Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Costco Trades Like A Tech Gian
Transcript
- 0:00You know, usually when we talk about a company trading on the
- 0:02stock market at an absolutely sky high valuation, well there
- 0:06is a certain expectation of what that company actually does.
- 0:09Right. Yeah, You expect it to be some
- 0:11sort of tech giant? Exactly.
- 0:13If you see a stock trading like a rocket ship, you expect
- 0:16cutting edge artificial intelligence, maybe
- 0:19revolutionary cloud software, or you know, some breakthrough
- 0:23green energy technology. A Silicon Valley darling?
- 0:26Basically, yeah. You do not expect a massive
- 0:28concrete warehouse that sells 50 LB tubs of mayonnaise,
- 0:32discounted tires and $1.50 hot dog combo.
- 0:36It really is the ultimate market paradox.
- 0:38I mean, you were looking at a business fundamentally rooted in
- 0:40moving massive physical pallets of goods around the world using
- 0:44forklifts, right? Yet it commands the kind of
- 0:47market multiple that makes high flying tech CEO's incredibly
- 0:51jealous. Welcome to today's Deep Dive.
- 0:53We are looking at a comprehensive financial research
- 0:55report on Costco Wholesale Corporation, updated through May
- 0:59of 2026. And the numbers we are about to
- 1:01explore are just staggering. They really are.
- 1:05As of this report, the stock has breached $1028.00 per share O.
- 1:10Our mission today is to deconstruct Costcos financial
- 1:14engine, explore their highly unusual approach to capital
- 1:17allocation and try to answer a really difficult question.
- 1:21Which is whether this retail giant actually qualifies as a
- 1:24deep value investment at its current valuation.
- 1:27OK. Let's unpack this, because to
- 1:28understand why this stock is over $1000, we first have to
- 1:32realize that Costco isn't actually, you know, in the
- 1:34business of selling merchandise. No, and that framing completely
- 1:38changes how you analyze their balance sheet.
- 1:39It is the great retail illusion. Illusion is the perfect word
- 1:43for. It look at their Q32026
- 1:45earnings, they posted total revenue of $70.53 billion for
- 1:50just a 12 week period. But when you split that revenue
- 1:53apart, the structural asymmetry is completely wild.
- 1:57So the net sales, meaning the actual physical goods people
- 1:59load into those massive shopping carts, make up 98.1% of that
- 2:03revenue. Exactly.
- 2:04The groceries, the massive televisions, the giant teddy
- 2:07bears, all of that is practically a break even
- 2:09operation. It is because Costco caps its
- 2:12merchandise markups at an incredibly strict 14 to 15%.
- 2:17Wow. Yeah, to put that into
- 2:19perspective for anyone listening, traditional
- 2:21supermarkets mark up their goods anywhere from 25 to 50% just to
- 2:25keep the lights on. That's a huge difference.
- 2:27Because Costco artificially suppresses its own margins, the
- 2:32merchandise segment essentially just covers the cost of
- 2:34operating the warehouses. The real engine is membership
- 2:37fees. Which make up just 1.9% of the
- 2:41top line revenue, right? Right, but that tiny sliver ends
- 2:44up generating roughly 75% of their total operating profit.
- 2:49It's incredible. I was reading through the source
- 2:51material and thinking about an analogy for this, and Costco is
- 2:55less like a traditional grocery store and more like an
- 2:59incredibly exclusive nightclub. Oh, I like.
- 3:01That the merchandise on the shelves, those are just the
- 3:03cheap drinks at the bar. The nightclub doesn't actually
- 3:06care if it makes a profit on the drinks themselves.
- 3:09Right, the entire business model.
- 3:10The real money, is the bouncer standing at the front door
- 3:13collecting the cover charge. What's fascinating here is the
- 3:16psychological brilliance of that exact dynamic.
- 3:19By passing all of their massive purchasing scale advantages
- 3:23directly back to the consumer through those capped markups,
- 3:26well, Costco effectively permanently secures the
- 3:29customer's loyalty. Yeah, the lifetime value of a
- 3:32Costco member is astounding. They have over 145,000,000 card
- 3:36holders globally right now, with a 92.3% renewal rate in the US
- 3:41and Canada. Which is just unheard of in
- 3:44retail. When a customer pays that cover
- 3:46charge, they are so determined to get their money's worth that
- 3:49they consolidate their shopping habit.
- 3:51Right. They buy everything there.
- 3:52Exactly. That turns the membership fee
- 3:54into basically a guaranteed annuity.
- 3:56And with the compounding effect of the fee increase they
- 3:59implemented in September 2024, that annuity is producing an
- 4:03avalanche of cash. But even if you make your profit
- 4:06at the door, managing the nightclub still comes with
- 4:09massive overhead. Oh absolutely.
- 4:10I mean, Costco has to physically stock 914 warehouses globally.
- 4:16Think about the logistics of purchasing billions of dollars
- 4:20of inventory that costs an absolute fortune.
- 4:22It does, yet they pull off this financial magic trick where they
- 4:26basically get their own suppliers to fund their global
- 4:29expansion. So how does that work?
- 4:31This introduces the concept of a negative working capital cycle.
- 4:35To understand how they achieve it, we have to look at their
- 4:37inventory strategy. A typical supermarket carries
- 4:40over 100,000 distinct items or skews on its shelves.
- 4:44OK, Costco only carries about 4000.
- 4:47That hyper consolidation is wild.
- 4:49You don't get 20 choices of ketchup, you get one, maybe 2.
- 4:52And often it's their own private label, Kirkland Signature.
- 4:54Kirkland Signature is a behemoth of a brand.
- 4:57It just celebrated its 30th anniversary, and it pulls in $90
- 5:00billion annually all by itself. That is roughly 33% of of their
- 5:05total sales, and the mechanics behind it are brilliant.
- 5:07Because Costco channels such immense, concentrated volume
- 5:11through so few items, they hold unprecedented, overwhelming
- 5:14bargaining power over their suppliers.
- 5:16So the suppliers really need them.
- 5:18Desperately, if a supplier wants access to Costco's 145,000,000
- 5:22premium shoppers, they have to play by Costco's rules.
- 5:25And that bargaining power allows Costco to dictate extremely
- 5:28favorable payment terms. So this is where standard
- 5:31financial metrics start flashing red for traditional analysts.
- 5:34The Deep Value report points out that Costco's current ratio is
- 5:381.06, right? For anyone listening who might
- 5:41be newer to reading balance sheets, the current ratio
- 5:44compares a company's liquid assets to its short term
- 5:46liabilities. It basically tells you if a
- 5:48company can cover its immediate debts.
- 5:50And usually a ratio that close to one point O means a company
- 5:53is dangerously close to a liquidity crisis, right?
- 5:56Like barely able to pay its bills Exactly.
- 5:58In a standard automated deep value Screener, 1.06 would
- 6:02absolutely flag a severe liquidity pressure.
- 6:05But we have to reframe this for Costco's specific operational
- 6:08model. For them, a low current ratio is
- 6:11not a weakness, it is arguably their greatest superpower.
- 6:14Costco turns its inventory over 12.5 * a year.
- 6:18Wow, that fast? Yeah.
- 6:20That means they take a pallet of goods, put it on the floor, and
- 6:24sell it to the customer, collecting cash immediately.
- 6:27But their negotiated terms with the supplier might dictate that
- 6:31Costco doesn't actually have to pay for those goods for 30 or 60
- 6:34days. Oh I see, they sell the product,
- 6:36collect the cash and earn interest on it before the bill
- 6:39is even due. Wait, I I want to push back on
- 6:41this 'cause it sounds almost too good to be true.
- 6:43You're telling me suppliers are basically giving Costco an
- 6:47ongoing massive interest free loan to fund their own corporate
- 6:51expansion? Essentially, yes.
- 6:54But what happens if consumer traffic suddenly slows down?
- 6:58Let's say there's a severe recession.
- 6:59Foot traffic drops, the inventory sits on the shelves
- 7:02and the cash doesn't come in. Those thirty day supplier bills
- 7:06are still coming due. Does this whole negative working
- 7:09capital treadmill suddenly fly off the tracks?
- 7:11That systemic risk is exactly what analysts monitor.
- 7:15If inventory turnover slows dramatically, a negative working
- 7:18capital cycle can instantly become a liquidity trap.
- 7:21So how do they avoid that trap? The buffer against that
- 7:24catastrophic scenario is there astonishingly stable cash flow.
- 7:29Over the trailing 12 months leading up to May 2026, Costco
- 7:33generated $9.10 billion in free cash flow.
- 7:37That is a massive safety net. It is an immense cash cushion.
- 7:40Combined with the fact that their inventory leans heavily
- 7:43toward essential goods. You know, food, paper products,
- 7:47pharmacy items, stuff that performs well even in deep
- 7:50economic downturns. That mitigates the treadmill
- 7:52risk. Still, no business is completely
- 7:55immune to macroeconomic gravity, and the report highlights some
- 7:58real headwinds. Wage inflation is a major one.
- 8:01It is a significant pressure point on their margins.
- 8:04Costco has a long standing commitment to leading the retail
- 8:06sector in employee compensation, right?
- 8:09In fiscal 2025, their average hourly wage in the US reached
- 8:12$32, or roughly $46 an hour when you factor in health care and
- 8:16their comprehensive benefits packages.
- 8:18Which puts constant upward pressure on their fixed to semi
- 8:21variable costs. Exactly.
- 8:23And beyond labor, you have global import tariffs,
- 8:26disrupting supply chains and increasing activist shareholder
- 8:31pressure regarding Scope 3 emissions, which is a.
- 8:33Massive logistical nightmare. I mean, it's one thing to make a
- 8:36corporate tech office carbon neutral.
- 8:37It's another entirely to police the carbon footprint of
- 8:40thousands of global beef and agriculture suppliers.
- 8:43Oh, totally. A landmark proposal previously
- 8:46secured nearly 70% shareholder approval demanding science based
- 8:50greenhouse gas reduction targets across Costco's entire value
- 8:53chain. Yeah, transitioning massive
- 8:56agricultural networks to carbon neutral standards could
- 8:59permanently elevate production costs, threatening that strict
- 9:0214 to 15% margin cap we discussed earlier.
- 9:05Yeah. Managing razor thin margins,
- 9:08mitigating supply chain bottlenecks, and navigating
- 9:11complex labor dynamics. That isn't something you can
- 9:13just run through a software program.
- 9:15Yeah, not at all. It requires ruthless experience
- 9:18to human discipline. So let's look at the people
- 9:20actually pulling the levers and how they reward the shareholders
- 9:23who own the company. Well, corporate governance at
- 9:25Costco actively rejects a lot of standard Wall Street practices.
- 9:29Take the CEO, Ron Vakris, who stepped into the role in January
- 9:332024. OK, he didn't parachute in from
- 9:36an Ivy League consulting firm with a playbook of theoretical
- 9:39efficiencies. He started at Costco 40 years
- 9:43ago as a literal forklift driver.
- 9:46A forklift driver to CEO, you really don't see that often
- 9:49anymore. You really don't.
- 9:51And there is a practical bottom line benefit to that, right?
- 9:54Because he knows exactly how warehouse operations work on a
- 9:57granular level, management isn't wasting money on out of touch
- 10:01corporate mandates that look good on a spreadsheet but fail
- 10:04on the warehouse floor. Precisely, and their
- 10:06compensation structure reflects that internal culture management
- 10:10based salaries are kept intentionally modest compared to
- 10:13S&P 500 averages. Interesting.
- 10:14So how do they make their money? Instead of huge cash salaries,
- 10:18executive wealth is tied up in performance based restricted
- 10:21stock units, or RSU's. Which makes perfect sense.
- 10:24Cash bonuses incentivize executives to cut corners this
- 10:27year just to hit an arbitrary quarterly target.
- 10:30RSU's force them to care deeply about what the stock is going to
- 10:34be worth 5 years from now. Yeah.
- 10:35And that long term view really shows up in how they return cash
- 10:40to shareholders. It absolutely does, because
- 10:42this. Is where I got a little tripped
- 10:43up reading the source material. Most massive corporations today
- 10:47return cash by constantly buying back their own stock to
- 10:51artificially inflate their earnings per share.
- 10:53Yep, it's standard practice. But Costco refuses to play that
- 10:56game. Their buyback yield averages a
- 10:59super low 3 to 4 over the last decade.
- 11:02Yeah, instead they hoard cash and then drop these massive,
- 11:06seemingly random Secial dividends, $5 a share in 2015,
- 11:10seven in 2017, ten in 2020, and a massive $15 a share in January
- 11:152024. Right?
- 11:17So what does this all mean? Like why use special dividends
- 11:20instead of just buying back stock like everybody else?
- 11:22I keep thinking about an analogy.
- 11:24Buying back an overvalued stock is essentially like paying $1000
- 11:28for a $500.00 bill just so you can say you have fewer bills in
- 11:31your wallet. That analogy hits the nail on
- 11:33the head. It comes down to a ruthless
- 11:35discipline regarding capital allocation.
- 11:37OK, management. Management understands that
- 11:39heavily buying their own stock when the price to earnings
- 11:43multiple is vastly inflated actually destroys capital value.
- 11:47Right, you're overpaying for your own business.
- 11:48Exactly. If the stock is trading at 50
- 11:50times earnings, every dollar spent on a buyback is an
- 11:54inefficient use of shareholder funds.
- 11:56So instead, when their cash reserves exceed their internal
- 12:00reinvestment opportunities, like opening new warehouses or
- 12:04upgrading global logistics, they simply hand the raw cash
- 12:08directly back to the owners. Even though it makes their
- 12:10balance sheet look objectively worse in the short term.
- 12:13Yeah, the report explicitly notes that Costco's book value
- 12:16per share actually contracted in 2017 and again in 2024.
- 12:21In a standard algorithmic Screener might flag that as a
- 12:23company losing fundamental value.
- 12:25It would. But those attractions happen
- 12:27solely because they distributed billions in those special cash
- 12:30dividends. They artificially shrank their
- 12:32book value on paper, but they maximize true realized
- 12:36shareholder returns. So it is proof of management
- 12:39prioritizing economic reality over financial optics. 100%
- 12:42which? Perfectly sets up the great
- 12:44debate among the value investing legends.
- 12:47The research details how Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway
- 12:50held Costco for over 2 decades but completely liquidated their
- 12:544.3 million shares in late 2020 when the price was hovering
- 12:58around 300 to 330 dollars. Yeah, Buffett bailed because the
- 13:02valuation got too rich. But his late partner Charlie
- 13:05Munger personally held onto his shares until his death, famously
- 13:08calling Costco one of the finest compounding machines he had ever
- 13:12seen. And this highlights the most
- 13:13crucial evolution in modern value investing.
- 13:16Early in his career, Buffett was famous for cigar butt
- 13:19investment. Right, finding mediocre
- 13:21companies trading at dirt cheap prices is taking one last puff
- 13:24of profit and discarding them. Exactly.
- 13:27But Munger fundamentally shifted Buffett's philosophy toward
- 13:30buying incredible, high quality businesses at fair prices.
- 13:33And Costco is the ultimate embodiment of Munger's
- 13:36philosophy. So if you were to look at
- 13:37Costco's stock today in mid 2026 at over a $1028.00 a share, what
- 13:43are you actually buying? Let's run this company through
- 13:45the deep value gauntlet. Well, if we run Costco through
- 13:48the traditional Ben Graham Deep Value checklist, it fails
- 13:51spectacularly on almost every single metric.
- 13:54Not a huge surprise there. A deep value investor generally
- 13:57wants a price to earnings ratio under 15.
- 14:00Costco's is 53.7. Wow.
- 14:03They want a price to book ratio under 1.5, Costco's is 15.1,
- 14:08they want a Peter Lynch PEG ratio under 1 and Costco's is
- 14:12five point O. Let's pause on that PEG ratio
- 14:14for a second because it's a vital concept for our listeners.
- 14:17The PEG ratio, price Earnings to growth, basically measures how
- 14:20much you are paying for the company's future growth.
- 14:23A PEG of 1 means you are paying a perfectly fair price for the
- 14:26growth you expect to get. A PEG of five point O is wild.
- 14:30It means investors are paying an enormous, almost unprecedented
- 14:33premium for whatever future growth Costco can muster.
- 14:36Right. By standard asset bargain
- 14:38metrics, it is undeniably overvalued.
- 14:40OK, but but then you evaluate it against the Charlie Munger test
- 14:43which prioritizes operational excellence over cheap multiples
- 14:47and Costco passes the Munger test, Florida State?
- 14:49How so? Their return on invested
- 14:51capital, or ROIC is a stellar 22.2%.
- 14:55Meaning for every dollar of capital invested into the
- 14:58business, Costco generates over $0.22 in profit every single
- 15:02year, which is incredibly efficient for a physical
- 15:05retailer. Absolutely.
- 15:07Additionally, their return on equity has averaged 25.8% / 10
- 15:11years. Their earnings per share growth
- 15:13is perfectly consistent with 0 contraction years over the last
- 15:17decade. So to really isolate what the
- 15:19company is actually worth today, the research report built a
- 15:22multi scenario discounted cash flow or DCF model.
- 15:27Yeah, for our listeners, ADCF model basically tries to
- 15:30calculate the present day value of all the cash a company will
- 15:34ever generate in its future. It requires making assumptions
- 15:37about how how fast the company will grow.
- 15:38Right, and the report's nominal historical growth case assumes
- 15:41Costco just keeps doing exactly what it has been doing, growing
- 15:45free cash flow at an impressive 15% for the next 10 years.
- 15:48And that model spits out an intrinsic value of $973 per
- 15:52share. Which is a very sobering number
- 15:54given the current trading price. Extremely sobering because even
- 15:59if Costco performs amazingly well, perfectly executing their
- 16:02historical average for the next decade at $1028.00 today, the
- 16:07stock is still technically overvalued.
- 16:09Yeah, to actually justify the current price and build in the
- 16:13standard 30% margin of safety, the model requires you to
- 16:16believe in the optimistic scenario.
- 16:19And that scenario assumes Costco can accelerate and sustain an
- 16:2218.22% growth rate for a straight decade.
- 16:25We are talking about immature massive global enterprise
- 16:30sustaining startup level growth for 10 years.
- 16:33It's a tall order. Here's.
- 16:34Where it gets really interesting.
- 16:36Costco is arguably a perfect business, but perfection is
- 16:39already entirely priced into the stock.
- 16:41You weren't just betting on Costco being good, you're
- 16:44betting on them never ever making a single strategic
- 16:47mistake. What's fascinating here is,
- 16:49well, if we connect this to the bigger picture, it explains why
- 16:52major institutional value managers hold the stock but are
- 16:55very hesitant to actively buy more at these levels.
- 16:58Yeah, that makes sense. Costco is structurally
- 17:00overvalued for a reason. Because of the sticky membership
- 17:03model we discussed at the start, their cash flow has incredibly
- 17:07low volatility. I'm almost like a bond.
- 17:10Exactly. It behaves almost more like a
- 17:12high yield treachery bond than a traditional retail equity.
- 17:16The broader market applies a massive premium to that safety
- 17:20and stability. Right.
- 17:21So the final verdict of the source material is deeply
- 17:24nuanced. Costco is a hold forever core
- 17:28asset for existing investors who bought in at lower valuations,
- 17:32but for new money looking to initiate a position today, the
- 17:35complete lack of any margin of safety makes it potentially
- 17:39dangerous at these multiples. It's the ultimate test of
- 17:41investing discipline. I mean, you can love walking the
- 17:44aisles, you can love the incredible value of the hot
- 17:46dogs, but as an investor you have to respect the math of the
- 17:49valuation. You really do.
- 17:51Now before we wrap up today, I want to leave you with a final
- 17:53thought to ponder based on a fascinating detail tucked away
- 17:56in the geographic breakdown of their footprint.
- 17:58Costco currently operates over 600 warehouses in the United
- 18:01States alone. Long term domestic saturation is
- 18:04a very real looming threat. To justify this $1000 stock
- 18:08price and keep that 15 to 18% growth engine running the future
- 18:12absolutely requires massive international expansion.
- 18:15Right, they have 40 stores in Mexico, 33 in Japan, 29 in the
- 18:19UK. But they need hundreds more
- 18:21globally to move the needle. So think about this.
- 18:24Costco was built on a deeply ingrained employee first
- 18:28forklift to CEO American corporate culture.
- 18:31Can that incredibly specific cultural magic successfully
- 18:35translate across dozens of completely different global
- 18:37labor markets? It's one thing to export massive
- 18:40pallets of cheap mayonnaise. It's entirely another challenge
- 18:43to export a corporate soul. That is a brilliant point.
- 18:46Before we sign off, I have a quick note to share with you all
- 18:49to access more advanced researches, applications and our
- 18:52latest published personal intelligent multi agent Deep
- 18:55value intelligence. Welcome to explore and join deep
- 18:58values dot AI community track total market temperature.
- 19:02Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 19:06Apple App Store. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 19:10on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 19:13or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 19:16is for information and research purposes only and does not
- 19:19constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 19:22before making investment decisions.
- 19:24If you like to access wider topics, including life's and
- 19:27investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel
- 19:29Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 19:32Much appreciated. Analyzing a company like this
- 19:34really emphasizes that whether you are looking at a tech
- 19:37startup or a bulk retailer, the fundamental mechanics of cash
- 19:40flow and capital allocation always dictate the long term
- 19:43reality. They always do.
- 19:45You know. At the start of this deep dive,
- 19:47we talked about how Costco doesn't look anything like a
- 19:50Silicon Valley tech darling. But maybe that's exactly why the
- 19:54model is so resilient. When the digital algorithms fail
- 19:58and the software trends inevitably fade, there is an
- 20:00enduring, unbreakable value in standing at the door of the
- 20:03nightclub, quietly collecting the cover charge while everyone
- 20:07else fights over the price of the drinks.
- 20:09Thanks for joining us, and we'll see you on the next deep dive.