Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Why Europe Let Constantinople Fall: The Secret Betrayal of 1453
Transcript
- 0:00May 29th, 1453, Dawn after 53 days of siege.
- 0:05The walls of Constantinople, walls that have stood for over
- 0:091000 years, walls that have repelled dozens of armies
- 0:14finally break. Ottoman soldiers pour through
- 0:16the breeches in the streets. Byzantine citizens flee toward
- 0:21Hagia Sophia, praying for a miracle that won't come.
- 0:26By midday, the last Roman emperor, Constantine the 11th
- 0:29Paleolos, is dead, his body lost among the thousands of corpses.
- 0:34By evening, Sultan Mamet the Second enters the city on
- 0:38horseback, rides to the Hagia Sophia and declares it a mosque.
- 0:43The Byzantine Empire, continuation of Rome itself, the
- 0:47civilization that stretched back 2206 years, is finished.
- 0:52But here's what the history books don't tell you.
- 0:55When Constantinople was under siege, the Pope had already
- 0:59written the letter to Sultan Mahmad offering him Rome if he
- 1:03promised not to attack Venice. And Venice knew it.
- 1:08Constantinople didn't fall because superior Ottoman
- 1:11military power. It fell because of betrayal,
- 1:14sabotage, and a catastrophic failure of Western Christianity
- 1:18to defend defend what was claimed was their holiest cause.
- 1:23By the end of this episode, you'll see exactly which
- 1:25Cardinals made which deals, which merchants profited from
- 1:29the Fall, and why every European power except the Pope chose to
- 1:34watch Rome burn. The documents are there, you
- 1:37just have to know where to look. Welcome back to Hidden Forces in
- 1:58History. I'm your host Jeremy Ryan Slate
- 2:01CEO of Command Your Brand. We help our clients to appear on
- 2:05some of the biggest podcasts in the world.
- 2:08Check us out via the link in the description.
- 2:11Remember to like this video, leave us a comment, and smash
- 2:14that subscribe button if you want more Hidden Forces in
- 2:19History. And now our story.
- 2:21To understand why Constantinople's fall was so
- 2:24shocking, you need to understand what this city was.
- 2:29Constantinople wasn't just another medieval city, it was
- 2:32the most fortified urban center ever built.
- 2:36Founded in 330 AD, the sheer defensive genius was embodied in
- 2:40the formidable Theodosian Walls, meticulously engineered triple
- 2:45layered system. Before any army could reach the
- 2:48main defenses, they faced a massive 60 foot wide Moat.
- 2:52Beyond that was the outer wall and finally the true strength,
- 2:57the middle wall, a staggering 40 feet high and equally imposing
- 3:0240 foot high inner wall study with 96 massive towers.
- 3:08The city's survival was rooted in the genius of stone.
- 3:11Any attacker had to cross the Moat, scale the outer wall and
- 3:15fight through the space between the walls, scale the middle
- 3:18wall, fight through another gap, then scale the inner wall, all
- 3:22while defenders rained arrows, rocks, and Greek fire from
- 3:26above. The sea walls protected the city
- 3:29on three sides, and the golden horn was blocked by a giant iron
- 3:34chain. The Byzantines also possessed
- 3:36Greek fire and incendiary weapon that burned even on water.
- 3:41The result? Constantinople had been besieged
- 3:43over 20 times in its history. It had never fallen to a direct
- 3:47assault. The only time Constantinople
- 3:50fell was during the 4th Crusade in 12O four.
- 3:54And that wasn't a military conquest, it was a betrayal from
- 3:57within. By 1453, Constantinople had
- 4:01stood for 1123 years. It was the longest continually
- 4:06inhabited major city in Europe. It was the Eternal City until it
- 4:12wasn't. By 1453, the Byzantine Empire
- 4:15was a shadow of its former self. Under Justinian the First, the
- 4:19empire commanded the entire Eastern Mediterranean.
- 4:23By 1453, all that remained was the great city itself, a few
- 4:28scattered islands and a small territory in Greece.
- 4:32Everything else had been conquered by the Ottomans.
- 4:35The once vibrant cities population had collapsed from
- 4:38half a million souls to a mere 50,000, leaving vast stretches
- 4:42of its city streets quiet and its grand structure sparsely
- 4:46inhabited. Entire neighborhoods were
- 4:48abandoned. Byzantium's final years were
- 4:51shadowed by a crushing economic despair.
- 4:54The Empire was utterly bankrupt, it's commerce strangled by
- 4:58Italian merchants. The treasury was so depleted it
- 5:01could no longer afford the basic upkeep of its legendary
- 5:05defensive walls. Even more tragically, the
- 5:08military had withered to a paltry force of maybe 7000
- 5:13soldiers, most of whom were foreign mercenaries.
- 5:17The political landscape was one of profound isolation.
- 5:21The Great Schism of 1054 had torn the Christian world in two,
- 5:25and the Catholic W saw the Orthodox Byzantines as
- 5:28schismatics, the wrong kind of Christian.
- 5:32Time and again desperate Emperor's pleaded for military
- 5:35aid, with the promise of church reunification as the only
- 5:39bargaining chip. But here's what's crucial.
- 5:42Despite all this decline, Constantinople itself was still
- 5:46clearly impregnable. The walls still stood.
- 5:49A properly supplied in Garrison city could hold out indefinitely
- 5:52against any medieval army. The city didn't need to be
- 5:55strong, it just needed help. And that's where the betrayals
- 5:59began. Understand why the West
- 6:01abandoned Constantinople in 1453.
- 6:05We need to go back to 12 O 4. The 4th Crusade was supposed to
- 6:09retake Jerusalem. Instead it ended with Catholic
- 6:13crusaders sacking Constantinople, the greatest
- 6:16Christian city in the world. The Crusaders needed Venetian
- 6:19ships, but they couldn't pay. Venice, led by the blind Doge
- 6:24Enrico Dondolo, made them a deal.
- 6:27Help us conquer some cities that owe us some money.
- 6:30They attacked the Christian city of Zara, then got involved in a
- 6:33Byzantine succession dispute, installing an emperor who
- 6:37couldn't pay what he promised, so they attacked.
- 6:41In April of 12 O 4, The Crusaders breached the sea walls
- 6:45and initiated A horrifying 3 day frenzy of destruction.
- 6:49They ransacked churches, snatching sacred relics.
- 6:52Libraries were put to the torch. Citizens face murder or
- 6:56enslavement. Even the magnificent Hagia
- 6:59Sophia was desecrated. 1 Byzantine historian wrote.
- 7:03Even the Saracens are merciful and kind compared to those men
- 7:08who bear the cross on their shoulders.
- 7:11The Crusaders carved up the Byzantine Empire, creating the
- 7:14Latin Empire. This was the original sin.
- 7:18From 12 O 4 onward, the Byzantines viewed Western
- 7:21Christians with deep suspicion. The West had proven they'd
- 7:25betray fellow Christians for money and power, and Western
- 7:28Europeans, they've gotten the taste of Byzantine wealth, Many
- 7:33in the West concluded. Why defend Byzantium when they
- 7:37can profit from its fall? By 1453, the two most powerful
- 7:42maritime republics in Europe were Venice and Genoa.
- 7:45Both had massive commercial interests in the Eastern
- 7:49Mediterranean, and both were playing a very cynical game.
- 7:53Venice, the pragmatic merchant, maintained extensive trade with
- 7:57the burgeoning Ottoman Empire. The Ottoman's expansion proved
- 8:01to be a boon for Venetian commerce, dismantling the
- 8:05restrictive Byzantine trade regulations and opening new
- 8:09markets. Venice's strategy was to
- 8:12maintain good relations with whoever controlled the trade
- 8:15routes. If that meant letting
- 8:17Constantinople fall, well, so be it.
- 8:19Genoa controlled the colony of Galeda directly across the
- 8:23Golden Horn. They were Venice's bitter rival.
- 8:27Anything that hurt Venice helped Genoa.
- 8:29If Constantinople fell, Genoa could negotiate favorable trade
- 8:33terms with the new rulers. When Emperor Constantine the
- 8:3611th pleas for aid echoed across the sea, what finally arrived
- 8:40was a pitiful sight. A few hundred soldiers, mostly
- 8:45Genoese mercenaries, and a small handful of ships.
- 8:49Yet with the Italian editor. I'm gonna give that to you
- 8:51again. Yet with the Italian cities
- 8:53supplied in overwhelming abundance was words a torrent of
- 8:58grand empty promises. No major fleet, no significant
- 9:03military force, no coordinated Western response.
- 9:07Why? Well, because Constantinople's
- 9:09fall serve their commercial interests.
- 9:13The calculation was pure commerce.
- 9:16The profit from trading with the Ottomans outweighed any benefit
- 9:20from defending Byzantium, Sultan memed.
- 9:23The second ambition for Constantinople was total.
- 9:26His forces were staggering, estimated to swell between
- 9:3080,000 and 100,000 men, including the elite Janissary
- 9:34Swift, Anatolian cavalry and the finest engineers.
- 9:39Herschel Mmed employed massive cannons, custom built siege
- 9:43Breakers positioned across the land walls to target the weakest
- 9:47sections. The bombardment would be
- 9:50continuous day and night for weeks.
- 9:53He also assembled A colossal Armada of over 400 ships.
- 9:58But he knew the Golden Horn Chain would block access to the
- 10:01harbor, so he prepared something unprecedented.
- 10:05By the dawn of April 1453, the monumental assembly was
- 10:09complete. Every cannon, every soldier,
- 10:12every piece of siege equipment was in position.
- 10:15The stage for history's greatest drama was set inside the
- 10:19besieged walls. Emperor Constantine 11th faced A
- 10:22grim reckoning. His defense was tragically thin.
- 10:27Roughly 7000 souls spread desperately along 14 miles of
- 10:31ancient fortifications. This was barely one lonely
- 10:35defender for every 10 feet of wall against the massive Ottoman
- 10:38host. Constantine's chief asset was
- 10:41Giovanni Justiniani Longo, a Genoese mercenary and one of
- 10:45Europe's finest military engineers, who arrived with 700
- 10:49battle hardened professional soldiers.
- 10:52Constantine granted him command of the crucial land wall
- 10:56defense. Those very Theodosian walls were
- 10:59another stalwart defender, but to endure they were formidable
- 11:03even against cannon fire, and the Byzantines had centuries of
- 11:07experience in repairs. Moreover, the defenders
- 11:10possessed A moral advantage. They were fighting for their
- 11:14homes and civilization, knowing that surrender met in slavery or
- 11:19death. In a final desperate move,
- 11:21Constantine reached out to the West for aid.
- 11:24Constantinople is the shield of Europe.
- 11:26If we fall, the Ottomans will invade Europe itself.
- 11:30Send help. The response?
- 11:33Pope Nicholas the 5th sent a cardinal with 200 Archers.
- 11:36Venice sent a few ships but ordered them not to engage.
- 11:40Genoa sent mercenaries. Hungary, the Holy Roman Empire,
- 11:44France, England, nothing. The West was watching.
- 11:48April 6, 1453 the bombardment begins.
- 11:52Orban's massive cannons open fire.
- 11:55The sound is deafening. The stone balls pulverize
- 11:58sections of the theat ocean walls.
- 12:00The stone that has stood for 1000 years shatters, Towers
- 12:05collapse, breeches open. Every night the defenders worked
- 12:09frantically, hauling rubble to fill the gaping breeches and
- 12:12racing against the dawn. But every day the ominous
- 12:16Thunder sounded again and the once impregnable walls crumbled
- 12:20a little more. The siege wasn't just artillery.
- 12:24The Ottomans pressed relentless, direct assaults.
- 12:27Fresh waves of troops constantly charged and massive siege towers
- 12:32rolled forward. Sappers worked tirelessly to
- 12:35tunnel under the foundations. Each assault is repelled, but
- 12:39everyone can see the math. Attrition favors the Ottomans.
- 12:43They have unlimited troops and supplies.
- 12:46The defenders are exhausted, outnumbered and running out of
- 12:50everything. And then Mehmed plays his
- 12:52masterstroke. April 22nd, 1453.
- 12:56The defenders wake to impossible sight.
- 12:59The Ottoman ships are in the Golden Horn.
- 13:02This should not be possible. The Golden Horn is protected by
- 13:06a massive chain, but they didn't go past it, they went over the
- 13:09land. Mehmed had his engineers build a
- 13:12greased wooden Rd. from the Bosphorus up to the hills of
- 13:17Galeda, then down into the Golden Horn behind the chain.
- 13:21In a single night, 70 Ottoman ships were dragged over land and
- 13:25then launched into the harbor. Now the Ottomans can attack the
- 13:28sea from inside the harbor walls that are weaker because they
- 13:33were never expected to face serious assault.
- 13:36Constantine has to split his already thin forces.
- 13:40The defenders are furious. How did the Ottomans move
- 13:42through Galeda, the Genoese colony, without being stopped?
- 13:47The answer is damning. Genoa let them in.
- 13:50The Genoese colony of Galeda has officially been neutral.
- 13:54They've made a deal with the Med Stay neutral and your colony
- 13:58will be spared. So when the ships are dragged
- 14:01past their walls, Galeda did nothing.
- 14:03The Genoese chose profit over Christianity.
- 14:07This is the first major betrayal.
- 14:10But the most devastating betrayal came from within.
- 14:12In December 1452, Emperor Constantine made a desperate
- 14:16political move. He agreed to the unification of
- 14:20churches. This was the deal the West
- 14:22demanded. The Orthodox Church would
- 14:25reunify with the Catholic Church, accepting papal
- 14:28authority in exchange for Western military aid.
- 14:31The ceremony was held in the Hagia Sophia.
- 14:34Constantine believed this would finally unlock Western support,
- 14:38but inside Constantinople the union was catastrophically
- 14:42unpopular. Orthodox Byzantine viewed this
- 14:45as a betrayal of their faith. Many believed it was better to
- 14:49fall to the Ottomans then submit to Rome.
- 14:52The Byzantine historian Dauchus recorded a popular saying better
- 14:56the Sultan's turban than the Pope's tiara.
- 14:59The memories of the 4th Crusade were long and painful.
- 15:03Many Byzantines believed incorrectly that the West would
- 15:06take the Union, then abandoned them anyway.
- 15:10The Western response to the Union.
- 15:12Pope Nicholas the 5th praised the Union.
- 15:14He issued calls for a crusade and then almost nothing.
- 15:19The union had split Constantinople internally while
- 15:22gaining almost nothing externally.
- 15:25The city was already lost before the final assault.
- 15:28Meanwhile, the Venetian ships in Constantinople's harbor are
- 15:32making their own calculations. Venice officially sent ships to
- 15:35help, but the captains have a secret order preserve the ships
- 15:40at all costs. Their orders were strictly
- 15:42pragmatic. Direct combat was to be avoided
- 15:46in the event that Constantinople's fall became
- 15:48inevitable. Their ultimate instruction was
- 15:50to flee, preserving the valuable ships and their crews.
- 15:54In late April, as the siege intensifies, Venetian captain,
- 15:58start secret negotiation with Memed's representatives.
- 16:03The message If you guarantee our ships can leave safely, we won't
- 16:07interfere with the final assault.
- 16:09Memed agrees. On the night of May 28th, the
- 16:12night before the final assault, several Venetian ships quietly
- 16:16sail away. They don't tell Constantine.
- 16:19They don't tell the defenders. The next morning, defenders in
- 16:23the sea walls realize the Venetian fleet is gone.
- 16:27This is the second major betrayal.
- 16:29The Genoese stay neutral, the Venetians fled, and the West
- 16:33sent prayers instead of armies. Constantinople is alone.
- 16:38May 29th 1453 the final all out assault begins.
- 16:43The massive Ottoman forces charge the shattered land walls.
- 16:46The defenders, led by Justiniani fight ferociously.
- 16:50But Justiniani is wounded and carried to a ship, his removal
- 16:54causing a final, devastating collapse of morale, Then a
- 16:58shocking mistake. The Kirkaporta Gate, a minor
- 17:01gate used for sorties, is found unlocked.
- 17:04A group of Janissaries pushed through, and suddenly Ottoman
- 17:07troops are inside the walls. They raise the Ottoman banners
- 17:11on the tower. Hannock spreads.
- 17:14The walls are breached. The Turks are inside.
- 17:17Emperor Constantine the 11th sees the Ottoman banners.
- 17:21He tears off his imperial regalia and charges into the
- 17:24battle with his remaining bodyguards, fighting as an
- 17:28ordinary soldier. His last recorded words.
- 17:32The city has fallen and I am still alive.
- 17:34He disappears into the melee. His body is never definitively
- 17:39identified. The last Roman emperor dies
- 17:41fighting in the streets of his capital.
- 17:44By dawn, Ottoman troops control the city.
- 17:47Med has promised his troops 3 days of plunder.
- 17:50What followed was a savage nightmare.
- 17:53Homes, churches and monasteries were systematically ransacked.
- 17:57Every glittering object was snatched up. 10s of thousands of
- 18:01the city's citizens were brutal, enslaved, torn from their
- 18:05families and herded towards the slave markets.
- 18:09Thousands of citizens flooded into the colossal Hagia Sophia,
- 18:13seeking refuge, their collective prayers a desperate plea for
- 18:17divine intervention that would never come.
- 18:20It doesn't come. Ottoman soldiers break down the
- 18:23doors. They kill those who resist and
- 18:25enslave the rest. The great church is defiled.
- 18:29After three days, Mahmed enters the city officially, and he
- 18:32rides to Higuia Sophia and orders it converted to a mosque.
- 18:36A moisin calls the Islamic call to prayer.
- 18:39For the first time, Mahmed declares himself Kaiser E Rome,
- 18:44the Caesar editor. I'm gonna give that to you
- 18:46again. Mahmed declares himself Kaiser
- 18:49I, Rome, the Caesar of Rome. In his mind, he hasn't destroyed
- 18:53the Roman Empire, he's conquered it and become its new emperor.
- 18:57Constantinople survives, but as an Islamic city, capital of a
- 19:01new empire, the Byzantine Empire is finished.
- 19:05So why did the West abandoned Constantinople in its hour of
- 19:08need? The simple explanation is that
- 19:10the fragmented Western world was too entangled in its own
- 19:14squabbles to rally effectively. But that's not what the evidence
- 19:18shows. The West didn't fail to save
- 19:21Constantinople. The West chose not to save it.
- 19:24The shocking truth was a cold, calculated commercial betrayal.
- 19:28Venice in Genoa had the naval strength to potentially save the
- 19:32city, but both made a purely economic decision.
- 19:36Ottoman victory was more profitable than Byzantine
- 19:38survival for Venice. The calculus was simple and
- 19:41brutal. A strong Ottoman Empire was a
- 19:44powerful and crucially negotiable partner that would
- 19:48open vast new markets. They swiftly negotiated
- 19:51favorable terms of Ahmed, securing continued access to
- 19:55Constantinople's markets and extensive trading privileges.
- 20:00Genoa ensured the survival of its colony of Galata by
- 20:03declaring it neutral. They negotiated similar trade
- 20:07privileges, benefiting from the elimination of restrictive
- 20:11Byzantine trade regulations. They bartered their silence and
- 20:15an action for peace. The Italian maritime republics
- 20:18made a devastating choice of finance over faith.
- 20:21There was simply more profit to be made trading with the rising
- 20:25Ottoman power than in expelling resources to defend the dying
- 20:29Byzantine Empire. The roots of Constantinople's
- 20:32isolation ran far deeper. 4 centuries had passed since the
- 20:36Great Schism. The Catholic W viewed the
- 20:39Orthodox Byzantines as theological adversaries,
- 20:44schismatics, and heretics. This religious contempt, already
- 20:48proven in the 12 O 4 sack, fueled to be.
- 20:52Editor, I'm going to see you again.
- 20:53This religious contempt, already proven in the 12 O 4 sack,
- 20:57fueled A prevailing Western sentiment.
- 21:00Byzantium was not truly Christian in the correct
- 21:02Catholic sense and therefore not worth defending at great cost.
- 21:07Furthermore, Western Europe was caught in a paralysis of
- 21:11self-interest and exhaustion. France and England had barely
- 21:15concluded the brutal 100 years war.
- 21:18The Holy Roman Empire was a political mosaic of incapable
- 21:22unified action. The Christian Kingdom of Spain
- 21:25was focused entirely on the Reconquista.
- 21:29Only Hungary understood the true gravity of the threat, but could
- 21:32not stand alone. The harsh truth was, for the
- 21:35great powers of the West, Constantinople was a foreign
- 21:39concern. They saw no vital national
- 21:41interest in its defense. To let it fall was the silent,
- 21:45pragmatic consensus. The most catastrophic error was
- 21:49the collective belief that Constantinople's fall wouldn't
- 21:52fundamentally threaten the West. They believe the Ottomans would
- 21:56be satiated. But they were tragically wrong.
- 21:59Constantinople's conquest was a devastating accelerator.
- 22:03Within a mere 70 years, the Ottomans laid siege to Belgrade,
- 22:08invaded Italy, crushed Hungary, and twice reached the gates of
- 22:12Vienna. The Ottoman Empire became the
- 22:14dominant power in the Mediterranean and Eastern Europe
- 22:17for the next 250 years. The West sacrificed
- 22:20Constantinople for short term commercial and political gain
- 22:25and paid for it with centuries of Ottoman military pressure on
- 22:29Europe. So what does Constantinople's
- 22:31fault teach us about how power really works?
- 22:34Well, Lesson 1 is the commercial interest.
- 22:37Trump religious solidarity. Venison.
- 22:39Genoa chose profit. The chilling pattern repeats
- 22:42itself throughout history. When vital allies are coldly
- 22:46abandoned, it's often on the Ledger of commercial
- 22:49convenience. Lesson 2 is the time to build
- 22:52your bridges is long before the enemy arrives at your gates.
- 22:56The religious schism drove a cultural chasm.
- 23:00When Emperor Constantine finally and agonizingly agreed to the
- 23:04union, it was a hollow gesture made under duress.
- 23:08It was too late. Lesson 3 is that neutrality is
- 23:11often complicity. The Genoese of Galeda declared
- 23:15neutrality. They were not fighting for the
- 23:17Sultan, they simply weren't stopping him.
- 23:20Their neutrality became a constant low humming betrayal.
- 23:24The inaction in the face of evil is merely a silent form of
- 23:28complicity. Lesson 4 is that walls are
- 23:31worthless without will and allies.
- 23:34The strongest fortress is only as secure as its defenders.
- 23:37The city's collapse came not from a breach of its massive
- 23:41stone bulwarks, but because a gate was left ajar.
- 23:45All the strength of the fortifications became utterly
- 23:48worthless because one critical entrance failed.
- 23:52Physical defenses cannot compensate for a lack of
- 23:55political unity and reliable friendships in the aftermath.
- 23:59Historians love to label Constantinople's fall as
- 24:02inevitable. They point to overwhelming
- 24:05military superiority and historical forces.
- 24:08But to call it inevitable washes away the bitter taste of human
- 24:12failure, betrayal, and missed opportunity.
- 24:15It wasn't inevitable. It was choice.
- 24:18The West chose commerce over solidarity.
- 24:21Genoa chose neutrality over Christianity.
- 24:23Venice chose profit over alliance.
- 24:26Constantinople fell because powerful actors decided it was
- 24:30more convenient to let it fall, and afterwards they called it
- 24:33inevitable. May 29th, 1453.
- 24:36The date that ended the Roman Empire 2206 years after it
- 24:41began. The date that opened Europe to
- 24:43centuries of Ottoman expansion. The date that proved religious
- 24:47solidarity means nothing when commercial interests point the
- 24:51other direction. The mighty walls of
- 24:52Constantinople did not crumble simply because of the Ottoman.
- 24:57The city's doom was a slow, self-inflicted wound, a tapestry
- 25:02woven from avarice, religious schism and short sightedness.
- 25:06Venice in Genoa, those great maritime republics, saw not a
- 25:11bastion of Christendom, but a lucrative opportunity.
- 25:14They chose the immediate, tangible profits of trade with
- 25:18the Ottomans over the abstract principle of defending the East.
- 25:22Even more devastating was the profound chasm between the
- 25:26Catholic West and the Orthodox E When Constantinople cried out
- 25:30for aid, the West, still nursing the wounds and bitterness of
- 25:34past ecclesiastical disputes, turn to deaf ear, effectively
- 25:38abandoning their spiritual brethren to siege.
- 25:41Compounding this external neglect was the cancer of
- 25:44internal division when it gnawed at the city's ability to mount a
- 25:47unified and spirited defense in the shadows.
- 25:51The seemingly innocuous stance of neutrality provided the
- 25:55perfect cover for outright betrayal, allowing vested
- 25:58interest to prioritize self preservation above the city's
- 26:02survival. In the end, the defenders and
- 26:04their so-called allies were undone by their own fatal flaw,
- 26:08the disastrous habit of making short term calculations that
- 26:12completely ignored the irreversible, devastating
- 26:15consequences that awaited them just beyond the horizon.
- 26:19The shocking truth behind Constantinople's fall isn't
- 26:22about military technology or historical inevitability.
- 26:26It's about cynical calculations by powerful actors who decided a
- 26:30Christian city's destruction serve their interests better
- 26:34than survival. And the pattern repeats.
- 26:37The chilling pattern repeats itself.
- 26:39Throughout history, you witnessed the moment when the
- 26:42vital allies are coldly abandoned, not on the
- 26:45battlefield of principle, but on the Ledger of commercial
- 26:48convenience. You see a fervent religious or
- 26:52ideological solidarity tossed aside.
- 26:55It's worth outweighed by the promise of greater profit.
- 26:58A policy of neutrality is declared.
- 27:00Get this calculation editor. I'm going.
- 27:02To get this again. Policy of neutrality is
- 27:05declared, yet this calculated inaction only serves to embolden
- 27:10and enable the aggressor. And finally, the terrible truth.
- 27:14What is later sold to the world as inevitable was in fact a
- 27:18series of deliberate self-serving choices made by
- 27:22those who serve to gain the most.
- 27:24Remember Constantinople. Remember that the Italian
- 27:27merchants kept trading. Remember that the Pope issued
- 27:30prayers instead of armies. Remember that Genoa stayed
- 27:34neutral while ships were dragged past their walls.
- 27:37Remember that the West sent prayers instead of soldiers.
- 27:41The walls of Constantinople stood for 1123 years.
- 27:46They survived Persians, Arabs, Avars, Bulgars and the Ruse.
- 27:50They fell in 53 days, not because they were weak, but
- 27:53because the people who should have defended them chose not to.
- 27:57Today, Istanbul thrives as one of the world's great cities, a
- 28:01bridge between Europe and Asia, a testament to resilience and
- 28:05reinvention. The Hagia Sophia still stands,
- 28:08converted back to a mosque in 2020 after decades as a museum.
- 28:13Tourists walk the Theodosian Walls, now crumbling monuments
- 28:17to a lost empire. But the lessons of 1453 remain
- 28:20urgent. When commercial interests
- 28:22conflict with stated values, commerce usually wins.
- 28:27When allies are needed most, they're often nowhere to be
- 28:30found. When powerful actors call
- 28:32something inevitable, ask who benefits from that narrative.
- 28:37Constantinople's fall wasn't a tragedy of military technology
- 28:40or historical forces. It was a tragedy of betrayal,
- 28:44calculation and the cold mathematics of power.
- 28:48The Byzantines knew it. As they watched Phoenician ships
- 28:51sail away on May 28th, as they saw Genoese Galada refused to
- 28:55help, as they waited for Western armies that never came.
- 28:59They understood they've been sacrificed not to Ottoman
- 29:03strength, but to Western convenience.
- 29:06That's the shocking truth behind Constantinople's fall.
- 29:10If this story revealed something that you didn't know about one
- 29:13of history's most pivotal moments, hit that subscribe
- 29:16button. We investigate the hidden forces
- 29:19behind history, the betrayals, calculations and power plays
- 29:23that textbooks leave out. The patterns repeat.
- 29:26The question is, are we paying attention?
- 29:29This has been hidden forces in history.
- 29:31I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, and I'll catch you next time.