Latest / Deep Dive / The High Price of Professional Smiles: The Hidden Cost of Emotional Labor
Transcript
- 0:00You know, when you think about clocking into a new job, you you
- 0:05naturally picture handing over a very specific set of things.
- 0:08Right, like your time? Exactly your time, your physical
- 0:10presence. Maybe you put on a literal
- 0:12uniform like a polo shirt or a name tag.
- 0:15You read the HR job description and it tells you you know
- 0:18exactly what tasks you're being paid to perform between 9:00 and
- 0:215:00. Yeah, it's a transaction that we
- 0:23all generally understand and and accept.
- 0:27You are selling your mental focus or your physical labor for
- 0:31set number of hours. You do the tasks, you get the
- 0:33paycheck. Right.
- 0:34But imagine if right after you put on your name tag, your
- 0:38manager pulls you aside and hands you a company issued
- 0:41personality. Wow.
- 0:42Yeah, and I don't just mean a script of what to say to a
- 0:44customer, I mean a literal dial that controls your internal
- 0:48nervous system, right? Like turning your actual
- 0:50feelings on and off. Exactly.
- 0:51They tell you to turn your natural empathy up to A10, dial
- 0:54your perfectly justified frustration down to a zero, and
- 0:58why are your very soul to the company's profit margin?
- 1:01It sounds like dystopian science fiction, honestly.
- 1:04We love to believe our inner lives, our actual feelings, are
- 1:07our own private property, right? But the truth is, a massive
- 1:11portion of the workforce is already wearing that invisible
- 1:15psychological uniform every single day.
- 1:18Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission today is to uncover
- 1:21the invisible, unwritten psychological work we all do at
- 1:25our jobs. The grueling labor that never,
- 1:28ever makes it into an official HR job description.
- 1:31But we have some incredible material to get into today.
- 1:34We really do. We are diving into two
- 1:36phenomenal sources to figure this out.
- 1:38The first is Arlie Russell Hawkschild's foundational book,
- 1:41The Managed Heart Commercialization of Human
- 1:44Feeling. A total classic in sociology.
- 1:46Absolutely. And to see how this plays out in
- 1:49the modern hyper competitive corporate grind, we're pairing
- 1:51it with a fascinating 2023 study from the Nepal Journal of
- 1:55Multidisciplinary Research by Ganesh Baturai.
- 1:58It's all about corporate politics and the wild psychology
- 2:00of office survival. It's a great combination of
- 2:02sources. OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:05Because whether you are serving a customer at 30,000 feet or
- 2:09dodging A manipulative boss in a cubicle, you are likely
- 2:12performing a hidden full time job inside your actual job.
- 2:17Yeah, and to really grasp what this hidden job actually is, you
- 2:21have to look at how the very concept of Labor has mutated
- 2:26over the last century or so. Right, the definition has
- 2:28completely changed. Exactly.
- 2:30And Haas Child gives us this incredibly stark historical
- 2:33contrast. To start with, she pulls A
- 2:36deposition from Karl Marx's writings about a 19th century
- 2:39boy working in a British wallpaper factory.
- 2:41Oh man, that passage was brutal to read.
- 2:44Yeah, it really is. I mean, we were talking about a
- 2:46child, seven years old, working 16 hours a day.
- 2:49The conditions are so physically demanding that his mother
- 2:52actually has to carry him to work through the snow.
- 2:54And feed him while he's working, right?
- 2:55Yes, she feeds him his meals while he stands at the machine.
- 2:58Because he literally cannot stop moving, he is entirely reduced
- 3:02to an instrument of physical labor.
- 3:04His arm is basically just a meat gear in the wallpaper machine.
- 3:08It's horrifying. He is completely alienated from
- 3:11his own body, but the transaction, as cruel as it is,
- 3:15is transparent. Meaning what exactly?
- 3:18Well, the product of his labor is incredibly obvious.
- 3:20You can just count the rolls of wallpaper.
- 3:22At the end of the day, the factory owner bought his muscle
- 3:25movements, nothing more. Right.
- 3:27You give me your muscles, I give you a wage.
- 3:29Exactly. But then Hochschild jumps us a
- 3:32century forward. We land in the 1980s inside a
- 3:36Delta Airlines stewardess training center.
- 3:38Quite a pivot. Yeah, we see a 20 year old
- 3:41flight attendant trainee sitting in an auditorium with over 100
- 3:45others and a company pilot stands up and tells these
- 3:48recruits, your smile is your biggest asset.
- 3:52I want you go out there and use it.
- 3:53Smile, really smile, really late on.
- 3:55Which, you know on the surface sounds almost folksy and
- 3:58encouraging. Sure, it sounds like standard
- 3:59corporate pep talk. Right until you realize what's
- 4:02actually being commanded there. The product isn't a physical
- 4:05roll of wallpaper anymore. The product is a state of mind.
- 4:09The airline isn't just buying her physical labor to push a
- 4:12heavy metal meal cart down an aisle at 30,000 feet.
- 4:15They are requiring her to induce an artificial elation.
- 4:19The goal is to make passengers feel secure, pampered and happy
- 4:23enough to buy another ticket. It's like having your actual
- 4:26personality turned into a company uniform.
- 4:28That's a great way to put it. But wait, let me push back on
- 4:31this a little bit. Sure.
- 4:32Isn't this just basic customer service?
- 4:34I mean, if I'm paying for a flight, I don't want a grumpy
- 4:36flight attendant. We all want polite service.
- 4:40Where is the actual harm in asking someone to smile and be
- 4:43nice in exchange for a paycheck? It's a very fair question, and
- 4:46it's actually the core assumption that Hochschild wants
- 4:49to dismantle in the book. To understand the harm, we have
- 4:53to look at what is being alienated, OK?
- 4:54Alienated how? Well, remember the boy in the
- 4:57factory? When you do purely physical
- 4:59labor, your body becomes an instrument, but when your job is
- 5:03what hostile coins as emotional labor, which she defines as the
- 5:06active coordination of your mind and feeling to produce a proper
- 5:09state of mind in others, you risk becoming alienated from
- 5:13your own emotions. So you become estranged from
- 5:15your own smile? Yes.
- 5:17You lose touch with your own face, essentially.
- 5:19She actually quotes flight attendants in the book who talk
- 5:22about coming home from a long, grueling multi day trip in a
- 5:26state of utter exhaustion, but they literally cannot drop this
- 5:31artificially created elation. Right, they get stuck in
- 5:33character. Yeah, they're sitting in their
- 5:35living rooms, stuck giggling and shattering, completely unable to
- 5:39access their genuine feelings of fatigue or frustration.
- 5:43The smile was on them, but no longer of them and the airlines
- 5:48know exactly what they are selling here.
- 5:51There was a radio Jingle for PSA Airlines back then that
- 5:53explicitly said our smiles are not just painted on.
- 5:57Wow, they really just said it out loud.
- 5:59They did. They're promising the consumer
- 6:01that the workers warmth is completely authentic.
- 6:04So the worker isn't just required to act polite, they are
- 6:06contractually required to sincerely feel polite.
- 6:09Which is wild. If it's so deeply alienating to
- 6:12essentially rent out your soul to a corporation, how do people
- 6:16not just snap on day 2? I mean, the corporate theater
- 6:18clearly has its own acting techniques to keep the
- 6:20performance going, right? It does.
- 6:23Workers essentially rely on 2 distinct types of acting to
- 6:27survive emotional labor. The 1st is surface acting is
- 6:31exactly what it sounds like painting on an expression.
- 6:34Think of a deeply exhausted ticket agent giving you a
- 6:37perfectly polite, entirely hollow apology when your flight
- 6:41is delayed for the third time. Oh, we've all been on the
- 6:44receiving end of that apology. Right.
- 6:46They aren't trying to actually feel sorry for you, they were
- 6:49just managing their outward physical display.
- 6:52They're literally just moving the muscles in their face to
- 6:55form the shape of an apology. Inside, they might be rolling
- 6:58their eyes or calculating how many minutes until their break,
- 7:01but the surface remains undisturbed.
- 7:03It's just a physical mask. Exactly.
- 7:05But then there is deep acting, and this draws straight from
- 7:08Constantin Stanislavski's method acting.
- 7:10Like what actors do for a movie? Role.
- 7:12Yes, exactly. In deep acting, workers aren't
- 7:15just changing their faces, they are actively trying to alter
- 7:19their internal feelings to match what the company demands.
- 7:23They manipulate their own imaginations to conjure up
- 7:25genuine emotion. Here's where it gets really
- 7:28interesting, because the sources outline exactly how companies
- 7:31systematically teach this psychological manipulation.
- 7:35Yeah, the training programs are intense.
- 7:37In that Delta recurrent training class, they are teaching flight
- 7:40attendants how to deal with what they call irates, which is
- 7:43industry slang for angry, abusive passengers.
- 7:46The instructor explicitly teaches these trainees how to
- 7:49hack their own empathy. Right, they give them specific
- 7:52mental prompts. Yes, she tells a story to the
- 7:55class about a passenger who was screaming at her, cursing,
- 7:59threatening to get her fired. And instead of getting naturally
- 8:02defensive or angry, she tells the class, she pretends that
- 8:05something deeply traumatic has happened in the passenger's
- 8:08life. She imagines that this screaming
- 8:10man's son has just died. Think about the profound
- 8:13psychological mechanics happening in that moment.
- 8:16It's heavy. It is.
- 8:17The instructor is using extreme deep acting.
- 8:20By actively imagining a tragedy, she bypasses her own natural
- 8:24anger and self-defense mechanisms.
- 8:27She artificially induces a feeling of deep pity and empathy
- 8:30for someone who is actively mistreating her.
- 8:32And she presents this to the class not as some bizarre
- 8:36personal coping mechanism, but as a standard company approved
- 8:40customer service technique. Right.
- 8:43Or if the dead relative approach is too dark, they are taught to
- 8:47imagine the drunk abusive passenger is just a helpless,
- 8:51throwing a tantrum toddler. That is just wild to me.
- 8:55Corporations aren't merely telling you what to do with your
- 8:57hands anymore. They are providing you with
- 8:59highly specific, emotionally devastating mental fantasies to
- 9:04trick your own brain into feeling empathy instead of
- 9:07justifiable anger. It's a total override of your
- 9:09natural instincts. Yeah, you're being yelled at,
- 9:12and instead of asserting A boundary, you're mentally
- 9:14writing a tragic back story for your abuser just so you can keep
- 9:17smiling sincerely. Well, to truly understand how a
- 9:20company can successfully hijack our inner lives like that, we
- 9:23have to recognize that they didn't invent this machinery
- 9:26from scratch. What?
- 9:27Do you mean? They are tapping into a
- 9:29psychological system that already exists inside us.
- 9:31They just found a way to monetize it.
- 9:33Oh right, because because we already do this in our private
- 9:35lives. Hawks child calls these feeling
- 9:37rules. Yes, feeling rules.
- 9:39These are the invisible, deeply ingrained cultural scripts that
- 9:44tell us what we should feel in any given situation, completely
- 9:48separate from what we might actually be feeling at the time.
- 9:51Feeling rules dictate the acceptable emotional currency
- 9:54for different social events. The text provides a couple of
- 9:58brilliant, relatable examples of this happening organically in
- 10:02everyday life. Like the wedding example?
- 10:04Right. The bride on her wedding day.
- 10:06Culturally, the feeling rule is absolute.
- 10:09This must be the happiest, most magical day of your life, no?
- 10:11Pressure or anything? Exactly.
- 10:14But this particular bride's rehearsal was chaotic.
- 10:17Her family was causing drama instead of helping her get
- 10:20ready, and as she was walking to the church, she felt intensely
- 10:23depressed and tense. Her authentic feelings were
- 10:26wildly misfitting the cultural situation.
- 10:28So what does she do? She used deep acting.
- 10:31She mentally prompted herself. She had this internal monologue
- 10:34where she said hey, people aren't getting married, you are.
- 10:37Be happy for the friends, the relatives, the presents.
- 10:40She actively worked to suppress the stress and generate the
- 10:43correct emotion of joy so she could fulfill the expectation of
- 10:47the wedding. And we see it in the opposite
- 10:49direction too, dealing with grief.
- 10:50There's a story in the book of a young girl at her baby sister's
- 10:54funeral. Oh, that one was fascinating.
- 10:57Yeah. The feeling rule is obviously
- 10:59profound, quiet sadness, but the girl, being very young, was
- 11:03actually kind of enjoying the fact that she was the center of
- 11:06attention again and she hadn't yet processed a deep personal
- 11:09loss. Which is totally normal for a
- 11:11kid. Right.
- 11:12But when the adults started blowing their noses, she thought
- 11:15the sound was funny and started giggling.
- 11:18But even as a child, she knew the rule.
- 11:20Yeah, so she immediately masked her laughter by pretending to
- 11:23sob uncontrollably just so her piano teacher wouldn't be
- 11:27horrified. Wow.
- 11:28Even kids are doing surface acting.
- 11:30Exactly. If we connect this to the bigger
- 11:32picture, what we are seeing is the transmutation of an
- 11:36emotional system. Transmutation.
- 11:37Yes, in our private lives, we use deep acting and feeling
- 11:41rules as organic gifts to the people we care about.
- 11:45A bride works up joy as a gift to her new spouse and her
- 11:48guests. A child suppresses inappropriate
- 11:50laughter at a funeral as a tribute to the mourners.
- 11:54It's a private, voluntary exchange.
- 11:56But in the commercial world, companies take over those exact
- 11:59same feeling rules. Precisely, they write them into
- 12:03the training manuals. The private voluntary gift
- 12:06becomes a mandatory commercial commodity.
- 12:08The transmutation is the shift from I want to feel happy for my
- 12:11spouse to I must feel happy because Delta Airlines quarterly
- 12:16profit margin depends on my sincere warmth.
- 12:19And this raises the ultimate question, what is the true
- 12:22hidden cost of this transmutation?
- 12:24Ha Child argues that the greatest danger is that workers
- 12:27lose the signal function of their emotions.
- 12:29The signal function. Let's make sure we unpack that
- 12:31clearly for everyone listening, because it feels like the core
- 12:33hazard here. Sure.
- 12:34Think of your emotions as a biological and psychological
- 12:37warning system. They are essentially your
- 12:40internal fire alarms. Anger signals that your
- 12:42boundaries are being crossed or an injustice is occurring.
- 12:45Fear signals danger. Sadness signals loss.
- 12:50Your feelings tell you where you stand vis A vis the world.
- 12:53So they give you crucial data about your environment.
- 12:56Exactly. But if you spend 40 hours a week
- 12:59deliberately suppressing your anger at abusive passengers by
- 13:03imagining they are grieving parents, you are actively
- 13:06dismantling your own alarm system.
- 13:08You literally lose the ability to know when you are genuinely
- 13:12being mistreated. Yes, because you've trained your
- 13:14brain to respond to abuse with manufactured empathy.
- 13:18You unplug the fire alarm so the noise doesn't bother the
- 13:21customers. That is incredibly unsettling,
- 13:23and it's one thing to do this for a stranger you'll never see
- 13:26again after they deplane. What happens when the person
- 13:28demanding this emotional labor isn't a temporary customer, but
- 13:32the manager sitting three feet away from you?
- 13:34That's a whole different level of stress.
- 13:36Right. Often the most intense emotional
- 13:38labor we do is to survive our Co workers and especially to
- 13:41survive our bosses. And this brings us directly to
- 13:44the 2023 study by Ganesh Padurai from the Nepal Journal of
- 13:48Multidisciplinary Research. This research shifts our focus
- 13:52away from the frontline service worker dealing with the public
- 13:55and plunges us into the internal corporate office environment.
- 13:59Potter I surveyed over 700 employees in the highly
- 14:04competitive banking industry in Nepal, looking specifically at
- 14:08how they cope with toxic internal environments.
- 14:10He focused on a concept called perceived corporate Politics or
- 14:14PCP, and I love that there's a formal academic term for this
- 14:17because anyone listening who has ever worked in an office knows
- 14:20exactly what this feels like. Oh definitely.
- 14:21Picture that one Co worker who constantly CCS your boss on
- 14:25every minor e-mail just to look busy.
- 14:27Or the manager who constantly shifts the goal posts on a
- 14:29project so they can take credit for the save.
- 14:32PCP is when employees perceive that the people around them are
- 14:35engaging in self interested, manipulative, policy bending
- 14:38behaviors just to get ahead. Yeah, it's the backstabbing, the
- 14:41resource hoarding, the playing favorites.
- 14:44It is the dark underbelly of organizational life.
- 14:47So true. Now older, perhaps more cynical
- 14:50studies sometimes suggested that corporate politics could
- 14:53actually be functional, that playing the game might
- 14:56positively help people advance their careers.
- 14:58Just play the game and win. Right, right.
- 15:00But patterized study wanted to measure exactly how being
- 15:03trapped in an environment with high perceived corporate
- 15:05politics effects an employee's actual career satisfaction
- 15:09today. Which brings up a major driving
- 15:11question for this whole thing. If you realize you are trapped
- 15:15in a highly political, manipulative, backstabbing
- 15:18corporate environment, does it just destroy your career
- 15:21satisfaction entirely? Are you just doomed to be
- 15:24miserable until you quit? Or is there some kind of
- 15:27psychological escape hatch employees use to survive?
- 15:30The data provides A deeply fascinating and somewhat
- 15:34disturbing answer to that 1st, the study mathematically
- 15:37quantified the misery. It confirmed that working in a
- 15:39highly political environment causes a massive direct plunge
- 15:43in career satisfaction. Like how massive?
- 15:45The direct effect was negative 0.35.
- 15:49The numbers show a severe drop in morale.
- 15:51Working in a snake pit makes you hate your career.
- 15:54Well, no surprise there. Snakes are generally terrible
- 15:57for morale. Right, But the twist comes in
- 15:59how employees adapt. The study found that employees
- 16:03don't just sit there and passively absorb the misery.
- 16:07They deploy a primary coping mechanism that statistically
- 16:10buffers the damage. An escape hatch.
- 16:12Yes, and that mechanism is ingratiation behavior.
- 16:16Flattery. Kissing up to the boss.
- 16:19Exactly. Ingratiation is conceptualized
- 16:23in the literature as actively flattering targets, vigorously
- 16:27agreeing with your boss's viewpoints even when they're
- 16:29completely flawed, displaying alignment with their values, and
- 16:33literally reminding and repeating what your colleagues
- 16:36like to hear. So they just become yes men.
- 16:38Pretty much. When employees perceive high
- 16:40corporate politics, they significantly increase their
- 16:43ingratiation behaviors. They realize the game is rigged,
- 16:46so they start playing the game. Wait, but flattery makes you
- 16:48feel better about your job? That sounds completely
- 16:51counterintuitor to me. It really does.
- 16:53I mean, if your boss is toxic and manipulative, wouldn't
- 16:56fawning over them and laughing at their unfunny jokes just make
- 16:59you feel more compromised? Wouldn't wouldn't that destroy
- 17:02yourself esteem even faster? You would think so, but the
- 17:05study found the exact opposite. While the direct effect of
- 17:09corporate politics on satisfaction is highly negative,
- 17:12the indirect effect routed through this increased
- 17:15ingratiation is actually positive.
- 17:17You're kidding. No, it created an indirect
- 17:20positive impact of plus 0.18. By actively flattering their
- 17:25manipulative bosses and colleagues, employees somehow
- 17:28offset a significant chunk of their own misery.
- 17:31How does that actually work psychologically?
- 17:33What is the mechanism there? It comes down to a restoration
- 17:36of agency. When you are just a passive
- 17:38victim of office politics, you feel helpless.
- 17:41But when you actively decide to ingratiate yourself, you are
- 17:43taking an action. You aren't just being
- 17:45manipulated anymore, you are actively managing the threat.
- 17:48So. You get some control back.
- 17:50Yes, you regain a sense of control over your environment,
- 17:54even if that control is achieved through fawning.
- 17:57What's fascinating here is how Botteri explicitly connects this
- 18:01behavior to Charles Darwin and the concept of survival of the
- 18:04fittest. Office Evolution.
- 18:06Exactly, and a politically charged, resource scarce
- 18:09corporate environment. Ingratiation is an evolutionary
- 18:13adaptation. You make yourself seem
- 18:16invaluable, agreeable and completely non threatening to
- 18:19the predators in the office. It is a calculated survival
- 18:23strategy. So what does this all mean?
- 18:24It's almost like developing Stockholm syndrome on purpose.
- 18:28That's a dark way to look at it, but yeah.
- 18:30You realize you can't escape the toxic environment, you need the
- 18:33paycheck, you can't just quit. So you actively trick your brain
- 18:36into aligning with the threat so it doesn't feel like a threat
- 18:38anymore, right? You use emotional labor, surface
- 18:41acting, maybe even deep acting to make the boss like you.
- 18:44And that resulting bubble of safety actually makes you feel
- 18:47slightly better about your terrible job.
- 18:50Basically, kissing up to the boss is the emotional hazard pay
- 18:53you give yourself to survive a toxic office environment.
- 18:56It is a profound survival mechanism.
- 18:59But think about the incredible emotional toll it demands.
- 19:03You are a bank employee. You see your boss bending
- 19:06policies, acting selfishly, maybe throwing a colleague under
- 19:09the bus. Your natural signal function,
- 19:12that internal fire alarm we talked about earlier, is
- 19:14screaming at you that this person is untrustworthy and
- 19:17unfair. You should feel angry or
- 19:19disgusted. But you absolutely cannot
- 19:22express that if you want to keep your job or get a promotion.
- 19:24Instead, you suppress the disgust.
- 19:27You actively search for things to praise.
- 19:29You repeat their flawed opinions back to them as if there were
- 19:32brilliant insights. You are performing intense
- 19:35emotional labor, transmuting your natural sense of justice
- 19:38into an artificial display of loyalty and admiration.
- 19:41And if you do it long enough, going back to Hofschild's
- 19:44framework, you might even start using deep acting to convince
- 19:47yourself that your boss actually is brilliant, just to reduce the
- 19:50cognitive dissonance. Wow, it's too exhausting to hate
- 19:53someone you have to flatter 8 hours a day.
- 19:55Yeah, so you hack your own brain to actually like the snake.
- 19:58And that is exactly where these two sources beautifully and
- 20:02tragically intersect. Whether you are a flight
- 20:05attendant using Stanislavski's acting methods to suppress your
- 20:08rage and abusive passenger by imagining A fictional tragedy,
- 20:12or a bank employee using calculated ingratiation to
- 20:15flatter a manipulative boss just to survive the fiscal quarter,
- 20:20the modern economy demands a massive, completely unpaid toll
- 20:24on our inner emotional lives. It really does.
- 20:27We are constantly managing our hearts just to grease the wheels
- 20:31of commerce. The invisible labor is
- 20:33everywhere once you know how to look for it.
- 20:35We are all actively managing the signal functions of our emotions
- 20:39to stay employed, to climb the ladder and to stay sane.
- 20:42We are quite literally selling our baseline reality.
- 20:45It makes you look at your own day completely differently,
- 20:47doesn't it? I want you to think about it for
- 20:49a second. It's a great exercise.
- 20:50Think about your own day today. How many times did you mentally
- 20:53prompt yourself to feel something different just to make
- 20:55a meeting go smoother? How many times did you paint on
- 20:58a smile, or swallow a very valid frustration, or eagerly agree
- 21:02with a strategy you secretly knew was doomed to fail?
- 21:05It's the unwritten requirement of the modern workplace.
- 21:08You don't just bring your skills, you bring your managed
- 21:11emotions. Which leaves us with a pretty
- 21:13terrifying question to Mull over.
- 21:15If we spend 40 hours a week deep acting.
- 21:18If we are constantly managing our feelings to appease
- 21:21customers and strategically ingratiating ourselves to bosses
- 21:25to survive the corporate snake pit, when we finally clock out,
- 21:28go home, and take off that invisible company issued
- 21:31personality, do we even know what our own unmanaged feelings
- 21:35look like anymore? Or.
- 21:36Is the dial permanently stuck? It's a profound question worth
- 21:39asking yourself the next time you find yourself smiling at
- 21:42work when you really just want to scream.
- 21:44Absolutely. Thanks for joining us on this
- 21:46deep dive. See you next time.