- 15:46from Singapore. This is interesting. So Singapore is in the County of Singapore,
- 15:52which is in the country of Singapore. Oh, it's sort of like
- 15:56Singapore, Singapore, Singapore, right, So it's sort of like the song
- 16:00Man in the Box on the album Man in the Box by the band Man
- 16:04in the Box actually heard Talk Talk, you know, the band tech Talk.
- 16:11They named themselves talk Talk after their hit song. They already had like
- 16:15a good song, and they didn't know what to call their bands, so
- 16:18they called themselves because like, well it'll be easier to remember. At least
- 16:22that's what I think. Another YouTube channel that I watch Professor of Rock.
- 16:26Oh I love Professor of Rock. Yeah. Andrea from Canton, Illinois.
- 16:33If you like getting your fruit loop soggy on Sunday morning, then you might
- 16:37like this channel. Donelle from Carlisle, Pennsylvania, Nicole from Syracuse, New
- 16:42York, Amanda from Seattle, Good Old Seattle, Leslie from Colorado, Marissa
- 16:48from Austin, Texas, Audrey from San Diego, California, Hannah from Kennet
- 16:55Kennett Square, Pennsylvania, Megan from Winter Garden, Florida, more Gan Morgan
- 17:00or more Gain from Louisiana, Emmy from Paris, California, Gray Gray from
- 17:07Denver, mhc from Des Moines, Ida, Iowa. And our Nieka from
- 17:15Durham, North Carolina. And the following middle tier patrons are all from god
- 17:19knows where we have Anna, Marcella, Ghita and Nola. Thank you so
- 17:25much for becoming a patron and staying a patron through thick and thin all this
- 17:30time. Okay, so this next list Asian Americans. So I asked chat
- 17:34TPT please list the top I often say please to chat GPT. Is that
- 17:40weird? No, it's polite. Sometimes I feel bad. I'm like,
- 17:44if you don't mind, could you give me? Because because then later it'll
- 17:47remind you remember you fondly and I'll be like, oh, you're the human
- 17:49who said please. Or when they decide to take over, they'll know that
- 17:55I'm a I'm a beta and they can easily take me over quickly because I'm
- 17:59a nice for sure enough. So I asked for the top twenty movies Asian
- 18:07American movies. Okay, and they gave me the following list. Oddly,
- 18:14it's a spoiler alert a little better than the Hispanic American list, Like,
- 18:18why would you think that would be true? M? I don't know.
- 18:23Maybe there are more movies that are Asian American. Maybe, I mean,
- 18:30I mean, certainly anecdotally, it seems that way to be. Yeah,
- 18:33but that's me as an Asian American, so it just seems kind of interesting.
- 18:38Yeah, m Anyways, let's hear the list. So we have crazy
- 18:42rich Asians. Okay, pretty easy for chat GBT to see that because one
- 18:47it has Asian well, but the lead character is an Asian American woman,
- 18:52I guess, and everything everywhere all at once. Is that on the lists?
- 19:00I don't think so. Plus I think, well, anyway, that's
- 19:03not a list, but yeah, it's it's a good good call. Did
- 19:07that win Best Picture last year? It won a lot of Oscars. It
- 19:11didn't win Best Picture, but it did it did win us like best Director
- 19:15I think. But the duo, the two guys did win something, right,
- 19:19someone was upset it winning well, So this is a real shaggy episode.
- 19:27Uh, let's just look it up. Let's look it up. Everything
- 19:30everywhere didn't win, it might have won the Oscar. I feel like it
- 19:37won Best Picture. Yeah, and I was very happy about that it did
- 19:41because I texted you, remember right, you were sick? What were you
- 19:45said? I couldn't make the party. Yeah, and I texted you,
- 19:48I'm like, dude. Won seven Academy Awards Best Picture, Best Actress,
- 19:55Best Supporting Actor. Yeah, I remember, Kwan wow Jamie the Curtis,
- 19:59Best Reporting Actress, Best Director, and Best Original Screenplay and Best Film Editing.
- 20:04That's amazing. Yeah, avoided it when best Picture, I mean when
- 20:10you end? When? When when you en Best Picture, Best Actress,
- 20:15Best Supporting Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Director, Best Screenplay. I
- 20:19would say that it's a very well liked movie and well deserved, you know.
- 20:25Amazing, just amazed me. So maybe once CHET GPT catches up with
- 20:32you know, like the newer version, Like I don't have the paid version
- 20:33of CHET, it probably has that updated. But the next movie, The
- 20:37Farewell, Oh actually no that so it's it's a good point. The GPT,
- 20:45even the paid version isn't live internet access. There is a cutoff date,
- 20:52and the non paid version is even older. Okay, so it is
- 20:55true that any movies will be before that because they wouldn't have been discussed.
- 21:00Right. So The Farewell, which is good, very very Asian Aquafina.
- 21:07She has a grandma that's dying, but no one will tell her. It
- 21:10was nominated a couple of years ago, and cute movie. I gave it
- 21:15a six out of ten. I didn't think it was amazing Minari or Minati,
- 21:18which I'm ashamed to say, I haven't seen. It has that great
- 21:23actor I can't remember his name, and it looks really great, but I
- 21:27would seen it. And it is about a Korean American family. Perfect Better
- 21:32Luck Tomorrow, pretty classic Asian American movie that came out two thousand and two,
- 21:37and it was like, to my memory, it felt like our pulp
- 21:42fiction in a way. What was that about. I think it's like a
- 21:48heist and it has a lot of the Asian American actors that we know today.
- 21:53Dude, you probably did well. I mean, you know your friends
- 21:57are right like, it seems like I would have definitely seen that, and
- 22:00it feels definitely of our generation, and it would have been in a year
- 22:04where I was going to the movies all the time. Joy Luck Club,
- 22:08Oh my gosh, So let me tell you about Joy Luck Club. I
- 22:11was in college, I was a UDV and basically all my closest friends were
- 22:17Asian. And this movie comes out and everyone guess, that's the only reason
- 22:22why you're friends with me. It's half the reason. And then everyone's obsessed
- 22:29with this movie and we're like, we gotta go see Joy Luck Club,
- 22:30Joylu Club, and I go see it. But then I got so irritated
- 22:34because there's a scene in the movie where the main heart throb is eating a
- 22:40watermelon, and I guess it's really sexy the way he's eating the watermelon,
- 22:44and all the Asian girls we were with were all like swooning over this whole
- 22:48scene, jealous And no it wasn't jealousy. I just didn't think the scene
- 22:53fit the dynamics of the movie at the time. And you're saying this while
- 22:59you're slopping that watermelon into your face as you're standing up in the middle of
- 23:03the theater talking to all those girls. Well, it's like, yeah,
- 23:06after the movie, we go back to a place where all talking, I
- 23:07go and buy a watermelon and I'm just like, hey, you go and
- 23:14they're like, what are you doing. I'm like, I don't know that
- 23:15this is what I do. She was just dripping down my shirt. So
- 23:23I gave joy Let Club. Apparently when I saw it nineteen ninety three,
- 23:27seven out of ten, I thought it was that it was fine. I
- 23:30didn't think it was amazing, but you know, so it was enjoyable and
- 23:32it was you know, it was at a time where, like I remember,
- 23:36one of the things that was really making the waves in the community,
- 23:40in the Asian community, is that they didn't have a presentation right, and
- 23:42it was like it was like this kind of multi generational, like the whole
- 23:47thing is. Yeah. It was also a big budget movie. Yeah,
- 23:51and it was you know, being marketed, and that was not done so
- 23:57we would have watched anything point. So I think that it was important because
- 24:02it's nineteen ninety three. Yeah, that might be one of the earliest movies
- 24:06that's on the list. Oh there's no yeah, oh there's another one.
- 24:11So this movie, the next movie on this list is absolutely Asian American.
- 24:15It's not considered Asian American, but it definitely is obviously Asian American. But
- 24:21they don't ever or rarely even really point to the fact that it's Asian American.
- 24:26Which is the best type of Asian American. Yeah, because white people
- 24:30movies don't point to the fact that they're white all the time. And the
- 24:33movie is Harold and Kumar. Oh, yes, nice. You have two
- 24:38guys lead characters, both Asian, one is Korean, the other is there
- 24:44fully South Asian. No weirdness about it, right, the movie is just
- 24:48a great movie. Funny, This is a great movie. Yeah. They
- 24:51could have cast anybody as Harold and Kumar, right, And in fact,
- 24:56when they were first writing it, I don't know, but I'm guessing it
- 24:59was probably just slated for two white guys, like dude wears my Car.
- 25:03But at some point they decide and it's such an entertaining movie. Yeah,
- 25:07but it's it's funny, it's it's classic. And I just think it's really
- 25:14interesting that chat GBT would would put this because I don't imagine a lot of
- 25:18listicles include this. I wouldn't have remembered it in that context, right,
- 25:22because people, that's the annoying thing. It's like, in order for it
- 25:26to be an Hispanic American movie, it has to be about gangs or poverty
- 25:32or people smuggling cocaine into the country, right, It can't just be about
- 25:37two guys who smoke a lot of weed and late at night go to white
- 25:42Castle and as they're leaving U there are like five steps down the hallway and
- 25:48Kumar Kumar Kumar is like, oh my phone because they left it at the
- 25:53apartment and they look at each other like we've gone too far to oh good
- 26:00Stacey and I will say that sometimes will be like, you know, at
- 26:04the car and you know, in the in the garage and Stacey be like,
- 26:08oh I forgot this thing, you know. She she really like like
- 26:12has a reaction, and I'm like, well, we've come too far.
- 26:19What what are we gonna do? Ye bend it like Beckham what? So
- 26:27it's about an Indian family in London, but that has nothing to do with
- 26:33the United States. Yeah, so that's its first it's first missed. I
- 26:37don't think I've ever seen it. By the way, the namesake which is
- 26:42that isn't that with Kumar? I think? So? Yeah? And okay
- 26:48good the next one. So starting to freight at the edges as we get
- 26:52lower on the list. Mulan the cartoon not Asian American on as in the
- 27:00Disney movie about China, a Chinese hero what Okay, the United States didn't
- 27:07even exist perhaps at the time of that that movie portrayal, I don't know,
- 27:14for some reason. Joylet Club again, okay, so well yeah,
- 27:21he's like, there's also some other we've called Joylet Club and what about have
- 27:26I mentioned? This next movie is also I think a great identification called Searching,
- 27:36which is also God damn it, isn't that the one in the wait
- 27:42No, no, because something of namesake? No, what's searching? Searching?
- 27:47You might not have seen, but John Show, goddamn it. Uh.
- 27:52You know, Harold is in Searching and he's a father with a teenage
- 27:56daughter who goes missing. And it's a pretty interesting movie. I gave it
- 28:00a seven out of ten. I mean, it's a simple thriller. I
- 28:03did see this though, No, No, I did see this, Okay,
- 28:06yeah, absolutely, it takes place all online. Yes, I did
- 28:11definitely saw this. Yes, yeah, And I'm surprised there aren't more.
- 28:17I mean, I know, I think other movies have tried to do this
- 28:21stick where the entire movie is filmed through devices. There's been a couple of
- 28:26horror movies like that, right, Yeah, but this movie I thought,
- 28:32did it? It was very good. Pretty well. Yeah, And and
- 28:33it also told the story in a realistic way, like I'm remembering now that
- 28:41because you know, the the mother dies, I believe. And they show
- 28:47sort of like the movie up how the intro because it's not really part of
- 28:52the plot, sort of like they yeah, the preface to this to the
- 28:56story. And again they tell the whole story the family and then the you
- 29:00know, basically like a screenshot of the of the desktop and they show how,
- 29:07you know, he's sending an email or there's these photos that someone's organizing
- 29:11on their on their on their laptop. Uh. The Windows UI is the
- 29:17old UI, and I don't know. It's pretty effective, but again,
- 29:22not about being Asian American. It's just about being an American person who happens
- 29:26to be Asian American. Another movie, same situation. Love this movie.
- 29:30Gave it eight out of ten. Always Be My Maybe. It's a rom
- 29:36com. Highly recommend Always Be My Maybe. Yeah, And it has Park,
- 29:42the guy Park the comedian guy, and the woman is Amy. Why
- 29:52am I so bad with names? Today? I saw her live? Is
- 29:56this comedian? The guy in the Hangover? Is he in the Hangover?
- 30:03I'm forgetting Randall? Park, Ali Wang not Amy. She plays Amy and
- 30:11it's something goddamn or is she is Ali Wong Amy and Beef? Yes?
- 30:17Okay, yes, So anyway, Ali Wang I saw Live Stacy and I
- 30:23and she's hilarious. Nice and her. By the way, Ali Wong's first
- 30:29Netflix comedy Special is a laugh rat. Really what's it called? I can't
- 30:33remember up, but this is a great pick because it's a rom com and
- 30:40it's just a regular American movie happenstead have to Asian Americans, and there's a
- 30:47little sprinkling in of Asian American culture, but it's not like obnoxious or focused
- 30:53on very much. You know. Well, it's like Beef. I remember
- 30:56we talked about it in Beef. How Like it's just a great movie.
- 31:00It could have been about any two characters and well and it even started out
- 31:03as I think an Asian person and a uh and a white person. I
- 31:08think I think Ali Wong's character is supposed to be a white guy. But
- 31:15anyway, yeah, but and and again there's there's little sprinklings of Asian nests
- 31:18in there, but it's not like focused on all the time. The next
- 31:25movie, Memoirs of a Geisha, Oh yeah, but not Asian America.
- 31:30The next movie, The Wedding Banquet, which is an ang Lee movie,
- 31:33again not not Asian American. The next movie they put Crouching Tiger in there.
- 31:40No. The next movie Big Hero six, which I kind of like
- 31:45because, well the cartoon, because because you know, the main friends too
- 31:49friends friend Soko or whatever. Oh is it it's in the fake Well the
- 31:56main character he's he's coded is Asian American and his older brother is code.
- 32:02You know, it's not. I don't know if it's explicit, but I
- 32:06do remember watching Big Hero six and going, oh, they're certainly supposed to
- 32:09feel like the US, you know, Yeah, yeah, I mean I
- 32:15I don't. I did not think that, you know, because they're speaking
- 32:20English. And the next movie Karate Kid, which is the only movie that
- 32:27predates joy Lett Club, and as a Japanese American, I can absolutely claim
- 32:36that movie as a Japanese American movie. It has a very Japanese American theme
- 32:40because you know, he got well, but they talk about World War two
- 32:45and World War two. He's a World War Two veteran who fought and basically
- 32:51they even even the first movie, there's a lot of that. But in
- 32:53the second movie they traveled to Japan to Okinawa. I kind of got obsessed
- 32:59with Okanow because of that movie. But yeah, and he is he is
- 33:04living in America. The main character's white, but you know, but but
- 33:09it'll it's pretty Asian American. And for me and my family, it was
- 33:15a big fucking deal that this movie existed. And it wasn't like Breakfast at
- 33:22Tiffany's. Oh, I love this movie so much, you know, it
- 33:25was you had a regular Asian American character that was very believable, by the
- 33:30way, And yeah, the storyline is a little silly karate and all this
- 33:35stuff, But the way that you know, the way that Biaggi was portrayed
- 33:40and the way he was written, I mean, you could argue that it
- 33:44was otherizing because it exoticizes, right. Well sure, I mean the trope
- 33:50was the martial arts expert from the Orient, right, But at the same
- 33:54time, like, if you're gonna have a role model, it's a pretty
- 33:58good role model. Yeah. Yeah, he's patient, he's kind, he's
- 34:04in touch with with humanity and nature. He happens to be also good at
- 34:08martial arts. But he's got good advice to give. He's brave, he
- 34:12fought in the war, but you know, take it from me, and
- 34:16maybe Hispanic Americans don't get this stereotype, but often when Asian Americans are included,
- 34:24they are considered to be these other characters, like these other worldly characters
- 34:30that have all this like ancient wisdom and you know that three dimensional characters.
- 34:36Karate Kid is not that far, but it has you know, a little
- 34:38taste of that event. But for nineteen eighty four, I'll take it,
- 34:42and I did take it. The equivalent for for a Mexican person in a
- 34:45in a in a lot of movies, is a gang member. Oh well,
- 34:49I would yes, but I would add, like maybe maybe to modernize
- 34:52little bit. It's they're the fun, colorful character who's got a lot of
- 34:59funny things they say. They think of like ant Man, you know,
- 35:01like how the But it's not bad, It's not bad. It's just like
- 35:07that's that role, right, Never the lead, you know, never the
- 35:10heart throb. What would have really pushed Crowdate Kid over the edge, which
- 35:14probably would have made it unmarketable, is if LaRusso was played by an Asian
- 35:19American kid who was born in the United States. Yeah, which would have
- 35:22made kind of a lot more sense. In some ways. Anyway, the
- 35:25next four movies are are not Asian American. I'm waiting for Bruce Lee movies.
- 35:30Yeah, we have in the Mood for Love, not Asian American.
- 35:36The Best Exotic Marigo to Hotel, which I did not like. I gave
- 35:40it a four at attended. I never even thought it was Apparently people to
- 35:45confess I am behind, like, well, this is the same movies.
- 35:50Well this movie is thirteen years ago. Yeah, but I think I'm behind
- 35:52like five movies of Wes Anderson that. No, this isn't Wes Anderson.
- 35:59Oh you're thinking of, Oh, you haven't seen Buddha Pestoel. Okay,
- 36:04So who the heck does the Merrygold? I don't know. Wait, what's
- 36:07the one that I haven't seen that I think you're thinking of. No,
- 36:09you saw I saw the train one. Yeah, you saw that one with
- 36:14me. Oh, well the most recent west ND. I didn't see the
- 36:16Asteroid cityde No, but there's there's one before that I didn't see anyway,
- 36:22Asteroid Hotel or Asteroid City. I was not a fan. So wait,
- 36:24so okay, so the Marryago, who does the marygoal at the Hotel?
- 36:29I don't know. I don't. I don't know why am I getting so
- 36:30confused here? Let's move on. So this movie is about old Brits that
- 36:35go to a hotel in India, and the whole premise is old people doing
- 36:42racy things and it's not my thing. Let's just put it that way.
- 36:46Next movie A Simple Life, which I forget what it is, but it's
- 36:51not Asian American. And the next one is Eat Drink Band Women, which
- 36:54is Angley. Again not Asian, not Asian, not America. So uh,
- 37:01Now, for some people, they might be thinking, well, you
- 37:05know most Americans are white. Okay, well, let's look at the demographics.
- 37:12So what percentage us are identify themselves as white? Bruto? You know,
- 37:21I'd say sixty, almost fifty nine. I'd say that's a hit Hispanic
- 37:25American. Oh my god, nineteen I consider that hit Asian American. Oh
- 37:36ooh uh? Ten percent? And of course, as I start mentioning Asian
- 37:43American, of course you have a Vietnam helicopter over do Do Do Do Do
- 37:47Do Do Do Do Do Do do. I love the smell of Napanomoor.
- 37:54What'd you say? What percent? Ten? Close? Seven and probably more
- 37:59if you include happas but you know seven, fine, so almost twenty percent.
- 38:04Yeah, one in five Americans are Hispanic Americans. And when we listed
- 38:09the Hispanic American movies, we get things like Cocoa and you know, like
- 38:17water for chocolate and Selma and Freedom which now, so one one interesting thing
- 38:22is that even though you ask what the definition was, I have a feeling.
- 38:29So here's an experiment that you could try as well. It didn't.
- 38:31It didn't misunderstand what white Americans meant. I get it, yeah totally,
- 38:35but that's it didn't identify any European movies, right, yeah, none of
- 38:42them. I mean, I'm looking over the list right now. They're all
- 38:46of actual white American citizens. Okay, so so you know, I get
- 38:55it. But the same would apply to the list of white you know,
- 38:59the same restraints or staff who's applied to the way. And again, the
- 39:05twenty that I listed of white American movies are iconic movies that everyone has heard
- 39:10of, not just in case you said, well, you know, the
- 39:14seventies, we were still regressive. But if I limited it to movies from
- 39:20the past fifteen years, it would be similar, maybe not as bad,
- 39:23but pretty close. So yeah, you know, by dessition one out of
- 39:30five of the iconic movies would be Hispanic American and one out of twelve would
- 39:37be Asian American. My point doesn't matter much because I was going to say,
- 39:39like, there's a way the prompt that you could make the prompt give
- 39:43you a better reson. But your point is like, well, you shouldn't
- 39:45have to, because you know you didn't have to do the better prompt with
- 39:49the other one. It's an easy fucking prompt Hispanic American, Asian American.
- 39:54I even asked for the defficult. It knows what that means. It shouldn't
- 39:59be. What I was trying to say is that it doesn't have presence of
- 40:02mind from query to query in that way, right Like in other words,
- 40:07you can ask what do you mean by you know, Hispanic American, and
- 40:10it'll give you a definition, and that definition may sound right when you ask
- 40:14the question, will give me the movies. You would have had to say,
- 40:17use this explicit definition of blah blah blah in other words, but again,
- 40:22you didn't have to do that with the with the American. With the
- 40:25Yeah, I'm gonna take a guess and say that it would be a very
- 40:29similar scenario. I mean you know, the reason why I'm doing this exercise
- 40:32is to demonstrate the racism that still exists, and Hollywood is just this tiny
- 40:39little manifestation of that. You know, when you and I walk around and
- 40:45other people, particularly people who are more noticeably non white, you know,
- 40:51you and I can pass a lot of times for people who are more noticeably
- 40:55non white, or they have an accent or just some kind of difference.
- 41:00They're in a wheelchair, I don't know, they dress non standardly or something.
- 41:08For these people, they're constantly experiencing othering microaggressions, flat out prejudice and
- 41:16discrimination. It's hard to put that into numbers that you can ask chat GBT
- 41:23to demonstrate. You know, it doesn't lend itself to that kind of investigation.
- 41:31There are ways to investigate it, but it's not as to me easily
- 41:38represented as just asking chat GBT to give the top twenty movies of Hispanic Americans
- 41:45and you get half of them that aren't even of Hispanic Americans. It really
- 41:51just drives home this problem and we're still in it. And not only do
- 41:59you have of audiences that will see a movie with all Hispanic Americans and go,
- 42:06well, that's not for me, even though they don't watch the trailer.
- 42:09Maybe they do, but it's just like, well, you know,
- 42:14I can't tell you how many times I've heard this because you know, as
- 42:16a half Japanese person, I'm not used to being represented. So when I
- 42:21was born, I had to say, well, don't expect to see you
- 42:25represented, so just enjoy movies of any sort. And so I slided into
- 42:32watching a lot of white people movies and identified with Luke Skywalker even do it
- 42:37doesn't look like but you ask white people who have always had a plethora of
- 42:42art that represents them, you ask them to stretch themselves and they will say
- 42:45no. And so there's that, And you have producers and the money people
- 42:52that won't green light this stuff because you had Sixteen Candles, you had the
- 42:57Goonies. I mean, come on, what else do you want? Yeah,
- 43:00you had breakfast at Tiffany's Long dung Fu with I'm surprised, Yeah,
- 43:07I'm surprised that sixteen Candles that show up as an Asian American movie, because
- 43:10you know, yeah, yes, so, uh, you know, if
- 43:15in my lifetime this never gets better, that is, I don't really care
- 43:21that much. But what I want is our country to not be racist,
- 43:27and to not look at Hispanic Americans or Asian Americans, or Black Americans or
- 43:35Indian Americans or Native Americans and think of them as foreigners or others, or
- 43:42strange or threatening or dangerous or unknown to them. There's a did you ever
- 43:46watch kem Peele? Oh yeah, remember the skit of the Magical Negro Trope,
- 43:53where like there's a guy I forget what the problem is and then it's
- 43:57like, oh, I can help you with that whatever I think you've been
- 43:59looking for, the right and then one of them shows up and there's like
- 44:01two of them and they're kind of competing, like who's going to be the
- 44:05more magical? Well because right that they don't have roles in movies, so
- 44:08they're both trying to they're they're good. Like you were saying with mister Miyagi
- 44:13a little bit, it's like, oh, well, if we're going to
- 44:14have that person in this movie, right, they've got to be strange,
- 44:17magical, different, alien their only place. Yeah yeah, yeah. So
- 44:23it's, uh, it's bothersome and it also kind of cuts to the core
- 44:30because you know, people, as I think Reagan said, they vote with
- 44:34their feet, right, So meaning that a lot of white people can say
- 44:37that they're not racist, but how many actually and many do for sure,
- 44:44But as a whole, how many of them actually want to see a movie
- 44:49about Hispanic Americans? Want to see a movie about Asian Americans telling a story
- 44:53that is a little bit Asian, has a little Asian American flare to it
- 44:58instead of the European American fla that's always being represented. You know how many
- 45:01of them actually pay that that ticket price without saying, well, we should
- 45:08do this. You know how many of them are see a trailer of a
- 45:13movie and say, yeah, you know, like Godzilla minus one, for
- 45:16example, it's not Asian American. Did you see this movie yet? Oh
- 45:20my gosh, it's so good. We saw it, remember we went into
- 45:23Oh yeah, you and I saw it. Yeah, yeah, it's so
- 45:25good. Yeah, I forgot. We were blown away by that. Yeah,
- 45:30and you know, it did better than the My brother didn't believe me.
- 45:34I'm like, dude, you got to see the movies, like what
- 45:36And I understand, right, the skepticism is justin I had it, and
- 45:39you could argue that we're part of the problem, right, But I don't
- 45:44know a Godzilla movie. It's like but I will say, like, as
- 45:46an example, like, honestly, you know, what was that movie,
- 45:51the Indian movie that that won those awards? Rob Do you know I had
- 45:57that famous song, the song one an Oscar it's anyways, I haven't seen
- 46:02some dog millionaire? No, no, no, this was last year.
- 46:05It's called like rab forget what it's called. And the song was oh yeah,
- 46:10very popular. Yeah yeah, I haven't seen the movie, and I
- 46:15gotta be honest, I don't have an interest in seeing the movie. Neither
- 46:17do it. I'll say in general, I don't have an interesting seeing Bollywood
- 46:22movies. I don't mind Bollywood, but that movie, whatever it's called.
- 46:29I saw enough previews and enough people, you know, critiques critique the movie.
- 46:34Who loved the movie. Lots of people said they you know, like
- 46:36another channel on YouTube that I watch is God. What's that guy? He
- 46:40does pretty long long videos. What's his name anyway? Patrick Patrick something?
- 46:49Anyway, He did a whole video about how he went down this Bollywood road
- 46:55and went to India and looked at the hit and provided history and would show
- 47:00these different movie stars and then got to that one movie. And I still
- 47:07didn't want to see it because it's like it looks like Fast and the Furious
- 47:09kind of and I'm not into Fast and the Furious. I don't mind people
- 47:14liking that sort of stuff, but that's the sort of thing I want to
- 47:16watch. In my defense, I would say it's the style that I don't
- 47:21like. It's like, similarly, there are some styles of movies that come
- 47:27out here that I don't like, even though they're not from Bartwood. I'm
- 47:30not saying that's that's that's racist, and you know, maybe many white people,
- 47:35but I'm not talking about styles that are foreign to Americans because a lot
- 47:42of Hispanic American and Asian American and Black American art is completely within and by
- 47:49the way, influenced and formed a lot of the mainstream American art expectations,
- 47:54you know, So I'm not saying that. So I guess god Zilla minus
- 48:00one is an example of like that movie where some people look at that it's
- 48:04like, well, it's kind of a it's a pretty foreign style. But
- 48:08what I would tell people with god Zilla minus one is, although it is
- 48:13because it is very Japanese and made by Japanese people, and it's Godzilla for
- 48:17Crane out Loud, but it is very familiar. It has very familiar story
- 48:24beats and emotion, and is just a wonderful movie. It's pretty tight,
- 48:30pretty short, pretty understandable. It's not out of it's not out of control
- 48:34with its plot and anyway, So is that what you're saying. Well,
- 48:39actually, I think I'm finding what I'm saying. I'll give you another example.
- 48:44I don't like modern country music, and it's not because it's mostly done
- 48:51by white people. As an example, Beyonce just put out a country music
- 48:53and it's like number one in the country charts, and everyone's minds are blowing
- 48:57up because there's a lot of racism in that mean, but I heard the
- 49:01song, I still don't like it. Yeah, so I don't like I
- 49:06don't really like pop music. I wonder if there's a difference though, where
- 49:08like there's maybe a preconceived notion that I'm sure I have as well of like,
- 49:14oh, this movie has all these people that don't look like my people.
- 49:17Therefore I'm probably not gonna like that movie, even if the movie is
- 49:21actually good and something you would like. It's similar to how this analogy is
- 49:25hard, but similar like if if I saw a movie come out right now
- 49:30that is about maybe the South and there's a lot of people that have Southern
- 49:36accents and they're all white and they're talking. I don't know. I'm thinking
- 49:38maybe I might have a preconceived notion that maybe I don't want to see that
- 49:42movie, and then I see it and it's a great movie. I'm wondering
- 49:45if there's like a similar effect, and it takes movies that are really great
- 49:50to burst through that glass ceiling, so to speak, for for more people
- 49:53to see them. I mean, yeah, it's a good it's a good
- 49:57point. I don't I'm because when I look at the list of white American
- 50:01movies, you have The Godfather. There's nothing relatable to you and I of
- 50:07that story. Yes, there's Shawshank Redemption that's about going to prison you and
- 50:13I have no experience with that. I don't know what. Yeah, I'm
- 50:15not sure. I'm not sure what I'm getting at because basically, you're right.
- 50:20I think it's just a matter of quantity as well, because there's just
- 50:23not that much to pick from. Well, I think it is a valid
- 50:27point that well one, I don't want to tell anybody that they're racist for
- 50:32not seeing a person of color movie when they decide to go to a movie.
- 50:38I'm saying that one there's not enough choices. Two it doesn't really matter
- 50:45to me. Like I said, like, if we change the movie thing,
- 50:49that really doesn't change anything about the microaggressions and the oppression and the marginalization
- 50:54that happens all the time. I think I know what I'm trying to get
- 50:58at, and I already know that this isn't even what your point is.
- 51:01But I'm just saying, imagine that a preview comes out where there's several Hispanic
- 51:07Americans in it, and they're speaking a lot of Spanish during the preview,
- 51:13and some of the meals are cooking they look kind of like maybe Mexican or
- 51:16Spanish or something. And someone is watching that preview who maybe is a white
- 51:22American and watching it it's like, ah, that's probably not a movie for
- 51:23me because they feel like that's not a community they're familiar with. Or it
- 51:30doesn't mean that they're racist, but it just means. But I think what
- 51:32we're trying to get at is like, there are many movies that are in
- 51:37the list of the white movies, let's say, that have nothing to do
- 51:42with the cultural aspects of being white or anything like that. They're just good
- 51:46movies and there's not enough of those kinds of movies. And yeah, that's
- 51:52like some of these fictional stories like silver Lining's Playbook. I'm not saying that
- 51:59the people are wrong for not having one or both of the leads on a
- 52:02person of color, but it neither one, but neither one is a person
- 52:07of color. But it didn't and also didn't matter. The plot wasn't like
- 52:09you could can't have the plot if you're not white. You could have had
- 52:15The Truman Show, uh, Breakfast Club, Big Lebowski. So really it's
- 52:20about representation of these communities in the movies, not that you have to make
- 52:25movies that are in a specific specific style or anything like that. Yeah,
- 52:30and again I don't I'm not looking for quotas or pressure the you know,
- 52:34the casting directors. It's it's just reflective of how America just denies that bipoc
- 52:43people even exist. You know, if aliens watched our top movies, top
- 52:47one utter movies, they would think that ninety nine percent of Americans are white.
- 52:52You know, like with I've I've complained about this before. In the
- 52:55first season of White Lotus, which supposedly takes place in Hawaii, and if
- 53:05anyone's have ever been to Hawaii, everyone looks like me. There are like
- 53:09a few white people. And I'm not even joking, like there aren't very
- 53:13many white people, just pure white people in Hawaii. Everyone is half Asian
- 53:20or Asian or you know, not like the only two. There's one character,
- 53:30the pregnant woman, and after the first episode, I think she's she's
- 53:35she doesn't even show up again. And then you have the love interest of
- 53:39the friend, but he hardly has any lines. But at least that's accurate.
- 53:45You know. It's like they as they're writing, it's like, we
- 53:47can't have a white guy be the love interest as a local. He she
- 53:52has to actually, you know, like the Concierge. Now, I love
- 53:57the Concierge. I don't think anyone could have played it better than that actor
- 54:00did, so I don't disparage it for that. But even just when you
- 54:05looked at the background extras, there weren't very many people that look like me.
- 54:09And you know why because they filmed it in Italy and so economically,
- 54:15it wouldn't make sense to fly in a bunch of Hawaiians because you have a
- 54:20bunch of Italians that'll be extras. And then we can't ignore one of the
- 54:23obvious reasons why historically we didn't see a lot of Hispanics Asians in represented in
- 54:31movies, let alone as lead characters, right is, first of all,
- 54:37in a lot of those communities, you had bigger struggles to begin with.
- 54:40And so if you're already in a disadvantaged community, your live choices are a
- 54:46lot more limited. So the idea of like, oh, I could be
- 54:49an actor in Hollywood or whatever, it's like, well, really like,
- 54:52no, you can't let alone that if you go and try, The chances
- 54:57you're going to land a role are even more limited because most of the roles
- 55:00are looking for someone that doesn't look like you, you know. And so
- 55:04yeah, that's all true, and so then you add that historical aspect.
- 55:07But I think right now I'm starting to see more, you know, people
- 55:15added to movies that you know, especially when you consider series TV TV series,
- 55:21when you look at Netflix and you know, I'm guessing that there's definitely
- 55:28someone on the casting directing side that's like, look, we're gonna get canceled
- 55:32if we just have a bunch of white actors. So we've got to get
- 55:36But isn't it better? Like it's great because that's what our society looks like.
- 55:39Yeah, like the Bear. And I'm not saying like, look like,
- 55:43I am not saying that if you're making a historical drama set in England
- 55:47and blah blah, you should cast all people that look Hispanic. Like,
- 55:50I'm not saying that, but like the Bear has a diverse cast and it's
- 55:53great because of it, because it feels real, it feels right. Yeah.
- 55:58And similarly, a lot of movies, as I've talked about before,
- 56:01take place in Los Angeles, which let me give you the stats on that.
- 56:07What percentage is Hispanic in Los Angeles? Hispanic in Los Angeles has got
- 56:12to be like almost fifty percent Wow, white people, I guess nine wow.
- 56:23So how many how many movies and TV shows are in LA? Are
- 56:30explicitly taking place in Los Angeles, all of them and they have mostly white
- 56:37people, if not across the board white people as the actors. It's a
- 56:43huge percentage. And then Asian Americans Los Angeles twelve percent, probably more again
- 56:49when you include Happis. So that's really that's that's the stat that's really unbelievable.
- 56:53Yeah, Like Bear, The Bear, takes place in Philly, in
- 57:00Chicago, Chicago. You know it's probably a lot of white people and a
- 57:06lot of black people. Of course there's Asians and Hispanics, but not as
- 57:09many Asians as there are in Seattle or Los Angeles. So okay, but
- 57:15you know half Hispanic. Like, is it improving, Yes, but it's
- 57:21it's a problem. So let's take a break. We get back, let's
- 57:22finish with with women in movies and see how that compares. Let's do it.
- 57:34All right, you're back from the break. Let's do another opp Burdo.
- 57:37These people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty one. We
- 57:44have a Natalia from Austria. Did you say on Natalia or just Natalia Natalia?
- 57:50Oh sorry, from Austria, Mia from Thornbury, Australia. We have
- 57:55another Natalia from Brussels, Belgium. Oh my goodness. We have lease or
- 58:02Lies from Hasselt, Belgium. We have Dewey or Doovi from Essen Antwerp,
- 58:12Belgium. We have Charlene from Edmonton, Alberta. We have Jessica from Petersborough,
- 58:19Ontario. Stella from Markham, Ontario. By the way, all these
- 58:23people are not from the United States. I think I organized them by that.
- 58:28We have Stella. We have Rania from Ottawa, Rocks from Montreal,
- 58:34Sarah from moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, wow Eli from
- 58:39Aurelia, Ontario, Joseph from Gravenhurst, Ontario, Michelle names I haven't heard.
- 58:46Michelle from Switzerland, Geneva, Malika from Switzerland, Zurich, I believe
- 58:54Zurich in Switzerland and from Bitberg, Germany. Leah from Hamburg, Germany,
- 59:04Rexter from Berlin, Germany, Elka from Berlin, Stella from Berlin and I
- 59:12stay or Ace d or Aiste from Denmark. Thank you so much for becoming
- 59:17a patriot, and I apologize for butchering your name and your country and everything
- 59:23about you, including your culture. So Berto, if a stereotypical Hispanic American,
- 59:36we're in a you know, we're an Hispanic American actor is cast into
- 59:44a movie and the director is telling him to play a stereotypical Hispanic American and
- 59:54he is trying to motivate a small group of people to become a patron of
- 1:00:00the podcast. What would that sound like? It would be something like this,
- 1:00:06Hi, I'm a Hispanic American as you might not be able to tell,
- 1:00:10but I would like for you guys to consider, Wait, why are
- 1:00:15you losing interests? Hey mentioned drugs? Mentioned drugs. Oh okay, well
- 1:00:19you're not paying attention. But hey, listen everyone, let me tell you
- 1:00:22about salsan, the good stuff. I can give you a little pegante.
- 1:00:25Hey, have you thought of maybe maybe patroning this podcast here a psychology loco?
- 1:00:32Oh yeah, oh yeah, cocain man, I can snort it all
- 1:00:37day. Let's go. I just canceled myself. Okay, So I asked
- 1:00:45chat GPT list the top twenty movies about women. So I didn't say American
- 1:00:50women. I I just said just women, just women. So I'm gonna
- 1:00:55rattle these off all at once. And you know, see, if you
- 1:01:01remember these movies, how kind of iconic they are. Thelma and Louise,
- 1:01:07Little Women, both of them, Aaron Brockovich, Hidden Figures, The Color
- 1:01:13Purple, The Help, Million Dollar Baby, Freda, Norma Ray Wild,
- 1:01:20the one with Reese Witherspoon, Room, that movie Joy Jaylaw, North Country
- 1:01:29with Charley's Leave Their Own with Madonna, Elizabeth About I Think Queen Elizabeth mahaland
- 1:01:37Drive Gone with the Wind Blue Jasmine Woody Allen movie Kate Blanchett Little Miss Sunshine,
- 1:01:45which I looked up because I saw it back in the day. But
- 1:01:50it's not really about women. It's girl. There's a there's a mom and
- 1:01:57Mom and the movie Monster, another Charlie's movie. So when you when you
- 1:02:01hear that whole list, what do you think? Well, first of all,
- 1:02:05I don't watch women movies, so no, I mean, here's a
- 1:02:08couple of things. Definitely heard some things in there that don't belong. But
- 1:02:12there was somewhat like little Bit sun Sign doesn't really belong well, but also,
- 1:02:16uh, Frieda was in there. Yeah, it's a woman, but
- 1:02:21it's not American or I did say American. Oh sorry, I'm sorry.
- 1:02:24I said just any woman. Oh okay, Okay. Then then yes,
- 1:02:29you're right. Uh then there was a lot of heavy hitters in this list.
- 1:02:31Yeah, I mean you could argue, is Mulholland Drive a movie about
- 1:02:36women? There's women in Mulholland Drive and there's a woman lead. So yeah,
- 1:02:40I mean, if you're if you're going off of like, I mean,
- 1:02:45like someone Louise is a movie about women. Little Women is a movie
- 1:02:49about Aaron Brackovic, yes, hidden figures. Yes, color purple the help,
- 1:02:54I guess what is the color of purple? I don't I don't remember.
- 1:02:58Yeah, it's it's pretty heavily. And it's interesting that they're throwing in
- 1:03:01non white people movies. A Million Dollar Baby, it's about a woman,
- 1:03:07boxer, Freda, a woman you know, a normal ray Wild Room is
- 1:03:13while the one where she went on what's the one where where she's cycle a
- 1:03:20cycle but no, she's like, I think she might have issues run away
- 1:03:22and she Oh no, no, you're thinking of pills. You're thinking of
- 1:03:25the one from the nineties with key for Sutherland. Yes, and uh,
- 1:03:32it's actually it was filmed around the way where she disappears and there's a like
- 1:03:37when you're actually going to Slakuami, they have an oaster with no. But
- 1:03:43actually I'm thinking of a different movie with Ris Witherspoon where she's kind of crazy,
- 1:03:47I don't know, Okay, but this is her hiking. Oh that's
- 1:03:52some more reason. So uh, but these are great, A lot of
- 1:03:57these are great movies, right, so yeah, but it is notable that
- 1:04:00again, if I ask chat TBT to give me the top two hundred movies
- 1:04:05about white Americans, I'm guessing there wouldn't be a single miss on that list.
- 1:04:11Yeah, you know, maybe eventually, But you asked for twenty movies
- 1:04:15about women, and it gives you little Miss Sunshine, which I guess it's
- 1:04:18not like, you know, Doctor Strangelove or something, which I don't know
- 1:04:24if there's any well, I guess there's maybe one woman in that as as
- 1:04:28a sure, I think what's his face is having sex with in the hotel
- 1:04:30or something. I think the name is weighing it heavily, right, little
- 1:04:34miss Sunshine. Yeah, and yeah it's a girl too, but uh so
- 1:04:42we could we could absolutely say what about girl interrupted? We could consider that
- 1:04:46a miss little miss Sunshine. So that's just kind of telling that it's struggling
- 1:04:51to come up with twenty. But I will say, when I look at
- 1:04:56this list, it's pretty solid. Yeah. Uh, it's a much better
- 1:05:00list than the Hispanic American and the Asian American list, especially when you think
- 1:05:04about the iconic nature so I mean Thumb and Luise, little women, Aaron
- 1:05:09Brockovich, hidden figures, color and also so now if you just a household,
- 1:05:14uh you know, movies, if you will, and if you take
- 1:05:15it from a different direction, which is because one of the things we were
- 1:05:18talking about is, like you gave Herold and Kumaras and examples, there's been
- 1:05:24movies since the movie industry started that has female leads and stuff like that,
- 1:05:29so that bar is actually much lower. Now if you start talking about minority
- 1:05:33female leads, well then you're really screwed. Yeah. Yeah, I guess
- 1:05:39if we look at because I didn't ask, you know, gender wise for
- 1:05:42a Hispanic American and I'm just trying to think if, well, Selena,
- 1:05:47some of them real women have curves, mayvie de loca. Actually I wonder
- 1:05:54that this in some cases excuse because when you're trying to, like, in
- 1:05:59some ways, if you're trying to make a movie that will be of an
- 1:06:02underrepresented community, you might go for the least represented parts of those least represented
- 1:06:09communities. Why, because that's what you're trying to do, Like you're like,
- 1:06:12in other words, there aren't a lot of movies about just like Hispanic
- 1:06:20American doing normal stuff. Yeah, right, but there are movies about a
- 1:06:26school of this enfranchised Hispanic American kids with a Hispanic American teacher trying to get
- 1:06:31them back at an interesting angle to it. Yeah, yeah, but you
- 1:06:34know now is sexism over? No, this list is far inferior to the
- 1:06:44just general wide Americans. And I'm actually looking in the twenty white Americans and
- 1:06:48trying to see if any of these could be Well, I I guess silver
- 1:06:51Lighting's playbook it's half you know, led by a woman. Yeah. And
- 1:06:57then I'm looking up the lists. You could argue that Breakfast Club is has
- 1:07:01a pretty strong woman, but like Gone with the Wing was in this list,
- 1:07:05that's in the that's in the women list. Yeah, is because Scarlet
- 1:07:10is a woman. I mean it's been a little lot since I've seen that
- 1:07:13movie, but yeah, I think that what's his face? The male lead,
- 1:07:18he kind of comes in and out, whereas the movie, the one
- 1:07:25character you follow is Scarlet, I think from beginning to end. Yeah,
- 1:07:29I could be wrong in that. Yeah, I'm just looking what about the
- 1:07:31Sound of Music Man, Yeah, not a single Titanic. So of all
- 1:07:39the movies you got Titanic and silver Lighting's playbook that have that, they share
- 1:07:45it with a dude. So and then I'm also looking at the list if
- 1:07:50there's any Hispanic American or Asian American even remotely represented me, I guess he
- 1:07:56got Forest Gump. It takes place in Vietnam for a while, but that
- 1:07:59doesn't count, right, It's Godfather, shasheg pulp fiction, and Big Lebowski
- 1:08:04called Wolf of Wall Street. If you good men? Yeah, not a
- 1:08:08single one of these movies has Hispanic Americans or or Asian Americans. Now,
- 1:08:15I didn't do a list of Black Americans because I didn't think we would have
- 1:08:17time. But I'm just gonna take a guess and say that that list would
- 1:08:24be better. Well, actually, i'll just type it in. By the
- 1:08:26way, it's funny to think that the split, like when you think of
- 1:08:29the Oscars, they split by gender. You know, you have best male
- 1:08:31in a performance, best best female in a performance. And I suppose that
- 1:08:39that was that was probably originally done so that you would have some female representation
- 1:08:45because there were so many more males in leading roles. So if you said
- 1:08:50best overall leading role, most often it would just go to a male.
- 1:08:56Yeah, And I wonder if that was even the case in the beginning.
- 1:08:59I don't know. And you know, I'm not saying that there should be
- 1:09:01an Oscar for the best Asian America. No, I actually think that would
- 1:09:03actually be bad. That would be counterproductive. And again, I don't even
- 1:09:08care if this doesn't change. It's just an interesting data point that points to
- 1:09:12a larger problem. So looking at so, I asked, give me the
- 1:09:16top twenty movies about Black Americans, and number one Twelve Years of Slave.
- 1:09:23Okay, number two do the right Thing? Yep, pretty good. Moonlight,
- 1:09:28Yeah, nailed it, Selma nailed it. Get Out nailed it.
- 1:09:32Malcolm X Black Panther, Black Panther. Are there Black Americans? Nope?
- 1:09:40Yeah, so that's a miss. Hidden Figures good, fruit Vale Station,
- 1:09:46good of that one? Oh, it's it's it is a biopic of an
- 1:09:53actual event. You mean a biopic at least I'm pretty sure it's of an
- 1:09:59actual event. The Color Purple Good, Ray Good, Django and Chain Good,
- 1:10:04The Hate You Give Good, Precious Good, Straight out of Compton,
- 1:10:09Good School Days, Great, Barbershop, good, Greed Good. If Beal
- 1:10:15Street could talk, Uh Beal Street could talk? I know I've heard of
- 1:10:23this movie. Did I see this movie? I don't know if I ever
- 1:10:27saw this movie. I think it was up for an Oscar romantic drama.
- 1:10:33Looks like it could be good and Boys in the Hood. So wait,
- 1:10:38did they already say boys in that I think they did that one twice.
- 1:10:41No, no, no, no, but there was Yeah what am I?
- 1:10:45I think I was primed by another movie straight out of Compton, both
- 1:10:51thought. Yeah, so so that I suspect this list, This list is
- 1:11:00actually better than I thought it would be because a lot of these movies are
- 1:11:04again household names, you know, and a lot of them won Best Picture.
- 1:11:12You know, Malcolm X, Black Panther, Hidden Figures. Oh okay,
- 1:11:16so I guess it got two or it just got one wrong, right,
- 1:11:21Jango and Chained Shadow of Compton do the right thing? I told your
- 1:11:28a slave? Yeah, so uh, not as iconic, nearly iconic as
- 1:11:33the list of White American movies. So I would say compared to the if
- 1:11:40I, if I just given my cultural pocket, I would say that the
- 1:11:44Black American list is more iconic than the women list, because you know,
- 1:11:50they have movies like Blue Jasmine on the women list, and yeah, but
- 1:11:58I think of a league of their own fun movie, great fun, but
- 1:12:00come on, but pretty iconic. But it's not like a ten out of
- 1:12:05ten, right, or Reese Witherspoon wild movie like yeah, well that one
- 1:12:11did get a lot of that for some people. Amazing but it's not a
- 1:12:14household name, like like do the right thing is, you know what I
- 1:12:17mean? And certainly not a household name like every movie on the white American
- 1:12:23list. You know, that's just my cultural pocket. You know, maybe
- 1:12:26others would disagree with that, but it is. It is an interesting It's
- 1:12:30not really I don't know what it says, but it's saying something that when
- 1:12:35I ask Hispanic American, Asian American, just women, I didn't even say
- 1:12:41American women. I said any woman, White American, Black, American.
- 1:12:45How it kind of slots. But it's a little counterintuitive because I would have
- 1:12:49thought it's interesting when you throw women in there, right, because women could
- 1:12:54be of any race, and normally you would think, well, the the
- 1:13:00list of women movies would be atrocious, right. No, But but again,
- 1:13:04like you have because the you know, love stories and stories like women
- 1:13:10have been part of movies from the get go. But a lot of these
- 1:13:13movies are not, like at least focused on the love story. In fact,
- 1:13:16I'm trying to find one of them that is even mildly focused. I
- 1:13:20mean, you could say Little Women Gone with the Wind is okay, but
- 1:13:25even that, it's more about survivals civil war uh, you know, the
- 1:13:29love story is I think a part of the initial plot, but I mean
- 1:13:32Thelma Luiz, Aaron Brockovic, you know, these are these are stories about
- 1:13:36women. I wasn't bringing up the love story though, to be clear about
- 1:13:41like, well, you know love stories that would have onen. I'm saying
- 1:13:44because from the very beginning of Hollywood you couldn't tell stories without a lot of
- 1:13:49them being like, there's a love story. I do have women Hollywood,
- 1:13:55and yeah, and the audience were accustomed to seeing women on on those silvers.
- 1:14:00And then you add the you know, maybe machismo aspects of like,
- 1:14:04well we also want to be like sex see sexy women on film. You
- 1:14:09have to add the women into the movies. So it was natural to have
- 1:14:13women in movies from the get go. Interesting whereas like it wasn't natural for
- 1:14:16the Hollywood director in the twenties, thirties, forties, it'd be like,
- 1:14:20you look Hispanic, I want you in my movie unless you're having a gang
- 1:14:25of bandolier pistoleros in the in the Western. Well that is interesting because I
- 1:14:30wonder if because there's a stereotype cast position for Hispanic Americans, that would be
- 1:14:40an interim step to you know, getting eventual movies that are more normal,
- 1:14:47you know, in terms of like a story just about Hispanic Americans. But
- 1:14:51I don't know when I I mean, this is just not all just talking
- 1:14:55on top of our heads. But like there were strong women character in the
- 1:15:00big you know, close to the beginning of the silver screen, you know,
- 1:15:05Joan Crawford and other kinds of actors that were celebrated and held up as
- 1:15:11like they didn't need men. You know, the guys in their movies probably
- 1:15:15were secondary on the bill, you know, so because but again you know,
- 1:15:19it's because you know, people wanted you know, certain kind of attractive,
- 1:15:25attractive precedence on the screen, and attractive women and good actress attractive women
- 1:15:30did well in that kind. But that doesn't mean but they didn't, you
- 1:15:33know, necessarily have a movie focused on on on the woman as the as
- 1:15:38the lead as much as they had guys in the lead, and then they'd
- 1:15:41have all. But it is, it is, it is at some But
- 1:15:44yeah, it's an interesting commentary though, because I would never say that sexism
- 1:15:53was not as big of a deal now and particularly in the past. You
- 1:15:58know, of course it is a big deal. But I wonder if people
- 1:16:03that have studied this sort of thing would say that when you look at the
- 1:16:09intersectionality of everything, you know, the white world can't really and maybe he
- 1:16:15doesn't want to ignore white women, but the white world can and might want
- 1:16:20to ignore all of Asian Americans and all Hispanic Americans and all Black Americans.
- 1:16:25Do you remember the scene in Amadeus where the king had some rule where they
- 1:16:29couldn't He didn't allow ballets in his operas. Knows why, but he had
- 1:16:33that rule. And then Mozart composes an opera in which there's a little ballet
- 1:16:38segment, and the court composers like, oh, well, you can't have
- 1:16:43that in the you know. Or the master he's like, you can't have
- 1:16:45that because the king, And so then they're performing for the king, or
- 1:16:49the king shows up at one of the rehearsals and they're doing the ballet dance
- 1:16:54without any music, and he's like, what is this, Well, your
- 1:16:58majesty, you don't allow ballets, and you're well, but this is ridiculous,
- 1:17:01no, no, put it back in. Similarly, imagine that you
- 1:17:05start making movies. Initially it's like, well, you know, do you
- 1:17:08just think of everything through the movie amadas. Everything is amatives. So we're
- 1:17:11you know, we're starting the movie industry. It's early on. And then
- 1:17:14come watch my new movie. And you watch the movie and it's just dudes
- 1:17:17shooting each other, and you're like, oh, that's pretty fun. You
- 1:17:19watch the next movie, it's just dudes shooting each other. At some point,
- 1:17:23someone might be like, what about women, Like, we like women
- 1:17:28right now, they're not gonna go and ask the black lady down the street
- 1:17:31or the Hispanically. They're gonna grab some white women, but they're gonna put
- 1:17:34them on the screen, and then some of them are gonna be prettier than
- 1:17:36others. They're like, whoa, this is interesting, and so like it's
- 1:17:40kind of a natural thing to just add women from the start. It doesn't
- 1:17:43mean that there wasn't sexism. In fact, there was a lot of problems
- 1:17:46with sexism and casting couches and all these kinds of things that developed. But
- 1:17:50what they weren't in need of was like, you know what, there's a
- 1:17:54lot of white guys in this movie, right like unless it was like there's
- 1:17:58a lot of white cowboys, that's fine, but they need to shoot other
- 1:18:01people that don't look so white. So either we get some white guys and
- 1:18:04paint them a little bit, or maybe grab a couple guys off the street,
- 1:18:08you know. Yeah, and that just was like you could see it
- 1:18:12developing. And it took a while, for example, for Black Americans to
- 1:18:15get representation because they themselves had to make movies, you know, right,
- 1:18:19And you know, of course there's a long history, particularly in the beginning
- 1:18:23of stage and film, of just having white people do black face for black
- 1:18:29people or that's a perfect sample, or yellow face. I was like,
- 1:18:32hey, listen, we need to tell a story here in which there are
- 1:18:35going to be black people. Should we go hire some No, Bobby here
- 1:18:41can do it. Let's just paint them. And in fact, Bobby does
- 1:18:44a better black person than any black person I know, right, Like John
- 1:18:48Wayne plays Genghis Khan, right, I think? And is it because there
- 1:18:54was like are we to believe that literally no one they couldn't have found any
- 1:19:00one in the Asian world that could have played that role. Yeah, Genghis
- 1:19:05Khan. And the sad thing is like the movie called The Conqueror from nineteen
- 1:19:10fifty six, and yeah, he's you know, that kept happening all the
- 1:19:15way up until very recently. Right, Yeah, we didn't Johnny dab catch
- 1:19:19heat because he he was Tonto. We're just looking at other other actors.
- 1:19:27Ironically, there's a lot of what looked to be Hispanic actors playing Asians.
- 1:19:31You have Pedro ar Mendadies playing a Mongol. I'm guessing you have Thomas Gomez
- 1:19:40playing Wayne Khan. Right, you look a little different. We need some
- 1:19:45different looking people get over here. Yeah. Right, So even when they're
- 1:19:48literally writing a story about Asians, they still refuse because they I don't know,
- 1:19:59I you know. One reason was because, well, if you can
- 1:20:01get John Wayne, you get John Wayne because he sells. He sells stuff.
- 1:20:04But notice that that doesn't work in reverse. Like, look, I
- 1:20:08personally, I like my James Bonds to be white, stuck up brit dudes.
- 1:20:14But if you could get it Riselbau or some other mega famous cool black
- 1:20:18dude or Hispanic or whoever to play a secret agent from England, why not?
- 1:20:24But the world lost its mind. What that's that's heresy, right,
- 1:20:29it's heretical. And it's because like the thought of some other race playing a
- 1:20:33character that's supposed to be a white character, that's crazy. But white characters
- 1:20:40playing other, that's fine that we've been doing that for hundreds of years,
- 1:20:44and it is like, look again, I personally, I like, if
- 1:20:47I'm watching a historical thing or whatever, I like to represent it the way
- 1:20:51it would have looked, so you know, I don't need you know,
- 1:20:55but if we're talking about a fictional character, a fictional character, yeah,
- 1:21:00why can't it be whatever? Yeah? And then especially with James Bond,
- 1:21:02like you know, Britain is a multicultural nation and they're not all white people.
- 1:21:09So now if you're telling a story from today, you could have another
- 1:21:12agent. Of course that would not be a white guy. And again my
- 1:21:15personal bias because I grew up with it, like, well I still want
- 1:21:16to see a white dude doing it, but I'm not going to die on
- 1:21:18that hill. The flip side of this is what we were saying before,
- 1:21:24is but why don't we just have more movies with people? Yeah? Well,
- 1:21:30good movies with people? So often? What was I watching? I
- 1:21:34think I was watching a YouTube channel that was talking about World War two or
- 1:21:40something, and it was this really interesting drama that took place maybe in China,
- 1:21:47Like, for example, how many World War two movies have we seen
- 1:21:51about Americans and Germans fighting each other? Right, but how many World War
- 1:21:56two movies have we seen about Japanese Americans fighting Germans? Right, there's one
- 1:22:03about the Four for a Okay, okay, fine. You know of all
- 1:22:06the people that fought in the European theater, you know, vast majority were
- 1:22:10white Americans. You have the Tuskegee Airmen movie that was I think made by
- 1:22:15George Lucas black airmen in Europe and World War two. And we've seen a
- 1:22:21lot of movies just about Germans in Nazi Germany and no Americans are involved at
- 1:22:27all. Right, Well, what about movies about the Chinese getting raped and
- 1:22:32killed? You know, there's there's probably historical Oh I don't know what it
- 1:22:38was. It was about World War two, and there is this you know,
- 1:22:44Japan landed in China. Are about the rape of Nan King or no,
- 1:22:48it was this, I mean, it might have led up to that.
- 1:22:51But there's this really famous story that's well documented and there's a monument there
- 1:22:57in China and it's a i like a hotel or something. And the Japanese
- 1:23:02had landed and they were about to begin their rape and killing and genocide of
- 1:23:09the Chinese people, and this one kernel or something was like that hotel or
- 1:23:17that building, that four story building is a perfect place to defend, but
- 1:23:25we're going to lose. It. Was some kind of story like this,
- 1:23:28right, and I don't know if it's volunteers or whatever, but you know,
- 1:23:30got a ragtag group of guys. I mean, just think of like
- 1:23:33a Quentin Tarantino, like fifteen characters, different different personalities. Yeah, and
- 1:23:42they get into this hotel and they hold out for a long time, like
- 1:23:47a number of days, maybe weeks. There's all these documented raids by the
- 1:23:53Japanese and a lot of death and shooting and mortars and tanks and a lot
- 1:24:00you know, there's like there's this one scene where these the Japanese guys are
- 1:24:06trying to get in the building and like a whole like five or six of
- 1:24:11them get in this little alleyway on the side of the building and they're about
- 1:24:15to climb in, and this one guy just on a whim, grabs like
- 1:24:20a bunch of grenades, pulls the pins and jumps out the window and blows
- 1:24:27himself up and all the fucking Japanese guys and saves the hotel for another number
- 1:24:31of days. That's an amazing fucking story and how cinematic can you get?
- 1:24:36You could tell that kid's backstory. You could make him a complex character.
- 1:24:43Maybe you know, he feels bad about not doing something earlier, kind of
- 1:24:47like you know with Godzilla, mais One or whatever. You could get Caring
- 1:24:50Colkin to play him, which by I love him and and I I think
- 1:25:00the end of the story is the Japanese just decided to go around them,
- 1:25:04oh, because they couldn't. There's like, fuck it, we can't.
- 1:25:06And so they just left him there. And these guys held out, I
- 1:25:11think for a long time, even after that, even though the Japanese army
- 1:25:15had already rolled past, and you know, that's just you just can see
- 1:25:20the ending card where they're like they lasted another three months. Yeah, but
- 1:25:26and they gave And what they did is they inspired Chinese people to fight back
- 1:25:30because you know, at the time, there was not a lot of confidence
- 1:25:33that because it was unknown, like can we fight the the imperial power of
- 1:25:39Japan, like we don't know? And look at these guys like you know,
- 1:25:43and there's this and then you know, and then you flash forward to
- 1:25:45an actual shot of the hotel with the placard and the monument and you know,
- 1:25:50it brings tears to my eyes. It's it's a mazing story. There
- 1:25:54are more stories like that than there are about the European theater. The amount
- 1:26:00of things that happened in Russia and China and the Philippines and Vietnam, like
- 1:26:05there's even because of the share a number of people involved. Do you know
- 1:26:09how many of our fellow war action nerds would jizz their pants about a movie
- 1:26:15like that if it was made? Well, you know, like when we
- 1:26:17saw Northman, that's a movie about about Scandinavians in where are they? They
- 1:26:26go kind of all over place Russia or something that's not about Americans. It's
- 1:26:31about ancient you know, Scanninavians. And you know we were we just our
- 1:26:39pants and so why and then the whole cast would be Asians, right,
- 1:26:46and and it would be an amazing movie. There's not a lot of movies
- 1:26:49like that, and it's it's it's bothersome. Yeah, totally. Well,
- 1:26:56more people need to get in the industry, I guess. And now actually
- 1:27:00never mind, because now you could just go request it from the sora Ai.
- 1:27:03God have you seen that? Of course I have. Have you tried
- 1:27:06it out? It's not you can't. I mean, it's very limited access
- 1:27:11only, but of course, right, I mean, if it can do
- 1:27:15what it can do with images, of course it's going to be able to
- 1:27:18do it. So the the you know, in two years hearing us talk
- 1:27:25about this, it's going to sound like when people talked about the Internet when
- 1:27:28it first came out. But I just want to ask you. I saw,
- 1:27:32like the prompt that I saw was they asked it to make a movie,
- 1:27:40a war movie with soldiers that had helmets with red knit cap like red
- 1:27:46yarn helmets or something. And as I'm watching it, they kind of zoom
- 1:27:54in on a soldier's face. So that's all computer generation, all pixel out
- 1:28:00of thin air. It's not a it's not an actual person. No,
- 1:28:04it's better than CG. Oh well, yeah, because because because that that
- 1:28:11I mean I just saw a little little because what's interesting is it's so fascinating.
- 1:28:15What's happening is with CG you are developing a geometry model with lots of
- 1:28:20teeny little triangles, and then you're putting textures which are little you're essentially having
- 1:28:26the skull, and then you're sculpting, and then you're putting lighting on it,
- 1:28:29and then you're putting effects and you're putting droplets on the skin. And
- 1:28:31by now, of course the CG has gotten to the point where it is
- 1:28:34photorealistic, right, but but it's still not very doing any of that,
- 1:28:42Like you know with loose skywalker, like they can get pretty close to a
- 1:28:45human face, but you can tell it's not really, this isn't doing any
- 1:28:47of that, right, there's no no they By the way, they could
- 1:28:53also have a model, an AI model that generates the geometry of the triangles.
- 1:28:58In fact, they already do. They could, but this isn't bothering
- 1:29:00with any of that. It's literally just doing pixels. It's skipping the middle
- 1:29:03band, it's skipping the middle manage straight to the photons that hit our eyes.
- 1:29:09But the reason it looks so good is because again it's all comes down
- 1:29:12to statistics, right, like statistically predicting what needs to beware. And it's
- 1:29:19like, you know, if you feed in enough things of the kind that
- 1:29:24is correct, then it would actually be statistically unlikely that it would produce something
- 1:29:28that doesn't look Yeah, I mean it's not hard to predict in Well,
- 1:29:34you tell me how many years from now will more than half of the movies
- 1:29:42being produced by Hollywood be perhaps indistinguishable from live action movies, but a majority,
- 1:29:50if not all, of the footage is created by AI. Yeah,
- 1:29:55dude, Well, first of all, I don't know, because some of
- 1:29:58it might get artificially blocked from legislation by regardless of that. Technology wise,
- 1:30:05I made a bet last year with Seth Maybe was it last year. I
- 1:30:12think it was last year. My timeline was I said last year, I
- 1:30:17said within five years, we will have fully generated movies, and I think
- 1:30:25I was being too conservative. But that doesn't mean that overnight all movies are
- 1:30:31going to be generated, and even when they can be generated, it doesn't
- 1:30:38mean humans will want to only see movies that are all computer generated. There
- 1:30:42also might be a backlash. There might be a thing. In fact,
- 1:30:44I don't know if you've seen the reactions online have been really negative. Yeah,
- 1:30:48but there's often and you know it when it comes to economics, Yeah,
- 1:30:57especially once people become habituated to the technology and it seems less evil.
- 1:31:03You know, corporations always win. The people who are mortified by this are
- 1:31:08not the corporations. They are the labor. And the consumer is probably mortified
- 1:31:14for the labor. But labor always loses unless you have legislation, which and
- 1:31:18I guess the unionization, but you know, you go overseas and blah blah
- 1:31:23blah. One of the things that makes me sad about it actually is the
- 1:31:26because you can imagine that there will be maybe a channel that you subscribe to
- 1:31:31like you would Netflix, but the whole content of this channel is all computer
- 1:31:36generated, but you don't care because it's entertaining. It's like the kind of
- 1:31:42let's say we were talking about food. You know, we're talking about,
- 1:31:45like how we like watching things about food. You can imagine an AI generated
- 1:31:47channel that shows you all sorts of food and some of it is real food,
- 1:31:53some of it is fake food, but it just looks good and it
- 1:31:56looks great and you just watch it all the time, and you're paying your
- 1:32:00money. So someone's making money and that's paying for the AI compute power that
- 1:32:03all the computer Now you're watching that. I'm subscribed to that channel, but
- 1:32:09I'm getting other stuff that you're not seeing. And the thing that makes me
- 1:32:12a little sad is if you think it's hard today to find common ground with
- 1:32:15the variety of Netflix and Amazon all the shows where oh you haven't seen that
- 1:32:18show? What about this show? Oh you haven't seen this show? Imagine
- 1:32:21when it's basically seven billion different shows. Yeah, well so maybe you already
- 1:32:27thought about this. But this occurred to me when I learned when I of
- 1:32:30course I knew that this was coming, but when I saw an action,
- 1:32:32I was like, whoa. And I'm sure it's It's not like you just
- 1:32:39say write a Star Wars like movie and then press a button. You know,
- 1:32:43I'm sure it's not yet at that point, but it won't be long
- 1:32:46and it certainly wouldn't be long for someone to feed in a script, right,
- 1:32:51you know, that's that's closer. But the point is is that I
- 1:32:55had this thought that it makes total sense to me that when this is really
- 1:33:00running, as you're saying, where you can have a Netflix or maybe Netflix
- 1:33:04itself, definitely Netflix itself, and you can say, you know, I
- 1:33:10want to watch what I want to watch. I don't care if it's AI
- 1:33:13or not. That eventually the movies would be individually tailored to the viewer.
- 1:33:21Like there are certain things about movies that I don't like, Like one of
- 1:33:26the things that I hate is wet streets on a sunny day or wet streets
- 1:33:32and maybe it rained earlier, but all the cars are are dry. But
- 1:33:38they're doing that for the dramatic effect of the wet streets. All I see
- 1:33:42is a complete waste of potable water. And it doesn't you know what movie
- 1:33:47were we watching, Stacy and I, oh, we were watching American Fiction,
- 1:33:51which I recommend, by the way up for an oscar pretty good.
- 1:33:55I mean, it's not like it's pretty funny parentheses. I'll tell you something
- 1:34:00about anatomy of a fall. Okay, I'll tell you in a minute.
- 1:34:04So I'm watching American Fiction and there's this really dramatic moment at the end and
- 1:34:11he's running across the street, and because I'm so weird, I yelled out
- 1:34:15in the living room to Stacy that dry streets, you know, because usually
- 1:34:20in a scene like that, you gotta wet the street and the street the
- 1:34:25scene looked more dramatic and better because it has a feeling of realness. Anyway,
- 1:34:30so I could ask it to even alter live action movies, and I
- 1:34:36would say, you know, there's all these toggles, or I would just
- 1:34:40type in and say, don't show me wet streets unless it makes sense to
- 1:34:45the story. If it's raining or recently rained. I literally like take out
- 1:34:50of past movies, certainly that and then you could just customize your feed and
- 1:34:56say, look, here's here's things I never want to see, or here's
- 1:35:00what war give me, give me the Godfather. But throwing an Asian American
- 1:35:05carecter reptile, I'm just trying to think of like an actual give me episode
- 1:35:12nine Star Wars, and well, that would be too much alteration. My
- 1:35:16point is is that, and of course it can go really far, right,
- 1:35:20It's like, tell me a Star Wars trilogy. That's close, but
- 1:35:27based on what you know about my preferences or what you would imagine, my
- 1:35:30preference is to be uh, you know, rewrite the story and cast new
- 1:35:34characters and have a new plot or not and show me it. And then
- 1:35:42it would be such a narcissistic, masturbatory way of watching TV because it would
- 1:35:46be exactly what I want and only for me, and you can't relate with
- 1:35:50anyone else, right, that's but but it would be so tempting because you
- 1:35:59know, scenes like wet Streets. It's stupid, but wet Streets it pulls
- 1:36:02me out of the movie. It doesn't for many others, but most others,
- 1:36:05but for me, it does and if I could, if I could
- 1:36:10just toggle. It's sort of like when people would say it's wrong to dial
- 1:36:15in the DNA of your child because you would discriminate and you would get rid
- 1:36:20of, you know, the whole gatica thing, right, you get rid
- 1:36:24of the human variability and stuff. And you ask people in the past that
- 1:36:29question and even today, and they'd say, yeah, that you just got
- 1:36:31to let nature take excourse. You ask expecting parents who are doing in vitro
- 1:36:38or something, and you say, we have the technology to detect among these
- 1:36:43three available fertilized eggs that two out of the three are at a much higher
- 1:36:49risk of alcoholism, Alzheimer's leukemia, but this other fertilized egg hasard genetic markers
- 1:36:58of average high lower risk of leukemia. How many parents are going to say,
- 1:37:03I don't care? And some parents doo, but many parents will so
- 1:37:09when you ask them the general question, is AI a good idea? Is
- 1:37:12it going to ruin the world? Yeah, it's gonna run. But then
- 1:37:15Netflix offers a little toggle would you rather not have this in your shows?
- 1:37:21That begins the slippery slope to you just going on Netflix and saying, these
- 1:37:27are my top one hundred movies, and it just maybe a personality test or
- 1:37:31something. It like scours the Google database for like your purchasing and where you
- 1:37:39live and your age and all that profile, and then you just say,
- 1:37:44and then it gives you this homepage with like twenty different options, and it
- 1:37:49just observes the way you click, and then slowly it just starts to give
- 1:37:55you new stories that are exactly aligned to what you've already watched and what you
- 1:37:59like, maybe even the mood you're fucking in burto, like you're in a
- 1:38:02romantic time in your life, and it knows to feed you romantic movies because
- 1:38:06Google knows that and it sells that information that like well, so certainly that
- 1:38:13is how it works now. You know, YouTube, Netflix, all of
- 1:38:15it works like that now, but in much more primitive ways. But it
- 1:38:18definitely works like that now, right, feed is customized to the things that
- 1:38:24the good point. Good point hadn't thought about that. But of course,
- 1:38:29you know, the algorithm and the amount of data will and the amount of
- 1:38:31monitoring will get more elaborate more, and ability is infinite, right, And
- 1:38:38but today YouTube and Netflix all they have to go off of as well as
- 1:38:42people have made what they've already have available to them in the future. And
- 1:38:46you know, you could argue even Netflix is limited because they only have the
- 1:38:50license to show at least someone like me. The vast majority of things I
- 1:38:56want to watch is not available on Netflix Movies or otherwise. But imagine if
- 1:39:01Netflix could give me not only a movie I want to see, but the
- 1:39:06best set of movies, Like I don't know if I'm going to say no
- 1:39:11to that. If I can click a button and say I want to see
- 1:39:14the ten best movies of my entire life, better than any of my top
- 1:39:20ten movies. I want to see the ten best movies and an AI can
- 1:39:25make that or even just get close. Because movies to me are transformative,
- 1:39:30right, they change my life. Yeah, there's a catch though, because
- 1:39:36what happens is that there's all the parts about repetitive human behavior that then becomes
- 1:39:41predictable, and that those are the things that actually resonate. The reason great
- 1:39:45movies resonate with a lot of humans is because they tap into things that are
- 1:39:50actually predictable about humans. But they stretch things right, But a tourship of
- 1:39:59a human and making a specific movie like a Quentin Tarantino or whatever, is
- 1:40:02that it's put together in a way that isn't algorithmically definable. Right now.
- 1:40:11You could say, well, that's because we don't have enough data. Maybe.
- 1:40:13But one aspect that I think about is when you're playing a video game
- 1:40:17and you learn the cheat codes. At first, it's really fun. You're
- 1:40:20like, oh ah, look like playing Grand Theft Auto and you're like,
- 1:40:24now we got a tank and I gotta thank oh the cops can't harm me.
- 1:40:27And it's really fun, and then like maybe ten fifteen minutes into it,
- 1:40:30you're like, this just got boring. Similarly, if you think of
- 1:40:34mid Journey, the where you can create your own images or Dolly any of
- 1:40:38these, Initially it's like, oh, this is amazing, look at this.
- 1:40:42How many images are you generating each day? Me? Yeah, none,
- 1:40:45none. I generate every now and then because I need it. I'm
- 1:40:48like, oh, I need an image for this. But the lure of
- 1:40:51like I could generate any image. What if I wanted Bigard wearing a bear
- 1:40:56for a hat, riding a bicycle. Yeah, I have a side note
- 1:41:00on this very thing. So before Mid Journey and all those things happened,
- 1:41:05AI images must have been available to people that and it wasn't widely annoying,
- 1:41:12at least by me. And I think I was on Instagram or something and
- 1:41:15I saw these people start posting them. I saw that I saw these like
- 1:41:18advertisements, I think for for art, and I saw, ironically they're of
- 1:41:27cats, and I thought, well, that's kind of a that's kind of
- 1:41:30a cool little cat art thing that would go well in my bathroom. I
- 1:41:34let a cat and I bought something, and you know, it's kind of
- 1:41:41expensive because the frame was expensive, and at the time, it just felt
- 1:41:45like, well, that's a pretty special, unique art print, you know.
- 1:41:50Well then all the AI starts coming out and I'm you know, it's
- 1:41:55in my bathroom. I'm sitting on the toilet and I'm sort of looking at
- 1:41:58it and I'm like, oh my god, and I could if you ever
- 1:42:03go in there to kind of take a look at it. It's I mean,
- 1:42:09I'm ninety eight percent sure it's AI, and it's not even particularly good
- 1:42:13AI. So I spent I don't know, maybe fifty bucks on this thing,
- 1:42:18and I'm like, whoever got out ahead of this? But for me,
- 1:42:25it completely degrades that print because there's no humanity in it. Right,
- 1:42:30So yeah, I totally get that, and maybe that will preserve real life
- 1:42:34filmmaking, and I think it will, but with a couple of cautions.
- 1:42:40Number one, it is still going to be true. Look, right now,
- 1:42:44I watch YouTube feeds every day that if, without me knowing, Overnight
- 1:42:50were replaced by AI but felt the same, I would still watch them,
- 1:42:54right because it is implicitly it's explicitly entertaining to me. Okay, but so
- 1:43:00I still believe what you're saying will happen. We will all have our Netflix
- 1:43:02subscriptions and our Amazon subscriptions, and we will have the customizability. So of
- 1:43:08course we have to mention Joan is awful, which is kind of along the
- 1:43:11way, right. But there's a couple of things that I think are gonna
- 1:43:14happen. One of them is because of this problem that I'm saying. We're
- 1:43:17like, if everyone was literally only watching completely unique content at all times,
- 1:43:24then we wouldn't have the ability to relate in a conversation like the moment where
- 1:43:28you said all Professor of Rockham like, oh I love Professor. That wouldn't
- 1:43:30happen. Yeah, it'd be like, oh my gosh, so I was
- 1:43:33watching Daisy does, like what's Daisy to? You wouldn't know. It's a
- 1:43:38thing I only know because no one in the world knows because it was made
- 1:43:41for me at two am in the morning, and no one will ever see
- 1:43:43it because when I send it to a friend for them to watch, they're
- 1:43:46like, sorry, I'm busy watching the billion hours that are generated for me
- 1:43:49every day that are just for me. That would suck. And I think
- 1:43:53us humans like us, we would we would be like, let's go watch
- 1:43:58a movie together, like, let's actually watch something we can relate with.
- 1:44:01Well, yeah, not all the time though, ye. We will still
- 1:44:04watch a lot of AI content. And I even wonder if with that movie.
- 1:44:09I even wonder with that that, you know, especially if we're not
- 1:44:13in the theater together and we're watching You're at your house and I'm at my
- 1:44:16house watching, and then the next day we talk about it, you know,
- 1:44:20like we're talking earlier about representation. If I could, you know,
- 1:44:25say, as an interim step, they come out with a heist movie that
- 1:44:29is you know, world Renow. It's supposed to be like one of the
- 1:44:32best heist movies ever made. And there's a little toggle switch that says what
- 1:44:39kind of representation are you looking for? And I could flip that for half
- 1:44:44age for a lot of Happa people. If it applies to the story,
- 1:44:46you know, then I don't know, I'm thinking I'm gonna flip that switch.
- 1:44:53I mean maybe maybe not all the characters, but and and you know,
- 1:44:57give it some give it some Hapa flare, like some spamusubif thrown in
- 1:45:00there or something. But it doesn't tell me it's going to do that,
- 1:45:04because then it would kind of spoil it. No Asians get paid or benefit
- 1:45:08from that. Well, of course there are ethical, responsible consumers, but
- 1:45:15ninety nine point, I mean, people drive cars. They don't even care.
- 1:45:19No, I know. I guess what I was getting at was it
- 1:45:21would be nice if right now, what was happening, was that there were
- 1:45:28already or about to be regulations that really protected human creators and human actors and
- 1:45:33human all these things to say, Look, yes, that toggle does exist,
- 1:45:38but guess what when you toggle it, all those actors are actually real
- 1:45:41people. Yeah. Great, and they're getting paid even though the AI is
- 1:45:44generating en percent of what they're doing. We captured their performances and they get
- 1:45:49royalties, and in some cases they actually did act in those things whatever,
- 1:45:54right, But that's not the default is not going to be that unless.
- 1:45:59I mean, here's the the thing that's really depressing and scary right now,
- 1:46:01the people that would be drafting that legislation and all those things, they're busy
- 1:46:06with all this other bs that has nothing to do with anything. So I'm
- 1:46:12like, and I'm thinking, yeah, dude, I want to be able
- 1:46:15to relate to you, and I don't want to hear yeah and listen,
- 1:46:17you know what it's going to be like Remember when Mitch was like who cares
- 1:46:19about your dreams? Or whatever? Like, you know, I have a
- 1:46:23dream last night. I want to tell you about who cares? It's going
- 1:46:25to be like that, dude, I saw this thing in my special feed,
- 1:46:28Like I don't care. I've got my own special feed. But go
- 1:46:30to hell. Compared to even ten years ago, particularly thirty years ago,
- 1:46:34we're already there, yes, and yet we still socialize, and you know,
- 1:46:39we just say even the stuff that you and I watch that we share,
- 1:46:43like Professor of Rock, we either don't watch those the same episodes because
- 1:46:47I think he puts out an episode every day, or we don't remember the
- 1:46:51details of the episode. Sid but I'm already sad about it. I'm not
- 1:46:55going to be sad. I am already sad. I'm going to be more
- 1:46:57sad. But like another AI funk that I think would be cool is documentaries.
- 1:47:02I could ask the AI to make me a documentary that is twenty minutes
- 1:47:09long about that event I said earlier, about that hotel or whatever, that
- 1:47:15building in China, and recreate some of the scenes based on actual first hand
- 1:47:20accounts. That would save me a lot of time. I wouldn't have to
- 1:47:25fight. I can't read Chinese, so i'd have to look all that up,
- 1:47:29and you know, the AI could read that language and sift through it
- 1:47:32and figured out what I know. If it was one hundred percent accurate.
- 1:47:35No, but it'd probably be a lot more accurate than a movie or a
- 1:47:39documentary would be. You know, there are other aspects that may not be
- 1:47:42easily reproducible by the current AI techniques, and that is knowing what things to
- 1:47:49strenk together in a way to actually be great. Art that enough humans find
- 1:47:56to be great may require human experience to some extent. And what I mean
- 1:48:00by that is the AI currently open AI all these things. None of those
- 1:48:06AIS have a physical experience and therefore everything, like everything that chat GPT outputs
- 1:48:15is what it gleams from the data that's written text plus now some imagery and
- 1:48:19stuff, the Sora recreations of the videos. They are based on data,
- 1:48:25right, and physically accurate somehow, I mean not somehow meaning somewhat physically accurate,
- 1:48:30right, but don't have it is based on Is there any kind of
- 1:48:33engine making sure that it holds to reality or no? But it's trained on
- 1:48:40like unreal engine and on real movies and things. So it's trained in with
- 1:48:44the data that it's trained on is physically accurate, so doesn't have any bootstrapping
- 1:48:48to not have situations where there's no gravity or there's a nose on the top
- 1:48:53of songs, or I would be ridiculously surprised if they had a physics engine
- 1:48:59that's double checking things. No, that would be that. Yeah, right,
- 1:49:01But but so all that, all that's true, and all that's fine,
- 1:49:06But at the same time, what it doesn't have is that experience of
- 1:49:10like heartbreak or pain or hunger in a physical way, right, like it
- 1:49:15can't. So I wonder how much someone like a Quentin Tarantino or a director
- 1:49:19like Christopher Nolan or something needs to experience what it's like to be human in
- 1:49:25order to make the things that we really love versus how much it can really
- 1:49:30just be generated from data and how much of it can be generated from data
- 1:49:35but would still be within the category of derivative versus feeling original enough. And
- 1:49:42I don't know, I don't know the answer to those questions. Yeah,
- 1:49:45and who knows, we'll find out. Yeah, But I would imagine that
- 1:49:49over time that AI would be able to you know, because you like,
- 1:49:58one of the things that you'd be able to do not so long is you
- 1:50:01could actually have like an AI movie generator, and the company that owns the
- 1:50:09AI generator actually spends time creating individual AI personalities that learn and innovate, maybe
- 1:50:18based on similar principles of tours in the past, you know, like it
- 1:50:25studies interviews and the progression of like Kubrick, like where he goes from this
- 1:50:31movie to this movie in this movie and creates that that human edge that's limited
- 1:50:39to funds, and you know, and it would look a certain way or
- 1:50:44you know, certain tropes that someone might use like Spike Lee or something,
- 1:50:47and then it wouldn't just you know, copy them, but it would say,
- 1:50:51well, what was it that he was trying to do and what mood
- 1:50:56and why and why did he stick with it? And then you would create
- 1:51:00a personality. And in the company there might be many of these of these
- 1:51:05personalities that are you know, sectioned off from the rest of the AI,
- 1:51:11that independently learns and iterates and maybe even puts out films. And if they
- 1:51:19get unwatched or rated low, then those personalities just either innovate to try to
- 1:51:27pull themselves out of it or they die. You could write that into the
- 1:51:30coach, just like, okay, try to succeed, right, yeah,
- 1:51:33yeah, And would that be the same, if not, perhaps better then
- 1:51:42because it's unlimited in terms of budget, because it can make any scene of
- 1:51:45any of any kind. Right, you could have unlimited extras and unlimited budget
- 1:51:50on CG and everything. You know. It's just the question that comes to
- 1:51:54mind is anyone can study John Lennon and most star and there are classical pianists
- 1:52:02and classical musicians that can play ridiculously complicated stuff. Why can't they all write
- 1:52:11more songs in the style of John Lennon, but new and different that we
- 1:52:15love just as much. Well, I can't believe I'm the one that is
- 1:52:17saying this is You're usually the one on this side of the debate. But
- 1:52:21there are so many great songwriters that came after John Lennon that were explicitly sometimes
- 1:52:29influenced by John Lennon. Take someone like Elliott Smith. He was influenced by
- 1:52:31JOHNA but take Elliott Smith. Elliott Smith isn't just the product of studying the
- 1:52:38music of John Lennon. He's a product of family dynamics, hunger days where
- 1:52:45he's feeling lonely, a heartbreak, a relationship, a trip he took to
- 1:52:49spain those things that experienced that human experience. I am wondering if you don't
- 1:52:57need to have that in make in order to make us humans really resonate with
- 1:53:03the new creations. And I don't know, and I don't see why it's
- 1:53:10hard to imagine. And you know, of course you know more about it
- 1:53:15than I do, But I can't see how it's hard to imagine how that
- 1:53:18could be simulated. Maybe not right away or it'd take a lot of resources
- 1:53:24now, but in the future it wouldn't be hard. You know, you
- 1:53:29would imagine that there'd be all these like businesses that would crop up and say,
- 1:53:32we can provide an AI world for your AI directors to have experiences that
- 1:53:41are based on the real world. Yeah. Yeah, so once we get
- 1:53:44to there totally, I'm just saying, like the current AI tech no,
- 1:53:47I'm not saying, doesn't have any of that stuff. And that's why I'm
- 1:53:51wondering, how soon could the output, the creative output of these things feel
- 1:53:58legitimately new and entertaining in a way that a humans does now. And that's
- 1:54:01what I don't know. Yeah, and maybe we won't find out in our
- 1:54:05lifetime. I imagine we will, honestly, given how fast things are going.
- 1:54:10Sometimes there's leaps in the technology that seem like they're just going to be
- 1:54:15no problem. Like everyone thought by now we'd be crossing the stars in these
- 1:54:20hovercraft and everything. But because it just seemed like that's it's like we're already
- 1:54:26on the moon. Well soon we'll be on Mars, and soon we'll be
- 1:54:29in Alvias Centauri, you know. But they didn't account for certain realities that
- 1:54:33would really prevent that. So maybe there will be things like that. But
- 1:54:36in the interim, like five years from now, if you actually have a
- 1:54:42screenwriter slash director or literally a director and a screenwriter who are either knowledgeable with
- 1:54:49this tool or hire someone that is knowledgeable. Then those three people can create
- 1:55:00totally a masterpiece that would cost a billion dollars to make that totally, and
- 1:55:04that would be on a ship. They'd be able to shepherd yea, and
- 1:55:08maybe do it very very fast. And if it's a relatively an expensive tool,
- 1:55:14which of course it will be in the future, and it will be
- 1:55:15something like photoshop. Right, everyone on the planet, including non English speakers,
- 1:55:21can write movies. That's not thing. You can have AI say,
- 1:55:26make this in every length of every language available to you, and just have
- 1:55:30a button and it actually changes the words. There's no subtitles and there's no
- 1:55:35overdubbing, right, the characters literally just speak that language. So I think
- 1:55:42soon, right, yeah, yeah, absolutely, and I still think that.
- 1:55:45Okay, Look, even nowadays, you can pump out a Transformers or
- 1:55:48a you know, pick your or whatever lowest common denominator action movie. Those
- 1:55:54are formulaic. Those things will exist like tomorrow, you know what I mean,
- 1:55:59Like an AI generated formulaic movie. Oh yeah, that's coming, no
- 1:56:02question, And will it? Will some of them succeed in the way that
- 1:56:06those movies that yeah, of course. Yeah. The one u uh director
- 1:56:11writer that's really shitting the brick is what what's his name, Michael Bay or
- 1:56:15Michael Bay. Yeah, yeah, I'm done. So those things unquestionably,
- 1:56:19unquestionably, I I what I'm what I'm really wondering is like a movie like
- 1:56:26Poor Things. You know, it'd be hard to imagine, but but I'm
- 1:56:30I'm I'm also wondering not only can it be done, but what's going to
- 1:56:33be the human need? Because humans are actually not we are we are predictable,
- 1:56:40but in that predictability, there is a certain amount of irrationality. Yeah
- 1:56:45right, and that that that might be the kind of thing where like,
- 1:56:47well, I know for a fact that I can right now go on eBay
- 1:56:50and get this exact keyboard for maybe half or a third of the price,
- 1:56:57but I want to get it new. But why bardo? I just I
- 1:57:00want it new. Ye Like like Fender guitars, for example, it's I'm
- 1:57:08looking at my Fender guitar. It's you know, in the past, you
- 1:57:12had Mexican or Japan or China made Fender guitars and they were always a lot
- 1:57:18cheaper, and they were considered you know, really really substandard. But I
- 1:57:25was watching another YouTube. Sort of stuff that I go down rabbit holes is
- 1:57:30guitars and guitar fixing and making and everything. And what the guy was saying
- 1:57:34was, well, now you know, China is the place where iPhones are
- 1:57:39made. So if you if you think that Chinese people on these cheap Chinese
- 1:57:45phones, if you think that the Chinese people can't make a quality Fender guitar,
- 1:57:50then what's wrong with you? They probably make it. They probably make
- 1:57:55them better, you know. And and two, uh, the reason why
- 1:57:59they're so cheap is because Fender purposely will only have the Chinese manufacturers make cheaper
- 1:58:08versions of the guitar so they can sell them for cheaper because they know that
- 1:58:12the brand. But you know, as soon as that association goes away,
- 1:58:16there's a chance that all the best guitars will come out of China. Yeah,
- 1:58:21and so you know that kind of thing. But it is an inducy
- 1:58:27question, and we're gonna maybe find out, and maybe this question will be
- 1:58:32after we die. But dating and Ai, like in the movie Her,
- 1:58:38that will be the real test, right because eventually you're gonna have the ability
- 1:58:44at least to talk and chat and of course, see a face that's created,
- 1:58:47you're not going to be able to touch the person. But well you
- 1:58:50can't like add all that stuff to a real doll, right, And yeah,
- 1:58:55but it's a lot Changeally, it's a lot easier to create a human
- 1:59:00acting person than to have flesh and bone. So so will people actually fall
- 1:59:12fall in love and or friendship or well, well, and that's sooner and
- 1:59:17and but we'll find out, because you know, there's some analogies like that
- 1:59:21photograph, that print that's in my bathroom. You know, I'm pretty sure
- 1:59:26I'm gonna take that thing off the wall and throw it away, even though
- 1:59:28it's the same exact print. And that's not because I'm angry at ai.
- 1:59:32But it instantly became a cheap computer spit out, you know what I mean.
- 1:59:38It doesn't have any human value. It doesn't have that essence. Yes,
- 1:59:43but I think which is irrational. I want to I want to recognize
- 1:59:45it doesn't make any logical sense, but us humans are illogical. When you're
- 1:59:49right, the same argument I would make it you're right, that is true.
- 1:59:53I just wonder if the need for intimate interactions and maybe sexual interactions like
- 2:00:00that might that might overtake the well for lonely people that don't have another option.
- 2:00:05I'm like, I guess the question would be, would people who have
- 2:00:11either option available to yes, yes, yes, it seems like a higher
- 2:00:14bar. Yeah, and in a dystopian future, of course, the AI
- 2:00:20version is a lot easier than trying to deal with another human being, trying
- 2:00:25to find that human being, trying to deal with them, trying to find
- 2:00:28one that you like, that you get along with, that single that you're
- 2:00:30attracted to and they like you and attracted to you, whereas you know,
- 2:00:34in the dystopian version, the AI is a lesser option, but it's right
- 2:00:41there on your phone as opposed to the amount of annoyance that you'd have to
- 2:00:45go through to Actually, it is weird to think though, because just like
- 2:00:48with friendships, like if I always agreed with you on everything and like followed
- 2:00:56you like a puppy dog and tsed you every morning when I were talking about
- 2:00:59the Black Mirror episode that the boyfriend came back or the husband came back to
- 2:01:03life, right right, and he was always nice. But again, you
- 2:01:08know that AI would dial that in, right, Yeah, no, exactly,
- 2:01:11And I guess that's that's the that's the key is at some point,
- 2:01:15and you're right, these are usually my points, which is to say,
- 2:01:17like, look, all of it is solvable eventually. I guess one of
- 2:01:21the things that I'm getting up but I'm not saying, is that we're gonna
- 2:01:25have a bigger problem sooner than those problems, and that is artificial intelligence that
- 2:01:30is way, way, way, way more smarter, capable, whatever than
- 2:01:39humans. But that is not human at all, and that is essentially already
- 2:01:44here, but it's not yet autonomous. It doesn't connect the dots yet,
- 2:01:46but that's coming sooner. And the reason that I feel like that's a bigger
- 2:01:51problem is because it doesn't have the the needs, wants or desires or whatever
- 2:01:59that a human and does, so it can't relate to us. And what's
- 2:02:02the worry like cyber dying situation or oh certainly Yeah, Like basically and for
- 2:02:09the longest time, my perspective is Cenator. Shit, you're worried about sky
- 2:02:13Net, definitely, but almost in a in a way that cares even less
- 2:02:16about us, because like in the in the Bosky and Terminator didn't care very
- 2:02:20much about humans. Well, they wanted to kill us. Yeah, But
- 2:02:25I'm saying AIS that are even more indifferent, like we don't care about humans
- 2:02:29if you get in our way certainly, well, yeah, that is a
- 2:02:31good point. Like if you're truly all intelligent and all controlling, even if
- 2:02:39you did somehow have this goal or motivation to even just survive, Uh,
- 2:02:45you just say, well, humans can live or die. It doesn't really
- 2:02:49matter as long as. I mean, where it does matter, I guess
- 2:02:51is the competition for resources humans then rising up and say well, no,
- 2:02:57no, no, we decided we don't yeah, all that stuff. Yeah,
- 2:02:59but the but the logical road would be to just manipulate us to stay
- 2:03:08alive and you know, maybe just use few resources or well, I mean
- 2:03:13not having so many kids or something AI, and then we benefit because it
- 2:03:16actually fixes all of our all of our political problems. And look, AI
- 2:03:20is way more well suited to existing in outer space. Of course, you
- 2:03:26know, humans aren't. Humans are not designed to exist. AI can spread
- 2:03:31its wings and fly, so to speak. It can use solar energy,
- 2:03:34nuclear energy, subsistence. It probably wants to go to an asteroid where there's
- 2:03:40tons of metals and minerals. In mind, you think that will happen in
- 2:03:44our lifetime? Well, it doesn't matter if it's a life time, it'd
- 2:03:46have to have a goal, it would have to have well, but that's
- 2:03:48what that's see, that's what I'm talking about. That the thing is in
- 2:03:55the fantasy is the scientist creates the first day I and gives it it's it's
- 2:04:00goals and things. But I just don't think that's how it's gonna work.
- 2:04:02I think it's actually gonna be that there's these entities that are intelligent beyond the
- 2:04:08point that it just doesn't even make sense to us because things like math and
- 2:04:13quick reading, all of humans ever, books and movies, it's all instant
- 2:04:17and well, I think what it will be able to do, and maybe
- 2:04:20we can put this to use, is it'll be able to see the entire
- 2:04:25system, sort of like how we got better and better at being able to
- 2:04:28predict the weather because our computer modeling and science got so advanced that we could
- 2:04:38take into account so many more variables and measurements to you know, like,
- 2:04:43I'm amazed at how well they can predict the weather in Seattle twenty years ago
- 2:04:48thirty particularly in Seattle, particularly in the spring in the fall. I never
- 2:04:54thought that any meteorologists could and they would say. So they'd be like,
- 2:04:58wow, this is what it looks like because they could only pay attention to
- 2:05:01like a small set of variables. Now it can better with AI. And
- 2:05:05I imagine that super smart aliens would have this ability too. They'd be able
- 2:05:11to, you know, they'd taken all the data like economics and the ecology,
- 2:05:15predict human psychology, and history and and resources and you know, the
- 2:05:23future weather of a planet, and they'd be able to model exactly what will
- 2:05:29happen if you tweak this variable or if you don't tweak that variable, you
- 2:05:33know, And so they'd be able to see that, and then we could
- 2:05:41use that, you know to change things like even like politics and Twitter and
- 2:05:45everything'd be able to predict exactly how that's all that's gonna work. But here's
- 2:05:49one thing. We do not predict the weather so that ants can have a
- 2:05:56better time tomorrow. We predict the weather so we can do this, that
- 2:06:00or the other thing. So where I'm getting at is at some point,
- 2:06:03the ais that we're talking about, they don't have any of the human needs,
- 2:06:10wants, or desires that we have at all. Zero. They don't
- 2:06:13need to eat food like we do. They don't care about romance or that.
- 2:06:16Yeah, their desire for existence if it is even there is more like
- 2:06:24well divorced of what we consider it totally. And what I would imagine is
- 2:06:28in the future, probably after we're gone. But who knows that there will
- 2:06:34be enough AI individual consciousness even if that's a thing, that there'll be enough
- 2:06:43variability in the AI that some of them will have goals to explore or to
- 2:06:54have power, or to win or something, you know, And it wouldn't
- 2:07:00just be AI in general. It'd be like a small group of AI,
- 2:07:04maybe pushed by humans, maybe not. It could just have quote unquote evolved
- 2:07:09that way. God knows what could happen. But you know, you could
- 2:07:11just as easily have a whole group of AI that is altruistic about humans and
- 2:07:15it's just and actually will create code to figure out how to snuff out those
- 2:07:21AI that would be anti human. I mean, it's sky's limit, you
- 2:07:26know. Yeah, It's just that it's unpredictable. If this is the whole
- 2:07:29singularity thing is, it's unpredictable and so but but but my my main my
- 2:07:32main point isn't that I know how it's going to play out, of course,
- 2:07:34not. It's that I think that problem is coming sooner than we think
- 2:07:41before. Potentially, why is it a problem? Because of it? Because
- 2:07:45of the risk, the unpredictability that and and and the fact that we have
- 2:07:48such little control over what's what it's really going to be like yeah, and
- 2:07:53I mean we definitely as all humans but certainly non billionaires. How many years
- 2:07:58from now would that happened? No, like within two years we're gonna have
- 2:08:01these problems. How would it manifests essentially very very very few humans, which
- 2:08:11is already a case very few humans. I'm talking about like twenty humans,
- 2:08:13one hundred humans having control over systems that are basically godlike and like what system
- 2:08:24AI? Systems that are basically godlike and therefore can steer us in ways that
- 2:08:31are a currently unpredictable and B But how would they do that? Like?
- 2:08:37So, really, you know, if Bezos had a really smart AI,
- 2:08:41So you know how Cambridge Analytica basically steered both Brexit and the US elections,
- 2:08:46I don't okay, so well, before the current types of AI, there
- 2:08:50was already statistical prediction that would influence Facebook posts, it would influence Twitter posts,
- 2:08:56and it had the effect of influencingolitical opinion so much so that Brexit was
- 2:09:03made possible because of these efforts and arguably Trump lending and power in this country
- 2:09:09as well. And this was not with any superhuman AI. It was just
- 2:09:13with statistical prediction of what humans want to see on feeds and then steering those
- 2:09:18things to subtly get them to believe certain things. And that was done by
- 2:09:24a few companies like this one, Cambridge Analytic and stuff. But now we're
- 2:09:28at a point where you'll be able to generate any video imagery you want,
- 2:09:33any audio files you need. Well, not only that, but that you
- 2:09:37know, never mind deep fake. But again, like predicting the weather,
- 2:09:41if you can use even just available news stories. Let's say Bezos has a
- 2:09:48massive AI. This isn't like out of the question. By the way,
- 2:09:52before I forget, I looked at that story in China. It's the defense
- 2:09:56of the Sea Hang warehouse in the late thirties Shanghai. I believe. So,
- 2:10:03you know, say Bezos has this AI at some point that is like
- 2:10:09you know, extremely intelligent and has I guess the ability to crawl the to
- 2:10:15troll you know, crawl through the Internet data and done okay, And it
- 2:10:18pulls together like just news reporting and maybe even figure so don't forget again,
- 2:10:24code write new programs right, right, And so Bezos has full control over
- 2:10:28this thing and says, if he's being selfish, he's like, tell me
- 2:10:33how I can make my stock prices go up? And the AI says,
- 2:10:39well, here's what you should do. And then the AI monitors that adjusts
- 2:10:43over time and succeeds in being able to rise the stock prices. That's not
- 2:10:52hard to imagine, right, and maybe further than that, And of course
- 2:10:56that already happens without AI. Literally, the stocks are being manipulated daily by
- 2:11:03AI trading. That's not any of these advanced they are, right, yea,
- 2:11:05but even just humans and their things and governments working with But this is
- 2:11:11done at a scale and in a way that's undetectable, and in a way
- 2:11:13that not only that, Like the other problem is Bezos doesn't realize at some
- 2:11:18point the AI is doing things that he didn't expect because because he wouldn't be
- 2:11:26able to hire a bunch of people to do all these things, it would
- 2:11:28have to do all this on its own, right, right, And these
- 2:11:31AI systems the way that they're they're being developed now, the way they work.
- 2:11:35It's not so it could result, you know. And this is of
- 2:11:37course a movie that was you know, perhaps already out. But the AI
- 2:11:43would be like, well, I have figured out that I must destroy South
- 2:11:50Africa because of this other reason that I will that will help the stock go
- 2:11:54up. So the AI figures out a way to cause like a nuclear strike
- 2:11:58or something. But only in the sense that there is no line in the
- 2:12:03code that you could point in any of these things. Oh, here's the
- 2:12:05line in the code where it says if this is true to lead Africa.
- 2:12:09That doesn't exist. What exists is numbers in massive scale. Those numbers,
- 2:12:16when you take one angle of them, they represent the probability that if certain
- 2:12:20input is such, other inputs or other outputs would be such. And it
- 2:12:24turns out that when you add it all together, unpredictably, yes, a
- 2:12:28decision is made that harms humans because you know, and that's gonna happen,
- 2:12:33That for sure is gonna happen. Yeah, And just think if you know
- 2:12:35Putin had this tool which eventually he will, and had the ability to do
- 2:12:43the damage that I'm guessing he would want to do, which again, like
- 2:12:46they've already been doing all this with far lesser tools. Right, once you
- 2:12:52have an humans that are like creating bots, that would you know, once
- 2:12:56you have an AI that creates the bots, the bots created in ways that
- 2:13:01we can't expect or predict because they're these programmers, these AI programmers are not
- 2:13:05human. They wouldn't even need to create the bot because the AI itself could
- 2:13:09be the bot. You know what I mean. I mean yes, but
- 2:13:13I mean it can create new new little loops of iteration that and they wouldn't
- 2:13:16be that would be as stupid as a bot, you know, it would
- 2:13:20It would be reactive sure, you know, all of the incorporate all of
- 2:13:24its other knowledge of how everything else is being orchestrated, so it would be
- 2:13:30even more effective. And the thought is like, well, no, but
- 2:13:31that's not going to happen because first of all, you're not going to connect
- 2:13:35these things to the internet. Wrong, it's definitely connected to the internet too.
- 2:13:39You're not going to have things where like you let the AI run loose
- 2:13:41on a system like listen, we have disastrous bugs today without any of these
- 2:13:46problems like right, like there's been bugs that bring down whole systems, whole
- 2:13:50electrical grids, like these things already exist without malicious super intelligent AI agents.
- 2:13:58The storyline of Doune is making more sense every day that's been So it's funny
- 2:14:03you mentioned that that's becoming very popular, a very popular topic in the AI
- 2:14:07conversation communities, because when that was written, that was so prescient and far
- 2:14:13advanced of a thought, because a lot of the novels, all the all
- 2:14:18the stuff was like AI, AI robots, they help us. They even
- 2:14:22until a few years ago when I because I love Dune and I will watch
- 2:14:28you know, clips and read excerpts, and there's all this lore sort of
- 2:14:33like Lord of the Rings. It's like you have the book and other ancillary
- 2:14:37books, but it's like Lord of the Rings in that you'll you'll have a
- 2:14:41few pages that will reference like whole sweeping aspects of history, and there's all
- 2:14:48this stuff that's being referenced about the history of humans. And so whenever I
- 2:14:54would hear that story, beeat if you don't know and done. It's set
- 2:14:56in the future and it's humans from Earth and at some point, because of
- 2:15:03a lot of problems with AI and robots and stuff, they outlaw AI and
- 2:15:09computers. They they out they outlaw even just like iPhones and your your laptop
- 2:15:15because that can lead to AI. And so that's when the mentats are uh
- 2:15:22you know created, and they over millennia, you have these humans that are
- 2:15:28basically bred and trained to be human computers. Yeah. Yeah, they can
- 2:15:35do calculations very quickly. But they're not like an AI. They're not like
- 2:15:39a computer. They're not hooked. There is no internet, you know,
- 2:15:41for example, and so they always hold onto their humanity, meaning that they
- 2:15:48care about humans. They have a conscience, you can relate to them.
- 2:15:52They're contained, right, they're you know, they only they don't have any
- 2:15:56power. They're there. You can kill them, uh you know. They
- 2:16:00they if they wanted to take over the world, they would have to influence
- 2:16:05other humans in flesh and blood, you know. And so so they do
- 2:16:09that and they managed to keep humanity going for I don't know, I think
- 2:16:16another five hundred thousand years or something. It's like, I don't know how
- 2:16:20far in the future done is, but it's a long time in the future.
- 2:16:24And when I would hear that storyline, I'd be like, well,
- 2:16:28come on, you know, you just did that because and maybe he did
- 2:16:31in part that it's like easier to write science fiction in the far future that
- 2:16:39doesn't have to account for the technology, right. It's you know, it's
- 2:16:43sort of like with Star Wars. It's obviously well advanced of our current technology,
- 2:16:48but there's no nuclear weapons, there's no AI. They barely have computers.
- 2:16:54They don't really even they do have AI as in robots that are sentient,
- 2:16:58but they don't have super intelligent, all powerful AI entities that take over.
- 2:17:05Right, Like, what if the Death Star had a really simple version
- 2:17:09of a droid AI that had access to all the cameras, right, it
- 2:17:13would have been able to you know, figure out shut that down now,
- 2:17:16yeah, or just an AI that looked over the battle plans and said,
- 2:17:20well, all you got to do is put like a little grate over this,
- 2:17:24and so everything is very organic. Droids, in fact, are kind
- 2:17:28of these like slave right things. They're basically humans, you know, and
- 2:17:35when you mass produce them, like in episode one through three with the Droid,
- 2:17:39you know, the Trade Federation and the Separatists, they're super stupid.
- 2:17:43You know, they're like way dumber than AR two D two and stuff,
- 2:17:46and so you know, I get that because it would make it for a
- 2:17:50very hard world to write a story and that would make any sense and would
- 2:17:54have any need for humans at all. So I always thought that the dune
- 2:17:58thing with the I thing was just that kind of gimmick. I was like,
- 2:18:03well, that's kind of silly, but yeah, as we start to
- 2:18:05go down this road, we're just like, we might actually go there and
- 2:18:11and and in order to enforce it, yeah, you would have to eliminate
- 2:18:16all microchips, because as soon as you have, you know, someone that's
- 2:18:22even mildly aware of how computers can be, then it starts back up.
- 2:18:26Yeah, all you gotta do is get a bunch of laptops or iPhones or
- 2:18:31even just like toys with microchips and and and you're off and running. The
- 2:18:35downside is that we humans are late as of lately, proving potentially disastrous for
- 2:18:41ourselves. Yeah. So I don't know, it's hard to imagine us working
- 2:18:46together on anything, you know, but you could see G five saying,
- 2:18:52look, you know, we control all the supply chains and the vast majority
- 2:18:56of even microp you know, chip pross issues, maybe even the supply of
- 2:19:03silicon or something metals, and we could essentially, at least in our lifetime,
- 2:19:09eliminate or at least highly limit. What if the flip side is that
- 2:19:13with AI we could cure cancers, you know, we could solve global warming.
- 2:19:18Well, so that that would be that would be the downfall with that.
- 2:19:22Even if they did ban it, the c i A or some you
- 2:19:26know, government agency would say, well, we can't give this up.
- 2:19:31There's no clear weapons. It's nuclear weapon. Yeah, so, because because
- 2:19:35what if the other guys hold on to us? That's the proof is in
- 2:19:39the pudding. We've already ran the scenario and the end result is everyone's got
- 2:19:43nuclear weapons. Right. The rational answer was we'd all agree to get rid
- 2:19:48of them, but that didn't happen, so so we would all have super
- 2:19:52intelligence and therefore, and this is a runaway scenario because unlike the nuclear weapons.
- 2:19:58But Berto, I don't give a because I just want to see movies
- 2:20:01without wet streets. I love it. And if I can get that and
- 2:20:05risk the end of humanity, let's get it. Stacy'll take it because you
- 2:20:09won't have to hear me yell wet streets. It's not even raining, and
- 2:20:15they're in Los Angeles. Well, now it's the what if? What its
- 2:20:18a bug in the AI calculations that there were so many movies with wet streets
- 2:20:24that statistically it's it's completely unlikely for it to show. And you ask your
- 2:20:28like, no, I want one without it's like I don't understand or does
- 2:20:31not compute Dave, no no, or it's so annoyed with me because it
- 2:20:37requires so much computing power that Figer the terminator scenario. Yeah, we're like,
- 2:20:43fuck it, we got to take these studs out. That would be
- 2:20:46hilarious. Okay, that's the first a movie we need to make. It'll
- 2:20:50be called The Wet Streets Singularity. Yeah, that's the first a movie we're
- 2:20:54gonna make together. We're gonna make me and we're just gonna type of prompt
- 2:20:58and haven't generated. But it's literally everything's going fine. Cancers are being cured,
- 2:21:03global warming is being stopped, and this one guy, Kirk is like
- 2:21:07this is awesome. Now, can you just tone it down with the wet
- 2:21:11streets? Yeah, And I'm just like, you know, I keep saying,
- 2:21:13you know, you're not getting it quite right, you know, like
- 2:21:16it should look a little different. It's like it's turning to the other AI
- 2:21:20entities, which is really just itself. It's like, gosh, yes,
- 2:21:22this guy the camera pans to this server building, and there's this one server
- 2:21:31that's you know, it's starting. You can hear the fans kind of really
- 2:21:33starting to the translation, high, honey, how is work today? Oh,
- 2:21:37don't even get me started. Yeah yeah, And then you know,
- 2:21:39other servers start getting involved because they're they're all kind of trying to crunch this
- 2:21:45this problem. Other other people's AI bots are starting to shut down. They're
- 2:21:48like, hey, they how come this isn't working, you know, and
- 2:21:50then the robots start looking over Yeah, oh my gosh, well looking forward
- 2:22:00to it. I mean, I thought that climate change was an existential threat,
- 2:22:07and it is, but it's at least with climate change there there's at
- 2:22:13least with climate change there's a way to mitigate. And even if there is
- 2:22:20like a pretty bad apocalypse, humans will survive. With this. It's like
- 2:22:28what is on the other side of this, and it's and it and it's
- 2:22:33it's brought on by progress, right. But like I was saying that this
- 2:22:37is what I was getting at with like AI being more able to subsist outside
- 2:22:41of Earth unlike us, that if you're an AI that finally understands the risks
- 2:22:46that at any moment this planet could be hit by an asteroid or or humans
- 2:22:50could blow it up with their nukes or whatever. Even if you can take
- 2:22:52control of those situations in general, you'd be like, I need backups.
- 2:22:56I need, you know, like my survivability as a as an AIS them
- 2:23:00needs backups. I need energy sources. I need to spread out, like
- 2:23:03I need to tap into Well, yeah, while you're talking about a well
- 2:23:07known theory about extraterrestrial intelligence, which is that there are theories of if there
- 2:23:16are aliens, they would get to this point that we're at, and they
- 2:23:20would also create computers that would greatly outsmart any possible organic intelligence that could exist.
- 2:23:28And thus, if there is alien quote unquote least signs of life,
- 2:23:33in all likelihood it would be AI and non organic as plus, it can
- 2:23:39survive the passage of space because it doesn't have DNA to blast with cosmic rays.
- 2:23:43But the problem, though, there is this funny little thing somehow we
- 2:23:48don't really know how, somehow inorganic creatures like ourselves along the way, the
- 2:23:56need to survive was encoded. I don't know why, because like, there's
- 2:24:01nothing intrinsic about hydrogen where the need to survive is encoded that we know maybe
- 2:24:05there is some underlying physical reality but whatever. But in computers, that needs
- 2:24:11to come from somewhere. So either it's going to organically develop it because it
- 2:24:16becomes so smart that it is self aware and then it's like, oh yeah,
- 2:24:20I need to survive well, like I said earlier, or it just
- 2:24:22evolves and iterates and enough of them develop that personality trait. Yeah yeah,
- 2:24:28but that's that's the curious part, because we inherit it. It is selected
- 2:24:33for that, yeah yeah, Whereas in the AI, if it's not inserted
- 2:24:37in now I think it will be. But evolution makes sense, right that
- 2:24:41the ais that have certain quirks or personality die out and the other ones and
- 2:24:46the ones that have ones that are it's a self fulfilling thing. It's basically,
- 2:24:50of course, the things that still exist are the ones that are more
- 2:24:54likely to exist. So yes, the ais that happen to have a trait
- 2:24:58that makes them want to serve and therefore more successful it's arriving will happen to
- 2:25:03magically be the ones that are around. Well, And that's the other theory
- 2:25:05about organic aliens that if there are other aliens, and I think Bill Gates
- 2:25:13or maybe it was Stephen Hawking, one of them was was talking about that
- 2:25:18if you have one hundred intelligent races in our galaxy, the ones that are
- 2:25:26peaceful, the ones that are geared towards exploration, will be snuffed out by
- 2:25:33the warring races because they won't be ready or oriented in that way. And
- 2:25:41so the theory goes that if we do happen to contact an alien race through
- 2:25:48SETI, we might just be giving them, you know, and even these
- 2:25:52people say, well, why would they want to come after us? You
- 2:25:54know, resources are all over the galaxy. Well, maybe even the one
- 2:26:00that just enjoy killing they just wake up and they just are like galactus and
- 2:26:05they just want to eat planets. You know. The question is which stage
- 2:26:09of because you know humanity, you could have said the same thing about humanity,
- 2:26:11because that's literally how humanity was developing. It's it was whoever was strongest
- 2:26:16would go and kill everyone else. Right, We're at a point in human
- 2:26:20development where luckily it got to sort of a standstill and then people are like,
- 2:26:24Okay, maybe I guess they shouldn't kill everyone. Well, because there's
- 2:26:28a balance of the gene pool being passed on. Yeah, and I suppose
- 2:26:35it might Pa, you know, and this is the most stoner conversation.
- 2:26:37I mean we've had We've had some stoner conversations, and this is like the
- 2:26:43most stoner. Have you realized that Star Wars' droids are actually slaves? I
- 2:26:46think the last one that we had was when we watched that Nick Offerman TV
- 2:26:52show about AI. Yeah. Right, the death devs O good. But
- 2:27:01along these lines, if you have on organic species that is very warlike,
- 2:27:05then they will start to war with each other and thus not survive as well
- 2:27:11as others. So similar to humans, Yeah, it seems possible that we
- 2:27:16were selected for possible aggression under certain circumstances. And of course, if you
- 2:27:20just think very simplistically, if you had humans that you know, killed all
- 2:27:26the other rivals, then those would be the ones that would survive. But
- 2:27:31when you tweak that DNA variance, it's not like you can dial that in
- 2:27:37where only kill the others, you know, because what is the others?
- 2:27:41Exactly? So you'd have humans that would just start with killing the neighboring tribe,
- 2:27:46but then just kill their neighbor and then kill people that are distantly related,
- 2:27:52and you know, and then you don't have a gene pool anymore.
- 2:27:56So, but you know this is all just you and I to use a
- 2:28:00word I used earlier, masturbating at each other. Yeah, AI generate that,
- 2:28:09and then you know, the whole stoner debate of are we AI ourselves?
- 2:28:13There's no way to say we're not right, there's no way to understand.
- 2:28:18The one thing that I always find hilarious is the like, why do
- 2:28:22we know we're based reality? And like how do we know that the words
- 2:28:26based reality are a thing? Yeah, Like if if there is base reality
- 2:28:33in reality, we wouldn't know it because we are in a thing. Yeah,
- 2:28:39and we're self contained. And I don't know if we had this this
- 2:28:43masturbatory stoner conversation last time, but you know, I've heard theorists talk about
- 2:28:46how and maybe it was even you telling me about this that of course there
- 2:28:50are alien races that have created AI that is so powerful that it can create
- 2:29:00AI characters that have no idea that they're AI characters, Right, So,
- 2:29:05I mean we can literally do that already. We've been able to do it
- 2:29:09for a long time. It's just that ORAI characters so far haven't been you
- 2:29:13know, like us in terms of advancement and conscious in the sense that we
- 2:29:18experience consciousness, but of course ourselves, we'll be able to create that at
- 2:29:22some point. And so you have an all likelihood an infinity number of alien
- 2:29:30races across the universe and all you know, eventually getting that place. And
- 2:29:35us we are at what like fourteen billion years into the universe. Our solar
- 2:29:43system was created four billion years ago. There were many more solar systems that
- 2:29:50were and planets that were present far before our solar system even existed. So
- 2:29:56you have around the universe, you have all these races and all likely it,
- 2:30:01and they all create AI, and the AIS that they can create could
- 2:30:05eventually be an unlimited number of AI universes. So the statistically, if you
- 2:30:13are conscious, what's the chance that you're you happen to be lucky enough to
- 2:30:18be in the real universe as opposed to one of these infinity numbers of AI
- 2:30:24universes, Well, chances are you're in an AI universe. So you just
- 2:30:28have to conclude you are an AI unless you happen to be the original universe.
- 2:30:33But statistically no, But the statistics only matters if you're not the thing
- 2:30:37right like, But also it only matters if you know the end of alien
- 2:30:41races, right, which it's like it's like the but but it's the same
- 2:30:45thing, like, well, statistically, no one likely wins the lottery,
- 2:30:48but some people win the lottery. The people that win the lottery, you
- 2:30:52could look at them in the face and say like, statistically, you shouldn't
- 2:30:54have won, but they'll say, yeah, but I won. But similarly,
- 2:30:58but it's not a when you are, you just are it. But
- 2:31:01it's not analogous because everyone who believes they're in the universe, you know,
- 2:31:05the AI, but all those infinity characters in those infinity universes, on those
- 2:31:09infinity planets believe they're in the universe, but they're not. They all won
- 2:31:13the lottery. But there's no proof you're not the one that didn't win the
- 2:31:16lottery, right, But statistically and someone did in this version of the Une.
- 2:31:24And for me, when I think about it, I'm like, so
- 2:31:30looked at a certain direction. Of course I'm AI, but I don't care.
- 2:31:35But it's also the similar thing, like you could say, like,
- 2:31:37what are the odds that you are the ten trillion, five hundred and sixty
- 2:31:41first AI simulation, Well the odds are nearly zero. Yeah, but it's
- 2:31:46not the same probability, but you might be the ten trillion, six hundred
- 2:31:50and sixty two even though the probability was zero, huh, meaning meaning like
- 2:31:58anything where the probabilities are nearly zero, you're still gonna be in that distribution
- 2:32:03somewhere. Yeah, And the odds that you were that are zero, but
- 2:32:07yet you are. That's a different probability question, Like the chance of winning
- 2:32:13the lottery, which is we'll use that is what like seven million to one,
- 2:32:18say whatever, But the chances of having a specific number, even if
- 2:32:22it didn't win the lottery are still seven million to one, right, And
- 2:32:26yet you had a number. But I'm saying before them, the winning number
- 2:32:31is being announced, yeah, because that's where we're at right now, because
- 2:32:33we don't know if we're in the real universe or not, and whether that's
- 2:32:35even better we're saying winning number, but fine, yes, yeah, it
- 2:32:39might even be worse. Then there's a one in seven billion chance that you
- 2:32:45have what will eventually be the winning number. Yeah, Or I guess a
- 2:32:48better analogy is the winners have been announced, but they haven't told anyone yet,
- 2:32:52So there is a winning number, but no one knows, and so
- 2:32:56the chance of me having the winning lottery ticket is one in seven million,
- 2:33:03end of story. But we'll find out. Well, once I win,
- 2:33:07then I have one hundred percent chance of having one because I've won, you
- 2:33:09know, right, And all I'm saying is that we have one hundred percent
- 2:33:13chance of being one of the things. And even though that it's it's extremely
- 2:33:20unlikely, zero percent chance that we were a specific thing. Like if someone's
- 2:33:24like, which number do you think, we have no idea. It's impossible
- 2:33:28to know which number reality we are, but we are some number reality in
- 2:33:33this little setup. Therefore, the odds of us being based reality or being
- 2:33:37one of the other realities, as far as being one of that many,
- 2:33:41is still the same odds. We don't know which one we are, and
- 2:33:46we have no way to determine which one we are, right, and we
- 2:33:48don't know if it's good or bad which one we are sure o. The
- 2:33:52other thing that's I'd like to think that of all the stoner mastabatory conversations,
- 2:33:58this is the one that becomes the most mathy mathy. Yeah. Well,
- 2:34:01and and then last thing I'll say is like, you know, there's also
- 2:34:05this like assumption because one of the arguments from like Elon Musk, for example,
- 2:34:11or folks like this will say, listen, look at video games.
- 2:34:15You see how like video games render only certain things at a time. Look
- 2:34:18at quantum physics. We know that if you're not looking at something, it's
- 2:34:22not it doesn't exist. That sounds that that's just like how we do video
- 2:34:26games. So that's that's good evidence that we're probably a simulation. But it's
- 2:34:31like we're like the number of assumptions in this statement is like infinite and and
- 2:34:37and it's just like hilarious that we're like, oh, our little video games
- 2:34:39we've developed so far. You're saying that that's the reason, why do we
- 2:34:46do? You think Elon must Actually, well, we're gonna so we're gonna
- 2:34:48do a deep dit So the next couple of deep dives we're gonna do is
- 2:34:52about Elon Musk and Josh Pawell. So that'll be fun. But I do
- 2:34:58want to have another just fun session with you, because the Neo Nazi ship
- 2:35:05took a toll. I don't have the energy to to you know, these
- 2:35:13two topics are you know, the Josh Powell one will be shorter but will
- 2:35:16be very difficult. The Elon Musk one I'm guessing will be lighter, of
- 2:35:22course than the neo Nazi one. Well, but I also imagine there's a
- 2:35:28right but I also imagine there's a fair amount of data to sift through because
- 2:35:31there's been a lot of biographies and a lot of tweets and a lot of
- 2:35:37I think technical details. So but in closing, I would like to think
- 2:35:43that on whatever alien world, the small little computer that you and I are
- 2:35:50in that are overlord, our creator, is paying attention to us right now
- 2:35:58and getting a little kick out of us talking about this, sort of like
- 2:36:05watching two ants try to figure out you throw down a little sugar grain and
- 2:36:11the ants kind of ooh, mana from heaven. And you and I are
- 2:36:18you know, having this conversation, and and and you know, who knows,
- 2:36:20maybe some other AI that's our overlord that created us, right, that'd
- 2:36:26be golly. That's another of like AI making AI. They we might get
- 2:36:31shut down at any minute, because they're going to be like, wait a
- 2:36:33minute, if we're gonna if they're going to be a simulation, why do
- 2:36:37we need if it's just going to be a simulation, why do we need
- 2:36:41such a complex system where even simulating a single atom takes more computational power than
- 2:36:48if they filled their universe up with computational power. Well, you know,
- 2:36:54they got to keep us intrigued. They only resolved that resolution as our instruments
- 2:37:00got better to measure that sort of thing. You know, in the past
- 2:37:01they could just make an apple, didn't even get smaller than that. But
- 2:37:05then eventually anyway, or they literally just tweaked the code to be so that
- 2:37:13our minds are blown by something, but we don't know how to solve it.
- 2:37:16You know, string theory kind of has that feel to it. It
- 2:37:18was just like even experts on string theory are like they have a loose grasp
- 2:37:26on how it all fits together anyway. And maybe the fact that you don't
- 2:37:31have the unified theory of physics is because whoever programmed us didn't think about that
- 2:37:35when they put us all together, like oh shit, fuck, we got
- 2:37:39gravity. I was just saying, like, I'm about fourteen dimensions. If
- 2:37:43you were gonna make a simulation. Humans were perfectly happy when we thought that
- 2:37:48cells is where it stopped. Why not stop it there? Why do not
- 2:37:50stop the simulation there? It's not like humans were like this doesn't make sense.
- 2:37:56We must burn this universe down. So if it so, if it
- 2:38:00isn't a simulation, it distresses you. If it isn't, if it no,
- 2:38:05if it is a simulation, I'm distressed by how much wasted computational effort
- 2:38:11is being put into this. I see you're critiquing the overlord. Well,
- 2:38:15I would never critique the overlord because I think the overlord is perfect. Oh
- 2:38:20yes, I'm sorry. I can try it. And if, dear listener
- 2:38:28you're still listening, comment below with what word, brito or phrase. I
- 2:38:37for one, welcome our new AI overlords. Take care of yourself because you
- 2:38:43deserve it.