Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / From Defense to Offense: The CUSO Advocacy Push on Capitol Hill with Brian Lauer of NACUSO
Transcript
- 0:01Mark Treichel: Forward and we'll both start here in about five
- 0:04or 10 seconds if you're ready.
- 0:06Brian Lauer: Yep.
- 0:07Mark Treichel: Very good
- 0:11Oh I, I forgot to mention too, so I, I have the podcast, but
- 0:14then I also put a same version up on YouTube with our video, so-
- 0:18Hey, everyone.
- 0:18W- uh, welcome to another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:21I'm excited today to be here with Brian Lauer of the NACUSO.
- 0:26You're the general counsel of NACUSO- That's it ⦠and you're a
- 0:28partner of Messick, Lauer & Smith.
- 0:31Brian Lauer: That's right, yes.
- 0:32Yeah, the,
- 0:33Mark Treichel: uh-
- 0:33Brian Lauer: Very good ⦠the proverbial last name soup.
- 0:37Mark Treichel: Yep, that's exactly right.
- 0:38So it's funny, w- as we were getting on here I ha- you know, I ran into
- 0:42you at uh, the governmental affairs in March at the NASCUS meeting and said,
- 0:47"Hey, we need to get you back on the podcast," and it took a couple months
- 0:50for, for me to get that invite out.
- 0:52And then I went back and looked, and it was four years ago.
- 0:55You know, I've, I've only been doing this about four and a half years,
- 0:57so, uh- Well, time flies, right?
- 0:58⦠you were in that first six months.
- 1:00Yeah, time flies.
- 1:00I tell you what.
- 1:01And then looking at the notes from the last time we chatted I first met
- 1:05you, uh, in 2013 when I had become the executive director, and that's when I
- 1:10that's when I realized how good of a, of a, communications plan y- you at NCUSO
- 1:16had with NCUA because w- we ended up meeting with you and, uh, Debbie Matz,
- 1:20who was the chair at the time, talking about different things that, that you
- 1:24were hoping to get NCUA to realize could provide some legislative relief
- 1:29or regulatory relief and all that.
- 1:32And, uh, and there were some things that came out of that.
- 1:35You know, loans, uh, of all types being able to be made and different things.
- 1:38So, uh, it's always about the long game.
- 1:41And, uh, and here we are, 2023, 13 years later.
- 1:46And so let's, let's chat a little bit about what's maybe happened, uh,
- 1:49in CUSOs over the last four years.
- 1:51Maybe that's a good place to start.
- 1:53Brian Lauer: Yeah, sure.
- 1:54So four, four years, I mean, it's a lot of the same, but also a lot of change.
- 1:59As you know, the credit unions and the credit union industry sort of looks the
- 2:03same, at the same time, lots of change.
- 2:06Right?
- 2:06So just like the credit union industry, I think the CUSO industry
- 2:09has, has evolved even more into the financial technology space.
- 2:13I think that while the traditional CUSO model is absolutely still alive and well
- 2:19in the industry, you know, there's still a lot of collaboration going on a lot around
- 2:24back office services and providing, you know, new and in- and innovative services
- 2:29for credit unions and their members.
- 2:31Um, but that has definitely moved more into the technology space, right?
- 2:35Credit unions looking to try and leverage not only their field of
- 2:39membership, but leverage their ability to grow through technology.
- 2:45So that's really been the big push of late.
- 2:48Mark Treichel: Well, and I, I think, um, the current administrationâ¦
- 2:52And so Helt- Kyle Hauptman just left, but he, uh, was very, uh, and
- 2:56Rodney Hood, uh, the two Republicans, the, the two last Republicans w-
- 3:00were very pro fintech, pro let's not unnecessarily hamper credit unions
- 3:07from, uh, doing those type of things.
- 3:09And w- you know, i- as far as the fintech side of things, uh, and
- 3:13we also talked a little bit about crypto and, and, uh, stablecoin.
- 3:17I'm sure that, that what you're seeing is maybe some advances there.
- 3:21A- AI, um, y- helping in loan decisions or AI in general, uh, are those the
- 3:28kind of trends we're seeing in fintech or am I missing the mark with those?
- 3:33Brian Lauer: Almost, So those are absolutely, you're not missing the mark.
- 3:35Those are- Yeah ⦠absolutely at the forefront, right?
- 3:38You know, we, we can get into a little bit what NCUSO is doing on the
- 3:41legislative slide, side of things.
- 3:42Y- yes, absolutely.
- 3:43Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 3:43Brian Lauer: But, uh, and certainly stablecoin affects that, right, with the
- 3:46Genius Act coming out, and, and we can talk through that a little bit maybe.
- 3:50But in general- I think the technology side is really touching,
- 3:55Mark, every aspect of what credit unions are doing today.
- 3:58Um, you know, AI for sure, and how that touches everything that
- 4:02credit unions are doing today.
- 4:03Right.
- 4:04Um, but, you know, the, the technology side is happening on d- deposit
- 4:07growth, it's happening in the loan growth area, it's happening in, uh,
- 4:11marketing, it's happening at digital, um, I mean, uh, cryptocurrency, like
- 4:16you said fraud, cybersecurity, all of these areas are really being touched
- 4:21or, or that are touching credit unions and, and important to credit unions.
- 4:25And CUSOs and the technology that they're investing in, in the form
- 4:29of CUSOs, really is, is in all of those spaces at the moment.
- 4:33Mark Treichel: A- and you know, from four years ago, I'm gonna guess there's
- 4:37probably 800 less credit unions, but there's probably more CUSOs.
- 4:41I- is that a, an accurate- Yeah ⦠a- an accurate statement?
- 4:44Brian Lauer: I, there, I don't think there's a decrease in CUSOs.
- 4:47Right.
- 4:47But I know it's interesting, you mentioned the NCUA, and they're very, very receptive
- 4:51to innovation and, and the like, but back, um, probably around your time, I
- 4:55think we probably talked about this last time on, on the podcast, but you know,
- 5:00we're not getting true numbers of from the NCUA on, on the number of CUSOs.
- 5:05They're in that registry.
- 5:07Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 5:07Brian Lauer: And ever since CUSOs have been self-reporting into the registry,
- 5:10you know, back 2016 or something like that- Right ⦠um, we get a
- 5:14list, the latest list from the NCUA is from 2024 and there's not really
- 5:20a check on that data either to know where, what, you know, where that,
- 5:23whether they're double-checking it, whether, you know, whether it's true.
- 5:27I can tell you that in my practice at Mesiklauer & Smith, I've probably
- 5:31formed, in the last four years, I'm probably forming somewhere between
- 5:3630 and 40 CUSOs a year or so.
- 5:38Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 5:38Yeah.
- 5:39Brian Lauer: So it's growing, for sure.
- 5:41Mark Treichel: Well, and, and the people who, who did that report in 2024 were
- 5:45probably part of the NCUA buyout, 'cause they're down 30%, so- That's right
- 5:49so there, there, there's probably not gonna be an update that uh, on
- 5:53that list for a little, little while.
- 5:54But- That's right ⦠30 to four, 30 to 40 a year, uh, as opposed to
- 5:58shrinking, that kind of tells you the importance CUSOs are playing in
- 6:02the everyday life of credit unions.
- 6:05You know, you mentioned the legislative side.
- 6:07So, you know, getting NCUA to to change a regulation so that you can, CUSOs can
- 6:13do A, B, and C is a little bit different than the legislative sl- side, which
- 6:17means you have to go to Congress, which requires an act of Congress, right?
- 6:21Yes.
- 6:21To get to get relief there.
- 6:22So what's going on as far as your lobbying efforts in that front?
- 6:26What is it you're looking to do?
- 6:28What, you know, what, what's the optimistic arc of that kind of
- 6:32thing being able to be achieved?
- 6:34Brian Lauer: Yeah.
- 6:35Yeah, so it's interesting.
- 6:36Over the years, the CUSOs had minimal presence on the Hill.
- 6:41We were really more involved with NCUA, trying to make sure that CUSOs were
- 6:45getting the regulatory relief that we felt they needed, and in addition,
- 6:49you know, making sure that CUSOs were being treated fairly by the NCUA from,
- 6:53in the examination process- Right
- 6:55and the like.
- 6:55Prior to about 18 months to two, 24 months ago, the CUSO's main focus
- 7:01on the Hill would've been talking to, to, um, members of Congress and
- 7:04their staff about, um, NCUA's push for vendor authority, which you're
- 7:09all too aware of, I'm sure, as well.
- 7:11Sure That, you know, was more of a defensive position, Mark, right?
- 7:16We were, we were ⦠a- and you, I think you find this often with, uh, many of
- 7:20the trade associations, uh, being more defensive on the Hill that, of late
- 7:25rather than- Right ⦠on the offensive.
- 7:27Sure.
- 7:27But NACUSO strategically has taken a position over the last, like I said,
- 7:3218 to 24 months, where we are actually, we've been on the Hill now four times.
- 7:37We'll be back in September on the Hill as a pr- as our own organization, so not
- 7:41necessarily as part of, uh, GAC or, or some other fly-in f- for the industry.
- 7:47We're going on our own with a small group, and we are pushing on the offensive
- 7:52for getting changes to the Federal Credit Union Act to allow for credit u-
- 7:55federal credit unions to have additional investment power when it comes to CUSOs.
- 8:00Right now credit unions, or federal credit unions I sh- I have to say.
- 8:04The state charters- Right, yeah ⦠are a little different.
- 8:05Federal credit unions right now are limited to investing up to 1% of their
- 8:10assets in the aggregate in CUSOs.
- 8:13So, you know, if they make an investment in one CUSO, all the
- 8:17cash that they outlay into that CUSO takes away from their ability to
- 8:20invest potentially in another CUSO.
- 8:23This has become all the more important of an offensive approach
- 8:26because of AI and cryptocurrency.
- 8:30The m- amount of capital that's needed to invest in these-
- 8:33Sure ⦠kinds of technologies is just gonna go, grow exponentially.
- 8:38We're not even sure how much capitalization a stable coin, for
- 8:42instance, CUSO, is gonna need, you know, in addition to its reserves,
- 8:47its dollar for dollar reserves.
- 8:49What kind of a capital infusion is gonna be necessary there?
- 8:52Are credit unions gonna be in a position where they have to choose
- 8:55between stable coin or making an AI investment in a, in a technology
- 8:59company or some other CUSO investment?
- 9:01So we're trying to, to eliminate that 1% cap so that credit unions can
- 9:06manage their investments on a balance sheet by balance sheet basis, right?
- 9:10If you have a particular board, you know this even better, right?
- 9:13There's a statutory constraint on capital, for instance, right?
- 9:17Where, you know, it's essent- You know, it's, it's a math equation,
- 9:20but it's essentially you're in prompt corrective action as a credit union if
- 9:23you don't, if you have less than 7% cap.
- 9:25Mark Treichel: Right.
- 9:26Brian Lauer: But that doesn't mean that all credit unions
- 9:29will have 7% capital, right?
- 9:32I'm sure you encounter many credit unions that have 10, 15% capital, right?
- 9:37That's because they manage where they are comfortable as a credit union board on ha-
- 9:41on their capital level, and we feel that their CUSO investments should be managed
- 9:46in the same way without this cap so that one credit union may be, may wanna make
- 9:51more investment and another credit union may not, and they have that ability.
- 9:54And through the examination process, the cred- the NCUA can make sure they're
- 9:58not taking on any additional risk.
- 10:00Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 10:00Yeah, that makes sense.
- 10:01A, a, a, a bright line limit doesn't work in every scenario.
- 10:06So what, a principle base, like when they change the commercial loan rule
- 10:09to say, "It has to be 80% LTV on loans.
- 10:13If not, you come in and get a waiver, and it has to be this.
- 10:16You can't make a loan to your member unless it's exactly these
- 10:2010 provisions," to going to, "You write your policy, and we'll tell you
- 10:23if that policy is safe and sound."
- 10:25Brian Lauer: That's exactly right.
- 10:27It's a more principled approach rather than a prescriptive
- 10:30approach, which I know you know from the regulatory scope for sure.
- 10:33Um, you don't wanna be in a position where one size fits all.
- 10:37And the other thing that's interesting, too, Mark, about the 1% cap, we
- 10:41went back and did research on it because it's way before my time.
- 10:43Um, I'm gonna guess it's before your time- Yes ⦠'cause it was in the '70s, right?
- 10:48Yep.
- 10:48Yep.
- 10:48So, but it was in the '70s that this 1% was put into the Federal Credit Union Act,
- 10:53and there is no legislative history for, for any reason as to why 1% was chosen.
- 10:59There's no regulatory or, or legislative basis for the 1%.
- 11:03So it is truly an arbitrary number.
- 11:05So why- Sure ⦠are we, why are we working off of an arbitrary number?
- 11:08That's, that's what we believe.
- 11:10Mark Treichel: Yeah, and I mean, you, it could be bench- benchmarked to inflation.
- 11:13It could be raised to pick a number, X percent.
- 11:17Uh, it could, in the st- the states out there, I'm trying to remember
- 11:20I, I wanna say maybe fi- is 5%
- 11:24Brian Lauer: i- So-
- 11:24relevant
- 11:25Mark Treichel: in some states, if I'm
- 11:26Brian Lauer: remembering correctly?
- 11:26It is.
- 11:27Yeah, so there are some states that have 10%.
- 11:29Some states have 5%.
- 11:31Some have 2, some have 3.
- 11:33So it is all over.
- 11:34But the, the interesting thing about that, too, that we're trying to sort
- 11:36of make clear is that while some states have A higher percentage.
- 11:42That's good for us because we can show that it's not creating additional
- 11:46risk- Right ⦠for the balance sheet.
- 11:47But on the other hand, about 20 or, let's call it somewhere between 20 and
- 11:5030 states, I don't have the number in front of me, are all following the NCUA.
- 11:55So if we are, are following the feds- R-
- 11:57Mark Treichel: right
- 11:58Brian Lauer: so if we're able to get this credit union, the Federal Credit
- 12:00Union Act changed, I think it will have a positive influence on a, a
- 12:05majority of the states out there as well that are following the federal rule.
- 12:09Mark Treichel: Yeah, it's a pretty good story that you can probably go
- 12:11back and look at all those states that allow more than 1%, and has there
- 12:15ever been an NCUA loss tied to it?
- 12:17Right.
- 12:17Has there ever been an IG audit that shows that it was a problem, right?
- 12:20I, I think the answer to both of those is no.
- 12:22Brian Lauer: I think that's no too.
- 12:23We, we FOIA'd for that kind of information, and we, we
- 12:26don't get it, but- Right.
- 12:29But, uh, but I agree with you.
- 12:30You would hear it in the news if that was a big issue.
- 12:32Right.
- 12:32The only time you hear of CUSO losses in the news was going back to the
- 12:36financial crisis, and that was really mo- more the CUSOs were supporting
- 12:40credit unions putting commercial loans and mortgage loans on their books,
- 12:43and they were attributing those losses to CUSOs even though they were credit
- 12:47union losses on the balance sheet.
- 12:48Sure.
- 12:48Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:49No, that makes sense.
- 12:50Yeah, I ha- I was, um, in a conversation in a previous podcast with Mike
- 12:55Bell, and, um, he was talking about the sale of CUSOs, right?
- 12:59A credit union who has, has taken a CUSO, uh, as far as they
- 13:05think they can take it and being acquired by another credit union.
- 13:08He's kind of seen some growth in that area.
- 13:10Is that something you're seeing as well?
- 13:12Brian Lauer: Yeah, we are seeing some of that.
- 13:13I don'tâ¦
- 13:14It's not generally another credit union per se, but, um, we are seeing
- 13:19scenarios where maybe a third-party vendor is it sees the value in-
- 13:25Okay ⦠bringing a particular service that a CUSO is providing int- in turn,
- 13:29or you know, in like a Jack Henry or something like that- Yeah, yeah
- 13:32may come and, and look to buy a, uh, a CUSO that is providing a service they,
- 13:36they feel is, it fits within their lanes.
- 13:39Um, so we have seen that.
- 13:40We've also seen, You know, you asked about the growth of CUSOs, and I was,
- 13:43giving you my average numbers on the growth of CUSOs, but we have some,
- 13:46seen some consolidation of CUSOs too.
- 13:48Not a lot, but you know, similar services being provided.
- 13:52Sometimes CUSOs were being formed collaboratively regionally, like a
- 13:56geographic kind of- Yeah ⦠scenario.
- 13:57And we are seeing some mergers of regions.
- 14:01Like if you're doing commercial lending CUSO, for instance, in, you
- 14:04know, the Midwest, and you wanna team up with somebody that's in the
- 14:07upper Midwest, there's been some consolidation in that way as well.
- 14:11Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 14:11No, that makes sense.
- 14:12The, the legislative, Side of things tied to the primarily serving credit
- 14:17union members uh, is that something, uh, i- is that of equal or, or this
- 14:22lesser importance to the 1% or is that, is that something you're also hitting?
- 14:27I- in a perfect world if, if someone said, "Hey, you can rewrite the
- 14:30Federal Credit Union Act today and we'll approve it," would that, I'm
- 14:33assuming that would be in there too?
- 14:34Brian Lauer: That would absolutely be in there, and the interesting thing
- 14:37about that, not to be too wonkish here- Yeah, yeah ⦠uh, but, uh, the way the
- 14:41act is written today, primarily serves is not in the investment p- it's not
- 14:46a limitation in the investment powers.
- 14:48Mark Treichel: Okay.
- 14:48Brian Lauer: It's only a limitation in the lending powers to CUSOs the NCUA,
- 14:53when it wrote the regulations for the first time back in the '90s for CUSOs,
- 14:58well, I think they had an earlier version, but the, the most robust sort
- 15:01of, uh, modern version was in the '90s.
- 15:03And when they wrote that reg, they conflated the investment and loan together
- 15:08and made them have to primarily serve, a- under investments and loans, right?
- 15:14That's sort of how the reg was, was crafted.
- 15:16So what our position on that from a legislative perspective is the investment
- 15:21powers have always not had a limitation of, of, uh, of primarily serving.
- 15:26That should not be a limitation to lending as well, instead of
- 15:30going the opposite direction.
- 15:31And I don't see why that from a legislative perspective, has a
- 15:36lot of basis in policy reasons or safety and soundness reasons for
- 15:41the federal credit unions to be able to not invest in a company that is
- 15:45serving the credit union industry.
- 15:47So you want it to be in the, the, as part of the routine operation of credit unions.
- 15:51That's an important piece, right?
- 15:53You don't want credit unions to be investing in, like, McDonald's franchises
- 15:56or something of that sort, right?
- 15:58They wanna invest in financial services, and that's still the focus.
- 16:02But by limiting it to primarily serves, you are limiting a credit
- 16:06union's ability to have that strategic investment, that seat at the table
- 16:11with some of these credit unions, I mean, with some of these companies.
- 16:13Because if you say to them, "Here's my money.
- 16:16I want a s- seat at the table.
- 16:17I wanna be a part of your growth.
- 16:18I wanna be a part of your, of your future.
- 16:21But oh, by the way, you have, 50% of your business has to be with credit
- 16:24unions," the company typically is the one then turning away, right?
- 16:28Right.
- 16:28Yeah, yeah.
- 16:29So it's really putting it's putting credit unions at a disadvantage in that context.
- 16:32Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 16:32It's, it's, it, it hurts the value of the federal or state charter in that instance.
- 16:38And, uh, it's inter- So, s- so it almost sounds like half the fix could
- 16:42be NCUA fixing their regulation, and the other half would be legislative,
- 16:47which, um, maybe when John Cruz comes in, that can be ⦠You know, new board
- 16:51members come in, they're always looking for a way to influence things, right?
- 16:55Yeah.
- 16:55Brian Lauer: Yeah.
- 16:55Uh,
- 16:56Mark Treichel: Because they're, that's what they're there to do.
- 16:58And, uh, the, he's gonna be likely in the ilk of deregulation.
- 17:03So,
- 17:04Brian Lauer: We will absolutely be- I, I'm, I'm
- 17:05Mark Treichel: guessing you're gonna be meeting with him, uh, this fall probably
- 17:08. Brian Lauer: Yes.
- 17:08We will absolutely be vis- visiting with the new chairman.
- 17:11We're gonna give him a little time to get his feet on the ground- For sure.
- 17:14Yeah ⦠I think before, before we jump in his office.
- 17:16But absolutely it's an important for ⦠You know, and, uh, a- as you know, um, b-
- 17:21being the executive director- the board members when they come in aren't always
- 17:26the most attuned to credit union issues.
- 17:29Right.
- 17:29They certainly have the expertise to sit in that position and sit- Yep
- 17:32in that role, but they don't necessarily know the operations of credit unions and
- 17:37the and really the weeds of the kinds of things you and I are talking about.
- 17:40Yeah.
- 17:41So I do think this is an opportunity for us to educate Chairman Cruz and
- 17:45talk to him about this, this difference in the act I just described for you.
- 17:49But, you know, maybe some other things within the CUSO rule as well.
- 17:52You know, we, one of the things that NCUSO focuses on for sure is
- 17:56modernization of that rule, right?
- 17:58The rule, while it's been tweaked here and there on the margins over the years, is
- 18:03essentially a rule from the '90s, right?
- 18:05Yeah.
- 18:05Almost pre-internet, right?
- 18:07Yeah.
- 18:07So we, we really do wanna try, try and focus on, uh, y- you know, the, the
- 18:12rising role of CUSOs in the industry, the complexity of CUSOs in the industry, and
- 18:17how that rule should fit those changes.
- 18:19Mark Treichel: Well, and I, and I can tell you, having sat at, the executive
- 18:22director's office is right across from where the board members are.
- 18:25And whether it's NCUSO or CUNA at the time now America's Credit Unions, the
- 18:30meetings would happen and, and, uh, b- before the end of the day, they'd
- 18:34be over in my office saying, "Hey, s- you know, the, the, NCUSO was in
- 18:38suggesting we do A, B, and C," right?
- 18:40And- Yeah that's how things get changed, is by, um, those that are impacted by
- 18:47regulations showing up and say, "Hey, have you thought about doing it this way?"
- 18:51And, for, for all the different, I- and they'll go out and speak,
- 18:54and they'll hear different things.
- 18:55But it's when a board member really wants to champion something
- 18:59and staff, you know, looks at it and going, "Yeah, you know what?
- 19:02We can put a ring fence around this, and we can do it," or, "No, we can't
- 19:06because our interpretation is the act says X, and because X, we need
- 19:09to drag that into the regulation."
- 19:11But without the associations and the interested parties
- 19:15going in, uh, and talking to the board, it usually a status quo.
- 19:19'Cause the, the staff aren't there looking to say, "Okay, how can we,
- 19:23how can we change regulations to make- ⦠uh, deregulate or regulate?"
- 19:26It's really driven by- Right ⦠the political appointees who come in and
- 19:29say, "How can we make this better?"
- 19:31And over time it works, right?
- 19:33Yeah.
- 19:33So that's back to the long game- Yeah ⦠of, of just- It
- 19:35Brian Lauer: has to be a long game.
- 19:36Yeah.
- 19:36Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 19:37And, and, uh, I, I, I remember, you know, when I was executive director,
- 19:41there were things policy-wise internally that I would wanna get done, and
- 19:45you'd have to wait for the right combination of board members to do it.
- 19:48And John Kutchey and myself, we would, we would have certain things
- 19:52in a box ready to go, you know, until the temperature was right.
- 19:55And when the temperature was right and you thought you might be able to get two
- 19:58votes, because now, you know, now you only need one vote, but- ⦠you get two votes,
- 20:02you'd be ready to run, so you didn't have to go research it for six, nine months.
- 20:06And then by the time, you know, it, they were onto something else by then.
- 20:10So that's- Yeah ⦠it, it's, to me you know, sitting where I sit now
- 20:13understanding the roles that, that your organizations and organization like
- 20:17you play it, it's supremely important to the greater good of credit unions.
- 20:23Brian Lauer: Absolutely.
- 20:24Absolutely.
- 20:24And now, you know, uh, w- we've been talking internally, I'm sure you have
- 20:28some real insight into this as well, and it's probably for, a, a subject
- 20:32of another one of your podcasts that I haven't seen, seen or heard yet.
- 20:36But the, the concept of the NCUA board is gonna be completely different in
- 20:40my mind moving forward, and how is that gonna affect this process, right?
- 20:44Mark Treichel: Right.
- 20:45Yeah.
- 20:45Well, you know, I mean, uh, you know, sometimes I'll say, I worked for five
- 20:49chair, chairpersons in eight years, which, uh, I, I think at the time was a record
- 20:56because of all the ins and out, right?
- 20:57Right.
- 20:57And they come in and they, they truly want to make a positive impact, so
- 21:02they're excited about doing things.
- 21:04But, uh, but my, you know, my line was, today purple is
- 21:08purple and yellow is yellow.
- 21:09Tomorrow, yellow is purple and purple is yellow.
- 21:12And, uh, a- and, and that can get, that can get a little, little chaotic.
- 21:16So when you have a situation where the terms don't mean anything, right?
- 21:20Right.
- 21:20Or they mean less, maybe they don't mean anything.
- 21:23But, you know, we- if we go to Democratic rule, it, uh, a- assuming Harper and
- 21:28Otsuka don't come back and that, that the, the law is that the terms, they
- 21:34can be terminated for any reason, th- they'll probably wipe them out when
- 21:38they come in with the new, uh, and, you know, come in with a, a new Democrat.
- 21:42Right.
- 21:42Uh, consumer compliance is gonna get elevated.
- 21:45Uh, and other things are, um, are gonna happen.
- 21:48So that pen- Yeah ⦠the pendulum, the, the pendulum was hard before, but
- 21:52it's gonna get harder for everybody now.
- 21:53It's just gonna swing quicker, with more velocity.
- 21:57Brian Lauer: More velocity bec- and I think with less compromise.
- 22:01Mark Treichel: You're right.
- 22:02Brian Lauer: Because, uh, the way things are moving now, I, I think
- 22:05things will get tested a bit, but still more, uh, i- as we move forward,
- 22:09but- I can see a, a presidential administration coming in and saying,
- 22:14"I'm just gonna appoint two members."
- 22:16"I'll leave, I'll leave one seat empty."
- 22:17Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 22:18Brian Lauer: And then that leaves no compromise, right?
- 22:20Mark Treichel: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:21And, you know, I, I mean, I was there when some, when two Ds didn't get along and two
- 22:24Rs didn't get along, but that, that, uh,
- 22:29But it ma- it makes it a lot better if y- you- if you only ha- if, if you're an
- 22:33R and you only have two Rs and no D, uh, it makes it easier to get things through.
- 22:37It doesn't mean it makes it better.
- 22:38Right.
- 22:39Uh, it doesn't mean that you know, you, 'cause you lo- lose that wisdom of crowds.
- 22:42But yeah, it's a, it's kind of a Wild Wild West on how this is
- 22:45all gonna play out, for sure.
- 22:46It
- 22:46Brian Lauer: really is, yeah.
- 22:47Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 22:47So you mentioned the Genius Act, too.
- 22:49So, let's, your take on what's going on in, in that arena a- as
- 22:54it relates to CUSOs, et cetera.
- 22:56Brian Lauer: Yeah, I mean, for one, I thought, I think it's really a,
- 23:01a win for an ACUSO and for credit unions that, that CUSOs are actually
- 23:06mentioned by name in the act.
- 23:09Going in, going, uh, for these hikes on Capitol Hill, you'd, you would not be
- 23:13surprised how many congressional staffers don't know what ACUSO is to begin with.
- 23:20So that education, you know, i- is part, is part of our, is part of our process.
- 23:25But it, it is pretty great that the Genius Act does have CUSOs written
- 23:29into the bill, and the idea being that a bank or a credit union will
- 23:33not issue themselves a stable coin.
- 23:38So they're gonna be issued through, in the case of credit unions,
- 23:41they'll be issued through ACUSO.
- 23:43So I think that's really yeah, I think that's a win for an ACUSO, having CUSOs
- 23:48be part of that, uh, legislative action.
- 23:51How it's gonna work in the offing your guess is still as good as mine, Mark.
- 23:57Uh, what I b- what I think is that the only real way it's going to work in the
- 24:02credit union space is- Well, first let me say, I do think it will be important
- 24:09for the industry for credit unions to have a credit union stablecoin.
- 24:15I, I think that concept, just that statement alone, is important because
- 24:21it is going to be important for credit unions to not be left out
- 24:24of this side of financial services.
- 24:28It's going to be an important part of payments and the like uh, moving
- 24:32forward, that, it being stablecoin.
- 24:35So I think credit unions need to have a stablecoin that is for their industry.
- 24:42Think about it like shared branching, right?
- 24:44Credit unions need shared branching.
- 24:46They needed it a, a great deal in the past.
- 24:49Now they're going to need shared stablecoin, I believe.
- 24:53Now, I do think that the only way that will work is through collaboration.
- 24:59You really do truly need a group of credit unions, and when I say group,
- 25:05more than 100 probably, more than, even more than that, probably closer to 1,000.
- 25:11You know, think of the way shared branching really works, right?
- 25:13Sure.
- 25:14You're going to need that kind of a collaboration Credit unions, while
- 25:19collaborative, can be like herding cats as well, so I hope it can work.
- 25:22You know, there's a little bit of hope in my voice there, but I think, I really do
- 25:26think that is the future of stablecoin.
- 25:28Mark Treichel: Iâ¦
- 25:28There, there's, there's a line or a joke that was, "I don't, I don't
- 25:31understand it, and I don't understand the people who understand it," right?
- 25:34Mm-hmm.
- 25:34And that was kind of my mantra on crypto and stablecoin.
- 25:38But I, I will say to Kyle Hauptman's credit, he helped me understand something
- 25:43at that same meeting where we last met.
- 25:45He gave a speech, and he, he was talking about stablecoin,
- 25:49and he made a referenceâ¦
- 25:50I- one of the themes of what he said was that if stablecoin can help the
- 25:56dollar remain the world currency, that it's something we should try and
- 26:01assist- Yes ⦠and be part of, right?
- 26:03And that was this, like, the light bulb.
- 26:05That one sentence in that whole thing, it was probably two minutes of his speech,
- 26:09but I thought, "That makes sense."
- 26:11Yeah.
- 26:11You know?
- 26:11Uh, I'm not sure it works for everybody, and, and itâ¦
- 26:14I'm not sure it works for me, but being the world currency is a really good thing.
- 26:19Right.
- 26:19And if other countries are allowing stablecoin, and the
- 26:24United States is more restrictâ¦
- 26:26It's kind of like the, the debate right now on, on AI, and, and what
- 26:30you ring-fence and, and if China's and the other countries are developing it
- 26:35and don't have all these regulatory requirements around it and they
- 26:38become the leaders as opposed to the US, that's not a good thing.
- 26:42Just like, um, Silicon Valley is where tech happens for the world, right?
- 26:47Right.
- 26:47Um, I think AI happening in the US and stablecoin happening in the US so
- 26:52that, that world currency thing was really kind of a tipping point for me.
- 26:56I think I, I get some of this now,
- 26:58Brian Lauer: yeah.
- 26:59Mark Treichel: Yeah, right?
- 26:59No,
- 27:00Brian Lauer: I mean, it's going to be important.
- 27:01I don'tâ¦
- 27:01You know, the guess is as good as mine comment earlier is that I don'tâ¦
- 27:06That's not clear to me how quickly it's going to take off You know, as far
- 27:11as many can talk theoretically about stablecoin, I'm just not sure there are
- 27:15that many average people that are gonna w- w- either need or want to be involved
- 27:21in it- Sure ⦠uh, moving forward.
- 27:22So I think it will be slower than we think y- you know, in, i- in adoption,
- 27:27but I do think the payment side of it is really, really important.
- 27:30Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 27:31Yep.
- 27:32No, it makes perfect sense.
- 27:33So, uh, Brian, I I got through the list of things I was chatting, uh,
- 27:38wanting to chat with you about today.
- 27:39This has been a lot of fun.
- 27:41I- I- if there was one thing I didn't ask you that you wanted
- 27:43to talk about, maybe conferences.
- 27:45Are there conferences coming up or anything else that you, before we
- 27:49wrap, that you wanna chat about?
- 27:51Brian Lauer: Yeah.
- 27:51Oh, that's a great, that's a great, uh, question.
- 27:53So NACUSO has its annual conference.
- 27:56We had it in Orlando back in April.
- 27:59Uh, we're gonna have it in, uh, Or- in Las Vegas this, this coming
- 28:03year in '26, in, in April again.
- 28:06Um, so I definitely would recommend everybody come see that.
- 28:09There's also the VentureTech.
- 28:11They don't call it a conference, they call it an event.
- 28:13Yeah.
- 28:13But the VentureTech event, you know, if you're a credit union that's interested
- 28:16in technology, it's a conference set up just for credit unions to get introduced
- 28:21to technology and, and the like, so that's another really great one to look for.
- 28:24We'll be at bo- we'll be at both of those, so, uh, yeah, I'd be, I would,
- 28:28I'd be happy to meet anybody there that, uh, you know, that wants to meet
- 28:31with me or, uh, or you can feel free to reach out to me, uh, you know, uh,
- 28:35my email and phone number are on our website at, uh, at www.cusolaw.com.
- 28:41Mark Treichel: Cusolaw.com
- 28:43and, and you're on LinkedIn as well?
- 28:45Yes.
- 28:45Is that a way that people can get in touch with you?
- 28:46Very good.
- 28:47Brian Lauer: Yes, absolutely.
- 28:48Very good.
- 28:48Mark Treichel: Well, it's been great catching up.
- 28:50Got to spend a little bit more time with you here than I was at the NASCUS
- 28:54and the running around at, at GAC.
- 28:56As always I learned a few things and, uh, Brian, I wanna
- 28:59thank you for your time today.
- 29:00Brian Lauer: Yeah, absolutely.
- 29:01It was my pleasure, Mark.
- 29:02Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 29:02And listeners, watchers, I hope you do the same again soon.
- 29:05This is Mark Trakel signing off with Flying Colors.