Latest / Jew York Times / Who is Gadi Eisenkot And Can He Defeat Bibi Netanyahu? (Ft Shanie Reichman from Israel Policy Forum)
Transcript
- Eitan Levine: Welcome to the Jew York Times. On today's episode, we are doing the Gotti Eisencott Explainer. It is the first episode, kind of a preview episode of the 120 Angry Seats Initiative limited series that I'm doing here. joining me for the first time is Shawnee Reichman from Israel Policy Forum. We st Shanie: Totally got both parts of the name wrong. Eitan Levine: No, my god, what did I get? It's Reichman. This is an Ashkenazi Jewish podcast, okay? We go hard in it, but I will do it Reichmann. Shani Reichmann and is it not Israel Policy Forum? Shanie: Shani Reichman. Yeah, with a sheen. Nope, it is Israel policy form. At least you got that. It's shiny. I told you it's I am like an iambic pentameter. The emphasis in the second half Eitan Levine: we'll respect it. Shani Reichman, from Israel Policy Forum. The way this started, by the way, is that with the upcoming elections in Israel, which is going to be happening in the late in late October, Shanie: Thank you, thank you. Eitan Levine: These are the most closely watched elections that are gonna be happening in Israeli's history. I think that everyone in the world is glued to this in a way where they've been exposed to Israel a little bit too much over the past couple of years. And because of that, everyone is gonna g glued into this election. The thing is, the Israeli election system and the government in general is complicated as hell. I don't understand that as like someone that thinks I know, you know, I know more than the average person, but definitely not as an expert level. So with the election coming up, I thought it was a really good opportunity to work with people that do understand this in a way that I don't understand this, which is why Shane Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum is gonna be joining us. Shanie, before we get into the Israel stuff that I wanna cover today, quickly the question because we're gonna do just a general Jewish story that is happening because this is this is the New York Times. I do want to talk a little bit about DSA candidates and do a general just state of the Iran war and where we're at with everything. and then we will end this with the Gaudi Isencott explainer episode. Gaudi Isencott is someone who has been trending over the past couple of weeks in the Israeli elections for the past couple of months. People have thought this was a battle between Netanyahu and Bennett. That changed over the past couple of days and I got he is gonna be a major player. so I'm super excited to have you on to talk about that. So all the stories and more on today's episode of the JU York Times. Sing it with me, Shani. Yay da day. Shanie: my God. enough to do that song. Eitan Levine: Not even a little bit. That's what the this is a diversity of of Jewish spectrum that we have on this on this podcast. Shani, first question that I have for you. over the past couple of weeks, DSA has really taken over the Democrat Party. right before I left, Daria Litza and Claire Valdez won their primaries, unseating incumbents. yesterday or two days ago, Melot Kiros won her primary in Denver. The common thread between all these people is that they are trash humans who hate Jews. I think that there is no other way to explain this. If you look back on the stuff that they have said, it they've said awful, awful things. Things that should have been disqualifying. that unfortunately some you know, nowadays you can have a Nazi tattoo on your chest. It's fine. I've got three and I'm running. Shanie: consensus. One with ink. As long as you hate Israel, you can still run for office if you have a Nazi tattoo. Eitan Levine: You could literally do it. And that was this trend kind of started with the Grand Platiner with Grant Platiner's primary run, where it came out that he had the Nazi tattoo and then just other stuff that he had said, and it really became this thing of if you just come out and say that you hate APAC, you can kind of steal a primary. Shanie: You too can run for Congress. Eitan Levine: You can unseat Susan Collins for the low, low price of covering up your Nazi tattoo and saying you hate APAC. I don't take APAC money by the way. Sheney, we're not taking APAC money. Shanie: Mm-hmm. good to know. was... No, no, never. Of course not. Wait, but we are looking for sponsorships. Are they interested? Eitan Levine: Not on this podcast. Milo Kiros Yes. Lockheed Bardin is the only place that we'll take from. Yeah. By the way, I just want to say this is a complete aside. World Cup happening right now. Tell me yes or no. Every team should have a patch on their jersey of the country that pays their defense budget. Okay? Shanie: I only take money from defense firms, just so you know. Yeah, but it's all good. It's only gonna be two countries. Eitan Levine: I know, yeah I that's what I'm saying. I want like y Israel's got the America patch, Lebanon's got the Iran patch, Iran's got the China Russia patch, Lebanon should have a three-way China Russia Iran patch. Tell them to do this. Shanie: Russia Pass, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's good. We'll just make it really like two way competition. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Mel Kiros won in the Denver primary. She is a fascinating person because she was saying that the firebom was happening on the march in Denver a couple maybe I guess two years ago at this point, maybe a year and a half ago at this point where someone did die, she said it wasn't an anti-Semitic attack. I'm saying all of that because the larger question that is happening in the Jewish community right now, it's not even a conversation, it's everyone broadly freaking out. And as is with everything. There is some justif there's a lot of justification in one way of handling it, and there's a lot of justification in another way of handling it. And I think the big question that everyone is having right now is should we be freaking out? Is this the end of days? Is America turning into 1930s Berlin? Are we are, you know, we're gonna start seeing you know, Jewish businesses get get bricks thrown at them and government officials turning us in, which is what a lot of the internet, a lot of the Jewish community is thinking. Or is it just not that bad? So yeah. Shanie: Okay, first of all, there have definitely been Jewish mythos that have already had bricks thrown out them, I can guarantee that. But not a Kristallnacht, yeah. Eitan Levine: Hundred percent. I a hundred percent. I'm saying that this is i in a government sponsored, like it's totally okay kind of way. Shanie: I don't think it's gonna be government sponsored. Anti-Semitism is getting worse. I don't think it's not getting worse. Like I'm a worrier. You're talking to a worrier in general. Which by the way, it's a little bit ironic because I work on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and I'm like always staying optimistic on that. But when it comes to America, I'm like, we're fucked. Eitan Levine: Good. Yeah. You're looking at the 3,000-year-old crisis and being like, this is fixable. America, the Democrat Party, unfortunately, not fixable at all. Shanie: Fixable, for sure. Eitan Levine: It is getting worse. Shanie: No, I've the DSA stuff's really bad. It's really bad and the fact that Israel is taking up so much space, it's like all consuming in the discourse, it's the defining feature of what party you subscribe to and where you land. Like that's a massive problem. Like do you hate Israel? Do you not hate Israel? Shouldn't be the one thing that is the defining feature of your campaign, of your party, of who you align with, right? Like you have people on the left. Support me like Tucker Carlson has a point Candace Owens has a point What's the point that the one point that they'd agree with is they hate Israel? So yeah, it's that's pretty terrible Do I think it's gonna permeate like American public opinion and how Americans writ large-view Jews I don't think most I mean I don't think this that their support for the idea and like surveys polling that most Americans hate Jews Me doesn't mean they don't hold some negative opinions or like stereotyping of Jews for sure But overall, Americans are friendly people to us. I hope that remains. I think it gets harder every day with the ongoing conflict, especially now that America is extra involved with Iran. That overcomplicates it because we could talk about that too, but Americans hate war. Americans really hate war that was ostensibly about regime change. Americans really, really, really hate war that affects their economy and their gas prices. So, yeah. The more that they blame Israel for a war that they're dragged into the worse it gets and that matters way more than anything that's gonna happen in Gaza even though all the DSA stuff is of course about that. Eitan Levine: It's all I mean, that's a that reason is why I think that like between now and the actual general election, Israel's gotta shut the fuck up for like a minute. There's never been a better time for everyone to kind of step away from the Israel conversation. Like nothing else should happen essentially until the general election. Because I do think, like you said, gas prices, the economy is gonna hit a wall. In December. Like there's a lot of there's a lot of like storms that are kind of hitting each other in a way where Israel being artificially made the number one topic. Whoever is in charge of polling, whoever in charge of messaging, the messaging should be Israel is not as important as it is as it is being made. And I do think that that logic does hit outside of DSA. Why I so my personal opinion is like freak out, but Mart, but like within reason. I think the first thing is that DSA pulls a negative 20% across all registered voters, negative 27%. The general election, right now, I think there's two DSA candidates that are in Congress. After the general election, there's gonna be about five to seven, depending on how they go. Maybe, maybe, maybe one senator, maybe one senator. And to be honest, that one senator is the Grand Platten or Susan Collins. election and we're that is gonna be a mess. W the stuff that is about to come out, the opposition research that is about to come out, the entire campaign is gonna be completely different with the lead up to the actual election in Maine. And I do think that Shanie: We're gonna find out a second Nazi tattoo on his butt. Eitan Levine: Yeah, a way bigger one. What if it was Israel's pre nineteen sixty-seven borders just on his back? And then it is it's pointing to Osama bin Laden kissing Bush. Shanie: way bigger. Mm. was too far. Eitan Levine: Under a mission accomplished banner. All the back. But there's a in the general election is going to be a big telling sign of this. I think at the general election, then we start freaking out. I think that there is a time when we can freak out. But I just don't see DSA is just not pop socialism, not popular with the rest of America. It's very popular in the places you would think it is popular. It's very popular in New York. It's very popular, you know, in Los Angeles. And then another thing, sorry, when I say very popular, 66,000 voters. It did the primary, there's 750,000 registered voters. the answer to what happened was yes, anti-Semitism. But the bigger headline from all of this was voter turnout and college-aged voters in gentrified neighbor neighborhoods being dorks who actually vote in primaries. And that is what shifted this. And it happened during the Democrat primary when Cuomo didn't beat Mom Donnie and it happened here and it will continue to happen until the Democrat, Central Democrats to figure out a way to rally people to go and vote in elections where they don't normally vote in a way where only nerds vote. And who do nerds vote for? Over educated theater nerds that, you know, went to Tish and have a hundred thousand dollars of debt in puppet design? They vote for Dorial Litza, they vote for Claire Valdez, you know, and that doesn't reflect the larger community. So I think that between now and the general election, the big thing is to keep on pushing away from Israel. Don't bring up Israel. We should be running away from the topic. Shanie: So yes, and that's going to be way harder because we're talking election season in Israel. And if you don't think there's going to be a million embarrassing, maybe racist, crazy quotes coming out of Israel during election season, then you haven't been following election season in Israel very well because it's always a mess. The types of things that Israelis need and want to hear ahead of an election are roughly the opposite of what anyone in America wants to hear coming out of Israel. So, you know, we can cross our fingers, but Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: can't guarantee what it together. What I will say is actually think it's looking like it could be a more moderate election cycle in Israel because Netanyahu is trying to pull a play for the center because a little stressed by Bennett and Eisenkot. So it's possible that he won't come out with as crazy, crazy shit as last time. Last time was pretty bad. Eitan Levine: Well, I mean, I guess I sorry, now that I'm like rethinking about this, which is hilarious. By the way, this is the podcast. Normally the the daily, they edit this out. Okay. We're not editing that out. The daily, you have a Claire tennis getter or whoever. She has no idea when the elections are either. And I'll and I challenge her to fight about that. but I guess the answer is then, is that if there is a change in in regime out here, then Shanie: you Eitan Levine: I mean, that's an interesting element of the election where if the Israelis do end up voting out Netanyahu, doing the one thing that America had asked them to do over and over and over and over, then I'm curious what effect that does have on the election, where the average voter is no longer like juiced up about Israel because they view Netanyahu as one of the stopgaps to keeping the region from settling fully. So if you get rid of him, you know, does it kind of like reset? A little bit in someone's brain. Yeah. Shanie: Calm down, calm down. I don't think it's gonna take five days to reset the relationship before the midterms here. Eitan Levine: Maybe everyone moves to everyone's moving. Listen, I think that the average American voter is gonna be moving to Tel Aviv within the within the month and you heard it. Shanie: So I heard it here first. No, I'm one of the people who's pretty optimistic. I think that a different government that's not Netanyahu would make a huge difference in the American political discourse around Israel and certainly how American Jews feel, certainly how American politicians will feel, but it's going to take more than five days and there's a lot that has to come along with it. But there's like a couple of fronts that I think will be different. If you have like a Bennett-Lepied-Eisenkot type of government, which we could call like a unity government of sorts, because it has like folks in the right and the left and the center. Although sometimes when people say unity government, they mean still having the Senyawan charge just with like Lapid and Bennett replacing Ben, Gver, and Smotrich, which is not my preferred route. I think it'll make a difference because the rhetoric is a huge piece of it. Like just not having crazy rhetoric shuffling out day after day after day from the government makes a really big difference. You have it. I think a pretty substantial difference in how things are operating in the West Bank on settler violence, stuff like that. And it wouldn't look that different in Gaza probably, but at least you would begin to see some semblance of a plan is my hope, especially with someone like Gadi Isenka who's been talking a long time about needing a long-term national security doctrine. I think that's something he would really... Eitan Levine: Let's let's actually then start the conversation on Gaudi Isencott. So I guess this is the soft launch to 120 Angry Chairs, the run-up to the Israeli election. In this election, the the two names have have always been Benjamin Netanyahu and Atali Bennett. over the past couple of weeks, there had been a new challenger that has been that has started to rise in prominence, who is having one of those like Mamdani-esque, a little bit like out of nowhere but shooting star moments that is happening at a really opportune time. And his name is Gaudi Eisencott. Chanee, who is this man? Shanie: First of all, we call this a Benny Gantz moment in Israel. We don't call it a Mamdani moment, okay? Because Benny Gantz was a IDF chief of staff, came onto the scene, everyone got super excited about him, rising star, RIP, you know, could be short-lived, but that's where it does happen. He was IDF chief of staff. That is like the highest you can possibly be in the military, which in Israel matters a lot because everybody knows Israel. Like obviously that matters a lot. IDF is the... Eitan Levine: Sorry, sorry, you're right. Shanie: only institution in Israeli society that Israelis overwhelmingly trust. They have like a ton of trust in the IDF compared to judiciary, police, government, Knesset, anybody else. Eitan Levine: In America that that ent that institution is Bucky's. Shanie: By the way, Americans also trust the military more than they trust other institutions, but it's still like way lower. Like Israelis, it's 90 % of them trust the IDF. So that's insanely high. Eitan Levine: Interesting. Yeah. I mean it's it it is so part of like the fabric of society here where everyone had to go through service at some point. I mean, most people had to go through service at one point. Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: Yeah, it's a people's army. It's a people's army, so it makes sense people are gonna trust it. And so having someone who like ran the military that they trust so much is really valuable. So that's a big part of why you see him rising, but there's like, there's a lot more to it. Eitan Levine: Can you just give me like the who is he? Where is he from? And then I also do want to hit specifically on social ca on social class, because there's a major difference between where Gaudi came from and where Benjamin Netanyahu came from that I think plays really interesting into the selection. Shanie: Yeah. Yeah, so gaudi is the son of moroccan immigrants. So he would if he were the prime minister, he'd be the first mizrahi prime minister, which is amazing. Although and so there's like a somewhat of a belief that he could bring in a mizrahi vote i'm not so convinced some of us remember putting afi ghabai at the top of the labor party seat just because you put a brown guy at the top of your list doesn't mean you're to bring mizrahi voters, but it's possible and either way it would be a huge milestone to see that he's also from a lat Which is the actual periphery? I just need to say that because in Israel if you live 45 minutes from Tel Aviv you tell people you live in the periphery But it's like living in Long Island and saying that you're from South Dakota. He's from actually South Dakota, which is a lot and And that like definitely changes things in turn when you compare him to BB Netanyahu Who's from Rehavia really fancy academic neighborhood in Jerusalem from like a very well-to-do very educated family Eitan Levine: I Mm-hmm. Shanie: comparatively got the eyes and cut with his broken English that they might make fun of him for, but he's like the everyday people's man. And that also means a lot. People are looking for that authenticity sometimes. It is kind of, on the one hand, people really like that Netanyahu is like clean cut and presentable and perfect English and intellectual and academic, but there's something really nice and comforting about someone who's like your uncle, you know. Eitan Levine: Is there does that not come is that not a problem? Because obviously, like the Israelis and the Americans have to work together so closely. Gotti Azokat does not speak like Benjamin Detanyahu. Benjamin Detanyahu has lived in America. You know, he it seems like he's basically in America all the damn time hanging out with the Adelsons or whoever. But like, this is an American dude. He's had to, he deals with Trump. He he talks to Trump in a very direct way that I don't think that Gotti has an ability to because he's not able to like shoot the shit. In the same way that I think that Netanyahu would be able to, does having an Israeli prime minister who can really speak English in a very like well in a very good way, does is that important? Shanie: Let him make Naphtali Bennett as foreign minister. Perfect English. Yair Lapid, foreign minister. Great. I mean, is like doing pretty well. The guy doesn't speak a word of English. I don't want to say Gadi Eisengad doesn't speak, Zelensky doesn't really speak English. I mean, you've world leaders all over who don't speak English. Gadi does speak English. It's just not, doesn't feel like an Anglo speaking English. It feels like your Israeli uncle speaking English. It's a little bit different. But I don't worry about it. Eitan Levine: There go. That is pretty. Agree or disag agree or disagree to the statement, it's not the worst thing to maybe have an Israeli Prime Minister that doesn't you know, that isn't so fluent. That maybe maybe is a little bit to the side. Shanie: I, yeah, who doesn't translate every thought into English? Maybe it'll be better for us. Eitan Levine: Exactly. so Gotti comes from the like you said, the periphery. For my listeners who don't don't know the concept, but the more center, the more the richer areas that that is I don't know what the term is, but basically everything outside of that, the parts that are on the literal periphery of the map, looked upon as like you said, like the South Dakota E, more the the the salt of the earth, I don't even know what to say. Yeah. Shanie: Less bougie, less bougie, it's more lower and middle class. They tend not to go as often to the elite units. By the way, he went to Golaní, which is also like the every man's unit. Netanyahu and a lot of these other folks went to like the really, really elite units that are overwhelmingly Ashkenazi and overwhelmingly from people in the center. And he didn't. He went to this like much more common Golaní unit and then worked his way up, which I think also demonstrates that it's not in Israel. There's like protechia, like nepotism. is a huge thing in the army in particular and in general in Israel. And he clearly didn't have any of that. And I think that demonstrates that he just worked his ass off and people really like and respect that. And people really trust him because of it, I think, not just because of that. If you've ever watched an interview with him, you can see he has that feeling of someone you can trust. He seems like he's, yeah. Eitan Levine: Talk to me about I was gonna say talk to me about Netanyahu's nep nepotism. I mean, this is a guy who th the term the term has used his brother dies during the raid of An in Antebbe. Now, the a war hero. And once again, BB was also in these elite units and everything. So a lot of people have accused him, you know, I I don't know if it's the correct thing to accuse him about like using his brother's death in order to push his political career. Who am I to say? Shanie: a war hero. Eitan Levine: BB ends up getting ends up kind of using that and using like the nepot the the military nepotism in order to push his career forward in a way that Gaudi Eisencott did not. Is that accurate? Shanie: I don't know if I would say that because I think that there's a lot of people who The reason it's interesting you're bringing that up is because Gadi Isengard actually lost his son and two nephews in this war. Not to say that he's using that. I don't think that at all. But it's almost an interesting parallel because he lost his son, Gail, a 25-year-old reservist in December 2023, really early in the war in Gaza, and he lost two nephews. I think that's part of why people feel he's trustworthy and that he's actually joining politics because he cares about the country. Eitan Levine: Mm. In yeah, yeah. Shanie: and wants to make it better and not for his political ambitions because these are bereaved family members and Generally speaking I think Israelis feel a kinship with bereaved families other than the far-right ministers who yell at them the Knesset But everybody else feels a kinship with bereaved families and I would not I wouldn't say like using or not using I think it's part of their story and Politics are really about who what made you who you are people ask you really personal things They dig up really personal things and they want to talk to you about it And then in terms of Netanyahu, he nepotizes every, look at many of these, I mean, Bougie Hurtzog, who I really like, the president, like he's, you know, was the son and nephew of Abba Eban, son of, you know, chief, his father's chief rabbi, UN ambassador, all that. So you can see these kind of lineages in general. I don't think Netanyahu is unique in that. His father was an academic intellectual, but yes, it's very different to have like a Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: bootstraps kind of guy. Obviously this like a Moroccan family in a lot is very different from an academic family in Jerusalem. Eitan Levine: Out out of curiosity, how how does the deaths in his family with this war come up in this election? Have they come up? Is it something that is talked about or something that's kind of like acknowledged and then, you know, not really brought up? Shanie: I've seen it talked about in a pretty respectful normal way. I think it makes it much harder for Netanyahu to criticize him. So he'll say things like, these are valuable perspectives because they're very emotional because you lost your kid. And you can't just say, attack him, right? You have to be a lot more sensitive and work around it. So it affects it in that sense. I think he has to be a lot more careful what he says about Gadi because he lost his son. He doesn't want to piss off bereaved families because then they will come for you. By the way, today is... I think a thousand days since the war started, I believe. And so there's a lot of families are like engaging in activism and advocacy today, generally anti-government activism and advocacy today. So I'm curious what kind of coverage that's going to get amidst the election cycle. Eitan Levine: It is a thousand days. Yeah. I'm actually going to the one of the marches that is happening this afternoon. I I guess that's another seven o'clock. No, I did. I put put it on Instagram. I'm in on this podcast. I'm in Israel, by the way. That's a good point. Guys, I'm in Tel Aviv. Yeah. That's right. I have it. Shine is in America like a traitor. and then I am here defending the home front. I Okay. The that okay, that does play into this though, because Shanie: You didn't tell anyone that you're in Israel. I mean, I know you're in Israel, but like the people listening don't know. Yeah. You kept saying here. Ha Eitan Levine: Thousand days, it's been a thousand days of since October 7th. Is that the what it's a thousand days since October 7th? That's the the landmark that is happening. Gaudis family or Gaudia's family members that pass in in recent wars. Those wars have been run by Bibi. Does that ever play into it? Is there ever because there is a general sentiment in Israel, is there a general sentiment in Israel or people Are annoyed that the wars are still going and that there's more conflicts that are that keep on popping up. Do they view Gaudi's family po passing in those wars as as something deeper than just him passing Or do they see that as kind of society's been dealing with the same exact thing that Gaudi has been dealing with? And they're seeing BB as one of the reasons why everyone is dealing with the same thing. Shanie: So I think it plays into, I think the war conversation plays into the elections conversation, but not necessarily because of his son. He went into the government with Benny Gantz in 2023, like this emergency government after October 7th, where Netanyahu said to them, listen, if you don't come in and join my war cabinet, Batsala Smotrich and Itzamar Ben-Gurir are gonna be running this war. So you better get here. And they did. And many people supported it. A lot of people didn't, but they did join and... Gaudi was known for really pushing for a hostage deal at every possible moment. And he continued to push for a hostage deal. Eventually in June 2024, he resigned because of how Netanyahu was handling the war. Now, in retrospect, some people would criticize him. Some people on the right would say, because if you're pushing for a hostage deal, it means you're pushing for at least a pause, if not an end to the war. And he often was. He was saying, like, let's not go further. Let's just take a deal and bring them home and figure out Hamas later or figure out the Philadelphia corridor or a fiat or like somewhere else later. Eitan Levine: Like that's not Shanie: And that is controversial in right-wing circles. But I also think a lot of people appreciate that he was kind of standing up for the hostages, which was a pretty consensus issue in Israel. Eitan Levine: for us. talk to me a little bit about his just political career. So he he starts to rise the ranks, he goes through the different military different military faction not factions, different military sections. How does he get into politics? Shanie: Mm hmm. Yeah. So that was his first time in politics was in 2022, joining Benny Gantz's Kacholavan blue and white slate. You might remember in 2019, there were three elections in one year. a five year period, over from 2019 to 2022, there were five elections in Israel, which is pretty insane. He stayed out of all of them until the last one, which helps because it was kind of a disaster shit show to have like election after election after election. And so a lot of people were tainted by it. Like it kind of killed Benny Gantz in a lot of ways. Like it can kind of kill your career to be associated with this like cycle of elections that feels never ending. And he didn't start joining until the last one, which I think helps him a lot. And then he's known for kind of joining with Benny Gantz, who was, you know, pretty mainstream centrist center right guy and joining in the war cabinet when the time came and when like he felt it was necessary for the country. So generally people are supportive of that. And he didn't join right away. Like he ended, he also, I don't know if he's it's legal to join right after you end as chief of staff. I think you have to wait a few years before you join politics, and he did. Eitan Levine: Yeah. H how did he get involved in this election? Shanie: He launched his party, which is called Yashar, which means like straight, which I think is like kind of the vibe he's going for. Like I'm gonna tell you like it is, I'm gonna tell Israelis what they need to hear, even if they don't want to hear it. And I can give you some examples of him like kind of being known for that. And I'm gonna tell Netanyahu what he needs to hear, right? Even when he doesn't wanna hear it. So I think that that kind of helps him. And I can tell you a little bit about some of the folks on his slate also, but he's trying to fill it with. like more professionals is what he's saying. He's saying he's gonna have 50 % women on the slate and a third young people. So that's awesome. He's trying to bring in the professionals. He's really focused on education. He's focused on the economy, brain drain. So I'll just tell you some of the names people might recognize them. Shaul Meridor, who ran the Ministry of Energy before. By the way, Israel has way too many ministries. That's a separate issue. Costs tons of money for no reason. Anyway. Eitan Levine: Yeah. I'm standing but I'm right across the street from the Ministry of Click, which is the decision on what kind of new chocolates to add to the click lineup. Government run, obviously. Yeah. Shanie: Ha Mmm. Of course, socialism. So Sholomery Dor is the son of Don Meridor, who is a Likud justice minister who turned on Netanyahu and is now a big government critic. Matan Kahana, who was a member of Knesset from Gantz's List, he wears a kippah. He's a B'nei Akiva kid. Rioram Cohen, who was the former head of the Shin Bet, so also like big security guy. Also Mizrahi, his parents are from Afghanistan, also wears a kippah. So like... I'm saying all that because identity politics are relevant. Having more people who wear kippot on your slate does make a difference. Having more Mizrachim on your slate makes a difference. I hope having more women on your slate makes a difference. And some of the women, Orit Farkasha Cohen, who was also in blue and white before she resigned, Sayyiri Faraghan, who's more of like a civil servant, Imbar Harushkiti, who led defense ministries, directed for promoting the, what is it called, recruitment integration of Kharedim in the IDF. That's something Gadi cares a ton about. Similar to Ben and Lapid, he's constantly talking about the draft of ultra-orthodox, is you, I'm sure know you probably got stuck in traffic because of it the other day, with all the protests. Eitan Levine: yeah. Well I was participating. I was cla I put on a black hat and I was scaling the side of the building to show. I okay, so let's let's talk about the actual policies then. what is he what what is he running on? What is he what is he planning on doing? Shanie: Yeah, I would say number one that I'll talk about, even though it's not, I don't think it's the most important issue to him, but it's relevant to the Netanyahu piece is the commission of inquiry. There is a deep desire, I think 80 to 90 % of Israelis want to have a real commission of inquiry into October 7th, which means to investigate what happened, to investigate who's involved. Obviously Netanyahu claims he wants that, but he wants to do, advance a very political version where basically his own members of Knesset. investigate themselves. don't really understand how that works, they kind of, the government investigates the government. Great. Eitan Levine: It's the Pinky Promise Commission, okay? Everyone, pinky promises. Shanie: Commission of Inquiry is a huge thing for him. Obviously, it's going to implicate Bibi Netanyahu an enormous amount. Although we should say, Gadi Aizenkot, he was the IDF Chief of Staff until 2019. This happened years later. But everybody involved in the security establishment also has some culpability. And he's acknowledged that, too. Everyone in the security establishment has basically taken responsibility for October 7th and apologized to the Israeli people. Everyone besides Netanyahu, obviously, couldn't possibly. He made a joke this week. Someone asked him what's changed since October 7th and he said he lost some weight and laughed about it So that didn't really do well on primetime is really news you can imagine It was it was pretty horrifying to watch he Eitan Levine: No no did the jokes just bomb in the room also? Was everyone like Wasn't also like his first like town hall he's done in a minute? Shanie: I think I saw him like kind of just walking on the street being asked. I don't think it was like as formal, but yeah, no, it was not great. Eitan Levine: He okay, so what are the other what are the other things that Gotti is running on? Shanie: Yeah, draft law. As I said, in Hebrew it's ch'ivyon banetel, which is like sharing the burden. obviously vast, vast majority of ultra-orthodox men do not serve in the military. The government claims that like 10 % of them do, but it's not accurate. They're including like modern orthodox boys. They're including people who were formerly ultra-orthodox. The real numbers are like one to 2 % of ultra-orthodox. Men serving in the military. So obviously that's really controversial in a time where you if I have friends I'm sure you have friends you've done 300 days of reserve duty over the past thousand days, right? People going in and out and in and out and out constantly You also have an issue of the IDF capturing in Lebanon capturing and Gaza, too They capture a place and then they like have to leave because they don't have enough soldiers to hold it So they go back and you keep hearing them recapture the same place three or four times, which is crazy And so all this is it's a little funny, but there's a massive shortage Eitan Levine: That's kinda funny though. Shanie: People are, Israelis are pissed. Like if you pull a non-Haredi, non-Arab Israelis, everybody else, it's like the most consensus they get Israel is they need to draft all tour thugs. It's like the only thing they all agree on is they want them to serve in the military. So he is a huge, usually in favor of this and talks about it all the time as a military guy. Eitan Levine: Is question here is that like you know BB has been able to court has been able to stay in power by courting you know the religious side and getting them to vote on his in his slate under by saying you know like you you don't have to serve or whatever. And then actually I remember at the UTJ stopped endorsing him because he wasn't going hard enough into it but is there there is a way to get those 61 seats control the government without having the Haredi voting block Shanie: Mm-hmm. Can Netanyahu be in government without them, or can anybody? Eitan Levine: No, no, no. No, no, no. Eisencott is able to, is what I'm saying. Is that Eisencott is able while while B B has been using that as a sticking point to remain in government, Isencott, is he able to to become the prime minister? Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: Mm. Yeah, he doesn't need them. I mean, it obviously depends how the polls look. I can tell you what some of the numbers are. He'll likely need Rahman Mansour Abbas's Arab party, but it is possible. Again, we're months out of the election, so I don't want to say for sure. But Netanyahu really needs it because Naftali Bennett's not sitting with Netanyahu. Yair Lapid, not sitting with Netanyahu. Yair Golan, Arabs, not sitting with Netanyahu. Actually Mansour Abbas, give him enough of what he wants and he might, but anyway, it will be hard. Eitan Levine: Is it so talk to me about that? Like, is Rom gonna go with Isencott? Is Isencot willing to work with the Arab slates? Shanie: I've been watching Naftali Bennett and Gadi Isaachut skirt around this issue in some of their Hebrew interviews. And they keep saying, it's not that we will or won't work with Arab parties. We will wait and see if we work with any Zionist parties that support Israel as a Jewish and democratic state. And they keep using language that anyone supports the Declaration of Independence, et cetera. And they keep saying, right now, we haven't seen that there's an Arab party that does that. Ram Mansour Abbas, like, he does do that. My guess, you heard this here first, my assumption is that Mansour Abbas is going to use different, more overt language closer to when coalitions are happening. And then they're going to say, look, he said what we need him to say, now we can join. That's my assumption. I think it's pretty obvious. And Mansour Abbas is very happy, like he said in the last government, like he doesn't need to be involved in war Israel-Palestine decisions. Like he understands that they're not going to be aligned. He wants to deal with crime in Arab society. Which is a huge issue for their community and he wants to like fix the education system and get funding like social welfare programs That's what he cares about. He's also supportive because by the way gadi eisenkot also wants all arab citizens to do national service so that everyone's serving the country, recognizing that like military service doesn't necessarily make sense and when sorabas supports that too generally, so it's actually makes a lot of sense. I think to work with him. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: And but but I don't think he's going to be willing or able to say that and neither is Natalia Bennett until until after the elections because people are still like a little bit racist. Eitan Levine: Just a little bit. I mean, listen, who amongst us? I is there what are the other what are the other issues that Gotti is running on that are different than B B? Shanie: I was talking a lot about education and I should say education is really tied to the Haradi issue too because there's not, I'm trying to think of the word in English, like core studies, core curriculum, science, math, English, things like that don't exist in ultra-orthodox boys schools for the most part. They exist a little in the girls schools, but obviously that's a huge barrier. I mean, I would say it's more of a, yeah. Eitan Levine: There's a joke there by the way about Jews only teaching women how to talk. That is that is a pretty funny thing. Shanie: Yeah, I the girls are, there's a recognition that the girls are going to go on and have jobs, whereas the boys are going to more study or teach Torah, things like that. And so he's very in favor of saying that all four of the education, you have four educational systems in Israel. You have a totally secular one, you have Arab one, you have modern Orthodox, religious Zionist, and you have Haredi. And he says all four of them, he doesn't frame it only as a Haredi issue, but he says all of them need to teach the values of the Declaration of Independence. They all need to teach about civics and about democracy and rule of law and mandatory service, plus all the course studies, because we need a new generation of pilots and doctors and scientists. So he talks a lot about that. I've heard of the way Naftali Bennett speaks about it as much harsher. I heard him saying, if you want to have a Haredi school, it doesn't teach English, math, whatever, fine, fund it yourselves. And he always says, like, it's the Brooklyn model. Like in Brooklyn, like you have a private school, you teach whatever you want. By the way, it's not true. In America. You have an obligation, whether it's a public school or a private school, you have to teach your kids English. You have to teach your kids math, science. It's an obligation. it's not just, it happens to me they don't, but like it is the law. It's not like, if it's a private school, you don't have to teach your kids. it's. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, but they don't though. Yeah. Let me just say that that that's Benny not explaining the situation correctly. The real situation is just don't do it and then don't tell us. The way that the way to do it is to do what the Hajj Siddhem did with Mamdani and just, you know, they want bike lanes and food stamps. And you know, they'll say whatever in order to get that. are there any are there any differences between sorry, I i did he have more points than he was running on? Shanie: You Yeah. Yeah, he does. So he has a lot on education, a lot on the economy. He talks about brain drain. There are a lot of Israelis left during the war, and a lot of them are obviously the educated upper class doctors, lawyers, pilots, et cetera, the bougie folk. And he wants to bring them back because of serious brain drain in Israel, and it's only going to get worse over time by every estimate. And so he's working on how do we bring them back and how do we incentivize coming back. So that's a big piece of it as well, which I think is great. And when he had his party launch, I guess it is, he had each of his six people on his list so far come up and give a talk, and one covered education, one economy, one, you know, they each had their own thing that they talked about. Eitan Levine: Is there anything that he disagrees on with Bennett? Shanie: Not really that I've seen. Like maybe there are some nuances here and there. Bennett has a different way he talks about things. Bennett identifies as someone who's on the right and of the right, but they definitely both agree on the Haridi draft. They definitely both agree on education broadly. I'm sure they both agree on like brain drain. I Bennett's coming from the tech sector. He's very much like... Eitan Levine: Actually Ben is coming from Teaneck, New Jersey, I think just constantly coming back and forth from there. a general qu okay, so what are the knocks on on Gotti Asacai? I remember when right when you started talking, you said that he had said some things or or to or whatever. So what what are the knocks on him? Shanie: Also true. Yeah, First of all, I do think people really like him the main knock people are hitting on him and the the BB the Likud ads are that he doesn't speak English Generally people really like Gotti Eisen Gotti is considered very trustworthy and he's considered to be someone partially because they mentioned his son was killed and partially because of his whole demeanor He's really perceived as someone not out for himself and not politically ambitious But I did want to bring up the Elora Zaria case because I think it's interesting. it is something that, like, it was the first thing that came to my mind when I heard his name mentioned again. Maybe it would be different if I lived in Israel. I shared with you a music video that you maybe understood 30 % of, but at least could acknowledge it was hilarious. In Eretz Nehderet, Israel's SNL had a skit years ago. This was 10 years ago, I should say. Elora Zaria was an IDF medic. Eitan Levine: Shout out Duolingo, by the way. Shanie: who showed up on a scene. There was a terrorist who had, I believe, stabbed a soldier. He was already neutralized on the ground, not moving. And the soldiers who were handling the scene were around and handling it. And he was a combat medic who walked over and shot the guy dead. And it was a complete violation of IDF rule of law, IDF code of ethics. It was very obviously something he should go to military prison for, or at least be on trial for. And Gadi Eisenkot said as much. Netanyahu and his Netanyahu originally agreed, because it was so like it was a really black and white issue, honestly. Elora Azaria claimed that he felt threatened, but there was like it was caught on film and there was no reason to believe that that was the case. So it's like a very clean, like black and white situation. Obviously, the chief of staff, like he was someone who really cared about the rule of law. And as is evidenced by him kind of going against the grain, you have Netanyahu and all of his like right wing folks, Avigdor Lieberman in particular. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: Saying like no this could have been anyone's kid, right? Which is a perception when the soldier does something wrong It's like no, he could have been my son He could have my nephew could have my brother and so it really humanizes them even if what they're doing is objectively wrong So anyhow, he ended up in prison for nine months of an eight serving nine months of an 18 month sentence but gadi was someone who like came out and And supported him him going to prison in support of the trial which is also getting a little bit involved in the politics, although he didn't do it until it was pretty further in. What's also like, he was really attacked for this. And so you can see in the video the phrase, Gadi, Gadi, tiz'er, Rabin mechapes chaveir, which is, Gadi, watch out, Rabin, Yitzhak Rabin, is looking for a friend. So it's a threat to assassinate him. And these were like mobs chanting and harassing him, but you can see it was the Beit Har Yerushalayim. Eitan Levine: Who and wait, who and who was saying that, by the way? Shanie: Crew that you can see in the music video with their like yellow scarves yelling about it So, you know people were really attacking him and talking about him a lot at the time It's I should say if this happened today that Laura's aria case like it would not it would barely break the news cycle. Okay like it's Eitan Levine: Yeah. Like I said before before we got on here, if if someone proposes on the Empire's Day building, then all of a sudden the news from the day is a hundred percent off. And by the way, the Baytar fans, for those at home, you don't know Baytar fans, they are Philadelphia sports fans. It is the same exact thing. These are a hateful group of bigots. And that is what it is. You know, and they they obviously they're they're a right wing anti Arab, anti anything, literally anti everything, group of of soccer fans that Shanie: Ha ha ha. In Jerusalem, I saw Betar O'Mavit, like, like, Betar or Death written on, like, on the Jerusalem stone graffiti everywhere when I was just there. Eitan Levine: Weirdly, yeah. It's also funny because you compare that to the other, like the the slogan for Hapoel Tel Aviv is we hate the management. Like that's it's like a way different vibe at the other games. what else do we have to know about Gaudi Eisencott? Shanie: Yeah He could be the prime minister. Yeah, let me tell you the numbers. Ha'ara has a site that like compiles all the different polls, but it's not working for me right now, unfortunately, but I do recommend that. Eitan Levine: Yeah. Shanie: But it looks like Likud is around 24 seats with Aizenkot around 22, which is really close. And then you have the Bennett-Lapid merger at 17. Again, that fluctuates within like five seats all the time. If you ask Channel 14 news, Bibi's going to get like 40 seats on his own, which is not, not going to, that's like totally out of touch with reality. But my point being, it depends on the time of day that you're asking and who you're asking and how you're asking. But, but still puts him neck and neck with Netanyahu, which is like a pretty big deal. He hasn't even released most of his list. Eitan Levine: Yeah is there here's my question. What was or was there an instigating event that pushed Gotti to surge in the polls? Well at the same time, because the the beat story to this is that the Lapide Bennett coalition or the party that had been formed has been slipping. like you said, they're only at like 17 votes. Shanie: Yeah, he's taking their seats. He's objectively taking their seats. He's taking a little from Likub, but he's taking from them. I mean, he just launched his party. Like that was what, it wasn't like a specific, yeah, he launched it. He just launched his party like a few weeks ago. And as soon as he launched it, he was picking up about one seat per week, basically. And that can be short-lived, but yeah, he picked up one seat for, people know him, people like him. was the chief of staff. He talked a lot about, you know, thinking a long-term about national security. He also has rejected this Netanyahu idea of, Eitan Levine: So why did that happen? that was it. Interesting. Shanie: total victory. He's like, that's a fantasy. have to, Israel has to have short wars and think long-term and not just be like bogged down in wars for very, very long periods of time. So I think where he's at is like pretty mainstream in Israeli society. He hasn't put out really intense opinions. People don't see him as like so much as right or left and people on the right will his like haters on the right will say that he's a classic like center left general. Cause IDF generals are known to be more on the left when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. And if you look at his 2022 interview, you can see some of that. But October 7th, everything's changed. I'm sure he, whatever he thinks about the future of Israeli-Palestinian conflict, he knows better and will keep it to himself. Eitan Levine: Let me just say by the way, polymarket forty point eight percent for Gauddy Eisencott So I don't know if polymarket is trustworthy for It's kind of like the the vi I was like, I wonder what like Calcian Polymarket say. And I was like, actually they're idiots. I don't go on there and bet money. we are at the forty eight minute market. Is there anything else? I don't want to go too long here. is there anything else that we kind of haven't missed about Gotti? Shanie: Hmm, I think there's still an open question of if he's going to join with anyone else So there's a question Willie join with Bennett Bennett and Lapid, which I will just say I don't think is a smart decision But he could do that. They'll they'll go down together. So it's not a good idea Or will he join a Vigdor Lieberman who is more to the right? He's like kind of represents the Russian vote and he would have an issue sitting with the Arab Party So that will affect there Or will he like stay on his own? So Those kind of outcomes we'll discuss in future weeks as it gets closer and more obvious what he'll do. But I think he's like put himself forward as a pretty good candidate. I was prepared to come on here and say that the guy has no opinions and no platform, but a week, like not a week ago, like two, three days ago, he put one out. So I was glad we had something to talk about. Eitan Levine: Yeah. I that was the it seemed to be that for a while the the it it was Bennett, Lapid and and Eisencott not saying anything because people were hating BB. And it's like if it ain't broke, don't fix it. Just let people keep on hating BB and then the you know, the rest will kind of like fall in line. So that is good that he's yeah. Shanie: Right, should be said, he was gaining seats without telling anyone what he thinks. Like he, didn't affect him. Like putting out a platform wasn't like, wow, now everybody supports it. I'm like, I don't think it did anything. Eitan Levine: Yeah. last question, Cheney. What's your favorite clique chocolate? Shanie: my God, the balls, the little balls that are crunchy inside. You mean the bag's green, the chocolate's not green. Okay. Eitan Levine: Like the cornflakes. The green one, the cornflakes, the click cornflakes. Yeah, the bag is green. If the chocolate if the chocolate's green is it's covered in mold. open up the green click and it comes out all green, get a new bag. Okay, go back to the AMP. Go back to Umpum and and and get a new bag. All right, Shaani, thank you so much for coming on to the episode. This is the Jew York Times. We're gonna be doing the episodes every week. We're specifically gonna be doing 120 Angry Seats, the lead up to the Israeli election. A bunch over the next couple of weeks. If you have any questions, feel free to DM me. Send them send them over to me. Shainee, do you have anything you want to plug? Shanie: We're gonna have our Israel Policy Forum 120 project website that's gonna have like all kinds of polling and analysis. So once that's up and running, I will send you the link. Eitan Levine: Awesome. All right. We'll talk to you guys later. We'd like to end this episode with something that my non-Jewish roommate yells at the end of every episode, and that is bar stuol. Shout out, Rich. Rich, pay your rent. All right. Shanie: Hahaha!