Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #36: Home Rule Part 1 - How Much Autonomy Should Local Governments Have?
Transcript
- 0:00We're back at it again.
- 0:01Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:04I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:07Today, we're gonna be talking about home rule.
- 0:10Government is divided into three basic geographic levels.
- 0:14You've got federal, state, and local level.
- 0:17And there are a lot of complex interactions that happen between all three of those, and
- 0:22what gets most of the attention in that regard is the tug and pull between the federal and
- 0:28state governments.
- 0:30We've seen an arguably number larger number of clashes between the federal and state levels in
- 0:36the past couple decades, but cooperation and conflicts between the state and local levels of
- 0:44government can be just as important, yet such instances usually get much less attention.
- 0:51This is typically the case with anything relating to local government because it's the
- 0:56level that just generally has less attention paid to it, but it's the level of government
- 1:02that has the most direct impact on our daily lives.
- 1:06And the interaction between state and local government is perhaps more convoluted than it
- 1:11is between the federal and state governments, and it needs to be talked about just as much.
- 1:17And this gets into what we call home rule, which can be briefly described as a local
- 1:23government's capacity to administer its own affairs apart from state government
- 1:28involvement.
- 1:29Yet how far should home rule extend?
- 1:33What types of policy should be in the purview of local government and which should be in the
- 1:37purview of state government?
- 1:39What other factors do we need to consider?
- 1:42All these things and more are, surprise, subject to considerable debate like most things
- 1:48in politics.
- 1:49We're gonna make this a two parter because we need to I wanna cover as much ground as
- 1:55possible.
- 1:55Can't really do that in one episode.
- 1:57So today, we focus on the basics of home rule, where we see it, and a bit of a history lesson
- 2:04as to how it developed because we all need to know our history.
- 2:08And then next time, we'll talk more about recent developments in home rule and why you
- 2:14should care about it.
- 2:15But for now, part one.
- 2:17Let's go.
- 2:18The US constitution and local governments.
- 2:22The US constitution makes clear some responsibilities of federal government.
- 2:26Now that's the whole you know, some of those things are are a bit of a debate, obviously,
- 2:33but to some extent, the US constitution marks a clear delineation between federal and state
- 2:40government.
- 2:42Though it does not specifically mention the word, it's where we get the concept of
- 2:46federalism from.
- 2:47You have dual federalism, and you have cooperative federalism.
- 2:50Dual federalism, think of it as sometimes described as a layer cake where there's
- 2:55separate spheres.
- 2:56Federal government does this thing.
- 2:58State government does this thing.
- 3:00And then you have the cooperative federalism, which is considered more like a marble cake,
- 3:05which is their shared responsibilities within a sphere.
- 3:09So federal and state government both have a hand in certain things like some aspects of law
- 3:15enforcement.
- 3:16Sometimes federal and state government will be involved in an investigation.
- 3:22However, the US constitution makes no mention of local governments.
- 3:27That is left mostly to the states through the tenth amendment, which is basically powers not
- 3:35expressly given to the federal government through the US constitution belong to the
- 3:40states.
- 3:41In practice, however, the federal government does have some direct authority over local
- 3:47governments.
- 3:47We'll get to that in a little bit.
- 3:49But like many political concepts, that demarcation between state and local governments
- 3:56has developed quite a bit over time.
- 3:59And because there are many different ways that the structure and function of state governments
- 4:05have developed, so too has that been the case for the local level of government as well.
- 4:10And as a result, the relationship between federal and state governments is somewhat
- 4:17analogous to the relationship between state and local government.
- 4:22There is there's a sort of federalism where state government again, that dual federalism
- 4:26where there's spheres where the state government is or has jurisdiction, and then the
- 4:33local governments have jurisdiction, and then you have cooperative federalism where state and
- 4:37local have some interconnecting responsibilities within a given sphere of
- 4:43influence.
- 4:47And just as The US constitution has that supremacy clause where US constitution is the
- 4:54supreme law of the land, you can't have any sort of state or local laws or even federal
- 4:59laws that conflict with the US constitution.
- 5:02Now that doesn't quite get into how people interpret the US constitution, but, state
- 5:08constitutions also have supremacy over local governments.
- 5:13And just as there is some debate over where the dividing line is between federal and state
- 5:19governments, there are similar conflicts for state versus local, although perhaps more
- 5:27convoluted.
- 5:28So how exactly do we get to this point of this interaction between state and local
- 5:36governments?
- 5:37Well, go back a little bit into history.
- 5:39We talk about what's called Dillon's rule.
- 5:43So prior to this more, I don't wanna say concentration, but a little bit more of a focus
- 5:51on home rule and how much it should extend at least of today.
- 5:55States primarily followed what was called Dillon's rule, and it's named after a judge by
- 6:01the name of John Forrest Dillon.
- 6:03He had served as the chief justice of the Iowa Supreme Court and later became a US circuit
- 6:09judge during president Ulysses s Grant's presidential administration.
- 6:15And he wrote quite extensively on municipal law.
- 6:19He was one of the foremost legal minds when it came to municipal law and how it interacted
- 6:25with state government.
- 6:26And most notably, he had an 1872 book called commentaries on the law of municipal
- 6:31corporations, Corporations being these local governments that existed, not quite
- 6:38corporations like businesses.
- 6:41But in two court decisions in 1868 while he was on Iowa's supreme court.
- 6:47He was the chief justice then.
- 6:48Dillon wrote that local governments only had power given to them by state governments.
- 6:54To a little more detail, but still pretty succinct, three basic tenets to what local
- 7:03governments could do.
- 7:04They had to have their powers expressly granted to them by the state governments.
- 7:09The powers were necessarily implied as part of the powers expressly granted.
- 7:14So if they, the government told them, oh, they can they can form this kind of government, any
- 7:21sort of powers that they didn't necessarily specify of how they can form this government,
- 7:25but would be needed to form that type of local government, they were also allowed to do.
- 7:30And things that were absolutely essential to the function of local government since even if
- 7:37you strictly follow Dillon's rule, it can't account for every single little thing that a
- 7:42local government can do.
- 7:44So, basically, anything that was explicitly that local governments were explicitly told
- 7:50they could do by state governments and the ways that they absolutely needed to be able to
- 7:54implement what state governments told them they can do, that was what local governments were
- 7:59allowed to do.
- 8:00And he was really Dylan, d I l l o n, he was really just expressing conventional wisdom at
- 8:07the time, but he was the first to really considerably expound on the interaction between
- 8:12state and local power.
- 8:14So that is why it's called Dillon's rule even though he's not the first person to really come
- 8:18up with it.
- 8:19And because state governments had so much authority over local government, you saw a lot
- 8:26more special legislation passed by state governments back then than there is now.
- 8:31Now you do still see these special acts.
- 8:34Special legislation basically means legislation that's aimed towards specific localities as
- 8:40opposed to general legislation.
- 8:42So if New York passed a law specifically for New York City or or California's passed one
- 8:50specifically for Los Angeles or Florida passed one specifically for Leon County, which is
- 8:56where the capital Tallahassee is.
- 8:58Those are special legislation as opposed to all counties have to abide by x y z rules.
- 9:04That's general legislation.
- 9:07But back then, local back in these earlier days in the nineteenth century and even a lot of the
- 9:12twentieth century, local governments and the representatives had to continually petition
- 9:18their state governments for changes.
- 9:19And you still see it today in places where home rule is a lot more restricted, but you
- 9:26especially saw it in earlier times where home rule was even less prevalent than it is now.
- 9:34So you still see a lot of special legislation in states that adhere closer to Dillon's rule
- 9:39because that's where if you adhere more to Dillon's rule, it means that there's less home
- 9:45rule, and local governments basically can only do or mostly can only do what state governments
- 9:53tell them they can do.
- 9:55However, after Dillon's role, there was considerable pushback.
- 10:00One of the most notable instances coming from contemporary Thomas McIntyre Cooley.
- 10:06He was the Michigan supreme Michigan supreme court chief justice, and he argued in an 1871
- 10:13ruling that local governments have some inherent rights of self governance.
- 10:18And he pointed to, for example, municipalities in colonial days governing their own affairs.
- 10:24So just like how there was a lot of debate with the creation of the US constitution, how much
- 10:33power and responsibility do state governments have and keep compared to what federal
- 10:39government has use, and a lot of it was states have some inherent rights of self governance,
- 10:44so too did a lot of these home rule advocates argue the same for local governments having
- 10:50some level of self governance rights.
- 10:54And Coolidge rule was picking up some steam in other states like Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky,
- 11:00Texas.
- 11:02But then the US Supreme Court upheld Dillon's role in nineteen o three and 1923 cases.
- 11:08So the it started to have a little bit of a setback, this home rule push, but some states
- 11:16began adopting home rule provisions in their state constitutions and statutes starting in
- 11:22the early twentieth century.
- 11:25So how do we exactly tell which states follow Homer rule and which ones follow Dillon's rule?
- 11:34Well, if we we first of all look to primarily state constitutions that as to which ones
- 11:42dictate that there's a lot lot more home rule.
- 11:45But there are also state statutes that have some input as well.
- 11:50State constitutions being at the primary rule of law besides The US constitution and federal
- 11:56law, obviously, and then state statutes right below state constitutions.
- 12:04A state constitution will probably have an article saying something like local government
- 12:08or municipal corporations, and then statutes might have a piece or a what they call title
- 12:15called municipalities and possibly a chapter or section called powers that's below that.
- 12:23But instead of saying this state follows home rule, this state follows Dillon's rule, it's
- 12:29more accurate to say to what degree local governments within a state have home rule
- 12:36because some states adhere to both in some degrees.
- 12:41Because home rule can differ both by state and sometimes within a state.
- 12:46It can differ by the type of local governments, the type of of, power that is afforded to local
- 12:54governments, the size of this of the of a local government's population or at least that or the
- 13:00of the population that's within that local government's jurisdiction.
- 13:03It can differ by policy or program area.
- 13:06So counties, for example, might have more home rule than cities do, or maybe the cities have
- 13:12more home rule than the counties do.
- 13:14Cities with a certain population threshold might be afforded more home rule power, like if
- 13:19they have 5,000 people under their jurisdiction.
- 13:26Maybe a specific program area like, how how how they handle picking up trash, for example.
- 13:35They might have a little bit more home rule than, say, taxation policy.
- 13:42And the the easiest way to to sort of delineate the level of home rule in that regard is and
- 13:50the National League of Cities, which is probably the premier advocate advocacy group
- 13:57for these local governments, at least for cities, they describe it as four categories
- 14:04where a state may allow discretionary authority, or in other words, where they allow
- 14:10local governments to have more autonomous input as to how the local government is is structured
- 14:20and functions.
- 14:21So the four categories that they use is, one, they're structural.
- 14:25So that's talking about how to form a government, charters, and enacting charter
- 14:30revisions.
- 14:31Charter is you can basically think of it as a constitution for a local government.
- 14:35So a lot of cities, especially big ones, will have a charter which outlines laws specific to
- 14:43that locality.
- 14:44Now there's there's still a lot of state laws that they have to abide by, but they have more
- 14:50leeway than a, generally speaking, at least, than a city that had that does not have a
- 14:56charter.
- 14:56Not always the case, but generally speaking, it is.
- 15:00And then how to form a government.
- 15:02So do they have to follow a mayor and city council form form of government?
- 15:09Does the mayor is the mayor a separate entity, or is he elected or is he part of the city
- 15:16council and he's a he or she is elected by the city council?
- 15:20How many people can be on that city council?
- 15:24Can counties have a mayor?
- 15:26Because usually mayor is specifically for a city or town or village, but you do see some
- 15:32counties that also have mayors.
- 15:35So what are those rules allowed there?
- 15:38And so a state constitution may or state statute may say, you can pick from these types
- 15:44of of of government structures or they have to follow this specific one.
- 15:52So if a city has more home rule in that regard, they can have a lot more say as to how exactly
- 15:59they form their government.
- 16:02Second category, functional.
- 16:04So we're talking the ability to exercise local government in a broad or limited manner.
- 16:12Number three, fiscal.
- 16:14So how do they determine revenue sources?
- 16:17Can they set tax rates, borrow funds, etcetera?
- 16:21Personnel.
- 16:23So whether they these local governments can set employment rules or remuneration rates,
- 16:29employment conditions, collective bargaining.
- 16:32So, again, first category, structural.
- 16:36Second category, functional.
- 16:38Third category, fiscal.
- 16:39Fourth category, personnel.
- 16:41These are the four basic categories where a state may allow discretionary authority.
- 16:46And usually, the broadest discretionary authority given to local governments is in the
- 16:52structural category.
- 16:54So based things like what structure of or how how can the government be formed?
- 17:02How exactly does it look?
- 17:04Usually, local governments have most leeway in that regard.
- 17:07And then the narrowest powers are in finance.
- 17:10So their ability to set tax rates, a lot of that, they have to these local governments have
- 17:16to go to the state to be able to determine how to set their tax rates or what kinds of revenue
- 17:24sources they have, whether they can borrow funds, and so on.
- 17:28And because of the complications of these interweaving stipulations, it's hard to say how
- 17:36many states follow home rule to x y z degrees and how many follow Dillon's rule to x y z
- 17:43degrees.
- 17:43Like like we said earlier, it's not as simple as, oh, this state follows home rule, but this
- 17:47state follows Dillon's rule.
- 17:48Doesn't quite work like that.
- 17:51Wikipedia has a list, but like most things that you see on Wikipedia, you have to take it with
- 17:58a grain of salt.
- 18:01And it's also not immediately clear how often it gets updated.
- 18:06It cites the National League of Cities, for totals of home rule and Dillon's role as to
- 18:11which states follow home rule and which ones follow Dylan's role and which ones follow both
- 18:17to some extent, but the citation comes from 2016.
- 18:21So it's probably not the most reliable.
- 18:26I I'd had to do a lot more research and digging into that.
- 18:30But for what it's worth, Wikipedia does have a list.
- 18:35Just be of course, like I said, be careful if you try to go by what it says.
- 18:43But an example of where states example of a state where home rule is quite limited or
- 18:50mostly prevented is a place like Alabama.
- 18:53And it's partly why Alabama's constitution is so absurdly long.
- 18:58Like, it's close to, if not at 400,000 words, which is way higher than I forget what the
- 19:06second largest state constitution is, but it's like a 50, hundred 60 thousand words more than
- 19:13the next largest constitution.
- 19:15And a lot of that is because it's been amended repeatedly to allow for specific local
- 19:21government powers without granting broader home rule power.
- 19:26So it and you need more special legislation to or the these local governments need more
- 19:34special legislation to be able to allow them to do certain things.
- 19:38It's they've just had to add on more and more to the state constitution and to the state
- 19:43statutes.
- 19:45But states where home rule is more expansive are ones like Florida and West Virginia.
- 19:51Florida is considered one of, if not the most home rule friendly states, although there have
- 19:57been some controversies, if you will, lately in regards to whether Florida is allowing for more
- 20:08home rule.
- 20:08There's been some well, the way they call state preemption where local governments try to do
- 20:16something and then the state tells them, nope.
- 20:18You can't do that.
- 20:19Or goes specifically tells them they can't do it before the local government tries to do
- 20:23something.
- 20:24Back in 2018, I think it was, there was a ban on or or there were a couple local governments
- 20:31that were trying to ban plastic straws, and the state government I I can't remember if they
- 20:36actually passed the law specifically.
- 20:39I believe they did, where they banned the plastic straw bans.
- 20:44It's basically a ban on a ban.
- 20:46Just as one example of of things that's where some people say that home rule in Florida is
- 20:56being more restricted.
- 20:58But generally speaking, though, home rule is still a lot more home rule friendly than some
- 21:02other states.
- 21:03West Virginia is another state where home rule is more expansive.
- 21:07They have a thing called a municipal home program, which is, part of the West Virginia
- 21:12code that sort of has the the guidelines for home rule municipal home rule program.
- 21:21Excuse me.
- 21:23So there is, that in in West Virginia.
- 21:29If a city does have a higher amount of home rule power, you may see a charter like we
- 21:35talked about before.
- 21:35It's basically like a constitution for a local government.
- 21:39Now it does not inherently mean that there's more home rule for that local government or in
- 21:46that state, but, and NSA may have to still grant much of those provisions, but it might
- 21:53indicate that that local government has a lot more autonomy than a than a city or town that
- 21:59does not have a charter.
- 22:03Now I do wanna make clear that even though we talked primarily about state governments and
- 22:09local governments interacting because that's what most of this controversy, you will,
- 22:17regarding home rule or this debate, I should say, regarding home rule.
- 22:21It mostly focuses on the state government versus local government interaction, but there
- 22:25are still some federal government interactions with local government because just because the
- 22:31US constitution is silent about local governments and state governments have the most
- 22:38purview over the local governments, it does not mean that the federal government has no
- 22:42interaction with local whatsoever.
- 22:46But much of the federal local interactions come from grants and aid for projects that local and
- 22:52federal policymakers want.
- 22:54So but you see state budgets.
- 22:56A lot of times, they have these local projects that need to be funded.
- 23:01Federal budgets also have some of these local projects.
- 23:06And there might be some restriction on what these grants are for.
- 23:12One noticeable exception in that regard was back during the Ronald Reagan administration,
- 23:20they had a lot more block grants where they had a lot less stipulation as to what these grants
- 23:27could be used for.
- 23:28There was a little bit more of a the states can figure and the local governments can figure out
- 23:33what they're gonna spend the money on.
- 23:36But generally speaking, though, federal grants, there is some restriction as to what those what
- 23:47what those grants are allowed to be used for.
- 23:52However, there are some cases where federal governments, particularly congress, have more
- 23:58authority over local affairs, especially back in earlier times, back when some states were
- 24:05still unorganized territories, congress had a lot of power over them.
- 24:09They enacted laws, established territorial governments, confirmed territorial governors,
- 24:15judges, and marshals, finance administrative operations.
- 24:19One example, future US president Andrew Jackson was a territorial governor of Florida.
- 24:25I believe he was the fur very first one, I wanna say.
- 24:28But because these territories didn't have their own governments initially, congress did have a
- 24:33lot of authority over them, but you still see a little bit of that in more recent times.
- 24:41For example, congress is heavily involved in the administration of Washington DC, although
- 24:46the district's home rule act in 1973 did decrease some of that.
- 24:51So Washington DC has a little bit more autonomy back now than they did about fifty plus years
- 24:59ago, but congress still retains control over Washington DC's budget and can overturn some
- 25:06local ordinances.
- 25:08And then congress also does things like confirm presidential nominees to local judiciaries in
- 25:14the current territories we have.
- 25:15So Puerto Rico, Guam, the US Virgin Virgin Islands, Northern Mariana Islands, the American
- 25:22Samoa.
- 25:23So you still see a lot more involvement by congress there.
- 25:29And then because these are still territories, they don't they they have some nonvoting
- 25:35delegates to the US Congress.
- 25:37So they sit down on US Congress.
- 25:39They can provide some level of input on bills, but they can't actually vote on these bills
- 25:46that are in congress.
- 25:49And then other ways of federal control over local affairs include the reservations of huge
- 25:55tracts of land for national use as a condition for granting statehood.
- 26:00Props to you if you know what I was just referencing there for huge tracts of land.
- 26:05It was money pie found on the holy grail.
- 26:08But some of these tracts have been used for military reservations, national parks and
- 26:14forests, fish and wildlife management.
- 26:17And there's also some reservations for Native American tribes that have some measure of self
- 26:22governing power, though congress still has some control over them, and that, of course, has led
- 26:28to some disputes over the years, quite a few disputes over the years.
- 26:33Now speaking of these disputes, not not necessarily in regards to Native American
- 26:40tribes, but disputes over home rule in general, you can find Republicans, Democrats, and
- 26:47independents that support home rule or that support Dillon's rule.
- 26:51So it's not really as much of a partisan issue as one might think.
- 26:55You might expect Republicans slash conservatives.
- 26:59Again, party and and ideology are not the exact same thing, although there's correlation.
- 27:05So some conservatives might not be Republicans.
- 27:08Some Republicans might not be conservatives, but you might expect Republicans and
- 27:13conservatives to be more supportive of home rule.
- 27:16But we see some instances of Republican governance governments stepping into local
- 27:22affairs often.
- 27:24Just mention my home state, Florida, in that regard.
- 27:28It's a very Republican state government, and they've had a little bit more involvement in
- 27:33local affairs as of the last decade, give or take.
- 27:42But what are some arguments that you might see regarding how much home rule these local
- 27:48governments should have.
- 27:50Remember, there there could be degrees of support for home rule.
- 27:54So somebody may be more supportive of home rule in regards to how they can structure a local
- 28:00government, but they might support Dillon's rule in terms of how the local government can
- 28:06finance itself.
- 28:06So they might say local governments have should have a lot more leeway as to how they structure
- 28:12themselves, but they might say in terms of how to generate tax revenue or how or their tax
- 28:19rates that they should say, hey.
- 28:21The state government should still dictate what they can do in that regard.
- 28:25But to make things simpler, we're gonna boil down basic stances based on a handful of
- 28:32questions to consider.
- 28:34So we won't have it won't be in regard to, in this sphere, advocates say home the the home
- 28:43rule should be what goes.
- 28:46But in this sphere, this is what Dylan's rule advocates say this should go.
- 28:50We're just gonna base it on some specific questions and then what home rule advocates
- 28:57would probably say and then what Dylan's rule advocates would probably say.
- 29:01So question one, is home rule or Dillon's rule better for tackling corruption in government?
- 29:10So a home rule advocate might say that state governments having an undue influence over
- 29:16these local governments opens the door for corruption at the state level to pick and
- 29:20choose winners in terms of officials and issues at the local level.
- 29:25And it it was a part of what prompted pushes for home rule in the first place in the late
- 29:32nineteenth and early twentieth century.
- 29:34For example, the progressive era, the the early twentieth century, progressive era reformers.
- 29:42Progressives of the early twentieth century and of the twenty first century, there's some
- 29:46similar, ethos there, but the issues are a lot different.
- 29:52So a progressive of the early twentieth century is not exactly the same kind of progressive as
- 29:59one in the twenty first century, but, they were a major example of of reformers who argued more
- 30:09for home rule because they saw state governments as being highly corrupt in how
- 30:15they, interacted with local governments, picking those winners and losers, like I was
- 30:20just saying.
- 30:22But Dillon's rule advocates would say that state governments need to keep these local
- 30:27governments in check.
- 30:28They need to make sure that they don't get out of line, or if they do get out of line, punish
- 30:32them when they do.
- 30:33So for example, you see state governors, the the level of authority they have to do this can
- 30:40vary between states, but they can suspend or remove certain local government officials for
- 30:46corruption.
- 30:49And people such as John Ford's Dylan argued for the state's more active involvement to tackle
- 30:55low local government corruption in the first place, basically saying, the state government
- 31:00needs to make sure that they prevent local government from getting out of hand.
- 31:05So that's the argument about what is best to tackle corruption in government.
- 31:12Question two, what should be the basic relationship between local and state
- 31:17governments?
- 31:18So home rule advocates would say, for example, local government has or local governments have
- 31:26inherent self governance rights apart from state governments akin to what state
- 31:31governments have apart from federal government.
- 31:34So they would use a lot of that argument about states' rights and apply it to local government
- 31:40rights.
- 31:42Whereas, Dillon's role advocates will say local governments are more so sub or administrative
- 31:47subdivisions of the state.
- 31:49Basically, they're creatures of the state and would say that it's not quite the same
- 31:55relationship between the state and federal government.
- 31:59And partly because of the tenth amendment saying that federal government's mostly left it
- 32:05up to the states as to how to deal with local government.
- 32:09Question three, can states budding into local affairs basically be a proxy for federal
- 32:15government involvement?
- 32:16So a home rule advocate might say that state governments, especially now, are starting to
- 32:22act more at the behest of federal government when the well, of course, when the state and
- 32:27the federal government align ideologically and partisanly because you still see sometimes
- 32:32state governments and federal government do not get along because they're not the same party.
- 32:37They're not the same ideology, making it more of a federal overreach.
- 32:42So we talk about now with immigration enforcement.
- 32:47You're seeing ICE have more deals with local law enforcement for counties and cities for
- 32:57rounding up depending on your point of view.
- 33:00Some people would call them illegal immigrants.
- 33:02Some people would call them undocumented migrants.
- 33:07But, basically, people who are not officially citizens of The United States.
- 33:13So they might say so that's a big example that some people would say of it being federal
- 33:20overreach even though, technically, it's state governments doing it of their own accord.
- 33:24They're basically being what they might say is coerced by the federal government to implement
- 33:33such policies.
- 33:34Whereas Dylan's role advocates might say that state governments, whether they are aligned
- 33:39with federal government, are still acting of their own accord and are within their rights to
- 33:43administer local affairs accordingly.
- 33:46And sometimes even if a state government or federal government or state and federal
- 33:51government are aligned together, they might not have the exact same kind of program in mind.
- 33:58So if we talk about immigration again, in Florida, it's just I use Florida just because
- 34:04it's my my home state, so it's easy for me to refer to it as an example.
- 34:10When the or right before the state legislative session started this year in 2025, there was a
- 34:21lot of Republican leaders in the state government and governor Ron DeSantis, also a
- 34:26Republican, even though they're both of the same party.
- 34:29They had a lot of disagreement over how exactly to implement immigration policy from the
- 34:37federal government from Donald Trump's administration.
- 34:40So they a Dylann's role advocate might look at that and say, well, it's it's it's they're not
- 34:47just doing exactly what the federal government is telling them to do.
- 34:50They're still implementing their own spin on federal policy.
- 34:53So, really, it's not federal overreach.
- 34:56Of course, home rule advocate would disagree with that.
- 34:59Question four, how much oversight should state governments have over local governments?
- 35:07So a home rule advocate will say something like a state government is too dissociated from the
- 35:13needs and issues of the local governments.
- 35:15They're just way too far away in a lot of cases.
- 35:18So it makes sense to let these local governments have more power in governing their
- 35:22own affairs.
- 35:24Whereas a Dillon's rule advocate will say a local government is still a creature of the
- 35:29state government, and state governments are close enough to local governments where that
- 35:34they are capable of overseeing what is happening to them.
- 35:37So it's this whole what what is too far away, especially, you know, back when the US
- 35:45constitution was being debated and then the articles of confederation, these state
- 35:51governments, one of the big reasons for besides just general philosophy of having state
- 35:58governments have some level of self governance is they said that you you saw this in the
- 36:04Federalist Papers, that were arguing for The US constitution's ratification.
- 36:10That's because the a lot of these state governments were so far away and especially
- 36:15back then in the eighteenth century where communication took a long time to cross
- 36:21businesses, not like now where you have the phones and the Internet.
- 36:27But the idea was they they still needed some level of of self the states needed some level
- 36:35of self governance because the federal government was too far away.
- 36:39And so you see home rule advocates argue a very similar thing for local governments, but a
- 36:48diligent advocate will say state governments are a lot closer to these local governments
- 36:53than the federal government is to a lot of these state governments.
- 36:57And some other questions to consider when we talk about whether a state should follow home
- 37:03rule or should follow Dillon's rule or should follow both of them to some extent.
- 37:08Does Dillon's rule work better for one state's intricacies while home rule works better for
- 37:14another state?
- 37:15Like I talk about for elections.
- 37:18Each election, you might find some similarities, but each election is has its own
- 37:25unique factors to consider.
- 37:27It's a similar thing for states.
- 37:30Does Dillon's rule work better for Georgia compared to Oregon or for New Mexico compared
- 37:38to Nebraska, for example?
- 37:41Or or or do those states have special unique circumstances for those states that makes it
- 37:49better to have home rule versus Dillon's rule?
- 37:5550 different states.
- 37:5650 and even though they will all have a lot of them will have some similarities, how exactly
- 38:04do those differences affect whether Dillon's rule or home rule is better for those states?
- 38:10Is Dillon's rule better for states with smaller populations and home rule better for states
- 38:15with a larger population?
- 38:16So we talk about couple of those earlier questions about, should should the states have
- 38:21a lot more oversight of local governments or, just that general relationship between state
- 38:30and local government.
- 38:31Is it easier for a state government to have a lot more say over what local governments can do
- 38:40in a state that has 2,000,000 people versus a state that has 30,000,000 people, the idea
- 38:48might be that while there's too many citizens in this state to dictate what each and every
- 38:57one of their local governments say and do.
- 39:00So maybe those states should have more home rule than a state that's a lot less populated
- 39:05where the state government can have a lot more easily oversee what those local governments are
- 39:13doing.
- 39:14You might see some difference in argument there.
- 39:16And then should we have both types of of both Dillon's rule and Home rule within a state
- 39:24based on the population within a local government jurisdiction?
- 39:28Talked about earlier, go back to population.
- 39:31In a couple of states at least, there are some more home rule powers of fortitude governments
- 39:37where the jurisdiction has at least 5,000 people.
- 39:40So should we have more home rule for states as they get or for local governments as they get
- 39:47bigger and bigger and bigger?
- 39:48Like, if a state has 25,000 people, 50,000 people, hundred thousand, two hundred thousand,
- 39:55one million people, should we see differences in home rule there?
- 40:01Would it get too complicated to have each of those stipulations where, oh, if it's if it's,
- 40:07you know, all these exceptions where if if this city or this county is of this population, they
- 40:15get more home rule powers in x y z regards.
- 40:19So a whole bunch of different questions to really think about when it comes to home rules
- 40:24just to give you a sense of the debate.
- 40:27And, obviously, it gets a lot deeper than that, but this is just one trying to make a sort of
- 40:33primer to the whole debate about home rule and how far it should extend.
- 40:40Of course, as always, I'm I don't take I mean, I have my own thoughts, of course, but I don't
- 40:46take official sides on anything.
- 40:48I'm not gonna tell you that home rule is better or that Dillon's rule is better, or I think
- 40:54it's one is better in x y z circumstances and the other one is better in a b c circumstances.
- 41:04That that's that's for you to decide.
- 41:05But just to give you a sense of the the parameters of the debate.
- 41:12And then in the next episode where we talk about home rule, we will I will get a lot more
- 41:18into the recent developments of home rule and some of the challenges facing it and why a
- 41:26little bit more into why you should care.
- 41:29Talks about a little bit about that already, but wanna get a little bit more in-depth in the
- 41:32next episode.
- 41:33But we are out of time for today.
- 41:36So as always, thank you so much for listening, watching.
- 41:41Please like, comment, subscribe, share with all your friends and enemies and and family.
- 41:48Every any anybody you encounter would tremendously appreciate it.
- 41:52Links in the show notes for my Facebook, LinkedIn, my educational email course, short
- 41:57educational email course about some common mistakes made when trying to depolarize the
- 42:03political climate in America.
- 42:06My book, why independents rarely win elections, and how did they become more competitive?
- 42:11My website, PaulRaider.org, and couple of other things in there as well.
- 42:16So go ahead and check those out.
- 42:18But once again, thank you so much for listening, and until next time.
- 42:23Take care.