Latest / The So What? / Corruption and Consequences
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website jplandman.co.au.
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:36Hello and welcome to another recording to go with JP's latest newsletter.
- 0:42This one is dated the 20th of October 2022, corruption and consequences.
- 0:48It is your annual corruption update if I can put it that way.
- 0:53It's a bit later than usual, why?
- 0:55Yes, normally I do it in August.
- 0:57You're quite right.
- 0:58This year I delayed it because in May the National Director of Public Prosecution, some
- 1:04Shomina Bartoy and the head of the Hawks committed in parliament that they will bring nine high
- 1:11profile arrests, nine high profile cases to the courts by the end of September.
- 1:17So I delayed this note to see what the status was at the end of September.
- 1:23And we start with the Gupta brothers.
- 1:26Absolutely, a month after Ms. Bartoy made that commitment to parliament, the two Gupta
- 1:32brothers were arrested in Dubai on a red notice from Interpol, of course initiated by South
- 1:38Africa.
- 1:39They are kept in jail.
- 1:41They've applied for bail a number of times but they didn't get it.
- 1:45Their extradition to South Africa is now dependent on the court decision in that country in Dubai.
- 1:51The other case, the second case, the big one is the Freda Dairy Project, also known as
- 1:56Estina.
- 1:57They're 17 accused, including a former cabinet minister.
- 2:01Mr. Zwane appeared as accused.
- 2:04They appeared next to two Gupta companies as well as a host of other people.
- 2:09One of the nice juicy parts of this was that Iqbal Sharma, an associate of Mr. Gupta's,
- 2:16who had a very, very high lavish lifestyle in Pretoria, had to spend a few nights in
- 2:21jail before he could get his bail.
- 2:23That must have been uncomfortable.
- 2:25So they've been prosecuted.
- 2:27Zwane stepped aside from his positions in ANC, where he was a senior person, he was a member
- 2:32of ANC, being a former cabinet minister and he's now out of the game, so to speak.
- 2:38Then the other big free state case is the asbestos case, which involves Esh Mahashuleh
- 2:43and 18 other accused.
- 2:45Now the aronical thing here is Mr. Mahashuleh and some of his accused wanted to take the
- 2:53prosecutor on appeal before the court started on certain technical points.
- 2:58They lost in a high court and they're now appealing for those technical points to the
- 3:03appeal court in Blumenbeet.
- 3:05The aronical outcome of that is, as long as the court case is not settled, that takes
- 3:10Mr. Mahashuleh out of any ANC elections, which will happen in December.
- 3:15Then there are three other cases which are interesting because they go back a long time
- 3:20and they're relatively small in state capture terms.
- 3:23Money is still at stake, but the amounts are fairly small.
- 3:28The one is the South African Express case, where people eight years ago in 2014 defrauded
- 3:35the North West government of a 158 million round.
- 3:39The NPA said they specifically took that case, or is bringing that case to court and arrested
- 3:45the people concerned because it has all the elements of a typical state capture case.
- 3:52Then another one, case number five.
- 3:54Sorry, but how did SA Express get involved in North West?
- 3:58Well it was about landing rights for SA Express from, I presume, where I'm able to be important
- 4:04of West, I presume, in my king.
- 4:06I don't know the details of the case.
- 4:08Then a case that goes back even further, 12 years to 2010, is the case of the Winnie
- 4:14Mardikis, the Zellam and the Elam Museum, which was built.
- 4:19A number of people, including two firms of architects, have been arrested and are accused
- 4:24by the NPA of defrauding the state.
- 4:27The amount of money is not a lot, again in the context of state capture, only 700,000,
- 4:32but the symbolic value of the Winnie Mardikis, Elam and Elam Museum speaks for itself.
- 4:38Then the last one, which is case number eight, is quite interesting.
- 4:41It's a former commissioner of police and three former generals in the police force in crime
- 4:46intelligence who have been accused with a number of private sector business people for
- 4:52procurement fraud.
- 4:54The amounts were 33 and 54 million.
- 4:57Aside from the criminal prosecution, what is really interesting is that the SIU, the
- 5:01official investigating unit, have confiscated the assets of these police generals.
- 5:08You will be interested to know that 19 immovable properties in Sant and Pretoria, Boxburg,
- 5:14Springs and Sesselberg were confiscated, as well as 115 vehicles.
- 5:20I can't imagine how one drives around in 115 vehicles.
- 5:24Clearly the high life of the previous police commissioners, as well as those private business
- 5:29people.
- 5:30Clearly their high life is now over.
- 5:32So that gives us six court cases of the nine that the director promised.
- 5:38At Transnet there were some fairly big developments.
- 5:41In total, 10 people that were previously headhunters like Brian Mulafi, who is the CEO and like
- 5:48Anoy Singh, who is the chief financial officer, have been arrested and the 10 of them are
- 5:54appearing caught on a number of corruption charges related to the purchase of locomotives
- 6:01from a Chinese company.
- 6:02We'll have to see how that case goes on the criminal side.
- 6:05On the civil side, we can take comfort from the fact that Transnet and the SIU again were
- 6:11successful in having a contract of 54 billion ram for those 1000 locomotives set aside.
- 6:18The four companies involved in the case, one was Canadian, one American and two Chinese
- 6:24companies refused to provide spare parts to the current Transnet locomotive fleet, as long
- 6:30as there was a dispute about the 54 billion ram.
- 6:34That dispute is now over because the contract was set aside and according to news reports,
- 6:38Transnet is close to finalizing a deal with those four original equipment manufacturers
- 6:44to supply spare parts.
- 6:45The lack of spare parts is one of the reasons why Transnet is performing so poorly.
- 6:53Hopefully, that will help to improve their performance.
- 6:57Then I can just say for the sake of Transnet pensioners that the two Transnet pension funds,
- 7:02the Transnet pension fund as well as the second defined benefit fund have both reclaimed more
- 7:09than a billion ram that were paid to them from Regiments Capital.
- 7:13The Regiments Capital you will know is a good associated company that creamed a lot of the
- 7:19state capture funds.
- 7:21Well it's actually not the only problem that is facing Regiments Capital, not so.
- 7:26Absolutely.
- 7:27Regiments Capital was put into liquidation.
- 7:29They're fighting to get it out, but as they were getting out of liquidation, SARS brought
- 7:34a 700 million ram claim against them and they're not out of it yet.
- 7:38What I find interesting about the SIU Transnet on the one hand and SARS on the other hand,
- 7:44the actions is that it indicates a degree of coordination between different state agencies.
- 7:50I suspect, but I don't know this, Rida, that the Fusion Center, which was created 18 months,
- 7:55two years ago, is playing a very big role in organizing this coordination.
- 8:02That is exactly why this called the Fusion Center.
- 8:04They bring together different law agencies, law enforcement agencies to pursue corrupt
- 8:10people.
- 8:11And there's also been action against another company, Bain.
- 8:14Yeah.
- 8:15Now Bain, way back in 2018, repaid the 164 million ram in fees that they got from SARS
- 8:22for the rubbish advice that they gave there.
- 8:25So that is done and dusted.
- 8:26But what has happened this September is that Bain was banned by the National Treasury from
- 8:31participating in any public sector contracts in South Africa for a decade.
- 8:36Now private companies, of course, can still use Bain if they want to, but they're excluded
- 8:40from all public sector work and that must be quite a blow.
- 8:44Then we turn to Escom and here you say no recent high profile arrests, but one arrest
- 8:51which did catch your eye.
- 8:53Absolutely.
- 8:54Two people that previously worked for the Swiss company ABP, Asiaban Bavieri, were arrested
- 9:00together with their wives, so it's four people and they appeared in court.
- 9:03Apparently what happened is there was a contract between ABP and Escom for 25 million and over
- 9:09time that contract was increased from 25 million to 520 million through what is called variation
- 9:18orders.
- 9:19Now variation orders is a fairly standard thing, but the idea is that it must be justified.
- 9:25And this was clearly not the case.
- 9:26ABP is cooperating with the South African authorities, but they've already repaid 1.6 billion grand
- 9:32to Escom and they've made provision in their latest set of accounts for another 6 billion
- 9:38grand as possible damages for costs related to corruption at the Kusilip Power Station.
- 9:45So we're talking really big money here.
- 9:46Now ABP is a very big international company, been around for a long time and even they
- 9:51were snared in this.
- 9:54And it's very gratifying that they're working with the South African government, but like
- 9:58Payne and like McKinsey and like other companies who had to repay money, well they also had
- 10:05to do that.
- 10:06Now the interesting thing about this case is although the two people that worked at ABP
- 10:11and their wives are not high-profile individuals, they are now in court, they have been charged
- 10:18and the rumors have it or reports have it rather that this contract could be linked to other
- 10:23senior people that used to work at Escom.
- 10:26And you can think of who the names are and hopefully we will see more arrests.
- 10:33So that was a race number 8, not high-profile, but certainly in the race that was being done.
- 10:39Escom is the big area of state capture.
- 10:41I mean the Hawks and the SIU just this week have or gave an overview to parliament of their
- 10:48work, the criminal work and the civil work on Escom corruption and it's a horrifying
- 10:54picture of networks and plain old-fashioned stealing and looting, bomb threatening people
- 11:02and so on.
- 11:03The Hawks are working on something like 55 cases, they already have some 18 cases in
- 11:09court.
- 11:10The SIU on the civil side succeeded in setting aside two contracts for coal supply to Escom
- 11:17worth 10.2 billion a round.
- 11:20These were long-term contracts and they were found to be invalid and set aside.
- 11:24The SIU is also claiming 3.8 billion round from former directors and managers that used
- 11:30to be with Escom as well as a number of private companies.
- 11:33So there's a lot going on at Escom, now they're by proper debt.
- 11:38It just sounds, it was corrupt at every level.
- 11:41It's not only the major big contracts.
- 11:44It's also at individual power stations.
- 11:48Oh no, absolutely, absolutely.
- 11:50And to Tuka power station for example is fingered very prominently but it's not the only one.
- 11:54Yeah, as you say, big fish and small fish.
- 11:57There's one guy who was an Escom employee.
- 12:00He then resigned, he became a supplier and Escom took action against him, fingered him
- 12:06and within a couple of hours after he was fingered he repaid Escom 1.2 million.
- 12:10Now it's not big money and if only all people were that cooperative but it proves your point
- 12:16that some people were small fry.
- 12:18So there's big fry, there's small fry and everybody is frying the consumer.
- 12:23But there is one arrest that you say is puzzlingly going nowhere.
- 12:28Yeah, that is in the first half of 2021, so it's about 15 months ago.
- 12:35Four people were arrested for 1.2 billion a round and each wrote a kusili.
- 12:40It included Mike Lomas who was a prominent South African businessman.
- 12:45He was arrested in the UK along with three people in South Africa.
- 12:49The four of them have been charged last year already and this case is constantly being
- 12:54postponed.
- 12:55It's not progressing.
- 12:56Now part of the postponement was because the defense lawyers, some of them are pulling
- 13:02all kinds of tricks but also because Lomas is still in the UK.
- 13:07He was released by the UK court on a £100,000 bail.
- 13:12It's quite a hefty bail and he's now claiming that he's in ill health and he cannot be extradited
- 13:17to South Africa.
- 13:18So there's a court case about that as well.
- 13:20But the case has again been put on the roll for three November, two weeks down or so and
- 13:27we will have to see whether it actually proceeds.
- 13:29But it's puzzling that an arrest that was made, as I've said, about a year and a half
- 13:34ago, 15 months ago, that that case is not proceeding.
- 13:38And then apart from these high profile cases, the NPA is just generally getting on with
- 13:44the job it sounds like.
- 13:46Absolutely.
- 13:47If you look at the annual report for the last year, which is the year to March 2022, and
- 13:52dealing specifically with corruption, they brought 388 cases to court and they won 344
- 14:00convictions.
- 14:01That's a 90% conviction rate, which is quite good.
- 14:06Interestingly enough, the number of government officials convicted of corruption increased
- 14:11from 86 to 119, 38% increase.
- 14:15But the conviction of people in the private sector for corruption increased by nearly
- 14:1940% from 147 to more than 205.
- 14:25Using all this to the value of 5.5 billion round were obtained by the NPA against many
- 14:31of these accused.
- 14:34Criminal conviction is one thing, getting the money back is a second objective.
- 14:38And it's also, I mean, I think they're doing quite well.
- 14:40And it's interesting to note that in June last year, just after the start of the financial
- 14:46year, more than 800 posts at the NPA were filled.
- 14:51Now that's a lot of people to a point in one go, and clearly the capacity will grow and
- 14:57the ability to prosecute cases will grow.
- 15:00So I think with these, the director promised, of which we have now seen eight of nine, well,
- 15:07I think things are moving also on the criminal case side in the right direction.
- 15:13And the special investigating unit, how's it going there?
- 15:16Very good.
- 15:17They've been on a roll now for about two years, most of the action against corruption
- 15:23came from them.
- 15:24I've written about this before and I've set up their role and their position.
- 15:28In essence, the SIU can only reclaim money via civil action.
- 15:32They cannot prosecute people.
- 15:34They must bring a civil claim and in that way recover money.
- 15:38And their work has been spread out quite a lot via a special tribunal which was created
- 15:44by President Homo Horsan 2019.
- 15:47Now the special tribunal are simply eight judges of the High Court, of the South African
- 15:51High Court in the various provinces.
- 15:54And when the SIU wants to bring a case before them, they act as the special tribunal presiding
- 16:01officer.
- 16:02So the big benefit of the special tribunal is you don't have to go the laborious route
- 16:07of going through the courts.
- 16:09As you know, our court system is very clogged and courts are just bureaucratic, slow and
- 16:16time consuming.
- 16:18This special investigating unit with its special tribunal is capable of hitting much quicker
- 16:23and much faster.
- 16:24Just to bring things together, Zverey McKeezy, the previous Minister of Health, was fingered
- 16:30in the SIU investigation in the digital vibes scandal, 159 million.
- 16:36There was no criminal charges there because of civil claim.
- 16:39Now Mr. McKeezy wants to object to that finding and he has brought the case to the High Court
- 16:46but there's been no finding in the High Court yet.
- 16:48But that's a side issue.
- 16:50The fact remains, the SIU is very active, they're very successful in reclaiming money
- 16:55and although they can't put people in orange overalls, they are reclaiming money, public
- 17:00money for the state.
- 17:03And then leaving the state and the state employees aside for a moment, Stinoff, the big news.
- 17:12Yes, I started writing about Stinoff simply because I think it is such a big story and
- 17:17what's going on there.
- 17:18And just as I finished it and as I send this note off, the news broke that the Reserve
- 17:24Bank got in order to attach 1.4 billion round in assets, that's apparently all the assets
- 17:30the Yoster family has for claims of more than 4 billion.
- 17:35So the Reserve Bank is claiming much more than what is available but it's quite a substantial
- 17:40amount.
- 17:41And this was granted by the High Court in the Cape in September.
- 17:45But that's on the civil side.
- 17:47It's quite interesting to look at what's happening on the criminal side.
- 17:51In June 2020, about two and a bit years ago, the Hawks asked the auditing firm PWC to do
- 17:59a forensic report on the Stinoff case.
- 18:02Apparently the report, according to the head of the Hawks, comprised 31 leverage files.
- 18:08Now they were prosecuted that must work through that.
- 18:12About a year later in July 2021, the Hawks reported to Parliament that they were in the
- 18:18process of collecting 14 witness statements from people in foreign countries, individuals
- 18:26living in Germany, France, Australia and the UK.
- 18:30And the Hawks started what is called mutual legal assistance processes to source 30 foreign
- 18:36bank accounts in foreign countries.
- 18:40And this evidence from the witnesses and the bank accounts and so on will be used to do
- 18:44a final forensic report.
- 18:46The PWC one was a preliminary report.
- 18:49In this July, three months ago, two, three months ago, the Minister of Justice reported
- 18:55in Parliament that the first leg of the Stinoff matter has been finalised.
- 18:59Now precisely what that means, I don't know.
- 19:01Presumably it means that the forensic report is completed and that they can now proceed
- 19:06to build a case on the basis of that.
- 19:08He also said that the South Africa is seeking mutual legal assistance.
- 19:12He didn't say with whom, but I presume it was the Germans, because that's where Stinoff
- 19:17was incorporated.
- 19:19Now it's worth remembering that the Stinoff officers in Germany were raided by the German
- 19:24authorities in December 2015, at the dates.
- 19:28Two years later, December 2017, the Stinoff bomb exploded.
- 19:32It took three and a half years from December 2017 when the bomb exploded for charges of
- 19:38balance sheet fraud to be brought against four people involved with Stinoff.
- 19:45Now the Germans in Germany, yes, the German authorities brought the charges in Germany.
- 19:51Now the Germans have a system in where a court conducts a pre-trial hearing to give an independent
- 19:58opinion on whether there's a good chance of getting a conviction or not.
- 20:02Normally in Germany too, that decision is taken by the prosecutor, but the Germans have
- 20:07got this extra layer of decision making if you want, where the independent court must
- 20:14also give an opinion on that.
- 20:16And the court ruled last year, now exactly a year ago, in October 2021, that the case
- 20:23must proceed against two of the four individuals, and those are two individuals living in Germany.
- 20:28The other two individuals are not identified, presumably Marcus Eustace is one, but that's
- 20:34just speculation, and they will appear in court later.
- 20:39Now at the time of writing this note, which is October 2022, note no further developments
- 20:46have taken place in Germany.
- 20:47So if you think about it, a raid in December 2015, the bomb explodes in 2017, charges
- 20:53brought in 2021, 2022 confirmation that four people must be charged, and then a year later
- 21:01October 2022, and nothing has yet happened in Germany.
- 21:05And I think that speaks to the fact that these cases are complicated, that legal processes
- 21:11take time, and you must either conclude that Marcus Eustace is not guilty, or you must
- 21:17conclude that the Germans are inefficient.
- 21:19And I think those two propositions are both a bit suspect.
- 21:24So legal processes take time, however impatient we may be for attribution.
- 21:32So with all of that said, so what?
- 21:36I think the big so what is, it's clear from the amount of detail that's in the note, that
- 21:43we've seen a step change in South Africa in both criminal and civil prosecution of state
- 21:49people, state capture, mass crimes.
- 21:53The public, the director of public prosecution promised nine cases, we got eight, and clearly
- 21:58a lot more is brewing and bubbling under the surface.
- 22:02Secondly, I think it's important to point out that people that were formerly untouchable,
- 22:07a cabinet minister, secretary general of the running of the ruling party, a commissioner
- 22:12of police, senior generals in crime intelligence, high flying CEOs like Brian Mulafay, these
- 22:21previously untouchable people are now in court as common accused.
- 22:28And it's not something that I think one should just tread lightly over.
- 22:32It is a very good thing that companies are being prosecuted as well, and that companies
- 22:36are also paying the price, some by being charged, others by having to repay money, some
- 22:42by being banned from public contracts.
- 22:45It's a refreshing development because corruption always involves two parties, not just one
- 22:49party.
- 22:50Of course, this does not mean that all the cases will be settled satisfactorily, that
- 22:56people will be found guilty.
- 22:57But if you can have a 70, 80% conviction rate, I think that would be very gratifying for
- 23:04the South African public.
- 23:07And then lastly, we mustn't forget, and Mr. Zuma is a prime example of that, that when
- 23:11you start in defending yourself in legal cases, it drains you.
- 23:16It takes money, it takes energy, it takes focus away, and the more you appear in court
- 23:21and have to go there and so on, the more your status diminishes.
- 23:25And as I've said, I think Mr. Zuma is a prime example.
- 23:28So the fact that people that actually is being taken against people mean that they are beginning
- 23:33to pay a price for what they did.
- 23:36Isn't there also a kind of sea change in the way corruption is viewed?
- 23:45That previously people may have thought, well, you just have to get a contract on the side
- 23:51and nothing will happen, you can just do it.
- 23:55But all of this now means that's not the way South Africa is going to work.
- 23:59I think that's a fair comment.
- 24:02Africa will still work like that for a long time to come, it's a different value system
- 24:07that must take hold.
- 24:08But the fact is these prosecutions help to conceive and give birth and grow that alternative
- 24:17value system.
- 24:18Yes, I think that's a fair comment.
- 24:21Yeah, how do you fight corruption?
- 24:23Well, by fighting it.
- 24:24There's no other way.
- 24:29Thank you for listening to the So What podcast.
- 24:32If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 24:37consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 24:41Also tell your friends.
- 24:43Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.