Latest / In the Loop AI / Announcing Google's Secret New AI Model With The Person Who Built It | Logan Kilpatrick
Transcript
- 0:00Logan: The best image generation and editing model in the world.
- 0:03Ejaaz: It's scary how realistic this stuff is. VO3 has kind of like killed the VFX studio.
- 0:09Logan: And this is, I think, principally enabled by Vibe Coding. My hope is that it
- 0:12Logan: actually ends up creating more opportunity for the experts and the specialists.
- 0:15Josh: How much of the tools that you build do you find are built with Vibe Coding?
- 0:19Logan: I'm like almost 85% of everything that I do Vibe Coded.
- 0:22Ejaaz: I remember when I first booted up a PC and I just had access to all these different
- 0:26Ejaaz: wonderful applications all within one suite. This kind of feels like that moment for AI.
- 0:31Josh: Gemini is feeling faster, but it's also feeling better, and it's also getting cheaper.
- 0:36Ejaaz: What's happening behind the scenes?
- 0:37Logan: We crossed quadrillion tokens, which comes after a trillion if you're not.
- 0:41Logan: You haven't thought about numbers higher than a trillion before.
- 0:44Logan: It's what comes after a trillion, and there's no slowdown in sight.
- 0:51Josh: We have an incredibly exciting episode today because we are joined by Logan
- 0:54Josh: Kilpatrick. Logan is the product lead working on the Gemini platform at Google DeepMind.
- 0:59Josh: We have an exciting announcement to break right here today with Logan,
- 1:02Josh: which is the announcement of a model that we previously knew as Nano Banana.
- 1:06Josh: The reality is this is a brand new image generation model coming out of Google
- 1:10Josh: and you can access it today.
- 1:12Josh: So Logan, tell us about this brand new model and what we need to be excited about.
- 1:15Logan: Yeah, for people who are not chronically online and seeing all the tweets and everything like that,
- 1:20Logan: part of the excitement has been in over the last, I think, like six months,
- 1:23Logan: we've seen the emergence of like native image
- 1:26Logan: generation editing models historically um you
- 1:30Logan: would see models that could actually do a really good job of generating
- 1:33Logan: images um they were usually like tend to be like very like beautiful um aesthetic
- 1:38Logan: images the challenge was like how do you actually use these things in practice
- 1:42Logan: to do a lot of stuff that's where this editing capability is really helpful
- 1:46Logan: um and then so we started to see these models that can actually edit images
- 1:49Logan: if you could provide an image,
- 1:51Logan: it would, and then prompt it, it would, it would actually change that image.
- 1:55Logan: What's really interesting though, is this fusion of those two capabilities with
- 1:59Logan: the actual base intelligence of the Gemini model.
- 2:02Logan: And there's a lot of really cool ways in which this like manifests itself.
- 2:05Logan: And we'll look at some examples of this.
- 2:06Logan: But it's this benefit of the world knowledge. The model is like smart.
- 2:10Logan: So as you, as you ask it to do things, and as you ask it to make changes,
- 2:14Logan: it doesn't just like take what you're saying at face value.
- 2:17Logan: It takes what you're saying in the context of its understanding of the world
- 2:21Logan: and its understanding of physics, its understanding of light and all this other
- 2:25Logan: stuff, and it makes those changes.
- 2:26Logan: So it's not just blindly making edits or generations. They're actually grounded
- 2:31Logan: in reality and context in which that's useful.
- 2:34Logan: And we can look at some examples of this. My favorite thing is actually this editing capability.
- 2:40Logan: So this is an AI studio, and we'll have a link somewhere, hopefully in the show
- 2:43Logan: notes, that will let us do this. My friend Amar, who...
- 2:47Logan: Is on our team and drives all of our design stuff um build
- 2:51Logan: this and it's called past forward and what you can do is you can
- 2:54Logan: put in an image of yourself and it'll regenerate a
- 2:57Logan: version of yourself um in this
- 2:59Logan: sort of like polaroid-esque vibe um following all the different trends from
- 3:05Logan: the last 10 or 20 uh 30 years um so if you look at this example this is from
- 3:12Logan: me from the 1950s and And I'm sure I have a picture of my dad from the 1950s
- 3:16Logan: somewhere or my grandpa who looks somewhat similar to that.
- 3:20Logan: Here's me in the 1980s, which I love. Here's me.
- 3:24Ejaaz: Some of these facial expressions are also different. Like you're showing your
- 3:27Ejaaz: teeth more in some and then it's a smirk in others. That's super cool.
- 3:32Logan: I like this sweater. I actually have a sweater that almost looks exactly like
- 3:35Logan: this 1970s one, though I don't like my hair in this 1970s one.
- 3:39Logan: Same with the 2000s. um so one of the cool things
- 3:42Logan: about this uh this new model and one of the features i
- 3:45Logan: think folks are going to be most excited about is this character consistency which
- 3:48Logan: is as you took the original image um and you
- 3:51Logan: made the translation to this 1950s image it actually
- 3:54Logan: looks like me still um which is really cool so
- 3:57Logan: there's lots of these really interesting use cases i think we'll
- 4:00Logan: we'll go out with a um um like a
- 4:03Logan: sports card demo where you can sort of turn yourself into
- 4:06Logan: a you know a figurine sports card um
- 4:09Logan: which is really cool so lots of really interesting examples like
- 4:12Logan: this um and another thing you'll notice is actually the
- 4:15Logan: speed and this is where the underlying model is not
- 4:18Logan: uh the code name was nano nano banana um
- 4:21Logan: the actual model is built on gemini 2.5 flash which is our workhorse model it's
- 4:26Logan: super fast it's super efficient um it's relatively priced in the market which
- 4:30Logan: is awesome so you can actually use it at scale um and yeah so this model behind
- 4:35Logan: the scenes or for developers who people want to build with it is Gemini 2.5 flash image,
- 4:40Logan: which is awesome. So this is a use case that I love.
- 4:44Logan: And it's a ton of fun. You can do this in the Gemini app or in AI Studio.
- 4:49Ejaaz: I mean, as you said, the character consistency just from these examples is like astounding.
- 4:57Josh: I need to give a round of applause. This has been my biggest issue when I'm
- 4:59Josh: generating images of myself.
- 5:01Ejaaz: Genuinely. And Josh and I are early users of, you know, Mid Journey V1,
- 5:07Ejaaz: OpenAI's Image Generator as well.
- 5:10Ejaaz: And one of our pet peeves was it just couldn't do the most simplistic things,
- 5:14Ejaaz: right? We could just say, hey, keep this photo and portrait of me exactly the same.
- 5:18Ejaaz: But can you show me what I would look like in a different hairstyle or me holding
- 5:22Ejaaz: a bottle of Coca-Cola instead of this martini?
- 5:25Ejaaz: And it just could not do that, right? Just simple video, like photo editing.
- 5:29Ejaaz: Can you give us a bit of a background as to what Google did to be able to achieve this?
- 5:35Ejaaz: Because, you know, I've been racking my head around like, why other AI companies
- 5:38Ejaaz: couldn't do this? Like, what's happening behind the scenes? Can you give us a bit of insight?
- 5:43Logan: Yeah, that's a good question. I think this actually goes back to and I'll share
- 5:46Logan: another example in a second as well.
- 5:47Logan: But I think this goes back to this story of what happens when you build a model
- 5:52Logan: that has the fusion of all these capabilities together.
- 5:55Logan: And I was actually just This is a sort of parallel example to this,
- 5:58Logan: but it's another example of why building a unified model to do all this stuff
- 6:02Logan: and not having a separate model that doesn't have world knowledge and all these
- 6:06Logan: other capabilities is useful. The same thing is actually true on video.
- 6:09Logan: Like part of the story, and we haven't, we have a bunch of stuff coming that
- 6:14Logan: sort of tells this a little bit more elegantly than I will right now.
- 6:16Logan: But part of the story of like VO3 having this really state-of-the-art video
- 6:22Logan: generation capabilities, if folks have seen this, is that the Gemini models
- 6:27Logan: themselves have this state-of-the-art video understanding capabilities.
- 6:31Logan: And a very similar context, actually, on the image side, which is since the
- 6:37Logan: original Gemini model, we've like,
- 6:39Logan: with the exception of probably a couple of months in that like two and a half
- 6:42Logan: year time horizon, have had state-of-the-art image understanding capabilities.
- 6:46Logan: And I think there is this like capability transfer, which is really interesting
- 6:51Logan: as you go to do the generation step.
- 6:53Logan: And if you can fuse those two things together in the same model,
- 6:56Logan: you end up just being able to do things that other models aren't able to do.
- 7:00Logan: And this was part of the bet originally that like, why build Gemini to be the original Gemini?
- 7:06Logan: Gemini 1.0 model was built to be natively multimodal. It was built to be natively
- 7:10Logan: multimodal because the belief at the time,
- 7:13Logan: and I think this is turning out to be true is that like that's on the path to
- 7:16Logan: AGI is that you combine these capabilities together and like similar to what
- 7:20Logan: humans are able to do we have this fusion of all these capabilities in a single
- 7:24Logan: entity just like these models should be able to do.
- 7:28Ejaaz: Wow. So if I were to distill what you just said here, Logan,
- 7:32Ejaaz: the way you've trained Gemini 2.5 or all future Google Gemini models is it's
- 7:39Ejaaz: in a very multimodal fashion.
- 7:41Ejaaz: So you're basically, it gets smarter in one particular facet,
- 7:45Ejaaz: which trains itself or has transferable capabilities to other facets,
- 7:49Ejaaz: whether it's image generation, video generation, or even text LLMs to some extent.
- 7:53Ejaaz: I just think that's fascinating.
- 7:55Ejaaz: I'm curious, I have one question for you, which I want to hear your take on.
- 7:59Ejaaz: How are you going to surface this to the regular consumer, right?
- 8:03Ejaaz: Because right now, you provide all of these capabilities through an amazing
- 8:07Ejaaz: suite, you know, called Google AI Studio.
- 8:10Ejaaz: But if I wanted to use this in, say, an Instagram app, or my random photo imaging
- 8:16Ejaaz: editing app, is this something that could be easily proved to someone or sourced?
- 8:21Ejaaz: Or do we need to go via some other route right now.
- 8:23Logan: Let me just diverge really quickly, which is if any of the researchers who I
- 8:29Logan: work with are watching this, they will tell me, they'll make sure that I know
- 8:32Logan: that capability transfer that we just talked about, you oftentimes don't get that out of the box.
- 8:38Logan: So there is some emergence where you get a little bit of that.
- 8:42Logan: You do have to do, there's real true research and engineering work that has
- 8:46Logan: to happen to make sure that that capability fusion happens.
- 8:49Logan: It's not often that you just like make the model really
- 8:52Logan: good at one thing and then it translates oftentimes actually it's
- 8:55Logan: like uh it has a negative effect which is as you
- 8:58Logan: make the models really good at code for example you trade
- 9:01Logan: that off against some other you know creative writing as as a random example
- 9:05Logan: of this um so you have to do a lot of like active research and engineering work
- 9:09Logan: to make sure that you don't lose a capability as you make another one better
- 9:12Logan: but then ultimately they benefit as if you can make them on the same level they
- 9:16Logan: benefit from this interleaved capability together.
- 9:19Logan: To answer the question about like, where is this going to be available?
- 9:22Logan: The Gemini app is the place that like for by and large, most people should be going to.
- 9:26Logan: So if you go to Gemini.Google.com, there'll be sort of a landing page experience
- 9:30Logan: that showcases this new model and makes it really easy.
- 9:33Logan: And you can put in all your images and do tons of fun stuff like the example that I was showing.
- 9:38Logan: If you're a developer and you want to build something with this,
- 9:41Logan: in AI Studio, we have this build tab.
- 9:43Logan: And that's what we were just looking at as an example of one of the applets
- 9:47Logan: that's available in the build tab,
- 9:50Logan: the general essence is that all of these applets can be forked and remixed and
- 9:54Logan: edited and modified so that you can keep doing all the things that you want
- 9:58Logan: to do with the AI capability built in.
- 10:01Logan: So it'll continue to be powered by the same model. It'll do all that stuff, which is awesome.
- 10:06Logan: So there's lots of cool fusion capabilities that we have with this.
- 10:10Logan: Same thing with this other example that we're looking at. So if you want to
- 10:14Logan: go outside of this environment, we have an API.
- 10:16Logan: You could go and build whatever. saw if your website is, you know,
- 10:20Logan: AI photos.com or whatever, you could go and build with the Gemini API,
- 10:24Logan: use the new Gemini 2.5 flash image model to do a bunch of this stuff, which is awesome.
- 10:29Josh: Awesome. So while this is baking, I noticed you had another tab open,
- 10:32Josh: which means maybe there's another demo that you were prepared to share.
- 10:35Logan: There is another demo. This one I actually haven't tried yet.
- 10:39Logan: But it's this idea of like, how can you take a photo editing experience and
- 10:44Logan: make it super, super simple? So I'll grab an image.
- 10:48Logan: Actually, we'll take this picture, which is a picture of Demis and I.
- 10:52Josh: Legends.
- 10:53Logan: We'll put an anime filter on it and we'll see.
- 10:56Logan: And so this is a completely vibe coded UI experience and all the code behind
- 11:00Logan: the scenes is vibe coded as well.
- 11:01Logan: And we'll see how well this works with Demis and I.
- 11:05Josh: How much of the tools that you build do you find are built with vibe coding
- 11:08Josh: instead of just hard coding software?
- 11:11Josh: Are you writing a lot of this as vibe coded through the Gemini model?
- 11:14Logan: I think you sometimes you're able to do some of the stuff,
- 11:18Logan: completely vibe coded um it depends on like
- 11:21Logan: how specific that you want to do i do i'm like almost 85
- 11:25Logan: of everything that i do vibe coded somebody else on
- 11:27Logan: my team built this one so i don't want to misrepresent the work it could
- 11:30Logan: have it could have all been human programmed because we have an incredible set
- 11:34Logan: of engineers the general idea is how can you make this oh interesting how can
- 11:39Logan: you make this photoshop like experience let's go 90 or do you have suggestions
- 11:45Logan: what would a good filter for this be i don't know oh.
- 11:48Josh: Man i yeah like perhaps uh going back to
- 11:50Josh: the last example maybe like a a 90s film or an
- 11:53Josh: 80s film grain all right and i guess while we wait for that to load is there
- 11:56Josh: a simple way that you would describe a nano banana or this new image model to
- 12:01Josh: just the average person on the street who's oh look there we go we have the
- 12:04Josh: film grain okay so what we're watching for the people who are listening um you're
- 12:08Josh: retouching you can retouch parts of the image you could crop adjust there are filters to be applied
- 12:12Logan: I'm just clicking through buttons to be honest, I've never done it before. So it's been fun.
- 12:17Logan: Live demo, day one. This is the exploration you're going to get to do as a user
- 12:20Logan: as you play around with this.
- 12:21Ejaaz: Logan is vibe editing and that's what's happening. Yeah. He's experimenting.
- 12:25Logan: Vibe editing, which is fun. I love it. That's a great way. And the cool thing,
- 12:29Logan: again, is like what I love about this experience is as you're going through,
- 12:32Logan: oh, interesting, this one's like giving me edited outline.
- 12:36Josh: Oh, yeah, a little outline. This is helpful for our thumbnail generation. We do a lot of this stuff.
- 12:40Logan: Let's see if I can remove the background as well.
- 12:42Ejaaz: Oh, yeah. Let's see. I should be.
- 12:44Josh: If this removes the background, this is going to be trouble because this is
- 12:47Josh: a big feature that we use for a lot of our imagery.
- 12:49Logan: Hopefully. Come on. Oh, nice.
- 12:51Ejaaz: Oh, done.
- 12:53Josh: Nicely done.
- 12:54Ejaaz: For those of you who are listening, he's typed in, put me in the Library of
- 12:58Ejaaz: Congress. So we're going to hopefully see Logan.
- 13:02Logan: Yeah, the context on that image was that Demis and I were in the Library of the DeepMind office.
- 13:08Ejaaz: Oh, nice.
- 13:09Logan: Yeah, so that was the Library of Congress reference in my mind.
- 13:13Logan: But yeah, so much that you can do.
- 13:14Logan: Again, what I love about this experience is that as you go around and play with
- 13:19Logan: this stuff, if you want to modify this experience, you can do so on the left-hand side.
- 13:24Logan: If you say, actually, here are these five editing features that I really care
- 13:28Logan: about, the model will go and rewrite the code, and then it'll still be attached
- 13:32Logan: to this new 2.5 flash image model.
- 13:36Logan: So you can do all these types of cool stuff. This experience is something that
- 13:40Logan: I'm really excited about that we've been pushing on.
- 13:42Josh: Yeah, this is amazing because I myself, I do photography a lot.
- 13:45Josh: I was a photographer in my past life and I rely very heavily on Photoshop and
- 13:49Josh: Lightroom for editing, which is a very manual process.
- 13:52Josh: And they have these smart tools, but they're not quite like this.
- 13:54Josh: I mean, this saves a tremendous amount of time if I could just say,
- 13:57Josh: hey, realign, restrain the image, remove the background, add a filter.
- 14:01Josh: I think the plain English version of this makes it really approachable, but also way faster.
- 14:07Logan: Yeah, it is. It is crazy fast. I think about this all the time.
- 14:10Logan: Like there's definitely cases where you want to go deep with whatever the pro tool is.
- 14:16Logan: I think there's, there's actually something interesting, like on the near horizon
- 14:19Logan: that our team has thought a lot about, which is how you can have this experience
- 14:23Logan: and how you can sort of in a, in a generative UI capacity,
- 14:29Logan: have the experience sort of subtly expose additional detail to users.
- 14:33Logan: And I think about this like if you're a new you know photoshop user
- 14:36Logan: as an example and you show up like the chance that you're
- 14:39Logan: going to use all of the bells and whistles is zero like you want
- 14:42Logan: like the three things i want to remove a background i want to crop something
- 14:45Logan: whatever it is like don't actually show this all of these bells and whistles
- 14:50Logan: i think the exciting thing about like the progress on coding models is that
- 14:54Logan: in the future the challenge with the challenge with doing this in the present
- 14:58Logan: rather is that software is deterministic.
- 15:00Logan: You have to build software to build the sort of like modified version of that
- 15:04Logan: software for all of these different like skill sets and use cases is extremely
- 15:08Logan: expensive. It's not feasible.
- 15:10Logan: It doesn't scale to production environments. But if you can have this generative
- 15:14Logan: UI capability where like the model sort of knows and as you talk to the model,
- 15:18Logan: it realizes, oh, you might actually benefit from these other things.
- 15:21Logan: It can create the code to do that on the fly and expose them to you,
- 15:24Logan: which is really interesting.
- 15:26Logan: So I think there's lots of stuff that is going to be possible as the models keep getting better.
- 15:31Josh: This is amazing. So the TLDR on this new announcement, how would I,
- 15:36Josh: if I were to go explain to my friend what this does, why this is special,
- 15:39Josh: how would you kind of sell it to me?
- 15:41Logan: The best image generation and editing model in the world, 2.5 flash image or
- 15:47Logan: nano banana, whichever you prefer, is the model that can do this.
- 15:52Logan: And I think there's so many creative use cases where you're actually bounded
- 15:57Logan: by the creative tool. And I feel like this is one of these examples to me where
- 16:01Logan: it's like, I feel like I'm 10x more.
- 16:03Logan: I was literally helping my friend yesterday doing a bunch of iterations on his
- 16:08Logan: LinkedIn picture because it was like, you know, the background was slightly
- 16:12Logan: weird or something like that.
- 16:13Logan: And we were just like, I did like 15 iterations and now he's got a great new
- 16:17Logan: LinkedIn background, which is awesome.
- 16:19Logan: So like, there's so many like actual practical use cases where you,
- 16:23Logan: and I literally just like built a custom tool on the fly vibe coding in order
- 16:28Logan: to solve that use case, which was a ton of fun.
- 16:31Josh: Yeah, this is so cool. Okay, so this model, Nano Banana Gemini 2.5 Flash Image Gen, it's out today.
- 16:37Josh: So we'll link that in the description for people who want to try it out.
- 16:39Josh: I think one of my complaints for the longest time, and I've mentioned this on
- 16:41Josh: the show a few times, is a lot of times when I'm engaging with this incredible
- 16:45Josh: form of intelligence, I just have a text box.
- 16:47Josh: And it's up to me to kind of pull the creativity out of my own mind.
- 16:50Josh: And I don't get a lot of help along the way. but one of the things that you
- 16:53Josh: spend your time in is this thing called Google AI Studio.
- 16:56Josh: And I've used AI Studio a lot because it solves a problem for me that was annoying,
- 17:00Josh: which is just the blank text box.
- 17:02Josh: It kind of has a lot of prompts. It has a lot of helpers. It has a lot of guidance
- 17:05Josh: into helping me extract value out of the model.
- 17:08Josh: So what I'd love for you to do for people who aren't familiar,
- 17:10Josh: Logan, is just kind of explain to everyone what Google AI Studio is and why
- 17:14Josh: it's so important and why it's so great.
- 17:17Logan: Yeah, I love this, Josh. I appreciate that you like using AI Studio.
- 17:21Logan: Go. It is a labor of love. Lots of
- 17:25Logan: people across Google have put in a ton of time to make progress on this.
- 17:28Logan: I really want to, so I'll make a caveat, which is we have this entirely redesigned
- 17:33Logan: AI Studio experience that's coming very soon.
- 17:35Logan: I won't spoil it in this episode because it's like half faked right now.
- 17:40Logan: And I wish I could show, and I think actually some of the features that you
- 17:43Logan: might see in this UI might be slightly different at launch time than what you see here.
- 17:47Logan: So take this with a grain of salt. We've got a bunch of new stuff coming.
- 17:51Logan: And I think actually it should help with this problem that you're describing,
- 17:55Logan: which is as you show up to a bunch of these tools today, the onus is really
- 17:58Logan: on you as a user to like try to figure out what's capable,
- 18:02Logan: what all the different models are capable of, what even are all the different
- 18:06Logan: models, like all of that stuff.
- 18:08Logan: So at a high level, like we built AI Studio for this like AI builder audience.
- 18:13Logan: If you want to take AI models and actually build something with them and not
- 18:18Logan: just, you know, chat to AI models, this is the product that was built for you.
- 18:22Logan: We have a way to, in this like chat UI experience, sort of play with the different
- 18:27Logan: capabilities of the model, feel what's possible. What is Gemini good at? What's it not good at?
- 18:33Logan: What are the different tools it has access to? But as you go into iStudio,
- 18:37Logan: you'll see something that looks like this.
- 18:38Logan: You know, we're highlighting a bunch of the new capabilities that we have right now.
- 18:42Logan: This URL context tool, which is really great for information retrieval,
- 18:45Logan: this native speech generation capability, which is really cool.
- 18:48Logan: Folks have used notebook lm and you want to build a
- 18:51Logan: notebook lm like experience um we have
- 18:54Logan: an api for for people who want to build something like that and
- 18:57Logan: we have this live audio to audio dialogue experience where
- 19:00Logan: you can share a screen with the model and talk to it and it can see the things
- 19:04Logan: that you see and engage with it of course we have our native image generation
- 19:08Logan: and editing model the old version 2.0 flash now the new version 2.5 flash um
- 19:13Logan: and lots of other stuff that's available as you sort of experience what these models are capable of.
- 19:18Logan: Um, so really this playground experience is one version. We have this chat prompt
- 19:22Logan: on the left-hand side. We have this stream.
- 19:25Logan: This is where you can talk to Gemini and sort of share your screen.
- 19:28Logan: And, um, actually you can like show it things on the webcam and be like, what's this?
- 19:33Logan: How do I use this thing? You can do this on mobile as well, which is really cool.
- 19:37Logan: We have this generative media experience where like, if you want to build things
- 19:40Logan: with, we have a music model, we have a VO, which is our video generation model.
- 19:45Logan: We have all the text to speech stuff, which is really cool.
- 19:48Logan: As I overwhelm people with so much stuff that you can do in AI Studio.
- 19:51Logan: The sort of key threat of all this is we built AI Studio to showcase a bunch of these capabilities.
- 19:57Logan: And everything you see in AI Studio has an underlying sort of API and developer experience.
- 20:02Logan: So if you want to build something like any of these experiences, all of this is possible.
- 20:07Logan: There's like no Google secret magic that's happening pretty much anywhere in AI Studio.
- 20:13Logan: It's all things that you could build as someone uh using a
- 20:16Logan: vibe coding product or you know by hand writing the
- 20:19Logan: code um you could build all these things and even more
- 20:22Logan: um and that is the perfect segue to this
- 20:24Logan: build tab where we're trying to help also you know actually help you get started
- 20:29Logan: building a bunch of stuff so you can use these templates that we have you can
- 20:32Logan: use a bunch of the suggestions you can look through our gallery of a different
- 20:36Logan: stuff um and we're really in this experience trying to help you build ai powered
- 20:41Logan: apps which we think is something that folks are really really excited about and,
- 20:45Logan: we'll have much more to share around all the ai app building stuff uh in the near future.
- 20:50Josh: Awesome thanks for the rundown so as i'm looking at this i'm wondering who do
- 20:54Josh: you think this is for what type of person should come to ai studio and tinker around here
- 20:58Logan: Yeah so i think you know historically and and so you'll see a little bit of
- 21:02Logan: this transition if you play around the product where there's some interesting
- 21:06Logan: edges we were originally focused on building for developers So it was built
- 21:10Logan: and there is like a part of the experience which like is tied to the Gemini
- 21:14Logan: API, which tends to be used mostly by developers.
- 21:16Logan: So if you go to dashboard, you can see all your API keys and check your usage
- 21:21Logan: and billing and things like that. By and large, though, I think the really cool
- 21:25Logan: opportunity of what's happening right now is this transition of like who is creating software.
- 21:31Logan: And this is, I think, principally enabled by Vibe Coding.
- 21:34Logan: And because of that, like we've recentered ourselves to be really focused on
- 21:38Logan: this AI builder persona, which is like people who want to build things using AI tools.
- 21:44Logan: Also, people who are trying to build AI experiences, we think is going to be
- 21:47Logan: the market that creates value for the world.
- 21:51Logan: So if you're excited about all the things that you're seeing,
- 21:53Logan: if you want to build things, AI Studio is very much like a builder first platform.
- 21:57Logan: If you're just looking for like a great everyday AI assistant product,
- 22:01Logan: you, you know, want to get help on coding questions or homework or life advice
- 22:08Logan: or all that type of stuff,
- 22:09Logan: the Gemini app is the right place for this. It's very much like a.
- 22:14Logan: DAU type of product where like you come back and it has memory and personalization
- 22:19Logan: and all this other stuff, um, which makes it really great as like an,
- 22:22Logan: uh, as a, as an assistant to help you in your life versus AI studio.
- 22:27Logan: The artifact is like, we help you create something and then you go put that
- 22:31Logan: thing into the world in some way.
- 22:32Logan: Um, and you don't necessarily need to come back and use it every day.
- 22:36Logan: You use it whenever you want to build something.
- 22:37Ejaaz: It's funny. Um, I'm dating myself a bit here,
- 22:40Ejaaz: but I remember when I first booted up a PC and I loaded up Microsoft Office
- 22:45Ejaaz: and I just had access to all these different wonderful applications that were
- 22:49Ejaaz: at the time super new or within one suite.
- 22:52Ejaaz: This kind of feels like that moment for AI.
- 22:55Ejaaz: And you might not take that as a compliment because it's a completely different
- 22:58Ejaaz: company, but it was what I built my childhood off of and my fascination with computers.
- 23:03Ejaaz: So I appreciate this and I love that it's this massively like cohesive experience.
- 23:08Ejaaz: But kind of zooming out, Logan, I was thinking a lot about Google AI and what
- 23:14Ejaaz: that means to me personally.
- 23:16Ejaaz: I have to say it's the only company that I think beyond an LLM.
- 23:22Ejaaz: And what I mean by that is when I think of Google AI, I don't just think of Gemini.
- 23:27Ejaaz: I think of the amazing image gen stuff that you have.
- 23:30Ejaaz: I think of the amazing video outputs that you guys have. I think of the text-to-voice
- 23:36Ejaaz: generation that you just demoed and all those kinds of things.
- 23:39Ejaaz: I remember seeing this advert that appeared on my timeline.
- 23:43Ejaaz: And I remember thinking, wow, this must be the new GTA. Then I was like,
- 23:47Ejaaz: no, no, that's Florida. That's Miami.
- 23:51Ejaaz: No, people are doing wild stuff. That's an alien. Hang on a second. This can't be real.
- 23:55Ejaaz: And then I learned that it was a Google VO3 generation of an advert for Kalshi,
- 24:00Ejaaz: which is like this, you know, prediction markets situation.
- 24:04Ejaaz: And I remember thinking, how on earth have we got to AI generated video that
- 24:09Ejaaz: is this high quality and this high fidelity?
- 24:12Ejaaz: I think in my mind, VO3 has kind of like killed the VFX studio.
- 24:17Ejaaz: It's kind of killed a lot of Hollywood production studios as well.
- 24:23Ejaaz: Give me a breakdown and insight into how you built or how you guys built VO3
- 24:28Ejaaz: and what that means for the future of movie video production and more
- 24:33Logan: Yeah that's a great question i think there's something really interesting along
- 24:37Logan: these threads and and not to not to push back on the notion that it's killing
- 24:42Logan: hollywood because i think i think there is like um,
- 24:45Logan: I think it's an interesting conversation. The way that I have seen this play
- 24:49Logan: out and the great example of this, that folks have seen Flow,
- 24:53Logan: which is our sort of like creative video tool.
- 24:58Logan: And if you're using VO and you want to sort of get the most out of VO,
- 25:01Logan: Flow is the tool to do that.
- 25:02Logan: If you see lots of like the creators who are building, you know,
- 25:06Logan: minute long videos using VO and it's like this really cohesive story and it
- 25:10Logan: has like a clear visual identity, similar to what you'd get from like a.
- 25:15Logan: Probably not the extent of a Hollywood
- 25:17Logan: production, but like somebody thoughtfully choreographing a film.
- 25:21Logan: Flow is the product to do that. And actually interesting, like Flow was built
- 25:25Logan: in conjunction with filmmakers.
- 25:28Logan: And I think that's actually like there is, and I feel this way about vibe coding as well.
- 25:32Logan: And it's this thought experiment that I'm always running through in my head,
- 25:36Logan: which is, yes, I think AI is like raising the bar forever or it's raising the
- 25:41Logan: floor for everyone. We're like, now everyone can create.
- 25:44Logan: What does that mean for people who have expertise?
- 25:49Logan: And I think in most cases, what it means is actually the value of your expertise
- 25:52Logan: continues to go up. And like, this is my personal bet.
- 25:55Logan: And I don't know how much this tracks to like everyone else's worldview.
- 25:58Logan: My personal bet is that expertise in the world where the floor is lifted for
- 26:02Logan: everyone across all these dimensions is actually more important because there was something about,
- 26:08Logan: and I think like video production is a great example for me because I would
- 26:12Logan: never have been able to make a video.
- 26:14Logan: Like it's not in the cards, like for my skillset, my creative ability,
- 26:18Logan: my financial ability, like I will never be able to make a video.
- 26:21Logan: I can make things with VO. Um, and now I'm like a little bit closer to imagining
- 26:26Logan: like, okay, if I'm serious about this, I need to go out and like actually engage with people.
- 26:32Logan: And I've like, sort of, it's like whetted my appetite in a way that I don't
- 26:36Logan: think I would. It was just like too far in a way.
- 26:38Logan: And I think software is another example where Vibe Coding, if you were to pull
- 26:43Logan: a random person off the street and you start talking to them about coding and
- 26:46Logan: seeing C++ and deploying stuff and all this, they're like, brain turns off, not interested.
- 26:53Logan: I don't want to learn to code. That's not cool. It's not fun. It sounds horrible.
- 26:57Logan: And then Vibe Coding rolls around and it's like, oh, wait, I can actually build
- 27:00Logan: stuff. And like, yeah, I don't really need to understand all of the details.
- 27:04Logan: But there's still a limit to what I can build and who is actually well positioned
- 27:09Logan: to help me take the next step.
- 27:11Logan: Like I, you know, vibe code something. I'm like, this is awesome.
- 27:14Logan: I share with my friends. They all love it.
- 27:17Logan: I want to, you know, go build a business around this thing that I vibe coded.
- 27:21Logan: There's still a software engineer that needs to help make that thing actually
- 27:24Logan: happen. So if anything, it's like it's increasing this.
- 27:28Logan: I mean, on the software side, there's this infinite demand for software,
- 27:31Logan: and it's increasing the total addressable market of like what software engineers
- 27:36Logan: need to help people build.
- 27:37Logan: I think there'll be something similar on the video side.
- 27:40Logan: You know, there will be downsides to AI technology in some ways.
- 27:43Logan: I think there is like as the technology shift happens, there is some amount
- 27:48Logan: of disruption that's taking place.
- 27:50Logan: And like someone's workflow is being disrupted. But I do think there's this
- 27:53Logan: really interesting thread to pull on, which is my hope is that it actually ends
- 27:57Logan: up creating more opportunity for the experts and the specialists.
- 28:01Ejaaz: So it sounds like you're not saying VFX Studio teams are going to be replaced by software engineers,
- 28:08Ejaaz: but rather that team in itself will become more adept at using these AI tools
- 28:14Ejaaz: and products to kind of enhance their own skill set beyond what it is today. Is that right?
- 28:19Logan: Yeah, yeah. And I think we've seen this already play out in some ways, which is interesting.
- 28:23Logan: I think code is a little bit wider distribution than perhaps the VFX.
- 28:29Logan: And it's VFX also in a space that I'm less familiar with personally.
- 28:33Logan: But yeah, I think this is likely what is going to play out if I had to guess and bet.
- 28:39Ejaaz: Can you help us understand how a product like VO3 gets used beyond just like
- 28:47Ejaaz: the major Hollywood productions?
- 28:49Ejaaz: Stuff, right? Because I've seen a bunch of these videos now.
- 28:52Ejaaz: And I'll be honest with you, Logan, it's scary how realistic this stuff is, right?
- 28:57Ejaaz: It's like from a high quality triple A game demo, all the way to something that
- 29:03Ejaaz: is shot like in an A24 film, you know, the scenes, the cuts, the changes.
- 29:09Ejaaz: I think it's awesome. I'm wondering whether that goes beyond entertainment in
- 29:13Ejaaz: any way. Do you have any thoughts or ideas there?
- 29:15Logan: Yeah, that is interesting. I think one of the ones that is like related to,
- 29:20Logan: it's sort of one skip away from video generation itself, which was Genie,
- 29:26Logan: which was our sort of world simulation work that was happening.
- 29:29Logan: I think if folks haven't seen this, go look up Genie 3 and you can see a video.
- 29:33Logan: It's mind blowing. It's like a fully playable game world simulation.
- 29:36Logan: You can like prompt on the go and this environment will change.
- 29:40Logan: You can control it on your keyboard similar to a game. I think that work translates
- 29:45Logan: actually really well to robotics, which is cool.
- 29:47Logan: So as you like one of the if folks aren't familiar with this,
- 29:51Logan: like one of the principal reasons we don't just have robots walking around everywhere.
- 29:55Logan: And the reason why we have LLMs that can actually do lots of useful stuff is
- 30:00Logan: it's this data problem, which is like there's lots of, you know,
- 30:04Logan: text data and other data that's like representative of the intelligence of humans
- 30:09Logan: and all this stuff that's available.
- 30:11Logan: There's actually not a lot of data that is useful for making robotics work.
- 30:14Logan: And I think VO could be part of, or like generally that sort of segment of video
- 30:20Logan: generation and this like physics understanding and all that other stuff,
- 30:24Logan: I think could be really helpful in actually making the long tail of robotics use cases work.
- 30:29Logan: Then I can finally have a robot that will fold my laundry so that I don't need
- 30:33Logan: to spend my time doing that.
- 30:34Logan: But that's my like outside of entertainment bet as far as like where that use
- 30:40Logan: case ends up creating value in the world.
- 30:42Ejaaz: With VO3, the goal is to enable humans to become a better version of themselves,
- 30:48Ejaaz: a 10x, 100x better version of themselves using these different tools.
- 30:51Ejaaz: So in the example of a VFX studio, you can now kind of like create much better movies.
- 30:56Ejaaz: How does that apply for Genie 3 exactly, right?
- 30:59Ejaaz: You gave the example of like being able to create simulated environments,
- 31:03Ejaaz: but that's to train these robots. That's to train these models.
- 31:07Ejaaz: What about us? What about the flesh humans that are out there?
- 31:10Ejaaz: Can you give us some examples about where this might be applied or used?
- 31:14Logan: Yeah, that's a good example. I mean, the robot answer is like the robots will
- 31:19Logan: be there to help us, which is nice.
- 31:20Logan: So hopefully there's a bunch of stuff that you don't want to do that you'll
- 31:25Logan: be able to get your robot to do.
- 31:27Logan: Or there's like industries that are like dangerous for humans to operate in
- 31:31Logan: where it's like if you can sort of do that simulation without needing to collect
- 31:35Logan: a bunch of human data to do those things, I could see that being super valuable.
- 31:38Logan: I think my initial reaction to the Genie use case, like I could see lots of,
- 31:46Logan: actually, the two that come to mind is like one entertainment I think will be cool.
- 31:51Logan: Humans want to be entertained. It's a story as all this time.
- 31:54Logan: I think there will be some entertainment value of a product experience like Genie.
- 31:59Logan: Um, I think the other one is actually back to a bunch of use cases where you'd
- 32:05Logan: actually want robotics to be able to do some of that work that don't yet, uh,
- 32:10Logan: the robot product experience, like isn't actually there.
- 32:14Logan: Um, this could be things like, you know, mining or like heavy industries,
- 32:19Logan: things like that, where like, there's actually like a safety aspect of like,
- 32:22Logan: how can you do these like realistic simulation training experiences, um,
- 32:27Logan: in order to make sure that like you're You don't have to like physically put
- 32:30Logan: yourself in harm's way in order to like understand the bounds or like the failure cases,
- 32:35Logan: like disaster recovery, things like that, where it would be you don't want to
- 32:41Logan: have to show up at a hurricane the first time to like really understand what
- 32:45Logan: the environment could be like.
- 32:47Logan: And like being able to do those types of simulations is interesting and building
- 32:51Logan: software deterministically to solve that problem would actually be really difficult
- 32:55Logan: and expensive and like probably isn't a large market that lots of companies are going to go after.
- 33:01Logan: But if you have this model that has really great world knowledge,
- 33:03Logan: you can throw all these random variables at it and like sort of do that type
- 33:07Logan: of like training and simulation.
- 33:08Logan: So yeah, it's perhaps an interesting use case.
- 33:12Logan: I don't know if there's actually a plan to use it for things like that,
- 33:15Logan: But those are things that come to mind.
- 33:18Josh: This is something I've been dying to ask you about because this is something
- 33:21Josh: that I've been fascinated by.
- 33:22Josh: When I watched the Genie 3 demo for the first time, it just kind of shattered
- 33:25Josh: my perception of where we were at because you see it work.
- 33:30Josh: And I saw this great demo where someone was painting the wall.
- 33:32Josh: We actually filmed an entire episode about this and it retained all of the information.
- 33:36Josh: And one theme, as I'm hearing you describe these things, as I'm hearing you
- 33:39Josh: describe VO3, Genie 3, you are building this deep understanding of the physical world.
- 33:44Josh: And I can't help but notice this trend like you are just starting
- 33:47Josh: to understand the world more and more and I could see this when
- 33:50Josh: it comes to making games as an example where like a lot
- 33:53Josh: of people were using genie 3 to just make these like not necessarily
- 33:56Josh: games but virtual worlds that you can walk around and interact with and I'm
- 33:59Josh: wondering if you could just kind of share the long-term reasoning why because
- 34:02Josh: clearly there's a reason there's a lot of value to it is it from being able
- 34:06Josh: to create maybe artificial data for robots if you can emulate the physical world
- 34:09Josh: you can create data to train these robots is it because it creates great experiences
- 34:12Josh: like perhaps we'll AAA design studios using Genie 5 to make AAA games like Grand Theft Auto.
- 34:18Josh: I'm curious the reasoning behind
- 34:19Josh: this like urge to understand the physical world and emulate it even.
- 34:24Logan: I had a conversation with Demis about this who's our CEO at DeepMind and someone
- 34:30Logan: who's been pushing on this for a long time.
- 34:32Logan: I think a lot of this goes back to like there's two dimensions.
- 34:35Logan: It goes back to like the original ethos of like why DeepMind was created and
- 34:39Logan: a bunch of the work the initial work that was happening in DeepMind around reinforcement learning.
- 34:44Logan: If folks haven't seen this, one of the challenges of, again,
- 34:48Logan: making AI work is that you need this flywheel of continuing to iterate and you
- 34:55Logan: need a reward function, which is what is the actual outcome that you're trying to achieve?
- 35:03Logan: And the thing that's interesting about these simulated environments is it's
- 35:07Logan: really easy to have a constrained environment.
- 35:10Logan: World, and it's really easy to also, or not maybe really easy,
- 35:15Logan: is overly ambitious. It's possible to define a simple reward function and then
- 35:21Logan: actually infinitely scale this up.
- 35:23Logan: And the opposite example of this, if folks have saw there was some work a very
- 35:29Logan: long time ago, and this is in the AI weeds, but there was this hand,
- 35:33Logan: this physical hand that could like robotic hand that could manipulate a Rubik's cube.
- 35:39Logan: And they were using AI to like help try to solve this Rubik's cube.
- 35:43Logan: And the, the, again, the analogy of why this, of why Genie and some of this
- 35:47Logan: work is so interesting is if you were to go and try to like,
- 35:50Logan: Hey, we need all the data to go and try to make this little hand,
- 35:54Logan: physical robotic hand, be able to do this.
- 35:57Logan: It's actually really challenging to scale that up. You need to go and build a bunch of hands.
- 36:01Logan: You need to like, what happens when the rubik's cube drops you need
- 36:04Logan: to have some system to like go and pick it back up and you just like go
- 36:07Logan: through the long tail of this stuff the hand probably can't run
- 36:10Logan: 24 hours a day like there's all these challenges with getting um the the like
- 36:15Logan: data in that environment to scale up um and these virtual environments don't
- 36:20Logan: have this problem which is if you can emulate and like self-driving cars is
- 36:24Logan: another example of this like again for folks who aren't familiar lots of you You know,
- 36:28Logan: there's lots of real world data that's involved in self-driving cars.
- 36:31Logan: There's also lots of simulated environments where they've built simulations of the world.
- 36:35Logan: And this is how they can get like a thousand X scale up of this like data understanding
- 36:41Logan: is by having these simulated environments.
- 36:44Logan: Robotics will be exactly the same. If you want robotics to work,
- 36:47Logan: it's almost 100% true that you're going to have to have these simulated environments
- 36:51Logan: where the robot can fall down the stairs a thousand times.
- 36:56Logan: And that's okay because it's a simulated environment and it's not actually going
- 36:59Logan: to fall down your stairs.
- 37:01Logan: So I think Genie is, there is definitely like an entertainment aspect to it.
- 37:05Logan: I think it's more so going to be useful for this like simulated environment
- 37:10Logan: to help us not have to do things in the real world and, but still have like
- 37:15Logan: a really good proxy of what will happen in the real world when we do them.
- 37:19Ejaaz: That's pretty funny. I spent the weekend watching the World Robot Olympics and
- 37:25Ejaaz: there was some very real fails and crashes of these robots, which is pretty funny.
- 37:32Ejaaz: Okay, so when I think of Genie, I think that it blows my mind because I still
- 37:38Ejaaz: can't get my head around how it predicts what I'm going to look at.
- 37:42Ejaaz: I remember seeing this demo of someone just taking a simple video of them walking and,
- 37:48Ejaaz: you know, it was like a rainy day on a gravel path and they stuck that into
- 37:53Ejaaz: Genie 3 and they could look down and see their reflection in the puddle.
- 37:58Ejaaz: So the physics was astoundingly accurate and astute.
- 38:02Ejaaz: Can you give us a basic breakdown of how this works?
- 38:05Ejaaz: Is this like a real engine, game engine, like happening in the background?
- 38:09Ejaaz: Or is there something more deeper happening? Like help us understand.
- 38:13Logan: My intuition, and we can gut check this with folks on the research side to make
- 38:17Logan: sure that I'm not, I'm not fabricating my intuition.
- 38:21Logan: But if folks have an intuition as far as like how next token prediction works,
- 38:25Logan: which is at some given, like if you're looking through a sentence of text,
- 38:29Logan: for each word in that sentence, there's a
- 38:32Logan: distribution uh between like zero
- 38:35Logan: and one basically of like how likely that
- 38:38Logan: word was to be the next word in the sequence um and
- 38:42Logan: if you look the and if you like look through this is like the basic
- 38:45Logan: principle of llms um this is why you get like the you know if you're to ask
- 38:49Logan: the same question multiple times um the the llm will inherently perhaps give
- 38:55Logan: you a different answer And that's why like small changes in the inputs to LLMs
- 38:59Logan: actually change this because like, again, it's this distribution.
- 39:03Logan: So like if you make one letter difference, it perhaps like puts you on a like
- 39:08Logan: a branching trajectory that looks very different than what the original output
- 39:14Logan: that you got from the model.
- 39:16Logan: Similar similar like rough approximation of this just like much more computationally
- 39:23Logan: difficult and i think they use a bunch of um architectural differences that
- 39:27Logan: sort of it's not truly next token prediction that's happening for the sort.
- 39:30Ejaaz: Of like pixels colors bunch of other things yeah
- 39:33Logan: Exactly yeah so it's like you can like roughly map
- 39:36Logan: the mental model of like as the as a model
- 39:38Logan: looks down or as like the figure looks down
- 39:41Logan: in some in some environment like again it has
- 39:44Logan: all this like context of the state of the world but then it also knows like
- 39:49Logan: what are the pixels that are preceding it etc etc it like loosely is doing this
- 39:54Logan: like next next pixel prediction you could you could sort of approximate with
- 39:58Logan: um that's happening at the at the genie level which is which is an interesting way to think about it.
- 40:04Josh: So ijaz one of the things you were mentioning was that um it's happening much
- 40:07Josh: faster right and it's happening presumably much cheaper because now i heard this crazy stat.
- 40:11Josh: You're at like 500, hundreds of trillions of tokens per month that is being
- 40:14Josh: pushed out by Gemini. It's unbelievable.
- 40:16Josh: And I want to get into the kind of infrastructure that enables this because
- 40:20Josh: Gemini is feeling faster, but it's also feeling better. And it's also getting cheaper.
- 40:26Josh: And behind you earlier in the show, you mentioned you have a TPU.
- 40:30Josh: I understand TPUs are part of this solution. And I want you to kind of just
- 40:34Josh: walk us through how this is happening.
- 40:36Josh: How are we getting these quality and improvements across the board?
- 40:39Josh: And what type of hardware or software is enabling that to happen.
- 40:42Logan: I think like one, you have to give credit to like all of these infrastructure
- 40:46Logan: teams across Google that are making this happen.
- 40:48Logan: If you think, and I think about this a lot, like what is Google's differentiated advantage?
- 40:54Logan: What does our expertise lend us well to do in the ecosystem?
- 40:58Logan: What are the things we shouldn't do because of that? What are the things we
- 41:00Logan: should do because of that? It's something I think about as somebody who builds products.
- 41:04Logan: One of the things that I always come back to is our infrastructure.
- 41:08Logan: And like the thing Google has been able to do time and time again.
- 41:12Logan: Scale up multiple products to billions
- 41:14Logan: of users, have them work with high reliability, et cetera, et cetera.
- 41:19Logan: And that's like a uniquely difficult problem. It's a even more difficult problem
- 41:24Logan: to do in the age of AI where like the software is not deterministic.
- 41:28Logan: The sort of compute footprint required to do these things is really difficult.
- 41:33Logan: The models are a little bit tricky and finicky to work with sometimes.
- 41:37Logan: So again, like our infrastructure teams have done an incredible job making that scale up.
- 41:42Logan: I think the stat was IO 2024, we were doing roughly 50 trillion tokens a month.
- 41:49Logan: IO 2025, I think it was like 480 trillion tokens a month, if I remember correctly.
- 41:56Logan: And just a month or two later, and this was in the conversation I had with Demis,
- 42:01Logan: we crossed a quadrillion tokens, which comes after a trillion,
- 42:06Logan: if you're not haven't thought about numbers higher than a trillion before
- 42:09Logan: it's what comes after a trillion um and there's
- 42:12Logan: no slowdown in sight and like i think this is just a great
- 42:15Logan: reminder of like um so many
- 42:17Logan: of these ai like markets and
- 42:21Logan: product ecosystems is still so early and there's
- 42:24Logan: this massive expansion i think about in my own life like how
- 42:27Logan: much ai do i really have in my life helping me like not
- 42:30Logan: really that much on the margin it's like you know maybe
- 42:33Logan: tens of millions of tokens a
- 42:35Logan: month maximum and like you think
- 42:38Logan: about a future where there's like billions of tokens being spent on a monthly
- 42:42Logan: basis in order to help you in whatever you're doing in your professional life
- 42:45Logan: and your work and your personal life whatever it is there's we're still so early
- 42:50Logan: and tpus are a core part of that because it allows us to like um control every
- 42:56Logan: layer of the hardware and software.
- 42:59Logan: Delivery all the way to the actual like silicon that the model is running on
- 43:04Logan: and we can do a bunch of optimizations and customizations,
- 43:08Logan: other people can't do because they don't actually control the hardware itself
- 43:11Logan: and there's some good examples of the things that this enables
- 43:14Logan: one of them is um you know we've been at the Pareto
- 43:17Logan: frontier from a cost performance perspective for
- 43:20Logan: a very long time and again if folks aren't familiar the Pareto frontier is this
- 43:23Logan: like trade-off of cost and intelligence and you want to be on the highest intelligence
- 43:28Logan: lowest cost um and we've been sitting on that for for you know basically the
- 43:33Logan: entirety of the Gemini life cycle um so far which is really important so people
- 43:37Logan: get a ton of value from the Gemini models.
- 43:40Logan: Another example of this is long context. Again, if folks are familiar,
- 43:44Logan: there's a limit on like how many tokens you can pass to a model at a given time.
- 43:49Logan: Gemini's had a million or 2 million token context windows since the initial
- 43:54Logan: launch of Gemini, which has been awesome.
- 43:56Logan: And there's a bunch of research showing we could scale that all the way up to
- 43:59Logan: 10 million if we wanted to.
- 44:01Logan: And that is like a core infrastructure enabled thing.
- 44:05Logan: Like research, There's a lot of like really important research to make that
- 44:08Logan: work and make that possible.
- 44:10Logan: But it's also really difficult on the infrastructure side. And you have to be
- 44:13Logan: willing to do that work and pay that price.
- 44:16Logan: And it's a beautiful outcome for us because we have the infrastructure teams
- 44:19Logan: that have the expertise to do this.
- 44:21Josh: Okay, Logan, one quadrillion tokens. That's a big number.
- 44:25Josh: We need to talk about this for a little bit because that is an outrageously,
- 44:28Josh: mind-bendingly big number.
- 44:30Josh: And when I hear you say that number, I think I'm reminded of Jevin's Paradox
- 44:34Josh: for people who don't know. it's increased technological efficiency in using
- 44:37Josh: a resource which can lead to higher total consumption of that resource.
- 44:40Josh: So clearly with these cool new TPUs, this vertically integrated stack you've
- 44:43Josh: built, you are able to generate tokens much more cheaply and produce a lot more
- 44:47Josh: of them. Hence the one quadrillion tokens.
- 44:49Josh: Do you see this trend continuing? Is there going to be a continued need to just
- 44:53Josh: produce more tokens or will it eventually be a battle to produce smarter tokens?
- 44:58Josh: I guess the question I'm asking is the quality of the token more important than
- 45:03Josh: the amount of the tokens?
- 45:04Josh: And do you see a limit in which the quantity of the tokens starts to like kind
- 45:09Josh: of go off of a cliff in terms of how valuable it is?
- 45:12Logan: Yeah, I could buy that story. And some of this is and it's something that's
- 45:17Logan: actually super top of mind for our teams on the like Gemini model side is around
- 45:21Logan: this whole idea of like thinking efficiency,
- 45:23Logan: which is like ideally you want
- 45:25Logan: to get to the best answer using the limited amount of thoughts possible.
- 45:28Logan: Same thing with humans like ideally like you're the example
- 45:32Logan: of like you're taking a test you want to as you know
- 45:34Logan: the shortest number of mental hops possible to get you to the answer.
- 45:37Logan: Of whatever the question was is ideally what you want you don't want
- 45:40Logan: to have to just like think for an hour to answer one question
- 45:43Logan: um and there's yeah there's a bunch
- 45:46Logan: of odd parallels in that world to like models and
- 45:49Logan: and humans doing this approach um so i
- 45:52Logan: do think thinking efficiency is top of mind you don't want to just
- 45:54Logan: like use tokens for the sake of tokens um i
- 45:58Logan: think even if we were to like 10x reduce the
- 46:01Logan: number of tokens required which would be like awesome and
- 46:04Logan: would be like a great innovation the models are like much more
- 46:07Logan: token efficient i do think there's like a um a
- 46:11Logan: pretty low ceiling to how far that will be able to go
- 46:14Logan: specifically because of this like next
- 46:17Logan: token prediction paradigm of like how the models
- 46:21Logan: actually approach solving problems using using
- 46:25Logan: like the token as a unit so it's
- 46:28Logan: not clear to me that you'll be able to just like you know a thousand x reduce
- 46:32Logan: the amount of tokens required to solve a problem i think it probably looks much
- 46:35Logan: more like 10x or something like that and then the there'll be a 10x reduction
- 46:39Logan: in the number of tokens required to solve a problem and there'll be a 10 000
- 46:42Logan: x increase in the total amount of ai and and sort of token consumption in the world.
- 46:47Logan: So I think you probably, even if we made that reduction happen,
- 46:51Logan: I think the graph still looks like it's going up and to the right for the most part.
- 46:55Josh: It still keeps going. There is no wall. We have virtual data to train models
- 46:59Josh: on. We have tons of new tokens coming into play.
- 47:02Josh: There's another question I wanted to ask, which is just a personal question
- 47:06Josh: for you, which is a feature that, because I find when a lot of people leave
- 47:10Josh: comments on the show and they talk about their experience with AI,
- 47:13Josh: a lot of them are just using like ChatGPT on their app or they have Grok on their phone.
- 47:17Josh: And I think Gemini kind of has some underrated features that don't quite get enough attention.
- 47:23Josh: So what I'd like for you to do is maybe just highlight one or two of the features
- 47:26Josh: you shipped recently that you think is criminally underrated.
- 47:29Josh: What should people try out that you think not enough people are using?
- 47:32Logan: I think the one that continues to surprise me the most is deep research.
- 47:37Logan: I think deep research is just like a, is the North Star for building an AI product experience.
- 47:42Logan: And if folks aren't familiar with this, so you can show up with,
- 47:45Logan: yeah, it's so, you can show up with like a pretty ill-defined question that's
- 47:50Logan: like very open and vague.
- 47:51Logan: And the model will traverse essentially across the internet hundreds or thousands
- 47:58Logan: of different web pages, try to accumulate enough context and then come back to you with initially,
- 48:05Logan: basically like a research report, could be like a 40 page report in some cases that I've seen.
- 48:10Logan: You might hear a 40 page report and say, that's not very useful to me because
- 48:13Logan: I'm not going to read 40 pages.
- 48:15Logan: And I'd say you and me are exactly the same because I'm not reading 40 pages either.
- 48:19Logan: There's a beautiful feature, again, if you've used Notebook LM,
- 48:22Logan: this audio overviews feature.
- 48:25Logan: The same thing actually exists inside of the Gemini app with deep research,
- 48:29Logan: which you can just press that button and then get like a, you know,
- 48:32Logan: 10, 15 minute podcast that sort of goes through and explains all the different
- 48:36Logan: research that's happened.
- 48:37Logan: You can, you know, listen to that on your commute or something like that or
- 48:40Logan: on a walk and not need to read 40 pages, which is awesome.
- 48:43Logan: The part of this that makes it such an interesting experience to me is,
- 48:47Logan: I don't know if other people have felt this before, but most AI products back
- 48:51Logan: to that, Josh, that like blank slate problem or that like empty chat box problem.
- 48:57Logan: You, you as the user of the product have to put in so much work in order to get useful stuff.
- 49:03Logan: I talk to people all the time who are like, yeah, I use these models and like,
- 49:06Logan: they're just not useful for me. And like, actually what's happening behind the
- 49:09Logan: scenes is the models are super capable.
- 49:11Logan: They're really useful. It just requires that you give the models enough context.
- 49:15Logan: And I think deep research, there's this new emerging like prompt engineering
- 49:19Logan: 2.0 is this context engineering problem where it's like, how do you get in the
- 49:24Logan: right information so that the model can make a decision on behalf of the user?
- 49:28Logan: And I think deep research is this really nice balance of going and doing this
- 49:33Logan: context engineering for you,
- 49:34Logan: bringing all that context into the window of the model, and then
- 49:37Logan: being able to answer what your original question was and principally showing
- 49:42Logan: you this like proof of work up front I think about this proof of work concept
- 49:46Logan: in AI all the time which is I have so much more trust in deep research because
- 49:51Logan: as soon as I kick off that query it's like boom it's already at like 50 web
- 49:55Logan: pages I'm like great because.
- 49:57Logan: I was never going to visit 50 webpages. Like there's pretty much nothing that I'm researching.
- 50:02Logan: I could be going and buying a car and I'm going to go and look at less than
- 50:05Logan: 50 webpages for that thing or a house.
- 50:07Logan: I'm looking at less than 50 webpages. Like I'm just, it's not in the car.
- 50:11Logan: At least this is maybe personal to me and other people are doing more research. I don't know.
- 50:15Logan: But so automatically I'm like in awe with how much more work this thing is doing.
- 50:20Logan: And I think there's, this is, again, this is the North Star from an AI product
- 50:24Logan: experience standpoint. and there's so few products that have like made that
- 50:29Logan: experience work and just every time I go back to deep research I'm reminded
- 50:33Logan: of this and that team uh crushed it so.
- 50:35Ejaaz: And it's not just deep research from a LLM context that is so fascinating about
- 50:42Ejaaz: Google AI um you guys have created some of the most fascinating tools to advance
- 50:48Ejaaz: science and I don't think you guys get enough flowers for what you guys have built.
- 50:54Ejaaz: Some of my favorites, AlphaFold 3 is crazy.
- 50:58Ejaaz: So, you know, this is this model
- 51:00Ejaaz: that can predict what certain molecular structures are going to look like.
- 51:04Ejaaz: And this could be applied to so many different industries, the most obvious
- 51:08Ejaaz: being drug design, creating cheaper,
- 51:10Ejaaz: more effective, curable drugs for a variety of different diseases.
- 51:15Ejaaz: And then I was thinking about that random model that you guys launched,
- 51:20Ejaaz: where apparently we could translate what dolphins were saying to us and vice versa um
- 51:26Ejaaz: Kind of stepping back from all of these examples, can you help me understand
- 51:30Ejaaz: what is Google's obsession with AI and science and why you think it's such an
- 51:35Ejaaz: important area to focus on?
- 51:36Ejaaz: Are we at a point now where we can advance science to infinity or where are we right now?
- 51:42Ejaaz: Are we at our chat GPT moment or do we have more to go?
- 51:45Logan: I'll start with a couple of cheeky answers, which Demis, who is the only foundation
- 51:51Logan: model lab CEO to have a Nobel prize, uh, in the science domain,
- 51:56Logan: which is, uh, for him, for him, chemistry, um,
- 51:59Logan: had this comment, which is actually really true.
- 52:02Logan: There's lots of people talking about this, like impact of AI on science and humanity.
- 52:07Logan: Um, and there's very few, uh, if not only one, um, being deep mind research
- 52:13Logan: lab, that's like actually doing the science work.
- 52:16Logan: And I think it's this like great example of like deep mind and just being in
- 52:20Logan: the like culture and DNA, DNA of like Demis is a scientist,
- 52:23Logan: all of these folks around, um, around DeepMind are scientists and they like
- 52:27Logan: want to push the science and, and push what's possible in this,
- 52:31Logan: this future of discovery,
- 52:32Logan: um, using our models.
- 52:34Logan: And I was in London a couple of weeks ago meeting with Pushmid who leads our
- 52:38Logan: science team and hearing about sort of like the breadth of the science that's happening.
- 52:43Logan: Um, and how like Dolphin Gemma is like a great, like kind of like funny example,
- 52:48Logan: cause it's, it's not super applicable in a lot of cases, but it's interesting
- 52:51Logan: to think about, um, alpha fold, like if, if folks haven't, um.
- 52:57Logan: Watched the movie, the thinking game, it's about sort of the early days of,
- 53:00Logan: of, uh, Google deep mind.
- 53:02Logan: And, um, they're talking about like folding proteins and why this is such an interesting space.
- 53:09Logan: And I'm not a, not a scientist, um, but the, to like hit on the point really
- 53:15Logan: quickly of like why Alpha Fold is so interesting. The the
- 53:18Logan: historical like context is humans to fold
- 53:22Logan: a single protein would take many humans millions
- 53:25Logan: of dollars and it would take on the
- 53:28Logan: order of like five years in order to fold a single protein the original impetus
- 53:33Logan: and like why demas won the nobel piece the nobel prize for this in chemistry
- 53:36Logan: was because deep mind was able to figure out using uh reinforcement learning
- 53:42Logan: and other techniques They folded every protein in the known universe,
- 53:46Logan: millions of proteins, released them publicly,
- 53:49Logan: made them available to everyone.
- 53:51Logan: And it was like, you know, dramatically accelerated the advancement of like
- 53:58Logan: human medicine and a bunch of other domains and disciplines.
- 54:01Logan: And now actually with isomorphic labs, which is part of DeepMind,
- 54:04Logan: like actually pursuing some of the breakthroughs that they found and like actually
- 54:08Logan: doing drug discovery and things like that.
- 54:10Logan: So like overnight, you see that hundreds of thousands of human years and hundreds
- 54:16Logan: of millions of dollars of like research and development costs saved through a single innovation.
- 54:22Logan: And I think we're going to continue to see that like acceleration of new stuff happening.
- 54:26Logan: A recent example of this, Alpha Evolve,
- 54:30Logan: which was our sort of like geospatial model that came out and being able to
- 54:37Logan: like fuse together all of this, the Google Earth engine with AI and this understanding of the world.
- 54:44Logan: Like it's just so much cool science and so much is possible when you sort of
- 54:49Logan: layer on the AI capability in all these disciplines. So I think to answer the
- 54:54Logan: question, I think we're going to see this acceleration of science progress.
- 54:58Logan: I think DeepMind is going to continue to be at the forefront of this,
- 55:00Logan: which is really exciting.
- 55:02Logan: And the cool thing for even for people who aren't in science is all of that
- 55:07Logan: innovation and like the research breakthroughs that happen, it feeds back to
- 55:11Logan: the mainline Gemini model.
- 55:13Logan: Like we had a bunch of research work about doing proofs for math.
- 55:17Logan: And it's like, oh, that's not very interesting at the face value. But like that research.
- 55:22Logan: Fuels back into the mainline gemini model it makes
- 55:25Logan: it better at reasoning it makes it better able to like understand these like
- 55:29Logan: really long and difficult problems um which then benefits like every like agent
- 55:33Logan: use case that exists uh because the models are better at reasoning through all
- 55:37Logan: these like difficult problem domains so there is this like really cool research to reality,
- 55:43Logan: science to like practical impact flywheel that happens at deep mind as.
- 55:47Ejaaz: A former biologist this warms my heart. This is amazing to see this get applied at such scale.
- 55:53Ejaaz: Okay, we can't talk about Google AI without talking about search.
- 55:58Ejaaz: This is your bread and butter, right?
- 56:00Ejaaz: However, I've personally noticed a trend shift in my habits.
- 56:05Ejaaz: I've used a computer for decades now, and I've always used Google search to
- 56:10Ejaaz: find things, Google Chrome, whatever it might be.
- 56:12Ejaaz: But I've now started to cheat on this feature.
- 56:16Ejaaz: I have started using LLMs directly to do all my searching for me,
- 56:20Ejaaz: to get all my sources for me.
- 56:22Ejaaz: And you've got to be thinking about this slogan, right? Is this eating the search business?
- 56:27Ejaaz: Is this aiding the search business? Or are we creating a whole different form
- 56:31Ejaaz: factor here? What are your thoughts?
- 56:33Logan: There's an interesting form factor discussion. I think on one hand, the AI...
- 56:38Logan: Sort of answer market is definitely distinctly different, it feels like,
- 56:42Logan: than the search market to a certain degree.
- 56:44Logan: Like, I think we've seen lots of AI products reach hundreds of millions of users
- 56:48Logan: and, you know, search continues to be a great business and there's billions of people using it and.
- 56:52Ejaaz: All that stuff.
- 56:53Logan: There's also this interesting question, which is like, what's the obligation
- 56:56Logan: of Google in this moment of this platform shift and all this innovation that's happening?
- 57:02Logan: And I, You know, as somebody who doesn't work on search, but,
- 57:06Logan: you know, is a fan of all the work that's happening inside of Google and has
- 57:11Logan: empathy for folks building these products, it is really interesting.
- 57:14Logan: And like my perspective has always been that search actually has this,
- 57:18Logan: you know, as the front door to the internet has this stewardship position that
- 57:22Logan: makes it so that they actually can't disrupt themselves for the right reasons
- 57:27Logan: at the same pace that that sort of,
- 57:29Logan: you know, small players in the market are able to do.
- 57:33Logan: And my assertion has always been that like, actually, this is the best thing
- 57:37Logan: for the world, the best thing for the world and for the Internet and for this
- 57:40Logan: entire economy that that Google has enabled through the Internet and bringing
- 57:45Logan: people to websites and all this stuff doesn't benefit by like,
- 57:48Logan: you know, day one of the LLM revolution happening.
- 57:52Logan: All of a sudden it's like a fully llm
- 57:55Logan: powered search product and like feels and looks completely different
- 57:58Logan: not only i think whether that throw you know users who
- 58:02Logan: are still trying to figure out like how do i use this technology what is the
- 58:05Logan: way that i should be engaging with it um what are the things that it works well
- 58:09Logan: for and it doesn't work for not only to throw those people into a bad um perspective
- 58:13Logan: from like a user uh from a user journey but i think it also has impacts on like
- 58:18Logan: people who rely on Google from a business perspective.
- 58:21Logan: So I think you've seen this sort of like gradual transition and like lots of
- 58:26Logan: shots on goal and lots of experiments happening on the search side.
- 58:30Logan: And I think we're now getting to the place where like they have confidence that
- 58:33Logan: they could do this in a way that is going to be super positive for the ecosystem
- 58:37Logan: and is going to create lots of value for people who are going and using these products.
- 58:43Logan: Like the understanding of AI technology has increased the adoption
- 58:47Logan: and the models have gotten better and hallucinations have gone down and all
- 58:51Logan: this stuff and I think there'll be also some like uniquely search things that
- 58:57Logan: like only search can do and I've spent a bunch of time with folks on the search
- 59:02Logan: team like Robbie Stein as an example who leads all the AI stuff in search and,
- 59:06Logan: There's all of this infrastructure that search has built, which as you think
- 59:11Logan: about this age of AI, where the ability to generate content,
- 59:16Logan: which actually like looks somewhat plausible.
- 59:19Logan: Has basically gone to zero. Like it's very easy to do that.
- 59:23Logan: Great search is actually more, it's like this premium is like more important than ever.
- 59:27Logan: There's going to be a million X or a thousand X or whatever than X number of
- 59:32Logan: like growth and content on the internet.
- 59:34Logan: How do you actually get people to
- 59:37Logan: the most relevant content from people who have authority who
- 59:40Logan: have you know expertise and all this stuff it's a
- 59:43Logan: really difficult problem and it's like it is the problem of
- 59:45Logan: the decade that like search has been solving for the
- 59:48Logan: last 20 years and is now a more important problem than ever um so i'm i've never
- 59:53Logan: been more excited for for the search team and like i think they've never had
- 59:57Logan: a bigger challenge ahead of them as they try to like figure out how to make
- 1:00:00Logan: you know these internet scale systems that they build continue to scale up to
- 1:00:04Logan: solve this next generation of problems,
- 1:00:06Logan: while also becoming this frontier AI product experience where billions of people
- 1:00:11Logan: are experiencing AI for the first time in a different way than they've done.
- 1:00:15Logan: There's so many interesting use cases too,
- 1:00:19Logan: even around like image search is a great example of this like new sort of,
- 1:00:26Logan: it's like one of the fastest growing ways in which people are using search now
- 1:00:29Logan: is showing up with an image and asking questions about it.
- 1:00:32Logan: And just like the way people had just traditionally used search is already changed.
- 1:00:38Logan: It's like different than it was five years ago or even two years ago.
- 1:00:42Logan: And I think we're gonna continue to see that happen. I think search as the product
- 1:00:46Logan: you see today will evolve to have things like multi-line text input fields as
- 1:00:52Logan: sort of user questions change and all that stuff.
- 1:00:55Logan: So there's so much cool stuff on the horizon for search that I'm really excited.
- 1:01:00Josh: Yeah, as I'm hearing you describe all of these cool new things,
- 1:01:03Josh: particularly funneling into a single model, like the science breakthroughs are unbelievable.
- 1:01:08Josh: And I think that's what gets me personally really excited, like Ejaz,
- 1:01:10Josh: is this is actually going to help people.
- 1:01:13Josh: Like this is going to make a difference in people's lives. Right now,
- 1:01:15Josh: it's a productive thing. It's a fun thing. It's a creative thing.
- 1:01:17Josh: There's a lot of tools. But then there's also the science part and a lot of
- 1:01:20Josh: this all funneling down to one amazing model.
- 1:01:22Josh: I think it leaves us in a really exciting place to wrap up this conversation.
- 1:01:25Josh: So Logan, thank you so much for coming and sharing all of this,
- 1:01:28Josh: sharing the news about the new model, sharing all of the updates and progress
- 1:01:31Josh: that you're making everywhere else. I really enjoyed the conversation.
- 1:01:34Josh: For you, you also have a podcast called Around the Problems.
- 1:01:38Josh: Is there anything you want to leave listeners with to go check it out or to
- 1:01:41Josh: check out the new AI studio or the new AI model?
- 1:01:44Josh: Let us know what you have interesting going on in your life.
- 1:01:46Logan: I love seeing feedback about AI studio. So if you have things that don't work
- 1:01:50Logan: that you wish worked, even for both of you, please send them to me.
- 1:01:53Logan: Would love to make things better. for the new model as well.
- 1:01:56Logan: Like if there's, I think this is like still, this is still early days of what
- 1:02:01Logan: this model is going to be capable of.
- 1:02:02Logan: So if folks have feedback on like edge cases or use cases that don't work well,
- 1:02:07Logan: please reach out to our team.
- 1:02:09Logan: Send us examples on Axe or Twitter or the like.
- 1:02:12Logan: Would love to help make some of those use cases come to life.
- 1:02:16Logan: And I appreciate both of you for all the thoughtful questions and for the conversation.
- 1:02:20Logan: This was a ton of fun. We got to do it again sometime.
- 1:02:23Josh: Awesome. Yeah, we'd love to. Anytime. time please come and join us we really
- 1:02:26Josh: enjoyed the conversation so thank you so much for watching for the people who
- 1:02:29Josh: enjoyed please don't forget to uh to like share it with your friends and do
- 1:02:31Josh: all the good things and we'll be back again for another episode soon thank you so much
- 1:02:39Josh: i have a fun little bonus for those of you still listening all the way to the
- 1:02:42Josh: end the real fans when we were first going to record with logan we actually
- 1:02:46Josh: had no idea that he would break the exclusive news of nano banana on our show
- 1:02:49Josh: it was super cool so we wanted to kind of restructure the episode to prioritize that at the front,
- 1:02:53Josh: we did record a separate intro where I said, hey, Google makes some really good stuff.
- 1:02:58Josh: In fact, you guys have an 80 something percent chance of being the best model
- 1:03:01Josh: in the world by the end of this month.
- 1:03:03Josh: Can you explain to us why, why Google is so amazing at what they do?
- 1:03:06Josh: And this was the answer to the question. So here's a nice little nugget for
- 1:03:09Josh: the end to take you out of the episode.
- 1:03:11Josh: Thanks for listening. I really hope you enjoyed and we'll see you guys in the next.
- 1:03:13Logan: My general worldview of like why Google is in such a good place for AI right now.
- 1:03:18Logan: There's many layers of this, depending on sort of what vantage point you want to look at.
- 1:03:22Logan: I think on one hand, it's like, I think search is this like incredible part
- 1:03:28Logan: of this story, which I think people have historically looked at Google search
- 1:03:31Logan: as this legacy Google product.
- 1:03:33Logan: And I think search is going through this transition and is actually like today
- 1:03:38Logan: actually just announced as we're recording this earlier, that AI mode is rolling
- 1:03:41Logan: out to 180 plus countries.
- 1:03:44Logan: English supported right now, and hopefully other languages in the future and is a great example of.
- 1:03:50Logan: Ai overviews and ai overviews sort of double
- 1:03:53Logan: clicking into ai mode being this
- 1:03:56Logan: product that actually like for many
- 1:03:59Logan: people around for for billions of people around the
- 1:04:02Logan: world is the first ai product experience that they
- 1:04:05Logan: actually touch um and i think there's like something
- 1:04:08Logan: really interesting where like google has been on this
- 1:04:10Logan: mission of like deploying ai and like you know there's some
- 1:04:14Logan: you know the the some naysayers on
- 1:04:17Logan: twitter will be like you know google created the transformer and then
- 1:04:20Logan: did nothing with it and it's actually uh very far from
- 1:04:22Logan: the truth which is search has been this like transformer which
- 1:04:25Logan: is the architecture that powers language models and uh
- 1:04:29Logan: and gemini um has been powering that experience with this
- 1:04:32Logan: technology for the last like seven years the product experience maybe
- 1:04:35Logan: looks slightly different today than it did then um but google's been an ai first
- 1:04:40Logan: company uh for as long as i can remember um basically as long as ai has existed
- 1:04:44Logan: that's been the case and now we're seeing more and more of these product surfaces
- 1:04:48Logan: like become these frontier AI products
- 1:04:50Logan: as sort of Google builds the infrastructure to make that the case.
- 1:04:55Logan: I think people also forget like it's not easy logistically to deploy AI to billions
- 1:05:00Logan: of people around the world. And now as you look at like, I think Google has
- 1:05:03Logan: like five or six billion plus user products.
- 1:05:08Logan: So the challenges of like, even just making a small AI product work today,
- 1:05:12Logan: if anyone's played around with stuff or tried vibe coding something like it's not easy,
- 1:05:15Logan: doing that at the billion user scale is also very difficult um
- 1:05:19Logan: so i i continue to be more and more bullish and
- 1:05:22Logan: like part of the thing that allows us to do that billion user scale
- 1:05:25Logan: deployment is the whole infrastructure story like if you're watching on video
- 1:05:28Logan: i don't know if you can see but i have a couple of tpus sitting behind me um
- 1:05:32Logan: yeah and like that tpu advantage which is our sort of equivalent to gpus um
- 1:05:37Logan: is something that i think is going to continue to play out so there's there's
- 1:05:40Logan: so many things that I get excited about,
- 1:05:43Logan: and the future is looking very bright.