Latest / Deep Dive / Rebranding of the Elite: The Hidden Engine Behind Culture Wars
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine you're watching a play and the villain of the
- 0:03story is standing center stage, and they're just bathed in this
- 0:07really bright, glaring spotlight.
- 0:09OK, setting a scene. Right.
- 0:11And everyone in the audience is completely focused on them.
- 0:14But then, right in the middle of the scene, someone sneaks out
- 0:17from the wings, grabs that spotlight, and physically tilts
- 0:21it. Oh wow.
- 0:22Yeah, and suddenly the villain is just standing there in the
- 0:25shadows, and the beam is shining squarely on the people sitting
- 0:28in the front row. You know the audience.
- 0:31That's a That's a pretty striking visual.
- 0:34Well, usually when we think of political or economic power,
- 0:37there's an expectation of who belongs in that spotlight,
- 0:39right? Like the elite.
- 0:41You picture a billionaire in a boardroom, maybe a multinational
- 0:44CEO or, I don't know, a Wall Street banker.
- 0:48Sure, the classic power brokers. Exactly.
- 0:51But today we're tracing how that spotlight got tilted.
- 0:55Welcome to another deep dive. We are digging into a stack of
- 0:58sources today that literally mapped this whole process out.
- 1:01It's quite a stack. It is.
- 1:02We've got a 2021 report from the ASPI Strategist on how
- 1:06Australian far right extremists fundraise online, a deeply
- 1:11researched 2007 academic paper comparing the rise of market
- 1:16populism in Australia and Canada, and then this really
- 1:19analytical breakdown of why extremely wealthy individuals
- 1:22pour money into these right wing populist movements.
- 1:25It covers a lot of ground. It really does.
- 1:27OK, So our mission for you today is to trace the financial and
- 1:32like ideological engines driving these movements.
- 1:35We're going to start from grassroots crypto hustling
- 1:37online and go all the way up to the sophisticated agenda setting
- 1:41of the ultra wealthy. Before we open this playbook, we
- 1:44really need to be transparent with you, the listener.
- 1:46Yeah, because we are looking at intensely political sources
- 1:50today. I mean, these researchers are
- 1:51analyzing right wing and far right movements, but they're
- 1:53also looking at left wing progressive and equality seeking
- 1:57groups, right? So we need to be clear that
- 1:59neither of us here is taking a political side.
- 2:01We aren't endorsing any of the viewpoints contained in these
- 2:03sources. No, absolutely not.
- 2:05Our job today isn't to judge the politics at all.
- 2:08It's strictly to unpack, synthesize, and impartially
- 2:11report on the factual analysis presented by these researchers.
- 2:15We're just looking under the hood to read the blueprints of
- 2:18how the mechanics of political influence actually function.
- 2:22OK, let's let's unpack this, because the sources present a
- 2:25totally counterintuitive idea. We really need to figure out how
- 2:28the definition of a powerful, shadowy elite shifted away from
- 2:33billionaires and corporate Titans and somehow landed onto
- 2:37like social workers, environmentalists, and equality
- 2:40advocates. That's a massive shift.
- 2:42Right. How did the people pushing for
- 2:44the welfare state suddenly become the villains in the
- 2:46political narrative? Well, to understand that
- 2:48mechanism, we actually have to start at the bottom of the
- 2:50pyramid and work our way up. OK, the bottom of the pyramid,
- 2:53yeah. Before we can talk about the
- 2:54macro level think tanks and the billionaires, we have to look at
- 2:58the grassroots level. We have to look at how fringe
- 3:00extreme right wing groups, or RW ES as the ASPI report
- 3:04classifieds them, how they sustain themselves financially
- 3:07in the modern digital age. Right.
- 3:09The AFPI report, it's titled Buying and Selling Extremism,
- 3:13and I got to say the picture it paints feels less like a
- 3:16traditional political movement and much more like an influencer
- 3:21economy. Oh exactly.
- 3:22It's highly entrepreneurial. Yeah, the researchers tracked 9
- 3:26Australian Telegram channels that were sharing right wing
- 3:29extremist content, and they found these channels were linked
- 3:32to over 20 different funding mechanisms.
- 3:34It's basically a diversified portfolio.
- 3:36We are talking about micro donations, cryptocurrency,
- 3:39merchandise sales, you name it. And the structural problem these
- 3:43figures face, you know, the reason they need all these
- 3:45mechanisms is deep platforming. Right, getting kicked off the
- 3:47main sites. Exactly.
- 3:49Mainstream tech companies like YouTube, Patreon, and PayPal
- 3:53have largely cracked down on extremist content.
- 3:56But when an extremist gets banned from earning ad revenue
- 3:59on YouTube, they don't just disappear.
- 4:01No, they just pivot. Right.
- 4:03They move to alternative live streaming platforms like D Live
- 4:07or newer services like Entropy. OK.
- 4:10Entropy is a wild mechanism to read about because it's an
- 4:13entirely alternative financial ecosystem designed specifically
- 4:18to catch the people falling out of the mainstream.
- 4:21It's literally built for them. Yeah, it actively encourages
- 4:25users who have been demonetized or banned from YouTube to port
- 4:29their live streams over to their site.
- 4:31And once they're there, they continue to receive what they
- 4:34call paid chats, which is essentially viewers tipping them
- 4:38directly to have their comments highlighted on screen.
- 4:40And what's fascinating here is how this structure completely
- 4:44blurs the line between genuine ideological commitment and just
- 4:48sheer financial grifting. Oh, Total like the ASPI
- 4:50researcher points out that distinguishing between the
- 4:52social harm caused by a bellicated extremist versus
- 4:55someone who is just, you know, exploiting A fundraising
- 4:58opportunity is incredibly complex.
- 5:00How can you even tell? You often can't.
- 5:02Are they producing extreme content because they truly
- 5:04believe it, or because saying increasingly outrageous things
- 5:07is just the most efficient mechanism to get their audience
- 5:10to send them Cryptor? See, I was reading about these
- 5:12paid chats and I immediately thought of the Wellness
- 5:15influencer economy. Oh, that's an interesting
- 5:18comparison. Think about it like those
- 5:20Instagram influencers who sell an entire aesthetic lifestyle.
- 5:24They aren't just selling a bottle of vitamins, they're
- 5:26monetizing the performance of living a specific, pure, healthy
- 5:30life. Right, they sell the identity.
- 5:33Exactly. And these extreme political
- 5:35streamers are running the exact same playbook.
- 5:38Instead of selling green juice, they are monetizing the
- 5:41performance of their extreme ideology.
- 5:44They are rewarded financially for the entertainment value of
- 5:47their outrage. That is a highly functional
- 5:50analogy, and you know the mechanism relies entirely on the
- 5:53globalization of local grievances.
- 5:56What do you mean by globalization of local
- 5:57grievances? Well, these specific local
- 5:59issues, they don't stay local anymore.
- 6:01The ASPI report tracked how funding requests for Australian
- 6:05figures were being forwarded into massive North American,
- 6:08American and British Telegram channel.
- 6:10Oh Wow. Crossing borders instantly.
- 6:12Yeah, the report highlights this guy, Thomas Sewell, who is
- 6:17associated with a white supremacist network in Australia
- 6:21when he was facing charges for armed robbery and assault.
- 6:23Pleas for his legal fund weren't just shared locally in Melbourne
- 6:27or whatever, they were pushed into overseas channels with 10s
- 6:31of thousands of subscribers. So an influencer in Australia is
- 6:34monetizing a global audience of grievance.
- 6:37Exactly. This influencer model creates an
- 6:40ecosystem where the funding itself acts as a vector for
- 6:43spreading propaganda globally. The act of fundraising builds
- 6:46the community and spreads the message simultaneously.
- 6:49But I mean a guy streaming on telegram asking for crypto to
- 6:53pay his legal bills is one thing that is still French.
- 6:56It is very. French, You don't shift the
- 6:57entire political culture of a nation just by selling
- 7:00merchandise to a niche audience online.
- 7:04So if this influencer model is the bottom of the pyramid, how
- 7:08does this anti elite rhetoric actually go mainstream and tilt
- 7:11that spotlight we were talking about?
- 7:13That's the crucial jump because the ideological framework these
- 7:16fringe actors are operating within it didn't just pop up
- 7:19overnight, it was built decades ago.
- 7:20OK. To understand how anti elite
- 7:23rhetoric became mainstream policy, the academic paper looks
- 7:27at the political strategy as of the 1990s and 2000s.
- 7:31Specifically, it analyzes Australia under Prime Minister
- 7:34John Howard and Canada under Prime Minister Stephen Harper.
- 7:37OK, so we're talking heads of state now.
- 7:39Yes, and this brings us to the academic concept of market
- 7:43populism. Right, Market populism.
- 7:46Because traditional populism usually targets financial
- 7:48elites, right? Like the bankers, the
- 7:50monopolies, the incredibly wealthy.
- 7:52The people with the actual capital.
- 7:54Right. But market populism does
- 7:56something completely different. It targets what the researchers
- 7:58call the new class. And the new class is a very
- 8:02specific rhetorical invention. It refers to university educated
- 8:05professionals, welfare state bureaucrats, and what the
- 8:08movement labeled special interests.
- 8:10A special interest. Yeah, but in this framing, a
- 8:13special interest group isn't like a corporate lobbyist
- 8:16working for an oil company. It's a feminist organization, an
- 8:19environmental group, an indigenous rights group or
- 8:22multiculturalists. OK wait, I'm struggling to buy
- 8:25this. How on earth does a politician
- 8:28convince a working class voter that an underpaid social worker
- 8:32advocating for the homeless is an elite special interest, but a
- 8:37massive corporate CEO making hundreds of millions of dollars
- 8:41is just an ordinary taxpayer? It does sound counterintuitive.
- 8:45It completely defies common sense.
- 8:47It sounds absurd until you look at the mechanism of how they
- 8:50framed it. It relies heavily on something
- 8:52called Public choice theory. Public choice theory.
- 8:55Yes, it's an economic model, suggesting that people working
- 8:58in government or advocacy are ultimately motivated by
- 9:02self-interest, just like a business owner.
- 9:04Oh, I see. And the market populists
- 9:06weaponize this. They introduce the concept of
- 9:08agency capture. Agency capture, break that down
- 9:11for us. Agency capture is the idea that
- 9:13a government department set up to help a marginalized group
- 9:16inevitably gets hijacked by activists, right?
- 9:19So according to this theory, these activists, the social
- 9:22workers, the environmentalists, they don't actually want to
- 9:25solve the problem. They don't.
- 9:26No, they just want to perpetually expand their own
- 9:29salaries, their own departments, and their own power.
- 9:33By casting equality seeking groups as self interested rent
- 9:37seekers who are just draining public funds for their own
- 9:40benefit, politicians can effectively delegitimize them
- 9:44entirely. There's just a it is a total
- 9:46rebranding of the welfare state. It makes me think of how a
- 9:49massive corporation will rebrand a price hike as a convenience
- 9:53fee. Great way to put it.
- 9:55You are looking at the exact same data point, but you have
- 9:58completely changed the emotional reaction the public has to it.
- 10:02You aren't cutting funding for women's shelters, you are
- 10:05bravely taking power away from elite rent seekers.
- 10:08Exactly, and the academic paper outlines 3 core propositions
- 10:13that made this rebranding stick in the public consciousness.
- 10:16OK. What are they?
- 10:171st the market itself is defined as the purest form of democracy.
- 10:20The market is democracy. Right.
- 10:22Any government interference in the market is framed as
- 10:25inherently undemocratic because it restricts consumer choice.
- 10:29Got it. Second, the welfare state is
- 10:31framed as a project of those Rhett seeking elites we just
- 10:34talked about who harbor a barely disguised contempt for the
- 10:37ordinary taxpayer. Creating an US versus them
- 10:41dynamic. Highly effective and third
- 10:44courts and tribunals are painted as strongholds of unelected
- 10:48elites who override popular opinion.
- 10:51Unelected elites. Yeah.
- 10:52For example, in Canada, critics associated with market populism
- 10:56actively attacked the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
- 10:59Wait, really? The charter of.
- 11:01Rights. Yes, they called it a victims
- 11:03constitution because it protected minority rights over
- 11:06the supposed will of the mainstream majority.
- 11:09And this wasn't just talk, either.
- 11:11The paper documents how this framework justified sweeping
- 11:15structural policy changes. Right.
- 11:16Absolutely real material consequences.
- 11:19Yeah, like in Canada, the Harper government defunded the Court
- 11:22Challenges program, which literally helps minority groups
- 11:25fund test cases for their constitutional rights.
- 11:28They just cut the funding. And in Australia, the Howard
- 11:30government government abolished the Employment Portfolio's
- 11:33Women's Bureau and systematically defunded dozens
- 11:37of national umbrella advocacy groups that engaged in policy
- 11:40work. Just cleared the board exactly.
- 11:43By portraying these groups as elites who are out of touch with
- 11:46the mainstream, the governments could freeze them out of the
- 11:49policy making process entirely. Which leaves a massive gap
- 11:52because if you freeze out the environmentalists and the social
- 11:55workers from advising on policy, who takes their place?
- 11:59Good question. And how do you get the broader
- 12:01public to accept this new reality?
- 12:03You need highly organized, highly funded institutions to
- 12:07launder this ideology into the mainstream.
- 12:10Right, the megaphone. I'm looking at the list of
- 12:12vectors the paper identifies Think tanks, media
- 12:16conglomerates, direct to public channels.
- 12:18The three pillars, basically. But let's focus on the think
- 12:21tanks for a second, like the Freezer Institute in Canada or
- 12:23the Institute of Public Affairs in Australia.
- 12:26How does a think tank actually change a voter's mind?
- 12:29I mean average people are not sitting at home reading 400 page
- 12:32economic white papers. No, they definitely aren't
- 12:34reading the white papers, but they are consuming the
- 12:37downstream effects. The downstream effects.
- 12:39Yes, the mechanism works like a laundering process.
- 12:43A wealthy donor funds a think tank.
- 12:46That think tank hires academics to write a very official
- 12:49sounding complex policy paper arguing that, say, environmental
- 12:54regulations are secretly destroying middle class jobs.
- 12:57Then a sympathetic media outlet takes that dense paper and turns
- 13:02it into a sensational front page headline.
- 13:05Finally, a politician points to that newspaper headline and
- 13:08says, look at this public concern.
- 13:09We need to cut these regulations.
- 13:11So the think tank transforms A billionaire's ideology into a
- 13:14neutral academic study, which becomes news, which becomes
- 13:18policy. And the media conglomerates
- 13:20amplify this relentlessly. The researchers point
- 13:22specifically to Conrad Black's Can West in Canada and Rupert
- 13:26Murdoch's News Corp in Australia.
- 13:27Massive, massive reach. It's huge.
- 13:31The paper notes how Murdoch's national newspaper, The
- 13:34Australian, regularly ran editorials denouncing the moral
- 13:38middle class, like portraying them as arrogant people who
- 13:42parade their superiority over ordinary citizens while
- 13:45basically living off government wealth transfers.
- 13:48And it wasn't just print media. The politicians themselves
- 13:51engineered ways to bypass traditional journalism to speak
- 13:55directly to the public. Cut out the middleman entirely.
- 13:57Exactly. In Australia, Prime Minister
- 14:00John Howard made unprecedented use of Talkback radio.
- 14:04He would go on these friendly populist radio shows every
- 14:07morning, entirely bypassing the critical press gallery
- 14:11journalists in parliament. Just talking straight to the
- 14:13base. And in Canada, before becoming
- 14:15Prime Minister, Stephen Harper led the National Citizens
- 14:17Coalition, which was an organization that used highly
- 14:20targeted billboard campaigns and direct mail to push a
- 14:23libertarian anti elite agenda directly to voters.
- 14:27OK, here's where it gets really interesting.
- 14:29The absolute irony of this entire mechanism.
- 14:31Oh, it's rich. You have politicians who hold
- 14:33immense structural power using heavily funded think tanks
- 14:37backed by massive multibillion dollar media conglomerates to
- 14:41convince working class voters that grassroots human rights
- 14:44advocates are the real powerful insiders.
- 14:47It is quite the flip. Political scientists term this
- 14:50insider populism or politicians populism.
- 14:53Insider populism. Yeah, it's a highly calculated
- 14:55strategy. Leaders present themselves as
- 14:57the only true voice of the mainstream, defending the
- 15:00ordinary citizen against the tyranny of political correctness
- 15:04imposed by these culturally powerful yet economically weaker
- 15:08elites. But if this massive,
- 15:10interconnected ecosystem of think tanks, media empires and
- 15:14political campaigns cost hundreds of millions of dollars
- 15:17to maintain, where is the capital actually coming from?
- 15:20And that raises the most important question, which leads
- 15:22us directly into our final source, the.
- 15:24Breakdown of the ultra wealthy. Exactly This source synthesizes
- 15:28the work of three major political economists, Jeffrey
- 15:31Winters, G William Domhoff, and Thomas Piketty, to explain
- 15:34exactly why extremely wealthy individuals and billionaires
- 15:38fund these populist movements. OK, I want to dig into the
- 15:41Geoffrey Winters portion because his theory of oligarchy is
- 15:45fascinating. It really changes how you look
- 15:47at wealth. Because we always picture a
- 15:49smoky backroom where evil billionaires sit around a
- 15:52mahogany table, steepling their fingers and like plotting how to
- 15:56deregulate the world. A comic book villain idea.
- 15:59Right. But Winters argues that
- 16:00oligarchy isn't a conspiracy at all.
- 16:02No, he argues that oligarchy is simply the political defense of
- 16:06concentrated wealth. OK, His central insight site is
- 16:09that extremely wealthy people don't actually need to
- 16:12coordinate their action. They don't, not at all.
- 16:15If you have a group of billionaires, they might
- 16:17passionately disagree on 100 different social issues, but
- 16:21they generally share a common material interest, which is they
- 16:24want lower taxes, fewer regulations, weaker labor laws,
- 16:28and stronger property rights. Therefore, they will
- 16:31independently funnel money into the politicians, think tanks and
- 16:35media that push those specific economic policies.
- 16:38So they're all just pulling in the same direction naturally.
- 16:40Exactly. The end result looks like a
- 16:43highly coordinated secret conspiracy, but it is really
- 16:47just individuals independently acting in their own aligned
- 16:50economic interests. Oh, it is like throwing a
- 16:52handful of magnets onto a table. They are all going to violently
- 16:56snap to the nearest piece of metal.
- 16:58They didn't have a meeting about it.
- 16:59They didn't coordinate, it is just the physics of the
- 17:02situation. That is a brilliant way to
- 17:04visualize it, and G William Domhoff builds on that physics
- 17:08by explaining the mechanism of how that influence is
- 17:11practically exercised. How so?
- 17:13Well, Domhoff spent decades mapping elite networks like
- 17:16corporate boards, philanthropic foundations, policy institutes,
- 17:20and he found that immense wealth doesn't, usually by direct
- 17:24dictation of specific laws. It doesn't just by a vote.
- 17:26Right. Instead, it buys agenda setting
- 17:29power. It buys the ability to shape the
- 17:31perimeter of what is considered reasonable to discuss in the
- 17:34public sphere. OK, the the source gives a
- 17:36perfect example of how agenda setting works in practice.
- 17:39Like if a media ecosystem can restrict a national debate to
- 17:42the question, how much immigration is too much, they're
- 17:45completely controlling the frame.
- 17:47Exactly. The question that is not being
- 17:49asked on the Evening News is why is housing so systemically
- 17:53unaffordable? Or why is corporate wealth so
- 17:56concentrated? You aren't necessarily ignoring
- 17:59immigration is a real issue, but you are ensuring the debate
- 18:03stays strictly contained within the realm of culture and
- 18:06identity rather than dangerous questions about economic
- 18:09distribution. Which aligns perfectly with
- 18:11Thomas Piketty's thesis. Right, the inequality guy, Yeah.
- 18:14Piketty is famous for documenting how wealth tends to
- 18:17accumulate faster than the economy grows, leading to
- 18:20massive, entrenched inequality. Sure.
- 18:23But his more recent argument is vital here.
- 18:26As economic inequality rises to extreme levels, political
- 18:30competition increasingly revolves around identity,
- 18:32culture and values, actively displacing class politics and
- 18:36economic issues. So if the general public is
- 18:38constantly arguing on social media about whether a beer
- 18:41commercial is woke or whether a local school curriculum is
- 18:44politically correct, absolutely no one is scrutinizing corporate
- 18:47monopolies. Everyone is distracted.
- 18:49No one is talking about tax loopholes for property
- 18:52investors, or capital gains tax discounts, or decades of wage
- 18:56stagnation. If we connect this to the bigger
- 18:59picture, the source actually outlines 6 distinct, overlapping
- 19:03motives for why wealthy backers fund these cultural war
- 19:07movements. OK, lay them on it.
- 19:08First, pure economic protection funding the groups that promise
- 19:12to cut taxes and slash regulations.
- 19:14Sure, the obvious one. Second, anti left politics,
- 19:17which is a deep historical fear of socialism or even moderate
- 19:20labor unions right. Third, genuine culture war
- 19:24alignment because some wealthy donors sincerely believe their
- 19:28national identity is under threat.
- 19:29So they're true believers in that sense.
- 19:31Yes, 4th is distraction and agenda setting keeping the
- 19:34public focused away from structural wealth.
- 19:36Like the immigration versus housing example.
- 19:38Exactly, 5th a desire for social hierarchy and traditional order
- 19:43and 6th simple network effects funding these causes simply
- 19:47because your peers, friends and business associates are doing
- 19:49it. Wow, it is a massive menu of
- 19:52motivations, but every single one of them pushes the political
- 19:56culture in the exact same direction.
- 19:58Whether it is a deliberate, cynical strategy of distraction
- 20:01orchestrated by a media mogul, or just a natural, chaotic
- 20:05byproduct of sensational digital politics, the material outcome
- 20:09is identical. It achieves the same goal.
- 20:12Right. The result is the defense of
- 20:14existing power structures and the continued accumulation of
- 20:16wealth at the top, while the general public fights bitterly
- 20:19over cultural grievances. So what does this all mean?
- 20:23We started by looking at a fringe guy on Telegram streaming
- 20:26offensive content to a few thousand followers just so he
- 20:29can collect micro donations in crypto.
- 20:31The very bottom of the pyramid, right?
- 20:34Then we zoomed out to see prime ministers using talk radio to
- 20:37convince the working class that social workers and
- 20:40environmentalists are the real greedy elites.
- 20:43And then we zoomed out again to see billionaires quietly funding
- 20:46the think tanks that launder the ideology that writes the scripts
- 20:49for those politicians. It all connects.
- 20:51It is a fully interconnected ecosystem.
- 20:55Cultural grievance is being monetized at the bottom by
- 20:57influencers and weaponized at the top by elites to protect
- 21:03economic inequality. And this isn't just abstract
- 21:05political theory playing out in a university lecture hall.
- 21:08This directly impacts you, the listener, every single day.
- 21:11Every. Time you log on.
- 21:12Exactly. Every time you open your phone,
- 21:14every time you read a headline, every time you see a viral
- 21:17political controversy exploding in your feed, you are
- 21:20participating in a curated agenda.
- 21:23The outrage you feel is quite literally funding A streamer's
- 21:27crypto wallet, generating ad revenue for a media empire, and
- 21:31protecting A billionaire's tax bracket.
- 21:33Which brings us back to our theater stage and that tilted
- 21:36spotlight we talked about at the beginning.
- 21:38Right the spotlight. We want to leave you with a
- 21:40framework, like a new lens to look through when you consume
- 21:42the news tomorrow morning. When you see a massive cultural
- 21:45controversy dominating the headline, consuming all the
- 21:48oxygen in the room, stop and ask yourself who tilted the
- 21:53spotlight? Who is directing your attention?
- 21:55It's exactly who benefits economically from you focusing
- 21:59all your anger on this specific cultural issue.
- 22:02Who funded the think tanks pushing these talking points
- 22:04into the mainstream? And most importantly, as you
- 22:07stare into that blinding beam of outrage, what boring,
- 22:10structural, deeply important economic issues are currently
- 22:14being hidden in the shadows? It's a structural question worth
- 22:17asking every time you log on. Thanks for joining us on this
- 22:19deep dive. We'll see you next time.