Latest / ZulfTalks: Working For Yourself / Lessons Learned: How YouTube Shorts Hurt My Channel (and What I Wish I Knew)
Transcript
- 0:01How YouTube shorts hurt my channel.
- 0:05Today's episode, I'm going to actually speak through and
- 0:07explain what. I wish I knew before I started,
- 0:11so I'm going to go through, I'm gonna explain what's going on.
- 0:14In this video, I'm going to break it down in chapters so
- 0:15check that out. So thanks for joining me on the
- 0:17stove. Talks podcast, what are you to
- 0:19draw tree? And look at that, the appeal of
- 0:22YouTube shorts short term benefits long-term challenges
- 0:26and the lack of Wild results basically.
- 0:29So how can I say this? Why am I saying this?
- 0:32Let's have a quick look at. Why I'm saying is, I've got
- 0:34number of channels that I've got a monetized to the YouTube
- 0:39channels. See there's loads of different
- 0:41accounts, it's considered, ABC, 23-year, so trustee creators,
- 0:45not always YouTube channel. Hyping check our YouTube channel
- 0:48is of course, the YouTube Zoo photography store in one, two,
- 0:51three, four. These are basically individual
- 0:53channels that basically go off to their own channels.
- 0:56If I come over here, Here is zou photography, YouTube channel.
- 0:59So what did I do? I went in and I deleted all my
- 1:03shorts. Why?
- 1:05And how many shorts that I have? I had a number of shorts.
- 1:08Let me get you a number and the last month of East regard, maybe
- 1:12400 500 the Circuit. Look, if you're following, you
- 1:15know, I do a live for each of my channels every day.
- 1:19So, for example, two days of talks with you hyping check with
- 1:24you type, in Tech podcast with you trust the Creator's light.
- 1:27Stream. So all of these are individual.
- 1:32Accounts that I create content for, we have a full long episode
- 1:37and I'm going to explain why a long episode 15, 20 minutes
- 1:42breaking down into shorts at the same time while I'm doing this.
- 1:46So if you listen to my previous episodes, you'll know what the
- 1:48workflow is on, why I do this to save time.
- 1:51So I have one hour session where I do have in the morning.
- 1:53I do a podcast, I record the entire podcast, I have a button
- 1:56here, which I can press, and it creates a short at the same
- 1:59time. And that short is then, Used
- 2:02across social media. It's in a 9 by 16 format so it's
- 2:06like a one of those instead of those and that is used on
- 2:11Instagram Twitter. YouTube short, Facebook
- 2:19Tick-Tock. I got bored of paper that tells
- 2:21me remember that basically helps because I can use them on the
- 2:24cross different sides. So I'm doing as I'm getting you
- 2:26a number just to give you an idea of how many shorts I had.
- 2:30Just so you know I gave it a good chance.
- 2:32It's not just that it's like okay, so let me kind of show you
- 2:37this, I'll probably can. Let me make this a little bit
- 2:39more easy to view. And we can share this video
- 2:44again. If you're watching on the
- 2:45YouTube channel, you will be able to see the sunscreen if not
- 2:48explain what I'm showing you. So what I have here is, these
- 2:53are just from one session if I look at those, how many of those
- 2:5836 across one session and uploaded with got quite obvious,
- 3:04scrolling the 95 there. And that's just one channel, and
- 3:11that was in the past. Last month.
- 3:14However, in addition to that let me just give you what I'm sure.
- 3:17You know is shortstop already uploaded.
- 3:19Let me show you. One of the accounts that had
- 3:20quite a few things. Hyping check was like one of the
- 3:23big ones if I do typing. Check videos short uploaded to
- 3:30YouTube, let's count how many we've got here. 47 to be
- 3:35uploaded, the plan was to upload them, but I'm no longer doing
- 3:38that now because it's basically a waste of your Time and your
- 3:42resources hundred thirty-two. Again, that's over a month.
- 3:45There's also additional Parts in there which have already been
- 3:48uploaded, which is add these numbers up.
- 3:50If you want another 129, it's actually more more higher than
- 3:56what? I thought it was some more like
- 3:57500 videos. So, what what we're gonna do,
- 4:01I'll give you a quick overview there.
- 4:02What the situation is just to let you know what we're talking
- 4:05about. I'm going to go into this in a
- 4:06lot more detail in this episode of the podcast and YouTube shows
- 4:10you what are they want to do them?
- 4:11So basically, you Reports are those small videos in YouTube
- 4:15which they want to compete with Tick-Tock people, watch them,
- 4:19it's more of a scrolling exercise.
- 4:21A lot of people have thought that, wait a minute.
- 4:23We can use shorts to get more people to have a normal YouTube
- 4:26channel and watch our long-form content.
- 4:28Based on my experience, with three different channels with
- 4:31multiple videos, ranging in the range of 400 shorts in the last
- 4:3530 days. And before that I had a
- 4:38scattering of videos which I didn't care, because I was in
- 4:40like a regular uploads. And whereas the Zone photography
- 4:43is nearly every day. One video is going up in the
- 4:46shorts Arena and the hyping Tech.
- 4:48I had maybe four or five every hour.
- 4:52Black multiple shots of the show's other being made, that's
- 4:55something to keep an eye on. In addition to that, we've got
- 4:59the channel dimension on my show.
- 5:01You this is obviously monetize Channel and I'll let you know
- 5:03what I'm thinking. So if you go to videos, I had a
- 5:06range of shorts in here. I went through, picked out all
- 5:09the shorts yesterday and I deleted all the shorts first to
- 5:13make them private then over n and at least the shorts.
- 5:16But you that's why did you do that?
- 5:17Why did you bother to do that? Firstly I noticed a dramatic.
- 5:21Attic increase in views. So YouTube gave you more views
- 5:27from shorts. So in 1,000 years, 2,000 views,
- 5:30whatever it was for each video. And that meant that my channel
- 5:34analytics said, oh wow, you're getting those views even though
- 5:37YouTube of tried to split YouTube videos and short into
- 5:40separate tabs, that still hasn't really worked in the back end
- 5:44where they summarize all the views.
- 5:47So what's happening is if I have n card in my YouTube Deal which
- 5:52says best for user so you can have a end card in the YouTube.
- 5:57So in this video finishes are be a card that says you show the
- 5:59user. Whatever video they will be
- 6:01likely to be watching based on my channels content and what the
- 6:05user likes to watch. A lot of people were being
- 6:08suggested shorts so that means from my long videos, people are
- 6:13being pushed to shorts because YouTube has a thing at the
- 6:16moment where they want to push their shorts, they've got a
- 6:18special dedicated Shorts YouTube.
- 6:21Manager, who reaches out to specific people and unwise of
- 6:26talks Channel, they have reached out to me, and they've asked me
- 6:29to be part of that program. So they're saying, can you
- 6:31upload more shorts? So we can basically get better
- 6:35and they give you benefits. That all the give you free
- 6:36courses, it's a bit of a waste of time, to be honest.
- 6:39It's just like a tick box exercise for the YouTube
- 6:41partners to say they're reaching out to YouTube clients and
- 6:44stuff. So I don't really benefit from
- 6:46that, but I did go along with the exercise and gave them the
- 6:48information. Like major also Pro leader,
- 6:51Regular might solve a short. I was doing a show every day on
- 6:55my soft rocks Channel. And then I got to a point where
- 6:58I was like, you know, this isn't working for me.
- 6:59I went to one week and now I'm just contemplating stopping you
- 7:03all together. Not contemplating, I have
- 7:06stopped altogether. So YouTube is all photography.
- 7:10Shorts are no longer existent and the reason for that is it's
- 7:14not doing anything for your channel other than hurting your
- 7:17channel. So, if I show you a video here
- 7:19on this screen, so I'm showing at my YouTube Channel right now
- 7:24is telling me I've got 11,000 more views than usual on my
- 7:29shorts feed. However, overall that is not
- 7:34good for my channel. Because firstly, I've got more
- 7:37views which haven't converted into anything of any value.
- 7:41In terms of subscribers, I'm gone up.
- 7:43People from the shorts have not gone on to watch longer videos.
- 7:47Even though in the shorts, I had a pinned comment with a video
- 7:51version. One of my full show for people
- 7:53to go and watch, then got time for that.
- 7:55They just scrolling and quickly looking through think of
- 7:57tick-tock. So firstly, the monetization is
- 8:01really low non-existent and I think is a bit of a mistake that
- 8:04YouTube have pushed. A lot of people to the shorts,
- 8:07you may be watching videos about those on personal opinion based
- 8:09on what I've done and what I've been looking at and let me cook
- 8:13you show you can I show you one of these earn screen the so we
- 8:16can see what is saying that if I go Analytics.
- 8:21Is it a sport? Okay, so looking good Channel
- 8:24views are slightly higher than usual in the last 28 days.
- 8:26This is now come back into line because I've gone through and
- 8:29get all the shorts. You got over 55,000 views which
- 8:34is around the upper end of forty two thousand views that your
- 8:38channel usually gets in 28 days. So there's an extra boost from
- 8:43the views subscribers. Did not change.
- 8:45What to watch time. You don't change.
- 8:47Estimated Revenue did not change that you earn from those videos.
- 8:51Just the views when top. So if you're looking to create
- 8:55content just to get oils on your content, Okay, maybe that's
- 9:00fine. But for short, you want luck
- 9:01jokey type stuff. So a lot of my videos were like
- 9:03one line of Photography Jokes which did quite well, and the
- 9:06tech ones were just about technology and luck, quick
- 9:08Snippets from the show to encourage people to watch the
- 9:10full show. So the appeal of YouTube shorts
- 9:12is, it's another way of doing it.
- 9:15If you've got kicked off videos, Instagram videos, Facebook
- 9:18videos, reels. You can use that same video on
- 9:22YouTube, however, that's what I was doing.
- 9:24I was basically recording a full episode like I'm doing right now
- 9:27of my soft rock spot. First, I was taking out shorts
- 9:30from that so that meant I had a YouTube podcast, episode 4
- 9:35video. I had a huge, I had multiple
- 9:39YouTube shorts which I could put on YouTube shorts those, same
- 9:42shorts. I could put on Facebook, reels
- 9:43up on Instagram, a couple and kicked a couple and Twitter.
- 9:47However, one of the now is I'm using them everywhere else.
- 9:50Apart from YouTube, don't put them on Facebook.
- 9:53I'll do another episode about Facebook.
- 9:55Why you Facebook? Reels is another time waste as
- 9:58well. So based on my two months on
- 10:01Facebook, again, on multiple profiles, why that is more for.
- 10:06Like, if you want to be famous and you want people to recognize
- 10:09you use Facebook reels because I noticed, as soon as I started
- 10:13doing Facebook realize more people started, recognizing me
- 10:16around, which I don't really mind, but it's, I don't read.
- 10:20That's not my goal. I don't want to be famous.
- 10:22I just want to be helpful so people can hear like what they
- 10:26need to hear and have them save time.
- 10:28So In some cases, Facebook is like a bit of a vanity thing
- 10:33that if you want people to recognize you on the street?
- 10:35Okay, do Facebook reals. So at some point I'm going to be
- 10:37stopping Facebook reels as well and sticking to YouTube, long
- 10:40form content, short-term benefits.
- 10:43Are you get spikes in views in YouTube?
- 10:46If you do short, you get a lot of bass, big spike in views.
- 10:49You get spike in comments. A lot of the comments are very
- 10:53non motivational, they're very like just people on it in a
- 10:57different mindset. So it's not positive comments.
- 11:01I've got filters on my channel so I don't see a lot of them.
- 11:02But I have noticed from other people's content, the types of
- 11:06things you see in short comments, people now say that on
- 11:08a normal video or in real life so don't worry about that.
- 11:10It can happen long-term challenges are if you boost
- 11:14loads of shorts, you basically get loads of short views.
- 11:17You're going to get any subscribers based on what I get
- 11:22from a long form video. I have seen another Channel easy
- 11:25each crew where I basically just got up 39 to 40 subscribers.
- 11:29Is just off the back of shorts. So it does work in some cases.
- 11:33But do you want subscribers? Who are looking for short
- 11:36videos, or do you want subscribers?
- 11:38Who are happy to look at a 15? 20 minute long podcast episode,
- 11:42you can you decide that for your channel?
- 11:44This may not be right for everybody.
- 11:46Obviously, I'm give you my personal opinion, so you might
- 11:48not agree with that but I'm just showing you that okay.
- 11:50I do prefer to have a 10-15 minute talk about another topic.
- 11:53Let you know what that topic is, how to learn from it rather than
- 11:57have like a 10 second show and People forget what they learnt.
- 12:00So that's where we upped and lack of watch time.
- 12:03And subscriber conversion is double.
- 12:05You've mentioned that. So if you doing both I am doing
- 12:08both but still I'm finally dies not doing anything for my
- 12:11Channel. I want the long version of the
- 12:12video and I've got shorts. So if you think you know I'll do
- 12:15both, what's the worst that can happen while?
- 12:17Yeah it got. There is some worst that can
- 12:18happen because it's shorter. Get loads of views and those
- 12:22views make your channel look like you had more views.
- 12:25However, in comparison to those views YouTube will say, actually
- 12:28What last month you got less views, you got more subscribers,
- 12:32you got more quality comments and people integrating with the
- 12:36content, as well as you enter, we were able to display ads and
- 12:40all those videos whereas on shorts because they're shorter
- 12:44and this lower income, you'll get a decrease in monetization.
- 12:47If that's your main goal for your channel, that might hurt
- 12:50you. That wasn't my main goal, so I
- 12:52didn't mind the monetization hitch.
- 12:54However, my main thing was people watching will not really
- 12:58picking up anything. Thing from the shorts, they were
- 13:01not going into a longer videos to get the full topic to help
- 13:05them get educated. So that's the main goal is my
- 13:07channel. I try and help educate, in terms
- 13:10of I've done this, this work from me and from my point of
- 13:13view, you might find it helpful. If you do great, if you don't
- 13:17have a look at some of the videos around this topic, you
- 13:18might find the right creator for you because obviously everybody
- 13:21has their own way of learning starts perfectly fine.
- 13:23You're not going to be able to show everybody how to do stuff
- 13:27so that's mine. All of you there and strategies,
- 13:32there's not really any strategies.
- 13:33My goal was, I'll make a podcast episode, making two shorts,
- 13:37share the shorts and hopefully, get people to watch the full
- 13:39episode to learn something that hasn't happened, because shorts
- 13:43are its own little system. So if you treat that totally
- 13:46separate you, okay, how have I got around this issue?
- 13:50Because I've got a ton of short stop being made.
- 13:52Now, I probably got another 600 shorts that are ready to go up.
- 13:56So, what I do is once I made my video, I Jewel short.
- 14:00So I have content through a separate situation where now,
- 14:04I've got my eyes all Clips Channel where I only put all the
- 14:10waisted shorts that don't do anything for anything.
- 14:12Anyway, I'll put them on a separate account.
- 14:15So if you go to short here, you'll see there's like a whole
- 14:19host of shorts there and you'll notice even though the short,
- 14:22some of them 1.3 K1 view, 1.5 K, 1 Point 2, K, 750 K.
- 14:27And these are all A mixture of the short star from all the
- 14:31other channels. So, I basically started putting
- 14:33them on to this account. I've got 150 one subscribers
- 14:36there, so, yeah, okay, you can get subscribers from it, but the
- 14:43channel is a Best Clips channel. So, the goal is, keep all your
- 14:47shorts, you two shirts, in a separate account, you'll be
- 14:50fine, because whatever that account does doesn't matter.
- 14:53So, now as of Clips, I'll be following along with that
- 14:56Journey. So, on the next podcast, like in
- 14:58a month or two, Storm and let you know how that's getting on.
- 15:00We may find, there's been a lot of channels where people have
- 15:03been monetized on just the shorts.
- 15:06But remember that's 10 million views over that 90 days and you
- 15:10need the subscribers of 1000. Start can happen, people have
- 15:13different types of content, so it won't fly to me.
- 15:16Maybe somebody else is making totally different content, which
- 15:18people relate to in Tick-Tock, shorts, trending topics, Etc,
- 15:21minds of more or less me talking about topics and Ivar joke, are
- 15:26in their educational type content.
- 15:28So Different parts in YouTube so I can't comment on what types of
- 15:32other contents out there. Maybe gaming channels will do
- 15:34bear, who knows? But so far, my experience
- 15:37already share this on this episode to let you know that
- 15:41YouTube's did hurt my YouTube. YouTube shorts did hurt my
- 15:44channel. I was not able to get as many
- 15:48people to watching other videos but all was push the short.
- 15:53Get those people from shorts the full version of the episode and
- 15:55watch the full episode like a trailer to the main event
- 15:58because it's a An episode that did not happen and I would would
- 16:02I do this again. What I learned is, I only found
- 16:06this out when I did it, so, you can watch as many videos as you
- 16:10want. You won't know until you do it.
- 16:12And if it doesn't work, just go through and delete the shorts,
- 16:15basically, because I can't say it would work for you or it
- 16:18might not work for you might find you deserve a lot better
- 16:20for you. That's why it's always good to
- 16:23try yourself. You'll learn a lot more from
- 16:26trying yourself, then watching somebody else telling you about
- 16:28it which is Big moral of the story.
- 16:31So this is a quick episode just to kind of give the view of
- 16:35shorts, how it's affected me how I've made a separate account
- 16:38Channel, just to highlight all the shorts and the clips.
- 16:42And the two channels that I've gone in and moved our Zoo
- 16:46photography, hyping Tech and resolve talks, I might go
- 16:49through and delete those shorts as well.
- 16:51However, it will affect your account in terms of views.
- 16:54So, keep that in mind. Thank you for joining me on this
- 16:56episode. This has been solved talks.
- 16:58I'll see you on the next version of this podcast episode.
- 17:01Take care. next version of this podcast episode.
- 17:01Take care.