Latest / SLEEPY HISTORY / Why Even the Closest Galaxy May Be Too Far For Us
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Right now, a galaxy is being torn apart just above
- 0:03the Milky Way's disk. It is not two and a
- 0:05half million light years away. It is not Andromeda. It
- 0:09sits barely 70,000 light years from Earth, and its stars
- 0:13are already mixing with ours in slow motion. This is
- 0:16one of the truly closest galaxies to us, and even
- 0:19it lies farther than any human machine has ever even
- 0:22come close to crossing. When people say Andromeda is our
- 0:25nearest galactic neighbour, they are quietly ignoring dozens of smaller
- 0:30galactic worlds hiding much nearer to home. And when we
- 0:33do the math on reaching any of them, the numbers
- 0:35turn from ambitious to absurd. Because getting there would require
- 0:39humanity itself to become something entirely new before it ever arrived.
- 0:44If this kind of deep exploration is something that fascinates you,
- 0:47consider tapping like and subscribe. It genuinely helps this channel
- 0:51keep making journeys like this one. Now, settle in, get
- 0:55yourself comfortable, Let's begin. Open any introductory astronomy book, click
- 1:06on any beginner-friendly space article, watch any casual documentary about
- 1:10the cosmos, and sooner or later, you will meet the
- 1:13same sentence. Andromeda is our nearest galactic neighbour. It is
- 1:18offered as a simple, almost cosy fact. A single spiral
- 1:22of stars floating two and a half million light-years away.
- 1:26waiting across the dark for humanity to notice it. The
- 1:29sentence sounds clean. It sounds settled. It sounds like something
- 1:34you can memorise once and forget forever. The sentence is wrong.
- 1:38Not almost wrong. Not technically wrong. Not wrong in some picky,
- 1:43footnoted way that only professional astronomers care about. Wrong in
- 1:47the ordinary, straightforward sense that it hides dozens of galaxies
- 1:51sitting much closer to us than Andromeda ever has. and
- 1:54that it has been quietly hiding them for as long
- 1:56as most of us have been alive. There are galaxies
- 1:59whose stars are threaded through the Milky Way itself right now,
- 2:02being pulled apart in slow motion above and below the disk.
- 2:06There are galaxies orbiting us so faintly that we only
- 2:09discovered them within the last two decades. There are galaxies
- 2:12so intimately tangled with our own gravitational field that some
- 2:16astronomers argue about whether they still count as separate galaxies
- 2:19at all, or whether they have already been swallowed, and
- 2:22are simply taking a long time to disappear. And once
- 2:25you understand that landscape, once you see the Milky Way
- 2:28as it actually is not a single spiral drifting alone
- 2:31in a quiet cosmic pond, but a large predator surrounded
- 2:35by a swarm of smaller companions, the friendly textbook sentence collapses.
- 2:40Andromeda is not our nearest galactic neighbour. Andromeda is our
- 2:44nearest major galactic neighbour. Those two words in the middle
- 2:47change everything. They change what the closest galaxy actually is.
- 2:52They change what a journey to it would look like.
- 2:54And they change the entire question we are asking, because
- 2:57how far is the closest galaxy turns out to depend,
- 3:01in the most uncomfortable way, on what we are willing
- 3:03to count as a galaxy in the first place. So
- 3:06before we can talk about how far away the closest
- 3:09one is, we have to do something that sounds trivial
- 3:11but is not. We have to define the word. And
- 3:14in doing that, we start to see why the phrase
- 3:17closest galaxy is one of the most misleading phrases in
- 3:21popular astronomy. A galaxy, in the most careful modern sense,
- 3:25is a gravitationally bound system of stars, gas, dust, and
- 3:29dark matter, held together by its own mass. That definition
- 3:33sounds like a formality, but hidden inside it are two
- 3:36arguments that professional astronomers still have. The first argument is
- 3:40about dark matter. A true galaxy, most researchers now agree,
- 3:45sits inside its own halo of dark matter, its own
- 3:48private gravitational cocoon. That distinguishes it from a globular star cluster,
- 3:53which is just a dense ball of stars with no
- 3:55meaningful dark matter around it. The second argument is about independence.
- 4:00To count as a galaxy in the fullest sense, a
- 4:03system is usually expected to have formed on its own,
- 4:06evolved on its own, and been recognisably its own object
- 4:10before some larger galaxy came along and started eating it.
- 4:13That second condition is the one that quietly ruins the
- 4:16tidy sentence about Andromeda. Because when you look carefully at
- 4:20the space immediately around the Milky Way, you do not
- 4:23see a peaceful gap between our galaxy and Andromeda. You
- 4:27see a crowd, a messy, still-being-cleaned-up crowd of smaller stellar systems,
- 4:32some of them clearly galaxies, some of them clearly not,
- 4:36and some of them arguing about it in the middle.
- 4:38Most of these systems are what astronomers call dwarf galaxies.
- 4:42They are small, sometimes containing only a few thousand or
- 4:46a few million stars, compared to the roughly 100 billion
- 4:49to 400 billion stars in the Milky Way. They are faint,
- 4:53they are old, and they are close. Not close in
- 4:57the way Andromeda is close. Close in a way that
- 5:00makes Andromeda look like it is in another postcode. Let
- 5:04us start with the one that best breaks the textbook
- 5:06sentence into pieces. Its name is the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy,
- 5:11and its story is quietly one of the most disturbing
- 5:14stories in modern galactic astronomy. It was only discovered in 1994,
- 5:19a whole galaxy on our doorstep, unnoticed until the last
- 5:23decade of the 20th century, because it lies almost directly
- 5:27on the far side of the galactic centre from us.
- 5:30Its stars are hidden behind the thick clouds of gas
- 5:32and dust that block our view toward the middle of
- 5:35the Milky Way. It took careful surveys of stellar motions
- 5:38to realise that a coherent, separate galactic system was sitting
- 5:43right there, tucked behind the glare of the core. But
- 5:46here is the part that matters for our question. The
- 5:49Sagittarius dwarf is not a comfortable neighbor minding its own business.
- 5:53It is being destroyed, actively, right now. The Milky Way's
- 5:58enormous gravity is pulling it apart, stretching its stars into
- 6:02long trailing streams that wind around our entire galaxy multiple times,
- 6:07like ribbons unspooling from a torn parcel. The core of
- 6:10the Sagittarius dwarf still exists, still faintly holding itself together,
- 6:15still recognisable as its own object. But its outer stars
- 6:19have already been stolen. They are drifting through the Milky
- 6:22Way's halo, mixing with our stars, becoming part of us.
- 6:27In a few hundred million more years, there will be
- 6:30nothing left to call the Sagittarius dwarf. It will just
- 6:33be scattered material in the Milky Way's outer regions, a
- 6:37former galaxy digested into a current one. And it is close.
- 6:42Its centre lies approximately 70,000 light-years from Earth, That is
- 6:46closer than the far edge of our own Milky Way's disk.
- 6:49Understand that information. There is a galaxy whose core is
- 6:53nearer to us than parts of our own galaxy. The
- 6:56textbook sentence about Andromeda being our nearest galactic neighbour does
- 7:00not survive contact with the Sagittarius dwarf. It cannot. Two
- 7:04and a half million light years is more than 35
- 7:06times farther than 70,000. The sentence is not slightly off.
- 7:11It is off by a factor that turns the whole
- 7:13map inside out. But here is the twist that makes
- 7:16it worse, and more honest. The Sagittarius dwarf is being absorbed.
- 7:21Depending on how strictly you define an independent galaxy, you
- 7:25might argue that it no longer counts as one. You
- 7:28might argue that we should not use a half-eaten galaxy
- 7:31as our answer to the question, what is the closest
- 7:33galaxy to the Milky Way? And that is a fair argument.
- 7:37But if you make it, you have to make it consistently.
- 7:40Because the moment you accept that a dying, dissolving companion
- 7:43no longer counts... you have to look at everything else
- 7:46nearby and ask the same question. And there is a
- 7:49lot else nearby. The Sagittarius dwarf is not the first
- 7:53galaxy the Milky Way has been caught eating. It is
- 7:55only the most recent, the most visible, and the one
- 7:59whose consumption is still in progress. Careful analysis of stellar
- 8:03motions using data from the Gaia spacecraft, the European Space
- 8:07Agency's Precision Stellar Mapping Mission, has revealed the ghostly outlines
- 8:11of an even older meal. Around 10 billion years ago,
- 8:15roughly two-thirds of the way back to the beginning of
- 8:17the universe, another galaxy fell into ours. Astronomers call it
- 8:21Gaia Enceladus, or sometimes the Gaia Sausage, after the sausage-shaped
- 8:26pattern its stars trace in velocity space when plotted carefully.
- 8:30That galaxy was substantial, perhaps a quarter or a fifth
- 8:34of the size of the early Milky Way at the
- 8:36time of impact. It was not a small dwarf being
- 8:39nibbled at the edges. It was a genuine collision between
- 8:42comparable partners, and the Milky Way won. and the stars
- 8:46of Gaia Enceladus are still with us. They did not vanish.
- 8:50They did not scatter into intergalactic space. They mixed into
- 8:54what we now call the Milky Way's inner halo, and
- 8:56they can be identified today, 10 billion years later, by
- 9:01their distinctive orbits and their chemical fingerprints. A significant fraction
- 9:06of the older metal pore stars in our galaxy's inner halo,
- 9:09including a number of stars visible from Earth on any
- 9:12clear night, are not native Milky Way stars at all,
- 9:15They were once citizens of another galaxy that our galaxy
- 9:18consumed before our sun even existed. This matters because it
- 9:22deepens the definitional problem we opened with. When we ask
- 9:26what the closest galaxy is, we are implicitly assuming that
- 9:29closest refers to something out there, some object that sits
- 9:33at a measurable distance from us. But galaxies leave residue.
- 9:37Long after they are absorbed, their stars remain, folded into
- 9:41the larger galaxy that ate them. In a strict sense,
- 9:44The closest galaxy to us right now includes the scattered
- 9:47remains of Gaia Enceladus, whose stars pass through the neighbourhood
- 9:51of the Sun in specific characteristic orbits. Those stars are,
- 9:56in origin, from another galaxy, and they are inside our own.
- 10:00There is, for instance, the Canis Major Overdensity. This one
- 10:04is even more controversial than the Sagittarius Dwarf. It was
- 10:08reported in 2003 as a candidate dwarf galaxy sitting only
- 10:13about 25,000 light-years from Earth, which would make it, if real,
- 10:17the closest galactic system to us and that has ever
- 10:20been proposed. 25,000 light years. That is closer than the
- 10:25distance from us to the Milky Way's own centre. And yet,
- 10:29in the years since, astronomers have argued vigorously about whether
- 10:33the Canis Major Overdensity is actually a separate dwarf galaxy
- 10:37at all, or whether it is simply a natural warp
- 10:40and thickening of the Milky Way's own disk, mistaken for
- 10:43an external companion. Some studies support the galaxy interpretation, others
- 10:48reject it, The scientific status is genuinely unresolved, which itself
- 10:53is a fascinating lesson. We do not fully know what
- 10:57is orbiting us at close range. We are still, in
- 11:00the year we are living in, arguing about whether there
- 11:03is a dwarf galaxy hiding almost inside our own outer disk.
- 11:07Move outward slightly, and the crowd continues. There are Segway
- 11:101 and Segway 2, two of the faintest galaxies known anywhere.
- 11:15They are so dim, so sparse. so ghostly that they
- 11:18contain only a few hundred stars each that we can identify.
- 11:22For a long time, astronomers were not sure whether they
- 11:25were dwarf galaxies at all or simply unusual star clusters.
- 11:29Careful studies of their internal motions revealed that their stars
- 11:32are moving far too quickly for the visible mass alone
- 11:35to explain. Something invisible is holding them together. That is
- 11:39the fingerprint of dark matter. And by the working definition
- 11:43of a galaxy, a dark matter dominated system with its
- 11:46own stars is a galaxy, no matter how faint. So,
- 11:50Segway 1 and Segway 2, sitting within about 70,000 to 135,000
- 11:57light years of us respectively, are among the smallest true
- 12:01galaxies we have ever found, and they too orbit closer
- 12:04than most people ever imagine. That question whether a system
- 12:08counts as a galaxy or merely as a dense star
- 12:10cluster is not a trivial one. It touches directly on
- 12:14what closest galaxy means, Consider Wilman 1, discovered in 2005,
- 12:21which sits about 120,000 light-years from Earth. When it was
- 12:25first identified, astronomers could not decide what it was. It
- 12:29was too diffuse and too irregular to be a normal
- 12:32globular cluster. It was too small and too faint to
- 12:35look like a typical dwarf galaxy. For years its classification
- 12:39bounced back and forth in the literature. The deciding test
- 12:42in each case was the same. If Wilman One's stars
- 12:46moved in a way that could be explained purely by
- 12:48the gravity of its visible mass, it was probably a
- 12:51star cluster. If its stars moved as if a much
- 12:54larger invisible mass were holding them together, it was a galaxy.
- 12:58Because a galaxy, in modern usage, is a system that
- 13:01requires dark matter to explain its motions. A star cluster
- 13:05is a system that does not. That distinction is what
- 13:08elevates Segway One from being merely an unusually sparse group
- 13:12of stars to to being a full member of the
- 13:14Milky Way's galactic family. When astronomers measured the internal velocities
- 13:19of Segway 1 stars carefully, they found stellar velocity dispersions
- 13:23far higher than the visible mass could account for. Segway
- 13:271 is dominated by dark matter with ratios of several
- 13:31hundred to one. It is one of the most dark
- 13:34matter dominated systems ever identified. This means that despite containing
- 13:39only a few hundred visible stars, it is unambiguously a
- 13:42galaxy in the modern technical sense. A vast, invisible gravitational cocoon,
- 13:48holding a few sparse points of light together, drifting through
- 13:51the outskirts of our own galaxy. This is why the
- 13:54count of galaxies near us has kept climbing over the
- 13:57past two decades. It is not that new large systems
- 14:00keep appearing. It is that the definition itself has sharpened,
- 14:04and increasingly faint dark matter dominated systems keep being confirmed
- 14:09as galaxies once their internal motions are measured with sufficient care.
- 14:13Then there is Antlia 2, discovered in 2019 using data
- 14:17from the European Space Agency's Gaia spacecraft. Antlia 2 is
- 14:23a strange one. It is enormous in physical size, roughly
- 14:27comparable in extent to the Large Magellanic Cloud, but it
- 14:31is astonishingly diffuse, so faint per unit area of sky
- 14:35that it hid from us for decades in plain view,
- 14:38It sits approximately 400,000 light years away, farther than some
- 14:42of its cousins, but it is a reminder of something important.
- 14:46As recently as a few years ago, we were still
- 14:48finding entire galaxies sitting in our immediate cosmic neighborhood, invisible
- 14:53to us until a spacecraft mapped the sky precisely enough
- 14:57to notice their sparse, drifting stars. When someone tells you,
- 15:01with confidence, that Andromeda is our nearest galactic neighbor, the
- 15:06honest response is, is that we are still discovering how
- 15:09many galactic neighbours we actually have. And once you start
- 15:13listing them, the list gets long fast. Ursa Major 2,
- 15:18Coma Berenices, Boots 1, Wilman 1, whose galactic status is
- 15:24also debated, Draco, Ursa Minor, Sculptor, Sextons, Carina, Fornax, Leo IV,
- 15:33Leo V, Hercules, Some of these are classical dwarf galaxies
- 15:38known for decades. Others are ultra-faint dwarfs, discovered only in
- 15:43the last 20 or so years through careful searches of
- 15:46survey data. Almost all of them sit within a few
- 15:49hundred thousand light years of us. Almost all of them
- 15:52are closer than Andromeda by factors of 10 to 50.
- 15:55And almost all of them are, in the strictest sense,
- 15:58gravitationally bound to the Milky Way. They are our satellites,
- 16:02our orbiting companions. our small siblings pulled along in our
- 16:06gravitational wake. Which brings us to a distinction that matters.
- 16:10Being a satellite of the Milky Way does not automatically
- 16:13mean you are not a galaxy. The Milky Way and
- 16:16Andromeda are both major galaxies of the local group, and
- 16:20both have their own retinues of satellite dwarfs. Andromeda's satellites
- 16:24include Messier 32 and Messier 110, along with many fainter dwarfs.
- 16:30Ours include everything we have been listing. A satellite galaxy
- 16:33is still a galaxy, in exactly the same way that
- 16:36a moon is still a real object. It just happens
- 16:39to be gravitationally bound to something larger. So, when we
- 16:43ask what the closest galaxy to the Milky Way is,
- 16:46the honest answer is that dozens of small galaxies are
- 16:49orbiting us right now, and most of them are far,
- 16:51far closer than Andromeda. The textbook sentence has been quietly
- 16:55counting only a certain kind of galaxy, the big, spectacular,
- 16:59spiral kind. and pretending the others do not exist. Now,
- 17:04some of you will already be asking the sensible question,
- 17:07if dwarf galaxies count, and the Sagittarius dwarf counts, and
- 17:11the Canis major over density might count, why do we
- 17:14keep hearing about Andromeda? The answer is that people are
- 17:17usually not asking what the closest galaxy is. They are asking,
- 17:21without quite realising it, what the closest galaxy comparable to
- 17:25ours is. What the closest galaxy that looks like a
- 17:28proper spiral is. what the closest galaxy that lights up
- 17:31a beautiful photograph is, Andromeda answers that hidden question. It
- 17:36is the closest galaxy that resembles the Milky Way in size,
- 17:40in structure, and in visual grandeur. It is the closest
- 17:43galaxy that carries hundreds of billions of stars, a bright disk,
- 17:48a bulge, and a swirl of spiral arms. In that
- 17:51specific and much narrower sense, Andromeda genuinely is our nearest
- 17:55major galactic neighbor. But that is a different sentence. That
- 17:59is a careful, qualified, honest sentence. And it opens a
- 18:03different question, which is the question this episode is really about.
- 18:07Because once you accept the distinction between nearest galaxy of
- 18:10any kind, and nearest major galaxy, you have to accept
- 18:14something else. There is no easy answer to what closest
- 18:17galaxy means. There are several answers, depending on what you count,
- 18:22and every one of those answers, even the friendliest, even
- 18:26the ones that let us pick the smallest, faintest, nearest
- 18:30dwarf orbiting us right now, is still a distance so
- 18:33far beyond human experience that we have almost no honest
- 18:36way to describe it. Let us make that concrete. The
- 18:39Sagittarius Dwarf's center, at roughly 70,000 light years, is closer
- 18:45to us than most of our galaxy's own stars. But 70,000
- 18:49light years is still 70,000 light years. A single light
- 18:53year is roughly nine and a half trillion kilometers. 70,000
- 18:57light years is nearly 700,000 trillion kilometres. Even if you
- 19:02were somehow moving at the speed of light itself, which
- 19:05nothing with mass can do, the trip to the centre
- 19:08of the Sagittarius dwarf would take 70,000 years. Modern humans
- 19:13have existed as a distinct species for only a few
- 19:16hundred thousand years. The trip to our closest dwarf galaxy,
- 19:20at the fastest speed physics allows, would consume a substantial
- 19:24fraction of the entire history of our kind of human.
- 19:27And that is the most forgiving answer available. That is
- 19:30the closest option on the menu. If you insist on independence,
- 19:34if you refuse to count the Sagittarius dwarf because it
- 19:37is being absorbed, and you refuse to count Canis Major
- 19:40because its status is disputed, and you refuse to count
- 19:43the ultra-faint satellites because they are too small for your taste,
- 19:47the list of acceptable candidates thins quickly. You might end
- 19:51up with the Large Magellanic Cloud orbiting us at about 163,000 light-years,
- 19:57or the Small Magellanic Cloud at close to 200,000 light-years,
- 20:01both visible to the naked eye from the southern hemisphere,
- 20:04and both large enough to look like proper little galaxies
- 20:07of their own. These two are still gravitationally connected to
- 20:10the Milky Way. Modern measurements suggest they are on long,
- 20:14complicated orbits and may not have been our companions forever,
- 20:17but they are our companions now. They are the closest
- 20:21satellite galaxies that everyone agrees are galaxies. And even they,
- 20:25at those distances, are twice as far as the Sagittarius
- 20:29dwarf's centre. There is a striking recent development on this front.
- 20:33For most of the 20th century, The Magellanic Clouds were
- 20:36assumed to be long-term satellites of the Milky Way, having
- 20:40orbited us for billions of years. That assumption survived, largely
- 20:44because nobody had a way to measure their motion precisely
- 20:47enough to test it. Then, in the 2000s, the Hubble
- 20:51Space Telescope, and later the Gaia spacecraft, produced measurements of
- 20:55the clouds' velocities that were dramatically more accurate than anything previous.
- 21:01The results surprised almost everyone in the field. The Large
- 21:04Magellanic Cloud is moving considerably faster relative to the Milky
- 21:08Way than a long-term companion should be moving. Its velocity
- 21:11is high enough that many researchers now favour a first-in-fall model,
- 21:15in which the clouds are not ancient satellites at all,
- 21:18but relative newcomers, falling into the Milky Way for the
- 21:21first time, having only recently begun to be gravitationally captured
- 21:25by us. If that model is correct, and it is,
- 21:28at the time of this recording, The leading interpretation among
- 21:31the researchers who study these motions most closely, it means
- 21:35our second and third answers to what the closest galaxy
- 21:38is are galaxies that were, until quite recently in cosmic terms,
- 21:43independent members of the local universe. They may not be
- 21:46Milky Way satellites in the deepest sense at all. They
- 21:49may be interlopers, dwarfs that formed elsewhere and only recently arrived,
- 21:54which introduces yet another wrinkle into the definitional problem. Because
- 21:58the closest galaxy that is gravitationally bound to us turns
- 22:01out to be a shifting category. Systems come in. Systems
- 22:05get absorbed. Systems drift out. And the picture at any
- 22:09given moment depends on how careful your measurements are and
- 22:12how you interpret them. And if you insist on going
- 22:15even further, if you insist on the closest galaxy that
- 22:19is a proper independent giant, comparable in scale to the
- 22:23Milky Way itself, then, and only then, do you arrive
- 22:27at Andromeda at approximately two and a half million light years.
- 22:31Which means the textbook sentence is not just wrong, it
- 22:34is the answer to a question no one thought to
- 22:36ask precisely. It is the answer to, what is the
- 22:39closest galaxy that is basically like ours? It is not
- 22:43the answer to, what is the closest galaxy? So the
- 22:46map we have to work with looks nothing like the
- 22:49popular picture. The popular picture shows the Milky Way, a
- 22:52comfortable stretch of empty space, then Andromeda. The real picture
- 22:57shows the Milky Way surrounded by a swarm of small, faint,
- 23:01sometimes dying, sometimes still forming, always intimate satellite galaxies. Some
- 23:07are being torn apart. Some are still being discovered. Some
- 23:11might not even be galaxies at all. And then, far
- 23:14beyond all of them, sits Andromeda, the nearest of the giants.
- 23:19There is a particular kind of vertigo that comes from
- 23:21realising this. Because our earlier sense of the closest galaxy
- 23:25was tied to a sense of separation. Andromeda felt like
- 23:28a destination. A distinct place. A somewhere else you could
- 23:33imagine pointing to and travelling toward. The real galactic neighbourhood
- 23:37does not have that clean separation. The Sagittarius dwarf stars
- 23:41are already mixed into ours. The Canis Major structure, whatever
- 23:45it is, blurs into our own disk. The ultra-faint dwarfs
- 23:49orbit through the same halo of dark matter that we do.
- 23:52When you ask where the Milky Way ends, and where
- 23:54its nearest neighbour begins, the honest answer is that there
- 23:57is no clean line. Our galaxy has a fuzzy edge,
- 24:01and its nearest neighbours have fuzzy edges, and those edges overlap.
- 24:04That has an unsettling consequence for the whole project of
- 24:07visiting another galaxy. If the closest galaxy is one whose
- 24:11stars are already threaded through ours, what does it even
- 24:14mean to travel to it? Are we travelling to the
- 24:17Sagittarius dwarf when we look up at certain streams of
- 24:20stars that pass through our own night sky? Are we
- 24:23already inside its remnants, in some sense? If so, has humanity,
- 24:28from a distance-only point of view, already crossed into another
- 24:31galaxy without noticing? And if the answer to that is uncomfortable,
- 24:35if the answer is that the Sagittarius dwarf is too
- 24:38far gone to count, and the Canis Major structure is
- 24:41too uncertain to count, then we are back to the
- 24:44Magellanic Clouds, or to Andromeda, and the distances explode again.
- 24:49This is why the question this episode is asking cannot
- 24:52be answered with a single number. It is not how
- 24:54far is the closest galaxy. It is a series of
- 24:57nested questions. What counts as a galaxy? What counts as separate?
- 25:03What counts as reaching it? What counts as a human
- 25:06still being human when they arrive? Every layer of the
- 25:10question multiplies the difficulty, and the deeper we go, the
- 25:13more the friendly textbook sentence dissolves into something much stranger
- 25:18and much more honest. The Milky Way is not a
- 25:21lone spiral floating in a quiet pond. It is a
- 25:24giant surrounded by a scattered cloud of smaller companions, some
- 25:29of which are already inside it, some of which are
- 25:31about to be, and one of which the largest, the
- 25:34most familiar, the most photogenic is astonishingly far away, for
- 25:39what everyone calls our closest galaxy. which is where the
- 25:43real problem begins. Because whichever definition you pick, whichever candidate
- 25:47you accept, the numbers are cruel. Even the friendliest, most
- 25:52generous answer to what the closest galaxy is places its
- 25:56centre at a distance that a modern human spacecraft could
- 25:59not cross in a hundred human civilisations laid end to end.
- 26:03Even light itself, the fastest thing that exists, would need
- 26:07tens of thousands of years to make the crossing. And
- 26:10that is before we even ask about the other galaxies.
- 26:13That is before we compare these distances to the width
- 26:16of the Milky Way, to the distance to the nearest star,
- 26:19to anything a human being can hold in their head.
- 26:22That comparison, when we do it properly, is what turns
- 26:26the friendly textbook sentence into something almost frightening. Because once
- 26:30you draw the real map, once you place the Sagittarius
- 26:33dwarf and the Magellanic clouds and Andromeda on a scale
- 26:36that a human body can understand, you discover that all
- 26:39the reassuring language about our galactic neighbours has been quietly
- 26:44relying on the fact that no one ever checks the ruler.
- 26:47On astronomical maps, these galaxies look adjacent to us. They
- 26:50look like dots pressed against the edge of our own dot.
- 26:53On a scale that matters for a spacecraft, or for
- 26:56a human lifetime, or for a civilisation, they are not
- 27:00adjacent at all. They are catastrophically distant. And even our nearest,
- 27:05our smallest, our most half-eaten, Our most quietly dissolving companion
- 27:09galaxy is still catastrophically distant. That is the real reveal
- 27:13hiding underneath the textbook sentence. Andromeda is not our nearest
- 27:18galactic neighbour. The Sagittarius dwarf and Canis Major and Segway
- 27:23One and dozens of others are much nearer. And none
- 27:26of that helps. None of that shortens the trip to
- 27:29anything a human being could survive. None of that brings
- 27:32a galactic destination within reach. It only means that when
- 27:36we ask, how far is the closest galaxy, we get
- 27:39to pick which impossibly far number we would like to use.
- 27:43And now we are going to place those numbers on
- 27:45a real ruler, not on a local group map where
- 27:48every galaxy is a friendly dot near every other dot.
- 27:51On a scale where the distance to the nearest star,
- 27:54the width of the Milky Way itself, and the gap
- 27:56to the Sagittarius dwarf are drawn honestly next to each other.
- 28:00Because the moment those distances are laid out side by side,
- 28:03something breaks. The idea of a close galaxy stops meaning
- 28:07anything at all. There is a picture that appears whenever
- 28:10anyone talks about the local group of galaxies. You have
- 28:13seen it. It is on textbook pages, on educational posters,
- 28:18on the opening slides of astronomy lectures. It shows the
- 28:21Milky Way as a small labelled disc on one side
- 28:24of the frame, Andromeda as another labelled disc on the
- 28:28other side. A cluster of even smaller dots scattered around them,
- 28:32representing the various dwarf galaxies. A neat little arrangement, all
- 28:37of it fitting comfortably on a page. Sometimes there is
- 28:40a scale bar in the corner reading 1 million light years,
- 28:44or 500,000 light years, but almost nobody looks at the
- 28:47scale bar. What people take away from the picture is
- 28:50the emotional impression the picture creates. And the emotional impression
- 28:54is that these galaxies are neighbours. That they are close.
- 28:58That they belong together in the same visual frame, the
- 29:01way houses on a street belong together in the same photograph.
- 29:05That impression is a trick, not a deliberate deception, but
- 29:09a trick nonetheless. When you compress hundreds of thousands or
- 29:13millions of light years onto a single page, everything on
- 29:16that page looks adjacent. The eye cannot help it. The
- 29:20eye evolved to interpret adjacency on the scale of things
- 29:23you might walk toward. It has no built-in defense against
- 29:27a scale bar in the corner that reads one million
- 29:29light years, so it treats the Sagittarius dwarf as if
- 29:32it is right next to us. and the large Magellanic
- 29:35cloud as if it is basically touching us, and Andromeda
- 29:39as if it is just across the way. The map lies,
- 29:43not by including wrong information, by including truthful information, at
- 29:47a scale that makes the information feel wrong. So what
- 29:50we need to do next is redraw that map, not
- 29:53on a textbook page, but on a scale that a
- 29:55human body, a human spacecraft, and a human lifetime can
- 30:00actually measure themselves against. Because the moment the distances stop
- 30:03being crushed onto a page, everything changes. What looked like
- 30:07a friendly neighborhood in the local group picture turns into
- 30:11a landscape so vast that even the friendliest destinations we
- 30:14identified earlier become almost unreachable in principle. And the way
- 30:18we are going to feel that is by starting small.
- 30:22By starting, in fact, with the closest star. The nearest
- 30:25star system to the sun is called Alpha Centauri, It
- 30:28is not one star but three, gravitationally bound together a
- 30:32bright pair called Alpha Centauri A and B, and a
- 30:35small red companion called Proxima Centauri which happens to be
- 30:39the actual closest single star to us. The whole system
- 30:42sits at a distance of about 4.37 light years. That
- 30:46number gets quoted so often in so many articles about
- 30:50interstellar travel that it has almost lost its meaning. Let
- 30:53us restore some of the meaning. 4.37 light-years is roughly
- 30:5741 trillion kilometres. If you tried to imagine that number
- 31:01on foot, or by car, or by any means of
- 31:04transport a human body has ever used, you would fail.
- 31:08A commercial jet flying non-stop toward Proxima Centauri, ignoring the
- 31:12small matter that it cannot fly through vacuum, would take
- 31:15approximately 5 million years to arrive. Voyager 1, the fastest
- 31:20spacecraft launched toward interstellar space, moves at about 17 kilometers
- 31:25per second. At that speed, pointed at Proxima Centauri, it
- 31:29would take roughly 75,000 years to arrive. 75,000 years. That
- 31:35is longer than the entire recorded history of human civilization
- 31:39applied to a trip toward the nearest star. And this
- 31:42is the important part. Alpha Centauri is not far by
- 31:45galactic standards. Alpha Centauri is next door. It is the
- 31:49closest possible destination in interstellar space. It is the answer
- 31:53to the question, what is the nearest thing outside our
- 31:57own solar system? And a Voyager speed journey to it
- 32:01takes something like a thousand times longer than the entire
- 32:04history of writing. If Alpha Centauri at 4.37 light years
- 32:09produces those numbers, imagine what happens when we start counting
- 32:13in thousands of light years, or hundreds of thousands, or millions.
- 32:18So let us keep going. Let us step up one
- 32:21rung on this ladder. The next honest scale to place
- 32:24next to Alpha Centauri is not another star but our
- 32:27whole galaxy. The Milky Way is not a small object
- 32:30at Alpha Centauri scale. It is a colossal, sprawling structure
- 32:35whose full extent astronomers now think is far larger than
- 32:38the neat 100,000 light-years across figure that appeared in old textbooks.
- 32:44Modern observations of stellar streams and outer halo stars have
- 32:48pushed reasonable estimates of the Milky Way's true extent to
- 32:51something like 150,000 to 200,000 light-years, and possibly more, depending
- 32:57on where you decide to draw the edge. The bright,
- 33:00familiar spiral disk is only part of the story. Around it,
- 33:05a vast, diffuse halo of stars, dark matter, and captured
- 33:09debris extends out much, much further. Take the conservative number
- 33:13for the visible disk, roughly 100,000 light-years across, and compare
- 33:17it to Alpha Centauri. The nearest star is at 4.37 light-years.
- 33:22The Milky Way is over 20,000 times wider than that distance.
- 33:27If you shrank the trip to Alpha Centauri down to
- 33:29the length of your outstretched arm, the width of the
- 33:32Milky Way's disk would extend across a distance longer than
- 33:35several sports stadiums placed end-to-end. Alpha Centauri is a fingertip.
- 33:40The Milky Way is a landscape, and these are both
- 33:43objects we already live inside. That is worth pausing on.
- 33:47We do not have to leave the Milky Way to
- 33:48encounter distances that dwarf anything human machines have managed. Voyager 1,
- 33:53after nearly half a century of flight, has barely started
- 33:57to cross the outer edge of our sun's influence, let
- 34:00alone made a dent in the distance to Alpha Centauri.
- 34:03And Alpha Centauri is a rounding error compared to the
- 34:05width of our own galaxy. Every one of the numbers
- 34:08we are about to use for other galaxies has to
- 34:11be understood in this context. We are not talking about
- 34:14scaling up from something we can nearly do. We are
- 34:16talking about scaling up from something we cannot even begin
- 34:20to do at interstellar scale. Now, bring in the Sagittarius
- 34:24dwarf galaxy. We established earlier that its centre lies at
- 34:28approximately 70,000 light-years from Earth. 70,000 light-years. That is close
- 34:34by galactic standards. Absurdly close for something officially labelled as
- 34:38a separate galaxy. In fact, it is closer to us
- 34:42than parts of our own Milky Way. But compare it
- 34:45to Alpha Centauri. 70,000 divided by 4.37 is roughly 16,000.
- 34:50The centre of the Sagittarius dwarf is about 16,000 times
- 34:55further from us than the nearest star. If Alpha Centauri
- 34:58is one step, the Sagittarius dwarf is 16,000 steps in
- 35:02the same direction, and Alpha Centauri already required timescales longer
- 35:07than recorded human history for our fastest spacecraft to reach. 16,000
- 35:11times that. just to reach the friendliest, most quietly dissolving,
- 35:16most half-eaten companion galaxy on the list. And now the
- 35:19picture starts to get uncomfortable. Because that number, 70,000 light years,
- 35:25is not an accident of scale. It is roughly the
- 35:28width of the Milky Way's inner disk, which means, on
- 35:31a real ruler, the distance from Earth to the closest
- 35:34thing anyone calls a separate galaxy is comparable to the
- 35:38distance from Earth to the far side of our own galaxy.
- 35:41In other words, Leaving the Milky Way and crossing the
- 35:44Milky Way are, at Sagittarius dwarf distances, essentially the same
- 35:49kind of journey. Both are staggeringly long, neither is meaningfully
- 35:54shorter than the other. The word intergalactic and the word crossgalactic,
- 35:59when applied to a spacecraft, are not describing meaningfully different
- 36:03orders of magnitude at this scale. Let us push further out.
- 36:07The Large Magellanic Cloud, One of the two proper satellite galaxies,
- 36:11visible with the naked eye from the southern hemisphere, sits
- 36:14at a distance of about 163,000 light-years. The small Magellanic
- 36:20Cloud lies a little further out, near 200,000 light-years. These
- 36:25are the ones that most people, when pressed, will accept
- 36:28as genuine independent galaxies orbiting the Milky Way. They are
- 36:32large enough to see. They are structured enough to look
- 36:35like something. They are gravitationally bound to us, but distinct.
- 36:39Compare them to Alpha Centauri again. 163,000 divided by 4.37
- 36:43is close to 37,000. The Large Magellanic Cloud is roughly 37,000
- 36:45times farther than the nearest star. 200,000 divided by 4.37
- 36:47is about 46,000. The Small Magellanic Cloud is roughly 46,000
- 36:50times farther than the nearest star. And Once again, Alpha
- 37:08Centauri already broke every reasonable timescale for our fastest spacecraft.
- 37:13Multiply those timescales by 37,000, by 46,000, and the numbers
- 37:18stop being numbers. They become abstract labels for durations that
- 37:22no human institution has ever survived. Now, step to Andromeda.
- 37:27Two and a half million light years approximately from Earth.
- 37:31In terms of Alpha Centauri, that is roughly 570,000 times
- 37:35further than the nearest star. In terms of Sagittarius dwarf,
- 37:39that is roughly 36 times further than the closest dying satellite.
- 37:43In terms of the Large Magellanic Cloud, that is roughly
- 37:4615 times further than our most familiar satellite galaxy. Andromeda
- 37:51is not merely a longer version of these trips. Andromeda
- 37:54is the moment where the scale changes character entirely. But
- 37:58here is the trap the local group map sets. When
- 38:01you look at the local group visualisation, all of these,
- 38:04the Milky Way, the Sagittarius Dwarf, the Magellanic Clouds, Andromeda,
- 38:10appear as dots on the same picture. They look like
- 38:13they belong to the same visual category of close. The
- 38:16map does not lie about their positions, it only lies
- 38:19about their meaning. Because to a human body, and to
- 38:22a human spacecraft, the Sagittarius Dwarf and Andromeda are not
- 38:27both close. 1. is impossible on one timescale. The other
- 38:33is impossible on a timescale that is many times longer,
- 38:37moving in a direction that does not lie inside the
- 38:39Milky Way at all, but reaches across a stretch of
- 38:42intergalactic space that has almost nothing in it. Let us
- 38:46make this even more concrete with a fresh analogy. Imagine
- 38:50that you replace the distance to Alpha Centauri with the
- 38:53length of a single sheet of ordinary printer paper, about
- 38:5630 centimetres. That sheet of paper stands for the nearest star. Now,
- 39:02on that scale, the width of the Milky Way's inner
- 39:05disk is approximately 23,000 sheets of paper laid end to end.
- 39:10A distance of roughly 7 kilometers. So the nearest star
- 39:13is a page in front of you. The width of
- 39:16our galaxy is an hour-long walk across town. On the
- 39:19same scale, the Sagittarius dwarf center is around 5 kilometers
- 39:23from you. The Large Magellanic Cloud is about 11km from you,
- 39:27the Small Magellanic Cloud is around 13 or 14km from you,
- 39:32and Andromeda? Andromeda, on this same scale where Alpha Centauri
- 39:37is a single sheet of paper, sits approximately 170km away.
- 39:40170km of that paper stretched out end to end, A
- 39:47full day of driving between us and our so-called nearest
- 39:50major galactic neighbour, when the nearest star has been reduced
- 39:53to something you can hold in one hand. That is
- 39:56what close means in the local group. That is the
- 39:59honest scale of the neighbourhood. And even that image is
- 40:02being generous, because it lets you keep the intergalactic space
- 40:05clean and empty and easy to imagine. In reality, the
- 40:09space between the Milky Way and Andromeda is not really
- 40:12empty in a boring sense. It has been mapped. especially
- 40:16by observations over the last two decades, as an extended
- 40:20halo of hot, thin gas, stray stars, dark matter, and
- 40:24slow filaments of material. Some of it belongs to us.
- 40:28Some belongs to Andromeda. Some might belong to both, depending
- 40:32on how you draw the halos. When you look at
- 40:35recent modelling of the extended dark matter halos of both galaxies,
- 40:39some estimates suggest the two halos may already be technically touching,
- 40:43or nearly so, spanning a large fraction of the gap
- 40:46between us. But the visible stellar bodies, the parts your
- 40:50eye would ever describe as the galaxy itself, are separated
- 40:54by that full two and a half million light years
- 40:57of almost nothing. Now this is where the honesty of
- 40:59the map really cuts, because the local group picture treats
- 41:03all these distances as if they matter equally. On a page,
- 41:07Sagittarius dwarf is a small hop, the Magellanic clouds are
- 41:10a slightly larger hop, and Andromeda is a longer hop.
- 41:14That is misleading, because the actual leaps in scale between
- 41:17them are enormous. Going from Alpha Centauri to Sagittarius Dwarf
- 41:21is a leap of roughly 16,000 times. Going from Sagittarius
- 41:25Dwarf to Andromeda is a further leap of roughly 36 times.
- 41:30Nothing about any of this is a friendly hop. Every
- 41:33step of the ladder is a factor of 10 or
- 41:34more that no spacecraft has ever crossed and no human
- 41:38machine has ever endured. There is another way to feel
- 41:41the same picture. Think about how long light itself takes
- 41:45to make each trip. Light is the fastest thing there is.
- 41:49Nothing with mass, nothing carrying a human body, nothing carrying
- 41:53a functioning machine will ever move at light speed. And
- 41:56yet even light, our absolute ceiling, needs specific and important
- 42:01amounts of time to make each of these journeys. Light
- 42:04needs about 4.37 years to reach Alpha Centauri. It needs
- 42:08about 70,000 years to reach the centre of the Sagittarius Dwarf.
- 42:12It needs about 163,000 years to reach the Large Magellanic Cloud.
- 42:17It needs about 2.5 million years to reach Andromeda. Set
- 42:22those durations against the age of the human species. Anatomically
- 42:26modern humans are, at most, a few hundred thousand years old.
- 42:30Light travelling to Andromeda has been in flight for roughly
- 42:32ten times the entire existence of our species. Light from
- 42:36Andromeda that reaches us tonight left before our species existed
- 42:40at all. Light travelling to the Large Magellanic Cloud takes
- 42:44about as long as our species has existed. Light travelling
- 42:47to the Sagittarius Dwarf takes a substantial fraction of our
- 42:50species' existence. And that is with light. That is with
- 42:54the fastest possible signal that physics allows. Anything human-built, anything
- 42:59carrying life, will need many times longer. Voyager 1, at
- 43:0517 km per second, if it were pointed at the
- 43:07Sagittarius Dwarf, would need on the order of a billion
- 43:11years to arrive, not 70,000. A billion. Because Voyager is
- 43:16moving at a small fraction of 1% of the speed
- 43:18of light, and the trip to Sagittarius scales up accordingly.
- 43:22A billion years is longer than the entire history of
- 43:25complex life on Earth. Multi-celled organisms have only existed for
- 43:28about that long. Voyager's trip to our nearest separate galaxy
- 43:32would consume all of that. And Voyager, remember, is our
- 43:36fastest interstellar spacecraft, not our slowest, our fastest, the one
- 43:42that people cite when they want to talk about the
- 43:44outer reaches of human capability. Compared to interstellar space, it
- 43:48is barely moving. Compared to intergalactic space, it might as
- 43:53well be standing still. This is the paradox the redrawn
- 43:56map exposes. The local group looks small on paper because
- 44:00the paper is small. In reality, the local group is
- 44:04one of the most stretched out neighborhoods it is possible
- 44:06to imagine. Its members are separated by distances that make
- 44:10Voyager's 50 years of flight to the edge of our
- 44:12own solar system look like the first breath a runner
- 44:15takes at the starting line of a marathon that lasts
- 44:18100 million years. And the runners we can imagine building
- 44:21are barely any faster than Voyager. There is a particular
- 44:24reason this matters for the question we are asking. Because
- 44:27earlier we allowed ourselves the possibility that the friendliest definition
- 44:31of nearest galaxy might rescue the question. We said, well...
- 44:37If the closest galaxy is the Sagittarius dwarf, or the
- 44:40Canis Major structure, or one of the ultra-faint satellites, at
- 44:44least the distances are shorter than to Andromeda. And that
- 44:47is true. They are shorter, but shorter in this context
- 44:51is not meaningful in the way it sounds. Shorter in
- 44:54this context is the difference between a trip that would
- 44:57consume 10,000 human civilizations and a trip that would consume 100,000
- 45:02of them. It is a shortening from unimaginable, to slightly
- 45:06less unimaginable. It does not turn any of these trips
- 45:09into something a human being could survive. There is another
- 45:13honest thing worth noticing on this redrawn map. The Sagittarius
- 45:16Dwarf's proximity is not exactly a gift, because that dwarf
- 45:20galaxy is being pulled apart. Its stars are trailing off
- 45:24into streams that wrap around the Milky Way multiple times.
- 45:28To even define a destination inside the Sagittarius Dwarf, you
- 45:31have to decide what you are aiming for. Its dying core.
- 45:35which will not exist in its current form for very
- 45:38much longer on cosmic timescales. A particular star inside it,
- 45:42a region of its diffuse remaining structure, the nearest galaxy,
- 45:46in this closest of all sense, is a moving, dissolving target.
- 45:51You are aiming at a place that is in the
- 45:53process of ceasing to be a place. The Magellanic clouds
- 45:56are more stable in the short term, though even they
- 45:59are on complicated orbits that make their long-term future genuinely uncertain.
- 46:03Some modern modelling suggests the Large Magellanic Cloud may itself
- 46:08eventually be torn apart or absorbed by the Milky Way
- 46:11over the next several billion years. So even our most
- 46:14familiar bright satellite galaxies, the ones people can point to
- 46:17in the southern sky and say, that is a galaxy
- 46:20near ours, are on their own long journeys that a
- 46:23human mission would have to somehow keep pace with. Only
- 46:27Andromeda offers something like a stable, coherent, unambiguous destination. And Andromeda,
- 46:33we have just seen, is on the far end of
- 46:35the redrawn map, at distances that make the closer, dissolving
- 46:39options look almost intimate by comparison. This is the shape
- 46:43of the problem. Not, how far is one specific closest galaxy,
- 46:48but which impossible distance would you like to attempt to cross?
- 46:51Every candidate on the menu is a trip so long
- 46:54that our fastest existing spacecraft would need timescales measured in
- 46:58the age of species or the age of continents to
- 47:01complete it. And that is before we even talk about
- 47:04carrying a human being through the trip alive. That is
- 47:07before we ask what happens to a machine, or a body,
- 47:10or a civilization over such durations. That is before we
- 47:14ask whether it is even possible to shorten the trip
- 47:16by moving faster. And if so, at what cost? Because
- 47:20the natural response to everything we have just laid out
- 47:22is the same response people always reach for. Fine, someone says.
- 47:27We cannot cross 70,000 light years at voyager speeds. nobody
- 47:31was ever seriously proposing to what if we go faster
- 47:35what if we build ships that move at a small
- 47:37percentage of the speed of light or a larger percentage
- 47:40or something close to the ultimate limit surely the trip
- 47:44becomes reasonable then surely the sagittarius dwarf comes within reach
- 47:48if we can get up to say one tenth of
- 47:50light speed surely the magellanic clouds are only a few
- 47:54centuries away at those velocities surely andromeda at truly relativistic
- 47:58speeds becomes a lifetime journey That is the natural response.
- 48:03And it is not entirely wrong. It is just far,
- 48:07far more expensive than most people realise. And that is
- 48:10what we need to look at next. Because the moment
- 48:13you start asking what it would actually take to move
- 48:15a real object at those velocities to accelerate it, to
- 48:18keep it going, to protect it from what it encounters,
- 48:22to slow it down at the far end, so that
- 48:24it does not simply pass through its destination at unimaginable speed,
- 48:28you discover that the equations do not treat percentages of
- 48:31light speed as gentle numbers. The energy required does not
- 48:35scale linearly. The impact hazards do not scale linearly. The
- 48:39distances and durations do not shrink cleanly. Every apparent shortcut
- 48:44brings its own catastrophe. The redrawn map we have just
- 48:47built is only the geography. It tells you where the
- 48:50destinations sit and how absurd their positions are compared to
- 48:53anything human machines have ever managed. It does not yet
- 48:57tell you what happens when you try to go there.
- 48:59It does not yet tell you what happens to the ship,
- 49:01or the crew, or the civilization that launched them. When
- 49:05they attempt to compress 70,000 or 163,000 or 2.5 million
- 49:10light years into anything resembling a human timescale, that is
- 49:14the next question. And it is the question where the
- 49:17arithmetic stops being just intimidating and starts to becoming genuinely brutal.
- 49:22Because the map, as we have redrawn it, is only
- 49:25the starting condition. What follows is the physics of trying
- 49:29to cross it. There is an instinct that emerges here,
- 49:32worth taking seriously because almost everyone has it. It goes
- 49:36something like this. Yes, Voyager is slow. Voyager was never
- 49:41meant to be a starship. Voyager is a small, decades-old
- 49:45probe drifting outward at the pace physics allowed us to
- 49:47give it in the 1970s. Of course, a trip to
- 49:50the Sagittarius dwarf at Voyager speeds is absurd, but surely
- 49:54we can do better. Surely a serious interstellar spacecraft, one
- 49:58designed from the ground up for the task, could move
- 50:01at a real fraction of the speed of light. Surely
- 50:04the numbers become sane once we stop using probes built
- 50:07for the outer planets and start imagining ships built for
- 50:10interstellar space. That instinct is completely reasonable, and it is
- 50:14completely wrong. Not because faster is impossible in principle, because
- 50:18the moment you ask what faster actually costs, in energy,
- 50:22in impact hazards, in navigation, in slowing down at the
- 50:25far end, the arithmetic stops being merely difficult and starts
- 50:29being genuinely hostile. So now we do the math. Not
- 50:32the friendly, hand-waved math of, well, at one tenth of
- 50:36light speed it would only take a few hundred thousand years.
- 50:39The math that respects what accelerating a real physical object
- 50:43actually requires. What happens to that object when it encounters
- 50:46real matter in real space? And what has to happen
- 50:50at the other end, so that the object does not
- 50:52simply pass through its destination too fast to see? We
- 50:55will start with the engines that already exist, and then
- 50:58we will step up the ladder of hypothetical velocities. Each
- 51:02rung will look better on paper. Each rung will introduce
- 51:05a new catastrophe underneath the paper. Let us begin with
- 51:09what humans have actually built. Voyager 1, as mentioned, moves
- 51:14at about 17 km per second relative to the Sun.
- 51:17That is roughly 61,000 km per hour. In everyday human terms,
- 51:22that is astonishing. In cosmic terms, it is a crawl.
- 51:26If Voyager were pointed directly at the centre of the
- 51:29Sagittarius dwarf, At approximately 70,000 light years away, it would
- 51:34need on the order of one and a quarter billion
- 51:36years to arrive. A billion and a quarter years. That
- 51:40is more than a quarter of the entire age of
- 51:42the Earth. That is longer than the entire history of
- 51:45animals on our planet. That is the trip time for
- 51:48our fastest working interstellar spacecraft to reach the closest galactic destination.
- 51:54We have a dwarf whose stars our galaxy is already
- 51:57tearing away and folding into itself. Aim it at the
- 52:00Large Magellanic Cloud instead, at roughly 163,000 light years, and
- 52:05the number becomes something close to 3 billion years. Aim
- 52:09it at Andromeda, at 2.5 million light years, and you
- 52:13are looking at something on the order of 45 billion years,
- 52:16which is longer than the current age of the universe.
- 52:19Voyager will not be doing this trip, or any version
- 52:22of it. Voyager is a lesson, not a candidate. it
- 52:26shows us how bad the problem is at the speeds
- 52:29our species has actually achieved. Now consider the Parker Solar Probe.
- 52:33This is the fastest human-made object ever built, and it
- 52:37achieves that title not because it has some revolutionary engine,
- 52:41but because it falls repeatedly toward the Sun on carefully
- 52:44designed orbits, using the Sun's own gravity to accelerate. At
- 52:48its closest approaches, Parker moves at approximately 200 km per second,
- 52:53over 10 times faster than Voyager. That is genuinely impressive.
- 52:58It is also completely dependent on the sun. Parker is
- 53:02not traveling anywhere. Parker is looping. But let us pretend, generously,
- 53:08that we could somehow send an object at Parker's peak
- 53:10speed toward another galaxy. 200 kilometers per second sounds much
- 53:15better than 17. So how much does the trip shrink?
- 53:19Not enough. 200 kilometers per second is still only about
- 53:221 1500th of the speed of light. a one-way trip
- 53:26to the Sagittarius dwarf at Parker's speed would take on
- 53:28the order of 100 million years. That is a genuine
- 53:31improvement on Voyager. It is also longer than the entire
- 53:35time since dinosaurs walked the Earth. The Large Magellanic Cloud
- 53:39would take on the order of 240 million years. Andromeda
- 53:43would take on the order of 3 and 3 quarter
- 53:45billion years. Even at more than 10 times Voyager's velocity,
- 53:49we are still talking about trips that would consume geological ages.
- 53:53And we should be honest, that even sustaining Parker's speed
- 53:56all the way to another galaxy is not something the
- 53:59probe was designed to do. Parker only reaches those velocities
- 54:02near the sun. It is not a design for interstellar cruise.
- 54:06But even if we grant it, the math laughs. So
- 54:09current spacecraft are not the answer that was expected. The
- 54:12interesting question is what happens if we consider velocities proposed
- 54:16on paper for future starships? Because now we enter territory
- 54:20where the numbers at first seem to work. and where
- 54:23the price tags, on closer inspection, get catastrophic. Let us
- 54:28start with 1% of the speed of light. This is
- 54:31a benchmark that has been floated in several serious speculative proposals,
- 54:35most notably in the breakthrough Starshot concept from the 2010s,
- 54:39which proposed pushing very small light sail probes toward Alpha
- 54:43Centauri at around 20% of light speed. We will get
- 54:46to 20% in a moment. First, 1%. 1% of the
- 54:50speed of light is roughly 3,000 km per second, which
- 54:55is about 15 times faster than Parker's peak speed, and
- 54:58roughly 175 times faster than Voyager. At that speed, ignoring
- 55:04for now the small matter of how you get up
- 55:06to it and how you slow down again, a trip
- 55:08to the Sagittarius Dwarf Centre would take approximately 7 million years.
- 55:13The Large Magellanic Cloud, about 16 million years. Andromeda, about
- 55:19250 million years. Notice what just happened. We move to
- 55:24a hypothetical velocity that is not remotely achievable with current technology,
- 55:28one that would require a propulsion system nobody has ever
- 55:31built at anything close to that scale, and we still
- 55:35ended up with trip times longer than the entire existence
- 55:38of the human species by factors of tens or hundreds
- 55:41or thousands. 7 million years is roughly 35 times the
- 55:45span of anatomically modern humans. And that is the friendly answer,
- 55:49the one for the closest, dying, dissolving companion galaxy. Andromeda's
- 55:54quarter of a billion years at 1% light speed is
- 55:56longer than the time since the first mammals appeared. A
- 55:59civilization would have to remain functional, purposeful, and coherent across
- 56:04that duration. No civilization has ever managed anything remotely like it.
- 56:09So push higher, 10% of light speed. This is where
- 56:13genuinely speculative propulsion concepts start to appear in the physics literature.
- 56:18Fusion drives, if they can ever be made to work
- 56:21at spacecraft scale rather than as failed reactor experiments on
- 56:24the ground. Antimatter drives, if antimatter can ever be produced
- 56:29and stored in gram quantities rather than the vanishingly tiny
- 56:32amounts we currently manage. Beamed propulsion, where a spacecraft carries
- 56:36almost no fuel and is instead pushed from behind by
- 56:39a colossal laser or particle beam based in the home system.
- 56:43None of these has ever been demonstrated at anything close
- 56:46to interstellar scale, and each of them faces fundamental engineering
- 56:50barriers that current physics can describe, but current industry cannot overcome.
- 56:55But they are the concepts serious researchers use when they
- 56:58want to talk about 10% of light speed as a
- 57:00possibility rather than pure science fiction. At 10% of light speed,
- 57:05or roughly 30,000 kilometers per second, the Sagittarius dwarf trip
- 57:09becomes about 700,000 years. The Large Magellanic Cloud, roughly 1.6
- 57:15million years. Andromeda, about 25 million years. Better, much better,
- 57:21in the sense that these numbers are no longer measured
- 57:24in billions. They're only measured in hundreds of thousands, in millions,
- 57:28in tens of millions. Which is to say, they are
- 57:32still trips no continuous human institution has ever attempted, and
- 57:36no human body has ever endured, and no human machine
- 57:39has ever survived. 700,000 years is more than three times
- 57:43the entire existence of our species, and this is the
- 57:47least demanding target on the menu, hit with a propulsion
- 57:50concept that requires technology nobody has built. Now push to
- 57:5550% of light speed. Somewhere around here, we cross into
- 57:58territory that is not just engineering hard, but physically punishing
- 58:02in ways that are not obvious from the trip time
- 58:04numbers alone. 50% of light speed, is 150,000 kilometers per second.
- 58:11From the point of view of an observer left behind
- 58:13on Earth, a trip to the Sagittarius dwarf takes about 140,000 years.
- 58:18To the Large Magellanic Cloud, about 325,000 years. To Andromeda,
- 58:25about five million years. These are still enormous numbers from
- 58:29Earth's frame of reference. Somewhat improved for the travelers, thanks
- 58:33to a small amount of time dilation, but only somewhat,
- 58:36At 50% of light speed, the time dilation factor is
- 58:40only about 1.15. The travellers experience roughly 87% of the
- 58:45trip time that Earth measures. It is a real effect.
- 58:49It is not a rescue. And then we get to
- 58:51the true relativistic regime, 99% of light speed or higher.
- 58:56Here time dilation finally begins to bite in a way
- 58:59that changes the story for the travellers themselves. At 99%
- 59:02of light speed, The time dilation factor is roughly seven.
- 59:07That means the crew ages roughly seven times more slowly
- 59:10than the universe outside the ship. Suddenly, the Sagittarius dwarf trip,
- 59:15which takes about 70,000 years from Earth's point of view
- 59:18at that speed, feels like only about 10,000 years to
- 59:21the crew. The Large Magellanic Cloud, at 163,000 Earth years,
- 59:27feels like about 23,000 years to the crew. Andromeda, at 2.5
- 59:32million Earth years, feels like about 350,000 years to the crew.
- 59:37Push further, to 99.9%, and the dilation factor rises to
- 59:42about 22. Push to 99.99%, and it rises to about 70.
- 59:48In principle, at velocities arbitrarily close to light speed, the
- 59:52trip time as experienced by the crew can become as
- 59:55short as you like. In principle, A crew moving fast
- 59:58enough could cross to Andromeda in something like a single
- 1:00:01human lifetime as felt aboard the ship while two and
- 1:00:04a half million years pass outside. That last sentence is
- 1:00:08the one that people usually stop at. That is the
- 1:00:10sentence that appears in articles about relativistic travel to other galaxies,
- 1:00:15framed as if it were a solution. It is not
- 1:00:18a solution. It is a description of the far end
- 1:00:21of a physics equation, sitting on top of an energy
- 1:00:24requirement that nobody who repeats the sentence usually mentions. And
- 1:00:28it is important, right here, to be honest about what
- 1:00:31is happening. The clock aboard the ship does slow down.
- 1:00:35That is real, tested physics, verified in particle accelerators every day.
- 1:00:41The clock at home does not. So if the crew's
- 1:00:43experience time shrinks to a lifetime, the universe outside the
- 1:00:47ship still ages by the full trip time. Andromeda's crew
- 1:00:51arrives biologically, having lived one lifetime, Earth, if it still
- 1:00:57exists in any recognizable form, has aged two and a
- 1:01:00half million years. The two clocks disagree and both are correct.
- 1:01:04The catch is what it costs to make those two
- 1:01:06clocks disagree that much, because the energy required to push
- 1:01:10a real massive object to those velocities does not scale
- 1:01:13like ordinary intuition suggests. In everyday physics, kinetic energy scales
- 1:01:18with the square of velocity. Double your speed and you
- 1:01:21need four times the energy. Triple your speed and and
- 1:01:25you need nine times the energy. That is already brutal.
- 1:01:29But at velocities close to the speed of light, the
- 1:01:32relativistic version of the equation takes over, and the energy
- 1:01:35required does not simply scale with the square of velocity anymore.
- 1:01:39It scales with the difference between the ship's total energy,
- 1:01:42including its rest mass, and its rest mass alone. And
- 1:01:46that difference grows without bound as the ship approaches light speed,
- 1:01:50getting from 99% to 99.9% of light speed, does not
- 1:01:55require slightly more energy. It requires roughly three times more
- 1:01:59energy for the same mass, getting from 99.9% to 99.99%,
- 1:02:05roughly another factor of three, every additional nine on the velocity,
- 1:02:09another enormous multiplier on the energy budget, and the ship's
- 1:02:13mass matters catastrophically. A small probe of a few kilograms
- 1:02:18is one thing, A ship carrying a functioning human crew
- 1:02:21and everything needed to keep them alive for the trip
- 1:02:23is a different problem by many orders of magnitude. Serious
- 1:02:27estimates for accelerating even a modestly sized crewed vehicle to
- 1:02:31a substantial fraction of light speed reach energies that exceed
- 1:02:35the total annual energy consumption of the entire human species,
- 1:02:39multiplied by figures that make ordinary industrial comparisons meaningless. To
- 1:02:43put a real number on it, accelerating even a modestly
- 1:02:47sized crewed vessel, say 100,000 tons. Roughly, the mass of
- 1:02:52a large modern aircraft carrier to just 10% of the
- 1:02:55speed of light requires kinetic energy on the order of
- 1:02:5945 million billion megajoules. That figure begins to lose meaning
- 1:03:03without comparison. Total worldwide human energy consumption across all sources,
- 1:03:08every power plant, every vehicle, every heating system on Earth combined,
- 1:03:13is currently around 600,000 billion megajoules per year, which means
- 1:03:18the kinetic energy for that single ship, ignoring all inefficiencies,
- 1:03:22would consume roughly 75 years of the entire human species'
- 1:03:26current energy production, and that is only for the acceleration.
- 1:03:30The deceleration burn at the destination requires a comparable amount
- 1:03:34of energy again, and that is only for 10% of
- 1:03:37the speed of light. Push the target velocity to 50%,
- 1:03:41and the kinetic energy for the same ship rises by
- 1:03:44roughly a factor of 30, pushed to 99%, and the
- 1:03:48energy required grows by a further factor of about 40,
- 1:03:51because relativistic kinetic energy diverges as velocity approaches the ultimate limit.
- 1:03:57And these are only the raw kinetic energies. Real propulsion
- 1:04:01systems are nothing like 100% efficient at converting stored fuel
- 1:04:04into motion. Chemical rockets manage a few percent. the most
- 1:04:08optimistic fusion drive projections convert less than 1% of their
- 1:04:12fuel mass to usable kinetic energy, which means that in
- 1:04:16practice the fuel and infrastructure requirements are many times larger
- 1:04:19than the raw kinetic energy figures suggest. Producing, storing and
- 1:04:23controllably releasing that much energy without the entire ship being
- 1:04:27destroyed by its own propulsion system is a problem that
- 1:04:30has no current solution at anything close to the required scale,
- 1:04:33and that is only for the acceleration phase. You have
- 1:04:37to do all of it again in reverse, to slow
- 1:04:40the ship down at the far end. That deceleration problem
- 1:04:43is one of the most consistently overlooked parts of every
- 1:04:46popular discussion of interstellar and intergalactic travel. It is easy
- 1:04:50to imagine an engine burning at the start of the trip.
- 1:04:53It is much harder to explain what stops the ship
- 1:04:55when it arrives. There is nothing at the destination to
- 1:04:59help you. No atmosphere to break against. No convenient star
- 1:05:03at the right position to gravity assist against, aimed the
- 1:05:06right way. If you accelerate up to 50% of light
- 1:05:10speed on the way out, you must decelerate by 50%
- 1:05:13of light speed at the other end. And that means
- 1:05:16burning a comparable amount of energy in reverse, using onboard mass,
- 1:05:20most of which you had to carry with you from
- 1:05:22the start. Which means the ship you had to accelerate
- 1:05:25was not the modest crewed vehicle you imagined. It was
- 1:05:28the crewed vehicle plus the enormous mass of fuel needed
- 1:05:32to slow it down. Which means the energy you needed
- 1:05:35at the start was much larger. because you are accelerating
- 1:05:38that additional mass too. This is why serious rocket equation
- 1:05:42style calculations for high fraction of light speed missions produce
- 1:05:45fuel requirements that dwarf the mass of the payload by
- 1:05:48ridiculous factors. Consider what ridiculous factors actually means in practice.
- 1:05:55A fusion propulsion system, even in the most optimistic theoretical calculations,
- 1:06:00converts less than 1% of the mass of its fuel
- 1:06:03into usable kinetic energy through hydrogen fusion. That efficiency, which
- 1:06:07is orders of magnitude better than any chemical propellant, is
- 1:06:11still catastrophically low for relativistic travel. To accelerate a modestly
- 1:06:16sized crude ship to 10% of the speed of light
- 1:06:19and then decelerate it at the far end. The total
- 1:06:22mass of fusion fuel required, even under generous assumptions, would
- 1:06:26exceed the payload by factors of tens to hundreds. Which
- 1:06:30means the ship you actually have to accelerate is not
- 1:06:33the crude vessel alone. It is tens or hundreds of
- 1:06:36times the crude vessel's mass in raw fuel wrapped around
- 1:06:39the small living compartment at the centre, which means that
- 1:06:43fuel mass itself must be accelerated to relativistic velocity using
- 1:06:47more fuel, which is why the rocket equation at these
- 1:06:50speeds and with these efficiencies tends toward requirements that break
- 1:06:54the calculation entirely. Antimatter propulsion looks better on paper because
- 1:06:59matter and antimatter annihilating each other release essentially all of
- 1:07:02their combined mass as energy. In principle, this is the
- 1:07:06most efficient reaction physics allows. In practice, humanity has produced
- 1:07:11antimatter only in vanishingly small quantities, at costs that make
- 1:07:15it the most expensive substance ever manufactured. Total antimatter production
- 1:07:20across the entire history of physics amounts to a few
- 1:07:22billionths of a gram, produced in facilities like the Large
- 1:07:26Hadron Collider and its predecessors over decades of operation. Serious
- 1:07:31estimates for the antimatter fuel required for a single crewed
- 1:07:34relativistic mission range from tons to thousands of tons, depending
- 1:07:38on the target velocity. There is a further subtlety about
- 1:07:41beamed propulsion that the standard summary does not usually cover.
- 1:07:45The beam that pushes the sail must remain focused on
- 1:07:48it for the entire acceleration phase, which for a large
- 1:07:51crewed vessel means years of continuous pointing accuracy across distances
- 1:07:56that grow to significant fractions of a light-year. Even the
- 1:07:59most tightly collimated laser beam diverges over distance. A beam
- 1:08:03that starts as a tight column at the transmitter will
- 1:08:05spread out into a widening cone as it travels, and
- 1:08:08if the spread is too large, the sail simply cannot
- 1:08:11capture enough of the beam to keep accelerating. Practical estimates
- 1:08:14for a beam capable of pushing a large sail across
- 1:08:17interstellar distances require transmitter apertures measured in tens or hundreds
- 1:08:22of kilometers, structures larger than any ever constructed by humans,
- 1:08:27held to pointing accuracy comparable to a rifle sight aimed
- 1:08:30at a target on the far side of a continent,
- 1:08:32sustained for years without interruption. A tremor in the alignment,
- 1:08:37a fault in the beam generation, an unforeseen expansion of
- 1:08:40the sail material under sustained illumination, any one of these
- 1:08:44ends the acceleration prematurely, leaving the ship coasting toward its
- 1:08:48destination at whatever partial velocity it had reached when the
- 1:08:51beam failed. And in the most demanding versions of these proposals,
- 1:08:55the sail itself must survive being illuminated by a beam
- 1:08:59whose energy density approaches that of a small star, without vaporizing,
- 1:09:04without warping, without tearing, for the entire duration of the
- 1:09:08acceleration phase. And then there are the impacts. This is
- 1:09:12the part that turns the relativistic dream into something genuinely violent.
- 1:09:16and it applies especially to any trip that crosses interstellar space,
- 1:09:20let alone the vast reaches between galaxies. The space between
- 1:09:24stars is not empty. It is thin, but it is
- 1:09:27not empty. It contains hydrogen atoms, dust grains, occasional larger fragments,
- 1:09:33all drifting slowly through the galactic environment. At Voyager speeds,
- 1:09:38that material is negligible. At 1% of light speed, it
- 1:09:42starts to matter. At 10%, it becomes a real engineering hazard.
- 1:09:47At 50% or more, and certainly at 99%, every stray
- 1:09:51hydrogen atom the ship encounters is arriving with the kinetic
- 1:09:55energy of a fast-moving bullet from the ship's frame of reference.
- 1:09:59Every dust grain becomes something closer to a small explosion.
- 1:10:03A relativistic starship crossing interstellar or intergalactic space is not
- 1:10:07gliding through a peaceful vacuum. It is being sandblasted at
- 1:10:11every second of every day by particles arriving at nearly
- 1:10:15the speed of light. Shielding against this is a problem
- 1:10:18nobody has solved. Ideas exist. Thick radiation shields on the
- 1:10:23leading face of the ship, magnetic deflectors to push charged
- 1:10:26particles aside, sacrificial ablative layers, but every one of them
- 1:10:31adds mass, and every additional kilogram of mass makes the
- 1:10:35energy problem worse. The situation over intergalactic distances has one
- 1:10:39silver lining and several new problems. The silver lining is
- 1:10:43that intergalactic space, on average, is emptier than interstellar space
- 1:10:47within a galaxy. There are fewer atoms per cubic metre.
- 1:10:51The bad news is that the trip is far, far longer,
- 1:10:54so the total cumulative dose of high-speed impacts integrated over
- 1:10:58the whole journey is still enormous. And there are also
- 1:11:01cosmic rays, which are high-energy particles moving through space independently,
- 1:11:06arriving at the ship from all directions with their own
- 1:11:08considerable energies. Even at rest, the ship would be exposed.
- 1:11:12At relativistic speeds, The ship's motion combines with the cosmic
- 1:11:16ray energies to produce an environment that is genuinely lethal
- 1:11:20to unshielded biology and highly damaging to unshielded electronics. Navigation
- 1:11:25is another problem that grows in ways people rarely mention.
- 1:11:28At voyager speeds over decades, small errors in course can
- 1:11:32be corrected. At relativistic speeds, over hundreds of thousands or
- 1:11:37millions of years, tiny miscalculations in the initial trajectory compound,
- 1:11:42the target itself is moving. The Sagittarius dwarf is being
- 1:11:45pulled apart, its centre drifting on a complicated orbit around
- 1:11:49the Milky Way. The Large Magellanic Cloud is on its
- 1:11:52own long orbit. Andromeda is falling toward us at roughly
- 1:11:55110 km per second. Over the trip time, all of
- 1:11:59these destinations will have moved from where they were when
- 1:12:02you launched. You cannot aim at where they are now.
- 1:12:05You must aim at where they will be. And the
- 1:12:07further the destination and the longer the trip, the more
- 1:12:10sensitive the arrival becomes to any error in that prediction.
- 1:12:14Even if you know exactly where you are going, you
- 1:12:17still have to know exactly where you are at every
- 1:12:19moment of a trip that lasts longer than any recorded civilization.
- 1:12:24Onboard navigation systems will have to remain accurate across durations
- 1:12:27that exceed the mean lifetime of every piece of technology
- 1:12:31humans have ever built. And communications with home for course
- 1:12:34corrections stop being useful very quickly. At Andromeda's distance, a
- 1:12:39radio signal takes two and a half million years to
- 1:12:41reach Earth and another two and a half million to
- 1:12:43come back. There is no help from home. There is
- 1:12:46no mission control. The ship is alone in a way
- 1:12:50no human vehicle has ever been alone. And through all
- 1:12:53of this, we have only been discussing what it takes
- 1:12:56to move an object across the distance. We have not
- 1:12:58yet talked about what has to be alive inside that
- 1:13:01object for the trip to count as humans reaching another galaxy.
- 1:13:05Because a probe crossing to the Sagittarius dwarf, however heroic,
- 1:13:09is not what people usually mean when they ask whether
- 1:13:11humans could ever reach another galaxy. a radio signal received
- 1:13:15in Andromeda millions of years from now is not what
- 1:13:18people mean either. What people usually mean is living humans,
- 1:13:22or something recognisably descended from them, arriving alive at the
- 1:13:26destination with the ability to walk out of the ship
- 1:13:28and stand somewhere new. That question is where all of
- 1:13:32this arithmetic meets biology and civilisation, because even in the
- 1:13:36friendliest relativistic scenario, where a crew moving at 99% of
- 1:13:41light speed experiences the trip as hundreds of thousands of
- 1:13:44years rather than millions, hundreds of thousands of years is
- 1:13:47still longer than every human civilization that has ever existed.
- 1:13:52Nobody has ever built anything meant to function continuously for
- 1:13:55that long. No power source has ever run without interruption
- 1:13:58for that long. No biological population has ever remained coherent, healthy,
- 1:14:04and reproductively viable across that duration in a closed environment.
- 1:14:08And that is the friendly answer. And that is only
- 1:14:11the friendly answer if the physics of getting up to
- 1:14:13those speeds can be paid for, which, as we have seen,
- 1:14:17requires energies that are almost impossible to describe using anything
- 1:14:21from human industrial experience, requires shielding that has never been designed,
- 1:14:26requires deceleration schemes that have never been tested, requires navigation
- 1:14:31that has never been sustained, and requires all of these
- 1:14:34problems to be solved simultaneously, not one at a time,
- 1:14:38because a failure in any one of them ends the mission.
- 1:14:42There is a temptation to declare intergalactic travel impossible. That
- 1:14:46would be dishonest. Nothing we have said proves that it
- 1:14:49is impossible in principle. The equations of physics do not
- 1:14:53forbid a sufficiently advanced civilization from building relativistic starships, at
- 1:14:58least on paper. Fusion propulsion, antimatter propulsion, and beamed propulsion
- 1:15:03are not violations of known physics. They are only violations
- 1:15:06of known engineering. What we have shown is something more
- 1:15:10specific and more uncomfortable than impossible. We have shown that
- 1:15:14every apparent shortcut carries its own catastrophe. That going faster
- 1:15:19does not simply shorten the trip. It multiplies the energy
- 1:15:23budget catastrophically. It intensifies the impact hazards. It compounds the
- 1:15:28navigation problem. It creates a deceleration problem as expensive as
- 1:15:32the acceleration problem. It does not make the journey easier.
- 1:15:36It makes the journey different. and different in ways that
- 1:15:39trade one impossible problem for another. And even in the
- 1:15:42most optimistic scenario, where every one of those engineering catastrophes
- 1:15:46is somehow solved, the crew still has to survive the trip.
- 1:15:51The ship still has to remain functional. The people inside
- 1:15:54still have to remain people, and remain the same people,
- 1:15:58in some meaningful sense, at the other end. Because the
- 1:16:01trip time, however you slice it, is not the trip
- 1:16:04time of a scientific expedition. Even reduced by time dilation
- 1:16:08to the friendliest possible number, it is a duration longer
- 1:16:11than any human enterprise has ever coherently endured. Which means,
- 1:16:16the real question is not whether we can build the engine.
- 1:16:19The actual question is what has to ride inside the engine,
- 1:16:22and whether that thing can still be called a human
- 1:16:24mission by the time it arrives. That is the question
- 1:16:27waiting for us next. Because the moment you stop asking
- 1:16:30how fast the ship goes, and start asking what has
- 1:16:33to remain alive and functional and purposeful inside it across
- 1:16:37the durations we have just calculated, the whole nature of
- 1:16:40the problem changes. The engine was never going to be enough.
- 1:16:43What has to survive is not just a machine. It
- 1:16:47is an entire way of being human. We left ourselves
- 1:16:50a moment ago with a strange question. Not, can we
- 1:16:53build the engine? But, what has to ride inside it?
- 1:16:58Everything we have said so far is really about physics.
- 1:17:01And physics, at least in principle, is negotiable. A sufficiently
- 1:17:05advanced civilization might one day learn to accelerate a small,
- 1:17:09crude vehicle to a substantial fraction of light speed. It
- 1:17:13might learn to shield that vehicle from what it encounters.
- 1:17:16It might learn to slow it down at the far end.
- 1:17:19All of that is enormously difficult, requires energies and materials
- 1:17:23nobody has ever produced, and stretches every known engineering discipline
- 1:17:27past the breaking point. but none of it violates a
- 1:17:30known law of nature. In that narrow sense, it is imaginable.
- 1:17:35The problem is that the imaginable engine is not the
- 1:17:37whole mission. The engine is only the thing that moves
- 1:17:40the ship. What has to survive the trip is not
- 1:17:43the ship. What has to survive is whatever is inside it.
- 1:17:47And when we lay out honestly what whatever is inside
- 1:17:50it would need to be, across the durations we calculated earlier,
- 1:17:55we start to see that the real difficulty of reaching
- 1:17:57another galaxy is not out there in the vacuum. The
- 1:18:01real difficulty is in what has to remain functional, coherent,
- 1:18:04and recognisably human for a length of time that no
- 1:18:07human institution has ever endured. This is where we look
- 1:18:10at that, and where the meaning of the trip finally
- 1:18:13comes apart. Let us begin with the simplest thing, air.
- 1:18:17A crewed spacecraft crossing to the Sagittarius dwarf at, say,
- 1:18:2110% of light speed, needs to keep a breathable atmosphere
- 1:18:25circulating inside its hull for roughly 700,000 years Do not
- 1:18:29skip past that number. 700,000 years. That is a duration
- 1:18:34longer than the interval separating us from the earliest members
- 1:18:37of our own genus. Older than the split between Neanderthals
- 1:18:41and modern humans by a comfortable margin, during which the
- 1:18:44ship must maintain the correct partial pressures of oxygen and nitrogen,
- 1:18:48remove the carbon dioxide the crew produces, filter out trace contaminants,
- 1:18:53prevent leaks that would kill everyone aboard, and do this
- 1:18:56without a single sustained failure across a duration that outlasts
- 1:18:59entire geological epochs. And that is on the friendly definition
- 1:19:03of the DRIP, aimed at the friendliest destination, with a
- 1:19:07propulsion technology nobody has ever built. Water and food and
- 1:19:11waste are the same problem in different forms. A ship
- 1:19:14on a trip of that length cannot be resupplied. It
- 1:19:17cannot carry water for the trip. It cannot carry food
- 1:19:20for the trip. It cannot even carry the raw feedstock
- 1:19:23for the food for the trip because the mass required
- 1:19:26over hundreds of thousands or millions of years is preposterous.
- 1:19:29The ship must instead operate as a closed recycling ecosystem.
- 1:19:34Water must be recovered from every biological process and purified
- 1:19:38and reused indefinitely. Nutrients must be cycled from waste back
- 1:19:42into food production through some combination of biological and chemical processes.
- 1:19:47Every element of the crew's diet must be regrown, refarmed, refished,
- 1:19:52or refabricated on board. And every one of those cycles
- 1:19:55must run continuously without a permanent breakdown for the entire
- 1:19:59duration of the journey. We have never built a closed
- 1:20:01ecosystem that works. The most famous serious attempt The Biosphere
- 1:20:062 experiment in the early 1990s aimed to sustain a
- 1:20:10small crew inside a sealed environment for two years and
- 1:20:14encountered severe problems within months. Oxygen levels dropped in ways
- 1:20:18nobody had predicted. Certain species collapsed. Others exploded in numbers.
- 1:20:24The chemistry of the enclosed atmosphere drifted. The system did
- 1:20:28not fail spectacularly, but it did not succeed either. It
- 1:20:31required continuous outside intervention to remain viable. That was two years,
- 1:20:37on Earth, with a full support team standing by, in
- 1:20:40an environment we had built specifically to study exactly this problem.
- 1:20:45The trip we are describing needs closed ecosystems that work
- 1:20:48not for two years, but for hundreds of thousands of years.
- 1:20:52Without outside intervention, without a support team, without a planet's
- 1:20:56worth of buffer chemistry to lean on. That is not
- 1:20:59a scaled-up version of Biosphere 2. That is a different
- 1:21:02category of problem. Now add the humans. A crewed intergalactic
- 1:21:07mission cannot be crewed by the same humans from launch
- 1:21:09to arrival. Even the friendliest relativistic scenario, where time dilation
- 1:21:14reduces the crew's experience time to tens of thousands of years,
- 1:21:18still requires many generations of crew inside the ship. Hundreds
- 1:21:23of generations. Perhaps thousands, depending on the target and the velocity.
- 1:21:28That means the mission is not a mission in the
- 1:21:30conventional sense. It is a multi-generational voyage. The people who
- 1:21:35launch it will not be the people who arrive. The
- 1:21:37people who arrive will not have known the people who launched.
- 1:21:41Every generation aboard the ship will live and die entirely
- 1:21:43within the ship, having never seen the destination and having
- 1:21:47only known the origin through records. Which raises the question
- 1:21:50of genetic viability. A closed human population aboard a spacecraft
- 1:21:55is subject to all the constraints that geneticists have identified
- 1:21:58for any small isolated population. Inbreeding depression becomes a real
- 1:22:03risk if the founding population is too small. Loss of
- 1:22:06genetic diversity through drift becomes real over long timescales. Estimates
- 1:22:11for the minimum viable founding population for a long-term human
- 1:22:15generation ship vary considerably in the literature, from a few
- 1:22:19dozen with heavy management to a few hundred with careful
- 1:22:22reproductive planning to several thousand for a more forgiving margin.
- 1:22:26All of those estimates assume that the population is actively
- 1:22:29managed that reproduction is monitored and organised across generations, that
- 1:22:34certain kinds of pairings are encouraged and others avoided. In
- 1:22:38other words, the crew is not free in the way
- 1:22:40people on Earth are free. Their reproductive lives are subject
- 1:22:44to the constraints of the ship's survival. And even a
- 1:22:47well-managed population will drift. Over hundreds of generations, the humans
- 1:22:52on the ship will diverge, biologically and culturally, from the
- 1:22:55humans on Earth. Not because of anything dramatic, simply because
- 1:23:00that is what closed populations do over long timescales. The
- 1:23:03people arriving at the destination will be genetically and culturally
- 1:23:07distinct from the people who launch them, in ways that
- 1:23:09will only grow larger the longer the trip lasts. Now
- 1:23:13consider the machinery. Every ship system, every reactor, every recycler,
- 1:23:18every pump, every seal, every processor must either continue to
- 1:23:22function for the duration of the trip, or must be
- 1:23:25repaired and replaced by the crew themselves, Nothing lasts hundreds
- 1:23:29of thousands of years without maintenance. Nothing we build lasts
- 1:23:33even hundreds of years without maintenance. Which means the ship
- 1:23:37must carry, or must be able to manufacture, replacement parts
- 1:23:41for every one of its components. And it must carry,
- 1:23:44or be able to manufacture, the tools needed to manufacture
- 1:23:47those parts. And it must carry the knowledge, distributed across
- 1:23:52every generation of crew, of how to make the tools
- 1:23:55that make the parts. That last point is quietly one
- 1:23:58of the hardest, because human knowledge is not stored in books,
- 1:24:02it is stored in people. The skill of a machinist
- 1:24:05is not the words in a manual, it is the
- 1:24:07practised understanding of what a piece of metal does under
- 1:24:10a lathe, learned by doing, transferred by working alongside somebody
- 1:24:14who already knows. The skill of a farmer, an electrician,
- 1:24:18a doctor, a chemist, a nurse, an engineer, is not
- 1:24:22a text file, it is a lived apprenticeship, And every
- 1:24:26one of those skills has to be transmitted, faithfully and continuously,
- 1:24:31across every generation aboard the ship, for the entire duration
- 1:24:34of the trip. If a skill is lost, even temporarily,
- 1:24:38the systems it supports will fail, and if enough systems
- 1:24:41fail at once, the ship dies. That is a civilizational problem,
- 1:24:46not an engineering one. It is not solved by building
- 1:24:49the ship better. It is solved, if at all, by
- 1:24:51ensuring the humans aboard keep teaching each other everything they
- 1:24:55need to know across hundreds of generations, without a single
- 1:24:59generation dropping the thread. No human civilization has ever done this.
- 1:25:04Every civilization that has ever existed on Earth has lost knowledge,
- 1:25:08sometimes catastrophically. Techniques for building certain kinds of arches, mixing
- 1:25:13certain kinds of cements, casting certain kinds of bronze, have
- 1:25:18all been lost and later rediscovered, sometimes only partially. And
- 1:25:22those civilizations existed in the far more forgiving context of
- 1:25:26an entire planet, with agriculture, with children learning skills their
- 1:25:30parents never used, with the freedom to fail in one
- 1:25:33region and recover from another. The ship has no other region.
- 1:25:38If knowledge is lost aboard the ship, there is nowhere
- 1:25:40else it can be relearned from. And there is the
- 1:25:43reason to keep going. A generation ship is not just
- 1:25:46a technical challenge. It is a cultural one. Every generation aboard,
- 1:25:51from the second onward, is being asked to spend its
- 1:25:53entire life inside a machine, maintaining the machine, so that
- 1:25:58a distant generation none of them will meet can arrive
- 1:26:01at a destination none of them will see. That is
- 1:26:04a particular kind of ask, and it has to be renewed,
- 1:26:08generation after generation, without loss of commitment. The people aboard
- 1:26:12the ship must continue to believe that the mission is
- 1:26:15worth their labour, worth their reproductive choices, worth the constraints
- 1:26:19on their lives, worth teaching their children the same way
- 1:26:23forever until arrival. Human beings have held purposes for a lifetime,
- 1:26:28occasionally across a few generations, and never for the durations
- 1:26:31we are describing here. Empires have fallen inside centuries. Religions
- 1:26:36have transformed inside millennia. Languages themselves become unrecognizable across a
- 1:26:42few thousand years. On the timescales we are discussing, the
- 1:26:45very language that the crew speaks will drift into something new.
- 1:26:49the stories they tell about why they are aboard the
- 1:26:51ship will drift. The stories will change, will be revised,
- 1:26:55will possibly be forgotten and rewritten. Whether the ship's purpose
- 1:26:59survives this drift is not a technical question. It is
- 1:27:02a question about whether any human population can hold a
- 1:27:05single long-term goal across durations longer than any civilization has
- 1:27:09ever held anything. Now let us fold in the time dilation,
- 1:27:13because in the more optimistic, relativistic scenarios, the crew's experience
- 1:27:17time can be much shorter than the trip time in
- 1:27:20Earth's frame. At 99% of light speed, as we noted earlier,
- 1:27:25a 2.5 million year trip to Andromeda is felt as
- 1:27:27about 350,000 years by the crew, pushed to 99.99%, and
- 1:27:33the crew's experience time drops to something in the tens
- 1:27:36of thousands of years. In principle, at velocities arbitrarily close
- 1:27:40to light speed, the crew's experience time can be reduced
- 1:27:44further still. That does not eliminate the problems above. It
- 1:27:47only compresses them. Tens of thousands of years is still
- 1:27:51longer than every recorded civilization. Even the most heavily time-dilated
- 1:27:55version of this trip still asks a closed human population
- 1:27:58to remain coherent, healthy, culturally continuous, and purposeful across a
- 1:28:03duration nobody has ever managed. And this is where the
- 1:28:06second half of relativistic time dilation becomes important, and it
- 1:28:09is the half that popular treatments almost always leave out.
- 1:28:13The clock aboard the ship slows. The clock outside the
- 1:28:16ship does not. Which means the crew's experience time is
- 1:28:19not the trip time. The universe's experience time is, if
- 1:28:23the crew feels one lifetime pass, and Andromeda's arrival takes
- 1:28:27two and a half million years in the frame of
- 1:28:29anyone left on Earth, then two and a half million
- 1:28:32years have actually passed on Earth. Not for the crew.
- 1:28:36For everyone else, the civilization that launched the ship, if
- 1:28:39it's still alive, exists, is two and a half million
- 1:28:42years older than the version that said goodbye, which is
- 1:28:45a way of saying that it is almost certainly not
- 1:28:47the same civilization at all. Two and a half million
- 1:28:50years is comparable to the entire span of the genus
- 1:28:53Homo from its earliest known members, longer than the span
- 1:28:57of any single human species. Longer, in fact, than most
- 1:29:01mammalian species survive at all. So even in the most
- 1:29:04generous relativistic case, the ship arrives at Andromeda, and the crew,
- 1:29:09having lived their compressed lives, steps out onto a world
- 1:29:13in a galaxy the size of ours, having severed every
- 1:29:16practical connection with the civilization that built them. Earth, if
- 1:29:20it still has an Earth, is two and a half
- 1:29:22million years further along its own history than when the
- 1:29:25ship left. Any message from the crew announcing safe arrival
- 1:29:29will take another two and a half million years to
- 1:29:31travel back and be received, if there is anyone left
- 1:29:34to receive it. Any reply will take two and a
- 1:29:37half million years more to reach the ship. Communication with
- 1:29:40home is not merely delayed. It is functionally impossible. The
- 1:29:44crew is not on an expedition. There is no ground
- 1:29:47control they are reporting to. There is nowhere they can
- 1:29:50return to. As browned. The stub, there is nothing they
- 1:29:55can meaningfully send home. Which brings us to the heart
- 1:29:58of what this whole episode has been circling. If the
- 1:30:02crew has severed every practical connection with the civilization that
- 1:30:05launched them, in what sense is the mission still from Earth?
- 1:30:09In what sense are the people aboard still emissaries of
- 1:30:11the species that sent them? They carry Earth's biology, in
- 1:30:15some altered and drifted form. They carry Earth's records, in
- 1:30:20whatever form has survived hundreds of thousands of years of
- 1:30:22storage and transmissions. They carry, perhaps, some memory that they
- 1:30:26came from somewhere else. But they do not share Earth's present.
- 1:30:30They do not share Earth's society. They do not share
- 1:30:33Earth's lived history. They are, functionally, a new human civilization,
- 1:30:39launched permanently away from the parent, arriving at a destination
- 1:30:43it has become its own reason for existing. This is
- 1:30:46the transformation the trip performs, and it is the reason
- 1:30:49the phrase, Reaching Another Galaxy, quietly changes its meaning as
- 1:30:53we look closely at it. Reaching another star is a
- 1:30:56long trip, but it is imaginable as an expedition. A
- 1:31:00crew leaves, a crew arrives, and even if the trip
- 1:31:03lasts centuries, there is some meaningful connection between departure and arrival.
- 1:31:08Reaching another galaxy is different. Reaching another galaxy, at any
- 1:31:12velocity physics currently permits us to imagine, is a trip
- 1:31:16that outlasts the practical continuity of any human civilisation. The
- 1:31:20people who arrive have not gone anywhere on behalf of Earth.
- 1:31:23They have become something else and taken it somewhere else.
- 1:31:27The mission has not so much reached another galaxy as
- 1:31:30it has grown a second civilization and set it down
- 1:31:33light years away. And this reframing matters because of what
- 1:31:36it means about the original question we set out with.
- 1:31:39The question was whether the closest galaxy might be too
- 1:31:42far for humans. We have been building the answer piece
- 1:31:46by piece. First we saw that the closest galaxy is
- 1:31:49not one number, but a definitional choice, and that even
- 1:31:53the friendliest choice, a half-dissolving dwarf orbiting inside our halo,
- 1:31:57is far. Then we saw that far, at galactic scales,
- 1:32:01is not what far means in ordinary experience. It is
- 1:32:04thousands or millions of times further than the nearest star,
- 1:32:08which is already unreachable at current speeds. Then we saw
- 1:32:12that going faster does not solve the trip, because every
- 1:32:15increment in velocity costs enormously more energy, introduces new impact hazards,
- 1:32:20and creates a symmetrical problem of deceleration that most enthusiasts
- 1:32:24quietly forget. And now, finally, we see that even if
- 1:32:28all of those physical problems are somehow overcome, the trip
- 1:32:32still requires the ship to become a world, and the
- 1:32:35crew to become their own civilization, and the connection to
- 1:32:38the origin to be functionally lost. Which means the phrase,
- 1:32:42too far for humans, has to be understood carefully. Nothing
- 1:32:47in what we have said proves that no object could
- 1:32:50ever cross to another galaxy. Nothing here shows that a probe,
- 1:32:54or a signal, or a self-repairing autonomous system could not
- 1:32:58in principle be sent across the gap. There is no
- 1:33:00wall of physics that forbids matter and information from making
- 1:33:04the crossing, given enough time and enough energy. That is
- 1:33:07not the constraint. The constraint is that humans, in the
- 1:33:10ordinary meaning of the word, cannot make the crossing without
- 1:33:13ceasing to be humans in the ordinary meaning of the word.
- 1:33:17The trip transforms the crew, it transforms the mission, it
- 1:33:21transforms the connection to Earth, and it does all of
- 1:33:24this before the ship even arrives, because the time scales
- 1:33:28themselves force the transformation. There is a quiet way to
- 1:33:31say this, and a loud way to say this. The
- 1:33:33quiet way is that reaching another galaxy is not a
- 1:33:36technological problem, but a civilizational one. The Loud Way is
- 1:33:39that reaching another galaxy would require humanity to launch, not
- 1:33:43a spacecraft, but a smaller version of itself, permanently, into
- 1:33:48a journey longer than its own history, in the hope
- 1:33:51that whatever eventually stepped out of the ship at the
- 1:33:53far end would still recognise itself as the descendant of
- 1:33:57the people who built it. Whether the Loud Way and
- 1:33:59the Quiet Way are describing the same thing, or slightly
- 1:34:03different things, is a question we can each sit with
- 1:34:05for a while. What they share is the recognition that
- 1:34:08the difficulty is not really located in the engine, or
- 1:34:11the shielding, or the recyclers, or the reactor. The difficulty
- 1:34:15is located in what has to remain a continuous human
- 1:34:18enterprise across a length of time no continuous human enterprise
- 1:34:21has ever endured. And there is something else worth noticing
- 1:34:25about this framing, because it changes the emotional shape of
- 1:34:28the answer. When people say that another galaxy is unreachable,
- 1:34:32they usually mean it in the language of impossibility. They
- 1:34:35mean that the numbers are too big, the energy is
- 1:34:38too vast, the distance is too extreme. That framing is
- 1:34:42not wrong, but it does treat the problem as if
- 1:34:44the universe were closing a door in our faces. There
- 1:34:47is a different framing available, which is that the universe
- 1:34:50is not closing any door. It is only telling us
- 1:34:53that the door is on the other side of an
- 1:34:55enormous room, and to walk across the room we would
- 1:34:58have to become the kind of thing that can walk
- 1:35:00across it, a species that has learned to build ships
- 1:35:03that are worlds. A civilization that has learned to distribute
- 1:35:07its purpose across durations longer than its own history. A
- 1:35:10biology that has learned to remain viable across generations counted
- 1:35:14in the hundreds or thousands. In an environment that provides
- 1:35:18nothing except what has been built into it. Whether that
- 1:35:21is impossible depends on what impossible means. It is certainly
- 1:35:25beyond us now. It may be beyond us always. It
- 1:35:29is not necessarily beyond every possible descendant of us. But
- 1:35:33even if some far future descendants of humanity manage such
- 1:35:36a thing, the mission they launch will not really be
- 1:35:39a mission home to their parent civilization. It will be
- 1:35:42a colony, in the deepest sense of the word, a separation,
- 1:35:46a permanent one. An act of setting one part of
- 1:35:49humanity down in a place none of the rest will
- 1:35:51ever see or hear from again. And this, finally, is
- 1:35:55the meaning of the distance. The gap between our galaxy
- 1:35:58and any other is not a distance that a mission crosses,
- 1:36:02It is a distance that a mission becomes. The people
- 1:36:05who go do not carry Earth to another galaxy. They
- 1:36:08become something else on the way and land there as themselves.
- 1:36:12There is a strange dignity in that idea. And there
- 1:36:15is also a strange grief. Dignity. Because it means the
- 1:36:19universe is not simply refusing us. It is asking a
- 1:36:22real question about what we would be willing to become
- 1:36:26in order to answer it. Grief. because it means that
- 1:36:29any success would also be a kind of loss. The
- 1:36:32humans who arrive at Andromeda, or the large Magellanic cloud,
- 1:36:36or the drifting remains of the Sagittarius dwarf, would carry
- 1:36:40Earth's ancestry in a way that a distant descendant carries
- 1:36:43the ancestry of a great-great-great-grandparent. They would know they came
- 1:36:47from somewhere, they would not know that somewhere in any
- 1:36:49lived sense. Earth would be a name in their records,
- 1:36:53a story in their traditions, a set of chemical signatures
- 1:36:56in their bodies, not a home. not a place they
- 1:36:59could go back to, not even a place they could
- 1:37:02imagine going back to, because the very idea of going
- 1:37:06back would have stopped being a coherent idea a hundred
- 1:37:08generations before they arrived. And so the nearest galaxy is
- 1:37:12too far for humans in a specific and precise sense,
- 1:37:16not too far for objects, not too far for information,
- 1:37:20not too far for very careful autonomous systems that might,
- 1:37:24one day, be able to cross the gap and record
- 1:37:26something on the other side. Too far for humans in
- 1:37:29the sense that a human going would not be the
- 1:37:32same human arriving. And a civilization launching such a mission
- 1:37:38would not be the same civilization receiving news of its success.
- 1:37:41The trip is too long for a person to survive
- 1:37:43as themselves. It is too long for a civilization to
- 1:37:46remain itself across. It is too long for the meaning
- 1:37:49of arriving to survive intact. Which is why, in the end,
- 1:37:54the closest galaxy is not close. Not because of a
- 1:37:57number of light years, though the numbers are formidable. Not
- 1:38:00because of an unpayable energy bill, though the energies are staggering.
- 1:38:04But because of what would have to change on the way. Distance,
- 1:38:08at galactic scales, is not really distance. It is a
- 1:38:12length of time that transforms whatever is trying to cross it.
- 1:38:15And humans, however far our engineering may one day reach,
- 1:38:19are made of the kind of continuity that does not
- 1:38:21survive being stretched that far. So when someone asks whether
- 1:38:25we will ever reach another galaxy, the honest answer is
- 1:38:28not yes and not no. The honest answer is that
- 1:38:31reaching another galaxy would require humanity to become something else
- 1:38:35before it arrived. Something that could hold a purpose across
- 1:38:39durations longer than any of our institutions. Something that could
- 1:38:42remain coherent across generations counted in the thousands. Something that
- 1:38:47could keep repairing itself, feeding itself, and teaching itself for
- 1:38:51spans of time longer than the age of our species.
- 1:38:54Whatever eventually did such a thing might carry our name.
- 1:38:57It might carry our chemistry. It might carry the distant
- 1:39:00memory of the world we launched it from. But it
- 1:39:02would be its own thing. It would have earned another
- 1:39:05galaxy by ceasing to be quite what we are now.
- 1:39:08Perhaps that is what the closest galaxy is really asking
- 1:39:11of us. Not a faster engine. Not a bigger reactor.
- 1:39:15Not a better shield. But a version of ourselves, patient enough,
- 1:39:19and continuous enough, and transformed enough, to become the kind
- 1:39:24of traveller such a distance requires. Whether we will ever
- 1:39:27be that, or whether any species ever is, is a
- 1:39:30question the universe leaves entirely open. What it does not
- 1:39:34leave open is the price of the ticket. The nearest
- 1:39:37galaxy is close only on paper. In the currency that
- 1:39:41matters in bodies, in generations, in civilisations, it is a
- 1:39:45distance so long that whatever pays it will not at
- 1:39:48the end. be the thing that started walking. And that, perhaps,
- 1:39:53is the deepest way to answer the question we began with.
- 1:39:56The closest galaxy may be too far for humans, not
- 1:39:59because it lies beyond a wall, but because reaching it
- 1:40:01would require humanity itself to cross a threshold on the way.
- 1:40:05The nearest galaxy is not on the far side of
- 1:40:07a distance. It is on the far side of who
- 1:40:10we would have to become to arrive.