Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / 9th Ceremony Episode
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and I can't hear myself. I'm
- 0:16not plugged in. I was like, I can hear you just
- 0:20fine. Wait, did you not clock this whole time
- 0:22that you weren't hearing yourself? Nope. Cool,
- 0:25man. I think I have tinnitus. Hello, everyone,
- 0:28and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:31The show that helps you realize whether you have
- 0:33tinnitus. I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Do you want to
- 0:37take that again? No, no, I don't. Okay. No, I
- 0:41don't think I will. We're having a goofy morning
- 0:46because you were just saying you couldn't hear
- 0:49yourself in the mic solely because you weren't
- 0:53plugged in. I wasn't plugged in. You plugged
- 0:54in and you're fine. You said you might have tinnitus,
- 0:55so I was playing with that. But also, we're just
- 0:59coming back from vacation. Vacation, all I ever
- 1:01wanted. Vacation, gotta get away. And that's
- 1:05all I know from that song. No, there's a third
- 1:07part that I'm trying to think of. We're the kids
- 1:09in America. Wrong song. Wrong song. I know there's
- 1:13a pitch change. Pitch change. Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 1:16All I ever wanted. That part? Yeah, okay. Yeah,
- 1:20I'm a musician. Me too. But we just got back
- 1:24from vacation. Not only did we both go on vacation
- 1:29at the same time, we went on vacation to the
- 1:32same place and ran into each other. Complete.
- 1:35Complete accident. We were like, you know what?
- 1:37We really need a break from each other in this
- 1:39podcast. And then lo and behold, there you are
- 1:43at Universal Studios Halloween Horror Nights.
- 1:46Legitimately very funny when we were here about
- 1:48maybe two, three weeks ago in this room. And
- 1:51I was like, hey, I'm going to be out of pocket
- 1:53for this week. And you were like, there was a
- 1:55pause and you're like, when are you going to
- 1:56Halloween Horror Nights? I was like, oh, Wednesday
- 1:58the 23rd. And you're like, yeah, me too. Yeah.
- 2:01It was pretty wild. Like we knew we were both
- 2:03going to go. Yeah. And we knew it was soon, but
- 2:07it ended up being the same night. And again,
- 2:09very cool. We made a video. It will be put online.
- 2:13But very cool that we were able to do a haunted
- 2:17house that was based on a Best Picture nominated
- 2:19film. Wild thing to say. Only the second time.
- 2:23Even wilder than that is that it's happened before.
- 2:27Right, yeah. Because in line, we were kind of
- 2:29going through what we would want to see as Best
- 2:31Picture nominated houses that are. Or movies
- 2:34that are houses. And The Exorcist was the only
- 2:37one before that. Yeah. Yeah, that was it. So
- 2:40that was a cool experience. It was. It was a
- 2:42lot of fun. I think the video is silly goofy
- 2:45and will be fun to watch. It's a good time. I'm
- 2:48looking forward to it. It's probably already
- 2:49out by now. I imagine so. Yeah. But one thing
- 2:54that I wanted to comment on it was the house
- 2:56is great. Halloween Horror Nights this year,
- 2:58if you're thinking about going, definitely go.
- 2:59It's a great year. The one thing I want to comment
- 3:02on was at the very beginning when you're walking
- 3:04into the house, it's honestly less of a haunted
- 3:07house and more of like, do you want to walk through
- 3:09the movie Sinners? Yeah. Which we did. So in
- 3:13the very beginning, it starts playing Ludwig
- 3:14Nornsson's score. And you had commented afterwards
- 3:17that you were just kind of levitating. Yeah,
- 3:19yeah. I agree. It's so hard because you're like,
- 3:22all right, I'm ready to be scared. And then it's
- 3:24like, somebody take me. And you're like, yeah.
- 3:28You're just grooving. It was a lot of fun. I
- 3:31was really excited for that. And it was a good
- 3:33time together to do that. The other thing I want
- 3:36to mention was, you know, these ceremony episodes,
- 3:39which, hi, welcome. We're doing a ceremony episode
- 3:42today for the ninth year, 1936. But before we
- 3:46do that, I kind of like. This is the episode
- 3:49that I think, this is okay to pull back the curtain
- 3:53a little bit. Okay. This is the kind of episode
- 3:55every month that we record closest to its release
- 3:58day. Correct. Right? So whenever there's any
- 4:01kind of like pressing news I like talking about
- 4:03on the ceremony episode because it's kind of
- 4:05relevant to that time period. Yeah. Something
- 4:07that has been out and as soon as it dropped,
- 4:10I sent to you and we've had a conversation about
- 4:12it. We have talked previously about how Tom Holland
- 4:16is working on a biopic for Fred Astaire. Yes.
- 4:20Guy who loves dancing. He loves to sing. Who
- 4:23could forget the Rihanna lip sync moment that
- 4:26he's had? When the sun shines, it shines forever.
- 4:28It sure does. So he's making this movie. Two
- 4:32things, I guess three technically, have come
- 4:34to my attention just this weekend. One of them
- 4:37may be inadvertently, like it's already been
- 4:39announced and I just didn't realize it. The other
- 4:41two, breaking news. Paul King is directing this
- 4:45film. Are you familiar with Paul King? No. Paul
- 4:48King is one of the creative minds behind The
- 4:51Mighty Boosh, the comedy team. But also, he directed
- 4:55Paddington 1, 2, and Wonka. Okay. I've only seen
- 5:02Wonka. You haven't seen Paddington 1 or 2? I
- 5:04haven't seen Paddington. We're taking that off,
- 5:06Mike. We can't do that on Mike. Extremely charming
- 5:09director. Clear sense of style, very whimsical.
- 5:13I cannot wait to see his vision of what a Fred
- 5:16Astaire biopic can be. I assume he's not going
- 5:19to shy away from any of the controversies either
- 5:21of his on -set particularities. Toupee. Toupee,
- 5:26yeah, that's another one. But the biggest news
- 5:29to come out of this this week that I want to
- 5:30talk about is Margaret Qualley was announced
- 5:33as Adele, Fred Astaire's wife. To play the role
- 5:38of Ginger Rogers, which is very important in
- 5:40the story of Fred Astaire, is Sabrina Carpenter.
- 5:44Now, I have said for a while that if Sabrina
- 5:47Carpenter, like, hypothetically, the Tangled
- 5:50reboot, or live -action adaptation that's coming
- 5:52out, I had said, if Sabrina Carpenter gets this
- 5:55role, that's kind of the final Infinity Stone
- 5:58for her. Like, that's the Infinity Stone of,
- 6:00like, I am... I'm going to be Mariah Carey. I'm
- 6:04going to be Jennifer Lopez. I'm going to be someone
- 6:07that for the longest time you will talk about
- 6:09Sabrina Carpenter. And she didn't get that. And
- 6:12I was like, okay, fine. But then I hear she's
- 6:15playing Ginger Rogers. And if you look at videos
- 6:17of Sabrina Carpenter, not only is she inexplicably
- 6:21charming, and not only is she incredibly hilarious,
- 6:24she is an incredible dancer. And not just choreographed
- 6:29dancing, tap dancing. She's really good at it.
- 6:32Is she? She's very good at tapping. Okay, cool.
- 6:34So this is just kind of like, oh, my God, why
- 6:37didn't I think about this? Like, that is the
- 6:40best possible casting for me. How does this land
- 6:42for you? You know, when you sent me the news,
- 6:46I was super excited. And now that you're explaining
- 6:49it, I'm like, oh, I kind of don't know if I love
- 6:52Margaret Qualley. I'm still trying to figure
- 6:54it out. We've talked about that a couple times.
- 6:56And then with Sabrina Carpenter, I'm like. Oh,
- 6:59I don't really know who Sabrina Carpenter is.
- 7:01She'll be great. That's cool. So I'm blissfully
- 7:05ignorant about everything. The thing that I will
- 7:09say is just what I know off the story of these
- 7:12three people. Adele is kind of the third hat.
- 7:15I think she'll kind of be secondary to the story
- 7:18of what Fred and Ginger are doing on screen.
- 7:21I think she'll have less screen time than Sabrina
- 7:23will. I'll say that. Who knows at this point?
- 7:26But the other thing to keep in mind, too, is
- 7:28that because Sabrina Carpenter is so good and
- 7:30just exudes like charm and like, you know, talent,
- 7:33it kind of, in my mind, pushes Tom Holland. And
- 7:37he's like, hey, man, you got to be like 100 %
- 7:38because otherwise she is a freight train and
- 7:41she's going to take this movie from you. Yeah.
- 7:43And it is not a Fred and Ginger biopic. It is
- 7:45a Fred biopic. So you got to like really be on
- 7:47your game, which I think he's up to the challenge
- 7:49for. It's just really interesting that he's doing
- 7:51that. So just big news that I saw. I'm sure it's
- 7:54a movie you and I are going to be talking about
- 7:55a good bit when it does release. So if you've
- 7:58enjoyed us talking about The Gay Divorcee, Top
- 8:01Hat, even mentioning Swing Time, which we haven't
- 8:04covered here. Definitely worth your time to get
- 8:07into the news and look forward to that coming
- 8:09out. I imagine 2028. 2028? Well, I mean, you
- 8:13gotta think. Tom Holland's gonna be like 70 by
- 8:14then. That's how years work, yeah. It might be
- 8:18next year, but I just have a sneaking suspicion
- 8:20that it's gonna be. Yeah, that makes sense. They
- 8:23have to teach Margaret Qualley how to tap. Does
- 8:25Adele dance? No, I have no idea. Okay. I was
- 8:30just being nice. Speaking of Adele. Hey, hello.
- 8:33Hello. We're talking about the year 1936, the
- 8:36ninth year of the ceremonies for the Oscars.
- 8:40And this was a really interesting year, mostly
- 8:44because we've talked about this before. Previously,
- 8:48when we talk about supporting actors, we had
- 8:51seen that some supporting roles have been nominated,
- 8:54but they had to be nominated in the lead actor
- 8:57category. Right. Yeah. So a good example here
- 9:00is like French O'Tone with Mutiny on the Bounty.
- 9:05Yeah, exactly. Smaller role in that film, definitely
- 9:07felt more like a supporting actor. But like you
- 9:10said, the only option was best actor. And Mutiny
- 9:13on the Bounty actually is the reason that we're
- 9:16seeing the change that we're talking about today.
- 9:18Yeah, and it's happened before, you know, I mean,
- 9:20Lewis Stone in The Patriot. Yes, I love The Patriot.
- 9:26Lewis Stone in The Patriot, and then Frank Morgan
- 9:29in The Affairs of Cellini. Those specifically
- 9:33were supporting roles. But as you mentioned,
- 9:38that was the only award available for acting
- 9:39for actors. So they were nominated for that.
- 9:43Which this kind of is exactly what you just said
- 9:45with Mutiny on the Bounty. When you do that,
- 9:47it's seen as kind of splitting the vote with
- 9:49a lead actor. So are they really going to get
- 9:51that recognition for this role? Generally, they're
- 9:55not. No. And in regards to Mutiny on the Bounty,
- 9:58it's splitting the nominees with two lead actors
- 10:01because you had Clark Gable and Charles Lawton
- 10:04nominated for that film as well. I've got to
- 10:06tell you, if I was going to be nominated third
- 10:08actor in any movie and I was against Clark Gable
- 10:12and Charles Lawton, yeah, I'm good. Right? Just
- 10:15the nomination. I'm like, thanks, guys, just
- 10:18for that. I'm just happy to be here. Oh, it's
- 10:19so funny you say that. I meant, like, don't nominate
- 10:21me. Oh, okay. I'm good. I'm not going to win.
- 10:25Like, don't bother. You're right. Yeah. No. But
- 10:27you're right. I should just be grateful for the
- 10:29nomination. Yeah, I'd be like, wow, am I really
- 10:30in their class? This is crazy. You know what's
- 10:33even crazier about that is that you morph into
- 10:36Kermit the Frog when you get nominated. I can't
- 10:39believe I'm up against Charles Lawton. There's
- 10:42a little Owen Wilson, too. Oh, no. It's okay,
- 10:45you don't have to do it on Wilson. Kermit Wilson.
- 10:48Yeah, and there's a couple of other things about
- 10:50this year that were really interesting. Walt
- 10:52Disney just continues to say, like, hey, where's
- 10:54my Oscar? Well, he says it, and then they hand
- 10:57it to him. Exactly. Like, he just shows up, he's
- 10:59like, Oscar, please, and they hand it, and he
- 11:01leaves. Yeah, it's not like Glenn Close, where
- 11:02she's like, where's my Oscar, and they say, go
- 11:04sit down. Or Diane Warren, where they're like,
- 11:05hey, next year. Oh, God, yeah. That's a better
- 11:08one. Did you see she made a song for the movie
- 11:12By All Means, the Mark Wahlberg, Yahya Abdul
- 11:15-Mateen movie? Uh -oh. You just mentioned Mark
- 11:18Wahlberg. Oh, no. Somebody get Donnie in here.
- 11:21Diane Ward, we got to go get this guy. That was
- 11:25my bad. But he picked up his fifth straight Oscar
- 11:29for producing the best cartoon of the year. That's
- 11:31Walt Disney, not Mark Wahlberg. Correct. Just
- 11:34to be clear. Yeah, correct. Sorry, going back
- 11:36to the relevant topic. Yes, Walt Disney picked
- 11:38up his firth. Walt Disney picked up his fifth
- 11:42straight Oscar here. Yes, he did. And for producing
- 11:46the best cartoon. So, and this is going to be
- 11:49really interesting next year because he will
- 11:53do something similar, but for a full length animated
- 11:56feature. Yeah. So I'm really excited to talk
- 11:59about that. We are going to talk about it at
- 12:02length and we are going to have a very special
- 12:03guest on to talk about it with us. So I can't
- 12:06wait. Ladies and gentlemen, Walt Disney. Oh,
- 12:08he's back. It's just a head. Yeah, just a frozen
- 12:11head just reeling in. With like the thing legs.
- 12:14He's just a spider walking in here. You know,
- 12:18I've always wondered what my first tattoo is
- 12:19going to be. Is that the one? That sounds like
- 12:21it. Now that you mention it, that's a pretty
- 12:24good idea for a tattoo. You know what you hate
- 12:26doing is walking into a tattoo shop and you talk
- 12:28to the artist and you're like, I think I want
- 12:29this. And they're like. Oh, yeah, I know how
- 12:31to do that. Oh, yeah. They're like, yeah, no,
- 12:33I've done that before. Great. This time they're
- 12:35going to be like, huh. Yeah. That's what I want.
- 12:38I want like, oh. What a unique idea. Yeah. What's
- 12:42going to be even crazier is if I walk in with
- 12:43that and they're like, oh, yeah. Yeah. We've
- 12:45seen this before. Even crazier if you walk in
- 12:48and it's Walt Disney and he's like, I won't do
- 12:49this. Defamation. Yeah. I'll be sued. A couple
- 12:54other things that were interesting about this
- 12:55year specifically. Pierre Collings and Sheridan
- 12:57Gibney of the story of Louis Pasteur. Yeah. Which,
- 13:00by the way, can we talk about it? Is it Louis
- 13:02Pasteur or Louis Pasteur? We've been talking
- 13:04for a month about this. I don't know who it is.
- 13:07You think we just go with it? Yeah. I mean, he
- 13:08cured polio or whatever. Right? That's that movie,
- 13:13right? Yeah, man. The germy movie? Yeah, germy
- 13:16movie. Yeah. Yeah. Germ King. He did it. So the
- 13:21stew... The story of Louis Pasteur did take home
- 13:27two awards for writing. One was original story
- 13:31and then screenplay. And this is the only time
- 13:35that's going to happen. Because of the way it's
- 13:37laid out. I'm so grateful for that. Now, we know,
- 13:39obviously, that it's original and adapted now.
- 13:42Right. Right. Two things that cannot exist at
- 13:44one time. Correct. Which is nice. And in this
- 13:47case, they just threw that to the wind. Right.
- 13:50And they said, who wins best screenplay? Now,
- 13:51who wins best original story? Can those be the
- 13:54same thing? Sure can. Sure can. So this isn't
- 13:57one of those things where it's like, hey, as
- 13:59of now. This is the only time this has happened.
- 14:01Yeah. No, this is the only time that's going
- 14:03to happen because they've changed it since then.
- 14:05And it's so confusing. Original screenplay to
- 14:08me sounds like the guys that actually write everything
- 14:11with the actions and everything. An original
- 14:13story is like you turn in your napkin that you've
- 14:16been doodling on and you're like, yeah, I had
- 14:18this idea. We're going to make this movie about
- 14:20this germy guy. And then that's it. Like, that's
- 14:23the original story. Right. I'm so glad this is
- 14:26the only time this happens. It's so confusing.
- 14:28Well, and it feels kind of like either you are
- 14:30going to win for writing it down or the napkin
- 14:33from Starbucks that you wrote it on. Exactly.
- 14:35Is going to win. Yeah. For like, that's what
- 14:37housed the original story or original idea for
- 14:39this movie. Yep. So with that said, do you want
- 14:43to get right into the ceremony? I do. I do indeed.
- 14:47So this being the ninth ceremony year, this was
- 14:50held on March 4th. 1937 at the Biltmore Hotel.
- 14:55We're back at the Biltmore. Over 1 ,500 Academy
- 14:58members attended, which is such a huge amount
- 15:01when you, like, go back and think about the 100
- 15:04people that showed up to the first one. Yes.
- 15:06Very different. Yeah. And we'll talk about that
- 15:09next year, too. Actually, our next episode, I
- 15:11think. Yeah. Yeah, for sure. George Jessel was
- 15:15the master of ceremonies here, and he presented
- 15:17every award except for one. And that was, what's
- 15:21his name, Victor McLaglin? Yeah, from the Informer.
- 15:24Yeah, he presented the award for best actor.
- 15:27Are they bringing that idea forward of whoever
- 15:32won the year prior or was nominated? I don't
- 15:35know. I don't know if this is like the dawn of
- 15:37that or if McLaglin was just like, I'll do it.
- 15:40Yeah, I really feel like doing something. I get
- 15:42restless leg syndrome. That's interesting, though,
- 15:45because obviously we know that that's kind of
- 15:47been an off and on again pattern of the previous
- 15:50winner giving that to the newest. Yeah, yeah,
- 15:52for sure. With the placements already set of
- 15:54where we're going and who is hosting it, we'll
- 15:56dive right into the nominations themselves. So
- 15:59a couple things here with the special award.
- 16:02For special awards, March of Time was given an
- 16:05award for its significance to motion pictures
- 16:07and for having revolutionized one of the most
- 16:10important branches of the industry, the newsreel.
- 16:12The newsreel. Which we don't talk about a lot.
- 16:15Not a ton. No, I mean, it's kind of talked about
- 16:17a little bit in the past with like Front Page,
- 16:20a little bit here and there, maybe with Live
- 16:22Old Lady a little bit. Right. But that's all
- 16:24like the fictionalized version of all that. This
- 16:27went to like actual newsreel creators. And I
- 16:32think that's something that we're going to start
- 16:33seeing, like have a presence at the Academy Awards
- 16:37because we're moving into the wartime era. So
- 16:40it's interesting to see this pop up here. Yeah,
- 16:43it's very hindsight, almost. I mean, obviously
- 16:46it's not at this, but it seems prescient. Yeah,
- 16:49like a preview for what's to come. Definitely.
- 16:52The other special award was for W. Howard Green
- 16:54and Harold Rawson for the color cinematography
- 16:58of the Selznick International production, and
- 17:01this was The Garden of Allah. Yeah, and that's...
- 17:04interesting because that's the first time that
- 17:07colored pictures were recognized at the academy
- 17:09awards outside of animation i believe right like
- 17:13short subject short subject and give it another
- 17:16three years something like that yeah we're getting
- 17:20close to seeing some some colorful pictures well
- 17:22i mean technically uh a star is born we'll talk
- 17:25about that oh yeah next year next year but in
- 17:28terms of uh major awards yeah right like their
- 17:31own categories and things Totally. We'll get
- 17:33there. So kicking off the official nominations
- 17:36for statuettes here, we'll start, as always,
- 17:39with short subjects. And, of course, this is
- 17:41broken out into multiple categories. This one's
- 17:44a little different, though. It is. Normally we
- 17:46have cartoons, sometimes color. What was the,
- 17:50is it? Novelty. Novelty. Yeah. And then, I don't
- 17:54know. Comedy. Yes. Comedy. Yeah, you're right.
- 17:57So cartoons, comedy, and novelty. This time,
- 18:02we have four categories. We have cartoons, one
- 18:06reel, two reel, and color. Now, with one reel
- 18:10and two reel, is this just length? Yeah. Yeah,
- 18:13that's all it is. I forget the length of a reel.
- 18:15I want to say it's around 15 minutes. So I think
- 18:18anything beyond 15 minutes. And this might be
- 18:21the precursor to what qualifies the length of
- 18:24a short in the modern -day Oscars. Anything below,
- 18:26I believe, 40 minutes falls into the shorts category
- 18:30now. Um, so a 15 minute reel times two is kind
- 18:36of close to that. That makes sense. Yeah. Because
- 18:39if it's about 15 minutes or so, then that's going
- 18:41to make sense as to why it's still considered
- 18:44short. Um, because everything else has been like,
- 18:47you know, up to 15 minutes at this point. So
- 18:48now they're just realizing they can't make it
- 18:50longer. Okay. That makes more sense. So with
- 18:53cartoons with short subjects, the nominees were
- 18:55Country Cousin for Disney, Old Mill Pond for
- 18:59Harming Eisen. And Sinbad the Sailor for Paramount.
- 19:03And the winner here was, as we mentioned previously,
- 19:05for the fifth year running, Disney for Country
- 19:08Cousin. Interesting. Have you seen any of these?
- 19:12I have seen... No, no. I was getting the Old
- 19:16Mill confused with next year's nominee. Yeah.
- 19:20I've not heard of the Country Cousin. And usually
- 19:23I can at least pull out the Disney cartoon. Right.
- 19:26But yeah, I'm unfamiliar. Monty City Mouse. Does
- 19:30that picture look familiar to you? Like a city
- 19:33mouse and a country mouse? No. Yeah, I've never
- 19:36seen this. One thing we can talk about Disney
- 19:40for a second here, picking up another Academy
- 19:43Award. This is his fifth one here, which is wild.
- 19:47RKO Radio Pictures was the company putting out
- 19:51Disney cartoons at this point. And I thought
- 19:53that was so interesting. I watched the old mill
- 19:55that I was just talking about the other day in
- 19:58preparation for next year. And the RKO logo popped
- 20:02up and I was like, oh my God. I didn't even realize
- 20:04Walt Disney didn't have their own distribution
- 20:07company at this point. No. So RKO was putting
- 20:10them out and I looked up when Disney started
- 20:14doing that. It wasn't until like the 50s. Wow.
- 20:18Like it's a long time. And of course it's Buena
- 20:20Vista pictures or whatever. Right. So I just
- 20:23thought that was really interesting that the
- 20:25company that will eventually go on to put out
- 20:28Citizen Kane. was the one dishing out Disney
- 20:31cartoons, and then also the company that kind
- 20:33of goes under eventually. Like, they're not around
- 20:36anymore. Well, I mean, it just shows how much
- 20:39of an empire Walt Disney built up. Yeah. I'm
- 20:42with you, though. I also thought, like, just
- 20:43from the get -go, yeah, he's always had a company.
- 20:45Yeah, yeah. Especially being recognized this
- 20:47many times in a row, you feel like that's going
- 20:49to be, hey, you have a lot of production going
- 20:51on on your side. Yeah, I'm curious what the lore
- 20:53is there for Disney being like, you know what,
- 20:56I'm tired of waiting for RKO. Let's make our
- 20:59own thing. Well, clearly it took like, you know,
- 21:01almost 20 years. Yeah, for sure. The next is
- 21:04One Reel. This is the 15 minute or under category.
- 21:07The nominees were Board of Education. That's
- 21:10B -O -R -E -D. I love that title. Very cheeky.
- 21:14Roach MGM. Moscow Moods. This was Paramount.
- 21:18And Wanted a Master. for MGM. And the winner
- 21:22here was not just based off of a funny writing
- 21:25of a name, Board of Education from MGM. I'm going
- 21:29to assume you haven't seen this one either. No,
- 21:31I can safely say I've not seen any of these shorts,
- 21:34unfortunately. I'll go ahead and keep that in
- 21:37mind moving forward. I think maybe it'll be a
- 21:39good idea to... Have Bryce do a segment on the
- 21:43ceremony episodes. Haven't we said this before
- 21:45where it's like, we'll say like board of education
- 21:47and then it'll just pop in him like, I haven't
- 21:49seen this. Yeah. But I think he's seen all the
- 21:52shorts up to like the 40s. Oh, that's right.
- 21:54No, we said that he would pop in. Yeah, I've
- 21:55seen it. Right. That's it. I have seen it. Maybe
- 21:59I'll just get him to do like a yes or a no and
- 22:02we'll have a soundboard. And that's it. It won't
- 22:05say anything else. Just give us a list of every
- 22:07movie, every project you've seen from the beginning
- 22:09of 1927 to today, and we'll just reference it.
- 22:14Yeah. And just have the soundboard. I liked it.
- 22:17I liked it. I like it, yes or no. Just Bryce
- 22:21like, yes. No. What did you think, Bryce? Try
- 22:25again later. And we just do eight ball responses.
- 22:30Bryce, you're welcome on the show whenever you
- 22:31want. Except not that time. Right. Too Real is
- 22:35our next subcategory within short subjects. Nominees
- 22:39are Double or Nothing for Warner Brothers, Dummy
- 22:43Ache, love that one, from RKO Radio, as you mentioned,
- 22:48and The Public Pays for MGM. Look, if we're going
- 22:53to give a movie, or a short, an award for a fun
- 22:57spelling of a name like Board of Education, I'm
- 22:59sure it's actually good, too, you've got to give
- 23:02Dummy Ache. I mean, dummy ache is one of the
- 23:04funniest things I've read. Dummy ache is good.
- 23:07Just reading that here, oh. Dummy ache is a pun
- 23:09that would pop up in, like, a modern rap song,
- 23:12I feel like. That, and also, can you imagine
- 23:15just, like, Howie Doody? Like, just kind of being
- 23:17like, yeah, I got a dummy ache. And, like, the
- 23:19mouth just, like, flies open. Yep. That's all
- 23:23I can think of now. The Public Pays from MGM
- 23:26was the winner for Too Real. Of course, that
- 23:28being longer than 15 minutes. And then finally,
- 23:31the final subcategory here of short subjects
- 23:33is color. And this was Give Me Liberty from Warner
- 23:38Brothers, La Fiesta de Santa Barbara from MGM,
- 23:41and Popular Science J62. Did I just conjure a
- 23:46robot? What is that? From Paramount. And the
- 23:49winner here was Give Me Liberty from Warner Brothers.
- 23:52Very nice. Very fun. And that takes us to Dance
- 23:56Direction. Dance Direction. So this is a big
- 23:59one. Lots of nominees here. Starting with Busby
- 24:03Berkeley for Love and War from the film Gold
- 24:06Diggers of 1937. Bobby Connolly for 1 ,000 Love
- 24:11Songs, a number from Cain and Mabel. A lot of
- 24:14puns this year. Really punny year. Yeah. Seymour
- 24:18Felix for A Pretty Girl is Like a Melody, a number
- 24:22from The Great Ziegfeld. Love that. That's the
- 24:24spiral one, the rotating? Yes. Correct. Wow,
- 24:29that feels like an eternity ago. I know. Dave
- 24:32Gould for Swingin' the Jinx, number from Born
- 24:35to Dance. Jack Haskell for Skating Ensemble,
- 24:39a number from One in a Million. Russell Lewis
- 24:42for The Finale, a number from Dancing Pirate.
- 24:45And Hermes Pan for Bojangles of Harlem, a number
- 24:49from Swing Time. And the winner here was Seymour
- 24:52Felix, as you know, for A Pretty Girl is Like
- 24:54a Melody. The Great Ziegfeld. This is kind of
- 24:57the beginning of a very successful night for
- 25:01The Great Ziegfeld. Yeah. I'm interested in talking
- 25:04about this moving forward with you. But one thing
- 25:06I want to kind of bring up was you mentioned
- 25:07Hermes Pan, a name that we've heard pretty often.
- 25:11And then Swing Time, which is Ginger Rogers and
- 25:14Fred Astaire. Why do you think it is that Swing
- 25:16Time didn't make it into the larger scope of
- 25:19the films nominated? My guess is that we've seen
- 25:22it. We've seen Fred and Ginger in... The two
- 25:25previous years with Top Hat and Gay Divorce.
- 25:28Gay Divorce, hey, thank you. And The Great Ziegfeld
- 25:31was giving us something just a little bit different
- 25:33with, you know, we talked about that whole sequence
- 25:36in depth on the episode. You were a big fan of
- 25:41it and I was a little lukewarm, but it was something
- 25:44that we hadn't seen before. And I think that
- 25:46deserves a lot of credit. So I think that's really
- 25:49what it boiled down to. Definitely. Maybe it's
- 25:52also, I haven't seen Swing Time just yet, but
- 25:54maybe it's that the Gay Divorcee and Top Hat
- 25:59were so similar that we just don't want to see
- 26:02another one like that nominated for Best Picture.
- 26:05Maybe, but still, I own it, so I'm excited to
- 26:07go back and watch it. Swing Time? Yes. Yes, me
- 26:10too. I do own great Ziegfeld, though, as well,
- 26:13so that one, I'm good for a couple years. A little
- 26:16bit, yeah. Assistant director, the nominations
- 26:20were for Clem Beauchamp for The Last of the Mohicans.
- 26:24Not that one. William Cannon for Anthony Adverse.
- 26:28Joseph Newman for San Francisco. Eric G. Stacy
- 26:32for The Garden of Allah. And Jack Sullivan for
- 26:35The Charge of the Light Brigade. And Jack Sullivan
- 26:37was the winner here for The Charge of the Light
- 26:39Brigade. So, I beg the question, what went wrong
- 26:43on the set of The Charge of the Light Brigade?
- 26:46Maybe the light charged a little too hard. You
- 26:48know what I'm saying? Extra charging. Extra charging.
- 26:52Yeah, it's like when you leave your laptop plugged
- 26:54in too long and it depletes the battery. Something
- 26:56like that. I think I've done that. We've all
- 26:59done that. No, I think I'm just a criminal offense.
- 27:02Because for me, I feel like I use my laptop for
- 27:04like 30 minutes and it's like, hey, I'm dying.
- 27:07Listeners at home, write in if you know what
- 27:10to do with a lithium battery that has bulged.
- 27:14Like, almost exploded? Oh, we have two very different
- 27:17problems. Yeah. What do you do with that? Where
- 27:19do you take it to dispose of it? I think you
- 27:21take that out of your house. Like, I don't think
- 27:24you keep that in your house anymore. Yeah, but
- 27:25where do you take it? Shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 27:29at gmail .com and let me know where I can go
- 27:31to recycle this. Please hurry. But to make us
- 27:36not feel like you are just a Zodiac killer, maybe
- 27:39include something other than coordinates. And
- 27:41maybe be like, there's a nice open field that
- 27:44I have personally been to. Yeah. Somebody's like,
- 27:46what a serendipitous moment. I know exactly where
- 27:51you can store things that you don't want people
- 27:52to see anymore. Right. Just don't go digging
- 27:54in that area specifically. Yeah. Where they buried
- 27:58the ET cartridges. But if you do feel like doing
- 28:00that, we would love a Pulitzer. So thank you
- 28:03for letting us know. And we will be very generous
- 28:06with not leaking that information. Yeah. Or the
- 28:10lithium from the battery. I think you just throw
- 28:12it out. I'm going to be so real with you, dude.
- 28:13No, it's going to blow up. It's bad. Okay. That's
- 28:18not your fault. That's Dell's fault. No, that'll
- 28:19be my fault when there's a garbage truck in front
- 28:22of my house on fire. You don't know that it's
- 28:26going to blow up. Yeah, but there's a possibility,
- 28:29and that makes me nervous. Then don't put it
- 28:32in your car. I'm saying don't do anything with
- 28:35it. And you can't just leave. You got to do something
- 28:38with it. It's either in my house in a problem,
- 28:40in my car in a problem, or somebody else's problem.
- 28:44Is this where we just learn how to, what is it
- 28:48called, skeet shooting? Where we just like, you
- 28:50throw it and I say pull, and then we just shoot
- 28:53it midair? I'm actually really good at that.
- 28:55Are you? Yeah, I used to do it pretty regularly.
- 28:57I think we do it. Because if it's going to explode,
- 28:59at least it's up in the air. That's true. Yeah.
- 29:01Isn't that what, there's some movie they did
- 29:02that in. Oh, they've done that in many movies.
- 29:04It's like Iron Man or Avengers. We're just going
- 29:07to go through the wormhole with it. Yes, that's
- 29:10exactly right. What time are we at? 31? We're
- 29:13doing great. Anyway, seriously though, tell me
- 29:17what to do with the battery. I'll tell you what
- 29:19to do with the battery. You're just not going
- 29:20to like it. Next category is going to be the
- 29:22music category. This one's going to take a minute.
- 29:24A little bit. Hopefully less time than the battery
- 29:27conversation. So we have two categories here,
- 29:29as always. There is the song category and then
- 29:32the scoring. We'll start with song. Did I Remember?
- 29:36Music by Walter Donaldson. Lyrics by Harold Adamson.
- 29:41And that's for the film Susie. I've Got You Under
- 29:43My Skin from the film Born to Dance. Music and
- 29:45lyrics by Cole Porter. Love that sentence. A
- 29:48Melody from the Sky. Trail of the Lonesome Pine.
- 29:52Music by Luis... Lewis and Louise is back. There's
- 29:58no E after it. There's no E. Lewis or Louis,
- 30:01alter. Lyrics by Sidney Mitchell. Pennies from
- 30:04Heaven from the film Pennies from Heaven. Music
- 30:06by Arthur Johnston. Lyrics by Johnny Burke. The
- 30:09Way You Look Tonight from the film Swing Time.
- 30:11Music by Jeremy Kern. Lyrics by Dorothy Fields.
- 30:15When Did You Leave Heaven? Sing Baby Sing. Music
- 30:18by Richard A. Whiting. Lyrics by Walter Bullock.
- 30:22The winner here went to The Way You Look Tonight
- 30:24from the film Swing Time. So Fred and Ginger
- 30:27are pulling in some awards, some wins. Where
- 30:30they are, they're doing pretty well. Yeah. For
- 30:33the scoring category, we have Anthony Adverse,
- 30:36head of the music department there for Warner
- 30:39Brothers, is Leo Forbstein. The score, done by
- 30:42Eric Wolfgang Korngold. The Charge of the Light
- 30:45Brigade, studio head Leo Forbstein again. Score
- 30:49by Max Steiner. The Garden of Allah. Head of
- 30:51the music department is Max Steiner. That's so
- 30:54interesting. And the score was done by Max Steiner.
- 30:56This man knows how to get an award. He knows
- 30:58how to play the system, apparently. The General
- 31:01Died at Dawn. Music department head, Boris Moros.
- 31:04Score by Werner Janssen. And Winterset. Head
- 31:09of the music department, Nathaniel Schilkret.
- 31:11Score by Nathaniel Schilkret. And the winner
- 31:15here was Leo Forbstein with Warner Brothers.
- 31:19For the film, Anthony Adverse. And we did say
- 31:21that Eric Wolfgang Korngold did the score, but
- 31:24the win does go to the head of the music department.
- 31:27Right. Which is why the Max Steiner nomination
- 31:30for the, was it the Garden of Allah? Yes. Is
- 31:33notable because then either way he's taking the
- 31:36award. Yeah. Yeah. He very much like Thanos did
- 31:40and was like, I'll do it myself. Except then
- 31:42Leo Forbes said, nope. Leo Forbes said, I went
- 31:46for the head. The head of the music department.
- 31:50Look at you. Good job. Film editing is our next
- 31:53category, and this one goes to the following.
- 31:57Anthony Adverse for Warner Brothers' Ralph Dawson.
- 32:01Come and get it. Goldwyn United Artists. This
- 32:03was Edward Curtis. The Great Ziegfeld. MGM William
- 32:07S. Gray. Lloyds of London. 20th Century Fox.
- 32:11This was Barbara McLean. A Tale of Two Cities.
- 32:14MGM Conrad A. Nervig. And Theodora Goes Wild.
- 32:19Uh -oh, Theodora. Columbia Otto Mayer. And this
- 32:23goes to Anthony Adverse Ralph Dawson from Warner
- 32:27Brothers for film editing. In terms of film editing,
- 32:29we watched three of these six movies. So do you
- 32:34feel like this went to the right winner? No.
- 32:37Yeah. We've talked about this film and its editing
- 32:39and how, I don't know, like robotic it feels
- 32:45almost. We spent a little bit of time talking
- 32:48about the title cards. Yes. And how it just feels
- 32:52like, and then this happened, and then this happened.
- 32:56And while that's not a direct... showcase of
- 32:59the editing, I think that it does provide a little
- 33:02bit of insight into just how kind of dull that
- 33:05movie feels at all times. So, I mean, how do
- 33:08you feel about it? Well, it doesn't feel like
- 33:10the right win. I'm looking between The Great
- 33:12Ziegfeld and A Tale of Two Cities, and my guess
- 33:16is I'd probably want to say A Tale of Two Cities.
- 33:18Yeah, just for the, what is it, the Battle of
- 33:22the Bastille. Yes. Right? Yeah. Oh, what was
- 33:26the word they used on it? It was like the siege?
- 33:29Yeah. Something like that. During the uprising,
- 33:32the revolution. But absolutely. Like that segment,
- 33:34maybe like the remainder of the movie, like the
- 33:36second half. Yeah. Way more interesting with
- 33:39the film editing than I thought anything in Anthony
- 33:40Adverse. Yeah. Anthony Adverse was pretty dull.
- 33:44I didn't care for it. Not me neither. Next up,
- 33:47we have sound recording. Doesn't that mean you
- 33:50did then? Not me neither. Oh, no. Uh -oh. Guess
- 33:54who just announced himself on record legally
- 33:57as a fan. Great. Great. Ralph Dawson's like,
- 34:01yay, they picked me. One guy. One guy. One guy
- 34:04in 2026. For sound recording, we have Banjo On
- 34:08My Knee, 20th Century Fox. That is for E .H.
- 34:12Hansen. The Charge of the Light Brigade, Warner
- 34:15Brothers Studios. Sound department head, Nathan
- 34:18Levinson. Doddsworth, Goldwyn United Artists
- 34:21Studio. Head of the sound department there is
- 34:24Thomas T. Moulton. General Spanky. That's MGM,
- 34:29How Roach Studio sound department. Head, Elmer
- 34:31A. Raguse. Mr. Deeds goes to town, Columbia Studios.
- 34:36That's John Lividary. San Francisco, the MGM
- 34:40film. Studio head, of course, Douglas Shearer.
- 34:43the Texas Rangers Paramount Studios Sound Department
- 34:46head Franklin B. Hansen, that girl from Paris,
- 34:50RKO Radio Studios Sound Department, J .O. Aylberg,
- 34:54and three smart girls for Universal Studios,
- 34:57and that's Homer G. Tasker. What I like here
- 35:00is that it's just, here's every studio, they're
- 35:02all going to be nominated, but only one can win.
- 35:05And that winner, of course, you know him, you
- 35:08love him, Douglas Shearer from MGM Studios. For
- 35:13San Francisco. Yeah. This makes the most sense
- 35:15to me. I agree. I think that with musicals and
- 35:18everything, sound recording is generally what
- 35:20you would think of. But San Francisco having
- 35:22music involved, but also the disaster sequence
- 35:25at the end. Yeah. This makes a lot of sense.
- 35:28It's kind of like, yeah, musicals are where the
- 35:30sound recording win should exist until you get
- 35:34like your action movies. Then that's where things
- 35:37start to change. Like San Francisco is kind of
- 35:39like the F1 when you start seeing that. Yeah.
- 35:42So I completely agree with you. I imagine that
- 35:46a lot of people think that we are probably the
- 35:49kind of guys who are going to take the low -hanging
- 35:51fruit of something like General Spanky and comment
- 35:54on it. And I've got to let you know, dead on.
- 35:57Dead on. General Spanky? Yeah. We've got to talk
- 36:00about that. I think it might be like a little
- 36:02rascals thing. I want to talk about it even more
- 36:05now. So are we saying that Spanky has gone to
- 36:08war and he is now the general but kept the name?
- 36:11Yeah, I think that's what it is. Lieutenant Alfalfa?
- 36:14Why not? Why not? No. I don't think I know any
- 36:18other little rascal. Oh, please get on. Buckwheat?
- 36:22Okay, yeah. Darla? Yeah. Don't do that. Don't
- 36:27even pretend like you forgot who Darla is. That's
- 36:31the little girl? Yeah. That loves Alfalfa? Yeah.
- 36:33Okay, yeah. I should be able to name one more.
- 36:37Yeah, you should. I've named four. Pathetic.
- 36:41I've named four. Oh, Froggy. Oh, yeah, of course.
- 36:44It's the Sling Blade Kid. Sling Blade Kid. That's
- 36:49good. It's the kid that's like, go tell Spanky.
- 36:51You know. Tell Spanky we're going to war and
- 36:54I need more mustard. I think I just surprised
- 36:58myself saying Sling Blade Kid. That's pretty
- 37:01good. Do you think that's the next spinoff we
- 37:02can do? Sling Blade Kid? Sling Blade Babies?
- 37:05Oh, okay. Yeah. Now I'm just singing Muppet Babies,
- 37:10but Slinkly Babies. I'm having a problem. What
- 37:12are you doing with all them books? Waka waka.
- 37:17All right, so cinematography. Art Direction.
- 37:21Yep. You got that one? No, I'm losing my mind
- 37:23all kinds of ways. Art Direction is our next
- 37:25category. Here are the nominees. Anthony Adverse.
- 37:28This was Anton Grott. Dodsworth. for Richard
- 37:32Day. The Great Ziegfeld, Cedric Gibbons, Eddie
- 37:35Imazu, and Edwin B. Willis. Lloyds of London,
- 37:39this is William S. Darling. The Magnificent Brute,
- 37:43my nickname. This was Albert S. D 'Agostino and
- 37:47Jack Otterson. Romeo and Juliet, Cedric Gibbons,
- 37:51Frederick Hope, and Edwin B. Willis. And Winterset,
- 37:54this was for Perry Ferguson. And the winner here
- 37:57is Dodsworth, Richard Day. This makes a good
- 38:01bit of sense. Yeah. Yeah, it does. With all the
- 38:04traveling? I think so. For sure. I just think
- 38:06it's interesting that the great Ziegfeld with
- 38:09its... Mini sets. The song that I've immediately
- 38:13forgotten the name. A woman is pretty like you.
- 38:16A girl is... A pretty girl is like a melody.
- 38:19No, I want to hear the end of that first thing
- 38:20you were doing. A pretty you is a girl. Yeah.
- 38:25Back to the sling blade voice. Yeah. no i yeah
- 38:29that's interesting to me i think like i get it
- 38:32for doddsworth that movie sold me more on the
- 38:35story and the acting and the drama more so than
- 38:37it did the set design but i'm totally cool with
- 38:41it uh and richard day we've seen him quite a
- 38:43bit so it's cool to see him take a win i think
- 38:46the great ziegfeld probably felt like they were
- 38:48going to the team behind it felt like they were
- 38:50probably going to clean up a bit more than they
- 38:52did they did pretty well Let's not get it wrong.
- 38:56But I think they thought they were going to sweep
- 38:58a bit more than they did. Yeah. With the kind
- 39:00of movie they made. Yeah, I think so, too. I'm
- 39:02okay that they didn't. I'm all right. That's
- 39:04okay. And I'm on record as liking that movie
- 39:08a good bit. Yeah. And I'm okay. You liked it
- 39:10more than me. Yeah. But not enough for it to
- 39:12sweep. Sorry about it. About 90 years in the
- 39:17future, that didn't change things. Sorry, guys.
- 39:19Yeah, yeah. That's fair. Moving on, we have Cinematography.
- 39:22Only three nominees here. You have Anthony Adverse,
- 39:25Gaetano Gaudio, The General Died at Dawn for
- 39:29Victor Milner, and The Gorgeous Hussie. Your
- 39:32other nickname. Damn it! George Falsi. I was
- 39:36going to say, it's your nickname. That went to
- 39:39Anthony Adverse for Gaetano Gaudio. I mean, that's
- 39:44the only one that we saw of the three films listed,
- 39:47so I really don't have any comparison. I don't
- 39:49know, man. I think overall, like, this year's
- 39:52movies kind of didn't impress me a whole lot.
- 39:55You know, like, I like some of them. But when
- 39:58I'm sitting here trying to think, oh, who else
- 40:00could we have nominated to really bring home
- 40:03this win? Like, Tale of Two Cities probably.
- 40:06I would have said San Francisco. Really? I mean,
- 40:09for cinematography? Yeah, but I think that's
- 40:11all reserved for the end of that film. Which
- 40:13could still be justifiable, but yeah, I don't
- 40:16know. I mean, sound recording, San Francisco
- 40:18is still one. But then again, the musical, not
- 40:20that it's a musical, but the music aspect of
- 40:23San Francisco probably helped that. Yeah, I don't
- 40:25know. I mean, there's some movies that I like
- 40:27the visuals of, but for the most part, trauma
- 40:30in the on -screen acting or the production design
- 40:33kind of seem to be the main things of an appeal
- 40:37in that. All right, so we'll take you on to the
- 40:40next category here. This was writing, and as
- 40:42always, writing is going to be an original story
- 40:44and a screenplay, which... As always, you say.
- 40:48Well, as always to this point. Right, we started
- 40:50this with, this is going away. Yeah, but as previous,
- 40:54there we go. There you go. As previous, original
- 40:57story and screenplay are the two subsets here.
- 41:00And starting with original story, although it
- 41:02doesn't affect things, because we already talked
- 41:04about the winners here, we have Fury for Norman
- 41:07Krasna. The Great Ziegfeld, William Anthony Maguire,
- 41:11San Francisco, Robert Hopkins, The Story of Louis
- 41:14Pasteur, Pierre Collings, and Sheridan Gibney,
- 41:17and Three Smart Girls, Adele Comandini. This
- 41:20was, of course, the win for The Story of Louis
- 41:23Pasteur, and that was for Pierre Collings and
- 41:26Sheridan Gibney. They were also nominated for
- 41:28Screenplay, and those other nominations were
- 41:31after The Thin Man. Nice to see a sequel come
- 41:34up in the ranks here. I wish I would have watched
- 41:36it before this. I still have to. Yeah. I need
- 41:39to watch all of them. I'm so excited, too. Me,
- 41:41too. Francis Goodrich and Albert Hackett were
- 41:44the writers for the screenplay. Dodsworth, this
- 41:47was Sidney Howard. Mr. Deeds Goes to Town, Robert
- 41:50Riskin, the frequent collaborator of Frank Capra.
- 41:54My Man Godfrey. My Man. My Man Godfrey. Eric
- 41:58Hatch and Morris Riskind. And the story of Louis
- 42:01Pasteur, Pierre Collings, and Sheridan Gibney.
- 42:04And again... Pierre Collins and Charity Gibney
- 42:06got the win for the story of Louis Pasteur, not
- 42:09just for original story, but also for screenplay.
- 42:12This is the original story of Louis Pasteur.
- 42:15And our screenplay. Yeah. Yeah, this one, sure.
- 42:19Yeah, like I get it. I get it. This is probably
- 42:22the big story here, you know? This is Jeremy
- 42:26movie, right? Yes. Yeah. Jeremy movie. I keep
- 42:29getting confused with the life of Emile Zola
- 42:31that we'll talk about next year. for obvious
- 42:34reasons that you'll understand when you listen
- 42:36next year but uh yeah like this is a big quote
- 42:41-unquote sweeping narrative that goes across
- 42:43this man's life so i get it i just don't necessarily
- 42:46love the movie you know yeah it's it's not terrible
- 42:50it's just kind of it's like when you see a movie
- 42:53you're like yeah i guess it's fine and man that's
- 42:55gonna sweep isn't it yeah and yeah it did this
- 42:57is one of those where i wish i would have watched
- 42:58my man godfrey because i i want to say that's
- 43:01Probably the most recognized film out of the
- 43:04bunch today. Yeah, I believe so. Yeah. I'm very
- 43:07excited to pick up that Criterion collection
- 43:09of it. Yeah, totally. Oh, I did like Doddsworth
- 43:13a lot, though. I did. And we talked about how
- 43:15I liked Delightful Lady a good bit. Not nominated
- 43:18here. Oh, I was like, huh? Yeah. So moving forward,
- 43:23we have the directing category. This is a big
- 43:25deal. I want everybody at home to remember who
- 43:29is the head of the Academy right now. Who appoints
- 43:32the voting members of the Academy? Doddsworth.
- 43:36That's him. Yeah, that's him. William Wyler.
- 43:39The Great Ziegfeld. That's Robert Z. Leonard.
- 43:42Mr. Deeds goes to town for Frank Capra. My man
- 43:47Godfrey. Gregory LaCava. And San Francisco for
- 43:51W .S. Van Dyke. And the winner here was Frank
- 43:55Capra. Head of the Academy. And... The man who
- 43:59appoints voting members of the Academy. What
- 44:02do you think of that? Hey, you guys know who
- 44:04really deserves that nomination this year? Me.
- 44:08Hey, hey, Sally. Would you like to be a voting
- 44:11member of the Academy? Here's a 20. Here's the
- 44:15problem. With them making movies as often as
- 44:17they did, it's kind of hard for this not to happen.
- 44:21Where it's like, oh, this is the year that you're
- 44:23qualified. Yeah, I'm qualified every year because
- 44:24I'm making seven movies a year. Right. Chances
- 44:28are that's going to happen. But also, the Frank
- 44:30Capra hype is real, right? At this time, like,
- 44:32he is talking about the American dream. He is
- 44:36talking about, like, you know, he is bringing
- 44:39the distraction and the attention away from the
- 44:43Great Depression, from the sadness of general
- 44:47life. And I think that that's taking hold. I
- 44:50think that Mr. Dietz Goes to Town is the kind
- 44:52of movie that they're not saying, hey, it's the
- 44:54best movie of the year, but they are saying.
- 44:56We love that Frank Capra. Yeah. So it makes sense
- 44:58that he's getting an award, and it's going to
- 45:00be for direction. Yeah. Yeah, like, I'm okay
- 45:03with it. You were more sweet on Mr. Deeds. Yes,
- 45:08definitely. And I'm not going to say that of
- 45:09these movies, far and away the best directing
- 45:12was Frank Capra, but it does make sense to me.
- 45:15Yeah, and I guess I just think, like, the list
- 45:18of names here is so huge. You have William Wyler,
- 45:22that... It does incredible things coming up in
- 45:24the future. WS Van Dyke, we've talked about multiple
- 45:27times. We love the thin man. And I don't know.
- 45:32I'm on record as kind of being lukewarm on Frank
- 45:36Capra up to this point, at least, other than
- 45:39it happened one night. So I guess I always just
- 45:41get a little disappointed when I see him take
- 45:44home another win, especially when you're up against...
- 45:48people like W .S. Van Dyke and William Wyler,
- 45:50and even Gregory LaCava here. We're going to
- 45:52see some big stuff from him coming up soon. That's
- 45:55right. We'll talk about him next year for sure.
- 45:57The next category is a new one. It is Supporting
- 46:00Actress, along with Supporting Actor, but I'll
- 46:03cover the actress portion. The nominees were
- 46:05Beulah Bondi in The Gorgeous Hussy, Alice Brady
- 46:10in My Man Godfrey, Bonita Granville in These
- 46:14Three, Maria Ospenskaya in Doddsworth, and Gail
- 46:18Sondergaard in Anthony Adverse. And the winner
- 46:21here was Gail Sondergaard in Anthony Adverse.
- 46:23Do you think that this is one of the only, well,
- 46:26I shouldn't say that, one of the shortest on
- 46:29-screen times for a supporting actress? She's
- 46:34like the villain in that movie? Yes. She is,
- 46:38I want to say at most, maybe five to eight minutes
- 46:41of screen time. Yeah, it might be. And listen,
- 46:44if not one of the shortest, appearances for this
- 46:48win like one of the most forgettable if if i'm
- 46:51being so real i don't remember her hardly at
- 46:53all well i think that if um if maria osmanskaya
- 46:57did win for doddsworth that would have been the
- 47:00shortest i think so too i i think her performance
- 47:03was better though yes i agree yeah i But I think
- 47:07because Ospenskaya was more of a complication
- 47:10in the story. I think that what Gail Sondergaard
- 47:14did in The Anthony Adverse was much more of a
- 47:16villainous turn. Yeah. So she was like the villain
- 47:19of the movie. But then there really isn't a villain
- 47:22for a long time. Right. Like she's not a villain
- 47:24throughout. What it really boils down to is I
- 47:28don't think Anthony Adverse is a very good movie.
- 47:30No. And anytime it's pulling a win, I'm just
- 47:32like, ah, what are we doing? Come on. I think
- 47:34Gail Sondergaard is the most. understandable
- 47:36of them. Like it's the one that I agree with
- 47:39the most. Yeah. I can back that up. I'm trying
- 47:43my best. So that was a new category. As we mentioned,
- 47:47the supporting is brand new here. And this is
- 47:49something that sticks around to the modern day.
- 47:52So you went with actress, the supporting actor
- 47:55nominations here. Miska Auer in My Man Godfrey.
- 48:00Walter Brennan in Come and Get It. Stuart Irwin
- 48:03in Pigskin Parade. Basil Rathbone in Romeo and
- 48:07Juliet. And Akeem Tamaroff in The General Died
- 48:11at Dawn. The winner here was Walter Brennan in
- 48:14Come and Get It. We only watched Romeo and Juliet.
- 48:17I feel like this is a common thing throughout
- 48:20time for the supporting actor and actress categories.
- 48:24I always end up just seeing like one of the films.
- 48:27And I'm like, man, I don't know who actually
- 48:30was the best because I didn't watch them all.
- 48:32I keep thinking about what happened to Frank
- 48:35Capra, where whoever was the emcee of the night
- 48:38was like, Frank, come and get it, Frank. Do you
- 48:41think that Jessel, the master of ceremonies here,
- 48:44had fun with come and get it? I think so. He
- 48:47had to have. Yeah. Although come and get it did
- 48:49win. Do you think he was like, come and get it,
- 48:51come and get it? Yeah. No, I think he was like,
- 48:54probably, Walter Brennan, come and get it! And,
- 48:57you know. Yeah. Just let that sit. And then he
- 49:00did. That's what I would have done. Yeah. I would
- 49:02have been like, okay. He just came and got it.
- 49:03I would have taken it with not a word either.
- 49:07Actress is where we're going to continue here.
- 49:10So for Actress, the nominations were Irene Dunn
- 49:13in Theodora Goes Wild. Gladys George in Valiant
- 49:16is the Word for Carrie. Crazy title. That is.
- 49:20Carol Lombard, My Man Godfrey. Louise Rayner
- 49:24in The Great Ziegfeld. And Norma Shearer in Romeo
- 49:28and Juliet. And the winner was Louise Rayner
- 49:31in The Great Seekafeld. Yeah. This one makes
- 49:35sense. This is the one I think. She's great in
- 49:37this movie. She really is. Over, I mean, obviously
- 49:39we didn't see My Man Godfrey Valiant is the word
- 49:42for Carrie or Theodora Goes Wild. But between
- 49:45Norma Shearer in Romeo and Juliet and Louise
- 49:47Rayner, I mean, it was Louise Rayner all day.
- 49:50Yeah. I imagine that the... Other big contender
- 49:53is going to be Carol Lombard in My Man Godfrey.
- 49:55Again, that movie just kind of has the legs with
- 49:58its criteria and release and people are familiar
- 50:01with it. I do want to point out, not to pull
- 50:04the spotlight away from Louise Rainier, but Norma
- 50:06Shearer here. Tough year. Yeah, she lost her
- 50:09husband, Irving Thalberg, who you may remember
- 50:11as being the man that said, you're not sexy enough
- 50:14to be in the divorcee. And then she said, bet.
- 50:19And... Boy, howdy. But she lost her husband and
- 50:22this was her first appearance since his death
- 50:25coming to the 1936 Academy Awards. So that's
- 50:30very sad. It was. Yeah. I mean, it's part of
- 50:34you kind of wants to see her take the win because
- 50:37it's been such a rough year for her. Yeah. And
- 50:39not even just like losing your husband, but like
- 50:40your husband was a very large part of film up
- 50:43to that point. Yeah. Enough to where there are
- 50:45films this year that have the, or at least in
- 50:491937, that have a thank you to Irving S. Thalberg
- 50:52for all the work that he did for a film. Yeah.
- 50:54So it's just a loss for the film community at
- 50:57large. So it's a rough year for her to then lose
- 51:00this. But again, I'm sure with Romeo and Juliet,
- 51:04it's not like anyone saw this and said, oh, she's
- 51:06going to win it. Yeah. And I hate to be this
- 51:09guy, but I do wonder if there was... A bit of
- 51:13nervousness about losing your producer husband.
- 51:16Yes. Because I believe she was mostly cast in
- 51:19Romeo and Juliet because Thalberg was like, I
- 51:22want to see you in this role. Correct. I want
- 51:25to see real quick when the Thalberg Award was
- 51:28introduced. Because obviously that's something
- 51:31that's still presented to this day. Right. It
- 51:33first showed up in 1938. So just shortly after
- 51:36this, we started seeing that award. Two more
- 51:38years. And that just goes to show how monumental
- 51:41he was for the industry and for the Academy specifically.
- 51:45So, yeah, sad news, I guess, historically. Yeah,
- 51:49for sure. So at least for film contributions,
- 51:51huge loss. Yeah, absolutely. And a sad year for...
- 51:56Norma Shearer as well. Yep. So the acting category
- 52:00here, we have Gary Cooper in Mr. Deeds Goes to
- 52:03Town, Walter Houston in Doddsworth, Paul Muni
- 52:07in The Story of Louis Pasteur, William Powell
- 52:10in My Man Godfrey. I didn't know he was in that.
- 52:13Oh, you didn't? No. Oh, yeah, man. Dude, why
- 52:15didn't we watch that? I would love to watch it.
- 52:18And Spencer Tracy in San Francisco. My Man Godfrey,
- 52:21the only one we didn't watch with William Powell.
- 52:24My guy. I feel like a fool. But Paul Muni here
- 52:27took the win. I'm going to call this controversial.
- 52:30Okay, go for it. At least in the modern day,
- 52:33right? Paul Muni, to me, is an actor who, when
- 52:38we first saw him in I Am a Fugitive from a Chain
- 52:40Gang, I was like, wow, just what a blazing performance,
- 52:46right? And every time I've seen him since, I've
- 52:49liked him a little less and less. This was fine,
- 52:55you know, but we have Gary Cooper, who's pretty
- 52:58solid in Mr. Deeds Goes to Town. I don't know
- 53:00if he'd be my pick, but Walter Houston and Dodsworth,
- 53:04that's a great performance. So for me, it's between
- 53:07Houston and Tracy. Yeah. Spencer Tracy as Father
- 53:12Collins? Tim? Father Tim Mullins? Mullins, that's
- 53:17it. Yeah, Father Tim Mullins. Fantastic work.
- 53:20And again, even just that little improv line
- 53:22about Mickey Rooney, that kid Mickey skipped
- 53:26church this week. Yeah, I gotta call him, something
- 53:30like that. Yeah, just that, and then also how
- 53:32imperative he is to the story. I thought he was
- 53:36fantastic in San Francisco, probably even better
- 53:38in Captain's Courageous, which we'll talk about.
- 53:40Right. But yeah, I mean, just the idea of, Dodds
- 53:45worth existing like that kind of movie we talked
- 53:48about in the episode, but to me, it could have
- 53:51just been this like very easily, very easily
- 53:53a melodrama and that's all. But instead it was
- 53:56this very like introspective meditation on like
- 54:00marriage and relationships. And I thought his
- 54:04part of this Walter Houston's was so well done.
- 54:08I agree. So no, I'm with you. I would have almost
- 54:10expected him to take it. Yeah. But I will say
- 54:12about Paul Muni, while I agree that I'm getting
- 54:14less interested over time, it's undeniable he's
- 54:17a good actor, right? He is very good. But it's
- 54:20just the roles that he's playing are so similar.
- 54:22That's what it is. You're like, okay. It's the
- 54:24roles, not the actor himself. Yeah. And I guess
- 54:28you could argue, we've talked about how he kind
- 54:30of has a major say in what he's playing and what's
- 54:34being made around him. So you can kind of argue
- 54:37that it is him a little bit, where it just feels
- 54:40like his talents are kind of wasted. I don't
- 54:42know. It's a little disappointing, this win here.
- 54:46A bit. But then that takes us to our final award
- 54:50category of the night, and that is Best Picture.
- 54:54Outstanding production, if you will. That's the
- 54:55one. Here are the nominees. Anthony Adverse,
- 54:58Warner Brothers, produced by Henry Blank. Sure.
- 55:02Dodsworth. Goldwyn United Artists, produced by
- 55:04Samuel Goldwyn and Merit Hulbert. The Great Ziegfeld,
- 55:09MGM, produced by Hunt Stromberg. Libel Lady,
- 55:12MGM, produced by Lawrence Wingarden. Mr. Deeds
- 55:17Goes to Town, Columbia, produced by Frank Capra.
- 55:19Perhaps you've heard of him. Romeo and Juliet,
- 55:21MGM, produced by Irving Thalberg. San Francisco,
- 55:25MGM, produced by John Emerson and Bernard H.
- 55:27Hyman. The Story of Louis Pasteur, Warner Brothers,
- 55:30produced by Henry Blank. A Tale of Two Cities
- 55:33MGM produced by David O. Selznick. And Three
- 55:36Smart Girls Universal produced by Joseph Pasternak
- 55:39with Charles R. Rogers. And despite Story of
- 55:45Louis Pasteur winning pretty much every award
- 55:47it was nominated for here, the great Ziegfeld
- 55:50did end up taking the win on this. Pretty interesting
- 55:54twist here. I'd say so. I don't know if it's
- 55:56the right call. I don't know what the right call
- 55:58is here. I know that I really liked Libel Lady
- 56:01a lot. I'm not saying it's the best picture of
- 56:03that year. It's the most fun. Most fun, for sure.
- 56:06I really like Dodsworth. I think it's the most
- 56:08interesting. I probably would have given it to
- 56:10Dodsworth overall. I think so, yeah. San Francisco,
- 56:13I liked a good bit. And of course, I really did
- 56:15like Mr. D's Goes to Town, but I'm not trying
- 56:17to say that it's the movie of the year or anything.
- 56:20Sure. I just enjoy a Frank Capra film. But The
- 56:23Great Ziegfeld, I will say, again, I enjoyed
- 56:25it more than you did on record. And I think that
- 56:28what it's going for... The leading man in William
- 56:31Powell, him not just being the charming comedian,
- 56:34he kind of has to do a bit more acting than that
- 56:37in this. I enjoyed him in it. And I think the
- 56:40set pieces are really great. I think the musical
- 56:42aspect is fun. And of course, seeing him with
- 56:46Myrna Loy, I'm never mad at that. But it's over
- 56:49long. It's just over three hours, which, you
- 56:52know, in 2026, we have some complaints whenever
- 56:55something's over three hours. I can't even imagine.
- 56:59The kind of concern of that in 1936. Yeah. If
- 57:02anything, the expense of filming that much, you
- 57:06know, with the cost of actual physical film.
- 57:09Right. So there is that. I think that its length
- 57:12may have worked for it, though. I think that
- 57:15there's still kind of that feeling. Oh, the best
- 57:19picture is going to be an epic or it's going
- 57:22to be a long sweeping narrative. So when you
- 57:24add length to a movie, people. might just automatically
- 57:28assume, like, oh, this is a big deal. Yeah, I
- 57:31think, first of all, I want to point out, like,
- 57:35half of those films were MGM. We talked about
- 57:38that briefly. Like, it's insane how much MGM
- 57:41is pumping out and how many of them are being
- 57:43recognized at the Academy Awards. My Letterboxd
- 57:47stats are going crazy this year. They're like,
- 57:49hey, man, there are other studios you could watch,
- 57:52you know? But yeah, beyond that, I think that
- 57:55overall this year was, it had some lows for me,
- 58:01some very low lows, and then it had some very
- 58:03mediums. And that's kind of where it sat. Nothing
- 58:08here really blew me away. There are things that
- 58:10surprised me. I think that when people go back
- 58:12and they watch these films, the ones that are
- 58:15highlighted and showcased aren't necessarily
- 58:17the ones that should be. I think San Francisco
- 58:20is a... pretty heavily overlooked film, at least
- 58:23for its finale. I think Doddsworth is an incredibly
- 58:27underrated movie. Yes, definitely. I think that's
- 58:29the number one overlooked. Yeah. It's wild that
- 58:32that's not talked about more. Some of the best
- 58:34performances I think we've seen on the podcast
- 58:35so far. Yeah. I don't know if I'd say that as...
- 58:40As much of a declarative. I think you're right,
- 58:43though. At least the kind of story that it's
- 58:46telling and the way it's telling it, very different.
- 58:49I think a lesser hand behind it would make it
- 58:52just focus on the events that happen and how
- 58:55melodramatic that is, and less the meaning behind
- 58:58it. Like, less the deep dive and real inspection
- 59:04of what it means to be in a relationship. Yeah.
- 59:07I really... Enjoyed my time with that movie.
- 59:10You know what we're going to do? Normally we
- 59:12would cut to a part of this where we go and see
- 59:15what you voted for, the audience here, the members,
- 59:18the voting body of Once Upon a Time in the Oscars,
- 59:22to what you would have picked instead. I think
- 59:25we're going to call an audible on this one. Okay.
- 59:30And I think you and I should declare here and
- 59:32now that Dodsworth should have won Best Picture.
- 59:35I agree. And that's not to... take away from
- 59:39what the voters have done. I'll just go ahead
- 59:43and say that the voters didn't vote. So we're
- 59:45taking over. We are taking over. I think that
- 59:48Dodsworth, yeah, I think that's right. I think
- 59:50Dodsworth should be recognized as the 1936 Best
- 59:53Picture winner, according to Once Upon a Time
- 59:56at the Oscars. Do you think that if the great
- 59:58Ziegfeld did not win Best Picture, that the Brutalist
- 1:00:02would not have won? Oh, wow. What a strange butterfly
- 1:00:07effect. Well, I'm just saying like 90 years in
- 1:00:10the future. Yeah. They're going to be like, is
- 1:00:12there a spot here for a three hour plus epic
- 1:00:15about like a great man? Yeah. That's interesting
- 1:00:19to think about. Do you think the Brutalist could
- 1:00:21have used a musical? Yeah, I think so. I would
- 1:00:23have been okay with that. Yeah. You know what
- 1:00:25I do think is that Adrian Brody's character in
- 1:00:27the Brutalist would have looked at that set of
- 1:00:30a pretty girl's like a melody. Yep. It would
- 1:00:32have been really. Really impressed. He would
- 1:00:34have been chewing his gum and been like, this
- 1:00:35is going to be great. But, you know, with 70
- 1:00:39,000 more words to say about it. Yes, exactly.
- 1:00:42And make sure there's a spotlight and a microphone.
- 1:00:44Yep. I've been here before. So, yeah, Doddsworth
- 1:00:48is what we're going with. As far as write -ins,
- 1:00:51we did not have any of those this episode either.
- 1:00:53We really are going to look into... Like a hotline
- 1:00:57or something. Something to make it easier for
- 1:00:59you guys to get your words into us. But let me
- 1:01:02ask you this while we're here. A question for
- 1:01:05you that I'm going to come up with. Okay. Do
- 1:01:07you think that at this time, 1936, that the Academy
- 1:01:13Award body has given too much importance to a
- 1:01:19biopic? Oh, yeah. Yeah, I think so. We're kind
- 1:01:23of getting into a rut. I think, with biopics.
- 1:01:27I think that at some point, I don't know when
- 1:01:30exactly, but the Academy saw one and was like,
- 1:01:32wow, these are really interesting. People like
- 1:01:35these. And now it's kind of what's being recognized
- 1:01:38over and over and over again. And you're not
- 1:01:40getting the opportunity to have films flourish
- 1:01:44that are really just innovative stories. San
- 1:01:47Francisco, I think, is incredibly innovative.
- 1:01:49Dodsworth is a really unique story. And those
- 1:01:52are the ones that I think both of us have been
- 1:01:54most excited for. So I'm looking forward to the
- 1:01:57biopic eventually taking a seat and going away.
- 1:02:01It's not happening anytime soon, but I'd like
- 1:02:03it to. Yeah, I think I think that's correct.
- 1:02:07I think that biopics are kind of like reigning
- 1:02:09supreme at this time. And that makes, you know,
- 1:02:12the libel ladies, the Doddsworths, like that
- 1:02:16makes them so much more enjoyable because it
- 1:02:19just stands out. Yeah. So, again, libel lady
- 1:02:22is a movie that I enjoyed a lot. It's also just
- 1:02:25kind of like The Thin Man, where it's like, hey,
- 1:02:27I don't know if this deserves Best Picture, but
- 1:02:28man, I love that movie. Dodsworth, though, very
- 1:02:31easy to see how that should have picked up a
- 1:02:33bit more attention than it did. Yeah. I agree.
- 1:02:37So make sure that you reach out to us in the
- 1:02:39future when you have these questions or we talk
- 1:02:41about a movie and you say, you know what? I should
- 1:02:44have won Best Picture that year. You can reach
- 1:02:46out to us at outaopodcast at gmail .com to let
- 1:02:50us know your thoughts. You can also follow us
- 1:02:53on Patreon, where you can be part of many tiered
- 1:02:57subscriptions, such as getting benefits like
- 1:03:00the movie reviews, early episodes, the exclusive
- 1:03:04bonus episodes, including Horror the Overlooked
- 1:03:08that we do every 13th of the month. And you can
- 1:03:11check out our Discord as well through the Patreon.
- 1:03:14Yeah. Next year, the nominees are as follows.
- 1:03:19The Awful Truth, Captain's Courageous, Dead End,
- 1:03:22The Good Earth, In Old Chicago, The Life of Emile
- 1:03:26Zola, Lost Horizon, 100 Men and a Girl, Stage
- 1:03:29Door, and A Star is Born. There's a lot of good
- 1:03:33stuff here. Yes. We're more than halfway through
- 1:03:36these films, peek behind the curtain and all
- 1:03:39of that. 70 % through, I think. Yeah, yeah. And
- 1:03:43there's a lot here to like. We're talking about
- 1:03:47the return of William Wellman. We have some Katharine
- 1:03:51Hepburn, Ginger Rogers collaboration, which is
- 1:03:53really unique and interesting. We got some Humphrey
- 1:03:56Bogart coming in. Yeah. Like, there's a lot here
- 1:03:59to enjoy. So, I think... As always, if you're
- 1:04:03looking for a place to jump on, the beginning
- 1:04:05of every month is that place. You don't need
- 1:04:08previous knowledge to hop in wherever. So if
- 1:04:12you know anybody that's looking for a cool new
- 1:04:14podcast and they want to follow along with us,
- 1:04:17now's the time to do it. I'm excited to talk
- 1:04:20about all these movies. I think we've got some
- 1:04:22interviews coming up that are going to be really
- 1:04:24special. But yeah, plenty to look forward to.
- 1:04:27That's right. And it is officially the 10th year.
- 1:04:31Of the ceremonies. So it will be a full decade
- 1:04:34that we have covered and kind of also marked
- 1:04:36the first year anniversary of this iteration
- 1:04:39of the podcast. That's true. Yeah, we're a couple
- 1:04:43days away from that. Yeah. That's wild. So maybe
- 1:04:46we'll release a bonus episode that's like an
- 1:04:49anniversary of the episode zero. Yeah. And we'll
- 1:04:53kind of do like a pulse check. That would be
- 1:04:55cool. Yeah. And maybe we'll do something for
- 1:04:57the Patreon as well, like a... A live event or
- 1:05:00something. So you're saying that the only way
- 1:05:02that I could get access to listen to that episode
- 1:05:05would be to subscribe to the Patreon? I think
- 1:05:08that's what I'm saying. You're saying that to
- 1:05:11me? Go ahead and subscribe to the Patreon. Sling
- 1:05:16Blade Babies. That's going to do it for this
- 1:05:19episode and this year. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm
- 1:05:22trying to think of another thing to say as Sling
- 1:05:24Blade. And we'll say you. At the movies.