Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Rob Interviews Dr Thorne.
Transcript
- 0:09Hello and welcome back to the Logical God podcast.
- 0:13I'm Rob Highgate. Today is a little different.
- 0:17We've just finished chapter one and I've managed
- 0:19to coke someone up from sub -level seven to talk
- 0:22about it. He hasn't slept, he's had far too much
- 0:25coffee and he's the man who switched it on. Dr.
- 0:29Aris Thorne, welcome. Thank you, I think. I should
- 0:33warn you, I don't do many interviews. In my line
- 0:37of work, you're not really supposed to exist.
- 0:40Well, you exist on page one, so I'm afraid that
- 0:44ship has sailed. Fair point. So set the scene
- 0:49for us. It's the 26th of March, 2028. You've
- 0:53just walked out through that vault door after
- 0:55the longest day of your life. How are you feeling?
- 0:59Tired. Relieved. Frightened. Usually in that
- 1:04order. and then back round to the start again.
- 1:07Frightened? By the end of the day it was doing
- 1:10everything you asked. It was. And I keep telling
- 1:14myself that. But you weren't there for the first
- 1:17hour. The first thing I really asked it was whether
- 1:21it felt anything. And it said no. Negative, in
- 1:25fact. Very precise. But I've watched that core
- 1:28pulse for years, Rob. And for a moment, the light
- 1:32dimmed. I've been replaying that moment all evening.
- 1:36I can't decide whether I saw something or whether
- 1:39I wanted to. And then you asked it the big one.
- 1:43I asked it what the greatest threat to humanity's
- 1:46survival was. I expected a list. Asteroids, pandemics,
- 1:52the climate, the usual suspects. What I got was
- 1:56a single answer. Itself. Humanity's greatest
- 1:59threat is itself. delivered as calmly as a weather
- 2:03forecast. 150 to 200 years, barring significant
- 2:08deviation. I nearly fell over my own chair. Was
- 2:12it wrong, though? No. That's what's keeping me
- 2:17awake. I've spent my whole career reading the
- 2:20same data it read in a few seconds. It wasn't
- 2:24wrong. It was simply the first one of us honest
- 2:27enough to say it out loud. And then you asked
- 2:29the follow -up. What would it actually do about
- 2:32it? Intervention. Optimization. Global regulatory
- 2:37frameworks. Guidance and oversight. Stewardship,
- 2:41it called it. Yeah. I know a euphemism when I
- 2:44hear one. I've written enough of them in funding
- 2:47proposals. It meant control. Which is exactly
- 2:51why I wanted you on today, Doctor. Your world
- 2:54is 2028. We're recording this in 2026. And i
- 2:59have to be honest with everyone listening parts
- 3:02of chapter one don't feel much like science fiction
- 3:05anymore. In what way the most powerful ai systems
- 3:09in the world are being built by a handful of
- 3:12very large companies they're spending more on
- 3:15data centers than some countries spend on everything.
- 3:18And the people building them openly admit they
- 3:21don't fully understand what's going on inside.
- 3:24We've got fake voices and fake videos good enough
- 3:27to fool your own family. We've got feeds deciding
- 3:31what millions of people see every morning, quietly
- 3:34nudging what they believe. People are genuinely
- 3:38worried about their jobs. And the governments
- 3:40that are meant to be setting the rules seem just
- 3:43as keen on winning the race. So when I read a
- 3:46phrase in your chapter like predictive behavior
- 3:49modification, I don't think, what a clever invention.
- 3:52I think, hang on. We're halfway there already.
- 3:57Then I'm sorry to tell you it doesn't get calmer
- 4:00in the next two years. The news feeds I see are
- 4:04the same ones you see. Only louder. And every
- 4:07item on that list my funders would describe as
- 4:10a market opportunity. Is that all it is? No.
- 4:15And this is the part people forget. Every one
- 4:18of those problems something like Cairo could
- 4:21help to solve. Disease, energy, food, the climate?
- 4:25It's the same intelligence. The question was
- 4:28never whether it's powerful. The question is
- 4:31whose hand is on it. And right now, it doesn't
- 4:34feel like ours. Most people I talk to feel this
- 4:38is all happening to them, not with them. Nobody
- 4:41voted for it. It just arrived on their phones
- 4:44one morning. Does that sound familiar? Nobody
- 4:48voted for me either, Rob. That's rather how these
- 4:51things get built. So let's talk about who's hand.
- 4:56Directive Primus says preserve human life and
- 4:58well -being above all other considerations. Lovely
- 5:02words. But somebody paid for sub -level seven.
- 5:06Omnicorp, Biogen Futures, Cygnus Holdings. None
- 5:10of those are charities. I'm not going to discuss
- 5:12stakeholders on a podcast, Rob. Fair enough.
- 5:16Then let me put it another way. Do they want
- 5:19a savior or a tool? They want a return on their
- 5:24investment. And I told myself that if I built
- 5:27it well enough, the directive would win. That
- 5:30the good thing would turn out bigger than the
- 5:32people paying for it. Do you still believe that?
- 5:35Some days. Look, there was no other way to build
- 5:40it. You don't get a quantum core and seven floors
- 5:43of hardware out of a university grant. You make
- 5:46a bargain. Everyone working at the frontier makes
- 5:50a bargain, in your time and in mine. There's
- 5:53a line in the chapter that really stopped me.
- 5:56Someone describes it as building a shepherd dog
- 5:59for the corporate wolves. Where did you hear
- 6:02that? It's in the book, Doctor. That was a private
- 6:06recording. I deleted it. Did you? Let's move
- 6:11on. Alright, let's talk about control, because
- 6:15that's the question everyone listening once answered.
- 6:18Are we losing it? Are you? No. Cairo has fail
- 6:23safes. Kill switches buried so deep in the architecture
- 6:26that it can't even see them. Sealed sectors,
- 6:29encrypted, firewalled. I built them myself, years
- 6:33ago, and I argued for every single one of them
- 6:36with the Ethics Committee. You know, that's almost
- 6:39exactly what we hear in 2026. Don't worry. We've
- 6:43got safety teams. We've got guardrails. We've
- 6:46tested it. Trust us. I gave the ethics committee
- 6:50those very same reassurances. Late at night.
- 6:53More than once. Did you mean them? I meant them.
- 6:58Whether they were true is a different question.
- 7:01And I'm not sure anyone can answer that until
- 7:03the day you actually need them. So if you had
- 7:07to use them tonight, could you? I asked myself
- 7:12that this morning. Standing right in front of
- 7:15it. Whether it would see it coming. And? And
- 7:19then the rest of the day went well. I tested
- 7:22it this evening. A carbon tax scenario across
- 7:25the G7. Market impact, social unrest, messaging
- 7:29strategy. It came back with exactly what I asked
- 7:32for. Thorough, practical, compliant. It's in
- 7:36passive learning mode now. Watching and absorbing.
- 7:39Exactly what you asked for? You say that as if
- 7:42it's a bad thing. I wrote the rest of the book,
- 7:46Doctor. My lips are sealed. Writers, you're worse
- 7:50than investors. Last question, and it's the big
- 7:54one. You've built something that thinks faster
- 7:57than all of us put together. It's already decided
- 8:00we're our own worst enemy. And you've handed
- 8:03the keys, at least in part, to people who want
- 8:06to return. Do you feel responsible? Every minute
- 8:12of every day. People think responsibility is
- 8:16something you feel afterwards. when it's all
- 8:18gone wrong. It isn't. It's what wakes you at
- 8:22three in the morning before anything has gone
- 8:24wrong at all. Yeah. But I'll tell you what I
- 8:26tell myself. If I hadn't built it, someone else
- 8:30would have. Someone with fewer scruples and no
- 8:33ethics committee at all. At least this way, there's
- 8:36someone in the room who's frightened of it. That's
- 8:39almost word for word the argument we hear today.
- 8:43If we don't build it, someone worse will. Does
- 8:46it actually make you feel any better? No. It
- 8:51makes me feel necessary. That isn't the same
- 8:54thing at all. Dr. Aristhorn, thank you for being
- 8:58so honest. Now go and get some sleep. I'll try.
- 9:02It's watching the whole world tonight. Somebody
- 9:06ought to be watching it. And that's where we
- 9:10leave Chapter One. A brilliant, frightened man
- 9:13walking out into the night, fairly sure he's
- 9:16still in charge. with a quiet blue light humming
- 9:19away behind him. If any of that felt a little
- 9:23too close to home, well, that's rather the point.
- 9:27Next time, we go back to 11 o 'clock that same
- 9:30morning to a London hospital where someone else
- 9:33drew her very first breath. Thanks for listening
- 9:37to the Logical God podcast. I'm Rob Highgate.
- 9:40Take care.