Latest / The World of Higher Education / What a Second Trump Presidency Could Mean for US Higher Education with Brendan Cantwell
Transcript
- 0:01Hi everyone.
- 0:02I'm Alex Usher, and this is the World of Higher Education Podcast.
- 0:07This fall, much of the world's attention is focused on the United States, where
- 0:11Vice President Kamala Harris is squaring off with former President Donald Trump in
- 0:16the presidential election on November 5th.
- 0:20Education was one piece of the government apparatus where Trump 1.
- 0:230 was not actually all that radical.
- 0:26Yes, he appointed Betsy DeVos, a passionate advocate for private
- 0:29education and voucher schemes, to be his Secretary of Education.
- 0:33But on the post-secondary file as a whole, the administration
- 0:36did not leave much of a legacy.
- 0:39True, towards the end of the mandate, there were emerging themes of trying
- 0:42to force universities to be anti woke.
- 0:45On the other hand, the Trump administration did add a fair bit
- 0:47of new funding to historically black colleges and universities.
- 0:51However, the world's changed a lot in four years and few now expect a Trump 2.
- 0:560 administration to be anywhere near as benign.
- 1:01Today, my guest is Michigan State University, professor of higher
- 1:03education, Brendan Cantwell.
- 1:06Faithful readers and listeners may remember that Brendan came on the show
- 1:09in the spring to argue, among other things, that Conservative opposition
- 1:14to higher education at the state level was to a certain degree, performative.
- 1:18Conservatives were largely happy to fund education, but really,
- 1:22they just wanted something to fight about in the culture wars.
- 1:24Not necessarily to win, just to keep the fight going.
- 1:28Over the summer though, Brendan wrote a couple of pieces, pointing out
- 1:31that a Trump win in 2024 might end up being a lot less performative, and
- 1:35do some real damage to the system.
- 1:37Damage from which it might have a hard time recovering.
- 1:41He's focused not just on potential Republican control of the White House
- 1:44and Congress, he's also pointed to the significant role that a Trump Supreme
- 1:48Court could play in shaping higher education policy, and indeed arguably has
- 1:52done so over the past four years through such cases as Students for Fair Admissions
- 1:57that was decided in the summer of 2023.
- 2:00Another Trump win might seal a right wing, a right leaning court for a generation.
- 2:05Very hard to come back from.
- 2:08Anyways, this discussion is lively and Brendan, as usual,
- 2:10is thoughtful and provocative.
- 2:12So let's turn it over to him.
- 2:15So, Brendan, we're talking about the potential effects of a second
- 2:19Trump regime or administration.
- 2:24Let's start off by being clear about what it is that a federal
- 2:27government can or can't do.
- 2:29What is the federal role in higher education in the United States?
- 2:33Sure.
- 2:33The Constitution of the United States gives the states the authority
- 2:38to supply and regulate education.
- 2:42But over the, you know, the decades and centuries, the federal government
- 2:49has taken a much more active role in, um, in higher education.
- 2:54It's main role uh, is to run the student financial aid system.
- 3:00So the federal government runs the large student loan system
- 3:04that many, many students use to participate in higher education.
- 3:08It offers the largest need based grant system, um, much larger than
- 3:14the most state financial aid systems.
- 3:17In addition to the financial aid role, it is also the main,
- 3:21supporter of research, right?
- 3:23So funds about 60 percent of the academic research that happens in the country.
- 3:28And through those, um, those two big roles, uh, organizing student
- 3:35financial aid and funding research, it also is able to regulate the
- 3:40sector by attaching a lot of strings to participation in those programs.
- 3:46Um, the federal financial aid system in particular has allowed enrollments
- 3:52to grow quite rapidly, or allowed enrollments to grow quite rapidly in
- 3:56the second half of the 20th century.
- 3:58And I think it's probably not really conceivable to think of the scale
- 4:04of the sector in the United States, States today without the federal
- 4:07government playing that pivotal role of financing student access.
- 4:12Um, so students could come with the aid federal government
- 4:16provided and pay tuition and that money really fueled, fueled the
- 4:20expansion of the, of the sector.
- 4:23And so with the 2024 election cycle is now underway, uh, normally we have, uh,
- 4:29a dynamic at least for the last 30 or 40 years of the Democrats being, um, more
- 4:34favorable to the higher education sector, more favorable to students, um, I assume
- 4:39that's happening again this time, but how big a deal is higher education within
- 4:43the, you know, the overall campaign?
- 4:46It doesn't seem to me like it's taking a lot of, um, of attention
- 4:50the way it has in previous cycles.
- 4:53Almost no attention to higher education this cycle.
- 4:56The last couple of cycles, you saw both parties talking quite
- 5:01a bit about higher education.
- 5:03Both parties more or less promised to make higher education,
- 5:07um, cheaper for students.
- 5:08So lowering the price, um, and to try to focus on making credentials,
- 5:15qualifications more economically relevant.
- 5:17So improving the return.
- 5:19Um, neither party was especially specific about how they could
- 5:23accomplish either of those things.
- 5:25Um, but, but they both kind of talked about how they wanted to do it, right?
- 5:29Make higher education work, make it cheaper, um, uh,
- 5:32get students in, into jobs.
- 5:34Democrats also, you know, in the— starting in 2020 really took up the mantle of
- 5:40reducing loan burdens for students.
- 5:43So Biden promised to, um, forgive student loans and also to expand, uh, uh, programs
- 5:52that would modify the way that students repay their student loans and maybe
- 5:56provide, um, relief to people who, um, participate in public service occupations.
- 6:03Um, the courts have more or less shut down the Democrats
- 6:06student loan forgiveness plans.
- 6:08Um, and so Democrats don't want to talk about it and Republicans don't really
- 6:13have any sort of appealing programs for, for the public to, to latch on to.
- 6:20So they're not explicitly talking about higher education in the campaign.
- 6:25Although I will say Trump's website has some ideas about
- 6:28higher education listed on it.
- 6:30So far as I know, the Democrats really have not advanced any specific
- 6:34plans, but Trump is not really talking about the plans that he claims to
- 6:39have for higher education, which is basically to establish a kind of
- 6:43alternative credential National Academy.
- 6:46Um, how that would work, kind of unclear.
- 6:49Um, if people are interested or care about that, also pretty unclear.
- 6:54Um, so it's not a big issue.
- 6:56So one of the things that you know, you've written about recently is,
- 7:00uh, the threat that a second Trump administration would pose to, to
- 7:04higher education and how the federal government could kill higher education.
- 7:07I think that was the title of one of the, uh, your recent blogs.
- 7:11You were on the show a few months ago and you argued that conservatism
- 7:15in, at least at the state level was of— around higher education
- 7:18issues was often very performative.
- 7:21Clearly, you don't think that's true at the federal level.
- 7:23What's different?
- 7:24Yeah, so I think the federal level, there is the power and perhaps
- 7:30the desire to really reshape the sector and to end it as we know it.
- 7:36And the clearest mechanism to do that would be to cut off the federal financial
- 7:42aid system and particularly the student loan system to either bring that down
- 7:46to zero or to dramatically reshape that.
- 7:50I think that there are some indications in the conservative, I would say the right,
- 7:56the right wing, um, sort of intellectual branch of the Republican party where,
- 8:02um, they see the federal role and supp— supplying higher education, basically,
- 8:08through the loan system as contrary to the constitution and very likely
- 8:13contrary to their political interests and would be quite interested in either
- 8:20redesigning it or eliminating it.
- 8:23Um, so I, I think that that is the main tool that they could have,
- 8:28which, which would be to, to rework the, the loan and, um, grant system.
- 8:33We can talk about how, how that might, how might that might play out.
- 8:36The other way that they can do it would be to, um, uh, uh, to, to
- 8:42dramatically reduce or change the way science funding works, right?
- 8:46So, um, the, uh, the federal government could, um, uh, very much re— reduce
- 8:56how much is spent on research.
- 8:58They could direct research to be spent in particular research funding to go in
- 9:04particular ways, like no climate studies, um, no, no, uh, no climate change studies.
- 9:10They could put strings on the kind of, um, uh, ways that grants support the
- 9:17administrative overhead of universities.
- 9:19One of their specific proposals is to really cut down on the
- 9:24amount of overhead support that the federal government provides.
- 9:27So those are the broad strokes way that they could do this.
- 9:31Well, okay, let's get to the means in a second here, but I'm wondering
- 9:34why the politics are different.
- 9:36I mean, if I think, you know, uh, at the state level, You know, there's
- 9:41a lot of performative vitriol, but at the end of the day, every, you
- 9:46know, most, most, um, people in state legislatures have got, um, you know,
- 9:52post secondary education institutions close to their, um, their institutions.
- 9:58They don't really want them shut down.
- 9:59They want them to keep having money.
- 10:00Surely that's true in Congress, too.
- 10:02I mean, if you stop putting money into, um, uh, student financial
- 10:06aid into the Pell Grant system that would close a lot of institutions
- 10:09and hurt a lot of Congress people.
- 10:11So what would be the incentive of Congress to go — even a Republican
- 10:15Congress to go along with a move like that by President Trump?
- 10:20Good question.
- 10:20And what you've described, I think, definitely captures how
- 10:23things have worked in the past.
- 10:25Um, there has been bipartisan support for expanding student
- 10:30financial aid programs, for example.
- 10:32Um, even if there were ideological opposition by individual members
- 10:37of Congress, they never wanted to hurt the colleges in their district.
- 10:41Always been the thing that they focus on, and they've also always wanted to
- 10:47provide college access to the constituents in their district who have demanded it.
- 10:51I think what's changed is the nationalization of everything and
- 10:55the, um, the effect on individual districts, particularly in districts
- 11:02where there's not, um, a chance of the party flipping, so what really
- 11:07matters is in the primary, ideological adherence is so much more important.
- 11:12And so, uh, you could see a Republican Congress going along with, um, with some
- 11:19pretty dramatic things that would hurt the institutions in their district, because it
- 11:25would be consistent with their ideological program and they would perceive it as
- 11:28in the interest of the Republican party.
- 11:31Um, at the state level, sort of posturing and exerting some control over the culture
- 11:39of public higher education is really important, but at the end of the day,
- 11:42the governors and state legislatures still are closer to the institutions
- 11:48and to the constituents, who, um, who, who may be angry at universities
- 11:52but don't want to see them go away.
- 11:54Okay, so you mentioned the possibility that they might try to end or
- 11:57curtail, um, student financial aid.
- 12:01How would they do that?
- 12:02I mean, that's is that I mean, again, one of the issues or where the, the
- 12:05Biden administration stumbled, I think, on student loan forgiveness has been
- 12:09overstepping its power with the power of the presidency vis a vis Congress, right?
- 12:14Like, who actually has the power to make this policy?
- 12:17So, um, you know, if you were part of the Trump administration coming in
- 12:22in January, how would you go about, um, getting rid of student aid?
- 12:28I think it would be challenging to get rid of it completely.
- 12:31I think that, um, there are ways that an administration...
- 12:38So, The courts have said that the Biden administration
- 12:42can't forgive student loans.
- 12:44Um, the, there is an established precedent that the administration, and
- 12:50working with Congress can decide on how student loans are administered.
- 12:55And, one proposal that is in Project 2025 policy document that your
- 13:02listeners may have may have heard of, it's a, um, it's a sort of manifesto
- 13:06from a right wing think tank.
- 13:08That is, uh, many people believe is a blueprint for the plans of the
- 13:13administration, calls for a sort of dramatic privatization of the student
- 13:17loan system that would allow banks, not only to issue the loans, the federally
- 13:25guaranteed loans, which happened under the Bush administration, right?
- 13:28So this isn't— that part is established uh conservative thought.
- 13:32And this happened legally in the United States before, but would
- 13:36do a couple of other things.
- 13:38It would shift the priority of the student loan system to making money for
- 13:43the federal government in the banks.
- 13:45And right now, the student loan system is supposed to primarily provide aid and
- 13:51access and it, it says that, um, it calls the federal interest in providing those
- 14:01loans suspicious and, um, indicates that only banks have the right information and
- 14:07incentive to make the loans, which would allow potentially banks to decide who um,
- 14:15is, uh, receives federal financial aid and, um, to what programs or institutions
- 14:21they receive federal financial aid.
- 14:23That kind of a move would, basically, uh, has the potential to reshape or
- 14:31dramatically reduce the aid system because right now it's a quasi entitlement.
- 14:39If you qualify, uh, if you attend college, um, and you qualify for federal aid,
- 14:48there's a formula that determines whether you require financial aid to be able to
- 14:52pay for college, then you are more or less guaranteed access to a student loan.
- 14:58It doesn't matter if, what program you're going to, it doesn't matter um, whether
- 15:04you're creditworthy or not, um, there's no determination of creditworthiness,
- 15:08you are entitled to a, to a loan.
- 15:10Now, the backstop to that has always been that the students
- 15:13can't discharge that loan.
- 15:15And that's where the loan forgiveness stuff gets in.
- 15:18So the idea is we're making this sort of guaranteeing you the right to borrow
- 15:23the money that you need to go to college to participate in higher education, and
- 15:29in exchange, you're going to have to pay this back come hell or high water.
- 15:33And what the new rule is saying, uh, or what the, what the proposed
- 15:38rule would, um, would do, would say, umm actually, we're not really sure
- 15:45if you're entitled to this loan.
- 15:47Um, we're required to make some loans, but we don't think that we're required to make
- 15:53them to everybody under all circumstances.
- 15:56Um, but it would keep the, you've got to pay it back part.
- 15:59Um, so.
- 16:01It would, move it from, something like an entitlement program, to a market
- 16:07facilitated by the federal government, but, um, but administered by, by banks.
- 16:16Right.
- 16:17So I think I'm hearing you, I think I'm hearing you say that it's a, uh, it would
- 16:21be relatively easy to cut back on loans.
- 16:23You haven't talked about grants at all.
- 16:25So Pell, is there a way that Pell could be restricted?
- 16:28Uh, only through, through Congress.
- 16:31Uh, to get rid of Pell, there are lots of possibilities that a Trump
- 16:39administration could experiment with and see if the courts let it fly.
- 16:44Um, for example, saying institutions are not eligible to receive, uh, um,
- 16:50uh, Pell Grants or other forms of federal aid if they violate ideological
- 16:56balance tests or free speech tests.
- 16:59Right.
- 17:00Um, uh, and wh— so to individually, kind of red line campuses.
- 17:07It's not clear whether the courts would go for that or not.
- 17:10I think the idea that the courts would apply the same standard of,
- 17:15um, administrative restraint on a Trump administration as they
- 17:19have on a Biden administration is, is, is, that's an open question.
- 17:24Um, the courts have displayed asymmetrical preferences, at least the
- 17:31Supreme Court and many of the circuit courts for Republican administrations.
- 17:35And so Trump could be given much more deference in terms of
- 17:39administrative rulemaking and steering money than Biden could.
- 17:43Now, this is all kind of speculative and admittedly, some of it verges
- 17:48into conspiracy theory territory.
- 17:51The reason that I think that that is not beyond the pale right now is because we
- 17:58have this, this document, this Project 2025 document that is sprawling in scope,
- 18:04that is vague— that is hyper specific at some points and enormously vague
- 18:09in other points, and the points where it's pretty vague when you read the the
- 18:16recommendations for administrative action, the recommendations for what Congress
- 18:20should do, you know, Congress should do this, if not, then the administration
- 18:23should use its executive power to do that.
- 18:27The possibilities of interpretation are pretty wide, and I think they're wide
- 18:32intentionally to provide a lot of latitude for an administration to engage in a
- 18:38sort of, um, uh, politics of punishment through the higher education system.
- 18:44Brendan, we've spoken a little bit about the power of the presidency.
- 18:47We've spoken about the power of Congress.
- 18:50But there's a third branch of government, right?
- 18:52There's the Supreme Court.
- 18:53And I, you know, you've mentioned in some of your writing that, um, you know, maybe
- 18:58it's the Supreme Court that could do the, the real damage to higher education.
- 19:03What could the Supreme Court do beyond say what it's already done
- 19:05on, on race conscious admissions?
- 19:07And how likely is it that you think the court will take such actions?
- 19:11Yeah.
- 19:11So, uh, I think that one distinct possibility is that the court, if the
- 19:18court could find that the Department of Education is broadly inconsistent
- 19:24with the Constitution, because the Constitution, the Constitution does
- 19:27explicitly give powers of things like education to the states.
- 19:33And so um, on— one thing would be to challenge the authority
- 19:37of the department to engage in regulation that affects the states.
- 19:42So can the department set rules that interfere with the way that the states.
- 19:46The states, um, administer, uh, the provision of education.
- 19:51The courts could also knock out, in the same vein, sections of the
- 19:56Higher Education Act, or the Civil Rights Act, both of which limit,
- 20:02um, the way that state universities can, can, um, can operate.
- 20:10So some specific things that you see floated in conservative writing would
- 20:15be getting rid of any kind of proactive civil rights, um, policing through the
- 20:21Department of Education, getting rid of something called a Disparate Impact
- 20:26Standard, so that if a policy or practice at a state or an institution has a
- 20:31disproportionately negative or positive impact for a particular protected class.
- 20:36So it benefits students of a particular race disproportionately or harm students
- 20:41of it of a race disproportionately.
- 20:44The other area would be, uh, really anything related to gender equity.
- 20:49Um, and in particular, um, uh, uh, any effort to, um, ensure, um,
- 20:57protections for transgender students, um, the court has shown, some
- 21:03appetite to wade into those questions.
- 21:06Those were definitely not things that were specified in the, in, in the,
- 21:11the various congressional acts, right?
- 21:14So like Title Nine is used to enforce gender equity.
- 21:17Um, that's a fairly narrow provision that has been uh, interpreted in a wide way.
- 21:23And so the courts could say, no, none of this and all of the kind of
- 21:27efforts that the Biden administration has made to ensure, um, gender equity
- 21:32rights for transgender people, uh, I think those will kind of be struck
- 21:37down by the courts, no matter what.
- 21:39Well, so that brings me to the question.
- 21:41I mean, presumably the Supreme Court could do most of this all of it, uh,
- 21:45under a democratic administration, right?
- 21:46Like, these are decisions that Kamala Harris might have to deal with,
- 21:49they're not predicated on Trump coming back to power and Project
- 21:532025 being, uh, being enacted.
- 21:57Like, what's.
- 21:58I mean, how likely is it that it happens under a Kamala Harris government and
- 22:02what do you think would happen if those kinds of decisions were made?
- 22:05How would the, how would the administration react?
- 22:08Uh, well, the administration.
- 22:10I don't know how the administration would react.
- 22:12I think that if there is a Kamala Harris administration, you will
- 22:17see more of the same of what you've seen in recent years with the Biden
- 22:23administration Department of Education.
- 22:25I mean, the courts are in the process of invalidating much of
- 22:27the Title Nine guidance underway.
- 22:30The courts have more or less eliminated all of the loan, um, the loan forgiveness
- 22:36programs that Biden wanted to enact and are showing some level of skepticism about
- 22:42existing public service programs, which are congressionally authorized programs to
- 22:49reduce student loan debt based on whether you work in a public service occupation.
- 22:55I think what you'll see in a, in a Harris administration would be the
- 22:59tussle between the states and the federal government where the federal government
- 23:05would be interested in ensuring, um, using existing stat, you know, existing
- 23:10statute to expand civil rights.
- 23:13That's something that, uh, Democrats have a track record of doing and something that
- 23:18a Harris administration would seem likely to want to do based on the campaign, the
- 23:22courts, the states would be especially Republican states would be especially
- 23:26hostile to those, I think that opens up the possibility for the court to make
- 23:31narrow rulings, striking down particular particular rules, and potentially much
- 23:36broader rulings that hollow out some of these landmark pieces of legislation, um,
- 23:42like, like the Higher Ed Act, like the Civil Rights Act, um, and that would be
- 23:48consistent with what we've seen before.
- 23:51Like when the Roberts Court hollowed out the Voting Rights Act
- 23:55during the Obama administration.
- 23:57Right.
- 23:57All right.
- 23:58So another, I guess, route to policy change that you've raised
- 24:02as a possibility is the dismantling of accreditation standards.
- 24:06Um, you know, I mean, accreditation is regional, but I guess there are some
- 24:11kinds of national standards that I, um.
- 24:15Um, that a president could mess with.
- 24:19What are the methods of policy change in this area?
- 24:21And are there any checks and balances to, to ensure that, uh,
- 24:24you know, nothing too dire actually happens to quality assurance?
- 24:28The short answer is that I think that this is an area where a Trump administration,
- 24:36for example, could do quite a lot to change the way that higher education
- 24:43is governed in the United States.
- 24:45Because the federal government is able currently and historically to attach
- 24:53conditions on eligibility of participating in the federal financial aid program,
- 24:57they have attached a sort of quality assurance measure to that through
- 25:02the form of regional accreditation.
- 25:05Quality assurance in the U.S.
- 25:06is decentralized.
- 25:07It's highly critiqued.
- 25:08I'm sure you could do a whole series of, of quality assurance podcasts,
- 25:12but basically it's, it's, um, it's devolved to a set of regional
- 25:18non for profit organizations that engage in a kind of peer review of
- 25:23institutions to get to certify that it meets the standards of good quality
- 25:29provision, you know, in in the region.
- 25:32And those regional standards are more or less nat— have more
- 25:37or less nationalized, right?
- 25:38But recently, conservatives have come out against it as saying it's constraining
- 25:45their ability in the states to, um, to govern higher education the way that
- 25:50they want to particularly govern the curriculum and, um, have a stronger voice,
- 25:55the state government have a stronger voice in the curriculum, and it forces
- 25:59institutions to participate in diversity, equity and inclusion programs, because
- 26:04that sort of thing, inclusive education is one of the sort of quality standards.
- 26:08So what, uh, what some conservative groups have floated and what seems
- 26:13like it could be a plausible plank in a Trump administration higher
- 26:16education policy would be to allow states to self accreditate.
- 26:21So rather than the accreditation coming from these outside regional bodies,
- 26:27states could establish their own quality assurance boards that would do whatever
- 26:32the state wanted it to do, and, that would be good enough to participate
- 26:36in the federal financial aid policies.
- 26:39This could allow, um, deep red states to really take control of their public
- 26:46higher education systems in terms of the curriculum and the way that it
- 26:51handled gender equity, race equity and things like that in ways that, um, would
- 26:59would be, um, would not be possible under the current accreditation system.
- 27:05The potential is that state higher education systems would have
- 27:08very different quality standards and very different standards
- 27:12around cultural standards around academic freedom around inclusion.
- 27:17And that would be a big change, right?
- 27:19That would be a huge change in US higher education.
- 27:22It's interesting because that's actually how Canadian provinces do it.
- 27:25They're, implicitly they're self accrediting, but nobody's got
- 27:28hugely varying views on what the right things to accredit on, right?
- 27:33On the substance.
- 27:34So that's kind of interesting.
- 27:36We had Simon Marginson on a couple of weeks ago, and we were talking about
- 27:39whether or not, um, institutions anywhere in the world were very good at resisting,
- 27:46uh, populist, or in some cases, fascist governments, like, you know, what can
- 27:50an institution do to protect itself?
- 27:53And I think Simon's reaction was not much, right?
- 27:57Um, and you mentioned last time you were on that, that, that higher education
- 28:01just doesn't have many friends.
- 28:02Um, in, you know, there's not many champions outside their own sector.
- 28:06Um, do you think that's likely to change in the next six months or,
- 28:09is the sector as exposed as it looks, uh, is it, is it going to
- 28:14be that exposed come January 20th?
- 28:16Yeah, I think the sector is pretty exposed.
- 28:19Um, what has protected it so far has been broad public support.
- 28:25We know that's eroding, um, strong within sector norms so that it was hard to
- 28:31find many, um, institutions that were willing to break the mold and go along
- 28:38with ideas that were seen as, beyond, um, you know, what was normal or acceptable
- 28:45in higher education and politicians who weren't really interested in challenging
- 28:50those norms, at least not explicitly.
- 28:51So, those conditions are eroding.
- 28:57There are very few legal or formal mechanisms, um, that protect institutions,
- 29:03even private institutions, um, which are exposed to, um, uh, to the federal
- 29:11government through its, through its ability to attach strings to, to, to aid
- 29:16and grant and research grants and, um, and so I think that, um, institutions
- 29:24aren't practiced at this, and even if they were to, to think very clearly about
- 29:29how to defend themselves, there aren't clear, um, there aren't clear avenues
- 29:35to, to remedy, um, to, to remedy the kind of, um, uh, overtures that, that the
- 29:43federal or state governments might make.
- 29:45Um, so.
- 29:47The short answer is I think Simon's basically right.
- 29:50There's not much institutions can do.
- 29:53To the extent that institutions can protect themselves, I think it's
- 29:58through direct appeals to people.
- 30:01Um, and, uh, they are reluctant to do that, um, because they're not
- 30:07practiced at doing it, they might be bad at it, and they might find
- 30:11that people aren't on their side.
- 30:13Right.
- 30:13So you've laid out what I think is a worst case scenario if Trump wins.
- 30:18Is there a best case scenario or maybe even just a better case scenario?
- 30:22Uh, what, what's, what's the best thing that could emerge
- 30:24from a second Trump presidency?
- 30:26Yeah, I think the best case scenario, which is not an unlikely scenario, it's
- 30:33a reasonably likely scenario, is that Trump doesn't give much attention to,
- 30:39um, the, uh, to higher education policy.
- 30:43I think that they will almost certainly do things around, um, Title
- 30:48Nine and really try to, um, prevent institutions from, um, allowing students
- 30:57to change their, their gender for federal reporting and other things.
- 31:03I think that they will, um, revert to the kind of Betsy DeVos guidance
- 31:09on Title Nine, which gives, um, uh, students who are accused of committing,
- 31:15um, sexual assault in a relationship, harassment and violence, a lot of
- 31:20rights, um, uh, that sort of cultural stuff will almost certainly happen.
- 31:27They will almost certainly get rid of a few of the accountability metrics in terms
- 31:32of gainful employment and good outcomes that Democrats have championed in part
- 31:39because they are much more sympathetic to the interests of for profit institutions
- 31:43that have been gotten the, that have been at the business end of those regulations.
- 31:48So I think the best case scenario is just kind of the flip flop that
- 31:52we have in federal regulation, where you get a new set of rules every
- 31:58time you get a new party in power.
- 32:01Um, and that's, you know, I'd say that that's one of the likelier scenarios.
- 32:06Um, but I think what's changed is that that's not, like, um, the
- 32:13certainty of that is much lower than it would have been, than it would be
- 32:16under, say, a Nikki Haley presidency.
- 32:19We could imagine that's what would happen if Nikki Haley
- 32:21were to become the president.
- 32:23Now, like, that's on the table.
- 32:26Um, but so is like everything else.
- 32:29And that kind of uncertainty is very hard for the sector to prepare for.
- 32:35Brandon Cantwell.
- 32:35Thank you so much for joining us.
- 32:37Thank you very much.
- 32:38It was fun.
- 32:39And it just remains for us to thank our excellent producers,
- 32:42Tiffany McLennan and Sam Pufek, and you, our listeners for tuning in.
- 32:46If you have any questions or comments about today's episode
- 32:49or suggestions for future ones, please don't hesitate to contact
- 32:52us at podcast@higheredstrategy.com.
- 32:57Join us next week when my guest will be Mary C.
- 33:00Wright.
- 33:01She's the author of Centres for Teaching and Learning, The New
- 33:03Landscape and Higher Education.
- 33:05She's from Brown University and we'll be talking to her
- 33:08about this fascinating subject.
- 33:11We'll be back in a week's time.
- 33:12Bye for now.