Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Data Centers: Site Selection to Approval
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to another episode of The Market Edge. This podcast is produced
- 0:04by the Market Intelligence Committee at the American Council of Engineering
- 0:07Companies, where we bring you conversations with industry experts on the issues
- 0:12shaping our firms and the markets we serve.
- 0:15This series is presented in partnership with the Engineering Influence Podcast at ECEC National.
- 0:21I'm Diana O'Leary, Vice President of Market Intelligence, and I will be your host.
- 0:25Today, we're joined by Navdeep Martin, co-founder and CEO of FlyPower,
- 0:29an AI-powered platform that helps developers protect millions in project investment
- 0:35by answering two critical questions.
- 0:37Should I build here? And what is my path to approval?
- 0:41FlyPower analyzes social, political, and permitting risks to develop,
- 0:45give development teams the intelligence they need to chart a strategic path to approval.
- 0:50So, Navdeep, thank you so much for joining us on the Market Edge today.
- 0:55Thank you. Thanks for having me. Absolutely. So let's jump in.
- 0:58I'm just going to give a little bit of background. So communities across the
- 1:01country are grappling with the growth of data centers because of the AI expansion
- 1:06and other large scale infrastructure projects, frankly.
- 1:10Engineering firms are finding themselves at the intersection of not only technical
- 1:15design, but now public perception and regulatory approval.
- 1:19And in many cases, project success depends, you know, not just on,
- 1:24you know, understanding on social and political dynamics.
- 1:27It's also on engineering solutions as well. So today we're going to discuss
- 1:31how firms can better anticipate those challenges and position projects for success.
- 1:36So I'm going to go ahead and jump right in with my first question.
- 1:40I kind of wanted to get your origin story.
- 1:42So what specific challenges in the development or infrastructure space led you
- 1:47to focus on permitting and approval risk? And when did you realize this was
- 1:52a broader industry gap rather than a project-specific issue?
- 1:56Yeah, no. So I actually have an AI background, was doing it for over 13 years.
- 2:03And in, I would say, 2024, I was out to start my own company.
- 2:08I was ready to start FlyPower.
- 2:10And at that time, ChatGPT was suddenly everywhere. And, you know,
- 2:16there was an excitement in the air.
- 2:18And having, you know, background in that technology, I felt like I went from
- 2:22that kind of nerdy, you know, person with glasses and braces and unfashionable clothes,
- 2:27you know, person in the 80s movies, right, to suddenly I was the popular kid
- 2:32and I could, you know, do whatever I wanted with this skill set.
- 2:35And it was a really exciting place to be.
- 2:38And so at that point, I picked renewable energy to start with.
- 2:42I soon moved to data centers. And,
- 2:45the pattern I was seeing was really that projects were getting shut down.
- 2:50Maybe they had sound engineering and the economics worked out,
- 2:53but they were still dying. And it was due to community resistance.
- 2:58And so we set out to fill that gap. I realized there wasn't anything in the
- 3:03market technology-wise. to be able to deal with that.
- 3:07And so that is, that's how we got started and where we are today.
- 3:11So I don't know if you've seen the latest movies, even though I love 80s music
- 3:15and movies, but smart kids are now the cool kids.
- 3:18Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, it was time anyway. So you've made it.
- 3:24So you often frame, you know, the challenge as answering, should I build here?
- 3:28And what's my path to approval?
- 3:30How should engineers and project teams think about structuring those decisions
- 3:34more effectively today.
- 3:36Yeah, I mean, I think in the old world, you found a location and you did your,
- 3:42environmental study. You know, are there endangered species?
- 3:46You know, am I on wetlands?
- 3:47And then you did your interconnection study. Like, how am I going to connect to the grid?
- 3:51And in this new world, this new paradigm, I would argue that community resistance
- 3:56is actually that third study you should be doing, right?
- 4:00The stats are staggering here. You know, Berkeley Lab analyzed one in three
- 4:05utility skill and solar and wind projects end up getting canceled.
- 4:10Over half experienced significant delays. Data center side, there's roughly
- 4:14$18 billion in data center projects blocked and over $46 billion delayed,
- 4:20right, over the past two years, all due to local opposition, right?
- 4:24So social risk now needs to be at the top, right?
- 4:28When you're analyzing your permitting, your environmental and technical due
- 4:33diligence, you also need to understand, am I going to be allowed to build here?
- 4:39And that's what we set out to build. So we have our two reports,
- 4:43the should I build here a fast, easy, go, no-go report, and then a full path
- 4:49due diligence report where we are analyzing your path to approval.
- 4:52So everything from the commissioners to past projects, what are the community
- 4:57expectations, who are the silent, say, gatekeepers that can quietly stop you.
- 5:02So that is how we approach that problem. But overall, the general kind of structural
- 5:08risk for engineering teams is now, will they let us? in parallel with can we build it.
- 5:13So in a world filled with everything you just listed, the social,
- 5:17political, and regulatory complexities, if it wasn't difficult enough to get a,
- 5:22project planned, permitted, and built, what does it take to translate those
- 5:27signals into actionable insights, and where do traditional approaches tend to fall short?
- 5:34Yeah, so we approach it with a framework. So we're classifying governing bodies,
- 5:39how they make decisions.
- 5:41Do they defer to staff or do they mirror, you know, the loudest voices in the room?
- 5:47And then we look at opposition as well. You know, it's not enough to just know
- 5:50that, hey, there's people kind of chattering online.
- 5:53You know, yes, there's probably opposition everywhere where people are complaining
- 5:58about things online. But more importantly is, have they managed to successfully
- 6:03shut down projects in the past?
- 6:05And so we're looking at the governance, the opposition, and then we interpret that.
- 6:11We're not just aggregating like a whole, you know, data set and kind of good luck with that.
- 6:16But we're actually giving you strategic insights to then take these thousands
- 6:19of data points and help you
- 6:21with this hyper-local grounding of like, okay, it's not enough to know that,
- 6:26hey, this county survey or the state average says X, but, you know, tell me about my
- 6:33specific site location, like down to the coordinates, right?
- 6:37Because the county is huge.
- 6:38You're going to have, you can think of all these different places I've lived,
- 6:41right? It's very different from the north versus the south or just one end to the next.
- 6:46So really understanding at a local level. And that's where I think developers
- 6:52can, And if they can begin to put forward this framework, they can then pivot
- 6:57where traditional approaches fail.
- 7:00Great answer. So I know your background was initially in AI,
- 7:03and it's transforming so many industries today.
- 7:06So where do you see it adding the most value in infrastructure planning and
- 7:10permitting, particularly in identifying risks teams might otherwise miss?
- 7:16Yeah, I mean, I think that it's now transformed how you look at projects, right?
- 7:22So the old way might be, hey, I'm building a data center and,
- 7:26oh, this location has a bunch of data centers that they must,
- 7:29you know, this looks like a good spot, right? You know, they've approved these data centers.
- 7:35And what you're missing out of that is, first, there might be possible development
- 7:38fatigue, right? A sense of, we've done our part, you know, we don't want any more of these.
- 7:43But next, you're missing like what happened there before.
- 7:48So we've seen situations where maybe the last developer left the roads and,
- 7:52you know, terrible conditions.
- 7:53And now you're showing up, you know, trying to alter those same roads or even
- 7:59just other technology projects.
- 8:01So you're building a data center, but everyone was also complaining about a
- 8:06local Aldi grocery store, or maybe there's a recent fire.
- 8:09So the point is being able to understand a location, again, back to this kind
- 8:15of hyperlocal location, AI gives you that real breath.
- 8:20It also gives you speed, right, on this unstructured data. So no longer do we
- 8:25need to listen to these government meetings.
- 8:28We don't have to go study the ordinances, scan local news, social media,
- 8:33right? There's this, I can click on a button and get a full report of this information, right?
- 8:40This is uncovering information that no human team could uncover.
- 8:45And I have two stories on this, actually, that I think was super interesting.
- 8:50There was one time where there was a lack of government meeting records,
- 8:54right? There was nothing available. And we were studying to do this location.
- 8:58And somehow someone took their iPhone, right, in the meeting and they videotaped
- 9:05the whole meeting. And they were like, it was a terrible video,
- 9:07right? It was underneath the desk. They were trying to hide their phone.
- 9:10But that single, like the AI found this, right? And that like completely changed
- 9:15the game in terms of how we understood those commissioners. They were actually
- 9:18very against projects in that area. And we wouldn't have known that, right?
- 9:22Because the lack of meetings were so, you know, they were just not there.
- 9:27But another situation was the government had actually redone their website,
- 9:32and the AI somehow uncovered remnants of the old website.
- 9:38The URL was not obvious. Like, you would never have known if you were trying
- 9:41to just search for this yourself.
- 9:43But we uncovered all of these old meetings that were still there, you know, accessible.
- 9:49So AI is just the breadth, the deepness that you can go into this data.
- 9:55It's finding things you wouldn't otherwise find.
- 9:57But the real moat is just the framework on top. So AI is, you know,
- 10:02AI that only summarizes is kind of hollow, right?
- 10:06You're going to miss, you know, the non-elected gatekeeper, right?
- 10:09The actual person who's in charge, who's pseudo in charge of accepting your project.
- 10:15You're missing the denied project from different technology types.
- 10:19You're also missing like this deceptively quiet looking jurisdictions,
- 10:23right? The ones that have by right permitting is that's not necessarily a win,
- 10:28right? Then your technical gatekeepers are now more important.
- 10:31And so I would just say AI is giving you that breath and giving you the ability
- 10:38to provide that human analysis on top.
- 10:40All right. So since we're going down the path of storytelling,
- 10:43can you share a high-level example of how better visibility into approval or
- 10:49stakeholder risk has changed a project's trajectory?
- 10:52And I know you can't share maybe too much, but also include what tends to surprise
- 10:56teams when they start using that kind of insight earlier on.
- 11:00Yeah, I would say the thing that surprised us and how our data was getting used.
- 11:06We've had more than one client tell us that they killed a project because of our report, right?
- 11:12So we do this risk rating one to five, five is bad, one is good.
- 11:16And so, and in one case, the client actually told us, like, she knew the location
- 11:21was not a good one, right? And she was trying to tell everyone,
- 11:24like, hey, we shouldn't build here.
- 11:26But it wasn't until she had this objective report, right, validating her concerns
- 11:31that she was then able to be like, hey, I told you guys, this is not a good location.
- 11:36So that's one thing because our clients want to be able to kill bad projects
- 11:40sooner. So that's a really important thing for them.
- 11:44But another example that surprised me was this particular client had ordered
- 11:49reports all in the same geographic area. Like, you know, one,
- 11:53you know, there was, I don't know, four, I think four counties all in the same kind of area.
- 11:59And they were all rated a four out of five, right? Five being the worst.
- 12:03So they were all rated and not a good location to build.
- 12:06And instead of backing away, the client actually decided to pursue those projects,
- 12:11but they put a full-time resource who lived there and who was going to live
- 12:16there for the next several years there.
- 12:18So they had someone who's there who could answer questions, be there whenever needed.
- 12:24So that was just another way that people are using our data.
- 12:28But I would say that the other things, too, is I would say affluence actually
- 12:34makes approval harder, not easier, because if you think about it, if you don't need.
- 12:40The tax revenue, then the developer has less to work with.
- 12:45And then the other kind of surprises is that the most predictive precedent for,
- 12:52understanding how past projects went and how yours might go is not always projects of the same category.
- 12:59And I mentioned that earlier. So, I mean, the most useful comparable is actually
- 13:04what activated the same type of community conflict, whether it's heavy industrial
- 13:09use, the roads. You know, what does this do to our town?
- 13:13That is sometimes provoked from a different technology type.
- 13:16So whether it's a denied warehouse or a gravel pit, that can actually predict
- 13:22a data center's fight better than the approved solar farm next door.
- 13:26Wow, really interesting. I want to go down the permitting path because that
- 13:30seems to be a big issue right now. So those challenges often come down to community
- 13:36sentiment, political dynamics.
- 13:38How should engineers and developers better incorporate those factors again into
- 13:43the early stages, which really sounds like the key here?
- 13:46And are they more predictable than people assume?
- 13:49It is actually more predictable than people assume.
- 13:54We talked about this earlier. You have your decision-making bodies,
- 13:57the governance archetypes.
- 13:59So we did a study last year through all of our reports looking at just the governance
- 14:04archetypes. Like basically, how does this governing body make decisions?
- 14:09How do each individual, how do the individuals within that make decisions?
- 14:14And we actually found it was really interesting.
- 14:18The governance archetype is actually the leading predictor of project outcomes.
- 14:24So how our decision-making body is making those decisions is actually going
- 14:30to affect your outcome more than opposition, more than anything else.
- 14:34And so if you know that, and you know that you can actually pretty easily classify
- 14:39your governance body into these
- 14:41archetypes, you can actually predict how your project is going to go.
- 14:46And of course, there's lots of nuances, And, you know, who are your allies?
- 14:49Who do you talk to? And what are your talking points with them?
- 14:52Like, we absolutely want someone on the ground. You know, our report is not
- 14:57a substitute for people actually making friends and connecting and understanding
- 15:03what the community means.
- 15:05But I think that having a starting point of who to contact and what to say to
- 15:11them and who not to contact and what are
- 15:14the talking points is actually the best way to then bring this,
- 15:18the political and community risk into,
- 15:21your decision-making process and throughout the whole development pipeline.
- 15:26All right. So I've probably got time to get one more rapid fire question in
- 15:29because, but it's forward looking.
- 15:31So I want to make sure we talk about it. So looking ahead five to 10 years,
- 15:35which I don't even know if I could guess where we'd But how do you see project
- 15:39planning evolving with better risk intelligence that you all are working on?
- 15:43And what is one particular step that firms could take today to move from a reactive
- 15:49place to proactive decision making?
- 15:52Yeah, I think approval, social political risk, that'll become the standard.
- 15:57I think that it'll become quantified and tied into the early stage input along
- 16:02with, you know, engineering and environmental diligence.
- 16:05I think portfolios will be triaged by the approval risk before capital commitments.
- 16:11And so site selection becomes risk intelligent, not just resource driven.
- 16:15And then second, I see the more AI first your firm is, the better positioned it'll be.
- 16:23And I'm talking about not just siting and permitting.
- 16:27I'm talking about everything. Like, think about your marketing,
- 16:30your sales, your operations, your finance, your attorneys even.
- 16:34Like, I'm not going to I'm not suggesting to go to get rid of all of your attorneys.
- 16:39But for us, like, I want to hire attorneys that are AI first,
- 16:44right? I want them to use AI.
- 16:46And then they, of course, I want them to double check their work.
- 16:48But I want them to be more efficient and catch more things than that human eye might catch.
- 16:54And so whether it's your core competency or your, you know, buy versus build
- 16:58is always like a question.
- 17:00But I think the winning combinations are firms that marry that AI within their
- 17:05operations from site selection all the way up to operations,
- 17:09tied with the right messengers to get their projects built.
- 17:13And you asked one lesson. So the practical step today is I would run an approval
- 17:18risk screen before committing to a site.
- 17:21So, you know, actually internally ask yourselves that question.
- 17:25Will they let us, right, upstream, like before, like right when you're thinking
- 17:30about the location itself so that it is, you know, answered on a spreadsheet, you know, early on.
- 17:36This is the risk level versus being discovered at the wrong time,
- 17:41right, when you're already down the path and at the hearing.
- 17:44Well, that really seems like the theme of this conversation and the strongest
- 17:47advice is to get in early and get ahead before it becomes a really big problem.
- 17:52So before we wrap, I want to let our listeners know about an upcoming educational
- 17:57opportunity that expands on many of the themes that we just discussed today.
- 18:02So we hope you join ACEC on August 20th and 21st. It's a strategic communications.
- 18:08Two-part series for mission-critical and public-facing projects.
- 18:12It's focused on practical strategies for managing what we talked about today,
- 18:16managing stakeholder engagement, public perception, communication challenges,
- 18:21including those surrounding data center development, of course.
- 18:23So you'll hear from industry leaders at member firms, GHD, DLR Group,
- 18:28and HDR, as well as a public relations expert, Adam Week Kunis of Mill Dam Public Relations, excuse me.
- 18:36You can find registration details on the ACEC website and in this episode's show notes as well.
- 18:41And I also have to give a plug that ACEC's Energy Committee also released a
- 18:46position statement on data center growth related to U.S. energy infrastructure,
- 18:50which we'll also link for you as well.
- 18:53That's about all the time we have for today. Navdeep, thank you so much for joining.
- 18:58Thank you. I enjoyed this. Awesome. And Thank you to our listeners for tuning in to another.