Latest / CSCS In The Car / The Doctrine of Necessity: When Breaking the Law Is Legally Justified
Transcript
- 0:06Speaker 1: Bud Adam a younger nineteen fifty five. Okay, make three
- 0:15word camp and grand Week for a to I believe
- 0:19it was called my Camera one. Welcome back, everybody. They're
- 0:22gonna be looking at the necessity doctrine. It's generally considered
- 0:26to be a considerate a justification, although it contains elements
- 0:29of excuse as well. Necessity is sometimes referred to as
- 0:32the choice of lesser evils because it involves choosing conduct
- 0:36that is technically unlawful in order to avoid some greater harm.
- 0:40This is what makes it a justification. Conduct that avoids
- 0:43a great harm is desirable from a societal perspective. Some
- 0:48call it the choice of evils because individuals were confronted
- 0:50with the unhappy choice between committing a crime or experiencing
- 0:53a harmful event. You might remember the Deadly Stevens case.
- 0:57We talked about the Queen versus Deadly Stevens. You can
- 1:00look at when our former podcasts It talks about this
- 1:03when they confront the most challenging, intriguing necessity case in history.
- 1:07It's actually one of the first cases he usually listen
- 1:09to in law school. But first let's go back to
- 1:12the Doctor of Necessities. We're not going to go over deadly,
- 1:15and Stevens you can find that on their own. There's
- 1:19five elements that that are needed for the defense under
- 1:21the common law. Number one, there must be a threat
- 1:24of eminent harm, right, somebody's gonna have to be getting
- 1:27ready to harm ye at that moment. Two the harm
- 1:29must be directed toward either a person or to property.
- 1:33Three the defendant must have no reasonable legal alternative to
- 1:36avoiding the threat. Four the defendant must come to the
- 1:39situation with clean hands. In other words, they shouldn't have
- 1:42caused the problem that they're in. And five the haarnt
- 1:46of the defendant seeks to avoid must be more serious
- 1:49than the harm caused by the defendant's conduct. Here's a
- 1:51couple of cases we'll quickly look at. Humphrey versus Commonwealth.
- 1:56The Virginia of Court Appeals recognized the defendant, the convicted felon,
- 2:00was justified in violating a gun possession statute in an
- 2:03effort to protect himself from an armed attack. The court
- 2:06stress that the appellant was without fault in provoking the altercation.
- 2:10The defendant also must not have been substantially a fallen
- 2:12creating the emergency, and state versus SS. Squires rode to
- 2:17a bar with his nephew because he was drunk. When leaving,
- 2:19asked his seventeen year old nephew to drive him home.
- 2:22His nephew was unfamiliar with the car, installed the vehicle
- 2:24on a well traveled highway. While backing out of the
- 2:27parking lot, Squires took control of the automobile and was
- 2:29stop by the police. He was determined to have a
- 2:32blood alcohol level a point twenty four and was arrested
- 2:34for operating a vehicle. The Vermont Supreme Court held of
- 2:38the defendant was not entitled to the necessity defense because
- 2:41the record establishes the defendant's own conduct created the emergency.
- 2:45So we got to see both sides of the coin
- 2:47there and when it would apply and when it wouldn't apply.
- 2:52So that was the doctrine of necessity. Hopefully you learned
- 2:55a little bit of something there and enjoyed it. Thank
- 2:57you very much for listening.