Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Sex Worker Therapist, Breadcrumbing, Objectophilia, and Cognitive Dissonance
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. Today, I thought I would answer some of your
- 0:03emails. Anonymous patron wrote in and they said, hey, doctor Kirk,
- 0:07what are your thoughts on being a sex worker or making porn before becoming a
- 0:12therapist. I have tried to come up with solid cons that might throw a
- 0:17wrench in my future as a therapist, but I do want to hear from
- 0:21a well seasoned therapist and supervisor such as yourself and of email. Well,
- 0:27the first thing I'll say is there's absolutely nothing wrong obviously with having been in
- 0:33sex work or in making pornography content and then later becoming a therapist. In
- 0:40fact, you might have learned a lot of skills from that previous profession that
- 0:45translate and help you as a therapist, like being a good listener or accepting
- 0:51sexual variety. Every therapist has a life before they were a therapist, and
- 0:57all have pros and cons. You know. For example, some therapists go
- 1:02directly from their bachelor's degree directly into their graduate program at the age of twenty
- 1:08two, and the pro to that is that because they're young, they have
- 1:14a lot of time to grow a lot of humility because they don't feel like
- 1:19they know very much, yet they might be willing to work for less in
- 1:23the beginning of their career, so they're less dissatisfied with entry level work in
- 1:30the field. So those are some pros. And con though is that you
- 1:34don't have very much life experience under your belt, so when you are in
- 1:40class talking about relationships or parenting or early development or something, it could be
- 1:47a con and I would experience that as a professor. Most of the students
- 1:52in my program were in their thirties forties. There were students in their twenties,
- 1:59for sure, but Antioch University markets itself toward continuing learners, towards adult
- 2:06learners, people who are maybe on their second third career kind of a thing.
- 2:10So most of my students weren't like that, meaning that they had a
- 2:15lot of life experience and it did help them they could call upon their own
- 2:21experience to help them in understanding other humans. A big part of empathy is
- 2:25actually going through life and experiencing a lot of things yourself, such that when
- 2:30you see someone else going through a similar situation, you don't have to necessarily
- 2:36have a long conversation with them to know how they might feel. You don't
- 2:39know how they how they'll feel about it. But you have some ideas,
- 2:44so you know there's pros and cons that, and you know, being a
- 2:47sex worker or being a porn content provider is no different than any other background.
- 2:53There's pros and cons the pros and it depends on what sort of work
- 2:57you might have done. But like I said, sending skills might be enhanced
- 3:00prior to entering the field of therapy. You might have small business skills.
- 3:05If you plan on going into private practice, you might be comfortable with all
- 3:10the ins and outs of working one on one with someone. You know a
- 3:14lot of what it is to be a therapist. A lot of what you
- 3:16learn about how to be a therapist has to do with on the job learning.
- 3:22You can read a lot of books, you can attend a lot of
- 3:23classes, you can write a lot of papers, you can be in a
- 3:28lot of discussions, you can do a lot of role plays in class,
- 3:30but nothing compares to actually sitting down with an actual human being who is asking
- 3:35you for help. There are so many nuances to the way in which you
- 3:38even just say hello at the beginning of a session. There's so many little
- 3:44things that have to do with coming across to someone in the way that you
- 3:47want to in the way that you know, depending on your style of therapy,
- 3:52So working one on one with people to becoming a therapist at any job,
- 3:58sex work or otherwise, you know, right, help Also professionalism,
- 4:01if you had to be professional with your clients, with your paying customers and
- 4:09having boundaries with them, that might help as well. Sex positivity I'm guessing
- 4:14you ascribe to that absolutely can help, and not only just with sexual issues,
- 4:18but just oppressed groups in general. Right, you know what it's like
- 4:23for people to feel bad about themselves for something that is innocent, like a
- 4:27fetish or something. And there's a lot of things in our society in which
- 4:31clients will feel bad about themselves for innocent things like the color of their skin.
- 4:36Also, you might have a greater capacity for acceptance of others and not
- 4:42ascribing to stigmatization of groups of people. I don't know that about you,
- 4:46but you know it's possible. Cons And the most obvious one is that some
- 4:50therapy clients in the future, or colleagues, professors, co workers, know
- 4:56other therapists. They might discover that you previously did this sort of work,
- 5:00and it could be an issue for some people for sure. If someone was
- 5:04in therapy with you for a few years and suddenly they come across your previous
- 5:11porn content or something, they might be thrown into a downward spiral of some
- 5:16sort where they're just like, wait, what what's going on? I don't
- 5:19understand and it might completely change their view of you, that kind of thing.
- 5:24So you know that's a risk. But being a sex worker is no
- 5:28different from any other profession profession, right, or any other detail about our
- 5:31lives. For example, if your trans and your clients don't know about that,
- 5:40and then suddenly they're googling you online and they discover that you're trans,
- 5:45and all of a sudden, they're like, wait, my client isn't the
- 5:48gender that I thought that they were in their heads, this is what they're
- 5:50thinking, of course, and they might freak out. Now, plenty of
- 5:55people won't freak out. It depends on the community you're in. In my
- 5:58neck of the woods in Seattle, I'm guessing the vast majority of people,
- 6:01particularly younger people, wouldn't care about either one of those issues. In fact,
- 6:05it might even enhance their idea of you. But in other communities it
- 6:10could be a huge deal. It could really be hard for some people.
- 6:14Having said that, you could decide to lean in. I don't know what
- 6:16your plans are, but when you start to practice, you could actually lean
- 6:20into your history and actually advertise yourself as a sex positive therapist, maybe even
- 6:26specialize in that sort of thing, and maybe even as a part of your
- 6:30bio. You would talk about your previous life and you would just be out
- 6:34there, and then clients that don't want to talk to a therapist with that
- 6:39background will weed themselves out, will screen themselves out, and people who do
- 6:43definitely want to talk with some of them like you, will seek you out
- 6:46and know about you and know that prior to even working with you, you
- 6:50would have boundaries about it and term whatever your boundaries you wanted to within the
- 6:57therapy office. But you know, there's different things that you can do,
- 7:00like I for example, one example that I think about sometimes it is related
- 7:06to this in my life, is that I am you know, I'm I'm
- 7:13so funny that I have It's like I feel like I shouldn't say these things.
- 7:17But when I take tests on my political leanings, one of the categories
- 7:23that I will be labeled as a progressive liberal, meaning that I believe in
- 7:30liberty. I believe in compassion for the poor, for the homeless, for
- 7:35oppressed peoples, and that the traditions of our society should be questioned heavily because
- 7:43a lot of them are oppressive and favor straight white males, And so I
- 7:47want people to feel comfortable with their religion or lack of religion, with whatever
- 7:54gender they are. And I also am in favor of raising taxes to help
- 7:59pay for the underprivileged, for the disabled, for people who are suffering,
- 8:05people who have maybe suffered from trauma and then developed a drug addiction and they
- 8:11need some money to get them a house so they can get back on their
- 8:13feet. You know, That's what a progressive liberal is, and that's how
- 8:18I identify, and it's in my language sometimes. Obviously, just saying it
- 8:22outright on a podcast puts it out there, But in the past I wasn't
- 8:28quite as disclosing about that on the podcast. So the place where people would
- 8:33see those kinds of indications were apparently on disclosure statement that I would give to
- 8:39clients as they would sign up for therapy. The disclosure statement has a bunch
- 8:43of disclosures that clients need to know about and be informed about in order to
- 8:48sign the informed Consent form, and so on this form it talked about how
- 8:52I was LGBTQ friendly something like that, and I had a client who sat
- 8:58down to my couch and he said, well, before we get started,
- 9:01I just want to ask about something because I see in your disclosure statement that
- 9:05you say you're LGBTQ friendly, and I'm guessing you must be liberal or a
- 9:09Democrat or something, and I want to tell you that I am in finance.
- 9:16And I don't know if he said he was a Republican or not,
- 9:18or a conservative or whatever, but I think mainly because he worked in banking,
- 9:24he thought that I would stigmatize him. And it's not unreasonable for him
- 9:28to think that even back then, I think, particularly now given the political
- 9:33divide and the culture wars, but you know, it was still present ten
- 9:37years ago, and I had to soothe his fears, which wasn't hard to
- 9:45do because I don't have negative associations with bankers or conservatives or Republicans. Therapists
- 9:54have to look past those things and to the individual. These ideas, these
- 10:01political leanings, or these contexts are a part of people's lives, and it's
- 10:05a part of my life as well, just outside of the office, but
- 10:11at least the way that I see the professions as a therapist, the therapy
- 10:16is so much more sacred and dear to me and important to me. It
- 10:22goes way beyond whatever sort of political leanings or how you know what sort of
- 10:26candidates you vote for in November. The human being that is present in my
- 10:31office is so much deeper and richer than anything any sort of political identification could
- 10:39summarize. So I've had that experience where I've had to blay someone's fears,
- 10:43and that wasn't very complicated. And maybe if you had a client that discovered
- 10:50you or a sex worker in the past, you might have to spend a
- 10:52little bit more time, but it can be done. You can just say,
- 10:56oh, okay, so you discovered that you might have a you would
- 11:01talk about this with your supervisor, or you would just develop a sense of
- 11:05what you would say prior, because you don't want to be caught off guard.
- 11:09And so you have a general idea of the bullet points that you hit
- 11:11upon, or the sort of questions you might ask, or the goal you're
- 11:15trying to get to, and so you might just begin a conversation and just
- 11:20say, so, what was it like when you came across that? You
- 11:24might say yeah, you know, depending on your policy, you might say
- 11:26yeah, when I started I as a therapist, I decided to leave that
- 11:31life behind me. I don't do that anymore. And in case you're wondering,
- 11:35not that there would be anything wrong with that, but I just want
- 11:37to focus on being a therapist right now. And I wondered what would happen
- 11:41if a client came across it. I'm not ashamed of it, and it's
- 11:46fine that you came across it, and you don't have to tell me anything
- 11:50more, but you can certainly tell me more if you want to. There
- 11:52are boundaries here, of course, but you know, you're free to have
- 11:54whatever feelings that you have, whether it's sexual or whether you were or disgusted
- 12:01or whatever. You know, whatever feelings you have, it's fine. You're
- 12:03in a therapy office, and I knew this might happen. It doesn't happen
- 12:07very often, but you know it's happened before, and so here we are.
- 12:11You know, if you don't want to work with me anymore, that's
- 12:15completely up to you. But I don't think that there's anything about my past
- 12:20that interferes with your treatment, and I want you to feel as safe as
- 12:24possible, though, So what sort of questions do you have or do you
- 12:28want to talk about it or you know, you enter into conversation and not
- 12:33only is it fine, and not only can you repair any potential rupture there,
- 12:37but it could be really elevating to the therapy, you know what I
- 12:41mean, could really provide a rich landscape to explore with a client, not
- 12:48only in their life, but also the issues between the two of you if
- 12:52you do that kind of work all right. This next email is from middle
- 12:56tier patron Nadine. She says, Dear doctor Kirk Honda, I've recently looked
- 13:03through my boyfriend's following list on Instagram and found out that he is following erotic
- 13:11models. He was following erotic models on Instagram. I got really upset and
- 13:16told him about it, and he unfollowed them. Yet it still upsets me.
- 13:20Ever since then, I feel extremely insecure in the relationship and I have
- 13:26extreme anxiety twenty four seven, to the point that I just lay in bed
- 13:28paralyzed all the time. I'm extremely monogamous and it's really hard for me to
- 13:33understand why someone would want to see sexual content just while casually scrolling every day,
- 13:41just jamming in here. Yeah, it sounds like you feel cheated on.
- 13:46It's hard to say if that's true or not. It depends on your
- 13:48agreement. If you had in your relationship an agreement, whether it was spoken.
- 13:54You know, sometimes you can have these sort of unspoken agreements where it's
- 13:58pretty clear what the bounds are hard to know. But if it's reasonable that
- 14:03he should have known that he shouldn't be doing that, or that if he
- 14:07did do that it would hurt you, then that is you could argue a
- 14:13form of infidelity or maybe some kind of trust violation, right because if it
- 14:18was an expectation that he knew that you had and he didn't talk with you
- 14:24first and you came across it, then you know, even if it was
- 14:26just something else, like you had drawn a boundary around not spending a certain
- 14:31amount of money when he goes to the casino or when he's out with his
- 14:35friends, and he instead decides to go against that agreement without talking with you
- 14:41and he spends more money than that's a trust violation because you know, relationships
- 14:46are based on trust, and when that is violated. It it's really hurtful
- 14:52and painful and worrisome because then you're like, well, can I trust this
- 14:56person with anything? So it sounds like that's what's happening, but you know,
- 15:01it really depends on what the agreement was. There's another possibility that he
- 15:05didn't know that this was not okay with you, or he thought that it
- 15:13would be okay as long as you didn't come across it or something. You
- 15:16know, a lot of relationships will have these kinds of agreements, whether they're
- 15:20spoken or not, that it's okay for each individual to fantasize or look at
- 15:26pictures as long as the other person isn't there or something like that, or
- 15:28masturbate. So, you know, it just a lot depends on the agreement,
- 15:33and couples range from one end of the spectrum to the other and all
- 15:37of it is okay. It just depends on what your preference is, right
- 15:41and also talking about it. Now there's a debate though, because say,
- 15:46for example, for you, you really do not want him looking at any
- 15:50kind of pornographic or erotic material and you do not want him masturbating. Well,
- 15:58he could counter that by saying, you don't have the right to control
- 16:02what I look at, what I think about, and you don't have the
- 16:04right to control my body and whether or not I masturbate. So you know,
- 16:08these things should be discussed early in a relationship so that everyone's on the
- 16:12same page. And maybe some of these things could be deal breakers for a
- 16:17relationship. You know, these are values that need to be ironed out and
- 16:22agreed upon or agree to disagree, but also love each other anyway, right,
- 16:26But you know, some of these things can be deal breakers. So
- 16:29I don't know what's what's going on here. A lot depends on that.
- 16:33And the second thing I'll say is it seems to be triggering to you.
- 16:37I don't know, you would only be able to say yes or no to
- 16:41this, but it's seemingly triggering for you to consider that he would be attracted
- 16:45to someone else. And if that's true, then I would explore that in
- 16:48detail. I wouldn't necessarily just say that it's wrong, because you know,
- 16:53there's a lot of stigma around this and a lot of weird notions in our
- 16:59society or various different societies that somehow if someone is in a committed relationship,
- 17:04a monogamous committed a relationship and they have an attraction to someone else, someone
- 17:10else, then that means that they're not really in love with the person,
- 17:12or they're going to cheat on the person, and that is just simply not
- 17:15true. The data demonstrates that the vast majority of people in good, committed,
- 17:21value oriented relationships will be occasionally, if not frequently, attracted to other
- 17:26people. It just depends on what you do with it, right, and
- 17:29do you entertain it, and what's the agreement between the two people, and
- 17:32how do you talk about it and what does it all mean? For example,
- 17:36I might ask you nating, have you never been attracted to anyone else?
- 17:41Ever? Like now, maybe you haven't. You know that that is
- 17:45certainly possible, but it's not likely. It's much more likely that you've been
- 17:51attracted to somebody. Now you might not have been, shall we say,
- 17:55in the groinal region attracted, you know, meaning that you're not sexually turned
- 18:00on. But you might have a crush on someone. Or you might have
- 18:03an actor or someone at work, or someone that you see on Instagram where
- 18:07you're just like you linger a little longer on their picture, or you go
- 18:12down a rabbit hole of like looking up you know, you see someone on
- 18:17Instagram and you click through their profile and you're looking at things you know,
- 18:21have you has that never happened to you before? Because if it has,
- 18:25which I'm guessing it has, does that mean that you're a terrible person?
- 18:29Does that mean that you're not really in love with your husband? Does that
- 18:33mean that you're going to cheat? I'm guessing you would say no. Now,
- 18:36I don't want to put thoughts in your head. So maybe that has
- 18:38never happened to you, but you know that would be something to explore because
- 18:42that would help. Now, the other thing I'll say is, I don't
- 18:45know what's up with him with your husband. There's a chance that he's shady,
- 18:48that he's up to no good, that he has been cheating. I
- 18:52don't know. I don't want to put that out there because it sounds like
- 18:55that might trigger you. But you know, there's no way for me to
- 18:57know what's really happening in so I want to value that your anxiety or your
- 19:03pain, you know, it might be reflective of reality. But there's a
- 19:07chance that if you really explore things in yourself and in your relationship end with
- 19:11him in an open, accepting way, that you might be able to alleviate
- 19:15your fears and your pain and actually expand the two of your lives. Now,
- 19:22maybe you don't want to expand your lives, but you know, I'm
- 19:23just saying it's possible. So I want to be clear that if after,
- 19:29for example, you do twenty years of therapy, because it could take that
- 19:33long exploring all these things. You know, what traumas do you have around
- 19:37sexuality, what messages have you internalized regarding erotic content or around sexuality in general.
- 19:42This can take literally twenty years plus of therapy, at least a good
- 19:48couple of years, depending on how much development in terms of your sexual awareness
- 19:52and awakening that you've had prior. So you know that could take a long
- 19:56time. But at the end of that period of time, whether it's a
- 20:00couple of years or twenty years, you might still conclude that you definitely do
- 20:04not want your husband to be looking at erotic content on Instagram. So I'm
- 20:08not saying that because you don't want him looking at erotic content that means that
- 20:12there's something wrong with you. I'm just saying that I don't know your situation.
- 20:17I don't know. Maybe you've already been through all that, but given
- 20:19the way that you're writing this, I'm guessing that there's some exploration that could
- 20:23be that could benefit you. So going on with the email here, So
- 20:26you say, I have a question. I have some questions here. Number
- 20:32one, why do men feel the need to have sexual content on all their
- 20:37social media platforms like this? Why do men feel the need to have sexual
- 20:41content on all their social media platforms like this? Just chamming in here.
- 20:45Well, lots of people, regardless of gender look at sexual content on social
- 20:49media for a variety of reasons. Masturbation, as I mentioned one, that's
- 20:55one reason, but there are many other reasons. Appreciation of art, just
- 20:59something to look at, mood enhancement, getting ideas for things for yourself or
- 21:04for your partner or something. You know, there's a lot of different reasons
- 21:07why people would look at that. And we don't know why he was looking.
- 21:11We just have no idea unless you unless you know. But it doesn't
- 21:15sound like you had a conversation about it. And then your second question here
- 21:21is how do I get over this nagging feeling that I'm not enough? End
- 21:26of email? Well, yeah, so that's really I'm guessing getting the nail
- 21:30on the head, that's what your pain is about. That's what your anxiety
- 21:33is about. Is if he is looking at these pictures, the implication that
- 21:37you are drawing, which is not necessarily true, is that you are not
- 21:42enough, that he is not attracted to you, that he is looking for
- 21:47something, you know, bigger or tighter or better, or smoother, or
- 21:52a different race. You know, it could. That's the implication. And
- 21:57part of that is just an inherent lack of communication or trust that you might
- 22:03have in their relationship, or the trust that you have in your relationship is
- 22:06based on a very thin foundation of a rule following or something, which is
- 22:11fine, but it's you know, because there's nothing about the situation that you've
- 22:17told me that tells me that you're in danger or that he doesn't think that
- 22:21you're good enough. I mean, there's there's nothing about him looking at Instagram
- 22:26that would tell me that he thinks you're not good enough. The other thing
- 22:29here is that in a lot of societies, gender socialization is such that women
- 22:33are raised to believe this that in order for them to be enough, in
- 22:38order for them to be a worthy creature on this planet, they must be
- 22:44a product of physical and visual desire to their husbands. And if anyone else
- 22:49encroaches on that space, then the wife has completely lost all of her worth
- 22:56and she is nothing. And you know, it's another or thing to investigate,
- 23:00because I'm going to take a guess and say that your husband looks at
- 23:03you, and certainly you inherently are much more valuable. So these are conversations
- 23:08of am I good enough to you? Who am I to you? What
- 23:14am I to you? What do you value about me? Because if you
- 23:17had that trust, then I'm guessing that coming across his Instagram follows wouldn't have
- 23:23triggered you as much. But I want to return again and say that I
- 23:29don't know the full situation, and there's a lot of pain that you're feeling.
- 23:34And you know, you know my model of emotions. Our emotions are
- 23:40our friends. They're telling us something. The pain and the anxiety that is
- 23:45paralyzing to you as you lay on the bed and stare into the nothingness is
- 23:48telling you something. It's telling you you're not safe, you're not okay.
- 23:53But it's not necessarily because your husband looks at erotic content on Instagram. It's
- 24:00probably more fundamental of am I Worthwhile? Am I good enough? Do I
- 24:07matter? Am I in a safe, secure relationship? This challenged that because
- 24:12I'm guessing you were. Your relationship was coasting in a state of you not
- 24:18necessarily knowing the answer to that question, because, like I said earlier,
- 24:22if you really knew the answer to that question, you were like, I
- 24:26know with one hundred percent certainty that he loves me, that he's attracted to
- 24:30me, that he's never going to leave me, and huh, he looks
- 24:33at a rotic content on Instagram. I don't think it would have affected you
- 24:37as much. So your emotions are telling you to do something to target Instagram
- 24:41or to start to control him is not the way to go. You can
- 24:45certainly draw boundaries, but that that's really a distant second to the first priority,
- 24:52which is working on your self esteem, having corrective experiences with him,
- 24:56healing with him, asking him why he looks at it, you know,
- 25:02tell him to describe it, even if he masturbates to it, like what
- 25:06does that mean for him to masturbate to it? You know, you can
- 25:07have these conversations and actually have it enhance your worth, enhance your relationship,
- 25:14deepen your trust. But you probably need a therapist to help you, not
- 25:18only individually, but as a couple. All right, let's take a break.
- 25:26All right, we're back from the break. I want to remind everyone
- 25:29that if you are a patron, a portion of your monthly or yearly pledge
- 25:33goes towards a very a number of charities, including scholarships that we are giving
- 25:41out. We've given out almost twenty thousand dollars in scholarships and art grants.
- 25:45We've given a lot of funds to Petfinder, Plymouth Housing Group, Camp ten
- 25:51Trees, Trevor Project, Special Olympics, National Alliance on Mental Health, Animal
- 25:56Aid and Rescue Foundation, Prevent Child Abuse, America Animal's Lebanon Environmental Defense Fund,
- 26:03Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund, Wikipedia, and Doctors Without Borders.
- 26:07So thank you so much for being a patron, because your money is
- 26:12helping a lot of people around the world in various contexts. Okay, so
- 26:18anonymous upper tier patron. They wrote in and said, hello, doctor Honda,
- 26:22I was wondering if you could talk about breadcrumbing. So apparently there's a
- 26:27term called bread crumbing on the internet. I have just become aware of this
- 26:32term as it seemed to describe my experience with someone who I have romantic feelings
- 26:37for We had a short relationship of about four months last year, but then
- 26:41things ended. But then he would text me on and off and showed signs
- 26:47of romantic interest in me, and there was never any follow through in real
- 26:51life. When he mentioned that he was thinking of moving back in with his
- 26:56ex girlfriend, I realized that this was going nowhere, and I asked him
- 26:59to stop contacting me. It was hard because I would get my hopes up
- 27:03only to be disappointed again and again, and it felt like I was getting
- 27:07dumped over and over. End of email. Okay, So I hadn't heard
- 27:11of this term breadcrming, so I looked it up and there was Google provided
- 27:15the following definition. The act of sending out firtatious but noncommittal social signals in
- 27:22order to lure a romantic partner in without expecting much effort. In other words,
- 27:27it's leading someone on. So that's the definition. Yeah, in my
- 27:33time, we would just call this leading someone on. So, but you
- 27:37know, breadcrbing, I suppose is a fine terms. It's very visual.
- 27:42It certainly paints a picture. So I don't know his motivation. Was he
- 27:48actively trying to lead you on? Like he woke up in the morning and
- 27:52said I'm gonna lead her on, or I'm just going to toy with her,
- 27:56or I just want to have some satisfaction of flirting with someone, but
- 28:02I know that I never want to actually contact this person and engage with this
- 28:07person. Did he wake up in the morning and say I just want my
- 28:10former girlfriend or partner or dating person to stroke my ego today? Who knows.
- 28:15That's a possibility, But that wouldn't be my top hypothesis. That seems
- 28:19to be the implication in this term, right, the definition the act of
- 28:23sending out flirtatious, noncommittal social signals in order to lure a romantic partner in
- 28:30without expecting much effort. In other words, it's leading someone on, so
- 28:34lure right is that? While is that volitional on behalf of the breadcrumber or
- 28:41is it just a side effect? Because my top hypothesis would not be that
- 28:47that implies psychopathy and sadism, which is out there and there's a range of
- 28:52traits. But it's a rare motivation, it's a rare personality. Most people
- 28:57would not feel good about doing something like that. Now, might someone be
- 29:03in denial about it? Yeah, there's a lot of different roads to this
- 29:07that I would not term as breadcrumbing. You know, it's a similar thing
- 29:11with the word narcissist and narcissism. So many people have been hurt by romantic
- 29:18partners or friends or people at work, and the assumption is is that the
- 29:22person that hurt you did it on purpose, that they woke up in the
- 29:26morning and knew that they were going to ruin your life. And certainly that
- 29:30happens, but that's rare. Usually it's a misunderstanding, or people have personality
- 29:34triggers, or you know, all the things that I talk about. So
- 29:37this term breadcrumbing is probably going if it starts to become more and more of
- 29:41a thing, it's probably going to annoy me. In this similar way of
- 29:45love bombing, right that people just assume that if you were love bombed,
- 29:52or you were breadcrumbed, or you were broken up with or you were cheated
- 29:56on or something, that the other person and is some sort of psychopath.
- 30:02And certainly that can be true, but it's not usually the case. For
- 30:06every time that someone has hurt you and you have assumed that the other person
- 30:11did it on purpose, there's another person out there that you hurt that assumes
- 30:15that you did it on purpose, and we just need to stop that whole
- 30:18thing. It does happen, but it's not the norm. It's not the
- 30:22average. It really distorts things and ruins people's lives when we assume that.
- 30:26So, I don't know, it could be this, it could be that's
- 30:29what he did too. But my top hypothesis would be something along the lines
- 30:33of he was probably trying to date other people I don't know, and he
- 30:40was struggling, and there were times when he was lonely and he reached out
- 30:45to you because he just thought you might be recepted to that, because maybe
- 30:51he even knew that you were pining for him or you were open to that
- 30:55or something, and he would reach out and maybe and it would get away
- 31:00from him a little bit, and then the next day he would say,
- 31:03oh, I think I'm I think I'm leading her on. I shouldn't do
- 31:07that, and then he would, you know, retract and beat himself up
- 31:11about it, and then you'd get drunk, or you get particularly lonely or
- 31:17something like that. That'd be one hypothesis. Another one could be that he's
- 31:21just flirtatious in nature and doesn't really know that he is giving off signals that
- 31:27could be interpreted as romantic rekindlings. That's another possibility. Another possibility is that
- 31:34he genuinely was at times thinking about getting back together with you and then would
- 31:40at other times not. You know. One of the top hypotheses that I
- 31:45would have for someone like this is that they're depressed. People who are depressed
- 31:48or have different waves or phases of depression will have moments where they might be
- 31:56able to motivate themselves or fuel connected or good enough or optimistic enough to reach
- 32:01out to someone, but then their depression will kick in and then they just
- 32:05retract and isolate and stop contacting, or might even be in a bad mood
- 32:12when they communicate with you. So that's another possibility. So yeah, who
- 32:16knows, And maybe ask if you cared to just be like, hey,
- 32:20you know, this is the way it looked to me that we dated for
- 32:25a bit and then things ended and then you would occasionally contact me, which
- 32:30is fine, But I one just wanted to know what was going on for
- 32:37you. Were you was I reading things wrong or were you just having moments
- 32:43of flirtation? Like what was going on in your heart and mind? And
- 32:47the other thing I want to tell you is that it kind of hurt me
- 32:50because there were time I would get my hopes up and then you would indicate
- 32:55otherwise and it would hurt. So I just want you to know that that's
- 33:00that, and I kind of deserve an apology, and maybe you shouldn't do
- 33:05that in the future. You know, you're perfectly and your rights to say
- 33:08something like that. All right, next email? All right, This next
- 33:13email is from good old upper tier patron Kim from Arizona. She says,
- 33:16I saw an episode of a TLC show called My Strains Addiction, and it
- 33:22featured a man who was in a committed romantic relationship with a car. The
- 33:27man described taking his car on romantic dates, he cries at the thought of
- 33:32being separated from the car, and we even get to see him have a
- 33:37sexual encounter with it. I discovered the word for it is called objectiphilia,
- 33:43and I'm left wondering, how does someone wind up falling in love with a
- 33:46car or other inanimate objects. I suspected this man probably had collected a lifetime
- 33:52full of painful experiences trying to connect with other humans, and he probably found
- 33:59it much safer to fall in love with something that couldn't hurt him back.
- 34:02I was wondering how you would treat someone experiencing objective philia? Do they even
- 34:07teach about it in psychology school? To what extent do you recognize the person's
- 34:13relationship to their object as a valid relationship? End of email. Yeah,
- 34:17Well, the second question I'll ask first, which is I'll answer first,
- 34:22which is do they even teach about this in school? And I certainly never
- 34:27heard of it in school in graduate school. I've never even heard a clinician
- 34:30talk about it. I've only seen it occasionally on the Internet or on YouTube
- 34:36or on some of these shows, and or people emailing me about it.
- 34:40So I think it's relatively rare, but it is a phenomenon that apparently is
- 34:46out there. It's hard to know what's going on, and why could it
- 34:51just be wires crossed, so to speak? That can happen? Is it,
- 34:57as you said, that the person is settling for a car when they
- 35:02really want to connect without other human but they've given up on humans due to
- 35:06trauma? You know, it's certainly a viable hypothesis, and I'm guessing that
- 35:12is true sometimes, right, And then you ask what would I do if
- 35:17I were treating someone like as well. It depends on the goal. Because
- 35:21if someone came in to my office and they tell me, as a part
- 35:25of the assessment that they're in love with their car and they have sex with
- 35:29their car, but they want to talk about their relationship with their parents,
- 35:32then you know, I'd probably do a little bit of assessment around this romantic
- 35:37sexual relationship with their car. But if they don't consider it a problem and
- 35:44it's not a problem and they don't want my help with it, then I
- 35:46don't help them with that. Or if they were to come into my office
- 35:50saying that their parents have forced them into therapy because they're in love with their
- 35:53car, I would do an assessment, and if I found that them being
- 35:58in love with their car had no I gative effect on their life other than
- 36:00the stigma around it, then I would say I can't treat someone for something
- 36:07that doesn't actually cause harm. It's causing harm because people are harming him because
- 36:12they're stigmatizing him and oppressing him. It's a free country. He can fall
- 36:16in love and have sex with the car if he wants to, so you
- 36:20know, and by the way, this doesn't apply to animals of course,
- 36:22because animals don't have consent and can't give consent, and so thus it's a
- 36:27completely different topic. What we're talking about is inanimate objects that don't have emotions.
- 36:30Now, could it become a problem. Yeah, absolutely. It might
- 36:35not actually meet their attachment needs. It might ruin their life because of the
- 36:39stigma. And they might come to me and say, I want help exploring
- 36:45this and figuring out if there's another life for me. Maybe I do have
- 36:49trauma. Maybe I would be better off and feel better if I actually had
- 36:53relationships with human beings. I don't know. Yeah, I would absolutely work
- 36:57on that, and I won't go into the details of the treatment because it
- 37:00would depend on a lot of different things and it would maybe be a little
- 37:04boring conversation here. But yeah, the way that I answer this question and
- 37:08I get it a lot for some reason on this podcast, which I laugh
- 37:14because if you ask any therapist or anyone in my field, I'm guessing that
- 37:17one they've never come across a client or a human being like this, and
- 37:22too they've never heard about it in graduate school or any kind of academic or
- 37:27clinical circles. But as a figure out the Internet, I get to ask
- 37:30these kinds of questions, and so what I'll say is that if it's not
- 37:36a problem, then it's not a problem. If it's not a problem,
- 37:37then it's not a disorder. And people are free to do what they want.
- 37:42If someone wants to fall in love with the car or the Eiffel Tower
- 37:46or whatever its songs, they're not harming others, and songs are not causing
- 37:50any kind of problems, then live and that live. Having said all that,
- 37:55because it is so rare, we don't have a lot of research,
- 38:00if any, I couldn't find any serious research on this topic. I'm sure
- 38:04it's out there. I'm guessing it's out there, but it might not be
- 38:06because it's relatively rare, rare. The other thing I'll say is that there's
- 38:09a possibility that some of these people are faking it because they want to be
- 38:13on TV. That absolutely happens, and it could be happening here. You
- 38:17know, when I hear about someone that wants to be on a TV show
- 38:21and wants to show how they're having sex with their car, it's one of
- 38:25the hypotheses that I have because you just wouldn't think that that would be what
- 38:30you would have the impulse unless that's your fetish, Like, not only are
- 38:34you in love with your car, but you have a fetish of having sex
- 38:37in public or something. I don't know, all right, So patron and
- 38:39YouTube member Leah wrote in and she said, hello, doctor Kirk, can
- 38:45you please discuss the phenomenon of cognitive dissonance. I have studied it mostly from
- 38:51the perspective of racism, but for whatever reason, I have a hard time
- 38:54cementing it into my brain. Can you talk about how it is different from
- 39:00projection or projective identification? End of email. Yeah, well it's complicated,
- 39:06but briefly, I will say, let's define these things cognitive dissonance, projection,
- 39:12and projective edification. Let's talk about cognitive dissonance first. Basically, cognitive
- 39:16dissonance is the experience of mental distress when there is an inconsistency between your beliefs
- 39:28and your actions or your experiences. So, for example, if you have
- 39:34a belief that you are a good person, but your actions you're cheating on
- 39:39your partner, then that's cognitive distance because the cheating indicates that you're doing something
- 39:45harmful willingly, but you believe you're a good person. So what do you
- 39:50do with that? Or if you have a belief that the world works in
- 39:55a certain way, but you read some research that contra addicts that worldview,
- 40:00then you have mental distress because of cognitive distance. You don't always have mental
- 40:07distress or cognitive distance, but those are scenarios in which you can have it.
- 40:12And the distress comes from the desire for internal consistency. We want things
- 40:17to line up in terms of our worldview. We as animals have a really
- 40:23hard time dealing with the gray area with nuance, with confusion. We want
- 40:29to know things. It's very unsettling to have things up in the air,
- 40:34to not know things, because if we don't know this one thing, then
- 40:37maybe we don't know anything, and then I can't keep me and my family
- 40:40safe. That's what it comes down to. So we are very oriented and
- 40:46very determined to establish internal consistency. And if you aren't aware of the distress
- 40:53and you can't manage the distress, then you're much more likely to fall into
- 40:58cognitive pitfalls like justification and denial or motivated reasoning this kind of thing. So
- 41:07we also have a desire for a positive self image. Even if you have
- 41:10low self esteem, we tend to want to see ourselves as good people,
- 41:16as people that wouldn't do harm to other people, at least most of us.
- 41:21So those are the two needs that we have. And leon Festinger actually
- 41:28developed this concept in the nineteen fifties, and from my understanding, he observed
- 41:32what people did after a difficult earthquake that happened in India nineteen thirty four.
- 41:37But for people who felt the earthquake but nothing bad happened to them, they
- 41:43were apparently more likely to believe and spread rumors that a bigger disaster was coming.
- 41:47So basically what leon Festinger was concluding was that people felt fear because of
- 41:55the earthquake. Right, they felt the earthquake, but it wasn't big where
- 42:00they were at, So they have this feeling of fear, okay, but
- 42:05there wasn't anything to actually be afraid of because nothing bad happened to them and
- 42:10there was no indication that anything bad would happen to them. So that's cognitive
- 42:15dissonance. They have a belief that there's something to be afraid of, that
- 42:19there is something looming because the earthquake was scary to them, but there's nothing
- 42:23actually threatening that's happening to them. That's the cognitive dissonance that they experiencing,
- 42:30so they were motivated to modify the world to fit their belief So instead of
- 42:37dealing with that dissonance and saying, well, I know, I feel afraid,
- 42:40but there's actually not anything to be afraid of currently or in the future.
- 42:45I mean, maybe an earthquake will happen in the future, but really
- 42:50my fear is just because of my associations with earth earthquakes and what it felt
- 42:54like to kind of have the world move underneath me. But a shortcut to
- 43:00resolving the cognitive dissonance is to just believe that the fear is true and that
- 43:07the world is a scary place. And so as a result, what was
- 43:10observed is that these individuals were more likely to believe rumors of major disasters happening
- 43:16in the future and more likely to spread them than other people. So that's
- 43:20the idea. And when it comes to racism, yeah, there's a lot
- 43:23of cognitive dissonance that you can talk about when it comes to racism. For
- 43:28example, if someone has been indoctrinated into the belief that black people are criminals
- 43:32or dangerous or something or violent, then they're at a party and they meet
- 43:37a black person. Maybe they don't have a lot of interactions with black people,
- 43:40and this interaction with a black person is pleasant, there's nothing of note,
- 43:45So there's a dissonance. There's distress because they have this really firm belief
- 43:50that black people are criminals or violent or dangerous. But they experienced the black
- 43:54person that was not that, so cognitive dissonance stress. They don't know what
- 44:00to do internally with it, and it's not conscious always right, It's happening
- 44:06sort of beneath the surface, if you will. So the individual could,
- 44:09for example, if they really wanted to better themselves in better society, they
- 44:14would really wrestle with that idea and think about it and talk about it with
- 44:16themselves and other people, that sort of thing. But most people don't have
- 44:21time for that or the awareness to do that, and so they will take
- 44:24an easier road. So much easier road that you could do literally in half
- 44:30a second, is the individual would say, well, I know that that
- 44:35was a pleasant experience with that black person, but you know he must be
- 44:38secretly up to something. You know, there's something creepy. I mean,
- 44:43remember that thing that he said, you know, just becoming suspicious and cherry
- 44:45picking or the individual might say, well, yeah, he must be an
- 44:51exception because he was raised in a nice neighborhood. So therefore my belief about
- 44:57black people being criminals is still upheld. But yeah, sure there are minor
- 45:00exceptions due to rare circumstances like being raised in a nice state retis, you
- 45:06know. So that's where cognitive dissonance causes a lot of problems in our society
- 45:13regarding racism and other kinds of oppressive notions. So all right, so you
- 45:17ask, what about projection. Well, let's define projection, and I could
- 45:22go into projective identification, but it's essentially in the same camp. So projection
- 45:28is defined as to when we have an unwanted aspect of ourself, then we
- 45:35will project it onto other people. So, for example, if someone is
- 45:38cheating and they don't like the fact that they are cheating, then they might
- 45:45constantly be suspicious of their partner instead, right, so they are seeing their
- 45:50partner as cheating, as being untrustworthy when they are the ones themselves that are
- 45:54cheating. This is a classic defense that Freudians identified in the early twentieth century
- 46:00called projection. Projective idification is just a furthering of that process by socializing the
- 46:07other two to agree with the projection. But that's what projection means. But
- 46:12in the lay person terms when they use projection, what they're using it for,
- 46:19in my language, is it's a distortion. Basically, they are imposing
- 46:24something different than reality, Like like earlier with the emailer, I don't know
- 46:29if this is true, but you know, it's possible that with the Breadcrumber
- 46:34email, that the emailer is actually distorting the previous partner as being malicious right
- 46:42when they aren't. Actually Now, who knows, maybe the Breadcrumber is malicious,
- 46:46But let's say the Breadcrumber is not malicious. And I don't even know
- 46:50if the emailer actually sees this person. Maybe I shouldn't use that an example.
- 46:53But you know, let's say in another world with another emailer, someone
- 46:59is giving signals of flirtation and you, as the recipient of that flirtation,
- 47:06you know, you see that as malicious when it's not. There's no indication
- 47:09that it's malicious, and you're just like, yeah, that person is trying
- 47:14to ruin my life by flirting with being on and off. So a lot
- 47:17of people would say that's a projection, but that's not a projection. It
- 47:21could be a projection because it might be that you're malicious, but the way
- 47:24people use it, what they mean in my language is that they're distorting,
- 47:30they are imposing, or it's not a projection. Right, So getting back
- 47:34to your question, what is the difference or is there overlap between cognitive dissonance
- 47:38and projection, Well, in my language, I think what you're asking is
- 47:43what's the relation between what's the relationship between cognitive disonance and distortion? And it's
- 47:50complicated, but what I'll say is that we you know, we've clearly defined
- 47:54cognitive dissonance with distortion. It might not necessarily generate the distortion might not necessarily
- 48:00generate from a distress that you're feeling between two opposing things in your mind.
- 48:06You might be distorting for a variety of reasons. You might be triggered,
- 48:10you might be you might have a world view that you're just imposing on the
- 48:15world. So, yeah, there's a lot of overlap, but they are
- 48:17different things, and I guess what I would say is that distortion is broader
- 48:22than cognitive distance. Also, cognitive dissonance has a very specific structure to it.
- 48:29You have to have these two opposing things. You have to have the
- 48:32stress of dealing with those two things, and that's it. So yeah,
- 48:37And to be clear, cognitive dissonance doesn't necessitate that one distort. You can
- 48:44have cognitive dissonance and do the healthy thing, which is to wrestle with it
- 48:50and achieve consonants, cognitive consonants actually in a healthy way. Like getting back
- 48:55to the racism example, the person at the party, if they down the
- 49:00road of actually dealing with things and challenging their own beliefs and modifying their beliefs,
- 49:06then they would achieve cognitive consonants in the same way that they would achieve
- 49:10cognitive consonants if they just quickly took the shortcut and said, well, he's
- 49:16you know, this guy must secretly be a criminal. So you know,
- 49:21cognitive dissonance doesn't mean that you have to distort. That's important understanding. We
- 49:25typically will use cognitive dissonance to refer to people who are distorting, but that's
- 49:30not always the case. Cognitive dissonance is just that experience of the distress.
- 49:35What you go, what you do from there could be positive or negative or
- 49:38neutral. All right, let's take a break. All right, we're back
- 49:45from their break let's do an opp These people became patrons all the way back
- 49:47in twenty twenty three years ago. Thank you for staying a patron. That's
- 49:52always the key is not only becoming a patron, but staying at patron.
- 49:55Jackie from Kirkland became a patron back then. Anka from Germany, Stephanie from
- 50:04Arkansas, I believe, Rachel from Minneapolis, Anna from Ireland, Katie from
- 50:09Minesto, California, Stewart from Australia, Alex from Australia, Joseph from Montlake
- 50:15Terrace, Washington. I love Mont Lake Terrace. I go to the Cinebar
- 50:20up there. That's me and my wife's favorite movie place to go to because
- 50:23they serve food and drinks. And they took out every other row, so
- 50:28every other rosa table, you know what I mean, So there's a lot
- 50:30of room to kind of spread out. Nora from New York, New York.
- 50:34Dana or Dana Dana probably from Olympia, Washington. Go to Olympia.
- 50:37Another person from Olympia. Sam from Olympia. Do you know each other?
- 50:40It's not that big of a town. Heather from Orlando, Florida, Matthias
- 50:45from Sweden, Mark from reading or reading Pennsylvania. Ashley from Samamish, Washington.
- 50:52That's where I grew up. Ashley hit me up Georgie from Great Britain
- 50:57and Flee from North Carolina. Thank you so much for becoming a patron and
- 51:00staying a patron through thick and thin. Honestly, really all right. The
- 51:04sext emails from patron Natasha from California. She says, Hey, Kirk,
- 51:08hope all is well with you. While listening to you talk about your pride
- 51:14in male identity. And by the way, the vulnerability was appreciated by me,
- 51:19I was trying to figure out why I was both annoyed and unable to
- 51:23relate to that feeling in myself. The concept of anyone gaining self esteem out
- 51:28of their traditional femininity is a bit nauseating to me, because it's a standard
- 51:31that was formed by men as a means of oppression, then disguised as something
- 51:37celebrated, a sort of patronizing reverence of our ability to be gentle homemakers.
- 51:42I would argue that the gender binary is in general, is more oppressive than
- 51:46not. I would argue that the gender binary in general is more oppressive than
- 51:51not. It may come down to my own jealousy that a man would be
- 51:54able to take pride in his gender because those positive masculine qualities or more desirable
- 52:00characteristics than those associated with women, they grant power, aspect and freedom in
- 52:06the world. If I want access to these things, I have to step
- 52:08into a more masculine persona, which I resent. End of email. Yeah,
- 52:14I think there were a few emails along these lines from various different angles.
- 52:17And what I'll say is, yeah, totally. And you know,
- 52:22the discussion of gender and the liberation of gender and the situation in our society
- 52:29and history and politics. You know, you could have a podcast dedicated to
- 52:34that topic and never run out of things to talk about. So the short
- 52:37conversation that Ambarto and I had about this doesn't represent the whole thing, right,
- 52:43Plus I'm only one person, And yeah, I totally get what you're
- 52:46saying. What I'll say is is that, on one hand, I absolutely
- 52:51am in your camp, Natasha, that the whole enterprise of gender socialization or
- 52:58associating qualities with gender is just weird. Like why, you know, there
- 53:05are just so many other factors that contribute to one's identity or one's qualities that
- 53:12have nothing to do with gender, right, So, and yet on our
- 53:15society we associate everything which enter you know, just like whenever you hear any
- 53:22sort of research, right, psychological research, they almost always break it out
- 53:25by men and women. Always the binary, by the way, which is
- 53:29oppressive in itself, but that's always something that identify. Well, what about
- 53:34age or ethnicity or where you live city folk versus country folk. Politically,
- 53:40he's you know, there's so many things that people will differentiate between others,
- 53:45you know, different groups of people that you can possibly lump people into.
- 53:51Why is gender always what people identify? It's like the only group that only
- 53:57grouping that people think is worth talking about, right, So it's odd to
- 54:01me and I agree. And obviously in our society, going back literally centuries
- 54:07in Western society, and I'm guessing others as well, that the whole enterprise
- 54:14of gender and associating different qualities with gender has been largely, if not entirely,
- 54:20oppressive to women and gives men power. As you're saying, so,
- 54:24as I'm taking pride in being honorable or being a leader, or being strong
- 54:30or something physically able to pick things up, then that is a part of
- 54:36the patriarchy of course, but it really just depends on what we do with
- 54:40it. Right on the other foot is I I'm just going to speak for
- 54:44myself. I cannot get rid of my socialization. I am socialized as a
- 54:49Japanese American. I'm socialized as a white person or as a mixed race person.
- 54:52I'm socialized as an American. I'm socialized as a man or boy or
- 54:57male. I'm socialized as a person in my family. I'm socialized as someone
- 55:02from Samanish Washington or from Seattle area. I'm socialized as a socialized as a
- 55:07Christian. I was social a particular kind of Christian. I was. You
- 55:13know, there's a lot of different things that I was socialized as that the
- 55:17values and beliefs are in me now. I don't just hand myself over to
- 55:22those, Willy Dilley, because that would be stupid, But I want that,
- 55:27you know, like when I see, I grew up with Superman being
- 55:30very different than the way Superman is depict it today. Now it's all dour
- 55:34and dark and depressing and angry and sad. I grew up with Superman being
- 55:39this in the eighties with Christopher Reeve. It's this do gooder who this really
- 55:45great guy and uncomplicated, not dark, not traumatized, you know, just
- 55:52a good guy. Oh shucks kind of a thing. And so when I
- 55:55see Superman with the American flag, because that's how I grew up identify with
- 56:02that, I see myself, and that I see myself as someone maybe that's
- 56:07masculinity, or maybe that's as an American, or as a human or a
- 56:10good human or maybe a Christian human. I grew up heavily identifying with that,
- 56:15and that's still in me. When I see Christophery in Superman the first
- 56:19movie and he brings Lex Luthor in at the end of the movie to spoiler
- 56:22alert to the jail, and the guard says, thanks Superman and Superman.
- 56:29It'll make me cry literally as I talk about it, because it's so I
- 56:34watched it when I was ten and it moved me and it still does because
- 56:37of that. You know, if you watch that movie today for the first
- 56:38time, I'm guessing you'd be like, yeah, I don't see what the
- 56:40big deal is, but you know, things resonate, right. We can't
- 56:44get away with that, and why would I want to. I don't want
- 56:45to get away from that. So when Superman drops him off and the guard
- 56:50says thanks Superman, and Superman says, I'm just doing my duty or I
- 56:54know you would do it too, or something. You know, this this
- 56:57really great, humble answer. That's this light. He recognizes it, but
- 57:00he doesn't revel in it or anything. He's just like, yeah, well,
- 57:02you know you would do the same thing, or I'm just doing my
- 57:06duty or whatever. Any flies on this country is safe against Superman. Thanks
- 57:13to you. No, sir, don't thank me, Warden. We're all
- 57:16part of the same team. And that value what that says that you do
- 57:25the right thing, that you help society, that you might even sacrifice parts
- 57:31of your life to make the world a better place. Like that's in me
- 57:37and I like that. And there's a whole kind of ball of wax that
- 57:40all these identities are wrapped up in that. Does that mean that non Americans
- 57:45can't do those things? No, But to me, as an American,
- 57:49that is how I feel. You know. I know, the American flag
- 57:52and the americanism or nationalism is something that especially as liberals, are supposed to
- 57:59hate, but I don't. I don't. I think we as liberals should
- 58:04take back the flag and take back Americanism and say America is founded on giving
- 58:09to the poor, on helping the oppressed. It was very different back then.
- 58:14They could only do so much. But over time the arc of history,
- 58:16we have achieved a lot and led the way. We're not the only
- 58:21leader on the planet or not any better than other countries. Other countries have
- 58:24done a lot as well. But I have that association. Other people look
- 58:29at the flag, they're going to see something different, or other people from
- 58:31another country, they might have pride in the Swedish flag. They look at
- 58:36this. You know they're from Sweden and they look at the Swedish flag and
- 58:38they have it gives them a certain feeling. Okay, So you can reject
- 58:43that, and that's every individual's choice, and that's fine. But for me,
- 58:47in my life, that's how I feel, and I am okay with
- 58:52it. I'm not only okay with it, but it inspires me. It
- 58:55wakes me up in the morning. And I don't have an American flag.
- 58:59I don't think about Superman. But you know, when you think about all
- 59:01the different things about what it is to be a man, what it is
- 59:05to be an American, what it is to be a husband, what it
- 59:07is to be fifty two, what it is to be from Seattle. Like,
- 59:10there's a lot of identification. Now, you could have another person that
- 59:15issues all identifications and or only retains a few of the groupings that they are
- 59:22within, And that's also okay. Everyone has that choice. Everyone has the
- 59:27responsibility, though, to evaluate how their pride or their identity is imposing on
- 59:32other people and harming other people. I am still in the middle of that
- 59:37process of I'll never be done with that. I've been doing that for you
- 59:40could argue my entire life, but more in earnest when I began graduate school
- 59:44when I was twenty four years old and started to formally discuss this and explore
- 59:49it in therapy and academia and with my colleagues. So that's my path.
- 59:54I could see it really sucking if you are a woman and you're trying to
- 59:59find pride in being a woman when the associations with femininity or womanhood are linked
- 1:00:06to things one that you don't identify with and two are oppressive to you and
- 1:00:10are societally oppressive. So yeah, I get that, and I can absolutely
- 1:00:16see and I know plenty of women that I heavily identify as a woman and
- 1:00:22who have explored it who revel and glorify womanhood and femininity and I can't speak
- 1:00:30to that. I could attempt it, but I would screw it up.
- 1:00:35But you could imagine that, right. So there's a lot of different things
- 1:00:37there. You know, if I, for example, wanted to say I
- 1:00:40have pride in being a white person, like, even as I say it
- 1:00:45out loud, why can't I have pride in my white side? Can I
- 1:00:50only have pride for my Japanese side? Can I not have pride as a
- 1:00:53man? If I explore it and make sure that I'm not giving in to
- 1:00:59the part of masculinity that has to do with oppression that I was indoctrinated into
- 1:01:05and probably did participate in and probably still due to some extent that I'm working
- 1:01:09on, you know, is it okay for me to have pride in that?
- 1:01:15Can I, after exploring have the values as a man have values?
- 1:01:20As a Japanese American have values? I mean even Japanese American or Japanese you
- 1:01:25could argue is a pretty awful There's a lot of awful associations with the Japanese
- 1:01:30nation, with Japan and their terrible mistreatment and genocide of Koreans and Chinese and
- 1:01:37Filipinos and all sorts of people. So Japanese. What I'll say is there's
- 1:01:44a value that has been passed down to me regarding being Japanese that has to
- 1:01:49do with honor and has to do with its quiet honor. You know,
- 1:01:52if you watch anime, often the hero is this quiet, honorable, very
- 1:01:58capable person who never takes any kind of credit and is humble but very good
- 1:02:05at what they do. Often it's a samurai person or something, you know,
- 1:02:08And I have internalized that just from my family and also from these media
- 1:02:14depictions, because it's a reflection of the society, and so I have that
- 1:02:20sign of me. Well, you could and have called upon that and feel
- 1:02:23that way and it inspires me. Right. Well, you could argue that
- 1:02:27where that comes from is feudalism in Japan, when they were oppressing the peasants,
- 1:02:31you know, like there were the barons and the landowners, and then
- 1:02:36you had then you had the noble class, which was like the samurai class,
- 1:02:39right, and then ninety nine point nine percent of everyone else was a
- 1:02:45peasant. And instantly, that's where I come from, is the peasant class,
- 1:02:47because that's most people. And to glorify samurai is to glorify the massive
- 1:02:54oppression and the mistreatment of poor people in Japan for hundreds of years. So
- 1:03:00is it okay that I identify with some of the aspects of Japanese samurai showgun
- 1:03:09culture while making sure that I don't give in to the notions of oppressing poor
- 1:03:16people or oppressing my own expression of my emotion. You know, is it
- 1:03:22okay? And I don't. I have concluded that it is okay. That's
- 1:03:27okay. So there's a lot of possibilities. And for you, Natasha,
- 1:03:32it sounds like you don't want to identify with feminine with feminine qualities. So
- 1:03:37for you, Natasha, you could identify however you want to. Because it's
- 1:03:43all a big ball of nonsense anyway, because none of these qualities that especially
- 1:03:47in the way that people talk about it, typically, none of these qualities
- 1:03:51are inherently of that identity and not of other identities. Right to say that
- 1:03:57men are associated with honor does not mean that men are honorable, and it
- 1:04:02doesn't mean that women are not right like, it's really a silly notion because
- 1:04:08everyone is just who they are, and there's a lot of different paths to
- 1:04:11personality and what motivates you and how we see ourselves. So you, for
- 1:04:15example, Natasha, and you don't need my permission to do this. But
- 1:04:18one possibility is that you say, I don't identify with masculinity or femininity.
- 1:04:26I identify as having the following qualities I have. I value this, I
- 1:04:33value that. I want to be this, I want to be that.
- 1:04:35I don't want to be that. I don't want to be that, and
- 1:04:38I don't care what association it has with gender or any other group, because
- 1:04:43that's what I want to be. And that is wonderful. That is you,
- 1:04:47and that is thought out, that is intentional. It is in ligne
- 1:04:53with how you see yourself. It is in line with how you want to
- 1:04:56live, and it's beautiful and wonderful. That's what I'll say, all right.
- 1:05:02This next emails from anonymous patrons. She says, doctor Honda, I've
- 1:05:05been listening to your podcast since twenty twenty, and I feel like I've been
- 1:05:09waiting the whole time for the video you did on Visceral Trauma for the ultimatum.
- 1:05:15Just chiming in here. So if you don't watch my YouTube channel,
- 1:05:17I did a series on reacting to the TV show The ultimatum. And you
- 1:05:24might have heard the episode that I did with Rebecca, and one of the
- 1:05:27episodes depicted an individual named Aussie who was seemingly experiencing a really heavy trigger to
- 1:05:34their trauma, and I named the episode Visceral Trauma. And in that episode,
- 1:05:42it's sort of funny because I think the episode was probably half an hour
- 1:05:45long, and I reacted to about maybe forty five seconds of the show,
- 1:05:53and then the rest of the half hour, I basically just talked about my
- 1:05:56model of trauma therapy because I had and my understanding of trauma and my path
- 1:06:02to competence and how initially I wasn't competent. And I did that because I
- 1:06:09didn't think I had fully lectured about that topic to the video audience. I've
- 1:06:15talked about it a lot on the audio podcast, but I thought, well,
- 1:06:18maybe it's a good opportunity to kind of put it out there, because
- 1:06:20one of the things that I want to put out there is that people,
- 1:06:25if they have trauma like legit PTSD, complex PTSD, then they should be
- 1:06:31very careful about talking about their trauma because they can retraumatize themselves, but often
- 1:06:36recovery and healing and symptom reduction does involve thinking or talking about the trauma through
- 1:06:44imaginal exposure, but you need to prepare for it, and you need to
- 1:06:47go slowly, and there's all these measures in place. You have to have
- 1:06:51emotional regulation skills that you can operate yourself in between sessions. You have to
- 1:06:57have emotional awareness, which isn't necessarily in the beginning of treatment, and a
- 1:07:01lot of clinicians don't understand this fact, and they will forge ahead, such
- 1:07:06as I did in the beginning of my career, and a client might even
- 1:07:11come to me and say I want to talk about my trauma, and I'd
- 1:07:14be like, oh, okay, yeah, I'm open. You know,
- 1:07:15I certainly would never shut that down. This is why I'm here is to
- 1:07:19listen to people's traumas, right, And then they proceed to talk about their
- 1:07:24traumas, and they re traumatize themselves and they get thrown into a state of
- 1:07:28distress or dissociation or triggering or depression or suicidality that lasts weeks and then they
- 1:07:34never go back to therapy, and the clinician had no idea why that happened,
- 1:07:41which is the way I was basically trained. While not Basically, that's
- 1:07:45the way I was trained when I was in the beginning of my career,
- 1:07:47and it wasn't ntil later that I learned otherwise. And it's pretty complicated.
- 1:07:53The form of exposure therapy that I use with my clients is a very tailored
- 1:07:59process to every client. No client is the same, and the treatment is
- 1:08:03also not the same, but the principles are the same anyway. So going
- 1:08:10on with the email, apparently and this a honest patient was really waiting wanting
- 1:08:15me to talk about that topic in the video. Going on with the email,
- 1:08:18I realized I have complex PTSD in mid twenty twenty one, and I've
- 1:08:24been in therapy for that ever since. I started with talk therapy that kept
- 1:08:29re traumatizing me. I developed so chiming in here. I think what anonymous
- 1:08:33patron is saying is that the therapist would ask or the client would offer up
- 1:08:40their trauma, and there would be no precautions to protect the client. I
- 1:08:44started to talk. I started with talk therapy that kept re traumatizing me.
- 1:08:47I developed severe depression and anxiety, and at one point was almost overwhelmed by
- 1:08:53how strongly I wanted to die. It was a very close call, but
- 1:08:58I did keep going back to therapy because I thought I needed more therapy for
- 1:09:01my increasing symptoms. Just chemming in here. Yeah, that is awful.
- 1:09:05You go to a clinician that's supposed to know what they're doing, and you
- 1:09:11start talking about your trauma and you start experiencing all these symptoms, and the
- 1:09:15therapist might not know what to do with it, or they might even frame
- 1:09:18it as a good thing. It's like, well, you're purging your toxins
- 1:09:21or whatever. I don't know, or this is what happens when you unearth
- 1:09:26those things. There's going to be temporary negative emotions instead of understanding the physiology
- 1:09:31of trauma and that it's harmful to the individual that you're basically making the PTSD
- 1:09:39worse and traumatizing them to therapy, traumatizing them to even getting treatment. And
- 1:09:45then your symptoms get worse and you're like, oh, well, well now
- 1:09:47I really need therapy, and you just keep going and you keep re traumatizing
- 1:09:50yourself. I'm so sorry that happened. It's awful going down with your email.
- 1:09:56It wasn't until six months ago that I found an EMDR therap rapist,
- 1:10:00which was highly effective for me. Hearing your explanation of trauma healing and the
- 1:10:04compassion you had for your clients and Assie made me very emotional. I probably
- 1:10:10cried during every minute of that video. I wanted to thank you because your
- 1:10:14videos played a part in saving my life. Finally, I was wondering if
- 1:10:18you could talk about the last phases of trauma healing, what is next for
- 1:10:25me? Is it going to last or well I regress? So just chiming
- 1:10:29in here, Well, you would talk with your therapist about that. I
- 1:10:32don't know at what point you're at. I don't know what point you're at
- 1:10:36in the treatment. I don't know what point you're at in terms of the
- 1:10:41discussion of the traumas. The general idea is that as you continue to expose
- 1:10:48yourself in an EMDR, you don't always talk about it, but you're thinking
- 1:10:54about it or you're visiting it, so to speak. And there's different phases
- 1:11:00to MDR therapy which I could get into, but generally speaking, with all
- 1:11:04the competent trauma therapy models, there's a phase of therapy where once you have
- 1:11:12emotional regulation skills and emotional awareness and safety and all that kind of stuff,
- 1:11:16and you also have the prediction that you'll be able to stay in therapy for
- 1:11:19a while because you don't want to just dabble in exposure and then stop.
- 1:11:23It's something you've got to kind of stick with for a long time and or
- 1:11:27at least as long as it needs to be. And so when you're in
- 1:11:30the exposure phase of therapy, and it depends on the situation because everything is
- 1:11:34tailored to everyone. But that's all. That's what you focus on, is
- 1:11:40exposing yourself in therapy or there's other regiments that you can do at home.
- 1:11:44Again, talk with your therapists, and you keep the distress under a five.
- 1:11:48You keep it to four below, but you need to get it up
- 1:11:51to a four in order to experience the distress necessary such that your body can
- 1:11:57habituate to the memory. And you do that over and over again, and
- 1:12:01then the same memory produces less and less down to zero distress. And you
- 1:12:08do that with every story that you can recall, and you do that with
- 1:12:12every association. And since you have such awareness of your distress, you're very
- 1:12:16good at being able to identify what stories are going to make you feel distressed.
- 1:12:19I gotta da. So you do that until no stories produce any distress.
- 1:12:26Or any or the stories produce very very little distress, you know,
- 1:12:30like a one point five. So when you do that, typically what that
- 1:12:33will coincide with is an elimination of PTSD symptoms or other kinds of symptoms like
- 1:12:41anxiety or depression. Depends. But that's the experience that I've had, and
- 1:12:45that's what the research shows for majority of clients. And when that happens,
- 1:12:50then you have a lot of options from there. You could switch to some
- 1:12:54other topic, or you can also go deeper into the traumas and start talking
- 1:12:59about the meaning of the trump And this sometimes can coincide with the exposure as
- 1:13:03well. Sometimes it could even precede the exposure. But meaning is important,
- 1:13:09right if, for example, you were abused heavily by your parents, one
- 1:13:14of the elements of recovery and this isn't always the case, but it often
- 1:13:18is that once the memories are integrated and the PTSD is drastically reduced or eliminated,
- 1:13:27then you can look back and say, Okay, what, what's the
- 1:13:30meaning of it all? Because it's similar to a loss, right If your
- 1:13:35partner dies tragically, there's a lot of grief and a lot of pain,
- 1:13:40a lot of anxiety, a lot of you know, being a you know
- 1:13:43a lot of upheaval, and what people often will find is that in the
- 1:13:48end they start searching for meaning, why did this happen? Where is he
- 1:13:53now? You know, where is my spouse now? Are they in heaven?
- 1:13:56Or what would they want me to do? You know, people will
- 1:13:59start to develop meanings purposes like, well, if my spouse were here,
- 1:14:04they would want me to continue to fight for this fight. Or if my
- 1:14:10spouse were here, they would want me to be happy. Or I can
- 1:14:13talk to my spouse and they're in a better place right now because they were
- 1:14:15really suffering up until then or something. Or I am now on a mission
- 1:14:21to live life by it's by the fullest, because I understand now that I
- 1:14:28shouldn't take life for granted. That's what my spouse's death gave me, was
- 1:14:32this gift of understanding that life is short and I shouldn't waste my time with
- 1:14:36stupid stuff. I'm going to change my career, you know, meaning meaning
- 1:14:40meaning, Well, the same goes for recovery from abuse. What's the meaning?
- 1:14:45And it depends on you. You explore that, you find that yourself,
- 1:14:48and you develop that. Sometimes I will try to provide a catalyst to
- 1:14:53clients around that, Like I'll throw out different ideas that other people have found
- 1:14:57and sometimes something will stick. But you know, usually just try to stay
- 1:15:00out of it because clients should find that on their own. But as a
- 1:15:03therapist, I need to create space for that conversation, for that exploration.
- 1:15:09So that's often what you would do after exposure, and then you ask is
- 1:15:14it gonna last or will you regress? Yeah, typically after treatment there will
- 1:15:21be retriggering, regression, but hopefully you have your therapist on speed dial that
- 1:15:30you can have some check up. But in my experience, if I do
- 1:15:34it well enough and thorough enough, there isn't regression in terms of PTSD.
- 1:15:41There might be regression in terms of patterns like people pleasing or something, but
- 1:15:46not actual PTSD. Once that has been healed, then generally it doesn't come
- 1:15:53back. In my experience, research shows you know, for most people that
- 1:15:57have a good regiment of exposure, and then that's usually the case, then
- 1:16:03you go on here. I also feel the need to explore my interests,
- 1:16:06but I also feel like I'm more at the age when everyone is settling down
- 1:16:12after having their exploratory phase In life. Think, thank you once again for
- 1:16:15everything. End of email. Yeah, so you're saying you feel the need
- 1:16:19to explore your interests, but you feel like you're at a phase of life
- 1:16:24where most people your age are kind of settling down. Well, one,
- 1:16:29there's a possibility that everyone your most people your age, also wants to explore
- 1:16:33but feels that same pressure. I don't know how old you are, an
- 1:16:38honest patron, but I get this from a lot of people that are,
- 1:16:42you know, almost dirty or in their thirties. They'll say things like,
- 1:16:45I feel like I should be further along, you know, and I look
- 1:16:48in career or family, and I look at people around me, and everyone
- 1:16:53just seems to be like figuring things out. But when you actually talk to
- 1:16:57those other people, they also feel like they figured things out. So it's
- 1:17:01this grass is greener kind of a thing. So that's one thing. The
- 1:17:05other thing I'll say is that who cares what people your age are doing?
- 1:17:10Typically meet your own needs, you know what I mean? If, for
- 1:17:14example, you haven't eaten in four days and you bump into a bunch of
- 1:17:20people who just had a big meal, does that mean that you don't eat?
- 1:17:26You know, that's essentially what you're saying, and I think that's what's
- 1:17:30happening because due to your complex trauma, you were denied the opportunity to do
- 1:17:35this exploration. And this is almost always the case that when I enter into
- 1:17:41treatment of individuals clients with their traumas, there often will depending on the level
- 1:17:46of trauma and how early it was. But if it was early enough,
- 1:17:48you zero to five, then they were not only abused and they have trauma
- 1:17:53run it and complex trauma, but they also were denied the opportunity to find
- 1:17:58who they are, to know their emotions, to have an identity, to
- 1:18:01explore things. And so once the immediacy of the PTSD has been reduced or
- 1:18:09eliminated, then that freeze the individual to finally return to when they were two,
- 1:18:14three, four or fifteen, whatever age you want to say, where
- 1:18:17they can actually explore who they are, where they can find out who they
- 1:18:21are, find out what you know. I'll work with people, for example,
- 1:18:27and will do the whole exposure thing, my model of exposure therapy for
- 1:18:32a couple of years, and then in the third year they suddenly come up
- 1:18:39for air from their life of being traumatized and being affected by their trauma.
- 1:18:44And they suddenly say, I don't know if anything in my life was my
- 1:18:47choice. I don't know if my career is my choice. I don't think
- 1:18:51it was. I don't even think the person I'm married to is my choice.
- 1:18:56I married that person because I thought that's what I was supposed to do.
- 1:18:59So I don't think even where I live, I don't even want do
- 1:19:02I want to live in this house? You know, they suddenly have this
- 1:19:05freedom to be able to ask that question that they could never ask before because
- 1:19:11they were panicking from minute to minute. And so that can be very distressing
- 1:19:15because you're suddenly faced with living like someone else's life, and it can take
- 1:19:20a lot of effort to change that. Right, It's like you got to
- 1:19:24start from the beginning, what do I want? And it can be distressing,
- 1:19:29but it's worth it, right because often what will happen is the individual
- 1:19:32will make some changes, but not all. Maybe some of the things they
- 1:19:38either discover well, maybe I did want to be married to that person,
- 1:19:41I just didn't really have contact with those feelings, or they choose to begin
- 1:19:46to actually voluntarily fall in love with their partner because they were never allowed to
- 1:19:54do that in the first place. So you know, there's a lot of
- 1:19:56opportunities, a lot of things. So it sounds like you might be in
- 1:20:00that situation and that's what you need and that's what you deserve. All right,
- 1:20:05Well, that doesn't for that episode of psychology in Seattle. Everyone out
- 1:20:09there, please take care of yourself truly, because you deserve it. You
- 1:20:12really, really really do.