Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Practical Aspects of Mediation (Do’s and Don’ts) with Hon. Vanessa A. Zecher (Ret.)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Practical Aspects of Mediation, Do's
- 0:09and Don'ts. I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive Director
- 0:11of the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm
- 0:14delighted to introduce today's speaker, the Honorable
- 0:16Vanessa Zecker. Judge Zecker is currently a mediator
- 0:19and arbitrator with jams. She brought to that
- 0:21role more than 20 years of experience as both
- 0:24an attorney and judge, including a term as supervising
- 0:27judge of criminal division and felony trials
- 0:29of the Santa Clara County Superior Court. She's
- 0:32handled complex family law matters, including
- 0:34high asset property division and custody disputes,
- 0:37and has presided over serious criminal trials,
- 0:39including capital cases. A committed advocate
- 0:42for ADR, Judge Zecker has led countless settlement
- 0:44conferences and supports arbitration as an efficient
- 0:47alternative to litigation. Before joining the
- 0:50bench, she managed her own family law firm, served
- 0:52as a court -appointed arbitrator, and was recognized
- 0:56for her pro bono work in federal court. We so
- 0:59appreciate her willingness in sharing her expertise
- 1:01with us today. Judge Zucker is a former family
- 1:04law litigator and judge, and her primary focus
- 1:06today will be on lessons learned from family
- 1:08law mediations. But she said that most of the
- 1:11content will be directly or analogously applicable
- 1:13to all practice areas. She encourages you to
- 1:16ask questions in the Q &A about any of the materials
- 1:19she covers and any cross applicability clarifications
- 1:23she can make. And now, let's get started. Well,
- 1:27thank you, Ms. McCauley for all of that. I appreciate
- 1:30it very, very much. And thank you for having
- 1:32me here today. For everyone who is here, there
- 1:37are some things that I would like to help us
- 1:40focus on. So we are going to talk about private
- 1:43mediation and we're going to talk about the whys
- 1:46and the do's and the don'ts. For those of you
- 1:50who do lots of mediation, I'm hoping that you'll
- 1:53leave either with a confirmation that yes, these
- 1:57are the things I'm thinking about, or perhaps
- 1:59you will leave with something a little bit new
- 2:02that you hadn't thought about. For those of you
- 2:05who are putting a toe in the water in terms of
- 2:08private mediation, I'm hoping that this will
- 2:10give you a little bit of an overview of what
- 2:13mediation is like and things that you might consider
- 2:16when looking at mediation. And for those of you
- 2:20who are starting or developing mediation practices
- 2:25where you are the mediator, I'm hoping to give
- 2:28you some thoughts from the mediator perspective
- 2:31that might help you in that endeavor. So Susie
- 2:35is gonna be advancing the slides for me today
- 2:37and Susie, I am ready when you are. And you may
- 2:40advance please, thank you. I know you all have
- 2:43access to the slides, so there are some things
- 2:45that I'm not going to, you can read a little
- 2:48bit later. So. When we look at the concept of
- 2:53private mediation in any area, be it family law,
- 2:57be it civil, be it any area that you're thinking
- 2:59about, the biggest piece and the biggest takeaway
- 3:03is that it is a voluntary process agreed to by
- 3:06the parties. Why is this important? Well, as
- 3:11a mediator, you have a leg up. because it is
- 3:16voluntary. People want to be there. People are
- 3:19motivated to settle their case. As attorneys
- 3:23who are assisting parties through the mediation
- 3:25process, this is something that you can use because
- 3:29it is voluntary. People are saying to themselves,
- 3:33the court system is crowded. It's complicated.
- 3:37It's tough to be around. I really need to get
- 3:39this solved. I'm tired of spending money. So
- 3:42that voluntariness is something that is critical,
- 3:45I think, in terms of resolution. A mediator is
- 3:51chosen by all of you, can be an attorney, a retired
- 3:55judge, or frankly, someone without a law degree
- 3:58at all, someone not involved in law at all. However,
- 4:02in California, if you are an attorney and you
- 4:06are a mediator, then you must have an active
- 4:09bar license. But short of that, Anyone can mediate,
- 4:13but there is that special rule for someone who
- 4:15is an attorney. Next slide, please, Susie. So
- 4:21the thoughts are, why consider private mediation?
- 4:24Some of these are going to be obvious to you.
- 4:28Our courts are backlogged. I can say as a judge
- 4:31who spent 10 years in criminal and then three
- 4:34years in family court, I saw it from the other
- 4:37side. I can tell you when I was in criminal and
- 4:40I supervised the division, any resource that
- 4:43I needed for criminal came to me because of the
- 4:46constitutional mandates. What did that mean?
- 4:49It meant that areas like civil and family, other
- 4:53non -criminal areas did not get the same resources.
- 4:57And I suspect many of you are feeling that in
- 5:00terms of processes in your court systems. Civil
- 5:06matters. I don't know about you, but I know in
- 5:09Santa Clara County and Northern California, in
- 5:12many of our counties up here, often those matters
- 5:14are set and reset several times. So they are,
- 5:20you get ready and then it's reset. They don't
- 5:22have a courtroom. They had to pull a courtroom
- 5:24for a criminal or whatever the issue is. Many
- 5:28parties, to any matter, really just want finality.
- 5:33They don't want to have to wait around. They
- 5:34want to take a little bit more control over the
- 5:37process. Mediation allows you to do that. Although
- 5:42mediation, I think, can be an expensive process,
- 5:46it is controllable. There's a start and an end.
- 5:49There is a shelf life to mediation. There is
- 5:52no shelf life to litigation. There are too many
- 5:54things that are outside of your control. The
- 5:56scheduling, the cost, the motions that are filed,
- 6:00when things are going to be heard, time, money,
- 6:03and stress. I think what people often underestimate,
- 6:07and I know that a lot of you speak with your
- 6:09clients about this, is that it's not just the
- 6:13financial aspects. of litigation that are stressful
- 6:16for people. It is the actual stressors. Every
- 6:20time they open an email from you, every time
- 6:22they have to take time off of work, every time
- 6:25they have to figure out how they're gonna find
- 6:27the piece of paper that you need from 10 years
- 6:29ago to prove whatever the claim is, those are
- 6:32all incredibly stressful, not to mention having
- 6:35to interact even on a limited basis with the
- 6:39opposing party. So those are the types of stressors
- 6:42that if you use a mediation or an ADR alternative,
- 6:46those are the types of things that you can mitigate
- 6:48for your client. And finally, sometimes folks
- 6:52say to me, well, should we do a settlement conference
- 6:56or should we do a mediation process? My general
- 7:01rule is do whatever works best for you. But I
- 7:04can say, and we all know, that when we have the
- 7:07mandatory settlement conferences at court, there's
- 7:10a time limit to those. And you also don't know
- 7:12who you're going to get to help settle your cases.
- 7:15Many, many attorneys who help settle cases at
- 7:18court and volunteer for those settlements are
- 7:21phenomenal. But sometimes they may not be the
- 7:27right fit for your clients, for you. that type
- 7:31of thing. So when you use a mediation or an ADR
- 7:35alternative and you're in charge of the decision
- 7:38making with respect to who you select, where
- 7:40it's going to be, how long it's going to be,
- 7:43those are all things that give your clients more
- 7:45confidence in the process because they are involved
- 7:47in the decision making in that area. Next slide,
- 7:51Susie. There are some special issues that I do
- 7:59talk about with family. I can't help it because
- 8:01I have to, because that is sort of the area that
- 8:05I manage. And Susie, I'm going to have you go
- 8:14back. Perfect. If we could stop there, that's
- 8:17perfect. All right. This can be in there if we
- 8:28could just stay there just for a minute. in any
- 8:32area. So although family law has its unique quirks,
- 8:36and some of you may be saying yourself, I am
- 8:38never touching a family law case. I don't care
- 8:40what happens. And others of you may have some
- 8:44cases in the family law areas and then still
- 8:46others may do family law full time. I think those
- 8:50in any area, be it in personal injury, be it
- 8:54in employment law, you do want a mediator who
- 8:57has some form of background in in the area in
- 9:02which you are mediating. And family law is particularly
- 9:05unique to that because we also deal with children.
- 9:09I had a lawyer come up to me in an event a couple
- 9:11of weeks ago and he was happy to hear that I
- 9:14had moved into the private world, but this lawyer
- 9:17does personal injury and he said, Judge, would
- 9:19you do some personal injury cases for me? And
- 9:21I said, well, maybe not so much. I said, there
- 9:25are so many good mediators with experience in
- 9:28personal injury. I may not be the best person
- 9:31to serve in that area. So you want to think a
- 9:35little bit about the background of your mediator
- 9:38to make sure that you're not having to catch
- 9:39your mediator up both on the culture in the area
- 9:42that you're managing, jury verdicts, what are
- 9:45juries gonna do, what's a judge gonna do, those
- 9:48types of issues. So I offer that for your consideration.
- 9:54I will also again reiterate that for those of
- 9:57you who practice in the area of family law where
- 10:00the stressors are very high, very high for your
- 10:03clients and the family, property issues, financial
- 10:07issues, those types of issues are given the lowest
- 10:10priority in terms of finding a trial department.
- 10:15And so again, for the family law world, we need
- 10:19to be careful. I know sometimes in some counties,
- 10:22they're only trying in the civil area, the five
- 10:24year cases and your five year statute issues.
- 10:29And so again, mediation gives an alternative
- 10:32where the parties can take control. And finally
- 10:36in family law, but I think in any area, an agreement
- 10:41made by the parties to the litigation is almost
- 10:45always going to be better than any decision a
- 10:48judge or a jury could make. There is something
- 10:51about taking control of your own destiny and
- 10:54being able to decide how you want to solve the
- 10:58problem, that even if you solve it on terms that
- 11:01are not 100 % favorable to you, even if you had
- 11:04to swallow something that you really didn't want
- 11:07to swallow, it's still a choice as opposed to
- 11:09a jury or a judge imposing a decision. That doesn't
- 11:14always feel very good. Susie, when you're ready.
- 11:20So let's talk about how to choose a mediator.
- 11:23And again, for those of you who mediate a lot,
- 11:27I am hopeful that maybe something new will come
- 11:30to you. For those of you who are developing your
- 11:33practice as mediators, this may be helpful to
- 11:36you. And for those of you who are just putting
- 11:37your toe in the water, I think this may be very
- 11:40helpful to you. So often mediators are selected
- 11:44by word of mouth. Those of us who mediate a lot,
- 11:49we know that how we treat people, whether we
- 11:53are kind to people, polite, respectful, those
- 11:57are all things that weigh into how a mediator
- 12:00is selected. And we know that often mediators
- 12:06are selected by reputation or by word of mouth.
- 12:11I think it is critical when you make a decision
- 12:14as to who your mediator might be that your mediator
- 12:18have some credibility or weight with the attorneys
- 12:22and in family law matters with the family in
- 12:25personal injury or other civil matters with the
- 12:28folks that you were talking about. It is most
- 12:31helpful once again to be sure that you have someone
- 12:34who has substantial experience, someone who could
- 12:37say, you know, I tried these cases as a lawyer
- 12:40or I try these cases now as a lawyer, if you're
- 12:44mediating. Or if you have folks who are retired
- 12:48from the bench or have otherwise left the bench,
- 12:51people who say, I tried these cases as a lawyer.
- 12:53And by the way, I also did these cases as a judge.
- 12:55So you have that whole 360. For me, the most
- 13:01critical characteristic a mediator should have
- 13:06is the ability to listen. I know that seems obvious.
- 13:10but it's to listen and to hear. Listening is
- 13:16where people are telling their story and you're
- 13:18like, I've heard this before. I've seen this
- 13:22issue before and I kind of know how it's going
- 13:24to turn out and let's just get on with it. As
- 13:26opposed to really hearing the parties and hearing
- 13:30their concerns, sometimes hearing their pain,
- 13:33sometimes hearing their resentment, their anger,
- 13:35whatever the emotions are that go along with
- 13:37everything. that they have to say. So it is an
- 13:41ability to make them feel like they've been hurt.
- 13:45Judges are trained, as you all know, that litigants
- 13:49can live with a decision that may be adverse
- 13:53or may not be what they wanted. But if they leave
- 13:56the courtroom and they feel like the judge has
- 13:58really heard and considered what their issues
- 14:01are, they will live with that decision. It is
- 14:04actually no different in mediation. People will
- 14:08live with a resolution that is not ideal, but
- 14:12it is a resolution if they feel that everyone
- 14:16has considered their point of view and the solution
- 14:19is just the best option that can be done under
- 14:22the circumstances. It is no different in any
- 14:26mediation. People are people. We all have a need
- 14:30to feel like the person we are speaking with.
- 14:36understands our point of view and hears it, even
- 14:39if they don't agree with it. And finally, your
- 14:43mediator really should be able to help organize
- 14:46and prioritize the issues. Some mediators I know
- 14:51let the parties kind of drive the mediation,
- 14:53let the attorney sort of organize and prioritize.
- 14:57I view it as really it should be a little bit
- 14:59more collaborative, and perhaps the mediator
- 15:02should make suggestions. Perhaps we should start
- 15:04with this and then move to this. And then, of
- 15:07course, listen to the lawyers and maybe adjust
- 15:09that based upon what the lawyers believe is appropriate.
- 15:13So I talked a little bit before about the costs
- 15:16associated with private mediation. And where
- 15:20the insurance company is paying, it's probably
- 15:22not as much an issue. But where you have private
- 15:25pays, on both sides. The costs of private mediation
- 15:29are substantial and it's something that you really
- 15:32should consider in terms of whether or not private
- 15:37mediation is going to be appropriate for your
- 15:40particular case. It is an investment and in terms
- 15:43of ROI, return on investment, if you're going
- 15:46to invest 50 and solve the case and save 200,
- 15:50that's a terrific return on investment. But if
- 15:54you're dragging the parties to the table, which
- 15:56we're going to talk about in just a minute, and
- 15:59you're just sort of using it as, let me kind
- 16:03of see and try this out and see how it might
- 16:05work, that may not be the very best use of money
- 16:10on behalf of your clients. A good family law
- 16:13mediator or any mediator is going to help the
- 16:16parties think outside the box to maybe think
- 16:19about things the parties had not thought about.
- 16:22or to come to solutions that are part of a mediation
- 16:27toolbox, but which are not part of a toolbox
- 16:30that a judge can use. So when we're looking at
- 16:35mediation as an alternative, if we're looking
- 16:37at solutions that are really not part of what
- 16:39a judge could do, perhaps mediation is a great
- 16:43option because the judge will not be able to
- 16:47do the same thing or to consider the same issues.
- 16:50When you hear that mediators alternate between
- 16:54facilitative and evaluative or directive, for
- 16:59those of you who may not be as familiar with
- 17:01those terms, most mediators will start as a facilitative
- 17:07mediator. In other words, you're moving information
- 17:09back and forth between the rooms. You're facilitating
- 17:14an understanding of the different perspectives.
- 17:17You're facilitating communication. You're facilitating
- 17:21people telling their story and trying to figure
- 17:25out how to process that information. As time
- 17:30goes on during the mediation, mediators may become
- 17:34a little more evaluative or directive as in,
- 17:38you know, based upon my training and experience,
- 17:41you might have an uphill battle with that particular
- 17:44argument in a courtroom. You should not hear
- 17:47a mediator say, There's no way a judge will ever
- 17:50do that. There's no way a jury would ever make
- 17:54that decision. We don't know, to be honest with
- 17:57you. Right, wrong, or in between, we don't know.
- 17:59So what you should hear is, generally, in a courtroom,
- 18:04this might work. I don't know what a judge would
- 18:07do with that. I can see both sides, those types
- 18:09of issues where you're really trying to help
- 18:11the parties and remove a little bit of mystery
- 18:14about what happens in in the courtroom via judge
- 18:19decision or via a jury decision. Susie, when
- 18:26you're ready. So again, for family law, but in
- 18:33any mediation. You really need to decide which
- 18:38issues are creating the most stress for the parties.
- 18:41In a family law matter, if it's custody, then
- 18:45maybe we start with custody, figure out how to
- 18:47decrease the stress even if we don't solve it.
- 18:51If it's personal injury or probate or some other
- 18:54civil matter, employment. Employment is very
- 18:56much like family law, very personal, very difficult.
- 19:01Then decide what issues are creating the most
- 19:03stress and help your mediator to prioritize.
- 19:07Sometimes we can start with the most stressful
- 19:10issues and see if we can get those solved. Sometimes
- 19:14I will want to start with what I call the low
- 19:17-hanging fruit, the more vanilla issues, and
- 19:19get a little more into a rhythm of settling so
- 19:23it gives people confidence that, oh, this is
- 19:26kind of how it works. This is how we get to a
- 19:27solution, even if it's an easy issue, so that
- 19:30by the time you get to the most stressful issues,
- 19:32you're already in the rhythm. of solving. Look
- 19:35it, we've solved 10 issues. Of course, the 11th
- 19:38may be the worst possible issue in the entire
- 19:40world, but you've already settled 10. So it gives
- 19:43people confidence in the process. There's no
- 19:46one size fits all in this area. There really
- 19:49is not as to where you start, whether you start
- 19:52with the most stressful or you end with the most
- 19:54stressful or you somehow bookend it and put it
- 19:57in the middle. So work with your mediator. If
- 19:59you are the mediator, then you work with your
- 20:02lawyers and the parties to say, you know, where
- 20:04do you think would be the best place to start?
- 20:07Sometimes everyone can't agree, and that's okay.
- 20:11You know, everyone has a very different perspective.
- 20:13In that case, as the mediator, you're going to
- 20:16make the best decision you can based upon the
- 20:18information that you have, and you're going to
- 20:21explain why. Transparency is key. Next slide,
- 20:24please, Susie. So for the pre -mediation preparation,
- 20:33and I'm hopeful that this will be helpful to
- 20:35everyone, and I'm hoping that even folks who
- 20:37do mediation a lot might pick some things up
- 20:41here. You're first gonna decide who your mediator
- 20:44might be, and then how long the session will
- 20:47be. Most sessions in the private mediation world
- 20:50are a half day or a full day. You'll decide,
- 20:54four hours or eight hours. as to what might work
- 20:58best. If you have a discrete set of issues, then
- 21:02maybe a half day will work, and maybe that's
- 21:03all your clients can afford, which is another
- 21:06big consideration, or maybe that's all they can
- 21:09manage because it's so stressful. For me as the
- 21:14mediator, the upfront, the pre -mediation preparation
- 21:19is critical. I would argue most important in
- 21:25terms of whether or not a matter is going to
- 21:28resolve. I do appreciate always a mediation brief,
- 21:34and I'm gonna talk a little bit more later about
- 21:36what I find helpful as the mediator. But more
- 21:41important to me is the joint pre -mediation call
- 21:45with council. And then potentially a pre -mediation
- 21:49separate call with one or both sides, whoever
- 21:52might request it or whomever might be willing
- 21:55to talk to me about it, where one or both sides
- 21:58can have a very frank conversation with me as
- 22:01to perhaps challenges with their client, challenges
- 22:04with the other side, the dynamic between the
- 22:07parties, things that you're not as comfortable
- 22:09saying in a joint call. I find that process absolutely
- 22:151000 % necessary for me to be able to be effective
- 22:20as a mediator. I am gathering information and
- 22:23sometimes I'm actually starting the sort of planting
- 22:26of seeds and the mediation process during those
- 22:29calls. So I have not yet done a mediation without
- 22:33those calls. I will not move forward without
- 22:36those calls. Sometimes they're a little bit closer
- 22:38to the mediation than need be because of the
- 22:41schedules of everyone, but they always take place.
- 22:46I greatly value the ability for each side to
- 22:50speak freely with me, to say what's on their
- 22:52mind without worrying about offending the other
- 22:55side or without upending the sort of collaborative
- 22:59dynamic that is part of mediation. And so again,
- 23:03those individual calls I find to be extraordinarily
- 23:06important. If I have not worked with the lawyers
- 23:10before or perhaps I only saw the lawyers in court
- 23:13in a different context, these pre -mediation
- 23:16calls allow me to get to know the lawyers a little
- 23:19bit, allow the lawyers to meet me so that you're
- 23:23not going in stressed and saying to your clients
- 23:25like, well, I haven't worked with this mediator
- 23:26before. I hear she can settle cases. In this
- 23:30way, you can relate to your clients. I spoke.
- 23:33with the mediator, whoever that might be. And
- 23:37I feel comfortable. I think this mediator gets
- 23:40it, mediators prepared, et cetera, whatever you
- 23:43need to do to give your clients confidence in
- 23:45the process. So those calls are critical. Next
- 23:49slide, Susie. All right, your mediation brief,
- 23:55these are my suggestions. They seem obvious,
- 23:57but we don't always get this information in the
- 24:00mediation brief. for family law, date of marriage,
- 24:05date of separation, ages and occupations of the
- 24:08parties. In your personal and shared cases, same
- 24:10thing, you know, ages of the parties. What do
- 24:14they do for a living? Give a little bit of background.
- 24:16Let us understand who we might be working with.
- 24:20Date of incident, a little brief description
- 24:23of what happened. Any mediator wants to know
- 24:27what issues have been solved. Judge, we've reached
- 24:3015 stipulations on all of these different issues.
- 24:34Here they are. I love it. Boy, if someone lays
- 24:37them out chronologically, that's even nicer.
- 24:40And if you upload them as an attachment, that's
- 24:43even nicer. But I understand that time is limited.
- 24:45So I understand lawyers are under a lot of stress
- 24:48and time pressure. So I'll take whatever you
- 24:50can give. Tell me what's been solved. Tell you
- 24:54something. What I'm looking at is do these parties
- 24:57have an ability to reach an agreement? The more
- 24:59agreements that have been reached, that tells
- 25:01me, okay, they are in a rhythm of reaching stipulations.
- 25:06They know what that feels like, and that's helpful
- 25:08to me. I also like to know if there have been
- 25:11prior settlement discussions or mediations. In
- 25:14particular, many cases come to me where parties
- 25:17have mediated one or more occasions before and
- 25:21it didn't work. I would like to know, particularly
- 25:23in those pre -mediation calls, I will ask about
- 25:27it, if I've seen it in the brief, what happened?
- 25:31How come things were not solved? Because I'm
- 25:33going to make sure that I try not to make the
- 25:35same issues that did not lead to resolution in
- 25:40the mediation that I'm doing. So I'm going to
- 25:42try and separate from those or use a different
- 25:44approach to help the parties move forward. I'd
- 25:49love to know what your settlement proposal is
- 25:51with some specificity. Again, I'm fond of saying
- 25:56I don't need anything fancy, but I do need to
- 25:59know a little bit about what your settlement
- 26:01proposal is. It can be a summary and a 60 ,000
- 26:05foot view, but I do need to have some understanding
- 26:07of what you're thinking. Sometimes mediation
- 26:11briefs are exchanged and sometimes not. There's
- 26:13no hard and fast rule. This is not a mandatory
- 26:16settlement conference. I tend to think that the
- 26:20exchange of briefs is a good thing. Sometimes
- 26:23lawyers say to me, nope, not in this case. I
- 26:26say, I defer to you because you've been in the
- 26:28case a lot longer than I have. Even in a situation
- 26:32where the lawyers might say, well, we really
- 26:34don't want to exchange, I might push back a little
- 26:37bit on that and say, well, could we exchange
- 26:39some things? maybe even the prior stipulations,
- 26:43even things that are known to both sides, so
- 26:45that at least there is some exchange as opposed
- 26:48to the parties really coming in in such a completely,
- 26:53totally sort of blackout polarized situation.
- 26:57So I generally am going to encourage the exchange
- 27:02of some form of brief even if it's heavily redacted.
- 27:06That being said, I'm also going to defer if the
- 27:09lawyers say, no, can't do it in this situation.
- 27:13Next slide, please. So at the mediation session
- 27:20itself, there are certain things really that
- 27:23I think should be highlighted. And normally,
- 27:26I do this as the mediator. I spend five to seven
- 27:29minutes. Now, there is all sorts of debate. about
- 27:33whether you do a joint session, whether you do
- 27:35a separate session, whether joint sessions are
- 27:37beneficial in mediations. And the school of thought
- 27:42in this area is continually evolving for mediators.
- 27:46So it's always a work in progress. I make a game
- 27:51day decision. If the parties have been able to
- 27:54reach agreements before, they seem otherwise
- 27:57just fine. I actually want a joint session, be
- 28:00it in person or on screen where I only I'm the
- 28:04only one doing the talking. I actually control
- 28:06this area a little bit more because things can
- 28:09go awry as we know at joint sessions, so I don't
- 28:12want to start things off badly. But I also think
- 28:15it's nice for everybody to be in the same space
- 28:18if they can be where they're hearing the same
- 28:21information from me at the same time. So I do
- 28:24talk about the confidentiality of mediations.
- 28:29And importantly, there are two aspects to confidentiality.
- 28:32The first is that they're completely confidential.
- 28:34They can't be used in court, et cetera. That
- 28:37I think we all know. And if we don't, we do now.
- 28:41And secondly, remember I talked to you about
- 28:44that facilitative piece where the mediator moves
- 28:47information back and forth between the rooms?
- 28:51Well, that piece is true. And if a room wishes
- 28:55to have some information kept confidential, they
- 28:59need to let the mediator know that. So my mediations,
- 29:02I talk about the red box. So if something is
- 29:04in the red box, that means it's confidential.
- 29:07I do not share it with the other room. I literally
- 29:10put it in my notes in a red box and in my brain.
- 29:13And if I feel like talking about that would be
- 29:18helpful to the other room moving forward, I'm
- 29:20going to ask permission. I may get that permission,
- 29:24or I may not, or I may get, yes, Judge, you can
- 29:26share this part, but not this part, but we're
- 29:28gonna talk about it. So remember those two aspects
- 29:31of mediation, particularly if your mediator is
- 29:36more of a facilitative mediator, sharing information
- 29:39back and forth, all with the goal of moving toward
- 29:42resolution. I talk about the attorneys. The attorneys
- 29:46are not just there as potted plants. You all
- 29:49are an active, integral part of the process.
- 29:53And I talk about the fact that if I'm talking
- 29:56with a client directly and you as the attorneys
- 29:59wish to interrupt, that's terrific. That's fine.
- 30:02It's conversational. It should be informal. It
- 30:06should be the vetting of ideas with everybody's
- 30:09input. Sometimes we need to redirect conversation
- 30:13a little bit, as you all know, but that's all.
- 30:15part of the collaboration with the lawyers. So
- 30:18I consider the attorneys to be absolutely critical
- 30:22part of the mediation process. Your Honor, it
- 30:27actually looks like we have two recent questions
- 30:29if we'd like to attend to those. Pre -mediation,
- 30:34briefs review, part of the mediation charges
- 30:37cost. That is a great question. So I don't know
- 30:40how other mediators do it. I can only talk to
- 30:43you about how we do it. at JAMS. So for me, my
- 30:49cost for the mediation is I think, I'm gonna
- 30:54say 8 ,500 for the full day. That includes eight
- 30:58hours of mediation and it includes two hours
- 31:01of prep time. And I always include those pre
- 31:04-mediation brief reviews. It usually goes longer.
- 31:07I'm gonna be candid than two hours. I just charged
- 31:09the two hours. because it's my prep that I want
- 31:12to make sure I'm doing it correctly. So that
- 31:14also includes the phone calls with council, the
- 31:17pre -mediation calls. Sometimes people will send
- 31:20emails. That's all part of that process. Generally,
- 31:24how do mandatory settlement conference differ
- 31:26from mediations quarter or otherwise? Okay, two
- 31:29major areas that I think they differ. First of
- 31:33all, mandatory settlement conferences are not
- 31:35voluntary, right? By their nature, they're mandatory.
- 31:40Second of all, they are not completely confidential.
- 31:45So a settlement conference in the family law
- 31:47world can be used to support a request for attorney's
- 31:50fees and costs, a request for sanctions for not
- 31:53settling the case when it should have been settled,
- 31:55et cetera, et cetera. At a mediation, completely
- 31:58confidential. So those are the two major areas.
- 32:03Third, I don't know if in your courts down here
- 32:06you can select. Who is going to be doing your
- 32:09mandatory settlement conference? I know up in
- 32:12our northern counties, we don't get to select.
- 32:15You're just assigned, okay? So from my perspective,
- 32:21those are the three major areas. I started with
- 32:23two, but it occurred to me to be three. Do you
- 32:25facilitate between the parties additional charge?
- 32:28That's a great question. So when we get to that
- 32:30slide, we'll skip over it. I'll just advance
- 32:32it now. Here's how I do it. And I'm told lawyers
- 32:37really, really like it. I will ask one of the
- 32:41lawyers ahead of time to begin a term sheet or
- 32:44a memorandum of understanding mediation agreement,
- 32:46whatever they want to call it. And I want them
- 32:49to start it ahead because there is nothing worse
- 32:52than being six hours into a mediation and having
- 32:54to draft something from scratch. Most lawyers
- 32:58appreciate that. A lot of lawyers have already
- 33:00started that. So one side will start that. When
- 33:04we get to a point in the mediation where I feel
- 33:07like, yeah, we have enough. I think we're there.
- 33:11Then we throw that up on screen, whether we're
- 33:14in person or whether we're on screen. It matters
- 33:17not. We share screen. That goes up. One of the
- 33:20lawyers agrees to be the scribe. Sometimes I
- 33:22am, if that's what they prefer, and I'm good
- 33:24with that. And we collaboratively draft that
- 33:28agreement as we are going through it. So we edit
- 33:32it in real time. I do not find, for me, that
- 33:36the red line process is efficient. It creates
- 33:39misunderstandings. And I find that when the lawyers
- 33:42really are participatory in the drafting of the
- 33:46agreement, by the time they get it to their clients,
- 33:49they are able to recommend it to their clients.
- 33:51And sometimes we have to go back and re -edit
- 33:53a little bit more. For my mediations, this is
- 33:56what I tell people right in that little talk
- 33:58that I give ahead of time, you're going to leave
- 34:01today and no, whether you have an agreement or
- 34:04not. Why? Because you're going to leave with
- 34:06something in writing or we don't have a settlement.
- 34:09That means you can keep talking. That's not the
- 34:12issue, but we don't have a settlement. So I hope
- 34:15that answered the question. Yes, I do participate.
- 34:19It's not extra charge. It's just part of the
- 34:21eight hours that's part of the session. And so
- 34:24I'm pretty careful on time management. Sometimes
- 34:27we go over the eight hours by everybody's agreement,
- 34:30then I charge for that time. That's just an extra
- 34:34hourly rate, okay? I hope that answered the question.
- 34:39Okay, Susie, thank you, and thank you, Susie,
- 34:41for monitoring the questions. All right, I do
- 34:48remind everyone, and I think those of you who
- 34:51are mediating, I think we want to remind everyone
- 34:54that you really have no interest in the outcome
- 34:56of the case. A lot of folks ask me, well, when
- 35:00you're preparing, Do you know how the case is
- 35:03going to solve? No, I genuinely do not. Am I
- 35:07looking for paths? Am I looking for a little
- 35:09bit of light where I can spark a conversation?
- 35:13Oh, yes. But no, I do not know how it is going
- 35:16to solve. And I say the same thing at mediation
- 35:19that I used to say to my juries and frankly that
- 35:23I believed when I did my court trials, which
- 35:26is I genuinely have no interest in the outcome
- 35:30of anything. I am very invested in the process
- 35:34and making sure the process is fair and that
- 35:37people are heard and that it is transparent and
- 35:41that in mediations we're moving people forward
- 35:43to resolution. So what they agree on at the end
- 35:47of the day, it's their agreement. I do care that
- 35:49the process helps them transparent, people are
- 35:53heard. With respect to transparency, for me,
- 35:58I believe that is the key to mediator credibility.
- 36:02I think if I am going to go and let the other
- 36:07side know that I think this is a good idea because
- 36:10you've asked me to tell you that, then I am going
- 36:14to let you know why I think it's a good idea.
- 36:21Why I think, you know, that may not land so well
- 36:24in the other room. I think that's all critical
- 36:26for you to know what is on the mind of the mediator.
- 36:32Okay, let me see. I have some questions, so let
- 36:36me just answer those lives because I think that
- 36:38these are the things that are important to you.
- 36:41How do you handle litigants that seek to unwind
- 36:44signed agreements with no 1542 waivers who claim
- 36:48that a spouse hid assets that they only found
- 36:51out about weeks or months later? All right, so
- 36:54I have... A fairly easy answer to this, and you
- 36:58may not like it. If I am just the mediator, I
- 37:02am only the mediator, that issue goes to someone
- 37:06else. That goes to a judge. So I think that if
- 37:13you're asking if it's signed already, it goes
- 37:17to a judge. And you deal with 664 .6. and you
- 37:22move forward from there. So I hope that answers
- 37:24it. If not, do a follow -up question, and I'll
- 37:26be happy to answer the follow -up question. What
- 37:29if a client is unable to confirm that an attorney
- 37:33will represent at the mediation? Can you proceed
- 37:37with a mediation where one party is not represented?
- 37:40Can you proceed if the client wants to go forward?
- 37:43All right. I have two answers to this. Yes, I
- 37:47will. go forward if one side is self -represented
- 37:56with caution. I think that's the best way to
- 37:59say it. It is not my favorite thing to do because
- 38:04there's that extraordinary line. It was the same
- 38:08at court sitting on the bench, that extraordinary
- 38:10line of not giving legal advice and really knowing
- 38:14where that line is that you cannot. sort of advice
- 38:19in any capacity. So it is not my favorite way
- 38:24to do it. I generally prefer if a self -represented
- 38:27litigant wants to meet with me that they at least
- 38:30have a consulting attorney. Again, I will do
- 38:36it if it appears appropriate under the circumstances,
- 38:41but there have been some times when I have said
- 38:43I don't think I'm the best fit. for this particular
- 38:46situation. How much should the mediator be involved
- 38:50in drafting the final settlement agreement? I
- 38:54think the mediator, at least for me, all I'm
- 38:57doing is facilitating discussion. So sometimes
- 39:01if they can't agree on wording and there is a
- 39:06sort of bridge between their wording, they might
- 39:09get a suggestion. But at the end of the day,
- 39:11I think it's really the lawyers who should be
- 39:13drafting the agreement and the mediator is really
- 39:16there to facilitate communication between them
- 39:20and to help edit real time. That's it. I don't
- 39:24make suggestions about, do you want 1542 language?
- 39:27Do you want waiver of reimbursements? I don't
- 39:32make any suggestions on that because I don't
- 39:34think that's my role. They disagree on language
- 39:37and I can figure out a way to bridge language.
- 39:41then I will do that. All right. Next slide, please.
- 39:50All right. We talked about the MOU and the slide,
- 39:56the term sheet. So I think I'm going to leave
- 39:59that if there are additional questions. The litigants
- 40:04want you to mediate again. Another question,
- 40:06the settlement agreement and whether it should
- 40:08be amended to deal with the undisclosed assets
- 40:11and your opinion on the matter. Okay. I would
- 40:17have no problem mediating again. I would have
- 40:21a problem with the opinion on the matter until
- 40:24I had everybody together and everybody in session
- 40:27in a mediation session wanted me to give an opinion.
- 40:31or a thought about how this could play out in
- 40:35a courtroom. Notice I'm being very careful. I
- 40:37do not predict what other judges will do. I hope
- 40:40that answers that. Another follow -up if you
- 40:42need it. At the mediation session itself, I always
- 40:49start with one side and I want to talk directly
- 40:54to the parties. I've already given that overview
- 40:57that we talked about. I've already had my little
- 41:01joint session, if appropriate, and now I'm with
- 41:05one side or the other. I will let the lawyers
- 41:07tell me who they think I should start with. If
- 41:09they don't really have a preference, I make a
- 41:12game day decision after I've had my pre -mediation
- 41:15calls and I've read my briefs, then I decide
- 41:18who I might want to start with. It's critical
- 41:22for me to hear from the parties directly. I will
- 41:25spend a half an hour to 45 minutes with them.
- 41:27I absolutely want lawyer participation in that.
- 41:31I want a lawyer to say to the client, let Judge
- 41:35Decker know about X, Y, or Z. I'm good with all
- 41:38of that. But I find it's very important to establish
- 41:41that connection with the client. And they can
- 41:45tell me what's important in their own words.
- 41:48I usually say to them, if you want to talk to
- 41:49me about the weather, perfectly fine. But I really
- 41:53want to talk with you directly. And it's my way
- 41:56of establishing a bit more of a connection with
- 41:59clients who are generally nervous. As lawyers,
- 42:02you all have been through this a million times.
- 42:04Or if you haven't, you've been through court.
- 42:06You've been through the system. Often for clients,
- 42:10it is a little bit more daunting because it's
- 42:14out of their comfort zone. And sometimes I actually
- 42:18genuinely have questions and I let the parties
- 42:20know that at the outset. I might interrupt you
- 42:23with questions. Please don't think I'm being
- 42:25rude or disrespectful, but I may want to interrupt
- 42:27with questions because I read the briefs and
- 42:30I had the pre -mediation calls. When might you
- 42:33recommend arbitration? What about, okay, so mediation
- 42:39or Med -Art, but mediation arbitration proceedings.
- 42:44I'm going to answer this in two ways. I love
- 42:48the concept of arbitration to resolve any dispute
- 42:51where the parties agree that arbitration is appropriate.
- 42:55I find arbitration to be cost effective. I know
- 43:01Jams has rule, you know, we have special rules
- 43:04for arbitrations on discovery. The arbitrator
- 43:07has a lot more say and the hearing can really
- 43:10proceed as the parties intended. which in court,
- 43:15as we know often, things are taken away from
- 43:19us in terms of what the judge can do, what the
- 43:22parties can do, and how the process manages it.
- 43:26So for me, any time arbitration can be considered
- 43:29as a process, I think that's a good thing. Now,
- 43:34moving from mediation to arbitration, I think
- 43:36sometimes can be tricky. And do I do it? I will
- 43:43do it on a case by case basis. And so for me,
- 43:47I will equate it in the family law world to having
- 43:51settlement discussions while also being retained
- 43:54as the all purpose judge. I did a lot of that
- 43:57in criminal and I did a lot of it in family where
- 44:01people would ask me to mediate or settle even
- 44:06though I was the trial judge. I'm careful about
- 44:09it. I'm going to be very honest. And I approach
- 44:12it very differently. You are going to hear me
- 44:15be more facilitative in those types of discussions
- 44:18than evaluative. And if I'm going to be evaluative,
- 44:23and I'm using it in quotes, it comes with all
- 44:25sorts of disclaimers. As in, I am only doing
- 44:29this. I am giving you this thought. Only based
- 44:36upon what I'm hearing right now. I have not assessed
- 44:40the witnesses. I have not assessed the evidence
- 44:43I have not heard anyone testify all of those
- 44:46types of disclaimers are going to come in so
- 44:48And sometimes I have had I know in court I had
- 44:52one case where I just could not it was just too
- 44:55hard It was too high conflict and I just said
- 44:57no, I need you to go somewhere else for your
- 44:59settlement discussions Because I'm the trial
- 45:02judge. So yes, I think Mediation, arbitration,
- 45:08settlement, APJ can work, but I do think it has
- 45:11to be assessed on a case -by -case basis. How
- 45:14would you handle confidential information given
- 45:18to the mediator that crosses truthfulness or
- 45:21legality lines? I'm a mediator. I am bound by
- 45:24the same confidentiality rules, but that can
- 45:28get us into trouble. Now, mind you, we just talked
- 45:31about moving from settlement to trial judge.
- 45:34If that happens in that situation, that's the
- 45:37risk. And that's why I'm saying you got to be
- 45:39really careful on that, that you were able to
- 45:42set that aside in terms of actually hearing the
- 45:46evidence and that there's a firewall. And that's
- 45:48why case by case is probably the best way to
- 45:50go. If there is a truthfulness issue or something
- 45:55is illegal, we're going to talk about it. I tend
- 46:00to talk about it in a very non -judgmental way,
- 46:03as in, I'm concerned. You told me one thing here,
- 46:06and you told me a little bit different thing
- 46:08here. We need to kind of solve that in the context
- 46:12of this mediation, because that could play out
- 46:14in a courtroom in directing cross -examination,
- 46:18not because of what was learned at the mediation,
- 46:20but because that's just the way it is. So we're
- 46:23going to talk about it. And I can say. For the
- 46:29legality side, I have had one issue and I actually
- 46:35believe it was on the bench that I could not
- 46:38sign off on a resolution because it just did
- 46:41not comport with the law. So I might have a further
- 46:45discussion. I find when you really talk to the
- 46:47lawyers about whether or not the law would support,
- 46:50if the resolution is completely contrary to the
- 46:53law, well, It's a resolution. So I look at it
- 46:57on a case by case basis. The bigger question,
- 47:00is it going to be enforceable? And so those types
- 47:04of things would be discussed. I don't prejudge
- 47:07that. How do you handle a mediator who beats
- 47:10down the plaintiff regarding the extent of the
- 47:12injury while it was a small dog and appears to
- 47:15be biased toward history of defense practice?
- 47:20So my first question would be, how did you select
- 47:24that particular mediator. So I want to make sure
- 47:27that everyone does their homework, right, in
- 47:30terms of how they are selecting meters. But let's
- 47:33say you got great information and then you get
- 47:36in and somehow it's a problem. I think from the
- 47:42mediator standpoint, I think it's critical that
- 47:45we genuinely remain neutral. I know that sounds
- 47:47academic. I actually believe genuinely we have
- 47:51to remain neutral. Why? I need credibility in
- 47:54both rooms. I don't want just credibility in
- 47:56one room or the other. I want both sides to say,
- 47:59you know what? I don't like what she's saying,
- 48:01but I think she's saying it the way it has to
- 48:03be said. And if I only have credibility in one
- 48:06room, how am I going to get this to a resolution?
- 48:09So I think if you remind your mediator that yeah,
- 48:13it may have been a small dog. That may be your
- 48:15perception. I'm not sure how a jury might feel
- 48:17about that, but even if it's a small dog, it
- 48:20still created a problem here. and my client has
- 48:23been injured and we need to talk about that my
- 48:25client needs to feel like you understand that
- 48:27those types of issues okay so that's probably
- 48:32how I would approach it is really to remind your
- 48:34mediator of the of the neutrality and you know
- 48:38I'm not going to be able to settle this mediator
- 48:42if you are not neutral and you're not really
- 48:45conveying to the parties that you understand
- 48:47their issues All right, next slide, please. All
- 48:55right, the attorney and mediation, we're going
- 48:58to kind of go through these a little bit more
- 49:01quickly. In the interest of time, I will continue
- 49:04to answer questions because I think that's critical.
- 49:06This is your MCLE, so I want to make sure I'm
- 49:10doing what's important to you. So when you are
- 49:15preparing your clients for mediation, please
- 49:18help them to understand the mediation process.
- 49:20And your pre -mediation call with the mediator
- 49:22should help you with that. How does this mediator
- 49:24work? Joint session, caucuses, how does your
- 49:28mediator work? For me, most critical is setting
- 49:33the client's expectations about what can happen
- 49:38at mediation. What's the potential outcome? If
- 49:42you set the client's expectation that it is my
- 49:45expectation that if everybody, if the mediator's
- 49:49able to get everybody moving in the same direction
- 49:51that we should resolve this, that's a great expectation.
- 49:57That's a reality -based expectation. If you are
- 50:02helping your client to keep an open mind along
- 50:05with that expectation, which is you may hear
- 50:08things you don't like, you may hear a mediator
- 50:10make a suggestion that you really don't like,
- 50:12but actually might make sense, those types of
- 50:15things, that's all setting your client's expectation.
- 50:20Some cases do better remote mediation. Some cases
- 50:23do better in -person mediation. Probably 85 %
- 50:27of mine are remote. I'm super comfortable with
- 50:29that. I did trials at court remotely, not in
- 50:32criminal family. So I'm very comfortable remotely.
- 50:38Some lawyers are not comfortable remotely. Some
- 50:40mediators are not comfortable remotely. OK, then
- 50:42do it in person. So for me, I let the lawyers
- 50:45decide. I tell them I like remote. I think it's
- 50:48less expensive and more comfortable for parties
- 50:50and for attorneys. But. You want me there in
- 50:53person, I'm going to be there in person. Why?
- 50:55Because you know your case. And as the attorney,
- 50:59what do you want to accomplish? And it could
- 51:01be nothing more than, oh, my goodness, this has
- 51:04to be solved. This case cannot be tried. It is
- 51:08so messy. It is so difficult. It needs to be
- 51:12solved. Next slide, please. All right. as attorneys,
- 51:22and really this is for any level, whether you
- 51:24do mediations all the time or you're not doing
- 51:26them as much, are you willing to get your client
- 51:29on this path even if they're resistant? So, you
- 51:34know, I don't want to spend the money on mediation.
- 51:36Nothing's going to happen at mediation. I'm right.
- 51:38I already know what a judge is going to do. I
- 51:40know what a jury is going to do. Are you willing
- 51:42to kind of work with that a little bit and see
- 51:45if you can redirect your client's thought process?
- 51:48We talked about return on investment. Really
- 51:51do think about cost of mediation versus cost
- 51:54of litigation. And often it's like this, which
- 51:57mediation is here and cost of litigation is there.
- 52:01Is your client a good candidate? Is your client
- 52:03listening to you? Does your client trust you?
- 52:05Does your client value your opinion? Is your
- 52:08client saying, and this says family law, but
- 52:11again, it's directed to anything. Is your client
- 52:14saying, you know, I think I'd like to hear. what
- 52:16someone else maybe has to say, and I'm really
- 52:18open to considering that viewpoint. Do you support
- 52:22the concept of mediation? I was talking with
- 52:25a lawyer the other day, and just on mediation
- 52:29in general, we were getting ready for another
- 52:31presentation, and she said, you know, until I
- 52:34started preparing for these mediations, I never
- 52:40really, I just thought about the process as another
- 52:43step to getting to trial. And she said, it's
- 52:45really caused me to step back and really think
- 52:47about what mediation can accomplish. That's the
- 52:51kind of thing that I'm talking about is, do you
- 52:54support that concept of mediation? Do you think
- 52:57that a resolution is most of the time better
- 53:00than what a judge or a jury could do? I would
- 53:03argue it's always better. I can get to most of
- 53:06the time with all of you if you think that that
- 53:09would be best for your case. And if you've done
- 53:12a thoughtful analysis of the strengths and weaknesses,
- 53:15meaning are you going in there saying we're right
- 53:17and they're wrong, well, that could be a little
- 53:20bit difficult process and you may not like it
- 53:22if someone pushes back and says, I see it a little
- 53:25bit differently. Are you open to that? Are you
- 53:27open to someone else giving a little bit different
- 53:29perspective? All right, if an attorney accuses
- 53:33the mediator of bias during the mediation, should
- 53:36the mediator resign? What are the ethical considerations
- 53:39to remain neutral? Can you continue if the attorney
- 53:43claims bias? All right. So in our training at
- 53:46Jams, they do a very intensive training on mediations.
- 53:49And I use the same role that I used at court.
- 53:53I don't want to become embroiled in the process,
- 53:57which means that I don't want the mediation to
- 54:04become about me. I never in a courtroom wanted
- 54:06a trial to be about me either, including a court
- 54:09trial. I wanted the lawyers to be able to do
- 54:12their job, the parties to be able to do their
- 54:14job, the witnesses to be able to do their job,
- 54:17if there was a jury, et cetera. So I think we're
- 54:22trained that if we become embroiled, if someone
- 54:26says you're just way biased and you're not listening,
- 54:30I'm not sure that the mediation would move forward.
- 54:33for me at that point. I've never had that happen.
- 54:37I hope it never happens. And honestly, if it
- 54:41did happen, we would have a conversation about
- 54:44it. What is it about the way that I'm approaching
- 54:47this that is not giving you confidence in what
- 54:51I'm saying? You don't have to agree with that.
- 54:53But how can I be more transparent? How can I
- 54:56help you to understand? I promise you, I'm just
- 54:59trying to get this done. those types of things.
- 55:02If that doesn't happen and if someone really
- 55:05said to me, Judge, you're just not getting it
- 55:07and my client really feels like you're beating
- 55:12up on the client or being incredibly biased,
- 55:15I think I would stop the mediation because then
- 55:18I'm not serving. If I am doing that or someone
- 55:22has that perception that I'm doing that, then
- 55:25I'm becoming part of the problem. And if I can't
- 55:27talk it through, if I can't help people to understand,
- 55:30I'm sorry if I said this the wrong way, or if
- 55:33you're taking it from what I'm saying, then I'm
- 55:36not able to effectively communicate, and I'm
- 55:39probably not the best mediator for that. Thankfully,
- 55:41I have not been faced even with an iota of that,
- 55:44but that's honestly, genuinely how I think it
- 55:47should probably be ideally managed. And jams,
- 55:50I know, really taught us when you're embroiled,
- 55:53you have to go. That's just the way it is. You
- 55:56can't be embroiled because you're not effective.
- 55:58And it's not fair to everybody. It's a voluntary
- 56:00process. OK, next slide. OK. Defendant wants
- 56:09to fully participate, but wants to conclude by
- 56:13full dismissal, described as a fraudulent filing.
- 56:16OK. So I look at that genuinely. That's our starting
- 56:21point. All right, I've got two parties. They're
- 56:24like as far apart as you can be. What am I going
- 56:26to do to help? So guess what? I start talking.
- 56:30Start talking to both sides. Why do you feel
- 56:32this way? Tell me what happened. I'm assessing.
- 56:36Does the defense have a point? I don't know.
- 56:39Let me hear a little bit more. And we start talking.
- 56:42And maybe I might say to the plaintiff, if it
- 56:45sounds like maybe that could be an issue. You
- 56:47know, I'm seeing some issues. I'm not sure how
- 56:49this might land with a jury. Can we talk about
- 56:52it? What are your thoughts on that? If I push
- 56:54back, if I ask some questions here, how do you
- 56:57feel about it? Defense side, why are you being
- 57:00dismissive about this? Maybe we need to talk
- 57:02a little bit about it. I'm seeing a little bit
- 57:05maybe of merit. I don't know. So those types
- 57:07of things where we're actually getting people
- 57:09talking. to really understand the different points
- 57:12of view. I don't dismiss points of view. People
- 57:15are entitled to their points of view. If I'm
- 57:17going to be dismissive about either side, I don't
- 57:20really belong mediating it. I'm not sitting as
- 57:23a judge. I'm here as a mediator. And even as
- 57:26a judge, you don't start that way. You don't
- 57:30start by being dismissive. You start by acknowledging
- 57:32you have a point of view. You have a point of
- 57:35view. They're very different. Either I'm going
- 57:38to be able to bring them together a little bit
- 57:40more and come up with a whole different point
- 57:42of view or a sort of modified point of view or
- 57:47something else is going to have to happen. So
- 57:49I am not dismissive about points of view. You
- 57:54want to talk about whether your client is the
- 57:56decision maker. You want to talk about what information
- 57:59needs to be confidential, and you really want
- 58:02to prepare for that pre -mediation call. Some
- 58:04lawyers say, Judge, I don't need a separate call
- 58:07with you. I think you get it. I'm good with that.
- 58:10Most lawyers actually really do want a separate
- 58:12call. And by the way, both of you don't need
- 58:14a separate call. Sometimes one lawyer says, no,
- 58:16I'm good. I don't need it. And the other lawyer
- 58:17says, Judge, I'd like to talk to you for a little
- 58:19bit. That's fine, too. OK? So it doesn't have
- 58:22to be all or nothing. Suzy, when you're ready,
- 58:31thank you. Okay, so here are our mediation do's
- 58:36and don'ts. And this is really just a summary
- 58:41of what we've talked about. But I'm hoping you
- 58:44take these two slides and you say to yourself,
- 58:47okay, you know what? Yeah, I knew all of that,
- 58:49but it's nice to have it reinforced. Or I knew
- 58:51some of it, but not all of it. Or, okay, you
- 58:54know what? This is kind of a helpful blueprint.
- 58:57That's the reason I do this. You do want to do
- 59:01an honest assessment about whether or not mediation
- 59:04is appropriate for your particular case. Some
- 59:09parties need a judge to tell them. Some parties
- 59:12need to go to a mandatory settlement conference
- 59:15that feels better to them than this voluntary
- 59:18process. A lot of people think mediation is kind
- 59:20of this touchy -feely process. To me, if it's
- 59:24done correctly, there is a definite absolute
- 59:27necessary element of empathy and humanness to
- 59:31it, but it's also a business process. It is saying
- 59:34to people, you're spending a lot of money here.
- 59:37We need to make sure that we're spending your
- 59:38time and your money well. And so we're going
- 59:40to look at this in a little bit more businesslike
- 59:43manner, but never forgetting the humanity of
- 59:47these people who are trying to figure out a way
- 59:49of their conflict. Don't force a matter into
- 59:53mediation, hoping it will solve. You can say,
- 59:57You know what, I think mediation would be good.
- 59:59I think getting these parties talking will be
- 1:00:02good, and I hope it resolves. That's different
- 1:00:04from, you know what, I know you don't want to
- 1:00:07do it, but I think you should do it, and let's
- 1:00:09see what happens. Do you see the difference in
- 1:00:11approach? I think if you're behind it as the
- 1:00:13lawyers, the most successful mediations to me
- 1:00:16are what the lawyers really are saying to the
- 1:00:18clients. This is the best option. There's no
- 1:00:21great option here. This is the best option. You
- 1:00:24will not be happy with what a judge does even
- 1:00:27if you win completely. It's still not going to
- 1:00:31take care of it. There are appeals and there
- 1:00:33are all sorts of other machinations that can
- 1:00:35happen. So that's what I'm talking about there.
- 1:00:39You need to do an honest assessment about whether
- 1:00:41your client is a good fit for the mediation process
- 1:00:44for the reasons that we talked about. able to
- 1:00:48set expectations, able to be open. Don't put
- 1:00:52your mediator in a position of talking some sense,
- 1:00:56literally like that, into the client. That doesn't
- 1:00:59mean you can't say to the mediator or judge,
- 1:01:01the bad news might be better coming from you
- 1:01:04than coming from me. That's a whole different
- 1:01:09ballgame, completely appropriate. You can schedule
- 1:01:13a mediation where your client is open to hearing
- 1:01:15an honest assessment of the strengths and weaknesses
- 1:01:17or at least willing to listen, maybe not hear
- 1:01:21it, but willing to listen, that's fine. If your
- 1:01:25client is saying, I'm not negotiating and the
- 1:01:27only purpose of the mediation is something like
- 1:01:30that, maybe that dog bite case or the fraudulent
- 1:01:33claim case. And the only purpose of the mediation
- 1:01:36is to have the other side say, oh yeah, you're
- 1:01:40right. that's not going to work. If it is, you
- 1:01:44know, I really think we're correct on this and
- 1:01:46I'm really hoping a good mediator can educate
- 1:01:50the other side on the law a little bit and maybe
- 1:01:53what might happen in a courtroom, that's appropriate.
- 1:01:56Next slide please. Please prepare for that pre
- 1:02:01-mediation call. I think you've heard me say
- 1:02:03enough on that. I need to stress that. Just if
- 1:02:08you take nothing else away, those pre -mediation
- 1:02:10calls are critical. Do prepare your client for
- 1:02:14mediation. That concessions will have to be made.
- 1:02:18And here's the big takeaway from everything.
- 1:02:23The resolution may not be fair. It's a resolution.
- 1:02:30I think lawyers and mediators try very hard to
- 1:02:34try to get to a mostly fair result. Sometimes
- 1:02:38I call it being arbitrarily fair. I think everyone
- 1:02:42tries to do that, but fairness is a subjective
- 1:02:46term. And that's the way we really need to prepare
- 1:02:49clients, right? It's subjective. What you think
- 1:02:52is fair may not be fair to someone else. That's
- 1:02:55why judges make different decisions. One judge
- 1:02:57says, this is my idea of fairness here. And another
- 1:02:59judge says, this is my idea of fairness. The
- 1:03:01juries are the same way. That's what they do.
- 1:03:05So I think the way to prepare is to say that
- 1:03:10we are going to try to reach a resolution, some
- 1:03:13things you will like, some things you don't like,
- 1:03:15and some things you may think are unfair, but
- 1:03:17we may have to do that to get it solved the best
- 1:03:20way that we know how. Do set your client's expectations
- 1:03:26that the goal of mediation is to get matters.
- 1:03:29resolved on terms that are agreeable to both
- 1:03:32parties. I cannot stress that strongly enough.
- 1:03:35That's all a resolution is, is what everyone
- 1:03:38is willing to do. I may think to myself, wow,
- 1:03:42I don't know. I don't know if that's fair. Guess
- 1:03:45what? That thought actually stays to myself unless
- 1:03:48I'm in an evaluated mode and people are asking
- 1:03:50me, Judge, what do you think might happen? What
- 1:03:52do you think is fair? Okay. Don't set your client's
- 1:03:56expectations for a particular outcome other than
- 1:03:58everyone is going to work very hard and we are
- 1:04:01very hopeful that it will solve, okay? And work
- 1:04:06through different scenarios with your client
- 1:04:08in terms of making concessions. Do try and work
- 1:04:12through that remediation to get them in the habit
- 1:04:14and to get that uncomfortable feeling where you
- 1:04:18may have to concede here and your client goes,
- 1:04:19no. And you start working with your client pre
- 1:04:22-mediation to say, well, actually, yeah, I want
- 1:04:25you to think about it. I'm not saying we'll do
- 1:04:27it. I'm not saying it will come up. But I actually
- 1:04:30want you to think about it. Next slide, please.
- 1:04:37Do talk to your client about the differences
- 1:04:40between facilitative and evaluative and the fact
- 1:04:43that the mediator may start as facilitative and
- 1:04:46then move to evaluative. So don't forget, you
- 1:04:49know, You can say, look, this mediator really
- 1:04:51is going to try and bridge our differences. But
- 1:04:54at some point, we may ask this mediator, based
- 1:04:56upon the experience of the mediator, how the
- 1:04:59mediator might solve this case. And I think that's
- 1:05:04fine. But you need to let your clients know that
- 1:05:06that can be all part of the mix. And then finally,
- 1:05:10it's interesting to me. One of my favorite questions
- 1:05:14in a mediation is, Judge, this is what we are
- 1:05:19thinking. How do you think that might land in
- 1:05:22the other room? What a fabulous question, because
- 1:05:26I generally, I'm the one who knows what's going
- 1:05:28on in both rooms, and I generally have an opinion
- 1:05:31about that. As in, yes, I think that'll be okay.
- 1:05:35Let me try it. Help me to understand why you're
- 1:05:38asking it, because I'm the one who's gotta go
- 1:05:40over there and sell it. So if I don't believe
- 1:05:41in it, or it's not transparent to me, We have
- 1:05:45to work that through, because when I go in, I
- 1:05:47want to know what I'm saying, why I'm saying
- 1:05:49it, and I want to be as transparent as possible.
- 1:05:53And sometimes I will say, wow, I'm not sure that's
- 1:05:57going to land well. I think that is going to
- 1:05:59be a difficult sell. Can we soften it? Can we
- 1:06:05think of something different? And I find that
- 1:06:07people are very receptive to that, right? Because
- 1:06:09we do want it to land well in the other room.
- 1:06:12So don't be afraid. to talk with your mediator
- 1:06:15about that. Could you please summarize the difference?
- 1:06:19Oh, sure. So, facilitative is someone who is
- 1:06:24really facilitating, exchanging information.
- 1:06:28Do you see the way my hands are moving? Kind
- 1:06:30of moving information back and forth between
- 1:06:33the rooms to see if we can all get on the same
- 1:06:35page. about sometimes about factual issues. If
- 1:06:39we can narrow our disputes on factual issues,
- 1:06:42we wanna try and get on the same page about legal
- 1:06:45issues. And so I'm exchanging information back
- 1:06:48and forth. Room A believes that the sun rises
- 1:06:52in the East. Room B believes that the sun rises
- 1:06:56in the West. How am I going to bridge that? Well,
- 1:06:59I'm gonna start by saying this is what each of
- 1:07:02you believes. Both can't be true, so what do
- 1:07:05we need to do to see if we can solve that problem
- 1:07:08and get you on the same page? An evaluative mediator
- 1:07:13would be, and there's kind of a fond saying most
- 1:07:17of you may have heard it, which is most mediators
- 1:07:19start out facilitative, and then as the day goes
- 1:07:21on and people are getting tired, they get a little
- 1:07:24more evaluative, which is, yes, the sun rises
- 1:07:28in the east, And from my point of view, based
- 1:07:32upon what I know about the law and the facts,
- 1:07:36the sun sets in the west. Okay, I can tell you
- 1:07:39that. I'm evaluating your claim and I'm telling
- 1:07:41you this is kind of what I think. It's in the
- 1:07:44for what it's worth department, because I'm not
- 1:07:46trying the case. I'm not the judge on the case.
- 1:07:48And I've only heard the things that I'm hearing
- 1:07:50in this particular mediation. Again, evaluated
- 1:07:54should not be, this is what a judge is going
- 1:07:57to do. This is what a jury is going to do. We
- 1:08:00don't know. I don't know what another judge is
- 1:08:03going to do. I can tell you how things might
- 1:08:06land in a courtroom. I might tell you if I think
- 1:08:09you might have more of an uphill battle. But
- 1:08:12at the end of the day, that's just one person's
- 1:08:14opinion. That's my perspective. All right. I
- 1:08:19did go over the time limit. I apologize for that.
- 1:08:21But I did try and answer the questions at the
- 1:08:24same time. Thank you all for having me today.
- 1:08:28I appreciate it very, very much. And I hope to
- 1:08:30see you soon.