Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Trump Bets Billions on Bitcoin: Why Treasury-Scale Custody Must Be Distributed
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into.
- 0:20The world of. OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational technology. What the Internet of money?
- 0:26Does is it creates a single network which can do a
- 0:30microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing. The role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be.
- 0:45Developed. Is a reliable E cash.
- 0:52All righty boys, welcome back to another episode of Final
- 0:56SETTLEMENT. Today is Tuesday, May 27th,
- 0:592025. Recording on a Tuesday instead
- 1:02of a Monday. Had a nice little break.
- 1:03Happy Memorial Day, boys. How are we doing?
- 1:07No shortage of the headlines. We were just chatting before we
- 1:10we hit record. Also, Riverside is down.
- 1:13So there's a lot happening in the world.
- 1:15They don't want us to record this pod.
- 1:17They don't want us to get the signal out there.
- 1:18So we're recording on Zoom. But yeah, headlines across the
- 1:23board. It's it's Bitcoin conference
- 1:24week. Think Trump just announced a
- 1:28Bitcoin treasury company with, yeah, billions, billions backing
- 1:32it. Multiple billions.
- 1:34Where do we want to? Yeah, well, definitely want to
- 1:37start with this almost didn't happen, But you know, we had
- 1:40such good feedback with the podcast that we the show had to
- 1:42go on. So we made a did a quick audible
- 1:45and got this recorded on Zoom. And so it'll still ideally be
- 1:48released today. And then yeah, I mean, from the
- 1:50news perspective, it's just so hard, like trying to live a
- 1:53life, run a business and then just go on Twitter.
- 1:56You got a Bitcoin conference happening this week and it feels
- 1:59like pre announcements are happening over the weekend or
- 2:02stuff happening. I'm kind of like really looking
- 2:05forward to not being there because I feel like we're going
- 2:06to get like 80% of the way there just by watching on Twitter
- 2:10without having to deal with like hangovers and flights and
- 2:13spending the money and like losing the client time.
- 2:16So it's going to be good to watch from a distance.
- 2:21Absolutely. Michael, can you give me sharing
- 2:23capabilities here in Zoom? Yes, you now can share and then
- 2:28while Brians sharing, yeah, I mean just this morning had we've
- 2:31had I've been on calls for the past few hours, but did a quick
- 2:35look on Twitter and it looks like at least four different
- 2:37people have allocated like a couple of billion dollars are in
- 2:40the process. So maybe, yeah, I'll let Brian,
- 2:43don't I? Yeah.
- 2:44So this is this is what we were just talking about.
- 2:46Trump Media and Tech Group Corp announces entered in a
- 2:49subscription agreement with approximately 50 institutional
- 2:52investors for a private placement offering totalling
- 2:54approximately 2.5 billion. 1.5 in common stock, one in 0%
- 3:00convertible Senior secured notes with all proceeds intended for
- 3:04the creation of a Bitcoin treasury Company Will use
- 3:07crypto.com and Anchorage for custody of its Bitcoin treasury.
- 3:11Expected to close on May 29th this week.
- 3:16What do we make of this, William?
- 3:18I mean #1 the president is putting his name on something
- 3:22Bitcoin related, right? Like we, we can say that this is
- 3:25like a scam all we want and we'll get into it.
- 3:28But like the president of the United States has a company that
- 3:33is buying Bitcoin. So I mean, please, just, you
- 3:38know, there's going to be a lot of noise out there, but like
- 3:40he's putting his name on this and we are going to see a lot
- 3:44of, you know, people in his circle just getting more
- 3:48interested. And, you know, people may say
- 3:50Bitcoin's a scam because of this.
- 3:51But like, you just have to realize that this is the
- 3:54direction that the US is going and the Trump is moving.
- 3:57We're seeing countries all across the world, like Pakistan
- 4:01has announced they're doing Bitcoin mining now.
- 4:03It's it's becoming really of strategic importance.
- 4:06You know, we're seeing long end yields across every single
- 4:11country go up significantly. People are, you know, looking
- 4:15away from, you know, traditional inside money versus hard assets
- 4:20at the moment across every single place in the world.
- 4:23Every institutional investor is waking up to this.
- 4:27There will, this is not going to be the last announcement I
- 4:29expect, you know, we, we should see at least probably like 20-5
- 4:34more announcements of, you know, Bitcoin treasury companies by
- 4:37the end of this Bitcoin conference week.
- 4:40This is kind of just the beginning of how crazy this is
- 4:43going to get. Yeah, I, I think the two things
- 4:50to call out, there was a tweet on top of this, but I don't know
- 4:53if it was Plebetter or one of the guys that are kind of
- 4:56cynical against the, the kind of like, I think that the Treasury
- 4:59stuff, but also just some of the stuff that Wall Street's doing.
- 5:03It was interesting because he says like, there's no chance SPR
- 5:06happens because of, you know, like political, not infighting,
- 5:12but like the notion that they have inside knowledge that SPR
- 5:17is coming, they're buying. But this kind of goes back to
- 5:19what we've been talking about the past few months with
- 5:21Lutnick's, you know, sons running the company and Trump's
- 5:24sons running theirs. It's like I don't think any of
- 5:27these roles matter anymore and I don't think this like precludes
- 5:30this probably further indicates that an SPR is coming that these
- 5:33private companies. And then the only other thing
- 5:35worth or two things worth mentioning is this is
- 5:37interesting because they already have an existing company.
- 5:39I don't know what their, you know, balance sheet looks like,
- 5:41but it's also accessing debt and common stock where a lot of
- 5:44these other companies are just selling stock versus being able
- 5:48to raise debt based on some of their existing cash flows.
- 5:52But the the other last thing, and I know, Brian, you're gonna
- 5:54have a lot of thoughts on this, is it's kind of just further
- 5:56underpins, you know, sure, it's great downwards pressure, but
- 6:00it's kind of underpins the full ICO notion of like these are
- 6:04just different tickers, access to larger liquidity pools via
- 6:07traditional brokerage. But at the end of the day,
- 6:11they're they're based on the vibes and memes of whoever's,
- 6:15you know, name is recognized. But it it hit me or thinking
- 6:20about over the weekend in the same way, because then O'Brien's
- 6:23been big proponent of like Bitcoin dominance rising.
- 6:26And I'm not saying it will to the extent we've talked about
- 6:29before, but this actually further perpetuates or like that
- 6:33notion that before it was Bitcoin, people came into
- 6:36Bitcoin and they cycled into alts.
- 6:39This is that same thing when you think about it is people are
- 6:41becoming wealthy in Bitcoin terms and then they're naturally
- 6:44taking the Bitcoin and they're saying I can make more Bitcoin
- 6:47on my Bitcoin by coming in to these products.
- 6:49And that's why you see the Adam Backs and all these like well
- 6:51known influencers are now wealthy being able to come into
- 6:54this and like, you know, effectively fleece like retail.
- 6:57So anyway, this is all like kind of maps to what we've seen
- 7:00before, but it's kind of crazy that we didn't see it coming.
- 7:02I didn't see this ICO like stock ticker for treasuries.
- 7:07Yeah. It's it's it's wild.
- 7:09And and just for the record, this has been part of my
- 7:12dominance thesis is like these are the new, the the new all
- 7:16coins effectively how you get or you try to outperform Bitcoin,
- 7:20but it's list like it's this very at least for Bitcoiners.
- 7:23And like for all the influencers who are now getting involved in
- 7:25this. Like it is this sort of elegant
- 7:29shroud of like this is OK, because it's Bitcoin.
- 7:32And, you know, while they're still the same or similar, I
- 7:37should say, layers of counterparty risk, potential
- 7:41leverage risk, like because it's Bitcoin, I think there's just
- 7:46this notion that like, well, because everything is good for
- 7:48Bitcoin, like this kind of OK. And that's not to say like all
- 7:52these companies are, you know, going to be unsuccessful, like
- 7:57there will be companies that do this right and do this well.
- 8:00But I think what we've talked about on in previous weeks is
- 8:03like there is a level of saturation.
- 8:06And so like if we get 25 more announcements of Bitcoin
- 8:08treasury companies this week, which seems likely, there's
- 8:13there's not that many ways to differentiate outside of like if
- 8:18you actually have a strong core business.
- 8:20And that's what I keep coming back to is like, you know, the
- 8:23most successful implementations of this, this Bitcoin treasury
- 8:27strategy are going to be those companies that are like already
- 8:30good companies, cash flowing, have some core business.
- 8:33And this is sort of like, you know, just preparing them to be
- 8:37more, you know, built, you know, extend their Moat for whatever
- 8:40their core business is by saving their their value in a better
- 8:43form of money. For all the zombie companies
- 8:46doing this or for just the SPAC's getting spun up to just
- 8:49specifically accumulate Bitcoin, there's not a lot of ways to
- 8:53differentiate outside of just taking more leverage.
- 8:55And that's where it sort of gets concerning in terms of its
- 8:58sustainability. Yeah.
- 9:01I mean, I think, I don't know if you want to pull it up.
- 9:03I think there's a few things to share there. 1 is that could be
- 9:06an angle where I am wrong on the Bitcoin dominance.
- 9:08I don't think it is simply because they came out today or
- 9:11this past couple days. There's like an EFF MSTR that
- 9:15just bought half a billion. I don't want to like focus too
- 9:17heavy on here, but it is worth sharing like we talked about
- 9:20this a few weeks ago that I think we're going to see more
- 9:22and more opportunists because you're going to look at just
- 9:25like the higher beta play, right?
- 9:27If you can get like an altcoin that's super illiquid and then
- 9:30you can put it into another illiquid SPAC or merge and then
- 9:33get it, you're going to be able to sell that story to a lot of
- 9:37institutional investors that don't get that Bitcoin is the
- 9:40dominant player, but like. I will say though, this, this
- 9:43specific 1 is like Joe Lubin, I think is who's doing this.
- 9:47Like that's that's very different than the president of
- 9:50the United States embracing Bitcoin for a treasury.
- 9:52Well, but the but the think about like Bitcoin has a five
- 9:58year plus head start meaning like trailer sailor started this
- 10:01in 2020. So if this is this is could
- 10:04potentially be a trend of a or a start of a growing trend where
- 10:08you needed somebody to to, you know, a conviction.
- 10:11I guess Lubin, because he holds the majority of the free mine or
- 10:13whatever he has conviction. But that's what but that's what
- 10:17the theorem will always was. It was how do you create lock in
- 10:20for people to like absorb a lot of that float so it doesn't
- 10:23move, IE versus Bitcoin, that's super liquid.
- 10:26But either way, forget about like the altcoins, like that's I
- 10:29think the two things, because I know this all sounds cynical, or
- 10:33at least personally feel cynical because I always bring it up and
- 10:35I feel like even internally, it's like, you know, like it
- 10:38might be good for Bitcoin. It's like 2 things to recognize.
- 10:40One is it's his trade. So Bitcoin, there's a whole
- 10:44show. It's really good.
- 10:45You should check it out. It's called the last trade.
- 10:47It's meant, you know, where you buy Bitcoin, you don't have to
- 10:49worry about it. You get to go back to your life.
- 10:50So there's that. If you're buying any of this
- 10:52stuff, you're ultimately trading it.
- 10:54But there's a more philosophical perspective that is important.
- 10:57And nobody can repeat this. And I happily, happily debate or
- 11:00talk about it is at the end of the day, all these products are
- 11:04taking advantage of the naivete of the individual, whether it's
- 11:07the institution that they'll sell can't get exposure all the
- 11:09way to the individual. And what I mean by that is
- 11:11because anybody that's listening to this has had to gotten has
- 11:14had to have or gone down the rack hole and is educated.
- 11:17And as they get educated, they ultimately want spot Bitcoin
- 11:20more than likely in a segregated wallet offline.
- 11:23So it's protected. So if you're an institution
- 11:26coming in that is theoretically uneducated and this is how you
- 11:28get proxy exposure or you're an individual, ultimately you're
- 11:31going to wake up and realize, Oh my God, how are they custody in
- 11:34it? Why am I don't have deliver?
- 11:35I have counterparty risk of execution risk of all these
- 11:37things under the sun. And then you're not going to
- 11:39want it. And then whatever goes up has to
- 11:41come down South. It's just like that's just
- 11:43fundamental all the way from a sovereign buying micro strategy
- 11:46shares. Eventually they're going to get
- 11:47to a certain points like this isn't good for me.
- 11:50And I don't think anybody talks about that enough.
- 11:52That's just like first principles thinking on the
- 11:54underline and then who's actually managing it all.
- 11:58Yeah, great points. And I think I would also add
- 12:02like I think the, there's an undercurrent here of if you are
- 12:08assuming that every single one of these specs call an ICO call
- 12:14whatever you want, that they're all going to be successful.
- 12:16The underlying assumption there is that like there's no cycles
- 12:19anymore and like we're just going up forever and there's
- 12:21always going to be a bid and there's not going to be some
- 12:24material correction where if a lot of these companies are over
- 12:27levered or you know, over their skis in some manner that there
- 12:31would be a massive deleveraging for a lot of these folks.
- 12:34And so I think that's sort of an underlying assumption that some
- 12:38are making that like maybe there's just no cycles and
- 12:41there's a forever bid for Bitcoin going forward and.
- 12:44You know what, I real quick, sorry, what I love about that is
- 12:46there's still a huge hole in that logic because two things
- 12:51are going to happen. One is it is, it is in, it is
- 13:01not. I got up very early.
- 13:02We had some calls with the central banks and other other
- 13:05parts of the world. So my brain is not fully there,
- 13:07but it'll get here. Is it is not.
- 13:13You're not being truthful with yourself.
- 13:15If you don't count what I'm about to say as a likely thing
- 13:19that will happen is somebody's going to lose their private keys
- 13:21to corporate treasury, like just full stop, whether it's whoever
- 13:24their custodian is or the one that nobody's talking about.
- 13:28These are some lovely jurisdictions that are launching
- 13:30these treasury strategies is the government comes and sees it for
- 13:34whatever reason. And when that happens,
- 13:37everyone's going to look at these assets and they're going
- 13:39to like, oh shit, can that happen to me?
- 13:41It's the same thing that happened in 21 and 22,
- 13:44specifically 22 in the market delevered.
- 13:46And it's like correlation of what?
- 13:47Everyone freaks out and removes the assets.
- 13:50So what happened in that point when you get that reflexivity in
- 13:54the market when people are moving or selling those shares
- 13:56and then they can't make their obligations, you're still like,
- 13:59even if we were up into the right, I think we're in a, you
- 14:02know, a secular bull trend because this is only goes up in
- 14:05the right. It's just at what time horizon,
- 14:07But I think that's something that people aren't accounting
- 14:10for is the execution risk around the underlying custodian.
- 14:13And it's not even that your custodian goes down because
- 14:15everyone doesn't believe theirs. It's that when one goes down and
- 14:18then what happens to the outflows and then what happens
- 14:21to that downward pressure? And then everyone's going to
- 14:24wake up and be like, how do we not see this coming?
- 14:25And we'll just be able to look back at these podcasts.
- 14:29Yeah, the, the jurisdiction piece is important and, and not
- 14:32being talked about at all. But like, yeah, the, the idea
- 14:35that every country should have a Bitcoin treasury strategy, it's
- 14:38like, OK, well, every country in the world doesn't have the same
- 14:41rule of law or respect for, you know, a public company operating
- 14:46that the United States does. And like, yeah, we're in this
- 14:49kind of crazy spot where like the president of the United
- 14:52States is, is implementing the exact strategy that we're
- 14:55talking about with his own public company.
- 14:58But that's just not the case everywhere else.
- 14:59And so, yeah, I, I, I totally agree, Michael, like that sort
- 15:03of knock on effect, if something like that were to happen would
- 15:07be severe because then everyone looks in the mirror and says,
- 15:09well, what's who are my counterparties and what's the
- 15:11risk there? And, and what's the the
- 15:13likelihood that they one, have the coins and two, that they're
- 15:17not going to be confiscated or lost in some manner?
- 15:22William, sorry. That's exactly right.
- 15:24I was just going to say to to some of their credit, some of
- 15:27the debt is unsecured, so they can't necessarily default on it.
- 15:31But to Brian's point earlier, people don't necessarily see
- 15:35that if you're not MicroStrategy or you know, top 15 holders, you
- 15:40have to differentiate somehow. You're going to take out that
- 15:45that is, you know, you have to pay it back.
- 15:47It's not going to be convertible.
- 15:48There's just going to be different ways that you have to
- 15:50differentiate yourself if you don't necessarily aren't run by
- 15:54a Trump or brand Bitcoin influencer.
- 15:57And so it will get more nefarious across these different
- 16:00companies as well. And how about this, because I'm
- 16:03not going to say it about the US, but how about this is how it
- 16:06turns out is if you speculative attack your local currency using
- 16:11the debt markets and your debt is unsustainable, what's called
- 16:15Japan as an example. What is the likelihood scenario
- 16:19as that reflexivity grows up until the rate for the
- 16:22government to say, hey, you actually access these markets,
- 16:26you arbitrage them, That's our Bitcoin, we'll give you dollars.
- 16:30No, I'm serious. Like that's a plausible like the
- 16:33government either has. To do it, or they're going to
- 16:36the government has to take their debt and buy Bitcoin themselves.
- 16:40Otherwise, they're going to take the companies that do either
- 16:45through really nefarious taxes or just, you know, seize it
- 16:49themselves and, you know, say this is, hey, this is you just
- 16:52seeded our, you know, sovereign wealth fund.
- 16:56Yeah. And that and that actually
- 16:58again, let's isolate the US and our capital and legal structure
- 17:03because everyone will say that that's crazy.
- 17:07But if you look at like Japan is the easiest example to your
- 17:10point, if you speculative attack the currency, which is what this
- 17:14is, which is what everyone knows it is, and they have an
- 17:19unsustainable structure and their currency is going to
- 17:21hyperinflate unless they are able to back it with a harder
- 17:25asset. That is a logical way that they
- 17:28would be able to explain it and then give everyone at par their
- 17:32dollars or whatever it looks like.
- 17:34And honestly, like, I think that's where this all goes.
- 17:40And, and, and, you know, it's funny when you talk to
- 17:42sophisticated people that are buying these MSTR shares and
- 17:44other things, they're all like, yeah, that's probably going to
- 17:46happen, but I'm going to get out before then or like.
- 17:50Everyone, everyone thinks they're going to they're going
- 17:52to complete the trade. As we mentioned before, anything
- 17:55goes wrong, which is just never the case.
- 17:59Someone less gets left holding the bag.
- 18:02OK, I want to transition slightly to this clip of of
- 18:07Chamath from the All In pod a few days ago.
- 18:11And he's talking about the this the big beautiful spending bill
- 18:16that is currently going through Congress.
- 18:19And effectively, I think I'm going to play the longer clip
- 18:23because it's let me know if you guys can hear that.
- 18:25Unfortunately for President Trump's agenda and for a MAGA
- 18:29movement, this is the worst of all conditions.
- 18:32The financial markets will punish this.
- 18:34The political calculus will be for the president to decide how
- 18:37much credit he actually wants to take for this bill, because even
- 18:41though it has his name on it, the contents of the bill are
- 18:44different in actual facts than what I think he intended.
- 18:49And what I mean by that is when you look inside of what happened
- 18:52in the 11th hour last night, it's disappointing.
- 18:55This thing is like anti Dodge. If Dodge was meant to be a
- 18:58reflection of the American voting populations desire for
- 19:03meaningful reform in government, cost controls, some form of
- 19:06austerity, and to get this dead spiral in check, this is the
- 19:10opposite of that. What happened was in the 11th
- 19:13hour, you had a handful of people abstain.
- 19:15You had one person that passed away in the last few days.
- 19:18You had one person that fell asleep on the floor of the house
- 19:21so he wasn't even woken up for the vote.
- 19:23And in the middle of all of that chaos, what happened was all
- 19:26kinds of things were added and attached and canceled at the
- 19:30last minute. Because what happens is you have
- 19:32to have these puts and takes as Freeburg described.
- 19:35If you want to spend over here, you have to find a cut over
- 19:38there. But I think what happened was
- 19:39there was really not a lot of financial literacy used to
- 19:43decide what to actually put in and what to cut.
- 19:46And that lack of discipline is going to create, I think, of
- 19:50negative set of consequences. So what are those consequences?
- 19:55Today, the 10 year is around 4 1/2%.
- 19:58At the rate in which it's escalating since Liberation Day,
- 20:03By the end of this year, we're going to be past 5%.
- 20:07The 30 year is on a rate now to get past 6 1/4, maybe even reach
- 20:136 1/2%. Those are way beyond what most
- 20:22people thought was a reasonable place to be for the United
- 20:26States economy. And So what will the
- 20:28implications be as rates go to those levels?
- 20:34You'll delever from the United States.
- 20:36You'll sell U.S. debt. You'll own things like gold and
- 20:39Bitcoin. If you're curious about what's
- 20:42happening to gold and Bitcoin, they started to spike in the
- 20:44last few days. You'll have ratings
- 20:48organizations that add to this cascade by down grading the
- 20:52United States. That happened on Friday.
- 20:54You'll have very smart people starting to signal that this is
- 21:01a much harder problem then they initially thought.
- 21:04That's how I person. Thanks Brian.
- 21:10I put you on mute because it was echoing, but thanks Brian for
- 21:13having audience listen to All In podcast.
- 21:15To be a final settlement is the longest audio clip ever.
- 21:19You're on mute. I had to put you on mute because
- 21:21there was an echo. Sorry, that was a lot of
- 21:25Chamath, I agree. But there was a lot of good
- 21:28things to pull out of that. And, and I think the the things
- 21:31that stood out to me or one like Chamath and others have been
- 21:37massive cheerleaders of everything that Trump has done
- 21:39over the past 6 to 12 months. This is a slight departure from
- 21:42that where he's saying he's kind of giving him an out and being
- 21:45like, oh, I don't think he knew that this was going to happen to
- 21:47the bill. And he maybe he ends up not
- 21:49taking credit for it because it's pretty much been the
- 21:53opposite of everything that he ran on in terms of actually
- 21:57cutting into spending and, and, you know, attempting to reduce
- 22:01the deficit with programs like Doge, which at this point seem
- 22:05like they've sort of been abandoned.
- 22:07And so lots of things got added to this bill and sort of the
- 22:1011th hour last week. And I think I've seen a few
- 22:14different numbers, but basically it sounds like this would add 2
- 22:17to 3 trillion to the deficit over the next decade.
- 22:20And so it's it's a long way of saying like we've kind of known
- 22:24this. Nothing stops this train.
- 22:25They have to print, they have to spend.
- 22:28And he mentions in there, This is why you're seeing people want
- 22:32to to own hard, hard assets, gold and Bitcoin.
- 22:35And so I think this was just worth calling out.
- 22:37Sorry for the long clip, Michael.
- 22:38I know, I know you're. It's it's all good.
- 22:41I think this kind of further supports we've talked about this
- 22:43for a few years on the last train.
- 22:45There's been a debate on how smart these guys are at the end
- 22:48of the day, I think like, you know, maybe not Calcanis and
- 22:52even Free Bird, but some of these other guys are insanely
- 22:55smart and they have to speak the language to their LP's and their
- 22:58investor base. And so Chamoth has called this
- 23:01since 12:00, I think, 2012. Thirteen Bitcoin schmuck
- 23:05insurance. He's understood where this all
- 23:07goes. He didn't talk about the
- 23:10government debt problem. Now he's in a position where
- 23:13Bitcoin and gold are a trade that makes sense.
- 23:15He's talking about rolling up some other fun to fund stuff.
- 23:18Like I think this plays into the to the more of the narrative
- 23:22that is palatable for him. And it's similar to the
- 23:25conversation we just had about, you know, there's an
- 23:28understanding that in Bitcoin space, as the Bitcoin price
- 23:31rises, they'll like, blame the people that were Bitcoin
- 23:33investors for whatever, you know, hyperinflation.
- 23:37I don't know if that's the case, but it's very similar to what
- 23:39we'll see in the debt structure. If everyone's accessing the debt
- 23:42to buy Bitcoin and there's all this stuff, they're not going to
- 23:45remember the 50 years of, you know, fiscal responsibility.
- 23:48They're going to remember the past five years or three years
- 23:51of all these people arbitraging the debt markets to buy Bitcoin.
- 23:55And so I think this just ties into like narratives versus
- 23:57reality because the last thing I'll share is like Luke Grumman
- 24:00was explaining this the whole time that they weren't going to
- 24:03be able to cut as deep as he explained.
- 24:05It was more of a vibe shift more than anything that doge was
- 24:08because it from a tax receipt perspective, you wouldn't be
- 24:11able to actually meet the obligations.
- 24:14And it was going to cut until either they were incompetent or
- 24:17the market pushed back and then they would naturally have to
- 24:19step in and reduce. And so I think it was all plays
- 24:22into like, what are you people, people are saying versus like
- 24:24what's happening behind the scenes?
- 24:26It was all just like a campaign strategy really of just like
- 24:30saying we're to cut the debt and deficit.
- 24:32At the end of the day, it's really up to Congress what the
- 24:35debt and deficit end up looking like.
- 24:36None of them really have any big desire to cut the deficit
- 24:41because, you know, that significantly hurts their
- 24:43reelection chances. And so they're not going to do
- 24:46that at all. I think it was kind of a just a
- 24:50narrative thing. And you know, at the end of the
- 24:52day, Trump is always run massive deficits as well.
- 24:56Elon has been very, very quiet about all the politics stuff
- 25:01over the past like two or three months, probably since like
- 25:05tariffs kind of first started off.
- 25:07That's likely due to Dodge not having as much of an impact as
- 25:11expected. He, I think kind of came out
- 25:13over the past week and said, hey, like I'm going to focus a
- 25:18lot less on campaign donations in the future.
- 25:21We need to grow our way out of this debt.
- 25:23There was not really any spending cuts in there.
- 25:27Scott Besson was originally came out and said we're going to get
- 25:31like deficit to GDP down to like 3%.
- 25:34He's pushed that back and like the whole narrative from
- 25:37everybody inside the administration is just we need
- 25:40to grow faster than our debt in order to get this out of this
- 25:45situation. Which just means that inflation
- 25:47will need to be, you know, kind of what it is now mildly hot for
- 25:52a sustained period of time as or there would need to be massive
- 25:58appreciation and assets so they can get significantly higher tax
- 26:03receipts from capital gains taxes.
- 26:07And I don't see any massive tax shifts.
- 26:09And it's just going to be more of what we continue to see,
- 26:12which is just, you know, people that have hard assets being able
- 26:16to significantly outperform those who who do not
- 26:20unfortunately. Yep, it's well said.
- 26:24I think it's yeah, the best thing doesn't had an interview
- 26:27last week which sort of, you know, tacitly admitted all of
- 26:33this as well of like, yeah, we're kind of we're kind of
- 26:36giving up on on the initial goals here.
- 26:38And we're just going to have to nominally grow our way out of
- 26:40this, which means they're going to continue to debase the
- 26:43currency effectively. And so, you know, it, it ties
- 26:47into everything like you mentioned, Michael, that that
- 26:49Groman has been saying for for months to a year around.
- 26:54They kind of they kind of understand this and they know
- 26:57that they need to embrace hard assets on one hand, while also
- 27:00embracing things like stable coins to continue to sort of
- 27:03kick the can down the road of, of filling the hole for long
- 27:07term government debt via the stable coin issuer.
- 27:09So I think it's, it's, you know, that plan that we've kind of
- 27:13been talking about for months. It's kind of coming more into
- 27:16the picture now as people grapple with the reality of the
- 27:19situation on the ground. OK.
- 27:24Do we want to go to the Sailor clip?
- 27:29I won't play the whole thing, Michael, because I know.
- 27:32Well, I mean, we can because I haven't heard it, but maybe
- 27:34we'll for that. I wanted to pull this up because
- 27:41I don't even think I'll get most of them, but we'll do 5 and
- 27:44they'll be, they'll be pretty big.
- 27:47So for anybody listening, I'm just going to pull up a few
- 27:50clips that have come up in the past.
- 27:52Call it 48 to 72 hours because I think this ties into the the
- 27:57some of the rest of the conversation and the thing that
- 28:00nobody's really talking about. We all know you know custody
- 28:03risk when it comes to third parties exchanges, but then
- 28:07thinking about just the notion of you know self custody and
- 28:12ultimately what has been deemed as OK, you know for a Bitcoin
- 28:17price of 100 bucks 1000 dollars 10,000 is starting to very much
- 28:22not be OK at 100,000 and beyond. So the first clip this is CNBC
- 28:27Bitcoin Rico fed say 260 million $65 million crypto theft ring
- 28:32blue 13 million on exotic cars night clubs.
- 28:35So this is prosecutors have charged 13 men stealing about
- 28:39265,000,000. This next one is crypto investor
- 28:43allegedly tortured captive Italian businessman with a
- 28:45chainsaw for weeks and Lux NYC pad and statistics scheme to
- 28:49game password. Again.
- 28:50These are all within the past two days.
- 28:53US this is on coin Telegraph US tourist drug by fake Uber driver
- 28:57and robbed of $123,000 in Bitcoin.
- 29:02This last one is less on the physical.
- 29:04This is more phishing. Minnesota man clicks phishing
- 29:06e-mail, opens Coinbase and watch Bitcoin vanish in real time.
- 29:10And then the most, this one is a little bit longer, about 7 days.
- 29:13It's a whole Wall Street Journal op-ed severed or I don't even
- 29:17know if it's an op-ed. I guess this is done with their
- 29:19columnist. But the title severed fingers
- 29:21and wrench attacks rattle the crypto elite and then it breaks
- 29:24down at least 5. This has been, you know,
- 29:26examples of things that have been outside of the ones we just
- 29:29called. And the main reason for calling
- 29:32all this out is all the data's out there.
- 29:36We've talked about it before. We made a joke yesterday in a
- 29:39group chat that, you know, folks were updating images on Twitter
- 29:43of like groups in the family office or my net worth,
- 29:45whatever's happened in Vegas yesterday.
- 29:47And it's kind of like crazy because I'm pretty sure this
- 29:50exists today. And if it doesn't, it'll exist
- 29:52very shortly as you can upload the picture and then effectively
- 29:56be able to search and index images, names, addresses.
- 30:00And people think this is crazy, but between chain analysis and
- 30:03then all the data that's been leaked by all these exchanges,
- 30:05you can pretty much discern directionally the amount of
- 30:08crypto holdings somebody has. And this is just a recipe for a
- 30:12lot of like pain and misery over the course of the next three to
- 30:15five years because there really isn't a solution or hadn't been
- 30:18a solution for a digital bear innocent.
- 30:20And how do you protect an individual from third party
- 30:23exposure via an exchange, but also not having to have this?
- 30:26And I set it in your house or next to your house and self
- 30:30custody. So it's just worth calling out
- 30:32because this is something that's just going to increase.
- 30:34We've been talking about it a lot and it's something for folks
- 30:37to be aware of. Because if even if you're an
- 30:39individual, which generally you know, Bitcoin adoptions via
- 30:43males in the age of 35 to 55, it's not even about that
- 30:47individual anymore. It's about their friends and
- 30:49family and they're where they're exposed to call with a
- 30:52significant client that was on Coinbase for nine years.
- 30:57Knew he needed to get it off the exchange.
- 30:59But reference like I thought it was always better there than if
- 31:02in self custody at a higher likelihood.
- 31:04And I brought up, you know, did you see this article about the
- 31:07severed fingers? And he's like, God, I did see
- 31:10that. That's why we're having this
- 31:10conversation. I hope to God my wife doesn't
- 31:12see it because his wife's going to kill him if he put, you know,
- 31:14their children, their family in that position.
- 31:17And so yeah, just a long winded way of explaining to be aware of
- 31:21the risks because they're coming if they're at 100K right now,
- 31:24happening to just imagine what 200K or 150,000 when it's like.
- 31:29Yeah, unfortunately it's only going to ramp up as a price and
- 31:34you know bad people see those articles as well and just kind
- 31:37of see a honeypot there and understand and are getting
- 31:40significantly more sophisticated over time.
- 31:43Would caution anybody in Las Vegas to you know, keep their
- 31:47what's about them not get too drunk at any of the events.
- 31:51I think that good practice regardless, but especially if
- 31:55you have, you know, a significant amount of your money
- 31:58in Bitcoin, you know, probably don't talk about your custody
- 32:02set up if it's unsecure and and just really think about, you
- 32:07know, how you want to mitigate the risk for not only yourself,
- 32:11but it's going to be ultimately if if you have any loved ones,
- 32:14they're really the biggest single point of failure.
- 32:17Yeah. And we, we have talked about
- 32:19this a lot. It's going to accelerate.
- 32:22And yeah, 1 aspect of this that we've we've also mentioned is
- 32:26like this, this kind of stuff is what keeps people out.
- 32:29This is what creates the friction to adopt Bitcoin in
- 32:31general, because you know, when a lot of these headlines were
- 32:35breaking over the weekend, you know, I was with a group of
- 32:38quote UN quote normies and they were bringing it up to me.
- 32:42Like, did you see these headlines?
- 32:43And I was like, yeah, like this is a bearer asset.
- 32:46This is why this is actually, you know, kind of, you know,
- 32:50relates to the company I work for and in in trying to mitigate
- 32:53these things from from being possible.
- 32:56And so this is this is permeating into the mainstream.
- 33:00And that's, I think historically, you know, why
- 33:04people have struggled to get comfortable in adopting the
- 33:07asset because they either think they're going to get wrench
- 33:10attacked or it ends up in a landfill.
- 33:12Is this this sort of the two the two tropes that they hear the
- 33:16most? And so, you know, it, it makes
- 33:19it much more difficult. You know, learning about Bitcoin
- 33:22and going down the rabbit hole is hard enough.
- 33:23And then when you see these things, it just, it puts up a
- 33:27natural blocker to say like, I, I don't want to even go down
- 33:29that road or deal with that because it seems really
- 33:32dangerous and risky. And so we, unfortunately, it's
- 33:36going to keep happening, but we need to keep talking about it
- 33:38and keep talking about solutions that mitigate these things
- 33:41because that's the only way that we're going to sort of, you
- 33:43know, allow adoption to proliferate in a, in a safer,
- 33:46more resilient way. Yeah, yeah.
- 33:51I think we'll cover a little bit more in the MIC stuff, but and I
- 33:55think it's just something yeah, to be aware of.
- 33:57I think the only thing maybe to add is historically we talked
- 34:00about this internally but weren't as loud about it because
- 34:03it sell it sounded self-serving or that we were talking our
- 34:06book. But the but we knew that these
- 34:08things were happening because for everyone that that you know
- 34:11is public, there's anywhere between 10 to 100 that happened
- 34:14that somebody doesn't report either because they're
- 34:16embarrassed. They don't want to be a future
- 34:18attack, you know, known that they have crypto and that
- 34:21they'll give it up if they're kidnapped.
- 34:23And so, but it's becoming so prevalent and most people aren't
- 34:26sharing this with them. Like that's one of the core
- 34:29things that I think we anchor towards as far as a lot of folks
- 34:32will ask what's different about on ramp versus other firms?
- 34:35And there's a lot of things, but I don't some things can be
- 34:38commoditized. The thing you can't commoditize
- 34:40is forward-looking nature and philosophical understanding of
- 34:43this space. And the thing I joke about is
- 34:45like we understand the space so deeply, we never put you in
- 34:48harm's way for this to happen. And so that's something just to
- 34:51be aware of. If you're exposed to these
- 34:54things, you should question who your counterparty or who who's
- 34:57not telling you about this, because everyone talks their
- 35:00book. If they have a hardware device
- 35:01manufacturer, they'll explain why hardware device is the best.
- 35:03If you collaborate custody, they'll explain that multi
- 35:06institution will explain why that is a has a great part in
- 35:08the market. But the reality is you have to
- 35:10start to look at the objective truths and where you fit in your
- 35:15risk profile and what could potentially happen and, and, and
- 35:17think critically of like what has been suited for the
- 35:20individual at 100K200K and $1,000,000 and beyond and really
- 35:25think about that. And that's when the inheritance
- 35:27and all the stuff you know comes into play.
- 35:31Absolutely. All right.
- 35:33We want to go to the Go to the Sailor clip for a minute.
- 35:35Let's do it. All right, let me pull that up.
- 35:41Before you pull it up, share how big your MSDR bags are.
- 35:43If you're if you're, you're showing Sailor, he must.
- 35:47My personal bags are non existent.
- 35:52OK. You might go want to go on mute.
- 35:59All right, point. A lot of people learn stuff from
- 36:05FT out of the Mount Gox, but I'm not sure they learned the things
- 36:09that the institutional community needs to learn going forward.
- 36:16The way the current conventional way to publish proof of reserves
- 36:20is an insecure proof of reserves.
- 36:22It actually, it actually dilutes the security of the issuer, the
- 36:28custodians, the exchanges, and the investors.
- 36:31It's not a good idea. It's a bad idea.
- 36:34It's like publishing the address and and the bank accounts of all
- 36:39your kids and your phone numbers of all your kids, and then
- 36:42thinking somehow that makes your family better.
- 36:44It doesn't make your family better.
- 36:46So no institutional grade or enterprise security analysts
- 36:51would think it's a good idea to publish all of the wallet
- 36:55addresses such that you can be traced back and forth and every
- 36:59future transaction you'll be traced.
- 37:02I was like, go to AI, put it in deep think mode and then ask it,
- 37:06what are the security problems of publishing your wallet
- 37:09addresses and how might they undermine the security of the
- 37:12company over time? It'll write you a book, It'll be
- 37:1650 pages of security problems. So, so the problem with proof of
- 37:21reserves, the way that people do it right now is it's it's first
- 37:24of all, it's a proof of assets that is insecure and it is not a
- 37:30proof of liabilities. And so if you're if you really
- 37:34want crypto security and you're maxi about this, my suggestion
- 37:39is buy Bitcoin, self custody your Bitcoin.
- 37:41It's pretty freaking obvious, right?
- 37:44You should own the Bitcoin yourself if that's what you
- 37:47want. If you're going to be a
- 37:49securities investor, OK, if you if you invest in securities,
- 37:55what you want is an institutional grade proof of
- 37:58assets and proof of liabilities with them netted out, OK.
- 38:03And the best practice of that is not to publish the wallet.
- 38:07The best practice of that would be have a BIG4 auditor that does
- 38:11an audit that checks to make sure that you actually have the
- 38:16Bitcoin. And then you also have to check
- 38:19to make sure the company hasn't re hypothecated or pledged the
- 38:24Bitcoin or entered or entered into any debt or credit
- 38:27obligations where the Bitcoin is pledged.
- 38:31And you have to net those out and you have to publish those
- 38:34and you have to sign them as the big four firm.
- 38:36Then you have to wash it through a public company where the CFO
- 38:40signs, then the CEO signs, then the chairman and all the outside
- 38:43directors are simply and criminally liable for it.
- 38:47And so if you really want the best practice for securities
- 38:51attestation, it would be a public company with a BIG4
- 38:55auditor with an audit subject to Sarbanes-Oxley in the United
- 38:59States. That's what my company is.
- 39:02It's much better than simply a proof of reserves wallet.
- 39:09At some point I would say I I can see implementing some kind
- 39:15of proof of reserves if you can come.
- 39:22Stopped it there. It's a long clip, won't play the
- 39:24whole thing, but the gist of it, the original question that was
- 39:27prompted from the audience was, you know, will Micro strategy
- 39:31ever publish a proof of reserves at the station like we've seen
- 39:36some of the ETETF issuers do to date?
- 39:39I think there's a few interesting things to pull out
- 39:41of here. I would say he's totally right
- 39:44on the component of, you know, proof of reserves is an
- 39:49incomplete picture. If you don't have proof of
- 39:51liabilities, then it's kind of, you know, worthless in some
- 39:56sense. And so on that point, I would
- 39:58totally agree with his stance. I think the other component of
- 40:01what he's saying is for a securitized version of Bitcoin
- 40:08exposure within a public company.
- 40:11Like what you actually want is just, you know, a BIG4 auditing
- 40:15firm to do the at station themselves and say this is how
- 40:18much Bitcoin they have. This is how much liabilities
- 40:20they have noted out. And that's sort of your
- 40:22financial picture. And you just trust that they're
- 40:24doing enough due diligence on the actual underlying custody
- 40:27and saying it's it's, you know, secure.
- 40:30I think where his, you know, I think the, the interesting part
- 40:35that people are talking about or, or, you know, pulling out of
- 40:39this or saying, you know, effectively, why wouldn't, you
- 40:43know, what is the security risk of just publishing the
- 40:45addresses? Because we've seen Bitwise ETF
- 40:48do this few others of, you know, publishing the address where the
- 40:52Bitcoin sits. Now he seems to be saying that
- 40:55that is a security risk because it, you know, I guess then
- 40:58becomes a larger target. But you know, if, if, if the, if
- 41:03the wall address is known, that in and of itself isn't
- 41:05necessarily the where the breach occurs.
- 41:07It's like, OK, if it's within a specific custodian, that's where
- 41:11you begin to have a single point of failure, right?
- 41:13So if like if something goes wrong at that entity, then
- 41:18something could go wrong with the Bitcoin.
- 41:19But I guess what he's trying to say is like his fear stems from
- 41:24highlighting where that single point of failure lies.
- 41:27Is that is that kind of your understanding of this?
- 41:29I'm not going curious your thoughts.
- 41:31I know you hadn't seen the clip, but like, I think that's where
- 41:34what he's getting at is like, why would I highlight where a
- 41:37potential single point of failure is?
- 41:41Yeah, I mean, I think it's, it's coherently incoherent.
- 41:45Like Michael Saylor's really sharp.
- 41:47There's a lot that he said that he helps conflate together to
- 41:51mask like a few things. One is ultimately I think it
- 41:55just comes down to optionality. If he doesn't have to provide
- 41:57through reserves, he just has future optionality to do other
- 42:00things with the asset. The I think it's obviously
- 42:04untrue from a security perspective from the blockchain
- 42:08protocol. If the while it's doxed,
- 42:10obviously you can get some like spam that we saw this with the
- 42:13proof reserve a bit wiser people are depositing tokens, but
- 42:16Bitcoin, but from a there's only so many custodians in the world
- 42:21and I think it's pretty much understood it's either Fidelity
- 42:23or Coinbase or some mixture of that that Sailor uses now.
- 42:29I think what he went in that long rant on the audit, is
- 42:34anybody listening to that would look at that and be like, sure,
- 42:37maybe you can pull that off, but that sounds insanely convoluted
- 42:43and how you would net out, manage, get audited and still
- 42:47have to trust the BIG4 auditor. And then there's no, there's a
- 42:49laundry list of fraud and, and, and, and I think the one that
- 42:54came was like 2019. There was a big one, I think
- 42:57either Asia Pacific or US credit wire or something.
- 43:01What he was alluding to was that's what you would want in a
- 43:03securitized version of Bitcoin because an ETF is fundamentally
- 43:08different, which should have inherent proof of reserves
- 43:10because that's what you're buying.
- 43:11So you want to know those assets and there should be no
- 43:13liabilities or that outside of the management structure and
- 43:15fees. So that kind of further supports
- 43:18why it's like in a long tail make zero sense why you would
- 43:21want securitized exposure because all that convoluted like
- 43:24what's the angle in a creativeness?
- 43:25You're, you're that's risk embedded into that cost
- 43:28structure versus just buying it. So I'll pause there.
- 43:32Does that make sense? Because then like we can go into
- 43:34the ETF, but anything you want to add on that side, go ahead.
- 43:39I think you hit the nail on the head.
- 43:42They have said that they want to be, you know, the Bitcoin Bank
- 43:45of the future, and that means lending out their Bitcoin.
- 43:47And so if they do that, they ultimately don't necessarily
- 43:51want everybody to understand how much Bitcoin they have versus
- 43:55how much they don't because there could be a quote UN quote
- 43:58bank run on, you know, strategy. I also think it has a lot to do
- 44:06with how they're and custodian. If let's just say it's Coinbase,
- 44:10it's understood kind of from the outside that they have a number
- 44:15of different wallets that are algorithmically, you know, done
- 44:18in order to put, you know, specific number of Bitcoin
- 44:23across like different wallets that would docks how their
- 44:28custodians are managing their own, you know, wallet.
- 44:34But ultimately, yeah, it's just it doesn't necessarily I think
- 44:38that the investors are fine with it.
- 44:40And so until they're not, then she can kind of just get away
- 44:44with having to do as little as possible in terms of their proof
- 44:48of reserves. Yeah.
- 44:50And this is ultimately that's those are great points.
- 44:52And this ultimately goes to why we've been doing these podcasts
- 44:56banging the drums for multiple years around multi institution
- 44:59and will continue to as the market slowly wakes up.
- 45:03Because at the end of the day, just like Bitcoin is the best
- 45:06product and nobody cares if you can pitch Bitcoin correctly or
- 45:09not because the market will adopt it.
- 45:10It's just it's because it's about self preservation is the
- 45:13same way everyone from an individual to sovereigns and
- 45:16micro strategy in the middle will eventually adopt multi
- 45:19institution because their shareholders won't allow it.
- 45:22That's the thing he didn't account for is if you're running
- 45:24a security, that means that you have beholden to shareholders.
- 45:28It's not really your Bitcoin and you have to manage it as a
- 45:31fiduciary. And it's actually it's not going
- 45:36to be deemed as credible if you do not leverage something that
- 45:39has inherent proof of reserve. So like, let's take a step back.
- 45:43I think there's two really important themes that again, you
- 45:46don't hear this publicly because nobody's incentivized to explain
- 45:49it. But one, you're not getting rid
- 45:52of KYC. It makes zero sense because you
- 45:54need to establish. And this goes back to the the
- 45:57more self side of things when it came to all the different
- 46:00factors around risk and injury and and personal harm is you'll
- 46:07hear people conflate KYC as the problem, but you can't get rid
- 46:10of KYC because of whether it's titling, inheritance and all the
- 46:13other issues when it comes to we're not getting rid of bank
- 46:16secrecy. And if we are bank secrecy and
- 46:18if we are, it still requires some understanding of who the
- 46:22owner is. So you need better market
- 46:25structure. You need better.
- 46:26You don't get rid of KYC for your Amazon shares.
- 46:28You want to know who owns them. You just have a better controls
- 46:30in place. That's what multi institution
- 46:32provides. The other side of that is proof
- 46:34of reserves is like a fallacy built into what people are
- 46:37trying to achieve in that. Oh, so I can prove it on the
- 46:40blockchain. Well, yes, there's the liability
- 46:43aspect, but I'm pretty confident you can glean a company's
- 46:47understanding and you can probably get some other
- 46:49accounting audits to support and tell a whole picture.
- 46:54But the other thing that nobody talks about is you can have
- 46:58proof of reserves of the single custodian in one day and be
- 47:01fully compliant and be everything on the books,
- 47:03correct? But the next day if they're
- 47:04hacked or somebody goes rogue at the firm, you lose all the
- 47:07assets. And then what was the point in
- 47:09providing the proof of reserves? And that's the whole notion of
- 47:12multi institution, whether it's two of three, three or five,
- 47:15five or seven, it scales proportionally to the amount of
- 47:18assets. But it's for the first time you
- 47:20have a wallet, it has provenance not only tied to 1 entity saying
- 47:24this is who the title owner is, There's three independent
- 47:27institutions that are all saying this title wallet is yours.
- 47:31But then also it's inherent to the underlying proof of reserves
- 47:35because those assets are all on the blockchain and they're
- 47:37provable. And so this is again, something
- 47:39that will become a standard just because again, when we talk
- 47:44about this deleveraging, that will happen naturally in the, in
- 47:47the Bitcoin treasury aspect, when somebody loses the assets
- 47:50or somebody's hacked or somebody's insolvent, then the
- 47:53market will start to naturally ask for this because why would
- 47:56you? It's just, it's just logical.
- 47:58Why would you, you know, give somebody your hard earned
- 48:00capital if you have no idea where the Bitcoin store?
- 48:02And he he goes into later to say there were lessons learned from
- 48:07FTX and Mount Goss, but you know, the people learned the
- 48:11wrong lessons. And the lessons should be don't
- 48:13work with offshore exchanges run by like childish tweakers.
- 48:18Any conveniently left out that Block Fi and Celsius and all
- 48:22those other. Ones prime trusts, prime trusts
- 48:24and fortress were regulated qualified custodians.
- 48:27There were US custodians have went under as well.
- 48:32And he's saying, you know, he's essentially implying that you
- 48:36can have some level of trust in US regulated custodians.
- 48:39But you know, ultimately this whole thing is about you don't
- 48:43necessarily need to trust any single institution because you
- 48:47can have three or five. You can see the Bitcoin address
- 48:50segregated in your own wallet. And so that's ultimately where,
- 48:55you know, every custodian who ultimately doesn't work in an
- 48:58MIC quorum is is going to go out of business.
- 49:00And every Bitcoin treasury company that doesn't show this
- 49:05or they don't even necessarily need to share their addresses
- 49:09with their investors. But if they don't necessarily
- 49:11show that they have MIC, it will ultimately, you know, the
- 49:17shareholders will move to those other Bitcoin treasury companies
- 49:21that do as they become more informed about the risks of, you
- 49:25know, working with a single custodian.
- 49:28Yeah, yeah. And, and it seems wild, but you
- 49:30know that there isn't this recognition of of the risks of a
- 49:34single custodian given, you know, the past 16 years.
- 49:37But it does seem like Michael, to your point, like it's going
- 49:40to take another something breaking somebody, losing keys,
- 49:44a jurisdiction, seizing assets that it will remind the entire
- 49:48market that there's there's real risk in trusting a single entity
- 49:53with custody of this asset. And there is now a way to
- 49:56distribute, distribute that counterparty risk so that you
- 49:59actually have fault tolerance in your setup and real resilience.
- 50:03So that's a nice little transition to we wanted to talk
- 50:07about some research that early riders put out.
- 50:09This is a multi part series on multi institution custody and
- 50:12why we believe it is sort of winner take all.
- 50:16Liam, maybe if you want to give like an intro, I'll pull up Part
- 50:181 right now. This is a multi part series that
- 50:20we're going to be putting out from early riders.
- 50:22Yeah, Kind of just taking a step back over the past 100 years,
- 50:26because custody hasn't been important, because it's been an
- 50:31asset that essentially you don't need to take custody of.
- 50:35You can always print more digital dollars.
- 50:37And if you lose them, there is insurance on them up to a
- 50:40certain amount. They showed with SBB that they
- 50:43will essentially cover any too big to fail custodians of
- 50:49assets. And that's fundamentally
- 50:52different than, you know, where we were for the past 100 years
- 50:55prior to that, as well as where we are now with both gold and
- 50:59physical digital bearer assets. You know, anybody could take
- 51:03custody of gold, but there was always somebody bigger and
- 51:05stronger who can come to your house and take it from you.
- 51:08The same thing is true with Bitcoin, except for that it's
- 51:12actually even more valuable because it can be distributed
- 51:16across multiple parties with multi state.
- 51:19And so that means, you know, one, we've been able to sidestep
- 51:24some of the challenges of gold within the 1st, let's say, 16 or
- 51:29so years with, you know, people holding Bitcoin in with their
- 51:34private keys, either in self custody, multi sig or
- 51:38collaborative custody across different jurisdictions.
- 51:41And, you know, some people that's still not without the
- 51:45inherent risk of, you know, somebody bigger and longer
- 51:48coming to your house and taking it from you.
- 51:50But ultimately that's what's going to happen, whether it's a
- 51:53government or these bad people who come in and, you know, cut
- 51:58people's fingers off. Just, you know, we, we brought
- 52:00up the five other slides earlier on and ultimately this, this
- 52:04whole thing is going towards every company that doesn't work
- 52:10with multi institution custody, that is financial service
- 52:13provider, whether it's buy, sell on ramp, you know, custodian who
- 52:20you want to work with for the next 100 plus years.
- 52:23Lender, any kind of party that you want to work with you, you
- 52:28really need to be able to have your Bitcoin for the long term.
- 52:32If we keep on talking about how this asset is going to be worth,
- 52:36you know, maybe even 50% of all assets in the future.
- 52:39And in order to get there, there's going to need to be or
- 52:44your, if you're a financial service firm, you're going to
- 52:46need to either work with MIC or you know you will ultimately
- 52:50lose the customers as they become more aware of all of
- 52:53these risks. Yeah, it's a great recap.
- 52:57I think this is the second part we'll cover.
- 53:02And I forget how many parts they ultimately got split up into,
- 53:05but the reality is we're actually going to put out as one
- 53:08piece and then thought it to do it justice.
- 53:11We'll piece it out and then talk about it a certain portion on
- 53:16the podcast to to make it a little bit more concrete.
- 53:20Like at the end of the day, Bitcoin is a new asset Liam keed
- 53:27on. It's different than gold.
- 53:29So the self custody component, while valuable, was predominant
- 53:35when the price was lower because there wasn't as much knowledge
- 53:37in the market. People steal from people's
- 53:39houses for much less than a Rolex watch.
- 53:42And so to think that hundreds of thousands, if not millions of
- 53:45dollars are going to be on our person.
- 53:47We're going to be open to risk. And so now like just breaking
- 53:52down three key components because what Liam's sharing is
- 53:56that multi institutions winner take all from the individual all
- 53:59the way to the institution from the individual.
- 54:02The three that are very easy to walk through and we can walk
- 54:05through a lot of them over the course of the next, you know,
- 54:07couple of weeks. But custody, inheritance and
- 54:09Iras, because you can say those are all objectively true.
- 54:12It's not to say multi institution should take over the
- 54:15100% of everyone's custody holdings or will.
- 54:20It's to say that for a large percentage you do not want to
- 54:24have that on your person and have yourself at the single
- 54:27point of failure in the same way you can have the third
- 54:30individual. You know, custody is the bedrock
- 54:32for all financial services. So now when you start thinking
- 54:34about some of the most, you know, obvious examples is
- 54:38inheritance is a very critical one.
- 54:40People preserve their wealth so they can pass it on.
- 54:42Well, if you leave it on a third party exchange, we all know that
- 54:45those probably don't outlive you.
- 54:47But then also, if you leave it on a hardware device, not only
- 54:50will the hardware device definitely not outlive you
- 54:52because of they just suffer from bit rot.
- 54:54They're pieces of technology, but ultimately you're left at
- 54:57best creating a treasure map for your family.
- 54:59These are all objectives really true.
- 55:00They're not like, you know, theoretical examples.
- 55:03The other one is Iras IRA is a great one because that's meant
- 55:06to live into the future, whether it's 10 to 30 years,
- 55:09historically, exchanges and custodians haven't lived that
- 55:11long and then definitely devices don't.
- 55:14And that brings up that issue on the other side of it just to
- 55:17further support, you know, on the business side, it's a thing
- 55:21that we fundamentally look at when we're investing in
- 55:23companies, whether it's, you know, on ramp as well as other
- 55:26companies. Building a multi institution is
- 55:28at the end of the day, it's just a Better Business model.
- 55:31Not only does it allow you to have a more robust offering to
- 55:34offer services to a majority or larger part of the market,
- 55:37specifically high net worths, because when they made larger
- 55:40amounts, they're not going to want to take delivery of all of
- 55:42that. But it also from a pure
- 55:44investment perspective, gives the exchange or the financial
- 55:47service firm better unit economics because now they're
- 55:51not trying to fight for every net new client.
- 55:53They're able to have reoccurring, reoccurring
- 55:57predictable revenue so they can build not only other financial
- 56:02services, reduce the cost that would traditionally be on like
- 56:04the brokerage and the buy sell side, but then also just have
- 56:09closeness and stickiness with the client to build other
- 56:11financial products. This is something you just don't
- 56:14see in the market today. You generally see it fragmented
- 56:16and somebody's offering collaborative custody, which is
- 56:18practically like free, which is a not necessarily the best long
- 56:21term model if you're hoping they're going to be around or
- 56:24you have the alternative where you have a Bitcoin brokerage,
- 56:27but they're constantly having to fight for net new clients.
- 56:29And that's worked because the Bitcoin total addressable market
- 56:32has been relatively small. But as the market gets further
- 56:35and further penetrated, you're going to naturally need to
- 56:38differentiate. And so that's the idea behind
- 56:42the winner take all is. And that's not even accounting
- 56:44for the ETFs and Treasury, where the markets just naturally going
- 56:47to gravitate to the most robust offering that protects their
- 56:51investment. Yeah.
- 56:53And one thing worth calling out, too is that if people are just
- 56:59told, hey, take this off the exchange, not your keys, not
- 57:02your coins, you're inherently going to limit how much business
- 57:05you can do. Because people get uncomfortable
- 57:08when they hear stories about, you know, people's fingers being
- 57:11chopped off and don't want to keep on buying this Bitcoin and
- 57:14storing it in their house because they're already
- 57:16uncomfortable. And yeah, as Michael mentioned,
- 57:19this is going to go across all different, you know, financial
- 57:24service providers and should be some get a pre announce, a pre
- 57:29announcement of, you know, some interesting announcements that
- 57:33should come out of the early rider side about, you know,
- 57:35other ways to use MIC moving forward and you know, would
- 57:40encourage any other founders interested in this to reach out
- 57:43as well. Yep, very well said, Michael.
- 57:47Maybe you want to walk through like just like a practical
- 57:50example of the financial services that get built on this
- 57:52more resilient foundation. So maybe if you just want to
- 57:54like touch on lending markets for example and and how MIC is
- 57:58ultimately winner take all for that type of financial service
- 58:01built on Bitcoin as well. Yeah, lending's the the prime
- 58:05example because we've seen it done in a different iteration
- 58:09where the keys are segregated at my previous firm and we're the
- 58:14only retail lender left standing kind of without ever suffering a
- 58:17loan loss. If you go to the market, even
- 58:19some of the players that are still existing that were around
- 58:23during block flying FTX in Celsius, they took significant
- 58:26hits and almost went under. And if, if I joke internally or
- 58:31when we're on calls, if you ever want to know, like hell on earth
- 58:33is having a margin like a loan out and getting margin called.
- 58:39As you know, naturally, the market's volatile and you not
- 58:42knowing if your counterparty, if you do a Bitcoin back loan with
- 58:45a single entity, not knowing if your counterparty is going to be
- 58:49solvent. So you're depositing BTC because
- 58:51you need to or you're going to get liquidated.
- 58:54You see your precious Bitcoin potentially is going to be sold
- 58:56off, but you also are sending more precious Bitcoin into that
- 59:00custodial solution, not knowing if there are still solvent and
- 59:03you're ever going to see it. And so multi institutions, a
- 59:06great example of this because now you have three independent
- 59:10different key holders managing that collateral, needing to work
- 59:14on behalf of the client, not only to manage the collateral,
- 59:18but make sure that the Bitcoin is safely guarded and
- 59:21distributions are made. But you can see how over time as
- 59:27more volatility, you know, loan to values compressed because
- 59:30people get more competitive, there's going to be, you know,
- 59:34just a higher risk appetite, which will incur more losses
- 59:37that the market starts to really coalesce around a more
- 59:41bulletproof, resilient foundation for for lending.
- 59:45And then what indirectly this happens.
- 59:47It's very similar. We'll save it for a different
- 59:49conversation, but on round insurance and how we're able to
- 59:51get our $100 million Lloyds of London policy is because they're
- 59:55isolated, segregated wallets and not omnibus, you're able to
- 59:59start credibly now bringing more and more dollars into the
- 1:00:02ecosystem at lower rates. Because if you think about it
- 1:00:06from a lender perspective, it gets a lot of slack.
- 1:00:08But the reason why lending rates are so high in Bitcoin is
- 1:00:11because it's private capital. Institutional capital is
- 1:00:14generally not been here. And it's simple because if
- 1:00:17institutional capital deemed Bitcoin back loans is not risky,
- 1:00:20even though everyone listening here knows they're not in
- 1:00:22bitcoins for staying collateral. Think about it.
- 1:00:24The the asset price would be much higher because institutions
- 1:00:27would have just bought the Bitcoin because if they
- 1:00:29understand bitcoins kegger versus the loan loans.
- 1:00:31So you have to force dollars out of private capital's hands and
- 1:00:36reward them for that risk. But over time, as that starts
- 1:00:40to, you know, proliferate, more people know about Bitcoin and
- 1:00:43especially institutional capital comes in.
- 1:00:46Well, now they're going to look at well, what's the riskiness of
- 1:00:48the underlying? Where is it custody?
- 1:00:50And so you can see how that naturally drives down prices as
- 1:00:52well. And so it's like a marketplace
- 1:00:55structure, right? You need more people demanding
- 1:00:57better loans and more credible lending constructs, but then
- 1:01:00institutional capital will feel more confident in there.
- 1:01:03So we have some exciting announcements on that space.
- 1:01:05And like Liam said, also just global on ramps that will be
- 1:01:08leveraging multi institution to it's, I don't even know if it's
- 1:01:12out compete, but I guess it is. I just don't think multi
- 1:01:14institution competes with single custodial exchanges because once
- 1:01:18the market's educated, they naturally don't go back to those
- 1:01:21entities unless it's for like, you know, friendly money to just
- 1:01:24buy a little bit of Bitcoin and then move it off into multi
- 1:01:27institution because there's no reason to trust a single
- 1:01:29institution after multi institution custody exists.
- 1:01:35Very well said. And as mentioned, this is a
- 1:01:37multi part series. So we'll have the next
- 1:01:40iterations, the next parts of the series coming out over the
- 1:01:43next few weeks and we'll continue to touch on touch on
- 1:01:46them here on the show and we'll link to these first two parts in
- 1:01:49in the show notes. Anything else before we wrap,
- 1:01:52boys? A great RIP.
- 1:01:56Well, if anybody's listening to this before last trade, we'll
- 1:01:58probably pick up on last trade on everything happening this
- 1:02:02week during the conference and talking about it in real time.
- 1:02:05So yeah, we'll try to get this one out for people traveling to
- 1:02:08the conference. And then if you're around, we'll
- 1:02:10we'll be talking about it. If you're not at the conference,
- 1:02:11this will be your recap to hear in real time while everyone's
- 1:02:14having fun. All righty.
- 1:02:17Sounds good. Thanks boys.
- 1:02:19Thanks. Later, thanks for listening to
- 1:02:22this week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:02:25valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:02:28rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:02:30All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:02:32notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:02:35reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:02:37entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:02:40investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:02:43your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:02:46Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:02:50one of our private Client advisors.