Latest / Surrounded / Why Gen Z Politics Have Become So Extreme
Transcript
- 0:00Look,
- 0:00you should not be hassling people who are American citizens
- 0:02to bring in millions of illegals into this country,
- 0:04and there are people that voted for Trump.
- 0:06What are you talking about?
- 0:07Look,
- 0:07look,
- 0:08look,
- 0:08JP,
- 0:08my name's JP.
- 0:09It starts for Juan Pablo.
- 0:10I love the Latino people.
- 0:12I might look like a white boy,
- 0:13have the white boy aura,
- 0:14but I'm a Latino man.
- 0:15Yeah,
- 0:16I like Juan Pablo.
- 0:17He was first.
- 0:17I wish I would have gotten a warm-up,
- 0:19um,
- 0:19uh,
- 0:20you know,
- 0:20because he came out of the,
- 0:21uh,
- 0:21out of the gate hot.
- 0:23All right,
- 0:24uh,
- 0:24here with Tim
- 0:25Miller from the bulwark,
- 0:26uh.
- 0:53surrounds the surrounds.
- 0:53I was I was I'm a rising and rising in what I would like the sort of like
- 0:55Rebooted and
- 1:11what has it been like to see over the years and sort of
- 1:12see a figure like that I find it strange to be honest,
- 1:12um,
- 1:12um,
- 1:12it was not intended by accident and we launched the bulwark,
- 1:14uh,
- 1:14basically folks don't know,
- 1:15I used to be a Republican operative um I was working for the moderate Republicans,
- 1:19um,
- 1:19but it's a different era.
- 1:22Um,
- 1:23much about Republicans like don't really exist anymore,
- 1:25um,
- 1:26and,
- 1:26uh,
- 1:27and,
- 1:27and we my friend Sarah Longwell launched the bulwark and asked me to help,
- 1:30and it was kind of like.
- 1:32A project we're all doing on the side and,
- 1:35you know,
- 1:36it just sort of took off and had a life of its own and,
- 1:38and like initially with that initial core group of like former Republicans
- 1:42that were listening and then we picked up a lot of,
- 1:44I think left folks that were listening who liked either
- 1:47hearing from us because we're former Republicans who felt bad and
- 1:51maybe it was that.
- 1:52Maybe they,
- 1:52a lot of people say they liked it because like they had family members
- 1:56that have gone MAGA and they felt like they couldn't talk to them and we were sort of,
- 1:59you know,
- 2:00uh,
- 2:00played like a surrogate role for them where they felt like they could have
- 2:03the conversations they used to be able
- 2:04to have with their conservative family members
- 2:07and have some disagreements,
- 2:08but they haven't good spirits and it was hard to do now because of Trump and,
- 2:12and,
- 2:12and,
- 2:12you know,
- 2:13and,
- 2:13and
- 2:14here we are,
- 2:15what,
- 2:1556 years later.
- 2:17And like we've grown a big audience,
- 2:19I think of people who don't even really know that backstory or like
- 2:22know anything like even realized that a lot of us were former Republicans,
- 2:26and I don't know,
- 2:26it's in that sense,
- 2:27it's kind of surreal,
- 2:28but um I think the thing that has
- 2:30worked in my estimation is because it was a side hustle,
- 2:34because all of us
- 2:35were kind of like doing a careerist thing,
- 2:38we're able to just be honest and like not bullshit people,
- 2:41and I think that people really want that and crave that in the political debate.
- 2:44I think there's a lot of bullshit out there.
- 2:46And so,
- 2:47you know,
- 2:48I,
- 2:48I,
- 2:48in that sense,
- 2:49um,
- 2:50to the extent that I'm having any influence on people on the left or
- 2:53politicians on the left is just because I think they feel like they can,
- 2:56they know they're not getting talking points from me
- 2:59and,
- 2:59um,
- 2:59and,
- 2:59and that's pretty cool.
- 3:00No,
- 3:01I feel like you do kind of more of a down to earth,
- 3:03um,
- 3:07you know,
- 3:07your content,
- 3:07your conversations,
- 3:07and so I can see how that resonates as relatable.
- 3:10Um,
- 3:11and also kind of millennial,
- 3:12which you know is the framing of,
- 3:14of your surrounded episode,
- 3:15you know,
- 3:16a,
- 3:16a liberal millennial and,
- 3:18um,
- 3:19conservative Gen Z.
- 3:21Did you,
- 3:22you know,
- 3:23did you anticipate
- 3:24conservatism kind of having a moment with the next generation?
- 3:27I'm,
- 3:28you know,
- 3:28I'm
- 3:29a millennial as well,
- 3:30but
- 3:31I,
- 3:31I,
- 3:31I've noticed people,
- 3:33people are surprised kind of by this like swing to the right that resonates with.
- 3:37With them,
- 3:38yeah,
- 3:39um,
- 3:39I,
- 3:39I,
- 3:40I,
- 3:40I guess I was a little bit surprised at the scale of it,
- 3:43um,
- 3:43in the last election,
- 3:44like the degree to which,
- 3:45um,
- 3:46people moved towards Trump and,
- 3:47and that generation that we're already seeing some backsliding.
- 3:50If you,
- 3:50if you trust the polls,
- 3:51I,
- 3:51I do think it's kind of tough to poll Gen Z.
- 3:53Um,
- 3:54but,
- 3:55uh,
- 3:55I,
- 3:55I,
- 3:55I wasn't totally surprised because I
- 3:59have been doing this thing for
- 4:01I guess 3 years now,
- 4:03and I was,
- 4:03I was thinking about writing a book about it and it
- 4:05just didn't come together for a variety of reasons where every Christmas
- 4:08I went to the Turning Point USA conference,
- 4:10uh,
- 4:11America Fest in Phoenix,
- 4:13and,
- 4:13um,
- 4:14and just kind of hung out
- 4:15with,
- 4:15um,
- 4:16the Gen Z conservative types and like talked to them and argued with
- 4:19them a little bit or asked them questions and listened and so.
- 4:22I,
- 4:23I felt like I had a pretty good sense actually of
- 4:26what of what was happening and like what the appeal was
- 4:30to
- 4:31conservatism.
- 4:32I think a lot of these words are sort
- 4:33of losing like are are they're not losing meaning,
- 4:36but the meaning is being redefined in some way and a lot of the
- 4:39Gen Z conservatives,
- 4:41particularly like the kind of nationalist
- 4:43isolationist ones like aren't really that conservative
- 4:46in my
- 4:47in like my old school Reagan sense,
- 4:49right.
- 4:50And I'm not like liberal really and like the lefty,
- 4:53like old school lefty sense,
- 4:55right,
- 4:55but I do think that there is
- 4:57just like,
- 4:58you know,
- 4:58kind of an evolution of how people talk about all this,
- 5:00but like the fact that there is
- 5:02an appeal
- 5:03to
- 5:05to um among young,
- 5:06particularly men,
- 5:07but not entirely men,
- 5:08to sort of a vision
- 5:10that is more isolationist,
- 5:12more America first,
- 5:15maybe a little caring a little bit less about some of the,
- 5:18you know.
- 5:19Uh,
- 5:19cutting regulations,
- 5:20cutting,
- 5:21like some of that sort of stuff that was so central to conservatism in the 80s and 90s.
- 5:25Um,
- 5:26I,
- 5:26I heard,
- 5:27I learned about all of that from,
- 5:29from kind of going to these Turning Point USA functions.
- 5:31And so I,
- 5:31I don't know,
- 5:32I,
- 5:32I,
- 5:33I felt like I have a pretty good sense of,
- 5:34of where it's,
- 5:35where,
- 5:35where these young folks are headed on at least,
- 5:38or at least where,
- 5:39why
- 5:40this kind of Trump brand of,
- 5:42of conservatism appeals to them.
- 5:43Mhm.
- 5:45No,
- 5:45that makes sense.
- 5:45And yeah,
- 5:46turning point,
- 5:47as you know,
- 5:47a lot more people are aware now.
- 5:49Um,
- 5:50really has been kind of like a foundational
- 5:53part of that movement.
- 5:54Um,
- 5:55something
- 5:56I'm curious about,
- 5:57you know,
- 5:57I know you talked to Mehdi after he came onto the show.
- 6:00Um,
- 6:01obviously his episode was,
- 6:02uh,
- 6:03notorious or infamous for a variety of reasons.
- 6:06Um,
- 6:07what were your thoughts just going into the series,
- 6:09uh,
- 6:09and were you hesitant to,
- 6:11to be a part of,
- 6:12of the show?
- 6:13I wasn't hesitant.
- 6:14I,
- 6:14I might have been last year,
- 6:15and,
- 6:16and
- 6:16after Trump won again,
- 6:17in part one of my big vows to myself
- 6:21was I wanted to get outside of the liberal bubble,
- 6:24you know,
- 6:24and I wanted to talk to people outside of it.
- 6:26I think because of my background as a former conservative
- 6:29because my views aren't really extreme on the left.
- 6:32I,
- 6:32I feel like I'm a useful
- 6:34messenger,
- 6:35um,
- 6:36to try to get,
- 6:37you know,
- 6:37to try to at least engage with
- 6:39people who,
- 6:41um.
- 6:42You know,
- 6:42went along with Trump,
- 6:43but maybe have might have mixed
- 6:44views about him and,
- 6:46and,
- 6:46and,
- 6:46you know,
- 6:46maybe had some uncertainty about him and so I just
- 6:49like I wanted to do that and find ways to
- 6:51either debate or communicate or engage with people,
- 6:55um,
- 6:56who were,
- 6:56were at least Trump curious.
- 6:58I don't,
- 6:58you know,
- 6:58I'm not gonna probably win over the MAGA hat crowd,
- 7:01right,
- 7:01but,
- 7:01um,
- 7:02to kind of engage with a broader group of people and so I,
- 7:04I was excited to do it.
- 7:05The Maddie thing didn't really scare me off that,
- 7:08that was to your to your last question.
- 7:09Were you surprised?
- 7:10Like,
- 7:11I feel like I was the only person on
- 7:12the internet that wasn't surprised by the what Mehdi
- 7:15ran into,
- 7:16right?
- 7:16Like I just,
- 7:17I,
- 7:17I,
- 7:17I'm like I know all these kids.
- 7:19Like I,
- 7:19I,
- 7:19I don't follow them all personally,
- 7:21but I've heard many of the arguments he made,
- 7:23uh,
- 7:23that were made,
- 7:24um,
- 7:24at his,
- 7:25uh,
- 7:26you know,
- 7:26going against him,
- 7:27um,
- 7:28and at some level,
- 7:29um,
- 7:29and I guess we can talk about this,
- 7:30I,
- 7:31I,
- 7:31I think.
- 7:32That maybe the
- 7:33the kind of makeup of the 20 that were at the many
- 7:36surrounded might have been more representative of like what actually
- 7:40at least the hyper engaged
- 7:43mega
- 7:44like young mega conservatives think and believe than
- 7:47uh my group which is a little bit more mixed and I think had softer,
- 7:51you know,
- 7:51views on on um some things and
- 7:54Uh,
- 7:54you know,
- 7:54I think there's a big Christian component in the one that I did,
- 7:57which I do think is an important part of
- 7:59young conservatism too,
- 8:00but,
- 8:01um,
- 8:01maybe it's a little bit less,
- 8:03uh,
- 8:04on the rise than,
- 8:05you know,
- 8:06more,
- 8:06the more kind of nationalist stuff that you saw in the Medi episode.
- 8:09Yeah,
- 8:10well,
- 8:10I could talk about Maddie's episode,
- 8:11uh,
- 8:12for a long,
- 8:12long time,
- 8:13but I,
- 8:13I wanna start reacting to some clips from yours.
- 8:16Um,
- 8:17so you ready to jump into it?
- 8:18I'm nervous a little bit.
- 8:19I was,
- 8:19I'm more nervous to rewatch the clips than I was to do it,
- 8:22uh,
- 8:23so we'll see,
- 8:23we'll see how I did.
- 8:24Yeah,
- 8:25it's gotta be,
- 8:25it's gotta be strange to see yourself,
- 8:27um,
- 8:28and I kind of black out when I go in there,
- 8:30um,
- 8:30and I just sort of do it and start spitballing,
- 8:32so I kind of don't even remember,
- 8:34but anyway,
- 8:34all right,
- 8:34let's do it.
- 8:36OK,
- 8:36so this first one I'm pulling up.
- 8:39Uh,
- 8:40this is
- 8:40in the context of your first claim in the edit,
- 8:43which was
- 8:44that ISIS has become a fascistic
- 8:47institution.
- 8:47Um,
- 8:48this is,
- 8:49uh,
- 8:49an exchange you have with
- 8:50a cast member named JP.
- 8:52I think that if you described what they're doing in another country,
- 8:54you'd obviously say it's fascist.
- 8:56You got people coming up in unmarked cars.
- 8:58They're wearing masks.
- 8:59They're jumping out and they're asking people for their papers.
- 9:02That's not American.
- 9:03That is not within our traditions or our rule of law.
- 9:05How should they deport them?
- 9:06Should they like just like knock on the door and be like,
- 9:08Hey,
- 9:08Mr.
- 9:09illegal,
- 9:10uh,
- 9:10can you come out?
- 9:11Yeah.
- 9:12Do you want to have a little chat?
- 9:13You know,
- 9:13like,
- 9:14yeah,
- 9:14they broke the law.
- 9:15They came here into this country illegally.
- 9:17And we have to enforce it.
- 9:18So like,
- 9:19if we're going to call ICE fascist,
- 9:21yeah,
- 9:21you guys call everything fascist nowadays,
- 9:23uh,
- 9:24then what are we gonna have?
- 9:26We're not going to deport them and then the people are going to be ignored.
- 9:28I don't think we need to ignore the people.
- 9:30I think if you look at deportation,
- 9:31there are a lot of Donald,
- 9:32look,
- 9:32there are a lot of Donald Trump supporters out there
- 9:34that don't like the way that ICE has been acting.
- 9:36You hear this from Joe Rogan.
- 9:37You hear it from Tim Dillon.
- 9:38What they've been doing
- 9:39is,
- 9:40is un-American.
- 9:41You should not be,
- 9:42look,
- 9:42you should not be hassling people who are American citizens to bring in millions.
- 9:46Illegals into this country and there are people that voted for Trump.
- 9:49What are you talking about?
- 9:50Look,
- 9:50look,
- 9:50look,
- 9:51JP,
- 9:51my name's JP.
- 9:52It sounds for Juan Pablo.
- 9:53I love the Latino people.
- 9:55I might look like a white boy,
- 9:56have the white boy aura,
- 9:57but I'm a Latino man,
- 9:58and I understand
- 9:59that
- 10:00they,
- 10:00that it might seem like they're coming after the Latinos,
- 10:03but really we're,
- 10:04what we're doing is respecting our laws.
- 10:05We're a constitution republic.
- 10:07They pause,
- 10:09pause,
- 10:10pause,
- 10:10pause,
- 10:11pause.
- 10:11I'm sorry,
- 10:12but you have to respect me when I say pause.
- 10:14You've been eliminated.
- 10:14You have to go back to.
- 10:16Good to see you,
- 10:16man.
- 10:17OK,
- 10:17so we're,
- 10:18we're jump,
- 10:19jumping right into it.
- 10:20Yeah,
- 10:20OK.
- 10:21What do you,
- 10:21what do you feel reliving it?
- 10:22Yeah,
- 10:23I like Juan Pablo.
- 10:24He was first.
- 10:24I wish I would have gotten a warm-up,
- 10:26um,
- 10:26uh,
- 10:27you know,
- 10:27because he came out of the,
- 10:28uh,
- 10:28out of the gate hot,
- 10:30and,
- 10:30uh,
- 10:30I liked that guy.
- 10:31Uh,
- 10:32we,
- 10:32we debated again later.
- 10:33I thought he's super smart,
- 10:35um,
- 10:35about,
- 10:36uh,
- 10:37you know,
- 10:37I,
- 10:38I think he was quoting Tocqueville and the second time that we discussed things.
- 10:42I,
- 10:42I disagreed with him on this point,
- 10:44um,
- 10:45as,
- 10:45you know,
- 10:45from the tactical strategy of dealing with Jubilee.
- 10:48Still,
- 10:49like,
- 10:49uh,
- 10:50still trying to navigate like how much do I talk over these guys,
- 10:52you know,
- 10:53how much do I,
- 10:54I wait,
- 10:54it's a long show,
- 10:56but,
- 10:56uh,
- 10:56you know,
- 10:56and the point that I was trying to make that I do
- 10:58end up making later in the show if I recall correctly,
- 11:00now this is jogging my memory
- 11:02is,
- 11:02is basically my reaction to what he said was like,
- 11:05yeah,
- 11:06immigration,
- 11:07uh,
- 11:07naturalization officials should go up to the door of someone and say,
- 11:10hey,
- 11:10Mr.
- 11:10illegal,
- 11:11you have 2 months to go.
- 11:12Like,
- 11:12here are your,
- 11:13here's your papers,
- 11:14here's your deportation papers,
- 11:15and if you don't go.
- 11:17Then I,
- 11:18we're gonna have to send in,
- 11:19you know,
- 11:20uh,
- 11:20uh,
- 11:21somebody with a warrant to come get you,
- 11:22right?
- 11:22Like,
- 11:23like,
- 11:23yes,
- 11:23like that is how you're supposed to handle it.
- 11:25It's how we've handled this
- 11:27throughout our history in this country,
- 11:28and I do think that they're,
- 11:30and,
- 11:30and I think particularly for young people this is something that is.
- 11:33That that I worry about,
- 11:34which is that like
- 11:36Trump era has gone on for so long now.
- 11:37Like a lot of people there were in
- 11:39fucking middle school when Trump came down the escalator
- 11:42and so all they know,
- 11:43yeah,
- 11:44a lot of this stuff feels normal and it's like this isn't really,
- 11:46I,
- 11:47I,
- 11:47I don't really love that phrasing like we can't normalize him,
- 11:50but
- 11:50like this isn't how things are supposed to work in a free society
- 11:52and there's a way to enforce the border and to enforce immigration law
- 11:56that is not doing
- 11:57kind of fascistic.
- 11:58Style tactics and I stand by that word which is like people jumping out of vans,
- 12:03going up to people on the street that look Hispanic and ask them to show,
- 12:06show us their papers like we should not live in a show us your papers country.
- 12:09We have no obligation in a free country to walk around
- 12:12carrying our papers and,
- 12:13and,
- 12:14and we get into it later,
- 12:15but there have been plenty of examples of,
- 12:17of people who are American citizens who were,
- 12:20who are hassled by ICE and CBP and,
- 12:22and treated horribly,
- 12:24um,
- 12:24you know,
- 12:25because of the tactics they've been using.
- 12:27Mhm.
- 12:27Something that came up a lot in the context of this prompt
- 12:31was,
- 12:32you know,
- 12:32this is the will of the voters.
- 12:34We have an extreme problem
- 12:36with illegal
- 12:37immigration.
- 12:38And so it does require kind of what will feel like an extreme
- 12:44approach to to solving it.
- 12:46I think
- 12:47somebody
- 12:48listening to this might want to hear from you.
- 12:50What,
- 12:51what do you think
- 12:53Democrats
- 12:53and
- 12:54you know the left in general got wrong about immigration and,
- 12:58and what do you think were the biggest.
- 13:00Factors that contributed to
- 13:02kind of this crisis that we,
- 13:03we have right now.
- 13:04I just want to say really quick to the question of,
- 13:06of people voted for this,
- 13:07which is like
- 13:08we live in a,
- 13:09we live in a liberal,
- 13:10this is why I say I'm a liberal,
- 13:11we live in a liberal democracy,
- 13:13OK,
- 13:13like we have a rule of law.
- 13:14Like we don't live in a country where if you get 50.1% of the vote,
- 13:18then the president is the king and gets to do whatever they want,
- 13:20right?
- 13:20Like they,
- 13:21they still,
- 13:21even if he still wants,
- 13:22even if there was an election.
- 13:24Where there's a mandate for deportations,
- 13:27he still has to deport people
- 13:28in a manner
- 13:29that is constitutional and that is within the American law and tradition.
- 13:32So I,
- 13:33that is,
- 13:33that's my response to that.
- 13:34Like it doesn't,
- 13:35we cannot even debate whether or not he really had a mandate for this or not,
- 13:37but it's like even if he did,
- 13:39like,
- 13:39he's still gonna follow the laws and what ICE and CBP are doing right now is,
- 13:43is unconstitutional.
- 13:44Um,
- 13:45uh,
- 13:45as for what the Democrat,
- 13:46what happened with the Democrats,
- 13:47um,
- 13:48uh,
- 13:48look,
- 13:48uh,
- 13:48this can go back to the 2020 primary.
- 13:51When
- 13:52I,
- 13:52I think Julian Castro,
- 13:53I believe it was,
- 13:54was pushing for decriminalizing border crossings altogether,
- 13:57and there was like one of the,
- 13:58one of the debates when there were like 100 Democrats up there,
- 14:00it was like,
- 14:01do you support decriminalizing the border at all together,
- 14:05so if you come across the border,
- 14:06you're not a criminal.
- 14:08And like pretty much everybody raised their hand.
- 14:09Joe Biden didn't raise their hand.
- 14:11I'm going from memory now,
- 14:12so I apologize to Pete if I get this wrong.
- 14:14I think Pete like kinda half raised his hand and then took it down,
- 14:16like,
- 14:17uh,
- 14:17you know,
- 14:17there were
- 14:18maybe one other person like Michael Bennett maybe didn't raise their hand,
- 14:20but I like,
- 14:22most everybody did,
- 14:23and,
- 14:23and I do think that the left
- 14:25got,
- 14:26you know,
- 14:27just way outside the mainstream from the public about how to,
- 14:30about how to handle
- 14:32immigration and how to handle,
- 14:33um,
- 14:34you know,
- 14:34just uh maintaining.
- 14:36Uh,
- 14:37a,
- 14:37a,
- 14:38a,
- 14:38a system at the border that was secure and that protected American citizens
- 14:43and,
- 14:44you know,
- 14:44you can do,
- 14:45you can do this humanely,
- 14:47like there are ways to,
- 14:49you know,
- 14:49if you go back and look at the Obama era,
- 14:51for example,
- 14:52you know,
- 14:52there were some influxes that happened at the border a couple of times,
- 14:55but like they,
- 14:57uh,
- 14:57you know,
- 14:57did the best they could,
- 14:59um,
- 14:59you know,
- 15:00where we could nitpick some of the things one way or the other of handling
- 15:03what was happening at the border and cracking down when there were big surges.
- 15:07That just didn't happen during the Biden administration.
- 15:09Maybe in part because,
- 15:10I think in part because Biden was kind of scared of his left flank,
- 15:13maybe in part because of the fact that he's aging
- 15:16and just didn't want to take on this fight,
- 15:18just would rather ignore it.
- 15:19I think maybe there's
- 15:21a lot of this of just like there's a head in the sand,
- 15:23I think among people in the Biden administration,
- 15:25they're focused on other stuff,
- 15:26and it just objectively kind of got out of control.
- 15:29And then they finally
- 15:31sort of got it in control in the election year,
- 15:33um,
- 15:34by doing the things they really should have been doing from the start,
- 15:36um,
- 15:37with regards to like remain in Mexico and some
- 15:38of the other policies they put in place,
- 15:40but it was,
- 15:40I think it was just too late like the,
- 15:42uh,
- 15:42it had set in already like the,
- 15:44the image of what they're doing it set in with voters.
- 15:47Yeah,
- 15:48an interesting argument or I guess just observation I've heard on,
- 15:51on the issue.
- 15:52Well,
- 15:53I mean,
- 15:53I do think it's hard to look at like um some of the
- 15:57memes that are posted or like the videos that feel like action films,
- 16:01you know,
- 16:01by this administration and not see that as
- 16:03cruel because you know people's lives are being
- 16:06pulled apart with some of these
- 16:08these raids and deportations and
- 16:10to turn that into entertainment is definitely cruel.
- 16:13But I've also kind of heard
- 16:14the observation that
- 16:16that that overly empathetic or that kind of
- 16:18maybe naive approach that the left had towards.
- 16:21Like you're saying,
- 16:22um,
- 16:23being too lenient around the idea of illegal border crossings,
- 16:26that was its own form of cruelty that kind of like built this,
- 16:29this crisis.
- 16:31Um,
- 16:31and so yeah,
- 16:33it's,
- 16:33it's just funny that,
- 16:34you know,
- 16:34this,
- 16:35this issue has been like a centerpiece of,
- 16:37of Trump's.
- 16:38Messaging,
- 16:39um,
- 16:40as long as he's been in,
- 16:41you know,
- 16:42in the political
- 16:43limelight,
- 16:43but
- 16:44Democrats are still sort of figuring out what exactly are their talking points
- 16:49around it.
- 16:50Do you agree?
- 16:51Yeah,
- 16:52I think so.
- 16:53I think that um.
- 16:55I,
- 16:55I think that might change.
- 16:56I think it'll be interesting to see what happens in 2028 on that front,
- 16:58and I think that,
- 16:59um,
- 17:00you know,
- 17:00that,
- 17:01that in 2020204
- 17:02they kind of had settled on
- 17:04a message of,
- 17:06you know,
- 17:06being for border security and,
- 17:08and,
- 17:08but also being empathetic and,
- 17:10and welcoming people into the country and not doing the
- 17:13racist stuff about how Haitians eat their cats and dogs,
- 17:15and it didn't land.
- 17:16So
- 17:17I,
- 17:17I suspect that there'll probably be
- 17:19a pretty varied difference of opinion on the Democratic side on how to handle.
- 17:23going forward
- 17:25and
- 17:25you know it's challenging.
- 17:26It's not easy.
- 17:26Look,
- 17:27Trump is finding out that it's challenging,
- 17:28right?
- 17:28Like it worked for him in two elections for sure,
- 17:31but the point that I made,
- 17:32uh,
- 17:32you know,
- 17:32in that clip
- 17:33is also true.
- 17:34Like he's underwater on immigration right now.
- 17:36Like the people wanted him to secure the border.
- 17:38They didn't want this,
- 17:39and like his numbers have,
- 17:40have dropped precipitously since we taped that.
- 17:42And,
- 17:43and at the time,
- 17:43like kind of the canaries of the coal mine like
- 17:45that some of these people who are in his coalition,
- 17:47but more on the outskirts like Tim Dylan and Joe Rogan were speaking out against it.
- 17:52Yeah,
- 17:52and you're right.
- 17:53I think in a year we'll definitely have a much clearer idea or sense of
- 17:57of
- 17:58you know the effects of this
- 18:00pretty intense approach.
- 18:02What also came up in
- 18:04this discussion of ICE was just your use of the term fascism or fascist.
- 18:09And Noel,
- 18:10the next clip I'm pulling up is with Noel,
- 18:12who just kind of objected to
- 18:14the use of that rhetoric.
- 18:16And so I'm going to play you a clip from her.
- 18:18I don't agree with the way that I.
- 18:20Approaching,
- 18:20approaching the immigration system.
- 18:21I'm with you there.
- 18:22I don't agree with it.
- 18:23I don't agree with sending American citizens without due process.
- 18:26I'm with you.
- 18:27My concern specifically is using the rhetoric
- 18:30of fascists because it fuels political violence.
- 18:32That is my concern.
- 18:33It's OK to disagree,
- 18:34but I don't think that that is an equivalency to Nazi Germany.
- 18:38I just don't.
- 18:38I don't either.
- 18:40All right,
- 18:40so that's a short clip,
- 18:42but
- 18:42what do you think this,
- 18:43this is something we're hearing more and more.
- 18:46Obviously in the aftermath of
- 18:47Charlie Kirk's assassination,
- 18:49but
- 18:49what,
- 18:49what's your response to this idea that
- 18:51the Democrats are,
- 18:53are throwing around the word fascist too much?
- 18:55Yeah,
- 18:55just a couple of things with this real quick.
- 18:57It's funny to watch this now.
- 18:58Um,
- 18:59with having Zoran and Trump having met in the White House,
- 19:02uh,
- 19:03uh,
- 19:03last Friday,
- 19:04where,
- 19:04where Trump's like,
- 19:05go ahead and call me a fascist.
- 19:06So I guess,
- 19:06I guess the fascist so fascinating.
- 19:08Yeah,
- 19:09I guess using the word fascist is no longer an incitement to violence,
- 19:12um,
- 19:12and then on the Charlie Kirk thing,
- 19:13which is sensitive,
- 19:14and I was sensitive about it in this group,
- 19:15obviously there are a lot of Charlie Kirk fans there,
- 19:17and I don't,
- 19:17I'm not for any sort of incitement to violence,
- 19:20but like
- 19:20there's not any evidence that
- 19:22this killer Tyler Robinson was like
- 19:25watching.
- 19:26ABC this week and was,
- 19:28you know,
- 19:28radicalized by the rhetoric of Democratic politicians,
- 19:31so I,
- 19:32you know what I mean,
- 19:32like we just have to be real about this.
- 19:34Like,
- 19:35like this is like
- 19:36it was a specific case,
- 19:37um,
- 19:37uh,
- 19:38you know,
- 19:38uh,
- 19:38we're learning more,
- 19:39but like kind of based on what was on the bullets and what his,
- 19:42what his relationship with the roommate,
- 19:44uh,
- 19:44the trans roommate,
- 19:45and,
- 19:45and why he's upset with Charlie Kirk.
- 19:47It's like I,
- 19:48it wasn't because of.
- 19:49You know,
- 19:50academic terms about like the direction of the regime,
- 19:53right,
- 19:53like that just wasn't what happened.
- 19:54And so we,
- 19:55we shouldn't,
- 19:55I think,
- 19:56start to stifle speech
- 19:57because like of some imaginary cause
- 20:00of that assassination,
- 20:01which wasn't the real cause.
- 20:03And lastly,
- 20:03I just think the point that I tried to make is like
- 20:05they are acting
- 20:06fascistic.
- 20:06They just are
- 20:07and
- 20:08and,
- 20:08and,
- 20:08and
- 20:09maybe part of the thing that complicates this is that
- 20:11maybe we need more words in the American language.
- 20:13I don't know,
- 20:13but the fascism does
- 20:15sort of go from everything from.
- 20:18Orban's Hungary
- 20:19all the way to.
- 20:21North Korea right now,
- 20:22all the way to Hitler,
- 20:24right?
- 20:24Like all of those things are fascist in their own way.
- 20:27I can fly into Orban's Hungary as a gay man who's criticized
- 20:30Viktor Orban and not be at all afraid for my life,
- 20:32you know,
- 20:33I can live and,
- 20:34and exist,
- 20:35right?
- 20:35I can't go to North Korea.
- 20:38In,
- 20:38in Germany,
- 20:39I would have been
- 20:39like in danger of going to the concentration camps,
- 20:41right?
- 20:42So like,
- 20:42uh,
- 20:42you know,
- 20:43I,
- 20:43I think that I,
- 20:44I think it's just a misunderstanding
- 20:46of kind of like the categorization to be like,
- 20:48OK,
- 20:48well if you call him a fascist,
- 20:49that means you're saying he's Hitler.
- 20:50Like I'm not saying.
- 20:51I didn't say it's Hitler.
- 20:52If I wanted to say it was Hitler,
- 20:53it would have been in the claim.
- 20:56Well,
- 20:56yeah,
- 20:57and you were specifically referring to,
- 20:59um,
- 20:59you know,
- 20:59ICE and not,
- 21:00not even necessarily the whole
- 21:02administration.
- 21:03It does feel though like there's this finger moving around of
- 21:06like trying to point the finger of blame of what's causing radicalization
- 21:10and
- 21:12Yeah,
- 21:12I mean,
- 21:12Jubilee,
- 21:13we obviously get our fair share of it,
- 21:14like
- 21:15engaging or or platforming people who do have extreme views in these videos.
- 21:19People say,
- 21:20you know,
- 21:20that's contributing to radicalization.
- 21:23And so it really is kind of a puzzle to me,
- 21:25like what,
- 21:26what is the game plan or what is a healthy approach to.
- 21:31I don't know,
- 21:31political disagreement,
- 21:33political argument that that's in favor of deradicalization.
- 21:36Do you have any,
- 21:37any ideas?
- 21:38Yeah,
- 21:38I do.
- 21:39I mean,
- 21:39for starters,
- 21:40I would just say like de-platforming is a,
- 21:42is a stupid argument.
- 21:43I wish I would never have to hear that word again.
- 21:45Like,
- 21:45uh,
- 21:46everyone is platformed already.
- 21:47It's too late.
- 21:47Like the fact maybe that was a sense of maybe I,
- 21:49I disagree with it personally,
- 21:51kind of,
- 21:51but maybe that would have made sense 20 years ago if we all to.
- 21:54Control the growth of the internet,
- 21:56but like,
- 21:56we haven't been able to.
- 21:58And,
- 21:58and,
- 21:58and Nick Fuentes and Hassan Pai,
- 22:00and I compare those two,
- 22:01but like what whoever is extreme to you,
- 22:03right?
- 22:03Like they have huge platforms already.
- 22:05Their followers have huge little mini platforms,
- 22:07you know,
- 22:08and
- 22:09Um,
- 22:09and so people are able to get their message out now,
- 22:12like,
- 22:12uh,
- 22:12and so to me
- 22:14I just think that you have to recognize this exists,
- 22:17and I think you have to engage with it.
- 22:19Like to me it's just like,
- 22:20I don't know,
- 22:20and,
- 22:21uh,
- 22:21you know,
- 22:21Candace Owens is out there saying some really crazy stuff right now.
- 22:24Some people say,
- 22:25well,
- 22:25ignore that,
- 22:26you know,
- 22:27because you don't wanna
- 22:28fuel it and give it more.
- 22:30Attention.
- 22:31I kind of think the opposite.
- 22:32I think it's like
- 22:33mock it
- 22:35and make fun of it and,
- 22:36and engage with it and try to engage on the merits with people about it.
- 22:39Like,
- 22:40you really think that
- 22:41the French
- 22:42president's wife is trans and that she hired
- 22:44an Israeli assassin to kill Charlie Kirk?
- 22:47I,
- 22:47there's no evidence of that.
- 22:48Let's go through the evidence,
- 22:49right?
- 22:50And so,
- 22:50I,
- 22:50I,
- 22:51I just think that's the only way to deal with it in this world.
- 22:53I do think the tech companies have some responsibility here.
- 22:56And I think that to the extent that there's any potential regulation,
- 23:00uh,
- 23:00like I,
- 23:00I do think that the algorithms are totally out of control and,
- 23:03uh,
- 23:03and,
- 23:04and incentivize this stuff.
- 23:05And,
- 23:05um,
- 23:06you know,
- 23:07I,
- 23:07I,
- 23:08um,
- 23:08did some consulting back from for Facebook back in
- 23:10the old times before I was a content man,
- 23:12and I was a junior person or whatever,
- 23:14but like my advice was always just like,
- 23:15can we just go back to the original news feed
- 23:17where people sign up for news from people
- 23:20and then you get that information from the people you've signed up for.
- 23:24Uh,
- 23:24because to me I think that would contribute to deradicalization.
- 23:26That just is like the idea that I have because it's like,
- 23:29OK,
- 23:30well then
- 23:31if Candace Owens or Nick Fuentes or whoever wants to
- 23:34build an audience of people that like them who choose to follow them,
- 23:37it's a free country.
- 23:38I don't know how we stop that,
- 23:39but like,
- 23:40should the big tech companies be forcing that into the feeds
- 23:43of 17 year olds who are just learning about the world,
- 23:47uh,
- 23:47who haven't heard all the arguments,
- 23:49who don't know everything that's going on in the news
- 23:51over
- 23:52forcing.
- 23:54You know,
- 23:54ABC News into their feed or if you're more on the right now,
- 23:57I guess CBS News,
- 23:58right?
- 23:58Like I,
- 23:59I,
- 23:59I just think that like the algorithms are doing a lot of this.
- 24:02I,
- 24:02I don't,
- 24:02you know,
- 24:03that's a tech regulation issue,
- 24:05I think more than the responsibility of any of us.
- 24:08Yeah,
- 24:08totally.
- 24:08I,
- 24:09I do think it's interesting this idea of kind of algorithmic freedom or
- 24:13or more transparency or choice around algorithms is,
- 24:16is something I'm hearing more and more,
- 24:18um.
- 24:19OK,
- 24:19so moving on to
- 24:21the next clip.
- 24:22The next claim that you had was um around
- 24:26guns,
- 24:27guns in the US,
- 24:28and you kind of took an angle on,
- 24:30you know,
- 24:31the claim that that infamous claim that Charlie Kirk made about saying,
- 24:35you know,
- 24:35gun deaths are,
- 24:36are worth it to preserve the Second Amendment.
- 24:39So I'm going to play a clip from your
- 24:42conversation with Micah.
- 24:43Obviously this is a reference to the,
- 24:44uh,
- 24:45Charlie Kirk quote about how it was worth,
- 24:47um,
- 24:47uh,
- 24:47some gun deaths every year to have the Second Amendment as it's currently written.
- 24:51And my view is this,
- 24:52look,
- 24:52I'm not,
- 24:52this is not an argument to repeal the Second Amendment.
- 24:54My point is that we shouldn't have a fatalistic view about this,
- 24:57to just say we have the Second Amendment.
- 24:59Nothing we can do now.
- 25:00Some people are gonna die because of it,
- 25:02and so we've just,
- 25:03that's just the price of freedom.
- 25:05For example,
- 25:05in Canada,
- 25:06you have,
- 25:07you have a right to bear arms still,
- 25:08but it's like
- 25:09you have to get a license.
- 25:10You,
- 25:11there has to be training,
- 25:12you know,
- 25:12you have to,
- 25:13um,
- 25:13pass background checks.
- 25:15Is that not
- 25:16also in the United States too?
- 25:18No.
- 25:19You don't have,
- 25:20you don't need a gun license.
- 25:21Well,
- 25:21no,
- 25:21you do,
- 25:22but no,
- 25:22what I'm saying is it's not like a driver's license.
- 25:24Like you,
- 25:24you don't have to like go to a when you're getting a driver's license here,
- 25:27it's more akin to what you do in Canada.
- 25:29You have to go to classes.
- 25:30You have to prove that,
- 25:31you know,
- 25:31you don't,
- 25:32you have to prove,
- 25:32you have to prove that you have to know how to use the guns.
- 25:35Like there is a process.
- 25:37There's no process in the United States.
- 25:38Well,
- 25:38in a lot of cases you don't have to go through a process.
- 25:40Sure,
- 25:40people have easy access to guns in this country without going through the process.
- 25:43There,
- 25:44um,
- 25:44is easy access for.
- 25:46Younger people to get high to get high powered weapons.
- 25:49That's definitely not true.
- 25:50But can,
- 25:51can you,
- 25:51can you name the legislation that would have
- 25:54prevented Charlie Kirk from,
- 25:56uh,
- 25:56being assassinated?
- 25:57Well,
- 25:58I,
- 25:58no,
- 25:59because I don't,
- 25:59there wouldn't have been a piece of legislation that
- 26:01could have prevented Charlie Kirk from being assassinated.
- 26:02My,
- 26:03my point is that his initial claim
- 26:05was in service of this idea that we have a maximalist view of the Second Amendment.
- 26:09When I hear this topic come up a lot,
- 26:11um,
- 26:12a lot of times I hear.
- 26:14The criticism of Democrats saying they don't understand
- 26:17gun laws or they don't understand guns enough to create effective legislation
- 26:22to have the outcomes that they desire.
- 26:25But then a lot of times what I hear
- 26:27from you in that clip is that it feels
- 26:29like there's such a common sense low hanging fruit that
- 26:32we could reach for to have
- 26:35safer gun laws in the US.
- 26:37What is,
- 26:38I guess the first place I want to start is,
- 26:39what is something,
- 26:40if you could just grab.
- 26:42A 2nd Amendment,
- 26:44uh,
- 26:45conservative in America and just be like,
- 26:46this is what,
- 26:47this is a common sense thing.
- 26:48It's not taking your guns.
- 26:50What's the most obvious thing you wish you could
- 26:52communicate to someone like that?
- 26:55I mean,
- 26:55I don't know that I think that we should have a very high um
- 26:59Bar
- 27:00for access to guns for anybody that's under 21 and maybe even under 25.
- 27:05I mean,
- 27:06I,
- 27:06again,
- 27:06like that guy was
- 27:08objecting to a lot of these people live in California,
- 27:09so the laws are a little stricter in California,
- 27:11but like in a lot of states,
- 27:13like,
- 27:13uh,
- 27:13if you're 24,
- 27:14like it's,
- 27:15it's pretty frictionless to get a gun and there's like some basic.
- 27:18Requirements,
- 27:19um,
- 27:19but compared to what
- 27:20you have to do
- 27:21like in Canada,
- 27:22as I mentioned,
- 27:22you have like an 8 hour training class,
- 27:24like I,
- 27:24I think it should be pretty challenging for you to be
- 27:26able to get a gun if you're not below 25,
- 27:28and most of these mass shootings are from people that are under 25
- 27:32and,
- 27:32uh,
- 27:32you know,
- 27:33and like we have a lot of rules in other areas,
- 27:35um,
- 27:36around this spot,
- 27:37I think I forget if I made it in this clip or
- 27:38one of the other places where it's like there's rules around zin.
- 27:42And guns,
- 27:43like,
- 27:43uh,
- 27:43you know,
- 27:44should not be that similar,
- 27:45right?
- 27:45Like I think it should be much more challenging to get a gun than it is to get us in,
- 27:48and that's not really the case here.
- 27:50So,
- 27:50uh,
- 27:51to me,
- 27:51I,
- 27:51I,
- 27:51I just think that it starts there.
- 27:53I like,
- 27:54I,
- 27:54I would personally be open to
- 27:56like much,
- 27:58um,
- 27:59you know,
- 27:59much more significant
- 28:01gun reforms than that,
- 28:02but I,
- 28:02I think that like my,
- 28:03the point of this dialogue is,
- 28:06I,
- 28:06I feel like.
- 28:07We've stopped talking about it.
- 28:08I feel like people have given up,
- 28:10you know,
- 28:10I mean,
- 28:10like there's a lot of movement towards,
- 28:11like,
- 28:12uh,
- 28:12here's one example,
- 28:13after Parkland,
- 28:14there was a movement towards red flag laws,
- 28:16and,
- 28:17and Rick Scott,
- 28:18the current Republican senator from Florida,
- 28:20signed it,
- 28:20a red,
- 28:21a red flag law in,
- 28:22in Florida,
- 28:23which is totally common sense bill.
- 28:25They're repealing that now.
- 28:28In Florida,
- 28:28like they've gone backwards.
- 28:29Like there's no like Republicans have,
- 28:31have,
- 28:32have essentially just shut down any debate around this where it's just like no,
- 28:36like,
- 28:36like there there's we're not open for any discussion
- 28:38and I just think that like if you look at the results of how we live
- 28:41in this country and like the amount of gun deaths we have in this country compared to
- 28:45Per countries.
- 28:47I,
- 28:47I,
- 28:47I just think it's a moral outrage and it's shocking that like we can't have,
- 28:51uh,
- 28:51you know,
- 28:52that we can't open back up the
- 28:54conversation about where,
- 28:56where to meet on gun legislation.
- 28:58No,
- 28:58I,
- 28:58I agree with you.
- 28:59It does seem like the conversation is halted.
- 29:01There's almost like a sense that the
- 29:03The line's not going to move and people just
- 29:05sort of have chosen their side on this issue.
- 29:08You know,
- 29:08you brought up this idea of red flag laws.
- 29:10Somebody later on in this prompt or in this kind of made the argument,
- 29:12look,
- 29:16we're already in this situation
- 29:19there are guns everywhere in the US.
- 29:21Millions and millions of people own them.
- 29:23Um,
- 29:24and so we can't really go back.
- 29:25We got to find a way forward.
- 29:27Other than like red flag flag laws.
- 29:29Do you think there's other kind of creative approaches
- 29:31that should be considered to reduce gun violence,
- 29:35you know,
- 29:35now that we just kind of have to face the fact that the only issue in which we do this,
- 29:40it's like there's so many guns here,
- 29:42I guess we just have to give up.
- 29:43People have to die.
- 29:44Now,
- 29:44I don't know,
- 29:45like
- 29:45there are so many cars in this country and there are a lot of car deaths.
- 29:48You know what we've done?
- 29:49We've figured out a ton of ways to make driving a lot safer now than it used to be,
- 29:53and,
- 29:53and shoot,
- 29:54who knows?
- 29:55And as we go to the next 5,
- 29:5610 years,
- 29:57you get to self-driving cars,
- 29:58we might be able to eliminate a lot of these
- 30:00deaths altogether,
- 30:01right?
- 30:01It's like drugs.
- 30:02It's like nobody,
- 30:02none of the people in that circle would be like,
- 30:04well,
- 30:04you know.
- 30:05They're already gonna be building the cocaine and the fentanyl,
- 30:08and so it's,
- 30:09so there's nothing we can do about it,
- 30:10right?
- 30:10There's nothing we can do.
- 30:11People,
- 30:12so I,
- 30:12I,
- 30:12I just sort of reject the whole notion as I,
- 30:15I don't.
- 30:16Uh,
- 30:17I mean,
- 30:17I,
- 30:17I think that they've tried gun buybacks in other countries that are,
- 30:21that are voluntary,
- 30:23that I think that is
- 30:24it's a worthwhile step.
- 30:26Like why not?
- 30:26As long as it's voluntary,
- 30:27why wouldn't we want to do that?
- 30:29I'm personally,
- 30:30this,
- 30:30this would not resolve kind of
- 30:32the preponderance of deaths in this country which are handgun deaths,
- 30:35but maybe some of these really.
- 30:36Traumatic
- 30:37mass shooting events,
- 30:38I think that there should be limits on magazine capacities.
- 30:42Again,
- 30:42so I don't,
- 30:43you know,
- 30:43uh,
- 30:43it's hard for me to understand the a reading of the Second Amendment to mean that like
- 30:47you have to be able to
- 30:49have an unlimited amount of bullets,
- 30:51right?
- 30:51Like you have to be able to have a high capacity magazine that has 15 bullets in it that
- 30:56you can,
- 30:57you know,
- 30:57fire off 15 shots before you have to reload again.
- 31:01Uh,
- 31:01like,
- 31:01I don't,
- 31:01I,
- 31:02I don't see any reason to think that like that,
- 31:05that,
- 31:05you know,
- 31:05should be interpreted why buying book like he,
- 31:08he wrote the Charlie Kirk example,
- 31:09but the kid that went to
- 31:10kill Trump
- 31:11and failed,
- 31:13you know,
- 31:13he stopped at a store
- 31:15and bought the bullets on the way.
- 31:17Why is that?
- 31:18Like,
- 31:19why do we have that?
- 31:20Like,
- 31:21shouldn't,
- 31:21shouldn't there be a waiting period?
- 31:23Like,
- 31:23should you be able,
- 31:24like,
- 31:25like if you're like a hunter
- 31:26and you,
- 31:26you know,
- 31:27there's,
- 31:27I,
- 31:27I,
- 31:28I'm sure we could come up with.
- 31:30Some rules around this where,
- 31:31you know,
- 31:32just like,
- 31:32you have to get a license to go fishing,
- 31:34you can go to the,
- 31:35you know,
- 31:35registered,
- 31:36you know,
- 31:37place and,
- 31:37and they can then have a certain amount of bullets that you're gonna need to go,
- 31:41you know,
- 31:41hunting for deer or whatever.
- 31:43But like,
- 31:44to,
- 31:44to be in a,
- 31:45to be in the suburbs and be able to go to a big box store and order 30 bullets,
- 31:49like why,
- 31:50why is that legal?
- 31:51How is that part of the Second Amendment?
- 31:53Um,
- 31:53so anyway,
- 31:54I,
- 31:54I,
- 31:54I,
- 31:54I,
- 31:54I just,
- 31:55I do think that there are,
- 31:56there are,
- 31:56there are things that
- 31:57are possible here.
- 31:59I don't think that there's a mandate for people under 21,
- 32:02uh,
- 32:03being able to access weapons legally or carry them even legally.
- 32:07Um,
- 32:07I've been pushing Democrats to run on that.
- 32:09I think that's a good starting spot for this issue,
- 32:12so those are the things that come to mind.
- 32:13Yeah,
- 32:14as someone who's,
- 32:15you know,
- 32:15formerly conservative,
- 32:17um,
- 32:18what do you
- 32:19like,
- 32:19do you have any
- 32:21kind of theory of why,
- 32:22why is this issue so precious,
- 32:23um,
- 32:24to conservatives on the right?
- 32:25Why,
- 32:25why is
- 32:26there's something unique about this one?
- 32:28It is a tough one for me because it's like the one,
- 32:30it's the issue I've moved the most on.
- 32:31It's why I picked the prompt.
- 32:32I just,
- 32:33I don't,
- 32:33I don't know,
- 32:34like,
- 32:34it's affected my life.
- 32:35Like I grew up right by Columbine.
- 32:37I had friends in Columbine and um.
- 32:39And um I,
- 32:40I,
- 32:40I don't,
- 32:41I,
- 32:41I,
- 32:41I think that at some level
- 32:44there's a cultural element of it for sure,
- 32:46um,
- 32:47but
- 32:48I
- 32:49do think that's
- 32:50overstated to a certain degree,
- 32:53right?
- 32:54Like I,
- 32:54I just
- 32:55like sure I,
- 32:56I understand that for some people there is,
- 32:58uh,
- 32:58you take the kid hunting,
- 33:00you know,
- 33:00this is part of the family tradition.
- 33:03Um,
- 33:04there isn't really a cultural family tradition around AR-15.
- 33:08It's a pretty new phenomenon to have an AR-15 in the house and have a bunch of them.
- 33:12I,
- 33:12I think that that is meaningfully different.
- 33:14And so to me,
- 33:14what that says is like,
- 33:15I think a lot of conservatives would tell you it's about,
- 33:18you know,
- 33:18city versus rural,
- 33:19cultural traditions,
- 33:21but I think a lot of it is about,
- 33:24you know,
- 33:24individualism,
- 33:25being anti-government,
- 33:27uh,
- 33:28giving a big FU
- 33:29to the left,
- 33:30and I think a lot about how
- 33:32Um,
- 33:32this guy Rich Lowry,
- 33:33who writes for National Review,
- 33:34wrote that like,
- 33:36like,
- 33:36even for people who didn't like Trump on the right,
- 33:38a lot of them saw him as a big middle finger to the people they didn't like.
- 33:41I think going out and getting a couple of AR-fifteens is
- 33:43a big middle finger to the people that you don't like.
- 33:46Um,
- 33:47it's like a statement of individualism.
- 33:49It's a statement of,
- 33:50you know,
- 33:51I,
- 33:52I'm not gonna be bossed around by these
- 33:55whatever liberal
- 33:56elites,
- 33:57um,
- 33:58and I think that's,
- 33:59again,
- 33:59I'm,
- 33:59I'm painting with a broad brush,
- 34:01right?
- 34:01Like surely there obviously there's some people for whom guns are big,
- 34:04like,
- 34:04you know,
- 34:04hunting is a big part of their family tradition,
- 34:06but I,
- 34:07I think that the latter
- 34:08is as big,
- 34:09if not more of a part of it.
- 34:11Yeah,
- 34:11it's definitely been kind of ingrained in kind of like the meme culture that we have,
- 34:15you know,
- 34:16like,
- 34:17like the memes of Trump standing with an eagle and kind of a gun in his hand.
- 34:21And yeah,
- 34:21it is kind of unique that just
- 34:25There's something about this issue.
- 34:27So the next one,
- 34:28next clip I want to bring up,
- 34:30which prompted you feel more,
- 34:32um,
- 34:33invested in your red state versus blue state,
- 34:35uh,
- 34:36prompt
- 34:38the American values.
- 34:39OK.
- 34:40Oh,
- 34:40OK,
- 34:40great.
- 34:41So I'm gonna pull up a conversation you
- 34:43had with Scott on your American values prompt.
- 34:46Uh,
- 34:47those liberal values are basically,
- 34:49uh,
- 34:49freedom of speech,
- 34:50freedom of religion,
- 34:51pluralism,
- 34:52tolerance,
- 34:52rule of law.
- 34:53But where do you get those values?
- 34:54Because you're saying the Trump administration,
- 34:55right?
- 34:55I believe the Trump administration actually protects American values,
- 34:58right?
- 34:59It protects the American values of the unborn,
- 35:01right?
- 35:02Those are things that us as Gen Z,
- 35:03we are passionate about,
- 35:04right,
- 35:05because
- 35:05it has killed.
- 35:07Martin just said 28% of us,
- 35:09abortion has killed 28% of us Gen Z.
- 35:11So that's something that we're
- 35:12very
- 35:13passionate about and you can only find that
- 35:15when you find your value in a creator.
- 35:18I mean,
- 35:18we,
- 35:18you know,
- 35:18we could go back to the Enlightenment.
- 35:20I don't know that we need to do a bunch of John Locke talk here,
- 35:22but,
- 35:23um,
- 35:23you know,
- 35:23essentially the,
- 35:24the values that I'm talking about
- 35:26are the ones in the Constitution and the Declaration.
- 35:29As I said,
- 35:29freedom of speech,
- 35:30freedom of religion,
- 35:32rule of law,
- 35:33democracy.
- 35:33Pluralism,
- 35:34that is,
- 35:34that is the foundation of what America was founded on.
- 35:36That's what the founders wrote about.
- 35:37You can go read about it in the Federalist Papers on
- 35:39all of those Judeo-Christian values that were instilled from the beginning.
- 35:43I hear you,
- 35:44man,
- 35:44but you're,
- 35:45you're trying to make this about faith.
- 35:46And,
- 35:47and what,
- 35:47and what the founders were explicit about was that
- 35:50this country was not founded based on religion.
- 35:52A lot of them were religious,
- 35:53of course,
- 35:54but we have freedom of religion.
- 35:55Excuse me,
- 35:56excuse me,
- 35:56we have freedom of religion in this country.
- 35:57So,
- 35:57uh,
- 35:58so if you go down that list that we said,
- 36:00it's.
- 36:00Freedom of the Declaration Trump is attacking that freedom of religion.
- 36:03Trump is attacking.
- 36:04He's not attacking freedom of religion.
- 36:06How is he had a freedom of religion?
- 36:07We had a Muslim ban in this country.
- 36:09No,
- 36:09we have never had an actual Muslim ban.
- 36:11That is an insane claim by you.
- 36:14That is insane.
- 36:14It had to be overturned by the Supreme Court.
- 36:16Well,
- 36:17what are you thinking?
- 36:18What are you feeling when you see that back?
- 36:19Yeah,
- 36:20that was fun.
- 36:20It did have to be overturned by the Supreme Court.
- 36:22You know,
- 36:23look,
- 36:23again,
- 36:24I think it was interesting and the group was very Christian.
- 36:27Um,
- 36:28and,
- 36:28um,
- 36:29and I,
- 36:29and there's like I think that that's like a big part of the young,
- 36:32um,
- 36:33conservative,
- 36:34uh,
- 36:34movement,
- 36:35of course,
- 36:35um,
- 36:36but
- 36:37you know that it was kind of a blinkered like argument about all of this,
- 36:40right,
- 36:40like where,
- 36:41where if,
- 36:41if you're gonna focus,
- 36:43you know,
- 36:43solely on that notion where he was obviously going,
- 36:46which I could see is this like,
- 36:47oh this is a Judeo-Christian country.
- 36:49You know,
- 36:49we should have Christian values.
- 36:51I,
- 36:51I just,
- 36:52I think that that's a wrong unders I,
- 36:53I,
- 36:54I don't think,
- 36:54I know that that's a wrong understanding
- 36:56of what the American values are,
- 36:58like,
- 36:58sure,
- 36:59like the founders were
- 37:00Judeo-Christian,
- 37:01um,
- 37:02but like they specifically
- 37:04founded the country based on the ability for
- 37:06people to express their religion freely and,
- 37:08and,
- 37:09uh,
- 37:10and to be unreligious.
- 37:11There were several of them that were not very religious at all,
- 37:13and that they were,
- 37:13they were leaving.
- 37:15Um,
- 37:15a place or places,
- 37:17uh,
- 37:18where like religion
- 37:19was forced upon them,
- 37:20right?
- 37:20And so,
- 37:21you know,
- 37:22I,
- 37:22I,
- 37:22we ended up kind of being able to expand that argument out,
- 37:24uh,
- 37:25out a little bit
- 37:26more,
- 37:26um.
- 37:27A lot of pro,
- 37:28a lot of pro-life talk.
- 37:29Like the Muslim ban argument is kind of like this,
- 37:32like arguing on a,
- 37:34uh,
- 37:34you know,
- 37:34on a technicality that like it never,
- 37:36uh like the Muslim ban itself never actually went in place.
- 37:39So it's like Trump tried to do a Muslim ban
- 37:41and then the Supreme Court overturned it and then they went
- 37:44back with like a tailored version of it that was like,
- 37:46OK,
- 37:46well,
- 37:46we're gonna ban people from Muslim countries and North Korea,
- 37:49by the way,
- 37:49just we'll throw that one in there too.
- 37:50So it's not a Muslim ban anymore,
- 37:52but it's the same thing,
- 37:53and,
- 37:53and so,
- 37:54you know,
- 37:54and,
- 37:54and that is like an argument on a technicality,
- 37:57but I,
- 37:57I would say now
- 37:58that you can see.
- 38:00Like a number of areas where,
- 38:02where these guys have been attacking
- 38:04like these fundamental American values and we get into it a little bit.
- 38:07Yeah,
- 38:08no,
- 38:08you're definitely right.
- 38:09There was,
- 38:09there's a lot of like Christian advocacy and there was just more of
- 38:12a Christian flavor to the circle in this episode and that was,
- 38:16that was definitely buttressing a lot of their arguments.
- 38:19Something though that I,
- 38:21we see it come up on the internet like you spend time on X and it's just.
- 38:25Get kind of showered with these kinds of posts
- 38:29about Judeo-Christian values and the West and how Islam is incompatible with that.
- 38:34And you know there's even people left of center,
- 38:37like Sam Harris who have really strong views on this.
- 38:41What's your reaction to kind of like that.
- 38:45That argument that there's something about Western
- 38:47values or American values that are like.
- 38:49You know,
- 38:50inherently
- 38:51tied to Judeo-Christian values.
- 38:54Um,
- 38:56yeah,
- 38:56I don't,
- 38:56I,
- 38:56I mean,
- 38:57look,
- 38:57I,
- 38:59I don't want this country to be a Sharia law country.
- 39:02I think that that would be in conflict with American values,
- 39:05sure,
- 39:05and I think to the extent that
- 39:07People want to move to this country and,
- 39:10and force their religion upon
- 39:13uh other Americans.
- 39:14Um,
- 39:14I,
- 39:15I would be opposed to that.
- 39:16Uh,
- 39:17I just,
- 39:17like that was like a big panic in the 2000s,
- 39:20right?
- 39:21It was like Sharia law was coming to America
- 39:23and
- 39:24I,
- 39:24I'm,
- 39:24I'm not really seeing that.
- 39:26I,
- 39:26I,
- 39:26I'm seeing a lot of
- 39:28examples
- 39:29now of a backlash where
- 39:32you have people in red states in particular
- 39:34that are forcing
- 39:36Um,
- 39:37Christian,
- 39:38uh,
- 39:38theology,
- 39:39or,
- 39:40and,
- 39:40and a lot of kids they're kind of warped,
- 39:42uh,
- 39:42interpretation of Christian theology
- 39:44onto kids in public schools,
- 39:48and I just don't think that's what this country is all about.
- 39:50And,
- 39:51uh,
- 39:51when I,
- 39:51the,
- 39:52the,
- 39:52to the extent that I agree with them.
- 39:54As I mentioned at the beginning of that,
- 39:55uh,
- 39:56clip,
- 39:57uh,
- 39:57like,
- 39:57sure,
- 39:57like I'm for the West,
- 39:58uh,
- 39:59that's,
- 39:59you know,
- 39:59that's why I'm a liberal.
- 40:00I'm for locking
- 40:02traditional classical liberal values.
- 40:05Um,
- 40:06those classical liberal values which I just listed all off for him
- 40:09are
- 40:10not compatible
- 40:12with people that are trying to say that like this should be
- 40:16a
- 40:17You know,
- 40:17in Catholic integralis country or a Christian nationalist theocracy,
- 40:22like that is not,
- 40:23those are not the Enlightenment ideas that have allowed the West to flourish.
- 40:28So,
- 40:28um,
- 40:29you know,
- 40:29to the extent that like you wanna say that,
- 40:31oh,
- 40:31it was a lot of,
- 40:32like I have a lot of pride
- 40:34in the
- 40:35You know,
- 40:36Judeo-Christians that like,
- 40:38you know,
- 40:39were
- 40:39the leaders of the country
- 40:41that instituted these values and that these values have been successful and that,
- 40:45you know,
- 40:46allowed us to,
- 40:47you know,
- 40:47to prosper and flourish and have freedom in a way
- 40:49that people have in other parts of the world.
- 40:51Like I agree with that,
- 40:52but I,
- 40:53I think it's a warped
- 40:54uh uh translation of that to say that,
- 40:57OK,
- 40:57what that means is that,
- 40:59you know,
- 40:59we need to impose
- 41:02specific
- 41:03interpretations of Christian doctrine onto other people.
- 41:06Yeah.
- 41:06And I think the tricky thing with religion
- 41:09is religion is both ideas and people.
- 41:13And so when we talk
- 41:15sweepingly about whether
- 41:17it's Christianity or Islam and whether that is a problem,
- 41:21it's hard
- 41:22to make the distinction between,
- 41:23are we talking about groups of people right now or are
- 41:25we just talking about the ideas baked into that religion?
- 41:28So it does,
- 41:29we do
- 41:30seem to continue to get stuck
- 41:32there.
- 41:33And also like,
- 41:33what are the interpretations again,
- 41:34it's like it's all,
- 41:35it's generally conservative people.
- 41:36It's like we have
- 41:37had two pretty
- 41:39liberal popes
- 41:40to a certain extent,
- 41:41and they might not be liberal on a couple of issues like about abortion or,
- 41:44or,
- 41:44you know,
- 41:44a couple of other issues,
- 41:45but like on issues of immigration,
- 41:47on issues of,
- 41:48of,
- 41:48you know,
- 41:48being welcoming to the stranger of,
- 41:51uh,
- 41:51you know,
- 41:51uh,
- 41:52public services.
- 41:53I,
- 41:54I could have two pretty woke popes in a row,
- 41:56and so,
- 41:56you know,
- 41:57it's like,
- 41:57OK,
- 41:57well.
- 41:59Uh,
- 41:59you're telling me that it is,
- 42:01that,
- 42:01that,
- 42:02you know,
- 42:02uh,
- 42:02it'd be one thing to say,
- 42:03OK,
- 42:04we should try to ground ourselves in the in
- 42:06the Judeo-Christian tradition and try to think about,
- 42:09you know,
- 42:09have
- 42:10open dialogue and debate about what that means.
- 42:13It's another thing to be like,
- 42:14no,
- 42:14I have to,
- 42:15that means that I'm gonna enforce my interpretation
- 42:19of
- 42:19this religion upon you
- 42:21and that that interpretation is one
- 42:24that has
- 42:25Like a ton of dissent
- 42:27within the Christian community,
- 42:28you know,
- 42:29whether it be,
- 42:30you know,
- 42:30from more
- 42:31kind of liberal
- 42:32Protestant churches or from,
- 42:35you know,
- 42:35our recent
- 42:36two popes.
- 42:38Yeah.
- 42:38Well,
- 42:39as someone,
- 42:39you know,
- 42:40with like a very Catholic family,
- 42:41I can,
- 42:42yeah,
- 42:43the popes have been woke,
- 42:44but there's been some unrest.
- 42:48Oh no,
- 42:48the Catholic world is crazy right now,
- 42:50and you think that,
- 42:51you think that there is polarization in our politics and what's happening in,
- 42:55in like Catholic Church politics,
- 42:57I also grew up Catholic,
- 42:58like,
- 42:58you know,
- 42:58the,
- 42:59uh,
- 43:00what's happening behind the scenes with the priest politics,
- 43:03um,
- 43:03I mean,
- 43:04the knives are out,
- 43:05not literally,
- 43:06but,
- 43:06um,
- 43:06for on the multiple,
- 43:07on the two factions within the church.
- 43:10And so,
- 43:10uh,
- 43:10that whatever,
- 43:11OK,
- 43:11I,
- 43:12uh,
- 43:12you know,
- 43:13the,
- 43:13my,
- 43:13the point that I was making,
- 43:15that word that I keep going back to of pluralism is in our society,
- 43:18in a Western society,
- 43:20that means that you need to be able to live
- 43:23side by side with people who you passionately disagree with,
- 43:26who you think are
- 43:27even people who you think are.
- 43:29Bastardizing your religion,
- 43:32right?
- 43:32Like,
- 43:33in,
- 43:33in this country,
- 43:34what it means to practice American values is to say,
- 43:38they will be my neighbor and I will,
- 43:40you know,
- 43:40go and,
- 43:41and we'll be in community together and we'll argue about that in the public square.
- 43:45Like what they seem to be wanting to take us.
- 43:47Back to is the west part of the West that was before the Enlightenment
- 43:51where they killed each other if they disagreed over their religion or where one
- 43:55interpretation had to dominate the other interpretation
- 43:57in the in the um in the government
- 44:00and like that's not what I'm,
- 44:02that's not what I'm about.
- 44:03That's not what the founders were about.
- 44:05No,
- 44:05I appreciate you digging into that.
- 44:07All right,
- 44:07the last,
- 44:08last clip I wanna pull up before I let you go,
- 44:11um,
- 44:11so you,
- 44:12you called back,
- 44:12uh,
- 44:13Micah to the center.
- 44:14So Micah,
- 44:14you were having a debate with him about guns,
- 44:17um,
- 44:17and then he brought up,
- 44:18you know,
- 44:18abortion really was like a,
- 44:20a thread throughout this episode.
- 44:22And so his claim was about
- 44:24abortion and kind of the,
- 44:25the morality of it.
- 44:26So I'm gonna share.
- 44:28That clip and we'll react.
- 44:30Abortion is a grave moral evil.
- 44:34From the moment of conception,
- 44:35I guess I would disagree with you.
- 44:37Um,
- 44:37but I think that,
- 44:39um,
- 44:40that abortion reaches a point where it is a grave moral evil,
- 44:43and I would agree with you on that.
- 44:44I think it's something that I fall
- 44:46on a disparate side with a lot of people on the left on.
- 44:49I'm curious where you put the line.
- 44:51You know,
- 44:52I think that's,
- 44:52I think it's complicated,
- 44:53um,
- 44:54but I'm pretty,
- 44:55um,
- 44:56compelled by,
- 44:58uh,
- 44:58arguments related to the heartbeat,
- 44:59and I'll tell you this,
- 45:00I,
- 45:00so I,
- 45:01I,
- 45:01um,
- 45:02adopted my child.
- 45:03Um,
- 45:03I've been,
- 45:04uh,
- 45:05we had a couple of adoptions that went south,
- 45:07uh,
- 45:07where I went and sat with,
- 45:09uh,
- 45:10mothers that were trying to make this hard choice what to do,
- 45:12whether to have their child or whether to,
- 45:15uh,
- 45:16terminate the pregnancy,
- 45:17whether to parent the child,
- 45:18whether to give the child up for adoption.
- 45:20And so I get to sit there with them,
- 45:22um,
- 45:22uh,
- 45:22in the hospital room,
- 45:24uh,
- 45:24where you can,
- 45:25you know,
- 45:25look at the,
- 45:26uh,
- 45:27monitor,
- 45:27you can see the heartbeat,
- 45:28you can see the little fingers,
- 45:30and,
- 45:31and in those rooms like you can feel a grave moral weight like you can just feel it,
- 45:36like you can feel that the decision is a big decision.
- 45:38I,
- 45:39I think that,
- 45:39um.
- 45:40You know,
- 45:41when you get into now the nitty gritty of like how the government remediates that,
- 45:46like I think that there are different questions,
- 45:48the different and this is obviously a
- 45:50really important thing just given the numbers,
- 45:53right?
- 45:53And so I think someone said earlier,
- 45:55it's almost like a third of Gen Z is not here.
- 45:58Because of abortion.
- 45:59And so,
- 45:59whether,
- 46:00you know,
- 46:01where we put the line is actually a huge thing that we need to get right on because
- 46:06human rights,
- 46:07right,
- 46:08the,
- 46:08the right to life is at stake.
- 46:10And so I think this is something very important that we need to think about.
- 46:14So I really,
- 46:15I really appreciated you kind of digging into your own story.
- 46:19Um.
- 46:19And
- 46:20as I was
- 46:21listening to you,
- 46:22you know,
- 46:23I just,
- 46:23I was like,
- 46:24I don't know if I've heard
- 46:25someone who I kind of with the connotation of left or liberal
- 46:30speak this openly about the nuances of abortion.
- 46:33Have you,
- 46:33has your comfort level kind of talking about this issue evolved,
- 46:37um.
- 46:38Just as,
- 46:39as like political correctness has changed,
- 46:41yeah,
- 46:41I don't,
- 46:42I mean,
- 46:42I'm pretty comfortable talking about it.
- 46:43I don't,
- 46:44I,
- 46:44it's sort of like Israel Palestine where it's got,
- 46:46it's like the hardest issue to talk about because it's like
- 46:49everybody has such a strong view on it.
- 46:51Who cares about it,
- 46:52and they have a maximalist view on it.
- 46:54And in both cases,
- 46:56I,
- 46:56I,
- 46:57I'm pretty in the,
- 46:57I,
- 46:58I,
- 46:58I,
- 46:58I have a pretty nuanced take of on both cases.
- 47:01So I,
- 47:02you know,
- 47:02I was kind of,
- 47:03I was gonna pick JP and I was,
- 47:05I was kinda wondering what he was gonna ask me when
- 47:06he brought up the abortion question cause I was like,
- 47:09I want a second,
- 47:10I want a second pass at
- 47:12which guy,
- 47:12which person to pick here,
- 47:13um,
- 47:14because,
- 47:14uh,
- 47:14look,
- 47:15I'm happy to talk about it.
- 47:16I just,
- 47:16like,
- 47:17in a debate show setting,
- 47:18it's kind of a weird
- 47:19one for me to pick because it's like,
- 47:20I'm not.
- 47:21I'm not a maximalist on abortion.
- 47:24I,
- 47:24I think that there should be limits to when you can have,
- 47:27um,
- 47:27elective abortions.
- 47:29I think that
- 47:30I do believe that,
- 47:31um,
- 47:32and,
- 47:32and,
- 47:33you know,
- 47:33that it's uh that at some point,
- 47:36um,
- 47:36you're dealing with an unborn life.
- 47:38Um,
- 47:38and I do believe also that like the mother's life
- 47:41is,
- 47:41is,
- 47:41is a life that has to be respected as well,
- 47:44and that's why this is so hard,
- 47:45right?
- 47:45Because like you are dealing with two lives.
- 47:48You and,
- 47:48and I feel like on both sides,
- 47:50somebody
- 47:51wants to just pretend like one life doesn't matter,
- 47:54right?
- 47:54Like,
- 47:55and,
- 47:55and,
- 47:56and,
- 47:56and they're like,
- 47:57you know,
- 47:57the guy that I'm debating is like
- 47:59really only focused on the life
- 48:01of the baby
- 48:02in the womb,
- 48:03and,
- 48:03and anytime I tried to bring up later,
- 48:05you know,
- 48:06about other,
- 48:07about,
- 48:08about the questions of,
- 48:09you know,
- 48:09how to respect the life and the dignity of the
- 48:12person that is carrying the baby and that needs to and
- 48:15You know,
- 48:15that,
- 48:15that they have basic rights as a human as
- 48:18well that the government can't infringe upon and,
- 48:20and we should support them as a society if we're pro-life,
- 48:24you know,
- 48:24he didn't wanna
- 48:25kind of talk about that.
- 48:25He always kept coming back to the baby,
- 48:27and I,
- 48:27and I feel like if I,
- 48:27if I was debating somebody on
- 48:29like a pro-choice activist,
- 48:31you know,
- 48:31they would only want to talk about the mother and,
- 48:33and anytime you talk about the baby's life,
- 48:35kind of pretend like that's not true,
- 48:37like it's,
- 48:37it's a,
- 48:38it's a fetus,
- 48:38it's not really a life,
- 48:39it's not really something that has to be considered.
- 48:42And I just,
- 48:42I don't think that's true.
- 48:43And so
- 48:44it gets much more murky and complicated
- 48:47uh when,
- 48:48once you say like,
- 48:48OK,
- 48:49well,
- 48:49there are two lives you're dealing with,
- 48:51and now we have a government
- 48:53that has to
- 48:54create a rule or some structure,
- 48:56some laws
- 48:58that is respectful of both
- 49:00and um that doesn't infringe on either.
- 49:03And it's like very challenging.
- 49:04And so when he's like,
- 49:05where do you draw the line?
- 49:06It's like,
- 49:06well,
- 49:06I,
- 49:06we have to kind of decide that as a society is the answer.
- 49:09Like I'm not God,
- 49:10like I can't decide it.
- 49:11We have to
- 49:12decide as a society what is a reasonable period of time.
- 49:16A,
- 49:16a lot of societies deal with this,
- 49:17and,
- 49:17and up until recently,
- 49:18I guess Europe was much more strict strict than we were on this,
- 49:22um,
- 49:22despite being
- 49:23more left than us on a lot of other issues.
- 49:25Um,
- 49:26I,
- 49:26that's changing a lot in this country.
- 49:27I think there's some crazy right-wing laws around this,
- 49:30like,
- 49:30uh,
- 49:30like Texas has a 5-week abortion ban,
- 49:33and now you can have a bounty where you can
- 49:35sue the mom
- 49:36if they have an abortion after 5.
- 49:38Like,
- 49:38I think a lot,
- 49:39like,
- 49:39I think a lot of that stuff is insane and extreme.
- 49:42And so,
- 49:42you know,
- 49:43um,
- 49:43I,
- 49:43in,
- 49:44in some ways,
- 49:45um,
- 49:45I,
- 49:46we keep coming back to,
- 49:46I keep coming back to this like definition of me as a liberal because it's like.
- 49:50That is like kind of in my view,
- 49:52like the redefinition of what like liberal means in our society right now.
- 49:55It's like you can live in those
- 49:57um complications
- 49:59like we can debate them,
- 50:00we can try to work them out,
- 50:01we can,
- 50:01we have a,
- 50:02we have a law and a structure that does so,
- 50:04we can try to respect
- 50:05the basic fundamental rights of everybody involved,
- 50:08you know,
- 50:08I just think a lot of people in our debate don't wanna do that
- 50:11right now because they have such strident views
- 50:14on um.
- 50:16Uh,
- 50:16on the issue,
- 50:17um,
- 50:17and so it makes it to be,
- 50:19it makes it kind of
- 50:20makes it
- 50:21a tough one to debate.
- 50:26I was like I was a much stronger debating about Trump being,
- 50:26uh,
- 50:27you know,
- 50:27morally vacuous,
- 50:29uh,
- 50:29than I was,
- 50:30um,
- 50:30here,
- 50:30but I,
- 50:31you know,
- 50:31what,
- 50:31I'm happy to work it out with people,
- 50:32and in some ways I've been kind of surprised some of them,
- 50:35and,
- 50:35and who knows,
- 50:36maybe it gives me more credibility with some people
- 50:38on the right to hear from somebody that like is
- 50:40at least grappling with it rather than,
- 50:42rather than just shouting past them,
- 50:44yeah.
- 50:45No,
- 50:45I think,
- 50:46um,
- 50:47what,
- 50:47what's interesting about kind of the issues we dug into,
- 50:49you know,
- 50:49like the border,
- 50:51guns,
- 50:51abortion,
- 50:53um,
- 50:53there really is,
- 50:55I,
- 50:55I mean,
- 50:55I feel like there really is an opportunity for
- 50:58future voices to,
- 50:59who wanna capture kind of the middle and who wanna capture or re-inspire the left
- 51:04to have more nuanced views on these issues because,
- 51:08uh,
- 51:08you know,
- 51:08you made the case and throughout the episode and I think it just become
- 51:14It became clear that a lot of people are really craving more of a nuanced view on,
- 51:18on these issues.
- 51:20The maximalist approach appeals to some,
- 51:22but it doesn't appeal to,
- 51:24I think the majority.
- 51:26But there's a lot of argument around that and that's that's
- 51:33maybe we're lonely in the middle and that's OK too.
- 51:35I don't know.
- 51:35All I can do is say what I think.
- 51:37Yeah,
- 51:38do you have,
- 51:38um,
- 51:39I just have to ask,
- 51:40is there anybody,
- 51:41uh,
- 51:41if you had to throw a hat in the ring,
- 51:43uh,
- 51:44for kind of like the future voice of,
- 51:45of the Democrats,
- 51:46is,
- 51:46is there somebody who you favor particularly right now?
- 51:50You know,
- 51:51I don't,
- 51:51and here's,
- 51:52and,
- 51:52and I,
- 51:53and I,
- 51:54here's what I want.
- 51:55And to the extent that I have any influence over where the left goes,
- 51:57this is what I'm gonna say a lot over the next two years.
- 52:01Which is,
- 52:01I want there to be a bunch of Democrats to try a different,
- 52:04a lot of different things.
- 52:06I think that this goes to our feet.
- 52:07I think we've become so rigid,
- 52:08and I,
- 52:09and I,
- 52:09you know,
- 52:10I
- 52:11I have a specific view.
- 52:12Like,
- 52:12look,
- 52:12I'm a former Republican.
- 52:13Like I'm gonna be,
- 52:15have,
- 52:15be,
- 52:15have more sympathy to capitalism than a lot of people on the left are,
- 52:18right?
- 52:18Like I'm obviously usually just saw gonna be more moderate
- 52:20on abortion than a lot on the left are.
- 52:22I'm open to
- 52:24Uh,
- 52:25no,
- 52:25no candidate's ever gonna agree with me.
- 52:26Uh,
- 52:27somebody that ran on my platform would get killed.
- 52:29So I'm not looking for somebody to be exactly like me.
- 52:31What I want is for people on the left to try new things,
- 52:35to,
- 52:35uh,
- 52:36have interesting ideas,
- 52:37to be heterodox,
- 52:39to not just like sing from the same hymn book that we've seen,
- 52:42which is just like either
- 52:44just down the line Bernie progressivism.
- 52:47Or this kind of tepid
- 52:49like center left establishment woke liberalism.
- 52:52I,
- 52:52I just,
- 52:52I,
- 52:52I don't,
- 52:53I,
- 52:53I,
- 52:53I,
- 52:54I want,
- 52:54I think that it's,
- 52:55I think that the country is desperate for
- 52:57somebody who offers kind of a different fresh
- 53:01path.
- 53:01I think a lot of people are really
- 53:03beaten down by all this that we've had for the last decade and
- 53:07if you look at Obama in 8 and Trump in 16,
- 53:10like both of them.
- 53:12Like we're very different
- 53:14from what came before.
- 53:15Like Obama attacks hard left on the wars,
- 53:18and,
- 53:19but then also,
- 53:20you know,
- 53:21is kind of a,
- 53:23you know,
- 53:23does this,
- 53:23there are no red states,
- 53:24there are no blue states,
- 53:25like I'm moderate in tone and temperament,
- 53:27but I'm really,
- 53:28you know,
- 53:29against the,
- 53:29the wars and I'm for reforms,
- 53:32and
- 53:32he didn't sound very much like John Kerry or Al Gore.
- 53:35Like he was a,
- 53:37you know,
- 53:37uh,
- 53:37he was within the same band of views,
- 53:40but like.
- 53:41He took some very different approaches
- 53:43and then Trump obviously just like shits on the old Republican establishment.
- 53:47So it's like I'm,
- 53:48he also goes left on the wars
- 53:49and he goes left on spending on,
- 53:52on Social Security and Medicare,
- 53:53and then he goes hard right on immigration and crime,
- 53:55right?
- 53:56And I want Democrats to try that and like right now what I'm seeing out there,
- 53:59which is why I'm,
- 54:00I'm reluctant to give a name,
- 54:01is a lot of Democrats who are like either
- 54:04carrying the banner for
- 54:06Clinton Biden Harrisism or carrying the banner for Bernieism.
- 54:10And both of,
- 54:11both of those things are fine.
- 54:13They both have their benefits and they're,
- 54:15they're,
- 54:15um,
- 54:16you know,
- 54:16things
- 54:17that are holding them back.
- 54:18But I'd like to,
- 54:19I'd like to encourage people to try different
- 54:21things and see if something catches and,
- 54:23and connects with people
- 54:25in a different way.
- 54:26So that's where I'm at.
- 54:27Nice.
- 54:27Well,
- 54:28Tim,
- 54:28it was
- 54:28fantastic meeting you and
- 54:31on behalf of Jubilee,
- 54:32thanks for jumping into the arena.
- 54:33Thanks for your time and have a great holiday.
- 54:35Cool,
- 54:35man.
- 54:36Happy to do it.
- 54:36Invite me back.
- 54:37I had so much fun.
- 54:38I,
- 54:38I got out of there and I said to everybody,
- 54:39I wanna do it again.
- 54:40I'm gonna do it again like tomorrow.
- 54:42I had a blast doing it,
- 54:43so anytime.
- 54:44Cool.
- 54:45Well,
- 54:45I definitely wanna see you on the channel again soon,
- 54:47um,
- 54:47so we'll make it happen.
- 54:49All right,
- 54:49later,
- 54:49man.
- 54:50See you.
- 54:51If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 54:53be sure to like,
- 54:54leave us a positive review,
- 54:56comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 54:58Uh,
- 54:58you can subscribe to Tubbili,
- 55:00Jubilee's second channel.
- 55:01You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 55:04surrounded episodes.
- 55:06But however you want to support us,
- 55:07just thank you so much for listening.
- 55:09Remember,
- 55:10you could be wrong,
- 55:11so could I.
- 55:12Keep your mind open
- 55:13until next time.