Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Are Bowl Game Opt-Outs Soon To Be A Thing Of The Past?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody. Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony? It's
- 0:12not like always because today we're talking about everyone's favorite topic, Tony. We're
- 0:20talking anti trust legislation. Tony. No, no, no, stop,
- 0:23don't don't. Don't change the podcast just yet. This is important. You
- 0:27got to kind of understand this. We will try to make it fun.
- 0:31I will try to read as few statutes as possible. No ten point three
- 0:35point three point two today, probably at least not yet. That will eventually
- 0:42happen once all of this stuff gets settled. But I do want to talk
- 0:45about the house versus NCAA thing that is happening and nil. But the first
- 0:52thing I want to talk about to get to that point was, and this
- 0:55is going to be a Ross Ellancher heavy show. Him and Pete Thamil are
- 1:00the two best guys nationwide in college football in terms of like the big picture
- 1:03thing. Ross Allendrew has been doing a great job for Yahoo with all of
- 1:08this NCAA stuff, and so something that he tweeted out on Wednesday was a
- 1:15conversation with the Bowl season director and BOL season is it's exactly what it sounds
- 1:21like. It's got a director. Basically, he wouldn't think it does what
- 1:23it does because it's an entire season. Bowl season director Nick Carparelli told Yahoo
- 1:30Sports in Phoenix that he expects NIL to soon come in house and for athletes
- 1:34to sign binding compensation contracts with schools that will will require them to play in
- 1:40bowls and college football playoff games, eliminating or greatly reducing opt outs. And
- 1:47we've been talking for a while now about how NIL is going to come in
- 1:51house, how exactly that happens, and what exactly that will and Tail will
- 1:53get into it a little bit later, but the idea that this is something
- 2:00that has been coming on, like if you bring it in house or you
- 2:05know, like why are players allowed to opt out when they've signed deals for
- 2:08money for play essentially, and so this would perhaps eliminate that by making that
- 2:17part of the deal part of the conversation, especially if it's in house,
- 2:22then maybe there's more recourse for the schools. I don't know whether you hold
- 2:28that last big check or the last quarterly check before until after the postseason,
- 2:34but I know this is something that has been going on for a while and
- 2:37wanting to get fixed for a while. And it's one of those things like
- 2:40you don't even expect. There was no chance Marvin Harrison was going to be
- 2:44playing in the bowl game last year. And we've seen it every year.
- 2:47Who's gonna opt out this year, Who's gonna opt out next year? I'm
- 2:53still wondering exactly how holding out or you know, I sure want to get
- 2:59that. I don't know one hundred and eighty five thousand dollars check is going
- 3:01to outweigh well. I sure don't want to get hurt and ruin my forty
- 3:06million dollar career. Yeah, I think there are certainly questions about how these
- 3:13things are going to be structured and how they're going to be enforced. And
- 3:16if you're a school like Ohio State, is it really in your best interest
- 3:22if you miss the college football Playoff to basically strong arm people into playing in
- 3:27a ballgame, and then if someone gets hurt then and it hurts their draft
- 3:30status, that feels like that's probably not really going to be in your long
- 3:37term best interest. I do want to have you back up, Tony,
- 3:39and I just want you to tell me again, tell the listeners again,
- 3:45who was it that talked to Ross Dellinger and explain to all of this.
- 3:50It was the Ball season director, Nick CARPERELLI mm hmmm. He directs the
- 3:58season of the Balls. So, if you, Tony, were in the
- 4:02position of the being the person who wants to direct the season of the Bowls,
- 4:08and you had seen and participation numbers dropping and in some cases interest level
- 4:14in some of your bowls dropping, as you have guys opting out, and
- 4:19you're probably trying to negotiate future contracts with TV entities about your games, it
- 4:30feels like, and correct me if I'm wrong here, but it feels like
- 4:32it would be in your best interest to kind of go not a no,
- 4:35bro, We've got this. We have got this fixed. The solution is
- 4:40coming. It's not going to be a problem. Don't worry. Trust me,
- 4:43bro, I can fix it. My dad has a whole bunch of
- 4:46tools. We can fix this. I don't know that this is going to
- 4:51be such a clean and easy solution as the director of the Bowl season might
- 4:58have you believe, just because I think there are questions about exactly how enforceable
- 5:04these deals will be, how they're going to be structured. If it's even
- 5:06in the school's best interest to try and enforce these I'm not sure the hit
- 5:14to Ohio State. Let's just go back to let's say that the Fiesta Bowl
- 5:18with Ohio State and Notre Dame like ten years ago, now, nine years
- 5:24ago, now, where Jalen Smith, the linebacker for Notre Dame got hurt
- 5:28and you know, blew out his knee in the ball game, was really
- 5:30kind of never the same, probably hurt his draft stock quite a bit blowing
- 5:33out his knee in a game that he now would have almost certainly opted out
- 5:38of. So if in that case, Notre Dame had kind of twisted his
- 5:42arm a little bit and said no, no, no, you have to
- 5:45play or we're going to withhold your last nil payment, that probably is not
- 5:49a great look for Notre Dame if that's how that all plays out, and
- 5:51then that leads to a loss of you know, you know, potentially a
- 5:57significant multiple of whatever you're last nil payment was in terms of lost NFL earnings
- 6:02and your first contract, and maybe you never get to that second contract.
- 6:05And that just feels like, I don't know that this is in the players
- 6:12or the school's best interests, And I don't know that the schools and the
- 6:14players are necessarily going to be willing to work against their best interests to serve
- 6:17the best interests of the bowl season folks. But I understand why the ballseason
- 6:21folks would want to have that message out there that, oh, yes,
- 6:24certainly they are well. And with these twelve team playoffs and whatever the expansion
- 6:31fourteen team or whatever it happens now, the ball games have been continued to
- 6:38continue to be diminished, and so you've got to try to do what you
- 6:44can do. I don't think that if you don't make it in a twelve
- 6:47or fourteen team playoff, the only purpose for having a bowl game for the
- 6:55say, Ohio State does not make the playoffs. The only reason for them
- 6:58to have to go play in a game at this point is for next year.
- 7:02So do you really need somebody who would rather opt out taking those reps?
- 7:08Do you need Marvin Harrison taking those reps that could go to Carnel Tate?
- 7:12No, you'd rather just have You've already moved on to next year.
- 7:15Yeah, sure, Well, we want to do right by the seniors.
- 7:18You can, I mean do right. However, you you know there's only
- 7:23so much right you can do by the seniors because you've missed the playoffs,
- 7:25and that's where the weight of the season now is. So do right by
- 7:30the seniors by taking care of them after football as best you can. And
- 7:34how come the coaches are tasked with doing right by the seniors, but the
- 7:40juniors aren't? You know, some of the juniors like, well, you
- 7:42know, I'm just gonna or the seniors. The seniors are the seniors that
- 7:45are leaving, Like you want to do right by the seniors, the seniors
- 7:47are opting out as well. So where is the real need to do that
- 7:54when, as I said, the bowl game is about next year more than
- 7:59in my opinion, probably not in the coach's opinions, but more about next
- 8:03year than this year, especially when you're talking lower levels. Now, you're
- 8:07you if you if Ohio State does not make a twelve or fourteen team playoff,
- 8:13that season is a disaster. This is this is Gator Bowl two thousand
- 8:18and eleven territory. Yeah, there was a tweet I think that got put
- 8:22out that Ohio State had never finished lower than seventh during the college football the
- 8:28four team college football playoff era, so they would have made it every single
- 8:31year. So there has not been a team going back to, like you
- 8:35said that, the twenty eleven team, and even before that, probably not.
- 8:39I mean you might have to go back to like two thousand and four
- 8:41for a season that was not a weird interim coach kind of season where Ohio
- 8:48State would have missed the playoff, like clearly missed the playoff. So yeah,
- 8:52you're talking about the almost generational disaster of a season by the Ohio State
- 8:56standard to miss the college football playoff in a twelve team format. So yeah,
- 9:01I just I don't think this is going to be necessarily the clean and
- 9:05easy solution that that the Bold Season folks would like you to think it is,
- 9:11because there's you have players dealing with their best interest. You have played
- 9:13coach schools dealing with their best interest, and those are not necessarily always going
- 9:18to align with the with the bowl season's best interest. And you know,
- 9:22there was also a you know, I don't I don't mean to do like
- 9:24Twitter digest here, but I'm going to paraphrase. There was a tweet I
- 9:28saw a couple of days ago that was basically, you know, so you're
- 9:31gonna have a deal. You're gonna have a contract with your school. That's
- 9:37going to be enforceable, and your compensation is going to be tied to your
- 9:41performance. Huh. And so it's like, oh, so they're athletes now
- 9:43it's like no, no, no, no, no, they're they're they're
- 9:45not their employees now, no no, no, no, no no,
- 9:46we're not employees. This is just nil. It's like, well, that
- 9:48sounds an awful lot like an employer employee relationship. So a lot of this
- 9:56stuff it all sounds good and I do. And we'll get into the house
- 10:01case in a minute, and why this is probably a very good idea for
- 10:05the NC DOUBLEA. But this is not a permanent solution to anything right now.
- 10:11This is a you know, this is this is the NC DOUBLEA running
- 10:15around with just buckets of water, just throwing buckets of water on different house
- 10:18fires and trying to put it out. It's like, oh, so so
- 10:22this is a sprinkler system. It's like, no, I'm just running around
- 10:24in an absolute panic trying to put out each individual house fire right now as
- 10:28kind of the whole village is burning. So this is not you know,
- 10:31this is not a permanent solution. This is just a Okay, let's get
- 10:37through this. Existential threat and try and survive this, and then that will
- 10:41maybe buy us a little more time to try and put something more permanent into
- 10:46place. But you know, hey, we might need Congress to do something.
- 10:48So I'm sure, Tony, Tony, those clowns in Congress may be
- 10:54added again, and if they are, well, they might just save college
- 10:56football as we know it well. And we'll see. And so let's let's
- 11:01get into this house versus the NCAA as we also dive into Congress and what
- 11:05they will be doing. But so this is basically a lawsuit by a a
- 11:09a doctor who plays by his own rules, Tony, is it lupus?
- 11:16Nobody's checked, but it might be lupus. So this is one of several
- 11:22lawsuits being brought against the NCAA regarding amateurism and money that is owed and things
- 11:33like that, and money that is due and money that should be being made
- 11:37by these student athletes, or that they should be allowed to collect and share
- 11:41in the revenue that they are creating. And it's it's sounding like there's they're
- 11:48getting closer and closer to a settlement basically, and I believe the judge in
- 11:54some of these cases has been like you guys might want to settle, telling
- 11:56the NCAA like you you really and the NCAA being the presidents of the university,
- 12:01that's really what the NCAA is made up of. It's the schools.
- 12:03They're like, you know, what you ought to do here is you might
- 12:07want to come up with a number and settle because you don't want to go
- 12:11through this and lose. And right now, the number being talked about is
- 12:15like a billion dollars and there's a four year statute of limitations, so it
- 12:18only compensate players from from four years ago to yesterday ish, and you're talking,
- 12:28you know, like a billion dollars of lost nil revenue is basically what
- 12:33this is about. And the thing is, if if you don't settle and
- 12:37you take this to court and you lose, now you're talking about tripling that
- 12:43and you know and more basically, because it may not just be a billion,
- 12:48it could be more. And so you you have you could really really
- 12:54stand to lose if you lose. And based on every single lawsuit that we've
- 12:58seen come up against the NCI at this point, there is no reason to
- 13:01think the NCAA is going to win any kind of court case being brought against
- 13:05them right now, Yeah, right now. The NCAA has been playing the
- 13:09role of the Washington generals in pretty much every court from the lowest to literally
- 13:15the Supreme Court where they lost nine to nothing on something. Try to get
- 13:18nine Supreme Court justices to agree on literally anything. And you had the in
- 13:24that case and the judges just it was basically like a dunkline going up against
- 13:30the NCAA. So the NCAA, I think has kind of figured out like
- 13:33this is not probably a winning strategy for us. And you mentioned, you
- 13:37mentioned there real quickly that the damages are going to be tripled. There is
- 13:41a legal term for this. It is during the anti trust cases. It's
- 13:45called the damages being trebled, and it is that it's the opposite of being
- 13:50based if my music understanding is correct. But yes, the damages are tripled
- 13:54in anti trust cases. So therefore instead of a million dollar dollars in change,
- 14:00it was like four point six million dollars was the expected loss. And
- 14:05where that money comes from, that's not like, well, Mark Emmert has
- 14:07to pay back his bonuses from a couple of years ago and that'll cover it.
- 14:13That is, every NCUBA member school that's where that money comes from,
- 14:18and it you know, maybe it comes out of the NCUBA tournament revenues and
- 14:20you're just not getting NCAA tournament revenues for I don't know, ten years or
- 14:24something like that. Like that, that is going to have a massive impact
- 14:28on school's bottom lines at a time when schools are potentially, as part of
- 14:33this, looking at paying money out, paying out fifteen twenty million dollars a
- 14:37year in terms of additional expenditures. And then you know, if you're also
- 14:43at that point taking in a lot less money from the NCUBA, that is
- 14:46not real good for your ballance sheet. I did not finish my accounting degree,
- 14:50but I took enough to remember that a lot less income and a lot
- 14:54more expenses is not great for you in terms of your your your balance sheets.
- 15:00So this is this is all about limiting the downside and limiting the fact,
- 15:05you know, limiting the fact that yeah, you're probably going to probably
- 15:09going to lose. It's probably going to be a real disaster. If you
- 15:13settle now, it simplifies everything. You know, the folks going after the
- 15:18money will get the money sooner. You limit the possibility for them that,
- 15:22you know, something crazy happens, and they don't get the settlement they want
- 15:26or they don't get the judgment that they want. And also it allows the
- 15:30inside of LA to potentially try to control this a little bit, because what
- 15:35has happened with the NC double A a lot over the last couple of years
- 15:37is you have outside forces going, I'll fix it, and that has you
- 15:43know, a lot of this started with well, the state of California has
- 15:48ruled that you can basically pay player players should control their NIL rights, and
- 15:52the state of Florida has ruled that the players can control their n AL rights,
- 15:56and at that point, the NC double A lost control, you know,
- 15:58the loss contain at that point, and you're now seeing new states.
- 16:03Virginia just passed one where the schools can pay players directly potentially for their NIL
- 16:10starting very soon. So what the NCA DOUAA is desperately trying to do is
- 16:14make the house case go away, because that is the single biggest existential threat
- 16:18to the organization and to its members, but also desperately trying to gain you
- 16:23know, gain control of how is this problem going to be solved? And
- 16:27even if they do kind of solve it, right now, this is not
- 16:30a permanent solution. This just buys them some time, you know, a
- 16:34span of what five years or so to then potentially put a more permanent solution
- 16:40in place, involving maybe congressional action, maybe legislative action at state lew.
- 16:45I mean, you don't know exactly what it is. This is just okay.
- 16:49You know, this is Apollo thirteen and we've got to figure out a
- 16:52way to use this SoC and this you know, this role of duct tape
- 16:56and this wad of chewing gum and we've got to fix the fix the thing
- 17:00before we run out of oxygen, and then we'll figure out how to get
- 17:02the spaceship back down to Earth. Well, if you ever want to suck
- 17:07the oxygen out of something, bring up politics. And I don't remember who
- 17:14exactly it was, they're all the same, but basically one of the congress
- 17:18people was like, we were not going to save you. We will help
- 17:22you. You need to save yourself and then we can talk. And this
- 17:26is really where the settlement would do that, because it's not just about back
- 17:30pay, it's also about future pay and how things would be set up and
- 17:33how what this model would look like. And one of the proposals, or
- 17:38I guess one of the things being socialized right now among presidents and the administrators
- 17:44would be like a fifteen to twenty million dollar revenue sharing thing per school in
- 17:49Ohio state brings in, however, two hundred million dollars a year whatever,
- 17:55fifteen or twenty of that would go to their athletes, mostly football. I
- 18:00mean, it's it's the biggest, biggest team anyway, so and it's also
- 18:03the one that brings in money and more money than all of the others,
- 18:08you know, certainly, so not everybody would be able to do that.
- 18:15And that's also one of these things that I think the main attorney in bringing
- 18:19this case, who's bringing others, is like one of his points is they're
- 18:23not all. All of these schools are not created equal, and they shouldn't
- 18:29be treated equally. The schools that can afford to do this can do it,
- 18:33and the schools that don't don't have to. But when when these power
- 18:37for schools now are generating so much revenue and they have they have this TV
- 18:41money, they have all of this money coming in, some of that should
- 18:45be going to the athletes. Toledo's not bringing in enough to share fifteen to
- 18:49twenty million, ten to fifteen million with their athletes. Go go look at
- 18:55the the MAC television contracts compared to the Big ten and the SEC, and
- 19:00you're talking like the entire conference is not making what one team is making,
- 19:03so vastly different worlds that everybody is living in. But if they can get
- 19:11this settlement done and whatever, that looks like you said five years, and
- 19:17Ross Dolingger is saying it might give them eight to ten years until the next
- 19:22round of lawsuits, because that's just the way things are, whether it's you
- 19:26know, the collective bargaining of the Athletes Union or whatever it's going to be
- 19:33called. You know, you sign a five year deal and because good luck
- 19:37getting an eight or a ten year deal out of the first players Union of
- 19:41college sports. It's not going to happen because this is going to be a
- 19:44learning process and you're never going to want to give up that much control.
- 19:48So eight to ten years seems pretty lofty in that. And also the way
- 19:52the sport is moving right now, the revenue is going to be changing in
- 19:56different ways from cable, which is you know whatever that is, to streaming
- 20:00to you know whatever, things are going to look like we've seen. Ask
- 20:06the ACC how they feel about projecting too far ahead right now, tom Right,
- 20:11the ACC is currently in a I keep using the phrase existential crisis involving
- 20:15different entities, but that's really what we're what they're in right now, where
- 20:19they are currently held together by the grant of rights that's been signed there,
- 20:23and that's the only thing that's keeping everyone from just scattering to the wins because
- 20:29everyone is upset because they signed a deal in the mid twenty tens in order
- 20:33to get the ACC network made set up, and they signed like a twenty
- 20:36year deal. It doesn't expire till twenty thirty six, and the market has
- 20:40changed quite a bit, but their deal has not. So they're making substantially
- 20:44less than pretty much all the other leagues, especially the SEC and Big ten,
- 20:49and they're not really able to compete financially. And just you mentioned Toledo
- 20:53earlier in terms of not being able to compete financially with you know, Ohio
- 20:57State and schools like that. Ohio State has an athletic budget annually of north
- 21:03of two hundred million dollars. Toledo's is thirty five million dollars. Give or
- 21:07take Kent State which is a smaller max school is twenty five million, so
- 21:11Ohio State might be spending potentially close to as much just on paying players directly
- 21:17if this model goes into effect, as it's sort of laid out as Kent
- 21:21State's entire athletic budget, and you know, yes, they're playing the same
- 21:25sport and they're doing it in the same state, but really they're kind of
- 21:29not. This is really kind of two teams or organizations playing at very different
- 21:33levels. And this is I think a reflection of the fact that Ohio State
- 21:37and Louisiana mon Roe or Alabama, and Troy or Michigan and Eastern Michigan,
- 21:44Michigan and Eastern Michigan are separated by about seven miles and probably about one hundred
- 21:48and eighty million dollars or so in athletic revenue every year. It's kind of
- 21:53the same thing, but it's really very much not. So I do wonder
- 22:00how there are a lot of conflating and conflicting factors at work here where you
- 22:07mentioned, you know, hey, fifteen twenty million dollars, that's all going
- 22:10to go to or mostly going to go to football players because that's where the
- 22:11revenue comes from. They get to figure out the title nine piece of this,
- 22:15because the title nine piece of this says that you've got to have,
- 22:18you know, basically equivalent opportunities for female athletes as you do for male athletes.
- 22:23So is that going to mean equivalent nil deals just in terms of numbers
- 22:29you have to pay an equivalent number. Is that going to be that you
- 22:32have to pay an equivalent amount. We don't know that yet. I think
- 22:36there's certainly an argument to be made that it might be more of a you
- 22:40have to pay an equivalent number of athletes, maybe a set fee. That's
- 22:45what the Charlie Baker NCAA model was. You had to pay basically an equivalent
- 22:48number of female athletes and male athletes about thirty thousand dollars a year. That
- 22:52was something that got floated a couple months ago. But none of this.
- 22:56You don't know this for a fact. The reason I'm the reason I say
- 23:00that's possible is because you're not you're not required to spend the same amount on
- 23:03women's basketball as you are in men's basketball, or you know, you have
- 23:07to spend the same amount on women's sports as you do men's sports. It's
- 23:10just you have to have the same number of scholarships. So but they have
- 23:12to figure that out. That's that's not absolutely settled, like, yeah,
- 23:17absolutely everyone will be fine with this because you have the folks who want equivalent
- 23:22access and type, you know, all the stuff that title mind set out
- 23:26to do, and you have the market forces which say, yeah, football
- 23:30should be getting a huge chunk of this. And you've got you know,
- 23:33people who are you are you trying to keep just football going because we've had
- 23:38lots of people talk about, hey, you know, this is a great
- 23:41way to go from twenty sports to six because we can't pay for all the
- 23:44other sports because football has you know, subsidized a lot of those other sports
- 23:48financially for decades. So there are just a lot of different parties that are
- 23:52involved in this, with a lot of different priorities, and I think it's
- 23:56going to be quite a mess to sort it out because you know, you're
- 24:00talking about unionizing college athletes. That is not a monolithic voting block by any
- 24:07means, even if it's football players, you're gonna have you know, Trevor
- 24:11Lawrence and Justin Fields had different interests than some other guys back in twenty twenty
- 24:15and you're you're going to have you know, your your top top level guys
- 24:19who are probably going to be making the you know, the the top level
- 24:23scale whatever the NIL deal is. They have different interests than the you know,
- 24:30star field hockey player or the star men's tennis player, or you know,
- 24:36whichever sport. There's just there's a lot of different parties with a lot
- 24:40of different interests. And I think it's going to be that's going to be
- 24:41a challenge for the athletes and whatever unionization or collective collective action type group that
- 24:49they put together. I think that's going to be a challenge to figure out
- 24:52how do you weigh all these different priorities because everyone has something slightly different that
- 24:56they care about. Well, I can't even get into the if these players
- 25:04athletes become employees and the different states that have different rules for unions of state
- 25:11employees and that sort of thing. Like there are so many branches to this,
- 25:17and I do like in the part in the Ross Dellinger article talking about
- 25:21Charlie Baker and say President back in January, the quote and the story from
- 25:27Dellinger is that Baker said he believed the title nine terminology is more about equal
- 25:33participation and not so much equal amounts. It's that the question again, it's
- 25:38like, well, I think that's what it would mean, but that's another
- 25:41thing that has to get figured out. And so one of the ideas in
- 25:47all of this is that, well, players will just you know, everything
- 25:49goes in house, and I ale goes in the house players. Schools will
- 25:52buy the NIL rights from the players. And I'm thinking, how many players
- 26:00aren't signing over their NIL rights to schools because there's gonna be plenty of them,
- 26:06you know, you know, you'll have QB Eagles on some of these
- 26:11teams basically because you know, we saw that in the NFL, where you
- 26:15don't necessarily sign over to your rights to the Players Association or the QB Club
- 26:18back in the eighties and nineties or where they're you know what, Marvin Harrison
- 26:23was delayed in doing something with the with the NFL PA or whatever and wasn't
- 26:30able to put a jersey out. But I don't know why. I don't
- 26:37see all of the players, especially with the number of agents and attorneys and
- 26:41family members they have giving them advice. Now, I don't think you're going
- 26:47to see all players sign over their NIL rights to schools, and unless there
- 26:53is, unless it's just some sort of thing where they just handle it,
- 27:00but you can still facilitate, like players themselves can still facilitate and they get
- 27:03it all. It's just the school now becomes part of your agency rather than
- 27:08that's they're in control of it. Well, and if the school is part
- 27:15of your agency, then how many more people does the school need to bring
- 27:18in? And now the school is you know, are they bringing in less
- 27:22money from TV deals? We don't know? Are they paying out more money
- 27:26for you know, to twenty million dollars a year to players, And now
- 27:30you get to add and they take a taste. Yeah, yeah, it's
- 27:33it's a this is this is one of these things where you read the articles
- 27:38like oh dust soft hands problem solved, Great work everyone, and it's like,
- 27:44well, I mean, this could potentially be a step in the right
- 27:48direction. But every time I read one of these articles, I walk away
- 27:53feeling like, well, I guess that's something. But I'm also walking away
- 28:00with like seven more questions than I had beforehand, because there's just there's we
- 28:04haven't even talked about. You know what, what does the unionization process look
- 28:08like? And I am not going to pretend to be a labor attorney here.
- 28:11But you know, I've listened to some folks from the NLRB, which
- 28:15is the National Labor Relations Board, talking about this in the past, and
- 28:22you know, there are there are pieces of how is this going to shake
- 28:25out? And will unions be recognized or you know, will they be able
- 28:27to form the you know, will the players be able to form a union
- 28:32and is that going to be a national nationally recognized thing. And some of
- 28:34that depends on so who's in charge of the government at that given moment,
- 28:38because you may have different philosophies in terms of what you know, how you
- 28:41want to run the NLRB. There are just so many moving pieces and parts
- 28:47here and so many different parties that I think anyone who's looking at this and
- 28:51going, I know, how this is going to get resolved is tony.
- 28:56I don't want to use the word charlatan, but it it feels like that
- 29:00is statistically unlikely that you really do understand every single piece and part of this
- 29:06whole deal, because there are so many different parties with so many different interests,
- 29:11and a lot of these things are going to be in conflict, and
- 29:15I doubt that even the folks in charge can say with any great degree of
- 29:19certainty, what is this going to look like in five years, Because if
- 29:22you go back five years ago, the stuff we're talking about now would have
- 29:26sounded crazy. Five years ago. You know, here's a college football player
- 29:33standing at a standing at a car dealership getting handed keys to the car.
- 29:37You would have thought that was you know, investigative reporter from rival schools sitting
- 29:41in the bushes with a long you know, a telephoto lens taking pictures of
- 29:45that, and boy, this is going to be a big scandal. And
- 29:47now it's like, you know, and now this is a TV commercial.
- 29:48So things have changed so much in the last five years, in such unpre
- 29:56predictable zigs and zags that I don't I don't even want to begin guessing what
- 30:02things might look like five years from now. And you know, I mean,
- 30:06whatever, college football will be here one way or another, but what's
- 30:10that actually going to look like? And what's that structure going to be?
- 30:12Good? Good luck. You mentioned the car thing, and I immediately thought
- 30:17back to one of my first years on the beat, talking with somebody about
- 30:21somebody else on the beat who was known for writing license plates down on the
- 30:25cars into Woody Hayes Athletics Center parking lot, because you know, this would
- 30:30have been around twenty ten or so, and it would have been around that
- 30:33time where there was stuff going on. And now it's like, well,
- 30:37if I want to get a play, I can just watch the commercials.
- 30:40That's what I'll do. If I want to find out who's taking a sledgehammer
- 30:44to car windshields, I'll just go watch the local car dealership in State College
- 30:48and say, hey, that's Julian Fleming doing that. I don't need to
- 30:51investigate any further. They are a bunch of different you know, we'll start
- 30:56wrapping up, but they're like you said, there are just so many differ
- 31:00and variables. Like an athletic department like Ohio State with thirty six thirty seven
- 31:06schools or programs sports and that fifteen to twenty million dollars is not going to
- 31:11go nearly as far as the fifteen to twenty million dollars will go at a
- 31:15South Carolina. So in terms of like the the non revenue sports where you
- 31:22know, that's why Charlie Baker had the idea, like let's just have a
- 31:25flat rate for everybody that you're going to get at least this. That way,
- 31:30there may not be such huge advantages and disadvantages and disparities between certain schools
- 31:34in terms of like this is how much we can pay a gymnast and Ohio
- 31:38State can't because they've got thirty five other sports, and it's like, well
- 31:41that's you know, too bad pay more. So stuff like that. I
- 31:47do wonder all of the you know, you think of the Ohio State practice
- 31:51facility and the everything that they're given in terms of mental health, food,
- 32:00all of these things, that that's where the money has had to go,
- 32:04because it has to go somewhere. Now I can go to the players.
- 32:07Do they then have to start that. Does it become like a coal mine
- 32:12type of thing where you've got the company store where you work for a coal
- 32:16mine. Everything that you buy from the store, you know, coal mine
- 32:21paid you, but they now you have to go pay for a shovel for
- 32:24your house and it's like fourteen dollars and all of the money that you bring
- 32:28in you give back to the company store. Is it still gonna be free
- 32:32meals at all of these schools? Do they start to penny pinch? Because
- 32:35I remember I think it was Bobby Carpenter talking about his time at the Cowboys,
- 32:38and I may be wrong, but it was some somebody talking about their
- 32:42time in the NFL where their meals weren't free, they were taken out of
- 32:44their checks, and it's like, that's that's the NFL doing that. Now
- 32:49they're not trying to recruit anybody. So that's I think always going to be
- 32:52the thing that wins out, like why do I have to pay for my
- 32:54food here? I don't have to do it at Georgia. So it's one
- 32:58of those things that kind of maybe fait is itself because if one school,
- 33:02if other schools aren't doing it, then you can't do it because it becomes
- 33:06a disadvantage for you. But yeah, so many different things that stuff have
- 33:12to be sorted out. And I'll go back to the original Bull season director
- 33:16Ross Ellinger's tweets saying that you know this guy, Nick Carperelli expects Nil to
- 33:22soon come in house soon, and then Ross relays the full quote from Carperelli
- 33:31and and it goes this way. I had a meeting recently with Charlie Baker
- 33:35and we discussed that on a national level, what needs to happen for everybody
- 33:37is collectives need to be brought in house, and university universities need to manage
- 33:43that. I think what will come with that is we'll see agreements much like
- 33:46any other employment agreements. Blah blah blah. He's saying that's that's what needs
- 33:52to happen, but it's being put forth as in it's happening soon, and
- 33:57I the quote didn't necessarily follow with that that it's going to be happening soon.
- 34:00Now. I do think that's what eventually happens. I just everybody knows
- 34:07what needs to happen, and they're progressing forward to it. But it's like
- 34:09each step of the way, you've got a little obstacle that you've got to
- 34:14figure out first. And you can see everything that you need to do,
- 34:19but you got to watch your toes every step of the way. And the
- 34:22people who are in charge need to be willing to take steps that they might
- 34:25not be thrilled about taking in order to get where they need to get.
- 34:29Because a lot of the issues that are happening right now and the fact that
- 34:34everything has just sort of like the NCAA has at times almost been a passive
- 34:37observer to the things that are happening to it from state governments or individual schools
- 34:44or whatever where you know, if they really were trying to draw it up,
- 34:47I doubt that a nil collective at your school going out and rattling the
- 34:53tin cup and you, you know, you the Buckeye fan having to pay
- 34:58twenty five dollars a month to the collective, or you know, the big
- 35:00the big donor having to you know, writing a big check when a certain
- 35:04player hit the portal or whatever. I doubt that that's really the way they
- 35:07would have set that up, because it doesn't make any sense for well,
- 35:12okay, it's okay for the players to get paid, but it can't come
- 35:15from the schools. It has to come from outside entities. Like, that's
- 35:17not the way you probably would have drawn that up if you were really doing
- 35:22this from square one. So now they have the potential to maybe if this,
- 35:28if this does get settled, maybe take a little bit of a deep
- 35:31breath and take a little bit more of a structured look at it and maybe
- 35:36set it up in a more logical way. Maybe, Tony, The question
- 35:39is how much do you believe in the people in charge of running college sports
- 35:43and the fact that they'll be diligent about this and very you know, come
- 35:46up with a very structured and thoughtful solution to this that will present no long
- 35:52term complications. How confident are you on a level of one to ten,
- 35:57ten being most confident and one being least confident. And I will let you
- 36:01know you are allowed to use negative numbers? Can I use letters? Can
- 36:06I just go W six? And there are still, as in the Ross
- 36:10Dellenjy article, there are still people against it in terms of administrators, and
- 36:15it like at some point you've got to do something or else you yah,
- 36:22And you can't just continue to live at the bottom of the volcano because eventually
- 36:27you're getting a lot is just gonna just overwhelm you. Eventually you got to
- 36:30stop being that coute and you got to move. You got to pick up
- 36:32your feet, as you said, and move on. And I think there
- 36:37are several other things things I had on my mind, but thankfully they're gone
- 36:42now, Tom. And what this means for a group of five, that's
- 36:46a whole other that's that's an entire show itself. But I think we'll go
- 36:52ahead and call it there and see if anything else comes of this. And
- 36:59it's some it's happening, so it's trying to keep you aware of it,
- 37:05and it's certainly a discussion point. College football is going to be impacted by
- 37:12this greatly, and Ohio State is going to be getting backed into by this
- 37:16greatly. But as we've seen so far, so far the nil stuff has
- 37:20helped Ohio States. It's done them some good things, so I wouldn't get
- 37:23too concerned. This will all get figured out. There's too too much history,
- 37:28too much money, more importantly involved for it to go away. So
- 37:31it's just gonna be some some bumps in the road a long way, but
- 37:37that will do it. I want to thank you all for tuning in.
- 37:38Go ahead hit the like. If you're watching this on YouTube, please thumbs
- 37:40up. We do appreciate that, and subscribe to the YouTube channel if you
- 37:45have not yet. As always, you can find us at Buckeye Huddle dot
- 37:47com. Become a member there. That is the best way to support us.
- 37:51And right now we're running our spring sale on annual subscriptions, so you
- 37:54get a nice reduced rate there if you sign up now and become an annual
- 37:59member, So check that out at pucke Huddle dot com and that will do
- 38:01it. For us today. We will talk to you guys later