Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Judges’ Perspectives on Discovery, Law & Motion with Commentary on the Role of A.I
Transcript
- 0:03Quick introduction. We've got two of our Superior
- 0:06Court judges from the Kern County Superior Court,
- 0:08who is the second of our series that we're doing.
- 0:11It is covering discovery, law and motion, and
- 0:15their views on AI. We have a lot of material
- 0:17to follow. And unfortunately, we lost about 10
- 0:19minutes in this process. If you're able to hang
- 0:21on afterwards, we're going to try to also have
- 0:24at the end some questions. But the judges do
- 0:26have to get back to trial. So we're going to
- 0:28do our very best to get through this as quickly
- 0:30as we can. Couple of introductions, Judge Clark
- 0:34and Judge Barman. They are both our senior -most
- 0:37judges in the current kind of superior court.
- 0:39You're going to get great information and views
- 0:41from them on how they view the subject matters
- 0:44that we run into every day, discovery in law
- 0:46and motion. And so as part of this process, we're
- 0:50going to try to ask questions that are probably
- 0:53affecting each of you in your practice on a regular
- 0:55basis. I want to do a few quick thanks. One is
- 0:59to our sponsor, Signature Resolution. I am a
- 1:01neutral at signature resolution, but they were
- 1:04kind enough to donate enough money so that both
- 1:07this program and the program on November 17th,
- 1:10dealing with trial, also by judges of the Kern
- 1:13County Superior Court who can present, that they
- 1:16can be able to put it free. So anyone who's a
- 1:18member of the San Joaquin chapter of ABOTA, Kern
- 1:22County Bar Association, or the Beverly Hills
- 1:25Bar Association, we're all doing in conjunction
- 1:27with each other. You have it free, courtesy.
- 1:29of signature resolution and with the assistance
- 1:32of the Beverly Hills Bar, which we want to thank
- 1:34as well. Now, with those intros in, let's go
- 1:38ahead and get started because there's a lot to
- 1:39cover. One of the issues that we deal with every
- 1:42day is discovery. And so one of the first things
- 1:44we want to find out of what kind of issues that
- 1:46the judges have to deal with from their perspective
- 1:49on discovery and their views on it. I'm going
- 1:52to start with Judge Barman. If you can give me
- 1:55a quick overview of what should the audience
- 1:59here know about you in dealing with discovery
- 2:01matters? Okay, well, I, as a litigator, spent
- 2:04a big chunk of my life dealing with discovery
- 2:06disputes. And in my view, most discovery disputes
- 2:10do not belong in court in front of a judge for
- 2:12us to decide. The rules of discovery are pretty
- 2:14straightforward for the most part. If you spend
- 2:18the time with opposing counsel to try to work
- 2:20out what you really need or what they really
- 2:21need, you should be able to resolve whatever
- 2:24the disputes are. You know, if a request is overbroad,
- 2:28overly burdensome in your view, you should be
- 2:29able to help trim that down to something you
- 2:31can both work with. But, you know, that being
- 2:34said, sometimes discovery motions are, you know,
- 2:38unavoidable and you need to come in and get a
- 2:40judge's opinion on, you know, maybe an objection,
- 2:43maybe there's a privilege issue, maybe there
- 2:45is an overbreath issue. But keep in mind that
- 2:50we're busy. We don't have lots of time to spend
- 2:52on your motions. You know, we're in trial most
- 2:55days. We don't have a lot of time to work up,
- 2:58you know, what you're asking for, what your basis
- 3:01for your opposition is. We have only a few minutes
- 3:03each day, really, to pay attention to the papers.
- 3:06And, you know, so on the on the responding party
- 3:11side, do what you can to put your position out
- 3:13there. Hey, we've been reasonable. We've said
- 3:15we'll give you this, but we're not going to give
- 3:16you this. And here's why or this question is
- 3:19vague. I don't really understand it. I'm not
- 3:21going to answer it until I have a clear understanding.
- 3:23But have a defensible position. If you're going
- 3:25to end up in front of a court, have a defensible
- 3:27position so that it is the other side that is
- 3:31being unreasonable. So those are sort of my views
- 3:35on generally on discovery motions in a nutshell.
- 3:38When Judge Barman says have a defensible position,
- 3:44he means show that you have made some effort
- 3:50to comply with your discovery responses. as opposed
- 3:53to a sheet of weather plate objections. I've
- 4:01got 1 ,100 cases more or less assigned to me.
- 4:06You can imagine how many motions come up on those
- 4:10cases. Probably half of them are discovery motions.
- 4:16Most of those do not have to have been filed.
- 4:21a little bit of civility and a little less gamesmanship,
- 4:25the attorneys should have been able to resolve
- 4:27those things. So I'm already not in a good mood
- 4:31when I'm addressing discovery motions. On your
- 4:38case, if you've had a couple discovery motions
- 4:41heard and decided by me, you should have a pretty
- 4:43good idea of how I'm going to rule on the future
- 4:46motions. So I really get distressed when I see
- 4:50round three, round four, and round five. And
- 4:55that's when, by that time, you're probably already
- 5:00at a discovery referee, which is a very expensive
- 5:03way to go. But out of 1 ,100 cases, I'm probably
- 5:09going to have 50 cases where the attorneys are
- 5:13really causing discovery problems. And I can't
- 5:16take the time to deal with that small number
- 5:19of cases. Just a quick note and update on the
- 5:24meet and confer process. There's a meet and confer
- 5:27declaration update that occurred to CCP 2016
- 5:30.40. Be mindful that just letters by themselves
- 5:35don't do it. Attempts to meet and confer are
- 5:37required to be in person by telephone or by video
- 5:40conference. Read your code and pay attention
- 5:43to what the requirements are. Let's go on to
- 5:46the next note though. And that is on the meet
- 5:49and confer process. I just described what the
- 5:52code is talking about in the section to talk
- 5:54about it. Tell us what you expect to see, because
- 5:57you get these declarations about there's been
- 5:59meet and confer. What do you expect as to a good
- 6:02faith meet and confer, and what are the issues
- 6:03you're coming across? So we'll send out a letter,
- 6:08and if you don't fully 100 % comply within 24
- 6:11hours, we're going to file a motion. That's not
- 6:13good faith meet and confer. You should be available.
- 6:17to work it out with the other side on a phone
- 6:20call, in -person meeting, whatever. So I see
- 6:24some of that where somebody just fires off a
- 6:25letter because they think that complies. In my
- 6:28view, it does not. Oh, I know the statute. No,
- 6:30it doesn't. Yeah. You know, and on the other
- 6:34side, if you're going to respond with, no, we
- 6:35stand completely on our objections. They're all
- 6:37merit. They all have merit. And so you're not
- 6:39getting bupkis from us. And you're standing on
- 6:42objections that essentially shield everything
- 6:43your client has from discovery. That's not going
- 6:46to work either. You need to make a good faith
- 6:48effort to try to work it out. That being said,
- 6:51it's rare that I'll deny emotion for lack of
- 6:53meet and confer. I'll usually cut to the substance
- 6:57of it. But. It will help. I think it'll help
- 7:01you if you do an actual good faith, meet and
- 7:04confer process. There are times I'll deny the
- 7:06motion because the moving party jumped into court
- 7:09too quickly. All right. Judge Clark, anything
- 7:13else to add on that? Well, I'll just repeat what
- 7:16I said earlier. Your meet and confer looks a
- 7:19lot more good faith if you have complied with
- 7:23the discovery request that you don't have legitimate
- 7:27objections to. Let me ask you now. Occasionally,
- 7:32they don't act in good faith. You've already
- 7:35given examples of it. What's your view on sanctions?
- 7:37What is your belief on the imposition of sanctions?
- 7:40What are you looking for? And what are some of
- 7:42the issues you see? Yeah, it's kind of a sliding
- 7:48scale. I mean, first of all, the law is pretty
- 7:50clear that you don't jump immediately to the
- 7:54Briconian sanctions, issue sanctions, striking
- 7:56pleadings. Those are a last resort. They expect
- 8:01us to go through the process of initially imposing
- 8:11monetary sanctions and then move gradually up
- 8:15the scale. But at some point, issue sanctions
- 8:20or striking the pleading sanctions become appropriate.
- 8:25Judge apartment, what do you what do you view
- 8:27on monetary sanctions? Do you generally issue
- 8:31when requested or how often does in your courtroom?
- 8:33If you guys say when sanctions are asked how
- 8:35often do you award them? Are you able to give
- 8:37me a ballpark? Yeah, I would say probably half
- 8:39the time I mean, I I'm not a big fan of imposing
- 8:42sanctions I would like to not do that, but we
- 8:45get a lot of Situations where the responding
- 8:47part of the party is just being recalcitrant.
- 8:50They're not be reasonable You know, if I think
- 8:53both sides are acting in a way that's meritorious
- 8:56or, you know, at least in good faith, OK, fine.
- 8:59And you'll get you'll get both sides asking for
- 9:02sanctions. And in those situations, if they both
- 9:04have a good faith position, then OK, I won't
- 9:07award sanctions. But I don't like imposing them.
- 9:11But in the appropriate circumstance, I will.
- 9:13And I'll usually reduce the requested dollar
- 9:16amount down to something that's more proportional
- 9:19to. what I think maybe really was going on. So
- 9:23I'm not afraid of imposing sanctions. I think
- 9:27some judges are. How often would you say you
- 9:29impose monetary sanctions? About half the time,
- 9:33if it's the first or second go round. We're deeper
- 9:36into continuing discovery disputes. I'm a lot
- 9:40more liberal about handing them out. Sanctions
- 9:45sometimes are mandatory where my hands are tied.
- 9:48But I also do the same thing Judge Barman does.
- 9:51It's not at all unusual for me to reduce the
- 9:54amount that's requested. Yeah. Just for note
- 9:57for everyone, there are some changes in the law
- 9:59that happened in the last couple of years where
- 10:01there are mandatory sanctions. For instance,
- 10:03if production documents are done in the last
- 10:04seven days, read the code section because there
- 10:07have been changes for those of you who have been
- 10:09practicing for many years. Note that sometimes
- 10:11the judges are going to impose monetary sanctions
- 10:13because they're required to. absent having written
- 10:16findings to the contrary. So I think that echoes
- 10:18what they've said. Next topic. What is your view
- 10:22on ordering a discovery referee? I think, you
- 10:25know, Judge Clark articulated, you know, when
- 10:28it gets burdensome, you've done it. How often
- 10:30does that occur and what usually triggers that?
- 10:36Continued non -cooperation after warnings from
- 10:38the court. I probably appoint discovery referees
- 10:44three to five times a year. Quite frankly, I
- 10:49think I should be doing it more often. But discovery
- 10:52referees are expensive. And I'm conscious that
- 10:57that is a big burden, not necessarily on the
- 11:01lawyers, but on the litigants. And that causes
- 11:05me to be patient the third and fourth time you
- 11:08come up in front of me. But at some point, I
- 11:11don't have time for you. Yeah, I've only appointed
- 11:14a discovery referee in two cases in the last
- 11:17five and a half years or something. One was in
- 11:20the category of the parties were just at war
- 11:22with each other and they couldn't get along at
- 11:24all at deposition in written discovery. And they
- 11:28were coming back to me way too much with just
- 11:30nonsense disputes. And after a couple of warnings,
- 11:33I finally just said, OK, I'm appointing a discovery
- 11:35referee. You guys go deal with the discovery
- 11:37referee. The only other case was a big giant
- 11:40monster case where there was going to be Lots
- 11:42and lots and lots and lots of discovery disputes
- 11:44over thousands and if not hundreds of thousands
- 11:46of documents. And so I generally with the cooperation
- 11:50of the parties just went ahead and appointed
- 11:51one. I don't like to have to do that. I don't
- 11:54have a problem with dealing with discovery issues
- 11:57if I have to. But if I think this is something
- 12:00where, OK, you guys aren't getting it, I'll put
- 12:03you over to a private referee. The referee in
- 12:06the second case I was telling you about, just
- 12:08so everybody knows, That was a case where the
- 12:10discovery referee's billing rate was $1 ,500
- 12:12an hour because he was a retired federal judge
- 12:15out of Los Angeles. But typically, I don't think
- 12:18you're going to find a discovery referee that's
- 12:20less than probably $7 .50 an hour. It is a big
- 12:24expense. And I warn them that you're going to
- 12:27be looking at this big expense and sometimes
- 12:30that doesn't do any good. I'll make a comment
- 12:33as the discovery referee who sometimes handled
- 12:35these either by privately retained or ordered
- 12:37by the court. And by the way, my fee is a little
- 12:39less than what they've described. But in any
- 12:42event, I think one of the things that should
- 12:43be noted is, yes, it usually comes that way.
- 12:46But sometimes you should consider a discovery
- 12:47referee on your own. Because I will tell you,
- 12:50as a practitioner, I dreaded the thought of it.
- 12:53As a discovery referee, what I've learned is
- 12:55that actually I can accommodate and resolve not
- 12:58only in a more timely fashion, but I can address
- 13:00the meat of the issues much more quickly than
- 13:03can be done through court. So you may have two,
- 13:05three, four rounds of motions that take 120,
- 13:08160 days, and you may never get to the meat of
- 13:10the information, discovery referees have the
- 13:12ability as timing -wise and access to do it.
- 13:15So as a plug for why discovery referees are not
- 13:17awful, I'm just letting you know that. And to
- 13:20follow up on that thought, because I think it
- 13:23is a good point, I'm a big believer in informal
- 13:27discovery conferences. When I had the time to
- 13:31do them, I thought they were effective. but I
- 13:34literally do not have and none of us have the
- 13:36time to do informal discovery conferences. If
- 13:41you retain a discovery referee, the referee will
- 13:45be able to have an informal discovery conference
- 13:48with you and that'll probably save a lot of time
- 13:50down the road. And I do appreciate it by the
- 13:53way when the parties themselves recognize that
- 13:55their case is going to involve a lot of discovery
- 13:58disputes and they will voluntarily submit themselves
- 14:01to a discovery referee to go off and deal with
- 14:03stuff and that makes makes our lives a lot better.
- 14:06All right now this is off script gentlemen and
- 14:09I occasionally will do that to you. So CCP 2016
- 14:14.090 came into effect not that long ago just
- 14:19within the last couple years and it is kind of
- 14:22the federal rule the state rule on federal mandatory
- 14:26disclosure where one party can demand a disclosure,
- 14:30both sides have to do it and has to be verified.
- 14:32How often are you seeing that becoming before
- 14:34the courts as a discovery issue or matter to
- 14:37deal with? Zero. I don't think I've seen it yet.
- 14:39Zero. All right. That was quick. All right. So
- 14:45now looking to... So what I don't know if that
- 14:48means the parties aren't engaging that, if they're
- 14:50not triggering it. or that they're playing nice
- 14:53in the sandbox and getting along. I don't know
- 14:55which it is. I'm sure you'll find out in the
- 14:56next few years, but I guess we're not seeing
- 14:59a whole lot of fights about that. All right,
- 15:02IMEs. With IMEs, medical examinations, independent
- 15:07medical examinations, there are oftentimes timing
- 15:11issues that come up before trial. Tell us what
- 15:17kind of disputes that you have been faced with.
- 15:20as to either the scope of the IME or having to
- 15:23deal with late timing of IMEs because some new
- 15:26issue or claim is now purportedly been put before
- 15:29the court. Well there's two issues that are often
- 15:32interrelated and that's scheduling problems for
- 15:35the examiner and that frequent postponements
- 15:39and then that relates because all of a sudden
- 15:42you're on the EVA trial now. have too many disputes
- 15:51about whether or not a party is entitled to an
- 15:54IME. There are some disputes about the scope.
- 15:59There's issues about whether or not someone else
- 16:02can be present, and if so, under what conditions.
- 16:05There's issues about whether or not the exam,
- 16:09the party being examined can record the proceeding.
- 16:14Most of the motions I have on IMEs is on the
- 16:20eve of trial when the party wants to go back
- 16:22and do a second examination. And what are the
- 16:26kind of circumstances where that you find is
- 16:28appropriate and where you have, not that it's
- 16:30an exact, but give us an example. It's usually
- 16:33pretty clear cut. It's not uncommon for a plaintiff
- 16:36to continue treatment after his initial exam
- 16:40by the IME, and sometimes that continuing treatment
- 16:44will unearth either a new condition or a condition
- 16:49that was worse than originally indicated. It's
- 16:53not unheard of after the initial IME for the
- 16:57plaintiff to discover the need for surgery and
- 16:59undergo surgical procedure. Under those circumstances,
- 17:03I will generally grant a second IME. And that
- 17:08usually occurs always right on the trial off
- 17:12and on our next part A basis. Do you ever deal
- 17:14with that on multiple disciplines? In other words,
- 17:16you have a neurologist, an orthopedist, an eye
- 17:19exam. There's multiple body parts and specialties
- 17:23being wanting to exam. But the code talks about
- 17:25a single exam. So how do you view that? I deal
- 17:30with it as a single exam. I don't I can't think
- 17:32of an instance where a defendant wanted to seriously
- 17:37wanted to subject a plaintiff to three or four
- 17:42IMEs by different specialties. All right. What
- 17:46about limitations on being able to take a history
- 17:50in it that sometimes has come before you? It
- 17:53has. Some plaintiff's lawyers view allowing a
- 17:59physician to take a history as being tantamount
- 18:01to some sort of interrogation discovery procedure.
- 18:06Occasionally, I'll get a motion for a protective
- 18:10order asking that the IME not be allowed to take
- 18:13the history. What I do on that motion depends
- 18:17on what the state of the medical records are.
- 18:20The medical records already have pretty good
- 18:22information on history. I'm more susceptible
- 18:26to issuing the protective order. If the examining
- 18:32doctor by declaration makes a pretty good case
- 18:34as to why in this particular instance, it's really
- 18:38important for him to make some inquiry about
- 18:43history. I'll generally allow it, although I
- 18:46may put some limitations on it. Quick note from
- 18:49Judge Barman, you had actually a published opinion
- 18:52that had to do with psych examinations. Got a
- 18:57little attention. Tell us about that. Yeah, so
- 19:01that was the Randy's trucking case. I don't know
- 19:03if anybody's familiar with that one. I will share
- 19:05that as a lawyer for 30 years, I never went within
- 19:08100 miles of a personal injury case. But that
- 19:11seems to be all that we get in terms of trials
- 19:13for the most part. But no, this was an issue
- 19:16about the psychologists that would conduct those
- 19:22exams, wanted to shield the content of the exam
- 19:25from defense counsel or from plaintiff's counsel,
- 19:29I guess it was. And they went back and forth
- 19:31about that. And I just came down on the side
- 19:33of, look, both lawyers on both sides need to
- 19:36know everything about the case. There shouldn't
- 19:37be any secrets whatsoever from them. You can
- 19:39issue a protective order that'll prevent them
- 19:41from using it on future cases or what have you.
- 19:45And the psych industry didn't apparently appreciate
- 19:48that, but that was appealed and was affirmed.
- 19:53But most of these issues to me are case by case,
- 19:56right? So let's see what the facts are. What
- 20:00does the law require? What does the law allow?
- 20:03You know what's reasonable in any given case
- 20:04whether it's wanting to take a history take a
- 20:07second exam You know that sort of thing. It's
- 20:10it's really very fact dependent What about I'm
- 20:13gonna switch now to the subpoenas? All right,
- 20:15so in medical cases There's always an issue on
- 20:18the length and how far back you can go what history
- 20:20what body parts? That comes up a lot at least
- 20:24in the litigated world. I now I'm gonna ask you
- 20:27as judges And the same thing happens also with,
- 20:29let's say, financial records in the business
- 20:31world. How far do I get to go on financial records
- 20:34or an employee's history? So have you had any
- 20:37issues in particular on that in views that practitioners
- 20:40should know? I've had more issues than I should.
- 20:44And I'm surprised at how many over broad, particularly
- 20:48medical subpoenas, but also financial records
- 20:52as well. But using the medical records as an
- 20:56example. I'm surprised how many over -broad subpoenas
- 21:00I continue to see, seeking discovery on every
- 21:05issue way beyond the body parts or the medical
- 21:10issues that are an issue in the case and going
- 21:14back years before the incident. The excuse I
- 21:20always hear is, well, we need to see if there's
- 21:22other instances in the medical history that could
- 21:27be an alternative source for some of the complaints
- 21:30or some of the injuries. But that's really another
- 21:32way of saying I want to go on a fishing expedition.
- 21:35So when I get those disputes in front of me,
- 21:39I limit it almost invariably to the specific
- 21:44injuries that have been alleged in the lawsuit.
- 21:48And I will sometimes allow disclosure of medical
- 21:54records within that scope. a year or two before
- 21:58the incident. Sometimes I won't allow a council
- 22:02to go back further than the incident unless they
- 22:05can make a really strong showing that there's
- 22:09a need and there's a reasonable expectation that
- 22:11they're gonna find something that's gonna be
- 22:13helpful. Mr. Barman? Yeah, so, you know, I'll
- 22:19often allow people to go back a bit in time,
- 22:21but, you know, we'll be pretty... cautious about
- 22:24how far back you get to go. But a lot of this
- 22:26stuff too, keep in mind, just because we say,
- 22:28okay, for now you get this, this is it. Once
- 22:31you get all of that discovery, you might learn
- 22:33some information that would allow you to come
- 22:34back and say, well, hey, wait, there's records
- 22:36in here that suggest we need more. Okay, then
- 22:40ask for the more. So, you know, whether it's
- 22:44financial documents or financial records or,
- 22:47you know, medical records, It's all the overarching
- 22:50thing for me is a rule of reason, right? So what's
- 22:54reasonable here and And the showing of need yeah,
- 22:58and then what's the burden on the responding
- 23:00party and that all that sort of thing? So, okay
- 23:03anything else you down on that topic that we
- 23:05haven't covered? All right. Great. We'll move
- 23:08on to expert discovery so expert Discovery a
- 23:13lot of different issues can come up in that arena
- 23:15designation and adequacy of disclosure so A lot
- 23:19of times people will designate an expert. They'll
- 23:23describe under the code what's required. But
- 23:25what happens if you respond and say, they're
- 23:28going to testify on causation, or they're going
- 23:31to testify on causation and damages, or they're
- 23:33going to testify on liability and causation,
- 23:36without any further detail? Is that adequate?
- 23:39And do you have any motions or issues that have
- 23:41come up? regarding inclusion or exclusion of
- 23:43testimony related to adequacy of disclosure.
- 23:46I can't think of any emotions that were objecting
- 23:49to vagueness or over -breath of the subject matter
- 23:54disclosed. Usually that comes out during discovery.
- 23:59But the problem I have is a witness designated
- 24:04for this particular issue, and then by the time
- 24:07they come to trial that opinion kind of bleeds
- 24:09over into issues that other experts opine on,
- 24:14such as causation. And that becomes a problem
- 24:19that I have to deal with, either in eliminate
- 24:22motions or at the time the witness is on the
- 24:25stand. My view is the witness is designated for
- 24:30the area that's in the designation and not for
- 24:33any other issue. Judge Barman, do you have any
- 24:37issues on that? Yeah, so I haven't had very many
- 24:40cases where before trial there had been motion
- 24:43practice on expert discovery. It does happen.
- 24:45Sometimes there'll be a case where somebody's
- 24:47designated multiple experts that appear to have
- 24:49overlapping opinions, and the other side doesn't
- 24:52want to have to take all of their depositions
- 24:54to figure out. And so I'll take that and consider
- 24:59addressing those. Where disclosure comes up mostly
- 25:03is at trial, you get a Kenemur objection, and
- 25:07now it's, okay, what was the disclosure? What
- 25:10was this expert advertised as? That goes to the
- 25:13issue of what was the opponent on notice about?
- 25:16And then what did you do at deposition to close
- 25:19out what their actual opinions are that they're
- 25:20going to offer? Did you ask the Kenemur question?
- 25:23Yeah, and so... So for those of us who are a
- 25:26little bit younger and may not know the Kenemur
- 25:28case, the brief overview and add if you can that...
- 25:32Under Kenimer, if you ask the questions that
- 25:36limit the scope and say, have you expressed all
- 25:38your opinions, are there any other opinions,
- 25:39work to be done, et cetera, then the issue is
- 25:43whether or not they can proffer additional opinions
- 25:45later, correct? And the answer in that situation
- 25:47is almost always no. Right. Now, if you don't
- 25:50ask those questions, then that broad unfair reading
- 25:54disclosure that says this witness is going to
- 25:57testify on liability, causation, and damages
- 25:59Well, if at the deposition you didn't close that
- 26:02out, you might have a problem. Because you're
- 26:05going to be trying to convince me that you're
- 26:08being unfairly surprised by some new opinion
- 26:11that you weren't aware of. The other attorney
- 26:14is going to be saying it's your fault because
- 26:15you didn't ask the right questions. He was there
- 26:18ready, willing, and able to answer your questions,
- 26:20and it's your fault. So the way to close that
- 26:24out is we call it the Kennemer question. Make
- 26:29sure you pin the expert down that there's no
- 26:31other opinions he intends to give. There's no
- 26:34other work that he intends to do that would change
- 26:36any opinions. And then turning kind of in the
- 26:40same area mentioned by Judge Barman, which was
- 26:43non -retained experts. So whether it's a medical
- 26:46case and there are, you know, 25 people listed
- 26:50as treaters because you have nurses, PAs, doctors,
- 26:53et cetera. Or maybe there's just a ton of percipient
- 26:56witnesses. It's a large gathering, a large event.
- 26:59It's multi -transactional business event, and
- 27:03there's 30 people listed on there as non -retain
- 27:06experts in the field. What, if anything, have
- 27:11you seen, and what can a practitioner do to try
- 27:14to deal with the scope of that kind of experts?
- 27:17Because that can be a big crunch just before
- 27:20trial. The problem I run into most frequently
- 27:23with respect to non -retained experts is an attorney
- 27:27will take all the traitors, every name mentioned
- 27:30in the medical records, designate them as non
- 27:33-retained experts. They don't realize that you
- 27:38still have to designate what area they're going
- 27:42to be offering opinions on. The older rule generally
- 27:47was, well, a non -retained expert who's a treater
- 27:50can only testify about treatment he or she provided,
- 27:55the reasons for the treatment, observations made
- 27:57during the treatment. That standard's been relaxed
- 28:01a bit, and there certainly are circumstances
- 28:04where non -retained experts who are treaters
- 28:08can offer some opinions, sometimes even opinions
- 28:11on causation. if they have a sufficient foundation
- 28:15based on the work that they did. But that's not
- 28:21an excuse to bring a treater in and then just
- 28:24out of the blue, ask him, do you have an opinion
- 28:26on causation? Do you have any thoughts on the
- 28:30higher volume? I mean, I haven't seen that too
- 28:34much to be frank. I mean, I've seen some where
- 28:36they list a lot of the treating physicians. And
- 28:38I think some of that could be a function of the
- 28:40fact that, well, if you have any hope of using
- 28:43them, you better get them on the list. But usually
- 28:46by the time you get to trial, the lawyers are
- 28:49working with each other on who's really going
- 28:50to come to trial. But where you have to be careful
- 28:54with non -retained experts is you don't want
- 28:56to turn them into a retained expert by giving
- 28:58them additional information. If you do that,
- 29:00and they weren't disclosed as a retained expert,
- 29:02they may not be able to testify at all because
- 29:04now they've been poisoned. If you're going to
- 29:08try to retain them as a free retained expert
- 29:11by giving them some additional information about
- 29:13your client or about the case and then try to
- 29:15ask their opinions and try to draft them as an
- 29:17expert, that's no no. It's more often than not
- 29:21the case that the non -retained expert is called
- 29:24to the stand and he has not had any communication
- 29:27whatsoever with the attorney and that's probably
- 29:29the better situation. And sometimes they're testifying
- 29:32in their scrubs in the hallway at the hospital
- 29:34over an iPhone. So that happens a lot. The other
- 29:37problem with over -designation is if you... And
- 29:40I've seen cases where 25 doctors or health professionals
- 29:45are designated as non -retained experts. And
- 29:48you know that maybe there's two of those guys
- 29:51you're going to use. It puts in a reasonable
- 29:54burden on the other side who potentially has
- 29:56to take 25 depositions. So I do look for some
- 30:00cooperation in meet and confer to avoid that
- 30:04burden. And if that were the case, consideration
- 30:09I think you had mentioned might be protective
- 30:11orders to bring to the court in those regards.
- 30:13Yes, that's exactly what the remedy. All right,
- 30:17yeah. Last thing on expert discovery and we'll
- 30:20go to our next topic. Real briefly, gentlemen,
- 30:23because we're limited on time. any issues on
- 30:25supplemental designations and rebuttal experts?
- 30:29You know, sometimes people are genuinely needing
- 30:33to supplementally designate, sometimes there's
- 30:35a sandbagging issue. What are your views and
- 30:38what have you seen? Supplemental designations
- 30:41and rebuttal designations are not an excuse or
- 30:45a remedy for naming someone that you forgot to
- 30:49name the first go -round, and I'm pretty strict
- 30:52on that. Yeah, because it that that does happen
- 30:56occasionally or you get somebody that's in a
- 30:59case in a particular area And they don't designate
- 31:01the type of expert that's normally designated
- 31:03in that case The other side does and now they
- 31:06want to come back and call it a supplemental.
- 31:08Oh, we didn't know So if you're in the cement
- 31:10mixing business and an expert's called on cement
- 31:14mixing material and you didn't designate one
- 31:17and now you want to put one in, then it's probably
- 31:19awkward. If you're in a medical malpractice case.
- 31:20It's going to be a very uphill battle. Yeah.
- 31:22Yeah. And you didn't have an expert on the subject
- 31:25matter involved and now you put it in. That's
- 31:27a problem. All right. Let's go on now to some
- 31:32of the issues on motion hearings. OK. So you
- 31:39have staff counsel. review motions. Do I understand
- 31:43that right? Tell me a little bit about the workup.
- 31:45Tell me how it gets to your desk and what your
- 31:47involvement is. Well, I think each of us has
- 31:51a full -time research lawyer who does nothing
- 31:53but review motions and do write -ups for us.
- 32:00I generally get my write -ups from my research
- 32:04lawyer two to three days in advance of the motion.
- 32:09But I'm usually in trial and almost invariably
- 32:13I don't have time to really grapple with your
- 32:15motion until the night before. I do review and
- 32:21they make recommendations. I do review their
- 32:25authorities. I don't read all of their authorities,
- 32:29but usually they're pretty good about pointing
- 32:31me to two or three key authorities and I do read
- 32:34those or at least skim them. I do disagree with
- 32:41my research lawyer, maybe 10 % of the time. And
- 32:44in that case, I make the ruling that I think
- 32:47is appropriate. But if we didn't have a full
- 32:52-time lawyer analyzing all of your motions, we
- 32:57wouldn't be able to handle motions and trials
- 32:59both. Judge Barman, do you need to add about
- 33:01your process? Well, so yeah, I tend to get my...
- 33:05Write -ups from my research attorney two to three
- 33:07days ahead of time. The thing I really appreciate
- 33:10is they're really, really good at picking up
- 33:11on the details. So if you've got a technical
- 33:14problem with your motion or your opposition,
- 33:16they will find it. Violation of court rules being
- 33:19an example? They'll point it out. Timing on service,
- 33:22whatever. They're very good at laying out the
- 33:27law, summarizing the party's opinions or arguments
- 33:30so that we don't have to go read the full briefs
- 33:33necessarily. almost verbatim, but in a summary
- 33:36form, give us what your points are. They'll give
- 33:38us the important cases. I will tend to agree
- 33:42with my and follow her recommendations where
- 33:45I see that it's an issue of judgment as opposed
- 33:48to, oh, you have to go this way because that's
- 33:50what the law requires. Then, you know, in those
- 33:53situations, I will sometimes veer off of what
- 33:56what she's recommending. But And sometimes we'll
- 34:00talk about it, right? Sometimes I'll read a write
- 34:02-up and I'm like, yeah, I'm not sure about this.
- 34:04Let's talk. So well, they're a resource to have
- 34:07that kind of a conversation. But we could not
- 34:11do our jobs without them. Or instead of your
- 34:14motions in this county being set roughly 30 days
- 34:17after you filed them, they would be getting set
- 34:1990 to 120 days out, which I think that's what
- 34:21the case is in some other courts. Anyways, so
- 34:24they're there. I'm gonna remind you guys all
- 34:26to use your courtroom voice just to make sure
- 34:29everyone can hear not over here, but online.
- 34:31Yeah so Let me ask you this then you have tentatives
- 34:36then each of you when you walk into the courtroom
- 34:39I give written tentatives every day I prepare
- 34:41them the day before and We don't have a local
- 34:44court rule The rules of court would require us
- 34:47to have a local court rule and an infrastructure
- 34:50with our IT folks to post tentatives on our website.
- 34:53We'd have to have a whole infrastructure for
- 34:55that. We don't have that. But I post tentatives
- 34:58in the courtroom every morning. And on court
- 35:01call, that interface has an ability for us to
- 35:04post tentatives as a file on the screen. So the
- 35:07only people that don't get to see my tentatives
- 35:09when I take the bench and start calling the CMCs
- 35:12and that sort of stuff are people that are on
- 35:14there only by phone. But yeah, I issue written
- 35:17tentatives every day. Judge Clark? Unfortunately,
- 35:20I don't. When I was a litigator, I depended heavily
- 35:23on tentatives, and most judges published tentatives
- 35:26either the afternoon before or at least had them
- 35:29posted on the courtroom door when I arrived.
- 35:33But with my caseload being in trial, I just literally
- 35:38do not have time to post tentatives. In many
- 35:42instances, I don't reach those tentatives until
- 35:457 or 8 o 'clock at night. the night before the
- 35:48hearing. Do you generally express it to the litigators?
- 35:50Yes. Pretty much every time I call a motion,
- 35:54I express what my tentative is. And let me ask
- 35:58you this. How often, gentlemen, I'll start with
- 36:01you, Judge Barman, do you deviate from your tentative?
- 36:04You hear these eloquent arguments from these
- 36:06fine litigators and counsel. How often do you
- 36:09deviate after hearing an argument from your tentative?
- 36:12So if you ask Ms. Estrada in the back row, it
- 36:15would be never. But that's not totally true.
- 36:20So it depends. So there's sort of two primary
- 36:26situations. One is where the lawyers have made
- 36:29a point that gives me pause about whether or
- 36:32not my ruling may have an issue that I haven't
- 36:35really thought thoroughly enough about, in which
- 36:37case I'm going to take that under submission.
- 36:39I'm not going to change my mind right there on
- 36:41the bench, but I'll take it under submission.
- 36:43I'll evaluate it. And I would say, a reasonable
- 36:47percentage of the time, I might change my ruling.
- 36:50There are other times where it's pretty clear
- 36:51that I've made a mistake in my analysis. There's
- 36:54something that's off, and I'll flip my ruling
- 36:58or amend it a little bit. But at least 80 % to
- 37:0490 % of the time, I'm probably sticking with
- 37:05my tenant ruling. All right. So there's some
- 37:08hope. 10 % to 20 % of the time, it may be changed
- 37:10for those of you out there. Judge Clark. I'd
- 37:12say about 10 % to 15%. Sometimes during oral
- 37:17argument, a party will either make a point or
- 37:20emphasize a point that I had not really emphasized.
- 37:24And it makes me look at the issue from a different
- 37:26perspective. In that case, I will usually take
- 37:29the matter under submission, do a little independent
- 37:32research myself. More often than not, I will
- 37:36come back to the same tentative that I had, but
- 37:38at least I will look into that. And if I take
- 37:41something under submission, I'm in the habit
- 37:43of giving you probably a two or three page written
- 37:47opinion to explain exactly how and why I got
- 37:51to that ruling. Occasionally, and this just happened
- 37:54with me this week, someone will cite authority
- 37:59to me that had not been cited before and that
- 38:04I had missed in my own research and convinces
- 38:07me that I'm wrong. reverse myself. Do you ever
- 38:12invite or allow supplemental briefing on issues?
- 38:17I sometimes allow it. They have to request it
- 38:20and sometimes I allow it, sometimes I don't.
- 38:23No, I'd say it's pretty rare. Okay. I mean, you
- 38:26know, your motion's filed on pretty long notice
- 38:29and both sides have a pretty reasonable amount
- 38:31of time to put their stuff in. But occasionally,
- 38:34especially if there's something raised in the
- 38:36reply, not new evidence, but some something that
- 38:39the opposing party hasn't had a chance to deal
- 38:41with, I may give them a shot at submitting something.
- 38:44And where I see that is sometimes in oral argument.
- 38:48It's not that someone brings up a new issue,
- 38:51but someone puts more emphasis on one issue than
- 38:54had been placed on it before. Perhaps it raises
- 38:59questions that the other party had not fully
- 39:02considered that, and if they request... probably
- 39:06allow them to do some supplemental briefing and
- 39:08I'll take it under submission and do some research
- 39:10myself as well. So for those who are having to
- 39:14draft all these law and motion and argued before
- 39:17you, what are the the tips in moving opposition
- 39:20and reply papers that you say, you know, it sure
- 39:23makes it a lot easier and a higher probability
- 39:25of doing well with me or here's where it's a
- 39:28problem and you should consider reconsider how
- 39:31you present them. What are the do's and don'ts?
- 39:34quick tips that we should know? Well, the first
- 39:35tip is really give a lot of thought. Do you really
- 39:38need to file a motion at all? The litmus test
- 39:43that I like to preach is, are you likely to get
- 39:50a result that's going to help you get to your
- 39:53ultimate objective? And I'll use Demers as an
- 39:57example because it's an easy example to use.
- 40:00There's a lot of technical grounds on which I
- 40:04can have to sustain demurse. But in most instances,
- 40:10it's a technical issue. All you've done is alert
- 40:13the other party to an issue that you know in
- 40:16advance he's going to easily be able to amend
- 40:19around. But by that time, you spend a lot of
- 40:22time in a court appearance, you're charging your
- 40:25client for it, and what have you gained? And
- 40:29that goes with... I'd say the same kind of thought
- 40:33on discovery motions. There should be no substitute
- 40:38for meet and confer really in a good faith attempt
- 40:44to resolve those issues without burdening the
- 40:47court with them. And for those who are following
- 40:50along, just as a quick note, the deferrer actually,
- 40:53as you all know, requires meet and confer process.
- 40:55And it's been beefed up a bit and does require
- 40:58that same in -person telephone or video conference
- 41:01as part of the process. You can look at CCP section
- 41:06430 .41. Judge Barman, would you have anything
- 41:09to add that people should know on their drafting?
- 41:13Well, one would be make sure that your arguments
- 41:17overall tell a coherent story in terms of why
- 41:21the court ought to rule your way as opposed to
- 41:23the other way. If your arguments are all completely
- 41:25technical, and are just a bunch of facts, and
- 41:28there's just no story there, it's not going to
- 41:31be very compelling. So make sure you've got a
- 41:34good story and a good reason that the court ought
- 41:36to go your way. And make sure you comply with
- 41:40the technical rules with respect to separate
- 41:42statements in discovery motions and dispositive
- 41:46motions, that sort of thing, because that's an
- 41:48easy way to lose if you don't comply with those
- 41:51rules. Also, in terms of formats of objections
- 41:54and things like that, make sure you're you're
- 41:56complying with the rules there. But generally
- 42:00speaking, remember at all times that whatever
- 42:04you're arguing in your papers, that's your name
- 42:07behind that. And your reputation and your credibility
- 42:12is on the line every time you're making an argument
- 42:14to us. So if your papers are patently frivolous
- 42:18on their face, I have a really good memory. The
- 42:23next time you come back to me, you're not going
- 42:24to get the same credit. than an unknown, unfamiliar
- 42:27lawyer might get. So, anyway. And he's talking
- 42:32about motions which we all see that really appear
- 42:37to be more of harassment than a reasonable belief
- 42:40that you're going to get something that helps
- 42:42you get to your ultimate objective. My comment
- 42:47would be keep your briefs focused on the issues
- 42:52that are really important and make them concise.
- 42:58Sometimes there are arguments that are going
- 43:01to take you three or four pages to develop. If
- 43:03that's the case, the most helpful thing you can
- 43:05do for me is to give me maybe a one -page introduction
- 43:10that's almost an outline form to totally focus
- 43:14me on what your arguments are. That's helpful
- 43:18for me as I'm then wading through all your arguments
- 43:22about the support. I mean, I would say as a lawyer,
- 43:26my I learned early on in terms of legal writing,
- 43:30basically, once the judge or research attorney
- 43:34has read the first page of your motion, if by
- 43:38that time they should be convinced that you're
- 43:39right and they shouldn't have to read the rest
- 43:42of it except for support. So that initial bang
- 43:46out of the gate, that introduction, make sure
- 43:48that that tells your story in a concise, persuasive
- 43:51way. You know, I'll sometimes see a motion that
- 43:57has merit, has maybe two or three important issues,
- 44:02but you've also along the way identified some
- 44:06other ancillary issues. So now you've got 10
- 44:09points and you spend the same amount of time
- 44:12on all of them. That just leads to me getting
- 44:16lost. So recognize what your significant points
- 44:20are and focus on those. Okay. A few miscellaneous
- 44:27things on law and motion, then we're going to
- 44:28go to summary judgment. If you've got, let's
- 44:34say, and this is a mix now between law and motion
- 44:38and discovery. Let's say you have a case that
- 44:41has 10 causes of action. And at the beginning
- 44:44of the case, the party says, you know what, I
- 44:47think I can demur or do a motion to strike to
- 44:50eight of those causes of action. And so you file
- 44:53that motion. You do your meet and confer, and
- 44:55then you have the additional 30 days, and then
- 44:57you ultimately file your motion. So you could
- 44:59be 60, 90 days into it before your motion will
- 45:03actually be heard because of the calendaring
- 45:05and everything. Meanwhile, the party who you
- 45:09are seeking to strike, whether it's in the answer
- 45:12or in the complaint by demur or by motion to
- 45:16strike, has now propounded a ton of discovery.
- 45:20You've got interrogatories, you got person most
- 45:23knowledgeable, you got key witnesses, you got
- 45:25the president of the company, whatever it is,
- 45:27there's a lot going on. The party who says, well,
- 45:31wait a minute, 80, 90 % of that doesn't relate
- 45:34to anything that I think is going to be in the
- 45:35case. But they aren't going to know that for
- 45:3790 days, maybe, or 100 days, depending on the
- 45:40timing when the ruling gets out. Meanwhile, the
- 45:43other side said, I want to march forward, because
- 45:45I want to develop those aspects. So what is your
- 45:48view in that scenario? What should a litigant
- 45:50do when that kind of thing is going on? One party
- 45:52doesn't want to produce discovery on stuff that
- 45:54they don't think is ever going to make it and
- 45:56that it's very expensive and time consuming before
- 45:59the court's ruled. And the other side says, well,
- 46:01wait a minute, my case is still pending. There's
- 46:02no ruling I get to go forward. If the case is
- 46:05as clear cut as your example, I will generally
- 46:09issue a protective order or a partial stay order
- 46:12pending my ruling. More often, the case is that
- 46:18the complaining attorney is saying, well, there's
- 46:21eight causes of action that are going to be gone
- 46:24and I need some relief on the discovery. But
- 46:26the discovery for those eight causes of action
- 46:29is going to blend over into the other causes
- 46:32of action anyway. And I take those on a case
- 46:36by case basis. Yeah, I'd say go call up the other
- 46:39lawyer and try to work something out in terms
- 46:42of a stay. That happens a lot. If you can't get
- 46:44it though, you're probably going to want to seek
- 46:47a protective order because, in my view, discovery
- 46:49can go forward independent of the status of the
- 46:53pleadings. I mean, a defendant can start propounding
- 46:55discovery out of the gate. Unless there's a protective
- 46:59order or a stay order. So we're not going to
- 47:01just, on our own, issue a protective order because
- 47:03I think, oh, I might grant this demur. The truth
- 47:05is, as Judge Clark said, we're not going to even
- 47:07know your demur exists until the night before
- 47:10you're coming into court. Try to work it out
- 47:13the other side. But if you need a protective
- 47:15order, I don't see that many applications for
- 47:18protective order, honestly. And I don't know
- 47:21what that's all about. You get people that are
- 47:23objecting to discovery and then not actually
- 47:26complying with their discovery obligations. That
- 47:29could end up leading to sanctions if you're not
- 47:32being reasonable. But if your basis for a protective
- 47:36order is legit, yeah, we think we're going to
- 47:39take out these issues which would make this discovery
- 47:42completely irrelevant. We'll listen to you. I
- 47:46would say if at all possible bring those motions
- 47:49on a notice motion basis not on an ex parte basis.
- 47:55Agreed, yeah. Switching to motions for summary
- 47:58judgment are special motions. Tell us a little
- 48:02bit about what you see and what we should know
- 48:04on the outset and then I'll ask you some specific
- 48:06questions but What should the litigants know
- 48:08in your courtrooms that you're seeing that they
- 48:12should know about on motions for summary judgment?
- 48:14Well, motions for summary judgment or summary
- 48:16adjudication are rarely granted, and that's because
- 48:19the courts of appeal tell us that they should
- 48:23be rarely granted. More often than not, I get
- 48:31parties arguing about the sufficiency of the
- 48:34evidence on an alleged disputed fact. It does
- 48:39not take strong evidence on one side to create
- 48:44a disputed fact. You can have the strongest evidence
- 48:47in the world supporting your position that this
- 48:51is an undisputed fact. If the other side comes
- 48:55up with any kind of coherent argument, that's
- 48:58probably going to be enough for me to find that
- 49:01there's a disputed fact and deny the motion.
- 49:03I'm not going to weigh the evidence. I've seen
- 49:07plenty of cases where I see the evidence advanced
- 49:10in support of the argument that this is a disputed
- 49:13fact, when I know that evidence is not going
- 49:16to carry the day with the jury. But if you make
- 49:19the showing every time, I'm going to find a disputed
- 49:24fact. Yeah, credibility is not a thing on summary
- 49:28judgment or summary adjudication. I remember
- 49:31once as a young lawyer practicing in LA, fairly
- 49:35senior judge looked at a pile of papers on their
- 49:37desk on a summary judgment motion that I'd filed
- 49:40and said, oh, there must be a disputed fact in
- 49:42there somewhere. Literally. And I thought, OK,
- 49:46that's nonsense. Because if you connect the dots
- 49:50to all of our arguments, we've got this airtight.
- 49:52But still, so understand that those motions are
- 49:58rarely granted but they are sometimes granted
- 49:59if you've got a good solid case but my suggestion
- 50:02there along with what judge clark said about
- 50:04demurs is make sure you're going to hit this
- 50:07out of the park because you make sure you're
- 50:09actually going to take out an important cause
- 50:11of action or take out the entire case because
- 50:13if you don't what you've really done is you may
- 50:16have woken up a lawyer who's asleep at the switch
- 50:18and hasn't really prepared their case and now
- 50:20you've told them what their problems are and
- 50:22so um just you know, be cautious about it. Don't
- 50:26be afraid to file one if you think you've got
- 50:29a meritorious one, but they're expensive. They
- 50:33take a lot of time for the lawyers before it
- 50:37even gets to me, and it takes a lot of my time
- 50:39and a lot of research lawyer's time. So let's
- 50:42talk about a couple things that come up. What
- 50:45about people who exceed the page lengths, right?
- 50:49Some people want to say, stop reading, Judge.
- 50:52You know, you got to page 10 or 15. You're supposed
- 50:55to end. It's over. Or there was not a table of
- 50:57contents with it. Other people, you know, say,
- 51:00well, you know, I need additional length. And
- 51:03if there's a lot of arguments, there's a process
- 51:05to go through to get additional length. So what
- 51:08do you see? What happens and how do you deal
- 51:10with it? I assume this happens once in a while.
- 51:13Yeah, it does. If they ask for permission ahead
- 51:15of time, it's it's typically branded and you
- 51:17may also then give the other side. you know,
- 51:20sort of proportional additional pages to deal
- 51:22with their motions, their reply brief or whatever.
- 51:27But you ask for it in advance is better. If you
- 51:30didn't ask for it in advance and didn't even
- 51:32acknowledge it in your papers, that creates an
- 51:36interesting circumstance because now you've burdened
- 51:38the other side, you've burdened the court with
- 51:39extra pages. Maybe it depends on how substantive
- 51:44those pages are. If they're super substantive,
- 51:46and I thought it unfairly you know, prejudice
- 51:51the other side. I might say I stop reading at
- 51:54page 15, but I haven't had that kind of thing
- 51:57happen much, so. What I will generally do is
- 51:59at least skim the excess pages, and if it looks
- 52:03like there's a fairly significant point there
- 52:06that needs to be considered, I'll exercise my
- 52:09discretion and more or less retroactively grant
- 52:14leave to file the lengthy brief. But like he
- 52:25said, if it's just a rehash that goes on and
- 52:29on and on, I'm not going to consider it. The
- 52:36worst thing you can do is what a lawyer did recently.
- 52:41He filed a brief that was 12 pages over long.
- 52:47The opposition brought that to his attention
- 52:50and asked me to stop reading. And then I get
- 52:53a reply that's nine pages over long. So that
- 52:59lawyer was not at the top of the hill when he
- 53:03came into court. Right. So let me ask you on
- 53:07separate statement of facts. All right. Always
- 53:09a challenge sometimes to you want to put enough
- 53:12facts in there so that the court has an understanding
- 53:15in context of what's going on. But there's always
- 53:19this fear that if I put all the facts in that
- 53:21I think you need to know to be able to get a
- 53:23good understanding of what's going on, then I'm
- 53:25going to create too many tribal issue facts and
- 53:28material facts when some of them are really not
- 53:30that significant as a material fact, but they're
- 53:33background facts, they're important. That's a
- 53:35real big problem for people filing the motions.
- 53:37I see it frequently. I know how I dealt with
- 53:41it, but tell us Judge, what do you recommend?
- 53:44You really pare down the facts that you need
- 53:50to support your undisputed issue. Be very careful
- 53:54about throwing extraneous facts in there that
- 53:57really don't do anything except maybe give me
- 53:59a better picture of what your evidence is. Because
- 54:02the more facts you put in there, the more chance
- 54:06the other side is going to be able to come in
- 54:08with an argument that alleges that there's a
- 54:11disputed fact in there. And also say it's not
- 54:14a material fact, right? Don't say, oh, you know,
- 54:16ignore that. and which that issue should have
- 54:21been addressed before the motion was filed. The
- 54:25other problem when you've got too many facts
- 54:27in there is I may lose my focus. But it's a big
- 54:35problem. I see it often. And it generally makes
- 54:39it easier for the opposing party to convince
- 54:43me that there's a disputed issue of fact. Yeah,
- 54:46I would just say the statement of facts, cyber
- 54:48safety is not the place to tell the story. That's
- 54:50in the brief. The statement of facts should be
- 54:53tight and concise to what you need to prove your
- 54:56case or prove your defense or whatever it is
- 54:58and tell the story in the points and authorities
- 55:01and that ought to tie everything together. So
- 55:03because if you put a fact in your statement of
- 55:06material facts and then the other side disputes
- 55:08it and ICE go, yeah, I guess there's a dispute
- 55:10here. And you've already told us it's a significant
- 55:14issue. Yeah. So what you're saying is you can
- 55:19include in your briefing a narrative history
- 55:21that lays out all the background that's of importance,
- 55:24but only identify the ones that are material
- 55:27facts that are going to be numbered and put into
- 55:31your separate statement facts. Yes. All right.
- 55:35All right. What do you do? What's your view on
- 55:42when the opposition says I don't have enough
- 55:46time. I didn't get enough discovery. I need to
- 55:49do more discovery. I need more time to oppose
- 55:52the motion for summary judgment. How do you view
- 55:54those? I mean, the statute addresses it. What
- 55:57are you expecting to see when you address that?
- 56:00Well, that person, first of all, has to make
- 56:02a compelling case, number one, that there really
- 56:06is a need to do additional discovery, and more
- 56:10importantly, convince me that there was a good
- 56:13reason he hadn't already done that discovery.
- 56:17Yeah, and I think they need to be, so first of
- 56:18all, if you are opposing a summary judgment motion
- 56:21and think you need more time, the amount of notice
- 56:24on that thing is huge. Get that request into
- 56:26the court ASAP. Yeah, don't do it ex parte two
- 56:29days before your responses do. Yeah, or in your
- 56:33opposition, which I think is allowed, but that's
- 56:35risky. Those are usually denied. But have a good
- 56:39showing of diligence, which in my book is kind
- 56:42of hard to make given the notice time, you know,
- 56:44why haven't you got done these depots, but also
- 56:46make a showing of what you expect that discovery
- 56:49to unearth that you don't already have evidence
- 56:52for that would defeat the motion if it existed.
- 56:55But if all you're saying is, oh, we haven't taken
- 56:57the PMQ of the defendant. Well, this case is
- 57:00two years old. Why haven't you done that? And
- 57:04once you receive the summary judgment motion
- 57:06and you read it, you should know at that point.
- 57:09that you need to do more discovery, that's the
- 57:12time to file the, if you can't work it out through
- 57:15meet and confer, that's the time to file the
- 57:18motion seeking more time. The closer we get to
- 57:23your response date or the closer we get to the
- 57:26hearing date, the more critical I'm going to
- 57:30be of looking for your showing. Of course, if
- 57:33you don't grant it, then what do you do about
- 57:35it? I go ahead and rule. All right. So, On that,
- 57:41I guess, in looking at the response to a motion
- 57:46for summary judgment, you have a separate statement.
- 57:48You have an opposition that can come in and respond
- 57:52to each of those separate statement issues. How
- 57:55do you like to see that? If the opposition is
- 57:59both evidentiary or it says it's not relevant
- 58:03or it's not material or it's not in the records,
- 58:06Do you want to see that all in another column
- 58:10put on there in the opposition and everything
- 58:12in there? Do you want a separate evidentiary
- 58:15objection document that says, here are all my
- 58:18evidentiary objections and I want you to rule
- 58:21on them? How do you like to see the documentation?
- 58:24Well, my research lawyer and I are more likely
- 58:26to grasp your point if you put it in the column.
- 58:33Yeah, I personally like to see a separate standalone
- 58:36set of objections that we can rule on. And then
- 58:40that should be tied then in your separate statement
- 58:44with the extra column of why it's disputed. Maybe,
- 58:47OK, when we've objected to this, and it's inadmissible
- 58:51for whatever the reasons are, to tie all that
- 58:54together in the separate statement. It's requiring
- 58:57you to kind of put a lot of information in there.
- 59:00sort of paint by numbers, tying it together,
- 59:02I think is important. All right, now I'd like
- 59:04to turn to, well, let me ask you, in summary
- 59:06adjudication, one of the things that are always
- 59:08challenging for attorneys is to say, how do you
- 59:11want it, Judge? Do you want each of those summary
- 59:14adjudication causes of action or claims that
- 59:17I am now adjudicating separately to each repeat
- 59:20and write down all these separate material facts
- 59:25that apply to each one? or do you want them to
- 59:28say, you know, number 7, 28, 32 of the material
- 59:31facts, how do you want to lay it out for you
- 59:34to read? Because they don't want to give you
- 59:36a document that's 50 pages long and you get irritated
- 59:39with them, but the same token, they don't want
- 59:41you to shortchange on anything you need. If you
- 59:45repeat the information as opposed to making me
- 59:47go back and cross -reference something else,
- 59:52repeat it. Make it easier for me to follow your
- 59:55point. Yeah, same. All right. Let's go to evidentiary
- 59:59support. Witness and party declarations. I'm
- 1:00:05going to jump to that. Sometimes you're going
- 1:00:09to have depositions, you're going to have interrogatories,
- 1:00:11you're going to have declarations. Somebody goes
- 1:00:14ahead and submits on the motion for summary adjudication
- 1:00:16or summary judgment an interrogatory or deposition
- 1:00:22testimony. And then in opposition, a declaration
- 1:00:26is provided by one of those either parties or
- 1:00:30witnesses that's exact opposite of what was just
- 1:00:33presented in their own interrogatory response
- 1:00:36or their own deposition testimony. How do you
- 1:00:39deal with that and how do you treat that for
- 1:00:41the purposes of evaluating the motion for summary
- 1:00:44judgment? I'm going to tend to give less credibility
- 1:00:47to someone who has totally changed their testimony
- 1:00:50apparently in response to a summary judgment
- 1:00:54motion. But if if that's going to be the case,
- 1:00:59make sure that declaration has a really good
- 1:01:02explanation as to why that testimony is different
- 1:01:06from the deposition. Yeah, depositions are the
- 1:01:10really clear example where a witness has now
- 1:01:13answered questions under oath, no constraints,
- 1:01:16lawyer's not writing the answer, and then their
- 1:01:18declaration comes in and contradicts that. That's
- 1:01:22kind of a hard sell. It should have an explanation.
- 1:01:25Interrogatories might be a little bit different.
- 1:01:27There's usually room to say, well, by the answer,
- 1:01:31I meant this, but here's really the truth there.
- 1:01:33Maybe give you more room to explain yourself,
- 1:01:35but you need to be able to explain yourself.
- 1:01:37I think what we briefly talked before coming
- 1:01:39on board here, each of you also mentioned, caution
- 1:01:42on what you think is really clear and in support.
- 1:01:46So your interrogatories, your request for admissions,
- 1:01:49your deposition testimony that you think are
- 1:01:51black and white, said occasionally those declarations
- 1:01:54are appropriate because you haven't locked it
- 1:01:57in well or as crisp as it should be. Am I correct
- 1:02:00on that? True. Correct. OK. All right. So I guess
- 1:02:04that's that footnote to that. Let's go on to
- 1:02:08expert declarations, motions for summary judgment.
- 1:02:12Court is somewhat gatekeepers, right? We know
- 1:02:14that from Sargon. We know that from other cases
- 1:02:17that you have to meet certain criteria as to
- 1:02:20what is in the declaration of an expert to support
- 1:02:22a motion for summary judgment. What do you look
- 1:02:25at? And how often do you deal with where the
- 1:02:29expert declaration is insufficient to support
- 1:02:32the motion? It's not too often that the declaration
- 1:02:36is insufficient, but it does happen that I read
- 1:02:40the declaration and I go, there's no foundation
- 1:02:43for this. Yeah, I think that's pretty rare, honestly,
- 1:02:48for an expert. If somebody seriously has an expert
- 1:02:51that's qualified to express an opinion, they'll
- 1:02:54provide enough information to support their credentials.
- 1:02:58And the expert's declaration will typically explain
- 1:03:00not just their opinion, but the basis for their
- 1:03:03opinion. It's pretty rare for it not to be sufficient,
- 1:03:07but I suppose it does happen. I don't have a
- 1:03:11real rigorous standard for foundation. The foundation
- 1:03:16is there in a general sense. then I'm going to
- 1:03:22accept the declaration and consider it for purposes
- 1:03:24of determining whether or not there's a contested
- 1:03:27issue. But occasionally, I'll see a declaration
- 1:03:31that's just devoid of foundation. And usually,
- 1:03:35there comes an objection to that at that point.
- 1:03:37Are there issues that you get on declarations
- 1:03:40that are maybe by attorneys as opposed to the
- 1:03:42actual witnesses that come up? Yeah, sometimes
- 1:03:46attorneys will shortcut and instead of giving
- 1:03:48me the Declaration from the witness who has the
- 1:03:51recipient knowledge They'll that they will essentially
- 1:03:55tell me what that witness is going to say, but
- 1:03:57they try to couch it in terms of their observations
- 1:04:00and really that's just a disguised form of hearsay
- 1:04:03and I usually can pick up on it or the attorneys
- 1:04:06trying to authenticate documents that They don't
- 1:04:09really have a foundation for authenticating.
- 1:04:12Okay Footnote for everyone, January 1, 2025,
- 1:04:18CCP Section 437C, little t, came into effect.
- 1:04:23That statute allowed partial summary adjudication
- 1:04:26that didn't have to be on a particular claim
- 1:04:28or cause of action. It could be on a particular
- 1:04:30issue, a separate issue that the parties want
- 1:04:33adjudicated. So question to the judges, have
- 1:04:35you seen any of those so far? It's relatively
- 1:04:37new law, but have you seen any of those presented
- 1:04:40to you or that? or that the parties are telling
- 1:04:42you it's going to come in the case? I think I've
- 1:04:44only seen it once. And in that particular case,
- 1:04:48it was not well supported. So that was an easy
- 1:04:50call. But I think you're right. I think we're
- 1:04:53going to see it more often. Yeah, I think I may
- 1:04:57be seen it once. But I would encourage the parties
- 1:05:00in cases to consider employing that. It might
- 1:05:02be a way around the problem that the way the
- 1:05:05law has been written for years is you have to
- 1:05:07take out an entire cause of action or an entire
- 1:05:09defense. as opposed to the issue that the parties
- 1:05:13really are disputing that may, once that's resolved,
- 1:05:18that might tell the parties where this is going.
- 1:05:21Since we're short on time, I'm going to now switch
- 1:05:23to real quick views on AI. There is brand new
- 1:05:27legislation. There is SB 574 that just came out
- 1:05:33on AI that's going to affect attorneys, judges,
- 1:05:36arbitrators, mediators. You all are going to
- 1:05:38have obligations with it. Quick plug, the Paralegal
- 1:05:42and Secretary Association are putting together
- 1:05:44a seminar on November 20th that I will actually
- 1:05:48be putting on as the speaker. I'm gonna highlight
- 1:05:51changes in the law that affect practitioners,
- 1:05:53including SB 574, changes how defaults are taken,
- 1:05:58changes how process servers have to do their
- 1:06:00job. For instance, they have to take photographs
- 1:06:02and GPS coordinates. So a lot of changes have
- 1:06:05gone on the law that affect us as practitioners
- 1:06:07and your staff. So we're going to try to cover
- 1:06:09some of that information then. November 20th,
- 1:06:11look for it in your emails. Now, having said
- 1:06:14that, Judge, tell us what it is that you're seeing
- 1:06:17in the AI. We know that there's hallucinations
- 1:06:19or poorly drafted breeze. Tell us what you're
- 1:06:22seeing and how you're dealing with it. What I
- 1:06:25see is citations that are inaccurate, occasionally
- 1:06:30a citation to a case that doesn't exist. That's
- 1:06:34a little bit rare. What I see probably more often
- 1:06:39is quotes from a case that is not a verbatim
- 1:06:43quote. Yeah, I actually am not personally seeing
- 1:06:47a lot of that. The research attorneys, I think,
- 1:06:49are under instructions to screen for that stuff.
- 1:06:53And I'm not getting reports of bogus authorities
- 1:06:57in pleadings that are being filed by the lawyers.
- 1:07:01I've had one example that I had to issue an OSC
- 1:07:04on, but that was like over a year ago. My my
- 1:07:10big concern is if you're giving us cases you
- 1:07:13want us to rely on and then you're going to put
- 1:07:15those in a proposed order for us to sign. I'm
- 1:07:18not signing that order unless I've had time to
- 1:07:20actually personally go review those cases. And
- 1:07:24so I will not sign your proposed order you submitted
- 1:07:27with your unopposed motion that contains a whole
- 1:07:29bunch of. case citations, because the first time
- 1:07:32I've actually even had a chance to look at that
- 1:07:34order is when you're sitting there in court in
- 1:07:36front of me and I've said, okay, I'm granting
- 1:07:37your motion, but I look at the proposed order
- 1:07:39and it's got all kinds of cases in there, I am
- 1:07:41not putting my name on that. There's usually
- 1:07:43no need to put case citations into an order.
- 1:07:47All right, so we're just running out of time,
- 1:07:50but I want to open it up for any questions out
- 1:07:52in the audience that you have. You'll have a
- 1:07:55moment or two before the judges have to go back.
- 1:07:57to their chambers to conduct their trials. But
- 1:08:01are there any questions out there that we need
- 1:08:03to address in the materials we covered? Yes,
- 1:08:06Mr. Sheffield. And I've had mixed issues with
- 1:08:28some judges saying, if it's said what it said,
- 1:08:30you're going to get it done. And Nicole says
- 1:08:32you're not supposed to be able to have time to
- 1:08:33explain, waffle around, and do that. So I'm just
- 1:08:35like. So let me interrupt just so that the audience
- 1:08:38online can hear the question. The question is,
- 1:08:42what is the case when there is a deemed admitted
- 1:08:44admission? You go to hearing or trial. The witness
- 1:08:49is now confronted with that admission. And now
- 1:08:52they want to back out of it or modify. their
- 1:08:55position from what was in the admission and explain
- 1:08:58why it really didn't apply. Whether or not I
- 1:09:00allow that is on a case -by -case basis. I'll
- 1:09:04give you an example where I did relieve a party
- 1:09:07of their admission where it was clear from the
- 1:09:12deposition testimony that the true facts were
- 1:09:15contrary to the admission. It was clear from
- 1:09:19every piece of evidence in the case And it was
- 1:09:22just a situation where an attorney had very sloppily
- 1:09:26admitted something. In that case, I'm going to
- 1:09:31exercise my discretion, and I'm not going to
- 1:09:34allow the case to be decided on facts that I
- 1:09:36know aren't true. If it's closer and more in
- 1:09:43the gray area where it's not so clear cut, then
- 1:09:48I look at that on a case by case basis. There
- 1:09:52is a lot of authority out there that says an
- 1:09:56admission, whether it's an RFA or a judicial
- 1:09:58admission in your pleading, an admission is an
- 1:10:01admission and you shouldn't be allowed to contradict
- 1:10:03it. But if the overwhelming body of the evidence
- 1:10:08shows me that that admission is not accurate,
- 1:10:12I will exercise my discretion. I was just recently
- 1:10:16taken up on appeal. and I haven't read the opinion,
- 1:10:20but I understand that I was upheld on that. Mr.
- 1:10:22Barman, anything you'd add? Well, I think it's
- 1:10:24pretty rare for a party that's actually had a
- 1:10:27RFA either admitted or deemed admitted that hasn't
- 1:10:31taken the steps to undo that before trial to
- 1:10:34come in and be able to reverse that. I mean,
- 1:10:37often they'll be in limiting motions saying,
- 1:10:40bind them to this, in which case I'm likely to
- 1:10:42grant that. And so if a question gets asked,
- 1:10:45objection. that's out of bounds, that's a matter
- 1:10:47that's settled, I'll probably sustain it. If
- 1:10:52you've got that issue, you should recognize it
- 1:10:55before the trial starts and should file a motion,
- 1:11:00ex parte, if necessary, to be relieved of your
- 1:11:05admission. That's the formal way to do it in
- 1:11:07advance. In practice, it more often comes up
- 1:11:12in the middle of trial when a witness wants to
- 1:11:15give some testimony that's contrary to, let's
- 1:11:19say, some judicial admission in the pleadings.
- 1:11:22And then there's a big argument as to whether
- 1:11:23or not I should allow that testimony. All right.
- 1:11:26I want to thank these two judges for giving it
- 1:11:28a time. A reminder for everyone, November 17th
- 1:11:35is the third in this series where we're going
- 1:11:37to have the Kern County Superior Judges talk
- 1:11:39about their views on trial and things that they're
- 1:11:42do's and don'ts in trials. So please put that
- 1:11:44in your calendar. You'll be getting flyers and
- 1:11:46emails soon. Thank you.