Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 4 – Can’t Take YES For An Answer
Transcript
- 0:00Jed: Hey Andy.
- 0:01Andy: Hey, Jed.
- 0:02How are you?
- 0:02Jed: I'm doing terrific.
- 0:03Great to see you again.
- 0:04Andy: It's great to see you.
- 0:05How's it been the last few weeks?
- 0:07Jed: Busy, but good.
- 0:09And I have to say, my optimism is actually increasing, I think there's
- 0:13a lot of good stuff going on in ed reform, which I hope we can touch
- 0:16upon some of those things today.
- 0:18Andy: Yeah.
- 0:18I think today we might touch on, there's good and bad, but yeah.
- 0:22It's a busy time, there is a lot of stuff going on, particularly some
- 0:24of the work you do is real close to the ground, some of the work we
- 0:26do is real close to the ground, and that's what gives you the energy.
- 0:31Jed: Yeah.
- 0:33It's getting close to the operators, getting close to the advocates I think,
- 0:36at least on the charter side, the closer that you get right now, you actually see
- 0:39there's a lot more progress happening than perhaps the general public is aware of.
- 0:43Andy: Yeah, totally.
- 0:44And also just like anytime you can get in and around schools and
- 0:47kids, it just gives you energy.
- 0:48That was always my strategy on bad days, just try to find a place you can go read
- 0:53to kids or just hang out at the school.
- 0:54And it kinda makes you feel a little bit better about things.
- 0:57So hey, we've managed to get through I think three episodes of this
- 1:01podcast not ever saying the name, so we should: this is the Wonky Folk
- 1:04Podcast, and I'm Andy Rotherham.
- 1:07Jed: And I'm Jed Wallace.
- 1:10Andy: Thanks for listening.
- 1:12Jed, on our last one, I think we talked about how the Economist has
- 1:16just been like hitting the cover off the ball on education coverage.
- 1:22Just great stuff.
- 1:23And I have not read the most recent issue, but you said there's an
- 1:26article in there that caught your eye.
- 1:28Jed: Yeah, I think The Economist is really interesting for a lot of reasons.
- 1:31I just love the kind of outsider perspective, although, the Economist
- 1:36has gotten so sucked into the American mainstream that they sometimes
- 1:41lose that European orientation on our work, but still, I just
- 1:47find them a very great pressure tester of some assumptions I have.
- 1:51And the last article that they issued around education was around math reform
- 1:57and in San Francisco, and they were really talking about how the quest for
- 2:03equity by getting rid of AP classes and accelerated classes and having everyone
- 2:07come together in the same class is actually not doing anybody any favors.
- 2:13It's not helping the accelerated students, it's not helping those that are far
- 2:17behind, but also just from an equity standpoint, they don't really see that
- 2:21those models of schooling are resulting in kids ending up staying together anyway.
- 2:28So it throws into question the whole math change that we've
- 2:33seen in a lot of different places in the last five or six years.
- 2:36And it also reminds me a lot of my High Tech High days because we had this
- 2:40notion of common intellectual mission.
- 2:42We didn't want to ability track, we didn't want to separate kids
- 2:46into different groups of learners.
- 2:48And so we ended up keeping all kids together and I think in some ways
- 2:53High Tech High really changed the national discussion, or at least
- 2:57influenced the national discussion on common intellectual mission.
- 3:00But the thing that I think was lost in all of that was that while High Tech
- 3:05High kept all the kids together in the same classes, they really specialized in
- 3:10teaching to the individual student and allowing the most accelerated student to
- 3:14get even more accelerated and to obviously remediate for those that needed it.
- 3:19And I just think this is another example of, "is it one thing?, is it equity?
- 3:24Or is it excellence?".
- 3:25You have these binary options that are presented to us and when we
- 3:29choose one or the other, we lose the common sense middle that I think we
- 3:34just have to keep front and center for Ed reformers whenever we can.
- 3:37Andy: Yeah, that makes sense.
- 3:38And I think teachers also don't get a lot of support in training
- 3:41and sort of, we talk a lot about differentiated instruction, things
- 3:44like that, they don't actually get training and even having a theory of
- 3:47action around like what level are you going to pitch to in the classroom?
- 3:51How are you going to help struggling kids catch up?
- 3:53This is stuff that teachers generally have to get on the job, you're not getting
- 3:57it in a lot of teacher prep programs.
- 3:59And so your article though reminds me of Ruy Teixeira, he's a
- 4:04democratic, political demographer.
- 4:07He wrote that book the Emerging Democratic Majority a while ago and more recently
- 4:13has been sort of pushing the Democratic party on sort of culture issues and
- 4:16so forth, and he had a piece about this issue in terms of merit and how
- 4:21Democrats are increasingly not perceived as the party of merit, and the political
- 4:26consequences that can flow from that.
- 4:28And I think it that article resonated with me because one of the really interesting
- 4:31things you saw in 2021, in the Glenn Youngkin election, was how many immigrant
- 4:37parents and so forth were very frustrated with efforts to either restrict access to
- 4:42advanced classes, stuff around selective high school, sort of all of this.
- 4:47And to your point a second ago about reformers: I think the same thing's true.
- 4:51Like, often the Democrats get caught up in this "are we for
- 4:54equity, are we for excellence?"
- 4:56And they become kind of all thumbs in ways that really alienate parents.
- 4:59And what the point of Ruy's article, -- and I'Il put in the show notes -- was,
- 5:04across all kinds of lines of difference, this idea of merit and excellence and
- 5:09so forth is actually really popular and that there's an opportunity then to
- 5:13use that as a way to advance education reform, make sure kids are getting
- 5:17what they need to succeed and so forth.
- 5:19But if you are seen as being against that, or if you actually are against that
- 5:23with some of these policies, there's a price you're going to pay with parents.
- 5:27Jed: Yeah.
- 5:27I was regretting that our last recording, I forgot the name of Daniel Markovits,
- 5:35who wrote this book, the Meritocracy Trap, and I think it's really an interesting
- 5:39book, not one that I would say I agree with all of its findings, because it
- 5:43basically lurches very far into the anti meritocracy, far left -- almost
- 5:49San Francisco orientation toward things.
- 5:51But the thing I think he does show that's very compelling is that the upper middle
- 5:56class and the wealthy have figured out how important education is and they do
- 6:02an incredibly great job of educating just their own kids and changing the
- 6:06entire public education system such that those that are focused on meritocracy
- 6:11get the great education that they need.
- 6:13And so, it's just something that we have to keep front and center and keep pushing
- 6:18because I think there are ways for us to push for all kids accessing more rigorous
- 6:24instruction without compromising on equity and some of the other things that
- 6:31are front and center for us these days.
- 6:33But San Francisco just provides another just shiny example
- 6:37of things just gone too far.
- 6:40And we'll see what happens to San Francisco itself.
- 6:43But for the rest of the country, I think, as the Economist presents for
- 6:46us, there's a lot for us to learn here.
- 6:48Andy: Yeah, I'm looking forward to reading that.
- 6:49And look, we saw this in the election with the school board, right?
- 6:52Like parents, even in San Francisco, parents have their breaking points, and
- 6:56that should have been sort of a wake up call that you need to be careful about how
- 7:00you approach these issues, and you need to remember where people are and not get
- 7:06caught up too much in sort of politics that are really out of the mainstream.
- 7:10The San Francisco experience I thought was just remarkable, in what happened there,
- 7:16and also remarkable and those lessons seem to have still bounced off a lot of places.
- 7:21Jed: Oh yeah, absolutely.
- 7:23Well, I'll look forward to returning to this issue because I do think
- 7:28that meritocracy and militancy from teachers unions together provide,
- 7:34you know, when the upper middle class liking their separate education co
- 7:39partner with the teacher union to keep a status quo in place, it's
- 7:44very formidable, a political power.
- 7:47And for me, the only way I can see us going forward is not to defeat it
- 7:50outright, but to basically have something that is there for the meritocracy folk
- 7:55and for the militancy folk, right?
- 7:56We show them that ed reform is not actually a zero sum game, but it's
- 8:01something that all boats can rise.
- 8:03But it's also incumbent upon us Ed reformers just to be presenting
- 8:06our work in different terms.
- 8:07Andy: Definitely.
- 8:07And there was a time not that long ago where Ed Reform was and was seen as
- 8:12very disruptive around these issues.
- 8:16Ed reformers have sort of allowed themselves to be painted into a corner in
- 8:20terms of what they're about and so forth.
- 8:22And there's probably some pretty serious conversations to be had
- 8:25about getting back to that Ed reform.
- 8:28Back in, in the early aughts for example, was highly disruptive
- 8:32around accountability policies and so forth focused on the kids who were
- 8:37most underserved and sort of really disruptive politics around that and
- 8:41we've kind of gotten away from that.
- 8:42Jed: Yeah, I thought on the second article I was thinking about bringing you up
- 8:46today, was this the Kane editorial Op-Ed in the New York Times where he was really
- 8:52talking about the parents not being aware of just how far their kids are behind,
- 8:58and Paul Vallas, his first public gesture after losing the race in Chicago really
- 9:04comes out and advocates for accountability systems and transparency systems so that
- 9:09parents actually have the information.
- 9:13The question I have for you Andy is how much do you think the question is, do
- 9:21parents know how far behind their kids are, or have we gotten to the point where
- 9:26maybe parents actually know but they're being trained not even to care anymore?
- 9:32Do you have any view on that?
- 9:33Because, it's sobering when you start thinking that maybe they
- 9:37don't care as much as they used to.
- 9:38Andy: Well, my first view is, you just referred as the Kane Paper,
- 9:41I like that this is Tom Kane.
- 9:44He's an economist at Harvard.
- 9:45I like that he's reached sort of Madonna or Prince like, that's one name Kane.
- 9:53So yeah, Tom Kane, he is a terrific, wonderful person
- 9:57and just a terrific analyst.
- 10:00Jed: Great researcher.
- 10:01Andy: Yeah, absolutely.
- 10:03I thought that Op-Ed was sobering.
- 10:05I was glad the times ran it, we need to get more attention on this, we
- 10:08still really are having arguments about how much this stuff matters
- 10:12and learning loss and all of that.
- 10:15That's a real reality on the ground, so people need to keep beating that drum.
- 10:19I go back and forth on this.
- 10:21I tend to be in the camp that, to the extent parents don't
- 10:24care, it's cause they're unaware.
- 10:26Most people want good things for their kids and so forth.
- 10:30And then there's obviously some cognitive dissonance.
- 10:32You don't want to think about your own kid being really far behind.
- 10:36I know as a parent, like I think about things, I'm like, "oh man,
- 10:38it's like hard to get my head around like mistakes you made" and so forth.
- 10:42That's real.
- 10:42But I think mostly parents want what's best, they are struggling to get
- 10:47good information on what's going on.
- 10:50There's not a lot of states...
- 10:52are not, we're still fighting, in your state, California, it's still
- 10:55throwing circles around when test results are going to come out and
- 10:58how they're going to be reported.
- 11:00New Jersey sat on results for a long time and there was no sort of outcry that,
- 11:06like why would particularly like, it's a state led by a Democratic governor.
- 11:11The party that reports to be for the little guy, why would
- 11:14they be sitting on this data?
- 11:15And one of the reasons cynically, I think, is it showed the charter schools
- 11:19had really done a particularly good job on average, around some of this.
- 11:24But what, for whatever reason, why is this data not getting out there?
- 11:28And so parents are kind of left confused, and meanwhile they're just
- 11:30trying to live their lives, right?
- 11:32They're not the wonks that are like, "Hey, when's the data is going to be released?
- 11:35What's going on?"
- 11:35But parents, they're not sort of on the edge of their seat about that.
- 11:39Life goes on, they're living their life.
- 11:41And so I think a lot of it is, we just have not communicated very clearly.
- 11:45This is a really serious situation, not for every kid, but for a lot of kids, you
- 11:50need to figure out what's going on and here are resources and tools, and then
- 11:56here are resources and tools for remedies.
- 11:58And I think some states have done a good job with this, but I think just overall,
- 12:03We have not had that kind of attention.
- 12:05And to the extent, like the public debate, you look at the last couple
- 12:08of weeks it's been this like, whatever version this is of the sort of Randi
- 12:13Weingarden School closure debate has been what's consumed everybody's attention.
- 12:18And they dragged her up to the hill for that hearing.
- 12:23There wasn't a whole lot of talk about like, "what do we do now?
- 12:25What does this mean?"
- 12:26It was just like, "let's fight about 2020 again?"
- 12:30And I think we need to figure out how do we sort of bring people together.
- 12:35We should give a shout out to learning heroes who are, you know,
- 12:38they're out there doing, trying to do public awareness work on this.
- 12:41They're doing actually advertising campaigns, billboards, and so forth.
- 12:45There's people trying stuff, but it's just not from our political
- 12:48leadership, we're just not getting the kind of concerted effort that we need.
- 12:53And I can tell you like just in Virginia, one state, every time we bring this
- 12:56up, every time the governor brings it up, and the state board does anything,
- 13:00you get a bunch of pushback about.
- 13:01"t's a manufactured crisis," and so forth.
- 13:03And we have the biggest NAEP drops of any state, that's not Virginia data, that's
- 13:09national data, our own data confirms that.
- 13:13But it turns into this political fight rather than "okay, like what now?"
- 13:17kind of conversation.
- 13:18So anyway, that's my read.
- 13:20I know, I think you think a little...
- 13:21you're starting to worry a little bit more and have some sleepless nights
- 13:24that maybe people actually don't care.
- 13:27Jed: I'm saying that a subset of people, the meritocracy folks, they'd
- 13:33care and they know exactly where their kids are and they're in contact with
- 13:38their private schools and maybe, upper middle class public schools that are
- 13:45segregated out from other kids and they know, and they really care, because
- 13:49they know that the wellbeing of their children depends on they are strong
- 13:53in these foundational skill levels.
- 13:56But I think across a growing percentage of the public education establishment,
- 14:03I think there's more and more indifference or, perhaps they've been
- 14:08convinced that these indicators aren't as important as social-emotional
- 14:13health or whatever it may be.
- 14:15And I'm not downplaying how important social-emotional health is.
- 14:19But when you look at the dashboard in California of the garbley gook of whatever
- 14:25it is, 16 indicators multiplied times 6.
- 14:29It's incoherent, no one can know.
- 14:31And in Chicago, they just adopted another one of these multiple measured pieces of
- 14:35garbley gook that mean absolutely nothing.
- 14:38And it could be that they're doing it in the face of parrots
- 14:42that are saying, "oh, no, no, no.
- 14:44You're denying me the access to what I really want to know", but I, we don't
- 14:48see that really emerging anywhere.
- 14:50And so, I feel like we may have to go through this cycle of people seeing
- 14:55the skill levels of their kids get dropped so significantly that we'll
- 14:59start to see the rebound at that point.
- 15:02But at this point, I can't say I see early indications of that rebound.
- 15:07Yeah,
- 15:07Andy: the one thing to bear in mind, I guess on this is the public school
- 15:12establishment, I mean, they approach all this stuff as a public relations problem.
- 15:17I remember a superintendent once who, there was a sort of real big
- 15:22reveal in the local paper that they'd basically been lying about
- 15:25their graduation rates and so forth.
- 15:27The superintendent was like, "we have to obviously get on top of this
- 15:31and we're going to make sure there's never a news story like this again."
- 15:35Right?
- 15:37These people are public relationists sort of at heart often, and I get
- 15:43it, because they're like, we have to preserve this institution, we have to
- 15:46keep support for public schools, so you have to tell a good story and so forth.
- 15:49And I've always been much more in the sort of just be a realist about achievement
- 15:53and you can bring people along and you can show them leadership and there's
- 15:56a theory of action there, but, so a lot of this is approached as a public
- 16:01relations exercise and you sort of see that, it's how do we tell the story?
- 16:07How do we point to the good stuff?
- 16:08We don't want people to be demoralized and this kind of thing.
- 16:10And so like that you see that reflected in a lot of the communications.
- 16:14And so it's also, I think it's understandable that parents would
- 16:18not realize the extent of some of the extent of some of these challenges.
- 16:23And it's also, it's a hard problem to think about.
- 16:26There's some stuff coming out of Macke Raymond's been vocal on this.
- 16:30She's out at Stanford has been real vocal on the pace of catch up is not sufficient.
- 16:39So there's also people are worried cause it's not as there is not like an easy
- 16:43vaccine here or something like that.
- 16:45Jed: Yeah I, well look, this is where my cynicism comes out and I just feel like
- 16:51there are broad comparison points that can sometimes start to change public
- 16:56opinion when we have some big foreign threat, that relates to education.
- 17:02"Oh, we're following behind the Russians, we're following behind, the
- 17:06Chinese, Japanese," whatever it may be.
- 17:08Oh, okay.
- 17:09We have to get our acts together.
- 17:10I don't really think that we have some international comparison point
- 17:15that's going to change the discussion.
- 17:16I think the one that actually is going to change the discussion is when the
- 17:20affluent and the elite kids, when their separation gets to be so pronounced from
- 17:26what we're seeing in the rest of society, it's going to be a sobering moment.
- 17:30But we've have to figure out a way, how do we make that emerging divergence
- 17:35in skill levels of children and young adults even more apparent to people.
- 17:39Andy: Yeah.
- 17:39I don't know if I agree, though.
- 17:41That gap has been there.
- 17:43I think this is part of the problem, right?
- 17:44When you talk to the meritocracy as you described, when you talk to
- 17:49people who they think the kids where the schools aren't doing well, they
- 17:54think they're like a little bit behind, it's probably not as good.
- 17:57People don't realize you're talking about high school students reading at
- 18:01like low elementary school levels and doing math at that level and so forth.
- 18:05And I think that gap is like already there.
- 18:08It's because we're already a fairly just segregated society in terms of where
- 18:13people socialize, recreate, mix, all of that, people just aren't generally
- 18:19aware of the extent of these gaps now.
- 18:23Jed: Yeah.
- 18:23But I think the general, I mean, whatever, there's so much variety in public opinion,
- 18:27whatever, but I think there's a vast swath that assumes that all kids, rich and
- 18:32poor, have suffered through this somewhat equally and we've seen a drop across them
- 18:37all, and I don't think that's the case.
- 18:39Andy: Right.
- 18:40Yeah, I don't think that the Kane data and some other stuff...
- 18:43and actually we can talk about the, Nate, you saw this on all the NAEP day that
- 18:47keeps coming out --and it's now showing up on the history and civics data that
- 18:50just came out earlier this month-- it's the kids for who are already furthest
- 18:54from opportunity are hardest hit.
- 18:56And I think you're right.
- 18:57People aren't getting their head around that.
- 18:59Jed: Yeah.
- 18:59Let's pivot to this NAEP civic stuff.
- 19:02You had talked to me earlier this week about your concerns on this.
- 19:06Get me started.
- 19:07Where are you thinking on this?
- 19:08What's your thinking on this?
- 19:10Andy: Well, it turns out we don't know a lot about history and civics.
- 19:14What's interesting, it's a longstanding thing.
- 19:17I found the reaction to it actually more interesting than the results.
- 19:20The results on these tests haven't been good for a long time, and it
- 19:23would've been kind of surprising.
- 19:25The story would've been if they coming out of covid, if like they somehow were really
- 19:28good, that would've been interesting.
- 19:30It was more the reaction and almost like the unseriousness of it.
- 19:35Like immediately, you know, Miguel Cardona, the Secretary of Education,
- 19:41put out a statement where he just lumped in all this culture war stuff and you
- 19:45were like, and then yeah, you had all these people who were tying themselves
- 19:49in knots that he wasn't making causal claims but it's like, well then...
- 19:52I think he missed a real opportunity for leadership.
- 19:56But then like two days later, three days later, whatever, like Betsy
- 19:59DeVos comes out with a statement and she's blaming a set of other things.
- 20:04And the weird thing, these really low and unacceptable results on history and civics
- 20:11predate both of their tenures, right?
- 20:15Nobody has to, from the Trump administration or the Biden
- 20:18administration has to own these things.
- 20:20They're a much more longstanding problem.
- 20:22And so it was just kind of interesting.
- 20:24We have this situation where I think it's fair to say a lot of kids who are
- 20:28graduating from high school couldn't pass the test we require of new citizens.
- 20:32They don't know some basic knowledge.
- 20:34And there was just sort of an unserious response when we know right in front
- 20:40of us some real causes for this.
- 20:42We don't teach this stuff, we don't spend enough time on it
- 20:44and we don't teach the content.
- 20:46And we're still sort of failing to talk about that.
- 20:50Jed: I'm a big fan of Jonathan Haidt the guy that wrote, has written several
- 20:55books, but his book, The Righteous Mind from 2015, where he really talks about the
- 21:01metaphor of the elephant and the rider.
- 21:03The elephant is your intuition, the rider is your intellectual ability,
- 21:07and everybody wants to say that they are governed by their rider.
- 21:12They are making their decisions based upon all the new data that's coming in.
- 21:16But really when you unpack it, we're all guided by our intuition.
- 21:21And so we're all guided by our elephants and whenever NAEP comes
- 21:26out, all I see at that moment is all the elephants come together into
- 21:30just a pack of pachyderms, right?
- 21:32And they just run in their direction and say whatever the heck they want,
- 21:35that aligns with their intuition or with their political agenda.
- 21:39And I think it's important that we have NAEP.
- 21:42Absolutely.
- 21:43For Pete's sake, we have to have NAEP.
- 21:46But the fact that we can draw no causal connection to anything, within NAEP
- 21:52just speaks to, it's not sufficient.
- 21:55We have to have more data so that we can start to make causal connections.
- 21:59Otherwise all of our pontificating on these ed reform issues or whatever is just
- 22:06going to end up in cacophony for forever.
- 22:10Andy: Well, NAEP's a treasure trove of data.
- 22:12You get all this data, they survey students, you get all this data on
- 22:15what kids are up to and all this.
- 22:18I think it's more like so many things, like the winners always sort
- 22:22of mono causality and it tends to be that cause tends to like curiously
- 22:27completely align with whatever anyone's priors are on anything.
- 22:31NAEP isn't causal and we should be careful, when you look at it in total
- 22:38and contextually you can start like if you look at the way we teach history in
- 22:43civics and then you look at the results, like I think a reasonable person can
- 22:47crosswalk and make some inferences there for perhaps why we're seeing
- 22:51those results, and it's not the kids.
- 22:54The debate becomes highly political.
- 22:58Tom Loveless, who is a longtime analyst of NAEP, you know Tom, he thinks that with
- 23:04the way we're doing the releases now, that this is like the way it's going to be,
- 23:08I sort of hope he is wrong about that.
- 23:09Some folks have sort of pushed back and been like, no, we're
- 23:12going to handle this and make it.
- 23:14But like Tom's kind of thinking that this sort of politicalization of every
- 23:19release is sort of going to be the new normal, which would be unfortunate.
- 23:25Jed: One thing about the civics component to NAEP is that I tend to encourage
- 23:30us to focus most of our testing...
- 23:33for me, like I've written that piece around the eight words that
- 23:38define a high quality school.
- 23:40And those are schools that positively affect the rate at which children learn.
- 23:45Positively affect the rate.
- 23:47And when it comes down to that, usually I want to think about
- 23:51basic literacy and basic numeracy.
- 23:54Are you accelerating growth in those two areas?
- 23:58And then what happens is when you start testing all the different curricular
- 24:03areas, now the testing regime gets to be so big, we create the option for the other
- 24:10side to start attacking over- testing.
- 24:13On the other hand, if you only test in basic literacy and numeracy then
- 24:17you're open to the accusation that, "oh, you're narrowing the curriculum
- 24:21to only care about those things".
- 24:23Do you have any idea about what's a good balance here for us to be focusing on?
- 24:28Andy: I think this was something the civics and and history results put
- 24:32up, particularly the history results.
- 24:33You have to ask when people are like we're teaching reading and we can't teach
- 24:38history or social studies, you have to ask them, what are these kids reading?
- 24:44And the answer is, honestly, often really low level garbage.
- 24:48Good schools can combine these and we know that like you need a knowledge
- 24:54rich curriculum that the knowledge is a predicate for learning, it's
- 24:57predicate for literacy and reading.
- 24:59And so I think good schools sort of tie this together and don't get
- 25:02caught up in this false choice.
- 25:03The problem is we just don't have as many of them.
- 25:05And I think we talked an episode or two ago about, like this new study on
- 25:11Core Knowledge schools was a lottery study of charters, in the Denver
- 25:17area using core knowledge, and not surprisingly much better results.
- 25:23Jed: Yeah.
- 25:23Well, my sense is that, I've been trying to keep track of how
- 25:29many school visits I've made.
- 25:30I'm definitely north of 850 and I'm thinking, well, the next
- 25:345 to 10 years, but what I make sure I get to a thousand, right?
- 25:38But the reason I made these visits is what you pointed out at the beginning of
- 25:43the episode, which is just, the closer that you get, the more you realize you
- 25:48remember the work and you can just come out with a little spring in your step.
- 25:51But that also, it gives, it gave me a chance to observe a lot of things in
- 25:56charter schools and other schools as well.
- 25:59And there certainly were during the NCLB days a subset, a fairly
- 26:04small subset of charters that really pressure cooked focused on the reading
- 26:09and math that would bump up, their API scores, at least in California.
- 26:14But generally that's not what happened.
- 26:17Generally, the charter schools were standing on their heads and using every
- 26:22everything that the kids were passionate about to increase the basic scores.
- 26:26But in the traditional public school system, in the school
- 26:29districts, that's where we absolutely saw the narrowing happen.
- 26:33And I also think that the teacher unions, they recognize that if they continue to
- 26:37push into that narrowing, they were going to get more allies from parents, so even
- 26:41though it was counterproductive for the kids learning in the short term, they
- 26:44chose that from a political standpoint.
- 26:46And I don't think we've gotten outta that cul-de-sac yet.
- 26:49Andy: We could do a whole episode on sort of the passive aggressive
- 26:52responses to policies that people don't like to effectively sabotage them.
- 26:58So like during No Child Left Behind you saw places where canceling field trips
- 27:02and stuff because of budget reasons.
- 27:03But everybody's just like, "oh, it's the testing", and that could
- 27:09be a whole episode that we could do.
- 27:10And we could call it like the passive aggressive episode.
- 27:12We could do like a whole thing.
- 27:13I think you are right about that.
- 27:15I also think it's just, it is a lack of capacity and I think one of the mistakes
- 27:19that was made with no Child Left Behind it, I was certainly guilty of this, was
- 27:22this assumption that if we started to put in place the accountability, it would
- 27:26create the context and conditions where states would invest, you'd build capacity.
- 27:32And instead you did get a little bit of the beatings will
- 27:36continue to morale improves.
- 27:38And so schools were doing unproductive things cuz they
- 27:42just didn't know any better.
- 27:43They didn't have better strategies.
- 27:45And that's a place where I think we do have to think about how
- 27:48do you build that capacity.
- 27:49And that's where some of this more systemic reformers who were the broader
- 27:56standards based reform, they always talked about this, and I think some,
- 27:59it was easy to be dismissive of that.
- 28:02Again, I think that was the thing I was guilty of.
- 28:04And it turns out like, they had a really good point that schools were going
- 28:08to react in counterproductive ways.
- 28:10We've certainly seen that.
- 28:12Jed: Yeah.
- 28:12They learned one of the best strategies against all boats
- 28:15rise is sabotage your own ship.
- 28:19And I think we've seen that played out on several fronts.
- 28:24But in terms of like, I don't know, sure if this is passive aggressivity,
- 28:27but it's certainly reactionary.
- 28:29Walk me through what's going on with DeSantis and some of his latest stuff
- 28:33because all this stuff seems like I do something because I've seen the other side
- 28:37do something that's even more ridiculous.
- 28:40Where are we?
- 28:41Andy: I don't even know that it's that.
- 28:43I mean, so education has sort of been dragged into this because it's an issue.
- 28:47I'm not actually sure, it's hard to tell with a guy like Ron
- 28:50DeSantis does, how strong his opinions about education even are.
- 28:54But he clearly gets, it's a convenient political cudgel so, higher ed
- 28:58and K12 are getting dragged in.
- 29:01I think it's more, he doesn't seem to have sort of any limiting principle.
- 29:06He just doesn't seem like a guy who will take yes for an answer.
- 29:10And so he's done some stuff that's actually more popular than
- 29:17people realize politically, but then he doesn't stop there and he
- 29:21just goes and takes it further.
- 29:23And you see it on sort of issue after issue.
- 29:25And it's kind of an unattractive way to practice politics.
- 29:28And the week we're recording this, they just passed a whole bunch of new laws,
- 29:34several of which are just clearly not going to pass Constitutional muster.
- 29:39Some of the stuff done it's already in court and DeSantis, he's a lawyer, he
- 29:43is clearly smart enough to know that.
- 29:45And so it's this sort of political theater with no limiting principle and I think
- 29:50it's aimed sometimes less at the Democrats and just how far can I push this stuff
- 29:55with, to make a name for myself within my own party, but it's causing chaos.
- 29:59It's causing you real wreckage in some cases, and it's just turning education
- 30:05into this complete sort of culture war foil for what seems like sort
- 30:10of electoral theater in large part.
- 30:14Jed: To what extent do you think that education's challenges long-term are a
- 30:19function of the fact that, from a public policy standpoint, it's just a canvas
- 30:24for people to make their statements and their statements always undermine
- 30:29consistency, coherence, long-term strengthening, whatever it may be.
- 30:34And that as long as we keep our public schools in a circumstance
- 30:37where they are the primary canvas for these kinds of political gestures.
- 30:42We're not long going to, we're not going to see the kind of improvement we want.
- 30:46Andy: Well, I think actually at the rate we're going with this stuff,
- 30:49you're going to see more and more people want to just pull out of the
- 30:52public schools, for different reasons.
- 30:55I think that's more the direction that goes.
- 30:58And it will become, because you're seeing like now...
- 31:01and on the pronoun thing is interesting where, I think...
- 31:06a lot of people like you don't want to do coercive things, and so telling
- 31:10people they have to say things that they don't believe and so forth,
- 31:12particularly kids in a public space is a First Amendment issue there.
- 31:16But it's different with employees of the school system.
- 31:19We, teachers engage in coerced speech all the time: it's why you
- 31:25can't teach that the earth is flat.
- 31:27You can't, like we have a curriculum.
- 31:30You can't teach both sides of the Holocaust.
- 31:34We have teachers do this, and now DeSantis is starting to push on this
- 31:37and no teachers have, we're going to say that agents of the state can and
- 31:40can't say certain things and so forth.
- 31:43If that's struck down it's theater, if that's upheld, it will unravel
- 31:48the public schools because the whole enterprise is predicated on this idea.
- 31:51And I think people have been a little dismissive, like," oh, that stuff
- 31:55will never happen" and so forth.
- 31:56But that's where we are, that's where they're pushing down there.
- 31:59So that's the first thing.
- 32:00And then I think the second, that's just interesting to me, Jed, with
- 32:03education, part of the thing that I think is going to run into some trouble
- 32:07in the courts, is they want to out...
- 32:11States have more control over schools than people realize.
- 32:13So they can say, "Hey, we're not going to have degrees in this".
- 32:16That's actually under your purview as a state.
- 32:22But they went much further than that and said, well, also you can't
- 32:25teach certain theories and so forth, and that's going to be contested.
- 32:30And I feel like you have to strike a balance.
- 32:33Academic freedom and inquiry is important in this, and the whole scientific process
- 32:37is different ideas getting tested and accepted and rejected and so forth.
- 32:41And we should be very cautious when we get to the point where we're
- 32:45like, we're not even gonna allow you to engage in certain theories.
- 32:49First of all, it's a little medieval, but it's also just counterproductive, right?
- 32:56It's interesting and we're seeing this where this plays out more substantively,
- 33:03K-12 is we're moving, I think, and this is a good thing to acquire
- 33:09you, teacher prep program science of reading in a way based on the evidence.
- 33:15But you don't want to get into a situation, if you're a professor at an
- 33:19ed school, you can't criticize science of reading, you can't say that you think
- 33:24there's merit, the whole language, there's a distinction between actually training
- 33:28and certifying teachers and sort of the academic freedom to continue to pursue
- 33:32different kinds of theories and so forth.
- 33:35So I think there's a lot happening here around these things and it does,
- 33:44I think, put pressure on some pretty important things, including like just
- 33:48the role of academia as inefficient and everything else as it can be, to have
- 33:52that role of being a place where you still have like real free exchange of ideas.
- 33:57So I think Florida is hopefully not sort of coming attractions on what
- 34:03this is going to look like, but if this style of politics works,
- 34:07politics is a monkey see monkey do business, so we'll see more of it.
- 34:11Jed: Yeah.
- 34:11I think we've just had generations of, there's really been no other option
- 34:16and the political wars on the public education canvas have not been as
- 34:21extreme, but you put the two things together, the wars are more extreme,
- 34:26that canvas is as in attractive as it's ever been and parents have options
- 34:31to just like, get out, forget it.
- 34:33This is just completely and utterly dysfunctional, puts the education
- 34:38establishment in a fundamentally different place, I think at risk and
- 34:44we'll see what happens between now and the end of the decade, but we
- 34:46can see a significant increase in the number of parents that choose to
- 34:51educate their kids in private settings.
- 34:53Andy: Yeah, and it'll be interesting because my theory on this right
- 34:56now is you've got like 10 to 15% of people on the left and 10 to 15% of
- 35:01people on the right who are going to struggle to be in public schools.
- 35:06They can't be in community with others because of just these
- 35:10strong beliefs that they have.
- 35:12And it will be ironic if instead of those people needing to go to private
- 35:16schools, so they can get the different things that they want, it ends up
- 35:20being this hollowing out of the middle cuz people are sick of the political
- 35:24theater and this kind of thing, would be sort of an ironic turn of events.
- 35:28Jed: So let's bounce it back.
- 35:29We've gone left, right.
- 35:31We started in the Bay area.
- 35:33We went to Florida.
- 35:34Now I don't want to bounce back to the Bay Area, into Oakland.
- 35:36Let's wrap it up there.
- 35:38Andy: This is your backyard Jed.
- 35:40Tell us, what's the matter with Oakland?
- 35:44Jed: Well, the thing is, I wrote about this at CharterFolk for so long that
- 35:47no one wants to hear me start on this.
- 35:50So let's, let me start with you.
- 35:52As a person observing from a distance, what do you make of the strike?
- 35:56What do you make of the resolution?
- 35:57What do you make of the idea that the teachers are advocating on not just
- 36:01their own issues, but on the common good.
- 36:04Any starting point analysis of that?
- 36:07Andy: Yeah, look, it told me Ron DeSantis does not have a monopoly
- 36:12on political theater, right?
- 36:14There was no the strike was clearly avoidable.
- 36:17They clearly wanted to strike.
- 36:19It was a membership engagement thing, to make a point.
- 36:21We're seeing more and more strikes like that.
- 36:24Everybody got what they wanted except the kids who lost untold learning and so
- 36:31forth, how their education's disrupted.
- 36:33Kids in Oakland, who can least afford it.
- 36:37And so the whole thing's unfortunate, I thought.
- 36:40And the common good bargaining, it's a fancy way of saying anything goes
- 36:47and it just expands the universe.
- 36:49It's completely preposterous and why people don't just be like,
- 36:55well that seems preposterous.
- 36:56We should be focusing...
- 36:57if you're going to bargain, you should be focusing on these core issues,
- 37:00not this expansive definition of it.
- 37:04And you saw this during the pandemic when the teachers in LA.
- 37:08At one point the union down there was like, we'll go back, one of
- 37:10our conditions for going back is a moratorium on charter schools, which
- 37:14I mean is obviously like you can be for or against a moratorium on charter
- 37:17schools, but as like a covid policy, that's obviously completely absurd.
- 37:22And you know that this sort of expansion, there aren't enough people just to be
- 37:25like, "Hey, this is ridiculous", and we're so sort of hardened as a partisan matter
- 37:31that when you say this is ridiculous, people are like, "oh, then you must be
- 37:34like a union buster Republican", when in fact like the median position is, this
- 37:39is kind of ridiculous, but too few people are willing to sort of get out there
- 37:43and the kids are taking on the chin.
- 37:45So that's my, that's my read that the whole thing was theater and avoidable.
- 37:50And I was stunned that like folks like Lakeisha Young and so forth, who
- 37:54were out there arguing against this, trying to get kids back to school,
- 37:57that there was not more national attention on them and their efforts.
- 38:01Jed: Yeah, I thought Lakeisha did an awesome job.
- 38:03And when the Los Angeles Unified Strike was recently resolved, I tried
- 38:09to show how there was virtually no difference substantively between
- 38:13where the parties were before the strike and where they were after.
- 38:17So what was this thing all about?
- 38:18Same thing in Oakland.
- 38:20From a substantive standpoint, there's no difference, and the union
- 38:26was on these common good things.
- 38:28They were negotiating over procedural things, make a committee and it
- 38:31has representatives of the teacher union and certain numbers, and but
- 38:36there's no substance there, right?
- 38:39They have majority control of the board of the whole USD to begin with, right?
- 38:44They're not even getting any substantive progress on there it matters.
- 38:48So I just think these things, they again shake the confidence of parents
- 38:55and the general public that our public schools are on the right track, or
- 39:01are anything other than completely and utterly broken and something that
- 39:04you wanna avoid if at all possible.
- 39:07And they're just folks, whether it's DeSantis, maybe he hears that
- 39:13--he just keeps doing his stuff with impunity-- the teachers union in
- 39:17Oakland and in Chicago and in Los Angeles, they may hear that, but they
- 39:20keep doing their stuff with impunity.
- 39:22And it just it reminds me of Warren Buffett talking about bankruptcies, right?
- 39:27Bankruptcies happen very, very, very slowly and then all at once.
- 39:33Andy: I thought that was Hemingway.
- 39:34Jed: Yeah.
- 39:35Oh really?
- 39:36It may.
- 39:36Well, I don't know.
- 39:38Andy: I think it's on The Sun Aso Rises.
- 39:39We'll put in the show notes.
- 39:42Jed: All right.
- 39:42Okay.
- 39:43Good.
- 39:43Andy: Well, Buffett probably said it too.
- 39:45So it seems right.
- 39:47Jed: All right.
- 39:48Well, but the overarching point: just that I think we are making incremental
- 39:54damage to our public education efforts that are really putting us
- 39:59at risk and it's a time for us to be more sober if at all possible,
- 40:04in terms of looking at these things.
- 40:05Andy: Yeah.
- 40:06A little less theater and a little more sort of...
- 40:09Again, I think the media has a role to play in that and
- 40:11is falling down on the job.
- 40:14And I think leaders in our sector have a role to play in
- 40:17that and are too frequently...
- 40:20the tribe has allure and the comfort of the tribal politics is real and it's
- 40:25hard for people to step out and say, "now this is nonsense and we can do better".
- 40:29And like Oakland seemed like that seemed like nonsense, and
- 40:33really unfortunate nonsense.
- 40:35Jed: Well, on that sobering note we'll have to make a mental note to start off
- 40:40with some positivity on the next call.
- 40:43But always does my heart good to see you, Andy.
- 40:45Andy: Yeah, great to see you, Jed.
- 40:47Jed: You smartened me up.
- 40:48Andy: Likewise.
- 40:49Jed: I look forward to talking to you in another couple weeks.
- 40:52Andy: Yeah, me too.
- 40:52See you.
- 40:52Jed: Okay, take care now.