Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Wood gives Gilmartin the boot, Worley talks AI, and delays, delays, delays
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. Delays, delays, delays.
- 0:15And Woods CEO gets the boot. That's a lot to talk about.
- 0:20I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, and to discuss both of
- 0:23those big news topics with me, we have renewables reporter
- 0:27Michael Baer. How are you doing today,
- 0:29Michael? I'm doing well.
- 0:30I'm looking forward to, to this is a little, just a, a bit of a
- 0:33tete, a tete between us. It's just the two of us talking
- 0:35today. Yeah, it's just just the two of
- 0:37us. As that famous song goes, it's
- 0:40not Valentine's Day, it's more Halloween, which I feel like is
- 0:42probably more accurate for the two of us anyway.
- 0:44Hey, believe me, date with me is about as scary as it gets.
- 0:48But yeah, it's just the two of us this week.
- 0:50But we do have a great pre recorded segment from Gas Tech
- 0:54as we look ahead to add a pack in a couple of weeks.
- 0:57Our editor, Mark Selby was sitting with Morley, so I'm sure
- 1:01you'll enjoy that too. But let's get into the meat and
- 1:04potatoes of the next segment of this show.
- 1:07Michael, you've been keeping an eye on wood quite, quite
- 1:11closely. You know, we had the the
- 1:13takeover saga that looked like you came to an end earlier this
- 1:17year with Sadara. Previously, Sadara had had had
- 1:22another attempt to take over that failed.
- 1:24And before that, Apollo. It's been a long running thing
- 1:28and that seems to be culminating right now in CEO Ken Gilmart and
- 1:34leaving the company, which some people might be surprised that
- 1:38some people might just say it's the order of business as you
- 1:41sell the company. What happened?
- 1:43Well, what should we start with? So we start with the background,
- 1:45the facts, or the conjecture. The conjecture is going to be
- 1:47the fun part, so let's keep that as our dessert.
- 1:50Yeah, I think let's let's get on to the the what's what happened
- 1:53this week and we'll provide context.
- 1:55Afterwards so Ken Gilmartin, CEO of Wood Group since was it 2022?
- 2:0220/22 he took over, yeah. Yep, He has been, he has handed
- 2:07in his resignation. I believe he has stepped down as
- 2:10part of the the takeover of Wood Group by Sidara.
- 2:14So I think if I recall a date correctly, it's going to be 12th
- 2:19of November that there's going to be this shareholder vote to
- 2:22actually finalize the deal. And he has stepped down ahead of
- 2:26this. And you know, I think it's very
- 2:30much that as our friend of the the show, Ashley Kelty has
- 2:36pointed out, you know, to a certain extent this did feel not
- 2:39a huge surprise. Sadara is coming in, they're
- 2:42taking over. They are very likely to to be
- 2:46looking for a change in leadership.
- 2:48Yeah. It kind of reminds me of the
- 2:50Ethica situation a couple of years ago when Annie took that
- 2:53massive stake in the company and you know, it, there was that
- 2:57discussion around who they were going to instill in the
- 2:59leadership position. Same with with Harbour and
- 3:03vintage Aldea. You know, there was a there was
- 3:05a leadership change around the time that that that deal was
- 3:08going through as well. So not not too surprising.
- 3:12It'll be interesting to see how how would bids farewell to to
- 3:17Ken, You know, he was at the helm during a turbulent time,
- 3:21obviously throughout the, you know, just the in the wake of
- 3:23the COVID pandemic. And then he'd sort of inherited
- 3:28these contracts that would then said was causing financial woes.
- 3:33Maybe they didn't stack up the way they did when they were
- 3:35first signed. So, you know, it is I think is
- 3:39always 10 years kind of been marred with with sort of
- 3:43difficult times and ultimately him going on to sell the
- 3:46company. It'll be really interesting to
- 3:48see how how folks will react to that.
- 3:52Yeah, he reminds me a bit of Mad Sniper, Orrsted's CEO who
- 3:57stepped down earlier this year. You know, there was very much
- 4:01the feeling of, you know, I think whenever the head of a
- 4:06company resigns, there's always that question of right jump or
- 4:10push the, you know, were they forced out?
- 4:13Were they, were they, or, you know, were they leaving perhaps
- 4:16before they, they were pushed? The, they both had very tough
- 4:21remits that, you know, they came in at, like you said, post
- 4:25pandemic for, for Ken, you know, they had a big job and I think
- 4:31we could probably see that the, his tenure was mixed.
- 4:35I think definitely last year, you know, when he was talking
- 4:37about the, the financial performance of the company as
- 4:41being disappointing, You know, it was, it's definitely been a
- 4:44tough time for them, especially when we look at, you know, where
- 4:47they were last year, what with their 200P per share £1.65
- 4:52billion valuation. Don't Fact Check me on that.
- 4:55I'm putting that numbers in my head.
- 4:57That and you know how the share prices, Well, you know, let's,
- 5:01let's what it's called speed has collapsed since then.
- 5:05It has I mean it we had that interesting conversations are
- 5:08behind the scenes recently of like when do we describe a share
- 5:11price is collapsing? I think when you look at wood,
- 5:14that is when usually with a with an announcement like this, when
- 5:18a CEO leaves, you tend to find what the market sentiment is
- 5:23based on share prices. Are they, you know, are they
- 5:26dipping because people think, oh, it's uncertainty at the
- 5:28company is, you know, are people saying this is a sorry, a
- 5:32positive step forward? Share trading is, is still
- 5:35suspended. It hasn't say, you know, it
- 5:37hasn't published its books. Still going through that
- 5:40investigation right now with Financial Conduct Authority is
- 5:44what I'm trying to say. So we can't really see what the
- 5:47market sentiment is, but it does feel like the writing was kind
- 5:51of on the wall for for this situation.
- 5:55Michael, you did say that you would provide a little bit of
- 5:57background. And I feel like I can, I can
- 5:59feel readers going, OK, but how did we get here?
- 6:03You know, we've touched on a share price drop segment.
- 6:07I was speaking about a couple of takeover beds.
- 6:10You wrote that amazing sort of everything you need to know
- 6:13timeline of woods takeover saga. I feel like you were the man to
- 6:18ask about this I. Mean definitely let's be fair as
- 6:21journalists, we've been eating well off of the Sadara Wood
- 6:23takeover. It's and you know, we keep
- 6:25getting stories out of it. So you know, it was last year
- 6:29like 2024 that now actually maybe before that we should
- 6:33mention I think it was Apollo. They were looking to to buy wood
- 6:37and they ended up get going with Ouija, which is, you know, I
- 6:40think been going relatively strong since then.
- 6:43Sadara kind of came in looking to buy Wood Group and there was
- 6:47a sort of long stack of will they won't they, you know, they
- 6:51were, you know, looking at this sort of 200 pence per share plus
- 6:54one point 1 1/2 billion. Let's just do a bit of rounding
- 6:58on that evaluation for the company.
- 7:00And in the end, they kind of they walked away.
- 7:02And since then it hasn't been great for wood.
- 7:06Like we said, the share price has just been going down.
- 7:08They've been struggling with some of these legacy contracts.
- 7:13So I've just, I've just quickly, quickly looked through your
- 7:15coverage from this week to get the numbers.
- 7:18So the the previous takeover attempt from Sedara saw it put
- 7:23in a 205 pence per share valuation for the company that
- 7:27that brought the company's value to 1.65 billion.
- 7:31Pounds, which I believe was I was correct on.
- 7:33That's great there hasn't filled me yet.
- 7:36Whereas the current current deal that's being discussed is for
- 7:40just £0.30 per share, a massive drop off that's valuing the
- 7:45company at just £260 million. And then we had and yeah, like,
- 7:51like I said, that's, you know, there were maybe some tough
- 7:56moments for for Ken having to deliver, you know, like we've
- 7:59had a very disappointed financial performance is being
- 8:03turbulent. And that kind of makes sense
- 8:05when Sudara, you know, like a like a third act twist coming in
- 8:11right at the end with the with the new the new deal.
- 8:14And, you know, we, we got a lot of stories.
- 8:18It was becoming a bit of a joke of like how they had the the put
- 8:21up and shut put up or shut up deadline.
- 8:24And it just kept getting extended slowly devaluing that
- 8:29that acronym. So eventually, yeah, they've
- 8:32gone with they've it looks like it's going ahead.
- 8:35So Dara had to come up with the the firm bid they did.
- 8:39And like I said, 12th November is now the the voting date
- 8:43essentially where it looks like the deal is going to go ahead.
- 8:47I would personally be surprised if it didn't.
- 8:49Yeah, it's also big. Kenny's leaving day around then,
- 8:52so, you know, maybe there'll be a big party afterwards or maybe
- 8:56a moment of solace, who knows. But one last thing before we
- 8:59wrap up. We didn't touch on it earlier
- 9:01and I kind of want to touch on it now. 10's successor.
- 9:04We spoke about how Sedaro probably want to put someone in
- 9:07in post, which is, you know, more than likely, but right now
- 9:12they're they're looking at bringing up the interim CEO, Ian
- 9:16Torrance, CFO, sorry. And Ian Torrance, he he joined
- 9:22the company in an interesting time himself.
- 9:24You know, he took over from the previous CFO, who, you know,
- 9:28it'd been revealed that his his CV wasn't entirely accurate or,
- 9:33you know, he didn't have the qualifications they thought he
- 9:36did. So he was shown the door and Ian
- 9:38was rushed in like the next morning, couple of days later.
- 9:41It always seemed to me like it was going to be a temporary
- 9:44measure to have ENN just based on the fact that, yeah, he was
- 9:46brought in as like interim CFO and now he's leading the
- 9:50company. He's really kind of just
- 9:51stumbled into this. But it looks like maybe that's
- 9:54downplaying Ian. I'm sure if he wants to clarify,
- 9:56he can always come on the show and tell us.
- 9:58Well, I can just do a quick addendum that I did get rating
- 10:01from with that he is the the permanent CEO.
- 10:04So it's not going to be, but you're right, it has very much
- 10:06been a sort of very strange career journey of Yep, the the
- 10:11CFOI don't know if we ever fully got to the bottom.
- 10:14From what I've understood, it was just an honest mistake that
- 10:17in his credentials that led to him being removed from the
- 10:21position, Ian coming in and now Ian is heading the company.
- 10:25It's been a interesting year for Ian, I think, and perhaps if
- 10:30he's in the role long term that it's going to be a few more
- 10:34interesting years given how things have been going for Wood.
- 10:37That's very true, we'll need to all need to stick around to find
- 10:40out, so from the 12th of November onwards, if you want to
- 10:44stay up to date with Wood, Well Energy Voice outlines the place
- 10:47to go. But we are also the place to
- 10:49chat to Warley, so stick around after this break to hear what
- 10:52they had to say. So as promised at the top of the
- 12:32show, our editor Mark Selby was over in gas tech recently in
- 12:36Milan, that lucky devil, and he was speaking to Fabrico Sousa
- 12:41from Warley Consulting about the hot button topic that is AI.
- 12:46So let's hear what they had to say.
- 12:48So Fabricio, tell me a bit more about Wally and what you know,
- 12:51what is Wally involved with at the moment?
- 12:53This obviously the theme of gas tech is heavily AI influenced
- 12:58and focused on the AI trend. But tell me a bit more about
- 13:01Warley and your role at the company.
- 13:03Thank you very much, Mark, for for having me here today.
- 13:06And within Warley, the core of what we do, it's really helping
- 13:10our customers within the energy, chemicals and resources sector
- 13:14on how to make projects end to end in a more efficient way,
- 13:19reliable way and faster and more economically viable.
- 13:23And obviously AI is one of the core foundations on how do we
- 13:27bring this efficiency and this consistency from the decades of
- 13:31engineering that we have. So how long have you been at
- 13:33Worley for? I've been at Worley for a year
- 13:35and a half right now, OK, But my background is 25 years within
- 13:39the energy industry across the globe.
- 13:41So very fortunate to be now leading our consulting and
- 13:45technology solutions business globally forward.
- 13:48Do you also within the energy industry, do you come from like
- 13:51a tech background or is it something you kind of move?
- 13:54Yes. I've been on the tech background
- 13:56within upstream, midstream and downstream throughout my career
- 14:00across Americas, Africa, Middle East and Europe, So have covered
- 14:04quite some ground in there. And within Warley right now with
- 14:07the end trend project delivery, I have the great opportunity of
- 14:10bringing that together with technology to accelerate our
- 14:15project delivery to the customers.
- 14:16So in terms of the, the, this overarching theme of AI and
- 14:20technological advancement and optimization, like are there any
- 14:22particular projects of Wally that you would want to flag, you
- 14:25know, as being particularly relevant to, to, to gas tech and
- 14:28this, this tech theme? Most of the customers that we
- 14:32have within the energy, chemicals and resources, they're
- 14:34all here, right? And this is a great opportunity
- 14:37that we actually bring together our engineering expertise on the
- 14:40delivery side, with the regulatory side, with the policy
- 14:44makers and with the investors themselves to how do we
- 14:47accelerate, lower the cost and make a lot of these projects and
- 14:50visions we have to decarbonize and the planet faster.
- 14:54From the worldly perspective as we go around and talk to to our
- 14:58customers, all of them regardless of the sector want
- 15:02the same outcome. They want operations to be
- 15:05safer, they want decisions to be faster, and they want the
- 15:09outcomes to be more reliable. And AI has a core role to play
- 15:13in all of this by by bringing in the right data foundation that
- 15:18you need to drive it right, making sure that we scale
- 15:21responsibly across all the assets and having people in the
- 15:26center of this transition because AI doesn't replace
- 15:29expertise. So have you how much have you
- 15:32already seen the impact of AI like in terms of you know
- 15:36bringing that enhancement and an optimization within Woolly so?
- 15:40Recently there has been a survey that shows that 78 to 80% of
- 15:46organizations already use AI in at least one of the functions
- 15:50within Woolly. We rolled this out internally in
- 15:53the aspect of how do you optimize our engineering
- 15:55knowledge internally and how do we reduce leads time on the
- 15:59delivery of projects by leveraging the the years of of
- 16:02experience and within technical functions, AI is proven to
- 16:07improve efficiency by 20 to 30%. And that's exactly what we see
- 16:11right now. In some instances, we've seen
- 16:14cases of once you have a good data foundation, you go from do
- 16:18not do diligence on a customer asset from six months down to
- 16:22three weeks. And internally, the way that we
- 16:25use AI is how do we identify exactly where the most of the
- 16:30value can be taken in leverage. And this is on our 60-70 years
- 16:37of deep engineering knowledge. And how do we digest all of that
- 16:41and put it very handy on the hands of our SM ES so they can
- 16:45deliver client impact much faster.
- 16:47And that's exactly what we see through our advanced
- 16:49developmental development labs. So again, this is a key to the
- 16:53the overarching theme here of the huge increase in energy
- 16:57demand that's being driven by AI.
- 17:00Do you have a view on So obviously AI and data centers in
- 17:03particular are going to be driving this electricity demand
- 17:06at an unprecedented rate. Do you have a view on, do you
- 17:10see this as the, you know, the truly the biggest disruptor in
- 17:13energy in the coming in the coming years?
- 17:15So there's a general consensus that the demand of energy is
- 17:20just going to grow at a pace that we haven't seen before,
- 17:22right? And obviously AI is one of the
- 17:24key players in it on this demand of energy on the US alone is
- 17:30expected that within the next three to four years, the
- 17:33equivalent power of Japan will be needed just to power AI.
- 17:38So the question then to us is there has been always a lot of
- 17:43discussion around energy transition and right now the way
- 17:48that we face it is how it's about energy addition.
- 17:51So how we actually add energy to drive this evolution in a very
- 17:55responsible and sustainable way, right.
- 17:57So we didn't Warley, we operate around traditional energy
- 18:01sources, transitional and sustainable.
- 18:03And what we see now as we accelerate this energy demand is
- 18:08navigating, supporting our customers across that into
- 18:10spectrum to achieve their goals on the most sustainable way.
- 18:14So if it's going from, you know, obviously the energy transition
- 18:17is going to be a, a navigating energy transition is going to be
- 18:20a huge deal for the coming years.
- 18:22But do you feel like that the focus is shifting from
- 18:25transition to addition and therefore pragmatism in the way
- 18:29that energy and what is bringing, you know, that energy
- 18:31to the table? I, I don't think it's a shift
- 18:35from transition to addition. I think the transition is still
- 18:38there, it's still needed and the direction hasn't changed, right.
- 18:43The question now that we are really navigating to the the
- 18:46project we see globally is how do we create that addition,
- 18:49which is needed because of the demand in a sustainable way.
- 18:53So how do we accelerate any addition that we do, and we do
- 18:56it in the most economical, faster, reliable and sustainable
- 19:00form. So is Warley playing a role in
- 19:05helping clients to prepare for this AI driven surge in demand?
- 19:10Absolutely. And this includes both on how do
- 19:13we create projects a lot more efficient and cost effective.
- 19:17Second, how do we support the workforce both on our side and
- 19:21the customer navigate this acceleration and bring the best
- 19:25to to to make sure that the timelines we have that become
- 19:30faster and faster and the deliverer projects are
- 19:33effectively achieved and it's AI being used to accelerate these
- 19:37timelines to deliver the demands that is needed within the AI.
- 19:42System do you do you actually think that renewables can scale
- 19:44quickly enough to power AI or do you think that when I was
- 19:47talking about practices earlier, you know, do you think that
- 19:49actually you don't have a crystal ball but like get your
- 19:53view on this and do you think fossil fuels would simply remain
- 19:55part of the picture far longer than.
- 19:57This. I I wouldn't say if it's I agree
- 20:00with with that view. I just don't think it's.
- 20:04Much farther along right, what I what I see is fossil fuels,
- 20:08renewables, hydrogen, any source of power that small nuclear.
- 20:13As we see all of the power sources are in the table to
- 20:17drive that demand. And we as an organization and
- 20:21the customers and the government and society have our key role to
- 20:24play on how to make that whole addition of power in a way that
- 20:29is sustainable for for the planet.
- 20:31Yeah. So all sources will have a key
- 20:33role to play on the long run on driving this demand increase.
- 20:36So. Where are you seeing the fastest
- 20:40adoption of AI? And you also have, you know,
- 20:42you, you digital twins are a big part of your business.
- 20:45Maybe you could tell us a little bit more about that actually.
- 20:47Yes. So for AI can help us achieve a
- 20:50lot of these challenges that we face, right?
- 20:52But it's just good data means very helpful AI.
- 20:57That data means hallucinations and not very useful outputs.
- 21:02And when you have that bad data driving those outputs, you
- 21:05actually lose trust within the organization in the SME
- 21:07community on what you're achieving.
- 21:10So good quality data, it's the first foundation for for proper
- 21:15successful AI. And once you have and what does
- 21:19it mean by a solid data foundation is identifying the
- 21:22data you have, the data you don't and feeding it into a
- 21:25digital clean or digital asset. And right now we talk a lot
- 21:30about digital tuning. I see we are building digital
- 21:34tunes, but in the very short timeline, we're going to be
- 21:38talking about digital assets. So once you perfect the data
- 21:41that you have and you achieve the results you want, that
- 21:44becomes your digital asset. And once you're fully satisfied
- 21:48on the outcomes, you create a physical tune.
- 21:51Yeah. So it's using the right level of
- 21:54data to drive adoption, to drive reliability on the result.
- 21:58And that's what develops trust, trust on the results that we
- 22:02want to achieve. Yeah.
- 22:04And actually on the subjects of hallucinations, I don't know if
- 22:07you have a view on this one, but like, why is it that this is
- 22:10still such a common issue? And like, what could be done?
- 22:13I don't know if this is something that's part, you know
- 22:15you're looking at within your business, but what can be done
- 22:17to try to eliminate that challenge?
- 22:18Yeah. So I think we people forget
- 22:21fairly quickly that GPT, it's not something from today, right?
- 22:26And what a lot of organizations tend to think is I'm going to
- 22:29take a GPT, throw on top of all my knowledge and data, and I'm
- 22:33going to have a magic solution out.
- 22:35What people forget is that GPT itself took five years to train
- 22:40roughly 5 pentabytes of data, which is equivalent to 2.5
- 22:45billion fifty pages PDFs. No organization in Earth has
- 22:50that amount of data. So as we look into an
- 22:54engineering organization, an operating asset within the
- 22:57energy, chemicals and resources, instead of thinking of a large
- 23:00language model which will create those hallucinations because of
- 23:04the limited data set we should be focusing on.
- 23:06And that's what we do. We can reward in our customers
- 23:08this on a small language model. So clearly identifying what's
- 23:12the good data, what is the strong data you have, right And
- 23:16then using that small language model to truly have all the the
- 23:20retrievable generation out of that information based on true
- 23:25validated experience from the past, right.
- 23:28So the large language model, it's not the solution for most
- 23:31of the enterprises, but it's how do you identify which pilot
- 23:36within the organization will drive disproportional result
- 23:39going deep into it, having a perfect data model within your
- 23:44digital twin and then expanding it across the other assets.
- 23:47That's probably one of the most interesting and concise
- 23:50explanations I've had for that particular area.
- 23:53In fact, I don't know if anyone has been able to explain that to
- 23:56me before. So that's great.
- 23:59And yeah, but going back to that, you know, adoption of AI
- 24:02within your business, like where where are you seeing, are you
- 24:05seeing any particular sector taking it up faster than
- 24:07another, you know, upstream oil and gas or chemicals or mining
- 24:11or? Right now, I would say AI is in
- 24:15the minds of everyone, right? And AI is, it's long are the
- 24:21days that AI was a science experiment.
- 24:25I mean the way that we are now across these industries and
- 24:28going forward, AI is truly the reliability engine behind any
- 24:33operations and all sectors are actually having that in mind.
- 24:37The question then becomes how do you make that with the good data
- 24:42bringing people along that can trust on the reliable responses
- 24:45that you get out of it, right? But absolutely across all the
- 24:48sectors, we are helping the customers identify not the 1520
- 24:52use cases, but what are the 345 that drives outsized value for
- 24:58the organization and the operations reliability and then
- 25:01rolling them out at scale across the assets.
- 25:04And then finally, when it, when it comes to real world people
- 25:07using these, these, these tools as AI tools and digital tools.
- 25:12I mean, I don't know if you can talk about about what kind of
- 25:15impact you've seen that having on people within your within
- 25:19Wooly or any of your clients at all, like what that means for
- 25:21the people, the actual human beings at the heart of this.
- 25:24So technology on its own fails, right?
- 25:28You need technology and people centric people adoption to make
- 25:32it successful. So there is, there are some
- 25:36people that think AI is going to replace what we do.
- 25:38And there's a group of people that look at it and say, I can
- 25:43just do so much more with AI. And that's exactly how you're
- 25:46focusing on the SMEs that we have.
- 25:49And the idea is not to get deep subject matter experts and
- 25:53transform them into data scientists, but actually, how do
- 25:57you give the tools to that, to those technical leaderships and
- 26:01expertise that we have? How do you give them the tools
- 26:03that they trust to just deliver so much more on a shorter amount
- 26:07of time, right? So it's bringing them along as
- 26:10part of the solution, delivering them outcomes that they trust,
- 26:13they believe, and there's just tremendously accelerated and
- 26:17what we see then we've been awarded, it's exactly that,
- 26:20right? It's bringing closing that gap
- 26:22between the science of data, the deep expertise that we have, and
- 26:27pushing it forward because AI does not replace expertise.
- 26:32Yeah, it augments it. And Turbo.
- 26:34Charges, advances it. Yeah, Yeah.
- 26:36And then finally, so you've been in the role for a bit about a
- 26:39year and a half, you say. What has been the biggest
- 26:42surprise or challenge that you've had to face since you've
- 26:44been in this role? The, I wouldn't say it's a
- 26:48surprise, but it was a validation, right, that
- 26:51everyone, the direction around transition hasn't changed, the
- 26:56direction around making projects more efficient hasn't changed
- 27:00the, the speed and how we get there.
- 27:02It's what has really changed. And what really made me very
- 27:06proud when I got into this role is realize the depth of
- 27:09expertise that we have across the globe.
- 27:12And the key, the key challenge going forward now is how do you
- 27:17bring all of that together to be able to deliver impact fast
- 27:21enough across the globe, no matter where the challenge is,
- 27:24making sure we have the we have the right brains in place to
- 27:27accelerate the result that our customers need.
- 27:31So that does it for Mark's chat with Worley.
- 27:35Thank you very much, Fabrico for joining us on the show.
- 28:34So Michael, you know, we, we often report on projects going
- 28:39ahead and things, you know, things happening.
- 28:41But this week I feel like headlines have kind of been
- 28:44dominated by things not happening.
- 28:46And I mean, I guess anyone who's been keeping tabs in the UK
- 28:50sector could say, well, you know, obviously, you know that
- 28:54that tends to be, that seems to be the way of things right now,
- 28:56project delays, but maybe not to the extent of this or maybe not
- 29:01in this kind of way. So to start with, I think we'll
- 29:04touch on Deltech. So it's currently looking to be
- 29:09bought over by Vieiro. They're expecting that deal to
- 29:13sort of be delivered by the end of the year.
- 29:17However, they've got themselves in a situation where as they're
- 29:20trying to transfer ownership of their licenses, the NSTA is
- 29:25overshooting its usual three month deadline on sort of
- 29:29approving transfer of ownership. And now this isn't a piddly
- 29:34little deal, you know, this is quite, a, quite a serious one,
- 29:36£7 million for the, the company. The reason, the reason I
- 29:41highlighted this was it was it, you know, it was kind of just a
- 29:43short, short stock market update on Monday from Deltech that
- 29:47essentially just said the NSDA has overshot the deadline.
- 29:51We're still hoping to to get a complete by by Q4 by the end of
- 29:56the year, but the NSTA says it's unlikely that we're going to
- 30:02deliver by the end of November. Speculation could say December,
- 30:07but you know if we're saying all of Q3 then obviously that could
- 30:10go Q4. That could obviously go into the
- 30:13start of next year as well. The reason I highlighted this
- 30:18was in the oil and gas sector, we're seeing a lot of
- 30:20consolidation. We're seeing a lot of assets
- 30:22changing hands right now. Cerec has made a couple of
- 30:26acquisition of assets and you know, obviously we've got a Jura
- 30:30on the horizon, Shell and Equinor trying to offload all of
- 30:33their ownership into one brand new company.
- 30:37We've got rumors of Total maybe looking to sell some of its UK
- 30:42assets. It just just offloaded greater
- 30:45lagging, for example. So there's a, there's a lot
- 30:49going on in the M and a space right now.
- 30:51And I just found it really interesting to to sort of
- 30:53highlight, you know, this kind of delay.
- 30:55I did ask the NSTA about, you know, is it just the quantity
- 31:00that's coming through that's delaying you?
- 31:04And they were, they were, you know, as you can imagine, a
- 31:07little bit tight lipped on this. They were saying that they don't
- 31:10comment on individual licensees or anything like that.
- 31:13And they didn't really get back to me on the question of is this
- 31:17going to impact our future M&A and this are this is it the
- 31:21scale of the are the quantity of the deals that's that's causing
- 31:26delays. So I thought that was quite
- 31:29interesting and that really set us up for the rest of the week
- 31:33because you and Floyd have also been speaking about offshore
- 31:37wind delays. Slightly different topic, but
- 31:42interesting nonetheless. I thought I would kick off this
- 31:44segment with that because it's kind of a standalone thing, but
- 31:46I feel like it ties in the search is like the NSDL was says
- 31:51it's a, it's a arm's length government regulator, right?
- 31:55So it doesn't say it's under the, the, you know, the umbrella
- 31:58of government per SE, but at the end of the day, it's still kind
- 32:02of in that wheelhouse. So I was, I thought I'd bring
- 32:05that up at the top of the segment.
- 32:06If we're going to use the polarizing language that the
- 32:09industry hates, we went from oil and gas to the opposite side of
- 32:13the coin. We're going to renewables, we're
- 32:14going to offshore wind. Michael, you started things off
- 32:19by speaking about outer dosing. It's also seen delays.
- 32:24Yeah. So, I mean, let's think in case,
- 32:26you know, the developers get on to me is do they've had a delay
- 32:29in the decision. Now as I'll get into later the
- 32:32way that that means knock on effects, you know, I was
- 32:35definitely throwing in perhaps a little conjecture into my
- 32:38article, but you know, that's always fun.
- 32:40But yeah, Amy, it feels a bit strange that we've had these
- 32:44three delays in the approval process kind of coming all more
- 32:49or less at the same time that and, you know, I was thinking to
- 32:52myself, I wonder if we're going to see any kind of record like
- 32:56with Berwick Bank. You know, there was definitely a
- 32:59feeling, you know, for for anyone who's not obsessively
- 33:02falling off your wind farms in the UK, Berwick Bank had, what
- 33:05was it, It was about 2 1/2 years that it was stuck in the
- 33:08approval process And, you know, it was missing sort of crucial,
- 33:13crucial milestones. For example, it couldn't enter
- 33:16into one of the allocation rounds to get a contract for its
- 33:19power because it was so long delayed.
- 33:22He almost felt like hopefully this source a sign that, you
- 33:26know, we're kind of moving past that there's more resources for
- 33:29these kind of approval processes that the expertise is being
- 33:33generated. Now again, you know, I let's be
- 33:35absolutely clear that these are different, different approval,
- 33:39you know, regulators essentially.
- 33:40So I think it's Disney's for outer dosing.
- 33:44You say appointed at the NSTA for the the Deltic deal and it
- 33:48was Scottish Government for Berwick Bank.
- 33:50But you know, it does just feel that way.
- 33:52So the story is the for outer dosing the IT was just last
- 33:57week. I think it was the IT was.
- 34:01And I think actually we need to almost get the dates right.
- 34:03I think it was the 8th of October that they came out and
- 34:06said or we're going to have to push the the deadline back
- 34:11because the deadline was actually the tenth.
- 34:13It was that Friday that it would be supposed to get its decision.
- 34:16We didn't know why, we didn't know when.
- 34:19And it was this week that we got the the ministerial decision,
- 34:23which quite frankly, we don't know why still, but we know
- 34:26when. So outer dosing is going to get
- 34:30its decision or it's the the latest, the decision.
- 34:33It's supposed to come out now is February next year, which for
- 34:37its timeline that you're, I think they were originally
- 34:41planning to get it this year. Obviously the the deadline was
- 34:46last Friday that that means that construction should start next
- 34:50year with commissioning in 20-30, which is that looming
- 34:56mythical deadline of Clean Power 2030, which we're also receiving
- 35:01a lot of signals that the the offshore wind target is very
- 35:05likely to be lost. So not having that 1.5 gigawatts
- 35:10to contribute to it would definitely be a bit of a loss.
- 35:13Now, obviously, you know, I think I can see your lips
- 35:15moving. You're ready to make a comment,
- 35:16but it is a point that it's a few extra months.
- 35:20I've no idea. I've not got anything out of the
- 35:22developers Total Energy, Cotton, Corio, they're two of them,
- 35:26can't remember the third that they haven't given any signals
- 35:31that this has completely lost up their their timeline.
- 35:34So perhaps they can absorb it. But let's be fair, for 20-30 it
- 35:37feels like every bit counts and every month delay could really
- 35:43be. To answer your question, it was
- 35:45Thailand's Gulf Energy development.
- 35:47That's the third company involved in Error Dyson.
- 35:51Yeah, I think it's, it's interesting, isn't it?
- 35:53Because you know, these delays, if you, if you take them in
- 35:57isolation, it doesn't matter, right?
- 35:59Or, you know, it's a couple of months, you know, that's, you
- 36:01know, they can still deliver by 20-30 in the theory maybe.
- 36:06But you've also got to think, you know, if you keep pushing
- 36:09these projects back and they all get approved at roughly the same
- 36:12time. We'll touch on Morecam in just a
- 36:15minute as well. That if they all came to proceed
- 36:20at a relatively similar pace, then you've got all these
- 36:24projects looking to come online at the same time, which then ask
- 36:28questions of the grid and, you know, connection issues there,
- 36:31which obviously is necessary for those clean power targets as
- 36:35well. You know, you can't just be
- 36:36generating power to go nowhere. I did sort of put my tinfoil hat
- 36:40on this morning when I was reviewing the stories a little
- 36:44bit and thought, do you know what?
- 36:45If you notice the two delays have been pushed back to after
- 36:49the budget. Does that mean there's going to
- 36:52be any offshore wind announcement?
- 36:54I don't know. I feel like that's probably a
- 36:56little bit too conspiracy theorist a bit for me, but
- 37:01potentially who knows. Conspiracy theories on a podcast
- 37:05I'll never catch on. No, it never happens, Never
- 37:08happens at all. But yeah, we touched on
- 37:10Morecambe as well. Now, this was our esteemed
- 37:12colleague in the northwest of England, Floyd that that wrote
- 37:16about this. Morecambe also was in a similar
- 37:20kind of situation. It's a 480 MW offshore wind farm
- 37:26in the Irish Sea. It's obviously slightly smaller
- 37:29scale, 35 turbines. It was originally planned to get
- 37:33its development consent order from government on the 23rd of
- 37:37October. So, you know, it was, it was
- 37:40slightly behind outer dousing, but now it looks like it's going
- 37:46to be, it's fate will be decided on the 19th of December.
- 37:51So that was according to Minister for Energy Consumers
- 37:55Martin McCluskey. And it was kind of a similar
- 37:59situation to, to outer dousing as well.
- 38:02From what I saw. It was like, Oh yeah, we're
- 38:04delaying because we need more information.
- 38:07What that information is, we're not going to tell you.
- 38:09We don't, you know, that's not something that we're, we're
- 38:12finding out. It's not something that's sort
- 38:13of publicly available to my understanding.
- 38:16Yeah, it's when I said there was you know, we don't know the why.
- 38:19Look, we we we know that they needed more information and
- 38:22yeah, you're right. Well, what information?
- 38:24Why wasn't it available? Was it a case that, look again,
- 38:29tinfoil hat, that's there was maybe some sort of a mistake
- 38:32made in the, the approval process?
- 38:34I remember the when I was covering, I think it was a
- 38:37Danish project that they had to kind of do this because the, the
- 38:41approval process had taken so long that new legislation had
- 38:44come into effect. Now, like again, conjecture,
- 38:48it's a podcast. We're, we're going to have a bit
- 38:49of fun speculating. I'm not saying that's what
- 38:52happened, but it is that is one of those answers that just
- 38:55creates more questions of, OK, well, what is the information
- 38:58that they're after and why wasn't it available?
- 39:00I think it's also worth knowing that these consent orders and
- 39:04it's the same like environmental impact assessments, these are
- 39:07quite big, big documents submitted by the operators.
- 39:10And like there's a, there's a lot of information there.
- 39:12And sometimes, from my understanding, it can sometimes
- 39:14just be terminology. You know, you meant one thing
- 39:17and you said something is maybe a synonym.
- 39:19That doesn't quite work. It might create a little bit of
- 39:22ambiguity and the government sort of needs you to resubmit.
- 39:25It could just be that and that means they've got another.
- 39:28They've had to get a new slot in the queue, which is December, a
- 39:31sort of time. We'll have to wait and see.
- 39:34But a sort of concophony of delays this week was definitely
- 39:38something that piqued our interest.
- 39:40Did it pique yours? Let us know on social media or
- 39:43get in touch via e-mail. I've been Ryan Duff, I've been
- 39:46joined by Michael Baer. You've been a fantastic audience
- 39:49as always and we'll see you same time, same place next week.