Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Earth vs Soup Ep 174 - Diary of a Madman (1963)
Transcript
- 0:00I didn't electoral care at the mind barble. You see, you see your
- 0:04stupid mimes, stupid stupid Santa Claus. Long enough, we will bring him
- 0:09to Mars. I've been afraid a lot of times in my life, but
- 0:12I didn't know the real meaning of fear until until I kissed backy one thing.
- 0:16I'll be clear, it's not for man to interfere in the ways.
- 0:19You've got good evening, everybody, and welcome to Earth versus Soup, episode
- 0:45one, seventy four. I'm Aaron Paullier and I'm Darlene. I apologize if
- 0:49I stumble a little bit. I bet my tongue very badly earlier, and
- 0:53boy, I'm I've gotten a swollen tongue. But we watched a movie that
- 0:59Darling suggested, and I'm actually glad that she did. She you suggested it
- 1:04because Vincent Price was in it. Correct. Yes, Diary of a Madman
- 1:11from nineteen sixty three, ninety seven minutes, ninety seven minutes. It's in
- 1:17color. It's in glorious color. The most terrifying motion picture ever created.
- 1:25No No No, based on Guy do Monipez, a French author from back
- 1:34in the day. The short story of La Horla Horla, and you kept
- 1:40saying all the way through watching it, it's a Horda, and I'm like,
- 1:42no, Hordas are silicon based life forms from Double in the Dark,
- 1:47from the original series. No no, no, no, no no no.
- 1:49Now. I had to look up what the short story was, and
- 1:53I guess it inspired. It may have inspired Lovecraft in some ways. It
- 2:00was also something that wasn't Star Trek. There was an episode that kind of
- 2:07used well, the Jack the Ripper episode. I don't know, you have
- 2:10to go. I didn't write not so uh, this is a movie.
- 2:16There are actual things in here that we liked. There are things in here
- 2:23we did not. I can't judge it based on the short story, as
- 2:28I've never read the short story. I read the summary of the short story
- 2:30just very quickly to touch base on what's going on and what it changed.
- 2:38I guess this movie has changed quite a bit from the story, but the
- 2:42basic premise is still there. Extraterrestrial, it's not extraterrestrial in this In this
- 2:50movie, it specifically says it's not it's from Earth. You pause, but
- 2:58like the story says it's extra rrestrial. The movie, the movie story does
- 3:02not it disagrees with that. There are some people in here that we may
- 3:09recognize, not not least of being Vincent Price. Vincent Price is always fantastic,
- 3:17even in this I think he's good. I think this is one of
- 3:22the lesser of the Vincent Price movies. Though we have Nancy Kovak, who
- 3:28is in this movie. You may not recognize her, but we sort of
- 3:35did in some ways. She's actually from our neck of the woods, believe
- 3:42it or not. She's actually from Flint, Michigan, still alive today,
- 3:46and I guess is a big genius because she went to U of M when
- 3:49she was a teenager, still like a young teenager, won many beauty pageants.
- 3:54She's the female lead in this, and she been in a few other
- 4:00things that we've seen, but she did a whole bunch of TV in the
- 4:05fifties and sixties. Yeah, I didn't know. See the two females.
- 4:10I don't know which one would be considered a lead because they had both the
- 4:14same amount of Oh really, no, I don't think so. I think
- 4:17I think Nancy Kovac definitely had more screen time. Do you think she had
- 4:21Nancy Kovac compared to Elaine DeVry. Both of these women have been in many
- 4:29nineteen fifties and sixties television shows. I recognize both of them from random TV
- 4:35shows growing up, like, oh, they always look familiar. In fact,
- 4:40I would go so far as to say most of the actors in this
- 4:44you will be familiar with, at least passingly. You'll go, I recognize
- 4:48them. I recognize them. The voice of the Horla, Darlene, has
- 4:53had a part in every Star Trek TV series from the original series all the
- 4:59way through Voyager, and was a background character in Star Trek Insurrection, mostly
- 5:05doing voice acting. But he was like one of the one of the critters,
- 5:12well people that were in that episode where they were kind of having to
- 5:15fight in an arena, not not arena which is like the Gorn, but
- 5:18I'm talking about like the slave planet where they're forced to fight. He's in
- 5:23that. The voice of the Horla is this guy, and you will recognize
- 5:29his voice. If you have watched nineteen fifties and sixties television shows, you
- 5:32will recognize his voice. Boy, what else do I have to say about
- 5:39this? For like background three hundred and fifty thousand dollars budget, So it's
- 5:45about in today's money, it's about multiply that by ten, so it's three
- 5:47point five million dollars. Vincent Price today would never ever take three point five
- 5:53million dollars because in general, high end actors are able to command far,
- 5:58far, much larger sums. But I would say that, judging on the
- 6:06fact that like actors actually worked for a living back then and had to work
- 6:11like ten twelve movies a year doing this kind of thing, I'm sure that
- 6:15Vincent Price still got paid well for this. Does this look like a three
- 6:18and a half million dollar movie today if you discount the fact that there's like
- 6:23an A list actor in it, durly, what's your opinion? Three point
- 6:30five million? What is our no? Because that would be a low budget
- 6:32That would be a very low budget movie. This does not look like a
- 6:38low budget movie. That's the thing like this is not made by like Hammer
- 6:43Horror. We looked it up, made sure, but it has this sort
- 6:47of ambiance that Hammer Horror tends to. I think it's because it's taking place
- 6:51in eighteen eighty seven that you are likely correct. I will also say that
- 6:59the thing that tends to punch my buttons, that says Hammer Horror is good
- 7:03sets and good costumes. This has good sets and good costumes. So well,
- 7:11we'll get into what works and what doesn't, but we should probably get
- 7:13into the plot. And again, I think this plot is confused before we
- 7:17get into it, and I have again, folks, I take notes.
- 7:20I have two pages of notes. There's a ton of stuff that happens in
- 7:25this movie. It's pretty rapid fire for being however, however long it was
- 7:30like ninety seven minutes you saturn. But even though it was a lot of
- 7:31stuff going on, there was times when I was just tired of it.
- 7:35Yes, so tired of it. Yes, No, you are completely correct,
- 7:41because I think I made that comment to you right after we got done
- 7:44watching. I'm like, there's a lot of stuff that happens in this film,
- 7:48but there's chunks of it that I felt like, you know, going
- 7:54get on with it? Or why why is this happening? Yeah? What
- 8:03point is there? So we start the movie with credits over the picture of
- 8:09a dagger and we learned that Vincent Price is in this Okay, So at
- 8:13this point with Vincent Price, I have to say that his batting average for
- 8:18movies that we'd like him in is probably still fairly high. It's probably like
- 8:22three out of four of the movies that we see him in are pretty damn
- 8:26good, if not more. But he's not like the He's not constantly hitting.
- 8:33It's not one hundred percent of the time at this point. So I'm
- 8:37like, Okay, Vincent Price, we're probably in for something decent. We
- 8:41have a text crawl that is taken right from the original short story, which
- 8:48sort of spoils the movie. If you haven't read the short story, I
- 8:52ask you to read it because I was doing something and you didn't. No,
- 8:56I didn't because I was reading it and I didn't want to read it
- 8:58out loud. I was trying to concentrate the fact that it was spoiling things.
- 9:03And basically it's to sum it up, it says, Horla will the
- 9:07Horla will enslave mankind. Okay, so here's the thing. This whole movie
- 9:16centers around Vincent Price being possessed. And I use lots of Airba magistrate,
- 9:24magistrate that is possessed by this Horla, yes, and doing some of the
- 9:31stuff. Is he possessed? And then this is this is where the movie
- 9:35says he's possessed. We just randomly talking about this movie say he's possessed.
- 9:41Okay, at certain points he is the horror is in control, yes,
- 9:48But a lot of the times the horror is just an independent actor, allowing
- 9:52Vincent Price's character to just do whatever. It doesn't matter because the Horla here,
- 10:00here's the weird thing. And I know I'm not talking about the plat
- 10:03yet. Vincent Price's character, Magistrate Simon Cordier or whatever Cordier, he in
- 10:13general has very very little agency throughout this entire movie. The only point in
- 10:20which he has agency is right at the end, so he doesn't really feel
- 10:28like a character like every literally everything is out of his control. Everything that
- 10:35he does in this movie is effectively influenced by the Horla. I wouldn't say
- 10:41everything effectively everything, not everything, not one hundred percent of everything. There's
- 10:46still small choices that don't matter that the Horla doesn't force him into. Okay,
- 10:54so well I'll point those out as we go through this movie. I
- 10:56know you're scowling and thinking there are choices in here that are his, but
- 11:03they don't matter to the end of the film, and as it does,
- 11:09make up one question of would you consider somebody that pushes someone to suicide because
- 11:18they want to escape their life with the person. Does that make that person
- 11:22a murderer? Oh, that is one of the things that it does.
- 11:28No, I would argue, no, it does not. It makes you
- 11:31a bad person, it makes you an abuser, yes, but it doesn't
- 11:41make you a murderer, because the person who commits suicide still has the choice
- 11:48to commit suicide or not. That being said, there are no heroes in
- 11:54this movie. There are no white hats. Maybe that's what's bothering me the
- 11:56most. Again, a lot of these, a lot of these that we've
- 12:00been watching lately, there are no good people in them. Well, no,
- 12:03I take it back, I take it back. There are side characters
- 12:07in this that are white hats. Perry and the housekeeper, Perry in the
- 12:11house, Pierre and the housekeeper, the butler and the cook, the priest.
- 12:18But these are all side characters. There's also theoretically, the cop is
- 12:24a good guy in this right, like the police officer. He's just doing
- 12:28his job, so you don't know whether he's good or bad or whatever.
- 12:33Yeah. Yeah, But like the only characters that you truly see mister d.
- 12:39R. Bell. Oh you mean Jane Jana's father, Okay, Janine,
- 12:50Jeanine he is like the police captain. You can't tell at this point,
- 12:58but he seems to be a good character. Okay, so let's get
- 13:01back into the plot. We start with a funeral in France, and by
- 13:05the way, this spoils the movie. We already had the text crawl that
- 13:11spoils the movie. We are then told what happens at the end of the
- 13:16movie, and that pisces me off something fear. So there's a funeral in
- 13:22France. We learned to magistrate has died. A priest says that he was
- 13:26a good man. No he wasn't. The priest is lying here to not
- 13:31speak ill of the dead, because it's clear everyone that's at this funeral that's
- 13:35still alive. When we get to the end of the film, we know
- 13:41they all know that this guy is a dick. Anyway, a woman says
- 13:46that she's glad he's dead, and that is Janine dr Vell. That's the
- 13:52woman who says I'm glad he's dead. But she's not a good character either.
- 13:58You say that, I actually think she's okay. She doesn't do anything
- 14:03negative. She's only trying to be a protective force with the man that she
- 14:09actually loves. Anyway, a few people are invited back to an art gallery
- 14:15for a reading of a will or something like that, and it turns out
- 14:18that the magistrate thought he was going to die and left this chest that contains
- 14:24a diary and a note and warns about a coming disaster like that. This
- 14:31that there's this evil force in the world called the Horla and it's going to
- 14:35destroy us all. Okay, So the people that are in this room are
- 14:41like the police officer Janine Paul. Paul's there, and are the is the
- 14:50butler and the maids. Butler and maid are there, Butler and the cook.
- 14:54So we flash back, so so we know that the magistrate is he
- 15:01died in a fire. One person thinks he was a piece of crap at
- 15:07the very least. But again, like I said later on, at the
- 15:09end of this film, we understand that they all know he's a bad person.
- 15:15Okay, So we know how the movie is going to end and that
- 15:18the Horla is trying to enslave mankind. And here's the thing. According to
- 15:24what is read, the problem of the Horla has not been solved. Spoiler
- 15:31It was solved, but for whatever reason, everyone believes it's not solved.
- 15:39So now we go flashing back as we read this diary of the magistrate played
- 15:43by Benson Price, and it's like September eighteen seventy six, September seventeenth,
- 15:48and we show him this local cop talking to him a man, and a
- 15:54man is going to the guillotine and wants to talk to the magistrate, and
- 16:00Vincent Price says, oh, we're going. I guess it's because he's going
- 16:04to confess because at some point, you know, everyone that's facing the guillotine
- 16:11killed four women. He killed four women, but anyone that's facing the guillotine
- 16:15might want to confess before they meet God. So he goes down to the
- 16:19jail and this guy's alone. He asks, I'm just going to talk to
- 16:25him alone. The guy says that he look, man, there was this
- 16:30thing called Horla. It was possessing me, making me do all these things,
- 16:33and his eyes start to glow and he tries to kill the magistrate.
- 16:41He ends up just dying sort of. I don't understand how he died.
- 16:45He just kind of falls over. It's not like Vincent Price really attacked this
- 16:52guy or defended himself very much. Just this guy kind of fell over.
- 16:56I don't know the fight. The fight was very underwhelming, let's put it
- 17:00that way. He ends up dying, so he no longer needs the guillotine,
- 17:06and there seems to be kind of a lighthearted comment about this murderer getting
- 17:10off easy. A few days later, Vincent Price comes home and finds a
- 17:15photo on the wall that he had taken down of his wife and son.
- 17:18This wife and son thing is some bullshit. This is some real bullshit,
- 17:26okay, And I think we need to cover this now. What happened to
- 17:30his son, Darlene. We don't know what had happened to his son.
- 17:34His son died at a young age, and then his wife committed suicide because
- 17:40he blamed her for his son's death and made her life miserable to the point
- 17:45that she took her own life. Maybe he feels guilty about it. He
- 17:53doesn't show it, but the horror Horla might be using his gilt elt in
- 18:00his point of view. He might feel very guilty of it and didn't really
- 18:08contribute to it as much as he thinks he does. You don't know.
- 18:15These are possibilities. It's not explained. All we know is that he doesn't
- 18:19want a visual reminder of his family around and it happened some twelve years ago.
- 18:25Yes, And the room where he spent a lot of time with his
- 18:29wife, which seemingly was their bedroom, but also is the sculpting room.
- 18:34No, there's a sculpting room. It was the same set. To me,
- 18:37it was the same set. It was just dressed differently. It looks
- 18:41the same. It could be the same set. But it's supposed to be
- 18:42a whole different room. So they died. We don't really know anything about
- 18:48it. He bitches at his butler and housekeeper, saying that they put this
- 18:53picture back up. So he goes into this disused part of the house.
- 18:57He he puts this picture away in a chest that is filled with young boy's
- 19:03clothes and women's clothes. This room is obviously not been kept up. It
- 19:10is codwebby, it is dusty. It is the attic. Yeah, in
- 19:15this room we see written in dust right by a bust of his wife that
- 19:21he sculpted. Is what I'm saying, is the same room. It's it
- 19:26says hatred is evil written in the dust. Okay, but then when Pierre
- 19:33comes up written it's not written there? So guess what the horla made Vincent
- 19:38Price? See, Hatred is evil. What does the horror represent, Darlene,
- 19:45total evil, It represents hatred. So it considers itself evil, even
- 19:52though in the rest of the movie it doesn't. It doesn't see itself as
- 19:59evil, just sees itself as something. It doesn't really have clear motives.
- 20:07Obviously Vincent Price sees it as evil, But what's its motive? Just to
- 20:17play sick madness? I don't think it's a sick madness. Everything is very
- 20:22calculated. Do you think it's very calculated like the Master would be the Master's
- 20:30crazy mad No, this is calculated like it knows what it's doing madness.
- 20:40Well, it knows what it's doing, it wants to do it. It
- 20:42doesn't seem anything wrong with it. And but not evil the only time.
- 20:51He just likes to torture people with their own emotions. Sure, but that's
- 20:56their fault, not his. I don't know. Like a lot of this
- 21:00movie, what makes it kind of is these questions that constantly get raised while
- 21:08you're watching it. So but he asked for the trial testimony of girth,
- 21:15No, he didn't ask for it. That's the point. He comes into
- 21:18his office the next day and he sees that trial testimony just sitting on his
- 21:21desk. Okay, here again, we should make very clear the Horla is
- 21:26moving things around, not using Vincent Price's body. He's not using because the
- 21:32Horla doesn't have to possess anybody. It just exists. It is a physical
- 21:38being that exists. Okay, there is a point in this movie in which
- 21:45it stands between Vincent Price and a mirror. So Vincent Price cannot see his
- 21:51reflection in the mirror, but he can see the reflection of the room.
- 21:53How that makes sense. I have no idea. It is a physical presence.
- 21:59It has no need to possess anybody. Now, in the short story,
- 22:03I'm actually sure that it doesn't have a physical press or at the very
- 22:07least, it is like a mist in the books. That's what it came
- 22:11across when I read the summary that it's some sort of myst It can't really
- 22:15move things, but it does exist. But it's definitely moving things, right
- 22:19that it moved the picture to the wall. It can move large weights,
- 22:26it can move large mounds of soil and things. Is it is a powerful
- 22:30being? Well? Anyway, this is out on his desk and something picks
- 22:37up an ink. Well, while he's in his office, and spills it,
- 22:40and we hear this laughing, disembodied voice, and it starts speaking to
- 22:44Vins and telling him that his body and mind will be taken by him by
- 22:48the Horla. Later that night, it forces him to kill his pet bird,
- 22:56Like he takes this beautiful little songbird out of a cage which is far
- 22:59too small for that bird. Can I make that comment that cage was far
- 23:03too small for that bird, very victorian age, but very ornate bird cage
- 23:08and he he he like crushes it in his hands while his eyes glow.
- 23:11Being Simon starts to write the diary before then yeah, so oh boy,
- 23:19Okay, so he ends up going to see a psychiatrist of sorts, or
- 23:22let's just say a medical doctor. And the medical doctor says, hey,
- 23:26you've been blaming yourself for the deaths in your family. Spoiler, he has
- 23:33every right to blame himself for it, and that he's he's been holding his
- 23:40grief back and it's coming out in this really strange way to me. I
- 23:44don't know if this is all you know, the mind, his mind is
- 23:48guilty of it, whether he actually was that shitty person to create here's another
- 23:57thought. It's entirely possible this Horla thing is entirely a psychotic break, that
- 24:06this is all in his head like this guy, he heard the story from
- 24:11this guy that's blaming it on a thing called the Horla, and full on
- 24:18goes into this kind of derangement where he's blaming all this shit on the Horla.
- 24:23It's entirely possible that's the case, because remember it's not like anybody else
- 24:29has any evidence that this Horrla exists. Right. The only thing that the
- 24:37only thing that says this horror exists besides what we see Vincent Price's character seeing,
- 24:44which all could be a psychotic break, is the diary that he wrote
- 24:49saying that this was true. Like that's it, Like all right, So
- 24:53anyway back to the plot. So the doctor tell asks him to start doing
- 25:00his art again. Yeah, why didn't you go find a hobby, you
- 25:03sicko? And he's like, oh, yeah, I used to be a
- 25:06sculptor. And so he goes into this like art district of Paris and sees
- 25:10a painting of a ballerina. It is actually a very good painting. Am
- 25:12I correct in saying this? Yeah, it's a nice painting, and it
- 25:18is a painting of a ballerina. That is actually a character named Odette Melo
- 25:23who has posed for this. That is Nancy Kovac from Flint, Michigan for
- 25:30her husband, that's the painter. For her husband, the painter Paul Paul
- 25:34Duclaus. Odette never took his last name. That's why there's some confusion in
- 25:41there, because that would have been a very rare thing at the time,
- 25:45not taking not taking your husband's last name. Regardless. No, that's her
- 25:52middle name, you think, okay, because they did call her miss miss
- 25:57Duclaus. Yes. Anyway, he stops and she's standing outside saying, hey,
- 26:03you know what, that's a really beautiful painting, isn't it. And
- 26:06he's like, yes, it is, and would you like to meet the
- 26:08model that posed? And she kind of kind of puts her her face in
- 26:12the same kind of pose. She is a very attractive woman, and he's
- 26:17taken with her because she is oozing charisma. Now here's the point where we
- 26:23stop and go do they have chemistry together on screen? Do Vincent Price and
- 26:29Nancy Kovac have chemistry and screen? No? But when he was walking to
- 26:33the place in the artist district, yes, he kept on noticing the females
- 26:40that were laughing and ing and stuff like that, enjoying the day. So
- 26:49it's clear that she's kind of seeing this guy like looking at women. And
- 26:56I don't think he's looking lustfully at them, He's just noticing them. And
- 27:03it's probably because there hasn't been a woman in his life and he misses that
- 27:07from his wife. He needs to find another woman to blame for another death
- 27:10and drive them to suicide. Aaron, we don't know if that's the case.
- 27:15I know that was me being snarky. That was me being snarky.
- 27:18And he basically says, hey, have you modeled for a sculptor before?
- 27:22And she's like, oh, okay, here we go. You're gonna take
- 27:26me up to see your etchings, and you're gonna try to get my courset
- 27:27off. You know, that's kind of what's going obviously going through her head,
- 27:30right. Nancy Kovac is good enough that you get that just from her
- 27:36side eyes and like attitude, but she really don't care. She probably already
- 27:44noticed him looking at all the females and and had probably looked at him for
- 27:51his cost of his cane, his yeses. So she basically says, fine,
- 27:56if I'm going to model you'll have to hire me. How much are
- 28:00you willing to pay? And he goes, oh, ten francs an hour,
- 28:03and her mouth basically just hits the floor because I guess that's an incredible
- 28:07amount of money, especially since her husband in the next comp Yeah, the
- 28:12next conversation only gets eight francs ten for he actually sold a painting of a
- 28:18sailboat for ten francs. And she's like, well, when he says ten
- 28:25francs, she says, when can I start? Okay? Now, does
- 28:29she look like she's hard up for money? No? Does he look like
- 28:33her husband look like he's hard up for money? Yeah, no, more
- 28:37so than her. But no, he has a nice suit, he's well
- 28:41groomed. He has his own store, yes, but no, this is
- 28:44not his own store. This isn't a gallery it is it is his own
- 28:48gallery, because I think this is the Develle Devella. It's supposed to be
- 28:53his gallery. He owns this. This is where he's selling things. Now,
- 28:57mind you wasn't think that this gallery has almost made them destitute opening it
- 29:03up. But it is his, Okay, I always got it with somebody
- 29:08else's. So that night he ends up, she ends up going to Vincent's
- 29:14house and he takes her upstairs to the room in order to start sketching her
- 29:18for this sculpture that he's going to do, and he titles it the Laughing
- 29:22Woman, because there's no more true beauty in the world than a woman laughing,
- 29:26and not laughing scornfully, but laughing with joy. And she she holds
- 29:33a pose for a little bit, and he's like, oh, that's perfect
- 29:34exactly. And as Nancy Kovac was an actual like beauty queen, she actually
- 29:41knows how to hold herself in such a way as to be stunning, even
- 29:48in repose. Let's put it that way, Like she can just hold a
- 29:52post. She didn't hold the post, no, but you see her kind
- 29:56of going through these steps of going what would look best for what he's trying
- 30:00to do. She put herself in the light. She takes her hair down
- 30:04and makes it go a certain way. She cocks her head a certain way
- 30:08to get the light, like I think the actress knew and a bit and
- 30:15then obviously whoever was the director of photography or the producer there was like,
- 30:19no, we need to add this this, and she made it better.
- 30:22I'm saying that she added the scene in a positive way. The artwork is
- 30:30helping Vincent cheer up, and this is like time is passing. Here we
- 30:34learned that Vincent's wife took her own life at this point and after a long
- 30:38conversation with Odette, he's unable to see himself in the mirror. This is
- 30:44where, like the Horla is, the sculpture is done. Yeah, the
- 30:49sculpture's done, and it's a very good sculpture. Whoever the artist was on
- 30:52this production did a very good job. There's a sculpture of Vincent's dead wife
- 30:59as well that is again very well done. I thought all the art in
- 31:03this was actually pretty good. And it's the same bust that was in the
- 31:08attic. Yeah. Now, see, the Horla says that it lives on
- 31:12Earth and is only able to exist in the same plane of the existence us
- 31:17humans. Us humans exist in when evil has occurred. Okay, so remember
- 31:26he wrote down hatred is evil. He exists because of evil, but is
- 31:34not evil? What is Simon hating himself? That's the only thing I can
- 31:41think of. And this makes all your comments about him going and taking his
- 31:45you know, pushing his wife to suicide, that makes me think, now,
- 31:51no, I think he did, and he hates himself for it,
- 31:55like I because everybody know he was distant to her. That is all so
- 32:00possible. But and he just lost his child, so at that point she
- 32:05needed him. He pushed her away. She committed suicide. But I mean
- 32:07that that's still the same kind of thing. He didn't. He might not
- 32:10have been as actively abusive, but he still contributed to her sadness and green.
- 32:16But like you said before, he didn't commit the murder. No,
- 32:21he did not. He did not that there is still a choice to be
- 32:23made in a suicide. But the horror Horla Horla at this time accuses Simon
- 32:30of murdering his wife yep, by accusing by him accusing her of their son's
- 32:38death. Yes, and it lifts this picture of his wife and child out
- 32:43of the crate and breaks it and then changes the sculpture of the laughing woman
- 32:49into a sculpture of her like scowling. See evil and you see evil in
- 32:52everything? Yeah, you see evil in everything. And here's the thing.
- 32:57Vincent wasn't seeing evil in no, but the Horla makes him see it in
- 33:05her by convincing him to have an affair with her and breaking up her marriage
- 33:12to her husband, Like this is when the sculpture changes to how she is.
- 33:17That's how she looked like to her husband when he was like, I
- 33:22don't want you to go there and do this her. Yeah, a man
- 33:25who's willing to pay ten francs an hour has other things on his mind,
- 33:31right like that. That's kind of what it came across as. And while
- 33:36Vincent didn't have that on his mind, he has that on his mind after
- 33:40this, not because the horror is possessing him to because he chooses to do
- 33:46it. And this is why I constantly say that I've been saying, like,
- 33:52yeah, no, Vincent's a bad guy. He is not being possessed
- 33:58by the horla one hundred percent of this movie. In fact, he's only
- 34:00possessed for like, let's say, five percent of it, and only to
- 34:06like force him to pick things up. Like all the decisions that he makes
- 34:10in this movie are his and his alone. I'd have to rewatch it.
- 34:15Yeah, maybe maybe. So it turns out that Vincent goes back to this
- 34:22gallery buys the ballerina painting for like a hundred francs, which seems like that's
- 34:27a big ripoff for the quality of the painting and its size because it's a
- 34:30large painting, it actually does look good and brings Odette there to see the
- 34:37painting and basically like impress upon her, look how wealthy I am. I
- 34:40bought your painting and I've put it up in this in my drawing room because
- 34:46I took down all the pictures of women in my house because I was so
- 34:50ashamed of my wife, and even the like the butler and the maid are
- 34:54like wow. I didn't know. I thought i'd never see the day when
- 34:58there was a painting of another woman in this house. But I don't think
- 35:00that he realizes she's married at that point. You're right, he does not.
- 35:07I agree with that he does not know she's married, because she knows
- 35:10she's married. He even gets to the point where he asked her to marry
- 35:15him. Yes, and I do not think that he knew at that time
- 35:20until her husband Darling, and I guarantee you you are correct. He did
- 35:23not know at that point that she was married. I agree, you are
- 35:29correct. But what the the evil is there is that she does not inform
- 35:35him. She just agrees to the marriage because she sees it as a way
- 35:39to move up the social ladder or or to be luxury, to have these
- 35:46luxury items that are around. So when you obviously see that she doesn't really
- 35:52love her husband either, and he ends up giving her the cameo necklace,
- 36:00like the the amulet, the brooch that he had given his wife. So
- 36:08it's like it's like the it's a little cameo that has like the silhouette.
- 36:13It's one of those Victorian kind of cameos. It's the silhouette of his dead
- 36:16wife, was it. Yeah, m that's that's a little messed up,
- 36:28right If that was because I didn't see it, okay, And that's fair.
- 36:32I might have just, you know, put that in my own head.
- 36:36Let's be fair. I'm I'm an unreliable narrator at times. I'll be
- 36:39I'll be honest. I thought that that it looked like there was a silhouette.
- 36:44And why would he have a woman's brooch with a silhouette on it other
- 36:50than his wife's, because it's not like guys would give a wife their own
- 36:55silhouette. That that just wasn't the say, his grandmother, you know,
- 37:00right, it could be his mother or something like that. That's fair,
- 37:05that's fair. We don't know, but all we know is that he had
- 37:08given it to his wife. Now he's giving it to O Debt. So
- 37:12we now jump ahead some time again, and Paul knows something's wrong. He's
- 37:19talking to Janine, his friend, his friend, Jeanine, who clearly cares
- 37:25for him, but because he's married, she has always stayed away. He
- 37:30knows something's wrong. Boy, I can't really figure out what it is.
- 37:34She's left and gotten her own apartment and has been hanging around with the magistrate
- 37:37a lot. Yeah, obviously something's wrong, Paul. She's moved out,
- 37:46she's not talking to you, she's sleeping with the magistrate. Okay, So
- 37:51anyway, we can't guarantee it's in fact, the magistrate's paying for this apartment
- 37:58because she doesn't have any of our own money. She's a kept woman.
- 38:04Yeah, you're nodding. This is an audio podcast, you can go Yeah,
- 38:07Okay, I see where you're saying. Going right, So Odette says
- 38:12that this wedding should wait to be announced until after she deals with Paul,
- 38:15and then Vincent finds out Paul the Artist is Odette's husband at this point,
- 38:20and he's like, oh, he doesn't call anything off. He doesn't feel
- 38:22bad that he's been sleeping with a married woman. He's just like, oh,
- 38:30Paul's here. He showed up to talk to me, bring him in,
- 38:35and he acts like there's nothing wrong in the world. She's made her
- 38:37choice. I have no fucking problems. Excuse my language. This is where
- 38:42I get really ticked with Vincent Price's character, because he's he clearly is not
- 38:46possessed right now by the horla no, but is acting like a complete home
- 38:52wrecker shit heel. And this is where I started kind of like disconnecting from
- 38:57the movie and like engaged in it. I was still watching and taking notes,
- 39:00but it was like, I don't care what happens to him here.
- 39:04Up until that point, you could make the argument that Vincent Price's character is
- 39:09a he's a victim of circumstance, that a lot of this is. Yes,
- 39:15he's making bad choices, but it's not like he really knows that anything
- 39:20is specifically wrong with Odette or what's going on with Odett. He now knows
- 39:25that this is all bad. And then Paul says, I could kill you
- 39:31now for what you're doing, and I had to pause the movie. I
- 39:36go, Darlene, Crime and Passion. You even look this up right in
- 39:39France at the time, say it puts it as man manslaughter, which is
- 39:45not murder. It is a type of murder. Manslaughter is accidental death.
- 39:52It basically means you're not gonna go to the Yeah. If Paul would have
- 39:57just pulled the knife and stabbed Vincent Price through the heart right there, guess
- 40:00what. Manslaughter at best still go to prison. Yeah, but not the
- 40:06guillotine, that's the thing. And but him saying I could kill you right
- 40:13now makes it not a crime of passion. It makes it premeditated. So
- 40:17Paul, you just screwed yourself there. Man, you could have just stabbed
- 40:21them through the heart been done with it. But nope. So let's see
- 40:24here, Horla says. At this point, Horla, the horrlor says that
- 40:30Vincent will kill Paul to end his agony about loving Odette because Paul is such
- 40:34a piece of crap because he loves his wife without reservation. Okay, fine,
- 40:44So then Paul, you know the horror at this point, you know
- 40:47that Cola is a lying piece of ship. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 40:51So Paul confronts Odette in her kept woman's apartment and he leaves knowing that he's
- 40:57a fool, and then Vincent is a fool just as much as he is,
- 41:00because he knows at this point that she's just a gold digger, basically
- 41:08that you know what, I'm done with you, Odette, I'm done,
- 41:13and you know what, It's just gonna take time before he figures out how
- 41:15bad of a person you are too. Well, it turns out it doesn't
- 41:20take very long at all. Vincent's waiting. I think he's possessed. He
- 41:25is possessed at this point, because we do see his eyes glowing. He
- 41:29has like this glowing green kirk light thing on him, and he walks up
- 41:34with a knife, pulls it out, murders Odette in her kept woman's apartment,
- 41:38leaving an immense amount of forensic evidence if this was the twentieth century,
- 41:44but it's not so. He leaves bloody footprints, a bloody trail. He
- 41:49severs her head and doesn't remember any of it. The Horror of puts her
- 41:54severed head in the sculpture of the Laughing Woman. How don't know how well
- 42:00the horla the horror is a physical being. It can just put her head
- 42:05inside there and then redo the sculpture around it. We see him manipulate the
- 42:09sculpture prior to this, So where am I. Let's see here, Paul
- 42:15is framed for the murder and the Horrla has Vincent disposed because the knife is
- 42:20in his apartment because the Horrlora put it there, and Vincent disposes the head
- 42:25in a grave that's been dug in the garden. And then he by the
- 42:29conviensation of the horror But yeah, because he's not possessed. Remember, at
- 42:34this point, he knows that under the under the influence of the Horla he
- 42:37has killed Odette. He is the guilty party, Okay. He also knows
- 42:43that Paul has been nabbed for the murder, and he does nothing to stop
- 42:47it. In fact, he's okay with Paul. There was a discussion between
- 42:52him and the Horla about that, yeah, and then he's just like fine,
- 42:55whatever, I don't care. But that's because the horror Lot was convinced
- 43:06him that something was gonna take place or yeah, that he was gonna get
- 43:09away with it, and all it took was Paul's death at the guillotine.
- 43:14That's the thing. Like Vincent Price's character, Magistrate Simon is a piece of
- 43:17crap. Every time he has actually given a choice to do the right thing.
- 43:22He doesn't. He actually does the wrong thing the morally, I don't
- 43:27think the horror Lot would allow him to do things I the way that he's
- 43:32he's you are correct, But he doesn't even try. That's the thing.
- 43:36He doesn't even like so well, he does try to commit suicide, yeah,
- 43:40after all of this, and the horror Lot does not allow him to
- 43:45commit suicide. Yeah, the Horrla does not allow him to commit suicide,
- 43:49and in fact, Knox the gun away. But at this point we learned
- 43:52that Vincent has had a really good plan. He has doused his entire study
- 43:57in charrosel So you forgot about Paul's talk to Jeanette and they actually kiss.
- 44:04Yeah, because Odeth's dead and now they can be together, even if it's
- 44:07for a few moments before he dies at the guillotine. He does not die
- 44:09at the guillotine, by the way, because Vincent lights up his whole freaking
- 44:15study, locking him and the Horla in there, and the Horla dies in
- 44:19like a brilliant green flash of light like it just he sets himself on fire.
- 44:22In these flames. Vincent wants to escape, but he drops the key
- 44:28and he dies, timbers fall on top of him, and uh, that's
- 44:34it. That's like we go back to the end, well, the beginning
- 44:37of the movie. Now that you know, they're all sitting around going wow,
- 44:40maybe he wasn't a piece of crap. No, he was, even
- 44:44according to his own diary. Since this is obviously all told from his point
- 44:47of view, he hasn't cover to deal with the priest. The priest is
- 44:53in danger, so Simon leaves to ask the priest to bring Jenne there.
- 45:00Yeah, and that's when he gives her the box with the information and he
- 45:05plans to do burning the So the question is is how do we know that
- 45:12Vincent killed the Horla since he didn't write that in his diary. We see
- 45:16him not write anything after a certain way. Don't know, No one knows.
- 45:21I guess we're just shown this because of whatever. Even though this entire
- 45:24movie is told as a retelling of what his diary is, it's it's a
- 45:30mess. There's this whole movie is a mess at the end. So I've
- 45:35talked about a lot. What works, what doesn't, Darling, what's your
- 45:37top thing that works? Good acting, good sets, boring, Yeah,
- 45:44good acting, Vincent Price even though this is up. I don't like this
- 45:46movie. Vincent Price elevates it from I will never watch this again too.
- 45:52I'm going to remember it. I might not watch it again, but I'm
- 45:54going to remember it. Nancy Kovac as Odette. She's a piece of crap
- 46:00character, a good actress. I liked Paul, played by Chris Warfield,
- 46:06who was in everything in the nineteen fifties sixties. So one of the big
- 46:08problems is you don't feel sympathetic with any character, no, even Paul.
- 46:14Like Paul, but he is such a side character. Like he he might
- 46:16be the most sympathetic of the people that actually have dialogue on screen for let's
- 46:22say more than one scene, but he's just kind of a victim rather than
- 46:28a person taking active interest in his own story, so to speak. Does
- 46:32that make sense? Oh? In Crosses, Oh God, that thing.
- 46:39Yeah, Vincent sees a freaking crucifix reflected in the in the dagger, and
- 46:44he's able to like throw it away at one point because I guess Christ dispels
- 46:47the horror man man. So Okay, the acting is great, the sets
- 46:54are great. The costumes I think are let's say, pretty good, if
- 47:00not very good. I won't say excellent, but pretty good or to very
- 47:06good. I really liked the artwork, the paintings and the sculptures in this.
- 47:12Clearly somebody was skilled that did them. Okay, I'm gonna give the
- 47:15movie credit for that. I'll even give the movie credit for proper lighting and
- 47:21editing. The plot is just I don't it's not awful. It's just that
- 47:29it's it's badly paced, it's badly thought out. I think it's badly converted
- 47:35from the short story to the screen. I don't think it's it's done properly.
- 47:38I think you likely could do this far better than it was. Do
- 47:45you have thoughts here? Speak up? I mean, I think it would
- 47:51have been better off as an extraterrestrial mind. It disembodied mind coming down.
- 47:57Yeah, and when it does doesn't need to possess you. It doesn't have
- 48:01to. Yeah. I also think that Vincent Price's character needed to have more
- 48:09agency, Like honestly everything, he's very rarely possessed, but even when he's
- 48:17not possessed, he's still making evil choices. And he's supposed to be a
- 48:22magistrate. He's supposed to be a moral person who people look up to as
- 48:25being more yes, so they should have had him struggling more with this.
- 48:30He doesn't struggle at all, Like he doesn't he doesn't want to kill anybody,
- 48:37but he has no problem with Paul going to the guillotine. The characters
- 48:45don't. They don't add up. They don't add up, like okay,
- 48:49Odette is always supposed to have been a piece of crap. She's a piece
- 48:52of crap. It makes sense, but I don't sympathize with her. I
- 48:55think she's an interesting foil if Vincent Price his character, Magistrate Simon was actually
- 49:04struggling because half half of this could be like Odette whispering in his ear and
- 49:08like tempting him, and then the other half of it could be the Horla
- 49:13doing it, which would have been an interesting a pyramid of evil trying to
- 49:21like make this man fall from his position of moral certitude. But they don't
- 49:27do that. He just is a bad person. I think that would have
- 49:32been much better with Odette like tempting. Can you have anything else to say?
- 49:37No? Really, no? Do you recommend this movie? No?
- 49:42No, I don't either, But what's your one out of ten to like
- 49:45kind of give a indication of how a force so it's not like awful,
- 49:51no no, see, but it's not even I could actually put it to
- 49:58a five oh maybe, oh really okay, and it's just average. But
- 50:04the problem I have with doing that is that it didn't give Simon Cordarre the
- 50:15there was no fight between the two. There's no agency, yeah there,
- 50:20And that makes it go down to all four. I see. I would
- 50:22say this is a three and a half because this is a movie in which
- 50:30the plot is silly and bad enough that I could mute it and the movies
- 50:37not any worse. But it's also not any you know, it doesn't make
- 50:42it any worse. It might actually even make it better muting it so you
- 50:47don't hear the nonsense you don't like really truly understand, like why that these
- 50:54characters really don't have any agency with what they're doing. If you did not
- 50:59hear any of the die, you might you might actually believe that Vincent Price's
- 51:04character is possessed for this entire movie and that's why he's making these these terrible
- 51:09choices, that like he's dead mentally and this is just the horror of making
- 51:15him do all these things, and that may and just that makes the movie
- 51:19better, just that simple change. I don't know, it's I was disappointed
- 51:23in it because I tend to think I think it's kind of terrifying to think
- 51:28that somebody could something could manipulate you, Yeah, and take over for just
- 51:34a small and make you do something that is totally against your character. Yes,
- 51:40but it's like they didn't show it in this at all. Yeah,
- 51:44you're right, You're absolutely right that idea you are. You are completely correct
- 51:49that idea is a good and interesting idea to explore, because that is kind
- 51:52of scary. That is a scary thought. Here's the thing that makes you
- 51:57just kill somebody that you love and then it disappears and you're left with the
- 52:01consequences. The thing is is that the horror does this and he doesn't seem
- 52:09to matter. It just this is an event that happened. Now we're moving
- 52:15on, and I don't like that. It makes it not a horror movie.
- 52:17It makes it just kind of this. It makes it nothing. There's
- 52:23no horror in this. Yeah, there's no horror in this because at the
- 52:29very the only thing that I could actually even say is a horror is the
- 52:32tiny bit of body horror that is, Oh, there's this disembodied head that
- 52:37he finds buried beneath the clay of this sculpture. But that would be only
- 52:43really meaningful if you thought that Vincent actually cared, which maybe he doesn't.
- 52:50It's not clear that he does. Or you cared about Odette and you felt
- 52:53awful that she died, but you don't because he's an evil person too,
- 53:00like, yeah, this isn't this isn't that great. It's not that great,
- 53:05So I think maybe we should leave it there. Next week, Folks,
- 53:08is episode one seventy five, and I have to go back through my
- 53:12notes because we recorded it already and it is going to be a guest host
- 53:20Charles Wilson again, and we are doing mathra versus Godzilla from nineteen sixty four,
- 53:24So tune in knowing that that is our next movie, and I hope
- 53:30you enjoy it. So I'm eron, I'm Darline. Good evening, and
- 53:32keep watching the Skies. At no point in your rambling incoherent response were you
- 53:38even close to anything that could be considered a rational five. Thanks for listening
- 53:45to this episode of This Week in Geek Hungry. For more, check out
- 53:49our website at this Week in Geek dot Net You can subscribe to the podcast,
- 53:52browse our Twitter and Instagram, and leave your thoughts on today's topics.
- 53:57If you'd like to give us some feedback, send us an email feedback at
- 54:00this weekendgeep dot net. Tune in next time, and remember, lower your
- 54:04shields and surrender your listenership. We would be honored if you would join us.
- 54:08Thank you for your cooperation. Good night,