Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 20 - The “Just No Steely Dan” Episode - WonkyFolk Theme Music and the Need for a Stronger Education Theme in National Politics
Transcript
- 0:02Hey Andy, how's it going?
- 0:04I'm good, how are you?
- 0:06I'm doing pretty good, doing pretty good.
- 0:08I mean, whatever, we're chuckling even as we get on this thing.
- 0:11But, I mean, I got the, I got the input from Dale Chu.
- 0:15He's like, dude, I actually kind of like you and Andy,
- 0:17but you need some theme music.
- 0:19What's going on?
- 0:21So,
- 0:22, you
- 0:22got to see him this week.
- 0:24What did dale recommend?
- 0:26What was his suggestion for us?
- 0:27All he said was just , you guys are pretty good But like, , it's pretty jarring to
- 0:31start from nothing and it just doesn't bespeak, seriousness So so i've been
- 0:36starting to think about Getting AI, to like mash together, incompatible,
- 0:45music ask it for the combination of Rage Against the Machine and, , Brahms
- 0:51Second Concerto or something like that.
- 0:53You could represent the Brahms, , I could represent, , the Rage Against the Machine.
- 0:57But I don't know, maybe you got other ideas.
- 0:59Or like Moon Age Daydream or Voodoo Child, something like that would be fantastic.
- 1:04I think that would fit us a little bit better.
- 1:06As long as it was played in a Muzak version, , or something like, like
- 1:10something you'd hear on an elevator.
- 1:13I guess I, I mean, if I would actually be okay with it, we just got some really
- 1:16cheesy porno jazz, that would be at
- 1:20least, but if I, if we could somehow get Hendricks, that would be amazing.
- 1:24All right.
- 1:25Can you work on the rights to that?
- 1:27Maybe bellwether can swing that for us.
- 1:29All the big money.
- 1:30This podcast is thrown off for us.
- 1:32Yeah.
- 1:33, we're getting lots of feedback.
- 1:35I've heard also, I heard somebody say the other day, how strong your mic
- 1:38sounds now, the audio is better, which made me immediately, unfortunately,
- 1:43think of Trump in Pennsylvania.
- 1:45And then one day I'm going to be like telling people.
- 1:47All the other podcasters said, Jed Wallace's, Mike, you should have
- 1:50heard you, you should have heard it.
- 1:51It was so strong the way he, sorry.
- 1:54My almost slap seems like a poor Bobby Kennedy.
- 1:56I don't dunno why my, that's not how Trump talks, but I certainly don't have
- 1:59a Trump, I don't have a Trump impression.
- 2:00Did
- 2:01is that, is that talk what, what the podcasters are
- 2:03talking about in the shower?
- 2:04Exactly.
- 2:05They're talking about, they're talking about your, that your mic
- 2:07has gotten really strong and our, our, our sound quality is better.
- 2:10So it makes sense that we would then segue in into having some actual intro music.
- 2:16I like it.
- 2:17I like it.
- 2:18All right.
- 2:18Well, I know you got other stuff going on this week around elections and whatever.
- 2:22It doesn't seem like we can get started without at least getting
- 2:26starting there and whatever.
- 2:27You're going to be sharing other stuff.
- 2:28I don't know if you got so much content.
- 2:31You can, , keep it fresh across several podcasts here.
- 2:34But what are you thinking here?
- 2:36I don't know.
- 2:36Look, whenever we talk about, I always want to be transparent.
- 2:38And I used to say, like, who I would vote.
- 2:40I've actually already voted.
- 2:42And I wish there was like, After you vote, there was some list you could get onto.
- 2:46So you would stop getting the texts and pleas for money and everything else.
- 2:49So you could be like, I popped out, like it's, for me, it's, it's game over.
- 2:53So I voted for Harris obviously.
- 2:55But I feel like it's important to say we're not just like out
- 2:57here, like,know, , somehow like independently handicapping this, but
- 3:01look, everyone wants to say the race.
- 3:04I don't think anyone, , I wrote the other day on Edgewonk, like.
- 3:07Everybody making predictions.
- 3:09I'm pretty sure figures they've got a 50 percent chance of being right
- 3:13because it's a two person race, and they've got like a 75 percent chance.
- 3:16Everybody will forget their prediction in the first place.
- 3:18And so that It seems very, very tight.
- 3:23And, , I talked to different people and political people in Pennsylvania,
- 3:26you get different takes on, on, on what they think's going to happen.
- 3:29I think if you, if you, if you're a Democrat and you want
- 3:31something to worry about, you should worry that she's not ahead.
- 3:35Like not substantially, it's a pretty divided country, but that she should be
- 3:39given the context of everything, , both favorable sort of tailwinds for her and
- 3:45what you would think would be pretty substantial headwinds for her opponent.
- 3:48Like she ought to be.
- 3:51In a more comfortable place.
- 3:52And so that's that's reason of concern.
- 3:53And then I guess for the republicans, if you want to, if they're republican,
- 3:55you want to worry, she's she still has time to close the deal.
- 3:59She clearly has not yet.
- 4:00But sometimes these elections shift hard and the conventional wisdom
- 4:05just doesn't apply in this case.
- 4:06Because like, , it always shifts against the incumbent party.
- 4:08Well, in this situation, who really is the incumbent party?
- 4:11And so there's Like, I think if she could, land some sort of clear, convincing
- 4:17messages about what she's going to do.
- 4:18I mean, I think she could still seal the deal.
- 4:21Yeah.
- 4:22Well, I'm going to vote for Harris as well.
- 4:24And, I mean, I, I'm not a happy Harris voter and, it's just, there's some
- 4:30things I kind of feel are disqualifying and I just feel like January 6th is
- 4:34just, is fundamentally disqualifying.
- 4:36We can talk about other things that are disqualifying as well.
- 4:38But, I mean, I actually think the worst public policy decision of my,
- 4:44of my lifetime is, is the Iraq war.
- 4:48And I swore that I would never vote for somebody who voted for
- 4:51the resolution and I never did.
- 4:52And I actually think that the Iraq war is what just, fractured the
- 5:01Republican party and has ultimately led to us having, having Trump.
- 5:05But, I don't like it.
- 5:07I just feel like I'm not happy with, certainly not happy with the education
- 5:11policies, , of, of, of Biden and, and, Harris and whatever it voting
- 5:17within the democratic blob within the state of California is just.
- 5:21So distasteful.
- 5:22So I'll try to find as many ways as I can within on my California ballot to like
- 5:28signal, Hey, I want something different than, Democratic Party, basically mono
- 5:34control of the entire state here, as I think the Dems are really driving,
- 5:38the state into a state of dysfunction.
- 5:41Yeah, it's weird.
- 5:42You said a couple of interesting things there.
- 5:43One is look.
- 5:44I mean, I, I agree with you January to me, to me, the pre January 6th conversation
- 5:49about Trump, the post January 6th, and he did plenty of things, , I didn't
- 5:53vote for him in 2020 or 2016, either.
- 5:55He did plenty of things I found offensive, but that like, was a different level.
- 6:00And so I feel like we have to have that conversation.
- 6:04With that in mind, that, that, , people talk about choices people made
- 6:08after 2016, people who decided to go into the administration or did this
- 6:12or that it was January 2017 was a different time than post January 2021.
- 6:17I think that's a nice gets, gets lost.
- 6:19The other thing he said, look, I will say one of the nice things, , it was something
- 6:22that you correct to Trump's credit.
- 6:24He didn't, he said he wasn't going to get us any wars and he didn't.
- 6:27And some of that stuff, a leader can't control, obviously.
- 6:31Things happen on your watch that you, that you can't control.
- 6:33But, per the post, your post Iraq comment, it's one of the
- 6:38interesting factors about the realignment of, of the parties.
- 6:43Yeah, it's kind of, it's kind of an interesting thing.
- 6:47And then the other thing you said, the blob, like, I just think this is one
- 6:50of these hidden in plain sight things.
- 6:53And two in a couple of ways.
- 6:54One, it's such a weird thing right now, how we talk about politics.
- 6:57Like I voted for Harris and walls despite my concerns about some of their
- 7:03positions, particularly on education.
- 7:05But everybody assumes that everybody else votes for a candidate based
- 7:08on, like the worst thing about them.
- 7:10And I think it's created just an incredibly toxic discourse in the
- 7:14education sector because it's all these things that, like, Everybody
- 7:18recognizes like their own bias and doesn't realize that everybody
- 7:20else probably has a similar one.
- 7:22Some of the people who are voting for Trump are certainly not
- 7:24voting for him because of the most like revolting things about him.
- 7:27And I think it's a problem we've come into in this sector.
- 7:29If you're like, I run constantly into these people.
- 7:31I can't imagine anyone voting for Trump.
- 7:34I can imagine that.
- 7:35That's not that to me, that's not even a very hard thought exercise.
- 7:38I handicapped the issues and his positions and things he has said
- 7:42and done and so forth differently.
- 7:44But like this idea that it's like unimaginable, like, no, it's, it, and
- 7:47I think that if there's a problem with the democratic message, it may be that
- 7:51it may be that it's oriented towards, it's unimaginable to vote for this
- 7:54person rather than it's imaginable.
- 7:56And we need to persuade you, in a, in a different way
- 8:00that may be alienating people.
- 8:01And then the last thing, look, the blob man, like she's a creature
- 8:05of California democratic politics.
- 8:06This is really her first time out harvesting national votes like this.
- 8:10And if you sort of.
- 8:13I didn't want to get some clues into how she operates and so forth.
- 8:16It's, it's look at politicians who have come up in that democratic machine.
- 8:20And it's like, I think that that's actually will reveal quite a bit about
- 8:24sort of how to think about, , what to expect and so forth and what
- 8:27we should expect on education.
- 8:29Yeah, it's interesting to see Gavin just having basically lock, stock and barrel
- 8:33in the early years of his administration, going far, far left, trying to keep
- 8:38the teachers unions, the other public employee unions, the other far, , left
- 8:42aspects of the of the coalition together.
- 8:45And then, , he's in his last 2 years.
- 8:47He doesn't need anybody anymore.
- 8:49And it just feels like it just feels like he's repositioning himself to try and be.
- 8:54So whatever he does in the future, at least I'll have something else to refer
- 8:57to other than, , what he did in these first four to six years as being governor.
- 9:03Yeah.
- 9:03And look, Trump has broken the rules of politics.
- 9:06Right.
- 9:06It, I mean, there is, so there's no, there's no Tim Russert anymore.
- 9:08And so I think you realize politicians are sort of behaving a little more
- 9:11like, , like, like, I mean, politicians, politics is always sort of situational
- 9:15opportunistic, all of that, but it's happening at a different level.
- 9:19I think it's because people realize there's so much noise in
- 9:22the issue environment and so much chaos that like, you can sort of.
- 9:27You can do that.
- 9:28And Gavin may very well be able to get away with that.
- 9:30Yeah, we'll see.
- 9:31We had a Charterfolk board meeting on Friday.
- 9:34Really interesting conversation.
- 9:35J.
- 9:36Arnis Wright from the Freedom Coalition was on.
- 9:38And, one of her comments during the board meeting was, We just have to have
- 9:43people talk about education a little bit.
- 9:47And, I thought it was an interesting, I mean, whatever we, you and I talked
- 9:50about it before, just how mostly education is off the radar screen altogether.
- 9:54But Jay really brought it home and she's going to write something at charter
- 9:58folk, in this week as well on this topic.
- 10:01But, , if it, there's very little about education at the top, if
- 10:05anything, at the top of the ticket.
- 10:07There's some interesting state, ballot initiatives in Kentucky, , in
- 10:11Colorado, couple other places around school choice in these things.
- 10:17, there's elections that are happening in Chicago, with the
- 10:20dysfunction with Brandon Johnson with the new school board there.
- 10:23So there are certainly some, some elections that are gonna have
- 10:27big bearing on education issues.
- 10:28Anything that you're tracking above others as it relates to education?
- 10:31Yeah, that's interesting question, Jed.
- 10:33One thing that I am, with education, that I am thinking about is like,
- 10:40you're right, it's not an issue, but it really is a factor in the election.
- 10:43It's really fascinating in these closing days.
- 10:46That, , Harris is trying to run up her margins with white
- 10:49college educated voters, because that could be a differentiator.
- 10:52And Trump's trying to run up his margin with non white voters.
- 10:56And education level is turning out to be highly predictive
- 11:00of, of, of voting behavior.
- 11:01It has been the last few cycles, geography and education have taken on
- 11:05a greater role, but even it seems even more so with, with the sort of these
- 11:09shifting coalitions within the parties.
- 11:11So there's that.
- 11:12I'm also watching this school choice.
- 11:14Ballot referend , like you all in California, I live in Virginia.
- 11:18Our ballots like pretty simple like this year.
- 11:20We have like a US Senate race, your house race in the presidential.
- 11:24And there's one ballot issue that was pretty straightforward.
- 11:27We don't get a ton.
- 11:27It's hard to get a constitutional amendment on the ballot.
- 11:30Colorado is like you all were like voters get this, like phone book to go through.
- 11:34And and one of them is this sort of innocuous sounding
- 11:39create a right to school choice.
- 11:41I think Kentucky has one of these as well.
- 11:43And the way it's worded, it seems extremely innocuous.
- 11:47So if you're like wading through all of these things you have to think about
- 11:51as a voter there, It could be very easy just to be like, Oh, what is this?
- 11:57It sounds Like parents have a right to direct.
- 11:59It sounds like it's basically codifying the Pierce decision of, , almost a
- 12:03hundred years ago at the Supreme Court.
- 12:05It doesn't sound like it's particularly revolutionary.
- 12:08And so I'm watching that one.
- 12:09I mean, obviously look at the passes.
- 12:11It will immediately be challenged.
- 12:12These things always end up.
- 12:14Wending their way through the courts.
- 12:15But, that one seems that one seems really interesting.
- 12:19Just in terms of is there a new sort of softer strategy that we
- 12:23might see around these things?
- 12:25It can't be by accident that that sort of similar approach
- 12:29on multiple state ballots.
- 12:31Yeah, colorado is interesting in that we're really testing some school
- 12:34choice stuff in a purple, but mostly blue context has shifted enough now.
- 12:39And so it's interesting to see the dynamics there because that was
- 12:43really driven by the voucher and E.
- 12:46S.
- 12:46A.
- 12:46People.
- 12:47And they kind of threw a bone into the charter school people saying,
- 12:51Hey, you'll benefit from this too.
- 12:53But the charter school people are like, what are we really
- 12:55going to get out of this?
- 12:56Not very much.
- 12:58And, and so I don't think the charter school world has gone all
- 13:01in as maybe the ESA and voucher people would have expected.
- 13:05I have what I think longer term is, Hey, if you're in red context and you're gonna
- 13:10do something different, I don't know.
- 13:12But outside of those contexts, If the E.
- 13:15S.
- 13:15A.
- 13:15And voucher people are going to come and expect charters to be a part
- 13:18of the coalition, there's got to be something tangible that's going to make
- 13:21things, , better for charter people.
- 13:24And in Colorado, there are all sorts of things that they could have done.
- 13:28One of the things I think is, and Starley has been out of the gate
- 13:31strong on this in her early months at the National Alliance, the partly the
- 13:36new head of the National Alliance of Public Charter Schools.
- 13:39Yeah, she, she's really talking about the problems with flexibility,
- 13:43autonomy, freedom, and I'm starting to become of the opinion that we need
- 13:48much stronger, structural barriers to re regulation in charter land, such
- 13:55that you need it in your constitution.
- 13:57Hey, if you want to re regulate charter schools, you need to have two thirds of
- 14:01the, of the, legislature vote for it, or there needs to be a two part process,
- 14:07or you need to vote it, vote on it, . Two years in a row or something that's just
- 14:12a higher bar so that we don't see charter schools run the same trajectory that all
- 14:18the rest of public education is run, which is toward being just overly high bound.
- 14:23Yeah, it's a weird thing though, right?
- 14:25Like, I agree with your and obviously what's going to happen and this
- 14:29will be saying to be vigilant about with the Harris administration
- 14:31is there'll be a pandemic.
- 14:32They'll be pressure on to, , under the guise of regulate sensible
- 14:35regulations for charter schools.
- 14:37It'll be a bunch of stuff that that is designed to, , cause problems,
- 14:41hamstring growth and all the rest.
- 14:43And it'll be well, how can you be against the stuff and all that?
- 14:45We've seen that debate and playbook before.
- 14:47It's, it's, it's both tired and effective.
- 14:51But what's, interesting is that's all happening.
- 14:55This, this, this push, you're right for all this regulation at the same
- 14:57time that on some of the core stuff, like measurement accountability.
- 15:00communicating clearly with parents about performance.
- 15:03That's all going out the window, right?
- 15:05And so, like, you got these two sort of very disjointed, pressures happening,
- 15:11like, basically at the same time.
- 15:13And the ed reform movement, best I can tell, they've sort of fallen
- 15:17under the sway of this idea that, like, test scores are pretty useless,
- 15:21accountability is, , yesterday's news, you don't need this stuff.
- 15:26And okay, maybe, but the problem is there's no, there's, there's certainly
- 15:30no alternative vision to replace it.
- 15:31There's no positive looking, right.
- 15:33Okay.
- 15:33We're not going to do that.
- 15:34We're going to do this.
- 15:35We're going to do, , some other mechanism and historically testing,
- 15:39, really smart testing critics.
- 15:41I would like to say like Ted size would be a good example of that, , just,
- 15:46, credibly wise and thoughtful about it.
- 15:48He was like, Oh yeah, that's why you have to let parents choose.
- 15:50You can't, you're not gonna have tests, but then you gotta let parents
- 15:52like have, have just a lot of choice.
- 15:54They can express.
- 15:55their preferences that way.
- 15:56Like he was very thoughtful and had a vision that was intellectually
- 16:00consistent, focused on equity, all the things you would want.
- 16:03And we don't have that now.
- 16:05We just have none of these measures matter.
- 16:07And so it's just going to further this sort of vacuum we're in.
- 16:10And it's again, it's just interesting relative to this on these other things.
- 16:16We've got this push to like, reregulate as fast as we possibly can.
- 16:19Yeah, I think that we in Charterland have been too associated with
- 16:24the sunset the test crowd.
- 16:26With the kind of the naive belief that if we get rid of this, testing,
- 16:32we're going to get rid of some unfair decision making being made against us,
- 16:36but
- 16:36I think it's actually the exact opposite of that when there is
- 16:39no objective data whatsoever.
- 16:41It basically makes every renewal decision a subjective one, a political one,
- 16:46and, and when people are motivated to, to turn us, turn us down or to
- 16:52deny us to have no objective data in the landscape to build our, our
- 16:57argument around is gonna be terrible.
- 16:59And the other thing, too, is that, like, look at look at Credo's report here.
- 17:02Just, , a couple of years ago.
- 17:04I mean, that is one of the most important stories for charter schools ever.
- 17:07And this this this PPI study that shows that charter schools, , where
- 17:11we have cities where 33 percent or more of the students are served
- 17:15by charter schools, all 10 of them gaps decreasing and boats rising.
- 17:19This is based on data.
- 17:21If we don't have that data, how the heck do we start telling
- 17:23these incredible stories?
- 17:24Right.
- 17:25Well, also, and Parker Baxter's new study in Denver as well, which
- 17:29is very, , student level data.
- 17:31The PPI study, I thought was great.
- 17:33I should, like, as a disclosure, I'm a senior fellow there.
- 17:36I used to work there full time, the, um.
- 17:39The president of PPI, Will Marshall, he's like the lead guitarist in my wife's band.
- 17:43So there is, there is like a lot of, there's a lot of conflicts.
- 17:47Hey,
- 17:47theme
- 17:47music.
- 17:48Ask him for the PPI though.
- 17:50There we go, though.
- 17:50He's like, honestly, I'm scared to ask.
- 17:52He's really into Steely Dan.
- 17:53And I don't know if I could have, team music for our podcast.
- 18:00But we'll see.
- 18:01Anyway, it's a great study.
- 18:03I mean, there is a basic correlation causation thing with
- 18:06it that they can't control for.
- 18:07But I do think what it clearly shows, and it hasn't gotten enough attention
- 18:10is the argument was, if you had lots of public school choice and charters,
- 18:14it was gonna be bad for everybody.
- 18:15And I think you can clearly like, All the districts that, that, Will
- 18:19and Tressa looked at that study.
- 18:21They are like all have substantial, market share of, of charters
- 18:26and bad things haven't happened.
- 18:27Good things have happened.
- 18:28So you certainly even accounting for the correlation causation,
- 18:31why did the good things happen?
- 18:33You can't argue that like having a bunch of charter schools means
- 18:36like a bunch of bad things.
- 18:38And then Parker's study, we can even talk about the substance.
- 18:41The effect sizes are actually unusual for our sector.
- 18:44There's some fast, but it's all, we'll put all this stuff in the show notes.
- 18:49Or we can talk about the politics of it, because what is fascinating to me,
- 18:53I mean, the findings are compelling.
- 18:55Parker did a study a few years ago that you couldn't control for certain things.
- 18:58The school district fought with him about getting student level data.
- 19:02He was finally able to get it.
- 19:03If I, I think I had this right on a, like just a one vote, majority on the
- 19:09board, like they had to fight for it.
- 19:11It's just crazy to get data, to get information.
- 19:13And this isn't like about students, this is anonymized, just data, just
- 19:18information that a researcher could use.
- 19:20I think probably cause they knew what it was going to show.
- 19:23And it shows that like the reforms that.
- 19:27I've been in place for a while.
- 19:29So, , Michael Bennett, Tom Bozberg, Susanna Cordova, like all like
- 19:34fantastic school leaders, that those reforms had a big impact, on student
- 19:40achievement, a big positive impact.
- 19:43And that's after all the blood that was spilled in Colorado
- 19:46around politics for this.
- 19:47And people almost like now kind of throwing in the towel, it's, which
- 19:49is like another one of these cases where we don't wait until we get
- 19:52the results and people give up.
- 19:55But here's the thing with Parker study.
- 19:57Like, that's really substantial information about one particular place,
- 20:00and yet it's gotten almost no attention in the media outside of Colorado,
- 20:04relatively little there, and it certainly hasn't, like, at an elite level in
- 20:09the sector, and you would think, and maybe I'm wrong about this, but I would
- 20:13think if, like, let's say, like, in L.
- 20:14A.
- 20:15or Sacramento, where you are, like, a study came out that there was some
- 20:17intervention, and suddenly, like, Cancer rates, , like, , incidents of
- 20:23breast cancer, incidents of asthma or diabetes had just like gone off a cliff,
- 20:27suddenly just declined precipitously because of some intervention.
- 20:31That the local government had decided to do their people would be like, get
- 20:35out there, figure out what's going on.
- 20:36How do we like, , there'd be there, there'd be a rush to like, figure it out.
- 20:41And there's just so little interest.
- 20:43It's really,
- 20:43it's really remarkable.
- 20:46I wonder if PPI is going to go back and try to make their own control group.
- 20:50Maybe that's something they could do.
- 20:51It's just you can't the correlation causation stuff, whatever.
- 20:54You're never going to get to it at the level that we would want.
- 20:57But.
- 20:57Where is the other side saying, Hey, just leaving the status quo intact
- 21:02over the last 15 or 20 years, we've seen the same results in those 10
- 21:06cities that these other 10 cities that have seen big charter school growth.
- 21:10I'm not aware of Omaha nailing it.
- 21:13, I'm not.
- 21:15Go ahead.
- 21:15I'm sorry.
- 21:16No, right.
- 21:17I was agreeing with you.
- 21:18I mean, I just whatever.
- 21:19I don't tell me what the great story is within a traditional approach to things.
- 21:23And I don't think there is one anywhere.
- 21:25But the thing that
- 21:26I will jump in here that I do think is also just a preponderance
- 21:29of the evidence kind of question.
- 21:30Like, you've got all the credo stuff, like you mentioned, which, which points
- 21:34in one direction And has changed.
- 21:36People still talk about Credo, like the early findings.
- 21:39They don't talk about the continuation, the updated, they, they go from
- 21:42the original credo findings.
- 21:43And what Credo has shown is just a, a steady increase in
- 21:46quality, a whole bunch of stuff.
- 21:48We'll put those in the show notes too.
- 21:50I mean, this is, that's kind of old news, but apparently.
- 21:52Penetrated.
- 21:53Then you've got all these various studies that come out in different ways.
- 21:57, the PPI study showing, , at least for certain, you can say there's
- 22:01not like huge harm being done.
- 22:03The study on, Denver, you've got like, you look at New Orleans where, , So
- 22:10they're doing substantially better than they were before the storm to the point
- 22:14where people are sort of losing that in a relatively high level of improvement
- 22:18because the sort of differences year to year and improvement events have slowed
- 22:21down because they've made progress.
- 22:23And all these places, are they like, , outstanding?
- 22:26Of course not.
- 22:26But they've made like real progress from, , improving
- 22:31their, , their overall performance.
- 22:33And so you can make, make a preponderance of the evidence case
- 22:37that like, okay, if I have, if I'm a policymaker, I have to make a decision.
- 22:39Am I gonna do this or not?
- 22:41Yeah.
- 22:41There's a lot of evidence I should probably do this.
- 22:43And so I don't know that we have, , you can't, if you always wait for the RCT,
- 22:47you can't, like, it limits the range of things you're gonna be able to do.
- 22:50Policy making's about making decisions.
- 22:52By definition, basically on imperfect, incomplete information.
- 22:55It's not social science.
- 22:57It's it's policymaking.
- 22:58And I just think the evidence here, is strong and, , it's frustrating that more
- 23:05people aren't challenged with the face of this plus what you just described, like
- 23:09against this backdrop and context, why aren't we, what are we talking about here?
- 23:14But I don't even think we ourselves talk about it in the right way.
- 23:17I put most of the blame on us.
- 23:18Yes, of course, , the world is distracted.
- 23:21And yes, our adversaries are going to try and, , play whataboutism or whatever.
- 23:26We won't even tell the story ourselves.
- 23:29Did you see in Denver, that Denver families, And rutted, two organizations.
- 23:35I respect a great deal, by the way, and, , boards I agree with and all, all
- 23:39that, but they decide to merge in the LA in the last week and then they announce
- 23:45what their agenda is for the future.
- 23:48And it has no reference whatsoever to the great progress that's been made
- 23:53over the last 15 years, and it has no commitment to, let's do even more.
- 23:58It's, they're pivoting to, let's focus on health and safety and academics,
- 24:04and I'm just like, if there's any place that should just unabashedly be
- 24:08like, we have made incredible progress.
- 24:10And our task now is to build on that.
- 24:13Keep going.
- 24:14No apologies.
- 24:16But that's not what we do.
- 24:18And when our own advocacy organizations won't say the thing, how can we get mad
- 24:24at other people for not saying the thing?
- 24:26I think that's fair.
- 24:27I mean, we talked about some of those.
- 24:30I think there's some interesting stuff there.
- 24:31I have a couple of thoughts.
- 24:32But I do think we've done a bad job and I and, telling the
- 24:37story and I think advocacy, look, philanthropic dollars for drying up.
- 24:41So you're going to see, I think you're gonna see a lot more of these
- 24:42sort of consolidations and mergers and acquisitions and so forth.
- 24:47And not just on advocacy, but in general, but particularly
- 24:50there, the dollars are drying up.
- 24:52People haven't learned the lessons and it is again, it's a little embarrassing
- 24:55to say we're not going to focus on.
- 24:57Academics and improvement right in parallel with the study coming out.
- 25:01The, by the way, Boasberg and, and Michael better, he's a us Senator now, wrote a
- 25:06company paper for it, like saying, , so it's also put in the show notes and , that
- 25:12in the face of all that to say, we're not going to do this is certainly a little
- 25:16embarrassing, but one thing they said that I thought was interesting is that
- 25:19we're not going to be just something to the effect, I'm, I'm paraphrasing the
- 25:22quote, we're not going to be disruptive, we're not going to be showing up at
- 25:25school board meetings and so forth.
- 25:27And I feel like, okay, you and I have talked on this podcast about there.
- 25:30We, we, I think we have like two problems.
- 25:32You and I have talked about the people who, they just seem to want disruption
- 25:34for disruption sake, they want to, they don't, they don't want that.
- 25:38They don't really care as much about better public schools as they do is
- 25:40like sticking it to the teachers unions.
- 25:42Right.
- 25:43Like, so any disruption or acrimony is sort of an end in itself.
- 25:46Not necessarily a means to an end in terms of education improvement.
- 25:50And I don't even mean like they think like we have to, like the teachers unions
- 25:55are in the way of education improvement.
- 25:57That's something I would agree with on a lot of counts.
- 25:58I just think they just don't like the teachers unions and they want
- 26:01them gone and sort of irrespective of whatever that means for schools.
- 26:05So we've talked about those people, the theater, that maybe we
- 26:09should call them the theater kids.
- 26:11And, and then you've also got this other side now, which wants like no acrimony.
- 26:17Okay.
- 26:17No disruption has sort of internalized this idea that any acrimony
- 26:21disruption must be like our fault, rather than sometimes in politics.
- 26:25That's just like, that's how you get things done.
- 26:27That's what happens.
- 26:27And, how to use it constructively and so forth.
- 26:30And so they're sort of saying out of the gate, we're just not,
- 26:33at least as the quotes that I saw, there may be more to it.
- 26:37But what I saw that I was like, well, that's, it's, it's, it's hard to do
- 26:40advocacy if you sort of acquiesce on some of the core tools of advocacy, like
- 26:47right from the jump, that's a problem.
- 26:49And, and by the way, the teachers unions don't do that.
- 26:52They never unilaterally disarm on the contrary.
- 26:54Everything is a constant.
- 26:56debate, battle, negotiation.
- 26:58They never stop and that's why they're good at what they do.
- 27:01Yeah.
- 27:02I think there's a lot of nuance to parse out here.
- 27:06Cause I, I think that, you're right.
- 27:08Just cheap attacks for the sake of attacks.
- 27:12Make the other side look like crap for this, for that, for it's for that sake.
- 27:16Is just, without integrity, without vision.
- 27:20And in the long term, I think ultimately counterproductive.
- 27:23The question, but on the other hand, you'll have people that will
- 27:28say, Hey, can we just, like, do the Rodney King thing and just
- 27:33all get along a little bit better?
- 27:34And hey, can we just agree that we don't care about governance model?
- 27:38All we want are great schools.
- 27:41Well, as soon as you start saying that, though, then the
- 27:44entire critique falls apart.
- 27:46And, , this is where I think we have to get precise and I do
- 27:51think I don't think I'm some kind of genius or anything like that.
- 27:54I think sitting in that seat at CCSA for 10 years and realizing the things
- 28:01that I could say that I could only keep saying until Tuesday versus the
- 28:05next month versus the next year versus the things that I could actually keep
- 28:10saying for my entire duration of time, the things that I could keep saying
- 28:15Those are the places where we should stay anchored to and, and they are ones
- 28:20where you say, look, yes, parents don't care about governance model for sure.
- 28:26For sure.
- 28:27But there's something about the design of the charter school world.
- 28:33That allows educators to be more successful and for the for a lot
- 28:38of the unfairness is that we find in education to be addressed.
- 28:43And all we want is for a landscape such that all educators
- 28:49operate within that landscape.
- 28:52And it's not and as soon as you say, oh, we just love all, , schools,
- 28:59whether they're bad or good.
- 29:00Then when you see these problems in Chicago.
- 29:02Then you see these problems, , in Denver.
- 29:04Then you see these problems in St.
- 29:05Louis, in Milwaukee, all these different places.
- 29:08If you don't think that there's something wrong with the system,
- 29:10what must your criticism be?
- 29:12There must be something wrong with the people, with the people.
- 29:16And I just totally disagree with that.
- 29:19It's just that we're no better as people than they care
- 29:22about kids as much as we do.
- 29:24It's that they, we are operating within a healthier environment and
- 29:28we should want that environment for all educators and for all kids.
- 29:32Yeah, I agree with you.
- 29:33And you said an interesting thing.
- 29:35I just want to double back on.
- 29:36You mentioned Rodney King and this is a little bit of an aside, but I think
- 29:41it goes to this idea like some of this is just generational people like the
- 29:48advocacy fights of the 90s and the 2000s, like the current generation and not
- 29:52necessarily even like burst in those.
- 29:54They weren't And so we have to relearn some of these lessons.
- 29:58And the reason that it made me think of that is, yeah.
- 30:00I remember in 2020 after the murder of George Floyd, you
- 30:04heard people saying nothing like this has ever happened before.
- 30:06This is going to change everything.
- 30:08And like, I was like, if you're of a certain age, you remember the Rodney
- 30:12King episode was, I think, very salient for a lot of people really at that
- 30:16time, young people who now sadly were older people, , in terms of like, just
- 30:20the, the, the issues around policing, the issues around racism in society.
- 30:25And it's very formative.
- 30:27And likewise, it's roughly the same time.
- 30:28The O.
- 30:29J.
- 30:29verdict, which again, shined a lot of light on on to these very different
- 30:33perceptions of the justice system that exists across racial lines.
- 30:37And those were very formative experiences for a lot of people.
- 30:41But when this happened more recently, it was it was as if those things for
- 30:46a new generation hadn't happened, which, by the way, is not their fault.
- 30:48That's obviously like every new generation, right?
- 30:51Has that, , but it's just interesting.
- 30:55I think we're seeing something of the same thing here where the newer generation
- 31:01of leaders and because there's been lots of intergenerational friction and
- 31:04whatever else, and it hasn't necessarily internalized kind of what worked, what
- 31:09didn't work, the lessons there hasn't been sort of a good job of sort of transferring
- 31:12that knowledge and information.
- 31:14And that's a miss.
- 31:16Because you want to essentially, I try to, when I mentor young leaders,
- 31:19I try, I'm like your, your, your role is to go out and make new mistakes,
- 31:23not, not replicate what we made.
- 31:25Right.
- 31:25Learn from ours.
- 31:26Don't make those again, go make new ones.
- 31:28That's what progress, that's what progress is messy.
- 31:31That's what it looks like.
- 31:32And, I think we've done it.
- 31:34We've done a, we've done a poor job of that, which something we've
- 31:37talked about in the past on this podcast that even shows up in like,
- 31:41CMO leadership transitions, which have often been pretty, pretty rough.
- 31:44We've just done, it's just been, there's just been a poor job of that overall.
- 31:49Yes.
- 31:49And let me just stay in the advocacy world, just because that's where
- 31:53I feel like my data is freshest and my understanding is deepest.
- 31:57It's one thing to say, Hey, we want a baton pass.
- 32:00We actually had some things figured out and we've modeled and we've given
- 32:04you some ideas and just take them.
- 32:05Oh, wait a second.
- 32:06You don't understand what the whole educate charter school thing is all about.
- 32:11Isn't that a shame?
- 32:12That's one scenario.
- 32:13The other scenario is we who went first.
- 32:17didn't get it right.
- 32:18We weren't crisp.
- 32:20We, we were not courageous enough.
- 32:24That's what I really do think.
- 32:25Like Brandon, Brandon Brown's piece, that he wrote about Indianapolis.
- 32:30And then I followed up on that.
- 32:32And I know that that post was just insufferably long, but
- 32:35Brandon and I talked about that.
- 32:37And it was just like, look, we want something in the landscape
- 32:41that tells the whole story.
- 32:42From, , 1995 until 2024.
- 32:46And it'll stay fresh for the next three years.
- 32:48We don't have one just write it yet.
- 32:50Okay.
- 32:51In there, Brandon was talking about in 2011 when the mind trust first came
- 32:56out with his ideas for Indianapolis and how the entire system was going
- 32:59to evolve and all that kind of stuff.
- 33:01I mean, it made things worse for two years.
- 33:04It was just really shrill.
- 33:06But then over time, when people saw the common sense of what they were proposing.
- 33:11It just come.
- 33:11And of course, there's ebbs and flows.
- 33:13It gets more controversial, less controversial, but I think a lot of
- 33:16our advocates are intuition is if we say anything that's controversial,
- 33:21the right thing to say in Denver right now is, well, we care about health.
- 33:25We care about safety and we care about academics.
- 33:27Oh, yeah.
- 33:27And everybody like congratulates you.
- 33:29And that's so great.
- 33:31There's nothing that's there that's built to last right?
- 33:34If you have a critique, , so you're, you're, you're
- 33:37rewarded for saying that thing.
- 33:38And then the value of anticipates over time.
- 33:40I feel like those of us that have done this before, , we need to acknowledge
- 33:45we did it wrong and we're handing things over to people and we're saying, oh, it's
- 33:48intuitive what they're supposed to do.
- 33:49And we didn't do it ourselves.
- 33:51But what, however it is, we get this theory articulated
- 33:54for the way going forward.
- 33:55Sure.
- 33:56There's nothing that's more important for us right
- 33:58now.
- 33:58Yeah, yeah.
- 33:59No, that's a, that's a really smart point.
- 34:01We should come back to it.
- 34:02I think it's also hard.
- 34:03We can come back to another podcast.
- 34:04Look, everyone's just scared right now.
- 34:06And that's part of the problem.
- 34:08And it's making everybody timid and, , there's lots of
- 34:12different reasons for that.
- 34:14But everyone's, everyone's scared and nervous and that's a hard, you
- 34:19can't lead, you can't leave like that.
- 34:21And you can't have, you can't have impact like that.
- 34:24But I think when you get data like this from PPI saying that we're
- 34:2710 for 10, I think we should have a greater sense of confidence.
- 34:31Yes.
- 34:32If we say the thing right now.
- 34:34It's going to result in blowback.
- 34:36But when we generate results like this over the long term,
- 34:40it's going to get better.
- 34:42But we, we have to be able to surface, , what our theory of action really is.
- 34:47Yeah.
- 34:47No, I, I, I, I agree.
- 34:49And, and, and certainly you can say the stuff that everybody
- 34:52says it's going to get worse.
- 34:53That's been, again, that's been disproven, which look, politicians
- 34:57are naturally risk averse, right?
- 34:58And so starting with, okay, it's not going to get worse.
- 35:00That's actually not a bad place.
- 35:01Cause they don't want that to happen.
- 35:03On their watch.
- 35:04Yeah,
- 35:05that place to start and then be like, and here's this other evidence.
- 35:09Yeah.
- 35:09And, , as it relates to this, this election right now, I wanted,
- 35:14I wanted to make this point during our election discussion,
- 35:17but I think it fits right here.
- 35:18See what your thoughts are.
- 35:19There's a part of me that just wishes there was no election happening
- 35:24whatsoever, not that I can be happy with the Biden status quo, not that I
- 35:28could be okay with the status quo in California or a lot of other places.
- 35:32But I just feel like right now, at least in charter land, We figured out
- 35:37how to keep making decent progress.
- 35:39And in fact, I would say we're seeing some acceleration right now.
- 35:43And if conditions could just stay this way for another five years or for
- 35:49another 10 years, I think we would see a resumption of momentum in Charterland.
- 35:54But what I worry about is an election that just shakes the can again,
- 35:58such that we're all, , reconsidering whether or not we're on the right side
- 36:02of history or whether we should be.
- 36:05In some way doubting our partners and those kinds of things.
- 36:08Do you have any feelings along these lines or might just,
- 36:11no, it's a great question.
- 36:11And I think one of the, another one of the weird things hidden in
- 36:13plain sight, I think there's this again, people, there's sort of these
- 36:16casual narratives that take off.
- 36:18There's this assumption that, Oh, Trump's a Republican.
- 36:20He's probably for choice.
- 36:22He's been, , in the past he's talked about choice, like, so he'll probably be
- 36:26good for charters and Harris will be bad.
- 36:29And in fact, like the evidence, if you take a look, we have something
- 36:33coming out on this from Bella shortly.
- 36:35Like if you take a look like they've both been pretty bad on it just in different
- 36:40ways I mean don't forget trump proposed to block grant the charter program to
- 36:44states Do you understand anything about how this stuff works and at the state
- 36:48level and all that like that was a dreadful idea he didn't actually do much.
- 36:53He talked he certainly he certainly talked about choice Like if you want,
- 37:01like if you're going to measure by rhetoric, he certainly talked about
- 37:04choice more than any president prior, but he did less on it substantively
- 37:11than Clinton, Bush, Obama, certainly.
- 37:16And, , it's kind of a wash, frankly, with, with, with Biden.
- 37:21He didn't do anything.
- 37:22Yeah.
- 37:23To, to, to really push it.
- 37:24Because, I mean, We don't need to, , get into the litany of reasons why in terms
- 37:28of focus and, and, , everything else, but like he did for whatever reason, he didn't
- 37:32do anything on choice, consequential.
- 37:34And, so it's like, it's out there in plain sight, like, like neither
- 37:38of these outcomes are actually good.
- 37:41For choice and charters, , particularly for charters, which is why I think
- 37:47lots of people, Yeah, I think there's probably relatively few national
- 37:49single issue charter voters, right?
- 37:51Like, , i'm a pretty big supporter of charter schools as , but
- 37:54like I was factoring to my vote.
- 37:57So I think that's another one of these things and it means like how do
- 38:01you reset that because like And and people are looking at this as well.
- 38:04One's better than the other It's actually they're both equally bad.
- 38:06And so if you're an advocate you care about charters You got to figure out
- 38:09How do you navigate in that environment, no matter what happens, here, here,
- 38:13coming up in November and then second.
- 38:15How do we like set the table differently, right?
- 38:19Like it's a little bit like it.
- 38:22I used this analogy recently at a meeting.
- 38:23I'm not sure how well it worked, but it's, it's like a restaurant, right?
- 38:26We're arguing over what should maybe be on the menu and like, should it
- 38:30be like, , fixed price or whatever.
- 38:32We need to be eating in a different restaurant, right?
- 38:35Like all together.
- 38:37Like where did this, where the, the ground we're playing on,
- 38:40we're playing on the ground, the charter opponents want us to be on.
- 38:44And that has, that has to change.
- 38:47I almost want to end it right there.
- 38:48I all I want to do is say, amen.
- 38:50I feel like on the other side of the election, what matters
- 38:53more than anything else.
- 38:54Do we just keep going and are we going to just stay, take, take pot shots at each
- 38:58other now, or are we going to crisper about what we're doing and more convicted
- 39:02within the realm that we actually have influence over in these other realms.
- 39:09And people are going to have to come to the table.
- 39:10Let's end it.
- 39:11I mean, we can end it there and we can come back after we have some, yeah,
- 39:14we'll come back in March when we have some idea of who the president is.
- 39:18We, , look, we can, everybody's going to have to get out of their fields.
- 39:24If Trump wins.
- 39:26like center left left performers.
- 39:28You have to say we cannot just have another four years of
- 39:30nothing happening for kids.
- 39:31We've got to figure out how to move the ball forward.
- 39:34I can't hide behind this excuse that it's so the only thing that's good
- 39:38for kids is saving our democracy.
- 39:40That's a slogan.
- 39:40We got to like, actually, like, how do you get school improvement?
- 39:44And if Harris wins, like these folks on the right, you're gonna have to get out
- 39:47of their fields that Oh, my God, socialism is coming to America or whatever.
- 39:51And, like, figure out, like, How do we push a agenda that is, is good
- 39:57for kids and so far as, as expanding opportunities for families and so
- 40:00forth is concerned in this, in this context, and so everybody's gonna have
- 40:04to like, we can't keep just hopping from election to the next, making up excuses
- 40:09for why we're not getting anything
- 40:10done.
- 40:11So I'll end it with a challenge to you, Andy.
- 40:14I am going to find theme music tackier than you will.
- 40:19I believe, I believe you are.
- 40:20I believe you're up to that.
- 40:23All right.
- 40:24I
- 40:27like it.
- 40:28Great talking to you.
- 40:29I look forward to talking to you next month.
- 40:30Yeah.