Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 128: On bikes, the Olympics, & the Transforming City with Brent Longley
Transcript
- 0:08You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:10I'm your host, Lindsay Tremuda. There's nothing like leaving
- 0:15Paris for a short time to reset some perspectives.
- 0:19I've recently returned from 10 days in New York and the
- 0:21Philadelphia region, hence why things have been a bit quiet on
- 0:24the show and I was struck by how worn and behind both
- 0:28destinations felt. Part of that might be lingering
- 0:31impact of the pandemic, and part of it may be insufficient funds
- 0:35devoted to much needed improvements to public services
- 0:38and transportation. Whatever's going on, it only
- 0:41serves to amplify how good we have it.
- 0:43In Paris, where major investment in urban renewal policies have
- 0:47shaped the city, the difference felt stark.
- 0:50Paris has 1000 kilometres of cycle paths and is in the
- 0:53process of expanding and updating its train network.
- 0:57By comparison, New York subway and its streets felt dilapidated
- 1:01and neglected. And so I returned with greater
- 1:04appreciation and less irritation at all the pre Olympics Rd.
- 1:08works and especially an urge to discuss this topic with a
- 1:11friend. Brent Longley is an urbanist who
- 1:14moved to Paris a year ago with fervent support for our mayor
- 1:17and her transformative policies. I knew he'd have just the right
- 1:21expertise to discuss Paris as a global leader in urban renewal,
- 1:25the opposition that still exists to some of the changes underway,
- 1:29and where the Olympics fits into the equation of a sustainable
- 1:33metropolis. Welcome to the show, Brent.
- 1:38Thanks, Lindsay. This is your first podcast, if
- 1:41I'm correct. That is right, yes.
- 1:43I am. I'm really glad to be doing this
- 1:45with you because you have an expertise that few people that I
- 1:49know personally can claim to have.
- 1:52And it leads to some very interesting conversations that
- 1:55we have offline or off, you know, off in our own world over
- 2:01coffee And and you know there's so many things happening in this
- 2:05city and specifically this year that I really wanted to share
- 2:08these conversations and these these sort of lessons with other
- 2:11people. And I've just come back from the
- 2:13US where I was sort of shocked at some infrastructural things.
- 2:19And it's by no means a surprise, but it is a reminder that
- 2:23sometimes you get sort of bogged down when you're living in Paris
- 2:27by the, you know, the attempts at making so many improvements
- 2:30all at once. And it feels like it's just, you
- 2:32know, a never ending cycle of Rd. works.
- 2:35But actually when you leave and you see how needed some of these
- 2:40investments are elsewhere, you're like, OK, actually we
- 2:42have such a good thing here. So that's sort of where I'm
- 2:44coming from. And you know, I want, I really
- 2:48want to talk to you specifically about what Hidalgo Mayor Hidalgo
- 2:52has tried to do here. And the reason I'm asking you is
- 2:56because you have first hand experience in urban planning
- 3:00that is your, you know, that has been your career.
- 3:03You've also worked with government in the US to enact
- 3:06change. And so I'm, I'm curious to you
- 3:09as someone who's lived in Paris now for a year, what were your
- 3:12first impressions of Hidalgo's policies that were meant to
- 3:16shift the balance from cars to bikes?
- 3:18And how do you interpret the resistance that we've seen and
- 3:22the way that has unfolded? Yeah.
- 3:25Thank you so much for having me. This is a great pleasure.
- 3:27And it's, it's been really interesting to kind of to come
- 3:31to Paris and and to see this city, you know, just both
- 3:34personally and through an urbanist lens, you know, all
- 3:37around the world right now, Paris is kind of the golden
- 3:39child. You know, there's been this
- 3:42enormous rebirth of people taking up cycling and just I
- 3:45think a a kind of renewed idea of what urbanism can be that's
- 3:48being led by this administration.
- 3:50That's the outside view. I think the inside view is, as
- 3:54it always is, a bit more complicated.
- 3:57I think Americans in particular can have a really kind of rosy
- 4:02picture of of life in Europe because these are sort of
- 4:05particularly among urbanists or architects.
- 4:07You know, these are maybe what we wanted our cities to be, what
- 4:11what American cities could have been initially.
- 4:13And so we always look to Europe, I think through a kind of a rosy
- 4:17lens. My initial impressions, you
- 4:20know, while I've been living here really is just incredible
- 4:25awe at at how quickly some of these changes have been made and
- 4:29how quickly the results of those changes have kind of changed the
- 4:33way that people move through Paris.
- 4:36So more specifically, you know there's this city is is has had
- 4:40a bike network superimposed on the city streets and that has
- 4:45been realized incredibly quickly.
- 4:48And that realization was accelerated during the pandemic.
- 4:51And even just in the time that I've been here, I can really
- 4:54sense the the acceleration of people taking up biking.
- 4:58We can look out our window right now and every bike parking, you
- 5:03know corral that we see is completely full.
- 5:06There's people biking by constantly.
- 5:07So just that it feels like this is a city which is really
- 5:11embracing these changes in a in a really profound and and kind
- 5:14of exciting way at the same time.
- 5:17You said there has been opposition to that.
- 5:22That does not surprise me at all.
- 5:26There has. I've never worked in a community
- 5:28that that had no opposition to any kind of change and that good
- 5:32change, bad change, anything. I think it's just in people's
- 5:35nature to to make themselves at home, in a in a community, in
- 5:38their own neighborhoods, and to get comfortable with what that
- 5:40feels like. And then when that changes, even
- 5:43if those changes are ultimately for the good, it feels local and
- 5:47personal and kind of like this is something that's happening to
- 5:50us instead of something that's happening for us, for us.
- 5:54With within a community. Yes, exactly.
- 5:56And and people often feel like they haven't been brought along
- 5:59in the decision making and that may may or may not be the case.
- 6:03People feel like, you know that that I'm not experiencing, you
- 6:06know, they're putting in a bike lane in front of my apartment
- 6:08saying, and I'm not experiencing that as as part of a network
- 6:12that's meant to transform the whole city and to bring us to a
- 6:16more sustainable place. I am experiencing that as an
- 6:18enormous disruption in my own life.
- 6:20Right. And maybe I'm not even going to
- 6:22use that bike lane. And so why right.
- 6:24Doing this. It that's an interesting
- 6:25example. Also, I remember this was now
- 6:28maybe two years ago. They tore up the sidewalks, both
- 6:33sides of the sidewalks on my street, to put in a series of
- 6:37new plantings, right? So they expanded the sidewalk or
- 6:40sort of redid the sidewalk, but also made room, narrowed the
- 6:43street and made room for trees, which obviously are not going to
- 6:48provide the, you know, the the shade and the and the greenery
- 6:53immediately, but will down the road.
- 6:54And I just remember, you know, obviously the jackhammering was
- 6:59a nightmare for my cats. It was for for us it was really
- 7:03horrible. And then it's true.
- 7:05Once it's done, you're like, OK, now it's done and it looks
- 7:09cleaner and it seems, you know, and then they block cars from
- 7:12using the street, you know. And so you see how how even
- 7:15within yourself, even when you're a proponent of these
- 7:17changes, how your immediate reaction might be like, damn, I
- 7:21wish this wasn't happening right outside my door.
- 7:23But like the net positive or the net effect is so positive, do
- 7:27you think this is just the way, like is there any nation that
- 7:29you think would sort of like embrace in a real way these
- 7:32changes or is this just human nature?
- 7:34I think a lot of this is just human nature, you know, I mean,
- 7:36I think we have this, we have this incredible kind of there's
- 7:39a word for this I can't think of, but it's this bias sort of
- 7:43toward, you know, we, we bias information.
- 7:45We bias what we already know, right?
- 7:47So like we'd rather kind of stick with the devil we know,
- 7:51the city that we already know than imagine the changes that
- 7:54might be coming could be good for us because maybe they won't
- 7:57be good for us. And so it's just, you know, like
- 7:59anything in life we sort of we have a bias toward the status
- 8:02quo. And at the same time we have
- 8:06this incredible ability to adapt and you know in our in our
- 8:11environments particularly as people who live in cities, we're
- 8:14incredibly adaptable and you see that all the time.
- 8:17You know you just simple things like my bakery closes I go to
- 8:20the other one or whatever, you know and and cities are
- 8:24constantly changing in ways that people aren't always thinking
- 8:26about because they're usually micro changes, right.
- 8:29They're little tiny things happening all the time that that
- 8:31over time transform the city. I think when we see these big
- 8:34infrastructural changes and it when it feels like they're
- 8:37undergirded by policies that really have something to say
- 8:41about the way we should live, I think that can feel prescriptive
- 8:44to people and maybe that can feel a little bit difficult to
- 8:47kind of swallow whole. I I totally get that.
- 8:50That leads me more into the opposition that Hidalgo faces
- 8:55and I think it goes back to what the average resident doesn't
- 8:58actually understand about how things get accomplished in
- 9:03government and what the city versus the region is responsible
- 9:06for. So for example and this is not
- 9:07related to infrastructure, but you know the the cost of
- 9:11individual metro tickets are going to you know jump to like
- 9:14€4.00 a ride during the Olympics.
- 9:16That is not a Mayor Hidalgo decision.
- 9:18That's actually a validate because decision of the region.
- 9:21You know, but the average person you know who doesn't know the
- 9:24the these things might be like Hidal goes at it again, you
- 9:27know. And one area of critique,
- 9:29however, that I have typically been more sensitive to is that
- 9:34she and her team, this is Hidalgo now don't make
- 9:37incremental changes. They sort of go in all in even
- 9:40if that disrupts like the flow of traffic, the flow of doing
- 9:43business And don't seem to attempt to mitigate some of the
- 9:47initial negative effects of such changes.
- 9:50Like you know when the riverbanks became pedestrianized
- 9:52again and they got rid of the thoroughfares for cars, you
- 9:54know, obviously it was great for pedestrians.
- 9:57It was not great for the car traffic and in fact supposedly
- 10:02traffic increased and there was no increase in pollution.
- 10:05So mitigating sort of the negative effects in order to get
- 10:09people on board with these decisions and you disagree with
- 10:12the sentiment that she puts the cart before the horse.
- 10:15Why is that? Yes, I should say first of all,
- 10:18I am, I am sensitive to sort of these perceptions, right.
- 10:22And I think again, because people sort of experience the
- 10:27city through the lens of their own neighborhood, their own
- 10:29commute, their own lives, the places they go, not the city as
- 10:33a system and the city as embedded in a metropolis and the
- 10:37metropolis as a system and these being the outcomes of different
- 10:42layers of political systems, right.
- 10:43I mean these are the ways I'm trained to think as an urbanist.
- 10:46These are not the way, the ways that you are trained to think as
- 10:48as a citizen. So you know, I, there's a
- 10:51disconnect here that I think makes all of policy hard to
- 10:54explain and that's some of what we're what we're seeing here.
- 10:56But there is, this is one of those places where expertise
- 11:00really matters. Think of a human doctor.
- 11:02They're trained to see the body as a system, right?
- 11:05We can't fix, you know, if you have something wrong with your
- 11:08mouth, that can indicate something else that's wrong
- 11:11elsewhere in the body, right. So just knowing, just being an
- 11:13expert at the mouth, you know if you don't know the rest of the
- 11:16body, you might not see it. So there's these things are
- 11:18interconnected and the cities work the same way.
- 11:20And so that is the sort of the expertise that people like us
- 11:26bring and that in it's our, it's our kind of burden and
- 11:28responsibility to explain that in a way that makes sense to
- 11:30people and and tries to get them on board.
- 11:33That's difficult. As far as some of the changes I
- 11:36think that you're seeing right now in Paris, let's maybe go
- 11:39back to the to the the bike network as an example because I
- 11:42think this is a good one for kind of illustrating why why
- 11:45this kind of implementation is, is the way it's done.
- 11:48If you look at a map of an American city, go to Google
- 11:51Maps, turn on a map of American city, turn on the layer that
- 11:54shows you and check the little box that shows you where the
- 11:57bike lanes are. What you will see is like
- 12:00scattered sticks of green just kind of all over the metropolis.
- 12:03They're disconnected. There's just a green line over
- 12:05here and a Green Lane over there, and these are
- 12:08representing bike lanes that have been implemented over time,
- 12:10but that are disconnected from each other.
- 12:12If you bike, particularly if you were an American biking in an
- 12:18American city, you realize quickly through that experience
- 12:20that if you have a block or two of infrastructure, you know, of
- 12:25bike infrastructure of a protected bike lane, but then it
- 12:27ends, it may as well be that that bike lane wasn't there.
- 12:30It doesn't really, you know, if you're trying to get from point
- 12:33A to point B and the the infrastructure that protects you
- 12:36on that journey is really discontinuous, you're going to
- 12:40need to feel safe during the parts that aren't protected.
- 12:43I mean it's you know, so these this disconnected infrastructure
- 12:46in other words doesn't really work and that's what keeps I
- 12:48think holds a lot of American cities back from being able to
- 12:52realize the impact of these enormous investments that
- 12:54they're making in in bike and transit infrastructure is
- 12:57because the the they're not forming a complete network.
- 13:00Is that something you would have been involved in if you had
- 13:02stayed in the US? Yes, Yeah.
- 13:03I mean it's it. Yes, that's.
- 13:05Would a comment like that be heard by, you know, the people
- 13:10you're advising? Because if you're like, OK, it's
- 13:14great that you're going to invest all this money on bike
- 13:16lanes. But if it's not part of a
- 13:17network, what are we even doing? Yeah, I mean, it's not I I think
- 13:21there's the American cities are diverse and sometimes that
- 13:26message lands and sometimes it doesn't.
- 13:28It depends on the community. I think there's bigger cities
- 13:30are often more sophisticated and they're thinking about systems
- 13:33and networks and so sometimes that lands.
- 13:36But there's constraints. You know, I mean, I, I funding
- 13:39is a huge constraint. Sometimes we only have this much
- 13:42money and we want to build the network or you know, we want to
- 13:45build the bike lane in the place where there's the least
- 13:47political resistance because that's going to give us the best
- 13:50spend for our money or something else, right.
- 13:52So there's kind of I think in a context of scarcity of of those
- 13:57kind of political and capital resources that it takes to build
- 14:00these like big infrastructure networks.
- 14:02Then the money and the the political capital ends up
- 14:04getting spent in the places that are kind of least resistant to
- 14:08it. And I think what you're seeing
- 14:09in Paris is the incredible kind of opportunity that the Olympics
- 14:14has presented to have a lot of capital and both financial and
- 14:18political capital flow into the yield of France and other cities
- 14:23in France, but really primarily Paris.
- 14:25To be able to realize some of these bigger visions on a scale
- 14:28and on a timeline that just would not be possible.
- 14:30And so that's why it feels like the city's turning upside down.
- 14:33Yeah. And also that kind of relates to
- 14:35what I assumed was the real reason we're hosting the
- 14:38Olympics, right? Like, does a city like Paris
- 14:41need the Olympics, You know, right.
- 14:46I mean, this is a very deep question.
- 14:47You could do a whole. Separate whole separate
- 14:49conversation. But you know, to me it feels
- 14:51like it's a really clear way. And especially since Hidalgo has
- 14:55been involved in this bidding for, you know, she's been in in
- 14:58the the city government for so long that of course she's sort
- 15:02of seen this from the beginning to to the, you know, to where we
- 15:06are now and knows that that influx of money would allow them
- 15:11to do a lot of the things that would either not happen during
- 15:15her her time or get completely sort of blocked if someone else
- 15:20takes over, you know, especially someone who isn't a progressive
- 15:24leader. What are some of the, aside from
- 15:27the bikes? What are some of the, like
- 15:29modern or urban renewal features of modern Paris that you find
- 15:34most impressive, especially having come from working in, you
- 15:37know, major metropolises in the US?
- 15:40And do you think that Paris could learn anything from the
- 15:44US? Like, is there anything that the
- 15:45US, we, we, we, we tend to have a lot of disdain, I think for
- 15:51American infrastructure projects.
- 15:54And I'm not talking about filling potholes and things, You
- 15:56know, like what? Is there something we can learn?
- 15:59I mean there's a reason why the world, the world particularly of
- 16:04urbanism is looking to Paris it right now.
- 16:06I mean there's there's a lot that the city does incredibly
- 16:09well and it's an it's an opportune time, right.
- 16:11So, you know, of course, as you said, the Olympics allows and
- 16:15creates A context to do really transformative change in a way
- 16:18that American mayors salivate over.
- 16:21So, you know, but I mean beyond, yeah, there's so much that goes
- 16:26beyond the bike lanes. I mean, that's just a a really
- 16:28visible and easy thing. But, you know, just thinking
- 16:30about Paris, you know, 1/1 impression I've had or or maybe
- 16:35surprising thing that I've noticed while being here is that
- 16:38although we think of Paris as this city of just continuous and
- 16:43miraculously largely intact historic fabric, you know, just
- 16:48this incredible historic fabric that's incredibly cohesive
- 16:52historic architecture. You can just read it on the
- 16:54city. But actually there's a lot of
- 16:57infill architecture here or a lot of infill development by
- 16:59which I mean, you know, a a building kind of inserted into
- 17:03the into the fabric, you know, contemporary buildings
- 17:08throughout the city. And certainly as as you approach
- 17:11the outskirts of the city, you'll see more and more of
- 17:13that. I live in the 18th.
- 17:15The kind of outer part of the 18th is full of these really
- 17:19interesting insertions into the urban fabric and the quality of
- 17:23a lot of this building is really quite good.
- 17:25Not that it's dazzling in a way, that similar architecture might
- 17:29be in a city like London or Los Angeles, but that what makes it
- 17:34good is that it is fresh and it adds, it often adds something to
- 17:38the streetscape and makes the most of the site, but but kind
- 17:42of carries forward that idea of continuity, which makes the
- 17:46Parisian urban fabric so singularly interesting.
- 17:49So, you know, I I just am really impressed by kind of the way
- 17:53that developers and architects here have managed to find
- 17:56inspiration through that context.
- 17:57And some of the larger district scale developments around the
- 18:01city are really quite good. You're you're speaking though of
- 18:04Paris on Camuros, so not necessarily like what happens
- 18:08when you get beyond the periphery and you see the
- 18:11housing. Developments and what?
- 18:12That looks like and the quality of that.
- 18:15OK. So you're speaking just about?
- 18:18Yes, yes, yes. And that's, I mean and that is a
- 18:21that is an important and I'm glad you brought that up.
- 18:23That's a really important distinction and something that,
- 18:26yeah, we can talk a lot about. Well, because it it also
- 18:28highlights, you know, what is a value and what isn't and where
- 18:31the money is seen as as priority and necessary.
- 18:38What could Paris learn from the US, though?
- 18:41Yeah. And if you tell me not much,
- 18:45then we move on. No, I I mean it's I think the
- 18:48the learnings probably go mostly in the other, the other
- 18:50direction. I think one thing maybe that
- 18:53jumps out to me is Paris is not a very accessible city, by which
- 18:58I mean, you know, physical access.
- 19:00Yeah, if you're not able bodied and that could be for any
- 19:03variety of reasons. For a personal example, when my,
- 19:07you know, chronic back pain flared, have a herniated disc
- 19:10injury and you when I had trouble walking for three weeks,
- 19:14you know, how do you navigate the city of Paris?
- 19:18And that that the issue was when my injury happened outside, you
- 19:22know, sort of the pain started outside of the city.
- 19:24Then the question was getting back into the city to see my
- 19:27doctor. Right.
- 19:28And then navigating, God forbid someone bumps into you on the
- 19:32street and how that could activate, you know, a whole
- 19:35shockwave of pain. You know, you start thinking of
- 19:38navigation in a much different way and that is that is not a
- 19:40chronic. You know, I mean chronic in the
- 19:42sense that you know I don't live with a disability in the in the
- 19:47way that other people do but all of us could become you know
- 19:52individuals who require a different form of navigation And
- 19:56and so it's it's there that you see the shortcomings and is that
- 20:00because you think in the US then because of disability act that
- 20:04forced cities small and large to adapt their.
- 20:08Yeah, I I did. You know the the yes the ADA,
- 20:12the Americans with Disabilities Act has been transformative to
- 20:15American cities and to American architecture and in sometimes in
- 20:18ways that you know I think have increased the accessibility but
- 20:21have other costs with them in terms of you know how things are
- 20:24allocated in space in the United States.
- 20:25And so there's there's trade-offs there trade-offs
- 20:27which are completely worth it for people of every ability to
- 20:30be able to access public space. It's crucial and and I think
- 20:34that would never have happened in America without national
- 20:37legislation and with for funding mechanisms attached to that that
- 20:41allow cities to to comply and allow businesses to comply.
- 20:44And so it's really kind of a top to bottom thing.
- 20:46And Paris has a really long way to go to embracing despite being
- 20:51the most visited city in the world, has a really long way to
- 20:55go. And I think that calls for
- 20:56greater national leadership here on those issues, but also just,
- 20:59you know, local agitation. Well, and and that's also a
- 21:03problem of the community of, you know, sort of the the, the
- 21:09resistance community within disability issues.
- 21:13And I heard that from the woman I interviewed from my book, who
- 21:17is herself someone who lives with great disability and is
- 21:20also an A lawyer and an advocate.
- 21:22And she says we just don't have the power in numbers that led to
- 21:26something like the ADA being passed in the 1970s, Right.
- 21:30And so she sees that as like one of France's and not just city.
- 21:35It's not just a city issue, but certainly if the country doesn't
- 21:38see this as a valuable issue, it's very hard to get a city
- 21:42like Paris for that to trickle down, even with a socialist
- 21:46mayor, even with pushing and and tourism.
- 21:49I mean, it's like, what else do you need, right?
- 21:51You need what someone in leadership to become severely
- 21:55disabled themselves to see that like they're going through life
- 21:58in a place that is not suited to them.
- 22:00And I think the way we all should look at this is not only
- 22:03that it could happen to us, but that it is not about society.
- 22:06It's not about the the person who needs to adapt to society.
- 22:10It's about society adapting to each individual person.
- 22:13Yeah. And there's an interesting
- 22:14actually parallel there I think with with, you know, just keep
- 22:18going back to the biking issues. But something, there's something
- 22:20related here, which is when we lack the infrastructure to serve
- 22:23people, they become invisible. And then it becomes so much
- 22:27harder to advocate for, for them to advocate for their own needs,
- 22:31for us to advocate on their behalf, for us to advocate just
- 22:33as complete communities because the infrastructure has has
- 22:36rendered them invisible, right. And you know, people, people
- 22:40often resist bicycling infrastructure by saying, well,
- 22:42so few people bike. Why do we need to do this?
- 22:45And so many people drive. Why do we need this
- 22:46infrastructure? Who is it serving?
- 22:48Well, when you have no place for people to safely bike or
- 22:51comfortably bike, how could they?
- 22:53How could they? Right.
- 22:54It doesn't reflect the real demand.
- 22:55And of course, the exact same thing is true in Paris.
- 22:58We see very few people getting around the city streets of Paris
- 23:02using wheelchairs or other assisted mobility devices
- 23:04because it's so difficult. And so it's no wonder that these
- 23:09issues largely appeal, appear invisible, even though, as you
- 23:11said, we will all someday get old.
- 23:14We all, 30 million of us a year in the city, carry roller bag
- 23:18suitcases, right? And those are really hard on the
- 23:20subway. I mean, there's just all kinds
- 23:22of ways. Right, it's true.
- 23:22It's not just about disability. It's about the the sheer
- 23:25inconvenience. And it's it's worth adding that
- 23:29you know, there are these laws in in the US, but the New York
- 23:32subway, you know, is not necessarily a a sterling example
- 23:37of success on these issues. Not at all.
- 23:39Not at. All elevators out of service or
- 23:42you know like these are these are our global, global issues on
- 23:46public transportation, both its efficiency and the access to it
- 23:48has you know, obviously been one of the markers of livability in
- 23:51Paris and since I was recently in New York, I appreciate it
- 23:55even more and and you know still there's more work that's needed
- 24:00and you know some of that is in progress.
- 24:01Some of it is going to be delayed.
- 24:03Connection between suburbs within greater Paris is
- 24:06obviously the the long-awaited improvement.
- 24:09What role do you think that that project which you know it
- 24:14involves better connection within the suburbs to prevent
- 24:16people from having to sort of come into the center of the city
- 24:19and then exit. What role does that play in
- 24:21breaking down economic and cultural barriers, which, as you
- 24:25and I both know through our heavy reading on these issues,
- 24:29is like a holdover from rulers, the royalty who made the capital
- 24:34the center of French life. And so some of those barriers
- 24:37still exist between Paris and the areas surrounding it.
- 24:41So is this idea of having better networks, even within the
- 24:45region, a way to break down some of the existing challenges, I
- 24:50guess? Right.
- 24:50I mean, there's this, there's this long standing distinction
- 24:52sort of between and I think this is a harder distinction.
- 24:55It's felt harder here than in other places in the world, this
- 24:58sort of intramurals, you know, outside the city, this, you
- 25:01know, the the wall, the literal and now figurative walls of the
- 25:04city are real here in ways that they're not.
- 25:07Psychologically. Yeah.
- 25:08Yeah. And well and physically I mean
- 25:09we have we have a a freeway Beltway surrounding Paris and
- 25:14everything is thought of as within and outside of that
- 25:17Beltway. And I think as the fortunes of
- 25:20this city and speaking specifically above Paris proper
- 25:24have risen, right. You know, the disparities
- 25:28between what lies within and what's experienced outside the
- 25:32city become stronger. And the media certainly
- 25:33exacerbates those narratives through the kinds of film and
- 25:38things that are made about the Paris suburbs versus the way we
- 25:41talk about inner Paris. You know, and I think to me this
- 25:44is so these these transportation projects which are really
- 25:48monumental and and hugely important and I think can play a
- 25:52really important role in kind of redressing some of those
- 25:54disparities. I'm, I'm not sure if you
- 25:57mentioned this before, but you know we can map income
- 26:00disparities, we can map energy use disparities and we can map
- 26:03all kinds of things that contribute to inequity right
- 26:07onto the map of Paris versus Paris's suburbs and income
- 26:14across those suburbs and even within Paris itself.
- 26:16So all of these things are mapped geographically and so
- 26:19much of it has to do with people having physical access to and
- 26:23the rights to the city. And that I mean kind of the city
- 26:26broadly, the city as a social and economic Organism of 12
- 26:30million, not Paris proper of 2,000,000.
- 26:34So I think the transportation projects you're talking about
- 26:38will really create the opportunity to transform how we
- 26:41think about Paris as greater Paris as a kind of region as a
- 26:47metropolis. And my hope is that of course
- 26:50that it could have the practical effect of of connecting people
- 26:55in the suburbs to of opportunity within the city of Paris and to
- 26:59the opportunities that lie in adjacent suburbs.
- 27:01And just to provide like a much richer set of opportunities for
- 27:04people in a lot of the really disadvantaged suburbs, in
- 27:07particular around Paris. But also that it helps Parisians
- 27:12think about this region differently, that there is life
- 27:14outside of the Ferif and and that we would not have
- 27:18everything we have in this incredible city were it not for
- 27:22the millions and millions of people living in this bigger
- 27:25region that are part of the kind of heart and soul of Paris too.
- 27:29That we are all part of that same Organism.
- 27:32And that it's all interconnected, it's all part of
- 27:35the system. Well, that's going to be a long
- 27:38process. I think in getting even once the
- 27:40transport is up and running, you know it's going to be a long
- 27:43reputation overhaul that it's you.
- 27:47Know. We're talking about generations
- 27:49of this barrier. I wanted to talk about the
- 27:52Olympics a bit and and something you wrote in your newsletter
- 27:55recently and we'll you'll have to tell my listeners about your
- 27:59newsletter but you say there's a lot of potential with the
- 28:03Olympics and and that one way we can assess that potential is
- 28:08looking at the London Olympics as an example.
- 28:10So you wrote if Paris is to maintain some semblance of its
- 28:13raucous, intellectually vibrant self in the face of ever
- 28:16increasing wealth and social disparities, it will do so
- 28:19thanks to supportive policies and neighborhood level
- 28:21investments that help connect residents to the opportunities
- 28:25and resources they need. Mega events can kick start big
- 28:28changes, but they're no cure, all without thoughtful and
- 28:31ongoing investments where people most need help.
- 28:33The 2024 games might turn out to be nothing more than a
- 28:36three-week blip on the long trajectory of deprivation and
- 28:40inequity in the greater Paris region.
- 28:42Based on what we know of the organization for the games and
- 28:46how few site specific new builds there are, what does your gut
- 28:49tell you about the long term outcome?
- 28:53I mean, I know it's all projection, but based on what
- 28:55you wrote, what is your gut saying?
- 28:58I think in the in the short term, I mean this is clearly
- 29:01spurring a lot of investments in communities that have long been
- 29:05starved of investment. And I say that as a fact and not
- 29:10as a judgement as to whether that's good or bad.
- 29:13I was just up in Sant'mond a couple days ago and was
- 29:17astounded by just the amount of of of new building and
- 29:22renovation and and changes to the street save happening near
- 29:25the Olympic Village. You know and in the kind of the
- 29:28the central area of that town and you know I think that's
- 29:31happening throughout the region because of these investments.
- 29:33And you know and we have the transportation networks that are
- 29:37creating opportunities all across the region even in places
- 29:39not touched by the Olympics. But that project is happening
- 29:42sort of along the timeline of the Olympics.
- 29:43So I think this is if if not an unqualified good thing, it is
- 29:48certainly an opportunity for good things to happen.
- 29:50And you know those investments can create opportunities for
- 29:55people today, this year, next year in communities that have
- 30:00really that are really thirsty for more opportunities for more
- 30:03investment, for more attention. They can also spur
- 30:07gentrification and price increases and displacement and
- 30:10all of the things that we know come along with investment.
- 30:13So I think in the short term, medium term, that's the question
- 30:16that has to be managed is can can these communities that are
- 30:18seeing this renewed investment, can that be absorbed in those
- 30:23communities in a way that creates benefit for the public
- 30:27broadly, but for people who most need access to opportunity, can
- 30:32that reach them in ways that are kind of real and tangible and
- 30:35meaningful and not just creating opportunities for people with
- 30:38higher incomes to move in? On the longer term, I think the
- 30:42games will be a blip in some way.
- 30:43I think, you know, this is a region that like I said earlier,
- 30:46sees millions and millions of people every year coming in.
- 30:49It's just sort of different people for a different reason
- 30:51this summer. But the role that visitation and
- 30:54worldwide visibility plays in Paris is no different than this
- 30:56year than it is any other year. And in the end, what will really
- 31:00matter is whether I think the government of Paris and EU de
- 31:05France and France broadly and all of the municipalities, if
- 31:10those, that whether those governments were able to come
- 31:12together and coordinate around changes that really transformed
- 31:15the region and address the problems that the region has
- 31:17today. And I think, you know, we can
- 31:19look at the transit network expansions as one kind of
- 31:22tangible example of that happening.
- 31:25But we know that this region just faces incredible
- 31:28disparities between its wealthiest segments and its most
- 31:32deprived segments, right? And to me the only legacy that
- 31:36matters from this enormous scale of public investment is whether
- 31:40we look back in 10 years, 15 years and we can point to this
- 31:43moment and these investments as as as the moment when that trend
- 31:47line started to change. And that we can say dude what
- 31:51these games kick started along with other investments and
- 31:53policy changes etcetera through the next 5 to 10 years.
- 31:56We are actually now chipping away at some of the inequities
- 31:58that exist in this region and people are better connected, the
- 32:01region is healthier. We have you know the transit
- 32:04investments have led to socio economic growth and changes
- 32:09throughout the region that are being felt and those inequities
- 32:11are being redressed. I think that's the only those
- 32:14are the only metrics that. That matter, And to your
- 32:17knowledge, how did London fare after the Olympics?
- 32:20OK, I I mean, I think, you know, I don't have hard numbers in my
- 32:24head, but I, you know, I, I recently kind of went to that
- 32:27part of town. I think, you know, the Olympic
- 32:30Village is now largely a park. It's beautiful.
- 32:34It's they tend. To used.
- 32:36It's used. Yeah, it's used.
- 32:37I mean, it's not, you know, it's not like one of the most heavily
- 32:40used, you know, most kind of iconic parks in London.
- 32:43But it takes a long time for something like that to reach
- 32:45that status. This is young public spaces
- 32:47always have a kind of a Bony look to them.
- 32:50And you know, it just takes time for these places to mature and
- 32:53become what they will. You know, the, the quality of
- 32:56new developments built at that scale and speed is often not
- 32:59super fine grained. It doesn't make for the most
- 33:01interesting urban places. But, you know, in London, a
- 33:04place that faces just terrible, devastating housing needs, this
- 33:10served to kind of help that a bit, I will say that I think the
- 33:15Olympic Games, also the timing of those investments coincided
- 33:18with a period during which there was a lot of kind of outside
- 33:22investment interest in neighborhoods like the East of
- 33:25London, which is where the Games took place.
- 33:27And you put those two forces together, and I think the result
- 33:31was probably an unexpected and quite unprecedented level of of
- 33:35gentrification and displacement in East London.
- 33:37And did the Games contribute to that?
- 33:39Probably. Did the Games also create
- 33:41housing opportunities and new transit connections and new jobs
- 33:43and everything else? Yeah.
- 33:45So these these things coexist. So it's a mixed bag, but.
- 33:49People have a hard time accepting when multiple things
- 33:51can be true. At once.
- 33:53I think that's that's the big lesson of adult life, isn't it?
- 33:56It's hard in is Paris in the way that changes unfold, all that
- 34:01different from other cities? You've researched whether
- 34:04they're in Europe, in Asia, other parts of the US, and is
- 34:08there any other city that you find particularly inspiring that
- 34:12isn't Paris? I know you you have quite a lot
- 34:14of affection for the urban renewal projects in Paris, and
- 34:17we talk about them often, but is there anywhere else that you're
- 34:20sort of like, wow, Paris would be even better if it could just
- 34:24get here? Yeah, I I I do.
- 34:27I I'm a big lover of urban change.
- 34:30So it's exciting to me to see the ways that Paris is adapting
- 34:34as far as is. Is Paris really different?
- 34:36I mean, I don't think so. Like, this is a gorgeous, you
- 34:39know, to me, this is just the crown jewel of of of urbanism.
- 34:43I mean, if this city embodies everything, that every concept
- 34:47in theory I ever learned about what a good public space looks
- 34:49like, it exists here in some way and you know, and so it's it's
- 34:53amazing. But in another sense, this is a
- 34:55living, breathing place and you know, your work has been hugely
- 34:59important to me in just understanding the ways in which
- 35:00this isn't a museum, this is a real city.
- 35:04And it's not here to exist for the traveler, even though we
- 35:07like to think that, like, all the the road works are really,
- 35:11you know, cramping my. Yeah, cramping my vacation here.
- 35:15Right. No, but it's, you know, it's a
- 35:16real living breathing place. And and with all of the and
- 35:21crazy the baggage, but just like it's chaotic and it's you know,
- 35:24it's a little crazy sometimes. But you know, my point is it it
- 35:27that that people are as resistant to change here as they
- 35:31seem to be everywhere. They are as, as adaptable here
- 35:34as they are everywhere. I think what makes Peres
- 35:36different is that Despite that resistance to change, there is
- 35:42strong leadership that is committed to to a portfolio of
- 35:47of policies that I think are the right ones or mostly the right
- 35:50ones well. She's going to keep going no
- 35:52matter what people say, I mean. She's.
- 35:55She gets a level of vitriol that really seems reserved to women
- 35:59in in leadership, but also anybody who's trying to do
- 36:03something that changes, you know, the way you might have to
- 36:06operate your life. And yes, sorry, if you can't
- 36:08take your car as many places in a city that was not built for
- 36:11your vehicle. You know, I think I think you're
- 36:14right that, you know, either you keep, you're committed to the
- 36:17idea and you take it as far as possible, which relates to
- 36:19something you didn't mention. But we've talked about in
- 36:21private. And I'm going to bring it out
- 36:23just because it's so smart, which is that you said from your
- 36:25experience, sometimes you have to sort of you, you pitch
- 36:30something or you run with something that's kind of a lot.
- 36:34Knowing that you may have to scale back just so that you can
- 36:38say like you're still in a good place if all you got was halfway
- 36:43through the idea or 75% of the way through.
- 36:46And that you're still ending up in a space where you feel like,
- 36:49OK, this is a legacy I'm I'm happy with.
- 36:52Yeah, yeah, that's true. I think that's a basic
- 36:54negotiating tactic too. But people don't see it that
- 36:57way, and no one considers the way government must have to
- 37:01function. You're just like this is shitty
- 37:02for me now. Look it takes a really long time
- 37:05and it maybe it's takes some experience in government to like
- 37:08really understand the the level of kind of negotiation that
- 37:12happens, right. And and that Mayor Hidalgo isn't
- 37:15just going out into the street and grabbing a shovel and doing
- 37:18these things. I mean these are this is the
- 37:20result of no like but people sort of pin it on her specific.
- 37:25I mean in in in this case maybe even more than in other
- 37:28administrations. I think she's a woman and she's
- 37:30visible and she's fearless, it seems in in terms of facing
- 37:34political winds, twins. And so you know, she's she's out
- 37:39there and that makes her a lightning rod and perhaps she
- 37:42deserves some of that. She certainly asked for the job.
- 37:45But in other ways it can feel a little unfair, both personally
- 37:48in her case but also just I think people don't always have
- 37:51hopefully developed understanding of of the many
- 37:54kind of negotiations and trade-offs and the difficulty of
- 37:58timing and money and the levels of government that have to be
- 38:01coordinated. I mean it's just very difficult.
- 38:04I think she's doing an incredible job at modeling what
- 38:08leadership can look like for a modern city that's really
- 38:12committed to becoming more sustainable and she's chosen to
- 38:16lead Paris in that direction. And I think she embraces the
- 38:18role of Paris being a bit of a of a world leader in that way
- 38:22and I applauded for that. I think if she were using the
- 38:25same tactics toward ends that I didn't agree with, I would be
- 38:28having a very different reaction to that.
- 38:30But I think she's, I think she's by and large committed to making
- 38:34this a safer, more sustainable, more equitable city and and it's
- 38:38important that Parisians see that because it is disruptive
- 38:42but that's. Change is uncomfortable.
- 38:44Change is uncomfortable, you know, and then and then it do
- 38:47things take a while to kind of mature and fall back into place.
- 38:49And that's just part of this process.
- 38:51And you know, I think it's important for us all to,
- 38:53throughout life, pull back, try to see what we're really working
- 38:57toward and and to be OK with being a little uncomfortable for
- 39:00a while. Well, maybe I should, I should
- 39:02write her a letter. Because, you know, the sirens
- 39:03that our listeners may have just heard, you know, I mean, that's
- 39:06got to be her fault too. Right outside of the window,
- 39:08she's out there. She's just causing a a ruckus.
- 39:13Brent, thank you for this. I would love just very briefly
- 39:18for you to give a a word or two on on what you're writing
- 39:21because this is part of what you're covering on your
- 39:24newsletter. What is that called and where
- 39:26can people find it? The.
- 39:27Newsletter is the Trifena project.
- 39:29And I will link to that in the show notes.
- 39:31And it can be found on Sub Stack.
- 39:33And I write about Paris, urban planning issues, travel, you
- 39:39know, just so it's broad, but really kind of looking at cities
- 39:42and places through this particular lens.
- 39:44Well, this is surely the first of what I would love to become a
- 39:48regular appearance, to talk about projects as they unfold
- 39:53and certainly come back. And let's talk about the
- 39:55Olympics in more detail as we get closer.
- 39:58Thank you Lindsay, I would love that and I appreciate you having
- 40:00me. Thanks for listening to the New
- 40:04Paris podcast. If you enjoy the show, it would
- 40:07mean the world if you would rate and leave a review on Spotify,
- 40:10Apple or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 40:13Until next time, I Bento.