Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: North Sea Scope 3, Global Offshore Wind and Iran-Israel conflict
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week, the North Sea finally
- 0:14got an update on environmental impact assessments and we
- 0:18address Iran. But first, I should introduce
- 0:21myself. I'm Ryan Duff, Aberdeen features
- 0:23lead, and joining me this week is reporter Matthew Perry.
- 0:26How you doing today? Matt, I'm doing pretty well,
- 0:28plodding along as always. How are you?
- 0:30Yeah, not too bad. I was at the Women in New Energy
- 0:32event that we hosted yesterday. It was an action-packed day, but
- 0:36it was, it's a lot of fun. It was really good.
- 0:38So coming into this a little bit more energized than usual, I've
- 0:42I'm also joined by E Forward editor Ed Reed.
- 0:46How are you doing today, Ed, other than melting away down in
- 0:49London? Yeah, well, this is the thing
- 0:51very much, you know, sort of essentially, as you say,
- 0:54dripping off my chair, but, you know, very much looking forward.
- 0:58Next week we're obviously off to Liverpool for for our event.
- 1:02Very excited to go and see some of the things going on there.
- 1:04It was always been quite fun. CCS and hydrogen plans in the
- 1:09offing so that'll be 1 to watch have.
- 1:11You been checking checking up on the forecast for Liverpool to
- 1:14see if you're? Escaping, I should be, I should
- 1:15be, but I feel like it, the event is sort of by the by the
- 1:19by the water. So I feel that always going to
- 1:21moderate the heat a bit like, you know, obviously it's crossed
- 1:25my fingers at this point. Not to sound too much like a
- 1:27mum, but you know it's it's the sea breeze that'll get you.
- 1:30It'll cool you down, but you're still burning.
- 1:32You're still burning like. A mother.
- 1:33I'm afraid of that. Yeah, there you are.
- 1:35Make sure to pack your suntan lotion.
- 1:37And if any of you, any of you listeners are going in
- 1:39Liverpool, maybe you'd remember to pack it too.
- 1:42But from suntan lotion to environmental impact
- 1:46assessments, there's not really a smooth segue into that.
- 1:49But Matt, you were Johnny on the spot yesterday when Michael
- 1:53Shanks appeared in Aberdeen to chat with the NSDA and announce
- 1:57updated rules for for climate regiments for upcoming oil
- 2:03fields. Obviously this came off the back
- 2:06of the Finch case last year, which deemed the approval of
- 2:09Rosebank and Jackdaw unlawful. How's things going?
- 2:13Yeah, well, this week the energy industry has gotten a bit of one
- 2:18of its favorite things, and that is clarity.
- 2:20We love to hear these product developers banging on about how
- 2:24much they want some clarity, and that has come.
- 2:26It's been delivered by Energy Minister Michael Shanks this
- 2:30week up in Aberdeen. And basically, as I said, Ryan,
- 2:32this kind of goes back to it all started the the what's now known
- 2:36as the Finch case, which basically was environmental
- 2:40campaigners challenging an onshore oil well development in
- 2:43Surrey. And in that case, the Supreme
- 2:46Court decided that the downstream emissions or scope 3
- 2:50emissions of that project needed to be taken into account.
- 2:52So that's essentially the emissions that, you know, come
- 2:55from burning the oil, all those kind of end downstream cases.
- 2:59And that, of course, LED into the Scottish Court of Session
- 3:03overturning the environmental approvals for Equinor and Ithaca
- 3:07Energy's Rosebank development and Shell's Jackdaw development.
- 3:11And since then, they've basically been in a bit of a
- 3:15kind of a holding pattern. They caught in the Scottish
- 3:17Court session and that decision allowed the development work to
- 3:21continue, but their original environmental approvals were
- 3:26basically rescinded. So what's happened now is the
- 3:30Department for Energy Security Net zero has released some
- 3:32updated guidance on how firms, when they submit their
- 3:36environmental impact assessments, you know, can take
- 3:39into account the the climate impacts or the the emissions
- 3:42impacts of their projects and then they can now resubmit.
- 3:47So Equinor, Ithaca, MG and Shell have already said that they're
- 3:50going to resubmit their applications.
- 3:51Obviously other projects that are still in the works that have
- 3:54existing licenses from RC developments can also now, you
- 3:58know, take heed of this guidance and and get their products
- 4:00underway. So it's kind of getting the ball
- 4:03rolling again. But importantly, what this
- 4:05doesn't mean is that Jacquard or and Rosebank have, you know,
- 4:10this isn't just a box ticking exercise for them.
- 4:13They do need to adhere to this guidance.
- 4:15It's been releasing, it's been interesting actually seeing
- 4:18quite a positive reaction from Uplift and Greenpeace, who were
- 4:22the climate campaign groups that that brought the original cases
- 4:26against Rosebank and Jackdaw. Tessa Khan and the executive
- 4:30director at Uplift was posting on LinkedIn this week in
- 4:34response to the guidance being issued.
- 4:36And then it kind of basically said that in her you, she says
- 4:40that the Disney's is actually taking, you know, quite a, you
- 4:43know, a fair approach to this guidance.
- 4:45And she kind of labeled it a genuinely robust, credible
- 4:49approach to assessing the emissions.
- 4:51So, you know, of course, in an upless view, that would mean
- 4:54that Rosebank shouldn't get approval from ministers.
- 4:57But of course, we have seen indications from, you know,
- 5:00Labour ministers like the Chancellor Rachel Reeves saying
- 5:02that they'd they'd like to see projects like Rosebank go ahead.
- 5:05So I guess not out of the woods yet for Ecuador, Ithaca and
- 5:08Shell. But it it, you know, clarity
- 5:11once again, is is kind of. Yeah, it's, it's a, it's a kind
- 5:15of coin flip from, if you remember the court case that
- 5:18overturned the rulings. We had both sides.
- 5:21We had like Ecuador, Shell, Ithaca all coming out and going.
- 5:25It's a win. We're fine, we're great.
- 5:27And then you also had Greenpeace and Uplift saying it's a win.
- 5:29Yes, they agreed with us this time around.
- 5:32I've seen Greenpeace, I've seen uplift sort of back, back this,
- 5:38although they do add the caveat of depends on how the government
- 5:42implements it and you know, depends on what, what way they
- 5:45end up deciding on IEA's, EIA's sorry from, from these projects,
- 5:51but I think all I've seen from Shell is, you know, we're still
- 5:54looking to pursue Jack Doll. We'll review the the new
- 5:57guidance. I think, I think it was kind of
- 6:00the same. I don't think I have seen much
- 6:02from Ecuador. Maybe that suggests a little bit
- 6:06of worry. Maybe it just it's just a case
- 6:08of they are genuinely needed time to gestate what the new
- 6:11rules. Mean just like in terms of what
- 6:13the new rules mean, right? So, so they've, they've, they've
- 6:15now got to do sort of scope through reporting.
- 6:17So they've essentially got to say, look, this is how much
- 6:21essentially emissions will come from combusting the oil or the
- 6:26gas, right? That's the thing.
- 6:29And then but the, the, essentially the ball is still
- 6:31back in Des Nez's court, right? In terms of the minister, like
- 6:34do they get ministerial approval?
- 6:36So it feels like the, the regulations say very much like,
- 6:40well, listen, you can, you know, like, I don't know, right.
- 6:42Get, get, get a, get a highly paid consultant to write another
- 6:45couple of pages in your, in your, in your impact assessment.
- 6:50That'll be lovely. And then the minister's still
- 6:52going to make the decision, right?
- 6:53I mean, I feel like, have we made progress?
- 6:57Well, there are some important changes I think that that we're
- 7:01key to note. So one of them is that the the
- 7:04guidance basically kind of puts to pay the argument that that a
- 7:08lot of people in the oil and gas industry might make.
- 7:10Well, if we didn't develop these fields in North Sea, they'd just
- 7:12be developed elsewhere. So that it kind of, I guess
- 7:15notice that the market substitution argument that they
- 7:17can't oil and gas companies can't rely on that kind of as an
- 7:20argument. Well, well, I mean, if we didn't
- 7:22develop Rosebank, these emissions would just happen
- 7:24elsewhere. They, they do have to take a
- 7:26kind of a different approach to accounting for the emissions.
- 7:29But yeah, as you say, basically it, it does put the the ball and
- 7:33I guess the political pressure back in, in Ed Miliband's court,
- 7:35who of course famously described Rosebank as climate vandalism.
- 7:39So it it is going to land on his desk at some point.
- 7:42Sounds like a great move. It, it, it, it is going to land
- 7:46back on his desk at some point and it's going to be interesting
- 7:50I guess, to see what decision the Labour ends up taking in
- 7:53regards to these projects. Because I mean, it's over.
- 7:55I mean, obviously it's all very well to kind of criticize the
- 7:57SNP for, you know, its failures in terms of sort of approving,
- 8:01you know, sort of say wind farm projects, right.
- 8:02I think Barrett Banks been sitting on John Sweeney's desk
- 8:05or and obviously his his, his predecessor for was it now three
- 8:08years and it's still got to sort of quite figure out how that
- 8:11works. But it feels like, you know, at
- 8:13some point, yeah, we've got clarity.
- 8:15But what is clarity if there's no political decision?
- 8:18Yeah, I think I think the only thing that might be in favor of
- 8:23of the announcement for oil and gas workers that I was saying
- 8:26this before, before it happened, before the announcement was
- 8:30fully made, and was the fact that Michael Shanks came up to
- 8:34Aberdeen specifically to do this.
- 8:36I feel like if it was a, you know, throw the hand grenade at
- 8:39the oil, oil and gas industry, you probably wouldn't do it
- 8:42while standing on their doorstep.
- 8:44And so maybe, maybe that's a slight, slight signal, but it's
- 8:48not it's nothing in black and white.
- 8:50It's no hard evidence is purely just, well, maybe Michael Shanks
- 8:54was a, you know, extending an olive branch.
- 8:57I don't know. It's reading into the reading
- 9:00into the ruins. Yeah, a little bit.
- 9:01I feel, I feel like, you know, that was my take before I saw
- 9:04the the assessment. You know, we knew he was coming
- 9:07up and I was kind of like, well, if it's for this, this updated
- 9:10guidance, like I say, if you were just going to tell, you
- 9:14know, Ecuador and Shell have both got offices up here.
- 9:19Yeah, we, yeah, we're just going to tell you no, then you
- 9:22probably wouldn't do that. You'd probably do that over
- 9:24e-mail so they can't shout back at you, you know, But who knows,
- 9:28maybe I'm just a coward and that's what what's coming out
- 9:32here. But I feel like that probably
- 9:34does it for the environmental impact assessment chat, as
- 9:37riveting as it was a great way to start the show.
- 9:40So from maybe a little bit of certainty for the future of oil
- 9:44and gas exploration to potential certainty for Peterhead and the
- 9:48energy transition. Join us after this break as we
- 9:51speak to Erica Askland. So I'm joined by our news editor
- 10:31Erika Askeland because she wasn't here when we were
- 10:34recording the rest of the show because she was out on her
- 10:37travels at Peterhead. What was going on in the blue
- 10:40tune? I was out of my adventures on an
- 10:42unfeasibly sunny day in the Northeast, which is just such a
- 10:46wonderful time to go drive up that coast road.
- 10:49But there was a good reason that I went and the Peterhead Energy
- 10:53Transition Forum, which is a group that has been forged out
- 10:58of some of the major industrial and governmental players around
- 11:03the Northeast, particularly around the Peterhead area.
- 11:06They commissioned a report from Bigger Economics to look at the
- 11:12impacts of what this massive pipeline of investments in the
- 11:17energy sector will have in terms of impacts over the next 10
- 11:21years. So basically they have
- 11:25discovered, this study found that they're looking at probably
- 11:29about £1 billion of investment, which they expect will create
- 11:35around about 820 jobs a year or support 820 jobs a year and as
- 11:41well generate an additional 71 million in GVA, which is a
- 11:46favorite, you know, kind of phrase used by economics, which
- 11:51is a favorite phrase used by economists.
- 11:55So I ended up, I also thought it was an interesting time to go
- 12:00because of course, just recently I was at Saint Fergus and Ed
- 12:05Miliband, the energy secretary was there to announce the £200
- 12:09million investment in the ACORN project, which is nearby to
- 12:15Peterhead Port. And there's lots of things that
- 12:17are going to be knock on effects.
- 12:19So I asked Keith how it was all going.
- 12:23Here's what. He said, yeah, it's exciting.
- 12:25And the Peterhead Energy Transition Forum was really
- 12:28pulled together about a year ago just to for the very purpose of
- 12:33both communicating and sharing good news information like this,
- 12:37but also to pull together information about all the
- 12:40transformational projects that are happening in the area.
- 12:43We felt as an organization or as a, as a collective, that there
- 12:47really wasn't anything out there that articulated what was
- 12:50happening in the Peterhead area in, in some kind of summarized
- 12:53farm. All the all the companies who
- 12:55make up the Peterhead energy transition for them.
- 12:58And, and of which there are, you know, there are large employers
- 13:01and small supply chain companies, academia, educational
- 13:05facilities, they're all doing really good things and that
- 13:08they're all, you know, pushing on the energy transition.
- 13:11There was nothing really that pulled all that information
- 13:13together in one sort of place. So, so getting, getting bigger
- 13:18economics to do the, to work out the, the, the socio economic
- 13:23impact for the region has been sort of eye opening for us in
- 13:27terms of the numbers of new jobs, the GVA that can add to
- 13:30the region and the yeah, just a general prosperity that the
- 13:34energy transition conveyed to the Peterhead area.
- 13:36So we're trying to pull all that together, but also talk about
- 13:39things like community based initiatives, upscaling the local
- 13:44community, you know, bringing along the Peterhead area, not,
- 13:50not, you know, the energy transition transitions, not all
- 13:54about commercial impact, but it's also about bringing the
- 13:58community along with you, you know, improving the, the
- 14:01lifestyle of the people living in the region and, and actually
- 14:04making it a, a sustainable and it's spinable place to work in
- 14:09and living. Now of course the port of
- 14:12Peterhead is kind of at the centre of this, but it's also,
- 14:17you know, kind of surrounded by the Saint Fergus terminal and of
- 14:20course the SSE thermal and then of course the green boat
- 14:25development being led by SSEN. So there's a a great deal going
- 14:31on here. But there was also a spending
- 14:34review. So we've seen that 200 million
- 14:37is going into the carbon capture plant and that has knock on
- 14:41effects for the port as well as the ASCO terminal.
- 14:46We're hoping to maybe start seeing shipments of carbon come
- 14:49in. You know, the plan is still to
- 14:51kind of do that, but and then we've also got the investment
- 14:55zone for the port, which should be bringing, you know,
- 14:58investment and tax breaks. So have you seen any impacts as
- 15:02a result of that too? I know it's only just been
- 15:04recent, but there just seems to be a sense that people are
- 15:07scratching their heads a little bit waiting to see detail.
- 15:10Yeah, I think from the, from the port's perspective with, with
- 15:12regards to the, the 200,000,000 lbs investment in ACORN which
- 15:16was announced last week, it, it, it's exciting news for us, you
- 15:21know as as Peterhead Port, the, the opportunity for us is to
- 15:25import CO2 into the port to be exported out to the, to the
- 15:30Goldeneye field for, for storage and carbon capture and storage.
- 15:34And for the port, that means investment that needs to be done
- 15:39in order to capture the opportunity, but also in the
- 15:42longer term means it's going to be extremely transformational
- 15:47for the port. You know, we're, we're a port
- 15:48that's, that's long been a fishing port, but it's also
- 15:52service the oil and gas community for the last 50-60
- 15:55years. And as the, the, you know, as we
- 15:58start to see an inevitable decline in the oil and gas
- 16:00industry, we need to find something that fills the space.
- 16:04And the Acorn project is certainly going to go a long way
- 16:07towards that. You know, once it's fully, fully
- 16:10funded and fully developed and fully operational in Peterhead
- 16:12Port, because just one emitter coming in through the port is
- 16:17enough to replace all our current oil and gas activity.
- 16:20So it's that kind of scale of transformational change that
- 16:23we're looking at. So, yeah.
- 16:26And then proximity plays a key part in that, but proximity also
- 16:30plays a key part in the the carbon capture and storage plant
- 16:34that Equinor and SSE Thermal are developing, which is just really
- 16:38on the periphery of the port. And as you mentioned, the
- 16:41investment zone is, is you know, Peterhead is part of the
- 16:44investment zone. And all indications seem to be
- 16:47that one of the tax sites for the investment zone will be in
- 16:50the Peterhead area. So that brings the opportunity
- 16:53for inward investment and selfishly as a support it gives
- 16:57the opportunity for the export of products and through the
- 17:01through the port, I mean you know, green hydrogen or
- 17:06sustainable aviation fuels or clean fuels or something of
- 17:09that. I mean, the hope is that, you
- 17:12know, they all work together and that, you know, the investment
- 17:16zone enables investment and expansion in infrastructure that
- 17:21helps to deliver, you know, the vision for carbon capture, as
- 17:25you say, SAF green hydrogen. You know, is there a sense
- 17:32though? You know, like, I kind of felt
- 17:34like it was in a knife edge not too long ago, but it kind of
- 17:36maybe feels like, you know, this report and, you know, Ed
- 17:40Miliband's recent investment and little 200 million there, you
- 17:44know, kind of has helped. Yeah, I think it's, you know,
- 17:48we're still a long way from, you know, moving forward at pace,
- 17:53but I think the, the, the investment from the UK
- 17:55government and the ACORN projects definitely a, a step in
- 17:58the right direction. And I should say the investment
- 18:01zone is, is, is going to be transformational for the area
- 18:04because it does give you the opportunity, if you've got
- 18:06projects that are either green energy or digital technology
- 18:10focused, then there's the opportunity to capitalize.
- 18:13And, you know, a share of £160 million / 10 years worth of
- 18:17funding. And, you know, the, the tax site
- 18:21provision is, is, is extremely, you know, is something that we
- 18:27definitely look at as well. Because as I mentioned, the, you
- 18:30know, if you want to be present, build some facilities within the
- 18:33tax site, you get all the benefits that a tax site can
- 18:36bring in terms of, you know, National Insurance
- 18:38contributions, rates relief, all that types of things.
- 18:40So all, all encourages inward investment.
- 18:43So it's it's kind of like little, little acorns, I suppose
- 18:46that are all kind of starting to starting to develop.
- 18:51And I'm hoping we'll see a snowballing effect, which is,
- 18:53you know, some funding and locks, some projects and that
- 18:57that will in turn encourage other investment in the area
- 19:01and, you know, and so on and so on until we see the big sort of
- 19:03transformational investment that we need.
- 19:06So some exciting times, both for the North Sea as it gets a
- 19:09little bit of certainty with environmental impact assessments
- 19:13and for Peterhead as it looks to double down on renewables
- 19:16investment as it accelerates the energy transition.
- 19:20However, we're going to get back to oil and how it's transported
- 19:23around the world as we finally discuss Israel and Iran.
- 20:21So avid readers of Energy Voice over the past few years will
- 20:25have known Ed Reed as our man around the globe.
- 20:30Started off looking at Africa, then started looking at Asia
- 20:33Pacific for us. Then he went off to E forward.
- 20:36But your byline has been appearing more regularly.
- 20:39And I feel like to to to, you know, celebrate that a little
- 20:43bit. We should probably do some
- 20:44international coverage. It's just a shameless.
- 20:47International coverage is quite scary.
- 20:49But yeah. Throwing you into the deep end.
- 20:52Yeah, yeah. Well, nothing says yeah, welcome
- 20:55back then the the Middle Eastern instability.
- 20:59But yeah, I mean, so I think that's the thing, right.
- 21:01Like we've seen Israel's attacks on Iran, Operation Rising Line,
- 21:05they call it sort of, you know, playing out over the last week.
- 21:10I think, look, obviously there's, there's there's an
- 21:12energy side to it. But I think, you know, primarily
- 21:15you've got to start off by thinking actually, there's a
- 21:17really human cost here, right? I think, you know, there are
- 21:19attacks going on from, you know, like Israel is setting missiles.
- 21:22They're obviously pursuing Iran's top leadership and
- 21:28likewise Iran is, is, is firing missiles sort of Willy nilly in
- 21:32it back, you know, both from Iran and, and, and from other
- 21:34places like Yemen. So I think look primarily like
- 21:37there are people here getting hurt and killed and there's the
- 21:40sort of, and then, you know, obviously we've got to sort of
- 21:43think about the energy design of things.
- 21:45And there is clearly, you know, this sort of potential for this,
- 21:48you know, sort of oil shock that we've seen in the oil price,
- 21:51right? Oil prices initially jumped to
- 21:53the night 10% and then essentially came back as it was.
- 21:56There was sort of a feeling that actually, you know, probably
- 22:00energy will be largely unscathed by these attacks at the moment.
- 22:04So we've seen some, some Israeli strikes on, I mean, they've been
- 22:07primarily focused on, as they say, sort of top leadership and
- 22:11nuclear facilities. There have been a couple of
- 22:14strikes on some energy infrastructure, a fuel depot, a
- 22:18refinery. That's one of the phases in the
- 22:21the South past that the world's largest gas field in Iran.
- 22:25But as yet nothing seems to have massively changed on that front.
- 22:28And I think obviously the big question is around the Strait of
- 22:32Hormuz, which is that key water way that links something like
- 22:3620% of the world's oil production to export markets
- 22:39around the world. And I think, you know,
- 22:41obviously, if in the sort of the doomsday scenario, Iran were to
- 22:47take action and to say, you know, you know, blockading it
- 22:50mines, I don't know, whatever, you know, sort of, you know,
- 22:53sort of technologies they they can throw at it.
- 22:55That would certainly pose challenges for the world and
- 22:58primarily China, which then would obviously seek sort of
- 23:02similar crude blends or grades from around the world.
- 23:06So I think absolutely we've got to be, we've got to be very
- 23:09aware of this. But I think the idea of Iran
- 23:14choosing to close the Strait of Hormuz would be very much a
- 23:17perfect victory for Iran. Iran obviously exports most of
- 23:21its crude. Obviously it's under sanctions.
- 23:23It's got a very limited number of people who are actually
- 23:25willing to buy Iranian crude. But the Chinese are very much,
- 23:28you know, in the mix. So Iran would essentially be
- 23:32choosing to cut off its own nose.
- 23:34And you're like, well, I mean, it's it's it's it's nice to have
- 23:37as a threat for Iran. But I suspect one that will
- 23:41never actually get played unless, as I said, there's a
- 23:45sort of dudes. I mean, obviously there's been
- 23:47talk in the last couple of days about, you know, Israel possibly
- 23:52targeting the Iran's supreme leader.
- 23:55I think, you know, President Trump has come out and said
- 23:57something quite similar along those lines.
- 24:00And you have to think if he were to be assassinated, which again
- 24:05would be unprecedented, I think, you know, the idea of killing
- 24:09other countries leaders is, is is, you know, verboten, you
- 24:12know, pretty much universally. If he were to be killed, might
- 24:17that trigger a, a, a closure of, of Hormuz?
- 24:21I mean, maybe who knows? I mean, I think it would be the
- 24:23sort of the last act of a sort of a of a regime on his legs.
- 24:26And there's very clearly no idea from Israel or the US really how
- 24:32this is going to play out, right?
- 24:33What the end game is, what they're trying to achieve in
- 24:35this sort of particular on the stored.
- 24:39But I feel that, you know, there are a number of of steps before
- 24:44we see that sort of dramatic Hormuz closure.
- 24:46Yeah, I will. Salam was speaking about it in a
- 24:49conference in Tokyo this week and he he said that that any
- 24:53impact on the straight from those would have a huge impact
- 24:56on global trade. But you did say that his firm
- 24:59has planned in the eventuality that things deteriorate.
- 25:04How robust those plans are, we don't know.
- 25:06As you say, those feel a bit like it's last, you know, last,
- 25:10last chance saloon for them if that's the case.
- 25:14But on that US interaction, I think that I think that really
- 25:19interesting because obviously I think we've all seen that Ted
- 25:23Cruz interview this week. The very it was very animated,
- 25:27very over the top. It didn't feel like it didn't
- 25:30feel like a BBC debate night interview at all.
- 25:33But you know, we heard Senator Ted Cruz say that the US is
- 25:39carrier military say strikes today.
- 25:42And that was earlier this week. And then he backtracked and
- 25:44said, oh, well, we're helping Israel.
- 25:47And then he said, we're not bombing them.
- 25:49Israel's bombing them. It's it, it feels, you know, as
- 25:54with a lot of things with the US political regime right now, it
- 25:57feels like they don't know what they're doing, which obviously
- 25:59doesn't help trying to try and assess the impact.
- 26:02Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I think that's that's
- 26:04absolutely right. And I think there is this
- 26:07element of sort of instability of volatility in the US And I
- 26:10think that I think President Trump, it kind of plays into, I
- 26:14think he's very keen to kind of essentially try and keep people
- 26:17guessing. And so I think, you know, the
- 26:20headlines, you know, recently saying this week that that the
- 26:23US wanted, you know, sort of a complete surrender from Iran
- 26:27within two weeks or something. And again, you know, I think,
- 26:30you know, the US coming into the war would pose some real
- 26:35challenges. I think, you know, essentially 2
- 26:39complete, you know, to, to, to, to carry out those, those, those
- 26:42attacks on the kind of, you know, essentially facilities
- 26:45that are buried deep underground in Iran.
- 26:47Israel would need AUS assistance, right?
- 26:50I think the US has got the technology to to to attack those
- 26:53those in ways that Israel doesn't.
- 26:57But I think, you know, there is a big question.
- 26:58What does, what is the US domestic political appetite for
- 27:03a war in Iran? And I think there are there are
- 27:05also kind of new knock on questions, right?
- 27:07We are obviously as the UK are kind of close allies of the US.
- 27:11It's a difficult relationship for Starmer to to to navigate
- 27:15obviously sort of trade talks going backwards and forwards.
- 27:18Would the UK have to take a position?
- 27:20Would the UK have to, you know, and then and then I think, I
- 27:23think for me, I think the the concern is, is in terms of sort
- 27:25of the the Iranian response, it's not so much about Hormuz,
- 27:28it's about sort of asymmetric terrorism, right?
- 27:31So I think, you know, tackling, you know, you know, missile or
- 27:34drone strikes in the Red Sea. I think that's that's something
- 27:37we should, you know, really be be aware of and, you know,
- 27:39around the world, right? I think, you know, there was
- 27:41something like 19 travel advisories from the FCDO after
- 27:45the sort of, you know, the sort of the launch of this, these,
- 27:47these Israeli attacks, you know, which essentially points to the
- 27:51fact that Iran does have the ability, although it's been much
- 27:55degraded over the last year or two, to carry out attacks in
- 27:59various places. And at the point where the US
- 28:03and UK interests start being drawn into, you know, being a
- 28:07sort of potential targets, that's when it starts to get
- 28:11quite worrying. So I think at the moment we're
- 28:13sort of skirting around it a bit.
- 28:15And obviously, you know, we've got to hope that there's some
- 28:17sort of an agreement reached where, you know, maybe Iran sort
- 28:21of commits to, I don't know, de escalating nuclear technology,
- 28:25you know, sort of return to the return to the sort of JCPOA that
- 28:28obviously Trump famously, you know, reneged on in in, in his
- 28:33first presidency. I think those are the sorts of
- 28:35things we've got to be thinking about because at the moment it
- 28:37feels like there's, well, it feels like there's, there's,
- 28:40it's hard to see how things escalate.
- 28:42It's also hard to see an, an off ramp.
- 28:44I think it's how do we, how do we walk this back?
- 28:46I suppose the the the crux of this really is, is, is less
- 28:51nuclear energy, more nuclear weapons that they're worried
- 28:53about, right? But I, I, you hear, you've heard
- 28:57of quite a few people online speaking about this over the
- 28:59past week or so sort of saying, but you know, Israel has been
- 29:04claiming that Iran's got nuclear weapons since the 90s.
- 29:07You know, it says this isn't a new, new argument that things
- 29:10have definitely escalated. But in terms of that, any of
- 29:13that oil export thing that you're touching on earlier, I'd
- 29:17like to say cycle back to that because I was looking at some
- 29:19really interesting pictures this morning.
- 29:22Essentially in Iran, they've got these oil tankers, they've got
- 29:25floating roofs. So with aerial pictures, you can
- 29:28see just how much is in in the tanks.
- 29:32And Bloomberg was reporting this morning that essentially these
- 29:34things are full, but you know, they're trying to load up
- 29:38tankers as quickly as possible. Do you think that maybe that's
- 29:42that's a case of Iran trying to trying to keep selling before
- 29:46before Israel does try to tackle those trade routes?
- 29:49Yeah. I mean, I think, I think that
- 29:51they've clearly got to be thinking about, you know, sort
- 29:53of risk management, right? And I mean, I think, but I mean,
- 29:55you know, Iran has been struggling to move its crude,
- 30:00obviously for some years. And even before the Israeli
- 30:04strikes beginning, you know, we were seeing signs that, you
- 30:08know, Trump was again, talking about, you know, cracking down
- 30:11essentially on on Iranian exports to bring sort of more
- 30:14pressure to bear. So I think, yeah, I mean, I
- 30:16think it's it's it's extremely likely that Iran will be looking
- 30:19at all ways in which it can, you know, push all out of the
- 30:22country and, you know, essentially largely to China.
- 30:26It's it's but it's going to be a challenge, right?
- 30:28I think, you know, obviously looking at, you know, Hormuz,
- 30:32it's, it's, it's a choke point, but it's a choke point for, you
- 30:35know, kind of, you know, both sides, right.
- 30:36I think, you know, in terms of sort of tracking those ships.
- 30:40I, I guess that's maybe another, another, another way that the US
- 30:45or Israel may be thinking about, you know, how do you put
- 30:48pressure on the Iranian regime? How do you, you know, obviously
- 30:51tackling that that kind of, you know, influx of cash, maybe
- 30:55that's another, another, another, another, another route
- 30:57for kind of consideration? Well, that wasn't the the
- 31:00cheeriest topic and the Friday on, however it was, it was an
- 31:03important one that we had we had to touch on.
- 31:05But unfortunately, that is the end of the program this week.
- 31:09So thank you very much, Matt. Thank you very much, Ed, for
- 31:12joining me this week. Just just a quick throw ahead.
- 31:15Ed, you spoke about this at the top of the show.
- 31:17We should probably flag it at the end.
- 31:18Next week you are going to be in Liverpool and I believe people
- 31:21can still sign up with their E Forward members, right?
- 31:24Yeah, I think, I think if you're quick, get your application in
- 31:29fast, you know, we are keen to get as many diverse voices in
- 31:33the room as possible. So yeah.
- 31:36Come along well with that. Thank you very much for
- 31:38listening and we'll see you next week.