Latest / No Way Out / Exploring the Impact of John Boyd's Theories on Investment Strategies and Market Behavior with John M. Jennings | Ep 38
Transcript
- 0:22Mark McGrath: So, john, I heard a great podcast of you speaking with a previous guest of this show, hunter Hastings, who's a co-author with me on two papers on John Boyd applied to entrepreneurial theory, and I sent you some stuff.
- 0:36Mark McGrath: And then you reply back with an article that you had written about John Boyd and his article is famous, really is only published piece Destruction and Creation.
- 0:44Mark McGrath: Why don't you share with us what you were thinking when you discovered that and some of the applications that you may have seen in the asset management space or investing space?
- 0:55John Jennings: Yeah, I was in a meeting five or six years ago probably, and I remember who it was with, and somebody referenced John Boyd and I was like, who is John Boyd?
- 1:03John Jennings: He's like, oh, my goodness, you don't know who John Boyd is.
- 1:07John Jennings: You are missing out.
- 1:09John Jennings: You need to go read some John Boyd.
- 1:10John Jennings: Of course I read the biography of John Boyd that everybody reads and I was just completely blown away.
- 1:23John Jennings: And on the creation and destruction point, that really spoke to me because I had been doing a lot of research on my book, which is really about investment, mental models, and partially had really liked the idea of really it's the old problem of induction, right?
- 1:44John Jennings: So it goes back hundreds of years and Boyd's creation and destruction somewhat rests on this whole problem of induction.
- 1:51John Jennings: I think it was David Hume the philosopher that really hit on it and I was just like, oh, what an amazing concept.
- 1:58John Jennings: So I went and read that paper.
- 2:01John Jennings: That's like what, seven or eight pages, and it's one of the most dense, and I don't mean that in a bad way, I mean the ideas per sentence or per square inch of paper, which is like unbelievable.
- 2:17John Jennings: And I'd read previously about Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, I'd read about Godel's theorems and everything but still had to go back and read and refresh myself on those before I could even make it through the paper and then had to read it again and again and parts again and again and then I just saw it as a challenge to be able to write a blog post.
- 2:36John Jennings: So I have a blog that published a few times a week.
- 2:38John Jennings: To write a blog post that could sort of explain it while still doing it justice, because it's so big.
- 2:49Mark McGrath: Yeah, it's not at all easy to understand.
- 2:51Mark McGrath: I'm a Bachelor of Arts in History, right undergrad, even as a master's with economics.
- 2:56Mark McGrath: I had to read and read it over and over because to your points very dense, there's a beautiful epistemology by Chuck Spinney, who was Boyd's primary collaborator, that helped him construct the Udallupinus Final Form.
- 3:10Mark McGrath: And once he came out with that in 2014, and we'll link to that it's a it made destruction creation not only readable but really informed the rest of Boyd's work, because everything that Boyd riffed off of from that point forward till his death goes back to that, that sort of three pronged approach of entropy, uncertainty and incompleteness.
- 3:33Mark McGrath: You know second law of thermodynamics, uncertainty principle and the incompleteness theorem.
- 3:38Mark McGrath: And then that was his snowmobile, which you wrote about in the article.
- 3:42Mark McGrath: That was his snowmobile.
- 3:43Mark McGrath: How do we make sense of the world as these circumstances unfold?
- 3:47Mark McGrath: Now, I've been under the impression for you know my almost when I was in asset management for almost 20 years this is the most applicable place to apply it.
- 3:55Mark McGrath: This is one of the best environments in that it's always changing, it's always fluid and you also have nothing but human decisions presenting themselves by form of price movements and business decisions and everything.
- 4:07Mark McGrath: It's the best place for applying Boyd's theories.
- 4:11Mark McGrath: What do you think of that?
- 4:13John Jennings: Yeah, I think it is.
- 4:14John Jennings: It's like this laboratory of you know human decision making and you can just see how complex adaptive systems work.
- 4:23John Jennings: And it's just crazy.
- 4:24John Jennings: And you look at economists and, like, I loved economics, I took a lot, I majored in finance, but I took a lot of economics courses and I love economics.
- 4:34John Jennings: But you know, I think that the number one problem with economics is they have what Andrew Lowe of MIT, who's an economist, describes as physics envy, right.
- 4:44John Jennings: So basically, what economists want is something like Newton's, you know, laws of motion that will govern the economy and the complex adaptive system that is the economy.
- 4:58John Jennings: And it doesn't work.
- 5:00John Jennings: They put math and formulas into everything and math and formulas don't govern how humans interact with each other in a changing external environment and feedback loops on their decisions.
- 5:14John Jennings: It just doesn't.
- 5:16John Jennings: And what Andrew Lowe of MIT says is really the economy is less like physics and it's more like biology.
- 5:25John Jennings: It's like evolution, right, Just sped way up, where things are adapting and changing over time and there's all this randomness that occurs, that has real effects, that is usually impossible to predict.
- 5:39John Jennings: But you know, what happens is you get theories like Andrew Lowe, who has come up with what he calls his adaptive markets theory and no one has heard of it.
- 5:47John Jennings: And it's because it's not satisfying, because as humans we want patterns.
- 5:51John Jennings: So to have someone, even from MIT, say, hey, guess what?
- 5:56John Jennings: You know I'm going to tear down your ideas that you're going to be able to express these patterns with all these formulas, and it doesn't work well.
- 6:06John Jennings: And then Benoit Mandelbrot, the father, the inventor of fractal geometry, you know he wrote this amazing book called the Misbehavior of Markets.
- 6:15John Jennings: He took fractal geometry and applied it to, you know, the change in prices in the financial and economic markets and it just showed you can so much better model what's going on in the economy and the financial markets with fractal geometry than you can the bell curve.
- 6:32John Jennings: But no one's ever heard of this because it doesn't set expectations for the future.
- 6:39John Jennings: Like you can't make money off of it, you can help you, not lose money.
- 6:42John Jennings: But you know people don't want to buy the idea of uncertainty and chaos, right?
- 6:50John Jennings: But I think really what John Boyd you know, if you look at him talking about the Blitzkrieg and all that, it's like, if you can get to where you can thrive in uncertainty and chaos, you're going to be the winner.
- 7:02John Jennings: Or like in the Blitzkrieg and what Germany did.
- 7:06John Jennings: They said since we thrive better in chaos, we're going to create chaos.
- 7:09John Jennings: Right, and then we're going to be able to thrive on it.
- 7:12John Jennings: But, to your point, in the financial markets, we don't need to create the chaos, it's always there.
- 7:19Mark McGrath: You've got the chaos daily.
- 7:20Mark McGrath: There's no rhyme or reason to anything of this constant ebb and flow of price movement of you know, literally billions of people in the world coming to market, whether they're going to stock exchanges or whether they're going to buy something at their local store or whatever, and you can't, to your point, create a formula or an equation to explain exactly what they're doing, because it's all asymmetrical.
- 7:43Mark McGrath: And I think that people are looking for symmetrical solutions like linear formulas.
- 7:47Mark McGrath: They try to explain all that and it's absolutely impossible.
- 7:51Mark McGrath: It's kind of like we've had guests on a talk about McNamara's kind of, you know, quantitative body count strategy.
- 7:56Mark McGrath: You can't do that when those numbers are reflecting on individual actions and individual choices and individual decisions.
- 8:05Mark McGrath: We also mentioned patterns and of course you know that's Boyd's most famous presentation was patterns of conflict and what's interesting about those patterns is all the human traits that, to your point, fractal right.
- 8:21Mark McGrath: These things happen at the low level of the individual riflemen or the squad or the platoon or at the organization.
- 8:27Mark McGrath: It goes all the way up and down, but the patterns emerge from how humans interact with the circumstances that unfold.
- 8:35Mark McGrath: It's just that you could probably write patterns of investing using the same principles.
- 8:40John Jennings: You should do that.
- 8:41John Jennings: Maybe that should be book number three.
- 8:44John Jennings: So this was book number one, my book, the Uncertainty Solution, how to Invest with Confidence to Facing the Known.
- 8:50John Jennings: Book number two is more on wealth and happiness and purpose.
- 8:54Mark McGrath: Maybe book number three will be the patterns of Well, we'd be happy to co-authored that with you, because we have a lot of the Boyd stuff down and it goes to speak to the universality of the stuff as long as there's humans present.
- 9:08Mark McGrath: This is where Boyd's theories not only work, they're totally applicable.
- 9:13Mark McGrath: And again, the nature of everything, investing everything, business decision making it's right at home there.
- 9:22Mark McGrath: The other thing that you mentioned was evolutionary biology, which, to his dying day, literally on his deathbed, that was one of Boyd's massive inputs to the final version that when I say final, the version that he left of the Oodaloo before he passed away.
- 9:37Mark McGrath: His favorite book was how the Leopard Changed its Spots and that was by Brian Goodwin and that was a book on evolutionary biology.
- 9:44Mark McGrath: And you're right on.
- 9:45Mark McGrath: I mean, that's what's informing his thinking, it's not trying to find math equations for what people are going to do when they go to market, it's how are they behaving as organic organisms, because I think that people forget that the market itself is a process, but the market or any business or company, that's organic, it's people, it's made up of humans.
- 10:10John Jennings: Well, yeah, and I think one of the biggest difficulties is that people have an investing, whether they're individuals or I find this with actual investment professionals is this inability to accept that there can be things that are both true at the same time, that are opposite, and F Scott Fitzgerald probably won't get the quote exactly right, but he said the mark of a first race intelligence is being able to hold two opposing thoughts in your head at the same time without going crazy.
- 10:41John Jennings: He said it more eloquently than that, but that's what's so difficult.
- 10:46John Jennings: So you have these two things that are opposing but true at the same time, which is patterns do exist in the financial markets, in the economy, they absolutely do.
- 10:55John Jennings: But you also have this thing that is opposing to that, which is that they're constantly changing.
- 11:01John Jennings: And you can have these overarching patterns, but they're different and they change and the new ones come up.
- 11:11John Jennings: And what's so important to understand?
- 11:13John Jennings: It gets back to creation and destruction, where you infer the general from the specific, but then you need to continually look at tearing down your general rules because, as your specific instances change, and knowing when to do that, what's an outlier versus when is the pattern changing?
- 11:29John Jennings: And you see this constantly investing in the 60s and 70s, leading into the 70s, you had this idea of investing that you'd invest in the nifty 50.
- 11:38John Jennings: So a lot of listeners may have heard of this, and it was these 50 blue chip companies that as long as you invest these companies, you were going to do amazing.
- 11:46John Jennings: And for a long time you did, until you didn't, because, basically, too many people piled in.
- 11:52John Jennings: Everybody knew about this investment and it just went on and on and on and then all of a sudden it didn't.
- 11:56John Jennings: And then there was the opposite feedback loop and there was another similar one called you invest in the dogs of the Dow.
- 12:02John Jennings: So if you invest in the worst performing members of the Dow, at one period of time they became the best performing, and you do cycle and cycle.
- 12:10John Jennings: But then too many people started doing it and destroyed it.
- 12:12John Jennings: And then we saw this with hedge funds.
- 12:14John Jennings: I mean, it's just the pattern repeats over and over, but it's a different pattern every time.
- 12:18John Jennings: So you saw the rise of hedge funds.
- 12:20John Jennings: So hedge funds did really well in the 90s and kind of sailed through the dot com crash.
- 12:27John Jennings: And so what happened?
- 12:29John Jennings: People started piling into hedge funds.
- 12:31John Jennings: And then hedge funds there was too much money chasing, too few investment opportunities.
- 12:36John Jennings: And then hedge funds their alpha, which is a measure of outperformance, was very positive and a little positive and almost nothing than quite negative after fees.
- 12:46John Jennings: And we see this over and over again.
- 12:48John Jennings: But it's a different pattern every single time.
- 12:52John Jennings: Right, but it does follow this general idea of pattern and again, this is the importance of tearing down.
- 13:00John Jennings: You see a pattern, it's a general pattern based on the specific instances, but then you need to reevaluate all the time of what's going on.
- 13:12Mark McGrath: And it's not enough to be an analyst, you also have to synthesize.
- 13:16Mark McGrath: That's one of Boyd's major points and one of the prime components of orientation is, analysis is not enough, and, as you know, that the industry is filled with tremendous analysts.
- 13:27Mark McGrath: Well, what do we do with that?
- 13:28Mark McGrath: How do we break that down?
- 13:29Mark McGrath: And how do we build that snowmobile to try to have an understanding or anticipation of what could be next?
- 13:36Mark McGrath: Do you find too that when things get so excessively aggregated, or you see crowds, crowds moving into things, I mean really what you're describing?
- 14:44Mark McGrath: That's behavioral traits that have a negative effect on our orientation.
- 14:48Mark McGrath: Right, we're operating with bad mental models that we're putting in our orientation, so we're coming up with misaligned observations.
- 14:58John Jennings: Yeah, I think that's true and failing to appreciate just the randomness and chance, what happens when you have a complex adaptive system, and how hard it is to really understand what the output of a system is going to be when it's a complex adaptive system, jumping to causation when none exists.
- 15:22John Jennings: We've evolved to be these pattern recognizing machines.
- 15:26John Jennings: If you think about it really, what uncertainty is, as its very basic definition, is our inability to spot a pattern.
- 15:34John Jennings: Being able to spot a pattern gave us a survival advantage back when the world was really dangerous and we were evolving as a species.
- 15:45John Jennings: Your ability to see seasonal patterns, weather changes, the migration patterns of prey, those berries or mushrooms poisonous or nutritious these things gave us a huge survival advantage.
- 15:57John Jennings: Those that were better at spotting patterns survived longer, and thus we are their descendants.
- 16:05John Jennings: When we can't spot a pattern, it makes us feel anxious and worried, and sometimes it can trigger a fight or flight response.
- 16:11John Jennings: We're constantly in the lookout for patterns.
- 16:15John Jennings: We can't see them, we feel bad, and so then we want to resolve that.
- 16:19John Jennings: In addition, our physiology, which is fascinating, also gives us an incentive for resolving uncertainty, because it causes us to calm back down.
- 16:27John Jennings: We get a dose of dopamine which makes us feel pleasure.
- 16:30John Jennings: We want to resolve uncertainty.
- 16:32John Jennings: This idea that we don't like uncertainty and we want to resolve it is actually what's known as a primary human motive.
- 16:38John Jennings: It's operating usually behind the scenes, but it's always there, influencing our behaviors and our decisions.
- 16:46John Jennings: As part of that, when we have a bunch of randomness or noise or whatever is going on, we're constantly trying to see patterns or we're wanting to have causation or explanations for things constantly.
- 16:58John Jennings: A lot of times, there isn't a pattern or there isn't a good explanation.
- 17:04John Jennings: What's really hard when it comes to investing and especially being an advisor, like I am, is your clients look to you and they want you to be able to make sense of the world.
- 17:11John Jennings: They want you to be able to say B happened and it was caused by A, not just.
- 17:18John Jennings: Well, sometimes things just happen or we can't predict what's going to happen.
- 17:23John Jennings: It's hard to do, but that's what we want is.
- 17:26John Jennings: We want certainty, because it's this underlying human motive, and we're willing to set aside how the world really works and turn to a fairy tale instead, these explanations that don't make sense or patterns that don't really exist, because that's what we crave.
- 17:45John Jennings: We do that by listening to this expert opinions on forecasts for what's going to happen in the future, because it makes us feel like we have certainty, even though, if you do any research at all, investment in economic expert opinions are atrocious in terms of predictions.
- 18:00Mark McGrath: This is a great segue to a very critical Boyd Maxim was number one.
- 18:06Mark McGrath: Don't ever call him an expert, ever.
- 18:08Mark McGrath: He would take massive offense to that because what he would say is that when you're calling me an expert, you're telling me I'm a know-it-all and I have no more further capacity to learn If you know destruction, creation and other things.
- 18:19Mark McGrath: It's a model for learning.
- 18:20Mark McGrath: That's how we continuously learn.
- 18:23Mark McGrath: The second thing is analysts, because he said that the worst thing you can call me after that would be an analyst.
- 18:28Mark McGrath: Because if I'm an analyst, you're calling me a half-wit.
- 18:30Mark McGrath: You're telling me that I'm really good at breaking things down period point blank, and I stopped there.
- 18:35Mark McGrath: I can't synthesize, so I'm not an analyst.
- 18:39Mark McGrath: And a synthesis to create novelty, right To create something new that didn't previously exist.
- 18:45Mark McGrath: Then, when you think of the best portfolio, managers, the famous, famous investors.
- 18:51Mark McGrath: I mean, we know all the stories of everything.
- 18:53Mark McGrath: It seems to me oftentimes that they have a different view of the world.
- 18:59Mark McGrath: Their view is largely differentiated from what everybody else is thinking.
- 19:03Mark McGrath: You were talking earlier about how things can be opposing.
- 19:07Mark McGrath: The same thing can be opposing and true.
- 19:09Mark McGrath: That's ambiguity, and that was another thing.
- 19:12Mark McGrath: That was Boyd's favorite thing.
- 19:13Mark McGrath: The average investor could look at something and say, oh my gosh, I'm staying away, I'm never going there.
- 19:18Mark McGrath: Then a savvy investor with a completely different orientation is going to have his or her observations implicitly guided and controlled by being differentiated to see opportunity, by looking at the same set of facts, by seeing opportunity where others saw tremendous risk that they want to get involved in.
- 19:37Mark McGrath: Yes, yeah, absolutely.
- 19:43John Jennings: It makes me think of, in terms of two opposing things being true.
- 19:46John Jennings: The first is to have a differentiated result in investing.
- 19:52John Jennings: You have to be different than the herd, right?
- 19:55John Jennings: But on the other hand, you have this idea of the wisdom of crowds, which is the herd is usually right.
- 20:01John Jennings: So you have these two opposing things of there's a reason why conventional wisdom is conventional wisdom it's because there's often truth to it.
- 20:15John Jennings: But to be different, you have to do different things and you have to have a good reason for doing it.
- 20:20John Jennings: The idea of just being a contrarian isn't just going to work out, because you've got to be the contrarian at the right place and at the right time.
- 20:30John Jennings: Right, and we like the comfort of being in the herd, but that's not going to differentiate you.
- 20:39John Jennings: You have to be able to go outside the herd.
- 20:41John Jennings: And what's really hard with public stocks, so publicly traded stocks is, if you think about it, there's really three ways to outperform, and you have to at least one.
- 20:47John Jennings: The first is that you have better information, and again this gets to the orientation point, the observation point, the first O and UDA.
- 20:58John Jennings: So you collect information, but the problem is with public stocks is it's nearly impossible to have better information.
- 21:06John Jennings: Basically, what's happened with the internet and different securities laws and things like that is everybody has the ability to have the same information at the same time.
- 21:16John Jennings: It's hard, maybe you can get a little here or there, but it's really hard.
- 21:20John Jennings: The second is you can have better analysis, and that's really hard because there are so many incredibly smart people that have gone into investment management because it's so lucrative.
- 21:34John Jennings: I mean people that should be doing something more important with their lives, and I say that as a member of the wealth management industry.
- 21:40John Jennings: I mean there should be people out there doing amazing things and like physics or biology or something, that are instead working in investment management firms.
- 21:50John Jennings: And I found this over the years, like we'll talk to an investment manager and they'll be like oh, this is how we view the markets and this is how we analyze things and it makes perfect sense.
- 21:58John Jennings: You're like that sounds fantastic.
- 22:00John Jennings: And then you meet with the next one and the next one and the next one, and they're all a little different, but basically everybody is doing really smart analysis.
- 22:09John Jennings: So it's really hard to be like okay, my analysis is different but yet valid.
- 22:14John Jennings: It's really hard, but the third way you can outperform in the public markets is to have better behavior, and this is really the only one that can persist in the public markets.
- 22:31John Jennings: So it's almost like when you go through the OODA loop and you're like, okay, I'm going to observe, I'm going to take my data, I'm going to orient, I'm going to decide, I'm going to act.
- 22:42John Jennings: So in the public markets it's a different way to apply it than it is in the private markets, where you absolutely can have better information and insight and analysis and some of these other things in the private markets, because it's not just this just crazy playing field where all these intelligent actors are just grinding each other down.
- 23:03John Jennings: And if you look like, there's few, if any, just famous public stock managers anymore.
- 23:09John Jennings: I mean, there used to be, oh, bill Miller, and he beat the S&P 500 for 15 years running, and you had Peter Lynch and some other great ones, even Warren Buffett.
- 23:20John Jennings: So Berkshire Hathaway and it's the one I own two single stocks, it's the one major position that I have in my portfolio, berkshire Hathaway but I buy it more for behavioral reasons.
- 23:31John Jennings: I mean, berkshire Hathaway is so big, it's so hard for them out to outperform and a lot of the things that Warren and Charlie were doing have been ground away, right, so there's so many people that can replicate so many aspects of what they do in terms of like value investing and their analysis of companies.
- 23:50John Jennings: So now the, the famous investors, are people that are doing private investing.
- 23:55John Jennings: So it is people like Mark Andreessen, right, andreessen Horowitz, the venture capital firm, and others that are playing in different sort of of markets.
- 24:06John Jennings: You know, you get different people in different areas Again, because things have changed, you know, and there's these great opportunities in private markets now and as a result, you know, the the number of public stocks has shrunk.
- 24:21John Jennings: People, you know, companies are waiting longer and longer to go public, and so, anyway, it just shows the landscape changes and you have to be able to say I'm gonna continue to observe and orient myself in an ever-changing landscape where a lot of the patterns repeat, but they repeat in different areas, right, and so maybe I'm gonna move my efforts from finding investments that outperform from the public markets to the private markets, and then the private markets will change, kind of like they did with hedge funds, right, as money plows into different areas.
- 24:52John Jennings: It's like, okay, where are the continuing opportunities, or should I just throw in the towel?
- 24:58John Jennings: And and and and so a lot of I'm hearing what you're saying.
- 25:03Mark McGrath: Public markets would be successful in thriving in markets over time, one has to continuously shatter their correspondence to what they think is real or true.
- 25:09Mark McGrath: They have to continually break, create.
- 25:12Mark McGrath: I'm sorry they have to continue to destroy their orientations and create a new one.
- 25:16Mark McGrath: They have to revise, they have to update because it's always in the state of ceaseless flux.
- 25:20Mark McGrath: It's always changing and if they don't change they're gonna become obsolete or irrelevant.
- 25:29John Jennings: Absolutely.
- 25:30John Jennings: And, and you know, people become too dogmatic about what they believe, you know, you have these people are like, oh I, you know, I am a value investor, value, value, value, value.
- 25:41John Jennings: And they just continually hit their wall of value or the same thing on growth or anything else, and realizing that they're, you know, obviously, different times of these different things.
- 25:51John Jennings: Things work and at some point it could be like, oh all the, you know, you look back and in 1992, fama and French came out with their, their, you know, the four factor, no, the three factor models, four factors now, but the three factor model which is, you know, basically stocks outperform bonds and value outperforms growth and small performs large, and not recognizing the fact that after that was published and people started looking at the data and going, oh wow, that's true, the more and more you had people invest in value and in size.
- 26:22John Jennings: Small size then affects that research or the results.
- 26:28John Jennings: Right, the results going forward may well be affected by how many people believe that, and that's the fascinating, complex, adaptive system nature of the stock market.
- 26:40John Jennings: So the important thing is to have these mental models around investing.
- 26:43John Jennings: By the way, that's what my book is about.
- 26:45John Jennings: My book is about investment mental models.
- 26:47John Jennings: So it's what things?
- 26:49John Jennings: You know what mental models are out there and knowing which ones to apply when right.
- 26:57John Jennings: So it's like you have this like quiver full of arrows and you know.
- 27:01John Jennings: It's like which one of these arrows or which multiple these arrows I'm not going to pull out as I make decisions in this ever changing.
- 27:09Mark McGrath: So when I have multiple perspectives, they have multiple things to think about.
- 27:12Mark McGrath: I'm able to see markets differently.
- 27:14Mark McGrath: I'm able to be more agile within the space.
- 27:22John Jennings: Yeah, or or you know, and sorry for the sirens here in the background.
- 27:29John Jennings: So you know, I think a part of it too, though is is in the stock market.
- 27:36John Jennings: It pays to be inactive it really does and it pays to have you know not to react with emotion and not be trying to thinking you see patterns where maybe none exist, and to set guardrails for your behavior.
- 27:54John Jennings: Because, again, behavior is the is the most important aspect of, of investing, and so a lot of it is not reacting to things that you think are happening and to and again, I have an entire chapter on market cycles, so it's like understanding in general the patterns of market cycles.
- 28:15John Jennings: But the point isn't to use the pattern market cycles to be able to call tops and bottoms and to move in and out.
- 28:22John Jennings: It's it's instead, it's it's to control your own behavior, so you're not piling in and making really dumb decisions at the top or at the bottom, like you're not going to be able to tell exactly when the top or bottom is, but you can start saying you know, here are the aspects I'm starting to see.
- 28:38John Jennings: The suggests we're reaching an inflection point and it could be next week or it could be in three years, we don't know.
- 28:45John Jennings: But in response to that, here's how I am going to behave, knowing that things will change.
- 28:53John Jennings: All trees don't grow or trees don't go to the sky.
- 28:57John Jennings: There will be a change that is coming.
- 28:59John Jennings: I just don't know when.
- 29:02John Jennings: It's like.
- 29:02John Jennings: It's like you're on the train, train tracks and you know it trains coming, you can see it in a distance, but you don't know when it's going to get there.
- 29:10John Jennings: You know it's like, I don't know if it's going to come in a week or in three years, but you understand, in terms of these market cycles, how you're going to react.
- 29:20John Jennings: So again, my book is not about here's how you should invest, because how can I possibly know?
- 29:25John Jennings: I don't know who the individual readers are, their financial circumstances, and I don't know what's going on at the time that they read it.
- 29:32John Jennings: And even if I did, I couldn't say here's how you invest, it's how to think about investing.
- 29:38John Jennings: It's kind of like what John Boyd did is.
- 29:41John Jennings: He didn't say, hey, marines, this is how you should fight.
- 29:43John Jennings: He said, hey, marines, this is how you should think about fighting, right?
- 29:47John Jennings: Because I don't know what's going to happen and everything's going to change.
- 29:50John Jennings: You know, even your strategy is going to change on the battlefield and that's why it's so important that everybody has trust, they have alignment in terms of the model, but then everybody can make their own decisions right.
- 30:02John Jennings: And when it comes to battle, it's the same thing with investing.
- 30:05John Jennings: It's like, okay, here's all these mental models and work on knowing which ones to apply when, but it's not a cookbook or recipe.
- 30:14John Jennings: Here's how you should invest.
- 30:16John Jennings: And I'll tell you.
- 30:19John Jennings: This is a challenging topic because, like the uncertainty solution the title of my book the solution is to embrace and accept the uncertainty and then to dig deeper and say I want to know how the world really works, which is chaotic and uncertain and full of mild and wild randomness.
- 30:33John Jennings: It's not a world filled with bell curves, it's a world full of fractal geometry and power law distributions.
- 30:39John Jennings: You know crazy things that happen.
- 30:40John Jennings: You know I'm going to accept that world and not cookie cutter.
- 30:51John Jennings: You know supposed certainty and it's a tough sale.
- 30:55John Jennings: Like my editor, when I was working on this book with her, she was like it's like learning.
- 30:58John Jennings: There's no Santa Claus.
- 30:59John Jennings: I'm like, yes, but that's reality.
- 31:03John Jennings: And if you can accept that and you know, mark, you and I have discussed as you worked in the investment management industry when you would talk about these things like creation and destruction of the Oodaloo, you know you were met with skepticism or blank stairs, because that's not what people want.
- 31:18John Jennings: They want certainty, they want the physics, they want the formulas.
- 31:23John Jennings: They don't want to say things evolve and change and we don't know how they're gonna evolve.
- 31:27John Jennings: In Jays, we will just tell you that they will evolve and change, like that's very unsatisfying.
- 31:32John Jennings: So for those of you who are interested in investing, yeah, the full disclosure.
- 31:34John Jennings: I have one, I think that's the brilliant side of it is that finally there's a book that teaches people this is a way of thinking, and it's interesting, and as a Marine, of course.
- 31:42Mark McGrath: I love the parallel that you draw.
- 31:43Mark McGrath: That's exactly what war fighting is and war fighting that anybody can get online for free.
- 31:49Mark McGrath: Just type in MCDP one war fighting.
- 31:51Mark McGrath: You can download it, you can print it out and you can cross out war fighting and you could put investing and you could cross out war fighting and put portfolio management.
- 31:59Mark McGrath: And for years and years and years I said here just take this, let's just take this chapter, let's just work on this one.
- 32:03Mark McGrath: It's about uncertainty.
- 32:04Mark McGrath: Let's cross out war fighting, let's cross out enemy and put competitors.
- 32:08Mark McGrath: Or let's cross out, let's cross out war and put markets or something like that.
- 32:14Mark McGrath: And what was crazy about it?
- 32:16Mark McGrath: And no surprise to us.
- 32:18Mark McGrath: But what people would say is like I don't understand.
- 32:20Mark McGrath: It's applicable to.
- 32:21Mark McGrath: It's not just about Marines fighting in combat, it's applicable to everything Because, as you say, it's a way of thinking.
- 32:29Mark McGrath: The other thing that you said I think this is brilliant is about, you said, dogma and becoming dogmatic.
- 32:34Mark McGrath: And so many get stuck in these dogmas.
- 32:38Mark McGrath: And right back to John Boyd.
- 32:41Mark McGrath: John Boyd, one of his admonitions was you have to challenge all assumptions, otherwise what becomes doctrine today will become dogma forever after.
- 32:48Mark McGrath: And what people don't realize about dogmatic ways of thinking because I would run them all the time, well, I'm an old value guy or I'm an old bond guy.
- 32:57Mark McGrath: I just, you know, I just.
- 32:58Mark McGrath: The problem with that is that they're massively vulnerable to the rate of change, to market anomalies, to other things that they're not anticipating because they're not creating and destroying.
- 33:09Mark McGrath: They're not destroying and creating their understanding of the marketplace.
- 33:22John Jennings: Yeah, absolutely, that's spot on.
- 33:24John Jennings: And you know, there's another concept, how people deal with uncertainty, and it's called the need for cognitive closure.
- 33:32John Jennings: And it's pretty fascinating.
- 33:33John Jennings: It's right along these lines.
- 33:35John Jennings: And these sociologists that came up with it they noticed, based on a lot of research and testing, that what happens when we can't spot a pattern or we're feeling uncertain, is that we kind of flail around and we look for an explanation and we seize.
- 33:51John Jennings: So the first aspect is we seize on the first one that fits our worldview, that seems to make sense, that we'll explain.
- 33:56John Jennings: And again, it's because we want certainty, we want the world to make sense, we want to be able to attribute a cause, right.
- 34:01John Jennings: So we seize on an explanation and then we freeze on it.
- 34:04John Jennings: So we don't want to revisit the uncertainty we felt when we came up with the explanation, right, or that we seized on it.
- 34:11John Jennings: So we seize and then we freeze.
- 34:13John Jennings: So then we don't want to change.
- 34:15John Jennings: And the problem with this is obviously twofold First of all, what we seized on may well not be true and second of all, even if it is the world changes and the main sociology Ari Kruglansky, if I'm pronouncing that right who came up with this.
- 34:32John Jennings: You know he had these fascinating things to say about it with respect to COVID.
- 34:37John Jennings: Like, covid was just this in a nutshell whether you were, you know, on the right or on the left or in the center, in terms of, you know, I guess, pretty correlated your political views of how you viewed COVID.
- 34:50John Jennings: You know, if you had people that said, oh, this is just like the flu, right?
- 34:55John Jennings: So that was the way they dealt with the uncertainty of a pandemic was like, oh, this is just like the flu, maybe a little worse.
- 35:00John Jennings: Then they seized on it and they freeze, no matter the contrary evidence.
- 35:04John Jennings: And then on the left you had the same sort of thing.
- 35:08John Jennings: You had people saying, oh, you know, the world's ending and we need to take all these precautions, whatever.
- 35:14John Jennings: And then when the vaccines came out, it was like, okay, everybody has to get vaccinated.
- 35:18John Jennings: And, you know, maybe that made sense for the first strain.
- 35:20John Jennings: But as the virus evolved and the science changed and it looked like the vaccines were less and less effective and it didn't stop the, you know, even if it kept you from being really sick or dying, it didn't stop the spread.
- 35:33John Jennings: You know, nobody wanted to change their viewpoint on vaccines and the view was, oh, if you didn't get vaccinated you're evil.
- 35:41John Jennings: And as the science changed, they didn't want to change that view and you had it on both sides, you know.
- 35:46John Jennings: And the people saying oh, I'm going to wear a mask, you know, I still know people that wear masks every day now, and then other people like I'm never wearing a mask, it's just a point of pride, you know.
- 35:54John Jennings: And it was just fascinating that people seized on whatever explanation fit the worldview and sometimes their politics, and then they wouldn't change as the science learned more and the virus evolved.
- 36:10John Jennings: It was fascinating.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: Investors and actors in the markets is sort of the hive mind or things that come from you know, things like mass media and other things that get people to think.
- 36:21Mark McGrath: You know, in one way or the other.
- 36:24Mark McGrath: We've had John Robb on and we're going to have him on again.
- 36:26Mark McGrath: John Robb, if you're not familiar with, he wrote a tremendous book called Brave New War, and what an amazing book and applicable from a principal standpoint to all of this.
- 36:36Mark McGrath: But one of the things that he's always talking about is a lot of the sort of the mass consensus of how it forms and how it develops and, ultimately, how it's overriding our orientation and shaping our orientation such that we observe things a certain way or decide to act a certain way and learn a certain way that are not necessarily aligned with our own wants and needs or not necessarily aligned with reality.
- 36:57Mark McGrath: And we're talking earlier about, say, causation.
- 36:59Mark McGrath: Right, and how many times do you watch?
- 37:01Mark McGrath: First of all, you walk into a brokerage house or whatever and CNBC is blaring not only in the lobby but in everybody's office and if somebody you know you're listening to that and you're being droned into that all day long.
- 37:15Mark McGrath: And every time the market would close, it says oh, the market's up On news out of Europe this and that.
- 37:19Mark McGrath: Oh, the market's down on news out of China.
- 37:27John Jennings: Yeah, ridiculous, which is ridiculous, like this whole single cause attribution.
- 37:34John Jennings: You have millions of investors trading hundreds of shares, or billions of shares of stock a day, all for their various reasons.
- 37:42John Jennings: It's affecting the market and it's like, oh, there was this one, this one single print.
- 37:47John Jennings: It's like maybe I sold some shares of the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index last week because I needed to rebalance my portfolio.
- 37:57John Jennings: Maybe I was like, oh, based on my investment in the business of planets up, and I'm gonna sell and buy bonds, and it had nothing to do with whatever.
- 38:08John Jennings: The news was out of the Fed meeting or whatever, and yet it's still the market move because of what the Fed said.
- 38:14John Jennings: Or again, the news out of China or whatever.
- 38:17John Jennings: It's just.
- 38:17John Jennings: But again, it's this idea we want the world to make sense, and including the stock market, and in terms of the in the media, what people believe, regardless of whatever flavor of media, because we all have the media we like and then we have the ones we don't like.
- 38:39John Jennings: Right and so.
- 38:40John Jennings: But what happens is and this was one of the most mind-opening things I read years ago from a sociologist.
- 38:46John Jennings: He said the truth is whatever your social group believes it to be.
- 38:51John Jennings: And think about that for a second and how true that is.
- 38:55John Jennings: And the point is is that we will seek out social groups that believe what we do, and if we start changing our beliefs from a social group, we'll switch social groups, and it can explain why a huge swath of the American populace believes the election was stolen and another huge swath believes everything was fine, right, and it's because, whatever social group you're in, you're just like who are these other people?
- 39:22John Jennings: It's just absolutely bizarre and if you and I were on different sides of that, we could talk to each other till we're blue in the face about all the different facts that we have and we wouldn't change either's mind at all because we're gonna believe what our social group believes, and it explains so much about politics and religion, but also investing or anything else in the world, and it's interesting.
- 39:46John Jennings: You look at the rise and the fall and the rise and then the winter or whatever, of cryptocurrencies and there are people, with respect to crypto, that their main belief and their true believership of crypto is the fact that we should have never gone off the gold standard, right?
- 40:03John Jennings: And you have this group.
- 40:06John Jennings: They're like, okay, we shouldn't have got out of the gold standard and any little bit of inflation is confiscation right and that is an absolute belief that some people have, and then it leads to cryptocurrency is gonna save us all from it, and then you'll have other people that have the opposite view of inflation and or crypto or whatever, and it's just fascinating to see the different views based on whatever you find the group that reinforces your own beliefs.
- 40:41John Jennings: Yes, because we get into that mindset of wanting to believe with the past and you don't want to be the group that you care about your beliefs, which is the hardest thing to do.
- 40:50Mark McGrath: And we don't want to.
- 40:51Mark McGrath: And you were talking about earlier, about Robert Corum's biography of John Boyd.
- 40:54Mark McGrath: As you go through that biography, boyd the fighter pilot changed your art of war is the title.
- 40:58Mark McGrath: You go through that and you realize here is somebody that embraced discomfort, that was okay with volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity and was riding it because he could look at it differently and he was okay being right or wrong on his own versus the crowd, which that's an off-putting feeling to a lot of the people.
- 41:20Mark McGrath: And as you go through that biography, there were a lot of people that didn't like him for that because he wasn't a quote unquote team player or a group person.
- 41:27Mark McGrath: You hit on behavior too and what I find interesting about that.
- 41:30Mark McGrath: So behavior, just saying we could put in some psychology, like our emotional state.
- 41:36Mark McGrath: Years ago, when I was a young wholesaler out in the field, there was an advisor who had a undergrad, a master's degree from I won't say their names, but very prestigious, globally known universities and a chartered financial analyst.
- 41:50Mark McGrath: And he said that if I could go back 40 years and restart my career, I never would have studied finance or business.
- 41:56Mark McGrath: I only would have studied psychology and understanding the emotions and behaviors around the decisions that we make, but not only that, but how we even view markets in the first place and how we handle the information.
- 42:08Mark McGrath: Yeah, I think that's spot on.
- 42:23John Jennings: And what we found is it's interesting we work with a really wealthy family, so we're mainly in the 50 to $500 million range.
- 42:31John Jennings: Our average family has $230 million on average Meetings about 170.
- 42:36John Jennings: So we were with a really, really wealthy family so we can invest in whatever.
- 42:43John Jennings: So they're credited qualified purchasers, all that jazz, and we get pretty good access to different things.
- 42:50John Jennings: So you'd think that like the bigger portfolio, so that the $70 million portfolio they can invest in higher level managers and get into private equity and everything without perform.
- 43:03John Jennings: But what we found is that a lot of times it's the small portfolio that do the best and it comes down to behavior Cause.
- 43:13John Jennings: Imagine you're like in a client meeting with your advisor and let's say you're a $100 million family and you have like $75 million in a single portfolio, then a smattering of smaller ones and including this, like $100,000 account that you set up for your grandchildren and trust or something you know, and your advisor's like, okay, let's say it's March of 2020.
- 43:30John Jennings: And the world seems like it's falling apart COVID, the market's down 35%.
- 43:34John Jennings: Your advisor says this is a perfect time to sell tens of millions of your stocks and buy bonds, because that's what the math says, we're gonna rebalance your portfolio and you're gonna be like, no, I really don't wanna do that.
- 43:49John Jennings: Who knows what's gonna happen.
- 43:51John Jennings: Everything's shutting down.
- 43:52John Jennings: I heard the NBA may be canceling their season.
- 43:54John Jennings: We can't.
- 43:55John Jennings: You know all these things are happening and you go okay, we'll wait.
- 44:00John Jennings: We'll wait, we'll talk about this in a quarter or two.
- 44:03John Jennings: But how about this $100,000 one for your grandchild?
- 44:05John Jennings: You're like, oh yeah, sure, who cares right?
- 44:08John Jennings: Or, you know, the $2 million one for this or that.
- 44:11John Jennings: Yeah, that's fine.
- 44:12John Jennings: And what we found is that's why.
- 44:16John Jennings: It's not about the underlying investments, it's about the behavior, and what good investing behavior looks like is a lot easier to do with a small account than is a larger one.
- 44:26John Jennings: It's really hard, and what we've found is that a lot of clients come to us when they've exited their business, so they've sold their family business, or maybe they were the wealth grader and they've gotten in a few hundred million dollars, and it is so hard to invest one big lump sum of cash.
- 44:43John Jennings: It is so incredibly hard, just, you know, behaviorally, and there's all these you know, ingrained biases that are gonna be hard about doing this.
- 44:53John Jennings: So we've done, you know, invested billions and billions of dollars of cash and there are no magic beings.
- 44:59John Jennings: You have to overcome some of your ingrained biases and set disciplined rules in place for how you're gonna do that.
- 45:06John Jennings: It's pretty fascinating.
- 45:07John Jennings: There is no secret sauce, I'll tell you.
- 45:15John Jennings: So we're, first and foremost, a multifamily office.
- 45:17John Jennings: We work 63 families and a lot of them, maybe even most of them, have money elsewhere.
- 45:23John Jennings: So we may be their primary, you know investment manager, but they'll be like oh, you know, I had, you know, I have money with my golf buddy at Morgan Stanley or the money at, you know, merrill Lynch or Goldman or whatever.
- 45:34John Jennings: And because we're a family office, we're like fine, we'll, you know, we'll download and report on it, we'll interact with them, we'll team with them, we will pull in all your portfolio.
- 45:43John Jennings: We'll, you know, we'll take into account what we estate plan.
- 45:46John Jennings: We'll oversee the entire portfolio investment management with this as a portion.
- 45:51John Jennings: So we download every night from over 70 banks and brokerages, which means these are portfolios that are mainly run by other people, and it includes, you know, goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley and Merrill Lynch and Northern Trust and Bank of America and US Bank, and on and on and on Right.
- 46:06John Jennings: So if you can think of them, we probably download and we get to see not what they say they do.
- 46:12John Jennings: We get to see what they actually do and I will summarize what we have learned after doing this now for 20 plus years, which is there is no secret sauce.
- 46:22John Jennings: There is nobody out there that we're just like, oh my God, they're killing it Right.
- 46:29John Jennings: And I'm saying that there aren't individual investments that do absolutely.
- 46:32John Jennings: There are absolutely, you know.
- 46:33John Jennings: You know different private equity investments that do great.
- 46:36John Jennings: And I'll tell you, a lot of private equity, we invest in private equity.
- 46:39John Jennings: There's a lot of private equity that beats the, you know, the public markets.
- 46:42John Jennings: I'm not saying there can't be great investment performance, but I'm telling you, when we look at you know, if I were to pick on Goldman or Morgan or Merrill or something when we look under the hood for everything that they buy, that's like wow, that was a home run.
- 46:55John Jennings: There's almost always an offsetting strikeout or there's two strikeouts for every you know home run or triple or whatever.
- 47:04John Jennings: And when you performance report on it and you just see all the expense and the taxes and the churn and the unnecessary complexity, it's just mind boggling, you know, and just the inability of most portfolios to keep up with you know, a 70, 30, you know, if S&P 500 and bond portfolio, the inability of the vast majority of portfolios to keep up with that just shows you that it's really about behavior.
- 47:33John Jennings: In fact, even if you take the endowment model, so everybody wants to invest like Yale it's the so-called Yale model or endowment model popularized by David Swenson, kind of the architect of it, you know.
- 47:44John Jennings: As of the data of last year I haven't seen this year, but the data of last year if you take all 735 reporting university endowments, most of whom have over, you know, a billion dollars.
- 47:56John Jennings: You take their investment performance, their average and median performance is indistinguishable over one, five, 10 and 15 years from a 70, 30 index portfolio indistinguishable.
- 48:09John Jennings: Now there are some like Yale and Stanford and Washington University, where I'm here in St Louis, so I actually teach at the business school there.
- 48:18John Jennings: They were actually number one last year and number two the year before.
- 48:22John Jennings: So there are some that can deliver outsized returns, but it means that most of them aren't because you have these huge outliers and then it averages out.
- 48:33John Jennings: It just goes to show you that many of these attempts to go and emulate Yale or do things that are actually gonna outperform often lead to underperformance.
- 48:46Mark McGrath: Whereas if you just say I'm just gonna index, it's a copycategory, you know you're gonna at least take the market performance which is gonna be better than most everybody else Peter Lynch and Bill Miller and others and as I recall from you know reading over the years and studying behavioral economics and behavioral finance, behavioral investing that many or most of the investors in said portfolios lost money.
- 49:09Mark McGrath: Many of the average investors were actually losers over the same time periods because they bought it hot, sold it cold and yeah, oh, oh.
- 49:27John Jennings: The vast majority of people who invested in Bill Miller's extraordinary run lost money because you had to be there at the beginning to get those returns if you invested.
- 49:39John Jennings: And again he's rebounded back.
- 49:40John Jennings: So this is just as of his decline.
- 49:43John Jennings: But yeah, it's kind of like the difference between time-weighted returns and dollar-weighted returns or internal-weighted returns.
- 49:49John Jennings: So the time-weighted return for Bill Miller and his investors was incredibly positive.
- 49:54John Jennings: The dollar-weighted return, which takes into account the timings of when the flows occurred, showed that people plowed in too late to really gain from his amazing returns.
- 50:04John Jennings: And we saw it with the hedge fund industry as well.
- 50:06John Jennings: It's the exact same pattern right when most of the money that's invested in hedge funds has enjoyed their underperformance, you know, because they piled in after most of the great performance happened.
- 50:20John Jennings: And that's the tough thing about investing is a lot of times you got to be in early in order to really reap the benefits of the returns.
- 50:28John Jennings: If you come in too late after you know, it's like once the pattern is established, it often gets destroyed Again, like the nifty 50 or the dogs.
- 50:37John Jennings: Now the hedge fund industry is even star investment.
- 50:41Mark McGrath: Simple, not easy, right?
- 50:42Mark McGrath: So we constantly we've alluded to it earlier how people are always looking for the easy button, the quick fix, the fast recipe, the magic formula, whatever.
- 50:54Mark McGrath: But in that, in a world of complexity, which the markets are filled with complex, adaptive systems, billions of them coming in every day, why is simplicity what we should be yearning for and searching versus what's easy?
- 51:21John Jennings: Yeah.
- 51:22John Jennings: So, and I love this concept of simple but not easy, because if you find something that is simple but it's not easy to follow not always, but it likely means that it's right, right.
- 51:38John Jennings: So, for instance, take Warren Buffett's adage that you should be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful.
- 51:46John Jennings: That's incredibly simple, but it is not easy to follow, and I think many, many things are like that that end up being true, especially in investing.
- 51:59John Jennings: So in investing, the investment management industry largely exists to justify its own existence.
- 52:08John Jennings: If people in the investment management industry were like OK, here's the deal.
- 52:13John Jennings: If you go out and do what Warren Buffett said to do in one of his letters, which is he didn't say everybody should do it, but he said when he dies, the amount that's going to his wife is going to go 90% in an S&P 500 index fund and 10% in a bond index fund and that that's what Warren Buffett said people should do.
- 52:31John Jennings: Imagine if everybody in the investment management industry is like oh yeah, that's great advice, that's what we're going to tell our clients.
- 52:38John Jennings: Everybody be like I can do that on my own.
- 52:40John Jennings: I can go to Robinhood or E-Trade or Schwab and I can do that on my own.
- 52:45John Jennings: What do I need you for investment manager?
- 52:48John Jennings: And, quite frankly, if you did that over time again, you would likely be 90 plus percent 95 plus percent of investors out there, maybe 99%.
- 53:02John Jennings: But what an investment advisor is going to do is they're going to want to justify their own existence, and I'll tell you they can justify their own existence.
- 53:09John Jennings: I'm an investment advisor.
- 53:10John Jennings: We charge a lot of money for what we do, but the main value we bring is on investing its behavior.
- 53:17John Jennings: We're going to help, we're going to make your portfolio as simple as it can be, and then we're going to help you with your behavior.
- 53:25John Jennings: But then we're a family office, so we're going to pay your bills, we're going to manage your charitable contributions, we're going to manage all your state planning entities.
- 53:32John Jennings: We're going to help you with the state planning.
- 53:33John Jennings: We're going to do all this tax stuff.
- 53:34John Jennings: We're going to do all these other things.
- 53:36John Jennings: So if somebody pays us all this money, they feel the value from that.
- 53:41John Jennings: That allows us to say, hey, we're going to be more simple in this portfolio that we're going to create for you.
- 53:49John Jennings: We're OK saying I'll tell you, we have a client that on her portfolio is $150, $170 million or something.
- 53:55John Jennings: It's in two funds.
- 53:57John Jennings: It's in a bond fund and it's an all country world index that we slightly tilted more domestic than it is, but that's it.
- 54:04John Jennings: It's incredibly cheap, it's incredibly easy behaviorally and her portfolio it's just rocking and rolling.
- 54:09John Jennings: And can you imagine Like if we weren't her family office?
- 54:14John Jennings: Because she'd be like why am I paying you all this money for you to put me into two funds?
- 54:19John Jennings: But in our first year and a half of working with her, she was recently widowed.
- 54:23John Jennings: When we worked with her they're working with her.
- 54:25John Jennings: We met with her every single week for over a year, like we had that much going on and that many things we were doing for us.
- 54:32John Jennings: And she was like, oh my gosh, you guys are indispensable.
- 54:33John Jennings: But imagine if we were only her investment advisors and we're like you know not her name, but Mrs Smith, let's meet once a year.
- 54:42John Jennings: All we're gonna do is rebalance to your 75, 25, stock bond, two funds.
- 54:47John Jennings: I mean there's no way, but I'll tell you doing that, that simple way of investing.
- 54:52John Jennings: I can't tell you the proportion and what exact index you should follow, but that sort of simple investing is likely going to be whatever listener, whatever else you're doing out there and I'll tell you I say this with total humility because my 401k plan is in four Vanguard index funds a bond fund, large cap fund, small cap fund, international fund.
- 55:17John Jennings: I never look at it.
- 55:18John Jennings: It rebalances I don't even know how often twice a year, four times a year, whatever.
- 55:22John Jennings: I have no idea and it is outperformed.
- 55:25John Jennings: I went back when I was writing my book.
- 55:26John Jennings: I looked it is outperformed my outright portfolio where I can invest in whatever I want.
- 55:30John Jennings: So here I am.
- 55:32John Jennings: I'm the president.
- 55:33John Jennings: I'm the president, chief strategist, of a firm that oversees $15 billion.
- 55:38John Jennings: I've written a book that's mainly about good investment behavior and my simple Vanguard account has outperformed what I do, and it's because I don't have as good behavior.
- 55:48John Jennings: I look at my portfolio too often.
- 55:50John Jennings: I tinker, I buy individual stocks here and there, not often.
- 55:54Mark McGrath: I mean, it's not too far off but goodness, I think we'll have to do another episode to get you on that, james.
- 56:02Mark McGrath: Damian, who he's had in the podcast and book rules with Victory, but he talks about something too which was a major influence to Boyd, underappreciate and you've said it in your work that sometimes inactivity is better than activity and most of the street, if you will, or the investment world, is trying to get activity, because that's how I mean fees are generated, right or whatever, and sometimes it's better just to sit on your hands and do nothing.
- 56:38John Jennings: It's almost always better sitting on your hands and do nothing.
- 56:41John Jennings: I'll tell you, an important mental model for investors to have is, when you go to make an investment decision so I'm talking about selling something and buying something else realize that on average, it'll be a loser.
- 56:55John Jennings: I can't not everyone will, but on average, like most of the time, it will be a loser and this has been shown in multiple studies, including even a professional investor.
- 57:06John Jennings: There's this great one of pension plan sponsors, but I'll tell you that the study that I go through my book that is so well illustrates this is called Boys Will Be Boys a Study of Gender Differences Investing, or something like that.
- 57:20John Jennings: And these academic researchers got a discount brokerage firm to give them 10 years of data on 35,000 accounts, individual accounts and what they looked at is who invested better, and they found that it went like this single females, married females, married males, and then with single males bringing up the rear, and they looked at why that was the case and they found that both genders were equally as bad at making investment decisions, regardless of marital status.
- 57:47John Jennings: On average, most of the time, whatever they sold out perform whatever they bought.
- 57:50John Jennings: So the reason the single females outperformed the single males and on down the line was they traded less.
- 57:57John Jennings: So they traded 45% less than the single males.
- 58:00John Jennings: So if, on average, every time you make an investment decision, you lose, you know it's like the people that didn't go to the casino right, didn't place slot machines ended up with more money at the end of the day, and that has been shown with other studies, been shown with pension plan sponsors and it's important to keep in mind.
- 58:22John Jennings: And I think if you go back anybody let's listen, if you go back to your own investment portfolio.
- 58:28Mark McGrath: Is it every read?
- 58:29Mark McGrath: Jack's way is market decisions both, and look at what your investment decisions were.
- 58:32John Jennings: I think you'll find that it's the same case.
- 58:34John Jennings: The same series of interviews with all kinds of traders Was a loser.
- 58:38Mark McGrath: Whether they're fund managers.
- 58:39Mark McGrath: There's an old series of them.
- 58:40Mark McGrath: There's like the very famous one that had, you know, a lot of the trend following traders and future traders, but a lot of it is interesting how it dispels so many myths of the greatest traders aren't in there looking at screens all day long and shouting and throwing order tickets and doing all this crazy, crazy stuff.
- 58:58Mark McGrath: They're usually quite patient, they're quite disciplined and I think it goes back to what you were saying about behavior.
- 59:04Mark McGrath: They've got their behavior under control, they've got their emotions, they've got their psychology under control and they probably do something to work at it to improve that.
- 59:12Mark McGrath: Maybe they're doing yoga or exercising or swimming or running or doing something to promote their mindfulness.
- 59:20Mark McGrath: Bring us home with you know you do a great job of talking about information.
- 59:24Mark McGrath: I think that this is something that people completely mess up.
- 59:28Mark McGrath: But what I loved about your how you categorize it.
- 59:30Mark McGrath: It's very similar to how we would do it in the Marine Corps, how we would parse information, starting with data.
- 59:37Mark McGrath: Why don't you walk us through that?
- 59:39Mark McGrath: Because I think that, not being able to discern and identify these things, people really set themselves up for failure if they don't understand the categorization of information, so bring us home with that.
- 59:51John Jennings: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:00:05John Jennings: So there's something called the wisdom hierarchy and there was a Russell Aikoff was an organizational theorist that came up with this.
- 1:00:12John Jennings: It's brilliant and basically information, or information, is one of the categories too, but it goes data at the bottom of the base of the pyramid, then information, then knowledge and then wisdom.
- 1:00:22John Jennings: And what data is?
- 1:00:23John Jennings: And I'll give you an example.
- 1:00:24John Jennings: It'd be something like housing starts, so you just get this data from.
- 1:00:27John Jennings: I guess the Bureau of Labor Statistics keeps this like just housing starts, right, so it's just raw data.
- 1:00:34John Jennings: It's very plentiful, it's everywhere in the world, but it's not all that useful on its own.
- 1:00:37John Jennings: Information would be taking data and organizing it in a way that gives you some insight and some usefulness.
- 1:00:43John Jennings: So you can take housing starts and you can look at it, maybe over time, and you can look at it by zip code and you can say, oh, multifamily versus single hand, family houses over a million versus 500 to a million versus.
- 1:00:55John Jennings: You can start seeing how different sectors of the economy, both in terms of wealth and geography, are doing with respect to housing starts.
- 1:01:02John Jennings: So that's information.
- 1:01:03John Jennings: So that is a lot more useful than data.
- 1:01:06John Jennings: Knowledge is taking information and this gets more to like the void idea of synthesizing right.
- 1:01:11John Jennings: So you synthesize it.
- 1:01:13John Jennings: You say, okay, I have now housing data and I'm gonna use that and I'm gonna put it together with unemployment claims and interest rates and GDP growth and other things and I'm gonna use that.
- 1:01:24John Jennings: I'm gonna have this knowledge about where we might be heading in terms of the market cycle.
- 1:01:30John Jennings: Wisdom is the very top and that's using your experience to know what to do with the knowledge and this is how to make decisions.
- 1:01:41John Jennings: So this is kind of like the the decide and act right.
- 1:01:45John Jennings: If this is, the others are.
- 1:01:48John Jennings: It's kind of like the observe is kind of data and information, and you get into orient, which is kind of knowledge, and then decide and act as like.
- 1:01:58John Jennings: What do you do with this knowledge?
- 1:01:59John Jennings: And that's wisdom.
- 1:02:00John Jennings: And wisdom is to know that you cannot time market tops or bottoms, that you're probably gonna be wrong, and to do it successfully you'd have to be right twice, at the top and the bottom, or at the bottom of the top, and you would know, based on wisdom, how you should act and what, what sort of actions you should take or, more importantly, what in investing, what sort of actions you shouldn't take right, and some of it's counter cyclical.
- 1:02:27John Jennings: So you'd be saying, as the economy is booming, maybe I'll be working on reducing my leverage.
- 1:02:32John Jennings: If I'm a business right, or if I'm an investor, I'm gonna do the very hard thing.
- 1:02:37John Jennings: I'm gonna sell stocks and buy bonds because my investment discipline says to do that.
- 1:02:41John Jennings: Even though everything's screaming, I went to pile in and make more money, and so that's a really, I think, important way of viewing the world, and wisdom is what's most important.
- 1:02:53John Jennings: But we tend to get caught down in the data and information areas.
- 1:02:57John Jennings: And I'll tell you, most of the investment management industry is about showcasing data, information or knowledge, and is really light on the wisdom.
- 1:03:06John Jennings: And I'll tell you, I'm the chair of a $250 million endowment.
- 1:03:10John Jennings: I've been on all sorts of different charitable investment committees and things like that, and what I love is these investment managers always come in and they present to us and they spend all this time explaining what's currently happening or what's happened in the past.
- 1:03:26John Jennings: So it's like, okay, here's all this information.
- 1:03:29John Jennings: And I guess their hope is is that, by showing us that they have their handle on all this sort of information or knowledge, that we're gonna be like you're a talented investment manager.
- 1:03:39John Jennings: But really, what differentiates a great investment manager from everybody else is how they apply wisdom.
- 1:03:48John Jennings: And again, these are things that are simple and not easy.
- 1:03:50John Jennings: So the wisdom would be we're gonna be inactive.
- 1:03:53John Jennings: We're gonna have a simple portfolio it's interesting.
- 1:03:56John Jennings: We're gonna focus on costs and taxes, and you alluded to it in your article Energy Media.
- 1:04:01John Jennings: We're not gonna look at our portfolio.
- 1:04:02John Jennings: One of his driving forces A lot of things that I first saw in my life, by the way Spending years to come up with destruction and creation was he was trying to figure out why me?
- 1:04:14Mark McGrath: How did I come up with energy maneuverability theory, where there's eminent PhDs and engineers and scientists all over the world, yet I'm the one that came up with it and it goes back to what you just said.
- 1:04:24Mark McGrath: Having that wisdom of experience in his years of flying fighter jets, I would, yeah.
- 1:04:43John Jennings: Yeah, yeah, first and foremost he was a pilot.
- 1:04:47John Jennings: Yeah, well, and it was fascinating.
- 1:04:50John Jennings: I guess he went back and got what his master's in engineering at Georgia Tech or someplace I mean just amazing Just shows his quest for information or his quest for knowledge and wisdom.
- 1:05:01John Jennings: Because, to take that sort of learning and the way he thought and put it, with the practical experience of being a top fighter pilot, an instructor, it's those things that came together that were very rare.
- 1:05:13John Jennings: Did other people do that?
- 1:05:15John Jennings: Yeah, I'm sure some people did.
- 1:05:17John Jennings: My uncle was a fighter pilot, in fact, was like the chief test pilot for the F-15 program, flew in Vietnam and everything, and majored in engineering at University of Illinois super smart.
- 1:05:28John Jennings: So there's other out there that are really smart engineering people and fighter pilots, but it's this small little group and it, you know, I guess it goes back to what we started with, then his personality is plus and plus.
- 1:05:41Mark McGrath: The structure, creation, the mission of that.
- 1:05:43John Jennings: The intent of that was to really improve our capacity for free and independent action, whereas my uncle was just a really good fighter pilot.
- 1:05:50Mark McGrath: If we can't continuously learn, we're never gonna be able to adapt.
- 1:05:53Mark McGrath: And if we can't adapt, we can't survive, let alone thrive.
- 1:05:58Mark McGrath: And it's again for the markets, world of markets and the ebbs and flows and the stocks of bonds, just the chaos and the volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity, aka VUCA.
- 1:06:11Mark McGrath: What a wonderful place to learn about Boyd, to talk about Boyd, to think about Boyd and to apply the theories, because they're gonna present themselves everywhere.
- 1:06:23Mark McGrath: The only requirement is you have humans that make decisions.
- 1:06:32John Jennings: Yeah, yeah, absolutely yeah, and the investing area is perfect for it.
- 1:06:46John Jennings: And I was telling you, I think before we started recording you know I had read about Boyd, I had done some studying of Boyd and yet I don't mention Boyd anywhere in my book.
- 1:06:57John Jennings: I think it helped inform my views of uncertainty and patterns and everything, but I didn't even link, like the oodle hoop and creation and destruction to investing until we first saw it.
- 1:07:10John Jennings: Oh my gosh, it doesn't unclick.
- 1:07:13John Jennings: I was going down the Charlie Munger route.
- 1:07:15John Jennings: That's the power of it.
- 1:07:16John Jennings: We'll have lots of content to speak about this.
- 1:07:18John Jennings: Who's probably got his idea of Mindelmars from Boyd?
- 1:07:20Mark McGrath: That's why I think it's so important.
- 1:07:22Mark McGrath: And, as you say, you know the themes in the books.
- 1:07:25Mark McGrath: We've said this to guests.
- 1:07:26Mark McGrath: Ponch was famous on, I think, our ninth episode with Ines at Belito.
- 1:07:30Mark McGrath: He said so you know nothing about John Boyd, yet you know everything about John Boyd, because all of these things are inherent, Successful.
- 1:07:38Mark McGrath: People are doing these things.
- 1:07:39Mark McGrath: If you're thriving, this is exactly what you're doing, and the awareness that he helped create around it with his ideas, that's what empowers people.
- 1:07:48Mark McGrath: That's what because it always comes down to Boyd Remember people, ideas and things.
- 1:07:53Mark McGrath: It's how we think and it's our cognitive power that we're all equipped with.
- 1:07:57Mark McGrath: And when we free that up to break those models, to create and destroy the models, revise and update them, that's how we get to that place.
- 1:08:08Mark McGrath: So Um.
- 1:08:20John Jennings: Mm-hmm.
- 1:08:24Mark McGrath: Well, I will definitely be directly quoting John Boyd in my second book, which is on more wealth and happiness and purpose in the face of abundance Especially as concept of being somebody versus doing something Amazing.
- 1:08:41Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:08:48John Jennings: What I mean.
- 1:08:50John Jennings: Look at, you know, he never had material riches and, if anything, at every turn eschewed them.
- 1:08:55John Jennings: It was like I'm not gonna go that direction.
- 1:08:57John Jennings: But yet here we are.
- 1:08:59John Jennings: You know when did he die?
- 1:09:00John Jennings: 1997?
- 1:09:01John Jennings: So you know, here we are.
- 1:09:03John Jennings: So, long after his death, he's still talking about the impact and the contributions he's made, and it's not just like two dudes talking about.
- 1:09:10John Jennings: I mean, he's had major effect on, you know, definitely the military, but other areas.
- 1:09:15John Jennings: You know he chose to do something which you know it's kind of interesting, I think.
- 1:09:19John Jennings: You know it caused him to be somebody, but not in the way he meant to be somebody.
- 1:09:24John Jennings: He became somebody that was, you know, really made an impact and has a lasting legacy which so many you know, he's the captain of industry that generated hundreds of millions of billions of dollars.
- 1:09:38Mark McGrath: Well, I think that was all over that.
- 1:09:40John Jennings: It shows that ideas can go on and on forever.
- 1:09:43Mark McGrath: So the book is the other material thing we're also going to go to learn more about your work, and everybody can read your great article on Boyd, which we'll link to.
- 1:09:54Mark McGrath: I also am a subscriber to your IFOD, so yeah, yeah.
- 1:10:04John Jennings: Yeah, yeah, the interesting fact of the day yeah, so johnmgenningscom, johnmgenningscom.
- 1:10:20John Jennings: And yeah, my blog is there.
- 1:10:21John Jennings: You can subscribe.
- 1:10:22John Jennings: We'd love to have you know people as a subscriber.
- 1:10:24John Jennings: More about me, more about my book and the interesting fact of the day I just write on just random things that are hopefully you know, hopefully sort of interesting.
- 1:10:35Mark McGrath: The one that I have Cookie that will probably come out tomorrow and is on how to do nothing in helping us continue to develop the work of Johnmoy.
- 1:10:41John Jennings: I had to throw in the product productively because we're in America.
- 1:10:46Mark McGrath: Well, we'll do it.
- 1:10:46Mark McGrath: We'll do it again.
- 1:10:48Mark McGrath: We've got a lot more to do, so we'll do it again, for sure.
- 1:10:51Mark McGrath: Thanks.
- 1:10:59John Jennings: I had a great time, totally different than any other podcasts I've been on In a good way.
- 1:11:06Mark McGrath: All right.