Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Guest Host Todd Caputo, Ford Slashes Mach-E Prices, Standalone Used
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, it's Wednesday. We're coming in hot today. We have special guest Todd Caputo coming in to us live from the Admirals Lounge in the Charlotte Airport.
- 0:08We're gonna talk about Ford cutting prices on the Mach-E and the difference between standalone used cars and digital-only used car sales.
- 0:15It's an interesting topic and, uh, one that I think is, uh, coming up for a lot of people, and it's great to have Todd here talking about it. Todd, how you doing today? Hey. Good morning. How you doing, Paul?
- 0:24Good to see you. You are running, like, all over the country all the time now. Um, so it's- It's fun. I like it... it- It's good... I can tell. You're smiling. Good to stay busy. You're much- Good to be busy...
- 0:32more relaxed than you were when you were, like, in the stores every day. [laughs] You got this whole vibe- Oh, I was-... about you... still as relaxed back then. No. [laughs] No, I'm good. Yeah, right. Having fun.
- 0:41You're still having fun, though? Yeah. Having fun. Not quite as I get to be around-... you last-... car dealers every day... I know it. Yeah. When I'm around dealers every day, it puts a smile on my face. Likewise.
- 0:48Likewise. Well, um, speaking of being around dealers, just wanna let everybody know we have a few great things happening right now. Um, today at 1:00 PM, we have our next ASOTU Edge webinar.
- 0:59It's with our friends at Upstart Auto Retail. They're gonna give us the results of a 100-dealer survey that they did, so speaking ab- about being around dealers and what they're thinking.
- 1:08We're gonna be, uh, answering a lot of questions and providing a lot of insights. I'm gonna be with my friend Keishaun Batts. Um, he's gonna be walking us through the survey. Very quick webinar. Very fast, 25 minutes.
- 1:20You're in, you're out. It's a lot of fun. You can go to asotu.com. It's right there when you, uh, when you land on the page. Just scroll up a tiny little bit. You can register for free. Hope you join us today at 1:00.
- 1:30It's gonna be worth it, 'cause every dealer wants to know what other dealers are thinking. That's just how it works. Um, also, ASOTU CON is only 83 days away now.
- 1:38Um, we are updating the speaker page on a regular basis now. It's gonna be in May 15- 14th through 17th. Main day is 15, 16.
- 1:46We have a lot of great announcements of dealer groups who are actually doing their inve- events in conjunction with ASOTU CON.
- 1:52So it's gonna be full of dealers, it's gonna be full of industry partners, uh, very innovative ones. Um, really, we're, we're starting to talk about it like the most innovative ideas in auto are born at ASOTU CON.
- 2:01We can often track conversations that happened at ASOTU CON through actual, like, product development and implementation. So still early bird tickets right now. That's gonna change, uh, probably in just a few days here.
- 2:12And, uh, we're gonna have a lot of, a lot of great panels. Go to the speakers page. You can start to see, um, I don't know, we probably have 20 or so up there, but we're gonna have over 50 amazing speakers.
- 2:21And if you go look at the speakers page right now, you're gonna be like, "Oh," like, "this isn't, like, you know, some new guy. This is very experienced industry expertise, people on the forefront." So, uh, check it out.
- 2:31Todd's gonna be there. You were there last year. You're gonna be there again- You bet I'm gonna be there... of course. Yeah, you bet I'm gonna be there. I can't wait. What was your favorite...
- 2:36What was- Best conference of the year... how would you explain the, the kind of like overall vibe of the people and the, the conversations at ASOTU CON? I mean, it's not a typical trade show by any means.
- 2:48Uh, the kind of people that show up at ASOTU CON are very forward-thinking car dealers and also very forward-thinking vendors and other people that are in the industry.
- 2:57And, um, you have intimate conversations, uh, that you're not gonna probably have at NADA. It's not quite as, uh, you don't have the hustle and bustle of NADA. Mm-hmm.
- 3:06Um, and I've just made a lot of great contacts, you know, come, you know, at ASOTU CON.
- 3:11And, uh, I know that the people that have attended that I've met have been really, really grateful that, uh, they've been able to attend and, and made some really good partnerships and friendships there.
- 3:19I just, I think it's, it's cutting edge, which I am, as you know. And, um, I, I can't wait. I think, you know, this is the third one right now. Isn't this the third one, Paul? This is number three. Number three.
- 3:28Third time's a charm. Yeah. Uh, last year was amazing, right? And I think that this year's gonna be even better with between all the people that you've got speaking.
- 3:37I've already seen a, a list of the, a lot of the attendees. I think it's gonna be an amazing conference, and I can't wait. And it's easy to get to, right? You fly into BWI. I think it's 15 minutes away. Not even.
- 3:46It's a piece of cake. Yeah. Yeah. Real easy to get to. It's, it's awesome. We try to do that, 'cause no one likes an hour drive in traffic after you land. That's the worst. No. Uh, some of the speakers- No...
- 3:55you, you know some of these names: Steve Greenfield; Mike Stanton, president of NADA; Daniel Govier; David Spisak; Ed Roberts; Erica Tiffany-Welds; Mike Cavanaugh from Lithia; Andrew DeFeo; Andy Gulcher; Ashley Cavazos; Dan Bannister.
- 4:07I could go on. We have, uh, four, four auto dealer association presidents who are going to be in attendance. So, um, you know, we just have a lot of representation of dealers in the dealer body there.
- 4:19And so, uh, we just wanna make sure that you get there, too. Uh, we're gonna, we're, we're likely gonna sell out this year. The venue can't hold everybody. So, uh, hope you can get some tickets and be there as well.
- 4:30All right. Let's talk about a little bit of news. Um, I wanna get to the last story. But it's appropriate, I think, Todd, that we have you as a guest today, because now you live in Charlotte.
- 4:37You're Charlotte, um, Charlotte-based. And today in 1948 was when NASCAR was founded by Bill France Sr.
- 4:46He was a race-loving mechanic, uh, who was tired of going to races where, um, the promoters would run off with the prize money, actually, which is why he actually started- That's cool...
- 4:55NASCAR, to standardize the ruling and enforce fair competition and, uh, serve as its first president. And obviously NASCAR has become a major, uh, American spectator sport, created a multi-billion dollar industry.
- 5:07And Todd, you kind of live in, like, like Nas- I'm in NASCAR heaven. I'm in Nor- I'm in, I'm in Mooresville. Like, that's NASCAR heaven. You ca- you saw my place, right? Like- Absolutely... it's everywhere. I love it.
- 5:16Yeah, it's awesome. So if you don't, if you don't understand this, people, you know, in most normal places in the world, there's like a house with a garage.
- 5:24Well, in, [laughs] in, in Mooresville in the area you live, they have these neighborhoods that is basically a garage with a living quarters, right?
- 5:32They have these, and they, you can fit like 20 cars in these garages, and they have like apartments attached to them. It's a really special, cool thing. Garageominiums. What are they called? Garageominiums.
- 5:41Garageominiums. [laughs] Yeah. It's- Everybody- I think-... down here just loves, loves cars. I mean, you talk about everybody loves cars. I think they might love cars actually more than people in Charlotte- I know.
- 5:51That's why we gotta get-... North Carolina do. But it's true... more of these shirts walking around so we get heckled a little bit. [laughs] Heckled, yeah. Uh, let's talk about some news, uh, Ford a little bit.
- 5:57So Ford has, uh, significantly reduced the prices of their 2023 Mach-Es, slashing costs by thir- $3,000 to, like, $8,000 across different models to enhance the competitiveness against Tesla primarily.
- 6:12So the price reduction is also coming with some very attractive finance offers, like 0% for 72 monthsPlus, you know, a 3 to $8,000 cash incentive on leased vehicles. So they're really trying to move these now.
- 6:27It's, it's really close to the pricing of the Model Y. They start now in the low 40s.
- 6:31Uh, Mach-E, it's worth mentioning, is second to the Model Y in EV sales, um, in the segment in the US, and they don't currently even qualify for the $7,500 tax credit.
- 6:43Ford CEO Jim Farley emphasized the need, uh, the need to get more affordable EVs out there.
- 6:49And Ford spokesperson Marty Gunsberg said, uh, "We're adjusting pricing to, um, keep up with, like, what the strategy and the demand is." So is this any surprise to you, Todd? No. [laughs] No.
- 7:03[laughs] We both- No, I mean, do we really need to talk about EVs this morning, right? Like, um- I think, I think it's like- Just people cannot, people cannot afford them. There's just not enough infrastructure, period.
- 7:14Um, someday, right? Like, EVs, they're great. I love them, but you gotta be able to charge them. People can't have range anxiety. You can't charge them in 20 minutes or a half hour or longer.
- 7:24They gotta be able to charge in five minutes or less, just like you pump your gas, and you gotta be able to do it everywhere. So it's gonna be a while. I think the cars are great, but- Yeah, you're an EV driver...
- 7:33it's not affordable for most- You, you own an EV. I do, and I like it a lot, but I don't trust it when I take it on long distances, which is part of the problem. So, um, you know, they just- [laughs]
- 7:43The government unfortunately tried to force these things down consumers' throats and dealers' throats, and I think everybody's backpedaling, which is smart, right? Sometimes you gotta try things and- Sure...
- 7:51be innovative and learn, but it's been very expensive to do it. And unfortunately, you know, the government is giving incentives. Well, the incentives are our money, right?
- 7:59Like, when things are subsidized by the government, that's our tax money doing it. Mm-hmm. So I, I, I'd like to see some more, uh, saneness when it comes to this, which hopefully we'll, we'll, we'll start to see now.
- 8:09Because the market, at the end of the day, the market's obviously showing what they want. People do not want these cars unless they can afford them.
- 8:15Yeah, I mean, s- Steve Greenfield was the, the co-host or the guest host yesterday and, you know, we were talking about all this conversation. You can't go anywhere without talking about EVs.
- 8:25Even in the major news publications, not in the automotive section, we're hearing about, you know, BYD, Chinese EVs coming to the US market, and all these things.
- 8:34And, you know, Steve was saying, you know, "What happens when we get a sub 20,000 EV? Does that change the game a lot?" And my, my, my follow-up question to that is, like,
- 8:44like, that is going to make the charging availability situation way worse if all of a sudden we get more people buying EVs without the infrastructure to support it, which in turn makes the EV owning experience worse, which may even stunt the growth of the...
- 8:59It's, like, this very cyclical thing, and I think you nailed it, right? Like, when we're trying to incentivize demand, um, it creates false demand. It's not even demand. It just creates mandates, right?
- 9:10Like, you have to make this many cars, um, try to get people to buy them. And, you know, we'll see, we'll see what happens.
- 9:16If, if, if China has sub $20,000 EVs coming into the United States, it's gonna be a real problem for the industry here, period. Doesn't matter if you're selling EVs or ICE vehicles.
- 9:24It's gonna be a huge, huge problem- There you go. I mean, across the board... for manufacturers here. It might, it might put some of them out of business, to be quite honest with you. Right. Right. That's a good point.
- 9:33I rented a, um- No question about it... I made a post about this, I think it was last week, and I posted my review of a Mach-E because I, I was going to rent a vehicle from, uh, while I, while I was in Orlando.
- 9:43The cheapest vehicle to rent was actually an EV segment, so I paid $45 to rent a Model, a Tesla Model 3 for a day. They ended up putting me in a Ford Mach-E, which I was excited to drive.
- 9:52And I wrote a, a pretty, a pretty lengthy review of my experience. I loved the driving experience. It's amazing. Far superior s- to an ICE vehicle, the driving experience, in my opinion, of an EV that size.
- 10:02But, um, some other challenges. I talk about them in the review. You can go find it if you want on my LinkedIn. They're great cars. No question about it. Absolutely. They're good cars. It's just- Fun to drive...
- 10:09gotta, you gotta be able to charge them. I didn't have to charge mine at all. At the end of the day, that's all that matters. I, I made sure I didn't have to charge mine.
- 10:15[laughs] And then, and, and you have to, you can't be where it's cold, like where you are in Upstate New York, because if you do, it crushes the battery life fast.
- 10:21I saw, I saw an article about, uh, it was from a, some, it was a Rivian article or an article about some Rivian drivers, and they were in Chicago, and they were at the car rental, and there was some, like, backup at the rental counter, and they were waiting on cars.
- 10:35And so it was this l- really long line. And they asked if... They said, "We have five EVs. Do we have anybody that wants to rent an EV? You can come right to the front of the l- the line and get it."
- 10:44Two people went up to get the EV, and the Rivian drivers were like, "I would never rent an EV in this climate. I don't trust it." And they were experienced EV owners, right?
- 10:54And they still were like, "No, not gonna do it." And it's someday, just not today. Someday, not today. Maybe 2030, not 2024. Yeah, exactly. All right.
- 11:03Let's get on to, uh, the main, the main topic and story I wanted to talk about today. You actually sent me this article.
- 11:08It's an auto remarketing article, um, written by Joe Overby, who strangely enough is going to be a guest at ASOTU CON. Joe Overby from, um- Great guy Yeah, he- Super sharp guy... amazing.
- 11:17So excited he's get to, gets to participate this year.
- 11:20Um, but basically, despite the turbulent market, some standalone used car stores, like Sonic Automotive's EchoPark, have actually been able to navigate through this market volatility with strateg- uh, strategic adjustments, while companies like Vroom, remember?
- 11:36Shift, Car lots, um, h- are no longer even around, which were digital-only used car outlets.
- 11:43Now, EchoPark is obviously a physical location-based, um, used car outlet, and there've been a lot of shifting back and forth and, you know, you have a lot of first-hand experience with Sonic, understanding how the EchoPark system works.
- 11:57What is your... You know, why did you send me this article, and what's your perception of, like, what's going on and why they're able to adjust and still make this work?
- 12:04We- well, I think, you know, not just talking about EchoPark, but just the standalone used car dealer, um, himself, right, or herself, they are really, really struggling.
- 12:14Uh- So tied to no, no, like, manufacturer- Doesn't make any difference. They're just- No new car sales. Only just used cars. They're struggling. I mean, look at, when you go travel, right?
- 12:22Or even if you're local, look at how many little car lots are closed down or even some of the bigger ones. I was in Reno a few weeks ago at a client.
- 12:29There were some big used car dealers on, on, on the auto strip there-They're closed, right? It's very, very difficult for an independent used car dealer to compete and be profitable, uh, in this environment.
- 12:41Um, whether or not they're omnichannel or completely online like Vroom or, or Shift, it's extremely difficult because of the prices of used cars are just too expensive.
- 12:49Um, supply issues, the pricing of the cars, uh, the financing.
- 12:53I mean, if you look at the price of a brand-new car with 0% financing for 60 or 72 months, or even 2.9, versus a comp- comparable car that's almost brand new, uh, maybe one or two years old with low miles, the payment is the same or lower on a brand-new car, and people are gonna buy...
- 13:10They're gonna buy the new one. Without a doubt. Right? Or they're gonna lease it. So, you know, the independent used car dealer's gonna get squeezed.
- 13:16Um, also banks have tightened up quite a bit on loaning money on used cars because I think they're nervous about the value of some of these used cars. Mm-hmm.
- 13:23So used car, after, you know, when COVID hit, price of used cars went up 40%. And, um, you know, we were at an average, you know, in all my stores, the average cost of my used cars, you know, pre-COVID was 19 grand. Mm.
- 13:35Right? And those, those are late model, low mileage cars. Yeah. It shot up during COVID. The average cost was, like, 32 or 33 grand. Went into the upper 20s. Now it's down to about 24 or 25 grand.
- 13:46And the prices have gone down, but interest rates also went up. So even if, as the price went down, the rates going up didn't make the payment any lower for people.
- 13:54So, um, and it's extremely, extremely competitive for these used car dealers to go out and buy cars at the auction or buy cars from consumers. Mm-hmm.
- 14:03And, um, they're not trading for the kind of cars that they can retail when they have these used car lots. Typically people that trade in, uh, a car for a, for a used car, typically trade in cars that get wholesaled.
- 14:14So they're getting squeezed. Yeah. Straight up, you know? Um, you know, a- a- and as far as EchoPark and Sonic goes, I mean, extremely well-managed.
- 14:23And I think the decisions that they made, although they were probably painful, it, it was a wise move, right?
- 14:28Um, y- y- if, if they couldn't supply enough cars to all their stores, um, because of supply issues, and then, you know, did the right things. And I don't think they shut them down permanently.
- 14:38I think the wording that they used in a lot of the press releases is they were just gonna, um, they were gonna close them temporarily, and they may open some of them back up.
- 14:45And I don't wanna speak for them, but I think that's what they said in their press release, um, when, when they spoke about the subject. Um, you know, Sonic's extremely well-run, very well managed.
- 14:54I know the people, uh, that manage the EchoPark platform. They're sharp guys, right? Mm-hmm. And sharp girls. And they know what they're doing.
- 15:01Um, I think that they're probably gonna be one of the ones that weather the storm. Mm-hmm. Penske did the same thing. Penske closed a couple of their car shop locations, and I think they paused- Yeah...
- 15:09on opening up any more of them in the US- Yeah... because they're being smart about it, right? They did. Uh, just used cars are not, they're, they're, the price is not there yet. Just like we talked about with EVs.
- 15:18The price of used cars needs to come down, just like EVs have, in order for people to be able to afford them again. If not, they're gonna buy brand-new cars. New car supply is coming up. Incentives are there now.
- 15:28And if a consumer has a choice between the two, I think they're probably gonna pick a new car, um, because most people are payment-driven. Got it.
- 15:35You know, there's also something to be said I think for the diversification of, uh, a new car franchise, and the u- where the used car operation is a, a department in the overall business.
- 15:47You have a new car department, a used car department, a service department, a parts department, right? And so you have all of these lanes. It seems like you're insulated a little bit more from, from- You are a lot.
- 15:56And, and so you had an interesting setup where you had, uh, a Chevy store, right? And that was your only new car franchise. But then you had multiple used car outlets. How did you leverage the new car store,
- 16:08um, to feed- Well-... to feed the lots? 'Cause it was a smaller Chevy store, but it was, like, pretty, several- Yeah... sizable used car operations. So, so two things. Number one, right?
- 16:17You gotta have fixed operations in order to cover a good percentage of your overhead, right? You gotta have absorption in your dealerships, and that's something that a lot of used car dealers lack. Ah.
- 16:25That's why a lot of them haven't made it. Um, you know, the, the, the, the fixed operations can cover the majority of, in some cases, some really great dealers, it covers all of it. Mm-hmm.
- 16:34So whatever you sell is pure profit. Mm-hmm. But in my situation, my used car departments, or excuse my used car operations, those standalone dealerships I had, I had, I had customer pay service in those stores. Mm-hmm.
- 16:45Right? I had them in two of the three used car locations that I had, and that allowed me to have that part of that overhead covered so I was still profitable in doing it. Mm-hmm. Um, and
- 16:57a lot of used car dealers just don't have that. Right. They're only fixing their own cars. It's just a sales lot. And they're not set up, yeah. Mm-hmm.
- 17:00They're not set up for customer pay or for warranty work on the extended warranties that they sell. So it makes it more difficult. Um, and that's why I think a lot of them have, you know, haven't made it.
- 17:09Does EchoPark have fixed ops or c- customer pay fixed ops? N- no, they don't. No, they don't. Got it. Most of them, most don't. Yeah. Most, most do not.
- 17:16I mean, I will say, having been, like, pretty closely tied, tied in with it, you had developed a, a really nice service experience, um, you know, where you would drive into a nice area, you were greeted by, like, professional service advisors, there were walk arounds, your facilities were beautiful and, like, it was- Yeah, it was like going to a new car store.
- 17:33It was. It, it felt just like going to a new car store.
- 17:36Um, except it felt actually a little more, I don't know, a little more creative and customer-friendly because you had the flexibility to design it however you wanted, and you did a great job. True. Yeah, true.
- 17:46Yeah, the fixed op side is good. Well, Todd, uh, safe travels wherever you're heading today. Thank you. Thanks for being with us today. Always appreciate it. Absolutely. Thanks for having me.
- 17:54And, uh, hey, everybody else, make sure you sign up for that webinar today, 1:00.
- 17:57We're gonna know- let you know what 100 dealers think about digital retail, and, you know, go grab an ASOTU Con ticket while you're at it, 'cause you don't wanna miss it.
- 18:06[upbeat music]