Latest / Yaron Brook Show / The History of the Western Enlightenment – And Why It Matters Today
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Good evening on this beautiful spring day.
- 0:06Speaker 2: We had a sod turning ceremony on our campus today.
- 0:11Speaker 2: One of the highlights for me was our objective was
- 0:14Speaker 2: to put our shovels into the ground and throw the
- 0:17Speaker 2: dirt into the air. I've spent the last half hour
- 0:20Speaker 2: getting that dirt out of my eyes and among other people.
- 0:24Speaker 3: But it was a good day.
- 0:25Speaker 2: It was a good day because we're investing more in
- 0:27Speaker 2: this community. Last year, we had an independent study here
- 0:31Speaker 2: at Northwood to understand what the economic impact is just
- 0:34Speaker 2: for the Great Lakes region. This little university in Northwood,
- 0:38Speaker 2: at Northwood University contributes about two hundred and eleven million
- 0:42Speaker 2: dollars to our community. And that was a way when
- 0:46Speaker 2: we kicked off our sod turning. Today a new field
- 0:50Speaker 2: and you're going to be reading more about a twenty
- 0:52Speaker 2: five million dollar investment in our automotive space. This is
- 0:56Speaker 2: a university that does not have debt, asn't.
- 1:01Speaker 1: A plan to do that. So with that, my name
- 1:07Speaker 1: is Ken McDonald.
- 1:09Speaker 2: Real privileged to serve as president at Northwoods. Northwood University
- 1:14Speaker 2: and something we call America's free enterprise university.
- 1:17Speaker 1: And when you look.
- 1:18Speaker 2: At a number of the things going on on campuses
- 1:22Speaker 2: across the country today. It's starting to cause some level
- 1:25Speaker 2: of doubt in terms of the relevancy and currency of
- 1:29Speaker 2: campuses today. I'm pleased to say that we happen to
- 1:33Speaker 2: be bucking that trend, but it should be a concern
- 1:36Speaker 2: for people when we have sixteen to twenty four year
- 1:39Speaker 2: olds in this country, two million of them are unemployed,
- 1:43Speaker 2: that we have a growing deficit in terms of and
- 1:46Speaker 2: the debt that these students are taking on. They're taking
- 1:49Speaker 2: programs that they're not able to find employment.
- 1:53Speaker 1: There is a question of what is the value of
- 1:56Speaker 1: a university education today.
- 1:57Speaker 2: Particularly we're seeing a rapid drop in enrollment from all groups,
- 2:02Speaker 2: but in particular young men. And so here we are
- 2:05Speaker 2: in Midland, Michigan at Northwood University, and we seem to
- 2:08Speaker 2: be bucking that trend where we're up in students in
- 2:12Speaker 2: undergraduate education, up in students in graduate education, up.
- 2:16Speaker 1: In students in online learning. So what might be behind that?
- 2:20Speaker 2: What are some proof points that we're trying to do
- 2:23Speaker 2: things differently here at Northwood University.
- 2:25Speaker 1: It's all tied into something we refer to as the
- 2:29Speaker 1: Northwood Idea, which I'll end off with. But some proof.
- 2:32Speaker 2: Points that this year, once again, Georgetown University in their
- 2:37Speaker 2: analysis of all forty five hundred colleges and universities across
- 2:41Speaker 2: the country. It's not an obscure ranking where can you
- 2:44Speaker 2: ride a bicycle or what type of citations that professor
- 2:49Speaker 2: might have. It actually looks at data over twenty thirty
- 2:54Speaker 2: and forty years after a student has graduated across the country,
- 2:58Speaker 2: nearly five thousand institutions. We're proud to show that at
- 3:02Speaker 2: Northwood for the last several years were in the top
- 3:05Speaker 2: eleven percent of all colleges and universities in the country.
- 3:09Speaker 2: That when you show up here, you pay your tuition,
- 3:12Speaker 2: you work hard, you earn your success, you're going to
- 3:15Speaker 2: be well on your way for prosperity in the future.
- 3:19Speaker 1: A second proof point I do.
- 3:23Speaker 2: And by the way, you're not going to have Northwood
- 3:25Speaker 2: students knocking at your door or the legislative houses asking
- 3:30Speaker 2: for taxpayers to pay their debt because they happen to
- 3:33Speaker 2: take on programs that they couldn't get jobs, and most
- 3:36Speaker 2: of that debt is in graduate school. This is a
- 3:40Speaker 2: school that produces young people who understand, earn success and
- 3:44Speaker 2: are ready to go out and make a difference. Another
- 3:47Speaker 2: proof point. This year Forbes magazine ranked Northwood University among
- 3:52Speaker 2: again all forty five hundred universities, in the top ten percent.
- 3:55Speaker 2: So from an academic point of view, our dean and
- 3:58Speaker 2: vice president of there, led by our faculty, are providing
- 4:02Speaker 2: our students the things that they need to advance our communities.
- 4:06Speaker 2: The last point I'll say is that this is an
- 4:10Speaker 2: entrepreneurship factory. Every college and university teaches entrepreneurship. You don't
- 4:15Speaker 2: become an entrepreneur by reading a book. You don't learn
- 4:18Speaker 2: to ride a bike by reading a book. You have
- 4:20Speaker 2: to get on it and fall down a few times.
- 4:23Speaker 2: This is a business factory that we surround ourselves in
- 4:28Speaker 2: the value of capitalism. And I'm probably the only university
- 4:32Speaker 2: in the country that has a picture of students in
- 4:33Speaker 2: my office that says that Thanksgiving, what are you proud of?
- 4:36Speaker 2: And they're holding up a sign that says capitalism. And
- 4:39Speaker 2: it's all rooted in the Northwood idea. If you haven't
- 4:43Speaker 2: spent time with us, this age a set of principles
- 4:47Speaker 2: of that were unequivocally clear on free enterprise, limited government.
- 4:53Speaker 1: Rule of law, private property.
- 4:55Speaker 2: And as a parent who just had their third grandchild
- 5:00Speaker 2: four hours ago. Personal responsibility, and so one of the
- 5:11Speaker 2: great highlights is to look down Main Street and have
- 5:14Speaker 2: an organization like the Macinaw Center side by side. And
- 5:18Speaker 2: the more we get to do work with Joe and
- 5:21Speaker 2: his team, I think, the better for our students, our faculty,
- 5:25Speaker 2: and hopefully we're contributing in that way as well to
- 5:29Speaker 2: the broader good communities. Macinaw Center is led by an
- 5:33Speaker 2: incredible leader and I'm just going to do Joe's introduction
- 5:37Speaker 2: if I could. Joe, so obviously, Joe is the president
- 5:40Speaker 2: of the Macinaw Center for Public Policy, and you know
- 5:43Speaker 2: that it's an independent, nonprofit research and educational institute not
- 5:48Speaker 2: only in Michigan but proudly right here on Main Street, Midland.
- 5:52Speaker 2: The Macinaw Center is one of the largest think tanks
- 5:55Speaker 2: that focus primarily on state level policies that affect people's
- 5:59Speaker 2: freedom and quality of life.
- 6:02Speaker 1: Joe joined the.
- 6:03Speaker 2: Mackinaw Center thirty years ago, nineteen ninety five, and he
- 6:08Speaker 2: later became vice president for communications at the Cato Institute
- 6:13Speaker 2: before luckily he returned here to the Macinaw Center and
- 6:18Speaker 2: became its executive vice president and he's been serving admirably
- 6:22Speaker 2: as president since two thousand and eight. Joe is a
- 6:26Speaker 2: leader among all of the state based public policy experts,
- 6:30Speaker 2: and the State Policy Network recognized him with its Roy
- 6:34Speaker 2: Award for Leadership, Innovation, and Accomplishments in public policy. Our
- 6:41Speaker 2: job as leader is to train the next generation, and
- 6:44Speaker 2: Joe has trained and led more than six hundred think
- 6:48Speaker 2: tank executives from nearly every state and more than fifty
- 6:53Speaker 2: countries around the world in strategic planning, communications, and fundraise.
- 7:00Speaker 2: Joe is a leading global instructor on the Overton window
- 7:04Speaker 2: model of policy change, developed by the late mcinaw Center
- 7:08Speaker 2: Vice president Joseph Overton. It's great to do an introduction
- 7:13Speaker 2: of Joe, and it's even better to call him a
- 7:15Speaker 2: friend and a colleague.
- 7:16Speaker 1: So Joe, welcome back to Northwood.
- 7:18Speaker 4: University, Kent.
- 7:29Speaker 5: I'm grateful to be welcomed so warmly, and I feel
- 7:35Speaker 5: that I know that you know that I know that
- 7:39Speaker 5: you are. You hail from Canada, but not everyone here
- 7:42Speaker 5: may know that. So we're doing our part here tonight
- 7:46Speaker 5: to strengthen US Canadian relations, which have been strained recently.
- 7:54Speaker 5: But that won't continue if we have anything to do
- 7:57Speaker 5: about it. The Macinaw Center loves to work with Northwood University.
- 8:03Speaker 5: We love to hire Northwood University students. We love to
- 8:08Speaker 5: hire Northwood University interns, and we even love it when
- 8:13Speaker 5: interns sometimes say I'll work for you for free, and
- 8:18Speaker 5: then when their internship is up, they just don't leave,
- 8:22Speaker 5: And then we decide, well, I guess we'd better start
- 8:24Speaker 5: paying them. That has actually happened. And talk to James Homan,
- 8:30Speaker 5: Director of Fiscal Policy, if you don't believe me. Tonight,
- 8:36Speaker 5: we are here to think about a few questions. Why
- 8:41Speaker 5: do we approach college education the way we do, as
- 8:45Speaker 5: a dedicated time of learning about many subjects and not
- 8:51Speaker 5: just one subject taught to you by an employer. Why
- 8:57Speaker 5: do we try to decide most things with reason and
- 9:01Speaker 5: evidence and debate and not with clubs and knives. Why
- 9:07Speaker 5: are accused criminals, even the ones who really really look guilty,
- 9:14Speaker 5: Why do they get a lawyer in a trial by
- 9:16Speaker 5: jury if they want one? And why does the majority
- 9:21Speaker 5: rule in a democracy while the minority still enjoys certain
- 9:26Speaker 5: rights in that same democracy writes that the majority cannot overrule.
- 9:34Speaker 3: Well.
- 9:34Speaker 5: Here to help us answer those questions is doctor your
- 9:37Speaker 5: own Brooke. He is chairman of the Einrand Institute, and
- 9:42Speaker 5: he is the co author of a national bestseller, Free
- 9:45Speaker 5: Market Revolution. How Heinrand. How Einrand's ideas can end big government.
- 9:52Speaker 5: And I think you can pick up your copyright outside
- 9:55Speaker 5: the front door. I saw one when we came in.
- 10:00Speaker 5: Your Own was born and raised in Israel. He has
- 10:04Speaker 5: degrees from Technion Israel, Institute of Technology in the University
- 10:09Speaker 5: of Texas. Doctor Brooke has been an American citizen for
- 10:13Speaker 5: twenty two years. And your Own and I wave at
- 10:17Speaker 5: each other once a year in Denver, Colorado, where we
- 10:20Speaker 5: are both instructors. It's something called the Leadership Program of
- 10:24Speaker 5: the Rockies. I come in and give my speech. He
- 10:27Speaker 5: follows me to correct any mistakes I make, and your
- 10:31Speaker 5: Own I promise this year I will stay for your
- 10:34Speaker 5: whole speech.
- 10:44Speaker 3: Thank you. It's a real pleasure to be back in Northwood.
- 10:47Speaker 6: This is my third time, second time in nackinawth, third
- 10:49Speaker 6: time in Northwood, so Midland, now four times. It's in
- 10:53Speaker 6: the middle of Norway. I don't know if you realize that,
- 10:55Speaker 6: but I make it.
- 11:00Speaker 4: So.
- 11:00Speaker 3: Over the last twenty to thirty.
- 11:04Speaker 6: Years, Western civilization, the idea of the West.
- 11:09Speaker 3: As a civilization has come under attack.
- 11:12Speaker 6: I mean even now, when I say Western civilization, some
- 11:15Speaker 6: of you, maybe not this group, but many groups out
- 11:17Speaker 6: there kind of start wiggling in their seats. It's a
- 11:19Speaker 6: little uncomfortable. West civilization. That sounds kind of off. But
- 11:25Speaker 6: the ideas that we're just mentioned, the ideas of science
- 11:28Speaker 6: and reason and and you know, representative government, all ideas
- 11:34Speaker 6: that represent Western civilization, or at least we believe they do.
- 11:38Speaker 6: And these ideas, the ideas of a civilization have come
- 11:42Speaker 6: under dramatic attack, both from within the West, the geographic West,
- 11:49Speaker 6: and from without. And I think the only way we
- 11:56Speaker 6: can defend the West is if we end a stand
- 12:00Speaker 6: what it is. One of the challenges I think we
- 12:05Speaker 6: have is there's a lot of confusion about what is
- 12:08Speaker 6: this thing called Western civilization? Where does it originate, where
- 12:12Speaker 6: does it come from, how is it born? Where do
- 12:15Speaker 6: these ideas come from? If you think about what's going
- 12:18Speaker 6: on in university campuses today, there is a real hostility
- 12:23Speaker 6: to our form of life of government. Hamas the idea
- 12:30Speaker 6: of a theocracy ruled by you know.
- 12:36Speaker 3: Mullah's.
- 12:38Speaker 6: Dictating life for everybody is now somehow superior to Israel,
- 12:45Speaker 6: a country where it's part of Western civilization. All of
- 12:49Speaker 6: those features of the West are attributo you can attribute
- 12:52Speaker 6: imperfectly as it is to Israel. And yes, our students
- 12:57Speaker 6: at the best universities in the country before Hamas's ruling Gaza,
- 13:05Speaker 6: a lot of the professors, not at Northwood but at
- 13:10Speaker 6: other universities teach us.
- 13:12Speaker 3: That all cultures are equal. All cultures are equal.
- 13:16Speaker 6: Whether it's cultures that have produced nothing or very little
- 13:20Speaker 6: and the culture that produces the amazing, amazing wealth that
- 13:24Speaker 6: we have, they're the same.
- 13:27Speaker 3: There's no difference between them.
- 13:29Speaker 6: Indeed, multiculturalism, this idea of the equality of all cultures
- 13:33Speaker 6: is common today, prevalent all over the world.
- 13:38Speaker 3: Well, I have an opinion about that.
- 13:41Speaker 6: Western civilization as a culture is superior to any other
- 13:45Speaker 6: culture that existed in human history.
- 13:48Speaker 3: It has elevated us to great wealth.
- 13:52Speaker 6: It is the only culture that supports freedom, the freedom
- 13:55Speaker 6: of the individual that live his life based on his
- 13:58Speaker 6: own values. It is the culture that has liberated us,
- 14:04Speaker 6: for the most part, from violence. This is by far
- 14:08Speaker 6: the best culture in the world that the world has
- 14:10Speaker 6: ever seen, and yet we're supposed to pretend they were
- 14:16Speaker 6: just the same as any other culture. Anywhere else in
- 14:21Speaker 6: the world, even those that are still going at each
- 14:24Speaker 6: other with bows and arrows and axes. We're not a culture,
- 14:31Speaker 6: nothing else, not our genes, not the color of our skin,
- 14:34Speaker 6: not anything else. A culture is just better. Why what
- 14:39Speaker 6: makes it better? It's part of the question, and how
- 14:43Speaker 6: did it get better? And this multiculturalism weakens us in
- 14:50Speaker 6: facing the threats from outside In Europe. You're seeing a
- 14:55Speaker 6: real threat from Islamists in Europe, from people would like
- 14:59Speaker 6: to turn Europe into a Sharia dominated continent. Let me
- 15:05Speaker 6: see that in the demonstrations that are happening in London
- 15:08Speaker 6: and Paris and Sweden.
- 15:10Speaker 3: And other parts of Europe. And how do we defend
- 15:13Speaker 3: against that?
- 15:13Speaker 6: If we think our culture is just the same as theirs,
- 15:15Speaker 6: that there's no difference between the two, it's very hard
- 15:19Speaker 6: to defend. How do we defend it when we don't
- 15:21Speaker 6: even know what our culture really is and what it represents?
- 15:26Speaker 6: So what is Western civilization? Where does it come from?
- 15:29Speaker 6: How do we get here? I think it's really important
- 15:33Speaker 6: to note that there was a time when the people
- 15:36Speaker 6: of the West, and let's define the West for the
- 15:39Speaker 6: purposes of now. Historically, Western civilization is Western Europe, and
- 15:44Speaker 6: the United States once it was created. There was a
- 15:48Speaker 6: period in which the peoples of Western Europe were the
- 15:51Speaker 6: barbarians of the Earth.
- 15:54Speaker 3: If you traveled the Earth.
- 15:56Speaker 6: In I don't know, fourteen hundred six, seven hundred years ago,
- 16:02Speaker 6: you would not have predicted that the West would become
- 16:06Speaker 6: what it is. It was more barbaric than Islamic civilization,
- 16:11Speaker 6: which was thriving at the time, much richer. And if
- 16:14Speaker 6: you think about science, between four hundred AD, which is
- 16:22Speaker 6: the fall of Rome about and fourteen hundred.
- 16:25Speaker 3: Eight, in the West there was almost no science.
- 16:31Speaker 6: One example of this is human beings have always looked
- 16:34Speaker 6: to the sky and they've always tried to map out
- 16:37Speaker 6: the stars and figure out how they move and figure
- 16:40Speaker 6: out what's going on. They didn't get it right usually,
- 16:42Speaker 6: but they were always curious about.
- 16:43Speaker 3: What's going on up there and what's happening.
- 16:46Speaker 6: And you know, in Greece and Rome there were astronomers
- 16:49Speaker 6: who had theories about the movement of the Sun and
- 16:51Speaker 6: the movement of the everything was documented. From four hundred
- 16:55Speaker 6: to fourteen hundred there were no astronomical observations made.
- 16:59Speaker 3: Nobody in the.
- 17:00Speaker 6: West theorized about what's going up on in the heavens.
- 17:05Speaker 6: In the Muslim world they were doing it. Even in
- 17:07Speaker 6: India they were doing it. To some extended China, they
- 17:09Speaker 6: were doing it. Not in Western Europe, no, almost no science.
- 17:17Speaker 6: Whatever writing was happening was mostly transcribing ancient books.
- 17:21Speaker 3: Very little new things were being written.
- 17:26Speaker 6: Economically, the West was generally depressed, certainly not as rich
- 17:31Speaker 6: as the Muslim world and not as rich as China.
- 17:35Speaker 3: And then over the course.
- 17:38Speaker 6: Of about five hundred years, the West takes off.
- 17:44Speaker 3: It takes off from every perspective wealth through the roof
- 17:48Speaker 3: we are.
- 17:50Speaker 6: You know, economists say we're three hundred times richer today
- 17:53Speaker 6: than we were three hundred years agour hundred year ago,
- 17:56Speaker 6: five hundred It doesn't matter because in those periods wealth
- 17:59Speaker 6: didn't change three hundred times I think did rum McCluskey
- 18:02Speaker 6: has done the calculation, and three hundred times richer than
- 18:05Speaker 6: we were back then, But that does not capture how
- 18:09Speaker 6: rich we are, right, because economists can only measure stuff
- 18:12Speaker 6: in terms of dollars and cents.
- 18:13Speaker 3: That's how we do things right. You can add up
- 18:16Speaker 3: balance sheets, you can add up value of assets.
- 18:19Speaker 6: What's the value of running water toilets, what's the value
- 18:23Speaker 6: of it having a toilet in your home. Economists can't
- 18:26Speaker 6: tell you because the toilet costs almost nothing. But what's
- 18:30Speaker 6: the value to you as a human being? What's the
- 18:32Speaker 6: value of electricity? It's not how much you pay for electricity.
- 18:36Speaker 3: The value to you is much higher than the value
- 18:38Speaker 3: of electricity.
- 18:39Speaker 6: What's the value of an iPhone? Much more than the
- 18:42Speaker 6: thousand dollars you pay for it. So we are thousands
- 18:47Speaker 6: of times richer than we were three hundred years ago.
- 18:50Speaker 6: So wealth exploded. Science, Oh, we don't know. The scientific revolution.
- 18:54Speaker 6: The technology we have today unimaginable. We have still holding
- 19:00Speaker 6: on Bailey to the rule of law, due process, we
- 19:04Speaker 6: still got them. We still view them as an ideal
- 19:07Speaker 6: that didn't exist not that long ago.
- 19:09Speaker 3: There was no such thing.
- 19:11Speaker 6: The king, the aristocrats, they did what they wanted pretty much,
- 19:15Speaker 6: and the peasants, which most of us would have been tough,
- 19:20Speaker 6: due process.
- 19:21Speaker 3: You gotta be kidding. Equality for the law, No way.
- 19:26Speaker 6: These are really modern innovation, and they all were products
- 19:29Speaker 6: of Western Europe. Nobody in the East, nobody elsewhere came
- 19:33Speaker 6: up with the idea of economic liberty, political liberty, due process,
- 19:39Speaker 6: and of course, the economic system and political system of
- 19:42Speaker 6: capitalism all of this is new.
- 19:47Speaker 3: It's why it's so precious.
- 19:48Speaker 6: It's why it's so easy for us to give it up,
- 19:51Speaker 6: because it's really really new. With human beings have been
- 19:55Speaker 6: around at least one hundred thousand years. What we're experiencing today,
- 19:58Speaker 6: the kind of life that we have maybe one hundred
- 20:02Speaker 6: and fifty years, two hundred since the founding of America.
- 20:06Speaker 3: That's it. Two fifty's that's how long we've lived relatively free.
- 20:12Speaker 3: How did this happen?
- 20:16Speaker 6: So I'm doing the history of Western civilization in twenty minutes, right,
- 20:25Speaker 6: I think the key or the turning point, the beginning,
- 20:29Speaker 6: really the beginning, but it took a long time to
- 20:31Speaker 6: manifest itself. The beginning is what we call today the Renaissance,
- 20:37Speaker 6: and the Renaissance is a renaissance of what. What does
- 20:39Speaker 6: the word renaissance mean? It means rediscovery? And what are
- 20:43Speaker 6: they rediscovering in the Renaissance. What is Michelangelo and Leonardo
- 20:47Speaker 6: da Vinci and Rephael and the thinkers, the humanists of
- 20:50Speaker 6: the Renaissance.
- 20:51Speaker 3: What are they discovering?
- 20:53Speaker 6: They're discovering an ancient civilization, an ancient civilization that some
- 20:57Speaker 6: extent had been buried at least this art suddenly had
- 21:01Speaker 6: been buried.
- 21:03Speaker 3: They're discovering a civilization.
- 21:04Speaker 6: Of people who believed in man, in our capabilities, in
- 21:09Speaker 6: our capacity to do great things, in man as a hero.
- 21:15Speaker 6: They discover a civilization that portrayed that in their art
- 21:20Speaker 6: that reflected that, and the kind of sculptures that they made,
- 21:23Speaker 6: the sculptures of what survived. We don't know much about
- 21:26Speaker 6: their painting, but the sculptures we saw, we discovered them
- 21:29Speaker 6: when they started digging in the ground all over Italy.
- 21:34Speaker 6: They discovered a civilization that had discovered the idea of philosophy,
- 21:39Speaker 6: and that had written fast philosophical works, many of which
- 21:44Speaker 6: had disappeared from the West for a thousand years, and
- 21:48Speaker 6: were now rediscovered by the way because the Christians conquered
- 21:51Speaker 6: the Muslim Spain, found the libraries of Toledo and these
- 21:56Speaker 6: other places, and brought the books back to the West.
- 22:00Speaker 6: So all somewhat accedents of history. But in the end
- 22:03Speaker 6: these ideas reached the West, and the greatest idea that
- 22:07Speaker 6: they discover in this book of the ideas of reason,
- 22:11Speaker 6: the idea that the human mind is capable of knowing
- 22:14Speaker 6: the world, knowing reality, understanding reality. They discover the great
- 22:19Speaker 6: scientific writings of the ancient Greeks. The Greeks were actually
- 22:23Speaker 6: quite advanced when it came to science, not only in
- 22:25Speaker 6: the stars, but medicine, beginnings of physics, the beginnings of
- 22:29Speaker 6: biology again, all things that were dead for a long
- 22:32Speaker 6: time in the West. And to the credit of the
- 22:36Speaker 6: thinkers of the time, they took the seriously.
- 22:38Speaker 3: And you can see it in the art.
- 22:39Speaker 6: If you've ever gone to a museum and you see
- 22:41Speaker 6: the art from the Middle Ages, and then you walk
- 22:44Speaker 6: into the art of the room with the Renaissance, it's
- 22:47Speaker 6: like you walked into a different universe. It's like the
- 22:51Speaker 6: colors are different, the anatomy is different, the individuation. Suddenly
- 22:56Speaker 6: in the Renaissance, people become individuals. They start being just
- 23:00Speaker 6: all they look in the same stick figures in the
- 23:03Speaker 6: sense they suddenly gain a respect for the individual, for
- 23:09Speaker 6: who he is and some extent to his mind. Now
- 23:15Speaker 6: the artists get it first, which is really interesting. The
- 23:18Speaker 6: artists get it before the intellectuals, before the philosophers. They
- 23:21Speaker 6: get it before their great thinkers.
- 23:24Speaker 3: The artists, if you look at.
- 23:25Speaker 6: Leonardo, if you look at Raferel, if you look at Michelangelo,
- 23:28Speaker 6: they get this perspective on human beings. They get Western
- 23:31Speaker 6: civili history way before the philosopher's rite about it. But
- 23:37Speaker 6: these ideas spad through Europe, these ideas of science of reason.
- 23:42Speaker 6: Think Galileo, Copernicus, Kepler in astronomy. Suddenly you have these geniuses.
- 23:46Speaker 6: Where did they come from? They were always there, but
- 23:49Speaker 6: they were suppressed, uppressed by the authority. Suddenly they were
- 23:52Speaker 6: allowed to experiment, to explore, at least to some extent. Right,
- 23:57Speaker 6: galil gets house arrest, but how rest is better than
- 24:00Speaker 6: being burned in at stake, which would have been this
- 24:02Speaker 6: fate one hundred years earlier. So suddenly you get a
- 24:05Speaker 6: little bit of freedom. And ultimately this period which lasts
- 24:13Speaker 6: maybe two hundred years, it's a period of this rebirth, rediscovery.
- 24:20Speaker 6: But at the same time it's a period of great
- 24:22Speaker 6: stress in Europe. Anybody know what's going on in Europe
- 24:25Speaker 6: during these two hundred years. A lot of wars, a
- 24:30Speaker 6: lot of violence in the name of what what is
- 24:32Speaker 6: the violence in the name of religion?
- 24:36Speaker 3: You know, the most violent.
- 24:37Speaker 6: War in Western civilization's history, in the history of the West, is.
- 24:42Speaker 3: Probably the Thirty Year War.
- 24:44Speaker 6: It's probably in terms of the number of people who
- 24:47Speaker 6: died per capita more casualties than.
- 24:50Speaker 3: World War II and World War One.
- 24:53Speaker 6: Something like a third to half of the German population
- 24:56Speaker 6: was killed during that war. And it wasn't other people
- 24:59Speaker 6: killing the Germans. It was the Germans killing the Germans.
- 25:03Speaker 6: There's Catholics killing Protestants and Protestants killing Catholics. War was
- 25:09Speaker 6: a huge part of life in that period of time.
- 25:14Speaker 6: The think is coming out of that period, take these
- 25:19Speaker 6: ideas that they got from Greece. They look at the
- 25:22Speaker 6: world around.
- 25:23Speaker 3: Them and they see these wars.
- 25:27Speaker 6: And they come to the conclusion that something new is needed,
- 25:30Speaker 6: something different is needed.
- 25:36Speaker 3: Two things happened during this period.
- 25:38Speaker 6: One is you get philosophers like John Locke. John Locke,
- 25:43Speaker 6: you know, he looks at Europe and he says, this
- 25:46Speaker 6: is ridiculous. Protestants and Catholics killing each other, the slaughter,
- 25:50Speaker 6: the bloodshed, this isn't the kind of life that it's
- 25:54Speaker 6: appropriate to human being. And the idea that he develops
- 25:58Speaker 6: as an idea no individual individuals. Individuals have rights. Individuals
- 26:06Speaker 6: have a right to their own life. Individuals have a
- 26:09Speaker 6: right to live their lives based on their own values.
- 26:14Speaker 6: The state, the authorities, even the Church doesn't have a
- 26:20Speaker 6: right to dictate to individuals how to live their life.
- 26:23Speaker 6: This is a revolution and thinking. It's a revolution that's
- 26:27Speaker 6: being developing in a sense was already in the art before,
- 26:30Speaker 6: but is now being put in paper right. And of
- 26:34Speaker 6: course John Locke spends a little time in jail and
- 26:37Speaker 6: has to escape Anglear to go there and then the Netherlands,
- 26:39Speaker 6: because these ideas are are difficult to remember.
- 26:41Speaker 3: This is pre free speech. This is before the idea
- 26:45Speaker 3: of free speech. There's no free speech.
- 26:46Speaker 6: Voltaire during the same period has to escape the Geneva.
- 26:52Speaker 6: So this is a period of a lot of new
- 26:55Speaker 6: ideas format and maybe the most important think of this
- 26:57Speaker 6: period is Isaac Newton, of all people, the scientist, the physicist,
- 27:06Speaker 6: because what Isaac Newton says is, you know before that
- 27:09Speaker 6: the idea that reason is good, reason is efficacious is like, yeah,
- 27:13Speaker 6: that's cool, Okay, what does that give me? But Isaac
- 27:19Speaker 6: Newton shows us that through reason we can explain the
- 27:22Speaker 6: physical world, really explain the physical world, and have explained
- 27:27Speaker 6: it in a way that's accessible to almost anyone. If
- 27:33Speaker 6: you took a physics class in high school or in
- 27:35Speaker 6: college and didn't understand Newton's rules of motion.
- 27:42Speaker 3: You had a bad teacher than not hard. This is
- 27:48Speaker 3: relatively simple stuff.
- 27:50Speaker 6: Certainly, if you've ever taken a class in in quantum
- 27:53Speaker 6: mechanics or in Einstein, then you know, I mean, that's unknowable.
- 27:57Speaker 6: This is noble, noble to almost anybody. And Europeans took
- 28:02Speaker 6: it that way. Americans took it that way. Megan still
- 28:06Speaker 6: was calling me at that point. But they took this
- 28:08Speaker 6: as whoa, we can understand the physical world now in
- 28:12Speaker 6: contrast to what in the past.
- 28:14Speaker 3: How did we know what was true and what was not?
- 28:17Speaker 3: What was the standard of truth before Newton?
- 28:22Speaker 6: Does it match the Bible or doesn't it? Does it
- 28:26Speaker 6: match Aristotle or doesn't it. They took Aristotle as like
- 28:30Speaker 6: the Bible. Like Aristotle was a scientist. He got ninety
- 28:33Speaker 6: percent of it wrong. Method was right, which is the
- 28:37Speaker 6: most important thing. But his actual observations, it's actually physical
- 28:40Speaker 6: theories about the word. Biological theories were wrong. But what's
- 28:43Speaker 6: important is the method right. That's how you correct the mistakes.
- 28:47Speaker 6: If you have the method right, you correct the mistakes.
- 28:49Speaker 6: They took Aristotle as the truth, and yet suddenly they
- 28:55Speaker 6: were discovering things that Aristotle didn't say that Aristotle was wrong.
- 28:58Speaker 6: They contradicted the Bible. This is why Galileo had to
- 29:05Speaker 6: be in house arrest.
- 29:05Speaker 3: Right.
- 29:06Speaker 6: And suddenly the standard for truth was not ancient books.
- 29:11Speaker 6: The standard with truth was the human mind. The standard
- 29:13Speaker 6: with truth the science was observation was discovering things in reality. Suddenly, people, individuals,
- 29:23Speaker 6: common people suddenly had their sense of efficaciousness.
- 29:27Speaker 3: We have a mind.
- 29:29Speaker 6: WHOA, that's pretty cool because before that, who made all
- 29:34Speaker 6: the choices for you? Like for most people, like we
- 29:37Speaker 6: romanticize the past, so we have movies, but the movies
- 29:40Speaker 6: are always about aristocrats, always because you don't want to
- 29:44Speaker 6: know how the peasants lived. You're not gonna go watch
- 29:47Speaker 6: a movie about that. Like who decided what your profession
- 29:51Speaker 6: was three hundred years ago? Like literally for everybody who
- 29:55Speaker 6: decided what your profession was? You did if you are
- 29:59Speaker 6: a man, because if you're a woman, it's irrelevant because
- 30:02Speaker 6: you have no choices. If you're a woman zero. If
- 30:05Speaker 6: you're a man, you did what your father did. You
- 30:06Speaker 6: joined the guild. You know a story of it's a
- 30:11Speaker 6: funny story about Leonardo da Vinci. You know Leonardo da Vinci,
- 30:14Speaker 6: Like he got to be an artist and a engineer
- 30:19Speaker 6: and a strategist and hung around with all kinds of people.
- 30:22Speaker 6: You know what his father did, he was a notary.
- 30:25Speaker 6: Saw come, Leonardo DaVinci didn't become a notary. He should
- 30:27Speaker 6: have joined the guild and become a notary like his dad.
- 30:30Speaker 3: That was the law.
- 30:31Speaker 6: How did he get the freedom to go out and
- 30:33Speaker 6: do all this fun stuff?
- 30:35Speaker 3: Anybody know? He was a bastard. He's an illegitimate child.
- 30:41Speaker 6: As an ill liberate child, he couldn't join the guild,
- 30:45Speaker 6: So he was freer than the legitimate child. The legitimate
- 30:47Speaker 6: child would have had to join the guild. He got
- 30:49Speaker 6: to go and do all this fun stuff. That's not
- 30:53Speaker 6: a healthy society, right. Who did you get to choose
- 30:56Speaker 6: who to marry for the most part, No, you gotta
- 31:01Speaker 6: choose your political leader. No.
- 31:03Speaker 3: And there's a reason for.
- 31:05Speaker 6: That because if you take away human reason, if you
- 31:09Speaker 6: say people don't have reason.
- 31:10Speaker 3: If you say people have to.
- 31:13Speaker 6: Abide by an authority a philosopher king according to Plato,
- 31:20Speaker 6: the religious authority according to our religions, then you're basically
- 31:24Speaker 6: saying you can't make decision for yourself, You don't have
- 31:27Speaker 6: the capacity to think for yourself. You have to follow
- 31:30Speaker 6: a leader, and you know, we've had lots of different authorities,
- 31:35Speaker 6: but it's always an authority. What Isaac Newton and John
- 31:38Speaker 6: Locke do is they liberate the individual's capacity to think
- 31:42Speaker 6: for himself. They say, no, you have reason, you can
- 31:46Speaker 6: think for yourself, you can choose for yourself. You can
- 31:49Speaker 6: discover truth. You're not reliant on these authorities to discover truth.
- 31:54Speaker 6: Truth is accessible to every human being. Suddenly people wake
- 31:59Speaker 6: up and say, wait a minute. If that's the case,
- 32:02Speaker 6: why can't I choose my own profession. Why can't I
- 32:05Speaker 6: start my own business? This is where entrepreneurship comes from.
- 32:09Speaker 6: Why can't I do my own invention without asking for permission?
- 32:14Speaker 6: Why can't I move cities. One of the things characteristic,
- 32:17Speaker 6: again of life before, was this idea of you were
- 32:23Speaker 6: born somewhere, you stayed there. Travel was very difficult and hard,
- 32:28Speaker 6: but people never moved. The whole idea of immigration, which
- 32:31Speaker 6: I know is controversial today, but hate all of your
- 32:34Speaker 6: ancestors were immigrants one way or the other. At some
- 32:36Speaker 6: point immigration was okay. In the United States, immigration was
- 32:41Speaker 6: unheard of. Nobody moved. Suddenly you could do that, You
- 32:48Speaker 6: could live your life based on your own mind, because
- 32:52Speaker 6: you had one before there was no mind. This period,
- 32:56Speaker 6: which starts at about sixteen seventy six in eighty and ends,
- 33:02Speaker 6: i would say, right at the beginning of the French Revolution,
- 33:05Speaker 6: or maybe in the first guillotine of the French Revolution,
- 33:09Speaker 6: is called what anybody know what that name of that
- 33:11Speaker 6: period is. It's the Enlightenment, but it has another name.
- 33:18Speaker 6: It's called the Age of Reason. There's a reason it's
- 33:22Speaker 6: called their age of reason because it's their age that
- 33:26Speaker 6: elevates man's reason as our means of knowing the world.
- 33:31Speaker 3: And the achievements during this period of time.
- 33:33Speaker 6: This is the period of time in which we get
- 33:35Speaker 6: all the innovations.
- 33:38Speaker 3: That we today accept and take for granted.
- 33:41Speaker 6: We get the political thinkers thinking about liberty and freedom.
- 33:44Speaker 6: We get the political thinkers thinking about the economics of freedom.
- 33:48Speaker 3: Think about Adam Smith and humans.
- 33:50Speaker 6: An economist is a great economist thinking about freedom from
- 33:54Speaker 6: an economic perspective, and the crowning achievement of the Enlightenment politically,
- 33:59Speaker 6: what's the crown achievement of the Enlightenment? From a political perspective,
- 34:03Speaker 6: what is the greatest achievement of the Enlightenment? The Constitution
- 34:08Speaker 6: of will put it well, broadly the creation of the
- 34:11Speaker 6: United States of America. I would argue the greatest document
- 34:15Speaker 6: is not the Constitution, but the Declaration Declaration of Independence,
- 34:19Speaker 6: which I think is the greatest document political document ever written.
- 34:21Speaker 3: By far.
- 34:22Speaker 6: Nothing comes close, because what does the declaration announce to
- 34:28Speaker 6: the world. All men are created equal equally in what sense?
- 34:33Speaker 6: Like we all have the same income, we all have
- 34:36Speaker 6: the same abilities, we all have the same rights, equal
- 34:43Speaker 6: before the law, but not just equal before any law,
- 34:47Speaker 6: before the law that is based on the idea of rights.
- 34:52Speaker 3: We all have the right inalienable. Inalienable means what.
- 34:58Speaker 6: Nobody can take it away from you. Nine percent of
- 35:01Speaker 6: the people could vote, they still can't take it away
- 35:04Speaker 6: from you. It's you, it's it's part of you, part
- 35:08Speaker 6: of your nature and every single human being. They say
- 35:13Speaker 6: all men are created equal. Not all Americans are created equal,
- 35:15Speaker 6: just by the way all men are created equal and
- 35:19Speaker 6: by men here we want to include women, right, But
- 35:22Speaker 6: all are created equal, and they have a right to life, liberty,
- 35:28Speaker 6: and the pursuit of happiness. It would be nice if
- 35:31Speaker 6: they kept property in there, would have made things a
- 35:33Speaker 6: little cleaner. But they didn't. Yeah, but they didn't. Unfortunately,
- 35:40Speaker 6: but it's still it's still there. What does it mean
- 35:42Speaker 6: to say you have a right? What did John Locke
- 35:45Speaker 6: mean when he said you had to write? What does
- 35:46Speaker 6: the Founders mean you had to write to something? Because
- 35:49Speaker 6: today people think we have a right to free healthcare
- 35:54Speaker 6: and free education, and maybe free food and free anything
- 35:57Speaker 6: we feel like.
- 35:59Speaker 3: Is that what the Founders rights meant? What it? Rights mean? Yeah?
- 36:04Speaker 6: But a right to life means what I mean. I
- 36:06Speaker 6: could say, look, I'm sick. My right to life means
- 36:10Speaker 6: that you have to provide me with health care for free.
- 36:14Speaker 6: But that's not what they mean by right to life.
- 36:15Speaker 6: What do they mean by right to life? They mean
- 36:18Speaker 6: you have the freedom to act in pursuit of the
- 36:25Speaker 6: values necessary for your life based on whose judgment yours,
- 36:31Speaker 6: not based on state's judgment, not some authority's judgment, your judgement.
- 36:37Speaker 3: And what does freedom mean?
- 36:39Speaker 6: Because everybody out there in the world is full freedom everybody.
- 36:43Speaker 3: I could speak in front of.
- 36:44Speaker 6: A group of communists and ask them how many people
- 36:46Speaker 6: here full freedom? And every hand would go up. What
- 36:49Speaker 6: does freedom actually mean? Not what the communis mean. It
- 36:53Speaker 6: means the absence of coercion, the absence of force. So
- 36:58Speaker 6: rights mean that you have the right. You have the freedom,
- 37:03Speaker 6: which means no couragion, no force to live your life
- 37:06Speaker 6: as you see fit with nobody has the ability to
- 37:11Speaker 6: force you to do otherwise. That's what freedom means, that's
- 37:15Speaker 6: what individual rights means.
- 37:17Speaker 3: That's what this country was founded on.
- 37:21Speaker 6: And that is only possible, as Thomas Jefferson will tell you,
- 37:24Speaker 6: only possible for people who can reason, can use their mind,
- 37:31Speaker 6: can discover truth, and therefore talk about personal responsibility, can
- 37:36Speaker 6: take care of themselves. Because the reality is if we
- 37:38Speaker 6: can't think, we don't have a reason, if we don't
- 37:41Speaker 6: have a mind, then we can't be responsible for ourselves.
- 37:44Speaker 6: And indeed, in the past, you won't expect it to
- 37:47Speaker 6: be the lord, the responsible for the manner he took
- 37:53Speaker 6: care of everybody, right because you couldn't take care of yourself.
- 37:57Speaker 6: So in the Enlightenment is a revolution that elevates reason.
- 38:02Speaker 6: Once it elevates reason, who reasons, the individual, the individual
- 38:08Speaker 6: becomes the unit, the end in itself, and therefore individuals
- 38:16Speaker 6: using reason must be free. And that's the political revolution
- 38:21Speaker 6: of representational government. And the founders are not pro democracy
- 38:29Speaker 6: as we understand democracy in the sense of Greek democracy,
- 38:33Speaker 6: or really any other democracy. It's not about majority rule.
- 38:37Speaker 6: Voting is not what makes America great.
- 38:42Speaker 3: I know this is a shock to many audiences. Voting
- 38:48Speaker 3: should be trivial.
- 38:49Speaker 6: It shouldn't matter that much because the government, in the
- 38:53Speaker 6: original intense is small.
- 38:56Speaker 3: It was limited, It couldn't do that many things.
- 38:59Speaker 6: The possible believe that the government in my life would
- 39:02Speaker 6: would there would be an intersection, was small. So who
- 39:07Speaker 6: was in Washington, Eh, didn't matter that much. The bigger
- 39:11Speaker 6: the government becomes, the bigger the state becomes. The more
- 39:14Speaker 6: we start caring. See, the more we talk politics, the
- 39:18Speaker 6: more it's a sign our cultures deteriorated. Right, in a
- 39:21Speaker 6: good culture, politics.
- 39:23Speaker 3: Is like one of the things we do in once
- 39:25Speaker 3: or four years. We vote big deal, no, no big deal.
- 39:27Speaker 7: Right.
- 39:29Speaker 6: The fact that it's so important that it animates everything
- 39:31Speaker 6: in our world today means that that government is way
- 39:34Speaker 6: too big, way too involved in our lives.
- 39:37Speaker 3: But this idea.
- 39:40Speaker 6: Of protecting minorities from the majority is what animates the constitution.
- 39:46Speaker 3: Because what is the smallest minority.
- 39:50Speaker 6: What's the smallest minority in any country, the individual? What's
- 39:57Speaker 6: the constitution's structure to do protect the individual from the majority.
- 40:03Speaker 6: Why do we have individual rights to protect us from
- 40:06Speaker 6: our majority.
- 40:07Speaker 3: They can vote to oppress.
- 40:09Speaker 6: Us, and they do, and they have and they still are.
- 40:16Speaker 6: So the Enlightenment brought us science, reason, individualism, and limited government.
- 40:24Speaker 6: It's intellectually the greatest period of time, greatest period in
- 40:28Speaker 6: I think human history. I think it's based almost exclusively
- 40:32Speaker 6: on the ideas, ultimately of the Greeks, primarily Aristotle and
- 40:37Speaker 6: some other Greeks. It is led to the kind of
- 40:40Speaker 6: flourishing we have today. It led to what some call
- 40:44Speaker 6: the permissionless society that we benefited from in the early
- 40:47Speaker 6: nineteenth century at least somewhat where you could go out
- 40:51Speaker 6: do what you wanted to do, was none of anybody's business,
- 40:54Speaker 6: start any business you want, invent anything you wanted without
- 40:57Speaker 6: getting a permit. That to me is Western civilization. That's
- 41:06Speaker 6: what created what we have today. And indeed, anybody who
- 41:09Speaker 6: adopts reason, individualism, and political freedom is part of the
- 41:16Speaker 6: West today. I think a country like South Korea, Japan, Taiwan.
- 41:22Speaker 3: A part of the West.
- 41:25Speaker 6: Because they've adopted these ideas of Western civilization imperfectly as
- 41:30Speaker 6: they have.
- 41:31Speaker 3: That's because we have them imperfectly. So Western civilization is
- 41:37Speaker 3: a real set of ideas.
- 41:40Speaker 6: They were discovered during the Enlightenment, manifest themselves in the
- 41:44Speaker 6: creation of the United States of America as the greatest achievement,
- 41:48Speaker 6: manifest themselves in science and in technology and the.
- 41:52Speaker 3: Success that we've had. It is a set of ideas
- 41:55Speaker 3: that are worth fighting for.
- 41:57Speaker 6: Is a set of ideas that liberates man and makes
- 42:00Speaker 6: us wealthy and prosperous. And it's what we need to
- 42:07Speaker 6: be fighting for rather than just fighting against. And these
- 42:11Speaker 6: ideas are the best ideas. They produce the best results
- 42:17Speaker 6: because they liberate the individual. And again it doesn't matter where,
- 42:22Speaker 6: it doesn't matter when, but when you liberate the individual,
- 42:26Speaker 6: they will flourish. So fighting for Western ideas, fighting Western civilization,
- 42:35Speaker 6: is fighting for the Enlightenment. It's fighting for reason, individualism,
- 42:39Speaker 6: and political liberty, and these ideas worth fighting for. These ideas,
- 42:43Speaker 6: they're important for our future, and ideas we are losing.
- 42:48Speaker 6: Collectivism is on the eyes, irrationality, anti reason is on
- 42:54Speaker 6: the eyse and of course as a consequence, as you
- 42:57Speaker 6: lose reason, and as you lose the individual, you lose
- 43:03Speaker 6: political freedom. So political authoritarianism is on the rise, whether
- 43:08Speaker 6: it's just the size of government, which is pretty authoritarian
- 43:11Speaker 6: to begin with, or where there's real authoritarianism, Worth wants.
- 43:14Speaker 3: To dictate everything we do. All of that is on
- 43:17Speaker 3: the rise today, and.
- 43:18Speaker 6: I believe that it's on the rise primarily because we
- 43:21Speaker 6: stop defending the good.
- 43:24Speaker 3: Bad evil succeeds.
- 43:27Speaker 6: When the goods stay silent, when the good refuses to fight.
- 43:32Speaker 6: So fight, fight for the good, Fight for the West.
- 43:39Speaker 6: Not as a geography, but as an idea reason individualism
- 43:44Speaker 6: and political liberty are worth that fight.
- 43:47Speaker 3: Thank you.
- 44:00Speaker 6: I think we have time for questions, and there is
- 44:03Speaker 6: a mike, how does man practice? I mean, I think
- 44:37Speaker 6: the founders understood that happiness is not something that just
- 44:41Speaker 6: happens to you, and happiness is not something that you
- 44:45Speaker 6: gain through instant gratification.
- 44:48Speaker 3: It's not a fleeting emotion.
- 44:51Speaker 6: Happiness is something that is a consequence of achieving your values,
- 44:55Speaker 6: not any values, values that are pro human life, pro
- 44:59Speaker 6: human flourishing, pro human success. So the founders understood, I think,
- 45:05Speaker 6: imperfectly right.
- 45:06Speaker 3: If I had to look back. I mean a lot
- 45:08Speaker 3: of the things the Founders did were imperfect. You know.
- 45:11Speaker 6: Obviously the big compromise around slavery is the biggest imperfection,
- 45:14Speaker 6: but a lot of things that were imperfect around what
- 45:16Speaker 6: the Founders did, not because they're at fault, not because they.
- 45:19Speaker 3: Weren't the smartest people on the planet.
- 45:21Speaker 6: They were, but because it was seventeen seventy six and
- 45:24Speaker 6: we're now in the twenty first century.
- 45:25Speaker 3: We've got the benefit of two hundred.
- 45:27Speaker 6: And fifty years of seeing what's happened, and we could
- 45:29Speaker 6: do better.
- 45:32Speaker 3: So I think their understanding of happiness was.
- 45:35Speaker 6: Living a great life, making the most of your life
- 45:39Speaker 6: using your reason. And again not all the Founders would
- 45:42Speaker 6: agree in exactly what that meant, but using your reason
- 45:45Speaker 6: to pursue worthwhile values that made you better as better
- 45:50Speaker 6: a human being, pursuing virtue. And they were in that
- 45:55Speaker 6: sense again children of the Enlightenment, or they were the Enlightenment,
- 45:58Speaker 6: not just children. They were part of the Enligenment. These
- 46:00Speaker 6: ideas were coming out of France. It's hard to believe
- 46:03Speaker 6: it was France, but they were coming out of France
- 46:04Speaker 6: in the years where France had good ideas. It didn't
- 46:08Speaker 6: last for very long, just reality. And then coming out
- 46:13Speaker 6: of England, I mean it was the Scotland. Really the
- 46:16Speaker 6: Scots would be upset at me Scotland, England and France.
- 46:19Speaker 6: The ideas were coming out of there the United Kingdom,
- 46:21Speaker 6: and and they were talking about what does happiness require?
- 46:26Speaker 6: What kind of life do we have to leave? But
- 46:28Speaker 6: all based on this idea of reason as the foundation for.
- 46:33Speaker 3: All of that. But it's about making your life the
- 46:36Speaker 3: best life think could be.
- 46:37Speaker 6: In my view, the thinker who is closest to the Enlightenment,
- 46:43Speaker 6: who basically completes in many respects the assignment that the
- 46:48Speaker 6: Enlightenment took on is iron Rand. So iron Rand at
- 46:51Speaker 6: the core of Ironman's ideas is reason right individualism, and
- 46:56Speaker 6: she actually gives it a mal foundation. It's not just
- 46:59Speaker 6: individualism as a political ideal, but as a moral ideal,
- 47:03Speaker 6: the idea of rational lung term self interest as a
- 47:06Speaker 6: moral ideal, and political freedom.
- 47:09Speaker 3: She is an advocate of capitalism.
- 47:11Speaker 6: I think the most consistent advocate of capitalism is a
- 47:14Speaker 6: political system that we've had. And in that sense, she's
- 47:16Speaker 6: completing the kind of the work of the Enlightenment bring
- 47:20Speaker 6: into the twentieth century and giving it to us. So
- 47:23Speaker 6: even when it comes to pursuit of happiness, I think
- 47:25Speaker 6: Iinrandez refined what the funding fathers meant even further to
- 47:30Speaker 6: give us a set of virtues and a set of
- 47:32Speaker 6: values that we should pursue as human beings to achieve
- 47:35Speaker 6: our individual happiness. Yeah, my reaction is that jd Vance, Ellen,
- 48:10Speaker 6: Mask and Trump don't understand the founding of America because
- 48:15Speaker 6: it's exactly to prevent us from being a democracy that
- 48:18Speaker 6: they established the separation of powers. It's exactly the role
- 48:22Speaker 6: of judges to say, uh uh, that's unconstitutional, you can't
- 48:26Speaker 6: do that.
- 48:28Speaker 3: The whole purpose of the separation of powers is exactly that.
- 48:33Speaker 3: So look, JD.
- 48:35Speaker 6: Vance famously said recently, he said it twice when at
- 48:38Speaker 6: the National Conservative Convention and then again at the Republican Convention,
- 48:42Speaker 6: he said, America is not an idea, not an idea.
- 48:48Speaker 3: America is a place and a people.
- 48:50Speaker 6: Now that is a perversion, with all due respect to
- 48:53Speaker 6: the Vice President. America is an idea. It is the Constitution,
- 49:00Speaker 6: it is the Declaration, and those are ideas.
- 49:02Speaker 3: It's not a people.
- 49:04Speaker 6: It's why for the first one hundred and something years
- 49:07Speaker 6: of America we had basically open voters and everybody came
- 49:10Speaker 6: in and whoever.
- 49:10Speaker 3: Showed up became an American.
- 49:14Speaker 6: America is the idea of freedom, the idea of liberty,
- 49:17Speaker 6: and the idea of freedom and liberty requires separation of powers.
- 49:22Speaker 6: It requires checks and balances, right, So Congress gets to
- 49:29Speaker 6: check the president, to check Congress, and then the judiciary
- 49:32Speaker 6: gets to check Congress and to check the president. And
- 49:35Speaker 6: if the judiciary really goes insane, then Congress can impeach
- 49:38Speaker 6: the judiciary. And of course it's the president in Congress
- 49:42Speaker 6: who appoint the judges. So it's you know, it's really complicated.
- 49:47Speaker 3: We have a crazy political system in America.
- 49:49Speaker 6: We have a House of Representative and a Senate, and
- 49:51Speaker 6: a president and the judicial. It's really hard to get
- 49:53Speaker 6: anything done. That's what the founders wanted. They knew that
- 50:01Speaker 6: if you made it easy on politicians, we would descend
- 50:05Speaker 6: into authoritarianism even faster than we already are. And what
- 50:10Speaker 6: you want is to make it hard. So every time
- 50:12Speaker 6: people complain, oh, we won't be able to pass that
- 50:15Speaker 6: legislation in Congress, well tough. That's what the system is
- 50:19Speaker 6: structured around. So you can just impose as a president
- 50:23Speaker 6: onto Congress whatever you feel like. You've got to go
- 50:26Speaker 6: through the motions getting a legislation, getting it passed, signing it,
- 50:30Speaker 6: and then making sure the courts approved that it's still
- 50:32Speaker 6: within the constitution.
- 50:33Speaker 3: If I had my way.
- 50:38Speaker 6: You know, like eighty percent of the laws that we
- 50:41Speaker 6: have today in America would be ruled on constitutional. If
- 50:44Speaker 6: the courts did their job, we wouldn't be in the
- 50:48Speaker 6: condition we are today. We'd still be a free country.
- 50:52Speaker 3: Right.
- 50:52Speaker 6: So, for one hundred and fifty years, our presidents and
- 50:56Speaker 6: Congress have been violating a proper, proper I think.
- 51:00Speaker 3: And can Papa understanding of the Constitution.
- 51:02Speaker 6: So I want judges who say, no, no, you can't
- 51:04Speaker 6: do that, and we celebrate that.
- 51:07Speaker 3: Conservatives used to celebrate that.
- 51:10Speaker 6: You used to celebrate when judges said, now, President, you
- 51:13Speaker 6: can't do that. That's that's not your power, it's not
- 51:15Speaker 6: within your realm. And now because it's Trump, Oh no,
- 51:18Speaker 6: now the judges can't.
- 51:20Speaker 3: Do that anymore.
- 51:21Speaker 8: It's the Constitution, thank you.
- 51:38Speaker 7: Yep.
- 52:15Speaker 6: I don't believe there is such a thing as a
- 52:17Speaker 6: collective ProView, right. Whenever you get a group of people,
- 52:22Speaker 6: it's a group of people, which means a group of individuals. Now,
- 52:27Speaker 6: they might agree on something and you might disagree. Who
- 52:32Speaker 6: gets to the side, what's right or wrong? The numbers voting,
- 52:37Speaker 6: no reality, facts, reason, logic gets to the site.
- 52:42Speaker 3: And I'd say almost.
- 52:44Speaker 6: All progress in all of human history has been the
- 52:47Speaker 6: result of an individual stepping up and saying, you guys
- 52:50Speaker 6: are wrong, and usually they burnt them a mistake, right,
- 52:55Speaker 6: and we've got missed about this. Prometheus brings us fire
- 52:58Speaker 6: and what do we you know, what happened them? He gets,
- 53:02Speaker 6: you know, punished for that, right, And we are still
- 53:05Speaker 6: busy punishing entrepreneurs today for bringing us fire.
- 53:09Speaker 3: Right.
- 53:09Speaker 6: We don't like the entrepreneurs, right, we antitrust them, We
- 53:12Speaker 6: take them to court. I just saw a post today
- 53:14Speaker 6: by conservatives. You know Amazon, This is unbelievable to me.
- 53:18Speaker 6: Amazon is now going to list when you see a
- 53:22Speaker 6: price in Amazon, they're going to give you information about
- 53:24Speaker 6: how much of the price is the tariff. People are
- 53:30Speaker 6: going nuts over this and one and some of the
- 53:32Speaker 6: comments are like, Bezus is getting married. His wedding is
- 53:37Speaker 6: going to cost five hundred million dollars. They want them
- 53:40Speaker 6: to list how much of your of the cost of
- 53:43Speaker 6: the thing is going to his wedding. That's how envious
- 53:46Speaker 6: we become, right, how day Jeff Bezos have a big
- 53:50Speaker 6: wedding when we're paying tariffs? Right, So we still prosecute
- 53:54Speaker 6: the individual who changed our lives. You remember, like before Amazon.
- 53:58Speaker 6: I bet you it's hard. Like it's so easy today
- 54:03Speaker 6: to buy stuff, it's so easy to do stuff on
- 54:06Speaker 6: the web, and you wouldn't be able to do that
- 54:08Speaker 6: with our cloud.
- 54:08Speaker 3: Services of Amazon.
- 54:09Speaker 6: Amazon has changed the world, and yet we still prosecute.
- 54:12Speaker 6: We still don't trust them, and we still are envious
- 54:14Speaker 6: about this success and we go after them. So no,
- 54:18Speaker 6: I think you have to stand on yourself.
- 54:20Speaker 3: Now.
- 54:21Speaker 6: Do you get information from other groups, other people, sure,
- 54:24Speaker 6: but at the end of the day, it's your responsibility,
- 54:26Speaker 6: is an individual, to integrate that information and to figure
- 54:28Speaker 6: out what's right.
- 54:29Speaker 3: Or what's wrong. Nobody can do that for you.
- 54:32Speaker 6: And if you join a tribe, a mob, a group
- 54:36Speaker 6: and just follow them, that's the end of civilization. Civilization
- 54:42Speaker 6: is about individuals thinking for themselves. When we start following groups,
- 54:46Speaker 6: we become tribal, which I fear is what we're becoming today.
- 54:49Speaker 3: When we become tribal, we.
- 54:51Speaker 6: Lose our liberties, we lose our freedoms, we lose our minds.
- 54:56Speaker 6: All we got is this, so get information. You know,
- 54:59Speaker 6: some times crowds have wisdom, sometimes they're mad. It's your
- 55:06Speaker 6: job to figure out which.
- 55:07Speaker 3: Is which and when to listen and when not to listen.
- 55:10Speaker 6: Nobody else can do that for you. Nobody else can
- 55:12Speaker 6: replace your mind.
- 55:15Speaker 7: Yeah.
- 55:30Speaker 6: Yeah, Mao was a not only was a monster, but
- 55:35Speaker 6: he was a failure. So I wouldn't take anything he
- 55:38Speaker 6: says seriously. He killed I don't know. You can debate
- 55:43Speaker 6: whether it's fifty or one hundred million people somewhere around
- 55:46Speaker 6: that or died under his regime. He didn't literally kill them.
- 55:51Speaker 6: And China is a different culture. But this is what's
- 55:53Speaker 6: interesting about China. I used to go to China quite often.
- 55:56Speaker 6: I donatey more because China has changed the last few years,
- 55:59Speaker 6: but he used to go to China quite often, and
- 56:01Speaker 6: it was a fascinating place. And one of the reasons
- 56:03Speaker 6: it was fascinating because since Mao died, really two years
- 56:07Speaker 6: after he died in nineteen seventy eight, until about ten
- 56:10Speaker 6: years ago, China was booming, it was thriving, it was
- 56:15Speaker 6: growing and technologically advancing and everything.
- 56:17Speaker 3: And then you go, how can that be?
- 56:19Speaker 6: They're like communists, right, And you go there and they're
- 56:23Speaker 6: not communists. I don't know what they are, but they're
- 56:26Speaker 6: not communists. And if you look at how they behave
- 56:30Speaker 6: and how they act, they're pretty individualistic.
- 56:34Speaker 3: Those Chinese will elbow you out of the way. They'll
- 56:37Speaker 3: go for what they.
- 56:38Speaker 6: Want without using violence, without a gun, that will actually
- 56:41Speaker 6: go and achieve their thing.
- 56:43Speaker 3: They're smart, they're using their reason.
- 56:45Speaker 6: They're trying to figure out as individuals, not as a government.
- 56:47Speaker 6: What they don't have is political liberty. Political freedom they
- 56:51Speaker 6: don't have, and that's the tragedy of China. China should
- 56:57Speaker 6: be Western, and I think China could become Western, and
- 57:02Speaker 6: China should become Western, but not as long as she
- 57:07Speaker 6: is alive, or at least as long as these dictate
- 57:09Speaker 6: over there. Not as long as the Communist Party, even
- 57:11Speaker 6: though they're not communists, they call themselves Communist.
- 57:13Speaker 3: Party rules China. They won't. But that's what they should become.
- 57:17Speaker 6: So it's not like they are a different culture and
- 57:20Speaker 6: they can never adopt the right culture. The right culture
- 57:23Speaker 6: is Western culture, and they should adopt it. And I
- 57:26Speaker 6: believe they're ready to adopt it. If you look at
- 57:29Speaker 6: young Chinese, they're ready to become Western. They dress like Westerners,
- 57:33Speaker 6: they talk like Westerners, the music is very similar to
- 57:36Speaker 6: the West. We just need to get they just need
- 57:39Speaker 6: to get rid of that authoritarian government that they have
- 57:42Speaker 6: and liberate themselves with regard to rights. Look, there's always
- 57:46Speaker 6: been skeptical about rights. Mao certainly was skeptical about rights.
- 57:50Speaker 6: So is every dictator in the world. But so a
- 57:53Speaker 6: lot of people.
- 57:54Speaker 3: We might you know, in other circumstances, many of you
- 57:57Speaker 3: might admire. I don't know. Judge se.
- 58:02Speaker 6: Famously said that, quoting Bentham, who was a British philosopher
- 58:07Speaker 6: in the nineteenth century, that writes a nonsense on stilts.
- 58:11Speaker 3: Where do they come from? Don't know where they come from?
- 58:14Speaker 3: And it's hard.
- 58:16Speaker 6: It's a hard concept, and it's a philosophical concept, but
- 58:21Speaker 6: it's a concept that is basically derived from the requirements
- 58:25Speaker 6: of human life. When we are in a social context.
- 58:30Speaker 6: In order for individuals to flourish and to thrive, they
- 58:33Speaker 6: must be left free. So if you assume that flourishing
- 58:38Speaker 6: and thriving is what we want, then rights on necessary
- 58:42Speaker 6: idea and necessary concept that we have to implement. They
- 58:47Speaker 6: don't come out of the mouth of a gun. Although
- 58:49Speaker 6: the only way to preserve rights is.
- 58:50Speaker 3: With the gun. No, it didn't.
- 58:59Speaker 6: There a came out of a piece of paper, out
- 59:01Speaker 6: of a declaration of independence, and then you needed a
- 59:04Speaker 6: gun to enforce it. Just like you need a gun
- 59:07Speaker 6: today to keep the bad guys out. But the rights
- 59:11Speaker 6: themselves were always there and were identified and recognized in
- 59:16Speaker 6: the declaration.
- 59:19Speaker 3: There was one other hand I saw.
- 59:20Speaker 6: Yeah, here's the funny thing about the Middle East. Right, So,
- 59:43Speaker 6: from about eight hundred eighty to about eleven hundred eighty,
- 59:51Speaker 6: the Middle East was a thriving civilization. The largest libraries
- 59:57Speaker 6: in the world were in Baghdad, and then when Dagdad
- 1:00:01Speaker 6: fell to the Mongols, the largest libraries in the world
- 1:00:04Speaker 6: were Muslim libraries in Toledo and Cordoba. And if you've
- 1:00:09Speaker 6: ever been to Andalusia, that part of Spain, it was
- 1:00:12Speaker 6: ruled by the Muslims. See, Slam was once a civilization,
- 1:00:18Speaker 6: a civilization.
- 1:00:20Speaker 3: That seemed like it was going to overtake the way.
- 1:00:22Speaker 6: It seemed like it was going to be the one
- 1:00:24Speaker 6: that had the industrial revolution and the wealth and all
- 1:00:26Speaker 6: of that, and it died.
- 1:00:29Speaker 3: So the real question is how do we get a
- 1:00:30Speaker 3: Slam back to that.
- 1:00:32Speaker 6: And to do that you have to ask the question
- 1:00:35Speaker 6: what caused Islam to be so civilized in about eight
- 1:00:39Speaker 6: hundred eighty what caused the science? Were there were great scientists,
- 1:00:43Speaker 6: you know what the number system we used today.
- 1:00:46Speaker 3: It's Arabic.
- 1:00:48Speaker 6: Double entry bookkeeping came from Arab the Arab world. So
- 1:00:53Speaker 6: you know, if you're an accounting student, everything you you
- 1:00:55Speaker 6: know the double entry basic accounting system. It's not Western Europe.
- 1:00:58Speaker 6: That's that's in the Middle East. So they had it.
- 1:01:03Speaker 3: What was it?
- 1:01:05Speaker 6: So when the Arabs conquered the Middle East, they conquered
- 1:01:07Speaker 6: the Byzantine Empire, what did they discover, Well, they discovered
- 1:01:12Speaker 6: Greek philosophy, they discovered Greek ideas.
- 1:01:15Speaker 3: They discovered Aristotle.
- 1:01:18Speaker 6: And if you read Muslim philosophers of the eight, nine,
- 1:01:21Speaker 6: ten to eleventh centuries, they are engaged in a debate
- 1:01:25Speaker 6: and a discussion with Aristotle over reason, and they have
- 1:01:31Speaker 6: to make a choice because they face these two things.
- 1:01:35Speaker 6: They have a Quran, they have a Holy Bible, right,
- 1:01:37Speaker 6: their Holy Bible that says this is what you must do.
- 1:01:41Speaker 6: And they have Aristotle it says go by reason, go
- 1:01:43Speaker 6: by your mind. And they're struggling, how do we how
- 1:01:46Speaker 6: do we faith versus reason?
- 1:01:48Speaker 3: You know that debate.
- 1:01:50Speaker 6: The Muslims are having that debate in eight hundred eighty
- 1:01:55Speaker 6: and as long as they have that debate, this civilization
- 1:01:58Speaker 6: does okay, because it's still kept alive. At some point
- 1:02:03Speaker 6: they decide they've settled the debate. What side do you
- 1:02:07Speaker 6: think they settled the debate on on faith? And they
- 1:02:10Speaker 6: rejected reason. There's a famous uh Muslim philosophy, Al Ghazali,
- 1:02:15Speaker 6: a famous philosopher who goes into the desert to consider
- 1:02:18Speaker 6: this question of faithless his reason, and he comes back
- 1:02:21Speaker 6: and he said, I've got the solution. It's abandoned reason.
- 1:02:25Speaker 6: Embrace faith. The Quran is the truth, that is it.
- 1:02:29Speaker 6: At the same time in the West, who is the
- 1:02:31Speaker 6: philosopher who has the same discovery and the same debate
- 1:02:34Speaker 6: going on in his own mind? Thomas Aquinas Thomas Aquinas,
- 1:02:40Speaker 6: same thing, discovers Aristotle and beings Aristotle into the Catholic
- 1:02:44Speaker 6: Church and has that debate, And at some point during
- 1:02:48Speaker 6: the Enlightenment, the West decided faithless his reason, mostly reason.
- 1:02:54Speaker 6: Faith relegated to your personal life, to your family life, home,
- 1:02:58Speaker 6: but mostly reason. And it's flurished. So what do we
- 1:03:02Speaker 6: need to get the Muslims to do? Embrace reason? We
- 1:03:05Speaker 6: discover Aristotle?
- 1:03:06Speaker 3: How do we do that? God knows?
- 1:03:11Speaker 6: Really hard, because they're so entrenched in their religion, in
- 1:03:16Speaker 6: their Qur'an, in a belief in faith, not it. I
- 1:03:19Speaker 6: mean there are lots of anecdotes about this, things like
- 1:03:22Speaker 6: how many books do they translate from European languages into Arabic?
- 1:03:28Speaker 6: Almost none, very few, Right, they don't, they don't. They're
- 1:03:33Speaker 6: not engaged much in science, they're not engaged much in
- 1:03:37Speaker 6: reason based activities, studying, learning, scientific inquiry, and as a consequence,
- 1:03:43Speaker 6: they're poor and the fanatical and the suicidal. Because that's
- 1:03:50Speaker 6: what a complete dedication the faith of a reason leads
- 1:03:54Speaker 6: you to. This is why reason is such an important element.
- 1:03:58Speaker 6: This is why it is what makes the way the West.
- 1:04:01Speaker 6: You want the Islamic world to change, it has to
- 1:04:05Speaker 6: recognize that, and that is a that is going to
- 1:04:08Speaker 6: take some time.
- 1:04:09Speaker 3: But you know what it really must take. It takes
- 1:04:11Speaker 3: us recognizing that in ourselves.
- 1:04:14Speaker 6: Unless we're willing to fight for reason, nobody else is
- 1:04:18Speaker 6: going to adopt it. They have to look at us
- 1:04:20Speaker 6: and say, wow, we want to.
- 1:04:21Speaker 3: Be like you. What's your secret? And the secret is
- 1:04:26Speaker 3: the Enlightenment.
- 1:04:27Speaker 6: If we could market the Enlightenment, that's when we when
- 1:04:30Speaker 6: we haven't been marketing the Enlightenment. When just as you know,
- 1:04:34Speaker 6: when Arab when wealthy Arabs in the late nineteenth century
- 1:04:38Speaker 6: early twentieth century. I know I have to finish just
- 1:04:39Speaker 6: this last story. When wealthy Arabs in the late nineteenth
- 1:04:42Speaker 6: century early twentieth century wanted their kids to get a
- 1:04:45Speaker 6: great education, where did they send them.
- 1:04:47Speaker 3: They wanted to be like the West. They looked at
- 1:04:49Speaker 3: the West.
- 1:04:50Speaker 6: This is the late nineteenth century. The West is becoming rich.
- 1:04:52Speaker 6: This stuck in the Ottoman Empire. It's going nowhere, nothing's happening.
- 1:04:56Speaker 6: They send their kids to Europe to get educated. And
- 1:04:59Speaker 6: what do they look learn in Europe? They don't earn
- 1:05:04Speaker 6: reason because this is the this is not the Enlightenment anymore.
- 1:05:07Speaker 3: This is the nineteenth century.
- 1:05:08Speaker 6: They learned German romanticism and French who knows what right
- 1:05:13Speaker 6: they learn egalitarianism, fascism, communism, that's what they learn because
- 1:05:20Speaker 6: that's what we are teaching, anti reason, anti enlightenment, anti
- 1:05:24Speaker 6: political freedom, anti individualism ideas. We in the West have
- 1:05:29Speaker 6: being teaching collectivism in our universities for well over one
- 1:05:33Speaker 6: hundred years.
- 1:05:34Speaker 3: And this is primelion Europe.
- 1:05:36Speaker 6: So when they when those Arabs who went there to
- 1:05:38Speaker 6: learn what how the West got rich come back to
- 1:05:42Speaker 6: their world, they bring with them fascism and communism.
- 1:05:46Speaker 3: So when they get into power.
- 1:05:47Speaker 6: And this is for example, the Boss Party that ruled
- 1:05:50Speaker 6: the Rock and Syria.
- 1:05:52Speaker 3: Before us said was just deposed Boss Party.
- 1:05:55Speaker 6: If you look at their manifesto, it's Mussolini's fascist manifesto
- 1:06:01Speaker 6: translated into Arabic. So what they learned all the bad
- 1:06:04Speaker 6: ideas of the West and they implemented those. And then
- 1:06:08Speaker 6: when those didn't work, who do they blame the West?
- 1:06:11Speaker 6: And now the skeptical of anything we tell them because
- 1:06:14Speaker 6: we taught them bad stuff. And by the way, just
- 1:06:17Speaker 6: this one additional story, right, where did Americans send their
- 1:06:21Speaker 6: kids if they wanted to get the best education in
- 1:06:23Speaker 6: the world In the late nineteenth century Europe Germany France
- 1:06:30Speaker 6: primarily the two worst places in the world you would
- 1:06:34Speaker 6: want to send your kids to get an education, bad
- 1:06:37Speaker 6: bad ideas? And what did they return with with all
- 1:06:40Speaker 6: the bad ideas we're seeing in our campuses today. And
- 1:06:42Speaker 6: by the way, when Harvard and Princeton and Yale wanted
- 1:06:46Speaker 6: to become world class institutions, they wanted to be the
- 1:06:49Speaker 6: best universities in the world, where did they get their
- 1:06:51Speaker 6: professors from Germany and France who bought with them all
- 1:06:56Speaker 6: the collected see Germany and France never went through and
- 1:06:59Speaker 6: American Revolution. They never had individualism as the standard, or
- 1:07:04Speaker 6: Fance did for a little bit, but then it got crushed, right.
- 1:07:07Speaker 6: They were mired with collectivism and they brought that to
- 1:07:11Speaker 6: the United States into our best institutions, into our elite institutions,
- 1:07:16Speaker 6: and we've never recovered. They've only just spread from there
- 1:07:21Speaker 6: to infect everything. So it's those ideas that the progressive movement,
- 1:07:25Speaker 6: it was called the progressive movements in those days. Those
- 1:07:27Speaker 6: were European ideas that were brought into America, and America
- 1:07:31Speaker 6: didn't have the founding fathers to protect itself, it didn't
- 1:07:34Speaker 6: have intellectuals of that caliber, so we just folded and
- 1:07:38Speaker 6: the Europeans dominated us, and you know, we'd become much
- 1:07:42Speaker 6: more of a European country rather than what America used
- 1:07:45Speaker 6: to be. And on that depressing note, thank
- 1:07:49Speaker 5: You, thank you very much, and I hope everyone here